You are on page 1of 9

RESEARCH IN EDUCATION

Constructing the Survey Instruments


BEEd 3-1 — Angeles, Cerono, Dela Cruz, Jalbuena, Saludades, Santos

Definition of Survey o They allow the respondent to fill it out at


their own convenience.
▪ Survey research is one of the most important
▪ But there are some disadvantages as well.
areas of measurement in applied social research.
o Response rates from mail surveys are
▪ The broad area of survey research encompasses
often very low.
any measurement procedures that involve asking
o Mail questionnaires are not the best
questions of respondents.
vehicles for asking for detailed written
▪ A “survey” can be anything from a short paper-
responses.
and-pencil feedback form to an intensive one-on-
one in-depth interview. Group Administered Questionnaire
▪ A sample of respondents is brought together and
Types of Survey
asked to respond to a structured sequence of
▪ Surveys can be divided into two (2) categories: questions.
o Questionnaire ▪ Traditionally, questionnaires were administered
o Interview in group settings for convenience. The researcher
could give the questionnaire to those who were
Questionnaires are usually paper-and-pencil instruments
present and be fairly sure that there would be a
that the respondent completes. Interviews are completed
high response rate. If the respondents were
by the interviewer based on the respondent says.
unclear about the meaning of a question they
▪ For instance, some people think that
could ask for clarification. And, there were often
questionnaires always ask short closed-ended
organizational settings where it was relatively
questions while interviews always ask broad
easy to assemble the group.
open-ended ones.
o In a company or business, for instance.
▪ But you will see questionnaires with open-ended
questions although they do tend to be shorter than Difference between Group Administered
in interviews and there will often be a series of Questionnaire and Group Interview/Focus
Group?
closed-ended questions asked in an interview.
▪ In the group administered questionnaire, each
Questionnaire respondent is handed an instrument and asked to
Mail Survey complete it while in the room.
▪ There are many advantages to mail surveys. ▪ Each respondent completes an instrument. In the
o They are relatively inexpensive to group interview or focus group, the interviewer
administer. facilitates the session.
o You can send the exact same instrument ▪ People work as a group, listening to each other’s
to a wide number of people. comments and answering the questions.
▪ Someone takes notes for the entire group – people facilitates the exchange of information between the
don’t complete an interview individually. research participants and the person or organization
carrying out the research.
Interviews
To give you a number of questions you might ask that can
Personal Interview
help guide your decision.
▪ The interviewer works directly with the
respondent. Unlike with mail surveys, the Population Issue
interviewer has the opportunity to probe or ask
The first set of considerations have to do with the
follow-up questions. And, interviews are
population and its accessibility.
generally easier for the respondent, especially if
what is sought is opinions or impressions. Is the population literate?
Interviews can be very time consuming and they ▪ Questionnaires require that your respondents can
are resource intensive. read.
▪ The interviewer is considered a part of the ▪ While this might seem initially like a reasonable
measurement instrument and interviewers have to assumption for many adult populations, we know
be well trained in how to respond to any from recent research that the instance of adult
contingency. illiteracy is alarmingly high.

Telephone Interview What are the geographic restrictions?


▪ Telephone interviews enable a researcher to ▪ Is your population of interest dispersed over too
gather information rapidly. broad a geographic range for you to study feasibly
▪ Most of the major public opinion polls that are with a personal interview?
reported were based on telephone interviews. ▪ It may be possible for you to send a mail
▪ Like personal interviews, they allow for some instrument to a nationwide sample. You may be
personal contact between the interviewer and the able to conduct phone interviews with them.
respondent. And, they allow the interviewer to
Are there language issues?
ask follow-up questions. But they also have some
▪ We live in a multilingual world. Virtually every
major disadvantages.
society has members who speak other than the
▪ Many people don’t have publicly-listed telephone
predominant language.
numbers. Some don’t have telephones. People
▪ Some countries (like Canada) are officially
often don’t like the intrusion of a call to their
multilingual. And, our increasingly global
homes. And, telephone interviews have to be
economy requires us to do research that spans
relatively short or people will feel imposed upon.
countries and language groups.
Selecting the Survey Method

A survey method is a process, tool, or technique that you


can use to gather information in research by asking
questions to a predefined group of people. Typically, it
Sample Issue ▪ Can you anticipate the most frequent or important
types of responses and develop reasonable
The sample is the actual group you will have to contact in
closed-ended questions?
some way.

How complex will the questions be?


There are several important sampling issues you need to
consider when doing survey research.
▪ Sometimes you are dealing with a complex
subject or topic.
What data is available? ▪ The questions you want to ask are going to have
▪ What information do you have about your multiple parts.
sample? ▪ You may need to branch to sub-questions.
▪ Do you know their current addresses? Their
Will lengthy questions be asked?
current phone numbers?
▪ If your subject matter is complicated, you may
▪ Are your contact lists up to date?
need to give the respondent some detailed
Can respondents be found? background for a question.
▪ Can your respondents be located? ▪ Can you reasonably expect your respondent to sit
▪ Some people are very busy. Some travel a lot. still long enough in a phone interview to ask your
Some work the night shift. Even if you have an question?
accurate phone or address, you may not be able to
Content Issue
locate or make contact with your sample.
The content of your study can also pose challenges for the
Who is the respondent?
different survey types you might utilize.
▪ Well, respondent has been for many years the
usual term for an individual who takes part in Can the respondents be expected to know about the
research project. However, this is increasingly issue?
replaced by the term 'participant' as researchers ▪ If the respondent does not keep up with the news
and clients recognize the value of a more (e.g., by reading the newspaper, watching
collaborative interviewing relationship. television news, or talking with others), they may
not even know about the news issue you want to
Sample Issue ask them about.
Sometimes the nature of what you want to ask
Will the respondent need to consult records?
respondents will determine the type of survey you select.
▪ Even if the respondent understands what you are
What types of questions can be asked? asking about, you may need to allow them to
▪ Are you going to be asking personal questions? consult their records in order to get an accurate
▪ Are you going to need to get lots of detail in the answer.
responses? o For instance, if you ask them how much
money they spent on food in the past
month.
▪ In this case, you do not want to Time
be involved in an interview ▪ Some types of surveys take longer than others.
where they would have to go ▪ Do you need responses immediately (as in an
look things up while they keep overnight public opinion poll)?
you waiting.
Facilities
Bias Issue ▪ Do you have the facilities (or access to them) to
process and manage your study?
People come to the research endeavor with their own sets
of biases and prejudices. Sometimes, these biases will be
▪ In phone interviews, do you have well-equipped
phone surveying facilities?
less of a problem with certain types of survey approaches.
▪ For focus groups, do you have a comfortable and
Can social desirability be avoided? accessible room to host the group?
▪ Respondents generally want to “look good” in the
Constructing Survey
eyes of others. None of us likes to look like we do
not know an answer. Constructing a survey instrument is an art in itself.

Can false respondents be avoided? There are numerous small decisions that must be made –
▪ With mail surveys it may be difficult to know about content, wording, format, placement – that can have
who actually responded. important consequences for your entire study.
▪ It is hard to convince respondents to go against
There are three areas involved in writing a question:
what is acceptable even when things are clearly
▪ Determining the question content, scope and
good. The respondents will have a propensity to
purpose.
provide the socially acceptable response over the
▪ Choosing the response format that you use for
true response.
collecting information from the respondent.
Administrative Issue ▪ Figuring out how to word the question to get at
the issue of interest.
Last, but certainly not least, you have to consider the
feasibility of the survey method for your study.
Close-ended Question
Cost ▪ Closed-ended questions have a limited set of
▪ This often the major determining factor in options that the respondents need to select from.
selecting survey type. ▪ They can be either questions that can be answered
▪ You might prefer to do personal interviews, but with a Yes/No or a multiple-choice format like A,
cannot justify the high cost of training and paying B, C or D.
for the interviewers.
Open-ended Question
▪ You may prefer to send out an extensive mailing
▪ These types of questions are completely opposite
but cannot afford the postage to do so.
of close-ended questions.
▪ Open-ended questions allow the respondents to
freely express their opinion in their own words.
▪ There are no options, but just a question to which
the respondent must write an answer as clearly as
possible. Filter or Contingency Question
▪ Questions that are only to be answered by some
Types of Survey Questions
subgroup(s) of respondents.
Survey questions are classified in to two: o Example: Are you a resident of Manila?
▪ Structured questions Yes or No. If yes, how long have you
o This is when the questions provided has been staying in Manila?
a fixed answer like multiple choice,
yes/no questions etc. Open-ended Questions
▪ Unstructured questions ▪ Questions that cannot be answered with a simple
o These are questions with open-ended 'yes' or 'no', and instead require the respondent to
answers, and the respondent does not elaborate on their points.
have a fixed answer. ▪ Open-ended questions help you see things from a
customer's perspective as you get feedback in
Dichotomous Questions their own words instead of stock answers.
▪ This refers to questions with two possible o Example: Where do you see yourself in 5
answers. years?
o Closed-ended questions
▪ Requires a one-word answer. Multiple Choice Questions

▪ Example: Are you a ▪ An assessment item consisting of a stem, which

resident of Manila? Yes poses the question or problem, followed by a list

or No of possible responses, also known as options or


alternatives.
Question Based on Level of Measurement
▪ Rating questions Question Content
o These are questions that answers are map Each question in the survey should be addressing the
onto a numeric scale. needed information that needs to be gathered for the
▪ Likert Scale questions research. Here are some questions that we may consider
o A question that uses a 5 or 7-point scale, when creating survey questions.
sometimes referred to as a satisfaction
scale, that ranges from one extreme Is the question necessary?
attitude to another. ▪ Decide whether each question is really needed to
o Typically, the Likert survey question avoid fillers and questions that don't really
includes a moderate or neutral option in address the topic.
its scale.
Does the respondent possess the necessary/needed attention that it needs without being introduced too early
information? in the survey that it makes the respondents uncomfortable
▪ This is important because if the respondents don’t to answer difficult questions or too far in the end that it
possess the needed information/ characteristics gets neglected.
that we need for the research, then the answers
Question Placement Components
may not be as reliable.
▪ Opening Questions
Does the question need to be more specific? o These are the easy and general questions
▪ This is important to ensure that the survey that the respondents will have to answer
questions would really target the needed first to allow them to be comfortable
information. before answering the much harder or
sensitive questions.
Is the question biased?
▪ This has to be considered for we want the ▪ Sensitive Questions
research to be unbiased and reliable. o Sensitive questions are inevitable in
some survey topics therefore, knowing
Question Wording
how to properly address this is important.
The choice of words and phrases in a question is critical o This kind of questions must be put near
in expressing the meaning and intent of the question to the the end but not too far that it gets
respondent and ensuring that all respondents interpret the neglected for the respondents are already
question the same way. Even small wording differences tired of answering.
can substantially affect the answers people provide. o A good transition between general and
easy questions to sensitive questions
▪ Answer the following questions:
would be helpful wherein a good
o Can the question be misunderstood?
transition could be something like,
o What assumptions does the question
▪ “In this part of the survey, we’d
make?
like to ask more personal
o Is the time frame specified?
questions regarding (a certain
o How personal is the wording?
topic).” and to assure them that
o Is the wording too direct?
they don’t have to answer the
questions if they are
▪ Identical question wording should be used when
uncomfortable.
the intention is to compare results to those from
earlier surveys.
Practices for Creating an Effective Survey
Instrument
Question Placement
The secret to designing a survey that works is to
Question placement is important because this determines keep validity, reliability, replicability, and
the order or the placement of the questions and to ensure generalizability in mind.

that the important questions would really be given the


Knowing what you want to learn is the first step in ▪ Include easy to understand instructions and
any study project.
questions
Determine the Objectives o Keep instructions and questions at the
eighth-grade level or lower, without
▪ Start with your hypothesis
being condescending.
▪ Have a clear idea of what decision you need to
make, and what information you need to make it.
All instructions, question directions, and response
o What is the purpose of the survey? categories need to be clear, especially with written
o What are we trying to measure? surveys.
o How many questions should we include?
Use as few words as possible in both the question and the
o What type of rating scale should we use?
alternatives and avoid the use of polysyllabic words.
o How will we know that the survey
worked — what will make the data
Provide general instructions
actionable?
▪ Provide general instructions to the respondents at
Design the Questionnaire the beginning of each section and clearly define
specific instructions associated with the different
The most crucial step in survey instrument design is
question types to order to aid in the correct
making sure you can acquire the information and
completion of that question.
outcomes your organization need.
▪ This includes phrases such as
Ask forthright, clear-cut, straightforward, and unbiased o “Please check one box only”
inquiries. Make sure every query is objectively o “Please rank in order of 1 to 5” with 1
"measuring" something. being most important.

Ask only one question at a time


▪ Begin with title and a preamble that explains the
▪ It is not uncommon to ask what we call double-
overall aim of the survey
barrel questions, such as “how satisfied are you
o This alerts respondents up front about
with cost and convenience of….?”
things like the length of the survey and
o With this question, you will not know
the degree of confidentiality, whether it
whether the response applied to cost or
is part of the survey invitation or at the
convenience.
start of the survey itself.
▪ Use the language of your respondents.
▪ Balance white space to improve readability
o If you want to make the survey easier to Avoid biasing questions
read without unnecessarily extending its ▪ Avoid questions like “what did you dislike
perceived size, you should utilize white about…?” and then only offering response
space sparingly between the questions categories to support the questions, which then
and the sections. forces the respondent to bias their answer.
▪ A better way to approach this question is to ask a o Organize the survey into sections or
qualifying question first such as, “Did you dislike topics with the easier items first.
anything about…? Yes or No.” o Keep sentences to 8 words or less and
o Those that say yes go on to the question limit the number of questions per page.
that asks them what did they dislike. o Extensively long surveys lead to fatigue
▪ These questions are important to the design of any and high abandonment rates.
type of survey, whether it be a customer o The shorter the better.
satisfaction survey, a product evaluation survey,
▪ Determine a rating scale
or a program evaluation survey.
o Scales are critical to the success of your
▪ It often helps to involve multiple departments in
research.
the process in order to gain consensus. When all
o Well-designed scales are easy to
units are involved upfront, your chances of asking
understand and accurately represent the
the right questions and not collecting unnecessary
respondent’s true attitude, preference or
data are greatly improved.
opinion.
Pre-test your surveys o Clear and well thought out rating scales,
Ask the tester to let you know if there are any words that as well as clearly defined instructions, are
they do no regularly use, or did not understand. key to minimizing rating errors.

▪ Select the sample and define your respondents


▪ Use filter questions
o It is important to have a sufficient sample
o Filter questions make it possible for
size if you want the results to be statically
respondents to bypass questions (or
meaningful.
whole sections) that are not relevant to
o Factors that affect a sample size are how
them
large the group difference you wish to
▪ “don’t know” and “not
detect, how variable your measure is in
applicable”
the sample or populations, and how
o This will help ensure people don’t select
precise you want the results to be.
something just because there is no other
o In order to achieve an accurate sample,
option available to them.
you must decide on a level of granularity
o However, when a large number of
to reach a conclusion.
respondents choose such options, it is
o Develop a process for finding these
time to examine whether the question is
respondents and engaging them.
badly worded, or in the wrong place in
the questionnaire, or if the question is
Survey Implementation
reaches the objectivity of the study.
A study's reliability is impacted by its low response rate.
▪ Keep it short, simple, and focused Before launching your survey, always test it.
o Keep in mind what you want to know,
and who you need to know it from.
The response rate is the single most significant indicator
of how much trust may be put in survey results.

What the survey author may consider to be obvious may


not make any sense to the usual receiver. Nevertheless,
even worse, a challenging question may be misconstrued
or skipped, and a challenging survey is almost guaranteed
to be ignored.

▪ Plan ahead for survey reminders.


▪ Make sure the respondents are qualified to answer
the questions, otherwise they may feel compelled
to make up an answer.

Analyze and Report the Results

▪ When gathering and analyzing data, follow a


methodical process.
▪ Describe your findings in objective, fact-based
sentences.
▪ Validity should be taken into consideration while
reviewing research findings. Analyzing the
proportion of respondents who selected each
response option allows one to judge the quality of
the questions.
▪ No answer should receive more than 85% of the
votes, and no answer should receive less than 5%.

Research is both a science and an art. The goal is to derive


insights from the data to foster more confident customer,
market, and product decisions. Be sure you have the
science under your belt.

You might also like