Grand Rounds Peer Review Template

Name of Peer Being Reviewed: ____________Michele Ros________

Name of Peer Reviewer: _______Jacklyn Hennessey-Smith____

Criteria On a Scale from 1-4, Rate Your Classmate

Completeness: 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts

Required elements of All of the All elements 1 element 2 or more
the assigned topic are elements addressed skipped, elements skipped
addressed fully are fully but some or many or missed, and
addressed key points key points many key points
are missed are are missed
missed

Critical Thinking:
Content indicates 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts
depth of thought and All Most Many All important
consideration of all- important important important aspects
important aspects of aspects are aspects aspects ignored and
covered and covered and covered and lack a clear
the grand round’s demonstrat demonstrat understandin
assignment demonstrate
e adequate e minimal g of content
s mastery of
mastery of mastery of
content
content content

Timeliness: The 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts

presentation included Appropriate Less than Less than 13 Less than 12 min
at least 15 minutes of time with at 14 min or min or More or More than 4 min
content, but no more least 15 min More than than 3 min overtime
than 30 minutes of content 2 min overtime
but no more overtime
than 30 min
Power Point 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts
Appearance and Logical flow Adequate Disjointed flow No clear flow
Layout: flow, with a very flow and a with a and an
professionalism professional professional professional unprofessional
appearance appearance appearance appearance

APA formatted 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts

references on final slide Proper Proper APA Proper APA Improper APA
and provided at least 3 APA formatted formatted formatted
separate references. formatted references references references, more
references with 3-4 with 4-5 than 5 errors
with 1-2 errors. 3 errors and/or and/or only 2
APA references 2 references references or
errors. 3 provided. provided less provided
references
provided

Spelling/Grammar 4.0 pts 3.0 pts 2.0 pts 1.0 pts

No errors 1-2 errors 3-4 errors More than 4 errors

TOTAL SCORE: 24

1) Please provide one

area of success for Michele, this was an excellent presentation. You showed confidence
Peers’ Grand Rounds and knowledge of the topic, and the flow was engaging.
presentation.
2) Please provide one
area for
improvement for The video was a little dark, but still visible.
Peers’ Grand Rounds
presentation.
3) Please provide one
suggested solution
We could consider providing community resources to the audience
for peers’ Grand to share with patients and family.
Rounds
presentation.