Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FINAL REPORT
A Road Infrastructure
Safety Strategy for Tanzania
MARCH 2023
DISCLAIMER
The information contained in this report is provided by the Ten Step Tanzania Project Team for
general informational purposes only. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date
information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the
completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the report or the
information, products, services, or related graphics contained in the report for any purpose.
Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. In no event will we
be liable for any loss or damage including without limitation, indirect or consequential loss or
damage, or any loss or damage whatsoever arising from loss of data or profits arising out of, or in
connection with, the use of this report.
Through this report, you are able to link to other websites which are not under the control of Ten
Step Tanzania Project Team. We have no control over the nature, content, and availability of those
sites. The inclusion of any links does not necessarily imply a recommendation or endorse the views
expressed within them.
The views and opinions expressed in this report are solely those of the authors and do not
necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any other organization, agency, or government.
If you have any questions about this disclaimer, please contact the International Road Federation
at info@irfnet.ch
Lead Authors:
This work is the result of the WG1 efforts. Special thanks to John Milton (PIARC) for his guidance and
contribution.
Other resources about the Ten Step Project in Tanzania can be accessed on:
https://www.gtkp.com/themepage/road-safety/ten-step-plan-for-safer-road-infrastructure/ten-
step-project-tanzania/
© 2023 Ten Step Project Tanzania – International Road Federation (IRF) – www.irfnet.ch
The Ministry of Works
and Transport,
Tanzania
FINAL REPORT
A Road Infrastructure
Safety Strategy for Tanzania
MARCH 2023
1 Introduction and Background
1.1. Introduction
The ‘Ten Step Plan for Safer Road Infrastructure’ framework was developed in 2019 by the United
Nations Road Safety Collaboration (UNRSC) ‘Safer Roads and Mobility’ group. It is designed to
provide countries with a proven step by step process to build national capacity for safer road
infrastructure, and to help them achieve Targets 3 and 4 of the World Health Organisation’s (WHO)
road safety performance targets.
Tanzania is the very first country in the world implementing the Ten Step Plan via a project jointly
funded by the United Nations Road Safety Fund (UNRSF) and the Global Road Safety Facility (GRSF)
of the World Bank.
Three technical working groups were established to deliver on these objectives. Working Group 1
(WG1) was established to develop and support the review and/or development of the national Road
infrastructure Safety Strategy and Action Plan.
Core membership of the Working Group included representation from the following stakeholders:
• Ministry of Works & Transport
• Tanzania Road Fund Board
• Tanzania National Roads Agency (TANROADS)
• Tanzania Rural and Urban Roads Agency (TARURA)
• Academic Institutions
• Other relevant national bodies competent and with expertise on infrastructure
management
• Representative of the Project Core Group (IRF, TARA, iRAP, PIARC, UNECA)
This document “A Road Infrastructure Safety Strategy for Tanzania” is the result of WG1s efforts. The
document presents recommendations for a Tanzanian national road infrastructure safety strategy
for the period of 2021-2030. The suggested action plan seeks to provide for the development,
implementation, monitoring and evaluation of safety interventions. It is intended to be a
component of a comprehensive national road safety strategy and action plan.
More than 40 people are killed in road crashes every day in Tanzania 1. Road crashes are the leading
cause of death for young people. But this is just the tip of the iceberg. It is estimated that more than
1,000 people suffer injuries every day, including severe brain injury, quadriplegia, fractures, internal
injuries and burns. Road crashes often result in life-long suffering and disability and place a huge
toll on families and communities.
Apart from the emotional impact of serious injury crashes, the cost of emergency response, trauma
wards and long-term health care is immense. International insurance claim data shows that more
than half of all costs occur more than two years after a crash, buried deep within health and social
welfare systems.
We also know that the cost of road crashes is borne by victims and society differently around the
world. For example, a road crash victim with a treatable injury in a country with advanced health
and welfare systems is likely to receive the adequate treatment to achieve a fast and full recovery.
In a country with a less developed health and welfare systems, the same victim is less likely to
achieve a fast, or even full, recovery. In the first case, the costs of the crash are experienced in a
short period and borne mostly by health and welfare systems. While in the second case, the costs
are often extended over a long period of time and are often borne by the victim and their family,
impacting both quality of life and economic opportunity for multiple generations.
To support debate about the right scale of response to this enormous level of trauma and cost, iRAP
has drawn on data from the World Health Organization, Transport Accident Commission (TAC),
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to make
simple, high-level estimates of the types of injuries that may be occurring in Tanzania, and their
costs. The estimates show, for example, that every year more than 5,000 people are likely to suffer
severe acquired brain injuries, more than 67,000 people suffer limb fractures and more than 30,000
people suffer internal injuries. Without intervention, fatalities and injuries will likely increase with
growing population and motorization. The costs of injuries significantly exceed the costs of road
deaths.
1
Global Status Report on Road Safety 2018. World Health Organization
The policy framework related to road safety in Tanzania comprises the following:
1. Tanzania Development Vision 2025 was launched in 1999.
2. Five-Year Development Plans. First 2011/12 to 2015/16; Second 2016/17 to 2020/21; Third
2021/22 to 2025/26.
3. United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
2 https://www.roadsafetyfacility.org/country/tanzania
The legal framework related to road safety in Tanzania comprises the following:
1. Roads Act No. 13 of 2007.
2. Road Management Regulations 2013.
3. Road Traffic Act Cap 168 of 1974.
1.3.3. Funding
The Roads Fund Board mainly finances road maintenance of Tanzania’s road network established
through the Roads Tolls Amendment No 2 Act of 1998. This has improved the road condition of the
road network, but the financing only meets 50% of the total maintenance needs. Efforts to improve
the funding are ongoing and must be approved by the Ministry of Finance and Planning. A Roads
Fund Board comprises members from both the public and private sectors that manage the Roads
Fund. The functions of the Roads Fund Board can be summarised into three main tasks ensuring
sustainable availability of funds from approved sources, disbursement of funds to implementing
agencies and ensuring sound utilisation of the funds.
The Roads Tolls Amendment No 2 Act of 1998 has ring-fenced sources for the Roads Fund, which
are:
1. Fuel levy (contributes more than 95% of the Roads Fund’s income)
2 Transit fees
3. Vehicle overloading fees
4. Heavy Goods Vehicle (HGV) license fees (this was abolished in July 2005)
The Roads Fund Board allocates funds to the various agencies for the maintenance of roads as
shown:
• Development partners such as the World Bank, European Union, African Development
Bank, JICA, DANIDA, and others provide funding for road development through loans and
grants.
Global road safety infrastructure KPIs can support Tanzania in planning and monitoring progress
towards the achievement of Global Road Safety Performance Targets 3 and 4, and the goal of
halving road deaths and injuries by 2030. These KPIs have been applied to existing data collected
using the iRAP methodology in Tanzania to produce a working baseline for this strategy.
At time of writing, iRAP methodology had been used to assess more than 11,000 km of national,
rural and city roads and designs in Tanzania.
The following table includes KPIs for the most recent data available for existing roads and, as a
comparison, data from the assessments globally. This data provides a basis for short-, medium- and
long-term target setting, and for routine monitoring.
Since availability of recent and comprehensive data is important, further data is currently being
collected through a grant from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office (UKAid),
through the Global Road Safety Facility of the World Bank. However, the intended date for delivery
is in April 2023 so after completion of this Road Infrastructure Safety Strategy document.
The Safe System principles recognize that humans, vehicles, and road infrastructure must interact
with a high level of safety to reduce fatal and serious crashes. A safe system: 1) anticipates and
accommodates human errors, develops and incorporates designs; 2) operates the system within
human tolerance for injury because of excess crash forces; 3) recognizes that road safety is a shared
responsibility, and seeks solutions to address road safety problem rather than on blaming the
driver; 4) seeks to proactively address and continuously improve roads rather than solely focusing
on locations where crashes have just occurred; 5) recognizes that safety should not be
compromised because of cost or the desire for faster mobility.
Road safety is the shared responsibility of all safety stakeholders, partners, and road users. To
ensure road infrastructure is safe to its users, transport organizations who are responsible for
planning, funding, designing, and operating the road infrastructure are called upon to develop
roads consistent with the principles and elements of the Safe System approach to road safety.
The Tanzanian Road Infrastructure Safety Strategy envisions proactive approaches to road safety
through a comprehensive analysis of Tanzania current road system using iRAP to assess which
roads would most benefit from changes to its design and operation through the appropriate
application of National Road Safety Standards and consistent with the Safe System Approach.
Ambitious, achievable, and evidence-based road safety targets are an essential part of a strategy to
reduce road deaths and injuries.
Following a request of the World Health Assembly (WHA) in 2016, the World Health Organization
(WHO) collaborated with other United Nations agencies and regional commissions and the UNRSC
to develop 12 voluntary Global Road Safety Performance Targets. Consensus on the targets among
United Nations Member States was achieved in 2017. Towards the 12 voluntary global targets for
road safety provides guidance to countries on how to operationalize and utilize these targets.
This Tanzanian Safety Strategy for Road Infrastructure is developed with the intent of addressing
the Targets set in the Decade of Action of halving deaths by 2030.
3 See: https://www.aprso.org/sites/default/files/document/2020-08/towards-the-12-voluntary-global-
targets-for-road-safety.pdf.
There are few better investments than in safer roads and safe speeds. Yet investment does not yet
match the scale of this preventable public health crisis.
The Global Plan for the Decade of Action aims to halve road deaths and injuries and ensure that all
road designs and 75% travel on existing roads are rated 3-stars or better for everyone.
Government, development banks, donors and the private sector each have a role to play in
mobilizing the sustainable investment needed to eradicate serious road trauma in Tanzania,
unlocking far-reaching economic, financial, and social benefits.
The anticipated reduction in fatalities and serious injuries, compared to the existing situation,
are very large, at more than 60%.
Studies on investments in safe speeds and safe road infrastructure indicate that:
• If Tanzania achieved the Global Plan targets for safer road infrastructure, more than 7,100
lives would be saved every year – almost 20 lives saved a day. This equates to a 43%
reduction in deaths.
• Investments of about 0.15% of GDP per year through to 2030 will unlock this incredible
outcome with $26 of benefits for every $1 invested
2.1. Mission
A road system for Tanzania that results in fewer deaths and serious injuries through proactive
standards-based infrastructure investment considering the Safe System approach to road safety.
2.2. Vision
To ensure that by 2030, all new roads are built to 3-star or better standard and that at least 75% of
travel on existing roads made by all road users is on the equivalent of 3-star or better roads.
2.3. Objectives
The objectives and goals of this plan are to align with the recommendations for safer roads outlined
in the global plan for the decade of action, namely:
1. To set forth a leadership and governance structure that will support decision making
necessary for reaching UN Targets for fatal and serious crashes
2. To increase capacity of road agencies to develop a Safe System Approach to roadway
infrastructure construction and maintenance that reduce deaths and serious injuries.
3. To create a mechanism for funding of road safety infrastructure necessary to achieve the
Safe System Approach.
4. To create an infrastructure-based plan of action that provides for continuous progress
towards the 2030 United Nations Targets for fatal and serious crashes.
5. To identify and improve upon the roles and responsibilities of Tanzanian safety partners
who have a shared responsibility of reducing fatal and serious crashes on Tanzanian
roadways.
This section outlines solutions and strategies toward achieving the objectives set forth in this
strategy between 2023 - 2030. These action strategies recognize that changes to the road system
will occur over time based on the resources made available for implementation. The strategies draw
upon the Safe System Approach to road safety.
Recommended actions:
1. Appoint a lead institution for road safety (Such as, the National Road Safety Council) in
Tanzania and continue with necessary actions, including maintaining cabinet approval of
the amendment of The Road Traffic Act Cap. 168 (The Road Traffic Act Cap. 168 R.E 2002)
and providing necessary support and information for an amendment to the respective Road
Traffic Act by the Parliament. Ensure that membership includes representatives from
engineering, enforcement, education, and emergency services professionals are part of this
leadership.
2. Through TanRAP steering committee and working groups, sustain the progress made by the
Ten Step Plan Steering Committee and Working Groups, provide leadership, coordination,
and monitoring for the implementation of this plan. Where needed, utilize the structure of
TanRAP to strengthen the coordination of road safety in Tanzania.
3. Using the structure created under the Ten Steps Program, create policy committees for
planning, design and operations with appropriate decision-making authority and reporting
requirements as necessary to maintain up to date policies, procedures, guidelines, and
manuals. These committees should also consider the following:
a. Assess the National Infrastructure Strategy and action plan, identify resources, and
set specific timelines for accomplishment.
4. Drawing on analyses performed during the Ten Step Plan, clarify roles, responsibilities and
decision-making processes in the planning, development, construction, and operation of
road safety infrastructure. Identify how their actions in combination are necessary to
achieve stated safety goals.
5. Develop a national, regional, and local safety impact and needs communication strategy as
necessary to highlight business case for improved road safety at all levels of government,
and within civil society.
3.1.2. Capacity
Road safety requires an understanding and ability to assess the current state of safety and from that
assessment to identify needs and priorities for the upgrading of roads. It is essential to use evidence-
based practices in the selection road interventions. Safety practitioners should have the knowledge,
skills and abilities necessary in using safety assessment tools, performing safety management
activities, and in having up to date design and operational standards and practices to implement
the Safe System Approach. The Ten Step Plan has made a significant contribution to road
infrastructure safety capacity, which this strategy and recommendations for an action plan builds
onto. To achieve improved capacity of Tanzanian road safety professionals, these are the;
Recommended actions:
1. Map and support organizational needs for road infrastructure related to safety
management amongst responsible transport agencies.
3. Continue to develop capacity and knowledge of road safety professionals to enable sound
safety infrastructure decision making and growth in expertise by establishing a sustainable
training program.
4. Collect, assess, and provide case studies of best practices on key topics for use in knowledge
and capacity building.
6. Develop a matrix of core competencies for safety professionals, as well as those in design
and operations to enhance safety understanding.
3.1.3. Policy
Policies and procedures are necessary for road safety programs. These policies set forth the
principles and strategies an organization uses to guide its decision making. Policies are intended to
provide clear guidance on the priorities, decision making process and to provide the necessary
guidance on how roads are going to be planned, designed, and operated.
Recommended actions:
1. MOWT, in collaboration with critical stakeholders, update the Road Safety Policy and
subsequent legislation.
2. Implement policies that requires that Road Safety Audits and Star Ratings for Design linked
to each road user type is performed for all road rehabilitation and upgrade projects with a
goal of achieving 3-stars or better roads.
3. Adopt the recommendations made in the Ten Step Plan and develop a policy and process
to regularly maintain, modify, and update the Tanzania design guides, manuals, and
standards to ensure that it is aligned with the safe roads infrastructure standards, the Safe
System Approach, and current international best practices.
4. Develop policy to ensure that road safety is considered in all road projects, the methods for
assessment, prioritization, project selection, evaluation, and decision-making authority.
Recommended actions:
1. Review the status of collecting data on road crashes and road safety risk in Tanzania
including how: data is collected, the information it provides suffices for analysis and
evaluation, the process for blackspot and system wide analysis and evaluation is managed,
the data is stored and maintained, and the data is made available for use by safety
professionals for decision-making.
3. Make necessary updates and upgrades to hardware and software to achieve data
assessments consistently across organizations.
4. Undertake crash-risk mapping (where crash data are reliable), and proactive safety
assessments and inspections on the target network with a focus on relevant road user needs
as appropriate.
5. Set a performance target for each road user based on the inspection results with clear,
measurable metrics at the road-attribute level (e.g. sidewalk provision)
Recommended actions:
1. Develop a program for funding of infrastructure projects that result in a reduction of death
and serious injuries for all road users including goals for new designs and upgraded roads.
Use economic evaluation (such as: benefit/cost analysis) to prioritise projects within the
funding available.
2. Prioritize the program to maximize safety benefits from investments using Blackspot
(reactive) and TanRAP (proactive) safety projects consistent with the Safe System approach
to road safety.
3. Identify a smaller set of specific priority projects that can be used to mobilize road safety
investment by having project ready plans. These plans are intended to be ready for
investment and financing of critical safety infrastructure needs and priorities. Develop
communication strategies that highlight the potential societal benefits for the investments
made for each location identified.
5. Identify and secure funds for data collection and road safety assessments necessary to
develop a prioritised program of Safety Infrastructure Projects.
2. Implement infrastructure treatments that ensure logical and intuitive compliance with the
desired speed environment (e.g., 30km/hr, <80km/h undivided rural roads <100km/h
expressways).
3. Ensure that newly built projects for TANROADS AND TARURA, and newly built national
highways, regional roads and urban roads implement the Tanzania National Standards and
will be designed to 3-star standards or better for all road users.
5. Transport facilities will be assessed and developed to provide for people with disabilities,
the elderly, and the young.
6. Develop speed management approaches near schools, hospitals, and areas with high
concentrations of vulnerable road users. Address any necessary law changes as
appropriate.
8. Ensure that road designs will undergo a mandatory road safety audit before they are let for
construction and will receive review at the end of construction/road opening to ensure
necessary elements are in place.
Road safety is being addressed by more than one institution or organization with the key
stakeholders being:
• Ministry of Home Affairs (MOHA),
• Ministry of Works and Transport (MOWT),
• President’s Office Regional Administration and Local Government (PORALG),
• National Road Safety Council (NRSC),
• Tanzania Police Force,
• Land Transport Regulatory Authority (LATRA),
• Tanzania Roads Fund Board
• Tanzania National Roads Agency (TANROADS) and
• Tanzania Rural and Urban Roads Agency (TARURA).
National Road
Tanzania Roads
Safety Council
Fund Board (RFB)
(NRSC)
TARURA ensures that all roads are designed, built and maintained to be as safe as possible. Several
policies and guidelines have been issued to the Regional Managers to instruct District Managers to
ensure road safety matters are included throughout project cycles.
Implementation Road
Map
Relative Owner/
# Action 2023 2025 2027
Cost Stakeholder
to to to
2024 2027 2030
3.1.1 - LEADERSHIP AND GOVERNANCE
Appoint a lead institution for road safety (Such as, the Road Safety Council) in Tanzania and
continue with necessary actions, including maintaining cabinet approval of the amendment of
The Road Traffic Act Cap. 168 (The Road Traffic Act Cap. 168 R.E 2002) and providing necessary
MoWT &
1 support and information for an amendment to the respective Road Traffic Act by the Low
NRSC
Parliament in the next Parliamentary Session. Ensure that membership includes
representatives from engineering, enforcement, education, and emergency services
professionals are part of this leadership.
Through TanRAP steering committee and working groups, sustain the progress made by the MoWT &
2 Ten Step Plan Steering Committee and Working Groups, provide leadership, coordination, and Low TanRAP
monitoring for the implementation of this plan. Leads
Using the structure created under the Ten Steps Program, create policy committees for
MoWT &
planning, design and operations with appropriate decision-making authority and reporting
3 Low TanRAP
requirements as necessary to maintain up to date policies, procedures, guidelines, and
Leads
manuals.
MoWT with
Assess the National Infrastructure Strategy and action plan, identify resources, and set specific
3a Low TanRAP
timelines for accomplishment.
Leads
Low/
Regularly review and update the National Infrastructure Strategy, performance targets, and
3b medium MoWT
actions plans
Ongoing
Regularly review National Infrastructure Strategy action plan to ensure consistency with SDG Low
3c MoWT
and Decade of Action Ongoing
MOWT &
Low/
TanRAP
3d Identify potential research needs or consultancy to address gaps in knowledge and capacity medium
Technical
Ongoing
Lead
MOWT &
Develop communication and outreach strategies to engage all relevant stakeholders in the medium TanRAP
3e
planning, design, and implementation of projects Ongoing Communica
tions Lead
Drawing on analyses performed during the Ten Step Plan, clarify roles, responsibilities and MOWT, Road
Agencies &
decision-making processes in the planning, development, construction, and operation of road
4 Low TanRAP Road
safety infrastructure. Identify how their actions in combination are necessary to achieve stated Managemt
safety goals. Lead
MOWT &
Develop a national, regional, and local safety impact and needs communication strategy as
TanRAP
5 necessary to highlight business case for improved road safety at all levels of government, and Low
Communica
within civil society.
tions Leads
3.1.2 - CAPACITY
Map and support organizational needs for road infrastructure related to safety management Low MoWT &
1 amongst responsible transport agencies. Ongoing NRSC
TanRAP
Develop and implement a framework to address institutional strengthening and Low
2 Technical
capacity building related safe road infrastructure (GRSF evaluation report.docx). Ongoing
Lead
Continue to develop capacity and knowledge of road safety professionals to enable TanRAP
Medium
3 sound safety infrastructure decision making and growth in expertise by establishing a Technical
Ongoing
sustainable training program. Lead
Ensure equal access to underrepresented groups and encourage participation of women in Low MoWT &
9
knowledge and skills development in road safety. Ongoing TanRAP
3.1.3 - POLICY
MOWT, in collaboration with critical stakeholders, update the Road Safety Policy and
1 Low MOWT
subsequent legislation.
Implement policies that requires that Road Safety Audits and Star Ratings for Design is
2 performed for all road rehabilitation and upgrade projects with a goal of achieving 3-stars or Low MOWT
better.
Assess gaps and needs in the crash data, and the resources necessary to improve data TanRAP &
2 Low
collection. NRSC
Make necessary updates and upgrades to hardware and software to achieve data assessments Medium/ TanRAP &
3
consistency across organizations. high NRSC
Undertake crash-risk mapping (where crash data are reliable), and proactive safety
Medium TanRAP &
4 assessments and inspections on the target network with a focus on relevant road user needs
Ongoing NRSC
as appropriate.
Set a performance target for each road user based on the inspection results with clear, TanRAP &
5 low
measurable metrics at the road-attribute level (e.g. sidewalk provision). NRSC
Analyze and evaluate safety outcomes. Modify program approaches as necessary to maximize Medium TanRAP &
7
crash reduction benefits. Ongoing NRSC
3.1.5 - PROGRAMMING AND FUNDING
Develop a program for funding of infrastructure projects that result in a reduction of death and
TanRAP
serious injuries for all road users including goals for new designs and upgraded roads. Use
1 High Technical
economic evaluation (such as: benefit/cost analysis) to prioritise projects within the funding
Leads
available.
Prioritize the program to maximize safety benefits from investments using Blackspot (reactive) Low/ TanRAP
2 and TanRAP (proactive) safety projects consistent with the Safe System approach to road Medium Technical
safety. Ongoing Leads
Identify a smaller set of specific priority projects that can be used to mobilize road safety TanRAP
investment by having project ready plans. These plans are intended to be ready for investment Technical
Medium/
3 and financing of critical safety infrastructure needs and priorities. Develop communication Leads &
High
strategies that highlight the potential societal benefits for the investments made for each Comm.
location identified. Leads
Road Agencies should mobilize funds from the Road Fund (for Existing Roads) and other MoWT, Road
High
4 appropriate sources recognizing the cost to upgrade to 3-star or better designs for Agencies,
Ongoing
new/upgraded roads Road Fund
MoWT, Road
Identify and secure funds for data collection and road safety assessments necessary to High
5 Agencies,
develop Ongoing
Road Fund
www.gtkp.com