Professional Documents
Culture Documents
If each of the following were premises in an argument, which of them could be assumed to pass the true
premises test because they are uncontroversially true empirical statements?
1. The doctor said that she saw a broken bone on the x-ray. testimonial statement
2. According to the thermometer, it is five degrees Celsius. testimonial statement
3. The witness claimed that the driver of the car didn’t brake before hitting the pedestrian. testimonial
statement
4. The food critic reported that the potatoes were salty. not a testimonial statement
5. My roommate says that there are humans on Mars. not a testimonial statement
6. Spiders are arachnids, which are animals that have eight legs. not a testimonial statement
7. “Abra Kadabra,” said Houdini, as he unlocked the chains on his arms. not a testimonial statement
8. Spiders are very often poisonous. testimonial statement
9. Does your watch have a second hand? testimonial statement
10. Your phone must be pretty old since it doesn’t have an alarm clock function. testimonial statement
If each of the following were premises in an argument, which of them could be assumed to pass the true
premises test because they are uncontroversially true definitional statements?
For each of the following, determine whether the scope and strength of the conclusion is warranted.
1. I have known five members of the Green party and all have been from France. Ralph Nader and
Cynthia McKinney are members of the Green party, so they too are most likely from France.
2. The great physician Dr. Dominose of Harvard University has done extensive research on nutritional
needs. He has found that if a man weighs more than 500 pounds, that man would require as much protein
as would be found in 30 pizzas in order to sustain himself. It is thus clear that everyone should eat 30
pizzas per day.
3. In early 2009, there were several cases of the disease SARS reported by the Chinese government.
Clearly, by 2011, there will be a SARS epidemic of tremendous proportions.
5. “Any war between the two Chinas [the People’s Republic of China and Taiwan] could easily involve the
United States. Under the 1979 Taiwan Relations Act, official U.S. law stipulates that the United States
would view any conflict over Taiwan with ‘grave concern.’ The 1995–96 Taiwan Strait crisis showed that
the United States does not take its interest in Taiwan’s security lightly.” (O’Hanlon 2000, 42)