Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0006CPRR
0006CPRR
net
Current
Psychiatry
Research and Reviews
*Address correspondence to this author at the Behavioral Disorders and Substance Abuse Research Center, Hamadan University of Medical Sciences,
Hamadan, Iran; E-mail: haghighi@umsha.ac.ir
via SMS for them to download the program via the study population are presented in Table 1. Among
provided link for answering the questions. For the participants, 1988 (69.71%) were girls and
those who did not respond, a new person was ran- 1508 (52.88%) were in grades 10-12. The educa-
domly selected (283 students, 9.92%). tion of the father of 1076 (37.73%) and that of the
mother of 1033 (36.22%) participants was aca-
The protocol of the study was confirmed by the
demic. Moreover, 1798 (63.04%) participants had
Hamadan University of Medical Science with
fathers that were self-employed and 2444
ethical code IR.UMSHA.REC.1399.251. The in-
(86.69%) of the participants had mothers who
clusion criteria were (a) high school students in
were housewives.
one of the schools in Hamadan City; (b) Consent
to contribute to this study. As shown in Fig. (1), regarding stress status,
70.3% were normal, 17.88% were mild, 10.62%
Two questionnaires were used in this study: a)
were moderate, 1.19% were in the stress category,
Socio-demographic questionnaire including age,
while regarding anxiety status, 28.37% of students
gender, educational status, level of education of
were normal, 29.42% had mild anxiety, 32.43% of
parents and occupation of parents; b) Depression
the students had moderate anxiety and 7.92% and
Anxiety Stress Scale 21 (DASS-21). The DASS-
1.86% were in severe and very severe category of
21 is a 21 item self-report scale that measures the
anxiety, respectively. About 47% of students were
negative emotional states of depression, anxiety,
normal, i.e., they did not have depression. In con-
and stress. The main value of DASS in clarifying a
trast, 26.86% of the participants were in the mild
clinical situation is the locus of the emotional dis-
category, 18.97% were in the moderate category,
order as part of the broader task of clinical evalua-
6.45% were severe, and 0.74% were in the very
tion. The basic function of DASS is to assess the
severe category of depression.
severity of the main symptoms of depression,
anxiety, and stress. Each of the three scales of The boys had reported a higher proportion of
DASS consists of 7 items responded to using a 0-3 normal status of depression (51.62% vs. 44.97%),
scale, where 0=did not apply to me at all, and anxiety (31.71% vs. 26.91%), and stress (77.66%
3=applied to me very much or most of the time vs. 66.10%) compared to the girls. Also, students
(the range of possible scores for each scale is 0– in grades 7-9 had reported a higher percentage of
42). The scores in the normal range are 0-9 for de- normal status in all three dimensions of stress,
pression, 0-7 for anxiety, and 0-14 for stress. The anxiety, and depression. Moreover, higher educa-
scores above these ranges show the degree of dis- tion of students’ mother and father was associated
order from mild to very severe. The severity levels with a higher percentage of reporting normal status
are not levels of the disease but rather levels away in all three investigated dimensions. The relation
from population means, and a true comparison between the baseline characteristics of the study
score would be to test it as a continuous measure. population and levels of anxiety, stress, and de-
The DASS was designed by Lovibond et al., in pression is shown in Table 2. There was a signifi-
1995 [12]. Asgharimoghaddam et al., in 2008 cant relationship between gender, grade, and fa-
translated and validated the scale in Iran [13]. ther’s and mother’s education on their depression,
anxiety, and depression scores (P<0.05).
Descriptive statistics were reported as number
(%) for categorical variables and mean (SD) for
continuous variables across the participant’s back- 4. DISCUSSION
ground. The associations between respondents'
The present study showed that although stress
demographic characteristics and categories of
status was normal among most high school stu-
stress, anxiety, and depression severity were as-
dents, the status of anxiety and depression was
sessed by Chi-square test. All statistical analyses
high. The boys had reported a higher proportion of
were conducted in STATA version 14. P<0.05 was
normal status of depression, anxiety, and stress
considered as a significant level.
compared to the girls. Also, students in grades 7-9
had reported a higher percentage of normal status
3. RESULTS in all three dimensions of stress, anxiety, and de-
pression. Moreover, higher education of students’
In the present study, a total of 2852 students
mother and father was associated with a higher
were selected. The baseline characteristics of the
Anxiety, Depression, and Stress During the Pandemic Current Psychiatry Research and Reviews, 2021, Vol. 17, No. 2 101
80
70.3
70
60
50
46.98
Depression
Percentage
40 Anxiety
32.43 Stress
29.42
30 28.37
26.86
20 18.97
17.88
10.62
10 7.92
6.45
1.19 1.86
0.74 0
0
Normal Mild Moderate Severe Very severe
Fig. (1). The mental categorization of students according to scores of Depression, Anxiety, and Stress. (A higher resolution /
colour version of this figure is available in the electronic copy of the article).
102 Current Psychiatry Research and Reviews, 2021, Vol. 17, No. 2 Jenabi et al.
Table 2. Relation between baseline characteristics of the study population and levels of anxiety, stress, and depression.
Scale Variable Category Normal Mild Moderate Severe Very Severe Pearson chi2 df P.Value
Father Guidance 241 (43.19) 154 (27.60) 116 (20.79) 44 (7.89) 3 (0.54)
237.99 12 0.001
education High school 31 (46.93) 176 (26.39) 137 (20.54) 39 (5.85) 2 (0.3)
Father Guidance 150 (26.88) 184 (32.97) 175 (31.36) 40 (7.17) 9 (1.61)
29.25 12 0.004
education High school 198 (29.69) 171 (25.64) 239 (35.83) 53 (7.95) 6 (0.9)
Mother Guidance 129 (27.8) 130 (28.02) 175 (37.72) 24 (5.17) 6 (1.29)
28.26 12 0.005
education High school 199 (26.15) 226 (29.70) 261 (34.30) 67 (8.80) 8 (1.05)
Father
19.69 9 0.02
education High school 461 (69.12) 122 (18.29) 76 (11.39) 8 (1.20) 0
percentage of reporting normal status in all three This study had two limitations: (a) This study
investigated dimensions. was conducted in urban areas; therefore, it cannot
be generalized to rural areas. It is recommended
Rehman et al., reported that among different
that this study be conducted in rural areas as well.
professions, students and healthcare professionals
(b) We utilized the online questionnaires to collect
were found to experience stress, anxiety, and de-
data, which prevents the participation of a large
pression more than others in the time of COVID-19
segment of the population, such as people who do
lockdown [7]. The study was performed from the
not have access to the Internet, especially the un-
3rd of April 2020 until the 6th of April 2020 and derprivileged. (c) We do not have a control group in
with 403 participants. However, this study showed this study for comparison with the group infected
that despite the current situation, stress, anxiety, with COVID-19. Thus, the effect of COVID-19 on
and depression were found to be in the normal depression, anxiety, and stress was without a com-
range. Our study reported that although stress parison group. This was another limitation of our
status was normal among most high school stu- study. According to our findings, we proposed that
dents, depression and anxiety were high. The rea- proper counseling services should be available to
son for the increase of anxiety status can be related support the mental health and well-being of students
to the fear of coronavirus. during the epidemic of COVID-19. In addition, we
Chang et al., reported that the overall incidence suggest that future research should be focused on the
of anxiety was 26.60%, and the incidences of mild, factors related to stress, depression, and anxiety
moderate, and severe anxiety were 23.19%, symptoms including adults and elderly individuals.
2.71%, and 0.70%, respectively, during the epi-
demic of COVID-19. Depressive emotions were CONCLUSION
detected in 21.16% of the students, and the inci-
dences of mild, moderate, and moderate-to-severe Our findings showed that although stress status
depression were 16.98%, 3.17%, and 1.01%, re- was normal among most high school students, the
spectively [14]. This study was performed among status of anxiety and depression was high. The
3881 college students in Guangdong Province. boys had reported a higher proportion of normal
They showed that depression and anxiety are status of depression, anxiety, and stress compared
closely related. However, the incidences of anxiety to the girls. Also, students in grades 7-9 had re-
and depression were higher in our study. ported a higher percentage of normal status in all
three dimensions of stress, anxiety, and depres-
Zhou et al., reported that multivariable logistic sion. Therefore, the present study was performed
regression analysis showed that girls were at a to investigate the rates of anxiety, depression, and
higher risk for depressive and anxiety symptoms stress among high school students during the pan-
during the outbreak of COVID-19. Also, senior demic of COVID-19.
high school was a risk factor for depressive and
anxiety symptoms; the higher the grade, the greater
the prevalence of depressive and anxiety symptoms ETHICS APPROVAL AND CONSENT TO
[11]. Our study confirmed the results of this study. PARTICIPATE
A cross-sectional study performed on 4,599 ado- The protocol of the study was confirmed by the
lescents in Tehran (Iran) showed the prevalence of Hamadan University of Medical Science, Iran with
depression to be 19.5%, which was significantly ethical code IR.UMSHA.REC.1399.251.
higher in girls compared with boys [15]. Another
study in Iran showed that the prevalence of depres- HUMAN AND ANIMAL RIGHTS
sion, anxiety, and stress were reported in 43.3%,
43.3%, and 38.9% among high school students, re- No animals were used for studies that are the
spectively [16]. In the study, data were collected us- basis of this research. All human procedures fol-
ing the validated Depression, Anxiety, and Stress lowed were in accordance with the Helsinki Decla-
Scale (DASS-21). However, in our study, the preva- ration of 1975.
lence of depression, anxiety, and stress was higher
after the COVID-19 pandemic. This may be due to CONSENT FOR PUBLICATION
the extent of stay at home, school closings, increased
homework, and concerns about coronavirus. Consent was obtained prior to the study.
104 Current Psychiatry Research and Reviews, 2021, Vol. 17, No. 2 Jenabi et al.