Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Deep-Dive Business Review For Retail: Marketplace Consumers Channels
Deep-Dive Business Review For Retail: Marketplace Consumers Channels
Macro view of overall category Understand consumer beliefs, habits, Evaluate channels, customers,
First, look at the average price and change versus ye
for each channel.
A
Match up the data to what the sales
performance with economic, trends via consumption data, strategy alignment, tool you should be looking
colleagues are saying about the different prices for each
Depending on channel/brand, B
consumer, tech, shopping, regulatory. funnels, tracking, VOC feedback. utilization, program effectiveness.
deal pricing, % on deal and coop ad points. Compare
the channels and compare to prior years.
Loyal
Beloved
% change +18%
Co Op Index 143 Gray’s Gray’s
8 ct Lemon
Share of Merch 25% 16 ct Mint Chip
% change -2%
March Index 111 Gray’s
8 ct Lemon
Take each section conclusion, draw out a brand Evaluate brand through lens Analyze competitors using
challenge to summarize the entire review of consumer, customer, brand, performance, pricing, We
Awareness
30 • Gray’s penetration of 43 and
12.4 trips/year, much stronger
• Exceptional brand health scores among early 20
Poor sales coverage. 3. Consumers love Gray’s new “transform lives” concept. Gray’s new advertising and tagline needs to reflect the
than new (SW) at
Sportsworld
• Low purchase frequency (2.2 boxes/yr vs. 7.3 Channel Review
adopters (“Proactive Preventers”) making it a
highly beloved brand among the niche. norm) even among most loyal.
beloved brands 1. Successful listings has driven strong distribution in Food Channels (90%)
10
“transform lies” brand concept. 21% and 7.3 trips.
2. Low distribution at specialty stores at only 16% due to poor sales coverage.
beloved brands 0
Summary Consumer
3. Weak coop/display for Gray’s is directly linked to our lower trade terms being offered.
Opportunities Risks Ø Gray’s needs to close distribution gaps, but must maintain advertising investment to drive trial.
Gray's SportsWorld SportsValue Play It Again Duke's • However, SW is much
stronger at $/trip at $39
• R&D has 5 new flavors in development. Could • Mainstream cookie brands could enter the ‘health’ Competitor Review
1. Re-evaluate strategy and use our power to begin to dominate the “good for you” segment.
60 beloved brands compared to Gray’s at $23.
launch Peanut Butter in Q4 of 2013 (top 15% in segment through R&D or acquisition. Rumors
2. Dad’s wins on innovation and deep price discounts, but is weak on taste. $39
test), Chocolate Chips in Q2 of 2014 (top 50%) that Pepperidge Farms will launch in Q1. 40 • Digging deeper, 45% of
Slides Analysis
3. Major risk if the major cookie brands launch healthy versions that are near-match taste versus current brands.
• Sales broker could specifically target specialty • De-listing of our 2 weakest skus because of POS Ø Gray’s has an opportunity to dominate “good for you” segment before traditional brands enter segment. Consumer review conclusion: $23
20 12.4 $15 $17 $14 Gray’s trips are browsing only,
stores, which are in high growth (+15%/year) thresholds, could weaken our in-store presence. 7.3
• Use social media to convert strong loyal following • Legal Challenge to “tastes as good as your Brand Review 4.3 2.7 3.2 while at SW, only 10% of the
1. Exceptional scores among early Adopters (“Proactive Preventers”), early base of brand lovers. New consumers attracted to Gray’s “transform world” 0 trips are browsing only.
into mainstream mass appeal favorite cookie”. 2.
3.
Brand funnel scores show we are still a niche player but yet to turn our sales into strong following
Awareness held back due to poor advertising scores with low attention scores and brand link scores.
positioning, but need to convert browsing to purchases. Gray's SportsWorld SportsValue Play It Again Duke's
Ø Gray’s growth due to taste quality, but “guilt free” positioning will connect deeper and fuel new demand. Trips/Year $/Trip
Overall Brand Challenge: It is time to transition Gray’s from a product-led brand into an idea-led brand to
connect with consumers by owning the idea of “guilt free” snacking, rather than just selling a great tasting
beloved brands cookie. Gray’s needs to begin to dominate and lead the “good for you” cookie segment. beloved brands How do we capture browsing consumers to convert purchases?
beloved brands
beloved brands
MARKETPLACE CATEGORIES
1. Volatility of sports participation during Covid created MARKETPLACE 2. Tracking key items across categories shows pricing CATEGORIES
uncertainty across sports retailers pressure on big 3 sports in reaction to Sports World EDLP
2. Major sports continue to dominate the sports retailers, but 3. Launching Gray’s Workout Sensibles own brand into fitness
golf provides the highest margin will provide added revenue and margins.
Footballs Baseball Glove Golf Putters Basketball
Avg Price $65.55 $64.47 $66.62 $65.54 • Entering the workout category with a
• Football, basketball, % change VYA -16.4% -12% +3.1% -1.9% launch of workout clothing and our own
baseball account for shoe brand.
Avg Price on Deal 59.99 65.59 52.29 54.49
75% of sales. % change VYA +8.3% -12.3% +1.7% +2.7% • Expected sales are $64 million in year on
total sales, with $50 million from clothing
M A R K E T P L A C E R E V I E W • Golf growth is offset C A T E G O R I E S R E V I E W % on deal 32% 22% 12% 20%
and $14 million from the shoes. Shoes are
by tennis decline. a high-risk entry.
M A R K E T P L A C E Golf brings in new CATEGORIES
• With 32% sold on deal in response to Sports World competitive pricing, the average price
consumers and the • Advertising spend of $10 will drive
1. Volatility of sports participation during Covid created 1. Need a clearer portfolio management and the strategic role of a football is down 16% vs year ago. Baseball gloves facing similar pricing pressure awareness, and using in-store displays
uncertainty across sports retailers 3. Growth of e-sports is cutting into youthhighest
participation
profit in for each category at Gray’s with 22% sold on deal, and average pricing is down 12% 1. Need a clearer portfolio management and the strategic role
around key workout dates (spring and new
• traditional sports.
Disruption of team sports led to increases in social distancing sports created margins for retailers • Demand in golf allowing for pricing increase of 3% and only 12% sold on deal. This helps for each category at Gray’s
years)
2. Major sports continue to dominate the sports retailers, but that led to high growth in sports like golf, working out, stationary bikes. 2. Tracking key items across categories shows pricing
golf provides the highest margin pressure on big 3 sports in reaction to Sports World EDLP drive profitability on golf to offset the margin declines on the big 3 sports.
• Declines in team sports caused price cuts among major manufacturers. Youth Participation
3. Growth of e-sports is cutting into youth participation in (% of 0-17 year olds)
3. Launching Gray’s Workout Sensibles own brand into fitness
• Invest in golf/workout
traditional sports. As sports participation stabilizes, use the time to return to normal • Declines in youth will provide added revenue and margins. Explore options to reach the specialty market, which could Watch key metrics on the
70
58 58 58 participation in baseball • Explore e-sports
launch, and cautiously manage
60
Continue to 47
win the50big three sports use golf as margin driver while add incremental sales volume.
50 and basketball the high-risk shoe entry
• Maintain big 3
40
40 32 football holding steady. (football, baseball,
30 basketball)
beloved brands beloved brands
Marketplace review conclusion:
Big 3 sports continue to dominate, but flat revenue. Youth shifting to
Marketplace 20
10
0
Baseball Basketball
beloved brands
Football
12
E Sports
• E-sports has tripled in
participation from 12%
to 32%.
Categories review conclusion:
Maintain volume in big 3 sports. Explore growth in golf and
Categories beloved brands
• Divest tennis.
Analysis Analysis
e-sports could be a future threat to sports retailers. workout clothing through our own brand.
2012 2022
• Ensure each product category is well-defined and well-organized. This requires a
thorough analysis of sales data to understand which products belong in which categories,
beloved brands beloved brands and how these categories should be organized to maximize sales.
Explore more experiential zones to capture younger
consumers including the use of sports technology.
Stay competitive in big 3 as they drive traffic into stores
COMPETITORS BRAND
COMPETITORS
3. Major risk of a global sports retailer launching into the US 3. New “Transform Life” advertising much stronger on aided
market, either through acquisition or aggressive entry
2. Increasing demand for e-sports gaming equipment could recall, brand link and purchase intent
create an opportunity for Gray’s to create a new category BRAND
• Decathlon: A French company that is the
largest sporting goods retailer in the world Tracking LY Ad New Ad Norm
with over 1,600 stores in 57 countries.
1. Seeing
• New advertising is above norm steady scores at top of the sales funnel, but declines
Aided Recall 38 73 62 on aided recall 73% vs norm of
at purchase/repeat due to Sports World EDLP impact
• JD Sports: A UK-based company that 62%, brand link .72 vs norm of
C O M P E T I T O R R E V I E W operates over 2,400 stores across 18 • E-sports is impacting the Unaided Recall 30 48 46 .50, and purchase intent
100 with
countries, specializing in sports apparel and participation in traditional sports, 22% vs norm of 9%. 90
Brand Recognition 10 30 23
footwear. especially among youth. 80
B R A N D R E V I E W Brand Link .33 .72 .50
• Main message within70the norm 67%
1. Sports World uses ‘Every Day Low Price’ (EDLP) on big • Sports Direct: Another UK-based company C O M P E T I •T OE-sports
R S has created a new but could be an area60to focus on B R55%A59%
ND
three sports allows them to drive higher sales that operates over 700 stores across 19 market for gaming equipment Main Message 64 59 60 for next year’s ad. 50
countries, offering a wide range of sports such as high-performance gaming
2. Increasing demand for e-sports gaming equipment could 1. Sports World uses ‘Every Day Low Price’
mice, (EDLP)
keyboards, onand
monitors, big 1. Seeing steady scores at top of the sales funnel, but declines Uniqueness 38 32 22
40
• Last year’s advertising failed on 2. Able to isolate the impact of Sports 32%
World pricing by looking
equipment and apparel. 30 24% 26%
create an opportunity for Gray’s to create a new category three sports allows them to drive headsets. higherAssales
a result, retailers are at purchase/repeat due to Sports World EDLP impact recall and brand link.20 at sales funnel drop off at purchase and repeat
• Intersport: A Swiss-based company that experiencing an increase in Purchase Intent 10 22 9 10
3. Major risk of a global sports retailer launching into the US operates over 5,500 stores across 66 2. Able to isolate the impact of Sports World pricing by looking
market, either through acquisition or aggressive entry countries, selling a variety of sports 40.0 Markup rates per categorydemand for these products. at sales funnel drop off at purchase and repeat
0
Awareness Familiar Consider Purchase Repeat Loyalty
equipment and apparel.
30.0
15%
3. New “Transform Life” advertising much stronger on aided 2020 2021 2022 2023
14% 14%
20.0 recall, brand link and purchase intent
Keep an eye on global entry, but also use as an opportunity
10.0
to New advertising will be a step up, make sure we see link to funnel steady at awareness to consider, but Sports World’s EDLP strategy on the big
• Brand
explore global expansion for Gray’s into newShould Gray’s enter the e-Sports market, either directly under
markets0.0
increased traffic and added revenue. three categories is seeing a drop off on purchase from 67% down to 55-59% range and
Gray’s banner or acquisition of a gaming retailer? repeat down from 32% to 24-26%. Concern is this shows up in loyalty in the longer run.
Competitor review conclusion: Tennis Golf Basketball Football Baseball Hockey
Gray's Sports World
Use our power position in US market to defend against all beloved brands beloved brands
Brand review conclusion: If brand health scores do not offset the impact of aggressive
Competitors Brand
competitors and explore competing in new ways. • Sports World every day lowbeloved brands
pricing on the big three sports has them using a lower markup on
pricing, may need to re-look pricing strategy on key items.
the big three sports (15% markup compared to 30—35% for competitors) to put them in a Gray’s brand in healthy position, but the impact of Sports • Gray’s is losing out at the conversion from consideration to purchase as consumers see
stronger competitive position.
World’s EDLP pricing strategy is hurting purchase lower prices at Sports World, 14 points below SW. The conversion from purchase to repeat
Analysis
• SW EDLP allows them to close the sale, a a higher $/trip at $39 compared to Gray’s at $23.
Analysis
is 4 points below. Gray’s uses their
beloved power to command high loyalty, but if the trendline on
brands
beloved brands However, Gray’s overall margin of 4.3% is significantly higher than SW at 1.5%. repeat continues, we could see a fall off on loyalty.
Conclusion
Headlines
Channel Review
Section Conclusion
Statements
Competitive Review
Brand Review
Example of the business review summary page
GRAY’S
Cookies
Business review summary
Drivers Inhibitors
• Taste drives a high conversion of trial to • Awareness among mainstream target
purchase (65% vs. norm of 50%). (20%) held back due to weak advertising
• Strong listings has driven strong scores. Low attention scores and brand link
distribution in food channels (95%) scores.
• Exceptional brand health scores among • Low distribution at specialty stores at only
early adopters (“Proactive Preventers”) 16%. Poor sales coverage.
making it a highly beloved brand among • Low purchase frequency (2.2 boxes/yr vs.
the niche. 7.3 norm) even among most loyal.
Opportunities Threats
• R&D has 5 new flavors in development. • Mainstream cookie brands could enter the
Could launch Peanut Butter in Q4 of 2013 ‘health’ segment through R&D or
(top 15% in test), Chocolate Chips in Q2 acquisition. Rumors that Pepperidge Farms
of 2014 (top 50%) will launch in Q1.
• Sales broker could specifically target • De-listing of our 2 weakest skus because of
specialty stores, which are in high growth POS thresholds, could weaken our in-store
(+15%/year) presence.
• Use social media to convert strong loyal • Legal Challenge to “tastes as good as your
following into mainstream mass appeal favorite cookie”.
How the best marketers think,
define, plan, execute and analyze
Winning
Familiar • Awareness is never enough. Anyone can get that. Contribution Margin
CM%
$6,949
23%
3.
focus and deployment be to drive our
awareness and share needs for Gray’s?
How will we defend Gray’s against the
of your health”. Media includes 15 second TV,
specialty health magazines, event signage, digital
and social media
brand idea starts to connect and move the • Exceptional brand health scores among Early Strategies Costco, health food stores and event sampling at
consumer. Inhibitors
•
•
Low familiar yet to turn our sales into loyalty
Awareness held back due to weak Advertising
trial with new consumers and building a
presence at retail.
Distribution
Support Q4 retail blitz with message focused on
holding shelf space during the competitive
3. Build defence plan against new entrants that
• Low distribution at specialty stores. Poor defends with consumers and at store level. launches. Q2 specialty blitz to grow distribution at
•
Launch of Mainstream cookie brands
(Pepperidge Farms and Nabisco).
De-listing 2 weakest skus weakened our in-
specifically up from 15% to 20% with the core
target. Monitor usage frequency among the
Launch 2 new flavors in Q4/15 & Q4/16.
Explore diet claims.
most loyal to ensure it stays steady.
consumer towards purchase and through the store presence •
Competitive Attack Plan
Repeat
Increase awareness from 33% to 42%,
• Legal Challenge to tastes claims specifically up from 45% to 50% within the Pre-launch sales blitz to shore up all distribution
gaps. At launch, heavy merchandising, locking up
core target. Drive trial from 15% to 20%.
experience. Opportunities
•
•
R&D has 5 new flavors in development.
Sales Broker create gains at Specialty Stores •
Close distribution gaps from 62% to 72%.
Hold dollar share during competitive launch.
key ad dates, BOGO. TV, print, coupons, in-store
sampling. Use sales story that any new
Continue to grow 11% post launch gaining up “healthy” cookies should displace under-
• Social media to convert loyal following.
Loyal • To drive loyalty (the heart) you need to create to 1.2% share. Target zero losses at shelf. performing and declining unhealthy cookies.
experiences that deliver the promise and use tools beloved brands
1 Brand 4 Brand
to create an emotional bond with the consumer.
Beloved Brands
The playbook for how to build a
brand your consumers will love.
Analytics Creative Brief
Creative brief
Why are we advertising
Tempt consumers to try Gray’s Cookies because
they are the “best tasting yet guilt free pleasure.”
beloved brands
5 Marketing
Execution
@ beloved brands inc.
Consumer
Marketing
Training