You are on page 1of 17

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/rser

Solar Energy-Powered Battery Electric Vehicle charging stations: Current


development and future prospect review
Kah Yung Yap a, Hon Huin Chin b, *, Jiří Jaromír Klemeš b
a
School of Energy and Chemical Engineering, Xiamen University Malaysia, Jalan Sunsuria, Bandar Sunsuria, 43900, Sepang, Selangor, Malaysia
b
Sustainable Process Integration Laboratory – SPIL, NETME Centre, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Brno University of Technology - VUT Brno, Technická 2896/2,
616 69, Brno, Czech Republic

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Solar energy offers the potential to support the battery electric vehicles (BEV) charging station, which promotes
Solar energy sustainability and low carbon emission. In view of the emerging needs of solar energy-powered BEV charging
Battery electric vehicle (BEV) stations, this review intends to provide a critical technological viewpoint and perspective on the research gaps,
Charging station (CS)
current and future development of solar energy-powered BEV charging stations to fill the gap of the absence of
Vehicle-to-grid (V2G)
Solar power systems
review articles. The current technical limitations of solar energy-powered industrial BEV charging stations
Grid integration include the intermittency of solar energy with the needs of energy storage and the issues of carbon emission and
Energy storage systems (ESS) maintenance of solar arrays. This review article also provides a detailed overview of recent implementations on
solar energy-powered BEV charging stations, pointing out technological gaps and future prospects to serve as a
guideline for academia and industry. The main observations from this review include the hybrid integration of
other renewable energy such as wind or biogas can be a feasible solution to mitigate the intermittency of solar
energy, battery swapping to mitigate the slow charging speed, utilising virtual inertia device to regulate fre­
quency fluctuation that mitigate electricity blackout due to high penetration of solar or other renewable sources
in power grid, and avoiding charging in the periods when the grid electricity has a high content of carbon
emissions. The decentralised operations of energy management should be promoted to allow secured energy
transactions and optimise charging/discharging operations. The optimal choosing criteria for the solar-enabled
BEV are also provided as guidelines for industry or academia.

the technology of BEV has improved tremendously over the decades,


there are inevitable limitations and technical barriers to the adoption of
1. Introduction
BEV due to the hardware and software limitations, as the followings:

Battery electric vehicle (BEV), which is a kind of electric vehicle


(i) The charging of BEV is usually done using the grid power, which
(EV), emphasizes its improvements on sustainability and environmental
is considerably generated by the conventional power generations
friendliness [1]. However, the source of electricity is in many cases
from coal, oil, gas and fossil fuel. The carbon emission of BEVs is
generated by conventional power systems from coal, oil and gas. It vi­
not improved if the aspects charging electricity is considered, as
olates the initial intention of BEV, which is to reduce the environmental
compared to the conventional car without the need for charging.
impact and carbon emission. As the trend of BEV grows significantly
(ii) The charging of BEVs deteriorates the local distribution grid by
after the relentless efforts by the government, BEV manufacturers,
drawing a higher amount of electricity, which may result in
environmental activists and non-government organisations (NGO), it
technical difficulties in voltage regulation, harmonic mitigation
introduces several controversies and technical limitations [2]. As the
and frequency regulation.
popularity of BEV increases with its matured technological advance­
(iii) The demand response (DR) management is burdened when there
ments and environmental sustainability trends, the BEV initially aims to
is the involvement of BEV. The EV battery is also subject to slow
achieve net-zero consumption of non-renewable sources from oil, gas
charging, ageing problem and stability issues.
and fuel as well as near-zero CO2 emission [3], which contributes to
global warming, air pollution and greenhouse effect [4]. Even though

* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: chin@fme.vutbr.cz (H.H. Chin).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2022.112862
Received 30 December 2021; Received in revised form 24 March 2022; Accepted 13 August 2022
Available online 6 September 2022
1364-0321/© 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Abbreviations ML Machine learning


MPP Maximum power point
Acronym Definition MPPT Maximum power point tracking
AC Alternating current NGO Non-government organisations
AI Artificial intelligence P2P Peer to peer
BEV Battery electric vehicle PCC Point of common coupling
BSS Battery-swapping station PEV Plug-in electric vehicles
CS Charging station PHEV Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles
DC Direct current PoW Proof of work
DL Deep learning PSC Partial shading conditions
DR Demand response PV Photovoltaic
EOL End of life RES Renewable energy source
ESS Energy storage system RNN Recurrent neural network
EV Electric vehicle SDG Sustainable development goal
FLC Fuzzy logic controller SM Synchronous machine
ICE Internal combustion engines ULEV Ultra-low emission vehicle
LC Inductor-capacitor V2G Vehicle-to-grid
LSTM Long short-term memory VI Virtual inertia

The most potential renewable energy sources, such as solar energy, (i) The availability of solar energy is usually better and highly
have become an alternative power system to provide electricity for BEV accessible in an urban area for BEV CS as compared to wind and
charging stations (CS). Apart from conventional CS, there is also an hydro.
emerging battery-swapping station (BSS) that swaps the depleted bat­ (ii) The technological maturity of solar power systems is relatively
tery with a fully charged battery [5]. The grid integration of higher as compared to wind and hydropower systems in terms of
solar-powered BEVs is crucial to eliminate the dependency on conven­ grid integration and DC conversion for BEV CS.
tional power sources, which are non-renewable with pollution. In the (iii) Solar power systems generate DC output which is optimal for BEV
foreseeable future, the combination of solar energy and BEV is inevi­ CS, which is dependent on DC-DC fast charging, whereas wind
tably significant to empower the BEV charging process with RES. The and hydropower generate AC. The power conversion from AC to
invention of BEV is aimed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, pollution DC introduces power losses and higher incurring costs.
and noise. It reduces the dependency on fossil fuel and conventional
internal combustion engines (ICE) [6]. Although a huge area or space is required for the installation and
The electricity generation required for BEV charging is also needed deployment of solar panels, some technological breakthroughs such as
to be renewable energy sources (RES) from wind, solar and hydro to flexible solar panels [14], roof solar panels [15] and floating solar panels
fulfil the net-zero initiative in huge declines in the use of coal, oil and gas on the water with water cooling effect [16] have been invented to
by BEV. Wind power is appliable to provide electricity for BEV CS with resolve the space issues encountered by the solar energy. The solar
the support of a storage system [7]. The wind power is readily available power systems exhibit some advantages as compared to the wind power
at a windy location; however, its generated power is in alternate currnet system, the required ESS would be less for wind power because of the
(AC), and it requires a rectifier to convert AC to direct current (DC) for high availability of wind even during nighttime. The manufacturing of
BEV CS. On the contrary, the solar panels are categorised as mono­ wind turbines can be more environmentally friendly than solar panels.
crystalline, polycrystalline and thin-film cells. The solar power systems However, the wind turbines require substantial foundations, in some
exhibit higher stability and contribute to direct DC for BEV CS; however, cases building the extra roads for the construction and also oil to keep
its biggest limitation is unavailability during nighttime. Hydro energy is smoothly running the rotating parts and gearboxes. It is to be noted that
also applicable to contribute electricity for BEV CS; however, due to its the wind turbine blades are still not easily recyclable and can create
large size for dam and its impracticality in the urban area, therefore piling up waste, which create environmental issues. A wind farm can
hydro power is the last choice for BEV CS among RES. generate electricity on a massive scale which can be built offshore, and
As an example, in California, USA, the grid has lowered carbon its generated electricity is much higher than solar panels but requires
emissions by more than 70% near zero-carbon by mandating zero- high land availability for the turbines. The choice of solar over wind
emission BEV deployment [8]. The BEV charging infrastructure in the power is due to the geolocation of BEV CS, which exhibits lesser wind
UK is promising, supported by ultra-low emission vehicle (ULEV) and consists of a roof. The solar array is more feasible to be installed in
strategy and aggressive emission targets [9]. Solar power exhibits some BEV CS than wind turbine or hydropower, which requires larger space.
limitations and shortcomings. The intermittency of solar irradiance (EE) A bidirectional EV charging system with a multi-controller is
and temperature (T) under dynamic weather and partial shading con­ required for EV CS. The revolution of electric vehicle (EV) [17] and also
ditions (PSC) is the major challenge for solar power. Plus, a maximum [18] and vehicle-to-grid (V2G) [19] systems are trending and sprouting
power point tracking (MPPT) controller is mandatory to track the global in recent years due to technological maturity and policy changes. A
maximum power point (GMPP) and maximise power extraction due to survey has been conducted to assess the car-buyers willingness to buy
the non-linearities of I–V and P–V curves [10]. The lack of virtual inertia product-bundles of solar power and EV in Germany [20]. The study
(VI) in solar energy [11] is also asynchronous with the modern power showed that there is a higher willingness to buy a bundle of an EV and
system and results in power instability issues [12]. Synchronverter or solar, despite the additional cost compared to a standalone EV CS. Solar
virtual-inertia (VI)-based inverters are used to mitigate this issue by energy charging for EVs is also deployed in two Scandinavian cities with
emulating the dynamic behaviour of a synchronous machine (SM) [13]. scenario-based modelling [21]. EVs include the commercial and private
The solar power system is chosen for BEV CS instead of wind and hy­ usage types, namely private electric vehicles (PREVs) and electric taxis
dropower due to the following reasons: (ETs), which are very common in developing and developed cities [22].
The recent researches of EV improvements include battery fault

2
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

diagnosis [23], V2G [24] and power stability [25]. bus via a rectifier to support the solar energy EV CS whenever the solar
In recent research publications, the paper in Ref. [26] focuses on the energy is not available. The energy storage system (ESS) is also appli­
control and safety aspects of the solar EV CS, available technologies, cable to be connected at the DC bus for the energy storage purposes of
economic and environmental aspects, as well as proposing future tech­ solar energy. The solar energy-powered EV CS can be on-grid (grid-­
nologies from a macro perspective. While this current manuscript pro­ connected) or off-grid (standalone) [32]. For on-grid type, the existing
vides more comprehensive details in terms of the detailed technical grid can support the solar energy-powered EV CS when there is a lack of
electrical components study and modelling for the technology, and also solar power or whenever there is excessive generated electricity from
reviewed several industrial implementations of the solar EV CS tech­ solar energy, and it can be sent back to the grid via an inverter. For
nologies. This paper mainly is to point out the technical limitations of EV off-grid type, it is typically located at remote area, house area or
CS, focusing mainly on the battery EV ranging from macro to micro standalone usage for individual type. It also can be a hybrid generation,
aspects. On the other hand, another review paper emphasizes the supported by fuel cell, existing conventional power generation,
technical and feasibility aspects of the charging system in EV CS, with hydrogen generation, energy storage, diesel generator and others energy
brief reviews of the application and technology description. This paper sources. The hybrid type usually deals with the uncertainties of solar
specifies in more detail the technologies in terms of their practical usage energy under dynamic weather, PSC and nighttime.
and limitations, as well as outlines more recent industrial applications
[27]. A review paper in Ref. [28] discusses the electric vehicle (EV) with 2.1. Solar power system for BEV
energy management system and sources, instead of the electric vehicle
charging station (EV CS). It is focused on the EV components and solar By definition, a solar power system for BEV is the utilisation of solar
for the EV itself, instead of solar energy for the charging station (CS). energy for electricity generation to charge the BEV at BEV CS. As
The motivations of this review are driven by the lack of technical depicted in Fig. 1, the typical circuit topology of a solar energy-powered
review of practical implementation in terms of solar energy-powered BEV CS has been presented with the grid and ESS support. This type of
BEV CS. Plus, the recent BEV CS is mainly powered by conventional system is a three-phase grid-connected solar power BEV CS with ESS
power systems generated from non-renewable sources such as coal, oil support. The solar array converts the solar irradiance (EE) to DC elec­
and gas, and the implementations of solar energy into BEV CS are still tricity and is connected to the DC link at the point of common coupling
limited in the real world. A proper identification for real world design (PCC). There are generally two types of solar charging stations for BEV,
constraints and technical limitations that restrict the advancing of solar which consist of on-grid BEV CS and off-grid BEV CS. As the name
BEV CS are yet to be defined. A more proper energy trading system suggests, on-grid means the BEV CS is connected to the grid to support
considering solar BEV CS needs to be studied as well. Based on the the solar power system. If there is excessive generated electricity, the
research gaps analysed, this review article intends to: user can sell back the electricity to the utility company. On the contrary,
off-grid implies that the BEV CS is not connected to the power grid but
(i) Provide the most recent implementations of solar-powered EV CS rather dependent on the standalone solar energy system, which requires
with the latest features and capabilities to envision future zero- ESS and other hybrid RES to mitigate its lack of electricity during
carbon EV CS using RES. nighttime.
(ii) Identify the research gaps, hardware limitations and technical The inductor-capacitor (LC) filter is used to attenuate the current and
difficulties of the existing solar-powered EV CS for future voltage ripples, which are produced by the electronic switching process
research direction. of converters [33]. The ripple filter is also used to reduce and minimise
(iii) Provide future prospects and recommendations for the next- the switching harmonics and smoothen the current and voltage. Fig. 2
generation solar-powered EV CS to further accelerate the high depicts the typical block diagram of a RES-powered BEV CS with ESS
efficiency and net-zero emission for the EV charging process. support. ESS is used to provide additional power whenever there is a
shortage of electricity from RES [34]. In general, a solar power-enabled
This paper is organised as follows. The technical overview of the BES CS commonly consists of these components:
solar energy-powered EV CS has been discussed in Section II. It follows
section III with the recent implementations, improvements and prac­ (i) Solar array or panel: solar panels consist of PV cells that convert
tical, real-world usages. Section IV presents the technical difficulties, sunlight to DC outputs.
limitations and research gaps of the existing solution. Eventually, the (ii) Inverter: Converts DC to AC for charging EV.
paper ends with future recommendations in Section V and a conclusion (iii) Electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE): Includes interface,
in Section VI. software, electrical conductors and protocols to safely manage
the charging process into EV battery.
2. Overview of Solar Energy-powered BEV CS (iv) ESS: Store excessive electricity from solar during daylight and
support the solar power system during nighttime.
This chapter reviews the technical aspects of a solar energy-powered
EV CS. In the past, the adoption of EVs didn’t look promising. However, Compared to the conventional on-grid EV CS without solar energy,
in recent years, the EV including plug-in electric vehicles (PEVs) [29], solar-enabled BEV CS exhibits the following advantages:
plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) [30] and full EV have been
tremendously developed and adopted. The trend of EV is accelerated by a) True net carbon zero as the conventional power grid is still gener­
the Government’s policy, sustainability development goals (SDG) and ating electricity from oil, gas and coal.
net-zero emission initiative. A solar energy-powered EV CS is simply a b) Reliability: The hybrid combination of solar energy and battery
conventional EV CS that uses the electricity generated by the solar storage leads to higher reliability even under power outages or low
power systems with ESS and power grid support. Typically, the solar sunlight.
panel produces DC output which is further optimised by a DC-DC con­ c) Cost-saving: Efficient electricity conversion from RES ensures lower
verter with MPPT capability [31]. The DC bus is used to universally energy losses and carbon emission.
interface the optimised output of solar and DC chargers for EV. It is d) P2P energy trading: Blockchain may enable P2P energy trading with
advantageous that solar power produces DC, which requires no further secured transactions between EV CS and EV.
power conversion, unlike the conventional AC grid, which requires e) Clean energy: The usage of RES for EV reduces carbon emission by
AC-DC conversion. It leads to unwanted power losses, slower charging eliminating conventional power generation and fossil fuel-powered
speed and lesser energy efficiency. The grid is also connected to the DC vehicles.

3
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Fig. 1. The circuit topology of an on-grid solar energy-powered BEV CS with grid and ESS support.

Fig. 3. The types of interactions between BEV CS, solar power, ESS and
power grid.

time and BEV driven distances.


( )
Es − dd −η drb ηinv
(1)
v
PV2G =
tdisp

Fig. 2. The typical block diagram of a RES-powered BEV CS. where PV2G is the power from V2G in kW, Es is the stored energy
available for inverter, dd is the distance driven in km from the fully
2.2. B. EV CS architecture and main considerations charged battery, drb is the distance in km, which is the minimum
remaining range required by the driver before charging is required at the
In this subchapter, the architecture of a BEV CS and its main design nearest EV CS, ηv is the vehicle driving efficiency, ηinv is the inverter
considerations have been discussed. The operation of solar energy- efficiency and tdisp is the dispatch time of the vehicle’s stored energy in
powered BEV CS can be four modes, but not limited to, namely unidi­ hours. On the other hand, the changing time of an EV is dependent on
rectional PV-to-vehicle (PV2V), PV-to-grid (PV2G), bidirectional V2G the division of battery capacitor by charging power of an EV CS, as
and vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V). For battery modes, it includes unidirec­ shown in Equation (2).
tional PV-to-battery (PV2B), battery-to-vehicle (B2V) and bidirectional Battery Capacity (kWh)
grid-to-battery (G2B), as illustrated in Fig. 3. V2G equation is typically Charging time (h) = (2)
Charging Power (kW)
expressed in Equation (1), where the power generated by V2G is
dependent on the inverter and vehicle efficiency, stored energy, dispatch To charge a BEV, the EV CS can provide AC or DC power. For AC

4
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

power from EV CS, the EV should come with a built-in onboard charger to power 21,000 km of electric driving each year. The estimation of
that converts power from AC to DC, then feeds it into a car DC battery. calculation is based on the current average values with the latest
AC power is the more common charging method for BEV. On the con­ standards.
trary, DC charging in BEV CS is equipped with an AC-DC converter or As compared to the total generated solar electricity in the UK was
rectifier in the charger itself. It is generally faster, bigger and better as approximately 549 MWh on December 28, 2021, the needed electricity
compared to AC charging, in terms of energy conversion, charging speed to charge the BEV and PHEV is around 107 MWh, given the BEVs have
and energy efficiency [35]. The most common AC charging capacities approximately 365,000 units and PHEVs have 705,000 units, as of
are rated at 3.7 kW and 22 kW [36]. November 2021 [48] and assuming the battery of each BEV is around
There are three types of DC chargers, namely combined charging 100 kW. The solar electricity needed is around 20% of the total gener­
systems (CCS), CHAdeMO and Tesla Supercharger [37]. CCS is the open ated solar for all BEV and PHEV, given that the whole solar power sys­
and universal standard for EV, combining single-phase, three-phase AC tem in the UK is optimally operating under sunlight and the needed
and DC in Europe and US. On the contrary, CHAdeMO is the DC charging electricity is for a single charge only. The power grid and ESS are still
standard for EV, developed by CHAdeMO Association, while Tesla Su­ needed to contribute most of the needed electricity for BEV charging.
percharger is Tesla’s own proprietary DC charger. For Tesla Super­ Overall, the limitations of solar energy-powered BEV CS include the
charger, it takes only 20–30 min to charge up to 80% of the battery from need for the power grid, large capacity of ESS, e.g. 51,660 kW of lithium
0%, and takes around 1 h for a full charge, depending on the state of the battery and required huge land size with more than 334 m2. These
battery, operating temperature, charging rate variation, environmental limitations are preventing the BEV CS from going towards full zero
factors and power conversion efficiency [38]. Although the efficiency is carbon emission electricity generation. Obviously, more research and
relatively high for EV CS, it demands a huge current drawing and ca­ breakthroughs in technology development should be conducted to
pacity of high kWh due to the nature of the battery EV. In solar power mitigate the research gaps.
systems, the output is DC [39], and assuming the DC output of solar is For the BEV CS application, the operating output voltage (VO) of the
directly connected to EV CS, the typical solar power system output is solar panel is expected to be approximately 200–500 VDC. The solar
around 500 to 800 VDC. If it is used to charge a Tesla model, the adapter irradiance (EE) and operating temperature (T) are the components of the
used is rated as 200 A and 100–800 VDC. The BEV CS can be categorised main input that will affect the power from solar. Due to the non-
into four categories, i.e. slow (3–5 kW), fast (7–22 kW), rapid (25–99 linearities of I–V and P–V of solar panels, varying temperature and
kW), and ultra-rapid (100 kW+) power rating. In general, a standard irradiance will affect the output power from the solar panel. It would
polycrystalline solar panel i s sized at 1.75 m2 and produces 275 W–350 eventually reduce the optimised power output of solar, resulting in low
W, ideally at a 20% efficiency rate under the full sun [40]. power conversion efficiency. As shown in Fig. 4 (a) and (b), there are
For instance, assuming the BEV is a Tesla 3 Standard Range model, visible temperature and irradiance effects on the current and power
its onboard charger is rated as 7.7 kW (32 A) [41]. Given the BEV CS is output of solar panels. When the temperature is higher, the output is
the most powerful 3-phase AC 400 V with 32 A, the charging speed limited. Similarly, when the irradiance is lower, i.e. shady, the power
would be 49.1 km/h, and the charging time would be 4 h and 20 min.
The socket output is rated as 22.2 kW; however, the charging speed is
limited by the car’s onboard charger, which can only run at 7.7 kW. The
average charging efficiency is approximately 90%, 10% is lost in elec­
trical conductors, heat and conversion by converters [42].
Assuming it is nighttime or bad weather without sunlight, the ESS
needed to be designed to accommodate the charging of 500 EVs, given
the BEV CS is a large-scale charging station. Given that the 500 EVs are
Tesla Model 3 with 82 kWh battery [43], and the total required power
would be 41,000 kWh, assuming these EVs are empty charged. The ESS
efficiency is approximately rated as 80% for a lead-acid battery and 95%
for a lithium battery [44]. The size of the lead-acid battery would be 41,
000 kWh*2*1.2 = 98,400 kWh. Noted that multiply by 2 is for 50%
depth of discharge, and 1.2 is the 1/0.8 of inefficiency factor. On the
contrary, for lithium batteries, the required size would be 41,000
kWh*1.2*1.05 = 51,660 kWh. Noted that multiply by 1.22 is for 80%
depth of discharge, and 1.05 is the 1/0.95 of inefficiency factor. It is
observed that the required capacity of a lithium battery is much smaller
than the lead-acid battery due to the compact sizing, technology and
high energy efficiency of the lithium battery [45]. It is observed that a
huge capacity of the lead-acid battery or lithium battery is required for
BEV CS to backup the unavailability of solar energy during nighttime.
The costing, maintenance and service of ESS are not feasible for the
long-time operation of BEV CS. The battery sizing is also subject to the
ambient temperature, seasonal factor and budget. The weather with too
cold or hot operating temperature could affect the battery efficiency and
stored capacitor as well [46]. During winter or any challenging weather
due to storm or rainy days, the days are shorter, and the peak sun hours
are further reduced to 1–2 h; the solar panels are only available to
produce 200 Wh to 700 Wh per panel. Solar power is undeniably
insufficient to charge BEV efficient, and ESS and power grid should be
standing by to provide a major part of the power of BEV CS. In reality,
the solar power system is only able to support the BEV CS with a smaller
amount of contribution by using energy management systems (EMS) Fig. 4. The I–V and P–V characteristics of the solar array under the variation of
[47]. In general, 10 solar panels can provide roughly enough electricity (a) solar irradiance (Ee) and (b) operating temperature (T).

5
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

output of solar is also limited. Partial shading condition (PSC) is also (i) Conventional EV charger
affecting the output of solar, and maximum power point tracking (ii) Solar panel array, which can be installed on roof, ground or
(MPPT) and electronically controlled mechanical tilting of solar panels canopy
are used to maximise the power output of solar, regardless of tempera­ (iii) Battery energy storage system in case of night time or off-grid
ture and irradiance inputs. A typical solar power system is defined as solar-enabled BEV CS
Equation (3) in terms of its solar power and voltage, where P is the active (iv) A solid foundation for the parking of EV
power, V is the voltage, and I is the current. (v) Intelligent software or energy management system (EMS) with
smart charging and payment gateway
dP d(IV) dI ΔI
= =I +V =I + V (3)
dV dV dV ΔV
From Table 1, it is observed that the solar energy-powered BEV CS
The main parameters and considerations needed to be taken before typically lacks MPPT optimisation, which can lead to power instability
the design of solar energy-powered BEV CS include the following: by PSC and shading conditions. Plus, the current research on EV CS
needs more AI integration for its optimisation of algorithms. The V2G is
(i) Solar panel sizing, connections and rated power output. emerging because of its ability to exchange energy in both ways between
(ii) Weather consideration and placement of solar panel (i.e. on BEV and the power grid. It is a good indicator that peer to peer (P2P)
rooftop, awning, land and etc.). energy trading will be soon available to enable V2G with blockchain
(iii) BEV charging demand response and types of BEV battery. security. The BEV users can enjoy transparent and faster transactions of
(iv) Charging topology (DC charging or AC charging). energy exchange between their BEV cars and power grids.
(v) ESS support for solar power systems. In [53], solar power systems have been implemented with battery
(vi) Stand-alone or grid-connected mode. and diesel generators for BEV CS. The diesel generator is used to back up
the unavailability of solar power during the nighttime. However, it is not
There is either unidirectional or bidirectional power flow for the in line with sustainability and will cause an environmental impact. In
charging. Power conditioning and load management unit are crucial to Ref. [50], the parking lots have been intelligently utilised to charge BEV
condition and manage the power flow to the load of BEV. The BEV via solar panels. It is effectively utilising the space given by the parking
Charging Unit is placed at the parking bay for BEV to charge [49]. The lots while installing the solar panel in available space in the parking lot
parking area is designated beside the BEV Charging Unit for easier to charge BEV CS. The power grid is also connected to support solar
accessibility. The solar PV arrays are recommended to be placed above panels during nighttime. On the contrary, the dynamic charging
the roof of the parking area/lot [50] or any designated areas such as scheduling has been deployed for BEV parking lots using solar power
shopping mall rooftop, awning [51] or rooftop [52]. Assuming a stan­ systems [54]. The difference is there is a dynamic charging scheduling
dard polycrystalline solar panel produces around 275 W–350 W, with a scheme (DCSS) to manage the BEV charging process based on model
20% efficiency rate. Its size is approximately 1.75 m2. Given that there is predictive control (MPC). The power grid is used as a backup whenever
only 1 h of peak sun hours with maximum irradiance, assuming the the solar is unable to generate clean energy. It is notable that the un­
worst-case scenario of winter short days or thunderstorms, one solar availability of solar during nighttime will be a challenging technical
panel will generate around 300 Wh. Assuming that to charge a Tesla issue, but it can be resolved by using hybrid power systems integrating
Model 3 for 65 km range in daily drive, we have 9.6 kWh/300 Wh = 32 wind power or non-RES and ESS support. In contrast, the stability issues
of the solar panels required. The total size of 32 solar panels will be 56 of a single-area load frequency control (LFC) system have been discussed
m2 in land size. If a BEV CS has 20 charging ports and stations which are in investigated in Ref. [55], particularly in electric vehicle (EV)
used to serve 20 BEV every hour, the solar panels should be at least 640 aggregators.
panels of 1,120 m2 in land size, in extreme weather with short days In [54], BEV parking lots are powered by a photovoltaic power
during thunderstorms or winter. system with a dynamic charging scheduling feature. The scheduling
ensures the efficient and economical operation of parking lot CS due to
3. Technological advancements of solar EV CS the uncertainty and fluctuation of solar energy. The system design for
solar-powered BEV CS has been proposed in Ref. [71]. Another chal­
This section presents the most recent implementations and research lenge of solar energy-powered BEV CS is that solar energy is available
on the solar energy-based BEV CS. In general, most of the solar energy- during day time, but the BEV is not in the building for charging. On the
powered BEV CS is dependent on ESS or the power grid for the continued contrary, at nighttime, solar energy is unavailable, but the BEV is ready
availability of electricity to overcome the unavailability of solar during to be charged. An adaptable charging and discharging pattern are
nighttime. designed in Ref. [72] to charge BEV efficiently while handling the un­
availability of solar during nighttime. On the other hand, the optimal
3.1. Recent implementations scheduling strategy is designed to enable emission trading for energy
hubs with energy storage and BEV [73]. It is to improve the emission
Solar energy can be utilised to charge the BEV. It can be implemented reduction and optimise the energy system. The energy management
either in the household (home), outdoor shopping malls, charging sta­ strategy of aggregator for solar power systems and BEV is applicable to
tions (CS), parking lots and other places which are applicable to put the manage the real-time operation of solar and BEV simultaneously [74].
BEV charger. For household usage, solar energy can even support other The aggregator can be used for stability enhancement in load frequency
loads as the surplus of excessive solar energy can be used in the control systems as well [55].
household. Usually, the design of solar energy-powered BEV CS includes A fast-charging station for BEV can also be powered by the combi­
the consideration of grid involvement (Off-grid/On-grid), charging nation of solar and battery based on Queueing theory and genetic al­
strategy (Model types), local energy storage (ESS), other power sources gorithm with optimised charging management [75]. Two-stage
(e.g. wind power or power grid), V2G capability and other features. stochastic mixed-integer non-linear programming is used to optimise the
Table 1 shows the most recent implementations of solar energy-powered location and sizing of EV CS and solar PV plants by taking solar gener­
BEV CS. Typically, the BEV CS is designed and proposed with the grid ation and EV traffic flows into design criteria. On the other hand, a
integration of solar power system in terms of optimal scheduling for probabilistic methodology can be deployed to optimise the EV loads at
charging, energy trading, hybrid operation of wind and solar, V2G and solar-powered EV CS in terms of power loss, voltage profile, average
ESS management. Typically, a solar-enabled BEV CS includes the voltage deviation index and voltage stability index [76]. In Ref. [77], it
following: was found out that the combination of solar PV, wind and batteries is the

6
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Table 1
The Selected Implementations of Solar energy-powered BEV CS from the year 2016–2022.
Ref. Model Design PV Array Harmonic ESS Support Application Finding
MPPT Mitigation

[53] Solar PV and Diesel With Less than 5% Battery energy storage EV CS Optimal operation of EV CS under dynamic
Generator EV CS (BES) weathers, solar irradiance level, changes in the EV
charging current and change in the loading
[56] Solar Assisted EV CS – – – Urban area Optimised model for planning the locations and
sizes of solar energy-powered EV CS in a city area
[57] Energy management Perturb and 3.1% (THD of Electric vehicle battery Support distribution grid To reduce the unexpected peak power demand and
for solar EV CS Observe grid current) (EVB) as an energy via EV CS assist in vehicle-to-grid (V2G) for the stability of the
(P&O) MPPT storage system (ESS) grid during peak load
[58] P2P operation for – – – P2P energy transaction To enable P2P energy trading between EV CS and
solar EV CS solar generation
[59] Optimal scheduling – – Energy storage system Optimal scheduling Optimally schedule the EV charging at solar energy-
of solar charging (ESS) powered CS for lower pricing, lesser computational
time and better accommodation of EV charging
[60] Solar and diesel With Less than 5% Storage battery Multimode operation of Enable the integration of solar energy, power grid,
generator for EV CS solar, grid, battery and battery and diesel generator for the operation of EV
diesel generator for EV CS CS even under varying conditions
[61] Batter for EV CS and – – – V2G Support power grid with V2G functionality by
V2G utilising the available EV battery
[62] Real-time EV CS – – Building energy EV Charging management A real-time EV charging management is designed
charging management system for commercial building by for the BEMS in a commercial building with solar
management (BEMS) on-site solar generation on-site power generation and EV CS
[63] Off-grid solar EV CS – – – Off-grid EV at a long-term Off-grid solar photovoltaic (PV) system to charge EV
parking location at a long-term parking lot
[64] Solar EV CS – – – Coordination between solar Matched the temporal nature of PV generation and
PV generation and EV EV charging for better PV and EV integration level
charging
[65] Solar EV CS With – EV battery as energy EV Charging at the Charge EV at the workplace by using solar panel
storage workplace using rooftop which is placed on the rooftop of the workplace
solar buildings
[66] Solar EV CS with With – Li-ion battery V2G EV CS with V2G technology by grid-connected solar
V2G power system
[50] A parking lot for EV With – Battery A parking lot for solar- Utilised parking lots with a solar panel to charge EV.
CS charge EV V2G enables the EV to support the grid back with
ancillary service
[67] Solar-wind EV CS With – Battery V2G by solar and wind- Combination of solar and wind power for EV CS
powered EV CS with V2G technology
[68] Solar-wind hybrid – – Battery Optimisation of wind and To optimise and design hybrid wind and solar
EV CS solar power for EV CS using energy EV CS for better performance and stability
HOMER Software under dynamic weather
[69] A multi-objective – – ESS An optimisation model for Hybrid optimisation algorithms consist of Multi-
optimisation model fast EV CS by using wind Objective Particle Swarm Optimisation (MOPSO)
for EV CS and solar energy with ESS algorithm and Technique for Order Preference by
Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) method are
used to optimise EV CS by wind and solar power
with ESS. It improves the demand response, the
performance on optimisation objectives and
computational speed
[70] Dynamic energy Perturb and – ESS Energy management EV CS is designed by using a solar power system and
management for Observe strategy (EMS) for an EVCS EMS at a residential level. The ESS is used to support
solar EV CS (P&O) MPPT at a residential level the solar energy-powered EV CS for standalone
mode and satisfying the requirements of EV
charging.

most optimal for EV CS in off-grid configuration. A fuzzy logic controller quantitative optimisation model [83], linear programming (LP)-based
(FLC) is also applicable in the modelling of EV CS using a solar PV system optimisation [84], Asynchronous Q-learning [85] and others. The main
to achieve maximum power point (MPP) in the maximum power point features of solar energy-powered BEV CS include the following:
tracking (MPPT) controller [78]. Hydrogen, biogas and fuel cells are also
feasible solutions to support the limitations of solar PV in BEV CS, 1. Electrical ancillary services: The harmonics are mitigated, and the
especially the hydrogen can be used as energy storage for BEV CS [79]. A reactive power (Q) is supported by using the CS. The power quality of
solar-driven and hydrogen-integrated charging station are possible to the voltage and current are maintained by maintaining the total
improve the efficiency of the existing solar-enabled BEV CS. harmonic distortion (THD) within 5% as required by the IEEE 1547
Solar energy has been utilised for a level-2 BEV CS, which is standard.
controlled by a Type-1 vehicle connector. Both experimental [65] and 2. Low carbon emission, sustainability and environmentally friendly: The
simulation results [80] validated that solar energy is a feasible way for integration of solar energy for charging makes the solar energy-
EV CS during daytime for affordable energy conversion from solar. The powered BEV more environmentally friendly. Instead of depending
installation of a solar array for BEV CS globally will accelerate the on conventional power generation from coal, oil and gas, the EV is
adoption of BEV and RES while increasing the location of BEV CS and supposed to be environmentally friendly. The carbon dioxide emis­
extending the driving range of BEVs in different areas. There are various sion is reduced significantly for BEV charging by using solar energy.
types of optimisations available for solar-powered BEV CS, namely 3. Optimum utilisation of DG and RES: Solar energy is able to be fully
Markov decision process [81], Joint capacity optimisation [82], utilised for EV CS instead of wasting it during daytime due to

7
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

excessive generation of electricity from solar energy. The ESS is Table 2


applicable to support the BEV CS during nighttime. The demand The practical implementations of solar-enabled BEV CS.
response (DR) is lower when solar energy is used to support BEV CS Industrial Location Modes Features and Limitations
instead of solely dependent on grid connection. Providers assumption
4. DC to DC without conversion loss and technical difficulties: Unlike Empower San Diego, On- EV with solar Solar energy
conventional AC grid, which is required to convert to DC before Solar United States grid power charging standard
charging the EV, the solar energy is produced in DC form under (US) and stations limitations,
MPPT DC-DC converter. It implies that the elimination of complex off- required
grid maintenance and
AC-DC rectification process and energy conversion loss is possible. ESS, highly
Plus, the DC charging from solar is proven to be faster than AC dependent on
charging or AC-DC converted charging. solar
5. Advanced energy trading platform: The purchase of electricity gener­ Sinovoltaics Hong Kong On- Solar charging Solar energy
and grid stations for EVs standard
ated from local solar energy is possible for BEV CS. Plus, the
Shanghai, and with on-grid and limitations,
emerging blockchain is also applicable for peer-to-peer (P2P) energy China off- off-grid required
trading with a secured transaction, decentralised platform and grid maintenance and
competitive energy trading. ESS, highly
dependent on
solar
3.2. real-world practical usage Envision California, On- Solar power for Solar energy
Solar United States grid EV CS standard
There are various real-world practical implementations of solar en­ (US) and limitations,
ergy for BEV CS around the world. Envision Solar has implemented off- required
grid maintenance and
solar-powered electric charging stations without the need for a power
ESS, highly
grid. Empower Solar has paired the BEV CS with a solar system to dependent on
maximise electricity saving and energy efficiency. It is intended to solar
charge the BEV within hours using the BEV CS powered by solar energy. Electrify California, Off- Rural Required ESS for
SunPower, another solar power specialist, utilises a mobile application America United States grid electrification of off-grid solar-
(US) solar-powered enabled CS
(app) to enable homeowners to assess and manage the energy usage, charging station
settings and generation. SunPower is also using solar energy to charge Solar Edge Israel, United On- With Solar energy
the BEV for a greener lifestyle. States (US), grid, smartphones standard
In Australia, as the amounts of BEVs increases, the charging infra­ France, Italy off- control limitations,
grid required
structure is also growing at the same pace. There is an industrial
maintenance and
collaboration between the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial ESS, highly
Research Organisation (CSIRO), Nissan Australia and Delta Electronics, dependent on
which focus on the integration of renewable energy for BEV CS. CSIRO is solar
an Australian Government agency responsible for scientific research. ELUM Energy France, On- Solar charging Required smart
Morocco, grid, station for charging and
The solar power has been assisted for BEV CS by installing on an existing South Africa V2G electric vehicles V2G algorithm
infrastructure of 1121 Petronas fuel stations [86]. PLUS North-South On- Highway Routine
HES PV provides solar charging stations for BEVs, including Nissan highway Expressway grid, application with maintenance of
Leaf, Tesla, Electric Smart Cars and MIEVS. Net metering is also enabled and Tenaga (NSE) off- solar-powered solar, downtime
Nasional Malaysia grid BEV CS during nighttime
to allow selling back excessive generated electricity from solar. A
Berhad
MicroBlox was invented to contain AC solar modules for easier instal­ (TNB)
lation with scalability. In Bangladesh, hybrid RES-based BEV CS has Paired Power California, On- Grid outage Solar energy
been deployed by using solar energy and biogas generator using the United States grid, proof standard
Hybrid Optimisation of Multiple Energy Renewables (HOMER) Pro (US) off- limitations
grid required
software [87]. It reduces CO2 emissions by at least 34.68% compared to maintenance and
a conventional grid-based charging station based on non-RES. In the ESS, highly
construction site located in Beijing, China, a fast-charging BEV CS based dependent on
on solar power has been deployed and installed to reduce the charging solar
time [88]. Table 2 shows the practical implementations of industrial
solar-enabled BEV CS.
integration of higher shares of residential solar power systems for BEV
CS [94]. A fast-charging station has been designed for distributed
3.3. Improvements on the solar power-based EV CS
photovoltaic (PV) power generation for BEV CS [88] to reduce the
charging time. Table 3 shows the main differences between the con­
MPPT with charging current protection is also applicable for solar
ventional BEV CS from the power grid and the solar energy-powered
PV-powered BEV applications to allow different types of BEV charging
BEV CS.
[89]. It is to ensure the charging is done within the rated values of BEV
while maintaining the optimal power output of solar PV. Short-term
4. Limitations and research gaps
solar forecasting is also used for BEV charge scheduling and optimisa­
tion [90]. The capacity of BEV CS is optimally determined by varying the
This section details and discusses the limitations of the solar energy-
charging speed and incorporating solar, battery and diesel hybrid gen­
powered BEV CS. In general, the solar energy-powered BEV CS faces
eration [91]. This is due to the uncertainty of the parameters involved in
some major limitations and gaps, such as the common problems of solar
stochastic programming and BEV CS. Smart charging is also deployed in
power systems, including the intermittency of solar energy and power
Ref. [92] to enable the generation of electricity from solar energy for the
quality issues.
usage of BEV charging. Low-voltage constraints have been considered to
optimally charge the BEV with solar energy [93]. By using the BEV with
controlled charging, it exhibits the potential to accelerate the

8
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Table 3 ESS plays a crucial role in power systems to smoothen the intermit­
The Comparison between Conventional BEV CS with Solar energy-powered BEV tency of RES while maintaining its operating stability, specifically for
CS. solar power systems [100]. For instance, in Ref. [101], ESS has been
Parameters Conventional BEV CS Solar energy-powered used for solar photovoltaic for rural electrification in Myanmar. It is a
BEV CS standalone ESS which is working independently with solar power sys­
RES Depends Yes tems with the connection of the power grid. The ESS is also subject to
Availability 99–100%, depends on the power grid Only during the energy management and optimisation in a deregulated power market
daytime without [102]. The optimisation of ESS, including its control methods, algo­
battery
rithms, ESS sizing, power quality, reliability, connection mode and other
Stability High stability Low stability
Carbon emission Yes, during electricity generation Lower up to 90% [95] relevant parameters, are required to be identified for low-carbon emis­
from non-RES sion [103]. Nevertheless, more components imply more maintenance
The need for Depending on the design Yes required and ageing problem. The ESS is required to be replaced after
battery storage certain charging/discharging intervals. The transparency of BEV CS is
Off-grid and on- Only on-grid because off-grid is not Both are applicable
grid capable of generating own electricity
doubtful without the proper regulations and applicable laws. The price
Scalability Yes Yes transparency of a BEV CS is subject to the system and pricing mecha­
Blockchain- Yes Yes nism. It can be solved by using blockchain by decentralising the BEV
enabled charging system. By removing the centralised system, the blockchain is
more transparent and accessible to all consumers and prosumers.
C. P.f. correction, harmonic mitigation, lack of VI and charging speed
4.1. The intermittency of solar energy
& capabilities.
Power quality is greatly affected by RES, specifically solar energy.
Solar energy typically is affected adversely by partial shading con­
This is due to the fast-interacting, intermittent, high fluctuation and
ditions (PSC), dynamic weather, dirty solar panel glass and conversion
non-dispatchable natures of solar, which is highly dependent on solar
loss in power electronics. The dynamic weather is the main challenge for
irradiance and temperature. The voltage and current stabilities of the
solar energy as the conversion from solar energy to electrical energy is
power grid are deteriorated by solar energy. When there is uncontrolled
highly dependent on the solar irradiance (EE) and operating temperature
charging without any intelligent controller, the BEV will be charged at
(T). The non-linearities of P–V and I–V curves are due to the dynamic
full power as soon as it has started charging. It will degrade the power
weather and PSC. The MPPT is crucial to overcome the dynamic
quality and stability by introducing frequency and voltage fluctuation.
weather, non-linearities and PSC by searching for global maximum
Moreover, grid overload is possible, and demand response w be affected.
power point (GMPP) instead of local maximum power point (LMPP) in
A bidirectional current-controlled BEV CS based on CHAdeMO 1.1
the P–V curve. Although the development of MPPT is relatively mature,
standard charging protocol and a master power factor controller is
there are still some concerns about the intermittency of solar energy.
applicable to correct the power factor in a solar power system [104].
Solar energy is not available all day long, especially during cloudy,
Demand response is also crucial to managing the BEV CS with minimised
rainy, stormy and nighttime. However, the BEV CS is required to be
energy cost and maximised power efficiency [105]. It is to protect the
operatable 24/7 all day long to ensure the operatable mileage of the
BEV CS from power outages. Voltage quality is also a major concern for
BEV. Overall, the grid integration of renewable energy sources (RES)
solar-powered BEV CS [106]. Voltage unbalances, undervoltage, or
and BEV introduces uncertainties and intermittency in the power sys­
overvoltage are the concerns for the use of solar power generation for
tem, affecting its operating stability [96]. Plus, the solar panel instal­
BEV CS. The charging speed of BEV CS can be slow due to a lack of high
lation and deployment require a huge space or area, which may
voltage support and high demand response.
contribute to space constraint or deforestation, which is not in line with
SDG goals. Plus, the wastages and potential pollution caused by the
manufacturing, disposal and ageing of solar panels, ESS and other 4.2. The lifespan of solar panels and their relevant maintenance
relevant components are inevitably unavoidable. Life cycle assessment
(LCA) and technological breakthroughs should be implemented to The electronics components and solar panels are subject to wear and
further reduce any pollution and wastages caused by the manufacturing, tear. The ageing of solar panels and other relevant components will
disposal and ageing of solar energy-powered BEV CS components. The contribute to additional costs. Plus, the solar panel glass should be
heat exposed by the solar array from sunlight is also affecting the effi­ cleaned occasionally or in a routine manner to ensure maximum power
ciency of solar panel power output adversely. extraction as the glass tends to be subject to dirt, dust or substances.
B. The need for an energy storage system (ESS) during nighttime and However, in recent research, such as [107], an antireflective,
BEV charging energy trading transparency. self-cleaning solar panel is possible with superhydrophobic polymers to
A solar power system is known for its lack of power generation reduce the cleaning maintenance. The thermal stability of the battery,
during nighttime without any presence of solar irradiance. However, supercapacitor or ultracapacitor used in the BEV is also a concerning
this limitation can be resolved by the support of an energy storage sys­ element for the stability of a hybrid energy storage system [108]. The
tem (ESS), which consists of a Li-ion battery, lead-acid battery, super­ lifespans of solar panels, BEV and batteries are subject to thermal, power
capacitor and ultracapacitor. In the current trend, ESS has been grown system stability and environmental factors. Due to its complexity and
and developed tremendously to support solar energy. For instance high quantities of elements, the solar energy-powered BEV CS requires
Ref. [97], introduces the reused EV batteries as an ESS in China for higher maintenance costs, frequent service routines and additional care.
distributed solar PV. The ESS is used to improve the performance of The typical lifetime of a solar panel is approximately 25–30 years or
distributed solar PV. Supercapacitor or ultracapacitor is also another more. It lacks any moving parts, and high winds, heavy snow, hail, or
development aspect to be implemented alongside ESS as a hybrid solu­ flooding should not affect its performance and reliability considerably.
tion for the improvement of solar vehicles [98]. ESS is proven to have During extreme weather such as heavy snow, tropical cyclone or tor­
the capability to support the network operation, stability and power nado, the solar panel may not be able to withstand such a huge impact.
quality whenever there is a shortage of electricity, especially for solar Heavy snow with a high thickness on the solar glass panel will block the
power systems [99]. The sizing, scheduling, location, and connection sunlight on the solar panel from directly generating electricity. The
configuration of the ESS are the main design criteria to maximise its routine maintenance of a solar panel is relatively easy. However, it still
efficiency and support for solar-enabled BEV CS. demands labour, water and chemicals. It includes calibration of the
mechanical hinge of solar, cleaning the solar panel glass, checking

9
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

ageing wires and other relevant normal maintenances. Plus, the ESS and components [114], the solar energy-powered BEV CS has room for im­
other electrical components are more prone to maintenance and ageing. provements to reach the net-zero emission goal.
For instance, the lifetime of ESS is dependent on the charging/di­ V. Future Prospects, Commercialisation Potentials and Outlooks.
scharging cycle, depth of discharge, temperature and environmental In this section, future recommendations are pointed out for the solar
factors. It ranges from 7,300 to 22,000-lifetime cycles of charging and energy-based BEV CS. In general, several technological advancements
discharging. Different ESS technology exhibits different lifetimes, but such as blockchain, V2G, synchronverter and a new type of solar panel
usually, it ranges from 3 to 15 y [109]. are the future trend for solar energy-based BEV CS. To mitigate the
aforementioned research gaps, various ways and mitigation plans ought
to implement to ensure effective utilisation of solar energy-powered BEV
4.3. The operating temperature of solar energy CS. For instance, the condition partial shading conditions (PSC) can be
mitigated using maximum power point tracking (MPPT) based on the
The nominal operating temperature of a solar panel is at 25 ◦ C, and it latest artificial intelligence (AI) instead of conventional MPPT. The
is able to output power optimally in the range of 15–40 ◦ C. However, latest AI-based MPPT enables faster-tracking speed without the adverse
when it is getting too hot, the power efficiency would be affected effect of PSC [115]. In addition to the software MPPT, the physical
adversely due to extreme weather and temperature. Apart from the tracking of sunlight can be mechanically installed for each solar array to
aforementioned limitations, other considerations such as traffic, user ensure maximum power extraction. Internet of Things (IoT) and sensory
charging behaviours and power grid stability are the constraints faced systems can be deployed for the solar power systems to detect a fault in
by the BEV CS [110]. advance in preventing any further maintenance or repair that may cause
The summary of current opportunities, benefits versus its corre­ electricity disruption [116]. The manufacturing of solar panels can be
sponding challenges and limitations for solar energy-powered BEV CS is further improved to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by incorporating a
listed in Table 4. Realistically, by considering the ageing of hardware green approach in manufacturing plants. The instability issues intro­
ageing, technical limitations required routine maintenance of solar duced by grid-connected solar power systems can be resolved by using
power systems and end of the life treatment, the solar energy-powered virtual inertia (VI)-based inverters, AI optimisation and ESS [117]. PV
BEV CS is still no way near zero emission. For the manufacturing of waste should be treated properly using end-of-life (EOL) management to
solar panels, the emission of carbon dioxide is inevitably high, rated at prevent any further pollution [118].
about 40–50 g of CO2/kWh during the initial year of operation by
considering the initial manufacturing of solar panels [111]. Although it 4.4. Blockchain-enabled EV charging
is still relatively lower than the carbon output of coal-powered elec­
tricity sources by at least 20 times (coal co-produced 1,000 g of A disruptive technology called blockchain is a technology that en­
CO2/kWh), the manufacturing, installation and commissioning of solar ables peer-to-peer energy trading with shared, decentralised ledger and
power systems have room for improvements in terms of CO2 emission. transactions for BEV CS [119]. In Ref. [120], EV charging is coordinated
Life cycle assessments (LCA) has been conducted for both traditional by blockchain. The blockchain can be used to coordinate traditionally
coal-fired power plants and PV-based power plants [112] to investigate centralized data flows throughout the power systems. It stores the data
greenhouse gas (GHG) emission. The result is positive since the GHG with a secured hash address within each personnel’s block through a
emission rates of coal-fired power plants and PV-based power plants are complex network of transaction connections. If the data is to be hacked,
975.2 g CO2-eq./kWh and 36.75 g CO2-eq./kWh [113]. The solar power the connected neighbours’ hash address is to be known as well to
systems exhibit a lower CO2 emission rate profit. Nonetheless, consid­ retrieve the personnel’s information. This allows a secured and decen­
ering the manufacturing of solar panels, the usage of ESS and the tralised transaction with private hash addresses and could enforce the
inevitable carbon dioxide emission due to the manufacturing of data privacy protection.
The contracts for energy flows and instant P2P payments can be
Table 4 facilitated and recorded on the blockchain. The real-time customer-
The Benefits and Limitations of The Solar energy-powered BEV CS. prosumer-utility interactions enabled by blockchain facilitate faster and
Benefits Challenges and Limitations secured payments, efficient energy use, energy trading and streamlined
Charge BEV with clean energy from RES RES intermittency, uncertainty, account management. From P2P energy trading, smart meter, mobile
instead of non-RES unavailability and instabilities issues application to trade, selling of electricity in bidding, efficient energy
Further acceleration of adoption of BEV Coordination of solar and BEV with management, secured transaction records to the smart contract, block­
market rate power grid remains unstable chain coordinated the flowing of energy using cryptographically
Increase of BEV mileage range and The development, stability and
reduce the risk of the drained battery technological maturity of solar energy-
encrypted blockchain to record all the transactions and trading record.
of BEV due to more available BEV CS powered BEV are still in the early stage In general, blockchain can be utilised to coordinate and manage
Provide sunshade and sun protection by More maintenance required, cleaning of electric vehicle (EV) charging. For instance, blockchain facilitates en­
a sun awning solar panel and tilting of solar towards the ergy payments at EV CS, allowing EV drivers to view maps and select
sun
their choice of the EV CS with real-time pricing data. The blockchain can
Value-added BEV CS with blockchain, Assessment of revenue is required with
smart contract, P2P energy trading, optimum charging policies, and a proven also be deployed in the microgrid, the competitive power prices at each
smart grid, energy sell back, V2G and track record is required station can be established by the grid and residential power suppliers. To
others charge the EV, the drivers are able to pay securely and instantly using a
Net zero-emission and reduced Solar panel manufacturing is subject to blockchain wallet or even using cryptocurrencies. In short, blockchain
greenhouse effect environmental factors and pollution
No longer dependent on the power grid; During the nighttime, it could be a
accelerates the adoption of EV by managing payments, energy man­
instead, solar energy-powered BEV CS challenge to store and harvest solar agement systems and charging systems securely. On the other hand,
can be off-grid and installed in a rural energy, except ESS. However, ESS is blockchain can also be used to coordinate the EV CS automatically by
place subject to ageing, capability issue and managing the energy optimally. A smart contract enabled by blockchain
high costs
is useful to automate, secure and enable peer-to-peer (P2P) energy
Solar energy is highly accessible during A huge place is required for the
the daytime and energy efficient installation and deployment of solar payments.
panels. Plus, the ageing problems of solar Some researches utilised the blockchain for incentive system for BEV
panels and ESS are uncertain and may using proposed cryptocurrency, including using prioritisation ranking
contribute to unwanted wastage and algorithm [121], a permissioned energy blockchain with proof of local
pollution after their lifespan
reputation consensus protocol [122], and prioritise the users with better

10
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

usage history [123]. Power management is also applicable for BEV using other miners of BEV CS are used to verify the contract, transaction,
the blockchain and cryptographic technology, as validated in various ledger and proof of work (PoW) only. The non-miner station of BEV CS is
researches and implementations, which include AI-enabled EV integra­ used to only verify the PoW. The blockchain is used to prevent any
tion system [124] and energy trading using contract theory with user tampering of charging or discharging data of BEV CS. It ensures pricing
reputation [125]. The energy can be traded in BEV CS using P2P feature transparency, high security and peer-to-peer (P2P) energy trading.
enabled by blockchain using the incentive contract model [126]. EV
data, EV CS coordination, energy trading and charging schedule can also 4.5. V2G enabled by synchronverter
be regulated and implemented based on blockchain technology on the
internet of electric vehicles [127]. In Ref. [128], blockchain has been The synchronverter technology can be adopted for V2G to improve
used for edge-as-a-service framework in secure energy trading. On the the grid stability [139]. V2G sources are applicable to expand the BEV
other hand, blockchain is also being used as the trading platform for EV CS with the integration of RES [140]. A smart V2G can be used to reduce
CS in smart cities with greater security and privacy [129]. For instance, the distribution network expansion cost, which is subject to the un­
Byzantine-Based Blockchain Consensus is used for trading energy with certainties of solar power [141]. Fig. 6 depicts the typical V2G termi­
better security and transparency [130]. Blockchain with K-Anonymity nology, which enables the BEV to contribute back the charged energy to
can be implemented for Vehicular Energy Network [131]. A smart the power grid via a bidirectional method.
contract is a contract that is automated to self-execute with the terms of The regulation of frequency is crucial as the penetration of BEV in­
the agreement between buyer and seller is met in the lines of code [132]. creases [142]. Due to the nature of power electronics, the frequency will
It can be used for faster energy trading for EV charging using the be greatly affected due to the lack of rotating masses and inertial
blockchain-based smart contract. response, unlike a conventional synchronous machine (SM) [143].
Other areas of interest related to blockchain-enabled BEV CS include Battery degradation is also another concern to be improved by using
the optimisation of charging and discharging for BEV [133], security dynamic programming and minimised energy consumption in
model [134], automation [135] and V2G [128]. It showed that the vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) communication on energy savings [144].
blockchain is a significant technological advancement for BEV CS, Virtual inertia (VI) is able to mitigate the frequency instability issues
especially in the P2P energy trading, security, decentralised transaction, introduced by the grid integration of solar power systems [145]. Syn­
transparency in energy trading and various improvements for BEV CS. chronverter is a type of virtual inertia (VI)-based inverter that emulates
Smart charging is another important aspect for BEV CS to improve the dynamic behaviours of a synchronous machine (SM) to interface
charging power rate and adaption of user charging behaviour [136]. The solar power system with power grid [36]. It is applicable to be utilised in
charging management for EVs can be further enhanced and improved by solar energy-powered BEV for DC-AC conversion in the V2G setting.
artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML) or deep learning (DL) Fig. 7 illustrates the single-line diagram of a grid-connected solar power
for reduced charging cost and charging time with optimised energy system with the ESS, BEV CS, and VI supports by synchronverter, where
management [137]. For instance, in Ref. [138], a long short-term Vabc is three-phase voltage, Iabc is three-phase current, PCC is the point of
memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network (RNN) based machine common coupling, R is resistance, Xs is reactance component, Vg is grid
learning (ML) algorithm has been used to schedule and optimise the voltage, L is inductance, C is capacitor and Rabc is three-phase resistive
charging and discharging of EVs in commercial-building prosumers. load. The synchronous static compensator (STATCOM), which is a type
Fig. 5 depicts the process of a blockchain-enabled BEV CS. For any of flexible alternating current transmission system (FACTS) device, can
successful transaction made by the first miner (initiator), a new block also replace the ESS for better voltage regulation by adjusting the
will be added with a timestamp and relevant data to the blockchain. The reactive power (Q).
Apart from solar energy, wind energy [146] is also applicable to be
installed for BEV CS, provided the installed place exhibits higher wind
speed and is beside the sea with wider area accessibility. Wind energy
can support V2G integration [147]. Solar wireless road charging station
for BEVs is also a new trend to enable the BEV to charge while travelling
[148]. The solar-powered CS is also applicable for hydrogen BEV apart
from conventional BEV [149]. Excess generated electricity from solar
energy-based BEV CS is applicable for other usage and feedback to the
power grid to support additional loads [150]. A fuel cell system is used
to support the solar power for BEV CS [151]. Connected, automated,
shared, and electric (CASE) vehicles are also the future of BEVs to
improve the road network’s level of service and technological
advancement [152].
Assuming the average roof size of a conventional commercial lot is
160 m2, the size of a 320 W solar panel is approximately 1.6 m2, and
160/1.6 = 100 panels would be fitted on the roof. Ideally, these 100
solar panels could output 100*320 W = 32 kW. The average sunlight
would be around 5 h in an optimum situation; gives have 32 kW*5 h =
160 kWh daily, and in a year, it would be 160 kWh * 365 d = 58,400
kWh, which can charge 712 EVs, such as Tesla Model 3 with 82 kWh
battery from zero charges. However, these assumptions are based on
optimal settings, as the average number of sunshine per month maybe
vary and be far from the optimum values. For instance, in the UK, there
are only ranging from 42.5 to 229.8 h of sunshine monthly from January
2021 to September 2021 [153]. Some places like Glasgow only record 1,
203 h/y, which is equivalent to an average of 3.3 h/d. The average
number of sunshine per month in places varies, and solar
energy-powered BEV CS has the weather limitation to acquire a suffi­
Fig. 5. The typical process of BEV CS platform using blockchain. cient amount of sunshine to generate electricity.

11
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Fig. 6. The terminology of V2G in BEV CS. C. The support from ESS, STATCOM and synchronverter.

Fig. 7. The single-line diagram of a synchronverter-based solar power system with ESS, BEV CS and VI supports. D. Flexible thin-film solar panel on EV roof.

It is commendable that it has reduced the dependency on conven­ by solar. When the BEV CS is used in weather with cold temperatures
tional power grids with is generated by coal, oil and gas. It will further like winter or rainy days, the charging speed will be slow due to extreme
reduce carbon emissions and utilize solar panels to generate clean en­ weather. Slow charging is not an issue for overnight charging without
ergy. By this method, the BEV can be considered as clean transportation any time limitation. However, slow charging will delay the travelling
since its fuel (electricity) is finally sourced from RES instead of coal, oil time of the BEV users. It can be mitigated by using several technologies,
and gas. Fig. 8 depicts the future trends of the solar energy-powered BEV including direct battery swapping without charging or preconditioning
CS, while Fig. 9 presents the current research gaps of existing of charging by heating up the battery and charger to reduce extreme
technology. cold. For instance, Tesla’s Supercharging V3 heats up the battery and
A similar setup can be adopted for other electrified vehicles such as charger while the driver is approaching a Supercharger in cold weather.
bikes or motors. For instance, similar solar-powered CS can be installed This heating function ensures the battery will be at the optimal tem­
at the workspace to provide charging facilities for electric bikes [154], perature for charging with a higher efficiency under cold temperature
electric buses [155], electric agricultural machinery [156] and other upon arrival at a Tesla Supercharger.
relevant electric-powered vehicles. Table 5 shows the open issues and Multi-objective optimisation is also applicable to optimise the
mitigation plans of the existing solar energy-powered BEV CS. schedule of BEV load in a power system [158]. A wind power system is
To mitigate the slow charging speed of BEV, battery swapping is also applicable to combine with a solar power system to support solar
another emerging technology to directly change the BEV battery [157]. during nighttime [159]. This kind of hybrid system is feasible for
The battery can be charged by using the electricity generated from solar large-scale BEV CS with higher availability of electricity. The solar
energy during the daytime. The depleted battery from the BEV car can energy-powered BEV CS is also applicable to find any nearby large-scale
be changed or swapped at the BEV CS bay using the fully charged battery solar farm to collaborate. The solar farm can be used to provide clean

12
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

Table 5
The open issues and mitigation plans.
Challenges and Limitations Mitigation

RES intermittency, uncertainty, Field testing, technological maturity of


unavailability and instabilities issues solar energy, support from ESS and
synchronverter
Coordination of solar and BEV with Coordination between BEV and parking
power grid remains unstable lot operators
The development, stability and More research and data are required to
technological maturity of solar improve the existing technologies.
energy-powered BEVs are still in the
early stage
More maintenance required, cleaning of Electronic, mechanical tilting of solar
solar panel and tilting of solar panels, collaboration with large-scale
towards the sun solar power systems nearby, and auto
cleaning features can be added for a solar
panel.
Assessment of revenue is required with Practical real-time implementations are
optimum charging policies, and a required to assess the revenue return and
proven track record is required profitability.
ESS, power converter and solar panel Research for long-lasting materials and
ageing issues components to reduce maintenance
routine.
Fig. 8. The future trends and advantages of a solar energy-powered BEV CS. Slow charging of BEV battery by solar Battery swapping technology whereby
panel the battery is charged by solar power
system and is being used to replace the
depleted battery of incoming BEV car at
the BEV CS bay

advanced ESS, automatic maintenance with cleaning function, me­


chanical tilting of the solar array, flexible solar panel and MPPT for
enhanced efficiency.
2. Slow charging of solar-enabled BEV CS: Alternative DC fast charging is
used to improve the charging speed for the solar-enabled BEV CS.
The direct DC output from solar can be used to charge the EV for
faster-charging speed and less power conversion losses.
3. The placement of solar array: The solar array can be placed on the
rooftop of a building or awning of EV CS. The thin, flexible solar
array can be used to place on a non-flat surface and improve the
space constraint of the solar array.
4. Required routine maintenance, cleaning and ageing problems: To miti­
gate the ageing problems and required maintenance for the solar
array and ESS, research for long-lasting solar array materials and ESS
components are inevitable to reduce the maintenance routine.

Although the solar energy for BEV CS is still in an early stage of


development, it is inevitably a better choice to integrate RES with BEV
CS to achieve true net zero-emission. By combining RES sustainability
and BEV environmental friendliness, solar energy-powered BEV CS is an
aspiration to replace conventional power generation for BEV or con­
ventional combustion engine vehicles. It is in line with the Sustainable
Development Goal (SDG) 7: Clean and affordable energy.
Fig. 9. The technical gaps to replace conventional power grid by using solar
energy for BEV CS. E. Solar-powered CS for other vehicles. 5. Conclusion

energy from solar to BEV CS, apart from its main supply to the power This review provides a detailed insight into the latest development of
grid. The investors or operators require financial returns on the invest­ solar energy for BEV CS. The original contributions include the inclusion
ment of solar energy-powered BEV CS. Limitations of solar of real-world practical implementation, the identification of real-world
energy-powered BEV CS should be addressed with the future prospects technical limitations and the future recommendations to accelerate
to increase the profitability and sustainability of maintaining solar the adoption of solar-enabled BEV CS in line with the net-zero carbon
energy-powered BEV CS. Various mitigation plans should be deployed initiative and SDG Goal 7. As the BEV becomes more popular due to the
and developed to overcome the limitations of the solar-powered BEV, support for lower carbon emission, political policy change and envi­
which include the following: ronmentally friendliness, the electricity provided for BEV charging
should be clean as well. Solar energy is the most feasible RES to replace
1. The advancements of solar energy: As solar energy is subject to the lack the conventional power generation for BEV CS. However, some limita­
of electricity generation during night time, intermittency of sunlight, tions and research gaps have been identified based on the recent
routine maintenance, the tilting angle of the solar array and effi­ implementations and research results. The limitations include the ne­
ciency problems, advancements should be made to the solar power cessity to install ESS in supporting the solar power system during night
system. It includes the inclusion of super or ultra-capacitors, time, the intermittency of solar energy, the required maintenance of

13
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

solar array and ESS and slow charging speed by solar energy. Despite [10] Yap KY, Chua HS, Bashir MJK, Albert FYC, Govinda S. Central composite design
(CCD) for parameters optimization of maximum power point tracking (MPPT) by
these limitations, there are various practical, real-world implementa­
response surface methodology (RSM). Journal of Mechanic of Continua and
tions to utilize solar energy for EV CS, including Empower Solar, Sino­ Mathematical Sciences (JMCMS) 2019;1(Special Issue-1):259–70. Mar.
voltaics, Envision Solar, Electrify America and Solar Edge. The solar [11] Yap KY, Sarimuthu CR, Lim JMY. Grid integration of solar photovoltaic system
energy-powered BEV CS has a bright future ahead, and various future using machine learning-based virtual inertia synthetization in synchronverter.
IEEE Access 2020;8:49961–76.
outcomes have been highlighted to further accelerate the adoption of [12] Yap KY, Beh CM, Sarimuthu CR. Fuzzy logic controller-based synchronverter in
RES-based BEV CS. It included blockchain-enabled P2P energy trading, grid-connected solar power system with adaptive damping factor. Chinese
faster-charging support and the integration of more RES such as wind Journal of Electrical Engineering 2021;7(2):37–49. Jun.
[13] Yap KY, Lim JMY, Sarimuthu CR. A novel adaptive virtual inertia control strategy
and hydro energy. The blockchain can be used to support the coordi­ under varying irradiance and temperature in grid-connected solar power system.
nation of EV CS in terms of P2P energy trading, energy management and Int J Electr Power Energy Syst 2021;132:107180. Nov.
secured transactional records. The advancements in solar energy, [14] Ma W, Li X, Lu H, Zhang M, Yang X, Zhang T, et al. A flexible self-charged power
panel for harvesting and storing solar and mechanical energy. Nano Energy 2019;
including flexible solar, solar on the rooftop and improved efficiency, 65:104082. Nov.
also contribute to the acceleration of solar energy in EV CS. Hybrid [15] Sánchez-Aparicio M, Martín-Jiménez J, Pozo SD, González-González E, Lagüela S.
integration of RES, including biogas, hydropower and wind power, is Ener3DMap-SolarWeb roofs: a geospatial web-based platform to compute
photovoltaic potential. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2021;135:110203. Jan.
also another feasible solution to support solar-enabled EV CS. [16] Vaishnav S, Kapadiya V, Harish R, Mohan R. Design and analysis of energy-
efficient solar panel cooling system. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 2021;1128:
Author contributions 012033.
[17] Soldati A, Pietrini G, Dalboni M, Concari C. Electric-vehicle power converters
model-based design-for-reliability. CPSS Transactions on Power Electronics and
Kah Yung Yap: Conceptualisation, Methodology, Writing-original Applications 2018;3(2):102–10. Jun.
draft; Hon Huin Chin: Conceptualisation, Writing-review and editing; [18] Na T, Yuan X, Tang J, Zhang Q. A review of on-board integrated electric vehicles
charger and a new single-phase integrated charger. CPSS Transactions on Power
Jiří Jaromír Klemeš: Supervision, Funding acquisition, Project man­ Electronics and Applications 2019;4(4):288–98. Dec.
agement, Writing-review and editing; [19] Kiaee M, Cruden A, Sharkh S. Estimation of cost savings from participation of
electric vehicles in vehicle to grid (V2G) schemes. Journal of Modern Power
Systems and Clean Energy 2015;3(2):249–58. Jun.
Declaration of competing interest [20] Stauch A. Does solar power add value to electric vehicles? An investigation of car-
buyers’ willingness to buy product-bundles in Germany. Energy Res Social Sci
2021;75:102006. May.
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial [21] Good C, Shepero M, Munkhammar J, Boström T. Scenario-based modelling of the
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence potential for solar energy charging of electric vehicles in two Scandinavian cities.
the work reported in this paper. Energy 2019;168:111–25. Feb.
[22] Shen J, Wang L, Zhang J. Integrated scheduling strategy for private electric
vehicles and electric taxis. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2021;17(3):1637–47. Mar.
Acknowledgement [23] Li D, Zhang Z, Liu P, Wang Z, Zhang L. battery fault diagnosis for electric vehicles
based on voltage abnormality by combining the long short-term memory neural
network and the equivalent circuit model. IEEE Trans Power Electron 2021;36(2):
This research has been supported by the EU project “Sustainable 1303–15. Feb.
Process Integration Laboratory – SPIL”, project No. CZ.020.1.01/0.0/ [24] Wei H, Zhang Y, Wang Y, Hua W, Jing R, Zhou Y. Planning integrated energy
0.0/15_003/0000456 funded by EU “CZ Operational Programme systems coupling V2G as a flexible storage. Energy 2022;239(Part B):122215.
Jan.
Research, Development and Education”, Priority 1: Strengthening ca­
[25] Sharma G, Sood VK, Alam MS, Shariff S M. Comparison of common DC and AC
pacity for quality research. bus architectures for EV fast charging stations and impact on power quality.
eTransportation 2020;5:100066. Aug.
[26] Khan S, Ahmad A, Ahmad F, Shemami MS, Alam MS, Khateeb S. A comprehensive
Appendix A. Supplementary data review on solar powered electric vehicle charging system. Smart Science 2017;6
(1):1419054. Dec.
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi. [27] Bhatti AR, Salam Z, Aziz MJBA, Yee2 KP. A critical review of electric vehicle
charging using solar photovoltaic. Int J Energy Res 2016;40:439–61.
org/10.1016/j.rser.2022.112862.
[28] Tie SF, Tan CW. A review of energy sources and energy management system in
electric. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2013;20:82–102.
References [29] Qureshi KN, Alhudhaif A, Jeon G. Electric-vehicle energy management and
charging scheduling system in sustainable cities and society. Sustain Cities Soc
2021;71:102990. Aug.
[1] Patil H, Kalkhambkar VN. Grid integration of electric vehicles for economic
[30] Energy A. Novel stand-alone, completely autonomous and renewable energy
benefits: a review. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2021;9
based charging station for charging plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs). Appl
(1):13–26. Jan.
Energy 2020;260:114194. Feb.
[2] Ebrahimi J, Abedini M, Rezaei MM, Nasri M. Optimum design of a multi-form
[31] Yap KY, Sarimuthu CR, Lim JY. Artificial intelligence based MPPT techniques for
energy in the presence of electric vehicle charging station and renewable
solar power system: a review. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean
resources considering uncertainty. Sustainable Energy, Grids and Networks23;
Energy 2020;8(6):1043–59. Oct.
2020, 100375. Sep.
[32] Mehrjerdi H. Off-grid solar powered charging station for electric and hydrogen
[3] Napoli G, Polimeni A, Micari S, Andaloro L, Antonucci V. Optimal allocation of
vehicles including fuel cell and hydrogen storage. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2019;44
electric vehicle charging stations in a highway network: Part 1. Methodology and
(23):11574–83. May.
test application. J Energy Storage 2020;27:101102. Feb.
[33] Büyük M, Tan A, Tümay M, Bayındır KÇ. Topologies, generalized designs, passive
[4] Elma O. A dynamic charging strategy with hybrid fast charging station for electric
and active damping methods of switching ripple filters for voltage source
vehicles. Energy. Jul. 2020;202:117680.
inverter: a comprehensive review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2016;62:46–69.
[5] Yang X, Shao C, Zhuge C, Sun M, Wang P, Wang S. Deploying battery swap
Sep.
stations for shared electric vehicles using trajectory data. Transport Res Transport
[34] Jafari M. MagnusKorpåsbAudunBotterudac. Power system decarbonization:
Environ 2021;97:102943. Aug.
impacts of energy storage duration and interannual renewables variability.
[6] Solanke TU, Khatua PK, Ramachandaramurthy VK, Yong JY, MiaoTan K. Control
Renew Energy 2020;156:1171–85. Aug.
and management of a multilevel electric vehicles infrastructure integrated with
[35] He T, Zhu J, Lu DDC, Zheng L, Aghdam MM, Zhang J. Comparison study of
distributed resources: a comprehensive review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2021;
electric vehicles charging stations with AC and DC buses for bidirectional power
144:111020. Jul.
flow in smart car parks. In: Iecon 2017 - 43rd Annual Conference of the IEEE
[7] Mehrjerdi H, Hemmati R. Stochastic model for electric vehicle charging station
Industrial Electronics Society; 2017. p. 4609–14. Beijing, China.
integrated with wind energy. Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments.
[36] Falvo MC, Sbordone D, Bayram IS, Devetsikiotis M. EV charging stations and
Feb. 2020;37:100577.
modes: international standards. In: 2014 International Symposium on Power
[8] Tarroja B, Hittinger E. The value of consumer acceptance of controlled electric
Electronics, Electrical Drives, Automation and Motion. Italy: Ischia; 2014. Jun.
vehicle charging in a decarbonizing grid: the case of California. Energy 2021;229:
[37] Chamberlain K, Al-Majeed S. Standardisation of UK electric vehicle charging
120691. Aug.
protocol, payment and charge point connection. World Electric Vehicle Journal -
[9] Chen T, Zhang XP, Wang J, Li J, Wu C, Hu M, et al. A review on electric vehicle
MDPI 2020;12:63. Dec.
charging infrastructure development in the UK. Journal of Modern Power
Systems and Clean Energy 2020;8(2):193–205. Mar.

14
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

[38] Collin R, Miao Y, Yokochi A, Enjeti P. Advanced electric vehicle fast-charging [71] Shariff SM, Alam MS, Ahmad F, Rafat Y, Asghar MSJ, Khan S. System design and
technologies. Energies - MDPI. 2019;12:1839. realization of a solar-powered electric vehicle charging station. IEEE Syst J 2020;
[39] G D, Singh SN. Selection of non-isolated DC-DC converters for solar photovoltaic 14(2):2748–58. Jun.
system. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2017;76:1230–47. Sep. [72] Mehrjerdi H. Resilience-robustness improvement by adaptable operating pattern
[40] Peters IM, Gallegos CDR, Sofia SE, Buonassisi T. The value of efficiency in for electric vehicles in complementary solar-vehicle management. J Energy
photovoltaics. Joule - Cell Press 2019;3(11):2732–47. Nov. Storage 2021;37:102454. May.
[41] Clipper Creek. Estimated Charge Times Chart for Pure Electric Vehicles. 2021. htt [73] Luo Y, Zhang X, Yang D, Sun Q. Emission trading based optimal scheduling
ps://energywisemnstore.com/content/Time-to-Charge-Chart-Clipper-Creek.pdf. strategy of energy hub with energy storage and integrated electric vehicles.
[Accessed 2 February 2022]. accessed. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020;8(2):267–75. Mar.
[42] Trentadue G, Lucas A, Otura M, Pliakostathis K, Zanni M, Scholz H. Evaluation of [74] Hu J, Zhou H, Li Y, Hou P, Yang G. Multi-time scale energy management strategy
fast charging efficiency under extreme temperatures. Energies 2018;11:1937. Jul. of aggregator characterised by photovoltaic generation and electric vehicles.
[43] EVs Inside. Inside EVs. 2022 [cited 2022 March 24, https://insideevs.com/news/ Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020;8(4):727–36. Jul.
519382/tesla-model3-82kwh-charging-analysis/. [75] Kumar N, Kumar T, Nema S, Thakur T. A comprehensive planning framework for
[44] Renewables Mayfield. Mayfield Renewables. 2022 [cited 2022 March 24, htt electric vehicles fast charging station assisted by solar and battery based on
ps://www.mayfield.energy/blog/energy-storage-101. Queueing theory and non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm-II in a co-
[45] Podder S, Khan MZR. Comparison of lead acid and Li-ion battery in solar home ordinated transportation and power network. J Energy Storage 2022;49:104180.
system of Bangladesh. In: 2016 5th International Conference on Informatics, May.
Electronics and Vision (ICIEV); 2016. May [Dhaka, Bangladesh]. [76] Ahmad F, Khalid M, Panigrahi BK. An enhanced approach to optimally place the
[46] Hu X, Zheng Y, HoweybHectorPerezcAoifeFoleydMichaelPechte D A. Battery solar powered electric vehicle charging station in distribution network. J Energy
warm-up methodologies at subzero temperatures for automotive applications: Storage 2021;42:103090. Oct.
recent advances and perspectives. Prog Energy Combust Sci 2020;77:100806. [77] Bastida-Molina P, Hurtado-Pérez E, Gómez MCM, Vargas-Salgado C. Multicriteria
Mar. power generation planning and experimental verification of hybrid renewable
[47] Mohamad F, Teh J, Lai CM. Optimum allocation of battery energy storage systems energy systems for fast electric vehicle charging stations. Renew Energy 2021;
for power grid enhanced with solar energy. Energy 2021;223:120105. May. 179:737–55. Dec.
[48] Next Green Car [cited 2021 Dec 28]. Available from: https://www.nextgreencar. [78] Priyaratnam Jain A, Verma N, Shaw RN, Ghosh A. Chapter eight - modeling of
com/electric-cars/statistics/. electric vehicle charging station using solar photovoltaic system with fuzzy logic
[49] Ahmed MA, El-Sharkawy MR, Kim YC. Remote monitoring of electric vehicle controller. Applications of AI and IOT in Renewable Energy 2022;1(1):151–67.
charging stations in smart campus parking lot. Journal of Modern Power Systems Academic Press.
and Clean Energy 2020;8(1). 124-13. [79] Erdemir D, Dincer b. Development of solar-driven charging station integrated
[50] Nunes P, Figueiredo R, Brito MC. The use of parking lots to solar-charge electric with hydrogen as an energy storage option. Energy Convers Manag 2022;257:
vehicles. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2016;66:679–93. Dec. 115436. Apr.
[51] Deshmukh SS, Pearce JM. Electric vehicle charging potential from retail parking [80] N. H, Hampannavar S, B. D, M. S.. Analysis of microgrid integrated Photovoltaic
lot solar photovoltaic awnings. Renew Energy 2021;169:608–17. Jan. (PV) Powered Electric Vehicle Charging Stations (EVCS) under different solar
[52] Gray MK, Morsi WG. On the role of prosumers owning rooftop solar photovoltaic irradiation conditions in India: a way towards sustainable development and
in reducing the impact on transformer’s aging due to plug-in electric vehicles growth. Energy Rep 2021;7:8534–47. Nov.
charging. Elec Power Syst Res 2017;143:563–72. Feb. [81] Wu Y, Zhang J, Ravey A, Chrenko D, Miraoui A. Real-time energy management of
[53] Singh B, Verma A, Chandra A, Al-Haddad K. Implementation of solar PV-battery photovoltaic-assisted electric vehicle charging station by markov decision
and diesel generator based electric vehicle charging station. IEEE Trans Ind Appl process. J Power Sources 2020;476:228504. Nov.
2020;56(4):4007–16. Jul. [82] Yi T, Cheng X, Chen Y, Liu J. Joint optimization of charging station and energy
[54] Zhang Y, Cai L. Dynamic charging scheduling for EV parking lots with storage economic capacity based on the effect of alternative energy storage of
photovoltaic power system. IEEE Access 2018;6:56995–7005. Oct. electric vehicle. Energy 2020;208:118357. Oct.
[55] Naveed A, Sönmez Ş, Ayasun S. Impact of electric vehicle aggregator with [83] Welzel F, Klinck CF, Pohlmann Y, Bednarczyk M. Grid and user-optimized
communication time delay on stability regions and stability delay margins in load planning of charging processes of an electric vehicle fleet using a quantitative
frequency control system. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy optimization model. Appl Energy 2021;290:116717. May.
2021;9(3):595–601. May. [84] Borray AFC, Garcés A, Merino J, Torres E, Mazón J. New energy bound-based
[56] Ji D, Lv M, Yang J, Yi W. Optimising the locations and sizes of solar assisted model for optimal charging of electric vehicles with solar photovoltaic
electric vehicle charging stations in an urban area. IEEE Access 2020;8: considering low-voltage network’s constraints. Int J Electr Power Energy Syst
112772–82. Jun. 2021;129:106862. Jul.
[57] Tran VT, Islam MR, Muttaqi KM, Sutanto D. An efficient energy management [85] Erick AO, Folly KA. Power flow management in multi-source electric vehicle
approach for a solar-powered EV battery charging facility to support distribution charging station. IFAC-PapersOnLine 2020;53(2):12590–5.
grids. IEEE Trans Ind Appl 2019;55(6):6517–26. Nov. [86] Alghoul MA, Hammadi FY, Amin N, Asim N. The role of existing infrastructure of
[58] Aznavi S, Fajri P, Shadmand MB, Khoshkbar-Sadigh A. Peer-to-Peer operation fuel stations in deploying solar charging systems, electric vehicles and solar
strategy of PV equipped office buildings and charging stations considering energy: a preliminary analysis. Technol Forecast Soc Change 2018;137:317–26.
electric vehicle energy pricing. IEEE Trans Ind Appl 2020;56(5):5848–57. Sep. Dec.
[59] Kabir ME, Assi C, Tushar MHK, Yan J. Optimal scheduling of EV charging at a [87] Karmaker AK, Ahmed MR, Hossain MA, Sikder MM. Feasibility assessment &
solar power-based charging station. IEEE Syst J 2020;14(3):4221–31. Sep. design of hybrid renewable energy based electric vehicle charging station in
[60] Verma A, Singh B. Multimode operation of solar PV array, grid, battery and diesel Bangladesh. Sustain Cities Soc 2018;39:189–202. May.
generator set based EV charging station. IEEE Trans Ind Appl 2020;56(5):5330–9. [88] Zhang J, Liu C, Yuan R, Li T, Li K, Li B, et al. Design scheme for fast charging
Sep. station for electric vehicles with distributed photovoltaic power generation.
[61] Alam MJE, Muttaqi KM, Sutanto D. Effective utilization of available PEV battery Global Energy Interconnection 2019;2(2):150–9. Apr.
capacity for mitigation of solar PV impact and grid support with integrated V2G [89] Singh HK, Kumar N. Solar PV array powered on board electric vehicle charging
functionality. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2016;7(3):1562–71. May. with charging current protection scheme. In: 2020 IEEE International Conference
[62] Liu Z, Wu Q, Shahidehpour M, Li C, Huang S, Wei W. Transactive real-time on Power Electronics, Drives and Energy Systems (PEDES); 2020. Mar. [Jaipur,
electric vehicle charging management for commercial buildings with PV on-site India].
generation. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2019;10(5):4939–50. Sep. [90] Wang GC, Ratnam E, Haghi HV, Kleissl J. Corrective receding horizon EV charge
[63] Ghotge R, Av Wijk, Lukszo Z. Off-grid solar charging of electric vehicles at long- scheduling using short-term solar forecasting. Renew Energy 2019;130:1146–58.
term parking locations. Energy 2021;227:120356. Jul. Jan.
[64] Fretzen U, Ansarin M, Brandt T. Temporal city-scale matching of solar [91] Mehrjerdi H, Hemmati R. Electric vehicle charging station with multilevel
photovoltaic generation and electric vehicle charging. Appl Energy 2021;282(A): charging infrastructure and hybrid solar-battery-diesel generation incorporating
116160. Jan. comfort of drivers. J Energy Storage 2019;26:100924. Dec.
[65] Mouli GRC, Bauer P, Zeman M. System design for a solar powered electric vehicle [92] Nunes P, Farias T, Brito MC. Enabling solar electricity with electric vehicles smart
charging station for workplaces. Appl Energy 2016;168:434–43. Apr. charging. Energy 2015;87:10–20. Jul.
[66] Fathabadi H. Novel solar powered electric vehicle charging station with the [93] Borray AFC, Garcés A, Merino J, Torres E, Mazón J. New energy bound-based
capability of vehicle-to-grid. Sol Energy 2017;142:136–43. Jan. model for optimal charging of electric vehicles with solar photovoltaic
[67] Fathabadi H. Novel grid-connected solar/wind powered electric vehicle charging considering low-voltage network’s constraints. Int J Electr Power Energy Syst
station with vehicle-to-grid technology. Energy 2017;132:1–11. Aug. 2021;129:106862. Jul.
[68] Ekren O, Canbaz CH, Güvel ÇB. Sizing of a solar-wind hybrid electric vehicle [94] Schwarz M, Auzépy Q, fKnoeri C. Can electricity pricing leverage electric vehicles
charging station by using HOMER software. J Clean Prod 2021;279:123615. Jan. and battery storage to integrate high shares of solar photovoltaics? Appl Energy
[69] Sun B. A multi-objective optimization model for fast electric vehicle charging 2020;277:115548. Nov.
stations with wind, PV power and energy storage. J Clean Prod 2021;288:125564. [95] Tulpule PJ, Marano V, Yurkovich S, Rizzoni G. Economic and environmental
Mar. impacts of a PV powered workplace parking garage charging station. Appl Energy
[70] Kouka K, Masmoudi A, Abdelkafi A, Krichen L. Dynamic energy management of 2013;108:23–332. Aug.
an electric vehicle charging station using photovoltaic power. Sustainable Energy, [96] Lu Z, Xu X, Yan Z, Wang H. Density-based global sensitivity analysis of islanded
Grids and Networks 2020;24:100402. Dec. microgrid loadability considering distributed energy resource integration.
Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020;8(1):94–101. Jan.

15
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

[97] Bai B, Xiong S, Song B, Xiaoming M. Economic analysis of distributed solar [124] Wang Z, Ogbodo M, Huang H, Qiu C, Hisada M, Abdallah AB. AEBIS: AI-enabled
photovoltaics with reused electric vehicle batteries as energy storage systems in blockchain-based electric vehicle integration system for power management in
China. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2019;109:213–29. Jul. smart grid platform. IEEE Access 2020;8:226409–21.
[98] Cabrane Z, Batool D, Kim J, Yoo K. Design and simulation studies of battery- [125] Yahaya AS, Javaid N, Javed MU, Shafiq M, Khan WZ, Aalsalem MY. Blockchain-
supercapacitor hybrid energy storage system for improved performances of based energy trading and load balancing using contract theory and reputation in a
traction system of solar vehicle. J Energy Storage 2020;32:101943. Dec. smart community. IEEE Access 2020;8:222168–86.
[99] Mohamed AAR, Best RJ, Morrow DJ, Cupples A, Bailie I. Impact of the [126] Chen X, Zhang X. Secure electricity trading and incentive contract model for
deployment of solar photovoltaic and electrical vehicle on the low voltage electric vehicle based on energy blockchain. IEEE Access 2019;7:178763–78.
unbalanced networks and the role of battery energy storage systems. J Energy [127] Sadiq A, Javed MU, Khalid R, Almogren A, Shafiq M, Javaid N. Blockchain based
Storage 2021;42:102975. Oct. data and energy trading in internet of electric vehicles. IEEE Access 2021;9:
[100] Zhang Z, Ding T, Zhou Q, Sun Y, Qu M, Zeng Z, et al. A review of technologies and 7000–20.
applications on versatile energy storage systems. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2021; [128] Jindal A, Aujla GS, Kumar N. SURVIVOR: a blockchain based edge-as-a-service
148:111263. Sep. framework for secure energy trading in SDN-enabled vehicle-to-grid
[101] Kim H, Jung TY. Independent solar photovoltaic with Energy Storage Systems environment. Comput Network 2019;153:36–48. Apr.
(ESS) for rural electrification in Myanmar. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2018;82(1): [129] Lasla N, Al-Ammari M, Abdallah M, Younis M. Blockchain based trading platform
1187–94. Feb. for electric vehicle charging in smart cities. IEEE Open Journal of Intelligent
[102] Asija D, Choudekar P. Congestion management using multi-objective hybrid DE- Transportation Systems 2020;1:80–92.
PSO optimisation with solar-ess based distributed generation in deregulated [130] Sheikh A, Kamuni V, Urooj A, Wagh S, Singh N D. Patel. Secured energy trading
power Market. Renewable Energy Focus 2021;36:32–42. Mar. using byzantine-based blockchain consensus. IEEE Access 2020;8:8554–71.
[103] Hannan MA, Faisal M, Ker PJ, Begum RA, Dong ZY, Zhang C. Review of optimal [131] Long Y, Chen Y, Ren W, Dou H, Xiong NN. DePET: a decentralised privacy-
methods and algorithms for sizing energy storage systems to achieve preserving energy trading scheme for vehicular energy network via blockchain
decarbonisation in microgrid applications. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2020;131: and K - anonymity. IEEE Access 2020;8:192587–96. Oct.
110022. Oct. [132] Iqbal A, Rajasekaran AS, Nikhil GS, Azees M. A secure and decentralised
[104] Ghani AA, Ramachandaramurthy VK, Yong JY. Design of a master power factor blockchain based EV energy trading model using smart contract in V2G network.
controller for an industrial plant with solar photovoltaic and electric vehicle IEEE Access 2021;9:75761–77.
chargers. Electr Eng 2021;2021. Dec 00202-020-01191-4. [133] Li Y, Hu B. An iterative two-layer optimisation charging and discharging trading
[105] Tian MW, Talebizadehsardari P. Energy cost and efficiency analysis of building scheme for electric vehicle using consortium blockchain. IEEE Trans Smart Grid
resilience against power outage by shared parking station for electric vehicles and 2020;11(3):2627–37. May.
demand response program. Energy 2021;215. Jan Part B : 119058. [134] Huang X, Xu C, Wang P, Liu H. LNSC: a security model for electric vehicle and
[106] Angelim JH, sAffonso CdM. Probabilistic assessment of voltage quality on solar- charging pile management based on blockchain ecosystem. IEEE Access 2018;6:
powered electric vehicle charging station. Elec Power Syst Res 2020;189:106655. 13565–74.
Dec. [135] Singh M, Kim S. Branch based blockchain technology in intelligent vehicle.
[107] Cherupurakal N, Mozumder MS, Mourad Ah I, Lalwani S. Recent advances in Comput Network 2018;145:219–31. Nov.
superhydrophobic polymers for antireflective self-cleaning solar panels. Renew [136] Clairand JM, Rodríguez-García J, Álvarez-Bel C. Assessment of technical and
Sustain Energy Rev 2021;151:111538. Nov. economic impacts of EV user behavior on EV aggregator smart charging. Journal
[108] Mali V, Tripathi B. Thermal stability of supercapacitor for hybrid energy storage of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2020;8(2):356–66. Mar.
system in lightweight electric vehicles: simulation and experiments. Journal of [137] Li S, Hu W, Cao D, Dragičević T, Huang Q, Chen Z, et al. Electric vehicle charging
Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2022;10(1):170–8. management based on deep reinforcement learning. Journal of Modern Power
[109] Khezri R, Mahmoudi A, Aki H. Optimal planning of solar photovoltaic and battery Systems and Clean Energy. 2022; 10(3): 719-730.
storage systems for grid-connected residential sector: review, challenges and new [138] Zhou H, Zhou Y, Hu J, Yang G, Xie D, Xue Y, et al. LSTM-Based energy
perspectives. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2022;153:111763. Jan. management for electric vehicle charging in commercial-building prosumers.
[110] Liu W, Shi X, Zhao J, Zhang XP, Xue Y. Electric vehicle charging simulation Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy 2021;9(5):1205–16. Sep.
framework considering traffic, user, and power grid. Journal of Modern Power [139] Liu D, Zhong Q, Wang Y, Liu G. Modeling and control of a V2G charging station
Systems and Clean Energy 2021;9(3):602–11. May. based on synchronverter technology. CSEE Journal of Power and Energy Systems
[111] National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). Life Cycle Greenhouse Gas 2018;4(3):326–38. September.
Emissions from Solar Photovoltaics. 2021 [Online]. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/ [140] Quddus MA, Kabli M, Marufuzzaman M. Modeling electric vehicle charging
fy13osti/56487.pdf. Available from: station expansion with an integration of renewable energy and Vehicle-to-Grid
[112] Milousi M, Souliotis M, Arampatzis G, Papaefthimiou S. Evaluating the sources. Transport Res E Logist Transport Rev 2019;128:251–79. Aug.
environmental performance of solar energy systems through a combined life cycle [141] Hemmati R, Mehrjerdi H. Investment deferral by optimal utilising vehicle to grid
assessment and cost analysis. Sustainability 2019;11:2539. in solar powered active distribution networks. J Energy Storage 2020;30:101512.
[113] Wu P, Ma X, Ji J, Ma Y. Review on life cycle assessment of greenhouse gas Aug.
emission profit of solar photovoltaic systems. Energy Proc 2017;105:1289–94. [142] Dong C, Chu R, Morstyn T, McCulloch MD, Jia H. Online rolling evolutionary
May. decoder-dispatch framework for the secondary frequency regulation of time-
[114] Park CH, Ko YJ, Kim JH, Hong H. Greenhouse gas reduction effect of solar energy varying electrical-grid-electric-vehicle system. IEEE Trans Smart Grid 2021;12(1):
systems applicable to high-rise apartment housing structures in South Korea. 871–84. Jan.
Energies 2020;13:2568. [143] Yap KY, Sarimuthu CR, Lim JMY. An adaptive synchronverter for ensuring fault
[115] Seyedmahmoudian M, Horan B, Soon TK, Rahmani R, Oo AMT, Mekhilef S, et al. ride through capability of grid-connected solar power system. J Phys Conf 2021;
State of the art artificial intelligence-based MPPT techniques for mitigating partial 1828(1):012054.
shading effects on PV systems – a review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2016;64: [144] Connor WD, Wang Y, Malikopoulos AA, Advani SG, Prasad AK. Impact of
435–55. Oct. connectivity on energy consumption and battery life for electric vehicles. IEEE
[116] Mellit A, Kalogirou S. Artificial intelligence and internet of things to improve Transactions on Intelligent Vehicles 2021;6(1):14–23. Mar.
efficacy of diagnosis and remote sensing of solar photovoltaic systems: challenges, [145] Yap KY, Sarimuthu CR, Lim JMY. Virtual inertia-based inverters for mitigating
recommendations and future directions. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2021;143: frequency instability in grid-connected renewable energy system: a review. Appl
110889. Jun. Sci 2019;9(24):5300.
[117] Polleux L, Guerassimoff G, Marmorat JP, Sandoval-Moreno J, Schuhler T. An [146] Santos PDd, Souza ACZd, Bonatto BD, Mendes TP, Neto JAS, Botan ACB. Analysis
overview of the challenges of solar power integration in isolated industrial of solar and wind energy installations at electric vehicle charging stations in a
microgrids with reliability constraints. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 2022;155: region in Brazil and their impact on pricing using an optimised sale price model.
111955. Mar. Int J Energy Res 2020;45:6745–64. Nov.
[118] Jain S, Sharma T, Gupta AK. End-of-life management of solar PV waste in India: [147] Wang W, Liu L, Liu J, Chen Z. Energy management and optimisation of vehicle-to-
situation analysis and proposed policy framework. Renew Sustain Energy Rev grid systems for wind power integration. CSEE Journal of Power and Energy
2022;153:111774. Jan. Systems 2021;7(1):172–80. Jan.
[119] Ping J, Yan Z, Chen S. A two-stage autonomous EV charging coordination method [148] Kandasamy V, Keerthika K, Mathankumar M. Solar based wireless on road
enabled by blockchain. Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy charging station for electric vehicles. Mater Today Proc 2021;45(9):8059–63.
2021;9(1):104–13. Jan. [149] Wang Y, Kazemi M, Nojavan S, Jermsittiparsert K. Robust design of off-grid solar-
[120] Ping J, Yan Z, Chen S, Yao L, Qian M. Coordinating EV charging via blockchain. powered charging station for hydrogen and electric vehicles via robust
Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy (MPCE) 2020;8(3):573–81. optimisation approach. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2020;45(38):18995–9006. Jul.
May. [150] Nunes P, Farias T, Brito MC. Day charging electric vehicles with excess solar
[121] Chen X, Zhang T, Ye W, Wang Z, Iu HC. Blockchain-based electric vehicle electricity for a sustainable energy system. Energy 2015;80:263–74. Feb.
incentive system for renewable energy consumption. IEEE Transactions on [151] He F, Fathabadi H. Novel standalone plug-in hybrid electric vehicle charging
Circuits and Systems II: Express Briefs 2021;68(1):396–400. Jan. station fed by solar energy in presence of a fuel cell system used as supporting
[122] Wang Y, Su Z, Zhang N. BSIS: blockchain-based secure incentive scheme for power source. Renew Energy 2020;156:964–74. Aug.
energy delivery in vehicular energy network. IEEE Trans Ind Inf 2019;15(6): [152] Mahdavian A, Shojaei A, Mccormick S, Papandreou T, Eluru N, Oloufa AA.
3620–31. Jun. Drivers and barriers to implementation of connected, automated, shared, and
[123] Zhang T, Pota H, Chua CC, Gadha R. Real-time renewable energy incentive system electric vehicles: an agenda for future research. IEEE Access 2021;9:22195–213.
for electric vehicles using prioritisation and cryptocurrency. Appl Energy 2018; Feb.
226:582–94. Sep.

16
K.Y. Yap et al. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169 (2022) 112862

[153] [cited 2021 Decmber 28.] Available from: Statista https://www.statista.com/stat [157] Li Y, Cai Y, Zhao T, Liu Y, Wang J, Wu L, et al. Multi-objective optimal operation
istics/609846/total-sunshine-hours-in-england-uk/. of centralised battery swap charging system with photovoltaic. Journal of Modern
[154] Mishra S, Dwivedi G, Upadhyay S, Chauhan A. Modelling of standalone solar Power Systems and Clean Energy. 2022; 10(1): 149-162.
photovoltaic based electric bike charging. Mater Today Proc 2021. https://doi. [158] Wei H, Liang J, Li C, Zhang Y. Real-time locally optimal schedule for electric
org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.02.738. Mar. vehicle load via diversity-maximization NSGA-II. Journal of Modern Power
[155] Erdemir D, Dincer I. Assessment of renewable energy-driven and flywheel Systems and Clean Energy 2021;9(4):940–50. Jul.
integrated fast-charging station for electric buses: a case study. J Energy Storage [159] Singh S, Chauhan P, Singh NJ. Feasibility of grid-connected solar-wind hybrid
2020;30:101576. Aug. system with electric vehicle charging station. Journal of Modern Power Systems
[156] Gorjian S, Ebadi H, Trommsdorff M, Sharon H, Demant M, Schindele S. The and Clean Energy 2021;9(2):295–306. Mar.
advent of modern solar-powered electric agricultural machinery: a solution for
sustainable farm operations. J Clean Prod 2021;292:126030. Apr.

17

You might also like