You are on page 1of 17

Japan Journal of Food Engineering, Vol. 16, No. 1, pp. 37 - 52, March.

2015

◇◇◇ Review ◇◇◇

Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying


1 2 3 3,†
Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT , Riitta PARTANEN , Tze Loon NEOH , Hidefumi YOSHII
1
Department of Chemical Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Pathumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand
2
Bioprocessing, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, P.O. Box 1000, 02044 VTT, Espoo, Finland
3
Department of Applied Biological Science, Kagawa University, 2393 Ikenobe Miki-chi, Kita, Kagawa 761-0795, Japan

The encapsulation of flavors is the important process in food industry. The encapsulation of flavors
with spray drying and the flavor release from spray-dried powder were reviewed. The hydrophobic
flavor was in the form of emulsion before spray dr ying. Therefore, the researches were mainly
related to the forming of emulsion which wall material containing emulsifier properties are required.
On the other hands, the hydrophilic flavor was mainly related to the antioxidant and coloring flavor
powder. The hygroscopicity of powder and their stickyness during the spray dryer were important
points to improve which the remaining of hydrophilic flavors were less concerned. The morphologies,
and flavor release behavior are important physical properties of the flavor encapsulated powder.
Especially, the correlation equations for the flavor release are summarized in the relation with
Avrami or Weibull equation. The glass transition temperature is important to estimate the collapse
of the powder and the permeation of the powder matrix to flavor compounds. The flavor release
(mass transfer of flavor) rate is affected by temperature difference (T- Tg ). In this review, recent
researches are summarized in the flavor encapsulation in spray drying, especially for tropical flavor
encapsulation.
Keywords: flavor, encapsulation, spray drying, powder, controlled release

1. Introduction al. [7] evaluated the flavor and quality of ‘Or’ and ‘Odem’
mandarins after 4 weeks of storage. Rouseff et al. [8]
Tropical fruits are of increasing interest to consumers reviewed historical review of citrus flavor research dur-
worldwide. Fabiano et al reviewed the drying of exotic ing the past 100 years. Bicas et al. [9] investigated vola-
tropical fruits and indicated the drying method affected tile constituents of exotic fruits from Brazil. They pointed
the quality of fruits such as the content of vitamins [1]. the flavor in these fruits was a very important factor.
The tropical fruits are exotic in flavor. Flavor contents in Perez-Cacho and Rouseff [10] reviewed processing and
the fruits were affected also by the drying conditions and storage effects on orange juice aroma. They indicated
method. Flavor (aroma) is one of the most important the flavor compounds were labile compounds and unsta-
attributes that affects the consumption of fruit from the ble during the storage. One method is the encapsulation
tropics and subtropics. In food industr y, various core to form stable flavor form. Madene et al. [4] reviewed the
compounds, such as volatile compounds, essential oils, flavor encapsulation and controlled release. They sum-
and oleoresins, are encapsulated with some specific con- marized the flavor release mechanism from the powder
cerns, such as safety usage of solvent and wall material. with diffusion, swelling, melting and degradation. Gibbs
The most common and economical way to carr y out et al. [11] reviews also the encapsulation in the food
microencapsulation to retain and protect chemically reac- industry. They showed encapsulation in foods is also uti-
tive or flavor compounds is spray drying so that it is lized to mask odours or tastes. Various techniques are
widely used in commercial scale. Many research works employed to form the capsules, including spray drying,
related to encapsulation of liquid flavors by spray drying spray chilling or spray cooling, extrusion coating, fluid-
have been reported [2- 5]. Several researchers investi- ized bed coating, liposome entrapment, coacer vation,
gated the volatile flavor constituents of tropical fruits and inclusion complexation, centrifugal extrusion and rota-
flavor behaviors at storage. Pino and Marbot [6] investi- tional suspension separation. Powder formation of these
gated the volatile constituent of acerola fruits. Tietel et flavors is one interesting process of food industr y.
Zuidam and Heinrich [12] edited the book of
“Encapsulation Technologies for active food ingredients
(Received 17 Jan. 2015: accepted 23 Feb. 2015)
† Fax: 087-891-3021, E-mail: foodeng.yoshii@ag.kagawa-u.ac.jp and food processing”. The aroma encapsulation were
38 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

summarized in the book. Spray drying has been playing used of wall materials to encapsulated hydrophobic flavor
a vital role in the encapsulation and microencapsulation by spray drying is gum arabic (also known as arabic gum
of functional compounds in food. or acacia gum) and n- octenyl succinic anhydride (OSA)-
The losses of both hydrophilic and hydrophobic fla- modified starch since both of them have the emulsifier
vors during the spray drying were reported in each step properties. The maltodextrin was also used to blend with
of process. The losses of flavors were occurred first dur- the emulsifier wall materials as the drying aid which was
ing the atomization step. The flavors and water are evap- also prevent the losses of flavor during the spray drying
orated with the hot inlet air at initial period of drying. process. The higher solid content increased the flavors
The loss of flavors especially the high volatile flavors retention because the rate of crust formation around the
(with low boiling point temperature) was expected in this atomized droplet as the selective diffusion membrane for
period with the temperature of droplet increase. In the the flavors is increased. The surfactants were also added
second step with the constant drying periods, the forma- to stabilize the emulsion with less used methods. The
tion of crust was occurred. The crust was the selective used surfactants are mostly in the form of viscous and
membrane allows the higher diffusion rate of water than sticky liquid affected to the physical properties as well as
the flavors resulted the higher remaining of flavor in the the yield of product. The surfactant can stabilize the
droplet. However, the high solubility flavor as well as emulsion but it cannot cover the flavor droplet during the
hydrophilic flavor was lost in the higher amount than in drying periods.
the hydrophobic flavor. The dissolved flavors were loss There are some of works that reported the new wall
during the drying as the water molecule. After the solid materials with the emulsifier properties comparing to the
droplets were formed, the loss of flavors was expected to conventional materials of gum arabic and OSA- modified
occur with the change of powder morphology. However, starch. Drusch [13] reported a novel emulsifying wall
the losses in this step were less amount comparing to the component of sugar beet pectin. Beristain et al. [14- 15]
first and second steps. showed the application of mesquite gum with the high
In this paper, the hydropobic and hydrophilic flavors retention. Xie et al. [16] reported the addition of peach
encapsulation focusing on tropical flavor by spray drying gum in the emulsion system resulted the smooth surface
especially the work published in last decade were of spray dried powder. Hogan et al. [17] used the whey
reviewed including the flavor release mechanism as well protein concentrate to encapsulate the soya oil. The
as the oxidation of encapsulated flavors. whey protein concentrate offered the surface active prop-
erties required to stabilize emulsion. Hogan et al. [18]
2. The encapsulated hydrophobic flavors showed the encapsulation with sodium caseinate/matlo-
dextrin blends. Charve and Reineccius [19] evaluated the
To encapsulate the hydrophobic flavors by spray dry- potential of selected proteins (sodium caseinate, whey
ing, the emulsion of flavors will first to produce under and soy protein isolates) as alternative materials for fla-
the wall materials solution. Therefore, the wall materials vor comparing to the gum arabic and modified starch.
with emulsifier properties or the additional of surfactant The highest flavor retention in gum arabic was reported
are required. Then the flavor emulsion is spray dried to but protein materials effectively limited limonene oxida-
form the encapsulated flavors powder. The flavor is in the tion. Calvo et al. [20] studied the microencapsulation of
form of droplet inside the shell wall of powder as the extra - virgin olive oil by spray - dr ying with proteins
multi core encapsulated powder. In the past decade, the (sodium caseinate and gelatin), gum arabic and malto-
research works are studied the effects of each factors on dextrin. A better microcapsule yield, ef ficiency, and
the flavor retention during spray drying. During the stor- internal- external fat ratio were achieved when a combi-
age with various conditions, the water, oxygen and flavor nation of proteins and polysaccharides was used as the
itself can diffuse through the shell wall. The stability of wall component. Liu et al. [21] used the soybean soluble
encapsulated flavors during the storage is also widely polysaccharide to encapsulate the hydrophobic flavors.
investigated. The increasing of flavor retention with addition of gelatin
to the emulsion was also reported. The volatile com-
2.1 Wall materials pounds were retained in dry emulsions stabilized by pea
Wall materials are one of the most important factors on protein isolate/pectin complex. The pectin was able to
the properties of encapsulated flavor powder. The widely preserve the β- sheet secondary structure of pea protein
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 39

when pea globulins/pectin complexes are heated. spray drying. Partanen et al. [31] reported the microen-
Drusch et al. [22] and Gharsallaoui et al. [23] described capsulation of caraway extract in β - cyclodextrin and
the fundamental physical characteristics of spray-dried modified starches. The inclusion complex seemed to pro-
carrier matrices based on sodium caseinate and casein tect volatile substances more efficiently during storage,
hydrolyzate. Surface accumulation of proteins at the air- whereas microcapsules with modified starches as wall
water interface led to a modified surface composition of material were more heat tolerant. Encapsulation of
spray-dried carrier matrix particles for microencapsula- extracted sea buckthorn kernel oil and the stability of
tion. However, the interfacial elasticity was markedly the products were also investigated. Encapsulation of
altered when using hydrolyzed casein as emulsifier, extracted sea buckthorn kernel oil in maltodextrin and
which is related to a decrease in microencapsulation effi- emulsifying starch derivative and the stability of the
ciency. Lipid oxidation during storage of the microencap- products were investigated [32]. Teixeira et al. [33]
sulated oil increased with the protein content in the for- encapsulated swiss cheese flavor in conventional wall
mulation. Excess protein led to an increase in free vol- materials of gum arabic and maltodextrin. The rose oil
ume elements and is suspected to increase oxygen diffu- which composed of 2 - phenylethanol (50.22%), nerol
sion. (22.34%) and citronellol (19.40%) was also encapsulated
Klinkesorn [24] used the two- layered interfacial mem- gum arabic and maltodextrin wall materials. The yield of
branes of lecithin–chitosan to emulsified the tuna oil encapsulated rose oil varied with wall materials (64–70%)
combination with the maltodextrin as drying aid materi- [34]. The model flavor of menthol was also encapsulated
als. The high oil retention levels (>85%) was obtained. in gum arabic and modified starch. The re- crystallize to
Loksuwan [25] showed the modified tapioca starch as form whisker of menthol during storage was discussed
potential wall material for encapsulation of β-carotene. [35]. Krishnan et al. [36] reported the microencapsula-
The efficacy of pullulan as stabilizer to achieve a stable tion of cardamom oleoresin using binar y and ternar y
emulsion of turmeric oleoresin and its subsequent micro- blends of gum arabic, maltodextrin, and OSA- modified
encapsulation was investigated. Kshirsagare et al. [26] starch as wall materials. Bixin was encapsulated by
and Yang et al. [27] used the konjac glucomannan spray - dr ying with gum arabic or maltodextrin [37].
(KGM) which have the excellent film forming capability Dzondo - Gadet [38] reported the encapsulation of safou
to encapsulate orange oil. The KGM was hydrolyzed pulp oil in maltodextrins(DE=6). Baranauskiene et al.
before used to decrease the viscosity of carrier solution. [39] reported the encapsulation of natural flavorings of
Because of the lack of emulsifier properties, the surfac- oregano, citronella and marjoram into skimmed milk
tant or gum arabic or OSA-modified starches have to add powder and whey protein concentrate. Vaidya et al. [40]
in the system. reports on the microencapsulation of cinnamon oleoresin
Furthermore, the combination of encapsulation meth- by spray drying using binary and ternary blends of gum
ods between the inclusion complex and spray dr ying arabic, maltodextrin, and modified starch as wall materi-
were also reported. The cyclodextrins and their deriva- als. Shaikh et al. [41] reports on microencapsulation of
tives was used to form the inclusion complex of hydro- black pepper oleoresin (piperine) by spray-drying, using
phobic flavor and then following by spray drying to form gum arabic and OSA- modified starch as wall materials.
the dry products. Liu et al. [28] showed the encapsulated The encapsulation of peppermint oil in modified starch
of menthols in β, α and γ- cyclodextrin following with was also reported with the encapsulation efficiency about
the single droplet drying process to simulate the loss of 80 percent [42]. About 60 percent encapsulation effi-
flavor during spray drying process. Kawakami et al. [29] ciency of cold pressed avocado oil using whey protein
showed the encapsulation of rice flavor in α-cyclodextrin and maltodextrin was reported [43]. Bae et al. [43] and
and highly branched cyclic dextrin by spray drying. Jimenez et al. [44] reported the encapsulation of conju-
gated linoleic acid in whey protein concentrate and gum
2.2 Type of hydrophobic flavors arabic. Ahn et al. [45] studied the encapsulation of high
Numerous of works have reported the encapsulation of oleic sunflower oil. The lipid oxidation of encapsulated
flavors as well as the tropical flavors in both of model fla- sunflower oil was remarkable decreased with the addi-
vors and natural extracted flavors. Bylaitë et al. [30] tion of the mixed natural antioxidants extract to the sys-
encapsulated the caraway essential oil in mixtures of tem. Natural Canthaxantin was encapsulated in soybean
whey protein concentrate and malodextrins matrix by soluble polysaccharides. The results showed the oxida-
40 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

tion was more suppressed for the microcapsules pre- quality of the product as the flavor concentration in dry
pared from the emulsion having smaller droplets [46]. basis was decreased. Numerous works was done to
Touré et al. [47] reported the microencapsulation of gin- improve these problems rather than the retention of fla-
ger oil in maltodextrin(DE=18)/whey protein isolate vor in the powder products.
with the application of the higher pressure homogeniza-
tion. The best conditions for higher retention at 93 per- 3.1 Wall materials
cent were found. The influence of some process condi- Some new wall materials and wall materials systems
tions on the microencapsulation of flaxseed oil (vegeta- were applied to solve the stickyness and hygroscopic
ble sources of ω- 3) in gum arabic by spray drying was properties problems with high flavor content. Oliveira et
reported [48]. Rodea- González [49] reported the encap- al. [54] showed the potential using of cashew tree gum to
sulation of chia essential oil in whey protein concentrate- partially replace the conventional maltodextrin as drying
polysaccharide matrices. Ko et al. [50] produced the aid agent in spray dr ying of cashew apple juice. The
encapsulated allyl isothiocyanate (AITC) in gum arabic retention of ascorbic acid was increased with the
and chitosan materials via spray drying. Lim et al. [51] decreasing of powder hygroscopicity especially when the
investigated the influence of the composition of the wall ratio of cashew tree gum to maltodextrin is higher than
material on the encapsulation and stability of microen- 50%.
capsulated red- fleshed pitaya seed oil by spray dr ying. Recently, the protein compounds were added to the
The study on oil retention revealed that sodium casein- feed solution in the small amount to increase the hygro-
ate > whey protein > gum arabic as effective wall materi- scopic proper ties instead of adding high content of
als for pitaya seed oil encapsulation. Rubilar et al. [52] maltodextrin. Jayasundera et al. [55] reported the pow-
prepared the formulation of soup powder enriched with der recover y up to 80% of amorphous fructose and
ω- 3 fatty acids of linseed oil in gum arabic/maltodex- sucrose powder with the addition of sodium caseinate at
trin mixture. Recently, the encapsulation of multiflavors 7.89% and 0.13% respectively. The protein compounds in
bergamot oil in gum arabic and modified starch were the emulsion were reported to form the film and crust
studied. The transformation among each flavor to give around atomized droplet during the drying process. Kim
the retention higher than 100 percent was discussed et al. [56] reported the surface composition of spray
[53]. dried of milk powder. The results showed that the sur-
face composition is very much different from the bulk
3. The encapsulated hydrophilic flavors composition of powders. A maltodextrin/apple pectin
based matrix was used to encapsulate the plant extracts.
To encapsulate the hydrophilic flavors, the aqueous The bioactive polyphenols and moisture content of the
solution of flavor and carrier solid was prepared. Then, particles or the antioxidant activity appeared significantly
the aqueous mixture was spray dried. The flavors are dis- modified [57].
persed and encapsulated in the dried carrier solid in the
form of matrix type. 3.2 Type of hydrophilic flavors
The researches work is now aim to improve the physi- There are numerous of works reported the encapsu-
cal properties of the powder. The main problem of the lated hydrophilic flavors such as juice powder and colo-
natural hydrophilic flavors is the content of the soluble rant powder. In general, for the hydrophobic and hydro-
solid as low molecular of saccharide in the extract aque- philic flavors which have the close molecular weight
ous flavor which is a cause of the stickyness and the high and normal boiling point, the retention of hydrophilic
hydroscopicity. Therefore, the research is aim to flavors during the spray dr ying are lower than the
improve the hygroscopicity of product as well as to retention of hydrophobic flavors as the mechanism
decrease the sticky of obtained powder during the spray explained above. However, the low amount of remaining
drying. The maltodextrin was normally used as the dry- flavor in the powder is enough for the application of
ing aid agents to the system. The higher maltodextrin juice powder as well as the colorant product. As men-
content decreased the stickyness and hygroscopicity of tion before, almost of the works done in encapsulate
the product. The gum arabic was also used because of its hydrophilic flavor the stickyness and hygroscopicity of
excellent film forming properties even the emulsifier product are concerned with a few reported of colorant
properties are not required in this system. However, the retention. Amaranthus betacyanin extracts were spray-
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 41

dried using a range of maltodextrins (DE10- 25) and obtained by spray dr ying of puntia stricta fruit juices
starches (native/modified) as car rier and coating with glucose syrup (DE 29) as drying aid. Color was
agents. Adding maltodextrins and starches significantly retained during the drying process (>98%) and drying
reduced the hygroscopicity of the betacyanin extracts yield was high (58%) [70]. Moreira et al. [71] assessed
and enhanced storage stability [58]. The extracted 2-ace- the impact of some processing parameters on moisture
tyl-1- pyrroline odor of rice flavor was encapsulated in content, flowability, hygroscopicity and water solubility
gum arabic and maltodextrin [59]. Shiga et al. [60] devel- of spray dried acerola pomace extract using maltodextrin
oped the encapsulated extracted shiitake flavors powder and cashew tree gum as drying aids. Bakowska-Barczak
by spray drying. The mixture between cyclodextrin and and Kolodziejczyk [72] prepared the encapsulated black
maltodextrin was used as carrier. A heat treatment to currant berries in maltodextrin (DE 11, 18 and 21) and
increase the lenthionine before the spray drying was rec- inerlin by spray drying. The retention of black currant
ommended. Cactus pear juice powder was produced with polyphenol compounds and their antioxidant activity was
maltodextrin with different DE values. The retention of investigated. The DE11 of maltodextrin had not only
vitamin C as well as the powder properties was also higher drying yield but also offered better protection for
reported [61]. Cano- Chauca et al. [62] investigated the phenolics during storage. Pomegranate bioactive com-
induction of crystallization on powder mango juice dur- pounds (polyphenols and anthocyanins) of juice were
ing the process of spray drying and the correlation of the encapsulated with maltodextrin or soybean protein iso-
microstructure of the powder obtained with the func- lates by spray dr ying. The polyphenols encapsulating
tional properties of stickiness and solubility. The malto- efficiency was significantly better in soybean protein iso-
dextrin, gum arabic and waxy starch were used as wall lates matrix whereas for anthocyanins was in maltodex-
materials with the additional of cellulose. They reported trin matrix [73]. Kha et al. [74] reported a good quality
that the cellulose as a substance that induces crystalliza- gac powder in terms of colour, carotenoid content and
tion of sugar is not suitable. Immature acerola juice pow- total antioxidant activity can be produced by spray dry-
der was prepared by spray drying with maltodextrin and ing at low inlet temperature (120 ºC) and adding malto-
gum arabic. The ratio of juice solid to carrier was 1:1. dextrin concentration at 10% w/v. Chin et al. [75]
The glass transition temperature and the stickiness of reported the stability of encapsulated durian powder by
the powder was discussed [63]. The raisin juice powder spray drying. Gum arabic, maltodextrin and N-Lok were
was produced with maltodextrins as drying aid agents. It used as wall materials. The retention of maker volatile
was shown that the lower the DE of the maltodextrin compounds (two esters and two sulfides) was investi-
used, the lower the temperature of drying air at the inlet gated during spray drying and storage. The retention of
and the lower the concentration of drying aid in the feed flavors was in the rage of 20- 70%. The study demon-
were required for successful powder production [64]. strated that volatiles with larger molecular weight tended
The watermelon powder was produced with maltodex- to retain better during spray drying. However, the stabil-
trin. Addition of maltodextrin reduced the stickiness of ity during storage was still low. Nayak and Rastogi [76]
the products and altered the physicochemical properties reported that maltodextrin is an effective drying aid for
of the spray-dried powders. The loss of lycopene and production of microencapsulated anthocyanin from gar-
carotene occurred at higher inlet temperatures [65]. cinia indica. Addition of gum acacia and tricalcium phos-
Microencapsulation of anthocyanin pigments of black phate fur ther reduced the hygroscopicity as well as
carrot by spray drying with maltodextrin (DE 10, 20, 30) increasing the stability of the pigments. Goula and
was reported. The highest anthocyanin content powder Adamopoulos [77] investigated the development a new
was found in DE20 of maltodextrin. The higher air inlet technique for spray dr ying orange juice concentrate
temperature the higher anthocyanin losses [66]. Gong et using dehumidified air as drying medium and maltodex-
al. [67] produced the instant bayberry powder by spray trin as drying agent. They indicated the hygroscopicity
drying following with the agglomeration process. Tonon and degree of caking decrease with an increase in inlet
et al. [68] studied the influence of spray drying condi- air temperature and maltodextrin concentration and a
tions on the physicochemical properties of açai powder decrease in maltodextrin dextrose equivalent and the
with maltodextrin DE 10 as carrier. The curcumin pig- combination of maltodextrin addition and use of dehu-
ments was also produced by spray drying using porous midified air as drying medium seems to be an effective
starch and gelatin [69]. A powder food colorant was way of producing a free-flowing orange powder. The pro-
42 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

duction of bayber r y polyphenols powder with MD 4. Effects of related factors on the retention of
(DE10) by spray drying with the retention of phenolic the flavor and properties of encapsulated powder
content and total anthocayanins after spray dr ying at
about 95% was reported [78]. The water extract of the The properties of wall materials, flavors, emulsion as
mountain tea was spray- dried by using β- cyclodextrin, well as the spray drying parameters have been reported
gum arabic and maltodextrins as carrier materials. The to affect the retention and properties of obtained encap-
product yield increased with the addition of the carrier sulated flavor powder. In this paper, some of the works
materials whereas decreased at higher drying tempera- that reported to each property were reviewed. Mongenot
tures [79]. Suhaimi et al. [80] carried out to determine et al. [87] showed the ultrasound emulsification on
the effect of different ratios of pineapple juice to malto- cheese aroma encapsulation. The use of ultrasound is
dextrin as a carrier agent. These results suggested that particularly effective to obtain a stable emulsion with
the ratio of pineapple juice solid to maltodextrin at 40:60 maltodextrin as support, which is known for poor emulsi-
produced the highest powder output at 84.85% recovery. fication properties. Buffo et al. [88] study the effect of
Yousefi et al. [81] reported the pomegranate juice was agglomeration process of fluidization on the retention of
diluted to 12° Brix and carriers (maltodextrin, gum ara- flavor in the powder. Flavors retention was not adversely
bic, waxy starch) were added with varying concentra- affected by the secondary processing as long as agglom-
tions of cellulose before being reduced to powder by eration did not promote structure collapse. Finney et al.
spray dr ying. The gum arabic still showed the most [89] report the effects of type of atomization and process-
effective carriers. The production of pomegranate juice ing temperatures on the physical properties and stability
powder with DE6 of maltodextrin was also investigated. of spray-dried flavors. Type of atomizer and inlet air tem-
The results showed that inlet temperature had a great perature did not af fected to the total oil content.
influence on the physicochemical proper ties of the However, the centrifugal atomizer gave the higher sur-
spray- dried powders. The antioxidant capacity of the face oil content than spray nozzle type. This study added
sample increased with increasing air inlet temperature. factual evidence to strengthen the hypothesis that shelf
However, the total phenolics content of the samples was life depends primarily on the porosity of dried particles
not affected by temperature [82]. Furthermore, also to and confirmed that surface oil is not a significant deter-
produce the pomegranate juice powder, Vardin and Yasar minant of shelf life. Cho and Park [90] showed the dou-
[83] showed the optimization of pomegranate juice ble encapsulation of limonene powder by coating the
spray-drying as affected by temperature and maltodex- powder with wax oil. The double encapsulated limonene
trin content. Solval et al. [84] developed a cantaloupe was consistently stable without the oxidation.
juice powders from fresh cantaloupe fruit by spray dry- Soottitantawat et al. [91] reported the effect of flavor
ing. The 10 wt% maltodextrin solution was used as a car- emulsion size on their retention after spray drying. The
rier. The results indicated that the inlet air temperature large emulsion size gave the low flavor retention in both
of the spray dryer can affect vitamin C and β-carotene of non- soluble and partly- soluble flavors because the
contents of cantaloupe juice powders. Caparino et al. droplet was sheared during the atomization process.
[85] showed the effect of dr ying methods (refractance However, for the small emulsion size give the higher
window dr ying, freeze dr ying, drum dr ying and spray retention of non-soluble flavor but give the lower reten-
dr ying) on the physical properties and microstructures t i o n i n t h e c a s e o f p a r t l y - s o l u b l e f l a v o r.
of mango powder. The maltodextrin was used as carrier Microencapsulation by spray dr ying of multiple emul-
for the spray dr ying technique. The higher porosity or sions containing carotenoids was reported to improve
lower bulk density in spray- dried mango powder was their properties [92]. Turchiuli et al. [93] investigated
due to the addition of maltodextrin. The spray dried the feasibility of encapsulation of a vegetable oil used as
powder showed the least hygroscopic comparing to a model into a mixture of maltodextrin and acacia gum.
other types of dr ying. Wang and Zhou [86] character- Encapsulation was completed in three stages, i.e. emulsi-
ized of spray- dried soy sauce powders using maltodex- fication, spray dr ying and fluid bed agglomeration.
trins. Maltodextrin concentration and DE value greatly Agglomeration did not change oil encapsulation proper-
influenced the caking strength of the soy sauce pow- ties of the spray - dried powder but considerably
ders. improved its wettability. Chegini and Ghobadian [94]
investigated the effects of the feed ratio, atomizer speed,
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 43

and inlet air temperature on properties of spray-dried reported. The salt concentration of not lower than 14 wt%
orange juice powders basing on a full factorial experi- was recommended [101]. Paramita et al. [102] developed
mental design. Tan et al. [95] reported the effect of the high content of encapsulated of d- liomonene powder.
marine oil loading on the encapsulation efficiency when The medium- chain triglyceride was mixed to the d-Limo-
modified starch was used as wall materials. The higher nene to make the emulsion in the OSA-modified starch
oil loading increased the droplet size of emulsions carrier solution before spray drying. Goula et al. [77,
formed resulted the higher surface content and lower 103] reported an effective way of increasing lycopene
production yield. The encapsulation of vegetable oil as encapsulation and reducing residue formation of spray
the model in MD and GA was studied. The direct dried orange juice concentrate by using dehumidified air
agglomeration process was used to increase the size of as the drying medium.
the particle to improve the flowability and wettability
[96]. A cool chamber wall spray dr yer was used to 5. Morphology of spray - dried powder
increase the production of yield of lime juice powder
because of the decreasing of particles stickiness on the Spray drying is the process by which a solution or
wall [97]. The different emulsifying ingredients (Tween slurry is transformed into a dry powder by spraying the
20, modified starch or whey protein concentrate) were fluid feed material into a hot drying medium. The mor-
used to produce sub- micron emulsions by high pressure phology of the spray- dried particle has been studied
homogenizer. The biopolymers were not efficient ingre- extensively by Walton and Mumford [104] and Walton
dients to produce ver y small emulsion droplets com- [105] using a suspended droplet drying techniques. They
pared with small molecule surfactants because of their classified the morphology of the droplet into 3 catego-
slow adsorption kinetics [98]. However, it was not possi- ries; agglomerate, skin-forming, and crystalline. Figure
ble to produce a fairly stable microfluidized emulsion 1 shows four powder photos of scanning electron micro-
with surfactants for encapsulation purposes. The influ- scope, milk proteins (a), spray- dried fat with maltodex-
ence of par ticle morphology of spray dried powders trin (b) , mannitol (c) and α-cyclodextrin (d). Several
obtained by using different carriers on the efficiency of spray-dried powders have aggregates as shown in Fig.
microencapsulation of rosemary aroma is investigated. 1(a), which were formed at the outlet gas temperature
The efficiency of encapsulating aroma inside the cap- above glass transition temperature. The cr ystalline in
sules depended on the size of obtained particles and the spray -dried powder with mannitol and cyclodextrin were
apparent density of powders. An increase in the average observed. Higher content fat in wall material could be
diameter and decrease in the apparent density of pow- observed smooth surface in spray-dried powder.
ders decreased the quantity of microcapsulated aroma Morphologies of the powder particle by spray drying
[99]. Serfert et al. [100] investigate the impact of the
emulsifying carrier matrix constituent, n- octenylsucci-
nate derivatised (OSA)- starch, and process conditions
on physical characteristics and oxidative stability of
microencapsulated fish oil. The highest oxidative stabil-
ity was observed for fish oil microencapsulated in OSA-
starch with the lowest average molecular weight. In
terms of spray-drying under inert conditions and in the
presence of air, lipid oxidation of microencapsulated fish
oil was rather attributed to oxygen availability in the feed
emulsion than in the drying gas. The present study indi-
cates that also discrete air inclusion may accelerate lipid
oxidation of microencapsulated oils. To produce low-salt
fish sauce powder, the effect of electrodialysis pretreat-
ment on physicochemical properties and morphology of
Fig. 1 Morphologies of spray-dried powders.
powder was investigated. Without the additional carrier (a) Spray-dried milk powder (x140), (b) Spray-dried powder
materials, the lower hygroscopicity of the low salt fish with maltodextrin and fat (x800), (d) spray- dried mannitol
sauce powder with the low product recover y was (x1500), (d) Spray-dried α-cyclodextrin
44 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

affects upon the porosity, the surface integrity and flow 6. Release of flavor from spray- dried powder
properties of spray dried powder. Figure 2 shows dex-
trose equivalent (DE) of maltodextrin affects the surface Spray drying is the most commonly used technique for
integrity. Surface crinkle structure might depend on the the production of dr y flavorings. Zuidan and Heinlich
drying rate. The powders produced with higher malto- [111] summarized encapsulation of aroma. Morphologies
dextrin concentrations were less hygroscopic and had a of the encapsulant depend on the flavor release behavior
lower moisture content after drying. as well as wall material. The release mechanism compari-
Hecht and King [106] investigated the morphology son may be carried out using model independent or
changes of the particle by using single droplet. Rogers et model dependent methods [112]. In order to investigate
al. [107] investigated particle shrinkage and morphology the release mechanism, several different models have
of milk powder made with a monodisperse spray dryer. been employed for outlining the release mechanism from
They suggest the surface crust (initially spherical) is vis- matrices. The analysis of flavor release from spray-dried
coelastic and deforms in response to dr ying stresses. powder is complex and difficult, since the phenomena of
They also investigated the modelling of the formation of flavor release take place with intrinsically overlapping
insoluble material for a monodisperse spray dr yer. mechanisms, mainly by dissolution and subsequent diffu-
Alamilla-Beltrán et al. [108] investigated the morphologi- sion of flavors and water as well as flavor oxidations. The
cal changes of particles during spray drying and con- release rates, that are achievable from single microcap-
cluded the particle changes are related to moisture con- sule, are generally 0, 0.5, or 1st order. Zero -order release
tent of the material and operating drying temperatures. relation can be used to describe the flavor release of sev-
Abadio et al. [109] investigated physical properties of eral types of modified release flavor dried powders, as in
powdered pineapple (ananas comosus) juice in the effect the case of some transdermal systems, as well as matrix
of maltodextrin concentration and atomization speed. particles with low soluble flavor, coated forms, osmotic
They showed the powder density could be correlated systems, etc., When the core is a pure material and
with atomizing speed and maltodextrin concentration. release through the wall of the reservoir microcapsule as
Bhandari et al. [110] investigated spray drying of concen- a pure material, the release rates might indicate the
trated fruit juices. They obtained the optimal ratio of zero- order. Half order release kinetics occurs with
maltodextrin to the juice. In the morphology of the spray matrix particles. Diffusion is controlled by the solubility
dried powder, the coagulation of the particles is impor- of a flavor in the matrix and the diffusivity of the flavor
tant to evaluate the powder properties. The stickiness through the matrix [113]. A simple equation of Avrami
problem of sugar products such as fruit juices has been equation has been proposed for the correlation of the
related to their low glass transition temperature (Tg ) and release time- course of a spray- dried ethyl- n- butylate
water-induced plasticization.. powder during storage [5]

Fig. 2 Surface morphologies of spray-dried particle with various DE of maltodextrin.


Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 45

tion kinetics. Table 1 shows the proposed equation for


(1) various n values. Flavor release rate are strongly affected
Where R is the retention of flavor in the powder, t is by the environmental humidity and temperature since
the storage time, kR is the release rate constant, n is a the humidity as water vapor pressure influence the
parameter representing the release mechanism. This degree of plasticization of wall material and emulsion sta-
equation is also called the Weibull distribution function, bility in spray -dried powder. Soottitantawat et al. [116]
which has been successfully applied to describe the showed the release of d-limonene from emulsified d-lim-
shelf-life failure. A general empirical equation described onene in spray-dried powder was closely related to water
by Weibull [114] could be adapted to the dissolution/ activity of the powder.
release process. Figure 3 shows the release time-course
of ethyl butyrate from spray- dried powder with the mix- 7. Collapse of spray - dried powder
ture of gum arabic and maltodextrin, and soluble soy-
bean polysaccharides and maltodextrin. The mechanism Most amorphous carbohydrate systems are not in
values of n depend also on the wall material. The release equilibrium and can be metastable with slow kinetics for
time-course of ethyl butyrate fitted well to the Avrami’s changes, or unstable with physical changes occurring on
equation. This Avrami equation is essentially analogaous practical time scale. Dried fruits and vegetable juices are
to the equation of Kohlraush - Willian - Watt (KWW) convenience foods that have long storage life at ambient
[115]. Taking a logarithm of both sides of equation 1, we temperature. However, environmental humidity affected
can get the parameter n as slope by plotting ln[-ln R] vs. the physical structure of the powder. Stickiness is a
ln t and release rate constant k from the interception at ln major reason that limits the spray dr ying of various
t = 0. For n of value, n = 1 represents the first- order sugar- rich food products. The main constituents of fruit
reaction, n = 0.54 represents the diffusion- limiting reac- juices are low molecular weight sugars such as sucrose,

Fig. 3 Ef fect of gelatin on the release time - course of ethyl butyrate. (○●, MD
conc.=20% (w/w); △▲, 30% (w/w). GA or SSPS concentration=10% (w/w). Closed
symbols refer to the addition of gelatin. Solid lines are the correlation cur ves
obtained by Eq. (1)). [5]

Table 1 Comparison of mechanism value of n with the release model equation in Avrami equation.

Value of n Release mechanism Model equation

0.54 Diffusion controlled (sphere)

0.57 Diffusion controlled (cylinder)


0.62 Diffusion controlled (tablet)
1.00 First-order mechanism
1.07 Moving interface mechanism (sphere)
1.11 Moving interface mechanism (disk)
1.24 Zero-order mechanism
46 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

Table 2 The theories linked with the physical state of carbohydrate matrix affecting oxidation of matrix-embedded flavors and lipids.

Observation Theory Uncertainties/Limitations

1. Aw affects lipid oxidation rate Monolayer theory – best stability at Assumption of equilibrium, sorption the only mate-
monolayer moisture rial property considered

2. Oxygen is needed for hydroper- Oxygen transfer is rate-limiting for Shown for glassy system at ambient/ high tem-
oxide formation oxidation perature, but may depend on oil susceptibility

3. Diffusion of small molecules is Glass transition theory Diffusion not coupled with viscosity in the transi-
facilitated due to plasticization tion region

4. Dry starch is a good oxygen Role of water as solvent, solubility of Solubility data only for solutions of sugar alcohols,
barrier O2 in dry carbohydrate limits perme- extrapolated to low-water systems
ation

5. Average volume of the voids Glassy state swelling affects diffusion Also molecular packing affects as demonstrated
between polymers increases of small permeants in carbohydrate for glucose syrup in comparison to maltose as
gradually with increasing water matrices length of jump distances
content

6. Oxidative stability of oil in carbo- More intense structural re-organiza- Antioxidativity of proteins at high humidity may
hydrate and protein matrices is tion of the protein matrix in the pres- affect oxidative stability
oppositely affected by water ence of water due to hydrophobicity

glucose, fructose, and some organic acids. Jaya and Das the water content–water activity–glass transition temper-
[117] investigated the glass transition and sticky point ature relationships of commercial spray - dried borojó
temperatures and stability/mobility diagram of fruit pow- powder, as related to changes in color and mechanical
ders. They showed glass transition temperature of the properties. They showed the changes in the mechanical
fruit powders were interpreted in terms of the Gordon- properties of borojó powder related to collapse develop-
Taylor model (Eq(2)) for verification and glass transition ment started when the sample moved to the rubber y
and sticky point temperatures were compared by plotting state and began to be significant at about 10℃ above Tg .
them in a graph against moisture content. Collapse has been found to occur in amorphous system
above Tg , where its rate affected by temperature differ-
(2)
ence (T-Tg ) [120]. Soottitantawat et al. [116] indicated
where Tgm, Tgs, and Tgw are the glass transition tempera- the flavor release rates and oxidation rate of d-limonene
ture (℃) of the mixture, solids, and water respectively, Xs from spray-dried powder could be correlated with the
and Xw are the mass fraction of solids and water (wet temperature difference (T- Tg ). In their results, flavor
basis), and k is the Gordon–Taylor parameter. In the release rate constant increased with an increase in T- Tg
equation, the value of ‘k’ depends on moisture content and reached a maximum at roughly (T- Tg ) equals to
and the empirical equations derived for ‘k’ of three differ- zero, which is analogous to the oxidation rate constant.
ent fruits were different from each other. The empirical Moisture sorption properties of dry food products and
constant ‘k’ of power equations for different fruit pow- ingredients are critical in their overall processing, stor-
ders are [117]: age stability, and application performance. Dronen and
Reineccius [121] investigated rapid analysis of volatile
(3)
release from powders using dynamic vapor sorption
where a and b are parameters for powder (a=0.548, atmospheric pressure chemical ionization mass spec-
0.642, and 1.294 for mango, pineapple, and tomato pow- trometry and indicated the system demonstrated differ-
der, b=0.628, 0.5571, and 0.4474 for mango, pineapple, ences in volatile release as a function of volatile com-
and tomato powder, respectively). Foster et al. [118] pound, relative humidity, and food polymer. Mortenson
investigated glass transition related cohesion of amor- and Reineccius [122] investigated dynamic real- time
phous sugar powders and indicated the rate of cohesive- analysis to determine how carrier material affects men-
ness development is proportional to the (T–Tg ) value, thol release characteristics from various spray- dried
that is, the greater the temperature above the Tg , the powders. They showed DVS - P&T–GC methodology
quicker the powders will develop liquid bridges which proved to be a useful screening tool to select samples for
may result in caking. Mosquera et al. [119] investigated the more precise DVS–PTR–MS analysis.
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 47

Recent advances in understanding the nano - scale Technol., 2, 55-61 (2001).


structures, and thus packing, of carbohydrate matrices 6) J. A. Pino, R. Marbot; Volatile flavor constituents of acerola
[123, 124] should lead to better control over diffusion of (malpighia emarginata DC.) Fruit. J. Agric. Food Chem., 49,
small permeants in glassy state. Also the role of water 5880-5882 (2001).
has been re- assessed not only affecting as plasticizer, 7) Z. Tietel, E. Lewinsohn, E. Fallik, R. Porat; Importance of
but also as a solvent e.g. to oxygen [125, 126]. The theo- storage temperatures in maintaining flavor and quality of
ries linked with the physical state of carbohydrate matrix mandarins. Postharvest Biol. Technol., 64, 175-182 (2012).
affecting oxidation of matrix- embedded lipids and the 8) R. L. Rousef f, P. Ruiz Perez - Cacho, F. Jabalpur wala;
permeation of small components are briefly summarized Historical review of citrus flavor research during the past
in Table 2. 100 years. J. Agric. Food Chem., 57, 8115-8124 (2009).
9) J. L. Bicas, G. Molina, A. P. Dionísio, F. C. Barros, R. Wagner,
8. Conclusion M. R. Maróstica Jr, G. M. Pastore; Volatile constituents
of exotic fruits from Brazil. Food Res. Int., 44, 1843-1855
The microencapsulation of tropical flavors by spray (2011).
drying is reviewed with the recently published papers. 10) P. R. Perez - Cacho, R. Rouseff; Processing and storage
Spray drying is a useful method to encapsulate extracted effects on orange juice aroma: A review. J. Agric. Food
flavors or liquids of the tropical fruits in powder form. Chem., 56, 9785-9796 (2008).
The selection of wall materials and emulsifier, as well as 11) F. Gibbs, S. K., Inteaz Alli, N. Catherine, B. Mulligan;
the process conditions are very important to form the Encapsulation in the food industry: a review. Int. J. Food Sci.
suitable powder in food industr y. The stability and Nutr., 50, 213-224 (1999).
release of flavor are affected with the glass transition 12) N. J., Zuidam, V. Nedovic; “Encapsulation Technologies
temperature of the wall materials, and presumably by the for Active Food Ingredients and Food Processing” N. J.,
nano - scale structure of the formed powder matrix. Zuidam, V. Nedovic, (Eds.) Springer, 2010, p.400.
Storage conditions have a major role in both physical and 13) S. Drusch; Sugar beet pectin: A novel emulsifying wall com-
chemical stability of the powders. Basic mass- transfer ponent for microencapsulation of lipophilic food ingredients
phenomena of flavor release and stability during spray by spray-drying. Food Hydrocolloid., 21, 1223-1228 (2007).
drying and storage at different humidity conditions are 14) C. I. Beristain, H. S. Garcıa, E. J. Vernon-Carter; Spray-
currently under investigation using the latest analytical dried encapsulation of cardamom (Elettaria cardamomum)
instruments. essential oil with mesquite (Prosopis juliflora) gum. LWT
Food Sci. Techol., 34, 398-401 (2001).
Reference 15) C. I. Beristain, E. Azuara, E. J. Vernon-Carter; Effect of
water activity on the stability to oxidation of spray-dried
1) F. Fernandes, S. Rodrigues, C. Law, A. Mujumdar; Drying encapsulated orange peel oil using mesquite gum (Prosopis
of exotic tropical fruits: A comprehensive review. Food Juliflora) as wall material. J. Food Sci., 67, 206-211 (2002).
Bioprocess Tech., 4, 163-185 (2011). 16) Y. L. Xie, H. M. Zhou, H. F. Qian; Effect of addition of peach
2) A. Gharsallaoui, G. Roudaut, O. Chambin, A. Voilley, R. gum on physicochemical properties of gelatin base micro-
Saurel; Applications of spray-drying in microencapsulation capsule, J. Food Biochem., 30, 302-312 (2006).
of food ingredients: An overview. Food Res. Int., 40, 1107- 17) S. A. Hogan, B. F. McNamee, E. D. O’Riordan, M. O’Sullivan;
1121 (2007). Microencapsulating properties of whey protein concentrate.
3) S. Jafari, M. E. Assadpoor, Y. He, B. Bhandari; Encapsulation J. Food Sci., 66, 675-680v(2001).
efficiency of food flavours and oils during spray drying. Dry. 18) S. A. Hogan, B. F. McNamee, E. D. O’Riordan, M. O’Sullivan;
Technol., 26, 816-835 (2008). Emulsification and microencapsulation properties of sodium
4) A. Madene, M. Jacquot, J. Scher, S. Desobry; Flavour encap- caseinate/carbohydrate blends. Int. Dairy J., 11, 137-144
sulation and controlled release – a review. Int. J. Food Sci. (2001).
Tech., 41, 1-21 (2006). 19) J. Charve, G. A. Reineccius; Encapsulation performance of
5) H. Yoshii, A. Soottitantawat, X. D. Liu, T. Atarashi, T. Furuta, proteins and traditional materials for spray dried flavors. J.
S. Aishima, M. Ohgawara, P. Linko; Flavor release from Agric. Food Chem., 57, 2486-2492 (2009).
spray-dried maltodextrin/gum arabic or soy matrices as a 20) P. Calvo, T. Hernández, M. Lozano, D. González-Gómez;
function of storage relative humidity. Inno. Food Sci. Emerg. Microencapsulation of extra-virgin olive oil by spray-drying:
48 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

Influence of wall material and olive quality. Eur. J. Lipid Sci. starches. J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc., 79, 219-223 (2002).
Tech., 112, 852-858 (2010). 33) M. I. Teixeira, L. R. Andrade, M. Farina, M. H. M. Rocha-
21) X. Liu, T. Atarashi, T. Furuta, H. Yoshii, S. Aishima, M. Leão; Characterization of short chain fatty acid microcap-
Ohkawara, P. Linko; Microencapsulation of emulsified sules produced by spray drying. Mater. Sci. Eng. C., 24,
hydrophobic flavors by spray drying. Drying Technol., 19, 653-658 (2004).
1361-1374 (2001). 34) M. Verma, B. B. Borse, G. Sulochanamma, B. Raghavan;
22) S. Drusch, Y. Serfert, A. Berger, M. Q. Shaikh, K. Rätzke, V. Retention of benchmark flavour impact components in
Zaporojtchenko, K. Schwarz; New insights into the microen- encapsulated rose oil. Flavour Frag. J., 20, 122-126 (2005).
capsulation properties of sodium caseinate and hydrolyzed 35) A. Soottitantawat, K. Takayama, K. Okamura, D.
casein. Food Hydrocolloid., 27, 332-338 (2012). Muranaka, H. Yoshii, T. Furuta, M. Ohkawara, P. Linko;
23) A. Gharsallaoui, G. Roudaut, L. Beney, O. Chambin, A. Microencapsulation of l -menthol by spray drying and its
Voilley, R. Saurel; Properties of spray-dried food flavours release characteristics. Inno. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol., 6,
microencapsulated with two-layered membranes: Roles of 163-170 (2005).
interfacial interactions and water. Food Chem., 132, 1713- 36) S. Krishnan, R. Bhosale, R. S. Singhal; Microencapsulation
1720 (2012). of cardamom oleoresin: Evaluation of blends of gum ara-
24) U. Klinkesorn, P. Sophanodora, P. Chinachoti, E. A. Decker, bic, maltodextrin and a modified starch as wall materials.
D. J. McClements; Characterization of spray-dried tuna oil Carbohydr. Polym., 61, 95-102 (2005).
emulsified in two-layered interfacial membranes prepared 37) M. I. Barbosa, C. D. Borsarelli, A. Z. Mercadante; Light sta-
using electrostatic layer-by-layer deposition. Food Res. Int., bility of spray-dried bixin encapsulated with different edible
39, 449-457 (2006). polysaccharide preparations. Food Res. Int., 38, 989-994
25) J. Loksuwan; Characteristics of microencapsulated β-caro- (2005).
tene formed by spray drying with modified tapioca starch, 38) M. Dzondo-Gadet, J. M. Nzikou, A. Etoumongo, M. Linder,
native tapioca starch and maltodextrin. Food Hydrocolloid., S. Desobry; Encapsulation and storage of safou pulp oil in
21, 928-935 (2007). 6DE maltodextrins. Process Biochem., 40, 265-271(2005).
26) A. C. Kshirsagar, V. B. Yenge, A. Sarkar, R. S. Singhal; 39) R. Baranauskienė, P. R. Venskutonis, K. Dewettinck, R.
Efficacy of pullulan in emulsification of turmeric oleoresin Verhé; Properties of oregano (Origanum vulgare L.), citro-
and its subsequent microencapsulation. Food Chem., 113, nella (Cymbopogon nardus G.) and marjoram (Majorana
1139-1145 (2009). hortensis L.) flavors encapsulated into milk protein-based
27) J. Yang, J. Xiao, L. Ding; An investigation into the application matrices. Food Res. Int., 39, 413-425(2006).
of konjac glucomannan as a flavor encapsulant. Eur. Food 40) S. Vaidya, R. Bhosale, R. S. Singhal; Microencapsulation of
Res. Technol., 229, 467-474 (2009). cinnamon oleoresin by spray drying using different wall
28) X. D. Liu, T. Furuta, H. Yoshii, P. Linko, W. J. Coumans; materials. Drying Technol., 24, 983-992 (2006).
Cyclodextrin encapsulation to prevent the loss of l-menthol 41) J. Shaikh, R. Bhosale, R. Singhal; Microencapsulation of
and its retention during dr ying. Biosci. Biotechnol. black pepper oleoresin. Food Chem., 94, 105-110 (2006).
Biochem., 64, 1608-1613 (2000). 42) R. Baranauskienė, E. Bylaitė, J. Žukauskaitė, R. P.
29) K. Kawakami, A. Fujita, T. Mikami, H. Yoshii, V. Paramita, Venskutonis; Flavor retention of peppermint (Mentha piper-
T. Neoh, T. Furuta; Formation of rice flavor powder with α ita L.) essential oil spray-dried in modified starches during
-cyclodextrin by spray drying. Eur. Food Res. Technol., encapsulation and storage. J. Agric. Food Chem., 55, 3027-
229, 239-245 (2009). 3036 (2007).
30) E. Bylaitë, P. Venskutonis, R. Maþdþierienë; Properties of 43) E. K. Bae, S. J. Lee; Microencapsulation of avocado oil
caraway (Carum carvi L.) essential oil encapsulated into by spray drying using whey protein and maltodextrin. J.
milk protein-based matrices. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 212, Microencapsul, 25, 549-560 (2008).
661-670 (2001). 44) M. Jimenez, H. S. Garcia, C. I. Beristain, Effect of water
31) R. Partanen, M. Ahro, M. Hakala, H. Kallio, P. Forssell; activity on physical properties of conjugated linoleic acid
Microencapsulation of caraway extract in ß-cyclodextrin and (CLA) microcapsules. J. Food Proc. Eng., 33, 434 - 447
modified starches. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 214, 242-247 (2010).
(2002). 45) J. H. Ahn, Y. P. Kim, E. M. Seo, Y. K. Choi, H. S. Kim;
32) R. Partanen, H. Yoshii, H. Kallio, B. Yang, P. Forssell; Antioxidant effect of natural plant extracts on the microen-
Encapsulation of sea buckthorn kernel oil in modified capsulated high oleic sunflower oil. J. Food Eng., 84, 327-
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 49

334 (2008). Aquino, M. R. Lauro; Maltodextrin/pectin microparticles


46) M. Hojjati, S. Razavi, K. Rezaei, K. Gilani; Spray drying by spray drying as carrier for nutraceutical extracts. J. Food
microencapsulation of natural canthaxantin using soluble Eng., 105, 468-476 (2011).
soybean polysaccharide as a carrier. Food Sci. Biotech., 20, 58) Y. Z. Cai, H. Corke; Production and properties of spray-
63-69 (2011). dried amaranthus betacyanin pigments. J. Food Sci., 65,
47) A . T o u r é , H . B . L u , X . Z h a n g , X . X u e m i n g ; 1248-1252 (2000).
Microencapsulation of ginger oil in 18DE maltodextrin/ 59) M. Apintanapong, A. Noomhorm; The use of spray drying
whey protein isolate. J. Herbs Spices. Med. Plants, 17, 183- to microencapsulate 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline, a major flavour
195 (2011). component of aromatic rice. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 38,
48) R. V. Tonon, C. R. F. Grosso, M. D. Hubinger; Influence 95-102 (2003).
of emulsion composition and inlet air temperature on the 60) H. Shiga, H. Yoshii, H. Ohe, M. Yasuda, T. Furuta, H.
microencapsulation of flaxseed oil by spray drying. Food Kuwahara, M. Ohkawara, P. Linko; Encapsulation of shii-
Res. Int., 44, 282-289 (2011). take (Lenthinus Edodes) flavors by spray drying. Biosci.
49) D. A. Rodea - González, J. Cr uz - Olivares, A. Román - Biotechnol. Biochem, 68, 66-71 (2004).
Guerrero, M. E. Rodríguez-Huezo, E. J. Vernon-Carter, C. 61) G. R. Rodríguez - Her nández, R. González - García, A.
Pérez-Alonso; Spray-dried encapsulation of chia essential Grajales-Lagunes, M. A. Ruiz-Cabrera, M. Abud-Archila;
oil (Salvia hispanica L.) in whey protein concentrate-poly- Spray-drying of cactus pear juice (Opuntia streptacantha):
saccharide matrices. J. Food Eng., 111, 102-109 (2012). Effect on the physicochemical properties of powder and
50) J. A. Ko, W. Y. Kim, H. J. Park; Effects of microencapsulated reconstituted product. Drying Technol. 23, 955-973 (2005).
allyl isothiocyanate (AITC) on the extension of the shelf-life 62) M. Cano-Chauca, P. C. Stringheta, A. M. Ramos, J. Cal-
of kimchi. Int. J. Food Micro., 153, 92-98 (2012). Vidal; Effect of the carriers on the microstructure of mango
51) H. K. Lim, C. P. Tan, J. Bakar, S. P. Ng; Effects of different powder obtained by spray drying and its functional char-
wall materials on the physicochemical properties and oxida- acterization. Inno. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol., 6, 420-428
tive stability of spray-dried microencapsulated red-fleshed (2005).
pitaya seed oil. Food Bioproc. Technol., 5, 1220-1227 (2012). 63) A. Mara Righetto, F. Maria Netto; Effect of encapsulating
52) M. Rubilar, E. Morales, K. Contreras, C. Ceballos, F. materials on water sorption, glass transition and stability of
Acevedo, M. Villarroel, C. Shene; Development of a soup juice from immature acerola. Int. J. Food Properties, 8, 337-
powder enriched with microencapsulated linseed oil as a 346 (2005).
source of omega -3 fatty acids. Eur. J. Lipid Sci. Technol., 64) S. E. Papadakis, C. Gardeli, C. Tzia; Spray drying of raisin
114, 423-433 (2012). juice concentrate. Drying Technol., 24, 173-180 (2006).
53) P. P e n b u n d i t k u l , H . Yo s h i i , U . R u k t a n o n c h a i , T. 65) S. Y. Quek, N. K. Chok, P. Swedlund; The physicochemical
Charinpanitkul, A. Soottitantawat; The loss of OSA-modified properties of spray-dried watermelon powders. Chem. Eng.
starch emulsifier proper ty during the high pressure Process., 46, 386-392 (2007).
homogeniser and encapsulation of multi-flavour bergamot 66) S. Ersus, U. Yurdagel; Microencapsulation of anthocyanin
oil by spray drying. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 47, 2325-2333 pigments of black carrot (Daucus carota L.) by spray drier. J.
(2012). Food Eng., 80, 805-812 (2007).
54) M. A. De Oliveira, G. A. Maia, R. W. De Figueiredo, A. C. R. 67) Z. Gong, M. Zhang, A. S. Mujumdar, J. Sun; Spray drying
De Souza, E. S. De Brito, H. M. C. De Azeredo; Addition of and agglomeration of instant bayberr y powder. Dr ying
cashew tree gum to maltodextrin-based carriers for spray Technol., 26, 116 -121 (2007).
drying of cashew apple juice. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 44, 68) R. V. Tonon, C. Brabet, M. D. Hubinger; Influence of pro-
641-645 (2009). cess conditions on the physicochemical properties of açai
55) M. Jayasundera, B. Adhikari, T. Howes, P. Aldred; Surface (Euterpe oleraceae Mart.) powder produced by spray dry-
protein coverage and its implications on spray-drying of ing. J. Food Eng., 88, 411-418 (2008).
model sugar-rich foods: solubility, powder production and 69) Y. Wang, Z. Lu, F. Lv, X. Bie; Study on microencapsulation
characterization. Food Chem., 128, 1003-1016 (2011). of curcumin pigments by spray dr ying. Eur. Food Res.
56) E. H. J. Kim, X. D. Chen, D. Pearce; On the mechanisms of Technol., 229, 391-396 (2009).
surface formation and the surface compositions of industrial 70) J. M. Obón, M. R. Castellar, M. Alacid, J. A. Fernández-
milk powders. Drying Technol., 21, 265-278 (2003). López; Production of a red–purple food colorant from
57) F. Sansone, T. Mencherini, P. Picerno, M. d’Amore, R. P. Opuntia stricta fruits by spray drying and its application in
50 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

food model systems. J. Food Eng., 90, 471-479 (2009). 84) K. M. Solval, S. Sundararajan, L. Alfaro, S. Sathivel;
71) G. É. G. Moreira, M. G. Maia Costa, A. C. R. Souza, E. S. Development of cantaloupe (Cucumis melo) juice pow-
Brito, M. Medeiros, H. M. C. Azeredo, Physical properties of ders using spray drying technology. LWT- Food Sci. and
spray dried acerola pomace extract as affected by tempera- Technol., 46, 287-293 (2012).
ture and drying aids. LWT - Food Sci. Technol., 42, 641-645 85) O. A. Caparino, J. Tang, C. I. Nindo, S. S. Sablani, J. R.
(2009). Powers, J. K. Fellman; Effect of drying methods on the phys-
72) A. M. Bakowska-Barczak, P. P. Kolodziejczyk; Black currant ical properties and microstructures of mango (Philippine
polyphenols: Their storage stability and microencapsulation. ‘Carabao’ var.) powder. J. Food Eng., 111, 135-148 (2012).

Ind. Crops Prod., 34, 1301-1309 (2011). 86) W. Wang, W. Zhou; Characterization of spray- dried soy
73) P. Robert, T. Gorena, N. Romero, E. Sepulveda, J. Chavez, sauce powders using maltodextrins as carrier. J. Food Eng.,
C. Saenz, Encapsulation of polyphenols and anthocyanins 109, 399-405 (2012).
from pomegranate (Punica granatum) by spray drying. Int. 87) N. Mongenot, S. Charrier, P. Chalier; Effect of ultrasound
J. Food Sci. Technol., 45, 1386-1394 (2010). emulsification on cheese aroma encapsulation by carbohy-
74) T. C. Kha, M. H. Nguyen, P. D. Roach; Effects of spray dry- drates. J. Agric. Food Chem, 48, 861-867 (2000).
ing conditions on the physicochemical and antioxidant 88) R. A. Buf fo, K. Probst, G. Zehentbauer, Z. Luo, G. A.
properties of the Gac (Momordica cochinchinensis) fruit aril Reineccius; Effects of agglomeration on the properties of
powder. J. Food Eng., 98, 385-392 (2010). spray-dried encapsulated flavours. Flavour Frag. J., 17, 292-
75) S. T. Chin, S. A. Hamid Nazimah, S. Y. Quek, Y. B. Che Man, 299 (2002).
R. A. Rahman, D. M. Hashim; Effect of thermal process- 89) J. Finney, R. Buffo, G. A. Reineccius; Effects of type of atomi-
ing and storage condition on the flavour stability of spray- zation and processing temperatures on the physical prop-
dried durian powder. LWT - Food Sci. Technol., 43, 856-861 erties and stability of spray-dried flavors. J. Food Sci., 67,
(2010). 1108-1114 (2002).
76) C. A. Nayak, N. K. Rastogi; Effect of selected additives on 90) Y. H. Cho, J. Park; Characteristics of double-encapsulated
microencapsulation of anthocyanin by spray drying. Drying flavor powder prepared by secondary fat coating process. J.
Technol., 28, 1396-1404 (2010). Food Sci, 67, 968-972 (2002).
77) A. M. Goula, K. G. Adamopoulos; A new technique for 91) A. Soottitantawat, H. Yoshii, T. Furuta, M. Ohkawara, P.
spray-dried encapsulation of lycopene. Drying Technol., 30, Linko; Microencapsulation by spray drying: influence of
641-652 (2012). emulsion size on the retention of volatile compounds. J.
78) Z. Fang, B. Bhandari; Effect of spray drying and storage Food Sci., 68, 2256-2262 (2003).
on the stability of bayberry polyphenols. Food Chem., 129, 92) M. E. Rodríduez - Huezo, R. Pedr oza - Islas, L. A.
1139-1147 (2011). Prado - Barragán, C. I. Beristain, E. J. Vernon - Car ter;
79) H. Şahin Nadeem, M. Torun, F. Özdemir; Spray dr ying Microencapsulation by spray drying of multiple emulsions
of the mountain tea (Sideritis stricta) water extract by containing carotenoids. J. Food Sci., 69, 351-359 (2004).
using different hydrocolloid carriers. LWT - Food Sci. and 93) C. Turchiuli, M. Fuchs, M. Bohin, M. E. Cuvelier, C.
Technol., 44, 1626 -1635 (2011). Ordonnaud, M. N. Peyrat-Maillard, E. Dumoulin; Oil encap-
80) A. M. Suhaimi, O. A. Malik, S. Asmui, O. A. Shokri; sulation by spray drying and fluidised bed agglomeration.
Production and properties of spray dried pineapple juice. Inno. Food Sci. Emerg. Technol., 6, 29-35 (2005).
Acta Hort., 902, 525-528 (2011). 94) G. R. Chegini, B. Ghobadian; Effect of spray-drying condi-
81) S. Yousefi, Z. Emam-Djomeh, S. Mousavi; Effect of carrier tions on physical properties of orange juice powder. Drying
type and spray drying on the physicochemical properties of Technol., 23, 657-668 (2005).
powdered and reconstituted pomegranate juice. J. Food Sci. 95) L. H. Tan, L. W. Chan, P. W. S. Heng; Effect of oil loading on
Technol., 48, 677-684 (2011). microspheres produced by spray drying. J. Microencapsul.,
82) E. Horuz, A. Altan, M. Maskan; Spray drying and process 22, 253-259 (2005).
optimization of unclarified pomegranate (Punica granatum) 96) M. Fuchs, C. T urchiuli, M. Bohin, M. E. Cuvelier,
Juice. Drying Technol., 30, 787-798 (2012). C. Ordonnaud, M. N. Peyrat - Maillard, E. Dumoulin;
83) H. Vardin, M. Yasar; Optimisation of pomegranate (Punica Encapsulation of oil in powder using spray drying and flu-
Granatum L.) juice spray-drying as affected by temperature idised bed agglomeration. J. Food Eng., 75, 27-35 (2006).
and maltodextrin content. Int. J. Food Sci. Technol., 47, 167- 97) O. R. Roustapour, M. Hosseinalipour, B. Ghobadian; An
176 (2012). experimental investigation of lime juice drying in a pilot
Encapsulation of Hydrophilic and Hydrophobic Flavors by Spray Drying 51

plant spray dryer. Drying Technol., 24, 181-188 (2006). 11, 1081-1092 (1993).
98) S. M. Jafari, Y. He, B. Bhandari; Effectiveness of encapsulat- 111) N. J. Zuidam, E. Heinrich; (2010a). “ Encapsulation of
ing biopolymers to produce sub-micron emulsions by high aroma ” , In “ Encapsulation technologies for active food
energy emulsification techniques. Food Res. Int., 40, 862- ingredients and food processing”, N. J., Zuidam, V. Nedovic,
873 (2007). (Eds.) Springer, 2010, pp. 127-160.
99) E. Janiszewska, D. Witrowa-Rajchert; The influence of pow- 112) P. Costa; An alternative method to the evaluation of similar-
der morphology on the effect of rosemary aroma microen- ity factor in dissolution testing. Int. J. Pharm., 220, 77-83
capsulation during spray drying. Int. J. Food Sci. & Technol., (2001).
44, 2438-2444 (2009). 113) G. A. Reineccius. “Controlled release techniques in the food
100) Y. Serfert, S. Drusch, B. Schmidt - Hansberg, M. Kind, industry”, In “Encapsulation and controlled release of food
K. Schwarz; Process engineering parameters and type of ingredients”, S. J. Risch, G. A. Reineccius (Eds), ACS, 1995,
n-octenylsuccinate-derivatised starch affect oxidative stabil- 8-25.
ity of microencapsulated long chain polyunsaturated fatty 114) W. Weibull; A statistical distribution function of wide applica-
acids. J. Food Eng., 95, 386-392. (2009). bility. J. App. Mech., 18, 293-297 (1951).
101) N. Chindapan, S. Devahastin, N. Chiewchan; Effect of elec- 115) J. Alie, J. Menegotto, P. Cardon, H. Duplaa, A. Caron, C.
trodialysis pretreatment on physicochemical properties and Lacabanne, M. Bauer; Dielectric study of the molecular
morphology of spray-dried-fish sauce powder. J. Food Eng., mobility and the isothermal crystallization kinetics of an
99, 31-39 (2010). amorphous pharmaceutical drug substance. J. Pharm. Sci.,
102) V. Paramita, T. Furuta, H. Yoshii; High-oil-load encapsula- 9, 218-233 (2004).
tion of medium-chain triglycerides and d-Limonene mixture 116) A. Soottitantawat, H. Yoshii, T. Furuta, M. Ohgawara, P.
in modified starch by spray drying. J. Food Sci, 77, 38-44 Forssell, R. Partanen, K. Poutanen, P. Linko; Effect of water
(2012). activity on the release characteristics and oxidative stability
103) A. M. Goula, K. G. Adamopoulos; A new technique for spray of d-Limonene encapsulated by spray drying. J. Agric. Food
drying orange juice concentrate. Inno. Food Sci. Emerg. Chem., 52, 1269-1276 (2004).
Technol., 11, 342-351 (2010). 117) S. Jaya, H. Das; Glass transition and sticky point tempera-
104) D. E. Walton, C. J. Mumford; The morphology of spray- tures and stability/mobility diagram of fruit powders. Food
dried particles: the effect of process variables upon the mor- Bioproc. Technol., 2, 89-95 (2009).
phology of spray-dried particles. Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 77, 118) K. D. Foster, J. E. Bronlund, A. H. J. Paterson; Glass transi-
442-460 (1999). tion related cohesion of amorphous sugar powders. J. Food
105) D. E. Walton; The morphology of spray-dried particles a Eng., 77, 997-1006 (2006).
qualitative view. Drying Technol., 18, 1943-1986 (2000). 119) L. Mosquera, G. Moraga, P. de Córdoba, N. Martínez-
106) J. P. Hecht, C. J. King, Spray drying: Influence of developing Navarrete; Water content–water activity–glass transition
drop morphology on drying rates and retention of volatile temperature relationships of spray-dried Borojó as related
substances. 1. single-drop experiments. Ind. Eng. Chem. to changes in Color and mechanical proper ties. Food
Res., 39, 1756-1765 (2000). Biophy., 6, 397-406 (2011).
107) S. Rogers, W. D. Wu, S. X. Q. Lin, X. D. Chen; Particle 120) S. Labrousse, Y. Roos, M. Karel; Collapse and crystalliza-
shrinkage and morphology of milk powder made with a tion in amorphous matrices with encapsulated compounds.
monodisperse spray dryer. Biochem. Eng. J., 62, 92-100 Sciences des Aliments, 12, 757-769 (1992).
(2012). 121) D. M. Dronen, G. A. Reineccius; Rapid analysis of volatile
108) L. Alamilla-Beltrán, J. J. Chanona-Pérez, A. R. Jiménez- release from powders using dynamic vapor sorption atmo-
Aparicio, G. F. Gutiérrez-López; Description of morphologi- spheric pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometry. J.
cal changes of particles along spray drying. J. Food Eng., Food Sci., 68, 2158-2162 (2003).
67, 179-184 (2005). 122) M. A. Mortenson, G. A. Reineccius; Encapsulation and
109) F. D. B. Abadio, A. M. Domingues, S. V. Borges, V. M. release of menthol. Part 2: direct monitoring of l-menthol
Oliveira; Physical properties of powdered pineapple (Ananas release from spray-dried powders made with OSA n-substi-
comosus) juice–effect of maltodextrin concentration and tuted dextrins and gum acacia. Flavour Frag. J., 23, 407-415
atomization speed. J. Food Eng., 64, 285-287 (2004). (2008).
110) B. R. Bhandari, A. Senoussi, E. D. Dumoulin, A. Lebert; 123) D. Kilburn, J. Claude, T. Schweizer, A. Alam, J. Ubbink;
Spray drying of concentrated fruit juices. Drying Technol., Carbohydrate polymers in amorphous states: An inte-
52 Apinan SOOTTITANTAWAT, Riitta PARTANEN, Tze Loon NEOH, Hidefumi YOSHII

grated thermodynamic and nanostructural investigation. 125) P. Forssell, R. Lahtinen, M. Lahelin, P. Myllärinen; Oxygen
Biomacromolecules, 6, 864-879 (2005). permeability of amylose and amylopectin films. Carbohydr.
124) S. Townrow, M. Roussenova, M. I. Giardiello, A. Alam, J. Polym., 47, 125-129 (2002).
Ubbink, Specific volume-hole volume correlations in amor- 126) M. J. Whitcombe, R. Parker, S. G. Ring; Oxygen solubility
phous carbohydrates: Effect of temperature, molecular and permeability of carbohydrates. Carbohydr. Res., 340,
weight, and water content. J. Phy. Chem. B, 114, 1568-1578 1523-1527 (2005).
(2010).
「日本食品工学会誌」, Vol. 16, No. 1, p. 53, March. 2015

◇◇◇ 和文要約 ◇◇◇

噴霧乾燥による親水性,または疎水性フレーバーの包括粉末化
1 2 3 3
スーチンタワット アピナン ,リッタ パータネン ,ネオ ツー ルーン ,吉井英文
1
チュラロンコン大学工学部化学工学科, 2 フィンランド国立技術研究所,
3
香川大学農学部生物応用科学科

食品の香りのコントロールは,食品素材の付加価値 係わる事項として,貯蔵中に賦形剤の相変化,粉末か
を大きく高める技術として注目され,フレーバーの徐 らのフレーバーの移動,酸化,賦形剤中の酸素移動,
放制御特性などの新しい機能を付与した機能性粉末を 水分の移動といった諸現象の経時変化がある.フレー
作製する研究が行われている.食品工業において,フ バー粉末の徐放性に関する研究のほとんどは,恒温恒
レーバーの包括粉末化は重要なプロセスである.本総 湿環境下(静的方法)における粉末からのフレーバー
説において,噴霧乾燥によるフレーバーの包括粉末化 徐放特性から評価されている.乳化フレーバー粉末や
と噴霧乾燥粉末からのフレーバー徐放挙動についてま フレーバー包接シクロデキストリンからのフレーバー
とめた.疎水的フレーバーは,一般的にオイルにフレー 徐放挙動は,次式のアブラミの式で良好に相関できる.
バーを溶解させたもの,またはフレーバーオイルその n
R=exp (-(kt) ) (1)
ものを,界面活性剤,賦形剤を溶解した溶液に添加後
乳化した溶液を噴霧乾燥機で粉末化する.親水性フレー ここで,R は粉末中のフレーバー残留率( - ),k は徐
-1
バーは,噴霧乾燥粉末内に均一に分散するため包括率 放速度定数(s ),t は時間(s),n は徐放機構定数( - )
は賦形剤に大きく依存する.これらのそれぞれの粉末 である,このアブラミ式(Weibull 式)は,結晶成長を
作製における賦形剤,フレーバーのタイプについて, 相関する速度式で多くの事象を解析するのに用いられ
既往の研究をまとめた.噴霧乾燥粉末は,粉末が凝集 ている.異なる n の値を用いて,多くのフレーバー徐
したものや,凸凹のしわが多い粉末,粉末内部が中空 放機構に対応しフレーバー徐放挙動を相関できること
や結晶が析出したものといった様々な形態の粉末があ から,この式は非常に有用な相関式である.フレーバー
る,この粉末の形態は,粉末内機能性物質の安定性や 粉末が球で賦形剤中の拡散速度によりフレーバー徐放
粉末の流動性に大きく影響する.食品粉末のフレーバー 速度が決まる場合は,徐放機構定数 n は 0.54 付近の値
の保持,徐放特性は,粉末の品質の点から非常に重要 をとる.アブラミ式を用いて噴霧乾燥粉末からのフレー
である.フレーバーの徐放に関して多くの研究が行わ バー徐放速度定数の湿度依存性(ガラス転移温度依存
れており,粉末からのフレーバー徐放特性が貯蔵温度 性)をみた結果,ガラス転移温度 Tg と徐放環境温度 T
における相対湿度と密接に関係していることが報告さ の差(T- T g )に依存していた.
れている.乳化フレーバー噴霧乾燥粉末の緩和現象の

(受付 2015 年 1 月 17 日,受理 2015 年 2 月 23 日)


〒761- 0795 香川県木田郡三木町池戸2393
Fax: 087-891-3021, E-mail: foodeng.yoshii@ag.kagawa-u.ac.jp

You might also like