You are on page 1of 4

2020 International Conference on Pervasive Artificial Intelligence (ICPAI)


       
   

  
"
!!"! !!"!
 !   ! 
!!# !& !!# !&
&"!&$ &"!&$
""!$ #!%"

" !    <0640?C8>=8=6DB4BC74&##=2>34A42>34A<>34;


    
! ./F782720=CA0=B;0C48<064B8=C>C4GC(78BC427=>;>6H8B
         !     E4AHBD8C01;45>A74;?8=6C74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43C>A42>6=8I4
 !     C74 =40A 4=E8A>=<4=C +4 8=C46A0C4 8C 8=C> C74 =0E860C8>=
       !      BHBC4<0=3?A><?C5>A46A>D=3B8CD0C8>=0CC74A867CC8<45>A
            ! C74 DB4A BD27 0B 4=2>D=C4A8=6 0 E4782;4 >A 0= >1BC02;4 8=
     ! 5A>=CF782774;?BC74B054CH>5C74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43F74=
     F0;:8=6>=C74A>03
 !      
           (74380;>6D4BHBC4<03>?CB0<D;C8CDA=380;>6D4<>34
   ./0;;>F8=6C74=0E860C8>=BHBC4<C>2><<D=820C4F8C7C74
DB4A 8= 34C08; C> A43D24 <8BD=34ABC0=38=6B >A 4G0<?;4
   
         
 F74=C74DB4AF0=CBC>6>C>0?;024C74380;>6D4BHBC4<F8;;
  

       8=5>A<C74?0C7C70C8C5>D=35C4AC74DB4A06A44BC74=BC0AC
 C74=0E860C8>=+74=8=C74=0E860C8>=?A>24BBC74DB4A20=
?DC =4F A4@D8A4<4=CB 8=2;D38=6 8=B4AC8=6 70;5F0H ?>8=CB
 #!$# 20=24;8=6>A270=68=6A>DC4B4C2F7827F8;;0;;1470=3;43
">BCE8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4>?;4A4;H>=70=37>;3B>A6D834 1HC74=0E860C8>=<0=064<4=CBHBC4<
3>6B C> CA0E4; >DC3>>AB 1DC C74A4 0A4 BC8;; E0A8>DB 8=0;;H 10B43 >= C74 <D;C8CDA= 380;>6D4 BHBC4< 0=3
8=2>=E4=84=24B>=C74A>03(74B?024C70CB7>D;31410AA84A BCA44C 8<064 20?C8>=8=6 F4 34E4;>?43 0 380;>6D410B43
5A448B>5C4=38BCDA143BD270BD=4E4=6A>D=3>A>22D?843 =0E860C8>=BHBC4<+42><?;4C430?A>C>CH?4>5C746D838=6
>1942CBBD270B5DA=8CDA4F0BC4BCA44B>A2>=BCAD2C8>=54=24B 34E8245>AC741;8=38=C46A0C8=64<14334320<4A0B+88
4C2>AE8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4>?;4F8C70;<>BC=>5D=2C8>=0; B?40:4AB0=3<82A>?7>=4C4=01;4BC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43C>
E8B8>= C74 1>3H F8;; 14 8= 30=64A 3D4 C> D=4G?42C43 A>03 DB4 =0CDA0; ;0=6D064 C> >?4A0C4 C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< C>
2>=38C8>=B. / 0AA8E40CC7434BC8=0C8>=B054;H
= C74 A4B40A27 584;3 0=3 2><<4A280; <0A:4C <0=H 
38554A4=C 1;8=3 6D834 34E824B 70E4 144= 34E4;>?43 =
0??40A0=24C74A40A470=374;3F40A01;40=37403<>D=C43 "
34E824B(745D=2C8>=<08=;H34C42CB>1BC02;4B0=35443B102: +4?A>?>B40=&##10B438<06420?C8>=8=60=3=0CDA0;
C>C741;8=3 ;0=6D064380;>6D4=0E860C8>=BHBC4<5>AC741;8=386 8B
(>H>C070B;0D=27430?A>942C20;;43!F7827DB4B C74BHBC4<0A278C42CDA4CC0:4B=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C0BC74
0 34E824 0A>D=3 C74 =42: C70C 20= 34C42C >1BC02;4B >A 2>A40=3B4AE4B0BC748=5>A<0C8>=?A>24BB8=624=C4A>5C74
834=C85820C8>= <0A:B 0=3 2>=E4H 8=5>A<0C8>= C7A>D67 =0E860C8>=BHBC4<=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C8BBDAA>D=3431H
B?40:4AB >A E81A0C8>=B . / +4+!  B<0AC 20=4 20= DB4 80;>6D4 'HBC4< "0?B ">3D;4 <064 0?C8>=8=6 >C
D;CA0B>=82 B4=B>AB C> B44 C74 10AA84AB 0=3 DB4 ?D;B4B 8= +>A3 4C42C8>= *>824 &4248E4A 0=3 GC4=B8>= ">3D;4B
38554A4=C38A42C8>=BC>A4<8=3C74;45C0=3A867C38A42C8>=B. / 027BD1BHBC4<20=148=C46A0C438=C>0?>AC01;4=0E860C8>=
')#) 0=3 ' C74 D;CA0B>=82 B<0AC 1A024;4C 5>A C74 1;8=3 34E824C70C20=;403C74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43C>C748A34BC8=0C8>=
DB8=6 B>=0A C427=>;>6H 20= 14 A>DC43 C7A>D67 D;CA0B>=82 BC742>A4=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C20=0;B>1420;;43C74
B4=B>AB 427>;>20C8>= 0=3 C74= C7A>D67 022DA0C4 E81A0C8>= 1A08= >5 C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< C <08=;H ?A>24BB4B C74
C02C8;45443102:C>C74F40A4A8=BC0=C;H./ B4<0=C82B >1C08=43 1H C74 80;>6D4 'HBC4< 0=3
(744=E8A>=<4=C34C42C8>=C427=>;>6H>5C741;8=36D834 2><<D=820C4B F8C7 ?A>?4A 4GC4A=0; BHBC4<B BD27 0B "0?B
34E824 8B <08=;H 10B43 >= C74 CA038C8>=0; B>D=3 F0E4 ">3D;4C>2><?;4C4C74C0B:B0=3C74=A4B?>=3C>C74DB4A
?>B8C8>=8=6=C748=34?C72><<D=820C8>=>55443102:C>C74 C7A>D67C7480;>6D4'HBC4<
4=E8A>=<4=CC747403<>D=C4334E824B7>D;314C742;>B4BC =C4=C8>= "0=064<4=C 8B 0;B> C74 4=CAH ?>8=C >5 C74
C>C74DB4A1420DB4C74<>BCA458=43?4A24?C8>=B>57D<0=B BHBC4< (74 8=8C80;8I0C8>= 0=3 58=0;8I0C8>= C0B:B BD27 0B
0A4>=C7474034B?4280;;H5>AB867C0=3740A8=6(74A48B=> A4B>DA240;;>20C8>=0=3A4;40B8=6F8;;0;;142><?;4C438=8C
<0CDA4?A>3D2CC>30HC70C20=0BB8BCC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43C> 420DB4 4027 <>3D;4 8B 0 38554A4=C C7A403 8= C74 B0<4
=0E860C4C>C7434BC8=0C8>= ?A>24BB=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C<08=;HDB4BB70A43<4<>AH
C>2><<D=820C4F8C7>C74A<>3D;4B

978-1-6654-0483-9/20/$31.00 ©2020 IEEE 140



DOI 10.1109/ICPAI51961.2020.00033

Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on June 18,2021 at 22:36:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
 <064 0?C8>=8=6 10B43 >= C74 &## 20= 02784E4 7867
 022DA02H 1DC C74 B4=C4=24 8B <>=>C>=>DB 0=3 C74 BCH;4 8B
 3D;; >5C4= =>C A827 4=>D67 C> 8<064 34B2A8?C8>= B
 D=BD?4AE8B43 ;40A=8=6 70B 142><4 0 A4B40A27 7>CB?>C 8=
 A424=C H40AB <>34;B BD27 0B * *0A80C8>=0; DC>
 =2>34A ./ 0=3 # 4=4A0C8E4 3E4AB0A80; #4CF>A:B
 .
/70E46>C<>A40=3<>A40CC4=C8>=(7464=4A0C8E4<>34;
 20= 74;? C74 <>34; 70=3;4 C74 D=24AC08=CH >5 C74 B4=C4=24

 / 7
 / 7

 2>=BCAD2C8>=14CC4AC20=140??;843C><0640?C8>=8=6C>
 64=4A0C4078674A@D0;8CH34B2A8?C8>=. /
 $DA=0E860C8>=BHBC4<DB4B8<06420?C8>=8=60B0=8=?DC
 >5C74380;>6D4BHBC4<0=3BCA44CE84F34B2A8?C8>=20=C78=:
9>09>4:9,9,20809>
 8=BC403>54H4BC>A4<8=3C74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43C>8<?A>E4C74
 A>03BB054CH
42 8,20.,;>4:9492,9/9,>?<,77,92?,20/4,7:2?09,@42,>4:9=C=>08
1:<>30-749/
$5 2>DAB4 5>A C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< C74 <>BC 2A8C820;
4GC4A=0; BHBC4< 8B C74 <0? <>3D;4 F7827 <DBC 70E4 1>C7
 ! $  34BC8=0C8>= 58=38=6 0=3 F0;:8=6 A>DC4 ?;0==8=6 $DA
=0E860C8>=BHBC4<DB4B>>6;4"0?B. /0BC74<0?<>3D;4
(74?A8<0AH5D=2C8>=>5C7480;>6D4'HBC4<8BC70CC74 1420DB48C8=0338C8>=C><44C8=6C74;>20C8>=B40A270=3A>DC4
BHBC4< DB4B ;0=6D064 0B C74 8=C4A5024 5>A 4GC4A=0; ?;0==8=6 8C 0;B> 70B 0 A827 %B 0B 0 1A8364 5>A BHBC4<B
2><<D=820C8>=>AC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A438C8B>52>DAB4C> 14CF44=<0?B0=3=0E860C8>=
DB4B?>:4=;0=6D064C>02784E4380;>6D4(74;0=6D0648=?DC
8B =>C >=;H 5A>< C74 DB4A 1DC 0;B> 5A>< <064 0?C8>=8=6 5C4AC74BHBC4<>1C08=BC7434BC8=0C8>=BD664BC431HC74
4G?;0=0C8>=>ACA8664A0D38>>1C08=431H>C+>A34C42C8>= <0?<>3D;48CBC8;;=443BC>2>=58A<F8C7C74DB4AF74C74A
80;>6D4 'HBC4< 8B 2><?>B43 >5 )=34ABC0=38=6 ">3D;4 C74 6>0; 8B 2>AA42C 5C4A 0??A>E0; 8C F8;; 142><4 C74
4=4A0C8>= ">3D;4 0=3 80;>6D4 "0=064<4=C =0E860C8>= BHBC4<B >558280; C0A64C >A 14 8=B4AC43 0B C74
A4B?42C8E4;H A4B?>=B81;4 5>A ;0=6D064 D=34ABC0=38=6 70;5F0H ?>8=C 5C4A 0AA8E8=6 0C C74 34BC8=0C8>= 58=8B7 C74
;0=6D0642>=BCAD2C8>=0=3380;>6D4<0=064<4=C0BB7>F= =0E860C8>=>A2>=C8=D4C>C74=4GC6>0;850E08;01;4
8=86 
 ##
(74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< =443B 0 <D;C8CDA=B 80;>6D4
'HBC4< C> D=34ABC0=3 C74 34BC8=0C8>= C7A>D67 8=C4A02C8E4 (74 34B86= 5A0<4F>A: F4 ?A>?>B43 70B 144=
380;>6D4 5D;;H (74 80;>6D4 'HBC4< 70B <0=H ?A02C820; 8<?;4<4=C43 >= 4<143343 70A3F0A4 0=3 70B A4;801;4
F>A:B +4 DB4 >>6;4 80;>65;>F ./ 0B C74 80;>6D4 ?4A5>A<0=24 CB DB4 >5 <D;C8C7A40343 ?A>6A0<<8=6
'HBC4< >5 C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< F7827 70B 0 784A0A27820; 270A02C4A8BC82B C> 02784E4 2;40A <>3D;0A8I0C8>= A43D24
8=C4=C8>= BCAD2CDA4 C70C 20= <44C <D;C8CDA=B 380;>6D4 BHBC4< A4B?>=B4 C8<4 0=3 >?C8<8I4 DB4AB 0??;820C8>=
A4@D8A4<4=CB C ?A>E834B 0 5D;;H 5D=2C8>=0; % C74 4G?4A84=24
=0E860C8>=BHBC4<20=40B8;H8=C46A0C4F8C78CB>C70CC74DB4AB  $   !
8=C4=C8>= 20= 14 2>AA42C;H D=34ABC>>3 >>6;4 80;>65;>F (74BHBC4<0A278C42CDA43806A0<>5C748<?;4<4=C0C8>=8B
0;B>?A>E834B0<D;C8;8=6D0;E>8240B8=?DCB>C74=0E860C8>=
B7>F=8=86 (7438A42C8>=;8=48=B834C74586DA4A4?A4B4=CB
BHBC4<8B=>C;8<8C431H;0=6D064<0:8=6C74BHBC4<38A42C;H C74 34?4=34=2H >5 DB4 B 34B2A8143 8= C74 34B86=
CA0=B=0C8>=0; 0A278C42CDA4 3806A0< C74 BHBC4<B 24=CA0; <>3D;4 8B C74
B0=8=C4A02C8E4E>824BHBC4<5>AC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43 =C4=C8>= "0=064<4=C F7827 4G42DC4B C74 80;>6D4
BC0AC8=6C74380;>6D4F8C70:4HF>A38B=424BB0AHB>C70CC74 'HBC4<B 8=C4=C 0=3 2>==42C43 F8C7 >>6;4 "0?B C> 58=3
A42>6=8C8>=A4BD;C5A><>C+>A34C42C8>=F8;;0;B>14C74 ?>BB81;4 ?0C7B 5C4A C74 DB4A 70B 3428343 C74 BHBC4<
8=?DC >5 C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< C> A4B?>=3 C> C74 DB4A BF8C274BC>'CA44C#0E860C>AGC4=B8>=C>?A>24BBF0;:8=6>=
8<<4380C4;H 0=3 C74= BC0AC C> ;8BC4= C> C74 =443B ;B> C74 C74 BCA44C (74 4<143343 70A3F0A4 DB4B #* 4CB>=
34B2A8?C8>= >1C08=43 1H C74 <064 0?C8>=8=6 <>3D;4 8B ,,0E84AC74>?4A0C8=6BHBC4<8B)1D=CD 
0=3
38A42C;H 2>==42C43 C> C74 80;>6D4 'HBC4< 0B 0=>C74A %HC7>= 8BDB430BC7434E4;>?<4=C;0=6D064
8=C4A;>2DC>A C> ?A>E834 BCA44C 8=5>A<0C8>= >F4E4A C78B (74DB4AB8=C4=C8>=B;40A=431HC7480;>6D4'HBC4<F8;;
8=C4A;>2DC>A>=;H?A>E834B8=5>A<0C8>=8=>=438A42C8>= 14BC>A438==C4=C8>='70A4"4<>AH0=3F08C5>A=C4=C8>=

  "0=064<4=C C> ?A>24BB (74 8=C4=C8>= 70=3;4 ?A>24BB 8B
<06420?C8>=8=68B4BB4=C80;;HC74CA0=B;0C8>=>58<064C> 3428343 1H ;>>:8=6 5>A 0 ?02:064 F8C7 C74 B0<4 8=C4=C8>=
C4GC C74 !>>: 0C ?82CDA4B 0=3 C4;; BC>A84B 8= 7D<0= 02C8>==0<48=C74=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C5C74?02:0648B
4G?4A84=24(74;4038=6?A02C8240;F0HBDB4B344?;40A=8=6 5>D=3 C74 8=C4=C8>= F8;; 14 70=3;43 1H 8C >C74AF8B4 8C 8B
C427=>;>6H C> CA0=B;0C4 C74 E8B8>= 8=C> =0CDA0; ;0=6D064 A460A3430BC748=C4=C8>=C70CC74BHBC4<20==>C2>=CA>;(78B
B4=C4=24B">BC>5C742DAA4=C8<06420?C8>=8=6<>34;B0A4 F0H >5 3H=0<820;;H B40A278=6 5>A C74 8=C4=C8>= 70=3;4A
10B43 >= C74 &## =2>34A42>34A 0A278C42CDA4 (74 4=01;4BC74BHBC4<C>70=3;4=4F;H033438=C4=CB5;4G81;HC
342>34A 8B DB43 C> 342>34 C74 540CDA4B 8=C> C74 >DC?DC :44?B C74 8=C4=C8>=B 784A0A27H 3458=43 1H 80;>65;>F
B4@D4=2405C4A540CDA44GCA02C8>=5A><0B4A84B>5?8G4;E0;D4B 2>=B8BC4=C F8C7 C74 8=C4=C8>= ?02:064B C 8B <0:8=6 C74
>5 C74 8=?DC 8<064 (74 540CDA4 4GCA02C8>= 64=4A0;;H DB4B ?A>6A0<40BHC>D=34ABC0=3=C4=C8>="0=064<4=C0;B>DB4B
##(74>DC?DC8BC74?A>1018;8CH>50;;F>A3B8=C74F>A3 B70A43 <4<>AH C> 2><<D=820C4 F8C7 'CA44C #0E860C>A
;8BC ./ GC4=B8>=

141

Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on June 18,2021 at 22:36:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.


42"C=>08,<.34>0.>?<0/4,2<,8:1>3048;70809>,>4:9
     )B4C74'=>F1>H?02:064C>
8<?;4<4=C :4HF>A3 34C42C8>= 5>A C74 =0E860C8>=
 #
  
02C8E0C8>= 9DBC ;8:4 ??;4B 4H '8A8 >A >>6;4
80;>65;>F8B0=0CDA0;;0=6D064D=34ABC0=38=6?;0C5>A< BB8BC0=CB $  >>6;4 '=>F1>H 8B 0= 4<143343 0=3
C70C <0:4B 8C 40BH C> 34B86= 0=3 8=C46A0C4 0 2>=E4AB0C8>=0; A40;C8<4 0;F0HB;8BC4=8=6 1DC >55;8=4 7867;H
DB4A8=C4A50248=C>C74<>18;40??F410??;820C8>=34E824 2DBC><8I01;4 7>CF>A3 34C42C8>= 4=68=4 C70C AD=B >=
1>C 8=C4A02C8E4 E>824 A4B?>=B4 BHBC4< 4C2 C 8B 0= 8=C4=C
&0B?14AAH%8)1D=CD!8=DG0=3"02$',7>CF>A3
10B43 380;>6D4 BHBC4< (74 BHBC4< 20= D=34ABC0=3 C74
8=C4A;>2DC>AB8=C4=C022>A38=6C>C742DAA4=CBC0C40=32>=C4GC 8B0:4HF>A3>A?7A0B4C70C02><?DC4A0;F0HB;8BC4=BC>
>5 C74 380;>6D4 B> C70C C74 A4B?>=B4 20= 427> C74 DB4A C CA8664A>C74A02C8>=B
DBD0;;HA4@D8A4B0;>C>530C0C>CA08=C74B4<>34;B  "(74E>82410B43=0E860C8>=BHBC4<
=0CDA0;;H=443B0E>824A42>A38=6<4270=8B<(74?H0D38>
(74 8<?;4<4=C0C8>= >5 8=C46A0C8>= 5>A 80;>65;>F 8B C> ?02:064 20= 14 DB43 74A4 C> 2><?;4C4 C74 F>A: 1DC C74
8<?>AC C74 380;>65;>F ?02:064 C> 2><<D=820C4 F8C7 C74 E>82458;4<DBC142>=E4AC43C>C74!0D38>5>A<0CC>
80;>65;>F B4AE824 1H %B '8=24 80;>65;>F 20= 0224?C
2><<D=820C4F8C780;>65;>F(78B?0AC=443BC>8<?>AC
38A42CE>8248=?DCF438A42C;H?0BBC740D38>58;4>5B?40:8=6
C74<?46?02:064<?468BC74;4038=6<D;C8<4380
C>80;>65;>F0=3F08C5>A0A4B?>=B4(74A4B?>=B4B2>=C4=C
F8;;8=2;D34C74BD1<8CC43C4GC0=3C748=C4=C8>=02C8>==0<4 5A0<4F>A: 01;4 C> 342>34 4=2>34 CA0=B2>34 <DG
F4 DB4 8C C> ;>20C4 C74 70=3;8=6 ?02:064 34B2A8143 01>E4 34<DG BCA40< 58;C4A 0=3 ?;0H "0=H CH?820; B>5CF0A4
0??;820C8>=B0=3F41B8C4BDB4<?46C>70=3;4A4038=6

 
   0=3 FA8C8=6 0D38>E8BD0; 58;4B 8=2;D38=6 *! >>6;4
>A 8<064 20?C8>=8=6 F4 DB4 C74 8<?;4<4=C0C8>= 5A>< 7A><4->D(D144C2
>>6;4&4B40A27. /(74CA08=8=6<0C4A80;8B2DAA4=C;H5A>< 
"'$$B8<064;81A0AH0=3DB8=6C74;>20;BCA44C8<064 (74 01>E4 ?A>243DA4B 8<?;4<4=C C74 E>82410B43
5>A CA08=8=6 8B C74 =4GC F>A: ?;0= +4 8=C46A0C4 <064 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< F4 70E4 2><?;4C43 +4 70E4 8=E8C43 A40;
0?C8>=8=68=C>C74=0E860C8>=BHBC4<0BC74BD1BHBC4<5>A E8BD0;;H 8<?08A43 ?0AC=4AB 5>A 02CD0; C4BC8=6 C> 02784E4
=>C85820C8>=8=?DCC>E8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4>?;4F8C7C74018;8CH BD1BC0=C80;74;?0=32>;;42C5DCDA48<?A>E4<4=C4G?4A84=24
C>834=C85HC745>A46A>D=3>1942CB (74 B>DA24 2>34 >5 C74 BHBC4< ?A>6A0< 0=3 C74 F0H C>
2><?8;4 0=3 1D8;3 20= 14 >1C08=43 >= 8CD1 0C
+74=C74C4GC>5<0640?C8>=8=62>=C08=BF>A3BC70C 7CC?B 68C7D12>< <5B78D 380;>6D4=0E68C
B7>D;314?0830CC4=C8>=C>BD270B20AB8=C4AB42C8>=BCA05582
B86=BCA44B>A>1BC02;4B=C4=C8>="0=064<4=CF8;;B?40: *' !#
C74 34B2A8?C8>= C> A4<8=3 DB4AB C> ?0H 0CC4=C8>= C> A>03
B8CD0C8>=B8<?A>E4F0;:8=6B054CH +427>B40BC0AC8=6?>8=C01>DC

<4C4AB0F0H5A><C74
(0>HD0= "&(BC0C8>=0=30B:430=0E4A0641;8=35>;343
 
! 
   ?4AB>=0=30E8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4AB>=C>2>=3D2CC74C4BC(74
$DA=0E860C8>=BHBC4<70BCF>0D38>B>DA24B=0<4;H>C C4BC4AF0;:43F8C7C74=0E860C8>=34E8242><<D=820C43F8C7
+>A34C42C8>=0=3*>824&4248E4A(74CF>0A42><?4C8=6 C74 34E824 0=3 5>;;>F43 C74 8=BCAD2C8>=B <>E8=6 5>AF0A3
8= C74 0224BB >5 0D38> 8=?DC A4B>DA24B C70C 8B <82A>?7>=4B (74CA0E4;A>DC40=3380;>6D42>=C4=C>5C744=C8A4DB4?A>24BB
(74A45>A4C74H<DBC14<0=06431HD38>"0=064<4=CC> 0A4B7>F=8=86 
0E>83B8<D;C0=4>DB0224BBC>20DB4D=4G?42C434AA>AB 8ABCC74C4BC4ABC0C4374F0=C43C>C0:40CA8?0=305C4A
+44G?;08=C745D=2C8>=B0=38<?;4<4=C0C8>=<4C7>3B>5 2><<D=820C8=6F8C7C74=0E860C8>=BHBC4<743428343C>6>
C74CF>E>8248=?DCBA4B?42C8E4;H C> "&('C8;;B7>AC;H05C4A34?0ACDA4C74C4BC4AB08374
F0=C43 C> 6> C> C74 BC>A4 C> 1DH 0 3A8=: B> C74 =0E860C8>=
BHBC4<C0:4B78<C>C74=40A4BC2>=E4=84=24BC>A4

142

Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on June 18,2021 at 22:36:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
$"

 &')$'


()'$-) $$"& 
'8=248<064A42>6=8C8>=0=3=0CDA0;;0=6D064?A>24BB8=6

"()!#)%)()) %$
70E4 <034 B86=85820=C ?A>6A4BB 3D4 C> 344? ;40A=8=6


!-")#!&"(, ) C427=>;>6H +4 14;84E4 C70C 0 2>=E4AB0C8>=0; =0E860C8>=


 ' ( -*$  "%) )) %$  BHBC4< C70C 8=C46A0C4B C427=>;>684B F4E4 DB43 F8;; 14 >5
#)'($'--)!-%*)'  6A40C74;?C>C74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43

())(' )
')$'
"(,"!()' )"%$)( ,"!
+48=C46A0C43C74380;>6D44=68=40=38<06420?C8>=8=6
<>34;>=C744<14334370A3F0A40=3?A>?>B4305A0<4F>A:

 &')$' F8C71>C7?4A5>A<0=240=35;4G818;8CH(74380;>6D4BHBC4<


""%%,$"&-%*  B4AE4B0BC74A4248E8=60=3A4B?>=B8E4F8=3>F(748=C4=C8>=

,$))%%)%)%$+$ $()%' '() <0=064<4=C BHBC4< 8B DB43 0B C74 3428B8>= 24=C4A 5>A


!-")#!&"(, ) 9D36<4=C0=3?A>24BB8=6B>8C8B40BHC><08=C08=0=34G?0=3


 ' (  # "-') %$+$ $
C74BHBC4<
()%' #)'(%*'%$-%*',-)%
)  ()) %$ % -%* ,$) )% % )% )) 5C4AC4BC8=6C78B2>=E4AB0C8>=0;=0E860C8>=BHBC4<3>4B
%$+$ $()%' '()  74;? C74 E8BD0;;H 8<?08A43 F0;: >= C74 A>03 $DA 0??A>027

!-&"()!# 70B 3>=4 <>A4 E8BD0; A42>6=8C8>= 0=3 380;>6D4 8=C4A02C8>=


 %* + '' + ) # "-') C70=<0=H0BB8BC8E434E824B5>AC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43
%$+$ $()%'&"(")#!$%, -%*
#4GCF47>?4C>8<?A>E4C74380;>6D4BHBC4<B5;D4=2H
,$))%%$) $*)%)()) %$
)'
0=3;4CC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A43D=34ABC0=3C748<064B8=5A>=C

 &')$'
>5C74<+4?;0=C>B7A8=:C7470A3F0A4C><0:4C7434E824


""%$"&-%*  <>A4?>AC01;40=38=C46A0C4<>A4A>03A42>6=8C8>=5D=2C8>=B

#% $)%)()) %$ BD270BA42>6=8I8=6CA05582;867CB>AB785C8=6;8=4BC8B7>?43


!-$%,, ""%$) $*)%)!-%*)% C70CC74E8BD0;;H8<?08A432>D;370E4<>A4B054CH>=C74A>03
)()) %$
&!"
42 #30<:?>0,9//4,7:2?0.:9>09>:1>3009>4<0?=0;<:.0==
 :<2,>0 " F..0==4-474>C :1 ?<-,9 =;,.0= 1:< @4=?,77C 48;,4<0/
(74 4G?4A84=24B >5 C74 CF> C4BC4AB 0A4 34B2A8143 0B ;0/0=><4,9=G ?94.4;,7 924900< 9=>4>?>4:9 :1 4@47 924900<= ;;
 ;<47 
5>;;>FB860A4?7>C>B>50A40;E8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4AB>=
 #:C:>, <:50.>7,4/&0,<,-70#0.39:7:2C#:07;#30749/9/
DB8=6C78BBHBC4< %4=?,77C8;,4<0/*97490+@,47,-70
  3>>;=AAA>:C:>,.:?6A:<7/:1>:C:>,=>:<40=90A=0@09>=>:C:>,
;<:50.>-7,4/
(74C4BC>5>A38=0AH?4>?;4F8C71;8=35>;3434H4B8BE4AH  &0&"8,<>,90*97490+@,47,-703>>;=A0A,764:09
BD224BB5D;1420DB44E4=C748A4H4B0A42><?;4C4;H2>E4A43
 "$$ ,9/ " *97490+ @,47,-70 3>>;=AAA=?9?.:8
$A38=0AH?4>?;40A4>DCBC0=38=68=2><<D=820C8=6F8C7C74  C?923C?9 3: ,<> @,9 0<<409-:0< ,27,< ?7.03<0 D84><C
<0278=4 0=3 2>=5834=24 8= F0;:8=6 4 20= A4027 C74 ,3/,9,? 0>34 :?2,<0= :720< ".3A096 (:=3?, 0924:
34BC8=0C8>=F8C7>=;H054F0BB8BC0=24B F0,<9492 3<,=0 !0;<0=09>,>4:9= ?=492 ! 9.:/0<E0.:/0< 1:<
">,>4=>4.,7,.3490#<,9=7,>4:9G,<'4@
  @ ?90

 !$    0-,95,9 3,?/3?<4 2?=>49?= <4=>4,/4 09= 038,99 ,9/ =5,
*8BD0;;H8<?08A43?4>?;4F8;;144GCA020A45D;F74=DB8=6 4=.30< F8;<:@492 !0=;:9=0 "070.>4:9 49 ?7>4#?<9 4,7:2?0
4@D8?<4=CC>F0;:(748ABC4?38BC0=24F8;;14B<0;;4AC70= "C=>08= -C 9.:<;:<,>492 :8,49 9:A70/20G ,<'4@ ;<0;<49>
,<'4@ 

C70C>5>A38=0AH?4>?;4=C4A<B>5B<>>C72><<D=820C8>=
 4,7:217:A , 9,>?<,7 7,92?,20 ?9/0<=>,9/492 ;7,>1:<8 *97490+
F8C7C74<0278=4C74HF8;;>5C4=4=2>D=C4AB8CD0C8>=BF74A4 @,47,-703>>;=/4,7:217:A.7:?/2::270.:8
C74H 20==>C C0;: (74 <08= A40B>= 8B C70C C74H 20==>C   %49C,7=  #:=30@ " 0924: ,9/  <3,9 H"3:A ,9/ >077 
D=34ABC0=3 C74 =0E860C8>= BHBC4< C 8B 38554A4=C 5A>< ?0BC 90?<,7 48,20 .,;>4:9 2090<,>:<F ,<'4@ ;<0;<49> ,<'4@


7018CB8=C4A<B>58=BCAD2C8>=B0=38C<DBC14CA08=43C>14 

B<>>C74A (74 F7>;4 ?A>24BB A4@D8A4B <>A4 0BB8BC0=24 C>   %49C,7=  #:=30@ " 0924: ,9/  <3,9 F"3:A ,9/ >077 
A4027C7434BC8=0C8>= 90?<,7 48,20 .,;>4:9 2090<,>:<G 9=>4>?>4:9 :1 4@47 924900<= ;;
 ;<47 
 3?,92 ,9 )30 ,9 '4,:/:92 0 4,91092 ,: 4 092 "
#=4923?,$94@0<=4>C?60$94@0<=4>C4.<:=:1>!0=0,<.3!0/8:9/
F">C700> 090<,>492 >><,.>4@0 %4=?,7 ,;>4:9= A4>3 ">C70=G 
;; ?7C 
 ::/1077:A :?20>-,/404<D,'?&,</0
,<70C"D,4<:?<@4770,9/(0924:F090<,>4@0,/@0<=,<4,7
90>=G49/@,9.0=4990?<,7491:<8,>4:9;<:.0==492=C=>08=;;
 E 

   4928, ,9/  &077492 F?>:09.:/492 @,<4,>4:9,7 -,C0=G
,<'4@;<0;<49>,<'4@  
 
  ::270,;=*97490+@,47,-703>>;=AAA2::270.:88,;=

 <4:7 %49C,7= 70B,9/0< #:=30@ ",8C 0924: ?84><? <3,9
F"3:A ,9/ #077 0==:9= 70,<90/ 1<:8 >30   " 8,20
  ,;>4:9492 3,770920G  ><,9=,.>4:9= :9 ;,>>0<9 ,9,7C=4= ,9/
8,.349049>0774209.0,<'4@ 
@ 
42
 @4=?,77C 48;,4<0/ ;0:;70 ?=0 >30 /4,7:2?0 9,@42,>4:9 :9 >30 =><00>


143

Authorized licensed use limited to: Cornell University Library. Downloaded on June 18,2021 at 22:36:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like