ENGINEERING

CLIENT:
CONSULTANT:
COMMENT RESOLUTION SHEET
EPC : Date : 28-07-2023

CLIENT HPCL Rajasthan Refinery Limited (HRRL)

PROJECT TITLE Crude Oil Terminal (COT) and associated Facilities at Mundra, Gujarat (EPCC-11)
Reff DOCUMENT TITLE 4118-20-CV-CL-SSB-027- Substation Design calculations
Rev. 1
Date 06-06-2023

Sr. No. Document No. COMMENTS BY EIL DATED (17-07-23) PEC RESPONSE Afcons Response Resolution Remarks
Show calculation for this value. This value should be as follows: Total  As per IS 1893 (Part‐4), clause 9.3 notes 1 & 2 ; Equivalent Static
1 seismic mass = 120686 KN, Ah = 1.5/5*0.75=0.2175. Static base shear =  method in not applicable for industrial structures. And no need to
120686*0.2175= 26249KN increase base shear.
2 Load combination for servicibility check Noted and Updated
3 Load combination for strength check Noted and Updated
For foundation sizing and  stability check load factor shall be considered  Noted and Updated
4
as unity.
Noted
Major comments are as follows:‐
1. EPCC to attach code‐2 architectural drawing for building along with
5 design calculation, currently as per architectural comment room size are
not freezed,column spacing may get change after incorporation of
comments.
2. EPCC to note that equipment weight assumed for design are only As per previous discussion with AFCONS, design loads were
preliminary, EPCC to put some margin in reinforcement calculation to confirmed to minimize the column, beam and slab sections
6 accommodate changes in equipment weight at later stage

Noted and Updated
3. Crack width check for all RCC members shall be included in design
7
calculation
Noted and Updated
4. Clear cover for all RCC component shall be as per of tender document
8
number B224‐999‐81‐41‐EDB‐1002.

Noted and Updated
5.Dia of special confinement r/f shall be established as per formula in
9
case 8 of IS:13920 with Fy for stirrups considered as 415 instead of 500

Noted and Updated
6.Roof slope shall be 1:100 or as per Arch. Drg. Maximum 150mm screed
10
thickness shall be considered for providing required roof slope 
4118‐020‐CV‐CL‐SSB‐027
Noted and Updated
7.Minimum and maximum bar spacing for foundations,slabs,stirrups for 
beams,Tie for columns,pedestals,walls etc. shall be 100mm and 300mm 
11 respectively. Bar spacing should be provided in multiples of 25mm.Refer 
clause no. B.4.2.3.4 of tender document number B224‐999‐81‐41‐EDB‐
1002.

Noted and Updated
8.For two way slabs spanning more than 3.5m shear check and deflection
12
check shall be added in design calculation.

Noted and Updated
13 9.Stair case loading and design shall be added in the report.

Noted and Updated
10.Column reinforcement to be checked with the drawing for STAAD 
14 beam number 869, provided reinforcement is not matching with the 
STAAD design.
11.EPCC to satisfy the requirement of beam and column relative strength  Noted and Updated
at a joint in line with clause 7.2.1,IS 13920
15

Clear to cover for slab shall be 45mm refer B.4.2.4.5 of tender document  Noted and Updated
16 number B224‐999‐B1‐41‐EDB‐1002 .Typical for all slab design calculation.

Maximum deflection due to allowable shear capacity in the pile is  Concluded that this comment is not relevant for Spring Model.It is
discussed. agreed that deflection will be limited to H/250 for seismic
17
condition and 5mm in Operating condition. Refer supporting
calculation shown in Annexure‐1.
Add brick‐tie to the Staad model. There is only marginal decrease in Moments & in time period.
18 Hence impact of diagonal strut (brick‐tie) neglected.
Refer supporting calculation shown in Annexure‐2.