You are on page 1of 69

More Power In Less Space

For Medium-Sized Ships


Sulzer RT-flex60C
Service - Engineer - Meeting
Rudolf Demmerle
Edition: 01 / 2003

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 1


Sulzer RT-flex60C Introduction

Second 7RT-flex60C engine on


test bed at Wärtsilä Italy, Trieste
l Power 22'470 bhp
16'520 kW
l Speed 114 rpm
l Bore 600 mm
Stroke 2'250 mm
l mep 19.5 bar

Type Approval Test succefully


achieved 20.12. 2002

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 2


Sulzer RT-flex60C Power and Speed Range

Sulzer RTA Series


Two-Stroke Marine Diesel
Engine Range

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 3


Sulzer RT-flex60C Engine Parameters

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 4


Sulzer RT-flex60C Engine Parameters

Engine parameters

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 5


Sulzer RT-flex60C Main Design Issues

Traditional design main features


l Double wall structures intensive FE investigations
l Gear wheel drive supply unit; second order balancers
l Mitchell thrust bearing pads adaptable; no overhauls needed
l Bore cooling combustion chamber components
l White metal bearings all bearings with thick running layers
l Cross head lubrication high pressure; forced lift-off

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 6


Sulzer RT-flex60C Main Design Issues

New design features


l flex system common rail type injection
and valve control
electronically controlled
l Bedplate, main bearings bore co-machined with cover
l Bedplate, thust bearing design rigid; welding at low stress area
l Con-rod big end bearings 2 thin shell WM bearings, no WM lining
l Con-rod big end bearings rod and cover: bore co-machined
l Cross- head guide shoes one-piece; WM lined

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 7


Sulzer RT-flex60C Main Design Issues (cont.)

New design features


l Stuffing box design improved for low system oil
consumption; internal recirculation
l TriboPack combined measures for safe piston
running behaviour
3 years between overhauls
l Turbo charger support stiff, integral part of air receiver
l Air cooler arrangement hanging tube stacks, fresh water
l Water separator design improved water mist catcher

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 8


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Arrangement

Common Rail System


l The pressurised media are collected
in the Rail Unit
l Electronic WECS 9500 control signals
actuate servo oil valves (Rail Valves)
inside the Rail Unit to actuate exhaust
and fuel valves
l Master signals from the FE mounted
CA sensor for absolute crank position
l Servo oil is fine filtered
l Fuel and servo oil are pressurised in
a Supply Unit
l The Supply Unit is directly driven from
the crankshaft gear wheel at driving
end as there is the lowest
torsional movement

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 9


Sulzer RT-flex60C CR System
tb`pJVRMM
WECS-9500
Servo Supply Åçåíêçä
control
Fuel System 200 bar

sçäìãÉíêáÅ
Volumetric
Cylinder
áåàÉÅíáçå
injection
6 5 4 3 2 Åçåíêçä
control

pìäòÉê=`çããçå=o~áä===úNMMM=Ä~ê

Fuel
ëáãéäÉ
======êÉäá~ÄäÉ= High efficiency

============ÑäÉñáÄäÉ Sulzer Common Rail Pump

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 10


Sulzer RT-flex60C CR System
tb`pJVRMM
WECS-9500
Åçåíêçä
control
Exhaust Valve Drive

Cylinder eóÇê~ìäáÅ
Hydraulic
6 5 4 3 2 ^Åíì~íçê
actuator

pÉêîç=pìééäó
Servo Supply ===OMM=Ä~ê
200 bar

ëáãéäÉ
======êÉäá~ÄäÉ=
============ÑäÉñáÄäÉ Servo oil pump

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 11


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex System Overview

Exhaust valve WECS 9500 Crank


actuator angle
control
system sensor

Fuel
injectors

50µ

Exhaust valve
actuating unit

Volumetric fuel
injection control unit

1000 bar fuel HFO / MDO

200 bar servo oil

30 bar starting air

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 12


Sulzer RT-flex60C WECS-9500 Common Rail Control

Ship Alarm hardwired RCS backup WECS 9500


System Local Ctrl

hardwired Amplifier ECR


RCS & Safety hardwired Servo Oil WECS
System ASM10 Assistant
(DENIS-9)
hardwired Amplifier
MCM700
4…20mA Fuel
Electronic
Speed 2x CAN Bus

Controller 2x SSI Shaftencoder

CCM10 CCM10 CCM10 CCM10 CCM10 CCM10


Power Supplies O=ñ=QQMs^`

VDM10 VDM10 VDM10 VDM10 VDM10 VDM10

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 13


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Rail Unit Arrangement

l Fuel high
pressure pipes
l double wall
execution

l Fuel supply
l Servo oil supply
l both supply lines
in redundant
execution
l 100 % power
possible with one
broken pipe

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 14


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Rail Unit Arrangement

Arrangement ot the Rail Unit


l Assembly state
l no hand rails
l no piping

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 15


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Rail Unit Components

Fuel rail
l Injection control units
l Fuel injection pressure up to 1000 bar

Servo oil rail


l Hydraulic exhaust valve drive
l Pressure up to 200 bar

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 16


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Rail Unit Components

Control oil side Injection control unit


l Sulzer rail valves LP-1 are
electronically controlled by
WECS 9500
l They hydraulically activate the
individual injection valves per cylinder
l A dosage piston stands for an exact
volumetric control of the fuel oil
HFO side

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 17


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Rail Unit Components

Partition device / Valve Actuator


l Hydraulic piston for valve acuation
l Separates fine filtered servo oil from
standard system oil
l for servicing:
l Prevents flow out of servo oil rail
alve
v
r ail l Prevents dirt from entering fine
- 1 filtered oil system
LP

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 18


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Supply Unit Components

Supply unit
l Heavy fuel oil supply of 1000 bar
l 4 or 6 jerk type pump elements
dependent on cylinder number
l Basis: fuel pumps of Sulzer ZA40S
l Direct mechanical gear drive

l Servo oil supply of 200 bar


l 3 Dynex pumps:
reversible, axial piston type

l Pumps’ capacity ensures redundancy


in case of failure

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 19


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Supply Unit Components

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 20


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Supply Unit Components

Automatic fine filter (Boll & Kirch)


l 5 µm needed to achieve
3 years TBO with the
Dynex pumps
l automatic cleaning
l recirculated in main oil stream
l stiffening bars to air reciver to
limit vibration level

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 21


Sulzer RT-flex60C RT-flex Local Manoeuvring Stand

fuel
Control Panel pressure
control panel
speed
servo oil
pressure

ctrl oil
pressure

fuel quantity

backup
control

safety
system

aux.
blowers

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 22


Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 23


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Computer Aided Engineering areas


l Finite Elements (stress & strain, temperature)
l Engine structure (column / bedplate)
l Air receiver / exhaust pipe
l Hot parts
l Cylinder block
l Running gears
l Rail unit / supply unit
l Girder casting and solidification simulation
l Hydrodynamics
l Elasto- hydrodynamic main bearing calcul.
l Supply and rail unit specific hydraulics
l Vibrations
l Torsional and axial shaft vibrations

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 24


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Bedplate
l Stiff double wall design
l Co-machined journal bores and
bearing covers
l Thin bearing shells with white-metal
lining with a thickness of 2.5 mm or
more

l Integrated thrust bearing

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 25


Sulzer RT-flex 60C Reliability

Main Bearing Design


l Thin shell design with thick
running layer in White Metal or
Aluminium
l Two holding down bolts for
sufficient force to omit fretting
l Semi-circular oil supply through
upper shell
l Elastic bearing cover;
co- machined with bedplate to
omit any step in bearing split
l Bearing cover mounted in
deformed shape to provide
pressfit to bedplate

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 26


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Main bearing cover


l Upper main bearing shell fitted
l mounting tool fitted

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 27


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Thrust Bearing
l Stiff thrust bearing girder with cast
intermediate piece
l Less welding work
l Reduced load in welding seams

l Compact holder for thrust bearing


pads (same as on RTA58T-B)
l Manufacturing friendly
l Easier maintenance
l Most reliable

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 28


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Crankshaft
l Semi built
l Stresses and deformations optimized
by FE calculation

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 29


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Flywheel
l Improved tooth geometry (contact
ratio > 1)
l Teeth of flywheel and pinion cast

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 30


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Connecting rod
l Crosshead bearing
l Lubricating and piston cooling oil
access through knee lever
l Lower shell with thick white metal
layer
l Cap with white metal lining
l High pressure lubrication
with hydrostatic lift-off

l Big end bearing


l Two thin shell bearings
with thick white metal layer
l 4 position pins for perfect
positioning of cap; co-machined
with rod

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 31


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Crosshead
l Increased contact surface between
guide shoe and guide rail in BDC
l Crosshead pin with one diameter
l Guide shoe in one part (steel cast)
with white-metal lining
l Deformations of guide shoe
optimized by FE calculations

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 32


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Contact area of guide shoe on guide rail in BTC

en
m
u
atD
b
cro
A

RT-flex60C

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 33


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Contact area of guide shoe


on guide rail in BTC
l used to be critcal issue on
RTA58T / T-B and
RTA48T / T-B
normal contact traces visible
en
m
u
atD
b
cro
A

l
after TAT of the RT-flex60C

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 34


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Column
l Sturdy double wall design
l Mid-sheets are executed as single
walls
l Thick guide rails to reduce
deformation and stress under guide
shoe forces
l Thin sections for ease of welding
l Access to running gear through doors
from both engine sides
l Design optimised for ease of
manufacturing combined with strong
quality assurance

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 35


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Gear wheels
l 4 gear wheels for supply unit drive
l All wheels made of 34CrNiMo6
(heat treated)
l In 5 and 6 cylinder engines
intermediate wheels act also as
second-order balancer
l Welding of wheel bosses with higher
QA requirements, but still delicate
l In future, more balancing will be
needed for 5 cylinder engines:
solution not decided (ELBA ?)

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 36


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Cylinder Block
l Grey cast iron
l Optimized for stress distribution and
weight
l Monoblock design is standard
l Dry block
l Easy access to piston underside
through large inpection doors

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 37


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Combustion chamber
l Bore cooled components
l Piston
l Cylinder liner
l Cylinder cover
l Exhaust valve seat

l Exhaust valve spindle is made of


Nimonic 80A
l Grey cast valve cage, water cooled
l Anti polishing ring

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 38


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Cylinder Cover
l Cast or forged
l Bore cooled
l 8 cylinder cover bolts
l 3 fuel injection nozzles
l Electronically controlled starting air
valve
l Electronic monitoring of cylinder
pressure instead of a relief valve
l Exhaust valve cage with hydraulic
valve drive and air spring

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 39


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Piston
l Proven jet-shaker oil cooling
l Stress and strain optimized by
FE calculation
l Simplified cooling nozzles

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 40


RT-flex60C Reliability

Piston Surface
Temperatures
l Calulated

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 41


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

400°
Temperatures of hot parts
200°

0° l Temperatures in combustion chamber


l Cylinder cover max. 400° C to avoid
heat cracks
l Piston max. 410° C to avoid corrosion
400°
l Cylinder liner max. 325° C to avoid
200°
heat cracks

l Temperatures in oil cooling space


l Piston max. 200° C to avoid deposits in
cooling bores


All temperatures are calculated
200°

0° 200° 400°

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 42


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Lateral Turbocharging
Arrangement
l Very stiff T/C support with integrated
T/C lub oil collector tank
l One scavenging box for two T/Cs
l Quasi symmetrical T/C arrangement
l Vertical cooler dismantling
l Cooler is split into two bundle stacks
for ease of handling
l High performance cooler for fresh
water only

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 43


Sulzer RT-flex60C Reliability

Modular built cooler system:


Cleaning Gap
l First part built for ease of cleaning
while installed
l Cleaning with high pressure
device possible
High pressure
cleaning device
l No dirt should be swept into the
cooler stack as usually
l Waste heat recovery possible
through corresponding waterfow
between HT and LW stage
l High eficiency tubes stack.
l Omit untreated water on testbed!
Cleaning water drain

LT-stage HT-stage
Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 44
Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 45


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

TriboPack iáåÉê
fåëìä~íáçå
^åíáJ=éçäáëÜáåÖ
oáåÖ
`êJÅÉê~ãáÅ
éêÉJéêçÑáäÉÇ
=qçé=máëíçå=oáåÖ
jìäíáäÉîÉä
iìÄêáÅ~íáçå

içïÉê=êáåÖë
éêÉJéêçÑáäÉÇ
=~åÇ=o`JÅç~íÉÇ
jáÇJëíêçâÉ
fåëìä~íáçå
iáåÉê qÜáÅâ
Ñìääó ÅÜêçãáìã
ÇÉÉé ä~óÉê
ÜçåÉÇ

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 46


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Cylinder liner
l Grey cast iron with optimal hard-
phase content
l Stress and strain minimised by
FE calculation
l Bore cooled collar with insulation
tubes if necessary
l Mid-stroke insulation
l Cooled O-rings
l Lubricating quills above and below
water space
l Anti polishing ring

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 47


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Liner
l mirror like surface after TAT
l simplified lubrication grooves

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 48


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Water Separator
Latest, improved design applied
l 3 noses to catch the droplets
l Well adapted air speed
l Moderate pressure loss
l Effective drain (pressure balanced)

Water
Air

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 49


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Water Separator Performance Old design


Improved
Laboratory Testing design

Start of carryover

First droplets visible


down-streams

low high
Fin load [l/min/fin]

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 50


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

P Air in receiver
Water separator and pressure
balanced condensed water drain
collector
l Separated water droplets must not
To piston
underside enter the piston underside
l An effective drain is essential
l No back-flow into drain pipes by
compensation of pressure differences
in a water filled drain collector
l communicating drain pipes
l No moving parts

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 51


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Pressure compensated
condensate drain collector
test installation
Silencer

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 52


Sulzer RT-flex60C 3 Years TBO

Pressure balanced condensate drain collector (RTA96C)

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 53


Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 54


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Cylinder Oil Consumption

Cylinder liner surface temperature


Calculated liner temperatures l High surface temperatures prevent
300
condensation of H2SO4

250
l Less condensation requires less
lubricating oil for neutralization
200
l Control of correct running surface
150
temperatures by insulation of the
100
Dew point line cooling bores and mid-stroke area

50

0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Insulation

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 55


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Cylinder Oil Consumption

Cylinder lubricating pump


l Electrically driven; flexible adaptation
to engine load
l Feed rate regulation by electronic
governor input signal to E-motor
speed control
l One injector per cylinder with local
cylinder oil distributors

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 56


Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 57


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low System Oil Consumption

Piston rod gland box


l 2 highly efficient pre-scraper rings to remove
dirt and remain with clean system oil
l 2 gastight sealing rings
l 6 highly efficient oil scraper rings with grey
cast iron lips
l High contact pressure between oil scraper
rings and hard piston rod
l Big oil drain area to re-circulate system oil
l Quasi-zero leakage to neutral space
l System oil consumption expected less than
6 kg per cylinder and day
l Running in RTA68T-B and RTA84CU

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 58


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low System Oil Consumption

RTA62U-B RTA60C

l 10 bronze oil scraper rings with 3 lips l 6 grey cast iron oil scraper rings with 2 lips
l contact pressure of oil l tested on RTA84C
scraper rings ca. 2 bar l introduced on RTA68T-B
l standard on B&W
l contact pressure of oil
scraper rings ca. 3.5 bar
Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 59
Sulzer RT-flex60C Low System Oil Consumption

Piston rod gland box


l Gland box can be dismantled
up- and downwards

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 60


Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 61


Benefits Smokeless Super-Dead-Slow

pÉèìÉåíá~ä=çéÉê~íáçå=çÑ=ëáåÖäÉ=áåàÉÅíáçå=åçòòäÉë

P=åçòòäÉë NJåçòòäÉ=çéÉê~íáçå=Ñçê=ëìéÉêJÇÉ~ÇJëäçï=ëíÉ~ãáåÖ

ëãçâÉäÉëë=Ççïå=íç=NM=íç=NOB=êéã=oN
ENOêéã=Ñçê=SoqJÑäÉñRUqJ_F
Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 62
Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Emissions by RT-flex

Sulzer 6 RT-flex58T-B MV Gypsum Centennial


Smoke measurement on combinator curve during seatrial
0.50

0.45

0.40 HFO
Filter Smoke Number [ FSN ]

380 cSt
0.35 3% sulphur
0.1% ash
0.30
ON OFF Aux. Blower
0.25

0.20
Smoke visibility limit
0.15
Conventional low speed engine
0.10

0.05
6RT-flex 58T-B with common rail
0.00
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Engine Load [% ]

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 63


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Emissions by RT-flex

Smoke during T/C emergency test


l one turbocharger cut-off
during TAT
l 50% load according to
propeller load

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 64


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Emissions by RT-flex

17.5

Precise adaptation
of emission level for
17
IMO NOx limit
best trade-off with bsfc
NO X emission [g/kWh]

16.5

16

RT-flex60C
15.5
70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200

Rated Engine Speed [rpm]

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 65


Sulzer RT-flex60C Customer’s Benefits

l High reliability
l 3 years between overhauls
l Low cylinder oil consumption
l Low system oil losses
l Low emissions by RT-flex
l Capable to run extremely low speed

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 66


Sulzer RT-flex60C Low Speed Operation

Extreme dead slow capability


l Steady running down to
10…12 % of R1 speed
l 9 to 10 r.p.m. could be
demonstrated during the TAT
with an empty water break,
corresponding to 9% or below

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 67


Sulzer RT-flex60C

In conclusion:
√ Right power and speed for 'faster' ships
√ More compact engine for smaller engine rooms
√ Reliable engine design
√ Three years' TBO via TriboPack
√ Smokeless operation through whole engine load
√ Compliant with IMO NOx regulation

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 68


Thank you very much !
More Power In Less Space
For Medium-Sized Ships
Sulzer RT-flex60C

Technology 60C- New Engines Team 15.01.03 - 69

You might also like