REVIEW DAN TELAAH KRITIS JURNAL

1. Judul Jurnal/ Artikel:

2. Penulis:

3. Publikasi:

4. Penelaah:

5. Tanggal Telaah:

I. Deskripsi Artikel
1. Tujuan Utama Penelitian :

2. Hasil Penelitian :

3. Kesimpulan Penelitian :

II. Telaah Artikel

A. Fokus Utama Penelitian

B. Elemen yang Mempengaruhi Tingkat Kepercayaan Suatu Penelitian

1. Gaya Penulisan
a. Sistematika penulisan :
b. Tata bahasa :

2. Penulis
a. Kualifikasi penulis :

3. Judul
a. Kelebihan :
b. Kekurangan :

4. Abstrak
a. Kelebihan :
b. Kekurangan :
C. Elemen yang mempengaruhi kekuatan suatu penelitian
1. Tujuan/ Masalah Penelitian :
2. Konsistensi logis (sistimatika penulisan) :
3. Theoritical kerangka (Kerangka Teori) :
4. Pertanyaan penelitian/ hipotesis :
5. Sasaran :
6. Pertimbangan Ethical :
7. Defenisi Operasional :

8. Metode
a. Desain penelitian :
b. Populasi dan Sampel
✓ Populasi :
✓ Sample :
✓ Teknik :
✓ Penentuan besar sample :
✓ Sesuai/tidak, jelaskan (pemilihan, teknik, penentuan besar sample):

c. Variabel penelitian :
d. Instrumen yang digunakan :
9. Data analisis/ hasil
a. Analisis statistik yang digunakan :
b. Hasil Penelitian :

10. Pembahasan temuan hasil penelitian

a. Kelebihan :
b. Kekurangan :
11. Literatur review/ Referensi :
12. Kesimpulan dan Saran
a. Kelebihan :
b. Kekurangan :

D. Penilaian VIA (Validity, Importancy, Applicability)

I. Study validity

Research question
--Is the research question well-defined that can be answered using this study
design?

Does the author use appropriate methods to answer their questions?

Is the data collected in accordance with the purpose of research?

Randomization
--Was the randomization list concealed from patients, clinicians and researchers?

Interventions and co-interventions

--Were the performed interventions described in sufficient detail to be followed by
others?

--Other than intervention, were the two groups cared for in similar way of
treatment?

II. Importance
--Is this study important?

III. Applicability
Using results in your own setting
--Are your patient so different from those studied that the results may not apply to
them?

--Is your environment so different from the one in the study that the methods could
not be use there?

III. Kesimpulan

✓ Sesuai atau tidak

✓ Dapat digunakan atau tidak