You are on page 1of 2

Whether Yolly is liable to Mira for the damage caused by the strong winds and blown reinforced roofs

will depend on various factors, including the terms of the sale agreement, local laws, and any warranties
or representations made by Yolly during the sale.

Terms of the Sale Agreement: The first thing to consider is the terms and conditions outlined in the sale
agreement. The agreement should specify any warranties or representations made by Yolly regarding
the condition of the house. If Yolly provided warranties or guarantees that the roof was in good
condition or that the house could withstand strong winds, and these warranties were breached, Yolly
may be liable for the damage.

Local Laws and Regulations: Local building codes and regulations may require that houses in certain
areas, especially those on cliffs or in typhoon-prone regions, meet specific construction standards to
withstand severe weather conditions. If Yolly sold the house without ensuring it complied with these
regulations, she may be held liable for selling a property that didn't meet local building requirements.

Disclosure Requirements: In many jurisdictions, sellers are required to disclose known defects or issues
with the property. If Yolly was aware of any pre-existing roof problems or issues related to the house's
ability to withstand strong winds and failed to disclose this information to Mira, she could be held liable
for nondisclosure.

Acts of God: Some legal jurisdictions recognize "acts of God" as events beyond a person's control, such
as natural disasters like typhoons. If the damage to the roof was solely due to the extreme weather
conditions of typhoon Henry, and Yolly had no control over it, she may not be held liable. However, this
also depends on whether Yolly made any warranties or guarantees about the house's ability to
withstand such weather.

In summary, Yolly's liability to Mira will depend on the specific circumstances, the terms of the sale
agreement, local laws, and any warranties or representations made during the sale. It may be necessary
to consult with a legal professional who can review the details of the case and provide advice based on
the specific facts and applicable laws in your jurisdiction.

2. In general, Yolly would not be liable to Mira for the damage caused to the house by a tornado unless
there were specific warranties or misrepresentations made by Yolly in the sale agreement.

Tornadoes are considered natural disasters and are typically beyond anyone's control. In most legal
jurisdictions, sellers are not held liable for damage caused by such extreme weather events, as they are
considered "acts of God" or force majeure events.

However, liability could arise if Yolly made false statements or warranties about the house's ability to
withstand extreme weather conditions like tornadoes during the sale. If Yolly provided assurances that
the house was tornado-resistant or had special protective measures in place, and these representations
turned out to be untrue, she might be held liable for misrepresentation.

It's crucial to review the specific terms of the sale agreement and any statements or warranties made by
Yolly during the sale to determine if there are grounds for potential liability. Legal advice from a
qualified attorney in your jurisdiction may be necessary to fully assess the situation.

You might also like