Unit III Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• It is often possible and advisable for an industry to
discharge its waste directly to a municipal treatment plant, where a certain portion of the pollution can be removed. • A municipal sewage-treatment plant, if designed and operated properly, can handle almost any type and quantity of industrial waste hence, one possibility that should be seriously considered is the cooperation of industry and municipalities in the joint construction and operation of a municipal wastewater treatment plant. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes • There are many advantages to be gained from such a joint venture: • 1. Responsibility is placed with one owner while the cooperative spirit between industry and municipality is increased, particularly if the cost sharing is mutually satisfactory. • 2. Only one chief operator is required, whose sole obligation is the management of the treatment plant. • The operator is not encumbered by the miscellaneous duties often given to the industrial employee in charge of waste disposal, and the chances of mismanagement and neglect that may result if industrial production people operate waste-treatment plants, are eliminated. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 3. Since the operator of such a large
treatment plant usually receives higher pay than separate domestic plant operators, better-trained people are available. • 4. Even if identical equipment is required, construction costs are less for a single plant than for two or more. Furthermore, municipalities can apply for state and/or federal aid for plant construction, which private industry is not eligible to receive. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 5. The land required for plant construction
and for disposal of waste products is obtained more easily by the municipality. • 6. Operating costs are lower because more waste is treated at a lower rate per unit of volume. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 7. Possible cost advantages resulting
from lower municipal financing costs, federal grants, and municipal operation can be passed on to the users and may permit higher degrees of treatment at a cost to each participant no greater than the cost for separate treatment at lower removal levels. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 8. Some wastes may add valuable nutrients
for biological activity to counteract other industrial wastes that are nutrient deficient. Thus, bacteria in the sewage are added to organic industrial wastes as seed material. These microorganisms are vital to biological treatment when the necessary BOD reduction exceeds approximately 70%. Similarly, acids from one industry may help neutralize alkaline waste from another industry. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 9. The treatment of all wastewater
generated in the community in a municipal plant or plants enables the municipality to ensure a uniform level of treatment to all users of the river, and even to increase the degree of treatment given to all wastewater to the maximum level obtainable with technological advances. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 10. Acceptance of the joint treatment
project and relinquishment of individual allocations would give the municipality full control of river resources and permit it to use the capacity of the river to the best advantage for the general public. The municipality has greater assurance of stream protection, because it has the opportunity for closer monitoring of effluent quality. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• 11 Public relations are good for the
municipality. • 12. Land is generally more available. • 13. No permit for discharge is needed except for a contractual agreement between the two parties. Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• Since most sewage plants use some form
of biological treatment, it is essential for satisfactory operation that extremes in industrial waste characteristics be avoided and the waste mixture be • (1) As homogeneous in composition and uniform in flow rate as possible and free from sudden dumpings (shock loads) of the more deleterious industrial wastes • (2) Not highly loaded with suspended matter Feasibility of treatment of raw industrial wastes with domestic wastes
• (3) Free of excessive acidity or alkalinity
and not high in content of chemicals that precipitate on neutralization or oxidation • (4) Practically free of antiseptic materials and toxic trace metals • (5) Low in potential sources of high BOD, such as carbohydrates, sugar, starch, and cellulose • (6) Low in oil and grease content. Joint treatment of partially treated industrial wastes and domestic sewage • Most industrial wastes contain only a few harmful constituents and the removal of these leaves the remaining wastes amenable to treatment along with domestic sewage. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • A certain highly industrialized city had for 25 years been handling all wastes from within its secondary-type treatment plant. • This facility was now over loaded and a decision had to be made concerning the treatment of industrial wastes. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • The existing plant contained a bar screen, grit chamber, circular clarifier, trickling filter, secondary clarifier, separate sludge digester and sand drying beds. • The average daily flow was 15 MLD per day, the suspended solids load was 4200 kgs per day and BOD load 5200 kg per day. Out of these 44.1 % of the average flow, 47.5 % of the average BOD and 41.2 % of suspended solids load occurred during the nine day light hours between 8 am and 5 pm. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • The industries and their contributing pollution loads were as follows: • 1. A dyeing and finishing mill for synthetic textiles contributed 33 % of the treatment plant flow and 80 % of the total industrial flow, 25 % of the total plant BOD and 62 % of the total industrial BOD but only 4 % of the total suspended solids. • 2. A laundry contributed 6.2 % of the total plant BOD and suspended solids. This waste includes rags which lead to stoppage of sewer lines, but it comprised less than 1 % of plant flow. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • 3. A meat rendering plant contributed 4.5 % of the total plant BOD. There was a great deal of grease and odor in the waste and 1.91 % of the flow and suspended solids came from it. • 4. A poultry-plant waste consisted of blood feathers and manure and contributed 10 % of the flow, 1.4 % of the BOD and 1.7 % of the suspended solids of the total combined wastes. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • 5. A slaughter house and meat-packing plant contributed 2.8 % of the BOD and 1.3 % of the suspended solids, but only 0.28 % of the flow. • 6. An electrical-plating company contributed 2.2 % of the flow, 0.69 % of the BOD and 0.87 % of suspended solids. High chromium concentrations were found in several samples of the wastes. • 7. The domestic customers contributed 84 % of the plants suspended solids, 60.4 % of the flow and 57 % of the BOD. An example of combined treatment following pretreatment • Three steps were followed to complete the technical solution to the problem; • 1. To ascertain the capacity of the various existing treatment plant units. • 2. To produce the incoming waste load to a minimum by proper pretreatment of industrial wastes at each individual factory. • 3. To evaluate the present plant and suggest the additions required to handle the future waste load effectively. Discharge of completely treated wastes to municipal systems • In many situations, an industry may find it advisable to discharge its waste into the city sewer system even after complete treatment. • It is, of course, an advantage to an industry to have someone else assume the responsibility for final handling and disposal of its residual wastes, because there is always possibility of a mishap at the plant which would make the wastes from the industry’s treatment plant unacceptable for direct discharge into the receiving stream. Discharge of completely treated wastes to municipal systems
• It may also be more convenient for an
industry to discharge by gravity into a nearby municipal sewer than to pump treated waste a long distance to a suitable location on a river. • The attitude of the municipality and the cost of its sewer-service charges play an important part in an industry’s decision to utilize the municipal sewer and treatment plant. Discharge of completely treated wastes to municipal systems • Acceptance of industry as an integral part of a city’s life and equitable charges for the use of city sewers encourage industry to make use of the city’s sanitary facilities. • This means of disposal of industrial wastes must be determined on an individual basis: each case is unique and often a single factor, such as location or precedent, can influence an industry’s selection of the final stage of its waste treatment. An example of the discharge of a completely treated waste into a municipal sewer system
• There is an industry which is erecting a
new plant near its existing one to manufacture electrical and mechanical business machines. • The site for new plant is selected for its convenience, setting surroundings and availability; but is often the case, at the time of the site selection little consideration given to waste disposal problem. An example of the discharge of a completely treated waste into a municipal sewer system
• Though this oversight has been a
common occurrence in the past, fortunately more and more companies are according waste treatment its proper importance when they select a future plant locations, since they are beginning to realize that it can be a costly experience when an industry does not look into all aspects of waste disposal prior to selecting a site for a new plant. An example of the discharge of a completely treated waste into a municipal sewer system
• The plant is located in a small town and is
the only major industry. Production in the new plant will be essentially similar to that of the old, on an expanded basis. • The existing plant manufactures about 1500 machines per day and discharges all its wastes untreated, through two holding lagoons, into a small creek. An example of the discharge of a completely treated waste into a municipal sewer system • The new plant, however, will be served by the municipal sewer system and the municipal primary treatment plant. • Effluent from this plant discharges by gravity to the only flowing stream in the area. • The municipality has agreed in advance to construct the necessary additional sewer lines to the industrial site and industry has agreed to pay for sewer construction. • The entire waste can flow by gravity from the industry to municipal treatment plant. Discharge of partially treated industrial wastes directly to streams • Large industries located outside city limits often have water requirements so greater that they must develop their own sources of water and likewise they must dispose off their own wastes. • This, one price an industry must pay to obtain sufficient space and escape industrial taxes. Discharge of partially treated industrial wastes directly to streams • There are scattered instances, of course, of cities extending their sewer lines to accept the waste of a nearby industry; but usually a plant draws its process water from a nearby river or well and discharges its waste to the same stream, after a careful analysis of the use of the stream and its condition. Discharge of partially treated industrial wastes directly to streams • Wastes from these large plants contain so much pollution that some treatment is required before discharging into the stream. • Since treatment of large volumes of wastewater is expensive, an industry should investigate many alternative methods of protecting the receiving waters. An example of discharging waste to a stream after partial treatment
• A large textile mill is located in a small
town with a Imhoff tank providing sewage treatment facilities. • The stream receiving the mill waste has been classified C (having fish survival for its best usage). An example of discharging waste to a stream after partial treatment
• Two dams downstream from the mill
cause impoundment of the stream and subsequent nuisance conditions. • The mill takes its water supplies from the stream just above the plant. • The state has directed the industry to maintain the stream condition as classified, so it has little choice except to treat its waste before discharging them directly to the stream. An example of discharging waste to a stream after partial treatment
• Extensive treatments of such large
quantities of wastes need a great deal of planning, research and analysis must be carried out in order to minimize the cost and yet attain the best possible efficiency. An example of discharging waste to a stream after partial treatment
• With the above problems in mind, the
textile mill asked the concerned authority to supervise the concerned authority to supervise the investigation and to analyze, interpret and evaluate the results. • In order to make positive recommendations to management, the concerned authority also made in-plant and river studies and held conferences with management to impress upon them the following facts. An example of discharging waste to a stream after partial treatment
• A plan for waste treatment in this instance
must, therefore, include the minimum of aeration, neutralization and retention which will still accomplish adequate reduction of the pollution load on the river. Discharge of completely treated industrial wastes to streams or land
• Complete treatment of wastes prior to
direct discharge to a receiving stream is gradually receiving more and more consideration. • The amount of dilution water in streams is not increasing and on the other hand, pollution loads unfortunately are increasing. Discharge of completely treated industrial wastes to streams or land
• With the population explosion and
industrial expansion, there are more extensive waste treatment requirements. • At present, complete treatment is required only in special instances and in the case of the large, wet industries such as textiles, pulp and paper, steel and chemicals. Discharge of completely treated industrial wastes to streams or land
• Complete treatment refers to treatment
that renders wastewater reusable for industrial and in some cases municipal water supplies. • This normally will mean a fairly complete removal of all suspended, dissolved and colloidal solids including both inorganic and organic fractions. Low cost wastewater treatment methods
• The conventional biological treatment
methods employing trickling filters or activated sludge process are very expensive to install as well as to run. • The past experience with such treatment plants shows that many of them either performing poorly due to the lack of skilled supervision and lack of maintenance. Low cost wastewater treatment methods
• On the other hand, the so called low cost
treatment systems, which include oxidation ponds, oxidation ditches, aerated lagoons, anaerobic lagoons are simple to construct, have the least amount of mechanization and require little or no skilled supervision for operation. Low cost wastewater treatment methods • The design criteria for such low cost treatment systems have been evolved in our country. • An extensive study conducted in our country revealed that, under certain conditions, the degree of treatment that can be achieved is as good as that of the conventional systems, if these low cost systems are adopted. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds)
• A stabilization pond is an open, flow
through earthen basin specifically designed and constructed to treat sewage and biodegradable industrial wastes. • It is a relatively low-cost treatment system which has been widely used. • These ponds may be considered to be completely mixed biological reactors without solids return. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds)
• The mixing is usually provided by natural
processes such as wind, heat, fermentation but may be augmented by mechanical or diffused aeration. • Stabilization ponds provide comparatively long detention periods extending from a few to several days when the putrescible organic matter in the waste get stabilized by the action of natural forces. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds) Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds) • There are fundamentally three types of pond, depending on the dissolved oxygen profile in the pond. • At one extreme are shallow (0.5 m deep), fully aerobic ponds, where a euphotic zone that reaches the bottom and effective mixing cause dissolved oxygen to be present the full depth of the pond. • Although the BOD5 of the influent waste is very efficiently reduced, the concentration of algal and bacterial suspended solids in the effluent can be high resulting in a high BOD5 concentration in the effluent. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds) • At the other extreme are anaerobic ponds (2.5 m to 5 M deep), where organic loading is so high relative to oxygen entering the pond that the pond is anaerobic right to the surface. • Under these conditions, fermentation processes and anaerobic oxidation can remove about 70 percent of the BOD5 of the waste. • Anaerobic ponds are mixed to some extent by the bubbling of gases (carbon dioxide and methane) produced in the pond. • The suspended solids turbidity caused by mixing reduces light penetration, and algal production of oxygen, when it occurs at all in these ponds, is negligible. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds) • A third type of oxidation pond is the "facultative pond". • The depth of natural-aeration facultative ponds - usually 1.0 to 1.5m - is too deep for oxygen to penetrate to the bottom of the pond, and an anaerobic zone develops there. • Solids from the incoming waste settle into the anaerobic sludge near the bottom of the pond and degrade anaerobically releasing soluble degradable organic material and nutrients which diffuse upwards in the pond. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds)
• Near the top of the pond oxygen is supplied by
algal photosynthesis and to a limited extent by diffusion from the air. • There is dissolved oxygen present to only a few centimeters depth at night, but dissolved oxygen diffuses deeper during daylight. • Thus there exists a fully aerobic zone at the top of the pond, and between this and the anaerobic zone at the bottom there is a middle zone where oxygen is cyclically present and bacterial respiration is " facultative" aerobic-anaerobic. Oxidation pond (Stabilization ponds) • A facultative oxidation pond receiving sewage typically achieves between 70 to 95 percent removal of BOD5 (non-filtered) at a loading rate to the pond of from 2.2 to 3.5g BOD5/m2/day depending on temperature. • An effluent quality standard of 30g BOD5/m3 is typically set. The BOD5 in the pond effluent comprises both residual BOD5 from the influent waste and new BOD5 created in the pond in the form of algae. • Algae may form the major part of the BOD5 in the Oxidation ditch • An oxidation ditch is a modified activated sludge biological treatment process that utilizes long solids retention times (SRTs) to remove biodegradable organics. • Oxidation ditches are typically complete mix systems, but they can be modified to approach plug flow conditions. • The oxidation ditch is used for a long-term aeration. Oxidation ditch • It consists of a long channel of an elliptical or circular shape equipped with an aeration equipment called a rotor for generating a water flow and stirring water in the channel to supply oxygen. • Preliminary treatment, such as screening and grit removal normally preceeds oxidation ditch. • Primary settling prior to an oxidation ditch is sometime practiced. • Disinfection and reaeration may be necessary prior to final discharge. Oxidation ditch Oxidation ditch Aerated lgoons • An aerated lagoon or aerated basin is a holding and/or treatment pond provided with artificial aeration to promote the biological oxidation of wastewaters. • They use of oxygen (or air) and microbial action to bio-treat the pollutants in wastewaters. • Aerated lagoons are complete mixing ponds used for treatment of wastewater and industrial wastewater. Aerated lgoons • Aerated lagoons are simple holding tanks usually 2-4 m deep with a continuous supply of oxygen. • The oxygen is supplied to the tanks by means of mechanical surface aeration units. Aerated lgoons Aerated lgoons