Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dynamic Analysis and Control Design of A Single-Phase UPS Inverter
Dynamic Analysis and Control Design of A Single-Phase UPS Inverter
4
July-August 2009
Abstract - An uninterruptible power supply (UPS) system with two kinds of fitters in the inverter
output is analyzed and simulated. The purpose of a voltage controller for UPS irrverters is to
produce .stähle output voltage with low distortion under all loading conditions, particularly under
nonlinear loads and load transients. The system modeled consists of the output filter, the control
system and the single phase inverter. A state-space mathematical model for .system is used. The
results show that system voltage total harmonic distortion to le.ss than 5% even when .supplying
nonlinear loads which draw current with a crest factor of 3. The simulation results are confirmed
by the experimental results. Copyright © 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - AH rights reserved.
Keywords: Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS), Filter, Harmonic, Two-Port Network, Stability
Manuscript received and revised July 2009. accepted August 2009 Copyright © 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S. rl-A It rights reserved
513
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
II. Voltage Source UPS Inverter distortion in the output voltage waveform, are much
more effectively attenuated by going for two filters. Figs.
Fig. 1 shows the main circuit of a single-phase UPS 4-5 show the multiple-filter in the inverter output and the
inverter. The system modeled eonsists of the controller block diagram of a single-phase inverter with two filters
part and power circuit parts. The controller part includes in the output, respectively, where i,,, u^ are current and
Ihe micro controller running the control algorithms and voltage load, un, u^: are filter capacitor voltage, ipi, i^•2
driver circuits. The power circuit part includes the full are filter inductor current, ici, ic2 are filter capacitor
bridge inverter, filter, dc voltage and the critical load. current, LFI, LF2 are filter inductance, CFI. CF2 are filter
capacitance, Rpi, RK2 are equivalent series resistance
(ESR) of the filter. In this paper, the parameters of the
system are LFi=0.09mH, CF,=100^lF and Udc=50 volt.
fint LC filttr
R/• L ; _1_ I
'/-I
U-
F\
O 0 D06 0 Ct nnia nts ti •?£ ata 0 036 o (M
d_. _1
'Fl
Fig. 2. Unipolar PWM technique for single-phase inverter d( '''^ Fl Lr:
F2
(1)
d_
'Fl
d i "'••' "
-i--h d
— We-,
dtFl =
i
1
a. 3. Load Model
1 lililí, .lili,.in.
lao isti
The load on a power system consists of a variety of
electrical devices. A linear element in a power system is
Fig. 3. Fourier spectnim of inverter Output voltage
a component in wbich the current is proportional to the
voltage. Typical examples of linear loads include heaters,
//, 2. Inverter Output Filter motors and incandescent lamps. The differential equation
with linear load (RL-LL) is given by:
Filters are used to reduce the harmonic content of the
voltage injected to the load. With single filter some
harmonics mange to pass to the load. The harmonics can d_. __A¿ . J _
(2)
be further reduced by going for multiple filters. The cW L, " L,
raise Worthy Prize S.r.l - AH rights reserved Intemational Review of Electrical Engineering, Vol. 4. N. 4
514
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomanä
With ihe increasing use of nonlinear loads in power is possible to represent MIMO (Multi Input - Multi
systems, the harmonic pollution becomes more and more Output) system as shown in Fig. 7. The output voltage
serious. The non-linear load causes a periodic dist- and output current of inverter in terms of load voltage
urbance. Nonlinear loads draw non-sinusoidal current, and current voltage in Laplace domain are as follows:
even though connected to a sinusoidal voltage. Also, the
voltage and current waveforms are not of the same shape
and contain fundamental frequency as well as non-
fundamental frequencies. With nonlinear loads, the
voltage and current waveform will be distorted and the
THD will be inevitably increased. Typical examples of
nonlinear loads include adjustable speed motor drives,
rectitler, ferromagnetic devices and arcing equipment
[12]. The non-linear load as shown in Fig. 6, include
single phase full bridge rectifier, second order filter (L- Fig 7, Transfer functicin model of inverter output filter
C) and resistor RL.
Uj (s)= A{s)Vo U)+ Bis) It, is) (8)
d . 1 1, 1
(3)
(il)
Ais)
d 1 . 1
— Ur =—'/ (4) Bis)
tt ^ C '' R,( ff I it) = 02)
Ais)
b) When diodes are off:
i, = 0 (5) In linear loads the function Hr(s) has little effect but in
nonlinear loads and load variations its effect cannot be
ignored. If the filter resistances are disregarded, then the
•u,. = u,. (6) function HLIOÍO) will be real and H|(jcü) will be imag-
inary. Inverters may be confronted with no-load or small
load conditions due to interferences. No-load or tight
where it and uc are current and voltage of DC-side LC load cases has no effect on the stability of the UPS
filter. Therefore Z|.(s) for nonlinear load is [13] (eq. (7)): system, therefore sensitivity of the load change has little
effect on the inverter output impedance. The output
voltage harmonics depend on both the hamionics genera-
where rectifier bridge turn off ted by the inverter output voltage and load current. The
transfer function of output voltage and inverter output
Lis current is represented as follows:
R,C LC
where rectifier bridge turn on
Unis) f is)
RrC (13)
Ais) Z¡is)+ Bis)
Copyright O 2009 Praise Worthy Prte S. r.l.-A ¡I rights reserved InlemaiioHo! Review of Electrical Engineering, Vol. 4. N. 4
515
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
TABLE1
EQUAL PAR/Wlirri-IRS O r Dll-KERKNT INVERTER OUTPUT FILTER
B L,,s
C
D 1
The transfer function of capacitor current of second in. Voltage Droop and Loss Reduction
filter is given by:
By ignoring the filter capacitor series resistance, the
equivalent circuits of the averaged system for mono- and
(15) multiple-filter are shown in Figs. 10 and 11 respectively.
In the mono-filter, L^ is filter inductance. Cr is filter
capacitance and RK is equivalent series resistance (ESR)
The plant open loop roots are dependent on the load of the filter. In this section analysis is based on a
impedance. The open loop root locus with toad resistance criterion such as the same load impedance, dc voltage,
changing form zero to infinite for multiple-filter and total inductance and capacitance, therefore LF^LKI+LH-J,
mono-filter are shown in Figs. 8 and 9 respectively. CK-CFI+CF2 and RK=RK,+RI.-2. If LK2-KFU, and Cn= Kc
As shown in the diagram, the points marked by (A) CFI, the inductors and capacitors reactance in the
are the pole positions under no load condition. The multiple-filter in terms of the inductor and capacitor rea-
points marked by (B) are the plant pole root positions ctance in the mono-fiiter are:
under zero load condition. It can be observed that the
location of the system poles vary with different kinds of (16)
loads, input dc voltage, the parameters of inverter output
filter and the incremental change in the modulation
index. (17)
(18)
(19)
Fig 11. Equivalent circuit of the averaged system with multiple-fil ter
Fig .9. Open loop root locus with load resistance (20)
changing with multiple-filter R,
Copyright G 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. • All rí^ts reserved international Review of Electrical Engineering. Vol. 4. N. 4
516
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
The niter inductors currents in the steady state for Consequently, voltage droop in multiple-filter is less
multiple-filter for a pure resistive load with resistance RL than mono-filter Figs. 12 and 13 shows the frequency
are: characteristic of the open loop system of the output volt-
age in terms of change of KC"CF;/CFI and KH"LV2/LFÍ-
(21) At high frequency ranges (more than 1000 Hz), harm-
onics attenuation is 80 dB per decade in two filter case.
Thus a multiple-filter with the same size as a second
and (eq. (22)):
order niter causes more attenuation in harmonics. Using
multiple filter the resonance frequency given by equation
( 16), depends only to values of the filter components.
R, 1 1
¿,..,
kf_K/,X,: R,. (28)
=0
X,
<\ (23)
1 - • •
•
+;••
! - •
— • - -
Af/ MiiNO
=J (26)
- - • -
At/ MULTIPLE _ ^ !
'1 1
K,- X,A X,
Figs. 13. Frequency charactenstic of the open loop system of the output
voltage in tenns of change of Kc=Cn/CFi (KF=1)
Copyright © 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S-r.l - AU rights reserved International Review of Electrical Engineering, Vol. 4. N. 4
517
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
I l\ i .... ....
i A
1 1f \
....
' irt !
, ,. .
•"s î1
r 'k
> <
^ ^ ^ ^
——, - — .
-K^iB---
•Ä?7n?r.»i'!
'• i
•I 02 03 04 as 0« 07 OB 09
10
•
T
Figs. 16. Frequency respotise characteristics for output impedance
e
with mulliple-lilter (dash) and mono-filter (line)
»
—
4
V. Control System
2 One of the fundamental for reasons for adding control
"T—— •-•.•.::-i it::::: to a system is that steady state errors reduced by the
I 0.1 as D.< us D.e Di* oe os i
action of the controi system. According to the feedback
control system theory, the standard close control loop
Figs. 15. The change of big resonant frequency changes in terms of
change of K<;- and Kp should the feedback signal from the output voltage direc-
tly. One of the most common controllers avaiiabie com-
Copyright O 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - AH rights reserved Intemationai Review of Electrical Engineering. Vol. 4. N. 4
518
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
(32)
Fig. 17. Transfer function model of closed loop system
B{s)+ Z, is) [A(S)+ K
-/•I
(33)
py
1
-'Fl
d_
//.,- (35)
dt c
Fig 19, Closed loop root locus for change of K¡ (Kp=O,OI )
Copyright O 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l - AU rights reserved international Review of Electrical Engineering. Vol. 4> N. 4
519
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
Gain = 0.0U
IS [
\
.
<
Gail
<
1
W—Ciin-0 t
-wn -3nni .xm -lam -isn -inn -MD n1 Fig. 21. Step response of closed loop system with
and K,=40
Fig. 20. Closed loop root locusforc h a i ^ of K)- (K|=40)
Runge-Kutta is used for Ihe calculation method of the
main circuit and the calculating step size Is sel at 1 ^s.
4
• IDoonia
1 ' •(•cur
1 ion 1 » 2
U
Fig. 22. System Simulink model
Copyright O 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Electrical Engineering. Vol. 4. N. 4
520
G. Shahgholian. J. Faiz. M. Arezoomand
/
/ \
\ /r\\ /
/ \
\ i
f
t\ \
\y \/ \
\
,
/
\
\y
J
\J
_—_j i—t \J
ñ
Í
-
1
1
Ik
-
- I]
•.'-• T. , .,1 1
1
s
1
1
...
1 ,v
\^
•
j i 1
•0
•ft f f^ t r
...X ^ T t
10 ' T 1
I 1
Fig 26 Fourier spectrum of inverter output voltage under linear load Fig. 29. Set of practical test
Copyright O 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l - All right'! reserved International Review of Electrical Engineering, Vol. 4, N, 4
521
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
S.1K S.1K
Figs, 34. Output voltage of the single inverter system operating with a
pure resistance (a) simulation with Matlab (b) measurement
Fig. 31 PI controller
—
à g
0!-!C
Fig. 32. PWM pulse generation circuit for switches in the each link Also, the THD of load voltage reduction, because the
harmonics reduced by going for multiple filters.
VIII. Conclusion
In this paper an uninterruptible power supply (UPS)
system with two LC filter in the inverter output is analys-
es and their effects on reducing the distortion in the
output voltage are shown. The proposed model uses the
Laplace transform and two-port network. Also, it has
been implemented in Matlab/Simulink. By running the
simulation model, the comprehensive performances of
multi-filter can be obtained efficiently. Fourier analysis
use to predict the load voltage harmonic spectrum. Inve-
rter output voltage have THD to less than 5% even when
Fig. 33, Dead time force circuit supplying power to highly nonlinear loads which draw
Copyright © 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved Inlemational Review of Electrical Engineering. Vol. 4. N. 4
522
G. Shahgholian, J. Faiz, M. Arezoomand
cun-ent with a crest factor of 3. Finally, simulation and performance power converter .systems", ¡EEE Trans. On Powe.
experimental results have been reported and discussed. Klecir.. Vol. 15. NoJ, May 2000, pp.456-463
119| S J Chiang. TL Tai. T S Lee, "Variable structure control of UPS
The simulation is achieved under the dc source inverters", ¡EE Proc. Elecir. Power. Apll.. Vol.145, No.6,
voltage is ripple free and constant. Also, in the simulatio- November 1998, pp 559-567
n, the inverter switching devices are assumed as ideal ]20] M.J Ryan, W (i.Brumsicklc, R.D.Lorenz, "Control topology opti-
switches, but SPWM modulation is not an ideal amplifi- ons for single phase UPS inverters". IEEE Trans. On Ind. AppI..
Vol.33. No.2, March/Apnl 1997, pp 493-501
cation including dead time and conducting resistance of
|2l] G Escohar, A A Valde7, J L Ramos, PMatlavelli, "Repetitive
device. Therefore, the THD of experimental result is based controller for a UPS inverter to compensate unbalance and
higher than the simulation. harmonic distortion". ¡EEE Trans. On Indu. Elec. Vol.54. No.l.
February 2007, pp.504-510.
References
Authors' information
11 ] J.Faiz, G.Shahgholian. M Ehsan, "Stability analysis and simulati-
on of the singte-pha.se voltage source UPS inverter with two-stage Department of HIectrical hngineering, Islamic Azad Univcrsrty.
cascade output filter". Euro. Trans. Elecir. Peru.. No.¡S. 2008. Najafabad Branch, Najafabad. Esfahan, Iran,
pp 29-49.
[2] H L Jou, J C Wu. C.Tsai, K D Wu, M.S.Huang, 'Novel line inter- 'Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Faculty of
active uninterruplibic power supply", lEE Prac. Elecir.. Pow. Engineering. University of Tehran, Iran
AppI.. K(?/,/i;..Va.î,pp.359-364, May 2004
[3] J Kim. J.Lee, K Nam. "Inverter ba.sed local AC bus voltage Gha/^nTar Shuhfiholixn was born in Hsfahan.
control utilizing two IX)F control". /£>,'£" Tran. On I'ow. Elec. Iran, on December 7, 1968 He graduated in cicct-
Vol.23. No.3. May2U08, pp 1288-1298 "^^' '^"g"'*-''^'^'ng 'J^""" Hsfahan University of
|4| M.Arias, DGLamar, M Rodriguez, M.Hcmando, A Fernandez, Icchnology (lUf), Isfahan, Iran, m 1992. lie
"Simple droop voltage control .system for parallel operation of received the M Sc and PhD in electrical engineer-
UPS", ¡EEE/APEC. February 2008. pp 1296-1302 ing from Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran in 1994
[5] J Faiz, G.Shahgholian, "Uninterruptible power supply - A and from Islamic Azad University, Science and
review", Electomotion. Voll3. No.4. Nov/Dec 2006, pp 276- Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, in 2006, respecti-
289 vely He is now an associate professor at Department of l-lectrical
[6] H Deng. R Oruganti, D Srinivasan, "Neural controller for UPS Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Islamic Azad tlnivcrsity
mvertcrs based on B-splinc Netuork", ¡EEE Tran. On Ind. Elec. Najafabad Branch His teaching and research interests include applicat-
Vol.55. No.2. February 2008, pp 899-909 ion of control theory to power system dynamics, power electronics and
]7] A Nasiri. Z Nie, S B.Bekiarov, A.Emadi, "An on-lmc UPS system power system simulation
with power factor conection and electric isolation using BIFRED
converter", ¡EEE Tran. On Indu. Elec. Vol.55. No.2, Febmary Jawad f»it received his Ph.D. in Electrical
2008. pp 722-730. I-'ngineering from the University of Newcastle
|8] H Deng, R.Oruganti, D Srinivasan, "A simple control method for upon Tyne. England in 1988 He is now a
high-performance ÜP.S inverters through output-impedance Professor at lieparlmem of Electrical and
reduction", IEEE Tran. On ¡nd. Elec. Vol.55. No.2, February (•(imputer l-ngineering. Faculty of Engineering,
2008, pp.888-898 University of Tehran He is the author of 215
[9] G Willmann, D F Coutinho, I. F A Pereira, F B Libano, "Múltiple publ ications in intemationai journals and
loop H-infinity control design for uninterruptible power supplies", conference proceedings Dr Faiz is a senior
¡EEE Tran. On ¡nd. Elec. yol.54. No.3, June 2007. pp 1591- member of IEEE. He is also a member of Iran Academy of Sciences
1602 His teaching and research interests are switched reluctance and VR
[10] TFWu, YEWu, HMHsieh, Y K Chen, "Cunem weighting motors design, design and modeling of electrical machines, drives, anil
distribution control strategy for multi-inverter systems to achieve transformers,
current sharing". ¡EEE Trun. On Pow. Elei, Vol.22. No.l, January
2007. pp 160-168 Mohsen Arezoomand was bom in Isfahan. Iran.
[II] MTTsai. C H Liu. "Design and implementation of a cost on September 2. 1976. He graduated in electrical
effective quasi line interactivo ups with novel topology", ¡EEE engineenng from Isfahan University of
Trans. On Pow. Elect.. Vo¡. 18. No.4. My 200i,pp 1002-1011. Technology (IUT), Isfahan, Iran, in 1992 He
]12] M NiriKimand, H R.Karshenas," Performances specifications of received the MSc in control engineering from
series-parallel UPS's with different control strategies", ¡nte. Rev. Isfahan University of Technology (IUT). Isfah-
of Elec Eng (IREE). Vol.4. No!. Jan-Feb. 2009, pp. 14-21. an, Iran m 2002 respectively His research
[13] H.Komurcugil, O.Kukrer, A.Doganalp, "Optimal control for interests include application of automation con-
single phase UPS inveners based on linear quadratic regulator trol, power elccuonics and power system simulation
approach", ¡EEE/SPEEDAK4, pp74-29. May 2006.
[ 14] F S Pai, S J Huang, "A novel design of line interactive unintcnu-
ptihle power supplies without load current sensors", ¡EEE Trans.
On PovK Elec. Vol.21. No.l. pp.202-210, January 2006.
[15] J.Faiz, G Shahgbolian, "Modeling and simulation of a three-phase
inverter with rectifier-type nonlinear loads", ¡nter. Con. Semi.
Mic & Nano. (ICSMNJ. Tsakhcadzor, Armenia, July 2009.
[16] ¡favA. Gh Shahgholian. "Study and Simulation of a Single Phase
UPS Inverter with Rectifier Load", ECTI-CON. May 2006,
pp 417-420.
]17] J K Steinke. "Use of an LC filter to achieve a motor friendly
performance of the PWM voltage source inverter", ¡EEE Trans.
On Ene. Conv.. I'ol 14. No.3. September 1999, pp 649-654.
[18] R Zhang. F C Lee, D Boroycvich, H Mao, "New high power, h i ^
Copyright C 2009 Praise Worthy Prize S.r.l. - All rights reserved International Review of Electrical Engineering. Vo¡. 4. N. 4
523