Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CM
MY
CY
CMY
K
AmmoniaCasale
Abstract
For many years now, Ammonia Casale has been very actively dynamic in the field of ammonia plant revamping and has gained
extensive experience in the design and implementation of complete plant revamping project and has successfully utilized this
experience to satisfy a wide number of customers around the world. Most of these projects have included key modifications
to reformers, machinery, ammonia converters and other equipment. The unique Casale’s ammonia plant revamp strategy has
always focused on the development and application of new, advanced technologies to obtain the best possible improvements
in plant performance at the lowest cost and a reduction in energy consumption, an increase in capacity, or a combination of
the two is normally achieved. The many Projects range from revamping of ammonia synthesis converters and their supply or
the revamping of other special equipment, such as pre-reformers and shift converters, to the revamping of complete ammonia
plants for capacity increase and energy conservation. This paper presents some of the Casale technologies and a few case
histories of the applications.
1
AmmoniaCasale
Most of the technologies are developed radial beds into successful service.
in house by a team of very specialized Here follows a brief description of each
and experienced people. Thanks to the application in the ammonia field.
innovative trend set by founder Dr Luigi
Casale, plus the heritage and background 2.1.1. Ammonia Synthesis Converter
of subsequent management teams, Am-
monia Casale invested significantly in The ammonia converter is one of the
technology development. most critical items when planning a re-
During the last few decades this dis- vamp for energy saving or capacity in-
cipline evolved from an empirical art, crease, and in most cases it is the first
with an intuitive sense for good design, item to be revamped thanks to the rel-
into a more rationalized activity. atively low cost and very high return.
Process design is now supported by AMMONIA CASALE is very active in this
sound insight into the chemistry of the field and has introduced fundamental
processes, catalyst behaviors, kinetic innovations in the converter design
data, heat and mass transfer phenom- Fig. 1: Gas Distribution in an Axial-Radial and revamping, such as the “in-situ”
ena, fluid mechanics, science of con- Catalyst Bed modification of bottle-shaped convert-
struction materials, and cost analysis. Mechanically the bed is very simple, ers such as the Kellogg ones, and the
Ammonia Casale Technical Services being made only of two vertical per- three-bed intercooled configuration
avail themselves of specialists in all forated walls and of one bottom clo- that is being used by CASALE for over
the above fields, as well as of sophisti- sure plate. The absence of a top cover ten years now.
cated tools for investigating, analyzing greatly simplifies and facilitates the This activity has been very rewarding
and picturing complex phenomena in a construction of the converter inter- and now AMMONIA CASALE has more
way unachievable with ordinary skilled nals, allowing at the same time the full then 160 converters on stream, out
manual calculations. The process de- utilization of the catalyst volume. of which about 80 are “in-situ” modi-
sign is based on advanced computer- Also catalyst loading and unloading fications, and about 40 are three-bed
aided techniques with applications is very easy, as the axial-radial bed is intercooled converters (new or re-
ranging from process flow-sheeting to completely open on the top granting an vamped) with full bore opening.
kinetics, to fluid dynamics simulations easy access to the bed even for small- The most important ingredients for this
and mechanical stress analysis. diameter vessels, while for unloading success are the axial-radial beds, de-
In addition to the technology, Ammo- there are drop out pipes provided at scribed above (see figure 2), and the
nia Casale can also provide all ser- the bottom. three-bed configuration, both adopted
vices required for the completion of a The materials used for its construction
project, from engineering right down to varies according to the application.
construction, start-up and operation of The essential advantages of the axial-
the plant. radial catalyst bed concept are the
same wherever in the ammonia plant
2. Proprietary Technologies it is applied, namely:
- low pressure drop;
2.1. Axial-Radial Catalyst Beds - use of small-size catalyst.
The axial-radial catalyst bed is the Casale makes maximum use of the ax-
base of most of the technologies used ial-radial bed concept, in all catalytic
by CASALE in catalytic reactors. reactors.
In an axial-radial catalyst bed most This technology was developed for am-
(about 90%) of the gas passes through monia converters and later applied to
the catalyst bed in a radial direction, shift converters and pre-reformer reac-
resulting in much lower pressure drop tors, since it was demonstrated as be-
than in an axial-flow catalyst bed. The ing flexible, economical and ef¬ficient.
balance passes down through a top Outside the ammonia field, it has also
layer of catalyst in an axial direc¬tion, been applied in methanol and form-
thus eliminating the need for a top aldehyde synthesis reactors. To date
cover on the catalyst bed (Fig. 1). Casale has put more than 500 axial- Fig. 2: Plate-cooled and 3-bed ammonia
converter
2
AmmoniaCasale
for revamping of any kind of convert- The new design also has the following the process air, thus increasing the air
ers and for new reactors as well. additional features: compressor capacity and/or reducing
AMMONIA CASALE has recently intro- • protection of catalyst from water its energy consumption. On account
duced into the market the next gener- droplets carried over from secondary of the very even gas composition at
ation of ammonia reactors, the pseu- reformer heat recovery train or others; the surface of the catalyst bed and
do-isothermal plate-cooled converters. • possibility to load different volumes the greater amount of the reaction
Three of these converters are already of catalyst with no mechanical modifi- that has already taken place in the
on-stream. cations; top space of the reactor, it is possible
• easy operation. to obtain greater service life from the
2.1.2. Pre-Reforming Reactor In case of application to existing plants, catalyst and/or to reduce the catalyst
Technology the existing shift converters can be volume. Casale burners are in use in
easily transformed to axial-radial de- seven ammonia plants and six more
The pre-reforming reactor proposed sign by introducing new vertical perfo- are being installed.
by AMMONIA CASALE is designed ac- rated walls, which are cylindrical and Casale has also a proprietary design
cording to the axial-radial technology form the inlet and outlet walls, in pre- for autothermal reformers, achieving
for catalyst beds, taking advantage fabricated sectors that are assembled essentially the same advantages high-
from the peculiarities of this design: inside the existing converter vessel. lighted here above. In this case burner
minimum pressure drop and use of The advantages achievable with this tip is water cooled, ensuring longer ex-
more active and poison resistant revamping are the low pressure drop pected life for this highly critical piece
small-size catalyst. with consequent energy saving, the of equipment. Casale autothermal re-
The utilization of this reactor enables low pressure drop also helps eliminat- former is already in operation in 2 am-
part of the primary reforming reaction ing the hydraulic constraints having monia plants and 4 methanol plants.
to be carried out (about 10%) outside more flow through the front end, allow-
the primary reformer, enabling the ing for higher plant throughput.
increase of the capacity of the exist-
ing unit, as well as the reduction of 2.2. Secondary Reformer Burner
the size of the reformer to be imple- and Autothermal reformer
mented in new plants.
Another advantage of the pre-reform- Ammonia Casale makes an advanced
er is that it transforms all higher hy- design for the secondary reformer
drocarbons to methane, and performs burner available, through its sister
part of the reforming reactions, thus company Casale Chemicals S.A. The
producing some hydrogen. These Casale Advanced Secondary Reformer
two actions enable the increase of Burner achieves the following goals:
the preheating temperature of the Fig. 3: Casale design for secondary reformer
process gas, and also the reduction • low pressure losses in both air and burner
of the steam carbon ratio, therefore primary reformer streams (<1 bar in
reducing the energy consumption of the air stream); 2.3. Ammonia Wash System
the primary reforming section. • low temperature of the burner sur-
faces exposed to the flames; The Ammonia Washing Unit removes wa-
2.1.3. Shift Converters • superior mixing in the flame; ter and carbon dioxide from the syn gas
• reduced flame length, avoiding cata- before entering the loop. Carbon oxides
The new design developed by Ammo- lyst impingement even at high operat- in synthesis gas are almost completely
nia Casale is based on the use of the ing loads removed by the CO2 Removal and Meth-
axial-radial catalyst bed, described • soot-free combustion; anation sections, while some moles of
above, and can be applied both to re- • homogeneous gas composition and water still remains in make-up gas and
vamping and to new converters. temperature distribution at catalyst they could poison ammonia converter
The new axial-radial configuration has bed entrance; catalyst decreasing its performances.
an inherently low pressure drop of the • protection of the refractory lining The Ammonia Wash System takes ad-
catalyst bed, and this makes it possi- from the hot core of the flame. vantage of the ammonia-water/carbon
ble to use small-size, more active and Introducing this design into an exist- dioxide reciprocal solubility to complete-
more resistant to poisons catalyst. ing plant reduces the pressure loss in ly remove them from make-up gas. The
3
AmmoniaCasale
oxygenated compounds (H2O and CO2) batão, Brazil, fed by both refinery off- Table 1: Pre-Reformer Performance
are completely dissolved in the liquid gas and naphtha. Originally designed Process Test-Run
Guarantees
ammonia; thanks to the Casale patent- for a capacity of 450 t/d, the plant was Conversion of >85 98.7
ed ejector, the unit is designed exploiting operating at about 520 t/d at the time C 2H 6, %
Conversion of >95 100
the differential pressures between the the revamp project was determined. C3+1, %
liquid ammonia and make-up gas in or- The flow rate and composition of the
der to optimize the nebulization of liquid off-gas fluctuated considerably as a Table 2: Synthesis Loop Performance
ammonia and allow an intimate contact result of changes in feedstock, load Process Test-Run
Guarantees
between the two phases. and product range in the refinery. To Converter 600 > 616
Due to the fact that undesired com- safeguard the primary reformer from Capacity, t/d
rd
NH3 at 3 bed 15.8 > 16.08
pounds have been removed, syngas can the ill effects of a possible sudden outlet, %
be fed directly to the ammonia convert- increase in the carbon content of the Converter 2.8 2.8
pressure drop,
ers, without crossing the ammonia chill- feedstock, it had to be operated at a bar
ing section. very high steam: carbon ratio.
The second phase of the work (expan-
Summarizing, the expected benefits The client requested Ammonia Casale
sion to 800 t/d) comprised replacing
from the installation of AMMONIA CA- to find the best revamping options for
the reformer tubes, revamping the
SALE AWU, are the following: increasing the plant capacity in two
shift converters, CO2 removal system
• Reduction of synthesis gas compressor stages, first to 600 t/d and then to 800
and the feed gas, air and synthesis
overall energy consumption, thanks to a t/d, while reducing energy consumption
gas compressors, and installing a new
better performance given by lower suc- and phasing out the use of naphtha as
purge gas recovery unit. Minor chang-
tion temperature at the H.P. casing inlet. feedstock on account of its cost.
es to the heat exchangers, pumps and
• More favorable conditions for ammo-
piping were are also planned.
nia condensation within the chilling sec-
tion, since the ammonia concentration in
the converter effluent stream is no more
reduced by the make-up gas mixing (re-
duction of energy consumption in the re-
frigeration compressor).
4
AmmoniaCasale
before in 1989 by replacement of the - Possible trips in new sections should - the S/C ratio could safely be re-
converter internals with a traditional not trip the existing plant. duced;
two-bed one-interchanger design, (not The capacity expansion was limited - every possible change in natural gas
a Casale design) and installation of to1,300 t/d by the suction capacity of composition could be accommodated.
a membrane-type hydrogen recovery the existing synthesis gas compressors.
unit, which allowed it to operate at a The feed gas desulphurization, feed Process Air
capacity of about 1,170 t/d. gas compression, secondary reformer
The main goal of the project was to and methanation sections were suit- This section was designed to provide
increase production capacity to 1,300 able for the new operating conditions sufficient process air for a production
t/d. Further targets were energy sav- and needed no modifications. of 1,000 t/d of ammonia under nor-
ing, reducing cooling water consump- The following modifications were im- mal conditions. Any increase in plant
tion and improving reliability. plemented: capacity therefore required debottle-
A second step of capacity increase necking of this compressor. This was
was also considered, meanwhile the Pre-reforming and Primary Reforming accomplished by the following main
natural gas quality of the Al-Bayroni modifications:
plant has considerably changed with The primary reformer of the Samad - addition of an air booster driven by a
a higher content of nitrogen. Casale ammonia plant is a typical Kellogg back-pressure steam turbine;
adapted their studies on plant produc- top-fired unit with 416 catalytic tubes - addition of an after-cooler down-
tion and efficiency improvement to the arranged in eight rows. The reformer stream the new air booster;
new design basis. All the new equip- tubes were replaced in 1997 with new The booster was sized to be able to
ment had therefore to be designed for HK40 tubes identical in every respect accommodate the prospective future
the highest capacity. with the original tubes. major expansion up to 1800 MTD.
An important requirement was the Without upgrading the reformer tubes
very tight project schedule. The proj- the heat flux to the primary reformer Shift Conversion
ect started in October 2000. All the could be increased only marginally.
engineering and procurement services Therefore, to increase the capacity of The high pressure drop in the shift
for the de-bottlenecking project were the reformer up to the level needed converters (0.5 bar in the HTS and
completed in September 2001. A turn- for the capacity expansion, the steam 0.6 bar in the LTS for new catalysts;
around took place in January 2002, : carbon ratio had to be decreased. and >1.0 bar each for the aged cata-
and all modifications were made dur- On account of the high concentration lysts for both reactors) was due to the
ing the period of a standard shut-down. of higher hydrocarbons in the natural axial-flow design of these converters.
Start-up followed immediately after. gas, this could only safely be done by Retrofitting with Casale axial-radial
Since every modification to machinery installing a pre-reformer. (Fig. 6). internals reduced the pressure drop
is very expensive, and since it would The advantages of the use of the pre- to about 0.3 bar, correspondingly in-
have been quite uneconomic to reharp reformer and of the fired heater can creasing the suction pressure of the
reformer because the existing tubes be summarized as follows: synthesis gas compressor. This pres-
were almost new, Casale prepared a
minimum-investment revamping op-
tion according to the following guide-
lines:
- Main rotating equipment would not
be revamped or replaced;
- No modifications would be made to
the primary reformer section;
- Modifications to the equipment had
to be suitable for the further capacity
expansion;
- Possible variations in natural gas
quality had to be considered;
- The plant should be able to operate
at original capacity when new sections
were isolated; Fig. 6: New Fired Heater and Pre-Reformer
5
AmmoniaCasale
sure increase was very important to al- a new one designed for the revised neered by Ammonia Casale, the plant
low this machine to achieving the high- flow conditions. The spare energy, production is now 953 MTD, while the
er capacity without any modification to resulting from the reduced recircula- energy consumption is now 9.7 Gcal/
the make-up stages. The advantages tion power requirement, provided the MT. The revamp involved converting
that resulted from this revamping can additional power needed to maximise the plant from the original Braun puri-
be summarized as follows: the discharge pressure of the make- fier design operating with 50% excess
- lower pressure drop; up gas compression stages at the in- air in the front end, to a conventional
- lower CO slip and thus lower inerts creased suction flow rate without any ammonia plant operation. The purifier
concentration in the make-up gas for other modification to the compressor was idled and a hydrogen recovery
the whole Campaign; or its turbine drive. unit was installed to treat the purge
- longer catalyst life; On account of the better converter per- gas from the synthesis loop.
- catalyst protection against water formance and higher loop operating The two existing converters were ret-
droplets. pressure, not only the ammonia con- rofitted with Casale isothermal design
centration but also the temperature at converter baskets. These are the first
CO2 Removal the converter outlet was higher. The of their kind to be installed in ammonia
latter was above the design value for service. They provided reduced pres-
The carbon dioxide removal system the metallurgy of the existing converter sure drop and improved conversion.
was an inhibited MEA system. The CO2 outlet pipe and for the boiler feed wa-
content of the purified gas was satisfac- ter preheater, so both were replaced. Revamp Scheme
torily low (around 120 ppm) but corro- The improved performance of the syn-
sion problems were observed. For the thesis loop significantly reduced the The Braun process is characterized by
revamp the BASF aMDEA process was specific chiller duty, allowing the plant the introduction of excess air in the sec-
adopted by means of a simple solvent capacity increase to be borne by the ondary reformer. This reduces the load
swap. None of the equipment needed refrigeration compressor and its steam of the primary reformer and requires a
modification. This change reduced the driver without any modification. cryogenic purifier, downstream of the
specific energy consumption, making Table 3 compares the performance of methanator, to remove the excess ni-
it possible to reduce the S/C ratio. the plant before and after the revamp. trogen. This purifier removes almost all
of the inerts contained in the gas. There
Table 3: Al-Bayroni Plant
Synthesis Loop Performance
is however, an expander located imme-
Before and After Revamp diately upstream of the purifier and this
The reduction of the steam / carbon ra- Before After creates a large pressure drop.
tio and the revamping of the shift con- revam revamp Therefore, the two main areas that need-
p
verter internals allowed an increase in ed to be improved were the reforming
Production, t/d 1170 1312
plant throughput without appreciably section and the synthesis loop.
Specific energy about 6
increasing the system pressure drop. consumption, % The following major changes were re-
To allow the synthesis loop to handle Gcal/tNH3 reductio quired for the revamp:
n
the increased flow new synthesis con- 1. Installation of a Pre-reformer.
Sea water about 7
verter internals were provided. The consumption, % This was comprised of:
existing cartridge was a two-bed inter- m3/tNH3 reductio a. A reactor with Casale designed axial-
n
cooled design installed in the 1989 radial internals.
revamp. This was replaced by a new b. A new fired heater to recover the re-
three-bed axial-radial cartridge with 3.3 PCS Nitrogen Trinidad, O3 Plant sulting temperature drop
one quench inlet between the first and 2. Revamp of the Primary Reformer In-
second beds and one interchanger be- The 03 ammonia plant is an origi- volving:
tween the second and third beds. The nal C.F. Braun design that was con- a. Replacement of the catalyst tubes.
greater conversion efficiency and low- structed in 1965 in Brea California. b. Extension of the radiant section.
er pressure drop of the new converter The plant was relocated to Trinidad in c. Replacement of the mixed feed coil.
internals meant that both the required 1994. The design capacity at that time d. Installation of a combustion air blower
gas recycle rate and the energy need- was 680 MTD. Some minor modifica- to supplement the gas turbine exhaust
ed to drive it round the system were tions increased the plant’s production (GTE).
reduced, so the recirculator wheel of rate to 753 MTD. 3. Installation of a quench nozzle on the
the main compressor was replaced by Following a recent plant revamp engi- HTS quench.
6
AmmoniaCasale
4. Upgrade of the CO2 removal system. replaced on site. The composition of the
This comprised: fuel gas to the burners was changed with
a. Replacement of the trays in the MDEA the elimination of the waste gas from the
Regenerator. purifier section. The gas from the HRU
b. Installation of an additional steam re- is much less and the burner tips were
boiler. changed as a result. The gas turbine
c. Installation of two additional Regen- exhaust, which supplies oxygen to the
erator Overhead Condensers. burners, was deemed to be insufficient
d. Installation of an additional Regenera- and an auxiliary air blower was installed
tor Overhead Condenser. to supplement the oxygen supply. The
5. Idling of the Purifier section. exhaust of this blower was tied into the
6. Replacement of the synthesis gas GTE ducting.
compressor HP rotor.
7. Replacement of the existing two con-
verter internals with the Casale isother-
Fig. 7 - PCS Axial-Radial Pre-Reformer
mal basket design. This consists of an
arrangement of exchanger plates in the Primary Reformer
axial-radial catalytic beds.
8. Installation of a BFW heater. The primary reformer was an original
9. Installation of a Hydrogen Recovery Foster Wheeler design side-fired reform-
Unit. This is a used unit that was refur- er. The tubes were at their end-of-life
bished and was handled as a joint effort and the frequent failures were causing
Fig. 9 – Photo of the Primary Reformer and
between Air Products and PCS Trinidad. severe plant reliability issues. The major Fired Heater
10. Changes in the ammonia recovery changes were:
section. - Tube arrangement changed from stag- Shift Conversion
a. Replacement of the MP ammonia ab- gered to inline.
sorber with a high pressure absorber. - Number of tubes increased The shift converters, both HTS and LTS,
b. Installation of a new HP Absorber feed - Extension of the radiant box. were found to be adequate for the re-
pump. - Installation of additional burners. vamp and the only change made in this
11. Replacement of the ammonia prod- - Replacement of the old burner tips. section was the installation of a BFW
uct pumps. This was handled as an inter- - Replacement of the mixed feed coil. quench system to control the HTS inlet
nal project at PCS. The radiant box extension was shipped temperature. This was necessary be-
12. Replacement/Addition of control in sections with insulation pre-installed, cause of the limitation of the secondary
valves and PSVs. ready for assembly. The insulation how- reformer waste heat boiler.
ever was damaged in shipping and was
Process Details
Pre-Reforming
7
AmmoniaCasale
8
C
CM
MY
CY
CMY