Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IEEJ-High-Impedance Fault Location Using Matching Technique and Wavelet
IEEJ-High-Impedance Fault Location Using Matching Technique and Wavelet
Paper
Locating the faulty section of a high-impedance fault (HIF) is quite challenging for the underground distribution network of a
power system. The complexity of the distribution network, such as branches, nonhomogenous lines, and HIF, contributes to the
difficulties in locating the faulty section. In this paper, the shortest distance (SD) technique and a database approach have been
proposed to determine the faulty section. A multiresolution analysis based on discrete wavelet transforms is chosen to extract the
unique features from voltage signals during the HIF event. The output coefficients from the decomposition process is stored in
a database and used as the input data for the SD algorithm. The first, second, and third level of detailed coefficients of the post-
disturbance voltage signal were utilized for the identification of the faulty section using the proposed method. A ranking analysis
was created to provide a number of possibilities of faulty section. In this paper, a 38-node underground distribution network
system in a national grid in Malaysia was modeled using the PSCAD software. The proposed method was able to successfully
determine the faulty section. © 2014 Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
© 2014 Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
HIGH IMPEDANCE FAULT LOCATION USING WAVELET TRANSFORM
better decision is to trigger the alarm. HIF can be successfully network. This is due to the complexity of the distribution network,
detected by utilizing the previous methods. However, locating the such as nonhomogenous line, branches, and an HIF that results
fault is still the most challenging because HIF in an underground in a variation of fault location. In engineering practice, there are
cable cannot be seen and located easily. Also, the complexity of two scenarios that can be taken after the HIF is detected: trip the
the distribution network, such as branches, nonhomogenous lines, feeder or give an alarm. First, trip the feeder right after the HIF is
and the HIF itself, results in a variation of the fault location. detected. The purpose of this action is to de-energize the feeder to
Although there are various methods to locate the fault for low- avoid the arcing and fire hazard. However, if this action is chosen,
impedance faults [10–12], there has been less work on locating locating the HIF will become difficult.
the HIF in an underground distribution network. For underground If the feeder is not tripped, the HIF can be located easily via
cables, locating the HIF is quite difficult. Pinpointing the exact sound, radio frequency interference (RFI), sight, or loss of power
location of the fault is necessary before digging up the cable and a in an area. However, the alarm signal has to be taken seriously and
visual confirmation of the problem is made before repair. In order immediately because the energized conductor can produce arcing
to pinpoint the location, a surge generator is turned on to thump the and is a fire hazard, which is very dangerous especially if the region
cable. However, if all cables at each section is thumped, especially is around a school or residential area. Therefore, the decision to
for a long cable, it could take days to locate a fault. Besides that, de-energize or not as a course of action must be based on the
a healthy but aged cable will be exposed to potential damage due relative consequences of each action.
to the high-voltage thumping.
Analyzing the faulty section and estimating the possible faulty
section is necessary to overcome these problems. There are 3. Proposed Method for High-Impedance Fault
several researches conducted to identify fault location. Nagy et al . Location
have used the DWT to extract the voltage and current residuals In this paper, the localization of the high impedance fault
to identify the faulty feeder. The faulty feeder is determined algorithm is constructed using the matching technique based
on the basis of the power polarity [13]. Nagy et al . have also on the SD adopting the output of DWT-based MRA. The SD
used the ratio of the residual current amplitude method to approach is described in three-dimensional space by means of three
determine the faulty section. The measured highest ratio of residual coordinates. The process to determine the faulty section is depicted
current amplitude determines the faulty section [14]. Dwivedi in Fig. 1. It involves two major steps, namely HIF detection and
et al . [15] determined the faulty section by comparing the sharp HIF location.
variation value of the third-level detail coefficient at each section.
A topology method has been proposed to identify the faulty
section [16]. The faulty section is identified on the basis of the 3.1. Feature extraction for fault localization For
last two nodes of a common “active sensor” path. HIF classification of fault location, two cycles of post disturbance
In this paper, classification of the faulty section in a radial of the three-phase voltage signal are analyzed and important
distribution network was done by utilizing a DWT-based multires- features extracted using the DWT-based MRA. The voltage signal
olution analysis (MRA) and a database approach. The proposed is split into one full cycle consisting of 128 samples, of which each
technique utilizes detailed coefficients of the first-, second-, and full cycle is analysed separately using the DWT of Daubechies
third-level resolutions obtained from the wavelet multiresolution fourth order (Daub4). Then, the features extracted from the three-
decomposition of a three-phase voltage signal. The proposed fault phase voltage are utilized to identify the fault location. The features
location method was tested on a typical 38-node distribution net- extracted can also be used to identify the occurrence of an HIF.
work system in Malaysia. The simulation results were compared The occurrence of HIF can be observed by the large fluctuation
with the actual fault location to validate the proposed method. in the first level of the detailed coefficient, d1 . The surge signal
132/11kV
132/11kV
Y
Y
#1 #1
section. In previous traditional methods for fault detection such as
#2 #2
the impedance-based method, a small fluctuation on the voltage
signal during HIF event cannot be detected since it acts as a
Measured
normal signal. However, the anomaly in the voltage signal can be
node
Bus
breaker
Circuit
breaker 20
Circuit
coefficients shows the abnormality of the signal and the time when
38
37
36
35
34
14
17
18
19
effectiveness of the proposed method, a certain fault impedance
21
S2 S3 S4 S5
S 23
S6
15
S9
S7
16
6
12
13
25
S 26 S 11 S 12
levels of the detailed coefficients obtained are summed up for each
S 13
8
S 14
Feeder 1 in the 1.6–3.2 kHz frequency range. The second and third levels
29
28
27
detailed coefficients for each level is used as input data for the
S 16
Feeder 2
proposed algorithm.
31
11
a certain fault was incorrectly located in the first iteration. Thus, (14) Elkalashy NI, Lehtonen M, Darwish HA, Taalab AMI, Izzularab MA.
the next line section was checked and the step was repeated until DWT-based extraction of residual currents throughout unearthed MV
the actual fault was traced. networks for detecting high-impedance faults due to leaning trees.
A better performance of the proposed method in locating the European Transactions on Electrical Power 2007; 17:597–614.
(15) Dwivedi UD, Singh SN, Srivastava SC. A wavelet based approach
faulty section at the first rank can be established by increasing
for classification and location of faults in distribution systems. India
the number of databases. However, the proposed method has Conference, 2008. INDICON 2008. Annual IEEE 2008; 488–493.
successfully determined the faulty section based on the voltage (16) Garcia-Santander L, Bastard P, Petit M, Gal I, Lopez E, Opazo H.
signals. Since only two cycles of post-fault voltage signals are Down-conductor fault detection and location via a voltage based
required, this method is capable of identifying the faulty section method for radial distribution networks. IEE Proceedings-Generation,
quickly. This method has also been found effective in locating the Transmission and Distribution 2005; 152:180–184.
faulty section and can be easily adopted in cable fault location. (17) Uriarte FM, Centeno V. (2005, 23–25 Oct. 2005). High-impedance
fault detection and localization in distribution feeders with micropro-
cessor based devices. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 37th
6. Acknowledgement Annual North American Power Symposium, 2005.
(18) Bretas AS, Moreto M, Salim RH, Pires LO. (15–18 Aug. 2006).
This work was supported by the University of Malaya, Kuala
A Novel High Impedance Fault Location for Distribution Systems
Lumpur, (UMRG grant: RG077/09AET) and under postgraduate Considering Distributed Generation. Paper presented at the Trans-
research fund (PPP) (Grant code: PS009-2012A). mission & Distribution Conference and Exposition: Latin America,
2006. TDC ’06. IEEE/PES.
References (19) Jung CK, Lee JB, Wang XH, Song YH. Wavelet based noise
cancellation technique for fault location on underground power
cables. Electric Power System Research 2007; 77(10):1349–1362.
(1) Lai TM, Snider LA, Lo E, Sutanto D. High-impedance fault detec-
tion using discrete wavelet transform and frequency range and Mohd Syukri Ali (Non-member) was born in Malacca, Malaysia,
RMS conversion. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 2005; in 1986. He received the B.E. degree in telecom-
20:397–407. munication engineering in 2009 from the Uni-
(2) Etemadi AH, Sanaye-Pasand M. High-impedance fault detection versity of Malaya, Malaysia.
using multi-resolution signal decomposition and adaptive neural fuzzy
inference system. IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution 2008;
2:110–118.
(3) Michalik M, Lukowicz M, Rebizant W, Lee S-J, Kang S-H. Verifi-
cation of the wavelet-based HIF detecting algorithm performance in
solidly grounded MV networks. IEEE Transactions on Power Deliv-
ery 2007; 22:2057–2064. Ab Halim Abu Bakar (Non-member) received the B.Sc. degree in
(4) Chen S. Feature selection for identification and classification of electrical engineering in 1976 from Southamp-
power quality disturbances. Power Engineering Society General ton University, UK, and M.E. and Ph.D. degrees
Meeting, 2005. IEEE 2005; 3:2301–2306.
from the University of Technology Malaysia in
(5) Avdakovic ANS. Identifications and monitoring of power system
1996 and 2003, respectively. He has 30 years
dynamics based on the PMUs and wavelet technique. Power Inter-
national Journal of Electric and Electronic 2010; 39:796–803. of utility experience in Malaysia before join-
(6) Dash PK, Panigrahi BK, Panda G. Power quality analysis using S- ing academia. Currently, he is a Lecturer in
transform. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 2003; 18; 406–411. UM Power Energy Dedicated Advanced Centre
(7) Suja S, Jerome J. Pattern recognition of power signal disturbances (UMPEDAC), University of Malaya, Malaysia. His research inter-
using S Transform and TT Transform. International Journal of ests include power system protection and power system transients.
Electrical Power and Energy Systems 2010; 32:37–53. Dr Halim is a member of the IEEE, CIGRE, IET. He is also a
(8) Li ZY, Wu WL. Classification of power quality combined dis- Chartered Engineer.
turbances based on phase space reconstruction and support vec-
tor machines. Journal of Zhejiang University: Science A 2008;
9:173–181. Hazlie Mokhlis (Non-member) received the B.E. degree in elec-
(9) Sarlak M, Shahrtash SM. High impedance fault detection using com- trical engineering in 1999 and M.E. degree in
bination of multi-layer perceptron neural networks based on multi- 2002 from University of Malaya, Malaysia, and
resolution morphological gradient features of current waveform. IET the Ph.D. degree from the University of Manch-
Generation, Transmission & Distribution 2011; 5:588–595. ester, UK, in 2009. Currently he is a Lecturer
(10) Mokhlis H, Mohamad H, Bakar AHA, Li HY. Evaluation of fault with the Department of Electrical Engineering,
location based on voltage sags profiles: a study on the influence of
University of Malaya. His main research inter-
voltage sags patterns. International Review of Electrical Engineering
ests include distribution automation and power
2011; 6:874–880.
(11) Mokhlis H, Li HY, Khalid AR. The application of voltage sags pat- system protection.
tern to locate a faulted section in distribution network. International
Review of Electrical Engineering 2010; 5:173–179. Hamzah Arof (Non-member) obtained the B.E. degree from the
(12) Mokhlis H, Li HY, Mohamad H, Bakar AHA. A comprehensive fault University of Michigan, USA, and the Ph.D.
location estimation using voltage sag profile for non-homogenous degree 1997 from the University of Wales,
distribution networks. International Review of Electrical Engineering UK, both in electrical engineering. Currently,
2010; 5:2310–2316. he is a Lecturer in the Department of Electrical
(13) Elkalashy NI, Lehtonen M, Darwish HA, Taalab AMI, Izzularab MA. Engineering, University of Malaya. His current
A novel selectivity technique for high impedance arcing fault detec- research interests include signal processing, pat-
tion in compensated MV networks. European Transactions on Elec- tern recognition, and electrical power generation.
trical Power 2008; 18:344–363.