Name: Neha Zainab

Roll no: 20i-1708

Accounting & Finance- 2020

Critique Review

Title: Review of "Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and FATA: A Complex

Relationship"

An original viewpoint on Jinnah's leadership and his relationship with Pakistan's

Federally Administered Tribal Area (FATA) may be found in this paper written by
Muhammad Nisar. "Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and FATA: A Complex
Relationship". In order to make this evaluation clearer and briefer, we shall evaluate the
article's strengths and shortcomings.

Throughout the article the author tries connect a linkage between Jinnah and his
feelings for FATA. The author presented Jinnah’s feelings by connecting it with his
leadership style. Jinnah’s leadership style processes different qualities, which goes
beyond to what a political leader requires.

As the article progresses, it shows a transition in Jinnah’s political profession. It portrays

how the leader leaps from Indian National congress to All Indian Muslim league. It was
during this transformation it became evident that Jinnah has strong feelings and is
passionate about saving FATA tribal areas and the people’s heritage. This moment also
became important in laying the foundation for a homeland we call Pakistan- a place that
people could call as an Islamic republic.

The main strength of this article lies in the relationship of Jinnah’s leadership with his
feelings for FATA. And this makes this article a smooth reading, as the reader can fully
grasp the idea behind Jinnah’s importance as a Muslim leader. The realization of his
Muslim heritage and growing sense of Muslim identity served as the driving force for his

1
support for Pakistan and the rights of Muslim. Jinnah's stance for FATA demonstrates
his ability to navigate challenging circumstances and draw reasonable conclusions. The
article highlights his commitment to respecting the traditions and goals of the native
residents of FATA while showing his ability to negotiate and humility.
The article highlights Jinnah's role as a unifying figure, rallying Muslims from various
regions behind the cause of Pakistan. The Lahore Resolution of 1940, calling for an
autonomous Muslim state, exemplifies his vision and leadership.

It further sheds light on a rich historical context that enhances our understanding of
Jinnah's relationship with FATA. It effectively conveys the complexities and tensions in
British India leading up to Pakistan's creation.

It examines the All-India Muslim League's quest for a separate Muslim state within India
under Jinnah's leadership, setting the stage for understanding his approach to FATA. As
it became very evident that Iqbal’s two nation theory became a need and had to
become a reality. And FATA's unique position within this historical backdrop,
emphasizing its distinct tribal structure and the complex relationship with the British
colonial administration.

It also highlights the Lahore Resolution of 1940, which laid the ideological foundation for
Pakistan and directly relates to FATA's historical significance as a predominantly
Muslim region.

Throughout the article, the author employs commendable evidence, including direct
quotes from historical sources and references to key events. These elements enhance
the article's credibility and allow readers to connect with the historical narrative.
The article's organization could be improved for a more cohesive reading experience.
Transitions between sections are not always smooth, making it challenging for readers
to follow the narrative and connect the dots between Jinnah's actions and their impact
on FATA.

2
Certain sections lack clarity and could benefit from more precise explanations,
especially regarding the political context of the time. A backdrop of the political
uncertainty of the time would have led to smoother transition between Jinnah as a
leader to Jinnah seeking a separated nation for Muslims, largely originated in FATA
areas.

In conclusion, the article on Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and FATA offers a
valuable perspective on an often-overlooked aspect of Jinnah's leadership. It
successfully contextualizes his role in shaping the destiny of FATA within the broader
struggle for independence. While improvements in structure and clarity would enhance
the article, it serves as a commendable resource for those interested in the historical
intricacies of Pakistan's founding and Jinnah's legacy in the region.