Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Importance of Teaching Science and Technology in Early Education Levels in An Emerging Economy
The Importance of Teaching Science and Technology in Early Education Levels in An Emerging Economy
net/publication/274063364
CITATIONS READS
14 34,929
8 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Roumen Nedev on 25 March 2015.
Original Article
Abstract
In the context of technological dissemination sessions aimed at prospective students at the Polytechnic University of Baja
California in the city of Mexicali, Baja California, the importance of engineering and its role in scientific and technological
progress was stressed, as well as its role in scientific and technological progress as drivers of economic development in
the region. A group of 2,154 students from 20 different institutions of public high school education answered a survey
designed as an evaluation tool for a career path or technology area of interest. The survey results show that students have
a low preference for engineering careers. Moreover, these results were augmented with an additional study on the high
attrition of students in engineering schools in the city of Mexicali, Baja California, also conducted by the authors. It raises the
importance of teaching science in the early education levels, which aims to prepare scientists and technologists needed for
the development of research and innovation as a foundation for economic prosperity and welfare of an emerging economy
such as Mexico.
Keywords
science teaching; science, technology and society (STS); education; engineering students; emerging economy
“Tell me and I forget, show me and I remember, involve me and featured in the “Declaration on Science and the Use of
I learn.” Scientific Knowledge,” adopted at the World Conference on
—Benjamin Franklin. Science held in Budapest in 1999, in these terms: “It is urgent
to renew, expand and diversify the basic education for all in
the field of science, emphasizing the skills and scientific and
Introduction technological knowledge to participate meaningfully in the
Disciplinary college training and high school average com- society of the future” (UNESCO, 1999).
pletion level in Mexico has some special points in epistemo- In most Latin American countries, the teaching of science
logical and historical reflection in the basic disciplines: and technology is intended to be among the priorities of edu-
mathematics, science, and technology. They focus on deep cation programs. Efforts and budgets have been devoted to
technical details, but lack a comprehensive and accurate improve the policies, curricular, teaching methods, and
view of the general concept of science and technology, how materials related to scientific disciplines as well as the train-
they perform in today’s world, their social impact and rela- ing of specialized teachers, so they are up to date and inter-
tionships, or the history of science and technology (Vázquez, ested in their professional mission. In this framework,
Acevedo, & Manassero, 2005). Training in these issues is well-educated teachers will have the natural motivation to
even more critical when considering that a technologist, spe- teach in early education levels. As a consequence of this
cializing in one particular technology, must become profes-
sor of the many and different technologies, received in his 1
Universidad Politécnica de Baja California, Mexicali, México
initial training, which are offered in the high school educa- 2
Universidad Autónoma de Baja California, Mexicali, México
tion curriculum.
Corresponding Author:
Paradoxically, science and technology education has not Maria Amparo Oliveros Ruiz, Universidad Politécnica de Baja California,
been developed at the same rate as science and technology. Calle de la claridad SN, Plutarco Elias Calles, Mexicali 21376, Mexico.
The role that education plays in these two areas has been Email: maoliverosr@upbc.edu.mx
Dropout Basic Assumptions better understanding of the social and organizational dimen-
sion of science and technology.
ANUIES identified, in 2006, a list of problems within the Important factors are as follows:
higher education system in Mexico:
•• the need to manage large industrial and military com-
1. disruption of higher education system compared to plexes such as the Manhattan Project during World
previous educational levels, War II and centers of research and development
2. persistence of high dropout rates and low efficiency, (R&D) associated with big science and high technol-
and ogy that emerged after WWII;
3. failure and little impact of policies to promote scien- •• the appearance of a critical awareness of the risks and
tific and technological research. negative effects of science and technology: nuclear
holocaust, environmental disasters, industrial acci-
The dropout at any educational level affects the student that dents, and so forth;
leaves, as well as other members of the system: the student •• the need to create institutions and training experts in
family, the institution (public and private), the economy of science and technology and impact assessment of
the country where this situation occurs, the productive sec- technology policy; and
tor, and so forth. Regarding the Mexican economy, the gov- •• the creation of research, especially from the perspec-
ernment spends about US$5,200 yearly for each student in tive of the sociology of knowledge, challenging the
college (Plan Nacional de Desarrollo 2007–2012), represent- traditional image of science and technology as an
ing an investment larger than twice of what is invested on a activity isolated from the social, political and eco-
high school student. nomic context.
The National Development Plan 2007–2012 describes the
following information regarding the average schooling at
different educational levels. It is estimated that the average The STS in Education
years of schooling among people between 15 to 24 years old Educational guidance of STS facilitates innovation in the
are 9.7, implying completed basic education both primary curriculum of science and technology at all levels of educa-
and secondary. Unfortunately, students have low perfor- tion, in accordance with the new goals for science and tech-
mance regarding reading, writing, and mathematics. For nology education, and is required for the 21st century. For its
those students who study beyond the average level of educa- effective implementation, it is necessary to change teaching
tion, only one in four young people between 18 and 22 years practice, the role of the teacher, and learning strategies. The
old reach the top level of educational coverage. It is consid- STS proposal is a field of study and research and, above all,
ered that the low enrollment in higher education is due to an innovative general education proposal. From the first per-
backlogs and inefficiencies in the previous levels, poverty, spective, it is to understand better the science and technology
and the institution’s own characteristics. On the other hand, in its social context, addressing the interrelationship between
50% of students enroll in areas of social and administrative scientific and technological developments and social pro-
sciences, in contrast to the exact sciences, where some insti- cesses (Acevedo, 1997). As a general educational proposal, it
tutions have decreased enrollments. is a radical new approach to the curriculum at all levels of
However, the completion rate is between 53% and 63%, education, in order to provide training and knowledge, espe-
depending on the type of program. Reaching a higher level cially in values that promote responsible citizenship and
does not guarantee that the graduates will join the world of democratic participation in the evaluation and control of the
work, reflecting lack of involvement of higher education social implications of science and technology.
institutions in the labor market (USAID 2014).
Therefore, it is important to know how the condition in
which senior students arrive at college is reflected in their The Teacher’s Role in Education STS
previous academic experience and their personal interest in In STS modality, teachers not only have to communicate the
higher education studies (Plan Nacional de Desarrollo objectives to be achieved, but must personally strive to lead
2013–2018). by example. The teacher should also promote communica-
tion in the classroom, increasing students’ activity and auton-
Didactics in Teaching Science as a omy (Waks, 1996).
Proposal to Improve Enrollment
and Prevent Dropout in Engineering The Curricula for Science, Technology,
Careers and Society
What is the Science, Technology, and Society (STS) move- In traditional training there is a very large gap between the
ment? It emerged in the second half of the 20th century due sciences and the humanities. However, in the new knowl-
to the convergence of various factors with the objective of a edge society in which we live, integrity of the individual’s
•• knowledge and learning skills for personal or cultural sociology, history, cultural, and economic aesthetic
purposes; (Aikenhead & Ogawa, 2007). STS activities may contribute
•• processes of scientific and technological research; and to these changes using the scheme of constructivist teaching-
•• development of values for professional, public, and learning process (Figure 2).
political issues, either local or global.
Figure 7. OECD percentage of 15-year-old boy and girls planning a career in engineering or computing.
Source. OECD (2012).
Rivera, M. (1990). El futuro de las Universidades en los Países en materials department and the founder of the master and doctoral
Desarrollo. Revista ANUIES, 19(74), 1–8. program in sciences and engineering for UABC. His professional
Secretaría de desarrollo económico de Baja California. 2014. career includes the collaboration with chemical, oil, water and
Directorios empresariales. Available from http://www.bajaca- energy industry of Mexico, and the preservation of the industrial
lifornia.gob.mx/sedeco/ infrastructure.
UNESCO. (1999). Enseñanza de las ciencias y la tecnología.
Michael Schorr Wienner is a professor (Dr. Hoonoris Causa) at
Retrieved February 5, 2014, from http://www.unesco.org/
the Institute of Engineering, University of Baja California. He has a
new/es/education/themes/strengthening-education-systems/
B. Sc. in Chemistry and, a M.Sc. in materials engineering from the
science-and-technology/
Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, with 40 years of experi-
University of California, Berkeley. (2012). Understanding science:
ence in industrial corrosion control. From 1986 to 2004, he has edi-
How science really works. Retrieved December 4, 2014, from
tor of Corrosion Reviews. He has published 340 scientific and tech-
http://www.oei.es/documentociencia.pdf
nical articles on materials and corrosion in English, Spanish and
USAID. (2014). Encuesta de competencias profesionales 2O14.
Hebrew. He has worked as a corrosion consultant and professor in
Retrieved February 3, 2014, from www.usaid.gov/sites/
Israel, the United States, Latin America, Spain, and South Africa.
default/files/documents/1862/USAID%20-%20Boletín%20
He has been a NACE International member for 22 years.
-%20Marzo%202014.pdf
Vázquez, A., Acevedo, J., & Manassero, M. A. (2005). “Más Juan Sevilla Garcia He is a Doctor in Educational Sciences by
allá de la enseñanza de la ciencia para científicos”: hacia una Universidad Iberoamericana. Professor-Researcher at the
educación científica humanista. Revista Electrónica de la Autonomous University of Baja California attached to the Institute
Enseñanza de la Ciencias, 4(2). of Engineering in the Masters and Doctoral programs in Science
Waks, L. J. (1996). Filosofía de la educación en CTS. Ciclo and Engineering in the field of Higher Education in Engineering.
de responsabilidad y trabajo comunitario. In A. Alonso, His academic activity focuses on the study of Higher Education, in
I. Ayestarán & N. Ursúa (Eds.), Para comprender Ciencia, particular, the administration and management of the Higher
Tecnología y Sociedad (pp. 19–33). Estella: EVD. Education Institutions (HEI), actors in higher education (teachers
and students) and management of university-industry relations.
Author Biographies Belongs to the National System of Researchers in the level I, com-
prises with the recognition of the Program for the Improvement of
Maria Amparo Oliveros Ruiz is a professor in the Science,
the Teaching Staff (PROMEP Profile), and is member of the
Technology and Society Program at the School of Engineering of
Committee of Institutional Administration and Management of the
the University Politechic of Baja California (UPBC). She received
Inter-Institutional Committees for the Evaluation of Higher
a BSc in public administration and political sciences from UABC
Education (CIEES) in the areas of Planning and Institutional
and holds an MSc degree in education from the State University for
Assessment and Liaison. He has had experience in the administra-
Pedagogic Studies, Mexicali. Currently she has been sponsored by
tion of HEI, as Director of the Faculty of Chemical Sciences and
the National Science and Technology Council in Mexico with a
Engineering, Vice-rector, Secretary General and Coordinator of
scholarship to get a doctoral degree in higher education in engineer-
Planning and Institutional Development of its University.
ing. Her project research is focused on the implementation of the
STS program in the engineering units of the UABC at Mexicali, Eduardo Cabrera Cordova is a professor at the Polytechnic
Mexico. She is a member of the PIEARCT (Iberoamerican Project University of Baja California. He has a bachelor degree in Chemical
for Evaluation of STS) network. Engineering from the University of Guadalajara, M.Sc. in Industrial
Management from the CETYS University and M.Sc. in Engineering
Lidia Esther Vargas Osuna is a professor at the Faculty of
of Materials from the Engineering Insitute, University of Baja
Engineering, University of Baja California. She has a B.S. degree in
California. Professional and academic experience with a focus on
Chemical Engineering from the Mexicali Institute of Technology
materials science, research products, processes and equipments.
and a M.Sc. degree and PhD degree in Engineering from the
Institute of Engineering of the UABC. With 15 years of experience Roumen Nedev has a M.Sc. in Electrical Engineering and, PhD in
in the manufacturing industry including reliability and failure anal- computer science from the Mediterranean University in France.
ysis of microelectronic devices. Her research is focused in the mate- From 2008 to 2011, he was an assistant professor in the Technical
rials science and engineering. She is a National Researcher University of Sofia, Bulgaria. He has published more than 10 scien-
Candidate by the National System of Researchers (SNI) of the tific articles, and 1 book in English, Spanish and French.
National Council of Science and Technology (CONACYT).
Roberto Ibarra is the Innovation Center Manager of Skyworks
Benjamín Valdez Salas is researcher at Institute of Engineering of Mexicali and student of the doctorate program at Institute of
the University of Baja California, member of the Mexican Academy Engineering of UABC, a M.Sc. in industrial management by
of Sciences and the National System of Researchers of Mexico. He CETYS University; currently he is participating in some National
was granted the B.S. degree in Chemical Engineering, the M.Sc. Advisory boards related with innovation, design and technological
degree in Chemistry and the PhD. in Chemistry by the Autonomous development; with 20 years of experience in electronic industry
University of Guadalajara. His activities include research on the manufacturing, he has created the Semiconductor Innovation
topics; corrosion and materials, electrochemical and industrial pro- Center (CISEM) and the technological and innovation Model for
cesses, chemical processing of agricultural and natural products, Skyworks and was recognized and awarded by the Mexican gov-
and consultancy in corrosion control in industrial plants and envi- ernment, also he has established an strongest relationship with
ronments. He is author of books, chapters in book and scientific government institutions and universities in order to deploy an
articles on electrochemistry, biodeterioration and corrosion of innovation ecosystem. He has leaded the Mexicali Design Center
materials and general chemistry. He is the head of the corrosion and for 2 years