Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Election as Caliph
• After Hazrat Usman’s assassination, rebels felt it necessary to choose a caliph before leaving Madina.
• Rebels asked various people to ascend to the office of caliphate:
(I) Hazrat Ali, Hazrat Talha and Hazrat Zubair refused to be elected as caliphs.
(II) The Ansar declined, saying that in the presence of Hazrat Ali, no one else deserved to be caliph.
• The rebels promised some severe action unless a caliph was chosen within the next 24 hours.
• The people of Madina gathered in the Masjid-e-Nabwi to hold council.
• The leader of the Egyptian rebels declared that the next caliph should be pious, brave, learned and should have been
close to Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Only Hazrat Ali perfectly fitted these criteria and was persuaded into becoming
RIGHTLY GUIDED CALIPHS HZRAT ALI R.A SIR SYED REHAN AHMED
the 4th Caliph. Hazrat Talha, Hazrat Zubair and others took Bayt at his hands.
Change of governors:
• Hazrat Ali felt that a change of provincial governors was in the interest of the state.
• Hazrat Ali’s advisors and friends warned him against taking such a strong step before establishing his caliphate.
• They especially warned him against deposing Hazrat Ameer Muawiya, Governor of Syria, as Hazrat Umar, not Hazrat
Usman, had appointed him.
• Hazrat Ali acted against their advice.
• Appointments made by Hazrat Ali:
Name Province
Usman bin Hanif Basra
Saad bin Ubaydah Egypt
Abdullah bin Abbas Yemen
Ummara bin Shahab Kufa
Suhail bin Hanif Syria
Battle of Siffin
• Hazrat Muawiya had refused to leave his post as governor of Syria.
• Under his influence, no one in Syria had taken the oath of allegiance to the new caliph.
• Hazrat Muawiya started a campaign, seeking revenge for the blood of Hazrat Usman.
• He declared the election of Hazrat Ali to be illegal and said that it had been under the influence of the rebels that he had
become caliph.
• As a result, Syria, Iran and Iraq were won over by Hazrat Muawiya.
• Not wanting to shed Muslim blood, Hazrat Ali offered peace to Hazrat Muawiya and said that since the people who had
selected Hazrat Abu Bakr, Hazrat Umar and Hazrat Usman as caliph had also accepted him, Hazrat Muawiya and his
RIGHTLY GUIDED CALIPHS HZRAT ALI R.A SIR SYED REHAN AHMED
Kharijites
• As a result of the Battle of Siffin, a new sect called the Kharijites was born.
• This term means ‘separatists’.
• On the way to Kufa, they insisted that Hazrat Ali should attack the Syrians.
• When Hazrat Ali replied that he could not break the agreement, 12,000 men separated from him.
• The separatists marched towards Harwara, where they formed a party and started their activities against the caliph.
• That is why they are called Kharijites.
• These people were involved in the murder of Hazrat Usman.
• They had allied themselves with Hazrat Ali in the Battle of Jamal.
• They said that they were the only true believers and had a right to kill unbelievers.
• They considered only Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Umar as true caliphs and regarded others as usurpers.
Arbitration
• Hazrat Abu Musa Ashari and Hazrat Amr bin Aas met at Dumat-ul-Jandal to discuss the
case of Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Muawiya.
• Hazrat Abu Musa wanted to depose both Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Muawiya and let the people choose their next caliph.
• Hazrat Amr wanted to depose Hazrat Ali alone.
• Hazrat Ali did not abide by the judgement as he felt that it was one-sided.
Battle of Nahrawan
• While Hazrat Ali was planning to attack Hazrat Muawiya, the Kharijites started creating problems.
• Hazrat Ali marched on them and a battle ensued at Nahrawan.
• Out of the 4,000 Kharijites, only a few dozen managed to escape.
• This was a hollow victory as it diverted Hazrat Ali’s attention from his campaign against Hazrat Muawiya.
Fall of Egypt
• After the victory at Nahrawan, Hazrat Ali wanted to attack Hazrat Muawiya. However, his troops deserted him.
• Taking advantage of this situation, Hazrat Muawiya ordered Amr bin Aas to attack Egypt.
• Egypt was re-conquered by Hazrat Amr bin Aas.
• After this, rebellion broke out in all provinces.
• Hazrat Ali was forced to sign a peace treaty with Hazrat Muawiya.
• It was decided that Hazrat Muawiya should rule over Syria and Egypt, while Hazrat Ali ruled over the rest.
Questions
Q 1: (a) ‘Ali’s caliphate was riddled with problems. Describe what these problems were. [10]
(b) Choose any one problem you have written about in Part (a) and say why you think it was
significant. [4]
(b) ‘ ‘Ali was the right ruler for the time’. Briefly discuss this statement. [4]
Q 2: (a) ‘Ali’s caliphate was riddled with problems. Describe what these problems were. [10]
(b) Choose any one problem you have written about in Part (a) and say why you think it was
significant. [4]
Q 3: (a) Which important battles were fought during the caliphate of ‘Ali? Write a descriptive
account of each. [10]
(b) ‘ ‘Ali was the right ruler for the time’. Briefly discuss this statement. [4]