Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/368369246
CITATIONS READS
0 356
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Sara Weuffen on 17 May 2023.
© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2023 1
S. Weuffen et al. (eds.), Inclusion, Equity, Diversity, and Social Justice in Education,
Sustainable Development Goals Series, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-5008-7_1
2 A. Goriss-Hunter et al.
Jenene: As an educator for over 40 years, I have 1.1 Inclusion, Equity, Diversity,
been actively involved in teaching across a broad and Social Justice in Education
range of education settings. My interest in dis-
ability as a socially constructed concept emerged In twenty-first century education, while the
from my doctoral studies into children’s experi- notion of social justice is postulated as under-
ences of play in purpose-built inclusive play pinning egalitarian pedagogies and curricula,
spaces. students defined as different to the middle-class,
Sara: I am an early-career researcher with con- white, heterosexual, and able-bodied norm have
siderable academic and life experiences with vastly disparate education experiences and out-
equity, inclusion, and social justice matters. comes. Despite social justice ideologies and a
Growing up in a lower socioeconomic environ- focus on diversity and inclusion, these students
ment in regional Victoria, experiencing are frequently viewed through a deficit lens with
marginalization based on gender, sex, and body their lived experiences and knowledge seen as
image, and being the first in my immediate something to be fixed, modified, or negated
family to attend higher education, I personally (Binns 2019; Patton Davis and Museus 2019).
and professionally champion humanistic notions Yet, over the past decade, there has been a
of inclusion for transformative education. growing body of literature highlighting the
unique skills and attributes these students bring
Margaret: My interest in diversity and equality
to classrooms, including how they enrich school
of opportunity stemmed from three decades of
environments, pedagogies, and social develop-
teaching and researching in Initial Teacher
ment (Slee 2018).
Education (ITE) programs in a regional univer-
While there has been an increased focus on
sity. My extensive involvement with rural and
diversity and inclusion in education settings
regional students, who although highly academ-
globally, metric-driven pedagogies combined with
ically capable often did not achieve to a level
additional workload pressures on educators have
commensurate with their potential, fueled my
resulted in entrenched and homogenized lenses
passion for providing guidance and resources to
influencing understandings and processes. This, in
help preservice and practicing teachers and
turn, has created education systems where the
school students understand the important rela-
extent of diversity may be invisible and where
tionship between aspirational outcomes and
educators may feel uncertain, reticent, and ill-
opportunity.
equipped to integrate inclusive pedagogies for
Susan: I have been an early childhood teacher as student success (Jarvis 2019; OECD 2019). For
well as a tertiary teacher for over 40 years. I have instance, Jarvis’ (2019) research observes that
worked as an educator and researcher within over half of Australian graduate teachers feel
many diverse communities throughout Australia unprepared to teach students with additional
including remote Indigenous settings, and I have needs. For inclusive education to work in gen-
observed and experienced just and unjust edu- uinely transformative ways, educators need to be
cational environments. The underpinning reasons well equipped with pedagogical knowledge and
for inequity have both intrigued and bothered skills employed through a lens of inclusivity as
me, and I have sought to understand how we well as a deep understanding of a diverse range of
recognize unfairness and proactively work to learners. Both educators and learners need to be
create inclusive educational contexts. I have open to unlearning what has become centralized
learnt the crucial nature of addressing inequality and assumed knowledge and re-learning/creating
as early as we can in a child’s life. new ontologies and epistemologies.
1 Inclusion, Equity, Diversity, and Social Justice in Education … 3
This chapter provides a road map for the col- from within interpretivist education and social sci-
lected edition which explores narratives from ence disciplines, and they foreground lived and
a diverse range of educators who all seek the associative experiences. The authors occupy a
fulfillment of Sustainable Development Goals variety of intersectional positions and mobilize a
(SDGs) 3, 4, 5, 8, 10, and 16 in various contexts range of theoretical frameworks to interrogate
around the globe. In this book, questions are political, philosophical, and social normative ways
raised, tensions observed, and practices high- of thinking about and acting regarding diversity
lighted, often through passionate discussion, and inclusion to promote the notion of justice
regarding the ways in which considerations of beyond legal and educational conceptions.
equity, inclusion, and social justice are config- The book itself is both provocation and process
ured, challenged, observed, or ignored in a range melding theory and practice. As a provocation, it
of educational settings. Within this collected challenges the reader to think about ways in which
edition, the authors offer nuanced explorations of assumed knowledge can be challenged and
the complexities of inclusion, equity, and equality unlearned. With a focus on transformation and
measures, as well as the impacts that these educators as agents of change, the book encour-
approaches may have on the experiences and ages the reader to interrogate the ways in which
learning of students and educators. The collective they think about and interact with concepts and
narrative provides a significant contribution to practices of inclusive education, equity, and social
understandings of how approaches that combine justice that are manifested in the SDGs. The col-
inclusion, equity, and equality measures may be lected edition gives voice to a range of academic
understood and employed critically and creatively authors who are diverse yet connected, in their
in a variety of practices and contexts. pursuit of utilizing the SDGs and interrogating the
The authors in this edited collection are discourses and policies of educational institutions
teachers within early childhood education, pri- and settings. In doing so, the book provides real-
mary (elementary), and secondary school back- world studies about how diversity and inclusion
grounds; academics from school and higher are enacted within education across the globe and
education sectors; teacher-academics with dis- discusses the critical factors associated with
abilities; parent-educators; people associated building capacity for social justice.
with equity groups; proud sovereign Indigenous While the book works as a provocation, call-
peoples; research by higher degree students; and ing for an examination of thought and practice
academic leaders. The authors’ unique combi- using a lens of inclusivity, it is also a demon-
nations of identity factors are indicated in their stration of the principles of inclusion and equity
positioning statements at the beginning of each which are embedded in the processes of the
chapter. These positioning statements provide a book’s production. Rather than writing about
snapshot of the diverse narratives of academics these concepts while employing what could be
who are active researchers and educators at var- argued as traditional and exclusionary selection,
ious career stages who often draw upon their own reviewing, and editing procedures privileging
lived experience to investigate and write about experienced writers, the editors made a decision
equity and social justice. This focus on lived to embrace and embed inclusive principles
experience, as indicated in the positioning state- within the fabric of the book and the ways in
ments, endows the narratives in the book with which it was developed. Inclusive editorial pro-
nuanced, and at times personal, perspectives. cesses celebrated diversity by working with
In their chapters, authors respond to the expe- inexperienced writers and reviewers, from a
riences, challenges, ambiguities, and tensions of range of backgrounds and circumstances through
diversity and inclusion characteristic in a variety of a network of mentors. Those who had previous
education settings across the globe including in publication experience monitored the progress of
Afghanistan, Africa, Australia, China, India, Scot- the project and mentored colleagues for capacity
land, and Sweden. These discussions are presented building throughout various stages of production.
4 A. Goriss-Hunter et al.
When appropriate, editors reached out to less chapter speaks to the United Nations Sustainable
experienced authors, and those who for a variety Development Goal 4: Quality Education which
of reasons either requested or appeared to need aims to “ensure inclusive and equitable quality
support, to offer assistance, and informally education and promote lifelong learning oppor-
monitor the progress of writing. When challenges tunities for all” (UN 2015). This is achieved
arose, they were examined from all sides and through the presentation of an intersectional and
met. These experiences built capacity for critical holistic narrative about the historical, the current
engagement with concepts, discourses, and landscape, and future of mainstream education
philosophies and the ability to objectively cri- where diversity and inclusion are concerned. In
tique writing while also facilitating the emer- addition, Sustainable Goals 3, 5, 8, 10, and 16
gence of diverse voices of the authors and the are addressed by various authors to illuminate the
participants in their research. The drawing on interconnectedness of SDGs across various edu-
principles of inclusion in this process also high- cational settings. These include.
lighted the importance of responsive and rela-
tional approaches when working with a diverse • Ensuring good health and well-being (SDG3)
range of people on a collected edition. • Achieving gender equality and empower all
The editors of this volume encourage the women and girls (SDG5)
reader to reflect on their personal and profes- • Promoting a sustained, inclusive, and sus-
sional experiences and practices and consider tainable economic growth, full and productive
how they might advance the fulfillment of the employment, and decent work for all (SDG8)
SDGs by using inclusive approaches, identifying • Reducing inequalities within and among
diversity, and fostering success for all their stu- countries (SDG10)
dents. The authors invite readers to reflect criti- • Promoting peaceful and inclusive societies for
cally on the following questions: sustainable development and providing access
to justice for all and build effective, account-
• What are the educational challenges you cur- able, and inclusive institutions at all levels
rently face/have faced? (SDG16).
• How might you disrupt these challenges?
• What kinds of resources could you draw on, The chapters are organized in three thematic
and equally, what resources and supports are parts: Part I: Interrogating perspectives of diver-
missing, that would be beneficial to over- sity and inclusion; Part II: Foregrounding diverse
coming these challenges? voices and inclusive practices; and Part III:
• By what avenues might unique experiences be Disrupting mainstream education through
expressed? capacity building, to present a scaffolded narra-
• When advocating for diversity and inclusion, tive about the current state of diversity and
what is one thing you could do tomorrow that inclusion in education spaces, and envisioning a
would instigate positive change in the situa- future for more sustainable, inclusive, and
tions and experiences you observe? diverse education systems.
point in this collected edition. In Chap. 2, Burke schooling to online learning. They posit that
et al. (2022) unpack the concept of inclusive despite positive government interventions, the
education by discussing how it has been applied impact of COVID-19 on the Indian education
and understood globally in policy and practice system and child welfare has highlighted con-
with a focus on educational environments. The nections between disadvantage and exclusion
chapter works in tandem with the following (Rana and Daniel 2022). Weuffen and Willis
chapter (Larsen and Emmett 2022) to investigate (2022) in Chap. 7 interrogate current thinking
fundamental concepts including human rights, and educational experiences regarding the
social accountability, inclusive education, dif- teaching of Australia’s shared history involving
ference, and intersectional analysis that underpin Indigenous and non-Indigenous populations. The
discussions throughout the rest of the collected authors contend that despite prevalent discourses
edition. In Chap. 3, Larsen and Emmett (2022) of inclusive education and social justice, Aus-
interrogate what they call The Wicked Problem of tralian educational systems are still struggling to
Social Equity in Higher Education, paying implement authentic and culturally inclusive
attention to political and historical narratives. education curricula and pedagogies (Weuffen and
The authors argue that these discourses of equity Willis 2022).
in higher education are fueled by complex and
sometimes disparate narratives (Larsen and
Emmett, 2022). Extending the investigative nar- 1.4 Part II Foregrounding Diverse
rative of equity, in Chap. 4, Larsen and Frost- Voices and Inclusive Practices
Camilleri (2022) conduct a scoping literature
review of the discursive constructions of under- In the first chapter of this part, Glowrey et al.
represented students in tertiary institutions, not- (2022) explore the World of Work (WoW) ex-
ing that these student cohorts are often targeted periences for youth in a disadvantaged region of
in formal literature concerning equity and inclu- Australia. WoW refers to a range of activities
sive policies which construct non-traditional mediated by schools that attempt to engage stu-
tertiary students in terms of deficit discourses. dents in the identification, understanding, and
In Chap. 5, Marsh et al. (2022) consider the preparation for future career and education
challenges and associated theoretical frameworks opportunities (Australian Government 2020;
concerning the “re-centering” of Indigenous OECD 2020; Torii 2018). The authors employ a
knowledge and philosophies in curricula and combination of self-determination theory (Reeve
pedagogies in Australian and Swedish tertiary 2012) and the theory of possible self (Markus
institutions. Using Indigenous Standpoint Theory and Nurius 1986) as a framework to interrogate
(Foley 2006; Moreton-Robinson 2009; Nakata and interrupt conventional discourse that con-
2007; Nakata et al. 2012) and Critical Race structs regional Australian youth in deficit terms
Pedagogy (Dunbar 2008; Jennings and Lyn (Glowrey et al. 2022). In Chap. 9, Browne
2005; Page et al. 2019), the authors argue for the (2022) examines a topic about which there is a
establishment of “an ethno-relative and culturally dearth of research—perspectives and experiences
responsive approach that effectively and consis- of early childhood teachers with disabilities.
tently centres and privileges Indigenous knowl- However, Browne (2022) adds critical knowl-
edges and philosophies to graduate students … edge to this topic by exploring autobiographical
that are critically and racially aware, in a position experiences of teachers with disabilities in
to advocate for social justice” (Marsh et al. 2022, obtaining work and their experiences while in
p. 9). In their exploration of the impact of work. From the unique viewpoint of parents who
COVID-19 on education systems and child rights are also teachers, Claughton et al. (2022), in
in India, in Chap. 6, Rana and Daniel (2022) Chap. 10, explore the challenges that occur at
examine education, health, and equity issues individual and systemic levels for parents who
involved in the movement from face-to-face are also teachers caring for a child(ren) with a
6 A. Goriss-Hunter et al.
justice in education: a critical exploration of the centering of Indigenous knowledges and philosophies
sustainable development goals. Springer in higher education in Australia and Sweden. In:
Goriss-Hunter A, Archer V, Arvanitakis J (2022) Identity Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M, Goriss-Hunter A,
and intersectional responsive pedagogy in higher Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity, diversity, and social
education: insights from two locations in regional justice in education: a critical exploration of the
and urban Australia. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plun- sustainable development goals. Springer
kett M, Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, Moreton-Robinson A (2009) Imagining the good indige-
equity, diversity, and social justice in education: a nous citizen: race war and the pathology of patriarchal
critical exploration of the sustainable development white sovereignty. Cult Stud Rev 15(2):61. https://doi.
goals. Springer org/10.5130/csr.v15i2.2038
Holcombe W, Plunkett M (2022) Bridges and barriers: Najibi P, McLachlan C (2022) Moving towards a
building an innovative model of support for teachers sustainable future for women in Afghanistan through
of students with ASD. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, increased tertiary education participation: challenges
Plunkett M, Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclu- and possibilities. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M,
sion, equity, diversity, and social justice in education: Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity,
a critical exploration of the sustainable development diversity, and social justice in education: a critical
goals. Springer exploration of the sustainable development goals.
Jarvis J (2019) Most Australian teachers feel unprepared Springer
to teach students with special needs. The conversation. Nakata M (2007) The cultural interface. Aust J Indige-
https://theconversation.com/most-australian-teachers- nous Educ 36(S1):7–14. https://doi.org/10.1017/
feel-unprepared-to-teach-students-with-special-needs- S1326011100004646
119227 Nakata M, Nakata V, Keech S, Bolt R (2012) Decolonial
Jennings ME, Lyn M (2005) The house that race built: goals and pedagogies for indigenous studies. Decol-
critical pedagogy, African-American education, and onization Indigeneity Educ Soc 1(1):120–140
the re-conceptualisation of a critical race pedagogy. OECD (2019) TALIS 2018 results (volume I): teachers
Educ Found 19(3–4):15–32 and school leaders as lifelong learners. TALIS, OECD
Kewalramani S, Kidman K (2022) Social and cultural Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/1d0bc92a-en
capitals of parents from Indian immigrant back- OECD (2020) Back to the future of education:
grounds: a case of developing childrens’ STEM Four OECD scenarios for schooling, educational
learning. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M, Goriss- research and innovation. OECD Publishing, Paris.
Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity, diversity, https://doi.org/10.1787/178ef527-en
and social justice in education: a critical exploration of Oxworth C (2022) African girls’ experiences of gender in
the sustainable development goals. Springer school communities: observations and reflections from
Kotzee B (2017) Education and epistemic justice. In: Kidd IJ, a researcher. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M,
Medina J, Pohlaus G (eds) The Routledge handbook of Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity,
epistemic injustice. Routledge, pp 324–335 diversity, and social justice in education: a critical
Larsen A, Emmett S (2022) The wicked problem of social exploration of the sustainable development goals.
equity in higher education: the conflicting discourses Springer
and the impact of COVID-19. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Page S, Trudgett M, Bodkin-Andrews G (2019) Tactics or
Plunkett M, Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclu- strategies? Exploring everyday conditions to facilitate
sion, equity, diversity, and social justice in education: implementation of an indigenous graduate attributes
a critical exploration of the sustainable development project. J High Educ Policy Manag 41(4):390–403.
goals. Springer https://doi.org/10.1080/1360080X.2019.1609390
Larsen A, Frost-Camilleri L (2022) Issues and solutions: a Patton Davis L, Museus S (2019) What is deficit
literature review of the deficit discourses concerning thinking? An analysis of conceptualizations of deficit
under-represented students. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, thinking and implications for scholarly research.
Plunkett M, Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclu- Currents 1(1):117–130. https://doi.org/10.3998/
sion, equity, diversity, and social justice in education: currents.17387731.0001.110
a critical exploration of the sustainable development Rana A, Daniel R (2022) Insights into the education
goals. Springer system in Indian and the current impact of COVID-19
Markus H, Nurius P (1986) Possible selves. Am Psychol on child rights. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M,
41(9):954–969. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X. Goriss-Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity,
41.9.954 diversity, and social justice in education: A critical
Marsh J, Daniels-Mayes S, MacNeil S, Nursey-Bray M exploration of the sustainable development goals.
(2022) Learning through an undisciplined lens: the Springer
1 Inclusion, Equity, Diversity, and Social Justice in Education … 9
Reeve J (2012) A self-determination theory perspective Dr. Anitra Goriss-Hunter is the Director, Learning and
on student engagement. In: Christenson SL, Teaching and a Senior Lecturer at Federation University Aus-
Reschly AL, Wylie C (eds) Handbook of research tralia. Her research and teaching focuses on gender and educa-
on student engagement. Springer Science + Business tion, inclusion, and pre-service teacher (PSTs) education. Anitra
Media, pp 149–172. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1- was awarded the prestigious Australian Women’s and Gender
4614-2018-7_7 Studies Association award for most outstanding Ph.D. thesis.
Scandone B (2021) “I don’t want to completely lose Anitra’s research investigates women’s careers in Higher Edu-
myself”: social mobility as movement across classed, cation; ways to improve female participation in Science, Tech-
ethnicised, and gendered spaces. Sociol Res Online. nology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) education; and,
https://doi.org/10.1177/1360780421992379 the development of inclusive teaching approaches that offer
authentic learning experiences for PSTs. Anitra’s contribution in
Shyman E (2015) Toward a globally sensitive definition
the last field was recognized when she was awarded the Feder-
of inclusive education based in social justice. Int J
ation University Vice-Chancellor’s Award—Citation for Out-
Disabil Dev Educ 62(4):351–362. https://doi.org/10. standing Contribution to Student Learning 2020.
1080/1034912X.2015.1025715
Slee R (2018) Defining the scope of inclusive education.
UNESCO. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/ Professor Jenene Burke is the Director, Academic Operations
pf0000265773 in the Institute of Education, Arts and Community at Federation
Slee R, Allan J (2001) Excluding the included: a University Australia. Jenene convenes the Social Justice, Inclu-
reconsideration of inclusive education. Int Stud Sociol sion and Diversity in Education (SJIDE) research focus area in
Educ 11(2):173–192. https://doi.org/10.1080/09620 the Institute. She is the President of the World Federation of
210100200073 Associations for Teacher Education (WFATE) and leads the
Torii K (2018) Connecting the worlds of learning and WFATE Inclusion and Social Justice in Teacher Education in
work. Prioritising school-industry partnerships in Global Contexts research development group. As a researcher,
Australia’s education system. Mitchell Institute. Jenene is best known for her world-class research into play
http://www.mitchellinstitute.org.au/wp-content/ spaces as inclusive environments for children and their fami-
uploads/2018/07/Connecting-the-worlds-oflearning- lies. She is particularly interested in research that privileges the
and-work.pdf voices of participants, especially children and young people.
United Nations (2015) Sustainable development goals. Jenene has a secondary teaching background and 20 years of
UN Department of Social and Economic Affairs. experience in Higher Education as a teacher educator. Her
https://sdgs.un.org/goals learning and teaching interests centre on educational responses to
Weuffen S, Willis K (2022) The fallacy of cultural student diversity, with respect to inclusive education and dis-
ability studies in education.
inclusion in mainstream education discourses. In:
Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M, Goriss-Hunter A,
Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity, diversity, and social
justice in education: a critical exploration of the Dr. Sara Weuffen is a teacher-researcher specialist with a Ph.
sustainable development goals. Springer D. in cross/inter-cultural education research between
Weuffen S, Burke J, Goriss-Hunter A, Plunkett M, non-Indigenous people, Aboriginal peoples, and Torres Strait
Emmett S (2022) Working towards a sustainable, Islanders in Australia. She specializes in learning and content
design for diverse cohorts across a broad range of platforms;
responsive, inclusive, and diverse global education
online, blended, face-to-face. As a non-Indigenous woman
future. In: Weuffen S, Burke J, Plunkett M, Goriss-
born on Gundijtmara Country (Warrnambool) and living on
Hunter A, Emmett S (eds) Inclusion, equity, diversity,
Wadawurrung Country (Ballarat), Dr. Weuffen draws upon
and social justice in education: a critical exploration of her formative grey methodological approach—where both
the sustainable development goals. Springer Poststructural theory and Indigenous methodologies are
Zhu H (2011) From intercultural awareness to intercul- bought together—and collaborations with Australia’s First
tural empathy. English Lang Teach 4(1):116–119. Nations Peoples, to critique dominant structures and ideolo-
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1080436.pdf gies, interrogate binary discourses, and push educational
boundaries for emancipatory and success-orientated
shared-learning outcomes and positive social progress.
10 A. Goriss-Hunter et al.
Dr. Margaret Plunkett is an Adjunct Associate Professor in Dr. Susan Emmett has been extensively involved in early
the Institute of Education, Arts and Community at Federation childhood education and the translation of research into the
University Australia. She has been a teacher educator and practical environment for over thirty-five years. Her profes-
researcher for more than three decades, specialising in the sional experience includes early childhood teaching in a range
fields of rural and regional education, teacher professional of settings, work as an early childhood educational consultant
learning and gifted education. She has extensive research and teaching and researching within TAFE and Higher Edu-
expertise in both qualitative and quantitative methodologies cation sectors. Susan is a Senior Lecturer in Education at
and across all educational sectors, particularly in relation to Federation University Australia where she coordinates and
diverse student populations in rural and regional areas, with teaches in Early Childhood and manages partnerships with
much of the work focusing on the intersection between external organisations both domestic and international. Prior
aspirations, rurality and achievement. Margaret has conducted to this, Susan worked as a Research Fellow within the School
research with schools in the Gippsland region, focusing on of Social and Policy Research at Charles Darwin University
how educational environments can help develop knowledge, where early childhood literacy was central to her research,
skills and competencies that assist in building meaningful and particularly in relation to rural and remote indigenous edu-
sustainable relationships and emotional competence within cation. Her research interests also include the wellbeing and
communities. Margaret is Associate Editor of the Australasian resilience of children and educators including trauma
Journal of Gifted Education, and a member of a range of informed, inclusive pedagogy and relationship-focused prac-
national and international education associations. tice in early childhood contexts. Susan’s expertise is in the
use of qualitative methodologies, including grounded theory.
She has recently published journal articles, reports, and book
chapters in these areas. She also applies and works with
mixed methods research processes including designing and
conducting randomised control trials. In 2016 Susan won the
Federation University Vice-Chancellor’s Award for Contri-
butions to Student Learning and Teaching Excellence, and in
2015 she was a recipient of The Deans Award for dedication
to partnership work and consequent provision of enriched
learning experiences for education students from a diverse
range of backgrounds.