You are on page 1of 99

lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Foreign Language Learning Part 1 2 combined

AB Communication Arts (Tarlac State University)

Studocu is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university


Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)
lOMoARcPSD|31637338

FOREIGN LANGUAGE LEARNING AMONG ABEL STUDENTS

An Undergraduate Thesis Presented


to the Faculty of English Language Department
PANGASINAN STATE UNIVERSITY
Urdaneta Campus
Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
BACHELOR OF ARTS IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE

By:

Coroña, Sheena Richelle M.


De Chavez, Charmaine L.
Voces, Lavishreiy Gail P.

January 2023

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPROVAL SHEET

In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Bachelor of Arts in

English Language, this thesis entitled “Foreign Language Learning among

ABEL students” prepared and submitted by Sheena Richelle M. Coroña,

Charmaine L. de Chavez, and Lavishreiy Gail P. Voces is hereby

recommended for approval and acceptance.

MARVIN Q. CORPUZ, M.A.Ed. VIRMA CRIS L. LAGUNA


Critic Reader Adviser

PANEL OF EXAMINERS

RUBY F. AMADO, M.A.Ed.


Chairman

EDNA C. QUERIONES, Ed.D. JANILYN GRACE C. PALEB, M.A.Ed.


Member Member

Accepted and approved in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the


degree of Bachelor of Arts in English Language.

ELIZABETH F. EPISCOPE, Ed.D. ROY C. FERRER, Ph.D.


Dean, College of Arts and Education Campus Executive Director

ii

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

"If you don't sacrifice for what you want, what you want becomes the sacrifice."

Foremost, the researchers would like to express their gratitude to God almighty,

who continuously recharged and comforted them by reminding them that they

were not alone in completing this paper.

The researchers, research adviser ma'am Virma Cris Laguna, and critic reader

sir Marvin Corpuz are also gratefully acknowledged for their patience in

providing guidance and reviewing the article during the study. These people's

unflinching perseverance inspired researchers to keep going in the middle.

The adviser and critic appreciation are extended to panels being tough on the

researchers and contributing to the improvement of this study. The families,

friends, and moral support of the researchers enabled them to complete the

project they had begun.

The path taken by the researchers to complete this study is not one they take

alone. This paper's allure and quality are the results of numerous

contributions and suggestions from others.

iii

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

DEDICATION

“The price of success is hard work, dedication to the job at hand, and the

determination that whether we win or lose, we have applied the best of

ourselves to the task at hand.” – Vince Lombardi

This paper is dedicated to God, our family, and our friends who give us constant

support and motivation to finish this study.

This paper is also dedicated to those who inspire us to keep moving.

We also dedicate this paper to those who work hard and gave their time and

effort to improve this study, our adviser and critic reader.

We also dedicate this paper to ourselves who work hard to finish this paper.

May this study assist future researchers and students in studying their foreign

language.

- Charmaine, Lavish, and Sheena

iv

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

ABSTRACT

Title of the Study: Foreign Language Learning Among ABEL


Students Researcher: Coroña, Sheena Richelle M.
de Chavez, Charmaine L.
Voces, Lavishreiy Gail P.
Degree/ Specialization: Bachelor of Arts in English Language
Institution: Pangasinan State University- Urdaneta City
Campus San Vicente, Urdaneta City, Pangasinan
Research Adviser: Virma Cris L. Laguna
Keywords: foreign language, Korean language, Japanese language, Chinese
language, challenges, perceived effects, strategies

This study aimed to examine the challenges, perceived effects, and strategies

that the students experienced and used while learning foreign languages,

specifically Japanese, Korean, and Chinese. This study focused on these three

languages because they are the foreign languages offered by the Bachelor of

Arts in English Language. The researchers chose these languages because they

have a different writing system than the Roman alphabet.

The study used qualitative research design and utilized semi-structured

interview as the research instrument. The researchers transcribed the recorded

interview and analyzed the data using thematic analysis. The respondents were

five (5) 4th-year ABEL students of Pangasinan State University Urdaneta

Campus. Results showed that the challenges students experienced in studying a

foreign language werethe writing system, pronunciation,

memorization, learning environment, time constraints, and

demotivation. The result also showed that the perceived effects of the

challenges of foreign language learning on students are

v
Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)
lOMoARcPSD|31637338

emotionally draining, mentally taxing, distracting and confusing, demotivating,

and motivating. Lastly, the result showed that students' learning strategies in

studying foreign languages are cognitive, memory-related, social, and

metacognitive. This study is essential for understanding the needs and

shortcomings of learning a foreign language because it will aid both instructors

and students in their learning and teaching. The study recommended that; (1) the

students are encouraged to reward themselves after finishing an activity, (2)

teachers should give more time to discuss the writing system, pronunciation, and

rules of a foreign language, (3) teachers should expose students to the native

speakers and foreign language, (4) school organizations should have programs

or seminars about mental and emotional health, (5) students may motivate each

other to study foreign languages,

(6) use social media sites such as YouTube and TikTok to learn foreign

languages, and (7) the current researchers recommend that a similar study be

conducted, considering other variables such as the instructors' teaching

strategies in foreign language teaching.

vi
Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)
lOMoARcPSD|31637338

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page
TITLE i

APPROVAL SHEET ii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iii

DEDICATION iv

ABSTRACT v

TABLE OF CONTENTS vii

LIST OF FIGURES ix

CHAPTER

1 THE PROBLEM

Background of the Study 1

Statement of the Problem 3

Significance of the Study 3

Scope and Delimitation of the Study 4

Definition of Terms 5

2 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

Related Literature 6

Related Studies 19

Synthesis of the Reviewed Related Studies 23

Theoretical Framework 26

Conceptual Framework 29
vii
3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Research Design 30

Respondents of the Study 31

Data Collection Instrument 31

Data Gathering Procedure 31

Data Analysis 32

4 PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION 33

OF DATA

5 SUMMARY, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATION 66

BIBLIOGRAPHY 69

APPENDICES

A Letter of Permission to the Campus Executive Director 75

B Letter of Permission to the Dean of College of Arts and 76

Education

C Letter of Permission to the Chair of English Language 77

Department

D Letter to the Participants 78

E Interview Guide Questions 79

CURRICULUM VITAE 82

viii

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

LIST OF FIGURES

Page

Figure

Figure 1. Research Paradigm 29

ix

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Chapter 1

THE PROBLEM

Background of the study

A foreign language is a language that is not extensively spoken within a

specific group, civilization, or country. Teaching and studying a foreign language

are both challenging endeavors. Learning a foreign language is difficult in many

ways, including the current state of education, which influences a student's

academic achievement, unfamiliar pronunciations, grammar rules, vocabulary

words, and the significant deviation of some native languages' writing systems

from the Roman alphabet. In addition, students have their learning strategies to

help them learn and understand the lesson.

Many of today's international students are eager to learn and

communicate in one or more foreign languages for the sake of scientific, cultural,

political, and economic exchange. As much as it can be challenging or difficult for

students in many places to physically interact with native language speakers.

Foreign language has set a precedent for it to be included in the new

curriculum of other college courses in the Philippines. The high-level demand for

foreign language talent has risen dramatically because of globalization.

Workplaces are becoming more worldwide, and as a result, cultures and

languages are becoming more diverse (Lonsmann & Kraft, 2018). As the

principal language education, higher education institutions are committed to

assisting with this. In the Philippines, CHED Memorandum Order No. 23,

Series 2010

1
Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)
lOMoARcPSD|31637338

established the teaching of foreign languages in curricular programs of higher

education. This is in the hopes of developing globally competitive and locally

employable graduates.

As stated in the Oxford taxonomy of foreign language learning strategies

(1990), the role of individual differences in second language learning, such as

motivation, aptitude, and learning strategies, as well as how negotiation for

meaning and all forms of education contribute to language learning (Schimdt,

2001). In addition, Wong (2015) stated that learning issues can be resolved by

understanding students' learning styles. Achievement in terms of learning skills

may follow when the foreign language classroom becomes a place where

students' needs are identified and satisfied. Students' academic achievements

are highlighted when teachers and students work together to achieve the desired

learning outcomes.

As per positive psychology in Wang et al. (2022), students who are in a

positive emotional state are better able to acquire foreign languages and resist

the impacts of negative emotions. Online learning modality were incorporated to

avoid disrupting the educational system, including foreign language learning,

however, the disadvantages of this new learning have an impact on student-

teacher interactions. This research looked at the issues students have learned a

foreign language, as well as the techniques that assisted them to deal with the

challenges that the pandemic has brought to their new learning modality. The

focused, of this research, is to address the problems of studying Japanese,

Korean, and Mandarin in an online setting, based on Everson's (2011, as cited in

Quintos, 2021) argument

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

that languages like Japanese and Chinese take at least four times longer to learn

and master compared to European languages. Hence, this study was conducted.

There is a growing population of students in AB English Language course

because of the inclusion of foreign languages to its curriculum as students wanted

to learn foreign languages. Moreover, the reason why the researchers perceived

this study to be significant. This study focused on foreign languages to benefit the

instructor and students. This study aimed to examine online foreign language

learning experiences, particularly the difficulties faced by ABEL students at the

Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta City (PSU-UC) campus. The present study

will also investigate how the students perceive the challenges and approach

learning a foreign language.

Statement of the Problem

This study aimed to determine the foreign language learning of ABEL

students in distance learning. Specifically, this study sought to answer the

following questions:

1. What are the challenges students experienced in studying the foreign language?

2. What are the perceived effects of the challenges of foreign language learning

on students?

3. What are the learning strategies of students in studying foreign languages?

Significance of the Study

The result of this study would benefit the following:

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Foreign language teachers. This study brings a clear understanding of

the challenges of students in learning foreign languages and their perceived

effects. It will also help the teachers in understanding the learning strategies of

the students. Students. This study aided students to discover the challenges of

foreign language learning and its perceived effects. It will also help the

students to

discover learning strategies for studying foreign languages.

Future researchers. This study provided pertinent data on the challenges

and their perceived effects on the students and the learning strategies students.

Hence, this can be a credible related study for future researchers.

Scope and Delimitation of the Study

This study focused on the challenges, the perceived effects of the

challenges, and the learning strategies of students in foreign language learning,

specifically in the Japanese, Chinese, and Korean languages. This study focused

on languages that have different writing systems from the Roman alphabet,

which will include Japanese, Korean, and Chinese characters. The respondents

of this study are ABEL students at PSU-UC campus who have taken subjects in

foreign languages like Japanese, Korean, and are taking Chinese subject.

The researchers focused on the data collected using qualitative methods,

and the instrument used was interview. The study is limited to distance learning

since it is the only modality that ABEL students use for learning foreign

languages due to COVID-19 pandemic.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Definition of Terms

The following terms are defined lexically and operationally for further

understanding.

Foreign language. It is a language that is neither one’s native language

nor used for communicative purposes among the members of the community

(Yildiz, 2021). In this study, it also works as the language that is not native in the

Philippines.

Learning strategy. It is the specific actions taken by the learner to make

learning easier, faster, more enjoyable, more self-directed, more effective, and

more transferable to new situations (Oxford, 1990). In this study, it works as the

students’ way of learning and further understanding their lessons.

Learning Environment. It refers to the “whole range of components and

activities within which learning happens” (Basque and Dore, 1998). In this study,

it works as the location where students study before, during, and after their online

class.

Language Acquisition. It refers to a process which starts 3 months

before birth (Elman et al. 1996; Karmiloff and Karmiloff-Smith 2001) and

gradually leads to the child's mastery of his/her native language/s, at around

adolescence. In this study, it works as the process of acquiring a language.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES

This chapter presents a comprehensive review of literature and studies

conducted which were related and relevant to the present study. The review of

related literature is carefully selected and analyzed to find the essential relevance

with the present study.

RELATED LITERATURE

Foreign language learning

Foreign language learning and teaching refers to the teaching or learning

of a nonnative language outside of the environment where it is commonly spoken

(Catalano and Moeller, 2015). Learning a foreign language, according to Connor

(2016), can improve cognitive skills, increase mental agility, and prevent brain

aging. Klimova (2018) cited Lee and Tzeng (2016) who propose that due to

neuronal plasticity, foreign language learning leads to effective structural and

functional connections in the brain. They claim that effective connection resulting

from foreign language learning improves language processing and executive

control by rearranging brain circuitries. Through collaborative and social

involvement, foreign language(s) learning can serve as an entry point for building

intercultural understanding and global citizenship (Kennedy, 2020, Porto &

Zembylas, 2020a; Byram, Golubeva, Hui, & Wagner, 2017).

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

A. Japanese as a Foreign Language

Fujiwara (2012) stated that Chinese and Japanese are two of the most

popular foreign languages after English. Gonzales (1998) stated that the

Japanese language is one of the foreign languages that Filipinos have learnt and

can speak. Rose (2019) stated that Kana, the Japanese syllabary, is written

using a further two scripts, hiragana, and katakana. Due to this complex

representation of language at its different linguistic levels, the Japanese writing

system is often considered the exception in world writing systems research.

B. Korean as a Foreign Language

Ancho (2019) asserts that the Korean language is offered in some

institutions since it has a favorable demand and interest from students. This

could also be attributed to the attractiveness of Korean popular culture in the

Philippines along with the presence of Korean nationals who live in the country

for short-term or long-term stays.

C. Chinese as a Foreign Language

Everson (1998) learning to read Chinese as a Foreign Language is

extremely difficult for children whose first language (L1) uses an alphabetic

writing system due to the non-alphabetic character of its spelling. Because

Chinese characters reflect the spoken language in a mostly irregular and

unsystematic way, it is critical to determine how much beginning Chinese

language learners depend

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

on their growing spoken language resources when recognizing Chinese word

meanings.

Challenges in studying Foreign Language

Learning a foreign language is much more complex, since; ″you must have

a comprehensive knowledge of the entry behavior of a person, and objectives

you wish to reach of possible methods″ (Brown, 2000). Everson (2011) claims

that it takes four times longer to learn and master languages such as Japanese

and Chinese than European languages.

Kuraesin (2020) concluded in his study that lack of interest, belief and

course difficulty, and family environment are the cause of the challenges in

learning Japanese language. On the other hand, grammar, aural reception,

words, oral production, pronunciation, and recall are the challenges that UK

learners experience in studying Chinese as foreign language in the study of Hu,

(2010). While in the study of Yang (2018), character recognition, homophones,

and lack of links of sound and logograph of characters. Wrongly written

characters because of confusion and miswriting components and stroke errors

are the challenges the students faced in studying Chinese as foreign language in

Deng and Hu (2022) study. Vocabulary is the most challenging in studying

foreign language as compared to pronunciation, grammar knowledge and/or

sentence construction in discourse (Kang & Chang, 2014) and it brings language

anxiety to the learners (Gregersen, 2005). Buted et al. (2014) discovered that

pronunciation of terms closer to their original sound received the lowest score

because there may be an

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

underlying explanation for this, such as environment, which makes it harder for

them to hear the professor's pronunciation after they are asked to repeat it.

Pappamihiel (2002) noted that the most difficult aspect of learning Korean

for Chinese-Korean learners is that they have less exposure to the language,

less practice time, and minimal interaction as cited by Kim (2022). Ancho (2019)

cited Kondo & Ling (2004) in her study about learning Korean that language

anxiety can pose a problem in studying foreign language as the learner’s attitude

and viewpoint are significant in the learning process of the learner.

According to Muhammad Salim Hossain and Muhammad Kamal Uddin

(2008) entitled, A Cognitive Psychological Explanation of Difficulties in Learning

Japanese Language Strokes can be considered as features that distinguish one

letter from another. Hence it can be said that the alphabet which is comprised of

more strokes has more distinctive features. And the alphabet which is comprised

of more distinctive features will be easier to learn. But the alphabet which is

comprised of fewer strokes has less distinctive features. Hence, the alphabet

comprised of fewer distinctive features will be more difficult to learn than the

alphabet comprising more distinctive features.

Fatmawati Djafri and Supra Wimbarti (2018) in their study ‘Measuring

foreign language anxiety among learners of different foreign languages: in

relation to motivation and perception of teacher’s behaviors’. They found out that

different writing system of Japanese, including the using of three different kinds of

alphabets at the same time, and the gradual increasing of difficulty as the

learners move to intermediate and advanced level, are some factors contribute to

it. There is also a

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

difference in foreign language anxiety levels between Latin languages (English

and French) and non-Latin languages (Japanese, Korean, and Arabic), in which

the non-Latin one has a greater anxiety level. While in the study of Yang (2018),

character recognition, homophones, and lack of links of sound and logograph of

characters.

A study conducted by Bright Nkrumah (2021) entitled, “Demotivating

factors in learning second language: The case of Chinese language learners in

Ghana’ also discovered that the learning environment was the most demotivating

factor that discourages students from learning, which cannot be overlooked

among Ghanaian students studying Chinses as a second foreign language at the

University of Ghana.

Ahn, Misook and Prescott Valley (2017) study entitled, ‘Arizona Student

Perception of Language Achievement and Learner Autonomy in a Blended

Korean Language Course: The Case Study of Defense Language Institute

Foreign Language Center’ includes that isolated feelings, expectations of less

class work, and lack of time management skills and responsibility for personal

learning due to the reduced social interaction in a face-to-face classroom are the

challenges student face in blended learning environment. Another challenge is

difficulty with technologies such as poor Internet connections and lack of support

for course design from universities.

Mahyoob (2020) said the sudden change of classroom settings, the lack of

direct interaction between teachers and learners, the weak emotional bond, and

the unstable internet access are all potential variables that can affect foreign

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

language learners’ level of anxiety. Demo and Parker (1987, cited in Kalanzadeh,

Mahnegar, and Hassannejad, 2013) contend that self-esteem and language

learning are complementary and interdependent in language instruction. It

implies that efficient language learning might come from having a high sense of

oneself. According to Bryman (2016) clarified that the demotivated learner is

once motivated but has lost motivation for a reason. As concluded by Egbert

(2020): engagement in language tasks can continue to support learners'

achievement. A foreign language class requires a carefully planned and

systematically organized curriculum to effectively and successfully achieve

course intended learning outcomes.

A study conducted by Chua H. W, Tan T. G, Lin Chia Ying (2015) stated

that learning Chinese characters are difficult since it takes a lot of time and effort

to retain and memorize the strokes and components that each character is made

up of. Although they share the same radical, various phonetics components do

not show resemblance in meaning range.

A study conducted by Chua H. W, Tan T. G, Lin Chia Ying (2015) stated

that some characters contain a phonetic radical component that provides hints as

to how to speak to them; nevertheless, since the Chinese language has

developed, characters are no longer pronounced in accordance with their

phonetic radical components. As a result, remembering how to pronounce

characters becomes more difficult as a result of this issue.

Study conducted by Sharon M. DiFino and Linda J. Lombardino (2004)

stated that memorization is an integral component of learning at all levels, but it

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

plays a particularly large role in the acquisition and mastery of an L2. From the

first to the last lesson in the L2 class, students are required to employ their

memory in almost every area of language learning. Poor remembering abilities

have catastrophic effects because they nearly invariably translate into

unsatisfactory performance in L2 classes.

A. Effects of the challenges in foreign language learning

Speaking a foreign language might cause specific anxiety, which is a

worry that is limited to the situation. The term "generic anxiety" refers to those

who experience general anxiety in a range of settings (Horwitz, Horwitz, & Cope,

1986). The expression "subjective sense of tension, uncertainty, apprehension,

and worry paired with an arousal of the autonomic nervous system" is used to

define anxiety, according to Spielberger (1983) quoted by Andrea (2022). Li

(2021) claimed that when students are anxious about the process of learning and

teaching in the foreign language classroom, it is frequently difficult for them to

acquire knowledge. Learners of second or foreign languages typically do not

focus much on their feelings while they are learning a new language. Also, the

cognitivism tradition is relevant to this circumstance. The learner's capacity to

absorb and learn a second or foreign language will be diminished as well as the

amount of information being ingested into the brain when the filter is activated.

This means that learners prefer to reject and have a negative attitude toward

language absorption when they experience anxiety emotion, which might

promote the switch of the filter. This will further impair learners' learning ability

and efficiency.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Jee (2012) stated that Korean is a challenging language, and studying it

takes much longer than learning other European languages. In order to lower the

anxiety level of students studying Korean as Foreign Language (KFL), educators

need to improve their teaching strategies by making a greater effort to create

sympathetic and supportive learning environments. On the other hand, Zhao et

al. (2013) evaluate the effects of factors like gender, course level, experience in

the nation, and reading performance as well as the levels of anxiety associated

with reading in Korean for non-native speaking Korean learners.

According to Saito et al. (1999) and Zhao et al. (2013), native English

speakers of all three languages—Japanese, Chinese, and Korean—experienced

a large degree of stress due to the foreign writing system, symbols, and

vocabulary. Japanese language learners have the highest level of foreign

language anxiety compared to other language learners, according to Wimbarti et

al. (2018).

According to Wimbarti (2018), learners of Japanese exhibit the highest

levels of anxiety when learning a foreign language. Hiragana, Katakana, and

basic Kanji are the three Japanese characters that learners must learn,

discouraged remarks and harsh language correction techniques, dominating the

classroom, and rigid teaching strategies that make it difficult to understand the

materials. Shen (2022) therefore writes that for Japanese language teaching to

be effective, students must be attentive and have a favorable attitude toward

using the corpora. Shi (2015) added that learning motivations were the inner

aspect that caused personal learning objectives and caused the learning

performance of students to

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

be constant efforts, fortifying the cognitive process, strengthening and increasing

the learning effect of students.

According to Yu and Geng (2020), the high dropout rate of students

learning Chinese as a Foreign Language (CFL) is a source of worry for

educators. While Gao (2020) stated that new challenges emerging for learning

Chinese characters in online education were principally caused by technological,

physical, and temporal constraints, as well as their effects on students' mental

health and wellness. Because all students were time-constrained, time

restrictions for handwriting constituted a substantial barrier for students to

acquire characters.

According to S. Kim (2015) found in her study that it can be postulated that

demotivation occurs when learners do not have a clear ideal L2 self and cannot

relate it to their current L2 learning. The core idea of the L2 Motivational Self

System is that learners’ drive to reduce the perceived discrepancy between their

current self and their hoped-for self provides the necessary motivation for

language learning. As motivation is a dynamic process (Dörnyei & Ushioda,

2011), demotivation is also a negative dynamic process that can “pull learners

down” (Kikuchi, 2015, p. 4). According to Kikuchi (2015), numerous demotivators

exist and can reduce learner engagement in the learning process. More

specifically, demotivators can range from internal factors (e.g., lack of self-

confidence) to external ones (e.g., teachers, teaching methods). S. Kim (2015),

(Dörnyei & Ushioda, 2011), Kikuchi (2015), said that demotivation arises through

internal and external factors. Those studies are related in the present study since

students are also demotivated in learning foreign languages. Furthermore, a

multitude of things,

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

such as losing interest in the main task, being unable to pay attention for a

variety of reasons, or the intensity of the distractor, might be the source of

distractions. Confusion makes it more difficult to complete any task correctly.

Others might have trouble concentrating, recalling, or making choices. According

to N. Hasan (2020) students found online learning to be particularly distracting

due to factors like noise, bad management, commercials, etc. Online teaching is

a relatively new phenomenon compared to traditional classroom teaching. Calls

between classes were a major source of distraction for 98% of students who

used their mobile phones for online learning. Lack of assistance, comfort, and

familiarity with technical tools may cause many learners to find learning to be

time-consuming, unpleasant, and unworthy. Research on online teaching has

produced inconsistent results, and online learning has not received the same

level of scrutiny as traditional classroom instruction (Ryan et al., 1999; Kenny,

2002; Atack and Rankin, 2002; Kozlowski, 2002).

According to Vroman (2015) learning a foreign language depends on the

individual's prior state, the nature and regularity of the resultant systems, the

susceptibility to motivational cues, and the degree of accomplishment. Individual

language learners do not use the intrinsic mechanism that controls learning in

children, which is an obvious reason. This would clearly explain why learning a

new language is often a difficult and ultimately unproductive endeavor.The

qualities of learners, along with their background of experience and cognitive

ability, are some of the most crucial aspects that define foreign language

acquisition (FLA) in adulthood. According to Singleton and Ryan (2004), learners

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

struggle to retain new material, and a reduction in hearing sensitivity impairs the

ability to recognize speech sounds, making it difficult to memorize words and

understand teacher instructions. However, Bosc (2007) asserts that grownups

are less bothered by it. According to Borg et al. (2016), this is caused by several

things, including work schedules, family obligations, the cost of attending school,

or having trouble finding a course that suits their interests. Ahl (2006) divides the

barriers to motivation for learning into three categories: structural, situational, and

dispositional. Personal characteristics like low self-esteem or "poor early school

experiences that produce negative expectations of continued education" are

associated to dispositional variables (Mikeladze 2014, p. 21). Situational

variables, such as a lack of time or money, are intimately related to the learner's

actual life circumstances. Barriers at the structural level include the absence of

childcare arrangements, issues with work schedules, and inappropriate teaching

pedagogies. According to Zammit (2014) and Knowles et al. (2005), lacking

financial or emotional support is also one of the primary causes for adults to

become very demotivated and decide to drop out of courses. In addition to these

factors, Wlodkowski (2008) lists a number of health challenges that come with

aging and make it more challenging for older people to comprehend information.

Strategies in Foreign Language Learning

Language learning strategies are defined by Oxford as "specific actions

taken by the learner to make learning easier, faster, more enjoyable, more self-

directed, more effective, and more transferable to new situations." Language

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

learning strategies can thus be thought of as steps or techniques that students

use to enhance their progress in comprehending, internalizing, and using the

second/foreign language. As per Oxford and Nyikos (1989), good language

learners use a variety of learning strategies, including cognitive, metacognitive,

memory-related, social, affective, and compensation strategies. Cognitive

strategies work by comprehending and producing new language through various

techniques such as practicing, receiving, and sending signals, analyzing and

reasoning, and establishing structure for input and output, according to Oxford

(1990). Metacognitive strategy refers to behaviors that go beyond cognitive

instruments. It includes centering your learning, arranging and planning your

learning, and evaluating your learning. Social strategies include asking

questions, interacting with people, and empathizing with them. Memory-related

strategies, often known as mnemonics, are methods of storing, recalling, and

retrieving information. Emotions, values, attitudes, and motivation are

characteristics of affective strategies. Compensation strategies enable learners

to utilize a language for compensation or output despite knowledge limitations.

As per Allado et al. (2016), they concluded that metacognitive, cognitive,

and compensatory strategies are used in studying Korean as a foreign language.

The main tools used were books and instructional videos. The least helpful tool

are the books because there are misspelled words. Allado et. al. (2016)

concluded that instructional films or videos were more effective than books for

foreign language acquisition in studying Korean language because its already

complete as it teaches sound, spelling, and English translation. While in Yan

(2020) study,

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

orthographic strategies, semantic strategies, memory strategies, phonological

strategies, and metacognitive strategies are the learning strategies that English

speaking learners employ in studying Chinese. While Ho (2018) reported that

learners studying Mandarin were engaged in online language learning, the tools

they used, as well as the learning behaviors they demonstrated, imply a continual

traversal between online and offline learning settings, such as physically writing

notes and letters. In line with Ancho's (2019) research, writing and repeating

words is useful in increasing vocabulary. She also states in her study that a

healthy and supportive classroom environment might aid in learning. Student

engagement, such as games and activities, as well as watching videos or films, is

an effective technique for learning a foreign language. Subsequently, Damayanti

et. al (2018) found out that the implementation of contextual teaching and

learning strategies should consider learning motivation. Gonzales (1998)

discovered that social strategies are used more frequently than other strategies,

indicating that a cooperative learning environment is extremely productive and

beneficial to language learners. The learning environment is extremely effective

and beneficial to language learners of Japanese as foreign language. Takeuchi

(2003) stated that metacognitive strategies linked to increasing input and, most

importantly, chances to use a foreign language; skill-specific strategies connected

to conscious learning; memory strategies related to internalizing the linguistic

system; and cognitive strategies for practicing, such as imitation, shadowing, and

pattern-practicing, are preferred learning strategies in Japanese as a foreign

language.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

RELATED STUDIES

Foreign Studies

The following studies reviewed by the researchers are valuable in the

conceptualization of this study. They served as guides in mapping the direction of

the present research.

Ahn (2017) embarked on a study entitled “Student Perception of

Language Achievement and Learner Autonomy in a Blended Korean Language

Course: The Case of Study of Defense Language Institute Foreign Language

Center”. The purpose of her study is to discover the perceptions of ten American

students studying Korean Language at the Osan Language Training Detachment,

Defense Language Institute Foreign Language Center (DLIFLC) in Korea

regarding the effectiveness of the blended Korean language curriculum on

student autonomous learning and language achievement, especially in listening

and reading comprehension skills.

The findings of her study found that a blended Korean language course

was effective for language learning and achievement, but only 50% of

participants stated it was effective for the improvement of autonomous learning

skills. The other responses said those skills were dependent on various elements

of the blended course such as activities, curriculum, teacher, and student’s

motivation and learning styles.

Another study by Hsiao (2013) entitled Anxiety and Achievement Goals:

Their Relationships in the Context of Chinese Language Learning investigates

the

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

connection of anxiety and cognition interaction in the processes of learning

Chinese as foreign language. She employed a quantitative method based on

existing theories regarding anxiety (Eysenk, 1992, 1997; Hozwitz, 2010) and

accomplishment goals related to cognitive processes and actions (Dweck, 2000).

The data was analyzed using a mixed-design ANOVA, residual effects, and

contrast analysis. The study's findings revealed that all three of the researcher's

hypotheses were found to be supported by empirical evidence. First, anxiety

levels varied depending on whatever language task was being performed:

listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Second, pupils who had a performance

aim felt more anxious than those who had a learning goal. Third, students'

anxiety levels were controlled during the completion of various tasks based on

their achievement goals as a function of their study length. Reading, writing,

listening, and speaking caused the most anxiety among students. In students

who had studied Chinese for less than a year, this effect was stronger for

students with a performance aim than for students with a learning goal. The

pattern of worry was inverted among students who had studied Chinese for more

than a year.

Another study was conducted by Mehring (2014) entitled “An Exploratory

Study of Japanese Undergraduate EFL Students' Lived Experiences in the

Flipped Classroom”. The purpose of her study is to examine the experiences of

Japanese university students studying English as a Foreign language (EFL)

students who have participated in a course taught using the flipped classroom

technique will aid in determining possible benefits of the flipped classroom in EFL

higher education in Japan, according to the study. This study took a

qualitative approach and

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

employed a case study design to examine the lived experiences of Japanese

EFL university students at Iwate University who are enrolled in a flipped

classroom course. This research looked at students' impressions, probable

changes in study habits, perceived rewards and challenges, and whether the

flipped classroom provided more possibilities for honest dialogue. This study

contributed to the understanding of learning technologies used to support the

implementation of a communicative, student-centered learning environment in

the undergraduate EFL classroom by examining the lived experiences of

students who have taken part in a course taught using the flipped classroom

technique.

According to Mehring's findings, Japanese higher education has decided

to move away from the traditional teacher-centered classroom and toward a

more student-centered, communicative environment. The flipped classroom

technique may be one potential option for assisting with the shift.

Local Studies

The study of Quintos' (2021) entitled "Difficulties in Learning Japanese as

a Foreign Language: The Case of Filipino Learners," was based on a sample of

481 randomly selected Filipino college students from 18 Nihongo programs

offered at a state institution. Quintos used a modified questionnaire from the

study of Yanagi and Baker (2016). The mean, frequency, and percentage

distribution were used to statistically examine the data.

According to the findings, students' memory and understanding of the

issues they are listening to is limited due to a lack of Nihongo vocabulary and

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

cultural context of the contents delivered. Furthermore, poor listening

comprehension makes it difficult for students to respond and express themselves

in class by speaking the language. The substantial divergence of Japanese from

their natural linguistic impact causes pronunciation problems with non-Nihongo

syllables, stress, and intonation. As a result, it has an impact on their reading and

writing abilities; unfamiliar foreign characters limit their text knowledge and

linguistic competency.

According to Gonzales' (2010) study entitled "Motivational Orientation in

Foreign Language Learning: The Case of Filipino Foreign Language Learners,"

examines what motivates foreign language (FL) students. The study's secondary

goal is to compare the motivation of Filipino FL learners using the Foreign

Language Learning Motivation Questionnaire, and to see if age, sex, the FL

being studied, and the length of time spent studying FL can influence FL learning

motivation among Filipino students. He believed that the characteristics

examined in this study could distinguish FL learners' motivation. The participants

in this study were 150 students from three Metro Manila universities who had

chosen to study foreign languages. There are 80 females (53.3%) and 70 males

among the participants (46.7 percent). The data was cross-sectional, with 26

students learning Chinese (17.3%), 40 students learning French (26.7%), 50

students learning Japanese (33.3%), and 34 students learning Spanish (22.7

percent).

The findings suggest that the motivational orientation of younger learners

is toward cultural comprehension, cultural integration, and self-satisfaction. In

terms of communication, affiliation, and self-efficacy, females are more

motivated than

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

males. Japanese language learners are more motivated by career and economic

advancement, while French language learners are motivated by association with

foreigners and Spanish language learners are motivated by self-efficacy.

Alcazaren et al., (2016) conducted a study on learner-related factors

affecting foreign language learners and their language learning styles. The paper

aims to identify the most and least frequently used language learning strategies

by multilingual students in a Philippine secondary school, as well as the

correlation this has on their language proficiency scores, using Rebecca Oxford's

study on language learning styles and strategies (2003) as a framework.

According to the findings, metacognitive is the most frequently employed

strategic category, followed by cognitive, social, compensatory, memory, and

emotive, according to the results of the rank order of frequency. It was also

discovered that language learning methodologies and language competency had

a statistically significant association. As a result, it may be reasonable to

conclude that learners who use a wider range of language learning strategies

have greater language competency.

SYNTHESIS OF THE RELATED STUDIES AND THE PRESENT STUDY

The past research had been a direct influence on the current investigation.

These parallels and differences between earlier studies and the current study are

extremely useful and informative for academics conducting this research. The

similarities and differences between this study and other studies are listed below.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Ahn (2017) and Mehring (2014)'s findings on the effectiveness of mixed

learning and embracing the flipped classroom in the context of language

acquisition have direct relevance to the current study. They differ in research

design and participant selection methods in order to determine the effectiveness

of the new learning system.

Ahn (2017) investigated the benefits of integrating traditional face-to-face

learning with an online tool such as a learning management system (LMS), which

has grown in popularity and use for both teachers and students in foreign and

second language education. The current research is descriptive. The current

study is similar to Mehring (2014) in that it includes the experiences of Japanese

university English as a Foreign Language (EFL) students who have taken a

course taught using the flipped classroom technique, and it will aid in determining

the potential benefits of the flipped classroom in EFL higher education in Japan.

Furthermore, to determine the effectiveness of flipped classrooms, Mehring

(2014) used both qualitative and descriptive study approaches. Similarly,

qualitative and descriptive methodologies were applied in this investigation. In

terms of respondents, however, the current study differs from Mehring (2014).

Hsiao (2013) conducted a study that was identical to this one because it

focused on linguistic anxiety and the relationships between it and other factors. In

the context of studying Mandarin Chinese as a foreign language, the studies

discovered that linguistic anxiety influences students' language anxieties and

achievement goals.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

The findings of Quintos (2021) and Gonzales (2010) on the difficulty of

learning Japanese as a foreign language and the orientation to motivate students

in learning foreign languages both applied to all Filipino learners studying a

foreign language. In order to establish the major obstacle that students have

while learning a foreign language and what motivation may affect them to learn a

foreign language, they differ in research design and participant selection

methods. Although the two studies have different research focuses, they are both

strongly related to the current study.

Quintos (2021) investigated the challenges that students face when

studying Japanese as a second language. In the case of Filipino students, it is

necessary to rationalize Nihongo teaching and learning among them. While this

information is useful for improving instructional materials for learning Nihongo, it

also emphasizes the necessity for the institution to consult with Nihongo

specialists on the best ways to teach and learn it, such as by utilizing the most

up-to-date technology and innovations. Quintos' study is quantitative while the

current study is qualitative in nature.

Gonzales' (2010) research is attempting to establish the extent to which

motivation divides foreign language (FL) learners. Some instructional and

pedagogical practices for teaching foreign languages are suggested in the study.

The current study, however, differs from Gonzales in terms of respondents and

topic. The current research is similar in that it includes motivation as a strategy to

encourage students to learn a foreign language.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

The study by Alcazaren et al., (2016) is relevant to the present study

because it focuses on foreign language learners and their language learning

styles. The study investigated the least commonly used language learning

strategies among multilingual students in a Philippine secondary school, as well

as the impact this has on their English language proficiency scores. The present

study investigated the language learner strategies that they regularly used.

Furthermore, the present study is like Alcazaren et al., (2016), which took a

descriptive approach. In terms of respondents, however, the current study differs

from Alcazaren (2016).

Theoretical Framework

This study was prompted by five (5) hypotheses of Krashen's theory of

second language acquisition (1988).

Acquisition-Learning hypothesis. The most fundamental of Krashen's five

theories, and the one that linguists and language teachers are most familiar with.

There are two distinct systems of foreign language performance, according to

Krashen: "the acquired system" and "the learnt system." The 'acquired system,'

sometimes known as 'acquisition,' is the result of a subconscious process

comparable to how children learn their first language. The "learned system,"

often known as "learning," is the result of formal education and consists of a

conscious process that culminates in conscious information 'about' the language,

such as grammar rules.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Monitor hypothesis. According to Krashen, the acquisition system initiates

the speech, whereas the learning system functions as the "monitor" or "editor,"

preparing, editing, and correcting the utterance when three precise

circumstances are met. First, the learner of a second language has enough time

on their hands. Second, they concentrate on form or consider correctness. They

finally understand the rules.

Input hypothesis. The Input hypothesis exclusively considers 'acquisition'

rather than 'learning.' According to this theory, when a student gets a second

language 'input' that is one step beyond his or her existing level of linguistic

ability, the learner improves and develops along the 'natural order.'

Affective Filter. According to Krashen, a variety of 'affective variables'

facilitate but do not cause second language acquisition. Motivation, self-

confidence, anxiousness, and personality traits are among the variables.

Natural Order. Research findings (Dulay & Burt, 1974; Fathman, 1975;

Makino, 1980 cited in Krashen, 1987) suggest grammatical structure acquisition

follows a predictable 'natural order'. Some grammatical structures are learned

early in a language, whereas others are learned later. Although individual

acquirers' agreement was not always 100 percent in the tests, statistically

significant parallels were found that supported the existence of a natural order of

language acquisition.

According to Krashen, studying the structure of a language can provide

general educational benefits and values that high schools and universities might

want to incorporate into their language programs. Any gain, however, will be

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

contingent on the learner's prior knowledge of the language. It should also be

clear that analyzing the language, formulating rules, separating irregularities, and

teaching complex facts about the target language are not language teaching, but

rather "language appreciation" or linguistics, which does not lead to

communicative proficiency. The only time that teaching grammar can lead to

language acquisition (and proficiency) is when the students are interested in the

subject and the target language is used as a medium of communication.

In this study, language acquisition is prominent since learning a new or

foreign language is interrelated to language learning. This study focuses on

assessing the various challenges that students have in learning foreign

languages, as well as determining which strategies are most beneficial for both

students and teachers when it comes to foreign languages.

Conceptual Framework

Figure 1 presents the conceptual model of the study foreign language

learning of ABEL students.

The paradigm illustrates the respondents' unique but interconnected

challenges, perceived effects of challenges, and strategies applied in foreign

language learning, which serve as the investigation's emphases. These three are

parts of the respondents' learning process.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Challenges students Perceived effects of the


experienced in studying challenges of foreign
the foreign language language learning on
students

Strategies for
studying foreign
language

Figure 1. Research Paradigm

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Chapter 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This chapter presents and discusses the methods of research and tools

used in this study. Specifically, this chapter presents the research approach,

respondents, sampling technique, data collection instrument, data gathering

procedure, and analysis of data.

Research Design

The present study is qualitative in nature. The qualitative research

methods strive to gather more information and acquire a thorough picture of the

issues, situations, or events (Arora and Stoner, 2009), and the researchers

performed an interview using thematic analysis. Thematic analysis is a sort of

qualitative, comprehensive, and detailed data analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006). In

conducting data analysis, the researchers took the role of the analyst and make

decisions based on coded, themed, decontextualized, and recontextualized data

(Starks & Trinidad, 2007). This study was concerned with the challenges,

perceived effects of the challenges, and strategies for learning foreign languages

of the respondents. To provide comprehensive and detailed data for this study,

thematic analysis was used in data analysis.

30

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

31

Respondents of the Study

The respondents of the study were 4th year AB English Language

students who have finished the Japanese and Korean language subjects and are

taking the Chinese language subject at Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta

City Campus for Academic Year 2022–2023. A total of five students participated

in this study. To determine the study's respondents, the researchers used a

simple random sampling technique using the fishbowl method.

Data Collection Instrument

The researchers collected data for this study by conducting virtual one-on-

one semi-structured interviews. The interview questions focused on the

challenges, perceived effects of the challenges, and strategies the respondents

encountered and used in learning foreign languages. The researchers asked

permission from the respondents to record the interview in compliance with

research etiquette. The researchers recorded the interview to ensure the

accuracy and reliability of the assessment.

Data- Gathering Procedure

Before collecting data, the researchers requested permission from

Pangasinan State University's Urdaneta Campus Executive Director, Dr. Honorio

L. Cascolan, the Dean of the College of Arts and Education, Dr. Elizabeth F.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Episcope, the Chair of the English Language Department, Mr. Marvin Q. Corpuz,

subject teachers, and the respondents.

The researchers obtained the official ABEL enrollment list from the

registrar's office for the academic years 2022–2023. In addition, the researchers

asked the respondent's permission to participate in a semi-structured interview

online. After getting their approval, the researchers conducted a virtual interview

on MS Teams. A follow-up interview was also conducted. In accordance with

research etiquette, the researchers asked a series of questions concerning the

challenges, perceived effects of the challenges, and strategies that respondents

faced and utilized in learning foreign languages. Afterwards, the data were

collected, tabulated, analyzed, and interpreted.

Data Analysis

The researchers gathered the data using a semi-structured interview and

transcribed the recorded interview and analyzed the data using thematic

analysis. The researchers chose the themes based on the codes created.

Psychology proposed the use of thematic analysis. Because the search

for an investigation of patterning across languages does not necessitate

adherence to any theory of language or explanatory meaning framework for

human beings, experiences, or behaviors, TA is considered theoretically flexible

(Guest et al., 2012). Using interview questions and thematic analysis, the

researchers examined the most relevant data needed for this study. The

researchers also used the themes gathered from the interview and interpreted

the data collected.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Chapter 4

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter presents a detailed presentation and discussion of data

analysis and the results of this study. The main source of data is the virtual

interview conducted with the randomly chosen 4th year ABEL students using the

fishbowl method. The findings are presented in response to the research

questions stated in the study. The method used to analyze the data is thematic

analysis, as discussed in the methodology.

CHALLENGES IN STUDYING THE FOREIGN LANGUAGE

Research question one (1) sought to answer the challenges respondents

experienced in studying foreign language, especially in Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese among 4th year ABEL respondents. Writing system, pronunciation,

memorization, learning environment, time constraints, and demotivation are the

identified themes..

1. Writing System

The most difficult aspect of studying a foreign language for 4th year AB

English Language respondents is the difficulty in writing the characters or writing

system of the foreign language, which includes Japanese, Korean, and Chinese.

33

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

34

The writing system, which is significantly dissimilar to the Roman alphabet, is

what respondents begin to learn.

The following responses give a glimpse of what challenges were

experienced by the respondents in the foreign language classes.

“Korean language yung writing talaga yung mahirap talaga sakin.”

“ung isa macurve ung isa matusok, mahirap pero compare sa iba,

mas

nadadalian ako sa Japanese.”

"I face difficulties in terms of writing characters, siguro nahirapan ako sa

writing pinapasulat pa satin 10 times.”

“Chinese ang pinakamahirap na writing characters kasi may mga box box

doon tas parang kelangan ano tama ung pinaglagyan mo don.”

“writing characters, parang nahihirapan ako kasi hindi maganda ung

penmanship ko parang damay.”

“iyong sa writing, iyong iba kasi parang magkakaparehas.”

The respondents' answers indicated that they find writing to be one of the

most challenging aspects of learning a foreign language since its characters are

very different from the Roman alphabet. Nevertheless, Korean and Chinese

received feedback that they were more challenging to write than Japanese. This

implies that respondents of AB English Language find the Japanese writing

system easier to learn than the Korean and Chinese languages.

A study conducted by Deng and Hu (2022) discovered that wrongly written

characters because of confusion and miswriting components and stroke errors

are the challenges that students faced in studying Chinese as a foreign

language.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Learning Chinese characters are difficult since it takes a lot of time and effort to

retain and memorize the strokes and components that each character is made up

of. Although they share the same radical, various phonetics components do not

show resemblance in meaning range as per Chua H. W, Tan T. G, Lin Chia Ying

(2015).

2. Pronunciation

The second most challenging part of learning a foreign language,

according to respondents, was pronunciation. There are instances when

respondents are not confident in speaking foreign languages like Korean,

Chinese, and Japanese since most of the respondents are not well equipped

with those languages and are afraid to make mistakes and be judged by others

for mispronouncing the words.

The following are the responses of the respondents, indicating that

pronunciation is one of the challenges they face in learning a foreign language.

“yung pronunciation mo iba yung meaning na, kapag nagkamali ka sa

pronunciation, iba yung mga difficulties nila.”

“nahirapan (Japanese mag pronounce), lalo na sa (Korean).”

"Korean is complicated due to its many rules, pronunciation, and writing.

Nahirapan sa Japanese mag pronounce, lalo na sa Korean."

“pronunciation of Mandarin because sometimes your classmates will say

para kang …, I got distracted sa pronounce.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“Mahirap siya sa pag pronounce pag sumasabay naman ako kay sir, ok

naman self-knowledge na it’s hard talaga repeating ung sound.”

“the pronunciation is different, meron mataas yung tone, meron yung

mababa, then meron naman yung combine and then the way you pronounce”.

“sa Mandarin naman the pronunciation kasi iba-iba.”

“Nakakalito lang po yung ipropronounce mo yung G as KA pronunciation

pinaka-nahirapan po ako sa mandarin kasi yung mga vowels ganun po.”

This means that they found pronunciation difficult because of the rules

needed to be considered and with just one wrong tone, they might change the

meaning of the word.

This implies that these three foreign languages—Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese—are all difficult in terms of pronunciation. Respondents are conscious

of their pronunciation because a mispronounced word can cause confusion and

change its meaning. Furthermore, respondents did not participate in class and

did not fully grasp the foreign language because they were afraid of being

judged.

A study conducted by Buted et al. (2014) discovered that pronunciation

of terms closer to their original sound received the lowest score because there

may be an underlying explanation for this, such as environment, which makes it

harder for them to hear the professor's pronunciation after they are asked to

repeat it. On the other hand, grammar, aural reception, words, oral production,

pronunciation, and recall are the challenges that UK learners experience in

studying Chinese as foreign language in the study of Hu (2010).

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

A study conducted by Chua H. W, Tan T. G, Lin Chia Ying (2015) stated

that some characters contain a phonetic radical component that provides hints

as to how to speak to them; nevertheless, since the Chinese language has

developed, characters are no longer pronounced in accordance with their

phonetic radical components. As a result, remembering how to pronounce

characters becomes more difficult because of this issue.

3. Memorization

According to respondents, memorizing is one of the challenges they face

in learning a foreign language. Remembering the writing system, rules, tones,

vocabulary, and sentence construction are all part of this challenge. The

respondents admitted that they could not recall the rules and were unfamiliar with

them.

The respondents' comments, which mention that memorization is one of

the difficulties people have when learning a foreign language, are provided

below.

“It is a challenge for me how am I going to master those new 14 or 20

characters.

“the mastery of the characters because they are so

many.” “mahina ako sa vocabulary.”

“sa characters parang magkakamukha po ang hirap I-memorize.”

“writings talaga, mahirap i-memorize.”

“writings nila, ang hirap nyang i-memorize.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“strictly memorizing the tones because you know because it differs it

highly differs in terms of tones.”

“minemorize pero parang super nag effort naman ako kahit papaano na,

alalahanin kung ano ba ung mga rules.”

“pag nagkamali ka sa paglagay ng rules parang yung writing mo

maapektuhan na.”

“Japanese constructing of sentence yun naman ung pinaka difficult

sakin.” "sa sentence construction- sobrang nahirapan, hindi ko

masyadong

memorize iyong rules nila.”

“sa Korean po parang yung lesson na’to para mabuo ko tong sentence

na’to, babalikan ko yung past na lesson kaya kailangan memorize mo po yung

rules.”

“sa Korean kasi parang andaming rules parang mas nahirapan ako.”

“siguro sa mga noun phrases, verbs. Hindi ko masyadong

maintindihan

iyon.”

“mahirap talaga iyong pagsabit ng particle sa Japanese at Korean

iyong mga noun phrase pati iyong writings.”

It can be gleaned from the respondents’ answers that most of them

struggle with the grammatical rules of different foreign languages. This finding

showed how memorization plays a big part in learning foreign languages and

how important it is to remember sentence construction, rules, and vocabulary,

which makes learning languages like Korean, Japanese, and Chinese more

difficult. This implies

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

that respondents can be more effective in acquiring a foreign language if they

remember and use the grammatical rules of that language.

In the study of Hu (2010), grammar, aural reception, words, oral

production, pronunciation, and recall are the challenges that UK learners

experience in studying Chinese as a foreign language. On the other hand,

vocabulary is the most challenging aspect of studying a foreign language

compared to pronunciation, grammar knowledge, and sentence construction in

discourse (Kang & Chang, 2014). It causes language anxiety in learners

(Gregersen, 2005).

A study conducted by Sharon M. DiFino and Linda J. Lombardino (2004)

stated that memorization is an integral component of learning at all levels, but it

plays a particularly large role in the acquisition and mastery of an L2. From the

first to the last lesson in the L2 class, students are required to employ their

memory in almost every area of language learning.

4. Learning Environment

The learning environment became one of the main challenges in the new

curriculum during the pandemic until now. Some respondents do not have their

own learning space in their houses. Their houses are prone to different

background noises, and during online learning, they may also experience poor

internet connection because of their location.

The replies of the respondents are listed below, saying that one of the

difficulties they have when learning a foreign language is the learning

environment.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“it is not just for the foreign language, sadly I do not have a personal

space where I can focus. That is also one factor, that I lost my interest, and I got

distracted like a domino effect”

“hindi ka makasabay dahil sa set up natin na online learning

“unexpected sounds like dogs, chicken, kapit bahay kasi we do not control

them tapos mga vehicles na mabibilis and mga bata na like it really interfere my

learning process and minsan mga deliver sa shopee, lazada.”

“lumalabas ako, naghahanap ng malakas na internet connection, walang

signal sa mismong bahay namin”,

“hindi ko talaga masyadong nacocope-up iyong lesson dahil na rin siguro

sa environment.”

It could be understood from the respondents' answers that most of them

struggled to connect and learn in an online class. The learning environment

significantly impacts respondents learning, especially in foreign languages.

Moreover, many kinds of noise in their study place make learning difficult. It

signifies that the respondents need a conducive learning environment to learn a

foreign language effectively.

A study conducted by Bright Nkrumah (2021) entitled, "Demotivating

factors in learning a second language: The case of Chinese language learners in

Ghana' also discovered that the learning environment was the most demotivating

factor that discourages respondents from learning, which cannot be overlooked

among Ghanaian students studying chinses as a second foreign language at the

University of Ghana.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

41

A study conducted by Buted et al. (2014) discovered that pronunciation of

terms closer to their original sound received the lowest score because there may

be an underlying explanation for this, such as environment, which makes it

harder for them to hear the professor's pronunciation after they are asked to

repeat it.

5. Time Constraints

Time constraints posed a challenge as well for the respondents. The

respondents revealed that the discussion is too fast, and the time allotted is

short. As a result, the respondents felt much pressure to cope with the demands

of the subject. The following sample responses disclosed the common perception

of the respondents concerning their foreign language classes.

The replies of the respondents are listed below, saying that one of the

difficulties they have when learning a foreign language is the learning

environment.

“masyadong mabilis iyong discussion.”

“nahihirapan talaga kasi pag binasa mo yung Korean ta-translate mo

pa sya in English para lang maintindihan mo.”

“experienced lack of time…na hindi narin ako nagkaroon ng time na

panuorin ang recorded videos and tangi ko nalang nagawa is basahin iyung

learning materials.”

“you will input a lot of information in your head so in your utak diba like the

information is kinda loaded that sometimes you are too overwhelmed to

comprehend everything, so hmm I think that the downside of two hours

“hindi tayo familiar sa writing mahirap kasi un nga sa deadline narin.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

42

“may mga times na sabay kasi binibigay eh gahol sya sa time ang

nagiging result is trash na ung gawa mo hindi na naayos ung writings.”

The respondents did not learn much in foreign language subjects due to

time constraints. Respondents must understand the foreign language's writing

system, pronunciation, and vocabulary in a short period of time, which causes

them to feel pressured and stressed when learning the language. This implies

that time is an important factor that foreign language instructors should take into

consideration while trying to cover lessons that are deemed important for the

course. The researcher claims that there are no studies that give data about the

challenge of time constraints, and this is the contribution of the study.

6. Demotivation

The final theme of the difficulties encountered in foreign language learning

is demotivation. Most respondents are disinterested in learning a foreign

language because it is not their preferred language. Aside from the fact that it is

not their first language, other factors contribute to the respondents' disinterest in

learning a foreign language. Such as consecutive writing activities, quizzes, and

assignments; low self-esteem because they are afraid of being judged; and

different distractions in their learning space.

Below are the responses of the respondents, which indicate that

demotivation contributes to difficulties in learning foreign languages.

“compare to other foreign language kasi hindi na ako nagkaroon ng

interest hindi ko na inaral, hindi ko na pinalawak”.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

"I lost my interest to learn a language, I found that the other foreign

languages are harder to learn."

“I do not show any interest sa Korean talaga.”

"we are in the middle of a pandemic like I lost my interest."

“my self-confidence affects my learning because sometimes I got afraid of

na baka hindi tama iyong sasabihin ko or hindi tama iyong alam ko."

“may time lang na magkakasama kami ng mga kapatid ko tapos online

class doon talaga nagkakaanuhan mga background noise.”

“may mga times na sabay kasi binibigay eh, eh like ung quiz and ung

writings tapos ganun pa kadami like last time ung pinasulat ni sir.”

Less exposure to the language is also a demotivating factor for

respondents just like this respondent said that:

“mas nahirapan ako sa vocabulary ng Korean kasi I am less exposed.”

It can be inferred that the respondent's answers show little interest in

learning foreign languages like Japanese, Korean, and Chinese. This finding

indicates that respondents are disinterested in learning a foreign language

because of the pandemic that forced the class to be held online, many

respondents feel incomplete and, as a result, have lost interest in learning. It

implies that there is a need to learn a foreign language face-to-face or in a

classroom setting for more exposure to the foreign language that will help them

learn more. A lack of interest exists in foreign language classes during

synchronous online classes. The respondent admitted that they lost their interest

in learning a foreign language during online learning. Respondents reveal that

they have lost interest in the

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

foreign language since it is not to their liking and they only learn it for their

activities, but after that, they do not learn anything.

Kalanzadeh et al. (2013) recommend that teachers of foreign languages

consider their students' academic self-esteem as a potent motivator that can

maximize learning the language, particularly if it is a second language. They went

on to say that one major objective of language teaching should be to boost

students' self-esteem because it plays a crucial role in their ability to learn a

language. Moreover, distraction can also be demotivating, or a challenge for a

respondent since distraction is taking away one's focus, and background noise

and multitasking are examples. According to Gurung (2005) students who study

with music on, TV on, with friends around, or while responding to e-mail all

perform significantly worse on course exams. Too many activities can also be

demotivating for respondents since sometimes it is more on completion than

learning, which can be challenging for them. Kuraesin (2020) concluded in his

study that lack of interest, belief and course difficulty and family environment is

the cause of the challenges in learning the Japanese language.

PERCEIVED EFFECTS OF CHALLENGES OF FOREIGN


LANGUAGE LEARNING

Research question 2 investigated the perceived effects of the challenges

among 4th year ABEL respondents in synchronous online classes in studying the

foreign language, especially Japanese, Korean, and Chinese. The identified

recurring ideas are emotionally draining, mentally taxing, distracting and

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

confusing, demotivating, and motivating. This is arranged according to the most

up to the least answer of the respondents.

1. Emotionally Draining

The emotional impacts of studying foreign languages in synchronous

online class lessons are the main effects of problems among 4th year ABEL

respondents. When respondents' academic performance has an emotional

impact, this topic is present. They begin overanalyzing their capacity to learn the

language and lose interest in doing so.

The responses that follow show how emotionally drained the respondents

are by learning a foreign language.

"Learning a language is a form of enjoyment, but as time goes by as we go

along with the lesson it gets harder... sobrang lawak ng language minsan hindi

na ako makasabay."

This means that the respondent was emotionally driven. When it was her

first time learning a foreign language, she felt the excitement of learning the

language, but as time and the lesson went by, due to the foreign language's

broadness, she lost interest in pursuing learning the language. It is supported by

respondents who have similar thoughts saying:

“At first medyo na e-excite pa’ko since bago nga parang excited akong matuto,

then pag tumatagal na, nahihirapan na’ko. I feel stressed.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

"The Japanese language was fun. While the Korean language was kinda

complicated for me since there are a lot of rules, especially the pronunciation,

and the writing is also complicated in a manner of you must add and subtract to

get the sounds … and for me, it's kinda comp complicated. In Mandarin, well

since it's a tonal language it's very hard. Especially with the tones, and even the

tones have rules to follow, and Mandarin Chinese is an exciting subject since it

is currently taking it."

"Parang I feel a na overwhelmed ako sa mga Chinese Characters. Visual

orientation, parang paranoia, iyung titignan mo iyung characters na pag

nakita mo naguguluhan ka nahihilo something like that.”

"Nakaka emotionally frustrated, and learning a new language can be

overwhelming especially a language like Chinese, it affected me somehow

especially in managing my time because it's time-consuming sa sobrang

daming kailangan na dapat intindihin iinput sa utak mo you'll be stressed out in

a way na parang maapektuhan na talaga iyung emotions mo."

“Chinese ang pinakamahirap na writing characters kasi may mga box box doon

tas parang kelangan ano tama ung pinaglagyan amo don…Kasi nagfocus tayo

sa structure sa pattern, hindi ako masaydong nagenjoy more on nahirapan ako.”

“Nakaka-stress, nakaka-excite kasi nga po bago parang, uy matututo ako nito,

pero pag nasa process na po, medyo ano na hard.” The other respondent also

mentioned that he/she emotionally affected “kasi syempre kapag na halt ang

internet connection mo ma frufrustatte ka na huh paano na to, ano bato paano

… nakakaka emotionally frustrated lalo sa learning process ko.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Apparently, the respondents were initially excited about learning a new

language, but as they progressed, they found the subjects challenging. It can be

deduced further they were also unhappy since they have had a variety of issues

with the Mandarin language, particularly with its characters, procedure, and

pattern.

This implies that the three foreign languages, Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese, are challenging in a way that respondents are emotionally affected

owing to their academic challenges, especially in studying a foreign language.

In a study conducted by S. Kasap (2021), a sense of extreme fear and panic

is called stress.

According to Wimbarti et al. (2018), Japanese language learners have the

highest level of foreign language anxiety compared to other language learners.

Ancho (2019) asserts that the Korean language is offered in some

institutions since it has a favorable demand and interest from students.

Everson (1998) learning to read Chinese as a Foreign Language is

extremely difficult for children whose first language (L1) uses an alphabetic

writing system due to the non-alphabetic character of its spelling.

2. Mentally Taxing

Another perceived effect of the challenges is mentally taxing of 4th year

ABEL respondents in studying foreign language in distance learning. This theme

exists when respondents are thinking superficially which affects their academic

performances.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

As shown below, studying a foreign language strains the respondents'

mental abilities.

“Sobrang nakakaapekto yon sa mental health ko. Minsan umiiyak nalang ako

kasi hindi ako makasabay sa ano sa lesson, ang hirap. Minsan parang ayaw ko

na mag-aral. Kasi hindi ko talaga masyadong nacocope-up iyong lesson … at

nakakawalang gana iyong scores ko mababa ... medyo nastress kasi hindi ako

makasabay sa klase, hindi ko din mapanood iyong recorded video sa

meetings.” “Stressful talaga sya, sa pagsulat palang sa rules the other student

added mga experiences na yun sobra talaga nadadamay na mentally,

physically kasi hindi ko alam minsan ano yung uunahin.”

“It's affecting my mental health in a way na it's too overwhelming. The

information is too overwhelming to comprehend and input to me and nag panic

siguro kasi nga mostly ang mga teacher natin sa foreign language ay

nagpaparecite... nakaka-stress”

"If you got the low point then it affects my mental tasks... I feel embarrassed

when I do not pronounce the word properly."

“Sometimes, naiisip ko parang wala naman improvement sakin parang di naman

ako natututo kasi parang may kulang pa it’s not enough pag sa self ko mismo.”

“Foreign language subjects are stressful when it comes to quizzes like you are

quizzing with different writing systems and characters and vocabularies.”

It can be deduced from the foregoing that respondents were affected by the

thought that their productivity was declining; they perceived themselves to be the

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

class's slowest learners. The respondents were subjected to mental pressure,

and they were unaware of the negativity that creeped into their thoughts.

This implies that the respondents’ attempts to acquire a new language

were not successful. They were more concerned with surviving than learning the

foreign language.

According to Saito et al. (1999) and Zhao et al. (2013), native English

speakers of all three languages—Japanese, Chinese, and Korean—experienced

a large degree of stress due to the foreign writing system, symbols, and

vocabulary. The learner's capacity to absorb and learn a second or foreign

language will be diminished as the amount of information is ingested into the

brain when the filter is activated.

3. Distracting and Confusing

Another perceived effect of the challenges is distracting and confusing of

4th-year ABEL respondents in studying a foreign language in distance learning.

This theme exists when respondents are affected by their vicinity during an

online class.

The following responses indicate how preoccupied and perplexed the

respondents are with learning a foreign language.

“When I'm distracted or uninterested in studying a foreign language, I learn

less. I am not focused on learning the language, so I don't know enough and

learn less.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“Pag tinignan ko iyung characters naguguluhan na ako.” Another respondent

added that “pronunciation of Mandarin … sometimes your classmates will

say para kang tanga, I got distracted sa pronounce uneasy ka to pronounce

para kang uncomfortable nakaka conscious ha tama ba ginagawa ko.”

“One problem na kaya ako coconcious is that since virtual tayo di ko nakikita

mga mukha ng mga classmates ko kaya you cannot tell if you are pronouncing it

correctly … unlike sa f2f nakikita mo sila … somehow the instructors they place

your other colleagues na oh ito si ganyan ang galing parang native speaker na

pero ikaw parang boses mo parang arte lang... somehow na kaka distract...

coconcious parin ako sa ms team like talking to via through phones,

microphones nakaka coconcocious… sa foreign language kasi syempre it’s a

new language mag iiba ang tone ng boses mo nakakhiya and nakakaconcious

like I feel embarrassed when I do not pronounce the word properly.”

“Sometimes I get confused, I search how to pronounce it properly.”

“Hindi ka naman sanay sa mga ganung tones you’ll be confused, and you’ll

be distracted…it distracts you sometimes kasi makikita mo na iba mong

kakalse

tumatawa na.”

“Nag-online class tayo parang nasanay narin ako sa pagmu-multitasking at the

same time nakakaapekto din yun sa studies ko… hindi mo alam kung anong

uunahin kasi online class, utos dito utos nyan.”

“Nakakalito iyong pare-parehas na stroke iyong mga alphabets.”

“I got distracted na parang okay na all along I thought.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

The respondents became conscious and distracted within their vicinity.

This explains why 4th-year ABEL respondents in synchronous online courses

face obstacles in that they are unable to manage every aspect of their online

sessions, including their internet connection, surroundings, virtual audience

pressure, the broadness of each foreign language, their comfort, and help from

both their family and teachers. This will reduce the ability of students to focus on

their education by paying close attention during online classes.

A multitude of things, such as losing interest in the main task, being

unable to pay attention for a variety of reasons, or the intensity of the distractor,

might be the source of distractions. Confusion makes it more difficult to complete

any task correctly. Others might have trouble concentrating, recalling, or making

choices.

This implies that respondents are not yet ready to fully embrace distance

learning since they are distracted by several elements while learning a foreign

language in which respondents is confused due to the language rules itself.

According to N. Hasan (2020), students found online learning to be

particularly distracting due to factors like noise, bad management, commercials,

etc. Online teaching is a relatively new phenomenon compared to traditional

classroom teaching. Calls between classes were a major source of distraction for

98% of students who used their mobile phones for online learning.

4. Demotivating

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

The challenges faced by the respondents in foreign language classes had

demotivating effects. This idea recurred as the respondents shared their

sentiments during the interview.

The findings indicate that there is the insufficient motivation among the

respondents to study foreign languages.

“I think it Korean subject there's a part ohh there's an interesting topic but nung

nag choppy na si sir… iyung interest ko…nawala so yah it does affect."

"In Japanese, you are very overload whereas the vocabulary bucket is full

and…not well and the only thing you can do now is to stop… and feel

unmotivated."

“Kulang ako sa self-confidence …to learn foreign language yung kawalan kasi

ng self-confidence parang hindrance yun para ano eh para mag excels ka sa

class.” “We are in the middle of a pandemic; I lost my interest and sometimes

unmotivated because of the hardness or the hard part na sobrang hirap.”

“My self-confidence really affects my learning … I got afraid na baka hindi tama

iyong sasabihin ko or hindi tama iyong alam ko.”

“Parang nadisappoint ako sa sarili ako.. mas nadagdagan pa iyong kawalan ng

interes ko mag-aral. Imbes na madagdagan iyong motivation, mas nawalan

ako ng motivation”.

“May mga times na gusto ko na din sumuko lalo na kapag ano kapag hindi ko

nagegets.”

“I do not show any interest sa Korean talaga. We are in the middle of a

pandemic, and I lost interest.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

It can be inferred from what the respondents revealed that they lost

motivation to study a foreign language because of their lack of confidence, up to

the point of losing interest in studying their lessons. This implies that foreign

language subjects posed serious challenges on certain respondents that

demotivated them.

“When you are distracted or have no interest in learning a foreign language you

acquire less.” This respondent also added that “hindi ko masasabi na natuto

ako ng sobra. I know na dapat mas may matutunan tayo but because of our

system or our set-up new set-up. We learned less.”

According to Singleton and Ryan (2004), learners struggle to retain new

material, and a reduction in hearing sensitivity impairs the ability to recognize

speech sounds, making it difficult to memorize words and understand teacher

instructions.

5. Motivating

If there were respondents that demotivated by the challenges in foreign

language classes, others perceived them as motivating. In this study, motivation

is highly needed to help the students learn a foreign language amidst pandemics.

The following responses give a glimpse of how the respondents motivated

to learn a foreign language.

"In Mandarin… I enjoy learning it and I'm looking forward kasi parang

nababalik na interest so since we are slowly having are face to face class and

so you know the momentum is there, I think it adds up to my motivation to

learn again

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

the language coz you know balik na tayo naseset na utak ko na oh I need to

study the pressure Is on but in a good way."

"I came from a school where… I personally experienced that like parang may

prior knowledge na ako about that. About the people, their culture how polite

they are, and I think my motivation is having prior knowledge … their

language." “Prior knowledge is one of my motivations and I want to learn more

like parang may seed na … a way to grow na mas matuto pa.”

"Though it is stressing still I get the motivation to strive to learn the foreign

though it is stressing somehow the exciting part of the motivation part where

you know you failed at kasi diba after mong makita or makuha iyung points or

correction sa quiz diba andun naman iyung answer or kung bakit mali sagot

mo and with that, you learn and you will be motivated to na oh mali pala ito so I

should I have to remember ito pala meaning nito or gamit nito."

“Stressing but when you failed at, then that’s the time where you appreciate

to learn, master and remember it that next time I know that I will answer

correctly na.”

These several respondents believe that one of the best things they can do

to motivate themselves to study a foreign language is to increase their exposure

and interest in it. Another factor is their prior understanding of the language,

which will drive them to put more effort into their studies. Another is student

failure, which means that if they have setbacks or errors when learning the

language, this is the moment they will be able to master it.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“Learning those foreign languages is an advantage for us who are in Asia also

it is a great motivation if you want to pursue foreign teaching in the future.”

“Pag may part na mahirap, may part na hindi ko nasabayan, yun nga tatamarin

na’ko, tatamarin nako aralin syempre pag malapit na po yung exam,

papanoorin na yung mga recorded, ano doon na mamo-motivate pag malapit

na ung exam, pag mag activity.”

“Oo yun lang talaga motivation for the grades lang. Grades lang talaga. hindi

na ako makikipagplastikan”.

In the extract above, one respondent sees the positive aspect of the

foreign language course as a steppingstone for the future if they desire to teach

foreign languages. And one respondent added that she/he only becomes

motivated to study the foreign language to pass the course material when an

exam or quiz is about to be administered. Another respondent answered

without filter that motivation is the grades alone. This implies that studying a

foreign language for the first time could inspire respondents because it's a new

language, and new chances, experiences, and discoveries are waiting to be

had.

Shi (2015), added that learning motivations were the inner aspect that

caused personal learning objectives and caused the learning performance of

students to be constant efforts, fortifying the cognitive process, strengthening,

and increasing the learning effect of students.

LEARNING STRATEGIES FOR STUDYING FOREIGN LANGUAGES

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Research question three (3) sought to answer the learning strategies of

4th year ABEL students when studying foreign languages online, specifically

Japanese, Korean, and Chinese. The themes generated are adapted to Oxford

(1990) language learning strategies. Cognitive strategies, memory-related

strategies, social strategies, and metacognitive strategies are the identified

themes. The themes are arranged according to the most up to the least answer

of the respondents.

1. Cognitive Strategies

The most used learning strategy that 4th-year ABEL respondents

employed in learning foreign languages is cognitive strategy. The respondents

practice how to pronounce words and write characters, take notes, and watch

instructional videos. According to Oxford (1990), cognitive strategies function by

understanding and producing new language by different means such as

practicing, receiving, and sending messages, analyzing, and reasoning, and

creating a structure for input and output.

"I try to practice by myself. I do advanced reading and advanced

pronunciation drills. After watching the video, via mimicry and imitating the

sounds. I practiced … and then imitate.”

“I am searching for it in google and I’ll know how to properly pronounce

it.” “ina-aral ko iyong rules kung paano ipronounce.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“Prinapractice ko din iyong writings. Nagprapractice ako magsulat ng mga

strokes ng Mandarin.”

“practicing the proper ways to write the characters to understand a certain

vocabulary in a sentence.”

“dalawang beses akong nagsulat, first ung strokes muna prinactice ko, tas

doon sa malinis na format. Napa-practice ko yung ano, pag connect-connect ng

grammar ng Korean.”

The respondents are practicing the proper pronunciation of the words

incorporating the rules of the foreign language as Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese have different alphabet compared to English. Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese do not have a Roman alphabet like English, rather they have their own

writing system. Practicing the proper pronunciation and writing the characters of

Japanese, Korean, and Chinese help the respondent to familiarize themselves

and memorize the language. Practicing the characters on paper is a typical

learning strategy or practice in traditional teaching or offline learning.

The respondent stated that they usually take down notes in Japanese,

Korean, and Chinese. The respondents stated the responses below.

“natuto ako kasi prinactice ko iyong napag-aaralan natin. I read. I write.

I pronounce. I practice the language.”

“because there is myriad tone so I must really immerse myself and try

to jot down numerous vocabularies and master it so that I will be able to go on

my

class.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“I do jot down notes especially pag sinusulat ni sir sa white board niya or

sa mismong pdf niya.”

“ni-no-notes ko, sinusulat ko sa papel. Nahihirapan matandaan kaya

ni- no-notes ko, sinusulat ko sa papel, pati sa Japanese.”

“isusulat … yung parang proper pronunciation.”

“may notes ako. For example, isang character yung pronunciation niya

meaning niya at the same time paano siya isulat. Ang notes ko lang sa mandarin

ay yung proper pronunciation.”

Writing down notes about the vocabulary and the proper pronunciation of

the character helps respondents to memorize it. The mode of learning of the

respondent is online and traversal of online and offline strategy is present as the

respondent read or listen on their devices such as smartphones and laptop and

write physically.

The respondents also watch the recorded discussion on MS Team as

seen their statements below.

“sa recorded discussion po, lahat ng discussion pina-panood ko po ulit.

Ginagawa ko po every after ng klase papanoorin ko po ulit tapos don ako

nagta- take note ng malala. sa Korean lahat ng klase natin pinapanood ko ulit

ng isang

beses.”

“papanoorin ko po, mag no-notes ako tas iintindihin ko pa ulit.”

"I preferred watching the recorded meetings.”

“repeating yung sounds tapos nagbabase ako sa recording and at the

same time sa YouTube, nanonood ako sa YouTube.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Taking notes is also effective aid for the respondents learning. One

respondent stated that watching every recorded discussion in every foreign

language subject helps her to not have zero grades on quizzes. Another

respondent preferred watching the recorded meeting in Chinese subject,

however this is contrary to her learning strategy in studying Japanese and

Korean where she preferred reading the instructional materials rather than

watching the recorded meeting.

Practicing their writing and speaking skills improved their fluency in foreign

languages. The traversal of online and offline strategy can be seen among 4th

year ABEL respondents. This implies that even if the mode of learning is online,

respondents still incorporate offline strategies as it is effective in helping them in

the learning foreign language.

Takeuchi (2003), Alcazaren et al. (2016), and Allado et. al. (2016)

concluded in their studies that cognitive strategies are one of the preferred

learning strategies of students in learning foreign languages such as Korean and

Japanese. Imitating, shadowing, and pattern testing was used by the students in

learning Japanese as a foreign language in the study of Takeuchi (2003).

2. Memory-related Strategies

The second learning strategy that 4th-year ABEL respondents employ is

memory-related strategies. According to Oxford (1998), memory strategy helps

students store and retrieve information. Almost all the respondents review the

lesson and their notes. The respondents stated that they usually review their

notes

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

or the learning materials that the instructor provides if there is a recitation, quiz,

or examination coming. The respondents also memorize vocabulary and print the

instructional materials given to them. This is employed in three foreign

languages: Japanese, Korean, and Chinese.

The respondents write notes to store information as seen below.

"I must immerse myself and try to jot down numerous vocabularies and

master them."

“I write and memorize every vocabulary na alam kong kakailanganin sa

Japanese foreign language class natin.”

“mag nonotes talaga ako para matandaan ung ano especially yung

pronunciation ng character na yun.”

Respondents write the vocabularies for them to memorize or master it.

The respondent do not only write the vocabulary, but also the pronunciation of it.

Writing the vocabulary and the proper pronunciation of the character help

respondent to memorize it.

The respondents revealed that they review their lesson through their notes

or the instructional materials that the instructors provided. The responses are

seen below.

“binabalikan ko ang previous para mas maintindihan

ko.” “review din kapag malapit na iyong exam.”

“after ng lesson natin inaaral ko iyong pronunciation, rules kung paano

ipronounce.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“I’m giving myself time to review the lesson. Review nalang ulit through

learning materials na prinovide din nila.”

“if may hindi ako maintidihan ano binabalikan ko nalang after ng class.”

“Reviewing, sa ano peers … parang siya na yung mismong nag volunteer

sa mga di nakakasabay, I take that opportunity para mas mabalikan at matuto at

makasabay sa lesson.”

“mas ni-review ko o mas inaral ko yung language.”

The respondent studies the lesson more because the instructor is calling

students to recite. Reviewing the lessons is one of the strategies respondents

employ in learning foreign languages. The above findings suggest that taking

down notes and reviewing helped the respondents retained what they learned in

their foreign subject. Thus, memory-related strategies can compensate for what

the respondents would miss due to some constraints.

Ancho (2019) emphasizes in her study that writing is useful in mastering

and remembering new vocabulary and it can be seen as one of the strategies

that 4th-year ABEL respondents used in studying foreign languages. Takeuchi

(2003) and Yan (2020) have memory strategies as one of the strategies that

students employed in their foreign language learning. Takeuchi (2003) concludes

that students learning Japanese as a Foreign Language use a memory strategy

related to internalizing the linguistic system.

3. Social Strategies

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

The third learning strategy that 4th-year ABEL respondents used is social

strategies. According to Oxford (1990), social strategies involve asking questions,

cooperating with others, and empathizing with them. The respondents asked their

classmates or peers for clarification or correction to understand the lesson.

Almost all the respondents asked their classmates when they did not understand

the lesson well. Only two respondents directly ask the instructor for clarification

and understanding. And only one respondent had a conversation with a native

speaker of a foreign language. The following responses below give a glimpse of

the respondents social strategies.

“actually nagtatanong ako sa mga kaklase natin iyong mga hindi ko

maintindihan na lessons. Nagtatanong tanong din sa mga kaklase natin like kung

anong ibig sabihin ng ganitong words, saan nakuha iyong ganito.”

“parang sya na ung mismong nag volunteer sa mga di nakakasabay, …

mag asks sa classmates.”

“if may hindi ako maintidihan ano binabalikan ko nalang after ng class o

tinatanong sa kaklase.”

“tinanong ko paano ung pronunciation nito mataas ba o mababa. Meron

naman akong kaklaseng na napagtatanungan.”

“nagtanong ako sa assignment lang, kung ano ba ung susulatan, ung

nandun ba na nasa may pdf or ung nakahiwalay na box box doon ganun

lang.

Nag-ask ako sa mga kaklase ko kung pwede magsend siya ng notes niya sakin

tas ung sinend nya naman.”

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“I ask directly the instructor, especially the instructions. Instructions

about the lesson kung bakit ganto, ganyan kung paano ito, paano sa

pagsusulat kung

pababa at pataas.”

“I reached my friends and professor just to aid the information in language

learning.”

“The way kami mag-usap natuto siya sakin ng English language, at the

same time natuto din ako sa kanya ng Japanese language.”

One respondent said that a classmate of them volunteered to teach.

Asking or seeking answers to classmates are commonly seen in classroom

interactions especially in a foreign language subject. This helps the respondents

to understand the lesson clearly and it encourages interaction using the target

language. Asking the instructor can aid more help with information in the lesson

or activities.

Exposure to native speakers will help the respondents to become more

proficient in the language. However, only one respondent interacted with a native

speaker which helps them to learn a foreign language. Exposure to native

speakers may also motivate the students to master the foreign language. This

implies that asking questions to classmates and foreign language teacher can

help the respondents to further understand the lessons in their foreign language

studies.

Gonzales (1998) stated that social strategy is more frequently used than

other strategies like cognitive strategies. However, social strategy is ranked third

as the learner's strategy in this study and in Alcazaren et al. (2016) studies.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Egbert (2020) stated in his study that engagement in language tasks can

continue to support learners' achievement. No or less exposure to the language

and minimal interaction with native speakers of a foreign language can be

challenging to language learners. This coincides with Kim (2020) as he cited

Pappemihiel (2002) in his study concluding that less exposure to the language,

less practice time, and minimal interaction is challenging to Chinese Korean

students studying the Korean language.

4. Metacognitive Strategies

The fourth learning strategy that 4 th-year ABEL respondents used is meta-

cognitive. The metacognitive strategy includes centering your learning, arranging,

and planning your learning, and evaluating your learning. Respondents read their

notes or the learning materials that the instructor provided. The respondents

always read in advance in every foreign language subject. Respondents also

print the instructional materials and watch instructional materials on YouTube,

Facebook, and TikTok where there are free lectures about foreign languages.

The following responses give a glimpse of the metacognitive strategies that

respondents do to enhance their foreign language learning.

"I do an advance reading. I need to read in advance what the instructors

provided." The respondent added, “library sa e-books nag dodownload at

nagbabasa ako to maximize my learning.”

"yung Nihongo nag-a-advance reading ako using the learning materials

they provided."

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

“nagbabasa ako ng notes sa Japanese.” One respondent said, “the

most effective way I used to do in learning a language is reading and writing

them… I

read. I write.”

“mas mag-advance reading nako,… nakakahiya … pag ikaw na ang mag-

recite pag nagkamali ka.”

"I have said I have difficulty reading the text in Korean or Hangul. I've

overcome … by giving time myself at least one hour or 30 minutes to just read a

Hangul or Korean transcriptions or textbooks.”

“nagpri-print ako and then nagha-highlight sa notes ko ng na discuss.”

“nagpri-print din po ako ng binibigay nilang mga notes pdfs, ppts, pati

po

yung mga ppts pini-print ko po yun.”

Some respondents watch videos on social media sites such as YouTube,

Facebook, and TikTok where there are free lectures. There responses are seen

below.

"I go to YouTube since it has free lectures and a Facebook group. Since I

have visual distortion or paranoia, I feel overwhelmed by Chinese characters.

I'm trying to watch a free class on social media like TikTok. There is a free

Chinese

lesson for me to feel comfortable with those Chinese characters."

"I'm looking or searching for a video tutorial. When I forgot about the

proper pronunciation of a character, I watch it and make myself familiar with the

character, its proper sound, and its proper usage. Sometimes I got confused … I

used the tutorial, video tutorial in learning a language."

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

One respondent does not want to limit his readings to the learning material

provided by the instructors. The respondent read in advance in Chinese and

Korean but not in Japanese because there is a designated reporter to summarize

the previous discussion. Reading Korean textbooks is one of the learning

strategies that the respondent employs to overcome his difficulty in learning the

Korean language. Online library can further enhance the learning progress of the

students in learning foreign language as they can borrow or download the book in

their gadgets. The respondents also utilized the used of internet and gadget to

learn more. Reading and writing are also effective strategies to the students.

Electrical sources which include pdf and instructional videos on YouTube are

effective aid that helps the learning progress of the students. This implies that

watching instructional videos is effective strategy in learning foreign language.

Ancho (2019) concluded in her study that student engagement, such as

watching videos or films, is an effective technique for learning a foreign

language. Allado et al. (2016) also concluded that instructional films are more

successful than books for foreign language acquisition in studying Korean

because it consists of misspelled words. However, this is contrary to the

experience of one student.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Chapter 5

SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter presents the summary of the research work undertaken, the

conclusions drawn, and the recommendations made as an outgrowth of this

study.

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

The objective of this study was to gather information about the challenges

students experience when studying a foreign language, the perceived effects of

the difficulties on students' foreign language learning, and the learning strategies

students use when learning foreign languages. This study uncovered specific

and context-based experiences of fourth-year ABEL students at PSU-Urdaneta

Campus. Even though confined to a different set-up, ABEL students give almost

the same response during the interview since the mode of teaching, instructor,

location, and foreign language are the same, which are Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese.

1. Challenges experienced in foreign language learning. The respondents

considered (1) writing system is challenging since Japanese, Korean, and

Chinese language are logographic (2) pronunciation is difficult since there are

rules to follow to pronounce it correctly (3) memorization of new information is

difficult (4) learning environment is challenging for the learning process (5) time

constraints are also a

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

67

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

68

challenge for students and instructors, and (6) Demotivation is one of the

challenges faced by students in foreign languages.

2. Perceived effects of the challenges of foreign language learning on

students. It was clear that the perceived effects of the challenges of foreign

language learning were (1) emotionally draining as they found the subjects are

challenging (2) mentally taxing as they pressure themselves to learn a foreign

language (3) distracting and confusing considering that there are several

elements distracting and confusing considering that there are several elements

while learning foreign language (4) demotivating since they lack confidence and

lose interest in learning foreign languages, and (5) motivating given that a new

language means new learning, new chances, and new experiences.

3. Strategies for studying foreign languages. It was found that (1) cognitive

strategies as respondents practice and creating structure for input and output, (2)

memory-related strategies as respondents review well, (3) social strategies as

respondents ask questions, and (4) meta-cognitive strategies as respondents

plan their learning.

CONCLUSIONS

After careful analysis of the findings, the researchers arrived at the following

conclusions:

1. Foreign language is strange as it is not spoken by everyone, which makes it

difficult to learn their rules, systems, pronunciation, and setup. Distance learning

makes it more difficult to study foreign languages.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

2. Foreign language learning is complex; thus, adverse effects are expected;

however, it can also motivate other students. Hence, foreign language learning is

compelling and terrifying, mainly when the class is held online.

3. Foreign language learners employ several strategies to deal with the demands

of language study. As such, the four Oxford language learning techniques are

used to categorize those strategies used by learners.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the summary of findings and conclusions drawn, the following

recommendations are composed:

1. The curriculum developer may lessen the foreign language in the

curriculum to one or two foreign languages instead of four. The teachers

should give more time to discuss the writing system, pronunciation, and

rules of a foreign language. Also, the foreign language teachers are

encouraged to conduct activities like film showing to expose the students

to the language and culture.

2. The school administration should provide seminars for the students about

mental and emotional health that will be attended by the students to help

them to learn how to manage their stress in learning foreign languages.

3. The students may watch instructional videos on the internet to aid their

foreign language learning. Also, the researchers recommend that a similar

study be conducted, considering other variables such as the instructors'

teaching strategies in a foreign language.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

BIBLIOGRAPHY

A. Books

Brown, H. D. (2000). Principle of Language Learning and teaching. New Jersey &
NY: Mcgraw-Hill.
Karmiloff, K., & Karmiloff-Smith, A. (2001). Pathways to language: From fetus to
adolescent. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Kidd, T. & Song, H. (2008). Handbook of Research on Instructional Systems and
Technology. Information Science Reference.
Oxford, R.L. (1990). Language Learning Strategies. New York: Nuebury House.

B. Electronic Sources

Aguilera Hermida, A Patricia. (2020). College Students’ Use and Acceptance of


Emergency Online Learning Due to COVID-19. International Journal of
Educational Research Open. 1. 100011. Retrieved from:
10.1016/j.ijedro.2020.100011. Retrieved on: April 28, 2022.
Akbari, E. et al., (2016). Student engagement and foreign language learning
through online social networks. Retrieved from: Asian-Pacific Journal of
Second and Foreign Language Education. Retrieved from: DOI
10.1186/s40862-016-0006-7.41. Retrieved on: June 17, 2022.
Alcazaren, H. K. & Rafanan, E. (2016). Language Learning Strategies: The Case
of Foreign Multilinguals in a Philippine Secondary School. Paper-iafor.
Retrieved from:
http://papers.iafor.org/papers/acll2016/ACLL2016_24515.pdf. Retrieved
on: June16, 2022.
Almaiah, M. A., Al-Khasawneh, A., & Althunibat, A. (2020). Exploring the critical
challenges and factors influencing the E-learning system usage during
COVID-19 pandemic. Education and Information Technologies, 25.
Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-020-10219-y. Retrieved
on: May 1, 2022.
Ancho, I. (n.d.). Learning Korean as a Foreign Language: The Case of a Teacher
Education Institution in the Philippines. Retrieved from https://so01.tci-
thaijo.org/index.php/hbds/article/download/158819/133643. Retrieved on:
June 28, 2022.
Andrea T. (2022). The effect of anxiety on foreign language academic
achievement. AKJjournal. Hungarian Educational Research Journal.
Retrieved from: DOI: https://doi.org/10.1556/063.2021.00098. Retrieved
on: June 29, 2022.
Alnuzaili, E. S., & Uddin, N. (2020). Dealing with Anxiety in Foreign Language

69

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

70

Learning Classroom. Journal of Language Teaching and Research, 11(2),


269. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.17507/jltr.1102.15. Retrieved on:
May 1, 2022.
Arbon, A.M. and Pariña, J. C.M. (2018). A Study of Language Learning
Strategies of College Female Students in the Philippines. Retrieved from:
Dlsu.edu.ph. Retrieved from: https://www.dlsu.edu.ph/wp-
content/uploads/dlsu- research-congress-proceedings/2016/LLI/LLI-II-
01.pdf. Retrieved on: May 8, 2022.
Barrot, J. S., Llenares, I. I., & del Rosario, L. S. (2021). Students’ online learning
challenges during the pandemic and how they cope with them: The case
of the Philippines. Education and Information Technologies, 26(7321–
7338). Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-021-10589-x.
Retrieved on: May 1, 2022.
Bessai, N. A. (2018). Using Oxford’s Strategy Inventory of Language Learning
(SILL) to Assess the Strategy Use of a Group of First and Third Year EFL
Algerian University Students. American Academic Scientific Research
Journal for Engineering, Technology, and Sciences, 42(1), 166–187.
Retrieved from:
https://asrjetsjournal.org/index.php/American_Scientific_Journal/article/vie
w/4019. Retrieved on: April 30, 2022.
Bley-Vroman, R. (2015). The Logical Problem of Foreign Language Learning.
Retrieved from:https://www.researchgate.net/. Retrieved on: December
02,2022.
Boca, G. D. (2021). Factors Influencing Students’ Behavior and Attitude towards
Online Education during COVID-19. Sustainability, 13(13), 7469.
Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.3390/su13137469. Retrieved on: April
28, 2022.
Bo Hu. (2010). The challenges of Chinese: a preliminary study of UK learners’
perceptions of difficulty. The Language Journal, 38:1, 99-118. Retrieved
from: DOI: 10.1080/09571731003620721. Retrieved on: June 15, 2022
Buted, D. R., Laisa, R. O., Barola, C. M., Mojado, A. A., Pesigan, J. A. & Canovas,
G. C.. (2014). Performance of Senior Tourism Students in Using Foreign
Language. Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 2(3).
Retrieved from http://ejournals.ph/form/cite.php?id=5793. Retrieved on:
June 26, 2022.
Chen, S, Caropreso, E. and Hsu, C. (2008). Designing Cross-Cultural
Collaborative Online Learning. In Kidd, T. & Song, H., Handbook of
Research on Instructional Systems and Technology. Information science
reference. Retrieved from: DOI: 10.4018/978-1-59904-865-9.ch067.
Retrieved on: May 1, 2022.
Chua HW, Tan TG, Lin Chia Ying. A review of challenges in learning Chinese
characters among non-native learners in Malaysia. Indian Journal of Arts,
2015, 5(16), 93-100. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/306400483_A_review_of_challe
nges_in_learning_Chinese_characters_among_non-
native_learners_in_Malaysia. Retrieved on: December 3, 2022.
Clarke, V., & Braun, V. (2013, February). Teaching thematic analysis: Overcoming

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

challenges and developing strategies for effective learning.


ResearchGate; British Psychological Society.
Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269928387_Teaching_thematic_
analysis_Overcoming_challenges_and_developing_strategies_for_effectiv
e_learning. Retrieved on: May 13, 2022.
Damayanti et. al. (2018). The Effect of Learning Strategies and Motivation of
Japanese Language Learning towards Japanese’s Learning Outcomes.
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume
200. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.2991/aisteel-18.2018.41. Retrieved
on: June 15, 2022.
DiFino, S. M., & Lombardino, L. J. (2004). Language Learning Disabilities: The
Ultimate Foreign Language Challenge. Foreign Language Annals, 37(3),
390–400. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1944-9720.2004.tb02697.x
Deng & Hu. (2022). An examination of Chinese character writing errors:
Development differences among Chinese as a foreign language learner.
Sage journal, 6:1, p.39-51. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1177/25138502221066611. Retrieved on: June 15,
2022.
Djafri,F. & Wimbarti S. (2018). Measuring foreign language anxiety among
learners of different foreign languages: in relation to motivation and
perception of teacher’s behaviors. Asian-Pacific Journal of Second and
Foreign Language Education. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40862-018- 0058-y. Retrieved on: June 29, 2022.
ED433669 1999-08-00 Learning Strategies. ERIC/OSEP Digest E577. (n.d.).
Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED433669.pdf. Retrieved
on: May 1, 2022.
Everson, M. (2011). Best Practices in Teaching Logographic and Non-Roman
Writing Systems to L2 Learners. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 31,
249-274. Retrieved from: doi:10.1017/S0267190511000171. Retrieved on:
April 20, 2022.
Everson, M.E. (1998), Word Recognition among Learners of Chinese as a
Foreign Language: Investigating the Relationship between Naming and
Knowing. The Modern Language Journal, 82: 194-204. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4781.1998.tb01192.x. Retrieved on: June
26, 2022.
Fujiwara, Takayoshi. (2012). Beliefs about language learning of Thai students
learning Chinese and Japanese: Relationships with past learning
experiences and target language variations. Electronic Journal of Foreign
Language Teaching. Retrieved from: Electronic Journal of Foreign
Language Teaching, 9(2), 170-182. Retrieved on: June 26, 2022.
Gao, Xiaoping. (2020). Australian Students' Perceptions of the Challenges and
Strategies for Learning Chinese Characters in Emergency Online
Teaching. International Journal of Chinese Language Teaching. 1.
Retrieved from: 10.46451/ijclt.2020.06.04. Retrieved on June 26, 2022.
Gonzales, R. d. (1998). Nihongo No Benkyoo: Learning Strategies and
Motivation of Filipino Learners of the Japanese Language. Layag, 3(1).
Retrieved from http://ejournals.ph/form/cite.php?id=1384. Retrieved on
June 27, 2022.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Gonzales, R. (2010). Motivational orientation in foreign language learning: The


case of Filipino foreign language learners. TESOL Journal, 3(1), 3-28.
Retrieved from http://www.tesoljournal.com. Retrieved on: June 16, 2022.
Harper, S. G. (2017). Engaging Karen refugee students in science learning
through a cross-cultural learning community. International Journal of
Science Education, 39(3), 358–376.
Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2017.1283547. Retrieved on: April 2,
2022.
Ho, W. Y. (Jenifer). (2018). Mobility and language learning: A case study on the
use of an online platform to learn Chinese as a foreign language. London
Review of Education. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.18546/lre.16.2.05.
Retrieved on: May 1, 2022.
Hsiao, C. H. (2013). Anxieties and Achievement Goals: Their Relationships in
Contexts of Learning Chinese as a Foreign Language. ProQuest LLC.
Retrieved from:
https://urresearch.rochester.edu/institutionalPublicationPublicView.action;j
sessionid=72365310F8FD97790A7F16A27CFE090D?institutionalItemId=
27891. Retrieved on: June 8, 2022.
Inero Valbuena Ancho. (2019). Meaning and Value of Learning Korean Language
in the Graduate School. Thai Journal of East Asian Studies, 23(2), 12–25.
Retrieved from: https://so02.tci-
thaijo.org/index.php/easttu/article/view/241332. Retrieved on: June 16,
2022.
Inero Ancho. (2019). Learning Korean as a Foreign Language: The Case of a
Teacher Education Institution in the Philippines. HUMAN BEHAVIOR,
DEVELOPMENT and SOCIETY, 20(2), 74–81. Retrieved from:
https://so01.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/hbds/article/view/158819. Retrieved
on: May 27, 2022.
Jee, M. J. (2012). Effects of Language Anxiety on Three Levels of Classes of
Korean as a Foreign Language. 2012Journal of Korean Language
Education 23(2):467-487. Retrieved from:
DOI:10.18209/iakle.2012.23.2.467. Retrieved on: June 29, 2022.
Joo, K., & Damron, J. (n.d.). Foreign Language Reading Anxiety: Korean as a
Foreign Language in the United States. Ncolctl.org. Retrieved from:
http://www.ncolctl.org/files/Foreign-Language.pdf. Retrieved on: May 6,
2022.
Kim, A. (2022). Mobile-Assisted Language Learning in L2 Korean Using WeChat:
A Case Study. International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies
(IJIM), 16(01), 94–105. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.3991/ijim.v16i01.24007. Retrieved on: June 1, 2021.
Kuraesin, U. (2021). Factors That Cause Difficulty Learning Japanese for
Students of Class XI IPA 3 SMAN I Pasawahan. Review of International
Geographical Education (RIGEO), 11(6), 365-372. Retrieved from: doi:
10.48047/rigeo.11.06.45. Retrieved on: April 18, 2022.
Li, W. (2021). Main Factors That Facilitate Second Language Learning With
Learning and Teaching Experience. Asian Journal of Social Science

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Studies, 6(4), 35. Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.20849/ajsss.v6i4.955.


Retrieved on: June 28, 2022.
Montiel-Chamorro M. L. (2018). Comparing Online English Language Learning
and Face-to-Face English Language Learning at El Bosque University in
Colombia. Scholars Compass.vcu.ed. Retrieved from:
https://scholarscompass.vcu.edu/etd/5343/. Retrieved on: May 17,2022
Natalia, S., Darwis, M., Kaharuddin, & Abbas, A. (2022). The Psychological
Constraints of Using Japanese Among Indonesian Students. Journal of
Language Teaching and Research, 13(2), 331–337. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.17507/jltr.1302.13. Retrieved on: May 10, 2022.
Nowell, L. S., Norris, J. M., White, D. E., & Moules, N. J. (2017). Thematic
analysis: striving to meet the trustworthiness criteria. International Journal
of Qualitative Methods, 16(1), 1–13. Sagepub. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1177/160940691773384. Retrieved on: May 20, 2022.
Osamu Takeuchi. (2003). What can we learn from good foreign language
learners? A qualitative study in the Japanese foreign language context.
System, Vol. 31, Issue 3, Pages 385-392. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0346-251X(03)00049-6. Retrieved on: June 26,
2022.
Oxford, R., and Nyikos, M. (1989). Variables affecting choice of language
learning strategies by university students. Modern Language Journal, 73,
291-300.
Pace, M. (2022) Needs and Motivations of Adults Learning Foreign Languages.
The Maltese Perspective. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/361439320. Retrieved on:
December 02, 2022.
Quintos, S. (2021). Difficulties in Learning Japanese as a Foreign Language: The
Case of Filipino Learners. Journal.bicol-u.edu.ph. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.47789/burdj.mbtcbbgs.20212402.04. Retrieved on: April
28, 2022.
Rose, H. (2019). Unique Challenges of Learning to Write in the Japanese Writing
System. In N. Yigitoglu & M. Reichelt (eds.), L2 Writing Beyond English
(pp. 78-94). Bristol: Multilingual Matters. Retrieved from:
DOI:10.21832/9781788923132-008. Retrieved on: June 30, 2022.
Rotas, E., & Cahapay, M. (2020). Difficulties in Remote Learning: Voices of
Philippine University Students in the Wake of COVID-19 Crisis. Asian
Journal of Distance Education, 15(2). Retrieved from:
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1285295.pdf. Retrieved on: April 29,
2022.
Schumaker, J. B., & Deshler, D. D. (1992). Validation of learning strategy
interventions for students with LD: Results of a programmatic research
effort. In Y. L. Wong (Ed.), Contemporary intervention research in learning
disabilities: An international perspective. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Retrieved from: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4612-
2786-1_2. Retrieved on: April 18, 2022.
Shamaki, T. A. (2015). Influence of Learning Environment on Students’ Academic
Achievement in Mathematics: A Case Study of Some Selected Secondary

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Schools in Yobe State – Nigeria. Journal of Education and Practice, Vol.6,


No.34, 2015. Retrieved from:
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1086080.pdf. Retrieved on: April 20,
2022.
Shen, R. (2022). The Effect of Internet Corpus Learning on Students’ Japanese
Learning Motivations and Learning Effect. Original Research Article
Frontiers in Psychology. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.766660. Retrieved on: June 29, 2022.
Shrestha, E., Mehta, R. S., Mandal, G., Chaudhary, K., & Pradhan, N. (2019).
Perception of the learning environment among the students in a nursing
college in Eastern Nepal. BMC Medical Education, 19(1). Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-019-1835-0. Retrieved on: May 15, 2022.
Singh, V., & Thurman, A. (2019). How Many Ways Can We Define Online
Learning? A Systematic Literature Review of Definitions of Online
Learning (1988-2018). American Journal of Distance Education, 33(4),
289–306. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1080/08923647.2019.1663082. Retrieved on: May 15,
2022.
Stephen Krashen’s Theory of Second Language Acquisition. (n.d.).
Www.sk.com.br. Retrieved from: https://www.sk.com.br/sk-krash-
english.html#:~:text=Krashen%20claims%20that%20learners%20with.
Retrieved on: May 29, 2022.
Vaismoradi, M., Turunen, H., & Bondas, T. (2013). Content analysis and thematic
analysis: Implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study.
Nursing & Health Sciences, 15(3), 398–405. Retrieved from:
https://doi.org/10.1111/nhs.12048. Retrieved on: May 20, 2022
World Health Organization. (2021). Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic.
Www.euro.who.int. Retrieved from: https://www.euro.who.int/en/health-
topics/health-emergencies/coronavirus-covid-19/novel-coronavirus-2019-
ncov. Retrieved on: June 01, 2022.
Yan, J. (2020). Chinese vocabulary learning strategies by English-speaking
learners: A think-aloud study. Global Chinese, 6(2), 237-262.
https://doi.org/10.1515/glochi-2020-0013. Retrieved on: June 15, 2022.
Yang, J. (2018). What makes learning Chinese characters difficult? The voice of
students from English secondary schools. Sage Journals. Retrieved from:
doi.org/10.1177/2513850217748501. Retrieved on: June 15, 2022.
Yildiz, Orkun & Ersoy, Abdullah & Yıldırım, İbrahim. (2021). The Impact of
Information and Communication Systems on Organizations. Retrieved
from: 10.4018/978-1-7998-3045-0.ch001. Retrieved on: June 1, 2022.
Yu, A. & Geng, G. (2020). Introducing Chinese Hanzi at the beginning of teaching
Chinese as a Foreign Language (CFL). Global Chinese, 6(2), 359-380.
Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.1515/glochi-2020-0018. Retrieved on:
June 26, 2022.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPENDIX A
LETTER OF
PERMISSION

TO THE CAMPUS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

October 12, 2022

HONORIO L. CASCOLAN, PHD.


Campus Executive Director
Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta Campus
Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Sir:

We, Sheena Richelle M. Coroña, Charmaine L. de Chavez, and Lavishreiy Gail


P. Voces, 4th year ABEL students on this campus, are writing to request
permission to conduct a research study entitled, “Foreign Language Learning
among ABEL Students”, as partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree
Bachelor of Arts in English Language.

In view thereof, we would like to request the school administration to allow us to


conduct a semi-structured interview with five (5) randomly selected participants
from the 4th year ABEL students using the platform of their choice, or the learning
platform of the institution, the MS Teams.

Your approval to conduct this study is highly appreciated.

Respectfully yours,

SHEENA RICHELLE M. COROÑA

CHARMAINE L. DE CHAVEZ

LAVISHREIY GAIL P. VOCES


Researchers

Noted:

VIRMA CRIS L. LAGUNA


Research Adviser

Approved by:

HONORIO L. CASCOLAN, PHD.

75

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPENDIX B
LETTER OF
PERMISSION

TO THE COLLEGE DEAN OF ARTS AND EDUCATION

October 12, 2022

ELIZABETH F. EPISCOPE, Ed.D.


Dean, College of Arts and Education
Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta Campus
Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Ma’am:

We, Sheena Richelle M. Coroña, Charmaine L. de Chavez, and Lavishreiy Gail


P. Voces, 4th year ABEL students at Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta
Campus, we would like to request your good office to allow us to conduct a
research study with the 4th year ABEL students through semi-structured interview
entitled “Foreign Language Learning among ABEL Students”. Rest assured
that all information to be gathered will be used for research purposes only.

Your kind approval to conduct this study is highly appreciated.

Rest assured that all information to be gathered will be used for research
purposes only

Thank you.

Respectfully yours,

SHEENA RICHELLE M. COROÑA

CHARMAINE L. DE CHAVEZ

LAVISHREIY GAIL P. VOCES


Researchers

Noted:

VIRMA CRIS L. LAGUNA


Research Adviser

Approved by:

ELIZABETH F. EPISCOPE, Ed.D.

76

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPENDIX C
LETTER OF
PERMISSION

TO THE CHAIR OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE DEPARTMENT

October 12, 2022

MARVIN Q. CORPUZ, M.A.Ed


Chair, English Language Department
College of Arts and Education
Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta Campus
Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Sir:

We, Sheena Richelle M. Coroña, Charmaine L. de Chavez, and Lavishreiy Gail


P. Voces, 4th year ABEL students at Pangasinan State University-Urdaneta
Campus, would like to request your good office to allow us to conduct a research
study with the 4th year ABEL students through semi-structured interview entitled
“Foreign Language Learning among ABEL Students”. Rest assured that all
information to be gathered will be used for research purposes only.

Your kind approval of this request will help us in the completion of our research
work.

Rest assured that all information to be gathered will be used for research
purposes only

Thank you.

Respectfully yours,

SHEENA RICHELLE M. COROÑA

CHARMAINE L. DE CHAVEZ

LAVISHREIY GAIL P. VOCES


Researchers

Noted:

VIRMA CRIS L. LAGUNA


Research Adviser

Approved by:

MARVIN Q. CORPUZ, M.A.Ed

77

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPENDIX D
LETTER TO THE
PARTICIPANTS

Dear participants:

We, Sheena Richelle M. Coroña, Charmaine L. de Chavez, and Lavishreiy Gail


P. Voces, 4th year ABEL students on this campus, are currently conducting a
research study entitled, “Foreign Language Learning among ABEL
Students”, as part of the fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Bachelor
of Arts in English Language.

In this connection, we would like to request your kind cooperation to participate in


a virtual one-on-one interview and respond with truthfulness and honesty. Rest
assured that all information provided will be treated with the utmost
confidentiality, and no ethical practices will be violated.

Respectfully yours,

SHEENA RICHELLE M. COROÑA

CHARMAINE L. DE CHAVEZ

LAVISHREIY GAIL P. VOCES


Researchers

Noted:

VIRMA CRIS L. LAGUNA


Research Adviser

78

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

APPENDIX E
INTERVIEW GUIDE

I. Establish Rapport

A pleasant morning! Permit me to first introduce myself. I am (name of

researcher), a 3rd year ABEL (AB English Language) student, and I am currently

conducting research entitled "Foreign language learning among ABEL students."

I would first outline the purpose of the meeting and how the respondents were

selected to take part in the study. I'll start by asking them about their days before

moving on to questions about the study questions. Although this questions are

not in the interview questions, it would be helpful to break the ice and learn more

about the interviewees. The sample questions are: Would you mind answering a

question that has nothing to do with the interview questions? We simply want to

know how your day has been. Can you remove the ice for us? Can we start

asking you the real questions now?

After hearing the participants' responses to that question, we would advise them

that we would be outlining the primary goal of this study and ensuring that all the

data was used solely for academic purposes. All information conducted will also

be treated with confidentiality.

SOP Data to Gather Guide Questions

1. What are the 1. Challenges of 1. Will you describedyour

challenges students students in experiences in your foreign

studying language class?

79

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

80

experience in studying foreign 2. How did the difficulties you

the foreign language? language. encountered affect your

2. Perceived language learning?

effects of the 3. Will you compare your

2. What are the challenges experiences in learning Korean,

perceived effects of the students’ Mandarin, and Japanese as a

challenges on experience in foreign language?

students’ foreign studying 4. Did you encounter the same

language foreign difficulties in the three foreign

learning? language language classes?

3. Learning 5. What do you think are the

3. What are the strategies of effects of this difficulties you

learning strategies of students in encountered in your foreign

students in studying their foreign language learning?

foreign languages? language 6. What do you think is the most

learning. affected in your foreign language

studies when you encounter

challenges in learning foreign

languages?

7. What are the things you do to

maximize your learning in your

foreign language subjects?

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

8. How did you manage to learn

Korean, Japanese, and Mandarin

as a foreign language, in spite of

the new educational system?

9. How did you make sure that

you learned a lot in your online

foreign language class?

10. What are your

preparations for your foreign

language class?

11. How did you employ your

learning strategies in your three

foreign language classes?

II. The aim of the interview is to aid the researchers in learning more about

the difficulties that students have when learning a foreign language, as

well as the perceived effects of these difficulties have on students' ability

to learn that language and their learning strategies. In accordance with

proper research protocol, the researchers will request permission from the

respondents before recording the interview. In order to guarantee the

reliability and accuracy of the assessment, the researchers will record the

interview exclusively for academic purposes.

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

CURICULLUM VITAE

Name: Sheena Richele M. Coroña

Date of Birth: March 27, 2001

Place of Birth: Moncada, Tarlac

Age: 21 years old

Gender: Female

Citizenship: Filipino

Religion: Roman Catholic

Civil Status: Single

Person to contact in case of emergency: Elma M. Coroña

Contact no.: 09568733912

Address: Anoyao West, Linmansangan, Binalonan, Pangasinan

Languages/Dialects Spoken: Filipino, English, Ilocano

Special skills: Microsoft Office literature

Video editing (Filmora)

Educational Background:

College: Bachelor of Arts in English Language

August 2019 – Present

Expected graduation: 2023

Pangasinan State University - Urdaneta Campus, Urdaneta

City, Pangasinan

Introduction to Front Office Services

82

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

83

January 5, 2022

Technical Education and Skills Development Authority

Secondary: Moncada Catholic School, Inc

Poblacion 4, Moncada, Tarlac

2012-2019

Primary: Moncada Catholic School,

Inc Poblacion 4, Moncada,

Tarlac 2007-2012

Seminar/Training/Workshop Attended:

14th Philippine Linguistic Congress

Participant

YouTube

August 24-27, 2021

Work Experience:

Work Immersion

Municipal Social Welfare Development Office

Moncada, Tarlac

February 2019

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name: Charmaine L. de

Chavez Date of Birth: September 26, 2001

Place of Birth: Biwas, Tanza, Cavite

Age: 21 years old

Gender: Female

Citizenship: Filipino

Religion: Roman Catholic

Status: Single

Person to contact in case of emergency: Reymundo C. de Chavez

Contact No.: 09164559123

Address: San Miguel, Natividad, Pangasinan

Languages/ Dialects Spoken: Filipino, English, & Ilocano

Special Skills: Computer Literate (MS Word & MS

PowerPoint) Korean language (basic)

Educational Background:

College: Bachelor of Arts in English Language

August 2019 – Present

Expected graduation: 2023

Pangasinan State University - Urdaneta Campus,

Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Secondary: Tayug National High School (TNHS)

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

Plaridel Street, B, Tayug, Pangasinan

2017-2019

Primary: San Miguel Elementary School

San Miguel, Natividad,

Pangasinan 2009-2013

Seminar/ Training/ Workshop attended:

Division Seminar Workshop on Campus

Journalism 2014-2017

Work experience:

Work Immersion

Pangasinan International Montessori Academy (PIMA)

Tayug, Pangasinan

September 2019

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name: Lavishreiy Gail P. Voces

Date of Birth: April 23, 2001

Place of Birth: Sta. Monica Moncada, Tarlac

Age: 21 years old

Gender: Female

Citizenship: Filipino

Religion: Jesus Is Lord (Born Again)

Status: Single

Person to contact in case of emergency: Asuncion L. Padilla

Contact no.: 09504151478

Address: 4 Caralipio St. Sta. Monica Moncada, Tarlac

Languages/ Dialect Spoken: English, Filipino, Ilocano

Special skills: Computer Literate (MS Word, MS Power point)

Educational Background:

College: Bachelor of Arts in English Language

August 2019 – Present

Expected graduation: 2023

Pangasinan State University - Urdaneta Campus,

Urdaneta City, Pangasinan

Secondary: Moncada Catholic School, Inc

Poblacion 4 Moncada, Tarlac

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)


lOMoARcPSD|31637338

2016-2019

Primary: Sta. Monica Integrated Elementary School

Sta. Monica Moncada Tarlac

2007-2012

Seminar/Training/Workshop Attended:

14th Philippine Linguistic Congress

Participant

YouTube

August 24-27, 2021

Work Experience:

Work Immersion

Moncada South Central Elementary

School Moncada, Tarlac

February 2019

Downloaded by maya avon (mayaavon00@gmail.com)

You might also like