Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN 1396-5883
A review of the dental curriculum was undertaken in Helsinki in However, feedback seminars after treatment of the patient were
the mid 90s. The objectives of the new curriculum were to re- not in favour. As part of the evaluation process, a DENTED visi-
inforce the links between basic biomedical and dental sciences tation took place in Helsinki in March 1999. The results obtained
in order to give more emphasis to oral medicine and comprehen- in the student questionnaire were consistent with the aims of the
sive dental care. Furthermore, the curriculum needed to promote undergraduate training and with the present patient treatment
an interdisciplinary approach and encourage students to under- range. In conclusion, the curriculum change enabled the school
stand dental diseases in relation to the community at large. A to broaden the biomedical aspects by increasing the period of
two-year, topic-based, preclinical curriculum, fully integrated with preclinical studies. Although the extent of these studies was
medical students, was started. For didactic teaching in the clin- greater than in the past, and meant postponement of clinical
ical phase, new learning entities were established to promote an skills courses by one semester, it did not jeopardise the compet-
inter-disciplinary approach. For the first time in Finland, objec- ency in clinical dentistry, owing to the effective integration of the
tives were formulated for attitudes and interpersonal skills. Clin- clinical phase teaching.
ical training was conducted in a comprehensive clinic, based on
the team concept, where emphasis was given to proven compet-
ency instead of to the number of procedures performed. The time Key words: schools, dental; dental education; competence, clin-
spent in the clinic was kept the same as previously (1440 h). ical; care, comprehensive dental; educational measurement.
Students’ learning process was assessed with a portfolio. The
majority of students welcomed the comprehensive care clinic, c Munksgaard, 2001
especially its team concept and treatment planning seminars. Accepted for publication 27 June 2000
Oral health
F INNISH DENTAL EDUCATION celebrated its 100th
anniversary in 1992 in the University of Helsinki.
In the same year, the State Council directed that all
Oral health in children and young adolescents has
steadily improved and the number of caries-free
dental training in Kuopio be terminated by 1998, and children has increased since the 70s. Today, 12-year-
only research and post-graduate training be con- olds have an average of 1.2 DMF-compared to 6.9 in
tinued in Turku. The total number of dental graduates 1975. Edentulousness has decreased in all age groups.
per year has decreased from 142 in 1990 to 60 in 1999. Whereas in 1970, 23% of the over 15-year-olds were
The early training of dentists in Finland has resulted edentate, the respective number in 1990 was 14%. In
in one of the highest number of working dentists per 1991, about half of 12–18 year-olds and about 28% of
capita (1:1060) in the world with minimal geographi- 33-year-olds had healthy gingiva (CPIΩ0). 75% of 30-
cal variation in their distribution. The education of year-olds needed periodontal treatment (CPI at least
dentists in Finland follows the EU legislation with 2) and the need for periodontal treatment increased
duration of minimum 5 years and recommendations with increasing age. These changes in the disease
for clinical proficiencies set by the Advisory Commit- spectrum lead to the need for curriculum change, as
tee on the Training of Dental Practitioners of Euro- simple restorative procedures are seldom needed and
pean Commission. Since 1974, Finnish dentists have preventive measures should be based on present
been able to specialise in oral surgery, orthodontics, knowledge (1,2). The future dentist is challenged with
clinical dentistry and in oral public health. Specialist elderly patients keeping their own teeth but de-
training programmes involve 3–4 years’ full-time manding comprehensive understanding of their
study in the University with salary. medical problems (3).
23
Kerosuo et al.
Helsinki University cussed most of the budget cuts on the dental training
The University of Helsinki, the largest university in programme. Regardless of the visions of the Institute
Finland, is among the oldest universities in Europe. of Dentistry, a significant cut in staff numbers was in-
Today there are 32,000 students and 2500 academic evitable. This created pressure for further planning of
and research staff in the University of Helsinki. The the dental curriculum as a whole, and an urgent need
Faculty of Medicine offers two basic degrees: Li- to reorganise existing resources.
centiate in Medicine with a yearly intake of 90 stu-
dents and Licentiate in Dentistry with a yearly intake
Curriculum revision: objectives
of 30 students. After graduation, 6 months internship
in the oral health service as an assistant dentist is The process of planning a new curriculum was started
compulsory in order to obtain a dental licence. in the Institute of Dentistry in 1993 by nominating an
Due to national economical recession in the early ad hoc committee representing each discipline. The
90s, new strategies by the University Senate in 1994 main objective was to produce a framework for the
enabled the faculties to achieve better results with curriculum change. Thus, a document – ‘Guidelines
fewer resources. Within the Medical Faculty, new for the Curriculum Change in Dental Undergraduate
goals were set and the faculty decided to implement Studies’ – was prepared and approved by the Faculty
a new curriculum in several stages, starting in August Council in December 1994 with the following curricu-
1994 with PBL for preclinical studies as a ‘parallel lar requirements:
track’, based on the Harvard system (4). Only volun- (1) To reinforce the links between basic biomedical
teer medical students were allowed to enrol for the and dental sciences, with emphasis on oral medicine
new programme. This change was preceded by the and comprehensive dental care.
integration of the preclinical curriculum through the- (2) To promote an interdisciplinary approach and
matic and topic-based teaching (5). As the preclinical encourage students to understand the dental diseases
studies were partly common for medical and dental in relation to the community at large.
students, changes also became inevitable in the dental (3) To formulate, for the first time in Finnish dental
curriculum. Furthermore, the Faculty Council fo- education, objectives for the behavioural sciences. The
graduate should possess a positive attitude towards
life-long learning and should have evidence-based
dentistry as the goal and should be able and willing
TABLE 1. Subjects (entities) and credit hours in European Credit to promote scientific reasoning. The graduate should
Transfer System (ECTS) credits in the preclinical studies during the
be able to manage patients from all age groups
1st and 2nd year of integrated medical/dental education in the Univer-
sity of Helsinki; the entities are presented in chronological order (healthy or handicapped) with ease and respect, and
should be aware of the ethics of the dental profession.
Entities Total ECTS
hours credits
(4) To emphasise interpersonal communication
skills and ability to work in a team both as a member
Semesters 1 and 2, 1st year
and as a leader.
introduction to medical studies 120 6
introduction to molecular and cellular biology and 200 9 (5) To arrange the clinical training in a comprehen-
pharmacology sive care setting.
cell biology and basic tissues 160 8
(6) To arrange the clinical training in a team-concept
from cell to multicellular organism 80 4
metabolism 200 9 setting to allow more patient contacts per student and
molecular biology and protein synthesis 160 8 thus ensure willingness to encounter patients with
the musculo-skeletal system 280 13
different types of oral health problems in the future.
interpersonal skills* 60 3
total 1260 60
Semesters 3 and 4, 2nd year Planning process
interpersonal skills 60 3
neurobiology 376 16 Reorganisation of the didactic teaching
circulation, kidneys and respiration 350 15.5 For the biomedical curriculum, a co-ordinator (EK)
the gastro-intestinal system and nutrition 200 9
endocrinology and the reproductive organs 160 7
was appointed to re-organise the pre-clinical courses
environment, protection and and extend the integration with the medical studies
defence mechanisms of the body 136 6 in order to consolidate the biomedical basis (6). The
final examination of the first (preclinical) stage 3.5
most feasible option was to integrate the dental and
total 1282 60
medical courses totally (Table 1), although only a few
* The course continues all through the studies. schools have so far implemented a total integration
24
New Helsikin curriculum
(5, 7). The only exceptions are the interpersonal skills teaching. It appeared that most teachers would have
courses, where the dental students have a programme preferred their course to be in the last clinical year,
specially planned from the dentist’s point of view. when the students already know ‘the basics of den-
Rather than keeping dental students separate as is tra- tistry’. To start the clinical training as soon as possible,
ditional, the merger grouped the students in alpha- the dental skills laboratory courses were grouped into
betical order so that there are always both medical smaller ‘packages’ alternating with the clinics. Thus,
and dental students in the small study groups, with- the delay in practising the newly-learned skills, which
out the teachers’ awareness. We feel that this is an could have been 6 months in the old model, was
important step on the way to regarding dentistry as avoided, and the students experienced hands-on den-
an equal partner with medicine and not as a ‘little tistry much earlier.
brother’, thus reinforcing the motivation of the dental These suggestions were forwarded to the Dental
students. Curriculum Planning committee and finally approved
To revise the clinical curriculum, an ad hoc commit- in the Faculty Council in May 1996.
tee was established. The following objectives were
formulated: (i) To evaluate the contents of the didactic
Implementation of clinical phase studies
teaching in the clinical phase (years 3–5); (ii) to revise
the didactic teaching; (iii) to reorganise clinical train- Roughly half of the 5-year curriculum comprises 9
ing to reinforce the links between theoretical knowl- newly formed entities and clinical training (Fig. 1). In
edge and clinical competence. Finally, the task was to order to synchronise the teaching/learning process,
reduce the clinical curriculum by 25 European Credit for each semester in the clinical phase (years 3–5),
Transfer System (ECTS) credits (8), so as to accom-
modate preclinical subjects without extending the
total of 300 ECTS as the total volume and duration TABLE 2. Inter-disciplinary learning promoted by arranging the sub-
(5 years) of the undergraduate degree is legislated by jects into new learning entities; entity .1 comprising substance from
statute (9). 10 courses/disciplines in the past
To ensure competency and completeness, senior lec- Courses/disciplines under which New integrated courses under the
turers from each discipline were invited to this ad hoc the topics were taught in the new learning entity .1 :
committee to work on a part-time basis for revision of past Growth of the masticatory system
the curriculum. Short-term clinical staff were hired to head and neck anatomy A. head neck anatomy
substitute for the committee members. Consultant tooth morphology B. tooth morphology
oral physiology C. facial growth, development of
economists also served on the committee and in line development of the dentition dentition & masticatory function
with current university practice, students were asked oral pathology D. developmental disorders of the
to nominate their representatives. After identification oral surgery face & teeth
oral radiological diagnostics
of the overlapping of subjects in the existing teaching, cleft lip & palate
the committee made a proposal, whereby the didactic principles of teratology
teaching was reorganised into 9 new entities. These human genetics
covered all aspects of modern dentistry, each forming
an umbrella for several conventional disciplines,
thereby promoting an inter-disciplinary approach
(Table 2). Special emphasis was put on oral medicine TABLE 3. New learning entities in the clinical phase and their teach-
ing load in ECTS credits
and oral public health, each of which was recognised
as an entity in its own right (Table 3). The proposal Title of the entity Total Credits
hours
also outlined the reorganisation of the clinical training
into a comprehensive clinic model (see implemen- 1. growth of the masticatory system 160 6.0
tation). 2. oral diagnostics 216 8.1
3. development guidance of the occlusion 220 8.3
4. stomatognathic physiology 172 6.5
Time schedule 5. reconstruction of bite function 280 10.5
The last step in the planning process was to prepare 6. infectious diseases of the tooth and 856 32.1
periodontium
a timetable for these courses and synchronise them 7. traumatology and diseases of soft and hard 228 8.6
with the clinical training. For this purpose, another ad tissues
hoc committee was nominated, comprising represen- 8. oral medicine 508 19.1
9. oral public health 180 6.8
tatives from newly established entities. Each entity
total 2820 106
was supposed to give its first priority for timing of its
25
Kerosuo et al.
26
New Helsikin curriculum
Clinic for Dental and Oral Diseases, which is an inde- capped as well as to private dental clinics. Project
pendent unit to provide teaching facilities for learn- work in ethics in dentistry, critical reviews of scientific
ing. articles and presentation of a scientific report to the
whole class, are compulsory. By challenging the stu-
dents as early as possible to independent study and
Interpersonal skills project work, utilising modern information tech-
Training in interpersonal skills introduces the student nology, we believe that the responsibility of the learn-
to the role of the dentist and allows early patient con- ing process is given to the students themselves, thus
tacts. It provides an excellent forum for practising be- promoting scientific reasoning and life-long learning.
haviour change skills (14), without being anxious of Each student keeps a study logbook during the in-
failing in the manual skills. Interpersonal skills add terpersonal skills studies. This course guides the stu-
up to 11.3 ECTS credits in 5 years, equalling 40 contact dent to develop and improve professional knowledge
hours per year. The main objectives are: (i) to support and self-respect, in relation to each student’s own
the student’s professional identity, (ii) to develop the background and level of personal skills.
student’s interpersonal skills needed as a dentist, (iii)
to develop the student’s ability in ethical reasoning,
(iv) to develop the student’s understanding of the Assessing learning process
dentist’s role as a member and leader of a team, and Preclinical courses are assessed by a written examina-
(v) to familiarise the student with the use of scientific tion after each of the 12 entities. The students are re-
knowledge in clinical practice (evidence-based den- quired to pass all preclinical courses in order to enter
tistry). the clinical phase. The format of these exams consists
The work towards these objectives occurs mainly of multiple choice questions (MCQ) and short essay-
in small groups, interviewing persons of different age type questions. Students’ representatives from the
groups on their experiences in dental care, with clinical phase of the studies along with the clinical
special emphasis on dental anxiety. Clinical work is instructors take part in the planning of the preclinical
observed in different clinics outside the university. final examination. Although traditional written ex-
Students may have their first exposure in real dental amination is the most widely used method of assess-
work carrying out simple preventive measures in the ment, other approaches have been developed to guide
2nd year. Short episodes in dental offices are simu- the students’ learning process. Currently, teaching in
lated and played, based on imaginary or clinically ob- the clinical phase is organised according to the enti-
served scenaries. Students take dental histories with ties, but the final examinations are so far organised by
emphasis on oral health habits. At a later stage of the each discipline. Exams are not necessarily conducted
course, visits are made to health care centres, hospi- at the very end of the courses so as to give students
tals, old people’s homes, and institutes for the handi- a better chance for feedback and improvement. This
TABLE 5. The three levels of competency applied to knowledge, skills and attitudes
Level of competency Applied knowledge Skills Attitudes and
communication
1 knows the basics for this needs help to perform minimal communication
beginner particular treatment relevant treatment skills, but still takes the
patient into account;
able to give instructions
to patients
2 knows the basics for this able to perform relevant able to understand
independent performer particular treatment and treatment independently treatment also from the
its relation to patient’s point of view
comprehensive care of
the patient
3 able to evaluate causes able to perform relevant able to discuss several
skillful performer and consequences; treatment independently aspects of treatment;
able to give reasons for in a reasonable time respects feed back
chosen procedures given by patient;
able to maintain
professional rôle
27
Kerosuo et al.
1
means a combination of assessment methods includ- /3 found that the overall competence of the teacher
ing both summative and formative aspects. More for- was better in the new model compared to the old
mative ways are introduced while supporting factors model. The seminars on treatment planning before
throughout the student’s learning process are empha- seeing the patient were arranged regularly for most
sised. For this particular reason, the progress test is of the students, and more than 1/3 found them very
being implemented during the clinical phase as part important. None of the students considered the sem-
of the continuous assessment starting in the year 2000. inars on treatment planning a waste of time,
The test is a modification of the progress test intro- whereas the feedback seminars (immediately after
duced in Maastricht University. The test is taken twice the clinical session) were considered not much use
a year and is mandatory for all students. The results and were only occasionally arranged. We found this
are only used to monitor individual progress in re- result disturbing, as in the Malmö model, the post-
lation to the candidate’s previous scores and then treatment seminars (1 h) comprise an essential part
compared with fellow students, but not to award of the learning process (15). Our result may indicate
grades. that still too much emphasis is being placed on the
The progress in one’s ability to perform clinical manual skills, at the cost of a holistic view (4, 10).
treatment procedures is assessed with a portfolio. The In the new model, only 12% of the students experi-
three different dimensions are: (i) duration of clinical enced problems in finding a vacant dental chair,
training; (ii) quota of clinical procedures to be com- whereas that had been the case for the majority in
pleted; (iii) comprehensive treatment. The student the old model. Thus, the time allocated for clinical
demonstrates his/her ability to perform clinical work studies was more effectively used.
in every phase of treatment, including documenta- In the new model, in orthodontics, emphasis has
tion. The performance is self-assessed and then been given to screening, diagnosis, treatment plan-
marked by the clinical instructor as described earlier ning and follow-up of the patients. The new team
in the Malmö model (10, 15). In this context, the stu- concept has allowed each student to visualise more
dent’s attitude, knowledge and clinical skills are as- clinical (and video-recorded) cases compared to the
sessed. Students are expected to reach the level of an individual approach, where students were respon-
independent performer on a scale modified from that sible for only their own patients. More than 2/3 of
used in Dundee (13) (Table 5). These overall descrip- the students favoured the new model and found the
tions are the guidelines for discussions. Short 15–30 load of teaching in orthodontics to be appropriate in
min group sessions on treatment planning and im- relation to the whole dental curriculum.
plementation precede and follow daily clinical work
in addition to a possible personal feedback to the stu-
dent. More thorough one-on-one feedback sessions DENTED visitation
are arranged once per semester. The student and the Dental educational standards vary widely across
teacher compare and discuss their results of the evalu- Europe and convergence is best promoted through
ation and, accordingly, set new objectives for the stu- exchanges (SOCRATES) and voluntary school visi-
dent. tations organised by DENTED (16–18). As part of
the evaluation process, a DENTED visitation took
place in Helsinki in March 1999. The visit was
fruitful and the Institute received several recom-
Evaluation of the new comprehensive
mendations to improve the undergraduate pro-
model for clinical training
gramme.
Questionnaires The DENTED questionnaire on clinical compet-
In spring 1998, 2 years after the implementation of encies, covering all fields of clinical dentistry was
the comprehensive clinic, a questionnaire was distributed to the final-year students. The vast ma-
handed out to the final year students. These stu- jority of the students (90%) felt themselves well ex-
dents were exposed to both the old and the new perienced or competent in all disciplines except
curriculum. The questionnaire was completed by oral surgery (periapical surgery and removal of a
74% of the students. More than 2/3 of the respon- buried root) and prosthodontics (preparing a three-
dents felt that the team concept was better than the unit adhesive-resin-bonded bridge). These results
old individual approach and that the facilities were are consistent with the aims of the undergraduate
more readily accessible. More than 1/2 the class felt training and with the present patient treatment
that the instructors were more readily available and panorama.
28
New Helsikin curriculum
29
Kerosuo et al.
30