Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AWARD OF DEGREE OF
Bhimtal
Roll No. 221405610025
Kumaun University
1
CERTIFICATE
This is certified that this Summer Training Report Project Titled "A Study on
performance appraisal system" in “ A ” submitted by
Jyoti Joshi of MBA III semester for partial fulfillment of award of degree of
Master of Business Administration has been completed by him under my
guidance.
f
He was sincere in putting efforts to prepare and present this research report.
2
STUDENT DECLARATION
The information incorporated in this project is true and original to the best of my
knowledge. This report is my original work and has not been copied from any
sources.
3
Certificate from Company
Jyoti Joshi
4
Preface
There are number of forces that make HR the greatest support system in an
organisation. Employees play a great role in the success of any organisation. So,
managing the human resources in an organisation is really a task of great concern
and there are many policies for them to get the right job contribution for the
success of the organisation.
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This project has been an honest and dedicated attempt to make the analysis on
marketing material as authentic as it could. And I earnestly hope that it provides
useful and workable information and knowledge to any person reading it. During
this period, I had the pleasure of working closely with accomplished organization
people who shared with me their experience and helped me in completion of my
research.
I sincerely thank my faculty for his guidance andi encouragement in carrying out
this project work.
6
CONTENTS
1. CHAPTER – 1
INTRODUCTION
LITERATURE REVIEW 9-16
REPORT OBJECTIVE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
LIMITATIONS OF THE PROJECT STUDY
2. CHAPTER – 2 17-21
3. CHAPTER – 3 22-39
4. CHAPTER – 4
▪FINDINGS 40-43
▪CONCLUSION
5. BIBLIOGRAPHY 44-45
6. APPENDIX 46-48
7
CHAPTER-1
8
INTRODUCTION
The history of performance appraisal is quite brief. Its roots in the early 20th Century can be
traced to Taylor’s pioneering time and motion studies. But this is not very helpful, for the
same may be said about almost everything in the field of modern human resource
management. As a distinct and formal management used in evaluation of work
performance appraisal really dates from the time of the Second World War –not more than
sixty years ago.
In the absence of carefully structured system of appraisal, people will tend to judge the
performance of the others, including subordinates, naturally, informally and arbitrarily.
Without a structured appraisal system, there is a little chance of ensuring that the judgment
made will be lawful, fair, defensible and accurate.
The human inclination to judge can create serious motivational, ethical and legal problems
in the work place. Performance appraisal system began as simple methods of justification.
That is appraisal was used to decide whether or not the salary or wage of an individual
employee was justified.
The process was firmly linked to material outcomes. If an employee’s performance were
found to be less than ideal, cut in pay would fallow. On other hand, if their performance is
better than supervisor’s expected, then pay raise would be follow. As a result, the
traditional emphasis on reward outcomes was progressively rejected.
9
organization uses both efforts and results. Performance Appraisal is also termed as
Performance review, annual review or annual appraisal.
The dictionary meaning of the verb is “to fix a price” or “to value an object or thing”. The
term Performance Appraisal is concerned with the process of valuing an employee’s worth
to an organization, with a view to increasing it. Hence, most appraisal systems are linked to
reward systems .The commitment of the management and acceptance by the employees
determines the success of an appraisal system in any organization. It is also important that
the appraisal system matches the organizational culture. For example, a 360-degree
feedback system would not deliver results if implemented in a traditional organization with
rigid hierarchies.
Modern Appraisal:
Performance appraisal may be defined as a structured formal interaction between a
subordinate and supervisor, that usually takes the form of a periodic interview (annual or
semi-annual), in which the work performance of the subordinate is examined and
discussed, with a view to identifying weaknesses and strengths as well as opportunities for
improvement and skills development.
10
LITERATURE REVIEW:
The history of performance appraisal ways back to the early 20th century and can
be traced to Taylor's pioneering Time and Motion studies. Though a formal
appraisal programme was introduced by New York City Civil Services in 1883
before WW1, it is believed to be started for the first time during WW1. Then US
army chief Walter Dill Scott, kept man-to-man rating in military establishment.
According to C. Heyel (1973) “performance appraisal is the process of evaluating
the performance and qualifications of the employees in terms of the
requirements of the job for which they are employed. For the purpose of
administration, including e-ISSN: 2582-5208 International Research Journal of
Modernization in Engineering Technology and Science ( Peer-Reviewed, Open
Access, Fully Refereed International Journal ) Volume:04/Issue:03/March-2022
Impact Factor- 6.752 www.irjmets.com www.irjmets.com @International
Research Journal of Modernization in Engineering, Technology and Science [1206]
selection for promotions, placement, providing financial rewards and other
actions which necessitate differential treatment amongst the members of a group
as distinguished from actions affecting all members equally”.
11
an organization, the supervisors of any organisation have a major role in
transforming the behavior of the employees which may improve it or decrease it.
As per the equity theory, a feeling of uneven treatment decreases the
performance and commitment among the workers. Hence fair performance
appraisals should be conducted with utmost care (Fulk et al., 1985) Anup Bhurtel
and Eka Raj Adhikar conducted a study with 14 supervisors of the Council for
Technical Education and Vocational Training (CTEVT) of Nepal to investigate the
perception of supervisors on performance appraisal in relation to employee
development adopting a qualitative design The results of the study implied that
supervisors interpreted the existing appraisal system in a less effective manner,
and it was mostly used for promotion criteria. The appraisal could not be
conducted on the non-permanent employees and the results of the permanent
employees were also kept confidential. Since they failed to discuss the results
they were not able to set the goals for further development. The study suggested
for a comprehensive performance appraisal system which could include the
developmental plans for the employees. (A.Bhurtel&EK.Adhikari, 2016) Paradise
Bank is a nationalized bank in India. The employees are highly satisfied as they
feel that the management is fair in terms of compensation. The Chief HR manager
at all times made it a point to see that the appraisal system being followed gained
the confidence and support of the employees. Hence a feedback session always
followed post the appraisals. (Caselet 1) Ashima Aggarwal, Gour Sundar Mitra
Thakur (2013) conducted a review on the methods of performance appraisal.
After the research, the authors came to the conclusion that determining whether
one methodology is better than another is challenging because it relies on the
nature and size of the organisation. Every methodology has its own pros and cons.
Performance Appraisal
The term performance appraisal has been called by many names, including
performance review, performance evaluation, personnel rating, merit rating, employee
appraisal or employee evaluation. A performance has been defined as any personnel
decision that effects the status of employee regarding their retention, termination,
promotion, transfer, salary increase or decrease, or admission in to a training program.
Definition:
Performance appraisal can be defined as “a systematic evolution of the individual with
respect to his or her performance on the job and his or her potential for development”.
13
Performance appraisal can be defined as “degree of accomplishments of tasks by an
employee in his job”.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research methodology is a way to systematically solve the research problem as it
guides how research is done scientifically. It consists of different steps that are
generally adopted by the researcher to study the research problem along with the
logic behind them.
RESEARCH
Research is the search for knowledge. It is a scientific and systematic search for
pertinent information or a specific topic.
John W. Best defines research as, “the systematic and objective analysis and
according of controlled observations that may lead to the developments of
generalizations, principles, or theories, resulting in prediction and possibly
ultimate control of events.”
Methodology
Sources of Data
14
Secondary Data – books, websites, internet.
For the purpose of this research primary data as well as secondary data both
are used. This is because data is collected using different types of
approaches, mediums etc.
Limitations of time:
The time which was available for research, was only 30 days, which was not
sufficient to collect more information or details of the company in the HR
department.
Lack of time and other resources as it was not possible to conduct survey at
large level.
15
CHAPTER-2
16
INDUSTRY PROFILE AND
COMPANY PROFILE
INDUSTRY PROFILE
Yoursthatsenior Private Limited (YPL) is a registered startup operating as a Private
Limited Indian Non-Government Company incorporated in India on 23 November
2021 (Two years 28 days old ). Its registered office is in North West Delhi, Delhi,
India. The Company is engaged in the Education & Learning Industry.
It is classified as a private limited company and is located in , Delhi. It's authorized
share capital is INR 1.00 lakh and the total paid-up capital is INR 1.00 lakh.
The current status of Yoursthatsenior Private Limited is - Active.
Details of the last annual general meeting of Yoursthatsenior Private Limited are
not available. The company is yet to submit its first full-year financial statements
to the registrar.
Yoursthatsenior Private Limited has three directors - Praveen Singh
Shekhawat, Mohit Kadayan, and others.
The Corporate Identification Number (CIN) of Yoursthatsenior Private Limited is
U80902DL2021PTC390304. The registered office of Yoursthatsenior Private
Limited is at FLAT NO-829 POCKET-GH-2 BAGHBAN APARTMENT, SECTOR-28,
ROHINI DELHI North Delhi, Delhi.
17
Mission: To bridge the gap between academic qualifications and industry skills by
providing comprehensive career preparation guidance and training to students
from non-elite colleges.
Services:
18
COMPANY PROFILE
Website
http://www.yoursthatsenior.com
Industry
E-Learning Providers
Headquarters
New Delhi, Delhi
19
Type
Privately Held
Founded
2021
Specialties
Interview Skills, Resume Building, Personality Development, Soft Skills
Development, Company Specific Training, Mock Interview, mentorship, and job
preperation
Mission
It has always been to bridge the gap between academic and industry, ensuring that
students are not just equipped with theoretical knowledge, but are also well-prepared
to excel in the professional world. With this partnership, we are taking a giant leap
towards realizing this vision.
20
CHAPTER-3
INTERPRETATION
21
Data Analysis
Data analysis is the process of cleaning, changing, and processing raw data and
extracting actionable, relevant information that helps businesses make
informed decisions. The procedure helps reduce the risks inherent in decision-
making by providing useful insights and statistics, often presented in charts,
images, tables, and graphs.
Interpretation
22
Question 1) Are you aware of the overall objectives/goals of the appraisal
system?
TABLE-1
Respondents 9 14 0 2 0 25
Percentages 36 56 0 8 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 36% are strongly agree, 56% are agree and remaining
8% are strongly disagree with the statement that they are aware of the overall
objectives of the organization.
23
Question 2) Are you aware of the performance appraisal process in the
organization?
TABLE-2
Respondents 10 13 2 0 0 25
Percentages 40 52 8 0 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 40% are strongly agree, 52% are agree and remaining
8% are strongly disagree with the statement that they are aware of the performance
appraisal process in the organization.
24
Question 3) Do you agree that the goals set for you at the beginning of
the year are attainable?
TABLE-3
Respondents 8 15 0 2 0 25
Percentages 32 60 0 8 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 32% are strongly agree, 60% are agree and remaining
8% are strongly disagree with the statement that goals set for you at the beginning
of the year are attainable in the organization.
25
Question 4) Organization plans for competency improvements of employees
on regular basis?
TABLE-4
Respondents 10 11 4 0 0 25
Percentages 40 44 16 0 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 40% are strongly agree, 44% are agree and remaining
16% are disagree with the statement that organization plans for competency
improvements of employees on regular basis.
26
Question 5) Do you agree that your career aspirations are being considered
and appropriate developmental programs are taken up?
TABLE-5
Respondents 7 16 0 2 0 25
Percentages 28 64 0 8 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 28% are strongly agree, 64% are agree and remaining
8% are strongly disagree with the statement that career aspirations are being
considered and appropriate developmental programs are taken up.
27
Question 6) Do you agree that good performance is duly recognized in the
organization?
TABLE-6
Respondents 14 9 2 0 0 25
Percentages 56 36 8 0 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 56% are strongly agree, 36% are agree and remaining
8% are disagree with the statement that good performance is duly recognized by
the organization.
28
Question 7) The performance is contributing for the identification of
training and developmental needs?
TABLE-7
Respondents 7 16 0 0 2 25
Percentages 28 64 0 0 8 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 28% are strongly agree, 64% are agree and remaining
8% are unable to decide anything about the statement that the performance review
is contributing for the identification of training and development needs.
29
Question 8) Do you feel the performance will enhance individual skill
and performance?
TABLE-8
Respondents 7 13 0 0 5 25
Percentages 28 52 0 0 20 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 28% are strongly agree, 52% are agree and remaining
20% are unable to decide anything about the statement that performance
appraisal will enhance individual skills and performance.
30
Question 9) Do you agree that performance management system helps in
planning for effective utilization of talents?
TABLE-9
Respondents 5 16 2 2 5 25
Percentages 20 64 8 8 20 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 20% are strongly agree, 64% are agree 8% are disagree
and remaining 8% are strongly disagree with the statement that performance
management system helps in planning for effective utilization of talents.
31
Question 10)Employees is to be made confident that their
performance would be adequately rewarded by the organization?
TABLE-10
Respondents 5 18 2 0 0 25
Percentages 20 72 8 0 0 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 20% are strongly agree, 72% are agree and remaining
8% are disagree with the statement that performance would be adequately
rewarded by the organization.
32
Question 11) Does financial incentive motivates employee better rather than
other forms of recognition?
TABLE-11
Respondents 3 5 10 1 6 25
Percentages 12 20 40 4 24 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 12% are strongly agree, 20% are agree, 40% are disagree
4%strongly disagree and remaining 24% are unable to decide anything about
the statement that financial incentives motivates employees better rather than other
forms of recognition.
33
Question 12) Do you agree that performance appraisal is to be considered
for promotion and increment and other related aspects?
TABLE-12
Respondents 7 14 0 2 8 25
Percentages 28 56 0 8 2 100
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 28% are strongly agree, 56% are agree, 8% are strongly
disagree and remaining 8% are unable to decide anything about the statement that
the performance appraisal is to be considered for promotion and increment and
other related aspects.
34
Question 13) Appraise main objectives in your duties are:
TABLE-13
INTERPRETATION
Among the 25 employees 16% are agree that appraisal main objectives in his
duties are to achieve the organizational targets and remaining 84% are agree
with both personal development also.
35
Question 14) Employees performance being appraised by:
TABLE-14
INTERPRETATION
Among 25 employees opinions about the statement are as follows:
4% are opined appraised by peers, 32% are opined it is self appraisal and remaining 24% are
opined it is 3600 appraisal.
36
Question 15) How is the relation between superiors and subordinates in your
organization?
TABLE-15
INTERPRETATION
Among 25 employees opinions about the statement are as follows:
44% opined it is cordially, 20% opined it is friendly, 16% opined it is healthy and remaining
20% opined it is good.
37
CHAPTER – 4
FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS
AND SUGGESTIONS
38
FINDINGS:
Performance appraisal process in an organization should be able to make
employees strength and should be able to motivate employees to exert
their maximum efforts. Specific performance of each and every employee should
be evaluated properly for results and they should be remunerated on the basis of
their contribution to the organization. Some of the findings concluded from the
survey as follows:
Employees in the organization are well satisfied with the reward system
followed by the organization.
Majority of the employees satisfies with financial incentives rather than the
other forms of recognition.
39
SUGGESTIONS:
Measurement of performance should be accurate.
40
CONCLUSIONS:
After my thorough observation and analysis, I would like to conclude that the
organization is good in the overall implementation of the performance appraisal
process. All the employees responded very next movement and co-operated a
lot in doing my analysis throughout the project. The employees were very friendly
and helped in doing my project and answered to my questions very
spontaneously and accurately.
My project guide is also very co-operative and has guided me in every step in
completing my project
41
BIBLIOGRAPHY
42
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Venclová, K., Salkova, A., & Kolackova, G. (2013). Identification of
employee performance appraisal methods in agricultural organizations.
Journal of Competitiveness, 5(2).
WEBSITES
https://www.scribd.com
https://yoursthatsenior.com/
www.google.com
www.businessballs.com
43
APPENDIX
44
QUESTIONNAIRE:
1. Were the employees aware of the overall objectives/goals of the appraisal
system?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
2. Are you aware of the performance appraisal process in the organization?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
3. Do you agree that the goals set for you at the beginning of the year are
attainable?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
4. Organization plans for competency improvements of employees on regular
basis?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
5. Do you agree that your career aspirations are being considered and
appropriate developmental programs are taken up?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
6. Do you agree that good performance is duly recognized in the organization?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
7. Do you agree that the performance is contributing for the identification of
training and developmental needs?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
8. Do you feel the performance will enhance individual skill and performance?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
9. Do you agree that performance management system helps in planning
for effective utilization of talents?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
10. Do you agree that the employees should be made confident that their
performance would be adequately rewarded by the organization?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
45
11. Does financial incentive motivates employee better rather than other
forms of recognition?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
12. Do you agree that performance appraisal is to be considered for
promotion and increment and other related aspects?
a) Strongly agree b) agree c) disagree d) strong disagree e) can’t say
13. Appraise main objectives in your duties are:
a) Personal development b) To achieve organization targets c) Both
46