Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brodman
Brodman
Abstract
100 years after their publication, Brodmann’s maps of the cerebral cortex are universally used to locate neuropsychological
functions. On the occasion of this jubilee the life and work of Korbinian Brodmann are reported. The core functions of each
single Brodmann area are described and Brodmann’s views on neuropsychological processes are depicted.
1
Klinik Hohe Warte, Bayreuth, Germany.
Figure 1. This photo- August 22, 1918 at the age of 49 years, just after he had
graph of Korbinian Brod- begun to work as director of the group of histology at
mann served as frontis-
piece in the original
the Psychiatric Research Center at the University of
1909 edition of his book Munich. Margarete Brodmann died on December 8,
[1] (from [2]). 1918, less than 4 months after her husband.
Brodmann’s biography and a lot of information ma-
terial concerning his life and work as well as the Kor-
binian Brodmann Museum in Hohenfels, Germany, is
available on the Korbinian Brodmann homepage (http://
www.korbinian-brodmann.de).
Figure 2. The cortical areas of the lateral and medial surfaces of the human cerebral hemispheres (printed in the original edition of Brodmann’s
book [1]; from [8]).
given different names by different authors [5]. Accord- of variability was present. Based on exclusively anatom-
ing to Brodmann the original pattern of the cortex is the ic features, e.g., cell density, cell size, cortical thickness,
“primitive six-layered type” and all variations in cortical and composition of different layers, Brodmann per-
structure (with the exception of some rudimentary cor- formed a parcellation of the cerebral cortex resulting in
tical zones) are derived from this cytoarchitecture [5]. a histological topographic map (Figure 2). He began his
Thus, Brodmann distinguished between two basic corti- studies in the rolandic region starting with the postcen-
cal cytoarchitectonic patterns [5]: tral gyrus, which could be separated into three different
(1) homogenetic formations (derived from the basic areas by reproducible but certainly not absolutely sharp
six-layered type, covering the major part of the borders (BA 1–3). Its main cytoarchitectonic features
hemispheres; today addressed as “isocortex”); are “the presence of a distinct granular layer and a lack
(2) heterogenetic formations (six-layered structure can- of giant pyramids” [8]. The precentral region (BA 4) “is
not be demonstrated, e.g., in the rhinencephalon, one of the most strikingly differentiated and cytoarchi-
piriform lobe, cingulate gyrus adjacent to the corpus tectonically delimitable structural regions of the whole
callosum; now called “allocortex”). human cerebral cortex” [8]. It is “characterised by the
Brodmann determined a cortical thickness in human appearance of giant pyramids and the lack of an inner
brains ranging from 2.3 mm to 4.5 mm, the giant pyrami- granular layer” [8].
dal cortex being always much thicker than the calcarine In this way, Brodmann defined 52 different areas
cortex [6], and assumed a total cortical surface area of of the cerebral cortex. Their borders sometimes were
1,900–2,200 cm2 [7]. He used the following scheme of sharp (e.g., the boundaries of BA 44 and the anterior
the basic six-layered cortex incorporating the nomen- border of BA 43) [8]. In spite of markedly different
clature of various authors [5]: cytoarchitectural features, Brodmann often found
I. molecular layer (lamina zonalis), ill-defined boundaries between the areas, e.g., the bor-
II. outer granular layer (lamina granularis externa), ders of BA 17–20, 23, 31, 37–39, 40, 46, and the poste-
III. pyramidal layer (lamina pyramidalis), rior border of BA 43 [8]. Not all areas show a homoge-
IV. inner granular layer (lamina granularis interna), neous pattern of cytoarchitecture: BA 6 (agranular
V. ganglion cell layer (lamina ganglionaris), frontal area) and BA 24 (ventral anterior cingulate
VI. spindle cell layer (lamina multiformis). area) gradually change their structure in a dorsoven-
Brodmann analyzed regional variations in cell structure tral direction [8]. It is important to recognize, that the
of the cerebral cortex in detail. Studying different mam- borders between the areas often do not correspond ex-
malian and human brains, he found a certain grade of actly to the sulci. The insular region of the human brain
constancy regarding homologous cortical areas. Con- was not parcellated by Brodmann. He found an ante-
cerning different cortical regions, however, a high grade rior agranular and a posterior granular area, separated
a b
Figures 3a and 3b. Color-coded illustration of Brodmann’s cortical maps. Lateral (a) and medial surface (b).
by a line that is a prolongation of the central sulcus [8]. Area 5 (Preparietal Area)
Nevertheless, he found it difficult to divide the insula This part of the superior parietal lobule and precuneus
into separate areas and concluded as follows: “The is addressed as secondary somatosensory cortex and in-
precise localisation of these individual fields must volved in visuospatial processing.
await further investigation” [8].
Brodmann studied variations in cortical architec- Area 6 (Agranular Frontal Area)
tonics among several species extensively. He also ana- The medial part corresponds to the supplementary mo-
lyzed the ontogenetic development of the cortical lami- tor area (SMA), the lateral one to the premotor area. Its
nar structure in mammals and man. However, these main functions are motor learning and planning as well
aspects are beyond the scope of this paper. Interesting- as motor activation of the hand (Exner’s area). It is part
ly, it is not clear whether Brodmann based his famous of the dorsolateral frontal cortex (DLFC), which is in-
maps (Figure 2) on the data of one single, adult, human volved in working memory [10, 11].
brain. This fact is one important source of criticism.
Area 7 (Superior Parietal Area)
Brodmann Areas: Core Functions Anatomically, it includes the superior parietal lobule
A huge amount of functional imaging data is available laterally and the precuneus medially. It is involved in
on the website of Trinity College, Hartford, CT, USA. It counting and mathematics (dominant hemisphere), vi-
reports on a meta-analysis of 478 published functional suospatial processing (especially in the nondominant
magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies to address hemisphere), and episodic memory retrieval [12].
the issue of functional localization [9]. Figure 3 shows a
more recent illustration of Brodmann’s cortical maps Area 8 (Intermediate Frontal Area)
based on his original publication. Medially, it represents the pre-SMA (motor learning),
laterally, it includes the premotor cortex (motor action
Areas 1, 2, and 3 (Intermediate, Caudal, and Rostral planning) and the frontal eye field (voluntary eye move-
Postcentral Area) ment). It is part of the DLFC.
These areas represent the primary somatosensory pro-
jection cortex, which is responsible for somatosensory Area 9 (Granular Frontal Area)
perception. Its neurons are organized in a somatotopic As part of the DLFC it plays a role in working mem-
manner in the postcentral gyrus. ory and higher cognitive processes (e.g., problem
solving). Together with BA 10, BA 11 and BA 46 it
Area 4 (Giant Pyramidal Area) builds the prefrontal cortex which is associated with
The primary motor cortex is localized in the precentral personality and is involved in memory and cognitive
gyrus and is the main source of motor activation. tasks.
perception. It is also involved in motor action planning Area 42 (Posterior Transverse Temporal Area)
and memory processes. Its dorsal and caudal partition is BA 42 plays a role as secondary auditory cortex and is
equivalent to the rostral cingulate motor cortex (rCM). – in the dominant hemisphere – an element of Wer-
nicke’s area.
Area 33 (Pregenual Area)
Little is known about its function. BA 33 is activated Area 43 (Subcentral Area)
during sexual arousal and plays a role in interoception. The primary gustatory cortex is located in the frontal
and parietal opercular regions. BA 43 is also involved in
Area 34 (Dorsal Entorhinal Area) language perception.
It belongs to the entorhinal cortex (see also BA 28) and
is important for memory, emotional assessment, and ol- Area 44 (Opercular Area)
faction. In the dominant hemisphere, the opercular region of
the inferior frontal gyrus is part of Broca’s area (speech
Area 35 (Perirhinal Area) expression). It is also involved in motor action of fingers
This area overlaps with the parahippocampal gyrus and and toes. BA 44, 45 and 47 were termed as “subfrontal
belongs to the limbic cortex. Involvement in memory area” by Brodmann.
and emotional functions was observed (happiness, sad-
ness, disgust). Area 45 (Triangular Area)
The triangular region of the inferior frontal gyrus is also
Area 36 (Ectorhinal Area) part of Broca’s area. It is involved in tongue move-
The functions of this area are not quite clear. Involve- ment.
ment in emotion perception has been suggested.
Area 46 (Middle Frontal Area)
Area 37 (Occipitotemporal Area) This division of the prefrontal cortex (see also BA 9) is
Visual and language functions are located in this area involved in motivation, attention, and several cognitive
(word and object recognition and naming, face recogni- tasks.
tion). It overlaps with the FFA.
Area 47 (Orbital Area)
Area 38 (Temporopolar Area) Memory, emotion, and olfaction are putative functions
Various putative roles are assigned to the temporal pole: of this element of the subfrontal cortex.
social and emotional processing, self-other distinction,
memory retrieval, and even humor comprehension Areas 48–51
[13]. These areas were not included in Brodmann’s maps of
the human brain.
Area 39 (Angular Area)
Major functions are visual processing (face recognition, Area 52 (Parainsular Area)
reading), spatial imagery, visuomotor function (eye It represents a narrow, band-like transitional area be-
movement), orthographic memory, and mathematics tween the temporal cortex and the insula. There are no
(dominant hemisphere). data concerning the function of BA 52 in humans.
a b
Figures 4a and 4b. Depiction of cortical activation (red) according to the Brodmann areas during neuropsychological tasks based on meta-analysis
data published by Lloyd [9]: motor action activation (a) and auditory perception (b).
to represent structural variations, which could be found are often used synonymously, although holism can be
in all healthy human brains [14]. regarded as a kind of compromise position between lo-
Brodmann was well aware of the meaning of field calizationism and equipotentialism. The essential point
topography for neuropathology and neuropsychology: for the equipotentialist is that no one area is function-
“Our comparative anatomical studies have furnished ally distinct from any other. Brodmann wrote: “The ac-
such fundamentally new data concerning the histologi- ceptance that all parts of the cerebral cortex participate
cal structure of the elements of the cerebral cortex, and uniformly in all its functions must forthwith be consid-
especially about homologies of individual elements, that ered as obsolete (…)” [15]. This is a clear statement
I believe we may even succeed in providing new direc- against equipotentialism. Holists, however, are of the
tions for many physiological concepts” [15]. “There is view that to understand how the brain subserves a given
an undisputed axiom: physiologically dissimilar ele- function it is necessary to understand the whole brain or
ments have dissimilar structures” [15]. at least large portions of it acting as integrated, func-
Brodmann distinguished “strict localisers” and “half tional units. They deny that any particular function can
localisers” as main groups of researchers. “The most ex- be understood as the isolated contribution of just one or
treme localisational hypothesis states that the cerebral even a few, selected components [16]. Brodmann did
cortex is divided into a large number of sharply sepa- not completely reject the idea of holism: “In reality
rated zones, rather like a topographical map, that cor- there is only one psychic centre: the brain as a whole
respond exactly to the different sensory organs and mo- with all its organs activated for every complex psychic
tor apparatuses of the body” [15]. “Our findings (…) event, either all together or most at the same time and
prove with unassailable certainty the existence of a so widespread over the different parts of the cortical
strictly circumscribed regional localisation of specific surface that one can never justify any separate specially
functions” [15]. “One must further accept that specific differentiated psychic centres within this whole. Natu-
complex processes occur mainly in one locality and oth- rally this does not mean that all the individual organs
ers mainly in another” [15]. Brodmann’s intuition was make equal physiological contributions to higher psy-
that a particular anatomic structure corresponds to a chic processes” [15]. Numerous functional imaging stud-
particular function. However, Brodmann recognized ies seem to support this holistic attitude. No single neu-
recovery from physiological deficits due to cortical plas- ropsychological task is fulfilled by the activity of only
ticity [15] and accepted the principle of functional re- one anatomically distinct area. The opposite is true: de-
placement. Thus, he cannot be classified as a “strict lo- pending on the number of experiments performed to
caliser” to use his own idiom. investigate a specific neuropsychological function, an
One century after Brodmann’s publication there is increasing number of active areas is found to be involved
still a lively debate between “localizationists” and “an- [9]. The examples of action execution (Figure 4a) and
ti-localizationists”. The two major anti-localizationist auditory perception (Figure 4b) are representative of
views are “holism” and “equipotentialism”. Both terms most neuropsychological tasks.
In the discussion about the meaning of cytoarchitec- 5. Garey LJ. The basic pattern of the cerebral cortex. In: Garey LJ, ed.
Brodmann’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the principles of com-
tonic cartography for cognitive neuroscience we must parative localisation in the cerebral cortex based on cytoarchitecton-
not forget the importance of white matter connections. ics. New York: Springer, 2006:13–57.
In the late 19th century, localizationism was comple- 6. Garey LJ. Particularities of the cytoarchitecture in different animals.
In: Garey LJ, ed. Brodmann’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the
mented by the associationist school. Associationists (or principles of comparative localisation in the cerebral cortex based on
connectionists) stress the importance of the patterns of cytoarchitectonics. New York: Springer, 2006:59–98.
white matter connection and explain neuropsychologi- 7. Garey LJ. Histological cortical localisation in relation to morphology.
In: Garey LJ, ed. Brodmann’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the
cal deficits using the disconnection theory of Karl Wer-
principles of comparative localisation in the cerebral cortex based on
nicke [17]. Campbell, a contemporary of Brodmann, cytoarchitectonics. New York: Springer, 2006:205–23.
based his cortical field map not only on cytoarchitec- 8. Garey LJ. Description of individual brain maps. In: Garey LJ, ed. Brod-
tonic features, but also on fiber anatomy and function mann’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the principles of compara-
tive localisation in the cerebral cortex based on cytoarchitectonics.
[18]. The science of connectional anatomy (hodology) is New York: Springer, 2006:105–70.
presently reexplored using magnetic resonance tractog- 9. Lloyd D. What do Brodmann areas do? Or: scanning the neurocracy.
raphy based on diffusion tensor imaging (DTI). (http://www.trincoll.edu/~dlloyd/brodmann.html, accessed January 26,
2009).
Brodmann finished his reflections as follows: “A 10. Fletcher PC, Henson RNA. Frontal lobes and human memory: insights
wide field of fruitful activity is opened up to physiology from functional imaging. Brain 2001;124:849–81.
here through newly acquired anatomical localisational 11. de Boisgueheneuc F, Levy R, Volle E, Seassau M, Duffau H, Kinkingne-
hun S, Samson Y, Zhang S, Dubois B. Functions of the left superior
information. Anyone wishing to undertake physiologi- frontal gyrus in humans: a lesion study. Brain 2006;129:3315–28.
cal localisational studies will thus have to base his re- 12. Cavanna AE, Trimble MR. The precuneus: a review of its functional
search on the results of histological localisation” [15]. anatomy and behavioural correlates. Brain 2006;129:564–83.
13. Olson IR, Plotzker A, Ezzyat Y. The enigmatic temporal pole: a review
Indeed, most functional neuroimaging studies refer
of findings on social and emotional processing. Brain 2007;130:1718–
their findings to Brodmann’s maps, which provide a 31.
steady basis for comparison across experiments [9], a 14. Garey LJ. Localisation and histopathology. In: Garey LJ, ed. Brodma-
kind of “lingua franca” of cortical location [18]. In view nn’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the principles of comparative
localisation in the cerebral cortex based on cytoarchitectonics. New
of the huge number of functional imaging publications York: Springer, 2006:225–37.
Brodmann is still present, even 100 years after his great 15. Garey LJ. Physiology of the cortex as an organ. In: Garey LJ, ed. Brod-
publication. mann’s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the principles of compara-
tive localisation in the cerebral cortex based on cytoarchitectonics.
New York: Springer, 2006:239–62.
Conflict of Interest Statement 16. Mundale J. Concepts of localization: balkanization in the brain. Brain
The author declares that there is no actual or potential conflict of in- Mind 2002;3:1–18.
terest in relation to this article. 17. Catani M, Ffytche DH. The rises and falls of disconnection syndromes.
Brain 2005;128:2224–39.
18. Ffytche DH, Catani M. Beyond localization: from hodology to function.
Phil Trans R Soc B 2005;360:767–79.
References
1. Brodmann K. Vergleichende Lokalisationslehre der Großhirnrinde in
ihren Prinzipien dargestellt auf Grund des Zellenbaues. Leipzig: Barth,
1909. Address for Correspondence
2. Garey LJ, ed. Brodman´s localisation in the cerebral cortex: the prin- Prof. Dr. Michael Strotzer
ciples of comparative localisation in the cerebral cortex based on cy-
Klinik Hohe Warte
toarchitectonics. New York: Springer, 2006.
3. Campbell AW. Histological studies on the localisation of cerebral func- 95445 Bayreuth
tion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1905. Germany
4. Economo C, Koskinas GN. Die Cytoarchitektonik der Hirnrinde des er- Phone (+49/921) 400-4402, Fax -4409
wachsenen Menschen. Wien–Berlin: Springer, 1925. e-mail: Michael.strotzer@klinikum-bayreuth.de