TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION

DOCUMENT NO. REV : 0

FENDER PAGES :

BIDDERS
NO. DESCRIPTIONS REQUIREMENTS NOTES
VENDOR'S NAME

BIDDER Reference No. / Date

PT CGN PT CGN PT CGN
Technical Clarification Reply

Place of Manufacture

Representative in Indonesia

General Information
Reference/ Experience list
Delivery Time Anchor Bolts

Fenders & Others

To fully comply with the requirements of the

A SCOPE OF SUPPLY
requisition and attached technical specifications

Supply of Fender, its frontal frame and

accessories
1. Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 4 Nos
2. Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 4 Nos
3. Type SCN 800 F.1.0 4 Nos
4. Type KVF 300H L=2000 mm (V- Fender) 4 Nos
5. Type KVF 300H L=2500 mm (V-Fender) 26 Nos

FAT/SAT 1 Lot

Test and inspection 1 Lot

Rust proof and preservation 1 Lot
Engineering & Documentation 1 Lot
Certification 1 Lot

Preparation, packing and marking for shipment 1 Lot

Delivery material to WIKA warehouse as per

Bidder to inform
clarification

Anchor and its template 1 Lot

Detail schedule that also inform fabrication

schedule, delivery schedule and delivery 1 Lot
anchor and its template

QA / QC Requirements 1 Lot

Warranty 1 Lot
B GENERAL TECHNICAL REQUIREMENT
B.1 Functional and Design Requirement
As per Requirements of Technical Specification,
Codes and standards
and/or BS 6349
- Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 = 913 kN.m
- Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 = 703 kN.m

Minimum energy absorption - Type SCN 800 F.1.0 = 190 kN.m

- Type KVF 300H L 2000 mm = 43.2 kN.m

Legend: C:Confirmed / Complied / Furnished, N:Bidder To Specify / Confirm / Furnish, A:Acceptable, X: Not Acceptable, *:Acceptable Subject To Company's Approval
 TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
DOCUMENT NO. REV : 0
FENDER PAGES :

BIDDERS
NO. Minimum energyDESCRIPTIONS
absorption REQUIREMENTS NOTES
VENDOR'S NAME

- Type KVF 300H L 2500 mm = 43.2 kN.m

- Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 = 1357 kN

- Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 = 1129 kN

Maximum Reaction after considering
temperature factor, velocity factor and angle - Type SCN 800 F.1.0 = 399 kN
factor
- Type KVF 300H L 2000 mm = 452.6 kN

- Type KVF 300H L 2500 mm = 452.6 kN

- Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 = 72%

- Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 = 72%

Maximum deflection of fender - Type SCN 800 F.1.0 = 72%

- Type KVF 300H L 2000 mm = 52%

- Type KVF 300H L 2500 mm = 52%

- Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 = 2.3 m

Minimum width of frontal frame - Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 = 2.3 m

- Type SCN 800 F.1.0 = 2.3 m

- Type SCN 1300H E.1.4 = 4.5 m

Minimum depth of frontal frame - Type SCN 1200 E.1.3 = 4.5 m

- Type SCN 800 F.1.0 = 4.5 m

B.2 Frontal Panel
Spark proof type low friction pads which allow easy
Type
replacement

Can reduce hull pressure to 200 KN/m2 under rated

Design Width of Panel
deflection

Maximum friction factor between vessel's hull

0.2
and any part of fender panel face

Backing plate Fully covered the fender panel

Corrosion allowance for panel structure YES (REQUIRED)

Corrosion allowance for all surface of fender

3 mm
panels and chains exposed to the environment

Tension chain for both horizontal and vertical

YES (REQUIRED)
plane

Dimension Tolerance ± 3 % or ± 2mm

Anchor hole distance tolerance ± 4 mm
B.3 Phisycal Properties of rubber compound
B.3.1 Before Ageing

minimum 160 kg/cm2, using test method : JIS

Tensile strength
K6301 Dumbell #3 or ISO 37 ASTM D412 BS 903 A2

Legend: C:Confirmed / Complied / Furnished, N:Bidder To Specify / Confirm / Furnish, A:Acceptable, X: Not Acceptable, *:Acceptable Subject To Company's Approval
 TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
DOCUMENT NO. REV : 0
FENDER PAGES :

BIDDERS
NO. DESCRIPTIONS REQUIREMENTS NOTES
VENDOR'S NAME

Minimum 350 %, using test method : JIS K6301

Elongation
Dumbell #3 or ISO 37 ASTM D412 BS 903 A2

Maximum 77 %, using test method : JIS K6301

Hardness Spring type Hardness (type A) or ISO 2783 ASTM D
2240 BS 903 A6

Maximum 30 %, using test method : JIS K6301 Heat

Compression treatment 70 ˚C ± 1 ˚C x 22 hours or ASTM D 395 BS
903 A6
B.3.2 After Ageing

Not less than 80 % from original value, using test

method : JIS K6301 Ageing test through air heating
Tensile strength
70 ˚C ± 1 ˚C x 96 hours or ISO 188 ASTM D573 BS
903 A2

Not less than 80 % from original value, using test

method : JIS K6301 Ageing test through air heating
Elongation
70 ˚C ± 1 ˚C x 96 hours or ISO 188 ASTM D573 BS
903 A2

Maximum + 8˚C from original value, using test

Hardness method : JIS K6301 Spring type Hardness (type A)
Ageing test through air heating 70 ˚C ± 1 ˚C x 96
hours or ISO 2783 ASTM D 2240 BS 903 A6
B.3.3 Other
Minimum 70 kg/cm, using test method : JIS K6301
Tear resistance
or ASTM D624 BS 903 A3

Maximum 1.5 cc, using test method : BS 903 A9

Abrasion resistance
method c 3000 revolutions
B.4 Fender Accessories

Cast in anchor socket Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31, JIS No G4305

Bolt Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31, JIS No G4305

Hot dip galvanized mild steel, Grade SS 41, JIS No

washer
G3101

U-anchor Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31, JIS No G4305

Hot dip galvanized mild steel, Grade SS 41, JIS No

Chain
G3101
Galvanized carbon steel, Grade 709A37, painted
Shackle and turn backle
with epoxy

Rubber flex Rubber & galvanized mild steel

Protector panel frame Steel, Grade 50B, painted

Resin Pad bolt Stainless steel, Grade 304531

Resin Pad washer Stainless steel, Grade 304531

Legend: C:Confirmed / Complied / Furnished, N:Bidder To Specify / Confirm / Furnish, A:Acceptable, X: Not Acceptable, *:Acceptable Subject To Company's Approval
 TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION
DOCUMENT NO. REV : 0
FENDER PAGES :

BIDDERS
NO. DESCRIPTIONS REQUIREMENTS NOTES
VENDOR'S NAME

C GUARANTEE

Fender will remain functionally adequate for their

intended purpose for minimum thirty (30) years
C.1 Guarantee from date of practical completion excluding damage
due to overloading or the effect of fair wear and
tear.

D TESTING AND CERTIFICATION

Compression test (ASTM F2192) for one of each
type
ASTM D412-2016 Standard test Method for
D.1 Testing vulcanized rubber and thermoplastic plastomer

ISO 2781 Density

PIANC 2020
Certificate of Type of Approval
D.2 PIANC CERTIFICATION Certificate of Compliance: Test Apparatus, Test
Protocol, Supporting Protocols.
E TECHNICAL RECOMMENDATION
E.1 Design Engineer Support Excellent / Good / Average / Poor
E.2 Similar Project Experience Bidder to inform

Legend: C:Confirmed / Complied / Furnished, N:Bidder To Specify / Confirm / Furnish, A:Acceptable, X: Not Acceptable, *:Acceptable Subject To Company's Approval
No Description Requirement Data Sheet Vendor's Data Sheet
A GENERAL REQUIREMENT
- SCN 1600 E.1.8 = 186.7
- HOM-1600H = 197.3 ton.m
1 ton.m
Minimum energy absorption
- SCN 1800 E.0.9 = 196.7
- HOM-1800H = 204.2 ton.m
2 ton.m
- SCN 1600 E.1.8 = 245.5
Maximum Reaction after - HOM-1600H = 221 ton
3 ton
considering temperature factor,
velocity factor and angle factor - SCN 1800 E.0.9 = 230 ton - HOM-1800H = 203.2 ton
4

Maximum deflection of fender 72% 70%

5
6 - SCN 1600 E.1.8 = 3 m - HOM-1600H = 3 m
Minimum width of frontal frame
7 - SCN 1800 E.0.9 = 3.5 m - HOM-1800H = 3.5 m

8 Minimum depth of frontal frame 5m 5m

9 - HOM-1600H = 174 KN/m2

Hull pressure - maximum = 200 KN/m2
10 - HOM-1800H = 135 KN/m2

B ACCESSORIES
Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31,
11 Cast in anchor socket JIS No G4305 SUS 316

Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31,

12 Bolt JIS No G4305 SUS 316

Hot dip galvanized mild steel,

13 washer Grade SS 41, JIS No G3101 Stainless steel, SUS316

Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31,

14 U-anchor JIS No G4305 SUS 316

Hot dip galvanized mild steel,

15 Chain Grade SS 41, JIS No G3101 Galvanized SBC490
 Galvanized carbon steel, Grade
16 Shackle and turn backle 709A37, painted with epoxy galvanized S45C

17 Protector panel frame Steel, Grade 50B, painted S355JR

18 Resin Pad bolt Stainless steel, Grade 304531 SUS 304

19 Resin Pad washer Stainless steel, Grade 304531 SUS 304
No Description Requirement Data Sheet Vendor's Data Sheet
C MATERIAL COMPOUND
20 Hardness Maximum 77 ˚ Maximum 77 ˚
21 Tensile Strength Minimum 160 kg/cm2 Minimum 160 kg/cm2
22 Elongation Minimum 350 % Minimum 350 %
23 Tear Strength minimum 70 kg/cm minimum 70 kg/cm
24 Compression Maximum 30 % Maximum 30 %
25 Abrasion Resistance Maximum 1.5 cc maximum 1.5 cc
26 After Ageing
a. Hardness Original value +8˚ maximum +8
b. Elongation Minimum 280 Minimum 280
c. Tensile Strength minimum 12.8 Mpa minimum 12.8 Mpa
 Note

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

No Deviation
No Deviation

No Deviation

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

Deviate, better than data sheet

requirement

No Deviation

No Deviation

Deviate, Stainless steel is better

than hot dip galvanized mild
steel for corrosive environment
and for lower yield strength has
been back up by bigger
diameter as requirement from
vendor calculation (see
statement letter)

No Deviation

Deviate, As seen in chain

calculation, Safety factor for
chain strength is more than 3 as
codes requirement. Tensile
strength of its material as to be
used in breaking load
calculation is also still in range
as data sheet requirement (see
statement letter)
Deviate, Vendor have U bolt
diameter bigger than common,
and the shackle also is bigger
than common long open link
(see statement later and JIS
manufacture table standard for
chain and accessories)

Deviate, S355JR is equal to

steel Grade 50B except tensile
strength, that S355JR is better
than Grade 50B (see statement
letter)

No Deviation
No Deviation
Note

No Deviation
No Deviation
No Deviation
No Deviation
No Deviation
No Deviation

No Deviation
No Deviation
No Deviation
 Item Specification Sumitomo's Material

Cast in anchor socket Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31, SUS 316
JIS No G4305

Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31,

Bolt JIS No G4305 SUS 316

Hot dip galvanized mild steel,

washer Grade SS 41, JIS No G3101 SUS316

Stainless steel, Grade 316 S31,

U-anchor JIS No G4305 SUS 316

Hot dip galvanized mild steel,

Chain Grade SS 41, JIS No G3101 Galvanized SBC490

Galvanized carbon steel,

Shackle and turn backle Grade 709A37, painted with galvanized S45C
epoxy

Protector panel frame Steel, Grade 50B, painted S355JR

Resin Pad bolt Stainless steel, Grade 304S31 SUS 304

Resin Pad washer Stainless steel, Grade 304S31 SUS 304