Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L3 Ethics Level of Dilemma
L3 Ethics Level of Dilemma
Structural Dilemma:
Structural dilemmas are systemic ethical challenges embedded
within larger social, economic, or political structures.
They involve issues related to inequality, injustice, distribution of
resources, and systemic biases.
Examples could include dilemmas related to poverty, healthcare
access, education disparities, environmental degradation, or
systemic discrimination.
Addressing structural dilemmas often requires changes at a societal
level, such as policy reforms, institutional changes, or shifts in
cultural attitudes and beliefs.
Each level of moral dilemma presents its own complexities and requires thoughtful consideration and ethical reflection
to navigate effectively. Understanding these levels can help individuals and organizations approach moral decision-
making with greater awareness and sensitivity to the broader implications of their choices.
Conventional Dilemma:
In this stage, moral reasoning is guided by societal norms, rules,
and expectations.
Individuals seek to conform to the expectations of others and
maintain social order.
Moral decisions are made based on maintaining relationships and
following established rules and norms.
An example of a conventional dilemma could be a person deciding
whether to lie to protect a friend's feelings or to adhere to the
principle of honesty.
Postconventional Dilemma:
At this stage, moral reasoning transcends conventional norms and
rules.
Individuals develop their own ethical principles based on universal
values and principles of justice.
Moral decisions are made based on an understanding of the broader
societal implications and consideration of ethical principles.
An example of a postconventional dilemma might involve a person
deciding whether to engage in civil disobedience to protest an
unjust law.
These stages represent a progression in moral reasoning and ethical understanding, with individuals
moving from self-interest and obedience to a more principled and universal approach to morality. It's
important to note that not everyone reaches the postconventional stage, and moral development can vary
among individuals based on various factors such as culture, upbringing, and life experiences.