Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Abstract
Background: In cases of non-infectious diarrhoea in children, the WHO and the Thai Antibiotic Smart Use (ASU) project recommend
that no antibiotics should be given and drinking water should be replaced with oral rehydration salt (ORS) solution until the diar-
rhoea is finished.
Aim: To survey the dispensing pattern for non-infectious diarrhoea treatment in children in Thailand.
Methods: Simulated clients visited 91 Class I community pharmacies in five districts in Khon Kaen province and asked for advice
to treat non-infectious diarrhoea in a 14-month-old child. The patient history questions asked by the dispensers, the medications dis-
pensed and non-pharmacological advice given were recorded by the simulated clients immediately after leaving the pharmacy.
Results: In this study, ORS solution was correctly dispensed to the simulated clients in only 7.7% of pharmacies with 68.1% incor-
rectly dispensing antibiotics. More than half of the dispensers (57.1%) did not give any advice regarding non-pharmacological treat-
ment.
Conclusion: The results of this study indicate the need to implement a program to emphasise the importance of providing ORS and
discourage the dispensing of antibiotics in this circumstance.
© 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388
doi: 10.1002/jppr.1345
384 S. Jaisue et al.
Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388 © 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia
Dispensing for diarrhoea in children 385
Table 1 Patient information requested by dispensers at community pharmacies during consultation with simulated clients for non-infec-
tious, acute, watery diarrhoea in a child
© 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388
386 S. Jaisue et al.
Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388 © 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia
Dispensing for diarrhoea in children 387
recommendations because of the considerable variability effective, it is a difficult strategy to implement over a
among the microorganism strains contained in commer- wide area due to the in-built costs. A study of interven-
cially available treatments and the lack of conclusive tions in diarrhoea management in Thai hospitals found
evidence indicating efficacy in children.20 Dispensing a that interactive educational meetings and offering free-
probiotic in this simulated scenario was therefore con- of-charge stool cultures dramatically decreased antibiotic
sidered inappropriate. use for watery diarrhoea.7 Another study found that
Supplemental zinc was not dispensed at any pharma- only enforcement of the appropriate laws by officials
cies despite evidence that zinc can decrease the inci- could change the dispensing behaviour for watery diar-
dence of recurrent episodes of diarrhoea in children.21 rhoea in community pharmacies in Thailand.24
As this recommendation was only recently included in Recommendations obtained from this study consist of
the WHO guidelines, this issue should be addressed three parts, and are targeted to dispensers in the com-
in any intervention to improve the quality of dispensing munity pharmacies, regardless of their pharmacy license
in children with diarrhoea. status. First, dispensers should be informed of the prob-
Typically, dispensers did not ask about frequency of lem as described in the current study and provided the
diarrhoea (59.3%), presence of sunken eyes (97.8%) and ASU guidelines. Although the ASU and WHO guideli-
production of tears when crying (98.9%), all of which can nes are freely available online, this does not seem to
indicate dehydration in the patient. This implies that the have prevented inappropriate prescribing in this circum-
dispensers did not realise the importance of fluid replace- stance. Sending the study results and ASU guidelines
ment in childhood diarrhoea. Similarly, inadequate directly to pharmacies ensures access to the relevant
patient history taking is likely to have led to the inappro- knowledge. The second step of the framework is to
priate supply of antibiotics as the dispensers only asked organise meetings with dispensers in this area to edu-
questions related to infectious diarrhoea (presence of cate them on appropriate watery diarrhoea treatment.
fever, vomiting or blood in stools) about half the time. The last step is law enforcement. Implementation of
According to Thai regulations, community pharma- these recommendations as educational, managerial and
cies must have a licensed pharmacist on duty at all regulatory interventions has been shown to be effective
times, but anecdotally the enforcement of this law is not whether implemented individually or in combination.25
strong. This is supported by data from a survey con- However, it is important to recognise that this is a con-
ducted by the Thailand Ministry of Public Health and tinuous process and the ongoing monitoring of pharma-
The Pharmacy Council of Thailand in 2013 that revealed cies and the appropriate enforcement of laws are
there was no pharmacist on duty at 76.4% of Class I required to ensure good pharmacy practice.
pharmacies visited in some regions of Thailand.22 For- Overall, the dispensing pattern observed in this study
mally trained and licensed pharmacists are expected to was of insufficient fluid replacement and antibiotic over-
know the current guidelines for watery diarrhoea treat- use. New interventions focused on educating the dis-
ment, but this cannot be expected of people who work pensers about these two issues are required as the
at pharmacies on their behalf. As the simulated client proportion of appropriate treatments remains danger-
method employed for this study did not seek consent ously low.6 Improving the proportion of appropriate
from the participants, it must preserve their anonymity treatments in the community would have significant
and cannot determine if the dispensers were actually benefits as diarrhoea is still the fourth major cause of
licensed pharmacists. Therefore, it cannot be concluded death in children under 5 years in this region.1
if the high level of inappropriate dispensing we
observed was due to poor decisions by unqualified dis-
pensers or a lack of knowledge about disease manage- ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ment in licensed staff. The framework to improve this
The authors would like to acknowledge the Faculty of
situation therefore needs to include aspects that are
Pharmaceutical Sciences, Khon Kaen University, Thai-
applicable to either scenario.
land for financial support and Miss Ammarat Saensorn,
Previous recommendations to improve retail phar-
Miss Panitnan Saensorn and Mr Teerawat Boonlerd for
macy behaviour in developing countries have included:
playing the role of simulated clients.
providing relevant and up-to-date information, influenc-
ing the dispensers’ decision making via effective com-
munication of the guidelines, rewarding dispensers who
Conflict of interests statement
follow the guidelines, and banning the stocking and sell-
ing of certain drugs.23 While interventions that reward The authors declare that they have no conflicts of
dispensers for correctly following the guidelines are interests.
© 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388
388 S. Jaisue et al.
Journal of Pharmacy Practice and Research (2017) 47, 383–388 © 2017 The Society of Hospital Pharmacists of Australia