Professional Documents
Culture Documents
USMLE
STEP 1
2020
TAO LE, MD, MHS VIKAS BHUSHAN, MD
Founder, ScholarRx Boracay
Associate Clinical Professor, Department of Medicine
University of Louisville School of Medicine
KIMBERLY KALLIANOS, MD
Assistant Professor, Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging
University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine
New York / Chicago / San Francisco / Athens / London / Madrid / Mexico City
Milan / New Delhi / Singapore / Sydney / Toronto
ISBN: 978-1-26-046205-0
MHID: 1-26-046205-6
The material in this eBook also appears in the print version of this title: ISBN: 978-1-26-046204-3,
MHID: 1-26-046204-8.
All trademarks are trademarks of their respective owners. Rather than put a trademark symbol after every occurrence of a trademarked
name, we use names in an editorial fashion only, and to the benefit of the trademark owner, with no intention of infringement of the
trademark. Where such designations appear in this book, they have been printed with initial caps.
McGraw-Hill Education eBooks are available at special quantity discounts to use as premiums and sales promotions or for use in corpo-
rate training programs. To contact a representative, please visit the Contact Us page at www.mhprofessional.com.
Notice
Medicine is an ever-changing science. As new research and clinical experience broaden our knowledge, changes in treatment and drug
therapy are required. The authors and the publisher of this work have checked with sources believed to be reliable in their efforts to
provide information that is complete and generally in accord with the standards accepted at the time of publication. However, in view
of the possibility of human error or changes in medical sciences, neither the authors nor the publisher nor any other party who has been
involved in the preparation or publication of this work warrants that the information contained herein is in every respect accurate or com-
plete, and they disclaim all responsibility for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from use of the information contained in
this work. Readers are encouraged to confirm the information contained herein with other sources. For example and in particular, readers
are advised to check the product information sheet included in the package of each drug they plan to administer to be certain that the
information contained in this work is accurate and that changes have not been made in the recommended dose or in the contraindications
for administration. This recommendation is of particular importance in connection with new or infrequently used drugs.
TERMS OF USE
This is a copyrighted work and McGraw-Hill Education and its licensors reserve all rights in and to the work. Use of this work is subject
to these terms. Except as permitted under the Copyright Act of 1976 and the right to store and retrieve one copy of the work, you may
not decompile, disassemble, reverse engineer, reproduce, modify, create derivative works based upon, transmit, distribute, disseminate,
sell, publish or sublicense the work or any part of it without McGraw-Hill Education’s prior consent. You may use the work for your
own noncommercial and personal use; any other use of the work is strictly prohibited. Your right to use the work may be terminated if
you fail to comply with these terms.
THE WORK IS PROVIDED “AS IS.” McGRAW-HILL EDUCATION AND ITS LICENSORS MAKE NO GUARANTEES OR WAR-
RANTIES AS TO THE ACCURACY, ADEQUACY OR COMPLETENESS OF OR RESULTS TO BE OBTAINED FROM USING
THE WORK, INCLUDING ANY INFORMATION THAT CAN BE ACCESSED THROUGH THE WORK VIA HYPERLINK OR
OTHERWISE, AND EXPRESSLY DISCLAIM ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED
TO IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. McGraw-Hill Education
and its licensors do not warrant or guarantee that the functions contained in the work will meet your requirements or that its opera-
tion will be uninterrupted or error free. Neither McGraw-Hill Education nor its licensors shall be liable to you or anyone else for any
inaccuracy, error or omission, regardless of cause, in the work or for any damages resulting therefrom. McGraw-Hill Education has no
responsibility for the content of any information accessed through the work. Under no circumstances shall McGraw-Hill Education and/
or its licensors be liable for any indirect, incidental, special, punitive, consequential or similar damages that result from the use of or
inability to use the work, even if any of them has been advised of the possibility of such damages. This limitation of liability shall apply
to any claim or cause whatsoever whether such claim or cause arises in contract, tort or otherwise.
Dedication
SECTION I
`` G U I D E TO E F F I C I E N T E X A M P R E PA R AT I O N 1
SECTION I SUPPLEMENT
`` S P E C I A L S I T UAT I O N S 27
SECTION II
`` HIGH-YIELD GENERAL PRINCIPLES 29
Approaching the Organ Systems 276 Neurology and Special Senses 489
Cardiovascular 279 Psychiatry 553
Endocrine 325 Renal 577
Gastrointestinal 357 Reproductive 611
Hematology and Oncology 403 Respiratory 659
Musculoskeletal, Skin, and Connective Tissue 445 Rapid Review 689
SECTION IV
`` TO P - R AT E D R E V I E W R E S O U R C E S 71 1
``
Abbreviations and Symbols 719 Index 749
Image Acknowledgments 727 About the Editors 808
vi
vii
viii
ix
Like all students before us, we noticed that certain topics tended to appear frequently on examinations. So we
compulsively bought and rated review books and pored through a mind-numbing number of “recall” questions,
distilling each into short facts. We had a love-hate relationship with mnemonics. They went against our purist desires
for conceptual knowledge, but remained the best way to absorb the vocabulary and near-random associations that
unlocked questions and eponyms.
To pull it all together, we used a then “state-of-the-art” computer database (Paradox/MS DOS 4) that fortuitously
limited our entries to 256 characters. That length constraint (which predated Twitter by nearly two decades) imposed
extreme brevity. The three-column layout created structure—and this was the blueprint upon which First Aid was
founded.
The printed, three-column database was first distributed in 1989 at the University of California, San Francisco.
The next year, the official first edition was self-published under the title High-Yield Basic Science Boards Review: A
Student-to-Student Guide. The following year, our new publisher dismissed the High-Yield title as too confusing and
came up with First Aid for the Boards. We thought the name was a bit cheesy, but it proved memorable. Interestingly,
our “High-Yield” name resurfaced years later as the title of a competing board review series.
We lived in San Francisco and Los Angeles during medical school and residency. It was before the Web, and
before med students could afford cell phones and laptops, so we relied on AOL e-mail and bulky desktops. One of
us would drive down to the other person’s place for multiple weekends of frenetic revisions fueled by triple-Swiss
white chocolate lattes from the Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf, with R.E.M. and the Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan playing in the
background. Everything was marked up on 11- by 17-inch “tearsheets,” and at the end of the marathon weekend
we would converge at the local 24-hour Kinko’s followed by the FedEx box near LAX (10 years before these two
great institutions merged). These days we work with our online collaborative platform A.nnotate, GoToMeeting, and
ubiquitous broadband Internet, and sadly, we rarely get to see each other.
What hasn’t changed, however, is the collaborative nature of the book. Thousands of authors, editors, and
contributors have enriched our lives and made this book possible. Most helped for a year or two and moved on, but
a few, like Ted Hon, Chirag Amin, and Andi Fellows, made lasting contributions. Like the very first edition, the team
is always led by student authors who live and breathe (and fear) the exam, not professors years away from that reality.
We’re proud of the precedent that First Aid set for the many excellent student-to-student publications that followed.
More importantly, First Aid itself owes its success to the global community of medical students and international
medical graduates (IMGs) who each year contribute ideas, suggestions, and new content. In the early days, we
used book coupons and tear-out business reply mail forms. These days, we get many thousands of comments and
suggestions each year via our blog FirstAidTeam.com and A.nnotate.
xi
xii
xiii
xiv
Each year we are fortunate to receive the input of thousands of medical students and graduates who provide new
material, clarifications, and potential corrections through our website and our collaborative editing platform.
This has been a tremendous help in clarifying difficult concepts, correcting errata from the previous edition, and
minimizing new errata during the revision of the current edition. This reflects our long-standing vision of a true,
student-to-student publication. We have done our best to thank each person individually below, but we recognize
that errors and omissions are likely. Therefore, we will post an updated list of acknowledgments at our website, www.
firstaidteam.com/bonus/. We will gladly make corrections if they are brought to our attention.
For submitting contributions and corrections, many thanks to Raed Ababneh, Antara Afrin, Rasim Agaev, Vanya
Aggarwal, Ataa Ahmed, Hasan Alarouri, Basim Ali, Muhammad Faizan Ali, Moatasem Al-Janabi, Mohamed
Almahmodi, Chima Amadi, Arman Amin, Jacqueline Aredo, Ranya Baddourah, Daniel Badin, Nida Bajwa, Dileni
Bandarage, Jerrin Bawa, Esra Bayram, Craig Beavers, Jacqueline Bekhit, Matthias Bergmann, Stephanie Biecker,
Aaron Birnbaum, Prateek Bommu, Nathaniel Borochov, Susan Brands, Olivia W. Brooks, Meghan Brown, Stanley
Budzinski, Kevin Budziszewski, Pavel Burski, Elisa M. Cairns, Sergio Camba, Katie Carsky, Esteban Casasola,
Marielys Castro, Jesse Chait, Bliss Chang, Santosh Cherian, Heewon Choi, Charilaos Chourpiliadis, Maruf
Chowdhury, Matthew J. Christensen, Matthew Yat Hon Chung, Alexander Ciaramella, Dillon Clancy, Sofija Conic,
M. Marwan Dabbagh, Parag Das, Ketan Dayma, Elmer De Camps, Charles de Leeuw, Xavier De Pena, Christopher
DeAngelo, Elliott Delgado, Anthony DeMarinis, Stacy Diaz, Evan Dishion, Nicola Helen Duzak, Emily Edwards,
Alec Egan, Mohamed Elashwal, Osama El-Gabalawy, Matthew Eli, Awab Elnaeem, Sally El Sammak, Dylan Erwin,
Stephanie Estevez-Marin, Gray Evans, Najat Fadlallah, Aria Fariborzi, Richard Ferro, Adam Fletcher, Kimberly A.
Foley, Kyle Fratta, Samantha Friday, Nikhila Gandrakota, Siva Garapati, Nicolas Curi Gawlinski, Joanna Georgakas,
Beth Anne George, Ashley Ghaemi, E. Sophia Gonzalez, Justin Graff, Gabriel Graham, Donovan Griggs, David
Gruen, Gursewak Hadday, Jacqueline Hairston, Hunter Harrison, Gull Shahmir Hasnat, Maximillan Hawkins,
Grecia Haymee, Briana Hernandez, Robin Hilder, Tammy Hua, Derrek Humphries, Audrey Hunt, Nanki Hura,
Danny Ibrahim, Jyothik Varun Inampudi, Hnin Ingyin, Maham Irfan, Mina Iskandar, Kritika Iyer, Christina Jacobs,
Arpit Jain, Neil K. Jain, Ala Jamal, Natalie Jansen, Jordan Jay, Mohammad Jmasi, Colton Junod, Talia Kamdjou,
Filip Kaniski, Lydia Kaoutzani, Panagiotis Kaparaliotis, Srikrishna Karnatapu, Patrick Keller, Olivia Keller-Baruch,
Cameron Kerl, Ahmed Ali Khan, Sara Khan, Shaima Khandaker, Samir Khouzam, Sonya Klein, Elana Kleinman,
Andrew Ko, Soheil Kooraki, Anna Kukharchuk, Dennis Vu Kulp, Anil A. Kumar, Julie Kurek, Chloe Lahoud,
Mike Lawandy, Ramy Lawandy, Jessica Lazar, Andrea Leal-Lopez, Lynda Lee, Chime Lhatso, Christine Lin,
Benjamin Lodge, Soon Khai Low, Estefanía Henríquez Luthje, Lisa-Qiao MacDonald, Divya Madhavarapu, Mahir
Mameledzija, Keerer Mann, Rajver Mann, Nadeen Mansour, Yusra Mansour, Bridget Martinez, Ahmad Mashlah,
Rick Mathews, Amy McGregor, Alexandra & Joshua Medeiros & Fowler, Viviana Medina, Areeka Memon, Pedro
G. R. Menicucci, Ben Meyers, Stephan A. Miller, Fatima Mirza, Murli Mishra, Elana Molcho, Guarina Molina,
John Moon, Nayla Mroueh, Neha Mylarapu, Behnam Nabavizadeh, Moeko Nagatsuka, Ghazal Naghibzadeh, Alice
Nassar, Nadya Nee, Lucas Nelson, Zach Nelson, Monica Nemat, Kenneth Nguyen, Michael Nguyen, Christian
xv
xvi
This version of First Aid for the USMLE Step 1 incorporates thousands of contributions and improvements suggested
by student and faculty advisors. We invite you to participate in this process. Please send us your suggestions for:
Personal ratings and comments on review books, question banks, apps, videos, and courses
For each new entry incorporated into the next edition, you will receive up to a $20 Amazon.com gift card as well as
personal acknowledgment in the next edition. Significant contributions will be compensated at the discretion of the
authors. Also, let us know about material in this edition that you feel is low yield and should be deleted.
All submissions including potential errata should ideally be supported with hyperlinks to a dynamically updated Web
resource such as UpToDate, AccessMedicine, and ClinicalKey.
We welcome potential errata on grammar and style if the change improves readability. Please note that First Aid style
is somewhat unique; for example, we have fully adopted the AMA Manual of Style recommendations on eponyms
(“We recommend that the possessive form be omitted in eponymous terms”) and on abbreviations (no periods with
eg, ie, etc). We also avoid periods in tables unless required for full sentences. Kindly refrain from submitting “style
errata” unless you find specific inconsistencies with the AMA Manual of Style.
The preferred way to submit new entries, clarifications, mnemonics, or potential corrections with a valid,
authoritative reference is via our website: www.firstaidteam.com.
This website will be continuously updated with validated errata, new high-yield content, and a new online platform
to contribute suggestions, mnemonics, diagrams, clinical images, and potential errata.
Contributions submitted by May 15, 2020, receive priority consideration for the 2021 edition of First Aid for the
USMLE Step 1. We thank you for taking the time to share your experience and apologize in advance that we cannot
individually respond to all contributors as we receive thousands of contributions each year.
xvii
All contributions become property of the authors and are subject to editing and reviewing. Please verify all data and
spellings carefully. Contributions should be supported by at least two high-quality references.
Check our website first to avoid duplicate submissions. In the event that similar or duplicate entries are received,
only the first complete entry received with valid, authoritative references will be credited. Please follow the style,
punctuation, and format of this edition as much as possible.
The First Aid author team is pleased to offer part-time and full-time paid internships in medical education and
publishing to motivated medical students and physicians. Internships range from a few months (eg, a summer) up
to a full year. Participants will have an opportunity to author, edit, and earn academic credit on a wide variety of
projects, including the popular First Aid series.
For 2020, we are actively seeking passionate medical students and graduates with a specific interest in improving our
medical illustrations, expanding our database of medical photographs, and developing the software that supports our
crowdsourcing platform. We welcome people with prior experience and talent in these areas. Relevant skills include
clinical imaging, digital photography, digital asset management, information design, medical illustration, graphic
design, tutoring, and software development.
Please email us at firstaid@scholarrx.com with a CV and summary of your interest or sample work.
xviii
START EARLY: Use this book as early as possible while learning the basic medical sciences. The first semester of
your first year is not too early! Devise a study plan by reading Section I: Guide to Efficient Exam Preparation, and
make an early decision on resources to use by checking Section IV: Top-Rated Review Resources. Note that First Aid
is neither a textbook nor a comprehensive review book, and it is not a panacea for inadequate preparation.
CONSIDER FIRST AID YOUR ANNOTATION HUB: Annotate material from other resources, such as class
notes or comprehensive textbooks, into your book. This will keep all the high-yield information you need in one
place. Other tips on keeping yourself organized:
For best results, use fine-tipped ballpoint pens (eg, BIC Pro+, Uni-Ball Jetstream Sports, Pilot Drawing Pen,
Zebra F-301). If you like gel pens, try Pentel Slicci, and for markers that dry almost immediately, consider
Staedtler Triplus Fineliner, Pilot Drawing Pen, and Sharpies.
Consider using pens with different colors of ink to indicate different sources of information (eg, blue for
USMLE-Rx Step 1 Qmax, green for UWorld Step 1 Qbank).
Choose highlighters that are bright and dry quickly to minimize smudging and bleeding through the page
(eg, Tombow Kei Coat, Sharpie Gel).
Many students de-spine their book and get it 3-hole-punched. This will allow you to insert materials from other
sources, including curricular materials.
INTEGRATE STUDY WITH CASES, FLASH CARDS, AND QUESTIONS: To broaden your learning strategy,
consider integrating your First Aid study with case-based reviews (eg, First Aid Cases for the USMLE Step 1), flash
cards (eg, First Aid Flash Facts), and practice questions (eg, the USMLE-Rx Step 1 Qmax). Read the chapter in the
book, then test your comprehension by using cases, flash cards, and questions that cover the same topics. Maintain
access to more comprehensive resources (eg, First Aid for the Basic Sciences: General Principles and Organ Systems
and First Aid Express videos) for deeper review as needed.
PRIME YOUR MEMORY: Return to your annotated Sections II and III several days before taking the USMLE
Step 1. The book can serve as a useful way of retaining key associations and keeping high-yield facts fresh in your
memory just prior to the exam. The Rapid Review section includes high-yield topics to help guide your studying.
CONTRIBUTE TO FIRST AID: Reviewing the book immediately after your exam can help us improve the next
edition. Decide what was truly high and low yield and send us your comments. Feel free to send us scanned images
from your annotated First Aid book as additional support. Of course, always remember that all examinees are under
agreement with the NBME to not disclose the specific details of copyrighted test material.
xix
xx
xxi
Years Prior Use top-rated review resources for first-year medical school courses.
Ask for advice from those who have recently taken the USMLE Step 1.
One Week Prior Remember comfort measures (loose clothing, earplugs, etc).
Work out test site logistics (eg, location, transportation, parking, lunch).
Print or download your Scheduling Permit and Scheduling Confirmation
to your phone.
After Exam Celebrate, regardless of how well you feel you did.
Send feedback to us on our website at www.firstaidteam.com.
xxii
Guide to Efficient
Exam Preparation
``Testing Agencies 24
``References25
INTRODUCTION
``
Relax.
This section is intended to make your exam preparation easier, not harder.
Our goal is to reduce your level of anxiety and help you make the most
of your efforts by helping you understand more about the United States
Medical Licensing Examination, Step 1 (USMLE Step 1). As a medical
student, you are no doubt familiar with taking standardized examinations
and quickly absorbing large amounts of material. When you first confront
the USMLE Step 1, however, you may find it all too easy to become
sidetracked from your goal of studying with maximal effectiveness. Common
mistakes that students make when studying for Step 1 include the following:
In this section, we offer advice to help you avoid these pitfalls and be more
productive in your studies.
The USMLE Step 1 is the first of three examinations that you must pass in
order to become a licensed physician in the United States. The USMLE
is a joint endeavor of the National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME)
and the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB). The USMLE serves
as the single examination system for US medical students and international
medical graduates (IMGs) seeking medical licensure in the United States.
Given the unique environment of the CBT, it’s important that you become
familiar ahead of time with what your test-day conditions will be like. You
can access a 15-minute tutorial and practice blocks at http://orientation.
nbme.org/Launch/USMLE/STPF1. This tutorial interface is very similar to
the one you will use in the exam; learn it now and you can skip taking it
during the exam, giving you up to 15 extra minutes of break time. You can
gain experience with the CBT format by taking the 120 practice questions
(3 blocks with 40 questions each) available online or by signing up for a
practice session at a test center for a fee.
For security reasons, examinees are not allowed to bring any personal
electronic equipment into the testing area. This includes both digital and
analog watches, iPods, tablets, calculators, cell phones, and electronic paging
devices. Examinees are also prohibited from carrying in their books, notes,
pens/pencils, and scratch paper. Food and beverages are also prohibited
in the testing area. The testing centers are monitored by audio and video
surveillance equipment. However, most testing centers allot each examinee
a small locker outside the testing area in which he or she can store snacks,
beverages, and personal items.
`` Keyboard shortcuts:
Questions are typically presented in multiple choice format, with 4–5
A, B, etc—letter choices
possible answer options. There is a countdown timer on the lower left corner
Enter or spacebar—move to next
of the screen as well. There is also a button that allows the examinee to
question
mark a question for review. If a given question happens to be longer than
Esc—exit pop-up Calculator and Notes
the screen (which occurs very rarely), a scroll bar will appear on the right,
windows
allowing the examinee to see the rest of the question. Regardless of whether
the examinee clicks on an answer choice or leaves it blank, he or she must
click the “Next” button to advance to the next question.
The USMLE features a small number of media clips in the form of audio
`` Heart sounds are tested via media questions. and/or video. There may even be a question with a multimedia heart sound
Make sure you know how different heart simulation. In these questions, a digital image of a torso appears on the
diseases sound on auscultation. screen, and the examinee directs a digital stethoscope to various auscultation
points to listen for heart and breath sounds. The USMLE orientation
materials include several practice questions in these formats. During the
exam tutorial, examinees are given an opportunity to ensure that both the
`` Be sure to test your headphones during the
audio headphones and the volume are functioning properly. If you are
tutorial.
already familiar with the tutorial and planning on skipping it, first skip ahead
to the section where you can test your headphones. After you are sure the
headphones are working properly, proceed to the exam.
The same USMLE Step 1 sample test items (120 questions) available on `` You can take a shortened CBT practice test at
the USMLE website, www.usmle.org, are used at these sessions. No new a Prometric center.
items will be presented. The practice session is available at a cost of $75
(or more if taken outside of the US and Canada) and is divided into a short
tutorial and three 1-hour blocks of ~40 test items each. Students receive a
printed percent-correct score after completing the session. No explanations
of questions are provided.
Prometric test centers offer Step 1 on a year-round basis, except for the `` The Prometric website will display a calendar
first two weeks in January and major holidays. The exam is given every day with open test dates.
except Sunday at most centers. Some schools administer the exam on their
own campuses. Check with the test center you want to use before making
your exam plans.
US students can apply to take Step 1 at the NBME website. This application
allows you to select one of 12 overlapping three-month blocks in which to be
tested (eg, April–May–June, June–July–August). Choose your three-month
eligibility period wisely. If you need to reschedule outside your initial three-
month period, you can request a one-time extension of eligibility for the next
contiguous three-month period, and pay a rescheduling fee. The application
also includes a photo ID form that must be certified by an official at your
medical school to verify your enrollment. After the NBME processes your
application, it will send you a scheduling permit.
The scheduling permit you receive from the NBME will contain your USMLE
identification number, the eligibility period in which you may take the exam,
and two additional numbers. The first of these is known as your “scheduling
number.” You must have this number in order to make your exam appointment
with Prometric. The second number is known as the “candidate identification
number,” or CIN. Examinees must enter their CINs at the Prometric
workstation in order to access their exams. However, you will not be allowed
to bring your permit into the exam and will be asked to copy your CIN onto
your scratch paper. Prometric has no access to the codes. Make sure to bring
a paper or electronic copy of your permit with you to the exam! Also bring
an unexpired, government-issued photo ID that includes your signature (such
as a driver’s license or passport). Make sure the name on your photo ID exactly
matches the name that appears on your scheduling permit.
`` The confirmation emails that Prometric Once you receive your scheduling permit, you may access the Prometric
and NBME send are not the same as the website or call Prometric’s toll-free number to arrange a time to take the
scheduling permit. exam. You may contact Prometric two weeks before the test date if you
want to confirm identification requirements. Although requests for taking
the exam may be completed more than six months before the test date,
examinees will not receive their scheduling permits earlier than six months
before the eligibility period. The eligibility period is the three-month period
you have chosen to take the exam. Most medical students choose the April–
June or June–August period. Because exams are scheduled on a “first-come,
`` Test scheduling is done on a “first-come,
first-served” basis, it is recommended that you book an exam date on the
first-served” basis. It’s important to schedule
Prometric website as soon as you receive your permit. Prometric will provide
an exam date as soon as you receive your
appointment confirmation on a print-out and by email. Be sure to read the
scheduling permit.
latest USMLE Bulletin of Information for further details.
You can change your test date and/or center by contacting Prometric at
1-800-MED-EXAM (1-800-633-3926) or www.prometric.com. Make sure to
have your CIN when rescheduling. If you are rescheduling by phone, you
must speak with a Prometric representative; leaving a voicemail message will
not suffice. To avoid a rescheduling fee, you will need to request a change
at least 31 calendar days before your appointment. Please note that your
rescheduled test date must fall within your assigned three-month eligibility
period.
Your testing location is arranged with Prometric when you book your test
date (after you receive your scheduling permit). For a list of Prometric
locations nearest you, visit www.prometric.com.
The USMLE reports scores in three to four weeks, unless there are delays
in score processing. Examinees will be notified via email when their scores
are available. By following the online instructions, examinees will be able to
view, download, and print their score report online for ~120 days after score
notification, after which scores can only be obtained through requesting an
official USMLE transcript. Additional information about score timetables
and accessibility is available on the official USMLE website.
The computer will keep track of how much time has elapsed on the exam.
However, the computer will show you only how much time you have
remaining in a given block. Therefore, it is up to you to determine if you
are pacing yourself properly (at a rate of approximately one question per 90
seconds).
The computer does not warn you if you are spending more than your
allotted time for a break. You should therefore budget your time so that
you can take a short break when you need one and have time to eat. You
must be especially careful not to spend too much time in between blocks
(you should keep track of how much time elapses from the time you finish a
block of questions to the time you start the next block). After you finish one
question block, you’ll need to click to proceed to the next block of questions.
If you do not click within 30 seconds, you will automatically be entered into
a break period.
Break time for the day is 45 minutes, but you are not required to use all of
it, nor are you required to use any of it. You can gain extra break time (but
not extra time for the question blocks) by skipping the tutorial or by finishing
`` Be careful to watch the clock on your break
a block ahead of the allotted time. Any time remaining on the clock when
time.
you finish a block gets added to your remaining break time. Once a new
question block has been started, you may not take a break until you have
reached the end of that block. If you do so, this will be recorded as an
“unauthorized break” and will be reported on your final score report.
Finally, be aware that it may take a few minutes of your break time to “check
out” of the secure resting room and then “check in” again to resume testing,
so plan accordingly. The “check-in” process may include fingerprints,
pocket checks, and metal detector scanning. Some students recommend
pocketless clothing on exam day to streamline the process.
Your scheduling permit shows a CIN that you will need to enter to start
your exam. Entering the CIN is the same as breaking the seal on a test book,
and you are considered to have started the exam when you do so. However,
no score will be reported if you do not complete the exam. In fact, if you
leave at any time from the start of the test to the last block, no score will be
reported. The fact that you started but did not complete the exam, however,
will appear on your USMLE score transcript. Even though a score is not
posted for incomplete tests, examinees may still get an option to request that
their scores be calculated and reported if they desire; unanswered questions
will be scored as incorrect.
The exam ends when all question blocks have been completed or when
their time has expired. As you leave the testing center, you will receive a
printed test-completion notice to document your completion of the exam.
To receive an official score, you must finish the entire exam.
Each Step 1 examinee receives an electronic score report that includes the
examinee’s pass/fail status, a three-digit test score, a bar chart comparing the
examinee’s performance to that of other examinees’, and a graphic depiction
of the examinee’s performance by physician task, discipline and organ
system.
The USMLE score report highlights the examinee’s strength and weaknesses
by providing an overview of their performance by physician task, discipline
and organ system compared to their overall performance on the exam.
Each of the questions (minus experimental questions) is tagged according
to any or all relevant content areas. Yellow-colored boxes (lower, same,
higher) on your score report indicate your performance in each specific
content area relative to your overall performance on the exam. This is often
a direct consequence of the total number of questions for each physician
task, discipline or system, which is indicated by percentage range after each
specified content area on the score report (see Figure 1).
The NBME provides a three-digit test score based on the total number of
items answered correctly on the examination, which corresponds to a
particular percentile (see Figure 2). Your three-digit score will be qualified
by the mean and standard deviation of US and Canadian medical school
first-time examinees.
`` The mean Step 1 score for US medical
Since some questions may be experimental and are not counted, it is
students continues to rise, from 200 in 1991
possible to get different scores for the same number of correct answers. In
to 230 in 2018.
2018, the mean score was 230 with a standard deviation of 19.
The passing score for Step 1 is 194. The NBME does not report the
minimum number of correct responses needed to pass, but estimates that it
is roughly 60–70%. The NBME may adjust the minimum passing score in
the future, so please check the USMLE website or www.firstaidteam.com for
updates.
100
80
60
Percentile
40
Minimum
passing score
20
0
150 175 200 225 250 275 300
Consult the USMLE website or your medical school for the most current
and accurate information regarding the examination.
The most important point with the Step 1 score is passing versus failing.
Passing essentially means, “Hey, you’re on your way to becoming a fully
licensed doc.” As Table 2 shows, the majority of students pass the exam, so
remember, we told you to relax.
Keep in mind that this bank of questions is available only on the web. The
NBME requires that users start and complete the exam within 90 days of
purchase. Once the assessment has begun, users are required to complete
the sections within 20 days. Following completion of the questions, the
CBSSA provides a performance profile indicating the user’s relative
strengths and weaknesses, much like the report profile for the USMLE Step
1 exam. The profile is scaled with an average score of 500 and a standard
`` Practice questions may be easier than the
deviation of 100. In addition to the performance profile, examinees will be
actual exam.
informed of the number of questions answered incorrectly. You will have the
ability to review the text of the incorrect question with the correct answer.
260
250 248 248 249 249
246 245 247 245
240 240
236 235 236
233 232 233 233 233
230 230 231
226 225 227
220 220
210
200
190
Ch tion e
ine
y
ry
ine
Va iatric e/
y
y
e
ry
ry
col nd
ery
ry
y
gy
log
y
y
ilit icin
log
tric
log
log
log
log
log
icin
atr
log
og
rge
ge
ge
ge
d in
dic
ne s a
olo
dic
urg
scu s
y
uro
Pe dic
chi
ab ed
sio
dia
iol
n co
uro
tho
ato
go
og
sur
sur
sur
ed
dio
gy tric
l su
me
alm
me
eh m
a
cs
rad
yn
Psy
he
me
Ne
m
Pe
rm
ne
Pa
no
l ra
ral
lar
dic
ste
ica
sti
d r al
cy
est
lar
al
ily
hth
De
c
al
ild
ne
an hysic
pe
tio
na
en
log
Pla
i
Ob
ern
ost
Oto
Fam
An
ern
Ge
Op
tho
tio
dia
erg
uro
Int
gn
Int
P
en
Ra
Or
Em
Dia
Ne
erv
Int
aVertical lines show interquartile range.
bData from National Resident Matching Program. Charting outcomes in the match. http://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Charting-Outcomes-in-the-Match-2018-Seniors.pdf. Published July 2018.
LEARNING STRATEGIES
``
Many students feel overwhelmed during the preclinical years and struggle to
find an effective learning strategy. Table 5 lists several learning strategies you
can try and their estimated effectiveness for Step 1 preparation based on the
literature (see References). These are merely suggestions, and it’s important
to take your learning preferences into account. Your comprehensive
learning approach will contain a combination of strategies (eg, elaborative
interrogation followed by practice testing, mnemonics review using spaced `` The foundation of knowledge you build
repetition, etc). Regardless of your choice, the foundation of knowledge during your basic science years is the most
you build during your basic science years is the most important resource for important resource for success on the USMLE
success on the USMLE Step 1. Step 1.
HIGH EFFICACY
Practice Testing
Also called “retrieval practice,” practice testing has both direct and indirect
benefits to the learner.4 Effortful retrieval of answers does not only identify
weak spots—it directly strengthens long-term retention of material.5 The
more effortful the recall, the better the long-term retention. This advantage `` Research has shown a positive correlation
has been shown to result in higher test scores and GPAs.6 In fact, research between the number of boards-style practice
has shown a positive correlation between the number of boards-style practice questions completed and Step 1 scores
questions completed and Step 1 scores among medical students.7 among medical students.
In addition to using question banks, you can test yourself by arranging your
notes in a question-answer format (eg, via flash cards). Testing these Q&As in
random order allows you to reap the benefit of interleaved practice. Bear in
mind that the utility of practice testing comes from the practice of information
retrieval, so simply reading through Q&As will attenuate this benefit.
Distributed Practice
Flash cards are a simple way to incorporate both distributed practice and
practice testing. Studies have linked spaced repetition learning with flash
MODERATE EFFICACY
Mnemonics
Elaborative Interrogation/Self-Explanation
Elaborative interrogation (“why” questions) and self-explanation (general `` Elaborative interrogation and self-
questioning) prompt learners to generate explanations for facts. When explanation prompt learners to generate
reading passages of discrete facts, consider using these techniques, which explanations for facts, which improves recall
have been shown to be more effective than rereading (eg, improved recall and problem solving.
and better problem-solving/diagnostic performance).5,12,13
Concept Mapping
LOW EFFICACY
Rereading
Highlighting/Underlining
Summarization
Before Starting
Your preparation for the USMLE Step 1 should begin when you enter
medical school. Organize and commit to studying from the beginning so
that when the time comes to prepare for the USMLE, you will be ready with
a strong foundation.
Make a Schedule
After you have defined your goals, map out a study schedule that is consistent
with your objectives, your vacation time, the difficulty of your ongoing
coursework, and your family and social commitments (see Figure 4).
Determine whether you want to spread out your study time or concentrate it
into 14-hour study days in the final weeks. Then factor in your own history in
Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept
`` Customize your schedule. Tackle your weakest
2019 2020
section first.
Typically, US medical schools allot between four and eight weeks for
dedicated Step 1 preparation. The time you dedicate to exam preparation
will depend on your target score as well as your success in preparing yourself
during the first two years of medical school. Some students reserve about a
week at the end of their study period for final review; others save just a few
days. When you have scheduled your exam date, do your best to adhere to it.
Studies show that a later testing date does not translate into a higher score, so
avoid pushing back your test date without good reason.15
Make your schedule realistic, and set achievable goals. Many students make
the mistake of studying at a level of detail that requires too much time for a
comprehensive review—reading Gray’s Anatomy in a couple of days is not a
realistic goal! Have one catch-up day per week of studying. No matter how
well you stick to your schedule, unexpected events happen. But don’t let
yourself procrastinate because you have catch-up days; stick to your schedule
as closely as possible and revise it regularly on the basis of your actual
progress. Be careful not to lose focus. Beware of feelings of inadequacy when
comparing study schedules and progress with your peers. Avoid others who
stress you out. Focus on a few top-rated resources that suit your learning
style—not on some obscure books your friends may pass down to you.
Accept the fact that you cannot learn it all.
You will need time for uninterrupted and focused study. Plan your `` Avoid burnout. Maintain proper diet, exercise,
personal affairs to minimize crisis situations near the date of the test. Allot and sleep habits.
an adequate number of breaks in your study schedule to avoid burnout.
Maintain a healthy lifestyle with proper diet, exercise, and sleep.
Year(s) Prior
The knowledge you gained during your first two years of medical school and
even during your undergraduate years should provide the groundwork on
which to base your test preparation. Student scores on NBME subject tests
(commonly known as “shelf exams”) have been shown to be highly correlated
`` Buy review books early (first year) and use
with subsequent Step 1 scores.16 Moreover, undergraduate science GPAs
while studying for courses.
as well as MCAT scores are strong predictors of performance on the Step 1
exam.17
We also recommend that you buy highly rated review books early in your first
year of medical school and use them as you study throughout the two years.
When Step 1 comes along, these books will be familiar and personalized to the
way in which you learn. It is risky and intimidating to use unfamiliar review
books in the final two or three weeks preceding the exam. Some students find
it helpful to personalize and annotate First Aid throughout the curriculum.
Months Prior
Review test dates and the application procedure. Testing for the USMLE
Step 1 is done on a year-round basis. If you have disabilities or special
circumstances, contact the NBME as early as possible to discuss test
accommodations (see the Section I Supplement at www.firstaidteam.com/
bonus).
`` Simulate the USMLE Step 1 under “real” Use this time to finalize your ideal schedule. Consider upcoming breaks
conditions before beginning your studies. and whether you want to relax or study. Work backward from your test date
to make sure you finish at least one question bank. Also add time to redo
missed or flagged questions (which may be half the bank). This is the time to
build a structured plan with enough flexibility for the realities of life.
Begin doing blocks of questions from reputable question banks under “real”
conditions. Don’t use tutor mode until you’re sure you can finish blocks
in the allotted time. It is important to continue balancing success in your
normal studies with the Step 1 test preparation process.
Make sure you have your CIN (found on your scheduling permit) as well
as other items necessary for the day of the examination, including a current
driver’s license or another form of photo ID with your signature (make sure
the name on your ID exactly matches that on your scheduling permit).
Confirm the Prometric testing center location and test time. Work out how
you will get to the testing center and what parking and traffic problems you
might encounter. Drive separately from other students taking the test on
the same day, and exchange cell phone numbers in case of emergencies.
If possible, visit the testing site to get a better idea of the testing conditions `` One week before the test:
you will face. Determine what you will do for lunch. Make sure you have Sleep according to the same schedule you’ll
everything you need to ensure that you will be comfortable and alert at the use on test day
test site. It may be beneficial to adjust your schedule to start waking up at Review the CBT tutorial one last time
the same time that you will on your test day. And of course, make sure to Call Prometric to confirm test date and time
maintain a healthy lifestyle and get enough sleep.
Try your best to relax and rest the night before the test. Double-check your
admissions and test-taking materials as well as the comfort measures discussed
earlier so that you will not have to deal with such details on the morning of
the exam. At this point it will be more effective to review short-term memory
material that you’re already familiar with than to try to learn new material.
The Rapid Review section at the end of this book is high yield for last-minute
studying. Remember that regardless of how hard you have studied, you cannot
know everything. There will be things on the exam that you have never even
seen before, so do not panic. Do not underestimate your abilities.
Many students report difficulty sleeping the night prior to the exam. This
is often exacerbated by going to bed much earlier than usual. Do whatever
it takes to ensure a good night’s sleep (eg, massage, exercise, warm milk,
no back-lit screens at night). Do not change your daily routine prior to the
exam. Exam day is not the day for a caffeine-withdrawal headache.
`` Arrive at the testing center 30 minutes before that will allow you to remain comfortable and to concentrate. Get to know
your scheduled exam time. If you arrive your testing station, especially if you have never been in a Prometric testing
more than half an hour late, you will not be center before. Listen to your proctors regarding any changes in instructions
allowed to take the test. or testing procedures that may apply to your test site.
After you have completed the exam, be sure to have fun and relax regardless
of how you may feel. Taking the test is an achievement in itself. Remember,
you are much more likely to have passed than not. Enjoy the free time
you have before your clerkships. Expect to experience some “reentry”
phenomena as you try to regain a real life. Once you have recovered
sufficiently from the test (or from partying), we invite you to send us your
feedback, corrections, and suggestions for entries, facts, mnemonics,
strategies, resource ratings, and the like (see p. xvii, How to Contribute).
Sharing your experience will benefit fellow medical students and IMGs.
STUDY MATERIALS
``
Quality Considerations
Certain review books are too detailed to allow for review in a reasonable
amount of time or cover subtopics that are not emphasized on the exam.
Many sample question books were originally written years ago and have
not been adequately updated to reflect recent trends.
Some question banks test to a level of detail that you will not find on the
exam.
`` If a given review book is not working for you,
stop using it no matter how highly rated it Review Books
may be or how much it costs.
In selecting review books, be sure to weigh different opinions against each
other, read the reviews and ratings in Section IV of this guide, examine the
books closely in the bookstore, and choose carefully. You are investing not
only money but also your limited study time. Do not worry about finding
the “perfect” book, as many subjects simply do not have one, and different
students prefer different formats. Supplement your chosen books with personal
notes from other sources, including what you learn from question banks.
Apps
Practice Tests
Additionally, some students preparing for the Step 1 exam have started to
incorporate case-based books intended primarily for clinical students on the
wards or studying for the Step 2 CK exam. First Aid Cases for the USMLE
Step 1 aims to directly address this need.
After taking a practice test, spend time on each question and each answer
choice whether you were right or wrong. There are important teaching
points in each explanation. Knowing why a wrong answer choice is incorrect
is just as important as knowing why the right answer is correct. Do not panic `` Use practice tests to identify concepts and
if your practice scores are low as many questions try to trick or distract you to areas of weakness, not just facts that you
highlight a certain point. Use the questions you missed or were unsure about missed.
to develop focused plans during your scheduled catch-up time.
Limit your use of textbooks and course syllabi for Step 1 review. Many
textbooks are too detailed for high-yield review and include material that
is generally not tested on the USMLE Step 1 (eg, drug dosages, complex
chemical structures). Syllabi, although familiar, are inconsistent across
TEST-TAKING STRATEGIES
``
Pacing
You have seven hours to complete up to 280 questions. Note that each one-
hour block contains up to 40 questions. This works out to approximately
90 seconds per question. We recommend following the “1 minute rule” to pace
yourself. Spend no more than 1 minute on each question. If you are still unsure
about the answer after this time, mark the question, make an educated guess,
and move on. Following this rule, you should have approximately 20 minutes
left after all questions are answered, which you can use to revisit all of your
marked questions. Remember that some questions may be experimental
and do not count for points (and reassure yourself that these experimental
questions are the ones that are stumping you). In the past, pacing errors have
`` Time management is an important skill for
been detrimental to the performance of even highly prepared examinees. The
exam success.
bottom line is to keep one eye on the clock at all times!
FOOTNOTES:
[11] Even M. Hamel admits this (Hist. de Robespierre, III. p. 499
et seq.), although he endeavours, in a manner that is not
convincing, to throw the responsibility on to Carnot. Carnot
claimed to have saved Hoche's life. He certainly joined in ordering
his release from prison almost immediately after Robespierre's
fall.
[12] Robespierre himself said, on the 8th Thermidor, that for the
last six weeks he had 'absolutely abandoned his functions as a
member of the Committee of Public Safety.' Louis Blanc argues
that he was therefore not responsible for the Terror. But another
of Robespierre's admirers, Hamel, has taken pains to prove that
Robespierre was constantly present at the Committee's meetings
up to the 9th Thermidor, and decides that his alleged retirement
must consequently have been 'toute morale' (vol. III. pp. 594-
601).
CHAPTER XI.
The Reaction.
With the fall of Robespierre the Terror came to an end. The men
who overthrew him were many of them worse men than he. They did
not intend to repudiate his system. They had acted from personal
motives, from a desire to save their lives and to maintain themselves
in power. But without Robespierre the Terror could not continue. It
was his reputation for moral earnestness and for disinterested
conviction which alone had reconciled to it many honest, narrow-
minded men, who accepted his theory, believed in his sincerity, and
had not the capacity to criticise his actions. In him and his associates
the principles of the Terror perished. There remained no one to throw
over the system the veil of sentimental virtue, and without that veil its
uglier aspects stood disclosed. Men who to the last had respected
Robespierre could not respect Collot d'Herbois or Billaud-Varennes.
The Convention which had revolted against Robespierre was not
likely, when once it had tasted freedom, to replace on its neck the
yoke of his colleagues. The Committee of Public Safety had
appeared irresistible so long as it was undivided. But when it broke
up into parties and appealed to the Convention to protect it, its
dictatorship necessarily expired.
Accordingly, in the weeks which followed the 9th Thermidor, a
number of measures testified to the growing reaction. The
Committee of Public Safety was remodelled, and a system was
enforced under which three of its members retired, without the right
of re-election, every month. The Convention and its Committees
resumed the powers of government. The Revolutionary Tribunal was
reconstituted and the law of the 22nd Prairial repealed. The
redoubtable Commune was abolished, and for purposes of local
government Paris was placed under the authority of the Department
of the Seine. The staff of the National Guard was reorganised. The
Revolutionary Committees in Paris and elsewhere were reduced in
number and shorn of their powers. The meetings of the Sections
were limited to three a month, and the decree which provided a
payment of forty sous for all citizens who attended them was
repealed. In the departments the officials of the Communes and of
the Clubs were sifted and replaced. Everywhere the prison doors
were opened and hundreds of prisoners were set free. Before the
end of August, voices were raised in the Convention against the
Terrorists who continued in the Government, and at the beginning of
September, Billaud-Varennes, Collot d'Herbois and the remaining
Terrorists retired.
As the autumn went on, the pace of the reaction increased. The
Jacobins, it is true, were still numerous and active. Although the
reputation of the leading Terrorists was shaken, the Mountain was
still a force in the Convention. Besides the members of the old
Committees, many deputies, like Romme and Soubrany, Goujon and
Bourbotte, maintained without flinching extreme Jacobin views.
Others, like Thuriot and Cambon, were not prepared to go too far
with the reaction. The Jacobin Club, though weakened by the fall of
Robespierre, had resumed its old activity, and, supported by some of
its confederates in the provinces, determined not to surrender its
power without a struggle. Billaud-Varennes declared passionately
that the old lion was not dead. But the tide flowed heavily against the
Mountain. The majority of the Convention was determined at all
costs to break with the system of the Terror. The deputies of the
Right and of the Centre recovered their voices under the courageous
leadership of Boissy-d'Anglas and Thibeaudeau. The Thermidorians,
under Tallien and Fréron, rallied to the side of the moderate
members, and gathered round them many old Dantonists and many
old adherents of the Mountain, Legendre, Lecointre and Bourdon de
l'Oise, Merlin of Thionville and Merlin of Douai, Cambacères, and
André Dumont. Sieyès, released from the necessity of silence,
brought to the same side his affectation of inscrutable wisdom.
Encouraged by the divisions in the Assembly, public opinion
expressed itself outside. The independence of the Press revived.
Fréron's paper, the Orateur du Peuple boldly took the lead of the
reactionary journals. The trial of the prisoners sent up from Nantes to
be tried at Paris revealed for the first time to the public the worst
iniquities of Carrier's rule, and in the weeks and months which
followed, evidence began to pour in against the agents of the Terror.
The indignation against the Terrorists in Paris increased every day.
Reactionary feeling showed itself overwhelmingly strong in the
Sections, in the cafés, in the streets. Bodies of young men, some of
them men of family and wealth, but most of them drawn from the
ranks of tradesmen, clerks and artisans, representing the great
majority of respectable people which had allowed itself to be
tyrannised over so long, and which had shown its readiness to rise
as early as May, 1793, gathering in the Palais Royal, once the
headquarters of revolutionary agitation, organised themselves into
an effective force, armed themselves with short and heavy sticks,
and led by Lacretelle and encouraged by Fréron and Tallien, began
to parade the streets, to suppress Jacobin speakers and meetings,
to pour contempt on Jacobin opinions, and to wage war against
Jacobinism in whatever shape it might be found. Extravagant and
ridiculous in some respects the 'Jeunes Gens' were, and in later
days it suited the Thermidorians to turn their affectation into ridicule,
and to denounce them as 'Jeunesse Dorée,' as 'Elégants' and
Muscadins.' But in their origin at any rate they represented a genuine
popular movement, and up to April, 1795, they acted cordially with
the moderate party, and rendered valuable service in destroying the
terrorism which the Jacobins had established in Paris. With the new
movement a new song came into fashion, and the Jeunes Gens,
rejecting the Marseillaise, sang in the streets the 'Réveil du Peuple':
—
'Quelle est cette lenteur barbare?
Hâte-toi, peuple souverain,
De rendre aux monstres de Ténare
Tous ces buveurs de sang humain.'
The reaction in Paris soon made itself felt in the Assembly. The
attacks upon the Terrorists and their supporters redoubled. In
October a law was passed forbidding the federation of popular clubs.
On the 12th November, the Committee of Public Safety announced
that it had closed the Jacobin Club. In the same month Carrier was
arrested. He was sent for trial before the Revolutionary Tribunal and
a few weeks later to the scaffold. On the 8th December, the seventy-
three deputies who had been imprisoned for protesting against the
expulsion of the Gironde, were readmitted to their places in the
Convention. At the end of that month the Assembly decided that
there was ground for investigating the charges against Billaud-
Varennes, Collot d'Herbois, Vadier and Barère. As the winter went
on, the members of the Right, reinforced by the seventy-three, and
determined to undo the work of the Terror, demanded a
reconsideration of the laws against Emigrants and priests, and the
restoration in certain cases of property confiscated for political
offences. In February, 1795, the Convention decreed the freedom of
all forms of religious opinion; but at the same time it continued the
penal enactments against non-juring priests, imposed a variety of
restrictions on the exercise of public worship, and, while refusing to
contribute towards the maintenance of any religion, retained its hold
upon the buildings and property of the old Church. A further advance
made in June towards the principles of complete toleration was
afterwards repealed by the influence of the Left. On the 2nd March,
Legendre carried a motion for the arrest of Billaud-Varennes, Collot
d'Herbois, Vadier and Barère. On the 8th, the survivors of the
Girondist leaders proscribed on the 31st May, including Isnard,
Lanjuinais and Louvet, were recalled to their seats in the Assembly.
The triumph of the reaction seemed to be assured.
But the Jacobins were not to fall without a struggle. They had more
than once secured the victory by appealing to the physical
necessities of the poor, and it was by that means that they
endeavoured to conquer again. In the spring of 1795 the distress in
Paris was exceptionally keen. With the political reaction an economic
reaction had begun. After Thermidor it became evident that the
economic system of the Terror could not stand. Its drastic laws were
on all sides disregarded. No penalties or prohibitions could force
men to observe laws which they were resolutely determined to
infringe. The State might fix the price of food, but the producers
would not produce it at that price, and when the guillotine had
ceased to compel submission, the vain attempts of the State to fix
prices broke down. Economic causes more powerful than any laws
overthrew the Maximum, and at last, towards the end of December,
the Convention recognised the fact and repealed the Maximum
decrees. With the repeal of the Maximum the whole system of
Terrorist finance collapsed. The practice of requisition was
abandoned. The restrictions upon foreign trade and upon the
exportation of specie were removed. In a short time the Bourse was
reopened. The intrepid experiment by which the economists of the
Terror had endeavoured to concentrate in the hands of the
Government the whole commercial system of the country, fell to the
ground, and the old methods of monopoly and competition, which
the Terrorists had so constantly denounced, and which they had so
boldly but recklessly attacked, reasserted their sway and exacted
their penalty. The financial system of the Terror was ruinously
mistaken, but by its draconian methods it had to some extent
checked the rise in prices, and had perhaps saved from extinction
the vanishing credit of the Assignats. Yet even under the Terror the
Assignats had deteriorated in value. In spite of the imperious
demands of the Terrorist Exchequer, in spite of its forced loans and
wholesale confiscations, in spite of the plunder which it drew from its
victims and of the money which, as Barère boasted, it coined on the
Place de la Révolution, the Jacobin Government had never been
free from financial troubles. The non-payment of taxes, the
peculation of local authorities, the failure of the forced loans to bring
in anything like the sum expected, the depreciation in value of
national property, the ignorance of economics which prevailed
among the ruling party, and above all the enormous expenses of the
war, of the administration, and of supplying Paris and the great
towns with food, had created a perpetual deficit. 'The Revolution and
the war,' said Cambon, the chief financier of the Terror, in a report of
January, 1795, 'have cost in four years five thousand three hundred
and fifty millions above the ordinary expenses;' and Cambon's
estimate was probably much below the fact. In vain had Cambon by
a partial bankruptcy put out of circulation fifteen hundred million
francs of Assignats which bore the image of the King. In vain had the
Convention, in August 1794, decreed, on Cambon's proposal, the
Republicanisation of the National Debt, ordered all the creditors of
the State to send in their claims, entered their titles in a Great Ledger
of the Public Debt, declared the capital borrowed by the State to be
irrecoverable, and, regardless of all engagements entered into and
of all promises of high interest previously made, informed them that
in future the State would pay five per cent interest to all its creditors
alike. This summary method of escaping liabilities had introduced, it
is true, some order into the finances, but it had not improved the
credit of the State. The chief resource of the Government had
continued to be the Assignats, and not even the drastic legislation of
the Terror had been able to keep their credit up.
The repeal of that drastic legislation and the financial policy of the
Convention in the winter of 1794-95 accelerated their decline[13].
Prices, no longer fixed by law, rose rapidly, as the value of the paper
money fell. The Government, no longer able to rely on the methods
which the Terrorists had used to swell their income, and face to face
with high prices and diminishing credit, could think of no better
resource than to issue Assignats faster than before; and of course
with every fresh issue the depreciation increased. At the end of
1794, some seven thousand million francs of Assignats were in
circulation. In May, 1795, these had risen to ten thousand millions, in
the August following, to sixteen thousand millions, and in the
October following that, to many thousand millions more. In proportion
to these enormous issues, the value of the currency declined. At the
end of the reign of Terror, Assignats had been worth 33 or 34 per
cent of their nominal value. In December, 1794, they had fallen to 22
per cent. In the ensuing May they stood at 7 per cent, and in the
months which followed they fell to 4, to 2, and even to less than 1
per cent. In vain different members of the Convention proposed
schemes for diminishing the number. The Government had no other
resource to look to, and its expenses seemed daily to increase, as
claims for compensation poured in upon it from those who had
suffered under the Terror. With the fall of the Assignats, prices rose
to an alarming height. All wage-earners who could not raise their
wages in proportion to the rapid rise in prices, all who lived upon
fixed incomes, all who depended on the paper-money and whose
small savings consisted of Assignats, suffered acutely from the
economic crisis. A certain number of people, tenant farmers for
instance, who paid their rent in Assignats, and who made it many
times over by the high prices fetched by corn, debtors who could pay
off long-standing debts in Assignats at their nominal value, and
speculators, who sprang up on all sides to traffic in the fluctuations of
the currency, made heavy profits and enriched themselves. But to
the great majority of people the fall of the Assignats meant grave
distress. The prices of bread, of meat, of fuel, of all the necessaries
of life, rose as in a siege. One reads of the most fantastic payments,
of thousands of francs paid for a dinner, a cab-fare or a load of
wood. The sense of the value of money vanished, when its
purchasing power declined every day. But it was only those who had
plenty of it who possessed the power to purchase at all.
There is overwhelming evidence of the general distress in the winter
of 1794-95. From all sides complaints came in of the exorbitant
dearness of food, and that trouble was aggravated by the intense
cold. In Paris and many great cities the authorities bought up food at
ruinous prices and distributed it in meagre rations to the poor. But as
the year advanced, these rations constantly diminished. The country
districts bitterly complained that they were starved in order that the
big towns might be fed. 'Many families, entire communes,' wrote an
official from Laon, in the summer of 1795, 'have been without bread
two or three months and are living on bran or herbs.' Around Caen
the peasants were living on unripe peas, beans and green barley. In
Picardy 'the great majority of people' overran the woods for food.
From all sides the same reports poured in upon the Government.
'Yesterday,' wrote the authorities of Montreuil-sur-Mer, 'more than
two hundred of our citizens set out to beg in the country;' and those
who could not get food in other ways took it by force. Nor, in spite of
the efforts of the authorities, were the large towns better off. Lyons,
in January, was without bread 'for five full days.' At Troyes, in March,
the public distribution of bread fell to two ounces a day. At Amiens, a
few months later, it ceased altogether. At Nancy a traveller noticed a
crowd of 'three thousand persons imploring in vain a few pounds of
flour.' In Paris the police reported case after case of misery and
starvation. 'Every day,' wrote a friend to Mallet du Pan, 'I see people
of the poorer class dying of starvation in the streets.... Workmen
generally have to work short time, owing to the weakness and
exhaustion caused by want of food.'
It is no wonder if this acute distress resulted in an outbreak. Many of
those who suffered the most had sympathised with the Jacobin party,
and the arrest of the Terrorist leaders gave a certain political colour
to the agitation which famine had produced. But in the main the
insurrection which broke out on the 12th Germinal (1st April), which
for a time threatened the safety of the Convention, and which joined
to its demand for bread a demand for the Constitution of '93, was a
spontaneous movement due to the pressure of starvation rather than
to political intrigue. The leaders of the Mountain failed to turn it to
account. The Jeunes Gens and the battalions of the Sections
enabled the Government to win an easy victory, and the failure of the
rising helped the reaction on. Motions were quickly passed for the
transportation of Billaud-Varennes, Collot d'Herbois, Vadier and
Barère, and for the arrest of Cambon, Thuriot, Amar, and other
prominent members of the Mountain. Pichegru restored order in the
streets. The Convention decreed the disarming of the Terrorists and
the reorganisation of the National Guard. The officials of the
Departments and of the Districts were restored to their old authority.
The State, which had already undertaken to pay the debts of
Emigrants whose possessions it had confiscated, now resolved to
restore to the families of the victims the property of all persons who
had been executed for political offences since the 10th March, 1793.
A commission of eleven members was appointed to consider the
bases of a new constitution. Early in May, Fouquier-Tinville and
several of his associates in the old Tribunal were sent to the
guillotine.
But the Jacobins were not yet silenced. The rapid progress of the
reaction disquieted many. The reappearance of Emigrants and of
non-juring priests, the extravagance of the Jeunes Gens, the revival
of Royalist opinions in Paris, the terrible excesses which began to
stain the reaction in the South-East of France, and which, under the
direction of the 'Compagnies de Jésus' and the 'Compagnies du Sol,'
had already made Lyons the scene of murder and of civil war,
alarmed the Thermidorians and many other members of the
Convention. The majority oscillated from day to day between their
fear of the Mountain and their fear of a Royalist reaction, and
displayed to all the world the vacillation and weakness of the ruling
powers in France. At the beginning of May, the Jacobins so far
prevailed as to carry a decree for the immediate arrest of returned
Emigrants and refractory priests, and for the prosecution of Royalist
publications. The disarming of Terrorists practically ceased. The high
prices of food and the distress which they occasioned became more
serious every day, and Jacobin agents laboured persistently to rouse
the workmen to another insurrection. On the 1st Prairial (20th May),
their efforts succeeded. A second rising, more formidable and better
organised than that of Germinal, confronted the Government, and
the Convention, after a sharp struggle, only saved itself by yielding to
the demands of the insurrectionary leaders. Fair promises, however,
gained the Assembly time to bring up troops for its defence. On the
evening of the 22nd May, a strong force of cavalry and infantry
arrived in Paris. The next day, the Faubourg St. Antoine was
besieged and compelled to surrender at discretion. Numerous
arrests were made. The disarming of the Terrorists was completed.
All pikes were seized. The reorganisation of the National Guard was
accomplished, and the right of serving in it was once more restricted
to members of the bourgeois class. A temporary military commission
was established to try those accused of complicity in the
insurrection, and the Revolutionary Tribunal was abolished. Six
prominent deputies of the Mountain, including Goujon, Romme,
Soubrany and Bourbotte, were sent to the scaffold. Lebon, long
since put under arrest, Panis, almost forgotten, Lindet, Jean Bon St.
André, Guffroy and Rühl, all except three of the members of the two
redoubtable Committees, Pache, Bouchotte, and several of their
associates in the former Ministry of War, shared in the proscription of
their party. The influence of the extreme Jacobins was finally
destroyed, and once again the policy of the reaction triumphed.
The decisive success of the moderate party was not without its effect
upon European politics. At the time of the insurrection of Prairial, the
French arms were completely victorious and many had begun to
hope for the cessation of the war. The history of the revolutionary
armies is the finest part of the French Revolution. There the spirit
which the Revolution had inspired, and which had spent itself so
fruitlessly in Paris, was seen at its best in the enthusiasm, the
devotion and the gallantry of the troops. There too the high qualities
of the Jacobin administrators appeared, their determined patriotism,
their dauntless vigour and resource. There the Government which in
Paris seemed to be only a Government of tyrants, revealed itself as
a Government of heroes. There the politicians and intriguers of the
Terror turned to the nobler work of national defence. Carnot and St.
Just, Merlin of Thionville, Rewbell and Barras, Milhaud and
Soubrany, Richard, Drouet, Cavaignac and Fabre d'Hérault are only
some among the many brave men who, as Representatives on
Mission with the armies, inspired the French troops with their own
lofty courage, and both by precept and example taught them the
impossibility of defeat. The enthusiasm which political intrigues had
wasted found a deeper expression in the war, and the levelling
freedom of the Republic threw open to all ranks alike the prospects
of a great career. In the campaigns of 1793-94, Hoche, Pichegru and
Jourdan had already reached the highest place, and Moreau and
Kléber, Bernadotte, Ney, Davoût, Augereau and Victor, Soult,
Masséna, Bonaparte were winning their way to notice and
command. It is true that at the first the French levies were ill-
organised and ill-disciplined, and that their earlier successes were
due chiefly to the disunion or incapacity of their opponents. But the
progress of the war and the vigorous measures of the Jacobin
Government soon produced a remarkable change. There was no
lack of material upon which to draw. To the old royal army there had
in turn been added the battalions of national guards, the volunteers
raised in 1792, the levée en masse of the same year, which was,
however, of very little use, the levy of 300,000 men formed, largely
by conscription, in the spring of 1793, and the forces raised in the
following summer by the imperious decrees of the Government,
which claimed the services of all men between the ages of eighteen
and twenty-five. On this material the Convention set to work, and the
efforts of Dubois-Crancé and Carnot, seconded by their able
advisers, and perfected by the strenuous action and wide powers of
the great Committee, met with complete success. To Dubois-Crancé
especially belongs the credit. It was he who, in the winter of 1793-94,
at last carried through the Convention the great scheme for the
reorganisation of the army which he had advocated so long, who
committed the Government to the principle of conscription and to the
amalgamation of the regulars with the volunteers, and who fused the
two elements together by dividing the army into demi-brigades made
up of one battalion of regulars and four of volunteers. The result of
these measures appeared before long in the formation of a
magnificent army, which for numbers, discipline and the spirit of its
troops, was a match for the united forces of Europe.
The campaign of 1793, which at one time threatened France with
serious danger, ended in complete success. The valuable victories of
Houchard and of Jourdan on the North-Eastern frontier in September
and October, drove the Allies back upon Belgium. The equally
notable successes of Hoche and Pichegru, which followed in Alsace,
drove the victorious Austrians and Prussians again across the Rhine.
The brave insurgents of La Vendée found themselves at last
opposed by a powerful army under a general of high ability, and
were defeated by Kléber at Chollet in October, and subsequently
routed at Le Mans. By the end of the year France had ten armies for
service in the field and an effective force of some six hundred
thousand men. On the North-East, four armies, those of the Rhine,
of the Moselle, of the Ardennes, and of the North, stretched from
Strasbourg to the sea. Further to the South, the army of the Alps
occupied Savoy, and the army of Italy, which had just reduced
Toulon, waited for a new commander to launch it on an illustrious
career. In the West, two more armies held the Pyrenees, and a third
watched the insurgents of La Vendée; while on the Northern coast,
the army of Normandy, not yet organised into a definite force,
guarded the sea-board and dreamed vainly of invading England.
With these resources the Allies could not compete. But even had the
troops been forthcoming, their disunion would have rendered victory
impossible. In 1794, when France was preparing with the brightest
prospects to reopen the campaign, the long-standing jealousy
between Austria and Prussia reached its climax. Thugut, the Austrian
minister, disliked his Prussian allies even more than his French
enemies, and carrying to an extreme pitch the traditional selfishness
of Austrian policy, intrigued on all sides for territorial
aggrandisement, and meditated schemes for extending the Austrian
dominions in every quarter of Europe, in Flanders and Alsace, in
Turkey and Poland, in Bavaria and Venice. In the North, Russia drew
nearer every day to the completion of her long-prepared attack on
Polish freedom, and Prussia, determined not to be left aside when
her rivals shared the spoils of Poland, turned her attention and her
energies towards the Vistula, when the sympathies of her king would
gladly have turned towards the Rhine. In vain the English
Government threw itself with fresh energy into the war, laboured to
draw the coalition together, and promised generous supplies. In
April, 1794, at the very moment when Malmesbury, the English
envoy at the Hague, was pledging England, Holland and Prussia to
renewed efforts in the war with France, the Polish revolt broke out at
Warsaw, and Kosciusko's brave struggle for freedom diverted the
attention of the Central Powers. It was evident that until the Polish
question was settled, neither Prussia nor Austria would act with
vigour against the French. Accordingly, the French armies on the
North-Eastern frontier, now under the command of Pichegru and
Jourdan, advanced against the divided Allies, defeated them at
Turcoign and Fleurus, and entered Brussels on the 11th July. The
conquest of Belgium and the invasion of Holland followed. While
Suvórof stamped out the insurrection in Poland, and Austria and
Russia drew up plans for the partition of that unhappy country, to
which Prussia was afterwards compelled to accede, the French
troops advanced into Holland, drove the Prince of Orange into flight
and occupied the Hague and Amsterdam. At last Prussia, isolated
and alarmed, consented to open negotiations, and on the 5th April,
she definitely separated herself from Austria, and made peace with
France in the Treaty of Bâle.
There were many who hoped that the Treaty of Bâle might prove the
beginning of a general peace, and so prepare the way for a Royalist
restoration. The fresh disturbances among the peasants of La
Vendée and their allies the Chouans of Brittany, which had been
provoked in 1794 by the merciless policy of the Republic, by
Turreau's 'Hellish Columns' and by Carrier's tyranny at Nantes, had
been quieted, in the spring of 1795, by the conciliatory policy of the
Republican generals, and the long struggle in the West seemed to
be drawing to a close. In the Pyrenees the advance of the French
brought the Spanish Government to terms, and a peace between
France and Spain was concluded in July. In Paris the suppression of
the insurrection of Prairial had raised very high the hopes of the
Royalists. Many things seemed to point towards the restoration of
the Constitution of '91, which at that time, as at an earlier date,
would probably have satisfied the wishes of the majority of the
nation. But events ordered otherwise. The high demands of the
French Government, the vigour of English diplomacy, and the
settlement of the Polish difficulty, which left the Emperor free to act,
disappointed the expectations of a general peace. In the summer of
1795, England, Russia and Austria drew closer together and formed
a fresh alliance for the prosecution of the war. Early in June, the
unhappy little Dauphin died in prison, and his death dealt a heavy
blow to the hopes of the Constitutional party. Many who would have
welcomed the son of Louis XVI as Constitutional King, could not
reconcile themselves to the restoration of the Comte de Provence,
the chief of the Emigrants in arms against France, the prince who,
learning nothing from adversity, still condemned in the bitterest
language all the changes which the Revolution had introduced, and
still denounced as an enemy of the Bourbons every advocate of
moderation or of liberal ideas. The French people had not made the
Revolution in order to restore the Ancien Régime. The attempt of the
Emigrants to renew the war in the West by an ill-timed descent upon
Quiberon, although stamped out by Hoche in July, and punished with
terrible severity by the Convention, revived the deep-seated hostility
which all friends of the Revolution entertained towards the
Emigrants. The fresh tidings which came in from the South of terrible
excesses committed in the name of the reaction at Marseilles and
Avignon, Tarascon and Aix, tended to check the flowing tide. The
rapid advance of Royalist opinions in Paris, and the threatening
demeanour of the Jeunes Gens and of the Sections at length
alarmed the Thermidorians. The members of the Convention
recalled to themselves that they were committed to the measures of
the Revolution, and began to fear lest the march of events should
carry them too far and involve them in a policy perilous to
themselves.
Finally the Convention chose a middle course. The Constitution of
1795 retained the Republican form, and divided the supreme
executive power among a Directory of five persons. The legislative
power it committed to a Parliament consisting of two Houses, a
Council of Five Hundred, who must be over thirty years of age, and a
Council of Ancients, who must be over forty. The Parliament was to
elect the Directory, but the functions of each were strictly defined; the
legislative and the executive powers were kept jealously distinct, and
cordial co-operation between them was rendered almost impossible.
The Convention had learned from the experience of the past the
necessity of making the Executive strong, but it had not yet learned
the folly of making the legislature and the Executive independent
rivals instead of harmonious allies. The new Parliament was to last
for three years, but one-third of its members were renewable yearly.
Apart from these new regulations, the Convention, rejecting a series
of fantastic proposals brought forward by Sieyès, adhered to the
main lines of the Constitution of 1791. The system of double election
was re-established. The franchise was limited by a slight property
qualification. In the local administration the division into Departments
and Communes was retained. But the Communes were strictly
subordinated to the Departments, the Districts were abolished
altogether, and the numbers and powers of the officials were so
reduced, as to simplify the whole system, and to increase the
authority of the central Government. Other articles established
freedom of worship, the freedom of labour, and the freedom of the
Press, prohibited political clubs and federations, and forbade the
return of the Emigrants to France.
But although the majority of the Convention yielded to the demand
for the establishment of a settled Government, they had no wish to
extinguish themselves. They knew that in the existing temper of the
nation they had little chance of being returned to power, and they
feared the lengths to which the reaction might run. Accordingly, they
proceeded to apply at once the principles laid down by the new
constitution for the renewal of the legislative body, and by the