San Beda University

College of Law

COURSE SYLLABUS

COURSE CODE:
COURSE TITLE: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW AND LAW ON PUBLIC
OFFICERS

COURSE CREDIT: 2 UNITS

COURSE PREREQUISITE/S: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW I
FACULTY: ATTY. RANDOLPH A. PASCASIO
ATTY. ANTONIO EDUARDO S. NACHURA, JR.
ATTY. ALGIE KWILLON B. MARIACOS
EMAIL ADDRESS: rpascasio@sanbeda.edu.ph
aenachura@sanbeda.edu.ph
akbmariacos@yahoo.com

TERM/ACADEMIC YEAR: SECOND SEMESTER - SCHOOL YEAR 2023-2024

DAY/TIME/ROOM/SECTION:
COURSE DELIVERY MODE: IN-PERSON CLASSES
CONSULTATION DAY/TIME:

COURSE DESCRIPTION:

A comprehensive study of the legal framework surrounding: (a) the creation, powers, and
effects of actions of administrative agencies and (b) the qualifications, rights, duties,
liabilities of public officers and their separation from service.

COURSE GOALS: Expected College of Law Graduate Attributes (ELGAs)

Know and understand the relevant provisions of the 1987 Constitution, the Administrative
Code, Republic Act 6713 otherwise known as the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards
for Public Officers and Employees, relevant civil service laws, and other related
administrative laws and rules on public officers; memorize provisions, critical and
analytical thinking, effective in written and oral communication, logical reasoning, and
sound judgment, exercise of proper professional and ethical responsibilities.

LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES (LOs):

1. Knowledge/Remembering: define, list, recognize

2. Comprehension/Understanding: describe, explain, identify, recognize
3. Application/Applying: choose, demonstrate, implement, perform
4. Analysis/Analyzing: analyze, categorize, compare, differentiate
5. Evaluation/Evaluating: assess, critique, evaluate, rank, rate
6. Synthesis/Creating: construct, design, formulate, organize, synthesize

Upon completion of the Administrative Law, Law of Public Officers, Election Law and Law of Public
Corporations course, the student is expected to be able to:

Expected College of
Law Graduate LEARNING OUTCOMES (LOs)
Attributes (ELGAs)
Critical and analytical LO1. Explain, during class recitation and discussion the following: (a)
thinking administrative agencies, their powers, and effects thereof and (b) creation,
Effective in written and exercise/powers, and termination of public office.
oral communication LO2. Analyze the practical implications of current and proposed statutes,
Logical reasoning regulations, judicial rulings, legal arguments, and strategies to the workings
Sound judgment and operation of the government.
Exercise of proper LO3. Assess the legality of current and proposed governmental action in
professional and ethical consideration of the policies sought to be achieved.
responsibilities
 LO4. Utilize legal research tools to gather information that aids in the
analysis of legal issues in submitting Position Paper that could serve as a
basis of governmental policies.

ASSESSMENT/GRADING SYSTEM:

The student will be graded according to the following:

Percentage
Scope of Work (Weight is based
Requirements (Based on the Learning Outcomes)
(Individual) on the importance
of the LO)
LO1 Class recitations, Quizzes, Case Digests, Individual
LO2 and discussion Individual
LO3 Individual
LO4 - - Research Paper, Case Study Individual

Class standing before Midterms Individual 16.67%

Midterm Exams Individual 16.67%
Class Standing after Midterms Individual 33.33%
Final Exams Individual 33.33%
TOTAL 100

LEARNING PLAN:

LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)

Course Introduction
 Course overview Syllabus Week 1 Lecture
 Course assignments Discussion
 Course requirements

2
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
MODULE 1: Weeks 1-2  Recitation
• Textbooks  Case study &
reporting
General Principles of
• Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
Administrative Law
 Quiz
1. Solid Homes vs. Payawal,
A. Administrative Law G.R. No. 84811, 29
August 1989
1. Definitions (Frank 2. Christian Gen. Assembly
Goodnow; Dean vs. Ignacio, G.R. No.
Nathan Roscoe Pound) 164789, 27 August 2009
2. Kinds 3. Dadubo vs. CSC, G.R.
3. Evolution (Origin and No. 106498, 28 June 1993
Development) 4. Lianga Bay vs. Judge
4. Criticisms and Enage, G.R. No. L-30637,
Advantages 16 July 1987
5. Malaga vs. Penachos,
B. Administration G.R. No. 86695, 3
September 1992
1. As an institution 6. Beja, Sr. vs. Court of
2. As a function Appeals, G.R. No. 97149,
31 March 1992
C. Administrative 7. Luzon Dev. Bank vs.
Agencies/Bodies ALDBEMP, G.R. No.
120319, 6 October 1995
1. Definition 8. ISA vs. CA, G.R. No.
2. Types 102976, 25 October 1995
3. Organization 9. Eugenio vs. Civil Service
a. Creation Commission, G.R. No.
b. Reorganization 115863, 31 March 1995
c. Abolition 10. PLDT vs. City of
d. De-activation Bacolod, G.R. No.
149179, 15 July 2005
11. Presidential Anti-Dollar
Salting Task Force vs.
Court of Appeals, G.R.
No. L-83578, 16 March
1989
12. Dario vs. Mison, G.R.
No. 81954, 8 August
1989
13. Larin vs. Executive
Secretary, G.R. No.
112745, 16 October 1997
14. Bagaoisan vs. National
Tobacco Authority, G.R.
No. 152845, 5 August
2003
15. Buklod ng Kawaning
EIIB vs. Zamora, G.R.
No. 142801, 10 July 2001

3
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
MODULE 2: Weeks 3-5  Recitation
• Textbooks  Case study &
Part I - Powers of Administrative reporting
Agencies/Bodies • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
A. General Principles 1. The Board of
Commissioners of the
B. Quasi-Legislative or Rule Bureau of Immigration
Making Power and Jail Warden v. Yuan
Wenle, G.R. No. 242957
1. Nature February 2023
2. Kinds 2. Republic v. Drugmakers
3. Requisites for Validity Laboratories, Inc., G.R.
No. 190837, 5 March
2014
3. Holy Spirit Homeowners
Association v. Defensor,
G.R. No. 163980, 3
August 2006
4. Land Bank of the
Philippines v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
118712, 6 October 1995
5. Commissioner of Internal
Revenue v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
108358, 20 January 1995
6. Cruz v. Youngberg, 56
Phil. 234
7. Romulo Mabanta v.
Home Development
Mutual Fund, G.R. No.
131082, 19 June 2000
8. Lupangco v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No. L-
77372, 29 April 1988
9. De Jesus v. Commission
on Audit, G.R. No.
109023, 12 August 1998
10. People v. Maceren, G.R.
No. L-32166, 18 October
1977
11. Commissioner of Internal
Revenue v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
119761, 9 August 1996
12. Philippine Consumers
Foundation v. Secretary
of Education, G.R. No. L-
78385, 31 August 1987
13. Cawad v. Abad, G.R. No.
207145, 28 July 2015
14. Department of Finance v.
Asia United Bank, G.R.

4

TOPIC/CONTENT
(arrangement or sequence of the
major topics is based on a logical
order)
MODULE 3:
Part II - Powers of
Administrative Agencies/Bodies
A. Quasi-Judicial or
Adjudicatory Power
1. Nature
2. Requisites
3. Administrative due
process
4. Determinative Powers
5. Doctrine of Res
Judicata
6. Administrative Appeal
and Review
LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
Nos. 240163 & 240168-
69, 1 December 2021
Week 6-8  Recitation
• Textbooks  Case study &
reporting
• Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
➢ Administrative Due Process
and Exceptions to Notice
and Hearing
15. Ang Tibay v. CIR, 40
O.G. 7th Supp. 129
16. Acuzar v. Jorolan, G.R.
No. 177878, 7 April 2010
17. Carbonell v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
187689, 7 September
2010
18. De la Cruz v. Abille, G.R.
No. 130196, 26 February
2001
19. Vivo v. PAGCOR, G.R.
No. 187854, 12
November 2013
20. Globe Telecom v.
National
Telecommunications
Commission, G.R. No.
143964, 26 July 2004
21. Office of the Ombudsman
v, Manuel Valencia, G.R.
No. 183890, 13 April
2011
22. Barrosco v. Commission
on Audit, G.R. No.
253253, 27 April 2021
➢ Incidental Powers and Res
Judicata
23. Pascual v. Board of
Medical Examiners, 28
SCRA 345
24. Dumarpa v. Dimaporo,
177 SCRA 478
5

TOPIC/CONTENT
(arrangement or sequence of the
major topics is based on a logical
order)
MODULE 4:
Judicial Review of Administrative
Decisions • Supreme Court Decisions:
A. Doctrine of Prior
Resort/Primary Jurisdiction
B. Doctrine of Finality of
Administrative Action
C. Doctrine of Exhaustion of
Administrative Remedies
and Exceptions
D. Judicial Review
1. Rule and Exceptions
2. Methods of Judicial
Review
3. Jurisdiction
4. Questions Reviewable
LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
25. Encinas v. Agustin, G.R.
No. 187317, 11 April
2013
26. Soriano v. Laguardia, 587
SCRA 79
Week 9-10  Recitation
• Textbooks  Case study &
reporting
 Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
➢ Doctrine of Prior
Resort/Primary
Jurisdiction
27. Industrial Enterprises,
Inc., v. Court of Appeals,
et al., G.R. No. 88550, 18
April 1990
28. Caballes, et al., v. Perez-
Sison, et al., G.R. No.
131759, 23 March 2004
29. Regino v. Pangasinan
Colleges of Science and
Technology, et al., G.R.
No. 156109, 18
November 2004
30. Paat, et al., v. Court of
Appeals, et al., G.R. No.
111107, 10 January 1997
31. Shell Philippines
Exploration v. Jalos, G.R.
No. 179918, 8 September
2010
32. Professional Regulations
Commission v. Alo, G.R.
No. 214435. 14 February
2022
33. Euro-Med Laboratories,
Phil., Inc. v. Province of
Batangas, G.R. No.
148106, 17 July 2006
34. Ligtas v. People, G.R.
No. 200751, 17 August
2015
35. Provincial Bus Operators
Association v.
Department of Labor and
Employment, G.R. No.
202275, 17 July 2018
➢ Exceptions to Exhaustion
6
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)

36. SSS Employees

Association v. Bathan-
Velasco, G.R. No.
108765, 27 August 1999
37. Industrial Power Sales,
Inc. v. Sinsuat, et al., G.R.
No. L-29171, 15 April
1988
38. Castro v. Gloria, et al.,
G.R. No. 132174, 20
August 2001
39. Pagara, et al., v. Court of
Appeals, et al., G.R. No.
96882, 12 March 1996
40. Tan v. Director of
Forestry, 125 SCRA 302
41. Calo v. Fuertes, 5 SCRA
399
42. Cabada, et al., v. Alunan
III, et al., G.R. No.
119645, 22 August 1996
43. National Food Authority,
et al., v. Court of
Appeals, et al., G.R. Nos.
115121-25, 9 February
1996
44. Department of Agrarian
Reform v. Apex
Investment and Financing
Corporation, G.R. No.
149422, 10 April 2003
45. Maglalang v. PAGCOR,
G.R. No. 190566, 11
December 2013
46. Information Technology
Foundation of the
Philippines v. Comelec,
G.R. No. 159139, 13
January 2004
47. Ejera v. Merto, G.R. No.
163109, 22 January 2014

➢ Judicial Review/Appeal

48. Philippine Sinter

Corporation, et al., v.
Cagayan Electric Power
and Light Co., Inc., G.R.
No. 127371, 25 April
2002
49. Arboleda v. NLRC, G.R.
No. 119509, 11 February
1999

7
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
MIDTERM EXAMINATIONS Week 11

MODULE 5: Week 12-13  Recitation

• Textbooks  Case study &
General Principles of Law of reporting
Public Officers • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
A. Concept of Public Office ➢ The Concept of Public
Office
1. Elements
1. Fernandez v. Sto.
2. Classification Tomas, G.R. No.
116418, 7 March 1995
B. Concept of Public Officer 2. Preclaro v.
Sandiganbayan, G.R.
C. Requirements for Public No. 111091, 21 August
Office 1995
3. Laurel v. Desierto, G.R.
1. Eligibility and No. 145368, 12 April
Qualifications 2002

2. Disqualifications and ➢ Eligibility, Qualification,

Inhibitions Disqualifications,
Inhibitions

4. Frivaldo v. Comelec,
174 SCRA 245
5. Frivaldo v. Comelec,
257 SCRA 727
6. Maquera v. Borra, 15
SCRA 7
7. Flores v. Drilon, G.R.
No. 104732, 22 June
1993
8. Lecaroz v.
Sandiganbayan, G.R.
No. 130872, March 25,
1999
9. Dumlao v. COMELEC,
95 SCRA 400
10. National Amnesty
Commission v.
Commission on Audit,
G.R. No. 156982, 8
September 2004
11. Civil Service
Commission v. Cortes,
G.R. No. 200103, 23
April 2014

8
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
MODULE 6: Week 14-15  Recitation
• Textbooks  Case study &
Commencement of Official reporting
Relations by Appointment • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
A. Concept of Appointment ➢ Steps in Appointing
Process
B. Requisites for a Valid
Appointment 12. Velicaria-Garafil v.
Office of The President,
C. Steps in the Appointing G.R. No. 203372, 16
Process June 2015
13. Lacson v. Romero, 84
D. Classification of Phil. 740
Appointment 14. Tomali v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
E. Appointments to the Civil 110598, 1 December
Service 1994
15. Luego v. Civil Service
1. Scope of the Civil Commission, 143 SCRA
Service 327
16. Aquino v. Civil Service
2. Classes of Service Commission, 208 SCRA
240
3. Classification 17. Costin v. Quimbo, 120
SCRA 159
18. Gayatao v. Civil Service
Commission, 210 SCRA
183
19. Agyao v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
182591, 28 January 2011

➢ Classification of
Appointment

20. Pamantasan ng Lungsod

ng Maynila v.
Intermediate Appellate
Court, 140 SCRA 22
21. Sarmiento v. Mison, 156
SCRA 549
22. Calderon v. Carale, 208
SCRA 254
23. Maniebo v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
158708, 10 August 2010
24. De Castro v. Carlos,
G.R. No. 194994, 16
April 2013
25. Marohombsar v. Alonto,
194 SCRA 391
26. Province of Camarines
Sur v. Court of Appeals,

9
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
G.R. No. 104639, 14
July 1995
27. Felix v. Buenaseda, G.R.
No. 109704, 17 July
1995
28. Gloria v. De Guzman,
G.R. No. 116183, 6
October 1995
29. Orcullo v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
138780, 22 May 2001

➢ Scope of Civil Service and

Authority of the
Commission

30. Light Rail Transit

Authority (LRTA) v.
Venus, G.R. No.
163782, 24 March 2006

➢ Classes of Service

31. PEZA Board of

Directors v. Mercado,
G.R. No. 172144, 9
March 2010
32. Civil Service
Commission v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
185766, 23 November
2010
33. General v. Roco, G.R.
Nos. 143366 & 143524,
29 January 2001
34. Montecillo v. Civil
Service Commission,
G.R. No. 131954, 28
June 2001
35. Orcullo v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
138780, 22 May 2001
36. PAGCOR v. Rilloraza,
G.R. No. 141141, 25
June 2001
37. Provincial Government
of Camarines Norte v.
Beatriz Gonzales, G.R.
No. 185740, 23 July
2013
38. Pacete v. Chairman,
Commission on Audit,
185 SCRA 1

10
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
39. Career Executive
Service Board v. Civil
Service Commission,
G.R. No. 196890, 11
January 2018

MODULE 7: Week 16  Recitation

• Textbooks  Case study &
Other Personnel Actions, reporting
Authority, and Rights of Public • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
Officers  Quiz
➢ Personnel Actions
I. Personnel Actions
40. Abad v. Dela Cruz, G.R.
A. Promotion No. 207422, 18 March
2015
1. Next-In-Rank Rule 41. Divinagracia v. Sto.
Tomas, G.R. No.
2. Automatic Reversion 110954, 31 May 1995
Rule 42. Quisumbing v. Judge
Gumban, 193 SCRA 520
B. Appointment through 43. Chato v. Natividad, G.R.
certification No. 113843, 2 June 1995
44. Causing v. COMELEC,
C. Transfer G.R. No. 199131, 9
September 2014
D. Reinstatement 45. Cuevas v. Bacal, G.R.
No. 139382, 6 December
E. Detail 2000
46. Gloria v. De Guzman,
F. Reassignment G.R. No. 116183, 6
October 1995
G. Reemployment 47. Garcia v. Chairman,
Commission on Audit,
II. Powers and Duties of Public G.R. No. L-75025, 14
Officers September 1993
48. Ejera v. Merto, G.R. No.
A. Authority of Public Officers 163109, 22 January 2014
49. Padolina v. Fernandez,
B. Duties of Public Officers G.R. No. 133511, 10
October 2000
C. Prohibitions 50. Pastor v. City of Pasig,
G.R. No. 146873, 9 May
D. Republic Act 6713 2002
otherwise known as the 51. Carino v. Daoas, G.R.
Code of Conduct and No. 144493, 9 April
Ethical Standards for Public 2002
Officers and Employees
➢ Authority of the Public
III. Rights of Public Officers Officer

A. Right to Office
11
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
52. Kilusang Bayan v.
B. Right to Salary Dominguez, 205 SCRA
92
C. Other Rights 53. Jandaya v. Ruiz, 95
SCRA 562
54. Lao v. To Chip, 158
SCRA 243
55. People v. Garcia, G.R.
No. 126252, 30 August
1999
56. Sharp International
Marketing v. Court of
Appeals, 201 SCRA 299

➢ Salary and Perquisites

57. Yap v. Commission on

Audit, G.R. No. 158562,
23 April 2010
58. Gloria v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
131012, 21 April 1999
59. Constantino-David v.
Pangandaman-Gania,
G.R. No. 156039, 14
August 2003
60. Galang v. Land Bank,
G.R, No. 175276, 31
May 2011
61. Balitaosan v. Secretary,
DECS, G.R. No.
138238, 2 September
2003
62. Profeta v. Drilon, 216
SCRA 777
63. Rabor v. Civil Service
Commission, G.R. No.
111812, 31 May 1995

MODULE 8: Week 17-18  Recitation

• Textbooks  Case study &
De Facto Officers and Liability of reporting
Public Officers • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
I. De Facto Officers ➢ De Facto Officers

A. Definition 64. Torres v. Ribo, 81 Phil

44
B. Elements 65. Monroy vs Court of
Appeals, 20 SCRA 620
C. Entitlement to Salaries 66. Tuanda v.
Sandiganbayan, 249
II. Liability of Public Officers SCRA 342

12
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
A. Statutory Liability – 67. Tayko v. Capistrano,
superior vs. subordinate 53 Phil. 866
68. Rodriguez v. Tan, 91
B. Threefold Liability Rule Phil. 724
69. Lino Luna v.
C. Liability of Ministerial Rodriguez, 37 Phil.
Officers 136
70. Garchitorena v.
III. Other Concepts on Crescini, 37 Phil. 675
Accountability of Public 71. Solis v. Court of
Officers Appeals, 38 SCRA 53
72. Tomali v. Civil Service
A. Ombudsman Commission, G.R. No.
110598, 1 December
1. Composition, 1994
Qualifications, 73. Flores v. Drilon, G.R.
Appointment, Term, No. 104732, 22 June
Disqualifications 1993
74. Menzon v. Petilla, 197
2. Powers SCRA 317
75. Arroyo v. Court of
a. Constitutional and Appeals, G.R. No.
Statutory 202860, 10 April 2019

b. Investigatory ➢ Liability of Public Officers

Powers
76. Vinzons-Chato v.
i. Criminal Fortune Tobacco
Corporation, G.R. No.
ii. Administrative 141309, 23 December
2008
c. Effectivity and 77. Rama v. Court of
Finality of Appeals, 148 SCRA
Decisions 496
78. Carpio-Morales v.
d. Judicial Review Court of Appeals, G.R.
No. 217126-27, 10
3. Office of the Special November 2015
Prosecutor 79. Padtu, Jr. v. Carpio-
Morales, G.R. No.
B. Sandiganbayan 230171, 27 September
2021
1. Jurisdiction 80. Office of the
Ombudsman v.
2. Judicial Review Capulong, G.R. No.
201643, 12 March
2014
81. Crebello v. Office of
the Ombudsman, G.R.
No. 232325, 10 April
2019
82. Office of the
Ombudsman v.

13
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
Malapitan, G.R. No.
229811, 28 April 2021
83. Madreo v. Bayron,
G.R. Nos. 237330 &
237579, 3 November
2020
84. Madera v.
Commission on
Audit, G.R. No.
244128, September
8, 2020
85. Aquino v.
Commission on
Audit, G.R. No.
227715, November
3, 2020
86. Abellanosa v.
Commission on
Audit, G.R. No.
185806 (Resolution),
November 17, 2020
87. Development Bank
of the Philippines v.
Commission on
Audit, G.R. No.
262193, July 11,
2023

MODULE 9: Week 19  Recitation

• Textbooks  Case study &
Termination of Official reporting
Relationship • Supreme Court Decisions:  Discussion/lecture
 Quiz
A. Expiration of term or tenure ➢ Expiration of Term

B. Reaching the age limit 88. Lecaroz v.

Sandiganbayan, G.R.
C. Resignation No. 130872, 25 March
1999
D. Recall
➢ Reaching Age Limit
E. Removal
89. GSIS v. Fernando De
F. Abandonment Leon, G.R. No.
186560, 17 November
G. Acceptance of an 2010
incompatible office 90. Civil Service
Commission v. Pililla
H. Abolition of office Water District, G.R.
No. 190147, 5 March
I. Prescription of the right to 2013
office

14
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
➢ Resignation
J. Impeachment
91. Ejercito-Estrada v.
K. Death Macapagal-Arroyo,
G.R. No. 146738, 2
L. Failure to assume elective March 2001
office within six months 92. Collantes v. Court of
from proclamation Appeals, G.R. No.
169604, 6 March 2007
M. Conviction of a crime 93. Joson v. Nario, 187
SCRA 453
N. Filing of a certificate of
candidacy ➢ Recall

94. Angobung v. Comelec,

G.R. No. 126571, 5
March 1997
95. Paras v. Comelec, G.R.
No. 123169, 4
November 1996

➢ Removal (see Sections 37

to 39, Presidential Decree
No. 807 and Section 48,
Chapter 3, Book V,
Administrative Code of
1987)

96. Civil Service

Commission v.
Magnaye, G.R. No.
183337, 23 April 2010
97. Duque v. Veloso, G.R.
No. 196201, 19 June
2012
98. Heirs of Celestino
Teves v. Felicidario,
A.M. No. P-12-3089,
13 November 2013
99. Advincula v. Dicen,
G.R. No. 162403, 16
May 2005
100. Miranda v. Carreon,
G.R. No. 143540, 11
April 2003
101. Fernandez v. Office of
the Ombudsman, G.R.
No. 193983, 14 March
2012
102. Land Bank of the
Philippines v. Artemio
San Juan, G.R. No.
186279, 2 April 2013

15
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
103. Tanjay Water District
v. Quinit, G.R. No.
160502, 27 April 2007

➢ Preventive Suspension (see

Sections 40 to 42,
Presidential Decree No.
807 and Republic Act No.
6770)

104. Trade and Investment

Development
Corporation of the
Philippines v.
Manalang-Demegillo,
G.R. No. 176343, 18
September 2012;
Manalang-Demegillo
v. Trade and
Investment
Development
Corporation of the
Philippines, G.R. No.
168613 & 185571, 5
March 2013
105. Hagad v. Gozo-
Dadole, G.R. No.
108072, 12 December
1995
106. Socrates v.
Sandiganbayan, G.R.
No. 116259-60, 20
February 1996
107. Villaseñor v.
Ombudsman, G.R. No.
202303, 4 June 2014
108. De la Cruz v. Court of
Appeals, G.R. No.
126183, 25 March
1999
109. Civil Service
Commission v.
Gentallan, G.R. No.
152833, 9 May 2005
110. Abalos v. Civil Service
Commission, 196
SCRA 8
111. Baculi v. Office of the
President, G.R. No.
188681, 8 March 2017

➢ Other Modes

16
 LEARNING
WEEK/ DATE
METHODS
TOPIC/CONTENT LEARNING RESOURCES (Schedule of
(activities designed or
(arrangement or sequence of the (print and non-print materials each Topic,
deployed by the teacher
major topics is based on a logical and online/ Assign, Exam
to bring about, or
order) open-access resources) for the entire
create the conditions
semester)
for learning)
112. Municipality of San
Andres, Catanduanes
v. Court of Appeals,
G.R. No. 118883, 16
January 1998
113. Canonizado v.
Aguirre, G.R. No.
133132, 15 February
2001
114. Quinto v. COMELEC,
G.R. No. 189698, 22
February 2010
115. Re: Ma. Cristina Roco
Corona, A.M. No. 20-
07-10-SC, 12 January
2021

FINAL EXAMINATIONS Week 20

TEXTBOOK/REFERENCE BOOK:

1. Philippine Administrative Law, Carlo L. Cruz

2. The Law of Public Officers, Carlo L. Cruz
3. Outline/Reviewer in Political Law, Justice Antonio Eduardo B. Nachura
4. Political Law Reviewer, Dean Ed Vincent S. Albano

Prepared by:

Atty. Randolph A. Pascasio

Faculty, College of Law

Antonio Eduardo S. Nachura, Jr.

Faculty, College of Law

Algie Kwillon B. Mariacos

Faculty, College of Law

Date Prepared: Approved by:

January 20, 2024 Atty. Marciano G. Delson

Dean, College of Law

17