Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review
High moisture food extrusion
Hülya Akdogan
United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Western Regional Research Center, 800
Buchanan Street Albany, CA 94710, USA
Summary Extrusion at higher moisture contents (. 40%), also known as wet extrusion, is relative-
ly less investigated compared to low and intermediate moisture extrusion. Literature on
high moisture food extrusion has been reviewed. Wet extrusion applications utilise twin
screw extruders due to their efficient conveying capabilities. Extruders can be used as
bioreactors for starch hydrolysis using thermally stable enzymes. This process is usually
followed by saccharification inside or outside an extruder to produce a high DE (dex-
trose equivalent) syrup. Starch-based high moisture extrusion research also reports a few
modelling studies. The rheological properties, torque and energy requirements of high
moisture extrusion systems are different from those of low and intermediate systems.
Other research reviewed includes the extrusion of low-cost plant and animal proteins to
manufacture nutritious food products that imitate the texture, flavour, and mouthfeel of
meat.
Keywords Extrusion, liquefaction, protein texturization, rheology, saccharification.
extruders (SSE), hence, they offer extended range the a configuration (Wong, 1995). Cereal starches
of applications (Harper, 1981). Both SSE and can be extruded with thermostable a-amylases of a
TSE are drag flow devices with forward pumping bacterial origin to convert starch to dextrins in
action of the rotating screws. The main difference order to produce a soluble, low viscosity
in the conveying mechanisms of SSE and TSE is hydrolysate of 10–15 DE. The liquefied
that conveying in SSE is established by the fric- hydrolysate can be processed directly to a mal-
tion between the barrel and the melt, and the todextrin product or used as substrate for conver-
screw and the melt. Therefore, SSE requires a sion (saccharification) to dextrose with the enzyme
grooved barrel for a good conveying action. glucoamylase (Wong, 1995). Continuous liquefac-
However, in TSE the product is transferred in tion of various types of starch via enzymatic action
bulk from one screw to the other which makes has been widely reported in the literature (Linko
the forward conveying more efficient. Extrusion et al., 1981; Chouvel et al., 1983; Hakulin et al.,
at high moisture levels where there is lower fric- 1983; Mattson et al., 1984; Brooks & Griffin, 1987;
tion and viscous dissipation would be difficult in van Zuilichem et al., 1990; Tomas et al., 1997).
an SSE. Wheat, corn, and rice starch were among the com-
monly used types.
There are several factors that influence the effi-
Starch-based high moisture extrusion
ciency of enzymatic starch hydrolysis in a TSE.
Extruders as enzymatic bioreactors Starch needs to be gelatinized for efficient hydro-
Considering extruders as continuous bioreactors lysis since gelatinized starch is more susceptible to
began in the late 1980s where materials were treat- enzymatic attack. It is important to optimize the
ed either in the presence or absence of enzymes processing conditions in the barrel for maximizing
under elevated temperature, pressure, and shear, at gelatinization and minimizing enzyme inactivation.
moisture levels as high as 70% or more (Linko The stability of a-amylase during high temperature
et al., 1983). In an extruder, enzymatic action can liquefaction is also important to efficiently solubi-
be coupled with thermal and mechanical break- lize starch. The critical controllable factors that
down, resulting in a significant reduction in the affect enzymatic conversion in a TSE are moisture,
viscosity of the product. Thermomechanical lique- temperature, pH, and enzyme concentration.
faction of cereals was discovered and demonstrat- Moisture has a significant impact on starch lique-
ed in the early 1970s. This process can yield a faction. Excess moisture in the feed results in com-
certain degree of starch breakdown with DE (dex- plete starch gelatinization if combined with
trose equivalent) values below two (Mercier & elevated temperatures; therefore, increasing mois-
Feillet, 1975). DE is defined as the percentage of ture usually results in a higher degree of starch
reducing sugars present calculated as dextrose (D- hydrolysis (Hakulin et al., 1983). DE increased
glucose) on a dry solids basis, 100 corresponding from 20 to 23.5 as feed moisture increased from 40
to the complete hydrolysis of starch (Hebeda, to 70% (Table 1). Lower enzyme to substrate
1993). The discovery in the late 1970s (Linko et al., ratios makes starch conversion more dependent on
1981) that cereal enzymes such as a-amylase can feed moisture (Chouvel et al., 1983). The optimum
either be completely inactivated by twin screw moisture content in the feed stream was deter-
extrusion cooking or can survive it, depending on mined to be quite high, 55–60%, for efficient con-
the processing conditions, led to detailed studies of version (Colonna et al., 1984). The temperature
the inactivation of biologically active materials and effect on conversion is two-fold. Firstly, tempera-
the use of extruders as bioreactors for various ture influences the starch gelatinization, and sec-
applications (Linko, 1989). The early research ondly enzymes function best in their optimum
regarding the effect of extrusion processing on operating temperature range. If the temperature is
enzymes and microorganisms was reviewed by outside the range of optimum enzyme activity,
Linko et al. (1981). The enzyme a-amylase, an starch conversion would be expected to be lower.
endo-glucosidase, cleaves the a-1,4-glucosidic This explains the findings of Chouvel et al. (1983)
bond of the starch at internal positions to yield that as temperature increased from 100 to 145 8C,
dextrins and oligosaccharides with the C1-OH in DE decreased from 19.5 to 16.5 (Table 2). Tomas
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 197
Table 1 Influence of moisture, and a-amylase would not be economically desirable. The enzyme
concentration on the extrusion-liquefaction of action has to be terminated immediately after
pregelatinized corn starch extrusion, otherwise starch hydrolysis continues
% moisture a-amylase Viscosity of DE (%) of
rapidly (Reinikainen et al., 1986). Direct collection
added extrudate freeze-dried of samples in a vigorously stirred, boiling 0.2 M
(mL kg21 (*109 Pa.s) extrudate acetate buffer of pH 3.5 was found necessary for
dry starch) immediate enzyme inactivation prior to DE deter-
minations. An unsuccessful method of inactivation
40 0 .200 0.5
40 30 20–30 20
via 0.1% mercuric chloride, resulted in samples
50 30 17 19.5 with 65–95% of the initial activity remaining
60 0 — 0.3–0.4 (Linko et al., 1983). Thermoamyl a-amylase is sig-
60 30 5–10 20–21 nificantly inactivated at temperatures above 155 8C
70 0 — 0.5
(Linko, 1989).
70 30 3–4 23.5
Saccharification can be partially conducted in
Temperature 5 125 8C, pH 5 6 (Chouvel et al., 1983) the extruder barrel if appropriate enzymes are
added or it can be a batch operation following
extrusion-induced liquefaction. If it is done solely
et al. (1997) reported an almost linear increase in in the extruder, due to limited residence time in the
the DE values for rice starch as temperature barrel, the conversion rates may be significantly
increased from 70 to 100 8C. Within the experi- lower than those for batch saccharification. In
mental range studied, the highest DE was 90. This order to attain reasonably higher DE values for
value is significantly higher than those reported in this case, the L/D (length-to-diameter) ratio of the
the literature for other starches. Likimani et al. barrel should be . 30 (van Zuilichem et al., 1990).
(1991) also noted an increase in the starch hydro- Researches indicate that significantly higher DE
lysis as temperature increased from 80 to 160 8C, values can be obtained with a longer barrel, such
maximum DE being 6.43. However, Chouvel et al. as a 1222 mm Werner & Pfleiderer Continua 58
(1983) noted a slight decrease in starch hydrolysis barrel (Hakulin et al., 1983), or a 1000 mm
as the temperature increased within the range 100 Creusot-Loire BC 45 barrel (Chouvel et al., 1983).
to 145 8C but the maximum DE value was only 21. Literature reports that liquefaction accomplished
Initial reports indicated that a-amylase had been in the extruder is usually followed by saccharifica-
used at mild conditions since elevated tempera- tion outside the extruder barrel (Linko et al.,
tures resulted in inactivation of the enzyme. Use of 1981;1983; Reinikainen et al., 1986; Linko, 1989;
thermostable amylases improved the enzyme- Govindasamy et al., 1997). During the mid 1960s
induced liquefaction. Neutral pH resulted in high- only acid-converted starch syrups were commer-
er starch conversion compared to acid or basic pH cially available, with a typical DE of 42 for con-
(Chouvel et al., 1983). Enzyme concentration and fectionery applications obtained by 6 minute
starch conversion are directly proportional, the hydrolysis with 0.03 M hydrochloric acid at
higher the enzyme concentration, the higher the 145 8C. Later on, the commercial scale availability
starch hydrolysis. However, conversion reaches of glucoamylase made an acid/enzyme process pos-
saturation at a certain enzyme concentration, and sible with syrup DE values as high as 94.
beyond this point any increase in the enzyme level Replacing the acid treatment with a-amylase liq-
would have little effect on the conversion and uefaction in an extruder followed by enzymatic
Moisture 5 50%, pH 5 6, a-amylase 5 30mL kg21 dry starch (Chouvel et al., 1983)
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207
198 High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan
saccharification resulted in production of syrups expansion at the die. The processing conditions
with DE values as high as 98. and ingredients utilized will have an effect on
The DE values accomplished by saccharification extrudate expansion. The lower the starch content
in an extruder are primarily influenced by feed of the recipe and level of gelatinization, the lower
moisture, temperature, pH, and enzyme concentra- the extrudate expansion. Also lower viscosity
tion. High melt viscosity at high solids content results in the inability of the extrudate to hold
results in slower hydrolysis, causing a lower per- expansion.
cent saccharification. Die pressure can be used as At elevated temperatures, biopolymers in foods
an index of melt viscosity (Tadmor & Gogos, start to lose their orderly molecular structure. On
1979). The higher the viscosity of the melt, the initiation of starch gelatinization, there is a rapid
higher the die pressure. Samples extruded at high- change in the physical properties of the biopoly-
er moisture contents were more easily saccharified mer mass, due to the formation of new molecular
(Govindasamy et al., 1997). According to van aggregate structures by hydrogen bonding. One
Zuilichem et al. (1990), concentration of glu- of the most significant changes, as far as model-
coamylase in the extruder is by far the most impor- ling is concerned, is the rapid rise in the viscosity
tant factor in saccharification. Glucoamylase in the extruder. After the initial rise, viscosity
concentration and conversion level was found to starts to decline as the melt is further heated and
be approximately linear. The other commonly used mechanically sheared (Olkku & Hagqvist, 1983).
enzymes for saccharification purposes are fungal The initial rise in viscosity is caused by gela-
a-amylase, and b-amylase (Ofoli et al., 1990; tinization when the crystalline structure of starch
Komolprasert & Ofoli, 1991; Bigelis, 1993). molecules results in complete irreversible disap-
Both starchy and cellulosic materials such as pearance of birefringence (ability to rotate the
cereal grain or straw may be extrusion-pretreated plane of polarized light). Fragmentation and for-
(liquefied with a-amylase or just thermomechani- mation of complexes may follow gelatinization of
cally processed in the barrel) for subsequent starch in the extruder, depending on the severity
ethanol fermentation. Saccharification and fermen- of the processing conditions.
tation can be simultaneous since this would mini- The complex physicochemical changes that
mize the substrate inhibition, yielding high solids take place during extrusion affect the viscosity
level. The glucoamylase concentration is known to and final product quality significantly. To
have a significant effect on the fermentation rate enhance utilization of extrusion and extruded
and ethanol yield. Use of the bacterium, Z. products, the effect of process parameters on the
mobilis, along with yeast may increase the initial rheological changes of the food melt in the
rate of fermentation. Ethanol can also be produced extruder and the resulting impact on final prod-
in a column reactor by immobilized yeast in beads uct quality need to be clearly understood
of calcium alginate gel, using clear glucose syrup (Akdogan et al., 1997). There are two methods
as the substrate (Linko, 1989). for analyzing and defining the rheological prop-
erties: developing a predictive rheological model
Rheological properties and modelling based on the final measured expansion at the die
High moisture extrusion systems differ from low and analyzing off-line; or directly measuring the
and intermediate moisture systems due to differ- rheological properties on-line by inserting a vis-
ence in the concentration of water. Therefore, the cometer between the extruder and the die. The
distribution of shear, mixing, mechanical heat, latter case is a preferred method since it is the
and convective heat will be different in such extruding melt, not the extrudate, that is being
extrusion systems (Akdogan, 1996). Higher mois- analyzed. Extruder dies can be equipped with slit
ture contents prevent viscous dissipation of ener- or capillary rheometers to measure rheological
gy in the extruder barrel due to low melt properties of the food melt continuously. Slit
viscosity, hence, the pressure build-up in the rheometers are most often used to measure rheo-
extruder barrel is not as high as in low moisture logical properties. This type of rheometer is based
extrusion. Lower pressure drop along the die is on measurements of flow rate and pressure drop
partly responsible for the minimal to non-existent along the slit die. These measurements are con-
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 199
verted into estimates of shear rate and shear teristics of starch and protein. Akdogan et al.
stress at the wall. The rheometer requires mea- (1997) presented a simplified approach to evalu-
surements of pressure drop for different flow ate the rheological responses of a twin screw
rates at each operating condition to analyze the extruder at high moisture contents (57–65% wb),
rheological properties of the melt. based on viscometry principles, including only
Akdogan (1996) used stepwise regression analy- extruder operating conditions as independent
sis to determine the contribution of each extrud- variables. A semi-empirical modified Harper’s
er operating parameter (temperature, moisture, model for viscosity was developed by incorporat-
feed flow rate, screw speed) on the variance of die ing moisture in the feed stream, temperature,
pressure drop, torque, and specific mechanical shear rate, and screw speed variables. The model
energy. An important aspect of this project was considered power law dependency of shear rate,
that temperature was determined to be the most and an exponential dependency on temperature,
important parameter influencing the rheological moisture, and screw speed. A multiple linear
properties of the melt. Temperature accounts for regression analysis was performed to determine
more than half of the variance in the responses the predicted viscosity values within the experi-
mentioned above. Moisture, feed flow rate, and mental range studied. The predicted apparent vis-
screw speed, in decreasing order, also affected the cosity values were found to be in good agreement
responses. Moisture is usually the most effective with the experimental viscosity. van Zuilichem
extruder parameter influencing the rheological et al. (1990) developed a Gaussian regression
behaviour of the melt for low and intermediate algorithm to determine the constants of an equa-
moisture extrusion. Since viscosity of a high mois- tion for the enzymatic conversion of cracked corn
ture extruding system is considerably lower, vis- into a fermentation substrate. Thermamyl a-amy-
cous dissipation in such systems is less. Therefore, lase during extrusion and glucoamylase during
the energy required for working the melt in the saccharification were utilized at a moisture range
screw channel would rely mostly on thermal input of 60–80%. A response surface methodology
through the barrel walls rather than friction (RSM) calculation on the calculated constants
between molecules. described the initial conversion rate and final con-
Several extrusion models for low and interme- version rate. These two constants were included
diate moisture (15–40%) starch-based dough exist in the proposed DE model describing the saccha-
in the published literature (Cervone & Harper, rification process. The independent variables
1978; Remsen & Clark, 1978; Harper, 1981; included in the algorithm were a-amylase concen-
Bhattacharya & Hanna, 1986; Mackey, 1989; tration, glucoamylase concentration, substrate
Morgan et al., 1989; Lai & Kokini, 1990; Wang concentration, and temperature. Tomas et al.
et al., 1990; Altomare et al., 1992). However, (1997) presented a model incorporating the inte-
modelling studies for high moisture extrusion sys- grated effect of moisture content, temperature,
tems are quite scarce in the literature (van shear rate, and enzyme concentration to describe
Zuilichem et al., 1990; Akdogan & Rumsey, 1996; the viscosity of extruding rice flour in the pres-
Akdogan et al., 1997). These models were either ence of a-amylase for 55–65% moisture. The pre-
purely empirical or semi-empirical statistical mod- dicted and observed viscosity of rice flour were
els which gave limited insight into structural and found to be in good agreement.
physicochemical changes. Also, such models are Steady state models can predict the perfor-
useful only within the experimental range of the mance of an extruder according to a set of oper-
variables and extrapolation is not advised. High ating conditions and material properties. When
moisture extrusion can certainly benefit from a this set of operating variables changes to a new
more general numerical model derived from fun- set of values, the extruder moves towards a new
damental equations of motion incorporating also steady state. The path followed between two dif-
the structural changes of the melt. This type of ferent steady states cannot be predicted by steady
model may need modifications for starch and state models. On the other hand, dynamic models
protein-based high moisture extrusion systems to offer an understanding of the transient states, the
account for the molecular and functional charac- rate at which this change occurs, and provide
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207
200 High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan
Figure 1 Dynamic response of die pressure and motor Figure 2 Dynamic response of die pressure and motor
torque to a step change in feed rate (screw speed 5 175 torque to a step change in screw speed (feed rate 5
rpm). (———) experimental, (– – –) model. Feed rate 3.8 kg h21). (———) experimental, (– – –) model. Screw
changes: (a) 3.8–4.5 kg h21; (b) 4.5–3.8 kg h21 (Akdogan & speed changes: (a) 175–225 rpm; (b) 225–175 rpm
Rumsey, 1996). (Akdogan & Rumsey, 1996).
valuable tools for designing model-based control function (Fig. 1), and step changes in the screw
systems for extruders. Dynamic analysis of extru- speed (Fig. 2) and screw speed-flow rate simulta-
sion has been widely reported in the plastics neously were modelled by an inverse response.
extrusion literature, however there is only one Upon changing the screw speed from 175 to 225
published food related study in the high moisture rpm (Fig. 2a), extruder throughput suddenly
extrusion area. In this, Akdogan & Rumsey increases; thereby, resulting in an increase in the
(1996) studied the dynamic responses of a lab-size pressure and torque responses. Throughput
co-rotating twin screw extruder (APV) at a con- returns to its original value after the system
stant temperature (80 8C) and moisture (60%), recovers. A new steady state is reached at which
applied to a rice starch system. Die pressure and pressure and torque stabilises at lower values
motor torque were found to respond in the same than initially. Figure 2(b) shows the similar but
manner. Responses to a step change in mass flow opposite effect of a sudden decrease in screw
rate were modelled with a first order transfer speed. Changing both the screw speed and flow
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 201
rate simultaneously also resulted in inverse Foods, General Mills, Nestle, Pillsbury, Proctor
response. Future work is needed to investigate the and Gamble, Quaker Oats, and Ralston Purina.
effects of other operating conditions and quality This has led to patents for meat analogs or meat
attributes such as density, textural properties, and extenders (Valentas et al., 1991). Millions of tons
colour as related to the dynamic responses of an of soy every year are being transformed and con-
extruder operating at high moisture levels. sumed directly, or incorporated into new or tra-
ditional foodstuffs by extrusion into texturized
vegetable proteins. Without this transformation,
Protein-based high moisture extrusion
this soy protein source would not be used as
Wet extrusion has made possible unconventional human food on this scale (Areas, 1992).
products such as texturized proteins. Some of It is possible to use extruders to restructure
these products have already been commercialized vegetable-based proteins to form fibrous struc-
in Japan, China, and USA. Examples include tures that resemble the texture of meat tissues.
extruded crab analog made from Alaska pollack ‘Texturization’ can be described by the processes
surimi with egg white and 1% starch, and textur- illustrated in Fig. 3. Soybean protein isolates and
ized soybean foods such as ‘fupi’ (Shen & Wang, concentrates, and flours are the most widely used
1992). Texturization processes via extrusion can raw materials for this purpose (Dahl & Villota,
make products that imitate the texture, taste, and 1991). Usually, one of the above mentioned soy
appearance of meat or seafood with high nutri- products is extruded, sometimes blended with
tional value (Cheftel et al., 1992). other ingredients, at moisture contents equal or
higher than 60% at temperatures of 100 to 150 8C.
Plant protein-based high moisture extrusion The dry material is fed to the barrel by a screw
The idea of producing meat analogs from inex- type of feeder and water is directly injected by a
pensive vegetable proteins has received consider- pump through the barrel wall.
able attention, not only in academic research but
also in industrial research by major food process- Protein reactions during texturization
ing companies such as Central Soya, General During extrusion, protein structures are disrupted
Figure 3 Texturization of wet proteinaceous foods in an extruder (Reprinted with permission from AACC; Noguchi, 1989).
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207
202 High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 203
hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions as and less texturized extrudates due to reduced pro-
mainly responsible for protein texturization by tein–protein interactions and lower viscosity. At
extrusion (Areas, 1992). relatively lower moisture contents, higher barrel
Properties of the protein extrudates are strong- temperatures (140 to 180 8C) resulted in better
ly influenced by the extruder operating condi- textures. At higher moisture levels, temperature
tions, pH, and ingredients (Noguchi, 1989; needs to be decreased as moisture flash-off may
Thiebaud et al., 1996). Hayashi et al. (1992) cause considerable water loss if a cooling die is
reported that extruder barrel temperature was the not used. Screw speed and flow rate are also like-
most important parameter for the texturization of ly to influence the texturization by affecting the
the dehulled whole soybean. Melt temperature is degree of barrel fill and mean residence time in
a critical factor in protein cross-linking reactions. the barrel (Thiebaud et al., 1996). Alkaline and
Increasing temperature from 140 to 180 8C results acid pH reduce the extrudate strength drastically.
in a proportional decrease in disulfide linkages The maximum strength was found to be obtained
formed in extruded soy protein isolates (Areas, at neutral pH (Noguchi, 1989). The type of pro-
1992). Temperatures lower than 90 8C hinder the tein has also an impact on texturization. Cheftel
expansion and layer formation (Cheftel et al., et al. (1992) noted that it is easier to extrude and
1992). Figure 5 shows the influence of barrel tem- texturize soybean concentrates compared to soy
perature on the tensile strength of an extrudate protein isolates under the same extrusion condi-
made on Clextral BC-45 at pH 7. The lengthwise tions. Soy protein isolates presented a homoge-
strength, FL, was always larger than the crosswise nous structure while those that contain only soy
strength, FV and was affected by the extrusion protein concentrate displayed an anisotropic
temperature more than FV. The ratio of FL to FV structure with layers or coarse fibres in the direc-
was always greater than 1, suggesting the exis- tion of flow through the die. Addition of wheat
tence of an aligned structure. At a given temper- gluten to soy protein isolates even enhanced this
ature, higher moisture contents resulted in softer type of fibre formation.
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207
204 High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan
surfaces move at a lower speed than the hotter and also called non-meat binders. Ingredient binders
more fluid internal region. include wheat flour, corn starch, soy protein iso-
Laminar flow exists from the screw head to the late, hydrolyzed vegetable proteins, gums, or mal-
die entrance and is necessary to achieve proper todextrin. Fish such as sardine, Alaska pollack,
texture. Velocity gradients and shear forces devel- and salmon may also be texturized into animal
oped in the peripheral zones permit the orienta- meat analogs after blending with non-meat
tion and alignment of the unfolded protein binders at ratios as high as 6–4.
macromolecules and result in formation of paral- The moisture content of fish and meat can be
lel layers of great length. The lowest shear stress as high as 75%. However, texturization by extru-
occurs at the middle section of the die so the pro- sion requires a lower moisture level. One method
teins would not be as well aligned in the extrusion for reducing the moisture in the feed is to dehy-
direction. A homogenous distribution of melt and drate the meat before extrusion, which is difficult
melt pressure across the die section can be pro- to accomplish, or to increase the level of non-
vided by using attachments with multiple holes meat binders in the recipe (Alvarez et al., 1990;
between the barrel and the die. These breaker Isobe et al., 1990; Hsieh et al., 1991; Thiebaud
plates also help initiate the stream alignment of et al., 1996). Non-meat binders also affect the
protein molecules. final protein content of the feed, which usually
Another factor influencing the protein textur- varies between 15 to 40%. The final protein con-
ization is the size of the die opening. This has sig- tent depends on the type of the non-meat binders
nificant impact on melt velocity. Melt velocity and on the ratio of the meat or fish to non-meat
and shear stress at the wall would significantly binders in the formula.
increase as the size of the die opening decreases. Non-meat binders affect the extrudate proper-
Noguchi (1989) reported extrusion of defatted soy ties. Comer (1979) noted that most non-meat
flour at 60% moisture by a Mitsubishi FT-60N binders decreased extrudate firmness. Cheftel
twin screw extruder with three different die open- et al. (1992) reported that extrudates with corn
ings of 1, 3, and 5 mm. The 5 mm die produced starch as a part of the recipe were superior to
tough and smooth extrudates with higher cross- those made with soy protein isolate or wheat
wise and lengthwise strength. On the other hand, gluten. Corn starch contributed to cohesiveness,
the 1 and 3 mm die openings gave very fragile hence, the extrudates did not crumble. Samples
products with low extrudate strength. This can be containing added corn starch exhibited increased
attributed to the excessive shear stress at the wall tensile strength compared with corn gluten or soy
causing the destruction of the product when using protein isolate added samples. Samples contain-
a very narrow die opening. Therefore, optimizing ing 15% added corn starch exhibited higher ten-
the die size is important from a quality stand- sile strength than 10% added corn starch samples.
point. Higher extrusion temperatures enhanced this
effect (Alvarez et al., 1990). If starch or flour are
Animal protein-based high moisture extrusion used as binders, both starch gelatinization and
High moisture extrusion cooking of animal tis- protein denaturation contribute to the texture,
sues, either alone or in combination with plant appearance, and physical properties of the ani-
materials, has been used to upgrade protein ani- mal-protein based extrudates (Alvarez et al.,
mal by-products (Ba-Jaber et al., 1992). It is pos- 1990). Increased gelatinization also enhances the
sible to texturize hand-boned or mechanically extrudate expansion (Chauhan & Bains, 1985).
deboned meat such as chicken, turkey, beef, and Extruder operating conditions significantly
pork by extrusion cooking. The product is usual- affect the extrudate texture (Foegeding & Lanier,
ly a gelled band with a multilayer structure. The 1987; Alvarez et al., 1990). Extrusion tempera-
use of cooling dies at a temperature of 10 8C after tures need to be high enough to affect new pro-
texturization of this type is also common practice. tein states in the binders in order for them to
The binding of meat pieces can be enhanced by have an impact on texture. Thiebaud et al. (1996)
the addition of non-meat proteins and/or poly- found that barrel temperature significantly affect-
saccharides (Lawrie, 1991). These ingredients are ed the colour of the extrudates, darkening occur-
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 205
ring at high barrel temperatures (. 180 8C), pos- now in operation at a Pink Bollworm Rearing
sibly through Maillard reactions. Hardness of Facility at Phoenix, Arizona.
extrudates was found to be decreased as temper- Cheese analogs from caseinate and butter oil,
ature increased from 85 to 105 8C (Ba-Jaber et al., and fat analogs from whey protein isolates can be
1992). Extrusion temperature has also an effect made through wet extrusion. The firmness of the
on the nutritional value of the extrudates. cheese analogs is highly influenced by water and
Chicken diets extruded with full-fat soybeans at fat content. The higher the fat and water contents
122 and 126 8C contributed to maximum growth in the recipe, the softer the extrudate. Higher
in broiler chickens, whereas diets extruded at 118 screw speeds and lower moisture (50%) may
and 120 8C resulted in significantly lower body improve smoothness. The extruded cheese
weights (Perilla et al., 1997). This might be attrib- analogs could be used in pizza, hamburger, and
uted to the inactivation of antinutritional com- sauces (Cheftel et al., 1992). The pH had a sig-
pounds such as trypsin inhibitors and protease nificant effect on the firmness and smoothness of
inhibitors at temperatures over 120 8C. these products. Improved smoothness and firm-
Temperatures above 126 8C resulted in overheat- ness would necessitate a pH between 3.5 and 3.9
ing of soybeans which might have adversely for fat analogs, and a pH as high as 5 for cheese
affected the bioavailability of some amino acids. analogs. For cheese analogs, extruder operating
Higher screw speeds usually result in a better dis- temperatures are lower than for other high mois-
persion, hence, improve the textural characteris- ture extrusion applications (, 60 8C) and mois-
tics. However, residence time in the barrel ture levels vary from 60 to 75%. Larger die
shortens at higher screw speeds and decreases the orifices are preferred for this application. The
reaction time. This could be compensated with a coagulation of skim milk powder to insoluble
more aggressive screw configuration, including acid casein and the conversion of acid casein to
spacers, reverse screw elements, and/or kneading sodium caseinates are also possible by extrusion,
blocks. Sasamoto et al. (1987) found that extru- offering a productive and time-saving alternative
dates resistance to stretching is directly correlated to batch mixing.
to barrel temperature and screw speed. Excessive
moisture may lead to poor texture by making
Conclusions
‘melting’ incomplete due to dilution effect. Aoki
et al. (1989) reported an increase in the longitu- Literature on high moisture food extrusion has
dinal stretching of the extrudates by lowering been reviewed and compiled. Temperature has the
moisture levels to 60 from 67% at temperatures dominant influence on the rheological behaviour
between 160 and 180 8C. When moisture in the in the extruder for high moisture starch-based
feed increases, the protein concentration per unit systems. This finding differs from low and inter-
mass decreases, which leads to a lower number of mediate moisture extrusion, where moisture is the
fibres per unit of cross sectional area because of most influential extrusion parameter. Twin screw
reduced protein–protein interactions (Thiebaud extruders used as enzymatic bioreactors for the
et al., 1996). liquefaction and subsequent saccharification of
starch, to produce high maltose syrup, have
Other wet extrusion applications gained attention by many researchers.
Twin screw extrusion of a larval diet for mass Applications of high moisture protein extrusion
rearing of the pink bollworm moth, by using a include texturization, especially for soy proteins
long barrel Continua 37 extruder (L/D 5 39.7), and soy concentrates, and various types of fish
was developed by Edwards et al. (1996). The diet and animal meats. Various meat analogs have
is mainly composed of soy flour, wheat germ, and been produced by utilizing twin screw extruders at
agar at a moisture level of 63%, and a tempera- high moisture levels. Although wet extrusion is
ture of 150 8C and screw speed of 275 rpm was not as well explored as low moisture extrusion, it
used. The screw profile was composed of several has been used for manufacturing many novel food
kneading blocks to improve mixing, heat transfer, products and possesses the potential for replacing
and residence time in the barrel. This process is conventional methods of food processing.
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207
206 High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207 © 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd
High moisture food extrusion H. Akdogan 207
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Food Science and Technology 1999, 34, 195–207