You are on page 1of 16

School Psychology Review,

2006, Volume 35, No. 2, pp. 309-323

Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits in Children


With Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: What Is
the Connection?

Kristen S. Berthiaume
University of Kentucky

Abstract. Based on the reliable findings that children with attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) have both attentional and academic difficulties, it
is assumed that the attentional deficit contributes to the academic problems. In this
article, existing support for a link between the attentional and academic difficul-
ties experienced by children with ADHD is reviewed, and questions for future
research are identified. This article goes beyond a discussion of visual attention
problems to an investigation of the more complex processing deficits that may
contribute to acadetnic difficulties. It is suggested that current interventions for
children with ADHD that focus on decreasing disruptive behavior and increasing
simple attention to tasks may not address deficits in story comprehension skills
such as those required for many school tasks. This article draws from the
educational literature to explore possibilities for creating academic interventions
that are more effective at remedying the story comprehension deficits experienced
by children with ADHD.

The combined type of attention deficit it is imperative that we identify why children
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is one of the with ADHD exhibit academic problems so we
most common behavioral disorders among can create interventions that more specifically
children of elementary school age (Barkley, address those areas of difficulty.
1997). Core symptoms include inattention, hy- Currently, there are three subtypes of
peractivity, and impulsivity (American Psy- ADHD recognized by the American Psychiat-
chiatric Association, 1994), and each of these ric Association (1994). The predominantly in-
can have a significant impact on children's attentive type is characterized by significant
academic functioning. Stimulant medications inattention and distractibility but fewer than
and behavior management have proven effica- six symptoms of hyperactivity or impulsivity.
cious in treating the core symptoms of ADHD; Children with the predominantly hyperactive-
however, at the present time, there is little impulsive type of the disorder experience con-
evidence suggesting that these treatments pos- siderable difficulty inhibiting excessive behav-
itively influence academic achievement. Thus, iors but do not have substantial attentional

This research was supported by National Institute of Mental Health Grant MH47386. The author would
like to thatik Dr. Richard Milich and Dr. Elizabeth P. Lorch at the University of Kentucky for their
comments on several drafts of the manuscript.
Correspondence regarding this article should be addressed to Kristen Berthiaume, Department of Psychol-
ogy, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 40506-0044. E-mail: kswhiiO@uky.edu.
Copyright 2006 by the National Association of School Psychologists, ISSN 0279-6015

309
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

problems. The combined type of ADHD dif- symptoms of ADHD and the particular aspects
fers from the other subtypes in that significant of academic performance they affect have not
levels of hyperactivity, impulsivity, and inat- received a great deal of research focus. Some
tention are all present (American Psychiatric evidence indicates a link between attention
Association, 1994). Recent research suggests and academic achievement. In a longitudinal
that the combined type diagnosis also may be study of attentional problems and reading,
associated with a different set of cognitive Rabiner and Coie (2000) followed 387 chil-
deficits (Milich, Balentine, & Lynam, 2001). dren from kindergarten through fifth grade and
This article will focus on children with the collected several standardized measures of at-
combined type of the disorder and it is likely tention and reading achievement. Attentional
that the findings reviewed here do not apply to difficulties were found to predict later reading
children with ADHD, predominantly inattentive achievement even when prior reading achieve-
or predominantly hyperactive types. Because ment, IQ, and behavioral problems were
relatively little is known about how symptom controlled.
presentation differs for males and females with The emphasis in the ADHD literature on
ADHD, gender effects in the ADHD samples are the attentional deficit makes sense given the
discussed when possible. However, ADHD is performance-oriented nature of many of the
less commonly diagnosed in girls and many associated problems (e.g., being off task, re-
studies have not examined gender differences. quiring frequent redirection). However, the
main measure of attention has often been
ADHD Symptoms and Associated whether a child was looking at a task or stim-
Difficulties ulus when it was presented. Thus, this research
has yielded findings about only the initial phases
Because of the disruptive nature of the of information processing by children with
disorder, children with the combined type of ADHD (i.e., visual attention; Sergeant & van der
ADHD experience a variety of difficulties in Meer, 1990) and has often left more complex
multiple settings. One area where the symp- capabilities unmeastired. In particular, we know
toms of ADHD are likely to have a significant little about how children with ADHD perform
impact is in the classroom. Evidence suggests on cognitive processing skills required for many
that children with ADHD typically experience academic tasks like applying, analyzing, synthe-
chronic underachievement and have high rates sizing, and evaluating information.
of school failure and grade retention (Barkley, Recently, researchers have begun study-
2006). Once thought to decline after child- ing story comprehension to gauge how chil-
hood, difficulties associated with ADHD have dren with ADHD perform on tasks requiring
been shown to continue into adulthood and simple visual attention as well as more com-
have long-lasting repercussions (Barkley, plex cognitive skills. This line of research
2006). Clearly, early academic intervention is might help us connect the cognitive difficulties
a necessary step towards improving the prog- exhibited by children with ADHD to some of
noses of children with ADHD. To determine the academic problems they experience.
the areas most crucial for intervention, the Through this process, it is hypothesized that
nature of the academic problems these chil- more effective interventions can be created.
dren experience must be explored. Reviewing the development of these skills in
ADHD consists of many intercorrelated nonreferred children is a crucial step towards
symptoms, each of which may contribute to identifying specific deficits present in the story
the academic difficulties these children expe- comprehension skills of children with ADHD.
rience. Failing to inhibit responses and hyper-
activity both could be problematic in the class- Story Comprehension Research
room. However, behavioral problems might
not fully explain this group's academic diffi- Story comprehension tasks make up a
culties. As yet, connections between specific significant component of school performance
310
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

(e.g., reading and writing tasks) and involve comprehended and remembered (Trabasso,
many cognitive skills in addition to simple Secco, & van den Broek, 1984; van den
visual attention (Lorch, Diener et al., 1999; Broek, 1989).
Sanchez, Lorch, & Milich, 1999). Thus, ex- As nonreferred children age, they be-
amining them provides us with the opportunity come more sensitive to causal relations among
to evaluate children's understanding of com- story events and better able to integrate them
plex events (van den Broek, Bauer, & Bourg, into a coherent whole (van den Broek, 1989).
1997) like those they encounter in many These improvements may be the mechanisms
school tasks. As such, story comprehension is through which children become better able to
a powerful gauge of both cognitive processing use causal relations to guide comprehension
and cognitive development. Investigating and recall as they get older (Ackerman, Paine,
story comprehension skills provides us insight & Silver, 1991). Children with ADHD are
into many aspects of children's cognitive believed to exhibit a lag in developing many
functioning, which include the following: the important academic and social skills; thus,
strategic allocation of attention; the selection, their performance on story comprehension
encoding, and interpretation of important in- tasks may more closely resemble that of
formation; the use of story structure; the re- younger, nonreferred peers. By examining
trieval of relevant background information; how children with ADHD comprehend story
the generation of inferences that allow inter- events and represent the relations among
pretation of presented information; the moni- them, we can gain new insight into their cog-
toring of comprehension; and the use of re- nitive processing abilities (Lorch et al., 1998).
trieval skills (Lorch, Milich, & Sanchez, Ultimately, investigation of story comprehen-
1998). Thus, the investigation of children's sion in children with ADHD may shed light on
story comprehension offers insight into many many of their acadetnic difficulties and inform
aspects of their comprehension in general the creation of effective academic interven-
(Lorch et al., 1998). tions for these children.
Current story comprehension research
emphasizes the importance of the causal con- Story Comprehension in Children With
nections that exist among story events ADHD
(Graesser & Clark, 1985) and their role in
maintaining a coherent understanding of the Research employing televised stories
story (Lorch, Diener et al., 1999; Sanchez et has found that school-aged children with
al., 1999). One important structural property ADHD do not produce deficient recall of fac-
of stories is a focus on the goals arising from tual story information, regardless of whether
story events that in turn lead to other actions salient distracters (e.g., toys) are present dur-
and outcomes (Stein & Glenn, 1979). Because ing viewing (Landau, Lorch, & Milich, 1992;
of their central role in maintaining story struc- Lorch et al., 2000; Lorch, Sanchez et al.,
ture, a thorough understanding of story goals 1999). Children with ADHD and their nonre-
is crucial for effective story comprehension. ferred peers have better recall of factual events
Another particularly important aspect of story that are high in importance (e.g., many causal
comprehension is the number of causal con- connections to other events; Sanchez, Milich,
nections that events have to one another. Hooks, & Welsh, 1997). Thus, these children
Events with many causal connections are can recall factual information from stories as
linked to several other events in the story well as their nonreferred peers, even when
through antecedents and/or consequences, and their attention is divided. In addition, their
are most important to story coherence. Re- recall is similarly influenced by event impor-
search findings suggest that the number of tance, as is that of nonreferred children.
causal connections that goals and other story However, a different pattem emerges for
events have to previous and subsequent events questions regarding causal relations (Lorch et
can influence the way in which stories are al., 2000; Sanchez et al., 1999). The extant
311
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

literature indicates that school-aged children tual information from lectures or stories, ig-
with ADHD are less sensitive to the causal noring the importance of how story events are
structure of stories and show poorer perfor- related to one another. Instruction emphasiz-
mance on causal relations questions than non- ing causal relations among events might help
referred peers when salient distracters are sensitize children with ADHD to the organiz-
present (Lorch et al., 2000; Sanchez et al., ing structure of stories and lectures, and assist
1999). This finding indicates that children them in building more effective representa-
with ADHD have a more tentative grasp of tions to guide understanding and recall. One
causal connections than do nonreferred chil- way of sensitizing children with ADHD to the
dren. Thus, they may have more difficulty connections among story events might be for
understanding how story events are related teachers to systematically ask students why
when their attention is divided. Not surpris- story events occur as information is being
ingly, children with ADHD appear to have presented. These questions of causal relations
more trouble organizing causal connections should help students with ADHD to appreciate
among story events into a coherent represen- that story events have an underlying coherence
tation (Sanchez et al., 1999). Specifically, they and are not merely a series of discrete facts.
may have difficulty identifying and under- Using the same folktales and participant
standing causal relations, effectively encoding recruitment methods as Lorch, Diener et al.
them, and/or using them to guide later re- (1999), Lorch et al. (2004) examined the effect
trieval of story information (Lorch et al., that studying has on story comprehension and
1998). recall among children with ADHD. Thirty-six
Lorch, Diener et al. (1999) used folk- 7- to 11-year-old children with ADHD and 43
tales to examine the extent to which the num- of their nonreferred peers listened to one of
ber of causal connections that events had to two folktales and recalled the story both be-
other events was predictive of later recall. fore and after studying a written version for up
Seventy-one 7- to 11-year-old boys and girls to 10 min. Events were presented on separate
with confirmed diagnoses of combined type pages of the study booklet so time spent on
ADHD, along with 64 of their peers, were each event could be recorded. For both groups,
invited to participate in the study. Children recall increased as the number of causal con-
with only learning disability diagnoses or sig- nections that events had to other events in-
nificantly low IQ scores were not included. creased, but this effect was stronger for non-
Each story event was coded for the number of referred children than for children with
causal connections it had to other story events, ADHD. Findings indicated that groups did not
and transcriptions from sessions were coded differ in terms of their observable study be-
for which story events participants recalled. havior. However, when children with ADHD
The number of causal connections that events and their nonreferred peers with similar IQ
had to other events was predictive of recall for scores were compared on the amount of new
all children, but nonreferred children were information they gained from studying, the
found to be more sensitive to story structure. former group performed more poorly, espe-
That is, as the number of causal connections to cially at the highest levels of causal
a story event increased, the increase in recall connections.
for that event was steeper for nonreferred chil- The results suggest that simply encour-
dren than for children with ADHD. aging children with ADHD to "study more" or
Findings from this study suggest that relying solely on interventions that facilitate
academic interventions placing emphasis on study behaviors (e.g., stimulant medication)
connections in text might be a way of sensi- may not sufficiently increase the effectiveness
tizing children with ADHD to the overall of their studying to identify and remember
structure of a story. Daily instruction of chil- causal relations among events. A more effec-
dren of elementary school age too often fo- tive strategy might be to teach children with
cuses primarily on helping children gain fac- ADHD to study the connections among story
312
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

events. Study aids could be created that re- acter's overall goal and specific attempts made
quire students to outline the material to be by the main character to reach the overall goal.
learned in such a fashion that causal connec- Flory et al. (2004) used the same activity
tions are highlighted. For example, a guide employed by Renz et al. (2003) to examine
like a story map that requires the student to fill group differences in story narrations of 116
in major events in sequence could assist him boys and girls, 7-9 years old, with and without
or her in connecting the events and solidifying ADHD. In addition to narrating the wordless
the overall causal structure of the story. Re- picture books, children completed three tasks
search employing story maps to help children assessing the core deficits of ADHD. Results
with ADHD understand causal connections is revealed that, although containing as many
currently underway by Lorch and colleagues words as those of nonreferred children, the
(Lorch et al., 2006). Given that the studying narratives of children with ADHD included
behavior of children with ADHD was similar fewer elements relating to causal structure and
to that of their nonreferred peers in the Lorch goal plan. No effects were found for gender.
et al. (2004) research, an examination of group Character goals and the subgoals that
differences in cognitive processing while the result from unsuccessful attempts to achieve
study period is ongoing might be another fruit- overall goals are aspects of stories that have
ful avenue of future research. special importance in understanding causal re-
lations among events. Research has found that
Measures of Ongoing Story children need to comprehend how goals and
Comprehension subgoals lead to actions and story outcomes so
they can develop a coherent narrative repre-
Only a handful of studies have em- sentation (Trabasso & Stein, 1997). Renz et al.
ployed methodologies that measure compre- (2003) and Flory et al. (2004) demonstrated
hension of ongoing printed or audiotaped sto- that children with ADHD have difficulty
ries by children with ADHD. In one investi- maintaining focus on characters' goals as they
gation (Milch-Reich, Campbell, Pelham, build a story representation. To remedy this
Connelly, & Geva, 1999), 79 boys, 5-10 years deficiency, instruction should focus on helping
old, with and without combined type ADHD, these children relate ongoing events to what
were asked to tell the story represented by a characters are attempting to accomplish and
series of pictures. Narrations were coded for how characters must change their behavior in
the kinds of events represented in the stories response to outcomes that result from unsuc-
and the causal relations among events. Find- cessful attempts to achieve goals. Story maps
ings revealed that, regardless of diagnostic and similar tools help children understand
group, stories represented a similar number of goals by identifying causes, character actions,
events. However, children with ADHD em- and outcomes. Teachers can help students fo-
ployed fewer causal relations in their narra- cus on goals by asking questions about char-
tives, indicating poorer understanding of how acter goals, attempts to reach those goals, and
story events were connected to one another. the outcomes of those attempts.
In a similar study, Renz et al. (2003) The study by Flory et al. (2004) found
asked 22 boys, 9-11 years old, with confirmed that the differences in understanding goal
diagnoses of ADHD, and 44 of their nonre- structure between children with ADHD and
ferred peers to narrate a wordless picture their nonreferred peers could best be ac-
book. Boys with ADHD were able to produce counted for by deficits in ability to sustain
narratives equal in length to those of nonre- attention. To examine how the sustained atten-
ferred boys but had difficulties representing tional deficit might relate to the difficulty chil-
some important aspects of the story. Specifi- dren with ADHD have in understanding causal
cally, stories produced by boys in the ADHD relations and goal-attempt-outcome sequences,
group were deficient in two major story gram- a technique for gauging ongoing engagement
mar categories: completion of the main char- with highly important, plot-relevant informa-
313
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

tion is needed. The secondary task provides Whirley, Lorch, Lemberger, and Milich
such a measurement tool. (2003) used the probe task to examine the role
attentional problems might play in accounting
Secondary Task Paradigm for the story comprehension difficulties expe-
rienced by boys with ADHD. Specifically, the
The secondary task paradigm requires study investigated whether ongoing variations
the child to divide cognitive resources be-
in cognitive engagement with a televised story
tween a primary task like television viewing
were related to the continuity of central or
and a secondary task like reacting to an audi-
incidental information. Reaction-time probes
tory probe. The assumption underlying this
were placed at preselected points throughout
methodology is that because mental process-
ing requires time and central processing ca- sequences of central, plot-relevant informa-
pacity is limited, the more resources one de- tion. Recruitment and screening procedures
votes to the primary task, the fewer that will similar to those used by Lorch, Diener et al.
be available for the secondary task (Lorch & (1999) were used; 22 boys, 9-11 years old,
Castle, 1997). Thus, slower or increased reac- with ADHD and 36 of their nonreferred peers
tion times to the secondary task are assumed to participated. Findings revealed that nonre-
reflect deeper processing of or greater cogni- ferred boys showed the expected linear in-
tive engagement with the primary task. As crease in cognitive engagement (i.e., probe
such, the secondary task contrasts with com- reaction times became slower) as additional
monly used measures of sustained attention important information was provided in the
(e.g., the Continuous Performance Task) that story. In contrast, boys with ADHD did not
merely require simple reactions to discrete show the expected slowing in reaction time
visual stimuli. The secondary task is an espe- until relatively late into the central sequences
cially sensitive measure that can pick up more (i.e., after 12 s), and actually exhibited a slight
subtle variations in cognitive engagement and decrease in reaction time as central sequences
link them directly to changes in the impor- continued from 7 to 12 s. Thus, as the central
tance of story events. information progressed and necessitated
Findings from research employing the deeper engagement, boys with ADHD actually
secondary task paradigm with nonreferred became less engaged. This delay in increasing
children suggest that the developing causal engagement may have caused the boys with
structure of the ongoing story guides the allo- ADHD to miss important connections between
cation of cognitive resources (Lorch & Castle, events, which might explain the comprehen-
1997). Listeners create mental representations sion problems children with ADHD have
of stories by strategically allocating their at- shown in previous studies and the difficulties
tention to highly important, plot-relevant story they experience in many complex academic
information. To effectively comprehend a tasks.
story, listeners must allocate greater engage-
It is unclear why children with ADHD
ment with central information and filter out
incidental information. The probe task is a show a delay in becoming engaged with im-
secondary task paradigm in which the child's portant story material. One possibility is that
primary activity is to watch a televised story they are unable to filter story information
that he or she will later be asked questions quickly enough to determine what is important
about, and his or her secondary task is to turn in time to increase their engagement. Another
off auditory probes as quickly as possible explanation is that these children do not notice
while the story is ongoing (Lorch & Castle, cues that signal the significance of an event.
1997). Engagement can be measured at vari- Either way, intervention strategies should fo-
ous points within a given segment of central or cus on helping these children learn what
incidental information through reaction times makes an event central versus incidental to a
to auditory probes. story. Teachers might collect from students'
314
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

Table 1
Story Comprehension Research
Effect
Study Groups Measures Group Differences Size /•"

Lorch, Diener 71 ADHD Free recall of Number of casual connections .31


et al. 64 NR folktales predicted recall less
(1999) Ages 7-11 strongly for ADHD group
Boys & girls
Lorch et al. 36 ADHD Free recall of For higher IQ group, ADHD .33
(2004) 43 NR folktales after group gained less new
Ages 7-11 studying them information from studying
Boys & girls
Milch-Reich 41 ADHD Tell a story ADHD group included fewer .36
et al. 38 NR represented by causal relations in
(1999) Ages 5-10 series of narratives
Boys pictures
Renz et al. 22 ADHD Narrate a wordless ADHD group less likely to .41
(2003) 44 NR picture book include completion of
Ages 9-11 overall goal & specific .41
Boys attempts to reach goal
Flory et al. 49 ADHD Narrate a wordless ADHD group less likely to .25
(2004) 67 NR picture book include initiating events &
Ages 7-9 completion of overall goal .15
Boys & girls
Whirley et al. 22 ADHD Watch TV show ADHD group failed to .40
(2003) 36 NR & turn off become engaged with
Ages 9-11 audio probes centrally important
Boys information until late into
sequences
Walczyk & 29 reflective Detect inconsistent Impulsive readers had more .36
Hall (1989) 30 impulsive information in difficulty detecting text
Third- & texts inconsistencies
fifth-graders
Boys & girls

Note. ADHD = attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; NR = nonreferred.


"F values used to calculate effect size r (Rosenthal, 1994). Large effect, r = .50; medium effect, r - .30; small
effect, r = .10.

evidence that a given event is central to the Story Comprehension Review


plot of the story by asking questions about how
the event is connected with other story events Based on this review of the story com-
and, more importantly, whether it is related to prehension literature (see Table 1), it appears
the main character's overall goal. Asking stu- that the difficulties exhibited by children with
dents to predict future story events based on ADHD are particularly evident in regard to
previous ones may also help prime students to their sensitivity to the causal structure of sto-
engage with important information. ries (Lorch et al., 1999; Lorch et al., 2004),

315
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

their understanding of and sensitivity to causal convergence of clinical, cognitive, and educa-
connections between goals and subsequent ac- tional literatures.
tion-outcome sequences in stories (Flory et
al., 2004; Renz et al., 2003), and their pattems Reading Comprehension
of engagement with continuing, plot-relevant
story information (Whirley et al., 2003). Comprehension instruction researchers
Many of the studies considered found (e.g.. Brown, 1980) have identified several
similar levels of visual attention between cognitive processes in which active, thought-
ADHD and nonreferred samples (Lorch et al., ful readers engage, including (a) activating
2000; Whirley et al., 2003), suggesting that prior knowledge and connecting it to new in-
the deficits the former group has in under- formation, (b) predicting consequences of an
standing causal relations are not because of action or event, (c) asking questions about the
difficulty in visually attending to the story. text, (d) monitoring comprehension and taking
Further, school-aged children with ADHD are corrective action when comprehension failures
able to remember a similar amount of factual are detected, and (e) recovering from dismp-
information as well as their nonreferred peers. tions and distractions. Poor comprehenders
In addition, tasks like story narration and sec- might have deficits in their current knowledge
ondary task methodologies limit the impact base, show difficulty understanding new infor-
memory deficits have on performance, yet mation they are reading, or have problems
story comprehension difficulties are noted for connecting the two sources of information.
children with ADHD even when those tasks They might fail to ask themselves questions
are employed. Thus, the problems these chil- about the text that would aid in understanding
dren have on measures of story comprehen- and recall. Finally, these children may be less
sion are perhaps because of factors other than skilled at connecting and integrating story or
deficits in visual attention or memory. text information into a mental representation
to guide comprehension and recall.
Intervention strategies designed only to
overcome deficits in visual attention or to in- Although not specifically focused on
crease the amount of time children spend children with ADHD, one study did examine
working on tasks may be insufficient for rem- the role impulsivity, a core feature of the dis-
edying the story comprehension difficulties order, may play in the effective application of
children with ADHD have. Although treat- comprehension skills. Walczyk and Hall
ment approaches aimed at improving the at- (1989) assessed the comprehension-monitor-
tending and studying behaviors of children ing abilities of 48 third-graders and 48 fifth-
with ADHD might prime them to better un- graders classified as "impulsive" versus "re-
derstand and remember stories, these methods flective" readers based on their Matching Fa-
may not sensitize them to the causal relations miliar Figures Test performance. Findings
among story events. Thus, research is needed revealed that reflective children were better
to guide the creation of interventions effective able to detect text inconsistencies than were
at remedying the difficulties in story compre- impulsive children, but there were no group
hension experienced by children with ADHD. differences in terms of information recall.
To design more effective academic in- However, reflective readers did recall more of
terventions for these children, it is necessary the information necessary for identifying in-
that we examine the skills identified by the consistencies in the text. The authors argue
educational literature as cmcial for success on that the difficulty impulsive readers had mon-
academic tasks. It might also be beneficial to itoring their comprehension is partially owing
exatnine how empirically supported treat- to their failure to employ any effective strate-
ments for children with ADHD differ from gies for analyzing reading materials. Although
those interventions found to benefit nonre- the comprehension-monitoring skills of chil-
ferred children experiencing academic diffi- dren with ADHD have not yet been subjected
culty, and how future research might guide a to a great deal of research, findings from the
316
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

educational literature suggest this could be a in inference making was superior to standard
fruitful next step toward improving metacog- comprehension strategies for helping less-
nitive awareness in these children. skilled comprehenders understand the story.
A number of techniques have been cre- This study and others suggest that, given ap-
ated and studied for their use in improving the propriate instruction, children with deficits in
reading comprehension of students identified understanding connections among story events
as poor comprehenders. In their research, Cain may learn how to use context and prior knowl-
and Oakhill (1998) discuss three specific pro- edge to improve their comprehension and re-
cesses that account for many of the difficulties call skills.
poor comprehenders experience: inferencing Another approach for helping students
ability, use of text structure, and comprehen- with ADHD learn to emphasize causal rela-
sion monitoring. Inferencing ability and un- tions is to provide them with the opportunity
derstanding of text structure are both crucial to practice drawing inferences from text. From
for creating mental representations of stories any given event, causal relations can connect
because they guide the allocation of cognitive backward to explain past occurrences or lead
resources and promote comprehension of text forward to produce future events, and antici-
information. Monitoring comprehension is a pating consequences of events has been shown
critical step towards ensuring that all impor- to be a better predictor of overall story recall
tant story information is incorporated into the than making backward connections (van den
ongoing mental representation used to guide Broek et al., 1997). Thus, teaching and en-
recall and understanding of a story. couraging students with ADHD to predict later
story events may be particularly critical in
Strategy Training in Reading
helping children grasp causal relations. To
Comprehension
train students with ADHD in metacognitive
Training students with ADHD to use awareness about predictions, teachers could
inference-making and self-questioning strate- engage them in evidence-gathering processes.
gies may be a way to remedy the story com- Following the formation of a prediction,
prehension difficulties they experience. These teachers might ask students to list the evidence
two approaches appear to directly target many based on previous events and prior knowledge
of the complex cognitive processes involved that the predicted event will occur. If the ex-
in reading comprehension because they focus pected event does not occur, students should
on causal connections among story events and reexamine their evidence to determine why
the overall causal structure of stories. their prediction was not confirmed.

Training in inference making. Infer- Training in self'questioning. A sec-


ential processing allows students to make ond strategy that helps to promote in-depth
sense of information implied in text, and often processing of texts is self-questioning. Skilled
requires making connections between previ- readers ask themselves questions about texts
ous knowledge and new information, or and about their own understanding of texts.
among text events. Inference making helps not Answering those questions helps the reader
only with understanding of text but also with develop a richer, more in-depth understanding
recall of text information (Yuill & Oakhill, of story events and the connections among
1991). Consequently, it is an important process them. In addition, self-questioning assists the
for connecting events in text and integrating text reader in identifying where comprehension
information to form a mental representation. has failed, allowing him or her to remedy the
McGee and Johnson (2003) examined difficulties before more confusion occurs.
the effects of training 75 children, 6-9 years Asking questions about text propels the reader
old, classified as "skilled" versus "less- forward and makes discontinuation of reading
skilled" comprehenders in inference-making less likely.
techniques. The findings revealed that training Research has supported the use of self-
317
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

questioning strategies to improve the reading important information from the story and to
comprehension of school-aged children clas- ask relevant questions to help with compre-
sified as poor comprehenders (Hansen, 1981). hension and recall.
A meta-analysis of 68 studies designed to im-
prove reading comprehension in students with Integration of Clinical, Cognitive, and
learning disabilities (Mastropieri, Scruggs, Educational Literatures
Bakken, & Whedon, 1996) found that inter-
ventions including a self-questioning compo- Although a good deal of research has
nent resulted in greater improvement than in- demonstrated the positive impact of training in
structional approaches that did not include comprehension strategies for nonreferred,
self-questioning. Consequently, Mastropieri less-skilled readers, very few strategies have
and Scruggs (1997) identified self-questioning been studied specifically for use with an
strategies as among the best practices for fa- ADHD population. As mentioned previously,
cilitating reading comprehension of students current empirically validated treatments for
with learning difficulties. children with ADHD are stimulant medication
and behavior modification. Such interventions
Learning to use effective comprehen-
have demonstrated efficacy for improving
sion-monitoring strategies might help children
some of the academic problems these chil-
with ADHD recognize the gaps in their under-
dren experience. For example, these treat-
standing of how text and lecture events are
ments have been found to decrease disrup-
connected to one another. Explicit training in
tive behavior and increase the quantity of
strategies for filling in those gaps, once identi-
academic work produced. However, the im-
fied, will further aid these children in creating
pact of medication on performance of com-
more complete story representations. Self-ques-
plex academic skills like comprehension of
tionitig about comprehension is one strategy
complex texts and skill acquisition has not
found effective at promoting comprehension
been established.
monitoring. Teacher modeling of simple, com-
prehension-related questions might help stu- In an early study, Conrad, Dworkin,
dents with ADHD learn to recognize when Shai, and Tobiesson (1971) found that neither
comprehension failures occur. Training in treatment with a stimulant medication (i.e.,
strategies like rereading, note taking, and sum- dextroamphetamine) alone nor in combination
marizing will assist children in repairing gaps with perceptual-cognitive tutoring had any ef-
in comprehension. fect on the academic achievement of children
with ADHD. More recently, the Multimodal
Multiple strategy training. Several Treatment Study of Children with Attention
studies have supported the use of multiple Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (The MTA Co-
strategy training for improving reading com- operative Group, 1999), a 14-month random-
prehension. For example, Heinsen (1981) ized clinical trial of treatment strategies for
trained 24 second-graders to use inference- children with ADHD, compared medication
making and self-questioning strategies. Find- management, behavioral treatment, medica-
ings revealed that students who received train- tion and behavioral treatment together, and
ing exhibited superior understanding of the standard community care in 579 children with
story, as evidenced by their performance on the combined type of the disorder. Findings
comprehension questions. In a series of stud- revealed that even the best-practices combina-
ies, Palinscar and Brown (1984) included self- tion of stimulant medication and behavioral
questioning and inference-making training in a modification did not normalize the functioning
multiple strategy approach taught to seventh- of these children. According to the consensus
graders identified as poor comprehenders. statement issued by this group, stimulant med-
Compared to a typical classroom teaching ication is effective in improving the core
method, the experimental approach led to im- symptoms of ADHD but has limited effects on
provement in children's ability to summarize academic achievement.
318
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

Table 2
Proposed Academic Interventions for Children With ADHD
Area of Deficit Proposed Intervention

Using causal connections to guide recall of Ask students why events occur as story infonnation is
stories & understanding causal structure presented
of stories (Lorch et al., 2000; Lorch, Train students in inferencing to help them use prior
Diener et al., 1999; Milch-Reich et al., knowledge & text information in understanding stories
1999; Whirley et al., 2003) Teach students prereading, listening, & studying
strategies to prepare them for upcoming important
story events & connections among events
Using causal connections to guide recall of Have students complete causal relations comprehension
story information while studying (Lorch questions while studying
et al., 2004)
Understanding importance of goals & Guide student practice in identifying & focusing on
subgoals in stories (Renz et al., 2003; goal-action-outcome sequences in stories
Flory et al., 2003)
Creating & understanding inferences Give students practice drawing inferences & engaging in
evidence gathering to support them
Monitoring comprehension & recognizing Train students in self-questioning to gauge understanding
when comprehension has failed during task
(Berthiaume, 2005; Walczyk & Hall, Instruct students in using self-questioning strategies to
1989) monitor ongoing comprehension
Practicing & employing comprehension Reinforce student effort in leaming & using
strategies comprehension strategies
Give students meaningful texts to read & present
information as to the purposes of reading

More specifically related to story com- modification. As Rabiner and Coie (2000)
prehension, Francis, Fine, and Tannock (2001) hypothesized in their study of reading achieve-
asked 50 children with confirmed diagnoses of ment, children with attentional problems may
combined type ADHD to retell stories they have trouble acquiring new reading skills and
had heard and seen as wordless picture books, catching up on reading skills they have failed
both on and off stimulant medication. Find- to acquire. This may be the case even when
ings revealed that although children more of- visual attention and on-task behavior have
ten reported story characters' internal re- improved.
sponses and attempts while on methylpheni- New academic intervention strategies
date, the medication had no effect on their may need to be created to assist children with
inferential comprehension performance. Thus, ADHD in making connections among events
stimulant medications and behavioral modifi- and using those connections to form coherent
cation programs may prime children with representations of lectures and texts. Many of
ADHD to perform complex cognitive tasks the comprehension strategies used success-
by helping them focus and attend. However, fully for nonreferred children with academic
there is research to suggest that children difficulty emphasize integrating infonnation
with ADHD exhibit academic and story from text and from previous knowledge into
comprehension deficits that are not reme- mental representations of story and text
died by stimulant medication or behavior events. Unfortunately, despite the obvious ac-
319
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

ademic difficulties children with ADHD ex- junction with the treatments currently recom-
hibit, very little research has examined use of mended for children with ADHD, as the symp-
interventions supported in the educational re- toms of the disorder are likely to interfere with
search literature with this group. children's ability to attend to, retain, and practice
techniques for improving comprehension skills.
Academic Intervention for Children
With ADHD Reinforcing Comprehension Strategies
for Children With ADHD
Children with ADHD are typically
treated with interventions aimed at improving Given that many children with ADHD
their behavior and visual attention, but not experience low frustration tolerance and mo-
their story comprehension skills. Also, aca- tivational difficulties, it will be important to
demic skill remediation strategies are gener- enlist their cooperation if strategy training is to
ally not implemented in the regular classroom be undertaken in addition to their regular
(Pressley, 2002). Thus, it appears that many of schoolwork. A number of methods may help
the cognitive deficits exhibited by children children with ADHD "buy into" these inter-
with ADHD in studies of their story compre- ventions. Applying a reinforcement system for
hension are not being adequately addressed at promoting the use of comprehension and com-
this time. The significant impact of compre- prehension-monitoring strategies is a neces-
hension strategy training on nonreferred, less- sary step. In addition, several researchers sug-
skilled comprehenders suggests that the diffi- gest that children will be more motivated to
culties children with ADHD have in these improve their performance outcomes (i.e., test
areas also might be improved through reme- scores, and so on) if teachers praise them for
diation. Table 2 presents many of the story engaging in leaming processes like metacog-
comprehension difficulties children with nitive strategies (Gaskins & Gaskins, 1997).
ADHD appear to exhibit, the studies docu- For example, a student who asks himself why
menting those findings, and proposed inter- a story event occurred following strategy
ventions for remedying the deficits. training should be reinforced for attempting to
make connections between events. Similarly, a
Unfortunately, the treatment literature
student who looks back to an earlier part of a
rarely, if ever, recommends interventions that
story to understand something she has just
focus on training children with ADHD to en-
read should be reinforced for using effective
hance their representation of story information
comprehension-monitoring skills. To make
by using causal relations. This omission is ex-
the intervention rewarding, students with
plained by the fact that very little research has
ADHD should be reinforced both for improve-
tied together findings from the clinical, cogni-
ments in performance and for effectively en-
tive, and educational research literatures to ex-
gaging in strategy training. Explaining to
amine how the cognitive-processing skills of
these students the purpose of a task may be a
children with ADHD differ from those of their
key step toward increasing motivation and
classmates. Further, research has not investi-
task persistence. Students will be more likely
gated how children with ADHD might benefit
to put effort into comprehending texts that are
from receiving strategy instruction that empha-
relevant to their lives and interests, and will be
sizes understanding causal relations. Research
better able to understand texts when they al-
suggests that current empirically validated treat-
ready hold some relevant knowledge.
ments for children with ADHD may not improve
some aspects of academic performance (Conrad Future Directions in Academic
et al., 1971; Francis et al., 2001; The MTA Intervention for ChUdren With ADHD
Cooperative Group, 1999). Thus, a move toward
use of strategies that target deficits in story com- An important area of future research is
prehension skills could be a crucial next step. determining the causes of and contributing
Educational intervention will work best in con- factors to the difficulties children with ADHD
320
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

exhibit in tasks like story comprehension. Spe- comprehension deficits may be caused by co-
cifically, strong evidence indicates that these morbid learning problems. Future research
children have deficits in their executive func- should attempt to further distinguish between
tioning abilities like planning, directing be- the problems associated with the two disor-
havior towards a goal, and mentally manipu- ders. On a more practical note, children exhib-
lating information (i.e., working memory). iting difficulty in understanding causal rela-
Several researchers have identified problems tions would greatly benefit from academic in-
with working memory as a central deficit of tervention, regardless of which diagnosis is
ADHD (Barkley, 1997; Rapport, Chung, most prominent.
Shore, & Isaacs, 2001), and the educational Future research is critical for better un-
research literature suggests that working mem- derstanding the effects that current ADHD
ory limitations contribute to the comprehen- treatments have on reading comprehension,
sion problems experienced by less-skilled, and for clarifying how interventions from the
nonreferred children (Yuill & Oakhill, 1991). educational research literature will transfer to
Given that skills involved in story and text an ADHD population. First, we need to iden-
comprehension place great demand on chil- tify the reading comprehension skills on which
dren's working memory, working memory children with ADHD exhibit deficits. Specifi-
deficits are certain to have a negative impact cally, researchers should consider how these
on reading and listening comprehension children perform on tasks like creating infer-
(Lorch et al., 1998; Lorch, Diener et al., 1999). ences and using self-questioning strategies to
Additional research is needed to examine monitor ongoing comprehension. One next
whether strategy training in nonreferred pop- step would be to examine how specific com-
ulations works to improve text comprehension ponents of story comprehension relate to these
through reduction of the burden placed on deficits. Investigating these connections can
working memory (Yuill & Oakhill, 1991). If allow for the creation of assessment measures
so, future studies should consider ways to re- that specifically pinpoint the comprehension
duce the constraints placed on story or text difficulties experienced by children with ADHD.
comprehension by working memory limita- Measures employed to diagnose ADHD
tions in children with ADHD. might begin to evaluate skill in making con-
It has been argued elsewhere that chil- nections among events, creating inferences,
dren with the predominantly inattentive type and monitoring comprehension. It will also
of ADHD have a different set of deficits from be important to explore how story compre-
their counterparts exhibiting both inattention hension predicts aspects of academic achieve-
and hyperactivity-impulsivity (MiUch et al, ment at different developmental periods.
2001). Thus, it is not clear whether these two Once research has identified ways chil-
conditions should be considered subtypes of dren with ADHD differ from their same-aged,
the same disorder. This article has focused on nonreferred peers in terms of academic and
children with the combined type of the disor- story comprehension skills, strategies that pro-
der and it is possible that findings reviewed mote understanding of causal relations and
here do not apply to children with the predom- comprehension of stories can be modified for
inantly inattentive type of ADHD. Examining this population. The next step is for research to
gender differences in story comprehension and examine whether children with ADHD can be
academic skills of children with ADHD is trained successfully to use those strategies.
another important avenue for research. At the Special attention should be paid to interven-
current time, relatively little is known about tions that reduce the working memory de-
girls with ADHD and how their cognitive def- mands made by story comprehension tasks, as
icits might differ from those of their male these are likely to have the best success. Pos-
peers. Children with combined type ADHD itive reinforcement may facilitate instruction
often have diagnoses of learning disability as in and promote the use of comprehension
well, and it is unclear to what extent story strategies.
321
School Psychology Review, 2006, Volume 35, No. 2

Conclusion C. Hume & R. M. Joshi (Eds.), Reading and spelling:


Development and disorders (pp. 329-342). London:
Even under optimal conditions in which Erlbaum.
Conrad, W. G., Dworkin, E. S., Shai, A., & Tobiesson,
visual attention is high and comparable to that J. E. (1971). Effects of amphetamine therapy and pre-
of nonreferred children (e.g., one-on-one test- scriptive tutoring on the behavior and achievement of
ing) children with ADHD have difficulty with lower class hyperactive children. Journal of Leaming
Disabilities, 9, 43-54.
certain story comprehension tasks. Findings Flory, K., Hayden, A. N., Milich, R., Lorch, E. P.,
from this literature review suggest that we Strange, C , & Welsh, R. (2004). On line story com-
may not be able to account for all of the prehension among children with ADHD: Which core
deficits are involved? Unpublished manuscript.
academic problems experienced by children Francis, S., Fine, J., & Tannock, R. (2001). Methylpheni-
with ADHD simply by examining whether date selectively improves story retelling in children
they appear to be attending (e.g., looking at with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of
Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology, 11, 217-
TV). Current empirically validated treatments 228.
are aimed at increasing simple attention and Gaskins, R. W., & Gaskins, I. W. (1997). Creating readers
decreasing problematic behavior. However, who read for meaning and love to read: Benchmark
these methods do not appear to positively in- school reading program. In S. A. Stahl & D. A. Hayes
(Eds.), Instructional models in reading, (pp. 131-159).
fiuence academic achievement in children Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
with ADHD and we must be open to other Graesser, A. C , & Clark, L. F. (1985). Structures and
types of intervention. The educational re- procedures of implicit knowledge. Norwood, NJ:
Ablex.
search literature offers numerous strategies Hansen, J. (1981). The effects of inference training and
shown to improve reading comprehension in practice on young children's reading comprehension.
less-skilled, nonreferred children. To the ex- Reading Research Quarterly, 3, 391-417.
Landau, S., Lorch, E. P., & Milich, R. (1992). Visual
tent the story comprehension difficulties expe- attention to and comprehension of television in atten-
rienced by children with ADHD (e.g., under- tion-deficit hyperactivity disordered and normal boys.
standing causal relations) are related to reading Child Development, 63, 928-937.
Lorch, E. P., & CasUe, V. J. (1997). Preschool children's
comprehension skills like creating inferences attention to television: Visual attention and probe re-
and monitoring comprehension, training in com- sponse times. Journal of Experimental Child Psychol-
prehension strategies may prove useful and re- ogy, 66, 111-127.
Lorch, E. P., Diener, M. B., Sanchez, R. P., Milich, R.,
sult in academic performance improvements. van den Broek, P., & Welsh, R. (1999). The effects of
Once problem areas are identified, research story structure on the recall of stories in children with
should focus on examining the potential benefits attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of Ed-
ucational Psychology, 92, 273-283.
of strategy training with the ADHD population.
Lorch, E. P., Lemberger, C. C , Milich, R., & Berthiaume,
K. S. (2005). A developmental examination of cogni-
References tive engagement and story comprehension in nonre-
ferred children and children with ADHD. Unpublished
Ackerman, B. P., Paine, J., & Silver, D. (1991). Building manuscript.
a story representation: The effects of early concepts on Lorch, E. P., Milich, R., & Sanchez, R. P. (1998). Story
later causal inferences by children. Developmental comprehension in children with ADHD. Clinical Child
Psychology, 27, 370-380. and Family Psychology Review, 1, 163-178.
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic Lorch, E. P., Milich, R., Sanchez, R. P., van den Broek, P.,
and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Baer, S., Hooks, K., Hartung, C , & Welsh, R. (2000).
Washington, DC: Author. Comprehension of televised stories in attention deficit
Barkley, R. A. (1998). Behavioral inhibition, sustained hyperactivity disordered and nonreferred boys. Journal
attention, and executive functions: Constructing a uni- of Abnormal Psychology, 109, 321-330.
fying theory of ADHD. Psychological Bulletin, 121, Lorch, E. P., O'Neil, K., Berthiaume, K. S., Milich, R.,
65-94. Eastham, D., & Brooks, T. (2004). Story comprehen-
Barkley, R. (2006). Attention deficit hyperactivity disor- sion and the impact of studying on recall in children
ders: A handbook for diagnosis and treatment. (3rd with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of
ed.). New York: Guilford Press. Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 33, 506-
Brown, A. L. (1980). Metacognitive development and 515.
reading. In R. i. Spiro, B. C. Bruce, c& W. F. Brewer Lorch, E. P., Sanchez, R. P., van den Broek, P., Milich, R.,
(Eds.), Theoretical issues in reading comprehension. Murphy, E. L., Lorch, R. F., & Welsh, R. (1999). The
(pp. 453-481). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum As- relation of story structure properties to recall of tele-
sociates. vision stories in young children with attention-deficit
Cain, K., & Oakhill, J. V. (1998). Comprehension skill hyperactivity disorder and nonreferred peers. Journal
and inference-making ability: Issues and causality. In of Abnormal Child Psychology, 27, 293-309.

322
Story Comprehension and Academic Deficits

Mastropieri, M. A., & Scruggs, T. E. (1997). Best prac- research synthesis (pp. 231-244). New York: Russell
tices in promoting reading comprehension in students Sage Foundation.
with leaming disabilities. Remedial & Special Educa- Sanchez, R. P., Lorch, E. P., & Milich, R. (1999). Com-
tion, 18, 197-216. prehension of televised stories by preschool children
Mastropieri, M. A., Scruggs, T. E., Bakken, J. P., & with ADHD. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 28,
Whedon, C. (1996). Reading comprehension: A syn- 376-385.
thesis of research in leaming disabilities. In T. E. Sanchez, R. P., Milich, R., Hooks, K., & Welsh, R. (1997,
Scruggs & M. A. Mastropieri (Eds.), Advances in April). Story comprehension in children with ADHD.
leaming and behavioral disabilities (pp. 201-227). Presented at the annual meeting of the Society for
Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Research in Child Development, Washington, DC.
McGee, A., & Johnson, H. (2003). The effect of inference Sergeant, J. A., & van der Meere, J. (1990). Convergence
training on skilled and less-skilled comprehenders. Ed- of approaches in localizing the hyperactivity deficit. In
ucational Psychology, 23, 49—59. B. B. Lahey & A. E. Kazdin (Eds.), Advances in
clinical child psychology (Vol. 13, pp. 207-246). New
Milich, R., Balentine, A., & Lynam, D. R. (2001). ADHD
York: Plenum Press.
combined type and inattentive type are distinct and
Stein, N. L., & Glenn, C. G. (1979). An analysis of story
unrelated disorders. Clinical Psychology: Science and
comprehension in elementary school children. In R.
Practice, 8, 4.
Freedle (Ed.), Multidisciplinary approaches to dis-
Milch-Reich, S., Campbell, S. B., Pelham, W. E., Con- course comprehension, (pp. 53—120). Hillsdale, NJ:
nelly, L. M., & Geva, D. (1999). Developmental and Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
individual differences in children's online representa- Trabasso, T., & Stein, N. L. (1997). Narrating, represent-
tions of dynamic social events. Child Development, 70, ing and remembering event sequences. In P. W. van
413-431. den Broek, P. J. Baur, & T. Bourg (Eds.), Develop-
The MTA Cooperative Group. (1999). A 14-month ran- mental spans in event comprehension and representa-
domized clinical trial of treatment strategies for atten- tion: Bridging fictional and actual events (pp. 237-
tion-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Archives of General 270). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Psychiatry, 56, 1073-1086. Trabasso, T., Secco, T., & van den Broek, P. W. (1984).
Palinscar, A. S., & Brown, A. L. (1984). Reciprocal Causal cohesion and story coherence. In M. Handler,
teaching of comprehension-fostering and comprehen- N. L. Stein, & T. Trabasso (Eds.), Leaming and com-
sion-monitoring activities. Cognition and Instruction, prehension of text (pp. 83-111). Hillsdale, NJ: Law-
1, 117-175. rence Erlbaum Associates.
Pressley, M. (2002). Comprehension strategies instruc- van den Broek, P. (1989). Causal reasoning and inference-
tion: A tum-of-the-century status report. In C. C. Block making in judging the importance of story statements.
& M. Pressley (Eds.), Comprehension instruction: Re- Child Development, 60, 286-297.
search-based best practices (pp. 11—27). New York: van den Broek, P. W., Bauer, P. J., & Bourg, T. (Eds.).
The Guilford Press. (1997). Developmental spans in event comprehension
Rabiner, D., c& Coie, J. D. (2000). Early attention prob- and representation: Bridging fictional and actual
lems and children's reading achievement: A longitudi- events. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
nal investigation. Journal of the American Academy of Walcyzk, J. J., & Hall, V. C. (1989). Is the failure to
Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 39, 859-867. monitor comprehension an instance of cognitive im-
Rapport, M. D., Chung, K. M., Shore, G., & Isaacs, P. pulsivity. Journal of Educational Psychology, 81,
(2001). A conceptual model of child psychopathology: 294-298.
Implications for understanding attention deficit hyper- Whirley, K. S., Lorch, E. P., Lemberger, C. C , & Milich,
activity disorder and treatment efficacy. Journal of R. (2003). Online cognitive engagement of boys with
Clinical Child Psychology, 30, 48-58. ADHD. Journal of Attention Disorders, 7, 71-81.
Renz, K., Lorch, E. P., Milich, R., Lemberger, C. C , Yuill, N. M., & Oakhill, J. V. (1991). Children's problems
Bodner, A., & Welsh, R. (2003). On-line story repre- in text comprehension. New York: Cambridge Univer-
sentation in boys with attention deficit hyperactivity sity Press.
disorder. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 31,
93-104. Date Received: March 8, 2005
Rosenthal, R. (1994). Parametric measures of effect size. Date Accepted: Septetnber 28, 2005
In H. Cooper & L.V. Hedges (Eds.), The handbook of Action Editor: Tanya Eckert •

Kristen S. Berthiaume received her MS in Clinical Psychology from the University of


Kentucky iti 2002 and expects to receive her PhD in Clinical Psychology in 2006. She is
currently a predoctoral intern at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School
of Medicine. Her primary research interests are in the areas of story comprehension Etnd
academic performance of children with ADHD and related difficulties.

323

You might also like