Professional Documents
Culture Documents
G K -L r
B S -L a t
H D -L
W M -L h
A I t W B n
D 0
S B a n k
w
C e
D T P D
N o P a u
K M Aa ce r r
U I O n
C o
T d p ab p o w b w i a b oo or h
l f e d a e u d a s e t x n o e
C @1 M &C I o c o
P i aP D r
T d I f u b M s o a m n b d o t F o c
\
I
I
CONFIDENTIAL
I W
B
10 June 1994
O O S B E J
1 T i w b p n h
2 T e I d t i h x
3 T e t c o s p h i axua
w b m h a
4 T d s o L r w i t a i
W B T A - F 1 J H 1 R A O
T ‘rOpic L
0 B 8 r .
0 I t t s 8 nG F . t
0 W i w b 8 K G Wh . r a
● P r
● H t w
● H t a u
0 O o f a w 9 K G W v . r
● D o t m i
● D f r a
● K f f s a u
0 W it t s 9 D H . u
● O p o p e a v
● C o w h a
● P r
1 R M L s 0 M W c. e
“1have no idea what it means but 1lovethe action.”
I
.>
,/ .
“
W B W I AN H A OH
a
C
b
a
o M
b
W B E H A O
‘ ‘ ‘ OI ‘ R n
g
) ) )
D P 1 1 r 19 a
E d ● I ● M n ● D x d ru ● E ue
f e e c x
● T ● S e
● P ● Be
r ● C p a e
p c
● T e
. .
,
P W B P H R RA
a M
a
a
a
u
a
D
e
o p
P
n
d
SOURCES OF ECONOMIC VALUE ALONG THE WHOLESALE BANKING* BUSINESS SYSTEM
a C
U
A R Distribution
A C
P
d
c
W R
W C P U
V A A
.M a .L g h a c
I .l w n n
.P U e
a o l v
- A d
I ,
O r \ N i
} I ,
, A
L - 1
cC ● S ● A o
● C F ● P o o i
●M ●M ● S a
● M B ● A e a r
O
S W B P
P R T R E
● L
● F e x
● M
● O u e n
● D e
● S t e
L
L C L O E A
C c
+
L
A
T
S
R
l
~
-
o
i
u (:
c
e
E
t
n
m
r
C L F - E O A E X R
T o f C h a a
O C i a t o va c a u t am f
L o c B a t a c t b u t am s ( a r
s p p
B a B a ca b o e ac c c
T l T f 1t u t 5y a p b I i ( y
o i p a ‘ r o p n
S c C b d d I s U t t t l p s r
s o a b ( c p u n o
R c C b d i s a eo r t f c b r u t r
a t
S f E n i fy ( ar u f ( n s
m o f ( e - s a b u
1
B R I AS L Y A
R D e
A m ● N r w c r e a
● C t p o o l o a
● T o o t f p y
B r ● A t l s s u y
C ● U t l to w t l m s
n t t -
c i g t f u
P b ● I ta p as o t f r n
A ● C t f f e p a p i t t b o a
● C t b p a p o t s o o
m
● H n a d o o
B S O R I S L F OY A E A
R s D ee o
F o f e f F f o p o t m f a a t t a fe
a i n
U f F p t u n b p t e t s n df t
r t
A f P f a s g
C f P m I b o p f t c t t M me a
b o t w l t d s o u s
L m R c o t i o p r f t m a n
F E
1
. .
F E XO
P S c
I~
C u
B o c u ● P u
I e f a x n
f s o a e ● H t
p v r a -
d ● S
,
, --------------------
,,
:: FX swaps ~
,,
-
,----- . . . ---- . -
F T O T B M R A A
“
> y
1m y o
1m
1
m
C F E R A O
XL
I I r =8 J I I nr = ~
I
1y f r c a o l
S @8 = f E a $ =$
$ @5 $
E r r t m r v o f i i $ i tx U ee e t n
Q i i f i U = 1 n
=$
1
,
M A
B R I M A
Role Example
A ● I c do d
● D s t
● V a
● F a i
● A a ( p r r
● N e
● F o a
F ● P f d i i r
D cM b i ne i
p o ● B r o ao d e r
e s i I n i
T A O W M D C I 1 O
D O
A N o
R B $ d a
1 S W G 1 5 a
2 M G 1 9 r
3 M S 9 3
4 W G e 9 6 r
5 G S 8 5 o
6 C F B 6 3
7 L H 7 3
8 J M 7 4
9 R G 7 4 o
1 L B 4 3 r
1 H B 4 1 a
1 K B 3 1 l
1 S B 3 2 r a
1 D R 3 3
e
1 U B o S 3 1 w
“ E d U a U b n x o
“ C a r a ~
S i S o
,
S b d w t a V K Lo wh b Ml l /
T 5E M D I 1 U
Value,
B A T A d a $i
● R ● N R o ● R t ● S W o 9 h i
C ● H o
● B a ● B B n ● G S 5 k e
B B H e e
L B a
● U ● L F ● C cW 2
● G S ●R
● A ● W ● N I ● M S 1 n a
● A B S ● E S
● G S
● K ● L B ● D i ● C L 1 r n
S m B o a
D E U
R D A E A Q
F i
M m a e ( Equities
e a a
S t d i w M a l t d n S i c c s
ad u t o y i w d o p u n
● C p o y o ● C s m
● M n ● M t n - o t r c a
● C o d ● C b e( w f c eo r
d o c - o fo
e
B a d l ● M b a v c se o
t b t ● F e r n ( l os o t s e l
n ● R o b b - I e e
● P s ● C d a p r
s
F i m e a P o f s t ● W r s
a o i a ( u o p n s
G p P o f s o p l
p
B d f p
r o a e
\
I
P O I S E R S
7
A I
$
8 netesdue
1999
Negotiate L b
B A
c b
B B
P I S S I e r A n B C r y
D
f
o
l s t p a a it s t ao By D f n
r r g t e e i t I listing g eeq
(amount,fore, prospectus, demand bys the investors Syndicate
etc.) pricingetc. securities peys Syndhte
withadvice fremthe Specutetive issuerlseffer fssuesa
Cheosingthe from(lead) issuer svndicete lessfee for ‘tombstone’
underwriters undetiritirs memberrney underwriting ad ‘forrecord
(leadmansger, reteina on~ to
c-lead Syndicste pesilbn advertisedeal
mensgers; formalisd saess
domesficand
gfebafm- Investors
ordinators solicited
I
D
D E R
P D U ee r
F Ac o o p t b a B o s f a aob d o t
t o t s as a f a p f p m p
f p a af d
I
F Af c t o a A f b u t i i ou o
e n t m d b t c x t
p w t c o b c
I
S A a
as o c
b t p
i t f
t e U
e
f
c
d
i
o
a
r
g
(
t
a
l
o
I
O A i g t h t r H p n f p p
b n a o t b as m o m b b p a u
q o a a f af p p F s g u g
d a. D o m p c s
I
S E X
I
S i
● A r C Ah a o t b f ab a 7Y0 f o a L f r I w
o
l t h af r l
● B r C Bh a o t b f ab a 1 f o a L + f ro
I w l t h af r
t
Swap
● Ab f b a 7 f a m a a t p L t B o g
● Bb f b a L + f r a a m a a t p 8 ot A l
R e
● Ap 7 t b a L t B b a r 8 f B I e Ap L - e
● BD L + t b a 8 t A b a r L f A I e Bp 9°/0 a e
b 1 8 o
+
7i-lLIBOR+” ““
B Bank
“ Thbswapopportunity
typkallycccumbecawefloating ratelenders
donotdstingukh
theCIOMmtingatothesamed~ee m tied rateIendemorWereing
view onyieldcuweorexchmgerate. Inreality,however,
thoMerencasarenotm big= inthisexaqk, butmeasured
ratherinbasispolnta
)
E O R M T V A E O
‘\
1 1 1
,
T
;
~]
B
u
O
o I
I a o
t
II P
D
r
s
s
s
E d o
;\ t
) e c a f
i I u
s T n f
1 [ s
u s r
O c o u
. f u -
bill f u
F Bo m b b o
E
Foreign curren~ f 1u
. Selected
Instmmnts
S me E
ChineManharlan: o c
\
/
D R E R
? D e
; c M c a om a an f b w t i af u o r
c f d t a c r c a o t c e
r c o u a o t m e n
M O m i c s a i r r e r oo a
r a c p r o
s D a b r e p c e e t e
3 A m a h t d p s r u d
c a p t r e l t u I r o
. E i O m w
i m d u i st o s m
C d m c e l e
o s
L E i i d t l o t c n sm b
q D e i t U l a u c o
d e
A A k a i g r a s d n i s g t
m a i T i c t r c n a t a
s o t f s a aw Ab i d om i
c ac f i s a p s ( a e
B H 1 ae
T E c
,
.
S T
S T E R C
T s e
● E q
● B
● C o
● M m i n
● F o a o d u e
:
●
v
I
l
:
f
o d
~
A/ Trading
~ }
n
f
i
i
a
$ ~j
e
v
s
3
,, ,.
A
T M R A
T ● R
a
p a ak v
. S a v I
F ● L t p p w l o
e f a e u i i al x
f i
L H
P r o
3
. .
5 DISTINCT TRADING MODELS
M Characterfsatlon Example o
C S S s p a h m NatWeste F -b d r a o
c s b o h
W C K D i m s c h p Na s o F -m c oi oa
a l m t v b a f m a
B T C t h m p f G e Sa InFX,Intereet
a rata
r
s d o andequityrleke p
F H I n p w i c s t Ba Tn r
e sounterparties
f h m o p
C O E ( a t o s t pG S uax t
i a m a l C n S o
m a e t i t e o n x
ac s o p p f a o o
b r o f m i
3
I.Nllmlnmn/
I
A O T R S C B S N I E R O T
i 1 =t n r e n
‘ f i
M I 5 ~ a
●
a u
S f p
c u
S f p
s t
S t ● P p
s I tt
S
● H r
N s p
P o s
g
N
r e
3
‘
W I S R E P
- M l
“ w ~ “ 2 ~ “ ~ “ w ~ “ 2 I “ h 1 W
y q ~ t o
T h
m t
3:’0’;’ \ ! ‘f”””’” t i o 3
i T n T p T a h b a
“ Will b 1 h 1a a p d a 2 l 2 a s a
f y a p o 2 t c t n 2
2 o s 1 i p n
t y f a
2
Spread !
t + t r
T h a T h T h P ‘ -
s p o m a m a
2 s a p s profit T
b a 2 1 o2 o 2 s
w i w a t s s a 2
2 v h w w
f t 2 w 2
3
H I S P P
——
——
“ w “ 2 “ y mat w)II “ 2 “ y W
y youquote
c o
- me f 1
of . . . ?“ of . . . ?“ T h
m t
t tt i o 3
T A T BI T As h b a
T A 2 a s a
n h 1a s o b a 2 f
ap o 2 a n 2
p p a r
Spread (
t t t P g (
T Ah T Ah a T Ah
r spread poeitionprofit paidepreedof e
Total .:
of2.5 s h o 3s p 2 s h
b a 2 h g u s a 2 w
w I w f 2 t W w 2
2 2
n 9 A m 9t ,
PROFESSIONALS
3
,.
2iAm,#,cw,2!s,>2,
‘ P
R 1 P 2 r
I
Professional3 r .
P
total o
C
E
P + R
- + S
- o P O
F
G O W M P H R R A
$v i 1 1 n o
4 -
3 -
# B i
@ ● * E i
2 -
- -
* h
- .................. = * *
1
m m .
;
I 1
,
1
1
1
I
1 1 1
I
Source: 4
, ‘,
I
F A W B B F H O UA
S e c
O O F V O
F D Ee os
S D e i Cc m s u i
D A r ce t b a L e r f f r o c o b s
r b c e
R B c c e a i t a B a - o c r n io e r
c d e m e c m a r po f
G I i f lm g C G uo gn a A o runb a
a g b h t f E c i 2 h m l r
c
g i n a r
T M e o m ei f R t s p f a nt c
d e
P S g r p t p i U B iF o B B r e p r vn
g e c n i c F aS G I ne p i
m L A a
G d G n t g f o f o B B
e U vi v
i m n t a
E m N m o a t w w m C L A a E E a p
f r e i q
I M e i i n f T n o r ix v r sa f
t s t i
Source:GlobalSanklngCmfeleme,Valdez
4
4
S L M D Y E E N A
$
6
5
—
2
—-. . _ .. ——
D —.— [
1 1 1 1 1
“ V o ~ n f d i c n a a t e
S E u r o o n w
. .
l
F A W L C L O O E
I s I r t
● V c m w o a
o v
● N c f I b o n
M a l r t e e
s l a o y a
● A f u p a b
c f l p o o
i S D I uo r C d b n
● Disintemrediation- use o s ● L s d d
e t ● L d I w c e e
instruments– is well developed In the U.S. c a d l ● L co u p e
a t al e U a i l t v ● E c e hx s oS i
i i o c ● A a r n oo b cc
● C v i s m r o c l v p oe a i
c t g e e t I o to c b q m n o u
c l m i U o a r
R e e n
● R oc a r c e oe
h I c s a n
e s m g n e
● C g h e p u a
d l
i I
WOIWIB,W.94WA89
T P W L R E
7 m a r g
A s i f [ n v p
A l I v
P b e 1 x r e
u
O e o
Q
p x
P b t b 0 r e
A p r o e 7 o v e
A r r o e e v 1 e
R g e
4
I !
P U B L C R U E
%
M t
4p r
3 e
2p r
1p ( p
p v l
Source: Disgukedclient
data
.,
I
L K F F S E A U
Skills S c a s s t
P d a s o h s p er
S G a t s e c b p ( ng o r ub
c c a t b t p - i af o b a a
l b
C E c r a t e t wis
f used as a
r c o o
relationshipbuilder,net returnsto the institutionare attractive
5
.
F E
5
D F D E A
$
1
,-
,,
,’
,
9 ,/ 7
d
I
I
,’ I
,.
,- 5 i
,
,’ , j W L
. 1
I ●T z ‘ t m
/— , ● T w a 5
,
1 , f b
O ● E t
● E l
T
N Y
L o
1
Source: B BankofEngland;
Valdez I
5
.
m
F A W F E O XO
I s s e n t c
. Fragmentedindustryin spot,forwsrdssndswsps
● @tbns snd exchsngeIradedpmductsmore
concentrated
● Marketisdominstedby commercial banks
● Someinvestmentbsnkshsvesggressh’efy entersd
msrketandgainsdshsre
● Economksare drivenbycustomsrbusiness and ‘true’
posfikming
E c d v u C o e
● Globslisetbnof fbredincoms/squify
businesses ● Despiteconcernsoncreditratings,majorbsnks
has bd to incressd hedgingdemsrsb remainrnsrkelleaders
● Increasedintemstionafflow ,[=,, ● fnlensecumpatifbnto werthe investor/nroney
● fnvestorlfundmsnsgersegmentfastestgrowing ● Affrsctiveproftisbilify
fromcustomer -9W sWmenl. e~~fly the nsmesvbwsd
● $, D s Y a f m ov E to have‘highinforrnstbn’
c ocontent
s h s d ● Potentialforposhbningprufiisremsins
t s ● Moveto onfinesystemsto exscufesmsfltrades
h
by sc.mscu~titors
E f x s
● W oc b s s i s
op t d
● C d musingcmee-hder growih so
of irrveafmsnfs
● PotentislImpsctof EMUiECUuncsrfsin
C O C I F D O H U E
n
n b E
r . . D
. . ..... aa a.
1 P a 4
2 L p 3 i r
3 M i 3 n
4 B o s 2 e
5 C f 1 i
6 R m 1 a
7 S p i b 8 r e
6 S p i e 8 r e q
9 c 7 u
1 S o q 6
1 I o f 2 n
1 R 1 e
source: EummneYMaY1994
,,
d I
F E K F F S X O A U
Coreteam . T a s w a at w f p a r
t c c ( a r n f w u C
b c o
. P c m a d b s n o o
o t r
Segmentation ● S c t f o t w m a p e
c - e o b he a
✎ C l n o c d w f i a
i m l o s n i
F ✎ F o b at d w c c t k
✎
U i o c o b a n m
o t m p
S ● S e s t c we y rn
h m r a b s t y a s
h e f
5
.,
M A
I
I
W M A A O C E Q R
V o e c Numberof deals q a
$b ; 9 0 2
1
— B
—
—
15 ,
1
7 1
5
4 5 10 ,
3
C 7
C
2
-
- .- - - f
n 1 ■ 1 ■ U m m :
1985 86 87 88 89 90 91 9 1 1 8 87 88 89 90 91 9 1
S S D t e o
5
I s a e tn
, Feeshsvedeclinedsigntiicently-
$1.06b in 1989to$205m in 1992for
:volvlng customer demsnd all dealsgloballybuti~mved in 1993
* Highlyconcenlratd market:top 10
Totalvalueof globsldealsdowndue firmsaccountfOr7TY0of feesin 1992
to recessbn
Cmss-barderdealshsvedeclined
evenmoresignfiicsntly
Increasingcustomersophisticslbnhas
Iedto moredealsbeingdoneinhouse
Veryfew bigdesls I o n
~{~;:~~sls haschangedsincethe
● Hightycompsfiftiemarketwith
- Hostiledeslsare virtualfynon- entrenched,conmntrstsdplayers
existent ● Whilebusinessmy resume,unlikely
- Prhrsfisst&nssre upin Europe- thetpmffiabilii wii supfxrrfsignifiint
e.g., Gsrmeny,Frsnw, Itafy investmentor newentrsnls
- GmMh marketsars LatinAmsrics
snd S.E. Asisas Europeremainsin
rscession I
E f x
.S of IPO markethas hurtMU t
businessas cmnpaniescan nc.wfind.s
premiuminthe publicmsrksts
. Lowerinterestratesandbefferatock
pricesmayIesdtoincresseddsmsnd
5
M K F F S A U
Relationahlps ● Strongrelationships
withC b u f m
p s t g s a e r s
I ● N c o r i s i t ng e o
expetiisa s m a
E ● S t t s a b x d n w t r
t ar o t e c o t a a x
R ● A t m l a a t re t c a b
q s o c s i u
M ● C o d t g t d d a f e u
r o p s e ae
C ● W t p f e o p i o ti m e x
r t
5
9m7!s94LN~A001EQ
D a E U
E N I U R S
$
1
4 i
1C
4 6 I 1
1 ,’
3 , 9 ,
3 :. . *
71 ,<
E 7 ,. u
. ,. 58 ,“
FRNs z 4
,4
3 3
E 2 2 2 u
7
1 1 1 1 1 1
Source:BankofEngland;
Quaner&Bulletins
1990-94
6
L P D A E I R I
$
U L d U
1 = 1 =$ $
L d
2
7
L e
@
L e
Japan Germany
IOWO = S2,S67 1 = $1,666 Listeddebt
D
2
Note: M oc s
L e
I m e 1 n
L 6
e
e
7
xo r
i
Source: E M c oI ou I w q i a 6
1
Debt:MarketvalueI!stedbon&(excluIngpublksector
d~t); FelV
F A W U N O D O
i s tn
● P c n b r t r
. N g s i o s mn
d t s G v c i f o
U
. L d n v t p t i e
s e
C d I o u I C oe n
. R b e i c o e● Graduelfy growingbusiness a
efferend-1960 f ● H s c x
g b w a t r slump o y o● S es h vh i 1 y
t a ac b o
. Competitiveenvironment r (cumrrrorr m
stockspreads3-6%, investment
● D ik i o i
. Nesdto n
commitownsquifyto underwriting l
gradedsbt0.5%) n e
l m f b b m a increasesrisk e r ● a buildexperience
Marketshsrefoughtoverto o
i d s d 1t m ● Irrnovativeness s
inproducts s i c a
I
E f x
. I d r n ei
● L r o t e c r
b c i U s m n
. Gmwlhof emergingrnsrkets
6
.
!
T 1 M O P E I 1 A U
1 C First Boston 1 9
2 U B o S 1 w 6
3 G S 1 7 o
4 M L 1 7 e
5 S B 1 6r a
6 D B 1 e 6
7 M S 1 7 t
8 J M 1 6
9 S B C 1
o 0
1 N S 1e 6
1 L B 1 r
1 S W S 9 e 4 a
1 B P 9 6 a
1 I B o J n 8 4
1 A A B 7 6
6
,
M S O M P I E B I A U H
p e
L a C o o
“M L
S B e B r a
G S
1 7
M L M S
O 1 t
4
1 m
1 D B e
@
s B o e
S B Dauts
& e Bank r a
D B Goldman Bechs e
7 G S 7
8 M S
m
86
@
O
Soutc.: Eummon.yliS4 6
T 1 M O I E I N A T
1 Merrill Lynch 2 1
2 Morgan Stanley 1 6
3 Goldman Sachs 1 1
4 CS First Boston 1 1
5 SG Warburg Secudtles 1 1
6 Lehman Brothers 1 9
7 SalomonBrothers 1 8
6 ABN-AmroBank 1 1
9 BardaysdeZoeteWadd 9 6
1 B S 9 3 t
1 B P 8 a
1 D B 8 e1
1 J M 8 4
1 S B C 7 1o
1 U B o S 7 w 1
.
..
..
6
wz20001m6.m.94,w061
P P I E OR N 5 YO I U V T
U K F F SN D A UE
R L t r we l c a e l o
g b e f p s o rs
E C u r o e x ro g n xn
h s f i
C E t s u m n a u
S C t p l i a
B f e o s c e
6
D
,
w0001m8.m.mPOm
D M D E E R AV
$t r
1 C
7
5 1
5.8 ;’
4
4.2 ,“
, 3
., , .
,
4 $
~ ; - , 3
O i n J2 s
T i B n r s
1 1 1 1 1 1 =
. N p a o a y e w o s i u r o( t mi i f tf onei r enwi f
c c I su t i f o oms m I u O I eu
r SWWS,
curfuancyandcro=+urrency
n np Interest
n tr
swaps,caps,collars,
floorsandswaplions) 7r
,.
S FIA;ISDA.BIS o u
,
)
F A W I D M E O R
Industry s and economics t
. Broad basedcompetilbnforplainvanilla
business
. Highermarginstrucfumlproductsare focusat
leadinghouses
. Developmentof liquidsecondarymarkets
. Competitionrapidlyincreasingas skillsbacome
morewidespread
E c d v u I C e o
● I e u s m n e [ = Many,firrnssettingu
p pspecislpurposeAAA
c ratsd
- H p oc f t e o r vehklesi n r
s I o ● increasingspacislisatbnbyncurrsncy,cweurdryor
- M complextailorsdpreducfs risktype
- Newtypesof users(e.g.,fundmanagers) ● C r gmWhbutslowingpmfifability, ● Capacitywntinuingtoo be addsdby Eurepean
● Continued linkageto debtunderwriting
(akut as basicproductsgradusffymature univeraafbanks,Jspanaaebanksand
● Profitability
increasinglydrivenby newpredud rmnfinsncislinstifutbne;smallfirmsbsinq
113)unbundlingco~orate decisionson interest
rateandcurrencyrisk innovat”nn or bw COS1, highvofumestrategies acquired
● OverallrfskprofileIiketyto riseas marginal ● Manybanksmanagingon a gbbsf basisbut
. Shiftinfocusfmm rsducingfundingcosts10
provkJingliabilitymanagementandasset-lad playemattemptto maintainpmffiIevefsandnew increasinglyfotdingswapsintoa broader
products productsare increasingly dflicutfto evaluate derivativesumbrelfsinorderto
● Intarestrateswapgrowlhcontinues rapidlywhile . Enduserandcounterpartriskrsrnsinsa rnspt - Provide‘packagsd’deals
currencyis slewerto ftst(daclinsd1993) cormern - Achievesmerbr riskmsnsaement
● Signifanf innovations wfihhighmarginsremain - Rsducecests
in commodifyand equity-link~swaps
. Emergenceof Treasu~ as profficentrevs.pure
hsdgingonty(e.g., Proctor&Gamblebssas) ~ E
● BIS and.Governmentregufstorsmayalbw
x
netiing,whichwilldrsmstkalfyrsducersquirsd
cs iial,butthismaybsoffselby includingnrsrfret
I ● SomeWall Streetfmusesfecusingexcfuaivefy
highervaluedproducts
● Rapidirnitatianof newproducfs
t fikefy
on
E in ~ifaf weighings
ns
. lncrsassdd.bclosureandregutato~oversightwill
providemoreIranspsrenq
. Incrsassdvolatilityof interssfrslesptadicfsdin
nextseveralyearsmayaiddemand
● Effectof EMU uncertain forswapdemand 71
. .
D K F F S E R A U
Low c h q c a s s e
S T
\
E M T W O QR A
$
{ CAQR
5 : 15%
‘
,,,
,
3 - - - - . - - - - ,
7
F R E D R B AE N V V
D g U l ea
U interestrates S
5
—
i.<
4
4
—
3 y
I
k e
3 2 2
Y c
:
P e
[ [ 1 —
{ 1988 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Total revenue 25 26 19 19 15 26 29 so
70
. InckdesIn1992:BearSteam, DillonRead,Firtieoston,Goldmn,Kiddar,Lazard,MorganStanley,
Salonmn,
Wenheim
Soume: Sacurilias
Induw &aclation, FederalR-ewe Board
7
. .
\
!.
SOURCESOFTRADINGPROFITSANDRISK
M o J
M
m S m
I
/
/ A
Marketspreads(bidtoffer)
T c
1
J r
T t r
p r
L w
M f b a t I
P o
t A b m t
V l t 1 l
7
. .
C V O A
R
%
T I AB ● U
P
. e
C
E
I n
Investment
m &o 1 1 17Y. 1
mgmt& other —
U 3 n 3 d
4
U 5 n
1
1
C 1 o 6
4 C 2 4
T r
( t 2 r p a
T 1
J ~
1 1 w 1
7
u
F A W T O R
l s a e t cd
Intensefycompetitivemarketwithmsny
dealers
Shsrerefsttielyconcentralsdamongtoptier
andincreasing
Excesscapacityhascauseddealingspreads
to declineto abouthailof 1986 levels
Industryprofitability
highlyvolatile
Numberof smsllerlmsrginsl playersstillrmde
economicpressure(e.g., smslferforeign
institutions)
,
:ompetltlve
conduct
ndustryoutlook L-l firmsexcelon hemsmsrketsbutfaw are gbbal
leaders
Increasinglyglobal Largestpfsyersheavifyrelianton~sitioning and
;rrstomerdemand Continuingcametifive intensify pursuemultiplestrategrns
Largestplayershavesignificantscale – Use bsfsrrcesheetcapacityand largecustomer
Customertmdingvolumegrowingvsryslowly advantages(inpositioning,risk
MufuaVmnevmarketfundsegmentfastest flowkrrowbdgeto peatiiononbalancesheet
management,information) aggressively- highns~igh vofstilify
Vofatileearnings;riskadjustedreturnson - Empby ‘quantjocks’10pfscelargebatsIn futures
squifyunattractiveexceptpmbsbfyfor markets(highsrrisk)
fargestplayers Sabmon Brothersscfmdsloncorneringmsrkethss
Spreadslikely10remainnsrrowand tarnisheditiusfry andledto ctrangesaimsdal easing
earningsdependento posifionin#mventory psrfkipstbnin auctkmsand numberof dealers(e.g.,
fundingprofils on finebidding,eliminstiend volumerequirements)
Marketvofetilifywillcontinueto generste Emergenceof onlinesystemsforsmsflertrades
proffis Sbw, but iwreasingavaifabifityof pricingInformstbn
to customers
1
, f t a
I t c t i n r
P c i r e i o n
d p ( f r i r n o
r
P a t s t v r e i
V e m o m
7
T K F F S R A U
C ● A t a c I p m l s a d
● A t s v e u s b
● A t m q t p a f l o b
B ● B p l i t e r i r n
p t c ( d r s r e o
m s e o
● I p i k o m n ( L tr
T
R ● S i r a ( t 3d sn w e l
c u
S ● S o c b e o p p e( t a g
l e i v n i
● G c i t b s i p
S yn u
● C m o i a p a no
● S c r t gu e t s
R a
c ( o i r F w I e u
W B R H I O
Y
W
3 ● G S
● M S
● J M
● C F B
2
.----\
,. .\ . .
1
●. * A *
. . . . = L
0
1 0 6 8 8 9 9 1
81
.
,.
Uf~WIB.WR.6.M
W B C O W A L H A IO
G w L s i
u n
L
w
s
I L
i
i
J
High Low
Returns
8
/ I
ND ~15.Wn,6.9U4
C O W A
H L A RI
P i m p
● N ● R i
● I ● L s n
● S p f a ● W b w c p a r
a c ta o t t t h
P i s p
● S s ● S s (
● F i m b l o n
● D i s p ● I o r e n
n m a
H L
R
8
P A P L R O E R F
I
Q 12%
~ Morgan Stanley
*
= ~CSFirst Boston
A M L
A C
u A S
~
A Morgan
A B
A D e u
~ B a
~ P
S G W ~ ~ Y a
D K ~
~ L % I a
H L
R
source: Globalbanking
conrernce
IN/2ZLllUl15.Wn.6.9b
S U S T
● E s c
● O r r
● M e
● S W a
● L a
● B S t
,,
.
E O B U
W h
● B b s o s
p l
● A t d s
● E b b
W h
. I m g e d
● L o p o o
● I
● C o
● C L y
8
WDW115.WO.6.W
F T R P L R E O
● C i
● S a
● P a
● D B e
● E e w m n n
d i
● D ap c e e
● D a g s
LNmml/s.wfl.6.9ul
P L P P S O
R P R R O E
P 1 p A r r
S S g E g u
F D G e
C e R g r G q o
M a a G c C e q
P N cr R g i o v
I m G n aR g v
8
.
.,
P P R R O
E t ● P ● F r
p ● M l
D e
● E
u n
B t ● M m r
● B
u n
● S l ● P v y
l
L M H —
S o c t o
Source:Tmdepre86,McKlnsey
matisia
fN/720w1fi.wn.6.w
L L F T P E E
L I f c e m
Individual product/markets particularly difficult to Individual product strengths unlikely to create long
predict and volatile term success
E o t l t e B i vs t c e i t f o x e o
c e o
O l t 5 a r f D p va m I a c e
p ro a o t s d ep
I F i l p ] r e n
9
W C H I A R
● N h i e
● P w t l t p h e
● H t m g i a a
● N f o s m a
● W d s o p e
t e
● G i n e
- k p B
- m o t e v c b t f R c
● F o e m po n l o p t
c p a i n a
● I s p f a a c n t
● O a e f f n p p p
S McKtnsey
an~k, GldIalS t o a i u
9
.!
W B C O S H U O
● A t w o t t
“ : $
P ● Solvetoughestproblems
x
Createposilhre
external
{
●
image
B l
& c e
● E w w t ‘ x o p
c a t o c\ l p
situations
- --—..-..- \
● S e s a t x r
c a p
. .
E M
E E W B x
1
9
R M E W E C U H E X
I
I
E
●
I
D f
S E
a c m I E
n
E
. D s f f t e a t
c o e s f ac v f t
client
I B
● D as t b aG B p
B d S
● E c p t e i a a i
i b n
R M E W E C U H E X
.. J M
-
- ● R c m b i E ( e
- s o f a s t i r p t
-
- i m r a c i o
----
. - -
N
● R t E b
P R
● E p b d b i t U (
s a p o a
B
● R t w c r p (
d i
● B ab E b b ( s
● R t t a f i a er
w B
B
● R c r m f t c s
‘
‘
‘ C S
. ‘
‘ ● R as i ( t a l i
‘ m a t a a
‘
‘
‘ C
‘ ● D n b t a o t r
‘ g i t u o c i w m b
‘
f i n i
9
,, /
R M E W E C U H E X
, E I n
,’ ‘ ● R t o o t l b o f m r
, a g b o
,,’
,
.’
,’
,’
,
G S
● R t o ( b o toreduce
e
operational
rkkassociated
w m s o I
O R N G A
S ● R c i T dK
● M c a i b I o s d
( m
‘
‘ CEDEL
-“’’’’’’’”ss
● Identify
shorttermopportunities
toimprove
corebusiness
(clearfrrg
ofEurobonds
andincreaslngty
domestic
equities)
9
R M E W E C U H E X
S
A .
,. .
,
,.’
,
N
c D
U B
a
Y
p
o S
G T
w
● R s f t i f e s
d a p m a w a f s e
- c b p ( p f l o o
- - c
-
-
R M E W E C U H E X
, M A M
;
● D a i as a n o f
t U i i m b n
B
1 ● D a i an s f l
c c i E a i A
, ● D a i as U f t
i p n
;
B
● D as f d s o t c
I m
,
,
S B C o
● P as f t i o b
b ( t t f e u
S T
CEDEL
● Evaluate
potential
ofdeveloping
a centralctaatinghousefor
- over
thacounterderivatives -
-------