Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Textbook Geographies of Making Craft and Creativity Laura Price Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook Geographies of Making Craft and Creativity Laura Price Ebook All Chapter PDF
https://textbookfull.com/product/grave-war-alex-craft-07-1st-
edition-kalayna-price/
https://textbookfull.com/product/hemingways-geographies-intimacy-
materiality-and-memory-1st-edition-laura-gruber-godfrey-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/creativity-spirituality-and-
making-a-buck-david-nichtern/
https://textbookfull.com/product/doing-couple-therapy-craft-and-
creativity-in-work-with-intimate-partners-2nd-edition-robert-
taibbi/
Making Global Value Chains Geographies of Market
Oriented Development in Ghana and Peru 1st Edition
Dorothee Niebuhr (Auth.)
https://textbookfull.com/product/making-global-value-chains-
geographies-of-market-oriented-development-in-ghana-and-peru-1st-
edition-dorothee-niebuhr-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/non-representational-
geographies-of-therapeutic-art-making-thinking-through-
practice-1st-edition-candice-p-boyd-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/persistent-creativity-making-
the-case-for-art-culture-and-the-creative-industries-peter-
campbell/
https://textbookfull.com/product/manifest-destinies-the-making-
of-the-mexican-american-race-second-edition-laura-e-gomez/
https://textbookfull.com/product/geographies-of-transport-and-
ageing-angela-curl/
Geographies of Making, Craft and
Creativity
Laura Price is a feminist cultural geographer. Her PhD thesis explored the
geographies of knitting, gendered creativity and the role of materials in everyday
lives. She is currently a writer of education resources at the Royal Geographical
Society (with the Institute of British Geographers) where she works with
universities, schools and teachers to promote and share geographical learning.
She is co-editor of Geographies of Comfort (Routledge, 2018).
The Routledge Research in Culture, Space and Identity Series offers a forum
for original and innovative research within cultural geography and connected
fields. Titles within the series are empirically and theoretically informed and
explore a range of dynamic and captivating topics. This series provides a
forum for cutting edge research and new theoretical perspectives that reflect
the wealth of research currently being undertaken. This series is aimed at
upper-level undergraduates, research students and academics, appealing to
geographers as well as the broader social sciences, arts and humanities.
Spaces of Spirituality
Edited by Nadia Bartolini, Sara MacKian and Steve Pile
Edited by
Laura Price and Harriet Hawkins
First published 2018
by Routledge
2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN
and by Routledge
711 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10017
Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
© 2018 selection and editorial matter, Laura Price and Harriet Hawkins;
individual chapters, the contributors
The right of Laura Price and Harriet Hawkins to be identified as the
authors of the editorial material, and of the authors for their individual
chapters, has been asserted in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the
Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or
utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now
known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in
any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing
from the publishers.
Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or
registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation
without intent to infringe.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data
A catalog record for this book has been requested
List of figures ix
List of contributors xi
Acknowledgements xiv
6 Work, value and space: Three key questions of making for the
Anthropocene 94
CHANTEL CARR, CHRIS GIBSON, ELYSE STANES AND ANDREW WARREN
Index 241
Figures
This book has been slow in the making, perhaps fittingly. It has its formal
origins in a series of sessions organized at the annual meeting of the Asso-
ciation of American Geographies in Tampa and the Royal Geographical
Society Annual Conference in London, both in 2015.
We wish to thank all the authors and our editors at Routledge in particular
Faye Leerink and Ruth Anderson for their patience with the slow evolution of
this book, we think, we hope, it is better for the time.
Our interests in the geographies of making date further back however and
encompass discussions and support from a range of colleagues and friends.
For both of us an interest in making stems from our families and the mate-
rials that have made our lives familiar. Whether it be knitting, carding and
spinning wool or the making of everything from sheds to airplanes from
stacks of wood. It stems from the valuing of the vernacular and the everyday.
In some ways, it is easy to research craft and making; hand-made objects
inspire storytelling. Who made it? For whom? Why has it been kept, or
mended or broken? Craft and making tells us stories of everyday lives and we
feel thankful for those who have shared their stories along the way.
For Harriet, this life experience evolved into an intellectual interest through
her doctoral work at Nottingham on artists working with rubbish and waste,
under the supervision of Stephen Daniels and Nick Alfrey, her postdoctoral
work with David C. Harvey and Nicola Thomas at University of Exeter, and
with Deborah Dixon and Libby Straughan at Aberystwyth University and
Sallie Marston and John Paul Jones III at University of Arizona. Whilst for
Laura, her studies of floristry at University of Manchester and of knitting,
under the supervision of Phil Crang, at Royal Holloway, University of
London, underpin her interest in geographies of making.
For Laura, this intellectual work began whilst studying gender, creativity
and embroidered mapping at undergraduate level under the supervision of
Chris Perkins at the University of Manchester. An interest in material lives
and the power of material at the University of Sheffield under the supervision
of Matt Watson led to doctoral research into knitting, wool and textile art at
the Department of Geography, Royal Holloway, University of London, under
the supervision of Phil Crang, with Harriet Hawkins as advisor.
Acknowledgements xv
As ever the production of books takes a village. In addition to the authors
of the chapters in this text, we both want to thank staff and students at Royal
Holloway, University of London, especially the Landscape Surgery group
(particularly Miriam Burke, Ella Harris, Flora Parrott, Danny McNally, Sofie
Narbed) and Phil Crang, as well as Chris Gibson at the University of Wol-
longong and Dydia DeLyser, Cal State Fullerton and Mark Jayne, Cardiff
University for their discussion and support of ideas contained within the text.
For the kind of support and friendship that makes writing books fun and
engaging and for reminding her, often through their own diverse practices,
what making is about, Harriet would like to thank all the artists and makers
she has worked with over the years, but especially Katherine Brickell, Mim
Burke, Luce Choules, Tania El Khoury, Anja Kanngieser, Flora Parrott,
Libby Straughan and of course Anne, Louis and Joseph Hawkins. She would
also like to thank the Arts and Humanities Research Council for their support
of some of the research and teaching relief that went into the production of
this volume: AH/N004132/1.
Laura would like to thank each knitter, maker and artist she has worked
with during her research – she has learnt much about generosity, humour and
the time it takes to finish projects well (or sometimes, to just finish). Whilst a
memorably terrible knitter herself, she thanks Rose and Mavis for their per-
severance and love. As ever, she would like to thank Martin, Mandy, Ryan
and Kieran for their support. Both Harriet and Laura would like to thank
Flora Parrott for the use of her image for the front cover of the book.
This page intentionally left blank
1 Towards the geographies of making
An introduction
Harriet Hawkins and Laura Price
Researchers have looked for creativity in fairly obvious places (big cities,
cities making overt attempts to reinvent themselves through culture,
creativity and cosmopolitanism); have found it there; and have theorised
about cities, creative industries and urban transformation as if their
subsequent models or logic were universally relevant everywhere.
The result of such geographic myopia was a neglect of creativity that was in
some way vernacular, mundane, or amateur, but also a neglect of spaces
beyond the urban – suburban towns, rural spaces, and ordinary places. As
Edensor et al. (2009: 1) put it, “an understanding of vernacular and every-
day landscapes of creativity honours the non-economic values and outcomes
produced by alternative, marginal and quotidian creative practices”. In
response, closer considerations of the ‘where’ of creativity and the what, i.e.
the beyond economic, have evolved and taken form in a recovery of the
‘other’ geographies of the creative economy as well as in the attention to
vernacular creativities. If the former draw our attention to creative sub-
urbias, the creative economy of small towns and rural places and creative
clusters beyond the city, then the latter encourage us to look at the small
scale or unexpected spaces and places such as garages, sheds, cafes, community
centres, gardens, and homes as well as rubbish tips, allotments and online
spaces (Edensor et al., 2009; Gregson et al., 2009; Gibson and Warren,
2016). The chapters in this volume situate making spatially in both local
and historical contexts (see chapters by Thomas, Delyser and Edensor in
particular), as well as in a variety of specialist locations such as maker-
spaces, studios and, indeed, sketchbooks (see chapters by Sjoholm, Rebecca
Collins, DeSilvey and Ryan), as well as taking place in homes, backyards
and hairdressers, community centres and churches (see chapters by Carr
et al., Zoe Collins, Burke and Holmes). Moreover, these making practices
are often situated in the context of contemporary environmental, social,
development and labour concerns (see for example chapters by Carr et al.,
Burke, Straughan and Ocejo in particular).
This commitment to expanding where critical geographical engagement
with creative practices takes place, also requires that we challenge those
Towards the geographies of making 7
geographies of making that might settle out into accepted imagined
geographies. Whether these concern differences between, for example, the
creativity of urban and rural areas (the former associated with a creative
economy, the latter with craft traditions as part of a good life), or between
unseen amateur home-based creativities and more public professional forms
of making.
To pick up, briefly, on just one of these strands – that of public/private
binaries: knitting historically has taken place at home, however, recently the
development of artistic and interventionist movements like yarnbombing
signal its move into ‘the public arena’. As Myzelev (2009: 161) observes,
“similar to other activities such as embroidery, crocheting, and breastfeeding, it
[knitting] allows women and in some instances men to bring their private
hobbies to public spaces and thus reformulate, even if temporarily, the function
of public areas such as cafes, buses, and libraries”. Of course as Price (2015)
and others note, not everyone who knits moves, or wants to move, their
knitting into public spaces; there are complex spaces of domesticity and
notions of femininity that are at work within and beyond gender, as well as
considerations of class, race, and religion. Everyday life is increasingly inter-
connected with digital spaces, particularly in the home, and as such demands
that geographers pay attention to the geographies of making and the changing
nature of domestic space. A top online site for home-based creative work is
Etsy, known as ‘e-bay for the hand-made’. By 2015 it had 15 million members
and amassed $63 million in sales each month. Women make up over 90% of
Etsy’s sellers, many of whom have set up shops online to enable the negotiation
of a family friendly work-life. A common narrative around ‘the Etsy-seller’ is
the economically active woman who, on giving up her job to have children,
sets up a micro-enterprise to combine contributing to household income and
on-going participation in world of work with caring responsibilities. As
Luckman (2013: 262) explains of Etsy “craft entrepreneurialism is more than
an extension of thrifty housewifery and of ‘making do’ removed from the
sphere of the monetary marketplace. Rather, it is precisely the kind of
pro-am creative entrepreneurialism enabled by the social and economic
expansion of the Internet.” Feminist geographers, such as Carol Ekinsmyth
(2011, 2014), have been concerned with gendered and emergent forms of
entrepreneurial businesses “that are not merely (or even necessarily) located
in the home, but creatively use the home, mother role and child oriented
neighbourhood space(s) to do business” (Ekinsmyth, 2014: 1230). There is
not the space to do justice here to the multiple, unsettled, spaces that the
geographies of making might encompass. Yet, what is clear across this
volume and wider disciplinary field, is that, firstly, sites of making are
expanding beyond those specialist sites of the workshop, factory, studio and
makerspace, and secondly, that practices of making often require that we
keep open and challenge fixed imaginaries of places, in other words that
ideas of home, of rural and urban, of public and private spaces are unsettled,
remade through practices of making.
8 Harriet Hawkins and Laura Price
Maker bodies
We encounter a range of ‘making’ bodies across this volume. These are bodies
that are learning to do; bodies that are tired and strained; bodies that are
repulsed, that are skilled, that are satisfied ‘in the flow’, that are passionate, that
are privileged; that are being coerced, frustrated and damaged (see especially
Straughan, Ocejo, Collins, Holmes, this volume). Indeed, the body, that space
closest in, is emerging as one of the most common sites in contemporary geo-
graphical discussions of making practices. There are perhaps two key contexts
that ground our understandings of these making bodies. On the one hand the
wider turn to the body and practice. Within geography, at least, this has become
coded through the advancing of non-representational geographies and those
feminist geographies that have long placed bodily experience and knowledge at
the fore (Anderson and Harrison, 2010). On the other, it is perhaps a re-visita-
tion of labour geographies that have had a tendency to distance themselves from
working bodies but which are now, to various degrees, attempting to recognise
the viscerality and material practice of bodies who make, produce and craft (see
for example discussions in Carr and Gibson, 2015, 2017). This speaks to,
amongst other perspectives, the political work of geographers who ‘follow the
thing’ in order to reveal the working conditions endured by those who produce
our clothing and objects. Such a political commitment is often entwined with a
desire to hand-make, or advocate the hand-made, because running throughout
these geographies is a recognition of the labour, skill and intensity required of
bodies to produce our stuff and how increasingly fast methods of production
may damage these bodies (human and non-human; particularly the later when
considering the environmental impacts of industry). In the case of both these
fields of work we hope that engaging the geographies of making not only draws
these two often disparate fields together but in doing so might offer new con-
tributions to them.
Pioneered by phenomenologists and feminist geographers, and growing to
encompass non-representational theory, geographical engagement with the body
combines phenomenological and post-phenomenological engagements with being
in the world with concerns around skill and habit, intersections of cognition and
the affective and emotional, as well as with appreciations of the messy-fleshy nature
of our bodies (Bissell, 2012; McCormack, 2014; Pickerill, 2015; Waitt and Stanes,
2015). The wider making literatures are no stranger to these approaches. Indeed,
there is much geographers can learn by thinking through existing literature by
sociologists, anthropologists and others that explores the phenomenological and
embodied practice of making (O’Connor, 2007; Dudley, 2014; Ocejo, 2014b).
One of the primary dimensions of the bodies often present in discussions of
making is that of the senses. So as Norris describes in her encounters with
worn clothing:
Language: Italian
Giambattista Bazzoni
MILANO
Presso Omobono Manini
1832.
INDICE
AVVERTIMENTO
DELL’EDITORE