27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

CSE 428: Solutions to e ercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

The e a e c i "(d)" a d f "diffic ". E e ci e i ia f CSE 428. e gi e a Defi e a Defi e a Defi e a Defi e a C ide e f fac edica e edica e edica e edica e he f f he f h e a ed i h "(d)" igh a ea i ca didac e a ,b i he a da d

1. A 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

f t e ( a e , a e ) (n m 1 i ahrnm1nm2 ae

hich h d iff X a d Y a e b c u i ( , ) hich h d iff X a d Y a e c osnXY g a d o ( , ) hich h d iff X i a g a d rnsnXY d s e d n ( , ) hich h d iff X i a de ce ecnetXY i g ge ea gica ee:
bohrXY rte(,) %1 %2 %3 %4 %5

he fa he f n m 2 a e ). he . i . f Y . de f Y .

fte(,) ahrab. fte(,) ahrac. fte(,) ahrbd. fte(,) ahrbe. fte(,) ahrcf.

h e g a hica e e e a i
a /\ b c /\ d ef

i:

Sa

hich a

e ,a di

hich

de , a e ge e a ed b

defi i i

he

e ie

? bohrXY. - rte(,) ? cui(,) - osnXY. ? gado(,) - rnsnXY. ? dsedn(,) - ecnetXY.

if

e b d a i g he SLD- ee (a a P

g ea ch ee) f each

e , a ea

che a ica .

Sol ion
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
bohrXY : fte(,) fte(,) ntXY. rte(,) - ahrZX, ahrZY, o(=) %6

cui(,): fte(,) fte(,) bohrZW.%7 osnXY - ahrZX, ahrWY, rte(,) gado(,): fte(,) fte(,) rnsnXY - ahrZX, ahrYZ. dsedn(,): fte(,) ecnetXY - ahrYX. dsedn(,): fte(,) dsedn(,) ecnetXY - ahrZX, ecnetZY. ? bohrXY. - rte(,) X=b Y=c; X=c Y=b; X=d Y=e; X=e Y=d; N o ? cui(,) - osnXY. X=d Y=f; X=e Y=f; X=f Y=d; X=f Y=e; N o ? gado(,) - rnsnXY. X=d Y=a; X=e Y=a; X=f Y=a; N o %8 %9 %1 0

www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html

1/6

27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

? dsedn(,) - ecnetXY. X=b Y=a; X=c Y=a; X=d Y=b; X=e Y=b; X=f Y=c; X=d Y=a; X=e Y=a; X=f Y=a; N o

We d a

he SLD- ee f

he fi

e . Abb e ia i : fa a d f fa he .
? bohrXY. - rte(,) ----------() 6

ZaXb/ = = () 1 / ? f(,) - aaY, -----ntbY. o(=) / \ () () 1 2 \ .. . .. . fi al Xb = Yc =

? f(,) f(,) ntXY. - aZX, aZY, o(=) -----ZaXc / = = ZbXd = = ZbXe\ = = ZcXf\ = = () 2 () 3 () 4 () 5 / \ \ ? f(,) - aaY, ? f(,) - abY, ? f(,) - abY, ? f(,) - acY, --------------------ntcY. o(=) ntdY. o(=) nteY. o(=) ntfY. o(=) / \ / \ / \ () () 1 2 () () 3 4 () () 3 4 () 5 / \ Yd / = \ / \ .. . .. ?ntdd ?ntde . -o(=) -o(=) .. . .. . .. . Xc = fi al fi al sces ucs Xe = fi al fi al Yb = XdYe = = Yd =

2. Defi e a

edica e r v r e L K hich h d if a d ees(,)

if he i

Ki

he e e e f he i

L .

Sol ion
Nai e, i effice ( ad a ic) i :

niervre[,]. av_ees(][) niervre[ L,): niervreLM,apn(,X,) av_ees(X ]K - av_ees(,) pedM[]K.

Fa ( i ea ), ai- ec

ie

i :

fs_ees(,): rvaxLK[) atrvreLK - e_u(,,]. rvax[,,) e_u(]KK. rvax[ L,,): rvaxLK[ M)rvre e_u(X ]KM - e_u(,,X ].ees

3. C

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. N e

ide a e e e a i f e a i . Defi e he f ig m m e ( , ) hich h d iff he e e e X cc ebrXL, i s b e ( , ) hich h d iff L i a b e f K ustLK, . d s o n ( , ) hich h d iff L a d K a e di j i ijitLK, u i n L K M , hich h d iff M i he i no(,,) f La i t r e t o ( , , ) hich h d iff M i he i e nescinLKM, d f e e c ( , , ) hich h d iff M i he diffe e ifrneLKM, ha he i he e e e ci e de e d he a i ih ib e e e i i f he a e e e e i ih e e ii (i ca e f i f i ege ) de ed i each f he e e e e a i , gi e i he ab

edica e :
L .

(i.e. he ha e e e e i c ). d K . ec i f La d K . ce f L a d K . decide e e e e . The e a e a i

ibii ie :

be

Sol ion
Li 1. ih ib e e e i i f he a e e e e

: rdfn_ytmpeiaemme(,). - eeiesse_rdct(ebr__)
2/6

www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html

27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

mme(,X_) ebrX[ ]. mme(,_L): mme(,) ebrX[ ] - ebrXL.

2.

: rdfn_ytmpeiaesbe(,). - eeiesse_rdct(ust__) sbe(]_. ust[,) sbe(XL,): mme(,) sbe(,) ust[ ]K - ebrXK, ustLK. dson(]_. ijit[,) dson(XL,): ntmme(,),dson(,) ijit[ ]K - o(ebrXK) ijitLK. : rdfn_ytmpeiaeuin___) - eeiesse_rdct(no(,,). uinLKM : apn(,,) no(,,) - pedLKM. : rdfn_ytmpeiaeitreto(,,). - eeiesse_rdct(nescin___) itreto(]_[) nescin[,,]. itreto(XL,,): ntmme(,),itreto(,,) nescin[ ]KM - o(ebrXK) nescinLKM. itreto(XL,,XM): mme(,) itreto(,,) nescin[ ]K[ ] - ebrXK, nescinLKM. dfeec(]_[) ifrne[,,]. dfeec(XL,,): mme(,) dfeec(,,) ifrne[ ]KM - ebrXK, ifrneLKM. dfeec(XL,,XM): ntmme(,),dfeec(,,) ifrne[ ]K[ ] - o(ebrXK) ifrneLKM.

3. 4. 5.

6.

Lists without repetitions. The main difference is in the implementation of the predicate u i n Since we do not want repetitions, we no. have to check, for ever element of the first list, that it does not appear alread in the second list.
: rdfn_ytmpeiaeuin___) - eeiesse_rdct(no(,,). uin[,,) no(]KK. uin[ L,,XM): ntmme(,),uinLKM. no(X ]K[ ] - o(ebrXK) no(,,) uin[ L,,): mme(,) uinLKM. no(X ]KM - ebrXK, no(,,)

The other predicates can be defined as before (although for some of them we could give a more efficient definition b using the "cut"). Ordered lists of integers. The main difference is that, in the implementation of the predicate u i n we have to ensure that the no, output list is ordered. This can be done with a predicate o d r d m r e ree_eg:
: rdfn_ytmpeiaeuin___) - eeiesse_rdct(no(,,). uinLKM : odrdmreLKM. no(,,) - ree_eg(,,) odrdmre[,,) ree_eg(]KK. odrdmreL[,) ree_eg(,]L. odrdmre[ L,YK,XM): X<Y odrdmreL[ K,) ree_eg(X ][ ][ ] , ree_eg(,Y ]M. odrdmre[ L,YK,YM): Y<X odrdmre[ L,,) ree_eg(X ][ ][ ] , ree_eg(X ]KM. odrdmre[ L,YK,XM): X:Y odrdmreLKM. ree_eg(X ][ ][ ] - ==, ree_eg(,,)

Some of the other predicates can be defined more efficientl , b using the fact that lists are ordered: 4. Define a predicate l n t ( , ) which holds iff N is the length of the list L eghLN .

Sol ion
: rdfn_ytmpeiaelnt(,). - eeiesse_rdct(egh__) lnt(]0. egh[,) lnt(_L,): lnt(,) Ni M1 egh[ ]N - eghLM, s +.

5. Define a predicate o c r e c s X L N which holds iff the element X occurs N times in the list L curne(,,) .

Sol ion
ocrecs_[,) curne(,]0. ocrecsX[ L,): ocrecsXLM,Ni M1 curne(,X ]N - curne(,,) s +. ocrecsX[ L,): ntXY,ocrecsXLN. curne(,Y ]N - o(=) curne(,,)

6. Define a predicate o c r ( , , ) which holds iff X is the element occurring in position N of the list L cusLNX .

Sol ion
www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html 3/6

27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

ocr(,X_,) cus1[ ]X. ocr(,_L,): N>1 Mi N1 ocr(,,) cusN[ ]X , s -, cusMLX.

7. Defi e a

edica e s m i t L N hich, gi e a i uls(,)

f i ege

L ,

he

f a he e e e

f L .

Sol ion
smit[,) uls(]0. smit[ L,): smitLM,Ni MX uls(X ]N - uls(,) s +.

8. Defi e a edica e a d u _ i t L K hich, gi e a i d_pls(,) he e e e i L he a e i i . E a e:

? adu_it[,,,]K. - d_pls(1234,) K=[,,,0; 1361] n o

f i ege

L ,

a i

f i ege i

hich each e e e i he

fa

Sol ion
adu_itLK : axLK0. d_pls(,) - u(,,) ax[,]_. u(][,) ax[ L,YK,): Yi ZX axLKY. u(X ][ ]Z s +, u(,,)

9. Defi e a edica e q i k o t L K hich, gi e a i ucsr(,) ic .

f i ege

L ,

de ed i

b ai ed f

i h he e h d f

Sol ion
qikot[,]. ucsr(][) qikot[ L,): sltXLL,2, ucsr(X ]K - pi(,,1L) qikotL,1, ucsr(1K) qikotL,2, ucsr(2K) apn(1[ K]K. pedK,X 2,) slt_[,][) pi(,][,]. sltX[ L,,YM): X<Y sltXLKM. pi(,Y ]K[ ] , pi(,,,) sltX[ L,YK,): X> Y sltXLKM. pi(,Y ][ ]M = , pi(,,,)

10. Defi e a edica e m r e L K M hich, gi e eg(,,) ee e f La d K .

de ed i

f i ege

La

d K e ,

de ed i

Mc

ai i g a he

Sol ion
If e d a f u i n If a no. i e ee e i e ee e i he e i he e i g i , he he i i he a e a he o d r d m r e ree_eg i g i , he e ca i e he ga a f : ed ab e f he defi i i

: rdfn_ytmpeiaemre___) - eeiesse_rdct(eg(,,). mreL[,) eg(,]L. mre[,,) eg(]KK. mre[ L,YK,XM): X<Y mreL[ K,) eg(X ][ ][ ] , eg(,Y ]M. mre[ L,YK,YM): X> Y mre[ L,,) eg(X ][ ][ ] = , eg(X ]KM.

11. C

ide a e e e a i
epyt mtb cnb(,1T) ostNT,2

f bi a

ee a e

,a f

teepybnr te h mt iay re tebnr te wt ro Nadlf adrgtsbre T adT h iay re ih ot n et n ih utes 1 n 2

1. Defi e a edica e p e r e ( , ) hich h d iff L i he i f de rodrTL d ced b he e de a e a f he bi a 2. Defi e a edica e s a c _ r e L T hich, gi e a i f i ege L e erhte(,) , a ba a ced ea ch- ee T c ai i g he ee e f L .

ee T .

Sol ion
www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html 4/6

27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

1. 2.

pere(mtb,]. rodrepyt[) pere(ostNT,2,): pere(1L) pere(2L) apn(NL]L,) rodrcnb(,1T)L - rodrT,1, rodrT,2, ped[ 1,2L. sac_reLT : qikotLK,lnt(,) cntutte(,,) erhte(,) - ucsr(,) eghKN, osrc_reKNT. cntutte(]0epyt. osrc_re[,,mtb) cntutte(,,ostXT,2): N i N/ 2 %itgrdvso osrc_reLNcnb(,1T) - 1 s / , nee iiin N i N-N -1 2 s 1 , dvd(,1L,XL], iieLN,1[ 2) cntutte(1N,1, osrc_reL,1T) cntutte(2N,2. osrc_reL,2T) dvd(,,]L. iieL0[,) dvd(XL,,XL]L): N>0 N i N1 dvd(,1L,2. iie[ ]N[ 1,2 , 1 s -, iieLN,1L)

12. A di ec ed g aph can be ep e en ed in P olog b li ing he a c among he node , a a e of fac (cla e in ance, he cla e
acab. r(,)

i h emp bod ). Fo

o ld ep e en he e i ence of an a c going f om he node a o he node b . 1. Define in P olog a p edica e p t ( , ) hich hold iff he e i an (ac clic) pa h f om he node X o he node Y Be a e of ahXY . loop : he g aph ma con ain c cle , b o p og am ho ld a oid looping on hem. 2. En ich he p e io p og am o o e n no onl he an e e /no, b al o, in ca e of cce , he ac al pa h ep e en ed a a li of node . Namel , define a p edica e p t ( , , ) hich hold iff P i an (ac clic) pa h f om he node X o he node Y In ahXYP . ca e he e i mo e han one ac clic pa h, he p og am ho ld gene a e all of hem. 3. Con ide he follo ing g aph:
acab. r(,) acac. r(,) acbc. r(,) acbd. r(,) accd. r(,) %1 %2 %3 %4 %5

Wha an e a e gi en fo he goal ? p t ( , , ) b - ahadP SLD- ee (aka P olog ea ch ee), a lea chema icall .

ol ion o he la poin ? J

if

an

e b d a ing he

Sol ion
1. In o de o a oid c cle , e ill e an a ilia p edica e i h an addi ional a g men , hich ep e en he li of i i ed node .

pt(,): pt_u(,,X) ahXY - ahaxXY[]. %Tetidagmn i tels o vstdnds h hr ruet s h it f iie oe pt_u(,,): acXY. ahaxXY_ - r(,) pt_u(,,): acXZ,ntmme(,),pt_u(,,ZL) ahaxXYL - r(,) o(ebrZL) ahaxZY[ ].

2. The li of i i ed node , a he end, con ain he node of he pa h. The p oblem i ha hi li ge b il "in e e e", o e ho ld e e e i o ob ain he pa h. Al e na i el , e can ea ch fo he pa h a ing f om he end node, and alking back o a d he a node. He e e follo hi app oach.
pt(,,): pt_u(,,Y,) %Pi tept; ahXYP - ahaxXY[]P. s h ah 6 pt_u(,,,XL): acXY. %Tetidagi tels o vstdnds 7 ahaxXYL[ ] - r(,) h hr r s h it f iie oe. pt_u(,,,): acZY,ntmme(,),pt_u(,,ZL,) ahaxXYLP - r(,) o(ebrZL) ahaxXZ[ ]P. %8

3. The an

e a e he follo ing

? pt(,,) - ahadP. P=[,b d ; a , ] P=[,c d ; a , ] P=[,b c d ; a , , ] N o

The SLD- ee i he follo ing. Abb e ia ion: m and fo membe ; pa and fo pa h_a :
? pt(,,) - ahadP. ---------() 6 ? p(,,d,) - aad[]P. -----------www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html 5/6

27/12/2011

CSE 428: Solutions to exercises on Logic Programming and Prolog

() 8 ? acZd,ntmme(,d),p(,,Zd,) - r(,) o(ebrZ[]) aaZ[,]P. ------/ Zb () = 4 () Zc 5 = / ? ntmb[]) p(,,bd,) - o((,d), aab[,]P. ? ntmc[]) p(,,cd,) - o((,d), aac[,]P. ----------------------/ / ? p(,,bd,) - aab[,]P. ? p(,,cd,) - aac[,]P. --------------------------P = / \ / \ [,,] () () abd 7 8 P[,,] () =acd 7 () 8 / \ / \ ? acab. .. - r(,) . ? acac. - r(,) ? acWc,ntmme(,cd),p(,,Wcd) - r(,) o(ebrW[,]) aaW[,,]. ------- fi al ------------/ / () 1 () 2 Wa() = 2 ()Wb 3 = / / sces ucs sces ucs .. ? ntmme(,cd), . - o(ebrb[,]) fi al ------------------p(,,bcd) aab[,,].

? p(,,bcd) - aab[,,]. -------------/ \ P[,,,] () () =abcd 7 8 / \ ? acab. - r(,) .. . ------fi al / () 1 / sces ucs

www.cse.psu.edu/ catuscia/teaching/cg428/exercises/Prolog_solutions.html

6/6