1

The Will to be Good

1
2

Thai Social Movement Watch

Thai Social Movement Watch

Thai Social Movement
Watch

1.

...


()

...
...

17
2553 - -
2

( 7 ..51)
?


2. The Will to be Good
(Development Agencies)



//

( Li 2007, Agrawal 2005, Mosse 2005)

The Will to be Good The Will to Improve:
Governmentality, Development, and the Practice of Politics Tania Li (2007)

3


Li
(trustees)
(Li 2007:4)


: the claim to expertise to optimizing the lives of others is a claim to
power (Li 2007:5)
The Will to Improve Li Governmentality
conduct of conduct



The Will to be Good
3 conduct of conduct Li



2-3

(
)

NGO - Non Government Organization

4
The Will to be Good
()


The Will to be Good
()

(hierarchy)

( , 25 .. 53)

( 2548:17)


( 2548:17)

(anti-politic machine) (Ferguson 1990)
(de-politicization)
(Li 2007:7)
trusteeship

5








() () ()
()

6

2549

3.

2510- 2540
(POs-People Organization)
NGOs POs
(Pasuk 2002)

2540
/
( Atchara and Chalita 2010)


, (.),
, (),
(.),

7

1-2 10
19 2553

19
2549






(..)
15 2550 .. ..

(
15 .. 50) .. ..

( 21 .. 50)

(.)
.



19 2549

() ()



()
()



()
3

4.
.
()

9


(.)

( Atchara and Chalita 2010 2551)

5

2510
25206

(empower)
()

()

5


6

10

7

3



25538

...



( 23 ..53)

(, 23 ..53)

(..)




( 1 ..53)
7

...
-

(fundamental class) .. ( 2525:164)
8
23 ..53

11

( 2553:23-24)

... ( 2553:62)

10 19
2535
26 25539

...
9

... ..2553





...

12


10

11

19 2553
12


10 2553
(.)

!!!

!

-
7 2553
http://www.oknation.net/blog/mataharee/2010/04/07/entry-1

10

2-3
26 .. 53
11
23 .. 53
12
TSMW
11 ..53

13

14

13








... ...
...
( 2553:61-62)

19

13

23 ..53

15

..

...

( 1 ..53)

/


(
Atchara and Chalita 2008)

16
14

15











14

10
..53

15

17

( 25 ..53)



16
Philip Hirsch




Philip Hirsch
.




( 23 .. 53)

16

18
5.

/17

10 19
2553 (
)




19 2553


18

24-25 2553
:

(.)

17

21 ..53
event

18

19

( 23 ..53)

19

..

...

... ( 1 ..53)

... 1 .. 2553

26 2553 .

19

21-22 ..53

20
VS

20

..


( TSM Watch, 8 ..
53)







( , TSM Watch, 8 ..
53)21




20
21

21
( 2552)

/

( 2552:51)

22
(2549)

22

22
...

(
14 48)

""

/ /

(2548: 69)

( 2553:26)

...

... (
2553:52)

23

(.)

/



2


( 2547:355)

( 2547:355)

24

10 2553





2553 ...



() (counterdiscourse)

...

25
-
... ( 2553:25-26)

23



24




25

26

23

.. 2550
..2550
24
2553
25
.. 5 2 2553


26
21 .. 2553

26





/

27

(local as container) ( 2547: 105)
Breman


(Breman 1988 2547: 105-106)




28

27

1 ..53

28

27










...
...

( 25 ..53)

29


29

TSMW

28

(De-politicization)

()

...
""

.. (, 1 ..53)

(Substantive
Democracy)
(Procedural Democracy)

(Top-Down) 30
30

29

...

...
, ( 25 ..53)

( , 29 ..53)

31

(normalization)

6. = ?
...
...
...
, TSM Watch 2 ..53
31

..
28 2553 ...
...

30
...
...
63 ...
......


.., TSM Watch, 21 ..53

32

32

22 2553

31




...
...( )
...




( 23 ..53)

33

/
/

34

33
34

22 2553
23-24 ..53

32

/



2550

"

33
35

36

(Conservative) 37 2
Hierarchy
Authority
38

()
39

40

( TSM Watch, 5 ..53)
35

.. 5 2 2553


37
7 1) Tradition 2) Pragmatism 3) Human Imperfection 4) Organicism
5) Hierarchy 6) Authority 7) Property
38
2 ..2553
39

40
..53
36

34

41

42

( Atchara and Chalita 2010)

( 2547: 343)


/ (organic) ( 2551: 6263)

( 2551:63)


41

42
24 ..53

35


() ( 2551:53)

...


...
...
...... radical
...
. ,
( TSM Watch 5 .. 53)

36



(Practitioner)

()

2549 :


2553
. :

2547 : , -
25 1: 328-380

2547 (Translocalities) 25
1: 103-149

37

2552 () 33: :
. :

2548 14 : 14 2548.: 14

2551 . .
1: 6. :

2552 . () 33:
: .
:

2553
. :

2525 (), Jarome
Karabel
(Revolutionary Contradictions: Antonio Gramsci and the Problem of Intellectuals).
:

2551 ?
30-31 ..2551 ..

2548 . :
Agrawal, Arun
2005 Environmentality : technologies of government and the making of subjects. Durham :
Duke University Press
Atchara Rakyutidharm and Chalita Bundhuwong
2010 People Sector or a New Technology of Power? A Discussion Paper for Roundtable Session in
the International Conference Revisiting Agrarian Transformation in Southeast Asia: Theoretical,
and Applied Perspectives 13-15 May 2010 Chiang Mai.
Ferguson, James
1900 The Anti-Politics Machine: "Development," Depoliticization, and Bureaucratic Power in
Lesotho.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Li Tania Murray
2007 The Will to Improve: Governmentality, Development, and the Practice of Politics.
Durham: Duke University Press

38
Mosse, David
2005

Cultivating Development: An Ethnography of Aid Policy and Practice. London: Pluto

Press
Pasuk Phongpaichit
2002 Recent Popular Movements in Thailand in Global Perspective in Popular Movements:
Asian Review 2002, Institute of Asian Studies Chulalongkorn University, 1-20.

15 2550 .. .50
http://www.prachatham.com/detail.htm?dataid=4842&code=n6_15072007_03&mode=th
21 2550 .. .50
http://www.prachatham.com/detail.htm?dataid=4855&code=n6_21072007_01&mode
=th
25 2550
http://www.prachatham.com/detail.htm?code=i1_2508210_01
1 2553 ? (2)
http://www.prachatham.com/detail.htm?code=i1_01092010_01
23 2553
http://www.prachatham.com/detail.htm?code=n2_23082010_01

7 2551
http://www.localtalk2004.com/V2005/detail.php?file=1&code=a1_07092008_01
29 2553
http://www.localtalk2004.com/V2005/detail.php?file=1&code=f1_29072010_01

23 2553 4 -- .
http://community.isranews.org/resource-the-environment/619-2010-06-23-21-37-23.html
Thai Social Movement Watch ()
2553 (32 )

http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%9A%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A
7%E0%B8%99&init=quick&sid=0.048677649833510306#!/pages/thbthwn-khbwnkarkheluxnhiw-thang-sangkhm-ni-prathesthiy/140759815942325?v=wall&ref=ts
/
23 2553