Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Evidence 1: “The vast forests the Evidence 1: “efforts to bring back Evidence 1: “resurrected, previously
pigeons required are partly gone and species are a colossal waste” (Text 2, benign organisms could become pests
badly fragmented at best” (Text 4, Line Line 26) in new environments” (Text 4, Line 24)
16-17)
Evidence 2: “a resurrected [animal] will Evidence 2: “the financial costs of de- Evidence 2: “it is important that we
need a safe home, not just its food extinction is heavy…resources would be address the causes of extinction…and
plants…where do we put them?” (Text better used for conservation” not divert resources from efforts to
2, Lines 18-20) (Moynihan 3) conserve currently existing species”
(Text 1, Lines 34-36)
MODEL: Body Paragraph
Topic Sentence + Evidence (x2) + Explanation + Analysis
If scientists bring back extinct species the new creatures will not
have safe, appropriate habitats to live in. Take for example the extinct
carrier pigeon; we know that “The vast forests the pigeons required are
partly gone and badly fragmented at best” (Text 4, Line 16-17). If the
pigeon was brought back from extinction it would essentially have no
place to live. We must recognize that “a resurrected [animal] will need
a safe home” (Text 2, Lines 18-20) to live in and we cannot expect to
magically find all of the space to safely place these animals. While it
may seem like a great idea, when thinking it through it becomes clear
that bringing back an extinct species is a bigger task that it may initially
seem. All of these new animals will need food and shelter to survive,
and that is something that our world can not sustain at the moment.
Mini-Lesson: Counterclaim + Rebuttal
• Do NOT undermine your claim!!!
– NO: Macbeth’s soliloquy had a bigger impact on the
audience.
– YES: Others may argue that Macbeth’s soliloquy has
a stronger emotional foundation.
• Be sure to provide a rebuttal (prove the other
argument wrong).
– The first piece of evidence appears to support the
counterargument.
– The second piece of evidence is your rebuttal.
Mini-Lesson: The Counterclaim
Be on the safe side! Use a counter claim sentence
stem to start off your paragraph.
CC¶ Sentence Stems
• Some people think…
• Others may believe…
• It may seem that…
• Others argue…
• Another perspective is…
• It is easy to think that…but when you look at the facts…
• It may be true that…however…
MODEL: Counterclaim
Topic Sentence + Explanation + Evidence + Analysis
Some may argue that Macbeth’s soliloquy is more emotionally daunting because
he makes his speech right after hearing about the death of his wife. Macbeth says
“life’s but a walking shadow…That struts and frets his hour upon the stage (Act 5, Sc
5) to demonstrate that life is brief and filled with worry and distress. As a result, the
audience feels sympathy for him and his loss. However, Hamlet expresses a similar
sentiment when he states that in life we must “suffer the slings and arrows of
outrageous fortune” (Act 3, Sc 1). Meaning that we cannot prevent life from hitting
us with hardships. Although Macbeth is in distress, he tries to defer his sadness by
saying that life is short and unpleasant no matter what we do. Instead of
rationalizing, Hamlet really sits with the notion that life is stressful and wonders if
there is any way to “fix” the situation. Of course, Hamlet’s solution is death, and this
intense choice is one that the audience can truly relate to.
Mini-Lesson: The Conclusion Paragraph
What needs to be included in a conclusion paragraph?
• Restate your thesis statement.
Do NOT just copy and paste your exact thesis!
• Summarize the sub-points of your essay.
Review the ideas from your topic sentences.
• Leave the reader with an interesting or striking impression.
Why does any of this matter anyway? What is the bigger
reason why the reader should care?
Leave the reading nodding in agreement and feeling glad
he/she took the time to read your essay.
MODEL: Conclusion Paragraph
Restate thesis + Recap arguments + Final Impression
• Ex: “This ruins our safety” HOW does it ruin our safety?