Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(1) A Strategic Framework for CRM, by Patrick Sue and Paul Morin. February 2001
Functional Elements of CRM
Marketing Sales Customer Service
• Market Research • Sales Automation and • Customer Inquiry
Management
• Product Development • Customer product
• Customer Profiling support
• Market Assessment
• Account Management • Customer Information
• Market & Customer Management
Segmentation • Opportunity Management
• Call Center
• Product Lifecycle • Product, Price, and Effectiveness
Management Contract Negotiation
• Trouble Analysis &
• Product Pricing and • Sales Alignment and Resolution
Profitability Incentives
• Billing
Pricing
Inventory levels
Billing information
process
33 redundant audit checks and took approximately
27 days
On-line quote system developed
Billing information
Customer preferences
30,000,000,000
25,000,000,000
20,000,000,000
15,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
5,000,000,000
-
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005
Years
Based on report by Aberdeen Group entitled “Worldwide CRM Spending: Forecast and Analysis 2001 - 2005”.
Forces Driving Spending
“Only 7% of global companies have reached mature
CRM deployments, indicating more spending to
come.” (1)
According to Gartner Group “CRM remains one of the
top three, if not number one, business priorities in
2001.”
“The average company loses 20% of their customers
each year and the number is rising.” (2)
(1) Data Warehouse Institute survey. CRM is Anything but Dead CRM Industry. June 2001
(2) Maximizing CRM Performance with Strategic Performance Measurement by James
Brewton
Forces Driving Spending Cont...
“It costs up to 10 times as much to acquire a
new customer as it does to keep an existing
one.”
Reasons growth is not higher:
Hard to prove ROI
Expensive customization
High failure rate
Slow economy has force IT budgets to tighten
Wireless CRM: Strings Attached by Marc Songini Computer World, November 2001
Trends in CRM Cont...
Netsourcing - Application Services Providers
(ASPs)
ASP work better in smaller organizations - less
customization
CRM applications are the second largest segment
of hosting sales, led only by E-commerce
applications
By 2003, Forrester predicts hosted CRM
applications will account for almost $2.5 billion in
revenue
The Forrester Report by Stacie S. McCullough. December 1999
CRM ROI
Source: Swift, “Accelerating Customer Relationships: Using CRM and Relationship Technologies
CRM ROI Cont…
Possible Returns
Up to 10 X’s more costly to generate
revenue from new customer than existing
customer
5% Increase in retention rate can increase
company profits by 60-100%
6 X’s more costly to service customer
through a call center than via the internet
Loyal customer referrals generate business
at little or no cost
Source: Swift, “Accelerating Customer Relationships: Using CRM and Relationship Technologies”
CRM ROI Cont…
Investments
Upfront costs
Takes time
Relationship vs database
Source: Rigby, Reichheld and Schefter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM”
Succeeding VS Failing Cont…
CRM Mistakes
Implementing CRM before creating a
customer strategy
Rolling out CRM before changing your
organization to match
Assuming that more CRM technology is
better
Stalking, not wooing, customers
Source: Rigby, Reichheld and Schefter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM”
BMC “Learning from Failure”
BMC Software
Systems-management software
provider
Based in Texas
Source: Rigby, Reichheld and Schefter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM”
BMC’s Failures
No research
No top-management involvement
Software would change culture
Source: Rigby, Reichheld and Schefter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM”
BMC’s Successes
Recreated the strategy
Communicated benefits across the
company
Changed the culture not just the process
Source: Rigby, Reichheld and Schefter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM”
Industry Uses
Airlines
AA
Aadvantage Frequent Flyer Program
Banks
Barclays
Realize profitability of customers
Car Rental Companies
Enterprise
ECARS System
Source: Swift, “Accelerating Customer Relationships: Using CRM and Relationship Technologies”
Enterprise Computer Assisted Rental System
(Ecars) - introduced in 1992 now supports 1.4
million transactions logged every hour
Locates cars, tracks customer preferences,
measures customer satisfaction ratings
Uses Enterprise Service Quality Index(ESQI)to
measure satisfaction - compensation for
management is tied to results
Enterprise uses its Automated Rental
Management System (ARMS) to allow
insurance companies to access rental
information
Allows agent to book reservations, EFT, and
reporting to support claims processing
Allows electronic monitoring of repair shop
progress
(CIO Magazine - Nov 2000)
Gartner’s 12 Key
Application Components
Gartner’s 12 Key Application Components
The scores in Figure 1 are based on vendors scoring 1 point for a 1/4 circle rating, 2 points for a
1/2 circle, 3 points for a 3/4 circle and 4 points for a full circle with 48 points equal to 100
percent. In the past year, SAP's scores improved the most, followed by Amdocs/Clarify, Siebel,
PeopleSoft then Oracle (see Figure 2). Today, Gartner estimates that Siebel still provides almost
twice as many features as the next closest competitors; and Siebel remains the only vendor to
meet more than 50 percent of the horizontal functionality requirements for a B2B large enterprise
CRM application suite.
http://www.gartner.com/reprints/ncr/104847.html
Key CRM Providers
PeopleSoft
Siebel
SAP
Oracle
Convergys
Leading provider of enterprise applications Headquarters:
that tie together customers' back-office Pleasanton, CA
operations
2000 revenue: $1.7 billion
Software addresses such tasks as accounting,
human resources, manufacturing, and supply Customers: 4,600
chain management
Employees: 8,000
Services such as consulting, maintenance, and Worldwide
training account for about two-thirds of sales
Customer relationship management software
has rekindled licensing sales growth and
helped offset a slowdown in the broader
enterprise software market, but it has also
exposed PeopleSoft to more direct
competition with companies such as Oracle
and Siebel Systems. (www.hoovers.com)
World's leading provider of eBusiness Founded: 1993
applications software
2001 revenue: $2.05
Provides an integrated family of eBusiness billion
applications software, enabling
2001 net income:
multichannel sales, marketing, and
$255 million
customer service systems to be deployed
over the Web, in call centers, in the field, Employees: 7,400+
through reseller channels, and across retail
and dealer networks
Sales and service facilities are located in
more than 32 countries.
29 Years in the Business of E-Business 2000 Sales (mil.): $5,881
1-Yr. Sales Growth: 14.3%
10 Million Users, 44,500 Installations,
1,000 Partners, and 21 Industry 2000 Net Inc. (mil.):
Solutions. $596
Founded in 1972 - recognized leader in 1-Yr. Net Inc. Growth:
providing collaborative e-business (1.6%)
solutions 2000 Employees: 24,480
Headquartered in Walldorf, Germany 1-Yr. Employee Growth:
12.8%
World's largest inter-enterprise software
company, and the world's third-largest
independent software supplier overall
Employs over 27,800 people in more
than 50 countries
World's leading supplier of software 2001 Sales (mil.): $10,860
for information management, and the 1-Yr. Sales Growth: 7.2%
world's second largest independent
software company 2001 Net Inc. (mil.):
Headquartered in Redwood Shores, $2,561
California 1-Yr. Net Inc. Growth:
First software company to develop and
(59.3%)
deploy 100 percent Internet-enabled 2001 Employees: 42,927
enterprise software across its entire 1-Yr. Employee Growth:
product line: database, server,
enterprise business applications, and
3.9%
application development, and decision
support tools.
(CVG) is a provider of Employees: 46,000
outsourced billing and Market Cap (Mil) $ : 5,155.226
customer management Complete Financials: Dec 2001
solutions, which Updated: 04/05/2002
encompass activities Revenues For the FY ended
12/31/01, increased 6% to
such as targeting, $2.32B.
acquiring, serving and
Net income decreased 27% to
retaining customers on $138.8M.
behalf of its clients.
Mini-Case Studies
Began in 1902 , is a market-leading supplier of electrical
distribution, industrial control and automation products
A new safety switch with the company's new logo, a "D" (for
Detroit) inside a square became the industry standard and many
customers began asking for "the square D switches." The
trademark was developed in 1915 and the name Square D
Company was formally adopted in 1917. To this day, Square D is
one of the few companies ever named by its customers.
On May 24, 1991, Square D Company merged with Schneider
Electric of Paris, France the world's leading manufacturer of
electrical distribution and industrial control and automation
products and systems, and the only manufacturer dedicated to
the distribution and control of electricity.
(www.squared.com)
Information Technology
Web server-enabled equipment for the plant floor
Equipment, including power monitors and PLCs, can automatically alert
plant officials to emerging problems by audible alarm or e-mail
Built-in server technology allows plant personnel to remotely monitor,
diagnose and correct equipment problems and remotely change set
points
E-Way
Online quote and order management system for distributor network
Check pricing, stock availability, and obtain shipping information
Digest Plus Selector
Online product selection with more than 66,000 part numbers
Search an electronic version of Square D's catalog based on the electrical
characteristics of the application
Generates a bill of materials to send to the distributor of choice for
pricing and ordering
(http://www.controleng.com/archives/news/2000/july/gm0720a.htm)
Information Technology
An employee Intranet
Powered by an Infoseek Corp. search engine. The site includes
everything from employee telephone directories to spec-writing tools
and news on customer-segment marketing activities. Employees can
access the site remotely
Customer Information Center
Uses sophisticated customer relationship management (CRM)
technology to give technicians instant access to a complete customer
history, and knowledge management and case management tools to
access a database of technical solutions to almost any question
Links customer service representatives and technical experts around the
country in a virtual technical support center through Soft Phone
technology from Lucent.
Extended nationwide in late 1999, the CIC now answers more than
13,000 calls each week from customers, distributors and employees.
(http://www.controleng.com/archives/news/2000/july/gm0720a.htm)
Successful CRM
Implementation
Began in 1993, after Schneider Electric acquisition
Reorganized the company’s three basic business units around
customer segments - Industrial, Residential, Construction, and
OEM
Only after internal systems were refocused on the customer did
Square D start using high-tech applications to upgrade its
customer-facing processes
According to Chris Curtis, VP of US marketing, managers were
taken out of their line jobs for months at a time to understand
issues involved in implementing the software
In 1996, $75 million was invested in an order-management
system that let sales engineers create proposals for customers
based on what the factory floor could deliver
(http://www.crmdaily.com/perl/story/16309.html)
Argosy Case Study
Company Overview
CEO: James Perry
Revenue: $595 Million
Stock: NYSE Symbol-AGY
$40.65
Employees:4,900
Source: www.argosycasinos.com
Jeff Poure, MIS Director
CIO
CEO
Current System
Player Tracking System
Built primarily as accounting/slot system,
not marketing
Only provide us with transactional data
Legal Staff
Marketing Staff
Representation)
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
Argosy Partners with NCR Terradata
for CRM Development
Why NCR?
“Value Added Supplier”
Harrahs (1998)
Application Server Evaluation Model (ADEM)
Evaluates IT Supplier on the basis of Technology,
Market Momentum, Best Practice, & Database
NCR won Technology & Database, and was second
in Best Practices – Overall highest score
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
CRM Application Scope
7,724 Hours (3+ Man years)
Only NCR Applications and Database
Developers time
Estimated Cost = $849,640
Not including Software Licenses or Servers
Two new full time MIS positions
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
CRM Application Operation
Data collection during registration –
Data Card
Player Data
Name
Address
SSN
License No
Age
And More! Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
CRM Application Operation
Data collection during the visit
Wins / Losses
Tables vs. Slots
Preferences / History
Restaurants
Smoking vs. Non-Smoking
Magazines
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
CRM Application Operation
•Prior to CRM Application
•Archaic Marketing campaigns based on recent nature of ones visit
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
Property Implementation Timeline
Phase I
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
Implementation
Phase I Criteria for Success
Have increased ability to view, analyze and act upon
detail player data down to the transaction level by
individual player, player segments or groupings.
Develop and agree to a methodology and calculation
for the “Lifetime Value” of a player.
Have the ability to analyze and evaluate Argosy
customers’ hotel, restaurant, entertainment, and offer
preferences at the customer level.
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
Implementation
Phase I Criteria for Success - cont.
Capture and maintain customers’ needs and
preferences for the purpose of determining
offers/programs, which will appeal to out most
profitable customers.
Increase analytical capabilities to drive more complex
segmentation and communication strategies for the
purpose of increasing customer trips/rate-of-pay,
frequency of visits, and for finding new/profitable
opportunities.
Ability to have a unified/consistent customer reward
program across the enterprise.
Source: Interview with Jeff Poure, Argosy Gaming Co. MIS Director
Is Phase I a Success?
“Yes, this phase has been considered a success. It(the
CRM package) has given us the ability to more
efficiently identify our key customers, anticipate their
needs and respond to them quickly.”
Source: Gartner, “Seven Key Reasons Why CRM Fails – And How to Avoid Them”
CRM Best Practices
CRM Best Practices consists of the
following:
Customer Involvement
Involve the correct sources early to develop
CRM Strategy
Understanding of Information Technologies
place
CRM Organizational Culture
Incremental Implementation
CRM Best Practice
Customer Involvement
Focus Groups
Prior to, during, and after CRM implementation
Customer Survey
If Feedback being passed to Top Management is being acted
on, then change will happen
Concentrate on your customer Lifecycle value
Which Customers repay investment?
Which Customers just take up resources and should be
considered competitors?
Segmentation Analysis
Source: www.CRM-forum.com
CRM Best Practices
Involve the “Right” People
Marketing
Provide means of determining our customers?
Business Strategists
What are our organizational goals (i.e. growth)?
Source: www.CRM-forum.com
CRM Best Practices
Involve the “Right” People
“Value-Added” IT Suppliers (If required)
Practical experience in CRM
CRM experience in same/similar industry
Can provide knowledge of CRM application(s) to allow
Marketing and Business strategists to evaluate the
opportunities
To often companies allow technology vendors
to dictate the manner they manage customers
because the vendor has implemented CRM
CRM is to be customized, not for software but for
strategy
Source: “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM,” Darrell K. Rigby, Frederick F. Reichheld, Phil Schefter; Harvard Business Review, Feb 2002
CRM Best Practices
Involve the “Right” People
Involve TOP MANAGEMENT from the start
For CRM to be successful, Top Management must…
Clearly communicate a vision for the future of the organization
that indicates the benefits of CRM
The will power to make CRM work across functional boundaries
Without Top Management participation or a
Strong Top Management
A common result is that a strong-willed committee
member will shape the final implementation that will
address their desires and not the organizations as a
whole
Source: “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM,” Darrell K. Rigby, Frederick F. Reichheld, Phil Schefter; Harvard Business Review, Feb 2002
CRM Best Practices
Implementation
Should not expect to be able to
implement CRM in one major
undertaking
Implement CRM in increments
Each Increment should have…
• Its own business case
• Measures of success
• Evaluation of how customers perceive the results of
this step
Source: www.CRM-forum.com
CRM Best Practices
While Top Management successful within ones
organization, employees make CRM successful
with your customers
Companies serious about CRM tie employee
incentives to customer indicators such as retention
and satisfaction. The more serious a firm is about
CRM, the sooner they will adjust the compensation
plan.
No less than 100 percent user buy in is acceptable..
Source: www.CRM-forum.com
Conclusion
What must we understand?
Expect a continuing evolution of CRM
As it evolves, customers will become more and
???