Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and
Boiler Efficiency Calculations
By
Dr. S. A. Channiwala
Professor,
Mechanical Engineering Department
S.V. National Institute of Technology
Ichchhanath, Surat, Gujarat
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
STOICHIOMETRY OF COMBUSTION
NUMERICAL EXAMPLES
PACKAGE BOILER
CONCLUSIONS
INTRODUCTION
Amount of heat energy liberated per unit mass or unit volume with H2O
in its liquid state under standard conditions [25C, 1atm. pressure]
Amount of heat energy liberated per unit mass or unit volume with H2O
in its vapour form under standard condition [25C, temp. 1 atm.
pressure]
FOR CONSTANT VOLUME COMBUSTION :
Qvh = GCVv=c = LCVv=c+ufg x mw
ufg = hfg –p.Vfg at 25C
= 2305 kJ/kg
mw = MC+9H, kg/kg of fuel
MC = Moisture, kg/kg of fuel
H = Hydrogen, kg/kg of fuel
DETERMINE :-
(a) Theoretical Air Required
(b) Actual Air
(c) Composition of Flue Gas
(d) Density of Flue Gas at 0C & 25 C & at 160 C
(e) Adiabatic Flame Temperature
SOLUTION :-
1. Combustion of Carbon :
C O2 CO2
12 kg 32 kg 44 kg
0.66 kg 1.76 kg 2.42 kg
2. Combustion Hydrogen :
1
H2 O2 H2O
2
2 kg 16 kg 18 kg
0.041 kg 0.328 kg 0.369 kg
3. Combustion of Sulphur :
S O2 SO2
32 kg 32 kg 64 kg
0.017 kg 0.017 kg 0.034 kg
O2 th O2 c O2 H O2 s O2 ] f
1.76 0.328 0.017 0.072
2.033 kg / kg of fuel
23 kg O2 77 kg N2 100 kg Air
2.033 kg O2 6.806 kg N2 8.839 kg of Air
Theoretical air required for complete combustion is : 8.839 kg/kg of fuel
mdry 12.8086
100.00 - 0.421701dry - 100.00
kg/kg
*2.8462-2.033 **0.12+0.369
(d) Flue Gas Density :-
Meq M x i i
(mol ) i (mol )
x i Mole fraction i
(mol ) i y
Where ,
y (mol ) i
mi
Now (Mol ) i
M i
mi 1 mi
Meq i M y Y
M
i
mi 13.2976 29.6245 kg / kgmole
moli 0.448871
Runiv 8314 [J / kgmole K ]
Req 280 .6456 J / kg K
Meq 29.6245 (kg / kgmole )
P 1.0132 105
2 5 C 1.2115 kg / m3
Req .T 280.6456 298
P 1.0132 105
& 0 C 1.3224 kg / m3
Req . T 280.6456 273
P 1.0132 105
& 1 6 0 C 0.8338 kg / m3
Req . T 280 .6456 433
Check : We know that
1 kg.-mole of any gas 22.4 m3 at 0 & 1 atm.
0.448871 10.05471 m3
mass 13.2976
C 1.3225 kg / m3
volume 10.05471
Tad = 1581.54C
Home Work Example :
The following data refers to a heavy oil fired in a boiler
C=85.4 % N=0.10 %
H=11.4 % MC=0.10 %
S=2.8 % Ash=0.10 %
O=0.1 % GCV=42.900 kJ/kg
Cpfg = 1.36 kJ/kg-K
It is operated at 25% excess air levels.
Determine :-
(i) Amount of air required per kg of fuel
(ii) Flue gas analysis on dry basis
(iii) Density of wet flue gas
(iv) Adiabatic flame temperature
ESTIMATION OF BOILER EFFICIENCY
DIRECT METHOD :
1.2 Efficiency of Boiler :-
Output Qu
1.2.1 Def . b
Input Qin
. .
Output ms hs mfw hfw Qu, kW
Input Qin Fuel Energy Auxiliary Energy Consumption
.
mf . GCVf E aux , kW
.
Usually E aux mf .GCVf
Qu
th .
100
mf . GCVf
1.2.2 Estimation By Direct Method :
. . .
Qu ms hs mfw .hfw ms (hs hfw )
.
Qin mf .GCVf
Qu
th x100
Qin
Qu
& overall .
100
(m . GCVf Paux )
NUMERICAL EXAMPLE :
A two hour boiler trial was conducted on a coal fired, smoke-tube boiler in a process
house & the following data was collected.
Rating : Equivalent Evaporation = 5 T/h
Max. Pressure = 10.5 kg/cm2
Av. Steam Pressure during trial = 7.5 kg/cm2 (g)
Barometric Pressure = 1.0132 bar
Av. Steam temperature = 179C
O2 in flue gas (dry basis) = 6.2 %
Ambient temperature = 35C
Unburnt in Ash = 7.2 %
Size of feed tank = 2.5m x 3.0 m
Depression of water level during trial = 1.87m
Temperature of feed water = 70C
GCV of fuel = 27000 kJ/kg
Coal consumption during trial = 1025 kg
Determine :-
(i) Boiler output in kW
(ii) Equivalent evaporation in T/h
(iii) Boiler efficiency, in %
We know that,
SOLUTION :-
Qu
x100
Qin
.
Qu ms (hs hfw )
.
Qin mf GCVf
Now Steam Generation A H]feed tan k fw / t
xD 2 H fw / t
4
.
ms (2.5)2 x1.87 x1000 / 2 3600
4
1.2749 kg / s
Psg = 7.5 kg/cm2 (g) = 7.3575 bar
Psabs = Psg + Pb = 7.3575 +1.0132 bar
= 8.3707 bar
Corresponding to Psabs = 8.3707 bar from steam tables :-
At P = 8.2 bar tsat = 171.5 C hg=2770.2 kJ/kg
At p = 8.4 bar tsat = 172.5 C hg=2771.2 kJ/kg
At p = 8.3707 bar tsat = 172.35 C hg=2771.05 kJ/kg
Now as ts =179C > tsat = 172.35C steam is superheated. From steam tables.
At p = 8.0 bar t = 200C hg = 2839.3 kJ/kg
P = 9.0 bar t = 200C hg = 2833.6 kJ/kg
At p = 8.3707 bar t = 200C hg = 2837.19 kJ/kg
At p = 8.3707 bar t = 172.35C hg = 2771.05 kJ/kg
At p = 8.3707bar t = 179C hg = 2786.96 kJ/kg
(iii) hffw = ?
From steam table at tfw=70C, hfw=293 kJ/kg
.
Qu ms (hs hfw ) 1.2749 x (2786 .96 293)
3179 .55 kW
.
(iv) Qin mf xGCV p c
GCVp c GCVV C nRoT
n np nr
0.421701 0.42924
7.539 x 10 3
GCVp c 27000 7.539 x103 x 8.314 x298
26981 .32 kJ / kg
1025
Qin x26981 .32 3841 .09 kW
2 x3600
Q
(v ) Boiler Efficiency b u x100
Qin
3179 .55
b x100 82.777 %
3841 .09
(vi) Equivalent Evaporation :
.
Qu meq xLevap at 1 atm and 100 C
.
3179 .55 meq x2256 .9
.
meq 1.4088 kg / s 5.0717 T / h
.
E dfg
.
E H 2O
BOILER
.
E fw
.
.
E loss
Ea
.
Ef
. .
E bd E ash
BASIS OF THE METHOD :
. . . . . . . . .
E fw E f Ea E s E d fg E H2O E bd E los s E as h
. . . . . . . . .
Ef (E s E fw ) (E d fg E a) E H2O E as h (E bd E les s )
. . . . . . .
E f E u (E dfg E a ) E H2O E as h E un
.
Divide by E f
. . . . . .
Eu (E d fg E a) E H2O E as h E un
1 .
.
.
.
.
Ef Ef Ef Ef Ef
Muliply by 100
. . . . . .
Eu (E dfg E a) E as h E H2O E un
100 .
x100 .
x100 .
x100 .
x100 .
x100
Ef Ef Ef Ef Ef
This is the Basis of Loss or Indirect Method
DETERMINATION OF VARIOUS LOSSES
1. Dry Gas Loss : [Stack Loss]
.
mdfg.Cpfg.(Tfg Tamb )
Qdrylos s 100 %
GCVf
Usually Cpfg 1.030 kJ / kg K
2. Losses in Ash
mMC .h
QMC 100
GCVf
(5) Unaccounted Losses :-
(i) Radiation loss = 0.3 to 1.0 %
(ii) Blow down loss=0.1 to 0.5 %
(iii) Loss due to unburnt gas 0.1 to 1.0 %
THUS
Combustion of Carbon :
C O2 CO2
12 kg 32 kg 44 kg
0.66 kg 1.76 kg 2.42 kg
Combustion of Hydrogen :
1
H2 O2 H2O
2
2 kg 16 kg 18 kg
0.041 kg 0.328 kg 0.369 kg
Combustion of Sulphur :
S O2 SO2
32 kg 32 kg 64 kg
0.017 kg 0.017 kg 0.034 kg
O2 th O2 c O2 H O2 s O2 ] f
1.76 0.328 0.017 0.072
2.033 kg / kg of fuel
23 kg O2 77 kg N2 100 kg of Air
2.033 kg O2 6.806 kg N2 8.839 kg of Air
FLUE GAS ANALYSIS
O2]ex 32 X 6.2
N2]f+N2]th [0.013+6.806]
28 0.243536 0.243536 -
= 6.819
N2]ex
28 3.762 X* -
N2]act 28
Air]th 8.839
Air]act
%Excess
Xwet 0.299067+4.
0.451525 100.00
Xdry 762X
N2]f+N2]th [0.013+6.806]
28 0.243536 0.243536 -
= 6.819
N2]ex 3.762
2.771384 28 -
X*=0.098978
N2]act 9.59038 28 0.342514 80.714
Air]th 8.839
Air]act 12.4653
%Excess 41.02%
Xwet 13.3753
0.451525 0.424355 100.00
Xdry 12.8863
N2]f+N2]th [0.013+6.806]
28 0.243536 0.243536 -
= 6.819
N2]ex 3.762 X=
2.77138 28 -
0.098978
N2]act 9.59038 28 0.342514 0.342514 80.714
Air]th 8.839
Air]act 12.4523
%Excess 40.88%
Xwet 13.3753
0.451525 0.424355 100.00
Xdry 12.8869
Xwet=Co2+MC+H2o+SO2+O2ex+N2act
Dry moles of flue gas 0.299067 4.762 X
% O2 6.2 X
0.062
100 100 0.299067 4.762 X
X=0.02631 moles of excess O2
3.762 x =0.098978 moles of excess N2
Total moles of dry flue gas = 0.424355 moles
Total mass of dry flue gas = 12.8863 kg/ kg of fuel
mco2 ms o2 mo2 ]ex mN 2
2. Calculation of Losses :
(i) Dry Gas Loss :[Stack Loss]
Qdfg [mdfg.Cpdfg. (Tfg Tamb ) / GCVf ]x100
[12.8863 * 1.03 * (210 35) / 27000] x 100
8.603 %
(ii) Losses in Ash
(a) Loss Due to Combustibles in Ash
mub mub
Now 0.072
mas h mub mas h, f
mub
0.072
mub 0.077
mub 0.005974 kg / kg of fuel
mas h mub mas h, f
mas h 0.077 0.005974 0.082974 kg / kg of fuel
mub xCVub
Qub 100
CVf
0.005974 x33820
100
27000
0.748 %
= O2 Theoretical + N2 Theoretical
= O2 Theoretical + 77 x O2 Theoretical
23
(3) X = 0.0116560
= %O2 in Flue Gas x No. of MolesWBof (CO2 + SO2 + H2O + N2fuel + N2Theoritical
)
CO2 44.0 1.46410 1.46410 18.084 19.187 0.0332750 0.033275 11.989979 13.222083
SO2 64.0 0.00880 0.00880 0.109 0.115 0.0001375 0.000137 0.049545 0.054637
H20+MC 18.0 0.46550 0.00000 5.750 0.000 0.0258611 0.000000 9.318533 0.000000
O2-Excess 32.0 0.37299 0.37299 4.607 4.888 0.0116560 0.011656 4.200000 4.631597
N2actual 28.0 5.78463 5.78463 71.45027 75.80910 0.2065938 0.206593 74.441943 82.091684
% Excess
27.0567 27.0567
Air
= 77 x Theoretical Oxygen
23
% Fly ash x % Ash in fuel x 0.84x(Flue gas Temp. – Ambient Temp.) x100
100 100
= 18.0127 %
= 100.00 – 18.0127
= 81.987 %
EFFICIENCY CALCULATION OF GIPCL, SLPP, MANGROL
2*125 MW UNIT, CFBC BOILERS WITH LIMESTONE ADDITION]
INPUT DATA: Steam Generation = 390 T/h
Steam Pressure = 130 kg/cm2 (g)
Steam Temperature = 540 oC
Flue gas
Carbon % 33.50 140.00
Temp. o C
Unburnt in Fly
Hydrogen % 2.50 1.50
Ash %
Unburnt in
Nitrogen % 0.50 0.05
Bottom Ash %
O 2 (FUEL) % 9.00 % of Fly Ash 70.00
% of Bottom
Sulphur % 0.60 30.00
Ash
Ash % 12.50 GCV kCal/kg 3322.98
Moisture % 41.40 GCV p=c kJ/kg 13999.60
Ambient
O 2 (FLUE GAS) % 4.0 35.00
Temp. o C
INPUT DATA: MODIFIED CONSIDERING
= O2 Theoretical + N2 Theoretical
= O2 Theoretical + 77 x O2 Theoretical
23
(3) X = 0.0084250
= %O2 in Flue Gas x No. of MolesWBof (CO2 + SO2 + H2O + N2fuel + N2Theoritical
)
CO2 44.0 1.16527 1.16527 19.310 21.394 0.0264833 0.0264833 12.573 14.881
SO2 64.0 0.01104 0.01104 0.183 0.203 0.0001725 0.0001725 0.0819 0.0969
H20 + MC 18.0 0.58788 0.00000 9.742 0.000 0.0326600 0.0000000 15.506 0.0000
O2-Excess 32.0 0.26960 0.26960 4.468 4.950 0.0084250 0.0084250 4.0000 4.7340
N2actual 28.0 4.00073 4.00073 66.2974 73.45323 0.1428832 0.1428832 67.838 80.287
% Excess
28.65941 28.6594
Air
TOTAL 6.03451 5.44663 100.00 100.00 0.21062 0.17796 100.00 100.00
Calculated Results:
= 77 x Theoretical Oxygen
23
% Fly ash x % Ash in fuel x 0.84x(Flue gas Temp. – Ambient Temp.) x 100
100 100
= 18.7316 %
= 100.00 – 18.7316
= 81.268 %
Conclusion
• Minimize Losses