Gardose, K.V. L. Asuncion, J. C. Suante, L.P. L. By the end of this lesson, you will have been able to:
Identify the features of an effective position paper;
determine the purpose of a position paper; define the context for a position paper; analyze the features of a position paper; use transitions to connect ideas; and write an effective position paper. Let’s Warm Up! • What do you think is the video all about? • What is the main argument of the author? • State some evidences used by the author to support his/her arguments Self-adult Usually Sometimes Seldom Never (3) (2) (1) (0) 1. I consider the reader’s beliefs, values, interests, and motivations when taking a stand on an issue. 2. I provide a background on the issue being discussed. 3. I use reliable sources when providing evidence for my arguments. 4. I clearly state my position at the start of a position paper. Self-adult Usually Sometimes Seldom Never (3) (2) (1) (0) 5. I anticipate possible criticisms to my arguments. 6. I conduct an in-depth research before writing my position paper. 7. I use emotional, ethical and logical appeals in my position paper. 8. I reflect on the weakness of my paper and revise it accordingly. Self-adult Usually Sometimes Seldom Never (3) (2) (1) (0) 9. I restate my position at the end of my position paper. 10. I suggest a course of action after presenting all of my arguments. Score Level of Proficiency 28-30 Advanced 25-27 Proficient Finished? Now total your scores. 23-24 Approaching Proficiency 21-22 Developing Proficiency 20 and below Beginning Proficiency Let’s Learn When we face an issue and are challenged to make a stand, it is necessary for us to support it with logical arguments. What is a Position Paper? A position paper is a type of academic writing that presents one’s stand or viewpoint on a particular issue. The main objective of writing a position paper is to take part in larger debate by stating your arguments and proposed course of action. Parts of a Position Paper 1. Introduction • Uses a lead that grabs the attention of readers. • Defines the issue and provide a thorough background. • Provides a general statement of your position through a thesis statement. Parts of a Position Paper 2. Body • States your main arguments and provide sufficient evidence (e.g., statistics, interviews with experts, and testimonies) for each argument. • Provides counterarguments against possible weaknesses of your arguments. Parts of a Position Paper 3. Conclusion • Restates your position and main arguments. • Suggests a course of action. • Explains why your position is better than any other position. • Ends with a powerful closing statement (e.g. a quotation, a challenge, or a question). Choosing as Issue
1. The issue should be debatable.You cannot take
any position if the topic is not debatable. 2. The issue should be current and relevant. 3. The issue should be written in a question form and answerable by yes or no. 4. The issue should be specific and manageable. Guidelines in Writing a Position Paper 1. Begin the writing process with an in-depth research about the issue at hand. 2. Be aware of the various positions about the issue and explain and analyze them objectively. 3. Reflect on your position and identify its weaknesses. 4. Establish your credibility by citing reliable sources. 5. Present a unique way of approaching the issue. Guidelines in Writing a Position Paper 6. Limit your position paper to two pages. 7. Analyze your target readers and align your arguments to their beliefs, needs, interests, and motivations. 8. Summarize the other side’s counterarguments and refute them with evidence. 9. Define unfamiliar terms at first mention. 10. Use an active voice as much as possible. This will make your tone dynamic and firm. Guidelines in Writing a Position Paper
11. Arrange your evidence logically using an inductive or deductive
approach. 12. Check your paper for fallacies and revise accordingly. 13. Use ethical, logical and emotional appeals. Ethical appeals relate to you credibility and competence as writer; logical appeal refers to the rational approach in developing an argument; emotional appeals pertain to feelings evoked during arguments. Make sure to check your appeals to ensure that they are not fallacious. Checking for Understanding Write T if the statement is true and F if false. 1. A good position paper considers all possible views on the issue at hand. 2. An issue is a crucial component of a position paper. 3. An issue is debatable if it cannot be answered by yes or no. 4. Audience analysis will help you write a more persuasive position paper. 5. One way to establish your credibility as a writer is to boast your credentials. Checking for Understanding Write T if the statement is true and F if false. 6. Opinions are better than facts supporting arguments. 7. Statistics can be used as evidence to support an argument. 8. The main goal of a position paper is to inform readers 9. The strongest type of appeal in a position paper is logical appeal. 10. Your position should be restated in the concluding paragraph. Application Select a topic and write your own position paper.