Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Agenda for Risk Review dated 3-Dec-08
Risk Synopsis : Overall scenario of Risk Event, Target mitigation date (out of criticality)
Plan vs Actual : Achievements as per actions suggested / committed earlier
Overall mitigation plan (How the risk event will be mitigated?)
Detail Mitigation Action plans with schedule & commitments (1 month look-ahead)
Critical Issues (Issues with action plan & dead line) etc…
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
IT System Procurement : Risk Synopsis
Title IT System Procurement
Completion of Specifications, Tender Documents, Tender Release, Tender Review
Description
and Award of IT Packages
Effect Delay to award and subsequent pressure on schedule for completion
Primary Owner S Malakar
Risk Response Strategy : Reduce Manageability : Moderate Proximity : Underway
10-Dec-08
Time now
Score 100 Score 48 Score 4
Probability VH Probability M Probability L
Overall Impact VH Overall Impact H Overall Impact L
48
Schedule H Schedule H Schedule L Target
Score
Actual
Cost H Cost H Cost L Forecast
Performance VH Performance H Performance L
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
DIAL clearance on
2 Release of Tender for Control Centre MAL L&T 15-Nov-08 15-Nov-08 5-Dec-08
Video wall required
Letter to IBM to participate in drawing
3 Co-ordination process MAL L&T 18-Nov-08 18-Nov-08 19-Nov-08 Letter issued to IBM
6 Availability of Raceway hardware’s MAL L&T 15-Dec-08 15-Dec-08 15-Dec-08 JB approval in-progress
7 Temporary Test & Integration Centre KBS DIAL 20-Dec-08 30-Dec-08 30-Dec-08
7a Finalization of Requirement KBS DIAL 20-Nov-08 20-Nov-08 20-Nov-08
7b Finalization of Contractor KKS DIAL 25-Nov-08 25-Nov-08 25-Nov-08
7c Development of Centre KBS DIAL 20-Dec-08 30-Dec-08 30-Dec-08
8 BMS briefing prior to start Negotiation KBS DIAL 20-Nov-08 20-Nov-08 20-Nov-08
ACS & CCTV – Sign-off agreement KBS DIAL
9 from Security agencies 22-Nov-08 22-Nov-08 25-Nov-08 Agreed in principle
MAL L&T
DIAL APD / RSK / FMT / 01 / V1.3 4
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
IT System Procurement : Ordering Status
Tender Quotation TER Negotiate Package SCP
SL Packages Vendor
Release Receipt Complete Start Concluded Award
1 System Integration (SI) Unisys 19-May-08 30-Jun-08 22-Jul-08 11-Aug-08 16-Sep-08 ?
2 Master System Integration (MSI) Unisys 31-May-08 30-Jun-08 22-Jul-08 11-Aug-08 16-Sep-08 ?
3 Network IBM 24-May-08 30-Jun-08 22-Jul-08 11-Aug-08 16-Sep-08 ?
4 Flight Information Display Sys (FIDS) - 27-May-08 26-Jun-08 21-Jul-08 14-Aug-08 14-Nov-08 ?
5 CUPPS –CUSS & BRS-MDS - 27-May-08 4-Jul-08 21-Jul-08 14-Aug-08 6-Dec-08
Public Address & Voice Alarms
6 - 29-May-08 30-Jun-08 22-Jul-08 22-Sep-08 6-Dec-08
(PAVA)
7 Telephony - 27-May-08 26-Jun-08 24-Jul-08 6-Aug-08 25-Nov-08 ?
8 Access Control System (ACS) & CCTV - 27-May-08 30-Jun-08 22-Sep-08 21-Oct-08 8-Dec-08
9 Building Management System (BMS) - 29-May-08 28-Jul-08 31-Oct-08 8-Dec-08
10 Electronic Point of Sale (EPOS) - 2-Jun-08 16-Jul-08 31-Oct-08 30-Dec-08
11 Info Kiosk (INK) - 31-May-08 8-Jul-08 21-Oct-08 30-Dec-08
12 Control Centers & Helpdesk (HED) - 5-Dec-08 15-Jan-09
13 Master Antenna TV (MATV) On Hold
14 APPS & SADS for MLCP - Clearance awaited from DIAL
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
IT System Procurement : Mitigation Schedule
2008 2009 2010
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
7 Award of SCP for Critical Packages MAL L&T 20-Dec-08 Within 7 days of notification
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
IT System Procurement : Critical Issues
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
IT System Procurement : Risk Analysis
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Risk Synopsis
Title Subcontractor’s Co-ordination
Effective Interface Management of the Sub Contractors with respect to Clash free GFC,
Description
Work fronts and interdependencies in PTB, Piers & Main Apron Area
Effect Potential for delays, re work and additional cost
Primary Owner Kamal Mehdiratta
Risk Response Strategy : Reduce Manageability : Moderate Proximity : Underway
31-Jan-09
Time now
Target
Score
Schedule H Schedule H Schedule M
Actual
Cost M Cost M Cost L Forecast
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Approved GFC Release Plan for PTB
Plan of GFC Release Nov-08 (Week Ends) Dec-08 (Week Ends)
Level Blocks 15/11 22/11 29/11 6/12 13/12 20/12 27/12
Sub-basement 5 3 2
Basement 8 6 2
Arrival 12 3 6 3
Mezzanine 15 1 5 9
Departure
Plan 40 0 4 14 19 3 0 0
Actual 0 0 3 6
Detail of Blocks
Plan G,H,J D,F
Sub-basement
Actual G,H,J
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
3g Arrival Level – Block A2, B2, C2 Kamal L&T 8-Dec-08 8-Dec-08 19-Dec-08
3h Mezzanine Level – Block A1, B1, C1 Kamal L&T 19-Nov-08 19-Nov-08 19-Nov-08
3i Mezzanine Level – Block G, H, J Kamal L&T 25-Nov-08 25-Nov-08 10-Dec-08
Mezzanine Level – Block A2, A3, B2, 22-Nov 29-Nov 6-Dec 13-Dec
3k B3, C2, C3, D, E, F Kamal L&T 5-Dec-08 5-Dec-08 30-Dec-08
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : PTB Progress
BIM
Last Actual / 2D SIGN 2D to BIM Clash Clash GFCs by GFCs
SL Mitigation Action Plans Owner Clash Approv
Committed Expected OFF BIM
report
Resolve free to S/Cs
al
S/Cs
3 BIM Release Commitments (PTB) Kamal L&T 8-Dec-08 Days > 6 1 3 3 1 3 3
3a Sub-basement – Block G, H, J Kamal L&T 20-Nov-08 27-Nov-08
3b Sub-basement – Block D, F Kamal L&T 2-Dec-08 15-Dec-08
3c Basement – Block A, B, C, D, E, F Kamal L&T 26-Nov-08 12-Dec-08
3d Basement – Block G, J Kamal L&T 5-Dec-08 15-Dec-08
3e Arrival Level – Block G, H, J Kamal L&T 22-Nov-08 1-Dec-08
3f Arrival Level – Block A1,B1,C1, D,E,F Kamal L&T 5-Dec-08 19-Dec-08
3g Arrival Level – Block A2, B2, C2 Kamal L&T 8-Dec-08 19-Dec-08
3h Mezzanine Level – Block A1, B1, C1 Kamal L&T 19-Nov-08 19-Nov-08
3i Mezzanine Level – Block G, H, J Kamal L&T 25-Nov-08 10-Dec-08
Mezzanine Level – Block A2, A3, B2,
3k B3, C2, C3, D, E, F Kamal L&T 5-Dec-08 30-Dec-08
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Piers Progress
2D Co-ordination BIM Clash Resolution
SL Mitigation Action Plans Blocks Owner
Blocks Completed Expected Blocks Completed Expected
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Piers Progress
2D Co-ordination BIM Clash Resolution
SL Mitigation Action Plans Blocks Owner
Blocks Completed Expected Blocks Completed Expected
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Process Flow for GFC Release
-1 -2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Duration in days
Level-B Approval
Drg Superimpose by ETA, Work out Clashes
& Suggest resolution
No 5
Acceptance of
Comments Major Co-ordination
2 Comments 3 GFC Approval
L&T, DIAL
Incorporation of Intervention Minor
Comments GFCs preparation by all S/Cs as
Co-ordination Sign-off 3
1 per CSD & Clash free BIM input
3
Clash Resolution / Free of Clash
DIAL APD / RSK / FMT / 01 / V1.3 17
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Subcontractor’s Co-ordination : Critical Issues
Within a day
Delay in submission of revised drg L&T/ Package Delay to release BIM clash
2 Expedite / Follow-up Vendors after 2D sign-
after 2D co-ordination to BIM Managers resolution
off
Non-availability of Revised ETA to revise & submit revised Delay in Mezzanine floor
4 L&T/ETA 5-Dec-08
Mezzanine HVAC drawing Layout to BIM co-ordination in BIM
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Risk Synopsis
Title Energization
Readiness of Energization System : (Start-up Power by 24-Jan-09)
Description
Engineering, Civil Work, Equipment Delivery, Installation, Testing and Commissioning
Effect Delay in Start of Equipment Testing & Commissioning in PTB Area
Primary Owner C. S. Seshadri
Risk Response Strategy : Reduce Manageability : Moderate Proximity : Underway
31-Jan-09
Pre-mitigated Position Status Now Post-mitigated Position
Score 80 Score 64 Score 4 64
Probability H Probability H Probability L
Overall Impact VH Overall Impact H Overall Impact L
Schedule VH Schedule H Schedule L Target
Score
Actual
Cost L Cost L Cost L Forecast
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
CSS L&T
4 Prepare revise plan for Energization 28-Nov-08 28-Nov-08 02-Dec-08
S Nag DIAL
Availability of BSES 66KV Power –
5 Weekly Follow-up S Nag DIAL 31-Jan-09 31-Jan-09 31-Jan-09
6 Release DG Fuel Tank FDN Drawing CSS L&T 15-Nov-08 15-Nov-08 15-Nov-08
Re-submission by
7 Fire Water Tank FDN Drawing CSS L&T 30-Nov-08 30-Nov-08 10-Dec-08
06-Dec-08
8 Civil Work
Finishing works by
1 11 KV Sub-station Building CSS L&T 23-Dec-08 23-Dec-08 02-Jan-09
31-Jan-09
2 66 kV Switchyard CSS L&T 17-Dec-08 17-Dec-08 17-Dec-08
Block work by 20th Jan &
3 DG #2 Building CSS L&T 30-Dec-08 30-Dec-08 31-Jan-08 finishing works by 31st Jan.
4 Start Fuel Tank Excavation Work CSS L&T 15-Nov-08 15-Nov-08 25-Nov-08
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Mitigation Plan (Revised Target 28-Feb-09)
SL Area / Zone Mitigation Steps Schedule 2008 2009
No. Description Description Start Finish Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Mitigation Actions : Civil Work (Dec-08)
SL Mitigation Action Plans Owner Start Date Finish Date Status
1 DG Building #2
1a Civil Structure CSS L&T 7-Dec-08 10-Dec-08 10.8m slab casting on 7-Dec-08
1b Block Work CSS L&T 8-Dec-08 20-Jan-09 Blocks Available
1c Plastering CSS L&T 20-Dec-08 25-Jan-09
1d Flooring CSS L&T 30-Dec-08 30-Jan-09
2 11 kV Substation Building
2a Civil Structure CSS L&T 2-Dec-08 4-Dec-08 Roof slab casting start 2-Dec-08
2b Block Work CSS L&T 4-Dec-08 2-Jan-09
2c Plastering CSS L&T 16-Dec-08 12-Jan-09
2d Flooring CSS L&T 25-Dec-08 25-Jan-09
3 Cable Trench (11 KV to DG Room) CSS L&T 25-Dec-08 15-Jan-09 Buried Cable
4 Fire Water Tank CSS L&T 20-Dec-08 15-Jan-09 Revised Drawing to be submitted
5 Fuel Unloading, Storage & Forwarding CSS L&T 25-Nov-08 25-Dec-08
6 Stack Civil Work CSS L&T 15-Dec-08 26-Dec-08 FDN Drawing under approval
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Mitigation Actions : Electrical Work (Dec-08)
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Statutory Approval
SL Statutory Approval For What Required by Status
Drawings will be submitted
1 CEA, Delhi Electrical Inspector 20.01.09
by 20.12.08
Drawings will be submitted
2 DFS, Delhi For DG 30.01.09
by 20.12.08
For underground diesel Drawings will be submitted
3 CCE, Faridabad 20.01.09
storage tanks by 15.12.08
Will be applied after DG
4 DPCB, Delhi For DG 30.01.09
Erection.
May be required for
5 DGCA, Delhi To be checked.
Chimney height (30m)
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Energization : Critical Issues
SL Issues Actions Responsible Dead Line Impact
Expansion of existing 66 kV
Start Procurement / Non-availability of
Mahipalpur Substation &
1 Construction activities BSES 31-Jan-09 incoming power to
Transmission line up to MRSS
immediately Energize
by BSES
30-Dec-08 Delay in PTB &
2 Readiness of HT LT Tunnel Expedite Civil Progress DIAL/L&T
15-Jan-09 Piers Energization
Area Grading for 11 KV Cable
Expedite Steel removal & Delay in PTB &
3 laying – Front of Project office L&T 15-Dec-08
then Civil work Piers Energization
to LT/HT Tunnel
4 Fire Water System Drawings Follow-up /Meeting L&T/ Areva 25-Nov-08 Delay in Charging
Slow progress of Civil Work Follow-up Sub-contractors 30-Jan-09 Delay in PTB &
5 L&T/Areva
due to low productivity of Labourer to expedite progress Piers Energization
Work completion
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Baggage Handling System : Risk Synopsis
Title Baggage Handling System
Sub-vendor Engineering, Sub-vendor’s Procurement, Manufacturing & Delivery,
Description
Installation, Testing & Commissioning & Integration Test
Effect Delay in completion could lead to Project Delay
Primary Owner Col Sharat Sharma
Risk Response Strategy : Reduce Manageability : Moderate Proximity : Underway
Time now
28-Feb-09
Score 72 Score 64 Score 4 64
Probability H Probability H Probability L
Overall Impact VH Overall Impact H Overall Impact L
Target
Score
Schedule VH Schedule H Schedule L
Actual
Cost M Cost M Cost L Forecast
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Baggage Handling System : Mitigation Actions
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Baggage Handling System : Critical Issues
Progressively
Augmentation plan submitted by Improper project
3 Lack of Competent Manpower Siemens to Mar 09 for
Siemens progress
IT
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
HVAC Works : Risk Synopsis
Title HVAC Works
Engineering, Subcontractor’s Procurement, Delivery of Long Lead Items, HVAC
Description
Works at Site
Effect Delay in completion of Passenger Terminal Building – 3
Primary Owner R K VERMA
Risk Response Strategy : Reduce Manageability : Moderate Proximity : Underway
28-Feb-09
Score 72 Score 64 Score 4
64
Probability H Probability H Probability L
Overall Impact VH Overall Impact H Overall Impact L
Target
Score
Schedule VH Schedule H Schedule L
Time now
Actual
Cost M Cost M Cost L Forecast
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
Achieved On Schedule Alert Delay, Critical
5 Start of Night Shift upon reaching 600 SRG L&T 17-Nov-08 17-Nov-08
DIAL APD / RSK / FMT / 01 / V1.3 36
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
SL Risks Proposed Actions Actions taken for Mitigation
HVAC Works : Risks
Workshop / Meeting to accelerate ETA has submitted a Calender of outstanding
GFC drawing non-availability generation of GFC drawings GFC Drgs, being monitored
1
based on 3D clash resolution Ensure resolution of 3D clash Not happening, taking more than 7 days as
within 2 days from clash report draftsmen have to re-understand and re-work
Deployment of adequate
Enforce higher management of ETA to
2 Manpower : Workmen,
deploy manpower as per contract
Supervisors
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
HVAC Works : Risks
SL Risks Proposed Actions Actions taken for Mitigation
Follow up with ETA for manufacturing schedule
Prepare Items-wise delivery Plan
of all 175 AHU panels
Delivery of Electrical & CMS Monitor progress items-wise on weekly
7 PO/ LoI copies taken from vendor.
Items basis – take vendor PO & contact detail
Checking of Physical Progress by To send L&T Engineers for AHU Inspections/
visiting vendor’s frequently Mukut large dia pipes
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
HVAC Works : Mitigation Plan
2008 2009
Target
SL Mitigation Action Plans Owner UoM
Finish Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
HVAC Works : Critical Issues
Release GFC drawings after co- 3D process for Clash analysis Duct Installation
2 L&T/ETA Immediate
ordination to speed-up Delay
Delivery
Delivery of Large Diameter Post expeditor at fabricator’s Done
3 L&T/ETA 1000/1200by
(>400mm) Pipes & Supports works to accelerate process 400-600 Dia in Jan 09
30-dec-08
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works
HVAC Works : Risk Analysis
Risk Review Meeting : 03-Dec-08 Airport Development Project : Terminal-3, Runway and Associated Works