Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OF HISTORY
WHAT IS HISTORY?
It’s from the Greek word The equivalent Latin word is
“HISTORIA” which means to search “Scientia” came to used more
or look into. As the time past by regularly to designate non-
there are some changes into its chronological systematic accounts of
meaning. The word history now natural phenomena; and the word
means “the past of mankind”. “History” was reserved usually for
accounts of phenomena (especially
human affairs) in chronological order.
9
Secondary sources
is a work that interprets or analyzes an historical
event or phenomenon. It is generally at least one
step removed from the event is often based on
primary sources.
Examples include: scholarly or popular books and
articles, reference books, and textbooks.
14
EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL
CRITICISM IN HISTORY
✣It is necessary to know whether the document or relic is in reality
what it claims to be, or what it claims to be, or what it has been
esteemed to be. That’s why historians criticizes a given document first.
✣It is important to determine where and when it originated, who was
the author, and where does the information on derived from. It is also
important to weigh the relation of testimony to the truth. One must
decide whether the statements made are trustworthy, and if not
absolutely certain, whether they are probable. The degree of probability
or possibility must be determined. (Archive.org 2017)
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 15
External Criticism in History
• Lower criticism in which it deals with the authorship
and its authenticity
• Mainly studies the outside form of the document
(forms and appearances)
• Examines and questions if the document is
fabricated, forged, fake or merely hoax
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 16
REASONS OF FORGED OR MISLEADING
HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS
1. The documents are sometimes used to support a false claim or title
‐ There might be some documents that shows biases towards certain topic
in history. Historians must know the difference between claims and
evidence.
‐ Evidence is the concrete facts used to support a claim. Claims are,
almost by definition, controversial, in the sense that not everyone
agrees with them. Once you know what the claim is, you are in a better
position to see what the facts .
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 17
REASONS OF FORGED OR MISLEADING
HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS
2. The documents are counterfeited for sale.
‐ A counterfeit document can be defined as one wherein
made in imitation of something else with intent to made an
imitation of a genuine article (document) without authorization
and permission of the real author with the objective of gaining
profit from it.
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 18
REASONS OF FORGED OR MISLEADING
HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS
3. Fabrication due to less mercenary considerations like political
propaganda
‐ Creation of such stories with the help of some people that are
primarily concerned with making money at the expense of ethics in
which it disseminates or promote particular ideas that supports their
agreed political point of view.
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 19
REASONS OF FORGED OR MISLEADING
HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS
4. Some historical “facts” are based on some practical jokes
For example:
The origin of the celebration of “April Fools Day” is unclear,
though some speculated it dates back to 1582, when France
made the move from the Julian calendar to the Gregorian
calendar. The change by Pope Gregory XIII moved the start of
the new year from the end of March to January 1, making
“fools” of those still using the original calendar.
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 20
The tradition of a “fools day” is marked
around the world.
Today, April Fools' Day is embraced by young
and old alike, with the corporate world getting
into the fun, too.
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 21
TEST OF AUTHENTICITY IN
HISTORY
IMPORTANCE: To distinguish a hoax or a misinterpretation from a
genuine document.
1. Date of the document
- Examines if the document corresponds with the author’s
chronology
2. Anachronistic
‐ Determines if the document or relic belongs to a specific
period of time
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 22
TEST OF AUTHENTICITY IN
HISTORY
3. Anachronistic Style or Composition
Examines signs of age by the means of handwriting, signature,
seal, letter head, or watermark
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 23
TEST OF AUTHENTICITY IN
HISTORY
Anachronistic styles determiner:
- Idiom
- Orthography
- Punctuation
- Spelling
4. Isography
a line drawn on a map to indicate areas having common
linguistic characteristics
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 24
TECHNIQUES USED BY EXPERTS TO DETERMINE
AUTHENTICITY
• PALEOGRAPHY
Study of ancient wring systems and the deciphering and dating
of historical manuscripts.
• DIPLOMATICS
The science of deciphering old official documents, as characters,
of determining its authenticity, age, and the likes.
EXTERNAL CRITICISM 25
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND
REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY
SOURCES
26
MODES OF HISTORICAL CRITICISM
EXTERNAL INTERNAL
CRITICISM CRITICISM
27
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
WHAT IS INTERNAL CRITICISM?
- often called the higher criticism and deals with the
process by which the trustworthiness of the
document is studied
- criticism/ evaluation deals with credibility
28
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
Is it credible and truthful?
29
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
EYEWITNESS OR SECONDHAND
ACCOUNT?
?
Meaning
PRIMARY
SOURCES LITERAL MEANING?
in Context
INTERNAL CONSISTENCY?
CONNOTATIONS?
30
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
Internal Criticism
31
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
National Archives
- the National Archives of the Philippines is the
home of about 60 million documents from the
centuries of Spanish rule in the Philippines, the
American and Japanese occupations, as well as
the years of the Republic.
32
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
National Museum
- the National Museum is a trust of the
government, is an educational, scientific
and cultural institution that acquires,
documents, exhibits and fosters scholarly
study and public appreciation of works of
art, specimens, and cultural and historical
artifacts representative of our unique to
the cultural heritage of the Filipino people
and the natural history of the Philippines.
33
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
National Library
- the National library of the Philippines was established as
the Museo- Biblioteca de Filipinas through the royal
decree of August 12, 1887- provided for the “the
consolidation of all libraries belonging to any branch of
the Philippine Government for the creation of the
Philippine Library’, and for the maintenance of the
same, and other purposes
34
INTERNAL CRITICISM AND REPOSITORIES OF PRIMARY SOURCESL
DIFFERENT KIND OF PRIMARY
SOURCES
35
KINDS OF PRIMARY SOURCES
1. Letters, diaries, journals, wills, bibles, report cards
2. Business records such as correspondence, ledgers, minutes,
speeches, invoices
3. Poems, songs, hymns
4. Photographs, paintings, films, advertisements, and other
artwork
5. Tools, machines, furniture, clothing, and other artifacts from
a particular era
Meaning and Distinction of primary Internal criticism and External criticism and
Relevance of history, and secondary Repositories of different kinds of
and different kinds of sources, and different primary sources, and primary sources
primary sources kinds of primary different kinds of
sources 38 primary sources
references
https://tl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mga_Negrito
https://it-it.facebook.com/notes/jubangnon-ka-kung/malaya-na-nga-ba-ta
yo/590653124288612/
https://s.docworkspace.com/d/AGANkz2Oj_03ooKW-5SnFA
https://kso.page.link/wps
https://askinglot.com/what-is-internal-and-external-criticism-of-
historical-sources
https://www.lib.uci.edu/examples-primary-sources
39
Thank you for listening!