Professional Documents
Culture Documents
• REJECTIONISTS
• SCEPTICS
• MODIFIERS
REJECTIONISTS
Scholars who dismiss the utility of globalization as an analytical concept
typically advance their arguments
from within a larger criticism of similarly vague words employed in
academic discourse. Besides globalization,
another often-cited example for such analytically impoverished concepts
is the complex and ambiguous phe-
nomenon of nationalism
Scholar’s Arguments:
Craig Calhoun - argues that nationalism and its corollary terms
‘have proved notoriously hard concepts to define’ because ‘nationalisms are
extremely varied phenomena’,
and ‘any definition will legitimate some claims and delegitimate others’
Hirst and Thompson claim that the world economy is not a truly global
phenomenon, but one centred on Europe, eastern Asia, and North America.
MODIFIERS
The third and final group of globalization critics disputes the novelty of the process, implying that the label
‘globalization’ has often been applied in a historically imprecise manner.
Robert Gilpin
confirms the existence of globalizing tendencies, but he also insists that many important aspects of globalization are not novel developments.
GLOBALIZATION AS ECONOMIC PROCESS
•Market globalism
•Justice globalism
•Religious globalism
Market Globalism - seeks to endow ‘globalization’ with free-market norms and
neoliberal meanings.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimensions_of_globalization
https://www.mindmeister.com/1755304644/approaches-to-the-study-of-globalization
THANK YOU!