Transformational is about change, dramatic, fundamental
learning change in the way we see ourselves and the world in which we live.
Transformative involves experiencing a deep, structural shift in the
learning basic premises of thought, feelings and actions. • Mezirow (1994) described the transformational learning theory as being constructivist, an orientation which holds that the way learners interpret .
1. Instrumental learning – focuses on learning through task-oriented
problem solving and determination of cause and effect relationships 2. Communicative learning – is involved with how others communicate their feelings, need and desires with another person. It helps the learners to become critical, autonomous and responsible thinkers Perspective Transformation leading to transformative learning occurs infrequently. Mezirow believes that it usually results from a disorienting dilemma, which is triggered by a life crisis or major life transition, although it may also result from an accumulation of transformations in meaning schemes over a period of time Process of Perspective Transformation Psychological (changes in understanding of the self) Convictional (revision of belief systems) Behavioral (changes in lifestyle)
From Mezirow (1997) , the goal of transformational learning is
to change the “frame of reference”, which is the collective assumptions through which we interpret and understand the world we live in. Perspective Transformation Elements of frame of reference: (Mezirow 1997)
Habits of mind – are always affected and shaped by
assumptions which build on cultural, social, educational and political codes Point of View – Originates from habits of mind Learning occurs in one of four ways: (Mezirow 1997)
By refining or elaborating existing frames of reference
By learning new frames of reference By transforming points of view, or By transforming habits of mind Perspective Transformation
Levels of Cognitive processing: (Mezirow 1997)
Cognitive processing: First order thinking Compute, memorize, read and comprehend
Cognitive processing: Metacognition
Monitoring progress and products of first order thinking
Cognitive processing: Transformative learning
Reflecting on the limits of knowledge, the certainty of knowledge, and the criteria for knowing Key points to apply transformational learning in practice (Imel, 1998, Taylor, 1998)
Ideal learning condition – promotes a sense of safety, openness, trust
and care Effective instructional methods – support a learner – centered approach, promote student autonomy, participation and collaboration. Sensitive relationship with the students – this provides the students with quality learning experience by being trusting, empathetic, caring, authentic and sincere The following are instructional practices that can be used to increase participation and engagement in the classroom (de Frondeville) Creating an emotionally safe classroom - students who have been shamed or belittled by the teacher or another student will not effectively engage in challenging tasks Creating an intellectually safe classroom – begin every activity with a task that 95 percent of the class can do without your help Cultivating engagement meter – be acutely aware of when your students are paying strong attention or are deeply engaged in their tasks Participating journal or blog writing to communicate with students – let your students write with regular reflections on the work they have done Teaching self – awareness about knowledge – creating a culture of explanation instead of a culture of right answer Using the design process to increase the quality of work – this is a draft – and – revision process used by many professionals to increase the quality of their work
Marketing the projects – assign projects which incorporate
authentic tasks that will help students in their lives, jobs or relationships Some issues
Educational Implications There have been plenty of criticism
about education that aims at an end product, rather than focusing on the learning process. The lack of a priority of experience and access to different areas of learning was also mentioned. To determine what to learn and how to learn requires a dialogue among all those who are involved in the educational process. Remember
Transformative learning involves the transformation of frame
of reference (points of view, habits of mind, worldviews) and critical reflection on how we come to know (Mezirow, 1997). In order to foster transformative learning, the educator should assist learners in becoming aware and critical of assumptions THANK YOU!