Community-based Initiatives Introduction • Every country is at the risk of exposure to some type of disaster, whether natural or man-made. In order for each country to prepare for any kind of disaster, it must inform its citizens about the different types of disasters. • The local residents must also be aware of how they can effectively participate in preparing for a disaster, mitigating potential impacts of a disaster and the recovery process after a disaster Introduction • One of the most effective mechanisms for a country to prepare for a disaster is by conducting education and public awareness programs at the local community level. • Public awareness in disaster management is a process of educating and empowering the population through sharing knowledge and information about the various types of disasters and their potential risks as widely as possible so that people act appropriately when a disaster happens Introduction • Public awareness: the process of transmitting information to the general population to increase their levels of consciousness about disaster risks so they can prepare appropriately to cope with a disaster
• Community-based approach: a method of education and public
awareness in disaster management in which community members are involved in the planning and implementation of the awareness programs Introduction • Hazard Map: a map which shows areas that are vulnerable to particular hazards such earthquakes, cyclones, flooding, volcanic activity • Community Disaster Management Organization : a national organization which ensures that planned activities for disaster management are implemented within a given timeframe Rationale for a Community-Based Approach All governments are responsible for protecting their citizens and endorsing the 2005 Hyogo Declaration which states that: “strengthening community level capacities to reduce disaster risk at the local level is especially needed, considering that appropriate disaster reduction measures at that level enable the communities and individuals to reduce significantly their vulnerability to hazards.” Rationale for a Community-Based Approach Members of a community are the immediate victims of adverse effects of a disaster. They have the best knowledge about their local surrounding in terms of the most disaster-prone areas, the demography of their community and their social and traditional organization. It is important that they have the capacity to cope with the impacts of a disaster and are involved in the development of disaster management activities right from the initial planning stages. Community participation can also make them more confident in their capabilities to act in the event of a disaster leading to a self-reliant community (Newport & Jawahar, 2003). Rationale for a Community-Based Approach Every community has members who can be ignorant of events around them especially when these events do not affect them directly or more frequently. This type of attitude can also be gradually changed by involving members of the local community in decision-making processes such as planning national disaster management plans or even designing awareness programs. This bottom-up, participatory approach can make community members more receptive of new knowledge and information presented to them. Local residents who speak or understand their native language only may be hesitant to accept non-native people conducting education and awareness programs for them. Stakeholders’ Roles and Responsibilities An effective and successful community-based approach in reducing disaster risks is often attributed to the spontaneous participation and involvement of the following stakeholders: Government Non-governments (NGOs) Regional and International Organizations/Donor Agencies Island council (Local government) National/Local Organizations (women committees, youth groups, schools, etc) Community workers Stakeholders’ Roles and Responsibilities • Trainers • Disaster Managers (Local and National) • Policy Makers • Grass-roots people • Religious Denominations Stakeholders’ Roles and Responsibilities There is a need for coordination in the Community-Based Approach among all the stakeholders. The parameters for participation by each of the stakeholders need to be clearly outlined at the national level to avoid overlap and confusion. The focus for all of the stakeholders should be the local people, who are at risk of being potential victims and who should also assume responsibility in managing that risk. The stakeholders must: develop a strong governance framework through legislation and policies; Stakeholders’ Roles and Responsibilities mainstream disaster risk management and capacity building into decision making, the budget process, and sector, provincial and community development plans; strengthen, empower and support local and national structures; and understand and recognize that disaster management and disaster risk reduction are environmental, humanitarian and developmental issues, so there is a need to coordinate the implementation, monitoring and evaluation of the approach Categories of stakeholders Government To have an effective and sustainable impact on the community-based disaster programs, policy makers should consider incorporating community- based disaster programs into their drafting of appropriate acts and regulations in order to implement them effectively. The governments have a prime responsibility for managing disasters and for taking into consideration the roles taken by different people in the community in terms of developing and providing approaches and strategic actions which can be used to manage the consequences of disaster within the community. Community-based disaster initiatives produce results so long as there is also government support Non Government Organizations (NGOs) NGOs are the appropriate organizations to conduct community-based disaster activities at the different communities and with different stakeholders. They consist of professionals, activists and grass-roots people who have wide networks which facilitate their capacity in programme development. Regional and International Organizations / Donor Agencies Selected donor agencies, regional and international organizations assist the communities in terms of initiating the community-based disaster programs and providing financial assistance and sometimes resource people for the programs Community Workers Community workers are the most reliable arms of the local government/island council in the implementation stage of the disaster policy and reduction initiatives. They have experience in handling disasters, hazards, emotional problems and coping mechanism and uncertainties. They assist the local government/island council in establishing a strong cooperation and understanding among diverse stakeholders including the local government, local NGOs, government, regional and international organizations. If this cooperation is effective, every person involved in all community- based disaster programs is benefited, but the actual ownership still remains with the concerned community National/Local Organizations National and local organizations such as women’s committees, youth groups, schools, religious groups, etc. should consider adapting the community-based disaster initiatives provided by the government, regional and international organizations as part of their overall disaster risks management. They are the main bodies in the community that can assist in the implementation of the community-based disaster programs effectively. National and Local Disaster Managers Disaster Managers are the disaster professionals and technical people in the national government, who are responsible for the implementation of the disaster management initiatives of the country. Since the communities are important parts of the national government, these disaster professionals and managers should be aware that the key aspect of community-based disaster initiatives is its sustainability. Therefore, it is the trainers, local managers and/or national managers’ roles and responsibilities to train people in the community to understand the basic community-based disaster mitigation practices Island Councils / Local Government The most common elements of the community-based disaster involvement are partnership, participation, empowerment and ownership by the local people. Thus, it is the responsibility of the local government and/or island council to ensure there is an effective partnership in place, plus participation, empowerment and ownership by local people in their communities towards disaster reducing initiatives and programmes. Methods of Dissemination The methods of dissemination that can be utilized in the Community- Based Approach are varied and depend entirely on the needs of the community and the resources available on hand. As you go through this section, you may think of other methods more relevant or applicable for use in your community. This section focuses on the most common methods that can be utilized in almost any community. The use of audiovisuals is one method of creating awareness and education at the community-based level. Audiovisuals typically used in developing countries are print based because of the unavailability of more highly advanced technically based mediums of delivery (e.g. television or the internet). The Simple Hazard Map A common visual aid utilized in the Community Based Approach is the Simple Hazard Map. It is basically a map of the local community which points out safe escape routes and safe refuges as a guide to where people can run and where they can gather if there is a hazard event (Disaster! 94). Simple hazard maps generally map out areas of risk and lead to action to reduce risk in those areas. It enables people to take the correct escape routes and gather at safe places when disaster strikes. It helps save many lives, homes and belongings which would otherwise be lost in a disaster. Posters and Videos Posters and leaflets on natural, technical and manmade disasters and their impacts can be produced and distributed or put up on community notice boards. The production and viewing of videos on past disasters can also be shown to communities to highlight important issues in preparation for or in response to disaster Community Theatre (Drama) A different but exciting method used in the dissemination of information that you may have heard of is community theatre. The delight of theatre groups to dramatize disaster management awareness message is a medium that is very powerful. During the awareness meetings a mobile travelling theatre group or a local group can highlight the event with classical important messages. This is also a highly effective means of creating awareness in developing countries as the majority of people often have no access to newspapers and television. Local theatre groups therefore provide entertainment for the local community to which they belong and simultaneously present issues that directly affect the people as themes for their drama. Workshops Workshops are excellent examples of informal training provided to the community. A week long workshop facilitated by experts in disaster management for community leaders covers enough information, examples, activities and discussion to adequately prepare them in the event that disaster strikes. In this situation, the Education Officers, teachers and schools will be involved within their own structure. The Government Officers which includes education staff, in the divisions form teams to organize the workshops to the communities. You see then that the dissemination of knowledge and awareness to community leaders is in turn transferred to other members of the community. This is done by gathering all the members of the community at a communal meeting place The Community Based Action Plan Community leaders can also create Community Based Action Plans specific to their needs. This action plan incorporates the hazard map, mock exercises and other important methods, skills and information needed in preparation for a disaster. The implementation of a community-based action plan involves a long process. The following describes how a community-based action plan (referred to here as a ‘disaster management plan’) can be actively implemented Implementation Actions Through participatory planning a Disaster Management Plan can be formulated. In most cases it may include a few small scale activities whereas in other communities it may entail a comprehensive disaster management project. To oversee and monitor progress of implemented activities, there is a need for the establishment of a central management body. This body or organization will have numerous roles from planning, implementation, monitoring and review phases of planned activities Implementation Actions Such a body or organization may differ from country to country or community to community and may have different names but its roles and responsibilities are essentially the same. For the purpose of this course this central management body will be referred to as the Community Disaster Management Organization (CDMO) and its primary role is to ensure the planned activities are implemented on time within the given resources. The success of activities of the disaster management plan will depend on the successful operation of the CDMO and will include various tasks and processes e.g. tasking, mobilizing community resources, capacity building, monitoring and review and making necessary adjustments Tasking The CDMO should be responsible for setting up appropriate committees to implement the various necessary risk reduction measures such as risk communication, health, evacuation, early warning, agricultural etc. The CDMO should ensure that committees responsible for risk reduction measure are clear on the roles assigned to them and each has access to individuals and groups with necessary skills and expertise to implement the tasks assigned to them. To ensure that these activities can be carried out, the CDMO could mobilize the broader community and its resources. The CDMO should also assign at least one person to carry out each of the following roles Tasking Leadership role – have overall responsibility for activities of the committee Management role – ensure implementation of agreed activities Administrative role – assist in management Technical role – provides inputs Financial management role – provides proper accounting Social mobilization – to mobilize community resources Advantages and Disadvantages of the Community-Based Approach • As with any other approach, the community-based approach has its pros and cons. The following are some that you should be aware of: Advantages • The following are advantages of using the Community-Based Approach: i Ownership and Sustainability • The Community Based-Approach involves people and gives them a sense of ownership of the materials created or methods incorporated in education and public awareness. Through ownership comes sustainability. The projects used as tools at this level become ongoing projects that can then be modified whenever the need arises. Advantages ii Addresses the Immediate Needs of Communities The Community-Based Approach is targeted specifically at particular communities and it addresses their immediate needs. This is because at the community based level, immediate needs are better identified. iii User Friendly Information is presented in such a way that people can easily understand or relate to, for example, the use of the language that people in a community are most familiar with. Advantages iv Provides Knowledge and Skills Finally the Community Based Approach empowers or equips people with the necessary knowledge and skills to help themselves in the first seventy two (72) hours of a disaster. This is the most crucial time at the onset of a disaster when outside help is still on its way Disadvantages These are some of its disadvantages: i Fear Communities are sometimes reluctant to expose the vulnerabilities of their localities to outsiders. This is because they fear that they will lose potential investors in their communities, e.g. tourists. ii Lack of Resources At the community based level, the lack or unavailability of resources required to effectively carry out awareness is also a disadvantage. Without the necessary resources, people have to improvise with what limited resources they have and this not only makes it very difficult for them but also impacts on the quality of work they have produced Disadvantages iii Misleading Information When public awareness and education is not carried out properly at the community level, misleading information is disseminated to the rest of the community. This can lead to a chaotic situation and ultimately loss of lives at the onset of a disaster. iv Lack of Proper Training A further problem with this approach is also the fact that those utilizing the tools of the communicative approach may not have had proper training in what they are doing. This can also lead to distortion of information, thus misleading the rest of the community Disadvantages v Gender Bias Last but not the least, there is a tendency in many developing countries not to involve women and young people in the creation of the tools of the Community Based Approach due to religious and cultural influences. Observation shows that too often those involved in public awareness and education at the community based level are males (middle aged and older). There are certain needs of communities that are overlooked by males (middle aged and older) but easily identified by women or youth