Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dabbawallas in Chennai
By:
Archit Mehrotra(09BM8012)
Balaji Murali(09BM8015)
Divyan Kavdia(09BM8017)
Piyush Padgil(09BM8037)
Rohit Khandelwal (09BM8042)
Ajeet Singh Kharra(09BM8062)
Ved Pal(09BM8077)
ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE...........................................................................................9
ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES........................................................................................... 10
Dabbawaala‟s have long served as „Food line‟ of Mumbai. Can their model be
replicated elsewhere? Will such venture be successful and sustainable? We try to answer
these questions in this report. We have studied in detail if the dabbawaala can operate in
the city of Chennai. Chennai is a city which houses a broad range of industry and also
broad range of people. People with different gastronomical preferences. One canteen in a
company may not be able to serve to the needs of different people. Sure Dabbawaala‟s will
be a boon to the working class community in Chennai, But is this a feasible proposition?
Chennai has all of these, a good Local mass transit system, a huge demand for
Home cooked food served hot, and closely knit groups living in the slums of Chennai.
Through this report we have established that Chennai will be a very good place for the
dabbawaala‟s to expand and replicate the model followed in Mumbai.
The operation will begin in a phased manner. We would first start with highly dense
residential and commercial areas like avadi and ECR and then over a period of two or three
years expand our operations to cover the entire city of Chennai. The authors have also
attempted to develop a coding system for the dabbawaala‟s which will be useful in
collection, sorting and delivery of the tiffin boxes. The report also suggests pricing strategies
which will help in service penetration. Also the authors have explored peripheral business
that the dabbawaala‟s can do to augment their income.
The Dabbawalla business was founded by Mahadeo Havaji Bacche who inaugurated
“The Nutan Mumbai Tiffin Box Suppliers Trust” with a handful of illiterate employees (100
men) and without any capital investment for lunch delivery. "Tiffin" was a nostalgic term
used by British for "light food". However, people call them Dabbawallas as they carry a
"Dabba" meaning "box". Almost 5000 Dabbawallas deliver and collect more than 200,000
lunch boxes very day, across the entire Mumbai (India). Nowadays, Indian businessmen are
the main customers for the Dabbawallas, and the service often includes cooking as well as
delivery.
Though the work sounds simple, it is actually a highly specialized trade that is over
a century old and which has become integral to Mumbai's culture. The most interesting fact
is that these people do not use any modern technology, yet they have never failed to deliver
the lunch boxes on time - irrespective of weather, riots, floods, etc. – with an error
coefficient of one in 16,000,000 boxes. This is more than Six Sigma - a quality that most
businesses strive to achieve.
A study conducted by Six Sigma concludes that excellent efficiency and reliability is
achieved by the Dabbawallas through competitive collaboration with team members and
efficient management of logistics.
CHOICE OF CITY
Out of the given Option between 6 cities for launching Dabbawalla
1. Hyderabad
2. Chennai
3. Bangalore
4. Delhi
5. Kolkata
6. Pune
We did a detailed study on the Transport Systems and Food Habits of all the cities
and came up with following analysis:
Chennai is the capital city of the Indian state of Tamil Nadu. Chennai is the fourth
most populous metropolitan area and the fifth most populous city in India. Located on
the Coromandel Coast of the Bay of Bengal, Chennai city had a population of 4.34 million
in the 2001 census within the area administered by the Corporation of Chennai and an
extended Metropolitan Population of 6.5 million. The urban agglomeration of metropolitan
Chennai has an estimated population over 8.2 million people. The city is classified as
a Gamma+ World City.
Chennai's economy has a broad industrial base in the car, computer, technology,
hardware manufacturing, and healthcare industries. The city is India's second largest
exporter of software, information technology (IT) and information-technology-enabled
services (ITES). A major chunk of India's car manufacturing industry is based in and
around the city. Chennai Zone contributes 39 per cent of the State's GDP. Chennai
accounts for 60 per cent of the country's automotive exports.
Demographics - Chennai also has a large migrant population, who come from other
parts of Tamil Nadu and the rest of the country. As of 2001, out of the 937,000 migrants
(21.57% of its population) in the city, 74.5% were from other parts of the state, 23.8% were
from rest of India and 1.7% were from outside the country.
CHALLENGES
1. Issue in Recruitment: There could be some cultural Issues in recruitment of
Dabbawalas.
2. There could be problem in getting support from state government for using railways
as transportation mode
3. Issue of Trust: There could be scepticism in customers mind about
others(Dabbawalas) carrying their food
Raja Annamalaipuram
Mylapore
Egmore
Adyar and Besant Nagar
Velachery
Tiruvanmiyur
Anna Nagar
Chromepet
In the 1st Phase of launch of sevice, the following sub-urban railway stations are
being considered for various hub and spokes of the distribution system.
Tambaram
Chromepet
Guindy
Egmore
Velachery
Adyar
Besant Nagar
Thirumayilai
Thiruvanmiyur
Avadi
Ambatur
Villivakkam
Loco Works
Perambur
Thiruvottiyour
Nandiambakkam
Gummidipundi
Sullupetta
Akkampet
President
General Deputy
Directors Treasurer
Secretary President
Salahkar
The organization will be having a 3-tier structure with a Board of Directors, Team
Leads and Delivery Man. The basic operating unit is a team comprising of about 8 delivery
man headed by a team lead. A team lead is a person with enough experience as a delivery
man. A delivery man with about 6 years of experience and excellent service record will be
promoted as a team lead. The promotion will happen for the same service area in which the
team lead has been performing initially to allow him the time to settle in. After a couple of
years if need arises because of growth in, adding of new areas or need to accommodate rise
in rank of the junior delivery man to the post, the team lead can be transferred to another
area or another team in the same area. Five-Six teams usually servicing the same will form
a group and will appoint one group head from among the team leads of each team on a
rotating basis (2 years per person). The group head will report to the Directors of each zone
(4 zones).
The BOD will consist of 8 members which will be elected by the general body every
five years. The head of the BOD will be the president presiding over all the matters of the
Trust.
JOURNEY OF DABBAWALLA
CODING PROCESS
In order to conveniently handle large volume of dabba flow throughout the city, we have
come up with a unique yet simple mechanism of labeling the dabbas. The motivation
behind this technique is to ensure that the moderately skilled dabbawallas should not face
any difficulty in decoding it and also we have ensured that it has the level of detailing which
ascertains that in case of any attrition of dabbawallas, any new employee can easily fit into
the existing delivery system. This coding approach helps in getting rid of any drifting away
or errors in delivery.
We are presenting two cases of labeling which handles the two scenarios of intra-
route delivery and inter-route delivery. As we have already seen that the Suburban rail route
of Chennai is divided into four color routes viz. Red, Blue, Green and Yellow. This system is
distinctly separate from the Mumbai local system where the railway route is more or less
extended along a single stretch. So in coding we have taken care of the change of rail route.
For example let‟s take the case where a client (or say service
receiver) wants the dabba to be picked from VS Building, Floor 12.
This area lies close to the Station code 2R, implying that the area is
serviced by the Red line of suburban rail route. The destination for
the dabba is 5Y serviced by the Yellow line.
A denotes the dabbawallas code servicing the client pickup location
and B denotes the dabbawallas code for the delivery destination. JC is
the building where the dabba is to be delivered and 10 gives the floor
where to deliver it in JC building. 4R & 3Y stand for the station where
Daba Code 1
the source side sorting and destination side sorting will happen
respectively.
Daba Code 2
The intra-route delivery would not require our In-transit merge (located in Chennai central)
where all the necessary route changes will take place. Like, for Dabba Code 1, the route
change from red to yellow will take place at the In-transit merge.
PRICING STRATEGY
The Dabbawallas in Chennai should adopt ‘Variable Pricing Strategy’ in order to
serve the customers at various locations in Chennai.
The price has to be fixed between Rs. 150-300 per month. While deciding upon the
pricing strategies the following factors needs to be considered:
SALARY
Salaries of dabbawallas are fixed between Rs. 4000-5000 and varies only in terms of
whether a particular dabbawalla is in the period of internship or a permanent one and do
not depend upon the number of customers seved by the dabbawalla.
For example, if one dabbawalla service 40 customers
and one another one service
just 20 customers, then both will receive equal salaries
because of two factors – time and
location. Here, the dabbawalla collecting 40 tiffins may have collected all
of them from one
area itself ( like Chetpet and Mambalam ) in 30 minutes. Whereas, the other
dabbawalla
collecting 20 tiffins may have had to travel long distance covering a large area
in order to
collect his 20 tiffins in over an hour‟s time. Thus, it would be unfair to him if the
first
dabbawala is paid a higher amount.
The travelling passes in train costs around Rs. 60-200 per passenger per month and
the bus passes will cost around Rs. 75-150 per passenger per month and these are to be
born by the dabbawallas themselves.
1. The overall population of Chennai has been calculated for October 2010 by
extrapolating from a population of 4,353,000 on April 13th 2007 and a population of
4,616,639 on March 14th 2010.
2. The population of various residential hubs has been calculated on the basis of the
Area (sq km) of the location and the Population Density (persons per sq km).
3. The Working Male Population above 18 years in Chennai has been considered as
10% of Total Male Population calculated by using the Gender Ratio of 0.954.
Population Density
Area (sq km)
(persons per sq km)
Tambaram
Chromepet
22 583704
Guindy
Egmore
Velachery
Adyar
Thirumayilai
Thiruvanmiyur
BREAK-EVEN ANALYSIS
Assuming each
Dabbawala serves 30
Dabbawalas required customers 282
1. The people belong to low income group and strive for a better life and a secure
source of livelihood. Including them in the trust would provide them both these
attributes and hence their loyalty towards the cause will increase so the attrition will
go down providing a stable business and reduced costs.
2. Once people from these sections join the organization they will attract others from
their neighbourhood to take up the profession. The trust factor works in these
sections and once a person is employed others will come forward. Also the increase
in life quality of an employee and fellow slum dweller would attract others.
3. The sense of community feeling would help in establishing strong loyalty,
commitment, dedication and empathy for the job. Hence inculcating a culture of
discipline.
4. Once the wave sets in this will provide a pool of hardworking, dedicated and loyal
workforce eager to join hands. This will reduce the cost of hiring and trustworthy
people would be hired.
5. Positive publicity in way of improving the lives of slum dwellers. The media coverage
would ensure more business.
CONS:
The people usually live in unhygienic conditions and carry the same impression
regarding their personal hygiene. Also many sections of workforce like Tamil Brahmins and
very orthodox in their thinking and would not want to avail service from such people. The
best way to insure against this will be to have an outreach program to prospective
customers alleviating their fears and concerns. The dabbawalas would be required to dress
in traditional kurta-lungi (yellow) which should be properly clean and the trademark
Gandhian cap. Fine would be imposed on any person found violating this practice.
1. The people from slums usually have drinking problems and are unwilling to put in
efforts having got used to the life. This may hinder their output. To take care of this
TRAINING PROGRAM
The new recruit would go under an apprenticeship for 1 year on a fixed
remuneration basis. After the successful completion of the training the apprentice is
required to pay a price in ratio of 1:7 (8 being the number of dabbawalas serving a locality)
for operating rights in the locality. The money would be used as a security deposit to be
returned to the dabbawalas at their retirement (65 yrs). The money would be kept in a fixed
deposit that can be used by the dabbawalas to get loan against for some exigencies. Also
upon death the money would be given to the beneficiary. The dabbawalas henceforth would
have a permanent job and a monthly income revised from time to time.
The same setup could also be used for nearby businessmen and shopkeepers for
whom tiffin can be collected and supplied at their shops.