You are on page 1of 5

The vertical screw conveyor-

powder properties and Screw conveyor design


Alma Kurjak
Department of Chemical Engineering, Lund Institute of Technology,
P.O. Box 124, SE-221 00 Lund, Sweden January 2005

1 Abstract
This Master Thesis is a study of how powder properties and screw conveyor design influence the flow
properties of a vertical screw conveyor. Studies show that different powder properties like particle
size, bulk density and particle shape have a large influence on screw capacity. Coarse powders will
flow into the screw easier than fine powders. The screw capacity will also be higher if a dense powder
is used. Particle with a round shape have lower internal friction that results in a greater screw
capacity. It was also shown that the Hausner ratio, assessed from tapped and apparent density and
angle of repose are effective methods to determine the free-flowing properties of the powder. Studies
also show that the clearance and the free length of the intake have a big influence on screw capacity.
No correlation between conveying length and conveyor capacity was found.

Key words: vertical screw conveyor; powder properties; Hausner ratio; iron powders; flowability;
screw design;

cohesive than course particles. Particles larger


2 Introduction than 250 µm are usually relatively free
Different mixers can be uses for flowing, but as size falls below 100 µm
homogenisation of powders. One of them is the powder become cohesive and flow problems
Orbiting screw mixer. Orbiting screw mixers are likely to occur.
work excellent and the only disadvantage is
that they are expensive. One cheaper
alternative is a centre screw mixer. It consists Powders having a particle size less than 10 µm
of a conical vessel and a screw that is are usually extremely cohesive. [1]
surrounding by a tube. The products to be
mixed are conveyed upwards by the screw 3.2 Bulk density
positioned in a central mounted guiding pipe. Because powders normally flow under the
The combination of the rotating screw and influence of gravity, dense powders are
conical vessel results in an efficient mixing. generally less cohesive than less dense
powders. [1]
The aim of this thesis was to identify different
powder properties and screw design that 3.3 Particle shape
influences the flow properties of the vertical Particle shape has a large influence on flow
screw conveyor. properties. A group of spheres has minimum
interparticle contact and generally optimal
3 Theory flow properties, whereas a group of flakes have
Different powder properties can be used to a very high surface-to-volume ratio and poorer
identify if powder is free flowing or not. flow properties. [1]

3.1 Particle size


Particle size has influence on flowability of a
powder. In general, fine particles with very
high surface to volume ratios are more

1
3.4 Hausner ratio Table 2 Properties of some different iron
powders
The Hausner ratio is a measure of how
compressible a powder is in relation to bulk AD Flow
density. It is derived from the quotient between Powder
(g/cm3) (s/50g)
tapped density (TD) and apparent density (AD)
Fe6.8Si 4.3 15
TD
Hausner ratio = ASC100.29 3.0 25
AD NC100.24 2.4 31
Values less then 1.25 indicate good flow AT40.29 3.1 29
whereas values greater than 1.25 indicate poor W40.24 2.5 38
flow. [1] SC100.26 2.7 30
MH300.29 2.9 27
3.5 Angle of repose
ASC300 2.9 25
The angle of repose given in table 2 may be
used as a guide to flow performance. [1]
Table 1 Angle of repose as an indication of 4.2 Apparatus
powder flow properties
The measurements were performed with three
ANGLE OF TYPE OF different screws. The first screw was used for
RESPONSE FLOW preliminary studies; just to see how screws
< 20 Excellent work. With the second screw almost all
20 – 30 Good experiments were done. The third screw was
30-34 Passable used to see if the results will be the same if a
bigger screw conveyor is used, see figure 1.
> 40 Very poor

4 Materials

4.1 Powder
Höganäs AB produces two different kinds of
ferrous powders:
• sponge-iron powders, and
• water-atomized (unalloyed and low-
alloyed) iron powders
The external shapes of both particles are
irregular and similar to one another. However,
the sponge iron particle has as its name
suggests a spongy internal structure and water- Figure 1 Vertical screw conveyor
atomized is internally compact.
In the Belgium plant, gas-atomized powders 5 Methods
with almost perfect round shape are produced.
In this work, nine different iron powders were 5.1 Methods to characterize powder
used:
5.2 Size measurement
Sponge-iron powder: NC100.24, W40.24,
MH300.29, SC100.29 and M1000 To determine particle size, laser diffraction,
Sympatec HELOS was used.
Water-atomised iron powder: AT40.29,
ASC100.29 and ASC300.29 5.3 Bulk Density (Apparent density)
Gas-atomized iron powder: Fe6.8Si Bulk density was determined by filling the
In table 1, apparent density and flow of powder through a standardized funnel into a
different iron powder are present. [2] small cup, levelling-off the surplus powder on
top of the cup and dividing the weight of
powder contained in the cup by the cup volume
(25 cm3). [2]

2
5.4 Particle Shape 5.11 Conveying length
To determine the shape of different iron Tubes with different lengths but the same free
powders, electron microscope pictures were length of intake were used to see which
used. influence the conveying length has on screw
capacity
5.5 Hausner Ratio
The Hausner ratio is derived from the quotient 6 Results and discussion
between tapped density (TD) and apparent
density (AD). Tapped density was measured 6.1 Powder properties
using Stamp volume meter. Figure 4, shows how mass flow depends on
screw velocity for different powders.
5.6 Angle of repose 2000
AS C 100.29
For measuring the drained angle of repose was
NC 100.24
used, se figure 2.
1500 W40.24

Mass flow (g/s)


AS C 300

1000 AT40.29

M 1000

M H300.29
500
Figure 2 Measurement of drained angle of S C 100.26

repose F e .6.8S i
0
3 6 9 12
5.7 Flow Velocity (rev/s)
Flow rate is the time in seconds, which an
amount of 50 g dry powder needs to pass the Figure 4 Mass flow for some different iron
powder
aperture of standardised funnel se figure 3.
6.2 Size
The screw capacity is greater for coarse
powders than for fine due to the differences in
flowability.
Fine particles have large specific surface area
and are more cohesive than coarse particles. If
the powder is more cohesive, it is not free
flowing. A coarse powder will be more free
Figure 3 Aperture for measurement of flowing than a finer powder and will thus flow
Flow and AD more easily into the screw.

5.8 Methods to characterize screw 6.3 Aerated bulk density


conveyor design Bulk density is one important parameter for
screw capacity since the screw has a fixed
5.9 Clearance volume. The higher the bulk density of a
Tubes with different diameters were used to powder the more mass of the powder can be
see which influence the clearance has on screw introduced into the screw. It means that
capacity. powders with o large bulk density will have a
largest screw capacity than obtained with
5.10 The free length of intake powders with a low bulk density.
Tubes with different lengths were used to see
6.4 Particle Shape
which influence the free length has on screw
capacity. If the shape of a particle is known then
conclusions can be made of internal friction of
the powder. In the following list powder with
high internal friction is given first; MH300.29
> ASC300 > ASC100.29 > NC100.24 >

3
AT40.29 > SC100.26 > W40.24 > M1000 > 6.8 Screw conveyor design
Fe6.8Si. This comparation is made on the
particle shape appearanced from SEM picture. 6.9 Clearance
A group of spheres has low internal friction At a large clearance a back flow of bulk
whereas a group of flakes has higher internal material opposite to the conveying direction
friction. Compared to powders with lower occurs followed by reduction in conveyor
internal friction, powders with higher internal capacity, see figure 5. However, if clearance is
friction flow into the intake area of the screw small milling and jamming can take place
conveyor with lower velocity. It implies that between screw and casing. Clearance is also
use of powders with low internal friction necessary for smooth running of the conveyor.
(round powder-Fe6,8Si) will result in greater Therefore, it is important to find the smallest
screw capacity than obtained with powders clearance at which no milling and jamming
with higher internal friction. process takes place.
4000
6.5 Hausner Ratio 60 Hz
Iron powders have different Hausner Ratios, 70 Hz
see table 3. Free flowing powders are less 3000

Mass flow (g/s)


80 Hz
cohesive and have Hausner Ratio close to 1
while less free flowing powder have Hausner 2000
Ratio > 1.25. If a powder is free flowing, it
will easier flow into the screw. Use of free-
flowing powders will result in a greater screw 1000
capacity than obtained with not free-flowing
powders
0
Table 3 Hausner Ratio and angle of repose for 2 4 6 8 10 12
different iron powders Clearance (mm)
PULVER HAUSNER ANGLE OF Figure 5 Mass flow for ASC100.29 at difference
RATIO REPOSE ° clearance
Fe6.8Si 1.10 25.8
M1000 1.10 33.4 6.10 The free length of intake
ASC100.29 1.27 34.6 At a very low speed, it is enough to have a
W40.24 1.12 34.9 short free length of intake to obtain maximum
NC100.24 1.26 35.3 output, se figure 6. As speed increases, the
AT40.29 1.17 36.0 vortex formed in the screw limits the amount
SC100.26 1.27 - of powder that can enter the screw. To
MH300.29 1.28 47.2 compensate for this, a larger free length of
ASC300 1.34 48.2 intake is necessary at higher speed to obtain
maximum output.
1000
6.6 Angle of repose I = 6 cm
900
Iron powders have different angels of repose, I = 12.5 cm
see table 3. A comparison between angle of 800
Mass flow ASC100.29 (g/s)

I = 17.5 cm
repose and screw capacity, figure 4, for 700
different iron powders shows that powders 600
with low angle of repose get a higher screw 500
capacity than powders with a high angle of
400
repose. It was expected because powders with
300
a low angle of repose flow more easily into the
screw. 200

100
6.7 Flow 0
No correlation between flow and screw 3 5 7 9 11
Velocity (rev/s)
capacity was found. It seems as if this method
is not sufficient to describe screw capacity. Figure 6 Mass flow at different length of intake

4
6.11 Conveying length 9 Reference
It is difficult to say which influence conveying [1] Aulton Michael E.:
length has on the conveyor capacity. It seems Pharmaceutics The Science of Dosage
as if there is no correlation between conveying Form Design p.197-210 and 133-135
length and conveyor capacity, see figure 7. [2] http://www.diegm.uniud.it/fmiani/PMS
Probably conveying length has no influence on CHOOL/CHAPT03.PDF
the capacity. Perhaps, the arrangement used in
this work was not big enough to see any
differences.
700 Conveyor lenght 28.5 cm
Conveyor lenght 33.5 cm
Mass flow ASC100.29 g/s

600
Conveyor length 40 cm
500

400

300

200

100
3 5 7 9 11
Velocity (rev/s)

Figure 7 Mass flow at different conveying


lengths

7 Conclusions
Powders with coarse particles will flow into a
screw easer than powder with fine particles.
This results in a greater mass flow. The screw
capacity will also be higher if dense powder is
used. Round powder, have lower internal
friction that results in a greater screw capacity.

Hausner Ratio and angle of repose are most


likely efficient methods to measure if powder
is free flowing or not.

The clearance and the free length of intake


have a large influence on screw capacity. No
correlation was found between conveying
length and conveyor capacity.

8 Acknowledgments
Special thanks to my supervisors Ingrid Eriksson
at Höganäs AB and Anders Axelsson at the
Department of Chemical Engineering, Lund
Institute of Technology for guiding me through
the whole work during my Master thesis.
I would also like to thank all at Höganäs AB
for useful help and advice on various
problems.

You might also like