II

1:

MaTepHaJIbI, npeztocraanennsre no sanpocy CYJeTHOM nanarsr POCCHMCKOM <I>e,n;epaI(HH OT 09 HIOIDI 2008 r. NQ 311-11-03-69/11-03

~

(

~ ).:1

..

Ii

I

3AllPOC C"llETHOH llAJIATbI POCCHHCKOH fl>E)J;EPAn;HH o llPE,lJ;OCTABJIEHHH HHfl>OPMAn;HH

YJI. 3y6oBcKan, /1.. 2, I'Cll-z, Mocxaa, 119992 TeJI.: (495) 986-05-09, WaKe: 986-09-52

Ilpezrcenaremo npasneaaa, npesnnenry OAO «AK «Tpaacrredm,»

n.n. TOKapeBY

~OHTPOJlb I

Y Ba)J<aeM1IH HHKoJIall Ilerponn-r!

B ,n;onOJIHeHHe K paaee aarrpaaneaasnr B BaIII azrpec sanpocaxr CIfeTHoH nanarsr POCCHllCKOll <Pe,n:epaU;MM H na OCHOBaHMH nonyaenaoii B pa60"IIeM nopaznce MH<!JopMaU;MM OT OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrn,» npoIIIY npencraarrrs B CpOK ,n;o 1 HJOn51 2008 rona rpyrrne JIHCneKTopOB CrIeTHOll nanarsi ,n;OKYMeHTbI H KOMMeHTapMM (nozrrsepacaaronrae nepmrrasre ,n:OKYMeHTbI H aHanMTMLfeCKMe MaTepHanlI, oneao-rasre aKTbI KOMrraHHM) no CJIe,n;YIDID;MM rrp06JIeMHbIM aonpocaa:

1. 06ocHoBaHHocT1 npoaaseneaasrx sarpar na npoexraposanae

rpytionpoaozmof CHCTeM11 «BocToIfHM CH6HP1 - THXHH OKeaR» (zranee - TC «BCTO» ).

2. Ofiocnonaaaocrs npoexrasix penrenaji H CMeTH1IX pacseros.

3. C06JIID,n:emre YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX HOPM, npaBHJI H nopaznca rrponezrenaa ToproB o B1160py noztpaaasrx H npoexrasrx opraHH3aL(HH, nOCTaBIIJ;HKOB ofiopyztoaanaa JI51 peaJIH3aU;HH npoexra cTpOHTeJI1CTBa ofisexron TC «BCTO», ofiocnonannocrs PHH5fTbIX na xonxypcax peIIIeHHH.

4. <PHHaHcoBa51 H npOH3Bo,n:CTBeHHa5I COCT05ITeJIbHOCTb opraHH3aL(HH,

pH3HaHHbIX [106e,n:HTeJI5IMH 'ropron,

~

l \

~

I )

~

~.

I .

I

~.

/. ~i

t-!

I "

t

\ I

~.

Ir'

I '

1\

2

cy6IIO,n:P5I,IJ;HhIX opranasanna.

5. Ofiocnonannocrs OnJIaThI cYpo11TeJIhHO-MOHTa)KHhIX pafior.

6. Ofiocaosaaaocrs sarpar aa 3aKynK11 MaTep11aJIhHO-TeXH11trecK11X pecypcos ,n;anee - MTP) , COOTBeTCTBI1e CT011MOCT11 MTP PhIHOIfHhIM nenan, ,n;y6JI11pOBaH11e (3a,I(BOeH11e) rrOCTaBOK MTP co CTOPOHhI 3aKa3trI1Ka 11 nonparrnncoa, 06ocHoBaHHocTh Kpe.n;I1TOBaHI15I rrOCTaBIaI1KOB rrocpe,n:CTBOM p83Hoca CPOKOB npenonnaru 11 <paKT11Qecl<OH rrOCTaBKI1, ofiocaonanaocn, JII13I1HrOBhlX cxev 11

norosopos.

7. KOHYpaKThI, aKThI, orsernsre, nnareaorue 11 mrsre .n;oKYMeHThI OAO «BHl1.I1CT» no BhIIIOJIHeHI1IO rrpoexrasrx 11 CTpOI1TeJIhHhIX pa60T no TC «BeTO», scex rennozrpannsrx opraH113alJ,I1H, a TaK)Ke OpraHI13an;I1l1, ocy.r.u:ecTBJI5IIOllJ,I1X aBTOpCKI1H 11 TeXHI1treCK11H Ha,l:I;30p.

8. I1HCPOPMaD,I1lD 0 npI1QI1HaX (06CT05ITeJIhCTBax), nOBJIeKlII11X Heo6xo.n:11MOCTh 3aKJIIOIfeHI15I p;OrrOJIHI1TeJIhHhIX COrJIalIIeHI1H K CJIe.n;yIOllJ,I1M KOHYpaKTaM na

BhIITOJIHeHHe:

a) cTp011TeJIhHO-MOHTa)KHhIX pafior:

- OT 28.12.2006 r. NQ 332-07, OT 06.03.2007 r. N2 447-07, OT 20.04.2007 r. NQ 545-07, OT 11.04.2007 r. NQ 579-07, OT 29.06.2007 r. NQ 602-07 - B QaCT11

YBeJI11QeHi15I CPOKOB 3aBepIlleHI15I pafior;

- OT 01.02.2007 r. N2 406-07, OT 06.03.2007 r. NQ 447-07, OT 20.04.2007 r. N2 545-07, OT 11.07.2007 r. N2 631-07 - B QaCT11 nOBhIlIIeHI15I CTOI1MOCTI1 pafior;

6) npoexrao- H3.bICKaTeJIhCKI1e pafiorsr:

- OT 29.08.2006 r. NQ MK 0855/7/UYTIl111106/227-06 - B IfaCTH nOBhIIlleHI15I

CT0I1MOCT11 pafior;

- OT 23.06.2006 r. N2 P 0855/2IWITIl111061165-06- B IfaCTI1 nOBhIIlleHHJI

CTOI1MOCTI1 pa60T;

B) TeXHI1IfeCK11H Ha,[(30p:

- OT 26.04.2006 r. N2 145-I1YTH 2006/124-06 - B QaCTI1 nOBhIIlleHHJI

CT0I1MOCT11 pacer.

9. I1HcpopMaI(mO 06 onnare zrorosopon noztpaaa na BhIllOJIHeHHe npoexrao-

lJ

I .

I i

~

..

~

I ..

3

H3hICKaTeJIbCKl1X pa60T no 06'beKTY: «Hedrrerrposon I-illC «CKOBOP0,Il,IIHO» - )l{eJIe3HO,Il,OpO:tKHbIH KOMnJIeKC nepeaanxa aerprn» OT 29.12.2006 r. N2 0247/WTIl370 H no 06'beKTY: «AEK 000 «Bocroxaedrrenposozo B r, Eparcxe» OT 07.02.2007 r. NQ 0251/L(YI1/409 (c npHJIO)ICeHl1eM YKa3aHHbIX noronopos (,n:onOJIHHTeJIhHbIX COrJIaIIIeHHH), aKTOB 0 npHH5ITHH BhITIOJIHeHHhlX pafior, nJIaTe)l{HhIX ,n:OKYMeHTOB, peIIIeHHH 0 paCTOp)ICeHHH ,Il,orOBopoB).

10. ,IJ,OIcYMeHT1I, CO,Il,ep:tKaIIJ;l1e OCHOBaHH5I (pemenaa ,Il,OJI)KHOCTH1IX JIHIJ;) 0 Heo6xo,Il,HMOCTH 3aKJIIOLIeHH5I CJIe,nYIOIIJ;Hx ,IJ;OrOBOpoB (KoHTpaKToB) 6e3 npOBe,n:eHH5I nO,IJ;p5I,Il,HhIX ropros (KOHKypCOB):

a) cTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa)l{Hble pafiorsr:

- OT 28.04.2006 r. N2 123-06, OT 27.12.2006 r. N2 330-06, OT 28.12.2006 r. N2 332-06 H OT 11.04.2007 r. N2 579-07, OT 27.12.2006 r. N2 329-06, OT 14.03.2007 r. N2 465-07 II OT 20.04.2007 r. N2 545-07;

6) nocTaBKaMTP:

- OT 10 anpena 2006 r. N2 076-06, OT 17 anpeJI5I 2006 r. N23548/2006/125-06, OT 15 HIOH5I 2006 r. N2 2006005241179-06, OT 23 IIIOH5I 2006 r, N2 31-09/06/187-06, OT 26 IIIOH5I 2006 r. N~ 192-06, OT 7 HIOJI.sr 2006 r, N2 32-023-04521177-06 II N2 44- 685-2006/178-06, OT 17 HIOJI5I 2006 r. N2 190-06 H OT 10 Ma5I 2007 r. N2 04-05- 1093/594-07 ;

B) roPH,IJ;If1:IeCKOe O<popMneHHe 3eMJl~OTBo,n:a: - OT 08.11.2005 r. N22633/2005/681-07.

11. I1HcpopMan;mo 0 npHLIHHax (06CT05ITenhcTBax), npIIBe,Il,IIIIIX K H3MeHeHHIO (noHH)l{eHIIIO) KOHTpaKTHoH ueasr no ztoronopav, pacroprayrsra C 3AO «KpacHo,n:apcTpoiiTpaHCra3», H BHOBh 3aKJIIOLIeHHbIM BMeCTO pacroprnyrsrx,

PYKOBO,Il,HTen1 KOHTpOJI1HOrO MepOnpH5ITM5I - lJIaBHbIH nncnexrop

A.C.AneKcaH)J;pOBIILI

T.H.EoraThlpeB 986-03-54

r.MOCKBa

17.1 0.2008

11. \";\

(

OTqeT 0 BhIllOJIHeHHH MeponpHRTHii no cfiopy H nO,l1;rOTOBKe ,l1;OKYMeHTOB H HHcflopMaqHH ,l1;JIR Cnernoii nana'rsr P<P

(no nepBOMY BOnpOCY Ilepesaa MeponpIUITHH no cfiopy H rroztrorosxe ,n:OKYMeHTOB H HHcpopMaU;HH ,n:JUI c-qeTHOH rranarsi P<I»

i, :

1 I(eJIh nposepxa

Y CTaHOBJIeHHe 06ocHoBaHHocTH rrpOH3Be,n;eHHbIX 3 arp ar na

npoexraposaaae TC «BCTO», B r.n.:

1.1. Ilposepxa 06ocHoBaHHocTH rrpHBJIe-qeHH5I OAO BHMI1CT B xa-recrae rea. rrpoeKTHpoBIIJ;HKa;

1.2. KaKHM 06pa30M 6bIJIa onpeneneaa rrena ,n:oroBopa aa npoexrnponaaae, npaaouepaocrs H ofiocnosanaocrs 3THX ,n:eHcTBHH;

1.3. AHaJIH3 CTPYKTYP:bI sarpar na rrpoexraposamre TC "BCTO":

1.3.1 na COCTaB npenycsrorpeaasrx T3 H cpaKTH-qecKH B:bIrrOJIHeHHbIX pa60T

(c YKa3aHHeM COOTBeTCTBH5I TeXHH-qeCKOMY 3a,n;aHHIO); 1.3.2 na npmreneaae pacrreaox aa npoexraposaaae; 1.4. C60p H aHaJIH3 HHcpopMaU;HH:

1.4.1 na npenxer HCrrOJIb30BaHH5I panee paspacoraaasrx npoexrnsrx ,n;OKYMeHTOB H MaTepHaJIOB;

1.4.2 aa npezcrer cpaKTH-qecKoro BbIIIOJIHeHH5I npenycsrorpeaasrx T3, KOHTpaKToM H HopMaTHBHbIMH ,n:OKYMeHTaMH npoexrasrx pafior;

1.4.3 B paspese rrpHBJIe-qeHHbIX cyfirrozrpaznrsrx npoexrnsrx opraaasauaa C YKa3aHIieM 06.beMa11 CTOHMOCTH BbIIIOJIHeHHblX HM11 pa60T B COOTHonreHHH C 06:rn;HM11 sarparana no reanoztpanaosry ztoroaopy;

1.5. AHaJI113 nOJIHOTbI 11 zrocroaepuocra OT-qeTHblX ,n:OKYMeHTOB C To-qrn 3peHH5I 11X rrOJIHOTbI, 06ocHoBaHHocTH H cBoeBpeMeHHOCT11 nponsaezreamax BbIIIJIaT;

1.6. BbI5IBJIeHHe II aHaJIH3 rpaxros H 06CT05ITeJIbCTB, npH-qllHHBIlIHX spezt aarepecav KOMrraHHH.

2 Cocraa pa60qeii rpynnsr

Iloaosrapea II.H. - Ha-qaJIbHHK KAO cpHJI11ana 000 «Tpancnedm, <P11HaHC» B r. TOMcKe;

1

,/~-'P

r

I

( ;

E3epCKa5I H.H. HaqaJIbHI1K OT,n; eJI a zioronopon

OAO «Fnnporpytionpoaon»;

TI1TOBa M.K. 3aMeCTI1TeJIb HaqaJIbHIIKa OT,n;eJIa OAO

«I'nnporpytionpoaon» ;

I'opes B.r. - 3aMeCTI1TeJIb HaqanbHHKa Jlpaaosoro ynpaBJIeHWI - HaqaJIbHI1K IOpI1,n;I1qeCKOrO OT,n;eJIa OAO «AK «TpaHCHe<pTE.»;

,lJ;eMH,n;OB TI.B. rJIaBHbIH IOPHCKOHCYJIbT IOpI1,n;I1qeCKOrO OT,n;eJIa

Ilpaaosoro ynpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacrredrrs»;

PYCJI5IKOB H.M. - 3aMeCTI1TeJIb ,n;I1peKTOpa nenapranerrra «CJIY)K6a 6e30IIaCHOCTH» - HaqaJIbHI1K OT,n;eJIa 3KOHOMI1qeCKOH 6e30naCHOCTI1 OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» ;

)KaBopoHKOB <p.E. - rJIaBHbIH cneI(I1aJII1CT OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30naCHOCTI1 OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrn,»;

TepeXOB ,lJ;.A. - 3aMeCTHTeJIb HaqaJIbHI1Ka OT,n;eJIa CTpaTerI1qeCKOrO pa3BI1TI15I OAO «AK «Tpaacacdrrs»;

I03e<poBHQ A.B. - 3aMeCTI1TeJIb HaQanbHI1Ka OT,n;eJIa HayqHO-TeXHI1QeCKOrO o6eCneQeHI15I I1 HopMaTHBHoH ,n;oKYMeHTaI(I1I1 OAO «AK «Tparrcaedrrs».

I:

I

( \

3 Pe3YJIhTaThI uposepxa

Pa60QeH rpyrmoii nposezteaa paoora no rrposepxe ,n;OKYMeHTaI(I1I1 H ,n;aHHbIX no rrpOeKTI1pOBaHI1IO 06'beKTOB «Tpyoonposozraaa CHCTeMa BocToQHa5I CI16HPb - TmcHH OKeaH (BCTO). TIepBbIH nycxonoa KOMIIJIeKC» H «Pacnmpenae Tpy6onpOBO,n;HOH CHCTeMbI BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaR (BCTO)>> B COOTBeTCTBHH C PaCIIOp5I)l<:eHHeM OAO «AK «Tpancnedm,» N2 22 OT 12.08.2008 H «TIepeQHeM MepOrrpH5ITHH no cfiopy H nozrrorosxe ,n;OKYMeHTOB H HH<popMaI(HH ,n:lliI CQeTHOH nanarsr POCCI1HCKOH <Pe,n;epaI(HH», YTBep)l(,n:eHHbIM npesnzrenroa OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» 23.07 .2008r.

reHepaJIbHbIM no,n;p5I,n;QHKOM no rrpoeKTHpoBaHFaO 06'beKTOB

«Tpyfionposozraaa CHCTeMa BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXllH OKeaH. Hepssra nycxosoa KOMrrJIeKC» H «Pacmnpeaae Tpy6orrpoBo,n;HOH CHCTeMbI BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)>> 5IBJI5IJIC5I OAO BHHI1CT. B paspafiorxe

pa60QeH ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HH npHHHMaJIH YQaCTHe npoexrnsre HHCTHTYTbI:

OAO «I'anporpyoonposon», <pHJIHaJI OAO «I'anporpyoorrpoaozr»

«Caaaparanporpyoonposon», <pHJIHaJI OAO «I'anporpyfionpoaozt»

«Yrparanporpyfionpoaozt», OAO «l1HCTHTYT «Hedrrerasrrpoexr», 3AO «HI1ITI1 «I1H)l(reo», 3AO «Ill1PC», 000 «CB5I3bKOMnJIeKc» H zrpyrae.

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM rrposenenm,rx MepOnpH5ITHH COCTaBJIeHbI I1 rrozmacaasr KOMIIeTeHTHbIMM axcrrepraxrn COOTBeTCTBYIOII(He npOTOKOJIbI, CnpaBKI1 H aKTbI KOMHCCHOHHbIX nposepox, rrpasezreansre B rrpHJIO)l(eHH5IX HaCT05III(erO OTQeTa.

~

I '

(

3.106ocHoBaHHocTb IIpHBJIeQeHH5I OAO BHHHCT B KaQeCTBe

reHepaJIbHOrO no.n;p5I,n;QHKa Ha npOBeneHHe rrpoeKTHO-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T H aBTopCKoro Ha,r!;30pa npH npoeKTHpOBaHHH Tpy6onpOBO.l!HOH CHCTeMbI «BoCTOQHa5I CI16HPb - THXHH OKeaH»

~ •. 1-,

I i

In

I

OAO BHI1MCT H33HaLJeH rOJIOBHhIM l1H)KeHepHhIM IJ;eHTpOM

OAO «AK «Tpaacnedrrs» B COOTBeTCTBl1l1 C npl1K330M OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprr,» N2 73 OT 21.08.2003 r. «0 nepezia-re CPYH~l1M OAO BHJ1I1CT».

29.08.2003 rozra Me)K,n;y OAO «AK «Tpancneqrrs» H OAO BI-:II111CT 3aKJIIOIfeH zroronop renepam.aoro nozrpsna N2 336114/03 na BhIDOJIHeHHe npoeKTHo-H3hICKaTeJIhCKl1X pa60T H asropcxoro nazrsopa.

Ha MOMeHT noznmcanaa npHK33 a N273 OT 21.08.2003 rona H BhIlIIeYK33aHHoro zrorosopa 3aKOHo,n;aTeJIhCTBOM P<!> He 6hIJIO YCTaHOBJIeHO orpaaaseaaii (nponeneaae KOHKypCOB) no BhI60py opraHH3aIJ;HM ,n;JI5I npoexraoH3hICKaTeJIhCKHX, HaytIHo-HCCJIe,n;OBaTeJIhCKHX H onhITHO-KOHCTPYKTOPCKHX pa60T ,n;JI5I Hy)l(~ OAO «AK «Tpancaeqrrs».

,L(eiIcTByIO~HM cpe,n;epaJIhHhIM 3aKOHo,n;aTeJIhCTBOM POCCHMCKOH <!>e,n;epaU;HH npezrycnorpeno ,n;Ba CJIYIfmI, xorna ,n;JI5I cy6'heKTOB eCTeCTBeHHhIX MOHOnOJIHM, K KOTOPhIM OTHOCHTC5I OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrs», HMnepaTHBHO BMeHeHO B 065I3aHHOCTh nposoznrn, OTKPhIThIH KOHKYpC ,n;JI5I BhI60pa KOHTpareHTOB ,n;JI5I 3aKynKH npozrymraa HJIH OK33aHH5I ycnyr:

1) 3aKoHoM POCCHHCKOH <!>e,n;epaIJ;HH OT 26.07.2006 N2 135-<!>3 "0 3a~HTe KOHKypeHIJ;HH", BCTynHBlIIeM B CHJIY C 26.l0.06r., COrJIaCHO CTaThH 13 xoroporo cyfit.exran eCTeCTBeHHhlX MOHOnOJIHH (non yrposoa B03MO)KHOCTH npH3HaHH5I c,n;eJIKH He,n;eHcTBHTeJIhHoH) BMeHeHO B 065I3aHHOCTh ocy~eCTBJI5ITh orfiop cpHHaHcoBhIX opraHH3aU;HH nYTeM nposezteaaa OTKphITOrO xonxypca HJIH OTKphITOrO ayKIJ;HOHa B COOTBeTCTBHH C nOJIO)KeHH5IMH <pe,n;epaJIhHOrO 3aKOHa 0 pa3Me~eHHH 3aKa30B na nOCTaBKH TOBapOB, BhlnOJIHeHHe pafior, OKa3aHHe ycnyr ,n;JI5I rocynapcrseaasrx H MYHHIJ;HDaJIhHhIX HY)K,n; ,n;JI5I OK33aHH5I CJIe,n;yIOID;HX <pHHaHcoBhIX ycnyr:

- npHBJIeLJeHHe ,n;eHe)J(HhIX cpeztcrs IOpH,n;HLJeCKHX JIHIJ; BO BKJIa,n;hI;

- OTKphITHe H sezieaae 6aHKoBcKHX CLJeTOB IOpH,n;HLJeCKHX JIHIJ;,

ocy~eCTBJIeHHe paCLJeTOB no 3THM CLJeTaM; - npe,n;ocTaBJIeHHe Kpe,n;HTa;

- HHKaccau;H5I ,n;eHe)KHhIX cpezrcrs, sexcerreii, nJIaTe)KHhIX H paCLJeTHhIX

,n;OKYMeHTOB H KaCCOBoe 06CJIY)J(HBaHHe ropH,n;HLJeCKHX JIHU;; - BhI,n;aLJa 6aHKoBcKHX rapaarnn;

- ycnyrn na psmxe u;eHHhIX 6YMar;

- yCJIyrH no ,n;oroBopy JIH3HHra;

- cTpaxoBaHHe HMy~ecTBa;

- JIHIf:HOe crpaxosanae, B TOM LJHCJIe Me,n;HIJ;HHCKoe CTpaXOBaHHe;

- Herocy,n;apCTBeHHoe neHCHOHHoe CTpaXOBaHHe;

- CTpaXOBaHHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH.

2) B COOTBeTCTBHH C LJ. 2 CTaThH 7 <!>e,n;epaJIhHOrO 3aKOHa OT 07.08.2001 N2119-<D3 "06 ay,n;HTopCKOH ,n;e5ITeJIhHOCTH" npn nposezreaaa 065I3aTeJIhHOrO ayznrra B opraHH3aIJ;H5IX, B YCTaBHhIX (cKJIa,n;OLJHhIx) KanHTaJIaX KOTOPhIX ,n;OJI5I rocyzrapcrsenaoa co6CTBeHHOCTH HJIl1 co6cTBeHHocTH cytisexra POCCHHCKOH <De,n;epaU;HH COCTaBJI5IeT He xreaee 25 npOIJ;eHTOB, 3aKJIIOLJeHHe ziorosopoa OKa3aHH5I ay,n;HTopCKHX ycrryr ,n;OJI)J(HO ocyru;eCTBJI5IThC5I no rrroran pasaemeaaa saxasa na OK33aHHe TaKHX ycnyr B nopsznce, npezrycxsorpennov <De,n;epaJIhHhIM

, .• ] .

r-"I

I '~

': '

~

.

)

II IJ

!

~ )1

I

1"1 ~ l I !

F,

I I

r

..

.

(

I,. r

I i

3

~-

3aKOHOM OT 21.07.2005 N294-<D3 "0 pasxrentemra 3aK330B aa rrOCTaBKH TOBapoB, BhII10JIHeHHe pafior, OK33aHI'Ie ycnyr ,n;mr rocyzrapcraeansrx H MYHHIJ;HrraJIhHhIX HY)J(,n;" .

Bo scex HHhIX CJIYl1a5IX cyfit.exrai« eCTeCTBeHHhIX MOHOrrOJIHH

percosreanonano ocymecrnnsrs aaxynxn npcnyxuaa (ycnyr) ,n;JI5I coficraenaoro nOTpe6JIeHH5I B COOTBeTCTBHH C nOp5I,n;KoM, upenycercipeansna ,n;JI5I paaxreutenna 3aKa30B na rrOCTaBKH TOBapoB, BhII10JIHeHHe pa60T H OKa3aHHe ycrryr ,n;JI5I rocyztapcraeansrx HY)J(,n;. ,ZJ;aHHoe nOJIO)J(eHHe 3aKpenJIeHO B IIocTaHoBJIeHHH ilpaBHTeJIhCTBa POCCHHCKOH c.I>e,n;epaIJ;HH OT 13.10.1999 N2115 8.

TIo CJIO)J(HBllIeHC5I B OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrr.» npaxrnxe ,n;JI5I saxynxn rrponyxuan (ycnyr) B KOMrraHHH C03,n;aHhI crpyxrypst, KOTOPhIe ocyr.u;eCTBJI5IlOT orfiop KOHTpareHTOB rrocpeztcraoxr npOBe,n;eHH5I 'roproa. TaKHM 06Pa30M, peKOMeH,n;aIJ;HJ:I ilpaBHTeJIhCTBa POCCHHCKOH c.I>e,n;epaIJ;I:IH, saxpennennsre B nOCTaHOBJIeHl:le OT 13.10.1999 N2 1158, HCrrOJIH5IJIH~h.

Ilonrracaaae B OAO «AK «TpaHCHeIPTh» npmcasa NQ 73 OT 21.08.2003 rozta no C03,n;aHHIO na fiase OAO BHI1I1CT OTpaCJIeBOrO TeXHHl1eCKoro IJ;eHTpa H pemeaae OAO «AK «Tpancaedrrs» 0 3aKJIIOlJeHHH 11.09.2003 rona ztoronopa renepansrroro nozipana N2 336/14/03 C OAO BHI1HCT na BhII10JIHeHHe npoeKTHO-1:I3hICKaTeJIhCKHX pa60T H asropcxoro nazrsopa, B paxrxax xoroporo rrocpeztcrsoxr 3aKJIIOlJeHIDI ,n;onOJIHHTeJIhHhIX COrJIallIeHHH, ocyr.u;eCTBJI5IJIHCh pa60ThI no npoexraposaamo 'rpytiorrposoztaoa CHCTeMhI «BOCTOlJHa5I CH6HPh - TI1XHH OKeaH», He COOTBeTCTBOBaJIO panee CJIO~UBmeHCB B KOMnaHHU nparcrmce. O,n;HaKO 3TO H He 5IBJI5IJIOCh rrp5IMhIM aapymeaaexr ,n;eHCTBYIOm;ero 3aKOHo,n;aTeJIhCTBa POCCHifcKOH c.I>e,n;epau;HH, TaK KaK B COOTBeTCTBHH C BhIllIeH3JIO)J(eHHhIM, rro,n;6op KOHTPareHTOB ,n;JI5I .raxoro sazra pa60T na KOHKypCHOH OCHOBe, HOCHT ,n;JI5I cyfisexron eCTeCTBeHHhIX MOHOrrOJIHH peKOMeH,n;aTeJIhHhIH xapaxrep,

Kpoxre roro, B crpyxrype OAO «AK «Tpancaedrrs» HMeeTC5I nosepaee ofimecrso OAO «Fanporpytionposon» - CneU;HaJIH3HpOBaHHa5I rrpOeKTHa5I opraHH3aU;H5I, KOTOpa5I B Te11eHHe ,n;JIHTeJIbHOrO BpeMeHH ,n;o H3,n;aHH5I rrpHKa3a NQ73 OT 21.08.2003 rona BbII10JIH5IJIa <PYHKIJ;HH rOJIOBHOrO rrpoexrnoro rrpezmpasraa H C nasana 2008 rozta B COOTBeTCTBHH C npHK330M OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrs» N2143 OT 03.12.2007 rrOCJIe OTMeHbI rrpnxasa NQ73 OT 21.08.2003 1:1 pacropzceaaa ztorcaopa NQ336/14/03 C OAO BIll111CT npoztonacaer ary pafiory,

Ilepenana q,yHKIJ;HH rrpoeKTHpOBaHH5I H asropcxoro nazrsopa OT ,n;ol1epHeH opraHH3aU;HI:I OAO «I'anporpyoorrposon» B OAO BHI1I1CT nOBJIeKJIO 3HalJHTeJIbHOe YBeJIHl1eHHe CTOHMOCTH YK33aHHbIX pa60T ,n;JI5I KOMlraHHH (nponenr reanonpana), npa TOM, lJTO KalJeCTBO npoeKTHpOBaHH5I He YJIYI111IHJIOCb, npoexrnsre pa60TbI nerrocpeztcrsenno BbII10JIH5IJIHCb TeMH xce npoexrasnra opraHH3aIJ;H5IMI:I, IITO H paaee. TIo,n;TBep)J(,n;eHHeM Hey,n;OBJIeTBOpHTeJIbHOrO KalJeCTBa BhII10JIHeHH5I OAO BHI111CT <PYHKU;I:IH renepam.noro rrpoeKTHpOBII(I:IKa 5IBJI5IIOTC5I pe3YJIbTaTbI rrpOeKTH0-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T 1:1 asropcxoro nazrsopa npa rrpoeKTHpOBaHHH rpytionposonnoii CHCTeMhI «BOCTOIIHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH

_1'1 n,1

l :

~

! '

Il I ·

1 I,

I, r

I i \ '

~

h ( ,

I

~,

"~I '"

; )

,

, '

h

r

I •

\ .

OKeaH», xoropsre npaseztensr HI1)Ke. I1pFIBne"lIeHHe OAO BHI1I1CT K 3THM pa60TaM 6blnO Heo60CHOBaHHblM H 3KOHOMH"lIeCKH HeBblrO,n;HbIM.

3.2 Crroc06 orrpe,IJ,eneHH5I n;eHbl ,IJ,OrOBopa Ha rrpoeKTHpoBaHHe

II

3.2.1 CTOHMOCTb npoexrao-asucxarem.cxax pa60T, 06'beMbI BbIfIOnH5IeMbIX npoexrno-nasrcxarenscxax pa60T, xanenztapmae CpOKH 3TanOB pa60T rro npoexry «Tpytionpoaozmaa CHCTeMa BOCTO"lIHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). I1epBbIH nycxosoii KOMIIJIeKC» onpenenenu B ,lJ;ononHHTenbHoM cornaureaaa NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ,lJ;oroBopy renepam.noro nozipana N~ 336/14/03 OT 29.08.2003 na sunonaenae npoexrno-aasrcxarenscxax pa60T H asropcxoro nazrsopa Me)K,n;y OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» H OAO BI--II111CT (c ,lJ;orronHeHHeM N2 1 OT 14.02.2005 K ,I(C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, ,lJ;orronHeHHeM N2 2 OT 30.06.2005 K ,I(C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, ,I(orronHeHHeM N2 3 OT 15.11.2005 K ,lJ;C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornamemrev NQ 1 OT 16.05.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,I(C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornameaaexr N~ 2 OT 04.11.2005 06 H3MeHeHHH ,I(C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornameaaexr N2 3 OT 15.03.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,I(C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornamenaea N2 4 OT 16.05.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,I(C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, COrJIallIeHHeM N2 5 OT 26.09.200606 H3MeHeHHH,I(C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005).

CTOHMOCTb pa60T B COOTBeTCTBHH C YCJIOBH5IMH Cornamenna N2 5 OT 26.09.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,nononHHTeJIbHOrO cornaureaaa N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ,I(oroBopy reaepansnoro rrozrpana N2 336114/03 OT 29.08.2003 na BbIfIOJIHeHHe rrpoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T H anropcxoro aansopa Me)K.z_:t;y OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» H OAO BHI111CT COCTaBJI5IeT 12381 443 772,95 py6. (B T."lI. H,I(C 18% - 1 888694812,82 py6.).

CTOHMOCTb npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T no npoeKTHpoBaHHIO

06'beKTOB «Tpytionposonaaa CHCTeMa BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). I1epBbIH rrycxoaoa KOMnJIeKC» <pOPMHpOBaJIaCb B COOTBeTCTBHH co CMeTHOH .n;oKYMeHTaU;HeH na rrpoexrao-aasrcxarenscxae pa60TbI «Tpy60npOBo,IJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa "BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)". I1epBbIH nYCKOBOH KOMnJIeKC». Bsrecre C TeM, CMeTa na npoeKTHO-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHe pa60TbI B KaQeCTBe HeOTheMJIeMOH "lIaCTH K ,n:onOJIHHTenbHOMY COrJlaIIIeHHIO He npHJIOJKeHa.

3.2.2 Pa60TbI no npoeKTHpoBaHHIO 06'beKTOB no npoexry «Pacnrapeaae Tpy60rrpOBO.n;HOH· CHCTeMbI BocToQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)>> <pHHaHCHpOBaJIHCb no ,lJ;oroBOpy rrozrpazta na BbII10JIHeHHe npoexrrroH3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T N2 P 0855/2/IJ;YIII111106/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 MeJK.n;y 000 «I(YTI BCTO» H OAO BHillifCT (c ,lJ;C N2 1 OT 11.08.2006, ,I(C NQ 2 OT 07.11.2006, nc N2 3 OT 06.02.2007, ):(C N2 4 OT 07.03.2007, ):(C N2 5 OT 30.03.2007, ,I(C N2 6 OT 24.08.2007, ):(C N2 7 OT 11.02.2008, ):(C N2 8 OT 19.02.2008, ,I(C NQ 9 OT 05.02.2008, ):(C N2 10 OT 01.04.2008, ,n;C N2 11 OT 16.05.2008, ):(C NQ 12 OT 20.05.2008).

CTOHMOCTb pa60T B COOTBeTCTBHH C YCJIOBH5IMH ,I(ononHHTeJIbHOrO COrJIarneHH5I N2 12 OT 20.05.2008 K ,I(oroBopy nonpazra na asmozraemre npoexraoH3blCKaTenbCKHX pa60T N2 P 0855/2/IJ;YI1I111/061165-06 OT 23.06.2006 MeJK,n;y

~r

I

5

~7

~

-

-

~

-

II

\....;.

I -]1

I '

I. "

II ~l ,I '.

- I :

~ il !

~

-

-

I \

~

/1

~

I (

Jl

~ :

i i

I

t

~ ~

- I

1-"

~

I i

In

Ir

000 «I(YTI BCTO» H OAO BHI1I1CT COCTaBJl5IeT 10 281 362413,62 py6. (B T.l:I. H,nC 18% - 1 568343419,03 py6.).

CTOHMOCTb npoexrao-asr.rcxarenscxax pa60T no npoeKTHpOBaHMIO

06'beKTOB «Pacuurpenne Tpy6onpOBO,ll;HOH CMCTeMbI "BOCTOl:IHa5I CH6MPb - THXMH oxeaa" (BCTO)>> CPOpMHpoBanacb B COOTBeTCTBMM co CMeTHOH ,ll;OKYMeHTaU;HeH na npoexrno-naucxarenscxae pa60TbI «Pacnmpeaae rpyfionposonaoii CHCTeMbI "BocTol:IHa5I CM6HPb - TMXMH oxean" (BCTO)>>. Bvecre C TeM, CMeTa na npoexrao-aasrcxarenr.cxae pa60TbI B Kal:IeCTBe HeOTheMneMOH l:IaCTM K ,norOBOpy He npanoxeaa.

CYMMapHble 3aTPaTbI na npOeI<TMpOBaHMe 06beKTOB «Tpyfiorrposonnaa CMCTeMa BOCTOl:IHa5I CM6MPb - TMXMH OKeaH (BCTO). TIepBbIH nYCKOBOH KOMnneKC» M «Pacruapeuae Tpy6onpOBO,ll;HOH CMCTeMbI "BocTol:IHa5I CM6MPb - TMXMH OKeaH" (BCTO)>> COCTaBMnH 22662806 186,57 py6. (B T.l:I. H,nC 18% - 3457038231,85 py6.).

3.3 AHMM3 CTpyKTYPbI 3aTpaT Ha npoeKTMpoBaHMe TC "BCTO"

3.3.1 Pe3ynbTaTbI aHMM3a CTPYKTYPbI 3aTpaT Ha npoeKTMpoBaHMe TC "BCTO" no cocTaBY npe.n:ycMoTpeHHbIx T3 M maKTMl:IeCKM BblnOJIHeHHblX pa60T (c YKa3aHMeM COOTBeTCTBM5I TeXHMl:IeCKoMY 3a,IlaHMIO)

TIo ,ll;aHHbIM, npeztocraaneaasrv 000 «Tpaacaedm, <DMHaHc», no COCT05IHMIO na 25.08.2008r pa60TbI no Ill1P ODJIaqeHhI B DOJIHOM o6beMe.

TIo ,ll;aHHbIM qm:nMana 000 «Tpaacaedrrs cDMHaHc» B r. Anrapcxe, no COCT05IHMIO na 25.08.2008 OnJIal:IeHO 10 191 270,8 ThlC. py6.

TIo MHcpopMaU;MM TeXHMl:IeCKOrO orzrerra 000 «WTI BCTO» no COCT05IHIDO aa 27.08.2008 saxpsrro aKTaMM BblnOJIHeHHblX pa60T M OnJIaqeHO pa60T aa cyMM)' - 10214869349,40 py6. AKTbI BblnOJIHeHHbIX pa60T na CyMMy 66493064,22 py6. He nozmacaasr 000 «WTI BCTO» B CE5I3M C 3aMel:IaHM5IMM K ITC,n: M nopaoorxoa ITC,n OAO BHMI1CT (Yl:IaCTOK NQ 3 (Tanaxancxoe MecTopo)J(.n;eHMe - r. Annan) HIIC 14. Ilepenoc na rrpassrfi 6eper).

Pe3YJIbTaTbI aaanasa crpyxrypsr sarpar aa upoexraposaaae TC "BCTO" na COCTaB rrpezrycnorpenasrx T3 M cpaKTMl:IeCKM BbIllOJIHeHHblX pa60T npnsezreasr B MaTepMaJIaX KOMHCCMOHHbIX nposepox.

3.3.2 Pe3YJIbTaThI aHaJIM3a cTpyKTyphI 3aTpaT Ha npoeKTMpoBaHMe TC "BCTO" Ha npMMeHeHMe pacgeHoK Ha npoeKTMpOBaHMe

Ilponeztea aHaJIM3 CMeT na npoeKTHo-M3bICKaTeJIbCKMe pa60TbI no 06'beKTaM «Tpytionposoztaas CMCTeMa «BocTol:IHa5I CM6MPb - TMxMH OKeaH». ITepBbIH rrycxosoa KOMnJIeKC» H «Pacmnpenae rpyfionposozmoji CMCTeMbI «BocTol:IHa5I CM6MPh - TMXMH OKeaH (BCTO)>>.

Pesyns'rarsi rrpoaepxa CMeT na rrpoeKTHo-M3bICKaTeJIhCKMe pa60ThI K cornaureuaaa N21, N24, N25 06 M3MeHeHMM ,nonOJIHMTeJIhHOrO cornaurenns N20855 OT 26.01.2005 K rrorosopy reneparn.rroro rroztpazra NQ336/14/03 OT

~ t:

\

~r.

I'

! .

29.08.2003 f. Me)l{,n;y OAO «AK «Tpancaedrn,» 11 OAO B.I-I1111CT no rrpoexry «Tpyfionpoacnaaa CHCTeMa «Bocro-mas CH6HPb - TrrXH11 OI<eaH». TIepBbIH rrycxoaoii KOMIIneKC» rrpaseneau B Ta6JIHIJ,e 1.

Ta6JIHI_J;a 1

N2 COrJIarneHIUl 06 CTOMMOCTb, py6. (6e3 ~C)
n/n H3MeHeHMM,I(C N2 ):(0 nposepxa nOCJIe nposepxa BblHBJIeHHOe
0855 OT 26.01.05 KOMMCCHH KOMHCCMH aansnnenne
1 1 11 348 725 539,08 6463 911 919,93 4884813 619,15
2 4 10982038219,23 6410394 182,48 4 571 644 036,75
3 5 10492 748 690,15 6 167617785,41 4325130904,73 Pe3YJIbTaTbI nposepxa CMeT na npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCK11e pa60TbI K ,D,oroBopy nozrpazta na BbIl10JIHeH11e npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T N~P 0855/2/QYTIlll1106/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 Me)l{,n;y 000 «uvn BCTO» H OAO BHill1CT (c ,l1;C NQ12 OT 20.05.2008) no npoexry «PacIIIHpeH11e Tpy6onpOBO,n:HOH C11CTeMbI "BoCToqHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO)>> npaaeneasr B rafirrane 2.

Tafinaua 2

Nl! ,l.l;orr. COmaWeHIiJI CTOHMOCTb, py6. (6e3 H,lJ;C)
n/n K ,l.l;oroBOPY nonpazta nOCJIe nposepxa BblHBJIeHHOe
Nl! P 0855/2/UYI1l1 1 11061165-06 zro nponepxa KOMI1CCI1I1 KOMI1CCI1I1
OT 23.06.2006 3aBhllUeHI1e
1 12 8859917515,86 3 130996 887,83 5 728 920 628,03 no peaynsraraxr 3KcnepTHOH OlJ,eHKH qrreHaMH KOMHCCHH YCTaHOBJIeHO Heo60CHOBaHHoe 3aBbIIlIeHHe CMeTHOH CTOHMOCTH npoeKTHO-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T co CTOPOHbI OAO BHHHCT no npoexraxr «Tpy60npOBo,n;Ha5I CHCTeMa «BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH: OKeaR». I1epBbIH: rryCKOBOH: KOMITJIeKC» H «PaCIlIHpeHHe TPy60npOBo,n:HOH: CHCTeMbI «BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPh - THXHH: OKeaH (BCTO)>> na o6J.QYlO cyMMy 10 054 051 532,76 py6. (6e3 H,l1;C), B TOM QHCJIe:

- no COfrraIIIeHHlO NQ5 OT 26.09.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,n;onOJIHHTeJIhHOrO COrJIaIlIeHH5I NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ,lJ;oroBopy reaepansnoro noztpazta NQ336/14/03 OT 29.08.2003 aa BLIl10JIHeHlIe npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJILCKHX pa60T H asropcxoro aansopa Me)l{,n;y OAO «AK «Tpancaerprs» H OAO BHMHCT na CyMMY 4325 130904,73 py6. (6e3 H,l(C);

- no ,lJ;OfoBOpy nonpxaa na asnronaenae npoeKTHo-H3hICKaTeJILCKHX pa60T NQ P 0855/2/QYIII111/06/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 Me)l{,n;y 000 «I(Yn BCTO» H OAO BHI1IiCT (c ztc NQ 12 OT 20.05.2008) B passrepe 5728920628,03 py6. (6e3 H,l1;C).

TIo pesynsraran pa60TbI KOMHCCHH BbI5IBJIeHbI OCHOBHhle npHQHHbI

3aBbIIlIeHH5I CTOHMOCTH Ill1P:

B QaCTH H3bICKaTerrbCKHx pafior:

- CMeTbI He COOTHeceHbI C OTQeTaMH no HH)l{eHepHLIM H3bICKaHH5IM;

- 06'beMbI BLIl10JIH5IeMbIX pa60T 3aBLIllIeHbI OT 2 zro 10 paa no cpannemno C

Tpe60BaHH5IMH HopMaTHBHLIX ,n:OKYMeHTOB;

Ii

&

I '

1 .

It, fL

I

I ~

!

- BbIIIOJIHeHHble 06beMbI pa60T no re03KOJIOnrqeCKHM H3bICKaHH5IM na ofir.exrax «fl3YQeHHe onacnux OnOJI3HeBbIX YQaCTKOB» H «JIe,lJ,OBbIX nepenpaB LJepe3 pexa» He npeztycxrorpenu Tpe6oBaHH5IMH HopMaTHBHbIX ,lJ,OKYMeHTOB;

- 06beMbI pa60T no rH,lJ,pOJIOrHLJeCKHM H re03KOJIOrHLJeCKHM H3bICKaHH5IM nOBTOp5IlOTC5I B 3 csrerax;

- o6beMbI pa60T no ouenxe B03,lJ,eHcTBH5I na oxpyzcaioutyro cpeziy H HX CMeTHa5I CTOHMOCTb BKJIlOQeHbI B paszten npoexra «Oxpaaa oKpY)l(alOIIJ;eH cpeztsr».

B LJaCTH npoexrrrsrx pafior:

- saztnoenne CTOHMOCTH npoexrnsrx pa60T sa CLJeT npHMeHeHH5I

KOMnJIeKCHblX pacrrerrox ,lJ,JI5I ofit.exron BMeCTe C pacuenxaxra na orztensnue 3,lJ,aHH5I H coopyxeaaa, BXO,lJ,5IIUHMH B COCTaB 3THX ofisercros;

- He npaneaeau nOHH)l(alOIIJ;He K03<P<PHll.HeHTbI, YLJ.HTbIBalOIUHe

npaaeaeane THrrOBbIX npoexrnux peureaaii (OT 0,3 ,lJ,O 0,7);

- He npaaeaeaa nOHH)l(aIOIUHe K03cpcpHll.HeHTbI, YLJ.IiTbIBaIOIll,He nosropnoe npaaeaenne npoexrasrx pemenan (no 0,7);

- He KoppeKTHO npauenea K03<pcpHll.HeHT, YLJ.HTbIBaIOIIJ;UH npaxreaeaae axmoprnoro o6oPy.n;OBaHHJI (zro 1,3 - npHMeH5IeTCJI TOJIbKO ,lJ,JIJI asmoprnoro o6oPY,lJ,OBaHH5I, acnonssyeaoro snepssre),

Pe3YJIbTaTbI aHaJIH3a CMeTHOH CTOHMOCTH npoeKTHo-H3hICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T no o6beKTY «Tpy6orrpOBO,lJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa «BOCTOLJ.Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH». TIepBbIH nycxosoa KOMnJIeKC» H «Pacnmpeaae Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,HOH CHCTeMbI «BOCTOLJ.Ha5I Cafiaps - THXHH OKeaH (BeTO)>> npaaezrensr B npHJIO)l(eHHH 1 HaCT05IIIJ;erO OTLJ.eTa.

3.4 Pe3YJIbTaTbI c60pa H aHaJIH3a HHIDopMaUHH

3.4.1 Pe3YJIbTaTbI c60pa H aHaJIH3 HHIDopMaunH Ha npe,n;MeT HCnOJIb30BaHHJI paHee pa3pa60TaHHbIx npoeKTHbIX ,n;OKYMeHTOB H MaTepHaJIOB

1) ITo pe3YJIbTaTaM axcnepraoii onemcn BbI5IBJIeHO 3aBbIIlIeHHe CTOHMOCTH npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T sa CLJ.eT HCnOJIb30BaHIDI panee paspatioraansrx rrpoexrasrx ,lJ,OKYMeHToB H MaTepHaJIOB (aeofiocaoaaaaux sarpar na paspaoorxy CTY H HHOKP, neofiocaonaaaoro npHMeHeHH5I saasnneanerx K031P<pHUHeHToB, Ha nOBTopHoe npIiMeHeHHe npoeKTHoH ,lJ,OKYMeHTaUHH). ITpH 3TOM pa3pa60TKa CTY H H110KP OTCYTcTByeT B 3a,lJ,aHHH na rrpoexraposaane, LJ.aCTb HopMaTHBHoH ,lJ,oKYMeHTaUHH paspafiorarra H yraepacneaa OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrrs» ,lJ,O 3aKJIIOLJ.eHH5I zrorosopa noztpxna (aanpaxrep CTT-29.240-KTH-041-06, CTT- 7S.200.00-KTH-044-06). PaCLJ.eT CTOHMOCTH ,lJ,aHHbIX pa60T BbIIIOJIHeH na OCHOBe TpY,lJ,03aTpaT. Tpynoesrxocrs, YKa3aHHa5I B CMeTe na Tll1P COCTaBJIJIeT 14 022 qeJI/,a:HH, LJ.TO JIBHO 3aBbIIlleHO.

2) BbI5IBJIeHbI cpaKThI 3aBbIIlleHH5I cMeTHoH CTOHMOCTH I1I1P no rrpoexry «Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa "BocToLJ.Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)". TIepBbIH rrycxosoii KOMnJIeKC» B LJ.aCTH pa60T no paspafiorxe CTY H HI10KP na cTpOHTeJIhCTBO HeqnenpOBO,lJ,HOH CHCTeMbI BCTO B paxncax pa3pa60TKH T30 no YKa3aHHoMY npoexry. l/13 5 pa60T no paspafiorxe CTY H HHOKP na ofimyro

CyMMy 193445259,63 py6. BbUIBneHO OTCYTcTBHe B 000 «I(YTI BCTO» pesynsraros pa60T no 4 pa60TaM na 06u.zyFO CyMMy 137 095 259,63 py6. (c H,n:C, C y-rerov K=I,15 aa coxpamenne CPOKOB npoeKTHpOBaHH.5I).

3) TIo nepBoMY nycxosoxiy KOMnneKCY BCTO sa CLIeT qlH:HaHCHpOBaHH.5I ITI1P BbITIOnH.5InOCb 34 pafiorsr, HMeFOIll,He xapaxrep HHOKP (Hl1P), na 06Ill,YFO cyMMy 705 793 822,94 py6. TIo ,1J;aHHbIM pa60TaM nO,1J;TBep)K,1J;eHo aKTaMH

BbITIOnHeHHe pa60T na CyMMy 348 030940,01 py6. ,lJ;oKYMeHTaJIbHO

nO,1J;TBep)K,1J;eHa nJIaTe)KHbIMH nopysenaaua onnara pa60T na cyMMY

173 651 092,33 py6. ,IJ;oKYMeHTaJIbHO nO,1J;TBep)f(,1J;eHO acnonssosaaae pe3YJIbTaTOB pa60T no 2 ,1J;OrOBOpaM, tPaKTHQeCKHe BhInJIaTbI no KOTOPbIM COCTaBHJIH 25091 699,10 py6. TaKHM 06Pa30M, no pe3YJIbTaTaM sxcneprnofi Ol(eHKH OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» uaaecea 3KOHOMHLIeCKHH ytnepf B passrepe 148559393,23 py6.

4) O,1J;Ha pafiora «Pa3pa60TKa H BHe,1J;peHHe CHCTeM aBTOMaTH3al(HH nO,1J;rOTOBKH H npe,1J;CTaBJIeHH5I HHcpopMal(HH 06 HHBeCTHl(HOHHhIX npoexrax B COOTBeTCTBHe C Tpe6oBaHH.5IMH Me)K,1J;YHap0,1J;H.bIX tPHHaHcoBbIX opraaasauaa», OnJIaLIeHa ,1J;Ba)f(,1J;bI (KoMnaHHeH «Tpaacnedrrr.» OAO BHl1l1CT B COCTaBe ,1J;OrOBOpa ua Ill1P B cyMMe 44,78 MJIH. py6. H OAO «rHnpoTpy60npOBO,1J;» OAO BHllliCT no OT,1J;eJIbHOMY ,1J;OrOBopy B cYMMe 23,0 MJIH. py6.). Pe3YJIbTaT.bI pa60ThI He MCnOJIb30BaJIMCb.

Pe3YJIbTaThI rrposepox npHBe,1J;eH.bI B npHJIO)f(eHH.5IX 2 H 3 HaCTO.5IIl(ero OTLIeTa.

1.· .•. ··.].

n

~ I '

~

r-

I

) !

I ,

f!l )liS)

I'

-,

Ci \

~

.

,

, I

I '

, '

3.4.2 Pe3YJIbTaTbI c60pa H aHaJIM3 HH<p0pMaUMM Ha npeP;MeT <i_laKTHLIecKoro BbITIOJIHeHM.5I npeP;YCM0IpeHHhIX T3, KOHTpaKTOM M HopMaTMBHbIMH p;OKYMeHTaMM npoeKTHbIX pa60T

B 000 «WIT BCTO» OCYIl(eCTBJI.5IeTC5I apxasaoe xpaaeaae nOJIYLIeHHoH no ,1J;OrOBOpaM na BbITIOJIHeHHe lTI1P npoexrao-csreraoa ,1J;OKYMeHTal(MM na 6YMa)KHOM M 3JIeKYpOHHOM HOCHTeJI.5IX.

1) Co CTOPOHbI 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» He aa ,n;OJI)f(HOM yponne OCYIll,eCTBJI.5IJIC5I KOHTPOJIb sa npOl(eCCOM npnesra, nepezra-m M xpaHeHH.5I pa3pa60TaHHOM no ztoroaopaxr na BbITIOJIHeHMe I1HP npoeKTHO-CMeTHOM ,n;OKYMeHTal(MM, B T.LI.:

1.1) OnMCb npoearno-cxrernoa ,1J;OKYMeHTal(HM no npoexry

«Tpytionpoaoznraa CHCTeMa BocToLIHa.5I CH6MPb - TMxMM OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBhIM nycxosoii KOMnJIeKC» H npoexry «PacIIIMpeHHe rpyrionposonaon CMCTeMbI "BocToLIHa.5I CM6Hpb - THXMH oxeaa" (BeTO)>> He CCPOpMMpoBaHa.

1.2) CJIa6hIM KOHTPOJIb sa 060POTOM apxaanoti ,1J;OKYMeHTal(MM co CTOPOHbI 000 «WIT BCTO» npasen K TOMY, qTO P5I,n; KHMr 6bIJI YTep5IH (123 KHMfM, BXO,1J;.5IIll,He B COCTaB npoexros, He 6bIJIH npe,1J;OCTaBJIeHbI ,1J;JI.5I nposepxa).

1.3) ITC,ll, B apxase He KOMnJIeKTHa no ncexr JIOTaM, B CB.5I3H C TeM, qTO CMeTHa.5I ,1J;OKYMeHTal(M.5I xpaHHTC5I OT,1J;enbHO, M He aKTYaJIbHa no BceM JIOTaM, B CB.5I3H C TeM, qTO H3MeHeHH.5I K I1C,lJ; He BHOC.5ITC5I B OCHOBHOH KOMnJIeKT I1C,n: H XpaH.5ITC.5I OT,1J;eJIbHO.

[

fI

nLl

1.4) Cocras npoexrao-cvernoii ,IJ.OKYMeHTaUJIH, npe,IJ.CTaBJIeHHbIH B

HMeIOlIJ;I1XC5f TOMax «0», He B normoxr 06'beMe COOTBeTCTBYIOT cpaKTw-reCKH pa3pa60TaHHOH H nepenaanoa B 000 «I(YTI BCTO» npoexraof ,IJ.oKYMeHTa:U;HH.

2) BbI5fBneHbI <paKTbI cpbIBa cpoxa BbIIIOnHeHH5f pa60T no ,IJ.OrOBopy na npoexr «Pacmapeaae TPy6orrpOBO,IJ.HOH CHCTeMbI "Bocro-nraa CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO)>> no 3 06'beKTaM (JIe,IJ.OBa5f nepenpasa -repes p. An,IJ.aH; 06'beKTbI B3C. Pa3pa60TKa H 3KCnepTIf3a pafio-reii ,IJ.OKYMeHTa:U;IIH (HI1C N2 17); CHcTeMa npoasaoncrneaao-rexaonorauecxof CB5I3H. Pa3pa60TKa H 3KcnepTH3a pafio-reii ,IJ.OKYMeHTa:U;HH (YqaCTOK N2 3 (Tanaxancxoe MeCTOpO)K,IJ.eHHe - r. An,IJ.aH) 11 05KM - 2202KM)) na CpOK OT 5 ,IJ.O 115 ,IJ.HeH.

<DaKTHQeCKHe CpOKH npe,IJ.CTaBneHH5f B normoro KOMIIJIeKTa TIC,n: na 6YMa)KHOM HOCHTene B COOTBeTCTBMH C Tpe6oBaHH5fMH 3a,IJ.aHH5I na npoexraposaaae (no HaKna,IJ.HbIM) npensnuaer CpOKH npe,IJ.CTaBJIeHM5I TIC,n: no 3aKnIOQeHHbIM ,IJ.OrOBOpaM no 15 06'beKTaM H3 52 na CpOK OT 32 ,IJ.O 408 ,IJ.HeH. Pa60TbI no paspafiorxe TIC,n: nOYKa3aHHbIM 06'beKTaM 3aKpbITbI aKTaMH BbInonHeHHbIX patior, TIpeTeH3HH OAO «BHI1l1CT» He BbICTaBn5IJIHCb. TIo 4 06'beKTaM BbI5fBneHbI cpaKTbI 3aKpbITH5I aKTOB BblnOJIHeHHbIX pa60T ,IJ.O MOMeHTa norryseaaa nOJIHOrO KOMnneKTa TIC,n: OT OAO «BI-II1HCT» H YTBep)K,IJ.eHH5I ,IJ.OKYMeHTa:U;MH B npOM3Bo,IJ.CTBO pafior, TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM nposepxa orpopxrnenaa TIC,n: YCTaHoBneHo, QTO 60nee 30% TIC,n: He COOTBeTcTByeT YCTaHOBJIeHHbIM HopMaTHBHbIM Tpe60BaHIDIM K otpopxrneaaro TIC,n:.

Pasxrep HepeanH30BaHHbIX npeTeH3HOHHbIX Tpe60BaHHH K OAO BHI1l1CT sa CpbIB CPOKOB BbIIIOnHeHH5I npoeKTHO-M3bICKaTeJI1>CKHX pa60T COCTaBHn no 3KcnepTHOH oneaxe 5 218 905,71 py6.

3)TIo pe3yn1>TaTaM 3KcnepTHoH o:u;eHKH no 26 o6beKTaM (noTaM) H3 52 rrpoexrso-cneraaa ,IJ.OKYMeHTa:U;H5I OAO BHJ1l1CT npencraanena B MeHbllIeM KOJIMQeCTBe 3K3eMnJI5IpOB, QeM npenycsrorpeao B 3 an aHH5f X na npoexrnpoaaaae (He,II.OnonYQeHO OT 1 ,II.O 6 3K3. TIC)]).

Pasaep rrpeTeH3HOHHbIX Tpe60BaHHH aa He,II.OCTaIOII(ee KOJIHQeCTBO rrpe,II.CTaBneHHbIX 3K3eMnn5IpOB TIC,lJ; aa 6YMa)KHOM HOCHTene COCTaBHn no sxcncpraoa onenxe 5 335 905,79 py6. (c y-reroxr CTOHMOCTH pa3MHO)KeHH5I 1 ,II.OnOJIHHTenbHoro 3K3. TIC,n: B paaxrepe 0,5% OT cMeTHoH CTOHMOCTH srarra I1I1P no zroronopy).

4) B XO,II.e 3KCnepTH3bI BbI5fBneH CJIYQaH pa3pa60TKH TIC,lJ; He

npe,II.CTaBn5fIOII(eH rrpaKTHQeCKOH Heo6xo,II.HMOCTH, a HMeHHO - YCTPOHCTBO KOJIO,II.:u;eB Y3nOB 3a,II.BH:>KeK. TIo 3KcnepTHOH onemce QJIeHOB pa60QeH rpyrmsr 3KOHOMH5f npoeKTHOH opraHH3a:U;HH COCTaBHna 60JIee 2 MJIH. py6. ITo 3aMeQaHIDIM 000 «Bocroxnedrrerrposon» N2 01-1114564 OT 09.07.07 npoexrnaa ,II.OKYMeHTa:U;H5f OTKoppeKTHpOBaHa.

Pesynsrarsr aaannaa HH<p0pMa:U;HH na npeznrer cpaKTHqeCKOrO B1>IIIOJIHeHIDI rrpenycvorpenmrx T3, KOHTpaKToM H HopMaTHBHbIMH ,II.OKYMeHTaMH npoexrnsix pa60T npHBe,II.eHbI B srarepaanax KOMHCCHOHHbIX nposepox no ,II.aHHbIM sonpocaa (rrpHJIO:>KeHHe 3, 6, 7 HaCT05III(erO orsera).

3.4.3 Pe3YJI1TaTbI c60pa H aHaJIH3 YIHcpopMalJ,HH B pa3pe3e rrpI1BJIeqeHH1IX cy6rrOnp5I,gH1IX rrpoeKTHhIX opraHH3aUHH C YKa3aHHeM 06'1eMa H CTOHMOCTH B1II10JIHeHH1IX HMH pa60T B COOTHOIIleHHH C o6IUHMH 3aTpaTaMH ITO reHIIO,gp5I,n;HOMY ,gorOBOpy

I1H<I>opMaUH5I ITO <paKTHqeCKH BhII10JIHeHH1IM pa60TaM ITO 06'1eKT)' "Ipyfionpononaaa CHCTeMa BOCTOQHa5I CH6HP1 - THXHM OKeaH (BCTO). T30 (npoexr), Pa6oQa5I ,I(oKYMeHTaUH5I. I1epB1IH nycxoncii KOMrrJIeKC" sa 2005, 2006 H 2007rr. H "PacIIIHpeHHe Tpy6orrpOBO,I(HOH CI1CTeM11 BOCTOqHa5I CH6HP1- THXHH:

OKeaH" sa rrepHO,I( 2006r., 2007r., 2008r., rrpe,I(CTaBJIeHHa5I OAO «Fnrrporpytionponozt», npaneneaa B Cnpasxe OAO «Tnnporpyfiorrposon» o pacnpezierreaaa cy6nO,I(p5I,I(qHKOB npn BhlnOJIHeHHH pa60T I H II OQepe,I(H BCTO (npHJIO)KeHHe 5 HaCT05IIUerO OTQeTa).

3.5 Pe3YJI1TaThI aHaTIH3a nOJIHOThI H ,gOCTOBepHOCTH OTQeTH1IX nOKYMeHTOB C TOQKH 3peHH5I IIX rrOJIHOThI, 060CHOBaHHOCTII II CBoeBpeMeHHOCTII npOII3Ben;eHHhIX B1IIIJIaT

~n

I i i \

~I~

I

~ r-,

I

3.5.1 CTOIIMOCT1 pa60T no ztoroaopy na Ill1P.N2 336/14/03 OT 29.08.2008r no 06'1eKTY «Tpyfionponozraaa CIICTeMa BOCTOQHM CII6IIPh - TIIXIIH OKeaH (BCTO). IIepB1IH: nycxonoii KOMnJIeKC» II nOrrOJIHHTeJIhHoM)' COrJIameHIIIO N2 0323 12.12.2003r K noroBopy N2 336/14/03 OT 29.08.2008r na npezmpoexrnsre pa60ThI - «,D;eKJIapaUH5I 0 HaMepeHII5IX II 06ocHoBaHIIe IIHBecTIIUHH B cYpoHTeJIhCTBO aerprenpoaozuroa CHCTeM11 BOCTOQHM CII6Hph - TIIxHH OKeaH}), 3aKJIIOQeHHhIX Me)Kny OAO «AK. «Tpaacneqrrs» II OAO «BHI1I1CT» COCTaBJI5IeT 13 212 843,1 ThIC. pyo.

ITo naHH.bIM, rrpe,I(oCTaBJIeHH1IM 000 «Tpaacaedrrs <l>HHaHc», ITO COCT05IHHlO na 25.08.2008r pa6oT11 ITO Ill1P onna-reasr B llOJIHOM OO'heMe.

3.5.2 CTOHMOCTh pa60T ITO norosopa» na I1I1P, 3aKJIlOQeHHhIM Me)Kn;y 000 «IJYII BCTO» H OAO «BHI1I1CT» COCTaBJI5IeT 14100 658,5ThIC. pyti, no naHH1IM tPHJIHaJIa 000 «Tpancaetprs <I>IIHaHC» r. Anrapcx, ITO COCT05IHIIlO na 25.08.2008r OrrJIaQeHO 13 731 224,7ThlC. py6., B TOM QHCne:

- ITO norOBOpy N~ 0247/UYI1l370-07 OT 29.12.2006r na BhIITOJIHeHHe llI1P

I-IT1C «CKOBOpOnHHO» CTOHMOCThIO 11 606,6T1IC. py6. OrrJIaQeHO

11 606,6ThIC. py6.;

- ITO ztorosopy N2 P0855/2JIJ;YI1II11/06/165-06 OT 23.06.2006r aa B1II10JIHeHHe IllIP na PacIIIHpeHHe Tpy6orrpoBOnHOH CHCTeMhI BOCTOQHa5I CH6IIP1 - THxHH OKeaH (BCTO) co CTOHMOCT11O 10281 362,4ThIC. py6., OrrJIaQeHO 10 191 270,8T1IC. py6.;

(no HHcpopMaUHH TeXHHQeCKOrO OTneJIa 000 «IJYIT BCTO» ITO COCT05IHIIlO na 27.08.2008 3aKphITO aKTaMH B1II10JIHeHH1IX pa60T H OrrJIaQeHO pa60T na CyMMy - 10214869349,40 pyfi, He BhII10JIHeHHhle pa6oT11 66 493 064,22 pyfi.)

wcr f-~~ ~r

I '

~

,

,

I,

l ,

ff ~t:

l

[h

I l

- no ,lJ;OrOBOpy N2 MK0855/7/IJ;YI1IIII/06/227-06 OT 29.08.2006r na nsmonaenae I1I1P CMHIl «K03hMHHO» co CTOHMOCThJO 3 807 689,5ThIC. py6., OnJIa1feHO 3 528 347,4ThIC. py6.

4 BhIBO,lJ;hI

11 Ii!

I j

II It

t

~

I

!:j

fn

l

4.1 CTOHMOCTh npoexrao-assrcxarenscxax pa60T no 06beKTaM

rpyfionpoeomrof CHCTeMhI BCTO no zrorosopaxr OAO «AK «Tpaucaedrrs» H 000 «llYn BCTO» C OAO BHJ11iICT no excrrepraoii oueaxe 33BhIllIeH3 60JIee qeM B ,lJ;B3 pasa H COCTaBfl5IeT 10054051 532,76 py6., 1fTO npnseno K Heo6ocHoBaHHoMY y,lJ;OpO~aHHIO npOeKTHpOBaHHH TC BeTO .

4.2 He06ocHoBaHHhIMH 3aTpaTaMH, CB5I3aHHhIMH C BhIITOnHeHHeM

npoeKTHo-H3hICKaTeJIhCKHX pafior, rarose ~IBmnOTC5I:

- sarparsr na p5I,lJ; HaY1fHO-Hccne,n;OBaTeJIhCKHX pa60T na CyMMy na CyMMy 258 654 652,86 py6., no KOTOPhIM OTCyTCTB)'lOT OT1feThI HJIH pesynsrarsr KOTOPhIX He Hcnonh3YIOTC5I na npaxraxe;

- rrosropaaa onnara B cysore 23,0 MJIH. py6. HI1P rro rene «Pa3pa60TKa H BHe,n;peHHe CHCTeM aBTOMaTH3a~HH no,n;rOTOBKH H rrpe,n;cTaBneHH5I HH~opMaQHH 06 HHBeCTHQHOHHhIX rrpoexrax B COOTBeTCTBHe C Tpe60BaHH5IMH Me)K,lJ;YHapO,lJ;HhIX ~HHaHcoBhIx oprannaamra»;

- nerrpezrsaaneaae npeTeH3HOHHhIX T}Je6oBaHHll K OAO BHHI1CT sa CphIB CPOKOB BhIllOnHeHH5I npoexrao-aasrcxarenscxax pa60T na CyMMy 5,2 MJIH. py6. H He,lJ;OCTaIOIIJ;ee KOnlI1feCTBO npeztcranneansrx 3K3eMnJI5IpOB nc,n; na CyMMy 5,3 MJIH. py6., aa paspaforxy nc,n; He npe,lJ;CTaBn5IIOIIJ;ell nparcnrsecxoa Heo6xo,n;HMOCTH aa CyMM)' 2 MJIH. py6.

4.4 Ilpa HaJIH1fHH coficrnennoro Cne~HaJIH3HpOBaHHoro ,lJ;01fepHerO

npoexrnoro HHcTHryTa OAO «I'anporpytionposon» H HenOCpe,lJ;CTBeHHOM ncnorraenmr 100% npoexmo-aaucxarenscxax pa60T H asropcxoro aansopa cy6nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;HhIMH npoeKTHhIMH opraHH3a~H5IMH, rrpaanesenae OAO BHill1CT B Ka1feCTBe reaepansaoro nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;1fHKa npa npoexraposaaan rpytionpoaormoii CHCTeMhI «BoCT01fHa5I CH6HPh - Tnxaii OKeaH» Heo6oCHOBaHHhIM H 5IBn5InOCh 3KOHOMH1feCKH aeasrronasie. Onnara OAO B:HIIHCT «nOCpe,lJ;HH1feCKHX rearronpaaasrx ycrryr» Heo6oCHOB3HHO YBeJIHQUJI3 3aTp3ThI H3 npoeicrnposanae TC BCTO na BenH1fHHY pa3HH~hI CTOHMOCTH Me)l(,lJ;y rennonpszrasm» Ii cy6nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;HhIMH ,lJ;OrOBOpaMH (OAO BHl1I1CT OTKa3aJIC5I npe,lJ;OCTaBHTh cyfinonpazmsre norosopsr).

~

.

.

~i .••

'I

,

~:

5 llpHJIOmeHHH (rrepe-rern, ,lJ;OKYMeHTOB KOMHCCHOHHhIX rrponeporc)

1. Pesynr.raru an aJIH3 a 06ocHoBaHHocTH npmI3Be,lJ;eHHhIX sarpar na npoexrapoaaaae TC BCTO, BhIITOnHeHHoro OAO «I'anporpyconposon».

2. OT1feT 0 nposezreaaa aHaJIH3a ,lJ;OrOBOpoB na paspafiorxy HopMaTHBHorexaauecxoii ,n;OKyMeHTa~HH H xonuernraji B paxrxax BhITIOnHeHH5I rrpoexra I o-repezur BCTO.

3. Ilporoxon nposepxa N21-UJIBC/2008 pa601feil ,lJ;OKYMeHTaWfH no rrpoercry «Tpy60npoBo).J;Ha5I CHCTeMa BOCT01fHa5I CH6HPb - THxHH OKeaH (BCTO).

~7

//7

I1epBhIM nYCKOBOM KOMnJIeKC» 11 npOeKTY «PaCIll11peH11e TPy6onpOBO,lJ,HOM C11CTeMhI "BocTotIHa5I C116HPb - THXHM OKeaH" (BCTO)>> OT 27.08.2008.

4. Ilporoxon nposepxa N22-L(I1BC/2008 CMeTHOM ,lJ,OKYMeHTaU;HH no npoexraa «Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa BocTotIHa5I CH6HPh - THXHM OKeaH (BCTO). I1epBbIH rrycxoaoa KOMnJIeKC» H «Pacnnrpeane Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,HOM CHCTeMhI "BocTotIHa5I CH6HPh - THXHM OKeaH. (BCTO)>> OT 27.08.2008.

5. Cnpasxa OAO «Fnrrporpyoorrposozr» 0 pacnpeneneaaa

cy6nO,lJ,p5I,lJ,tIHKOB npn BbIIIOJIHeHHH pa60T I H II oxepezta BCTO.

6. Ilporoxon nposepxa N21 OT 28.08.2008 npoexrno-caeraoit

,lJ,OKYMeHTaU;HH no npoexry «Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa BocTotIHa5I Cafiaps - TrrxHM OKeaH (BeTO). I1epBhIM nycxosoa KOMnneKC» rr npoexry «PacIIIHpeHHe Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,HOH CHCTeMhI "BocTotIHa5I CH6HPh - Tnxnn oxeaa" (BCTO)>> OT 28.08.2008.

7. ,II;onOJIHeHrre N2 1 K I1POTOKOJIY npoBepKH N2 1 OT 28.08.2008 npoexraocMeTHoM ,lJ,OKYMeHTa[(HH no npoexry «Tpy6onpOBO,lJ,Ha5I CHCTeMa BocTotIHa5I Crr6Hph - THXHM OKeaH (BCTO). I1epBhIH rrycxoaoii KOMnfleKC» rr npoexry «Pacnmpenae Tpy6onpoBO,lJ,HOM CHCTeMhI "BoCTOQHa5I CH6rrph - THxrrH oxean" (BCTO)>> OT 19.09.2008.

11, I"'"

\ ,

~

I ,

~

I

qJIEHhI PABOlffiH rpYIIIIbI:

It

r;

II r~

I, "

,

~ P-

I '

\ ,

it

,

I ' i '

Hasansnn« KAO rpannaaa 000 «Tpaacnedrrs <PHHaHC» B r. TOMCKe

I1.H. Ilonoxrapea

Hasansnax OT,lJ,eJIa ,lJ,OrOBOpoB OAO «I'artporpyfionpoaozt»

H.H. E3epCKa5I

3aMeCTFITeJIh HaqaJIhHHKa OT,lJ,eJIa OAO «I'anporpyoonposon»

M.K. TrrTOBa

3aMeCTHTeJIh aasansuaxa Ilpaaosoro ynpaBJIeHH5I - HaqaJIhHHK IOpH,lJ,HqeCKOrO OT,lJ,eJIa OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs»

rJIaBHhIM IOPHCKOHCYJIhT IOpH,lJ,HqeCKOrO OT,lJ,eJIa Ilpaaosoro ynpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs»

3aMeCTHTeJIh ziapexropa nenapraaeara

«CJIY:)l(6a fieaonacnocra» - HaqaJIhHHK

OT,lJ,OeJIaAK3KOHOMlI'reCK~ii 6e30nacHocTH ila/ ____

OA« «Tpaacacdrrs» v(lVV'7

H.M. PYCJI5IKOB

~ -----~'

'.1

I

i

rJIaBHbIH Crren;HaJIHCT OT.n:eJIa 3KOHOMHLIeCKOH 6e30rraCHOCTH OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,»

3aMeCTHTeJIb HaLIaJIbHHKa OT.n:eJIa CTpaTerHLIeCKOrO pa3BHTH5.I

OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrn,»

3aMeCTHTeJIb HaqaJIbHHKa OT.n:eJIa HaYLIHO-TeXHHLIeCKOrO 06eCrreLIeHH5.I H HOpMaTHBHOH .n:OKYMeHTan;HH OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrs»

If n i

~

1 I

!

i

\

~

/

~

1 :

fl

i

It .. ~ :

I

It, .. r

I :

I '

"

I .

~ ~. r

[

h

I'

<D.E. )l{aBopoHKOB

):(.A. Tepexos

r.MOCKBa

17.l 0.2008

~

,

I ,

~

,

I )"

~ ~ ~

~ \ '

F:

! '

~, 'i

f

~ f

,

"

It., , :

t,

,

,

t

,

,

l" ~1

( ."

~

I I

I I

OTqeT 0 BhInOJIHeHHH MeponpHHTHii: no cfiopy H no~rOTOBKe ~oKyMeHToB H HH4>opMa~HH ~JIH CqeTHOH nanarar P<l>

(no BTOpOM)' nonpocy I1epeqIDI MepOnpH5ITHM no cfiopy H uoztrorosxe ,n;OKYMeHTOB H HH<!>0pMa:U;HH ,n;n5I CqeTHOM nanarsr P<!»

1 n;eJIh nposepxn

Y CTaHOBneHHe 06ocHoBaHHocTH npoexrnsrx peIIIeHHM H CMeTHblX pac-reroa

B I1C,[( no TC «BCTO», B r.x. axcneprnsa I1C,[(:

1.1 na COOTBeTCTBHe TeXHHqeCKOMY 3a,n;aHHIO; 1.2 na nOJIHOTY H KOMnJIeKTHOCTb;

1.3 aa COOTBeTCTBHe HopMaTHBHoM ,n;OKYMeHTa:U;HH no npoeKTHpoB'aHHIO H CTpOHTeJIbCTBY;

1.4 na ofiocaonanaocrr, IIpHMeHeHH5I CMeTHblX pacnenox H

K03<!><!>H:U;HeHToB;

1.5 aa npaKTHqeCKYIO Heo6xo,n;HMOCTb 3annaHHpOBaHHbIX parior; 1.6 na COOTBeTCTBHe PbIHOqHbIM :u;eHaM (nensr aa MTP);

1.7 aa COOTBeTCTBHe KOJIHqeCTBa npezrycsrorpenasrx npoexron MTP ,n;eMcTBHTeJIbHbIM nOTpe6HOCT5IM H 06'beMaM pafior;

1.8 na COOTBeTCTBHe YCTaHOBJIeHHoMY nOp5I,n;KY npOBe,n;eHH5I 3KcnepTH3bI H YTBep)K,n;eHH5I I1C)J; B pafiory;

1.9 na COOTBeTCTBHe npoexrmrx peIIIeHHM ,n;eMcTBHTeJIbHbIM nOTpe6HOCT5IM, na HaJIHqHe CYIl.(eCTBeHHbIX He,n;OCTaTKOB H OIIIH6oK;

1.10 na ofiocaonaaaocrs H caoeapexreanocn, OnJIaTbI.

2 Cocran pa60qeH rpyrmsr

Kopneesa E.A. - Be,n;YIl.(HM cne:U;HaJIHCT KAO <!>HJIHarra 000 «Tpancaeqrn, <I>HHaHc» B r.H'Hosropon;

E3epCKa5I H.H. HaqanbHHK ornerra ztoroaopos

OAO «I'anporpyoonpoaon»;

THTOBa M.K. 3aMeCTHTeJIb na-ransmnca OT,n;eJIa

OAO «Tnnporpyoonposon»;

III rl ! ,I

Fopes B.r. - sanccrarem, nasansmrxa Ilpanonoro ynpaBneHl15I - HaqanhHHKIOpH,IlJlqeCKOrO OT,IJ;ena OAO «AK «Tpaacnerprs»;

,IJ,eMH,IJ;OB n.B. rnaBH.bIH IOPHcKoHcyn.bT ropH,IJ;HqeCKOrO OT,IJ;ena

Ilpasoaoro ynpannenaa OAO «AK «Tpaacnerprr,»;

Pycn5IKOB H.M. - 3aMeCTHTenh zrapexropa ,IJ;enapTaMeHTa «CnY)K6a 6e30naCHOCTH» - aaaansnmc OT,IJ;ena 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30nacHocTH OAO «AK «Tpancnedm,» ;

)KaBopoHKOB <p.E. - rnaansrli cnennanacr ornena 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30nacHocTH OAO «AK «Tpaacneqm,»,

BOn5IHCKHH II.,IJ,. - 3aMeCTHTen.b na-ransmrxa rrpOH3BO,IJ;CTBeHHoro OT,IJ;ena OAO «AK «Tpancnedrri,»;

Pa,IJ;qeHKO E.5I. - aanansnax OT,IJ;ena 3KOnOrHqeCKOH: 6e30nacHocTH H paunoaam.aoro npHpO,IJ;OnOn.b30BaHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacneqm,»;

IOraH: C.H. - rnaBHbIH: cneuaanacr OT,IJ;ena nenonoro KOHTP0J151 OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,»;

Tepexos ,IJ,.A. - 3aMeCTHTenh na-ransnaxa OT,IJ;ena crparera-recxoro pa3BHTH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»;

I03e<poBHg A.B. - 3aMeCTHTenh naaam.aaxa ornena aayvao-rexaaaecxoro ofiecrreaeaaa H HopMaTHBHoH ,IJ;OKYMeHTall;HH OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs».

~

, i

I

l I

3 Pe3YJIhTaThI npoaepxa

Pa6o-qeH: rpynrroa nposeztena pafiora no nposepxe ,IJ;OKYMeHTaU;HH H ,IJ;aHHhIX no npoeKTHpoBaHHIO ofisexros «Tpy6onpOBo,IJ;Ha5I CHCTeMa Bocroxaaa CH6HPh - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBhIH nycxosoa KOMlrneKC»H «Pacnrapeaae Tpy6onpOBo,IJ;HOH CMCTeMhI Bocrosnaa CM6MPh - THXIIH: OKeaH (BCTO)>> B COOTBeTCTBMH C PacnOp5I)KeHMeM OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» N2 22 OT 12.08.2008 II «Ilepexnea MeporrpmITHH no cfiopy H nO,IJ;rOTOBKe ,n;oKYMeHToB H HHtP0pMaU;HH ,n;n5I C-qeTHoH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH: <Pe,IJ;epau;HH», YTBep)K,IJ;eHHhIM npe3H,IJ;eHToM OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» 23.07.2008r.

Fenepansnsra no,n;p5I,n;QHKOM no npoeKTHpOBaHHIO ofiscrcron

«Tpyoonponozmaa CHCTeMa BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPh - TIIXHH OKeaH. ITepBhIH nycKOBOH: KOMnneKC» H «Pacnrapeane rpyoonposonnoa CHCTeMhI BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPh - THXHH: OKeaH (BCTO)>> 5IBn5InC5I OAO BHI111CT. B paspafiorxc

pa6o-qeH: ,n;OKYMeHTaU;MH npHHHManH y-racrae npoexraue IIHCTIITYThI:

OAO «I'anporpytionposozr», <pHnHan OAO «Fnnporpyfonposozr»

«Caaaparanporpytionposozr», <pHnHaJJ OAO «I'arrporpyoorrpoaozt»

«Y cparHnpoTPy6onpOBO,n;», OAO «I1HCTHTYT «Hedrrerasnpoexr», 3AO «I-ll1Ill1 «I1H)Kleo», 3AO «III1PC», 000 «CB5I3hKOMnneKC» H zrpyrae.

ITo pesynsrarav nposenenasrx MepOnpH5ITHH COCTaBneHhI 11 nozmacansr KOMneTeHTHhIMH sxcrrepraxrn COOTBeTcTByroIIJ;He npcroxonsr, cnpasxa H aKThI KOMHCCHOHHhIX npoaepox, npnsezreaasre B npHnO)KeHH5IX HaCTOJIIIJ;erO OTQeTa.

~,

I

II f' i

r.

,

,

i ..

F;

1 :

f,

~il

~: '

I

\ ;

[h

1 :

'.

~~~:

( .'

3.1 Pe3YflbTaTbI 3KcnepTH3bI DCLI Ha COOTBeTCTBHe TexHw:£ecKoMY 3a,gaHHIO

~

) i

, 1

F

1

i

1 )

CBe.IJ,eHH5.f 06 yraepsciemnrx TeXHHBeCKHX 3 a.IJ, aHH5.f X na npOeKTHpOBaHHe 06'beKTOB «Tpy6onpOBO.IJ,Ha5.f CHCTeMa BOCTOBHa5.f CI16HPb - THXHH OKeaH. ITepBbIH nYCKOBOH KOMnfleKC» H «Pacmapenae Tpy6onpOBO.IJ,HOH CHCTeMbI BOCTOBHa5.f CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH», npI1Be.IJ,eHbI B Ilporoxone nposepxa N~ 1- IUIBCI2008 OT 27.08.2008 (npanoaceaae 1 HaCT05.fIII;erO or-rera),

B XO.IJ,e npoeKTHpOBaHH5.f 06'beKTOB no npoexraxr «Tpyfionposonaas CHCTeMa BOCTOBHa5.f CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). DepBbIH nycxosoir KOMnfleKC» H «Pacnmpeaae 'rpyfiorrpononaoti CHCTeMbI Bocro-raas CH6Hpb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)>> 000 «llYIT BCTO» ocyurecrsnanacs BHyTpeHHAA sxcneprasa ITC,lJ; aa COOTBeTCTBHe Tpe6oBaHH5.fM 3a,n;aHH5I na npoexrapoaanae.:a raroxe rocyztapcraenaaa sxcneprasa ITC,lJ;.

3KcnepTH3a ITC,lJ; nposonanacs B COOTBeTCTBHH C «PerJIaMeHTOM CPOpMHpOBaHH5.f nnana III1P, BbI,n;aBH 3a,n;aHHH na rrpoexraposanae, pa3pa60TKH H 3KcnepTH3bI ITC,n; ,n;JI5.f CTpOHTeJIbCTBa, TeXHHBeCKoro rrepesoopyaceaaa, peKOHCTpYKIJ;HH H KanHTaJIbHOrO peMOHTa 06'beKTOB OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs» H ,n;eHCTBYIOIII;HM B 000 «L(YTI BCTO» «Pernaaearosr opraHH3aIJ;HH pa60TbI no npOBe,n;eHHIO 3KcnepTH3bI ITC,lJ; B 000 «L(YIT BCTO».

ITo pe3YJIbTaTaM nposepxn BbUIBJIeHO, BTO no 2 06'beKTaM CBO,n;HbIe sxcneprasre 3aKJIIOBeHH5.f 000 «IJYI1 BCTO» OTCYTCTBYIOT.

B npoexre He npezrycuorpeasr B ,n;OCTaTOBHOH Mepe B,n;OJIbTpaCCOBbIe npoesnu, asronopora K JIHHeHHbIM 3a,n;BH)l{KaM H Y3JIaM nycxa, rrpaexra H rrponycxa CO,lJ;, a rarose rrocazronnsre BepTOJIeTHble nnonramca, B TO spexra, KaK B cxterax na npoexrasre pa60TbI, sarparsr na npoexraposaaae, 3THX, B3aHMOHCKJIIOBaIOIIJ;HX zrpyr ,n;pyra 06'beKTOB, 3aJIO)l{eHbI.

CMeTHa5.f ,n;OKYMeHTaIJ;H5I Tpe6oBaHH5.fM 3a,n;aHH5.f na npoexrnpoaaaae He COOTBeTcTByeT H rpefiyer KoppeKTHpOBKH.

Pe3YJIbTaTbI rtposepxa TIC,lJ; na COOTBeTCTBHe Tpe60BaHHH TeXHHBeCKHX 3a,n;aHHH npnneztensr B MaTepHaJIaX KOMHCCHOHHbIX rrponepox no ,n;aHHbIM sonpocaa (npHJIO)l{eHHe 1, rrpHJIO:>KeHHe 3 nacroanrero OTQeTa).

~

! '. , .1

~ ~

I '

PI

( "

3.2 Pe3YflbTaTbI 3KcnepTH3bI TICll Ha nOJIHoTY H KOMnJIeKTHOCTb

Ii

I

! '

Il!

I I

( 1

t·"

,

I

~

t)

~~'.' l

( :

L .. ~ I

, '

B xozre pa60TbI KOMHCCHH rrposezreaa nposepxa COCTaBa, KOMnJIeKTHOCTH H COCT05.fHH5.f xpaaenna pa60QeH ,n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH no npoexry «Tpyfionposoztnaa CHCTeMa BOCTOBHa5.f CH6Hpb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). TIepBbIH nycxosoa KOMnJIeKC» H «Pacrnapenae rpyfionpoaonaoji CHCTeMbI Bocroxaaa CH6HPb ~ THxHH,oKeaH (BCTO)>>.

TIOJIHbIH COCTaB 06'beKTOB no rrpoexry «Tpytionpoaozmaa CHCTeMa BOCTOBHa5.f CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH. TIepBbIH nYCKOBOH xoxmnexc» H «Pacmnpenae rpyrionpoaonaoji CHCTeMbI BOCTOBHa5.f CH6HPb - THXHHOKeaH», pa3pa60TaHHbIX no paCCMaTpHBaeMbIM B xozte rrposepxa ztoronopaxr C OAO BHJ1I1CT, He npezrocraanen.

COCTaB npoexra no KmK,n:OMY npoexrnpyeaovy 06'beKTY He npeziocraanea, OIJ,eHKa COCTaBa pa60l.JeH ,n:OKYMeHTaU;HH no KmK,n:OMY 06'beKTY (nOTY) rrpn npaexnce OT nonpaznn,rx npoexrnsrx opraHH3aU;HH nposozmnacs pa60THHKaMI1 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» na COOTBeTCTBHe naxnazmoii,

B xozre npOBe,n:eHH5I nposepxa YCTaHOBneHO HaJIHl.JHe B apxase 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» ITC,I.( no 52 06'beKTaM (noraxi), pa3pa60TaHHoM B pavxax HcnOnHeHH5I ,n:oroBopHbIX 065I3aTenbcTB no ,n:ononHHTenbHoMY cornaIIIeHHIO N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ,I.(oroBoPY renepam.noro nonpana N2 336/14/03 OT 29.08.2003 na BbITIOnHeHHe npoeKTHO-H3bICKaTenbCKHX pa60T H asropcxoro naztsopa Me)l{,n:y OAO «AK «Tpancnedrn,» H OAO BHI1I1CT H ztorosopy nonpana na nsmorrneaae npoeKTHO-H3bICKaTenbCKHX pa60T N2 P 0855/2IL(YI1I111/06/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 MelK,n:y OAO BHI1I1CT H 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO».

Cocras mpoexra no Ka)l{,n:OMY 06'beKTY (TOM 0) BbI5IBneH B apxase 000 «IJ;YIT «BCTO» no 11 npoexrapyensna 06'beKTaM. TIo 41 npoexrapyexroray 06'beKTY COCTaB pa60l.JeH ,n:OKYMeHTaU;HH Ou;eHHBaJIC5I no CBO,n:HOH Be,n:OMOCTH OCHOBHbIX KOMlmeKTOB pa60l.JHX l.JepTe)l{eH (npa HaJIHl.JHH) HnH naxnanaoii, no KOTOPOM ,n:aHHa5I ,n:OKYMeHTaU;H5I npHHHMaJIaCb 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO».

ITC,n: pasaerneaa B apxase TIC,n: 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» (na rrony H crennazcax). CMeTHa5I ,n:OKYMeHTaU;H5I B apXHB na xpanenae He nepezraerca H xpaHHTC5I ornensao B CMeTHOM orztene 000 «I(YITBCTO». 3neKTpOHHbIH apXHB TIC,n: He C<P0pMHpOBaH.

06r.u;a5I onacs npoeKTHO-CMeTHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaIJ,HH sa 6YMa)l{HOM H :meKTpOHHOM HOCHTene, aaxoaameaca na xpaaeaaa B 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO», He C<pOpMHpOBaHa. ,I.(oKYMeHTaU;H5I BapXHBe l.JaCTHl.JHO He CTPYKTypHpOBaHa H He onacarra. I13MeHeHH5I, BHOCHMble B IIC,n; npoeKTHbIMH HHCTHZYTaMH, XpaH5ITC5I B apxase orztensao H B OCHOBHOH KOMnJIeKT IIC,n; He BHOC5ITC5I.

B nponecce npHeMKH TIC,n; OT nonpszmux npoexrnsrx opraHH3a:U;HH 000 «I(YII BCTO» npOH3Bo,n:HTC5I xoarpons COCTaBa rrpencraanaeaoii ,n:OKYMeHTaIJ,HH no HaKna,n:HbIM, xoarpons COCTaBa npoeKTHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaIJ,HH no COCTaBY npoexra (TOMY 0) He npOBo,n:HTC5I. Konrpons COOTBeTCTBH5I ztonomrarensno npencraanaesrsrx no,n:p5I,n:HbIMH npoeKTHbIMH opraHH3aU;H.5IMH 3K3eMnn5IpOB IIC,n; H3Hal.JanbHO npencraaneaaoa ,n:OKYMeHTau;HH, na KOTOpyIO nonyaeno nonoaorrensaoe sxcnepnroe 3aKnIOl.JeHHe 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» He npOBo,n:MTC5I. Korrrporrs COOTBeTCTBH5I npezrcrasnsewsrx nonpxzmsrsm npoeKTHbIMH opraHH3a:U;H5IMH 3neKTpOHHbIX BepCHH IIC)); 3K3eMnn5IpaM IIC,n; na 6YMa)l{HOM HOCHTene He npOBo,n:HTC5I. Konrpom, COOTBeTCTBH5I <popMaTOB ,n:aHHbIX M KOnHqeCTBa 3K3eMnJI5IpOB 3neKTpOHHbIX BepCHH IIC,n; na COOTBeTCTBHe Tpe6oBaHH5IM YTBep)l(JJ:eHHOrO 3a,n:aHH5I na rrpoexraposaaae He npOBo,n:HTC5I.

B 000 «WIT BCTO» ocyr.u;eCTBn5IeTC5I apxnnnoe xpanenne 1 3K3eMnn5Ipa IIC,n; no npoexrav «Tpytionposoztnaa CHCTeMa BocTol.JHa5I CH6HPb - THxHH OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBbIH nycxosoii KOMnneKC» H «Pacnmpenae rpytiorrposonnoii CHCTeMbI Bocro-maa CH6HPb - THxHH OKeaH (BCTO)>>. ITpOqHe 3K3eMnn5IpbI IIC,n: 6bIJIH rrepezraasr B 000 «Bocroxnerprenponozr», OAO «Fnnporpyfionpoaon», no,n:p5I,n:HbIM OpraHI13aU;H5IM H opranaaarraav, ocyr.u;ecTBJI5IIOI.IJ;HM rexaansop na

r r

( .

r

( .

f

\

,

!.

4

~

. j ;_J

ofisexrax BCTO C OcpOpMneHHeM COOTBeTCTBYIOII(HX aKTOB nepeztaau

,n;OKYMeHTOB WHJ1I1 HaKna,[(HbIX.

,n;OKYMeHTbI, nO,n;TBep)I(,n;aIOII(He cpaKT nOJIYQeHH5I TIC)], na rrepsorrasanr.noe paCCMOTpeHHe 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» OTCYTCTBYIOT.

Komrsecrao KHHr pa60qeH ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HH no npoexrax, «Tpytionposonnaa CHCTeMa "BOCTOIIHa5I CH6HPb- THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO) TIepBbIH nYCKOBOH KOMnneKC», «PaCIIIHpeHHe TC BCTO» no COCTaBY npoexra 6953 IlIT., no <PaKTY HaH,n;eHo 6861 KHHra. Kpoxre Toro, B apxase xpaHHTC5I 31 KHHra, OTCYTcTBYIOII(a5I B COCTaBe npoexra.

TOM 0 npencraanen no 11 o6beKTaM (JIOTaM) H3 52, B T.q. no 2 06'beKTaM (JIOTaM) no neperpaccnponxa neqrrenponona BCTO. Bee 11 TOMOB 0 He COOTBeTCTBYIOT YCTaHOBneHHbIM Tpe6oBaHWIM.

Cnpasxa 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX aHaJJH3a TOMOB 0 no rrpoexry «Tpytionpoaoriaas CHCTeMa Bocro-maa CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). TIepBbIH nYCKOBOH KOMnJIeKC» H «PaCIlIHpeHHe rpyfionposozmoa CHCTeMbI Bocro-maa CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)>> rrpaseztena B npHJIO)I(eHHH 2 npOTOKOJIa rrposepxa NQ 1- lJ,TIBCI2008.

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM nposepxn ocpopMJIeHH5I TIC,n; YCTaHOBJIeHO, qTO 60JIee qeM K 30% KOMnJIeKTOB TIC,n; HMeIOTC5I 3aMeqaHH5I no odiopxoremno ,n;oKYMeHTaI(HH. BbI5IBJIeH TaK)I(e P5I,n; THnHqHbIX 3aMeqaHHH K TIC,n;. Pe3YJIbTaTbI nposepxa npaaeztensr B npOTOKOJIe nponepxn N2 l-I01BC12008 OT 27.08.2008.

B COOTBeTCTBRH C npe,n;cTaBJIeHHbIMH 000 «uYTI BCTO» HaKJIa,n;HbIMH no 26 06'beKTaM (JIOTaM) H3 52 ,n;oKYMeHTaI(H5I na 6YMa)I(HOM HOCHTeJIe npencraaneaa B MeHbilleM KOJIHlfeCTBe 3K3eMnJI5IpOB, qeM YKa3aHO B yrseparneaasrx 3a,n;aHH5IX na npoexraposaaae (neaononyseno OT 1 zro 6 3K3. TIC,n;).

,n;aHHbIe 0 cpaKTHqeCKOM KOJIHqeCTBe 3K3eMnJ15IpOB H <p0pMaTax 3JIeKTpOHHbIX sepcati npHH5ITOH 000 «uYTI BCTO» TIC,n; TeXHHqeCKOH ,n;HpeKI(HeH 000 «uYTI BCTO» ,n;JI5I rrposepxa He npe,n;OCTaBJIeHbI. 3aKJIIOqeHHe o KOMnJIeKTHOCTH H COOTBeTCTBHH TIC,n; na 3JIeKTpOHHOM HOCHTeJIe Tpe6oBaHH5IM 3a,n;aHH5I na npoexraposanae npOH3BeCTH HeB03MO)I(HO.

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM BbI6opOlfHOH nposepxa HMeIOII(eHC5I nc,n; na

3JIeKTpOHHOM HOCHTeJIe qneHaMH KOMHCCHH YCTaHOBJIeHO HeCOOTBeTCTBHe KOJIHlfeCTBa 3K3eMrrJ15IpOB TIC,n; na 3JIeKTpOHHOM HOCHTeJIe H <popMaTOB ,n;aHHbIX 3JIeKTpOHHbIX BepCHH nc,n; Tpe6oBaHH5IM YTBep)I(,n;eHHbIX 3a,n;aHHH na npoexraposaaae. He CMOTP5I aa YKa3aHHe B pazre 3a,n;aHHH na npoercrapoaaaae Tpe60BaHHH 0 nepezrase 1 KOMnJIeKTa TIC,n: na 3JIeKTpOHHOM HOCHTeJIe no p5I,ZI;y 06'beKTOB B anpec 000 «Bocroxaeqrrenposon» YKa3aHHa5I ,n;OKYMeHTaI(H5I no 3aKJIIOlfeHHIO npe,n;CTaBHTeJI5I 000 «BOCToKHeqJTenpOBO,ZI;» He nocrynana.

KOMnJIeKTHOCTb CMeTHOH ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HH orpaxeaa B TIpoTOKOJIe nposepxa NQ 2-L(TIBC/2008 (rrpHJIO)I(eHHe 2 HaCT05III(erO or-rera).

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM aHaJJH3a cMeTHoH ,ZI;OKYMeHTaI(HH no 06'beKTY

«PacIIIHpeHHe TC BCTO. Ysacrox N2 3 (Tarraxancxoe MeCTOpO)I(,ZI;eHHe - r. AJI,n;aH). JIHHeHHa5I lfaCTb 1372,4KM - 1474KM» YCTaHOBJIeHO HeCOOTBeTCTBHe cMeTHoH ,ZI;OKYMeHTaI(HH 3AO HI1IlJiI "I1H)I(reO" C60pHHKaM CneI(HcpHKaI(HH H Be,lJ.OMOCT5IM 06'beMOB pafior.

~

.

I

I, ,I

fJ

\ '1

I ,I

i .

I ..

.Ll

B xozte nposepxn TaK)J(e nposenena ouenxa KOMrrJIeKTHOCTH MaTepHaJIOB HH)J(eHepHhIX H3hICKaHHI1, t:(OH H T30 no npoexraxr «Tpyoonpcsozmas CHCTeMa BOCTOlJHa5I CH6HPh - THXHI1 OKeaH (BCTO). TIepBhIH nycxosoii KOMrrJIeKC» H «Pacurapenae rpyfiorrposonaoit CHCTeMhI BocTolJHa5I CH6HPh - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO)), Haxo,n;5IIQHXC5I na xpanemra B apxnne 000 «l_"(YTI BCTO». Pe3YJIbTaThI nposepxa npaaezrensr B npOTOKOJIe nponepxn N2 1-IJ,IIBC/2008 OT 27.08.2008.

~

.

(

3.3 Pe3YJIhTaThI 3KcnepTH3hI TICll Ha· npaKTH~ecKyIO Heo6xo,UHMOCTh 3anJIaHHpOBaHHhIx npoeKToM pa6oT, COOTBeTCTBHe npoeKTHhIX peIIIeHHB: ,UeHcTBHTeJIhHhIM nOTpe6HOCT5IM, cTpOHTeJIhHhIM H 3KCnJIyaTaUHoHHhIM CTaH)!apTaM POCCHHCKOH <De,n;epaUHH no Tpy6orrpOBO,n;HOM)' rpaHcnopT)'

fl

i.

r

l .!

t it-

I .

TIo pe3YJIhTaTaM nposepxa JIOTOB N2N2 1-5, 16, 27-29, ID1C N2 1, N2 4, N221 no «I-MY nycxoaoxry KOMnJIeKcy ... » H JIOTOB N2N2 1-16, N2N2 22-27, HTIC N2 8, N2 10, N2 14, N2 17 no «PacIIIHpeHHIO ... » B nepBOHa~aJIhHyIO TICt:( BHeceHO 3254 H3MeHeHH5I. Hs HHX:

-724 IIIT. BhI3BaHhI OIIIH6KOH npoeKTHpoBIII;HKa;

- 1069 IIIT. He ,n;OCTaTO~HOH npopa60TKOH TeXHHlJeCKHX peIIIeHHH;

- 772 IIIT. C YTBep)J()!eHHeM HOBOH HTt:( HJIH H3MeHeHHH K HeB:;

- 689 IIIT. aa OCHOBaHHH peIIIeHHH TeXHH~eCKHX COBeTOB OAO «AK

«Tpaacaeqm,», 000 «L(YTI BCTO», OAO BHI1I1CT H 000

«Bocroxaedrrenposon» .

1. B xozre 3KcnepTH3hI TIC,n; BhI5IBJIeHhI OIIIH6KH H He,n;OCTaTKH npoexraposaaaa, a HMeHHO:

• Heco6JIIO,n;eHHe Tpe60BaHHH «TIpaBHJI 3KCnJIyaTaU;HH 3JIeKTpoycTaHoBoK» B lJaCTH He COOTBeTCTBH5I 3arrpoeKTHpOBaHHhIX pasxrepon 6JIOK-60KCOB IIKY.

• He)!OCTaTO~Hoe KOJIH~eCTBO HH)J(eHepHOH 3aIIJ;HThI Tpy6orrpOBo,n;a,

BbI5IBHBIIIeHC5I B npou;ecce CTpOlITeJIhCTBa no)! B03,n;eHCTBHeM BHeIIIHHX npHpO,l1;HhIX 5IBJIeHHH (pa3MhIBhI CKJIOHOB H nOJIOK, OnOJI3HH H T.,U.).

• He npaBHJIhHOe onpeneneaae xareropaa Y'laCTKOB rrpOXO)J(,l1;eHIUI uerprenponozra, nOBJIeKIIIee aa C060H rrepecner TOJIIu;HHhI CTeHKH Tpy6hI B CTOPOHY YBeJIHlJeHH5I.

• Heo6xo,l1;HMOCTh )!OnOJIHHTeJIhHOrO c1poHTeJIhCTBa JIe)J(HeBhIX zropor ,l1;JI5I npOe3,l1;a c1poHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH H ztocrasxn MaTepHanoB.

• Heo6xo,l1;HMOCTh YCTaHoBKH ,l1;OnOJIHHTeJIhHhIX BaHTY30B ,l1;JI5I sarrycxassmycxa nosztyxa, npa npOBe)!eHHH pa60T no OTKa~Ke H 3anOJIHeHHIO rpyfionposona aedrrsro.

• He C06JIIO,l1;eHHe Tpe60BaHHH HTt:( B ~aCTH YCTaHOBKH BaHTY30B ,UJI5I sanycxa H BhIIIYCKa noszryxa na MaKCHMaJIhHbIX BhICOTHhIX TO~Kax TpaCChI MH.

~

I .

l •

~

I

• necaoeapevenaoe nOJIYlJeHHe TeXHH~eCKHX YCJIOBHH OT OAO

«Cypryraedrreras» nOBJIeKIIIHH ,l1;OnOJIHHTeJIhHhIH 06'beM pa60T no cTpOHTeJIhCTBY nepexozrcs lJepe3 KOMMYHHKaU;HH na Tanaxaacxoe MecTopo)J(,l1;eHHe.

2. K He,n:OCTaTKaM rrpoeKTHpOBaHH5I MO)KHO OTHeCTH:

• He npopafioraaaocrs sonpoca aannrrsr rpyoonposona OT 06pmOBaHH5I BM5ITHH rrpn YKJIa,n:Ke B TpaHIIIeIO B CKaJIbHbIX rpyrrrax.

• He KaLIeCTBeHHoe nposenenae HH)KeHepHO-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T B LIaCTH

onpeneneaaa OrrTHMaJIbHbIX xrapnrpyron ,n:OCTaBKH CTpOHTeJIbHbIX

MaTepHaJIOB na rpaccy TC BCTO.

• He KaLIeCTBeHHoe npoaeztenae HH)KeHepHO-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T B LIaCTH onpeneneaas MeCT pacrrOJIO)KeHH5I xapsepos C rpYHTOM, ru:e6HeM H nrc B6nH3H 30HbI CYpOHTenbCTBa TC BCTO H HX ljJaKTHlleCKHX sarracoa.

• H3MeHeHHe ren. nnaaos nnonranox HTIC, CB5I3aHH1Ie C rrepeTpaCCHpOBKOH

cereii KaHaJIH3aL(HH H Bo,n:OCHa6)KeHH5I.

• H3MeHeHHe rrnaHHpOBKH HaCOCHOH CTaHL(HH 060pOTHoro Bo,n:OCHa6)l<:eHH5I.

• H3MeHeHHe cxev H nnaaos pacnOnO)KeHH5I xosmpeccopnoro 6nOKa.

• H3MeHeHHe ceres KaHaJIH3au:HH H sononposona B paiioae xosmpeccopnof CTaHL(HH.

• B nC,lJ; ztofiaanenn 6nOLIHble nyHKT1I rroztorpesa nosnyxa zrna ~BHraTeneH HaCOCOB OTKaLIKH aedrra H3 PBC.

• H3MeHeHHe nocazuca HaCOCOB OTKa"tJKH H3 PBC-3000 I-llIC N2 4.

2. B L(enOM pa3pa60TaHHa5I nC,lJ; no «I-MY nycxososry xoxrrrnexcy ... » H no «PacIIIHpeHHro ... » coorsercrsyer ,n:eHcTBHTen1HlIM nOTpe6HOCT5IM, crpoarensasne H 3KcnnyaTaL(HOHHbIM craanaprax POCCHHCKOH <l>e,n:epaL(HH no Tpy6onpOBO,n:HOMY TpaHcnopTY, sa HCKnIOLIeHHeM cnyaaes orosopeansrx BbIIIIe no TeKCTY·

3. KOMHccHeH OTMeLIeHO, LITO B apxane 000 «WIT BCTO» OTCYTCTBYIOT ,n:OCTOBepHbIe onHCH COCTaBa npoeKTHO-CMeTHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaL(HH H H3MeHeHHH K HeH. Ha HaLIaJIO nposepxa rronHOCTbIO OTCYTCTBOBaJIH orraca no «I nycxososry xoxmnexcy ... » H HTIC.

4. MMeIOTC5I cnYLIaH napynrenati ycraaoaneaaoro nopxznca npOBe,n:eHH5I BHYTpeHHeH sxcrrepraasr nC,lJ; CrreL(HaJIHCTaMH 000 «uvn BCTO».

5. MMeroTC5I cnYLIaH xpaHeHH5I He aHHynHpoBaHHbIX H3MeHeHHH, no cpaKTY 3aMeHeHHbIX HOBbIMH.

6. B 000 «uYn BCTO» rrpHHHMaIOTC5I aa paccxrorpemre BHYTpeHHeH

3KcnepTH3bI H3MeHeHH5I K nC,lJ; 6e3 ,n:OKYMeHTOB, 060CHOBbIBaroru:HX

Heo6xo,n:HMOCTb HX BHeCeHH5I B npoeKTHYIO ,n:OKYMeHTaL(Hro.

7. no peaynsraraa B1I6opOLIHOH rrpoaepxn nc,lJ; CHrraMH KOMHCCHH TaK)Ke OTMeLIeHbI cnezryrounre He,n:OCTaTKH:

7.1 B nC,lJ; no 06'beKTaM «Tpyfionpoaozmaa CHCTeMa BocToLIHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH. Ilepnsni rrYCKOBOH KOMnneKC» H «PaCIImpeHHe Tpy6onpOBo,n:HOH CHCTeMbI BOCTOLIHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaR» He npezrycraorpear.r B ,n:OCTaTOLIHOH xrepe aztonsrpacconsre npoesnsr H nocano-rasre sepronernsre nJIOII.J;a,n:KH . YLIHTbIBa5ICnO)KHble npnpozmsre reonora-recxae H KnHMaTIfLIeCKHe oco6eHHOCTH npOXO)I(,n:eHH5I 'rpaccsr MarHCTpaJIbHOrO rredrrenposona BCTO ,n:JI5I nposezrenaa TeXHHLIeCKoro 06cnY)I(HBaHH5I xramcrpam-noro nedrrenposorra na rrpOT5I)I(eHHOCTH 0-2620 KM rro sxcnepraca OL(eHKe pa60LIeH rpyrrrrsr neooxonaxo crpourenscrso

m ~ I :

I '

\ :

II f! I.

fL·

.

I ' I I \ I

It, ~ .

i \

[h

(

~~\ i

I .

fl

\

,

~l .~

t.

,

\ ,

~ ~ \

~,

1

~.

,

,

,lJ;onOJIHllTeJIhHO 1233 KM B,lJ;OJIhTpaCCoBhIX npOe3,lJ;OB II 143 ,lJ;onOJIHllTeJIhHhIX nocazro-nrsrx BepTOJIeTHhIX nnoutaaox,

7.2 no pe3YJIhTaTaM rtponepxn nC,lJ; no JIOTY 14 ztoroaopa noztpazta Me}K,n:y 000 «I(Yn BeTO» II OAO BHI1l1CT na BhII10JIHeHlle npoexrnoH3hICKaTeJIhCKllX pa60T N2 P 0855/2/L(YIT/ll1106/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 (Ilpoexraposanne YLIacTKa N2 2 Cr. ThIH,n:a - r. AJI,n;aH), KM 2202 - KM 2620. KM 2202 - KM 2420), paspafioramroii cy6no,n:p5I,n:Hoii oprauasanaef 3AO "I1HPC" B COOTBeTCTBllll C YTBep}I(,n;eHHhIM 3aKa3LIHKOM 3a,n:aHlleM aa npoexrapoaanae N2 6/H OT 25.05.2006 BhI5IBJIeHhI cneztyioutae HeCOOTBeTCTBll5I:

- H1l3Koe Ka"lJeCTBO nposeneaaa llH}I(eHepHO-1l3hICKaTeJIhCKllX pa60T na ysacrxe I1IIJ\1H LIepe3 p. qYJIhMaKaH (KM 2336);

- H1l3Koe KaLIeCTBO npopafiorxa TeXHllLIeCKllX peureaaii B nC,lJ; no I1IIMH sepea p. qYJIhMaKaH (KM 2336).

Yxaaannue HeCOOTBeTCTBll5I rrpnaena K neofixoztaxrocrn neperpaccaponxn aedrrerrposona na npaaofiepexaoli xacra III1MH sepes p. qYJIhMaKaH, BKJIIOLIa5I nposeneaae ,n;onOJIHllTeJIhHhIX llH}I(eHepHO-1l3hICKaTeJIhCKllX pa60T CllJIaMH OAO «Farrporpytionposon» II xoppexraposxy rrpoexrno-csrernoti ,n;OKYMeHTaU;Hll C YLIeTOM ocotieaaocra crpoarenscrna nedrrerrposorra ua ysacrxax C orracasraa reonora-recxana 5IBJIeHll5IMll.

7.3 no pe3YJIhTaTaM aHaJI1l3a rexaaxecxax peurennit no CTpOllTeJIhCTBY BhICOKOBOJIhTHhIX JIllHllH snexrporrepezraaa BhI5IBJIeHhI onmfixa npoexraposaaaa no orropaxr ,n;JI5I cTpOllTeJIhCTBa BJI.

B CB5I311 C H3MeHeHlleM TeXHll"lJeCKllX pellIeHllii reHepaJIhHOii rrpoeKTHoH oprannsanaea (OAO BHI1I1CT) 3aMeHOH MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKllX orrop na )KeJIe306eToHHhIe onopsr BhI5IBJIeHhI CJIe,n;YIOID;lle cpaKT.bI, npaxaaaanme spezr 3KOHOMll"lJeCKllM HHTepeCaM Koxmaaaa:

- yaenaseaac CTOllMOCTll rpaacnoprasrx pacxonos npn ,n;OCTaBKe orrop na MeCTO crponrenscrsa (sec }I(eJIe306eToHHoH onopsr 1850 xr, sec MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKOii onopsr 300 xr);

- ysernrseaae CTOllMOCTll MOHTa}I(a onop rra MeCTe cTpOllTeJIhCTBa (sec )KeJIe306eToHHoH onopsr 1850 xr, sec MeTaJIJIllLIeCKOH onopsr 300 xr, rrpn nozrsecxe nposozra na MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKllX orropax cnerrrexaaxa He rrpllMeH5IeTC5I, npa MOHTa}I(e npoaozta na )KeJIe306eTOHHoii orrope neorixonmro rrpaxierremre MOHTa}I(HOii BbIIIIKH BbICOTOH 11 M);

- ysemrseaae CTOllMOCTll <i>YH,n;aMeHTa orrop (B <i>YH,n:aMeHTax

)KeJIe306eToHHbIX orrop rrpllMeH5IeTC5I CBa5I 113 rpyfisr 530 npa MllHllMaJIbHOH ronuraae CTeHKll 10 MM, B cpYH,n;aMeHTax MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKllX orrop rrpllMeH5IeTC5I rpytia ,n:llaMeTpOM 325 MM);

- coxpaureaae cpoxa CJIY}I(6bI orrop 60JIee "lJeM B 2 pasa B YCJIOBll5IX noneranaa .rpaccsr neqrrerrpcaozta BCTO (CpOK CJIY)K6hI MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKllX orrop OKOJIO 25 JIeT, }I(eJIe306eToHHbIX 8-10 JIeT);

- saasnueaae CTOllMOCTH cpYH,n;aMeHToB onop na CKaJIbHbIX II rJIbI60BbIX rpyrrrax rrpn npHMeHeHllll nOBepXHOCTHbIX CPYH,n:aMeHToB (ztna MeTaJIJIll"lJeCKllX onop npllMeH5IeTC5I llIBeJIJIep 80 MM, YCTaHOBKa )K/6 orrop na YKa3aHHbIX rpyrrrax aarpyzmcna) .

~

I "

Ha YLIaCTKe aerprenposozra 0-570 KM (JIOT 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ,lJ;onOJIH11TeJIhHOrO COrJIallIeH115I NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ~oroBopy renepansnoro nonpaaa Me)l(.n;y OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,» 11 OAO BHI1l1CT NQ 336114/03 OT 29.08.2003 na BhITIOJIHeH11e npoeKTHO-113hICKaTeJIhCKI1X pa60T 11 asropcxoro nazrsopa) no sxcrrepraoii oueaxe KOM11CC1111 np11MeHeHO .n;o 20% )I(eJIe306eToHHhIX onop, na YLIacTKe 1105- 2620 KM - 100% npaueneansrx TeXH11LIeCK11X pemcanii B B11.n;e )l(eJIe306eToHHhIx onop.

Ilepe-reas cyuiecraeansrx ollI116oK 11 He.n;OCTaTKOB npOeKT11pOBaHI15I TIC,I(, nOBJIeKllI11X K 113MeHeH11IO cMeTHoH CT011MOCT11 rrpasenen B npOTOKOJIe npOBepK11 NQ 1 npocxrao-caernoa .n;oKYMeHTaU;I1I1 no npoexry «Tpytionpoaozmaa C11CTeMa BOCTOLIHa5I CH611Ph - T11X11H OKeaH (BCTO). ilepBhIH rrycxonori KOMnJIeKC» 11 npoexry «PaCIII11peH11e TPy60npoBo.n;HOH C11CTeMhI "BoCTOLIHa5I C11611Ph - T11X11H oxean'' (BCTO)>> OT 28.08.2008 (np11JIO)l(eH11e 3 nacroanrero oTLIeTa) 11 ,l(onOJIHeH1111 Nd K TIPOTOKOJIY npOBepK11 NQl OT 28.08.2008 rrpoexrao-cvernoa ,L(OKYMeHTaU;1111 no npoexry «Tpy6onpOBO,L(Ha5I C11CTeMa BocToLIHa5I CH611Ph - T11X11H OKeaH (BCTO). Ilepasni nycxosoii KOMnJIeKC» 11 npoexry «Pacnrapeaae Tpy60npOBO,L(HOH C11CTeMhI "BoCTOLIHa5IC11611ph - T11x11H oxeaa" (BCTO)>> C np11JIO)I(eH115IM11 (np11JIO)I(eH11e 4 nacrosruero oTLIeTa).

~

;::1 i ,j

I,

~ II

3.2.4 Pe3YJIhTaThI 3KCnepT113hI TICll Ha 060cHoBaHHocTh np11MeHeH115I CMeTHhIX pacueHoK 11 K039?<P11U11eHTOB

~,

i, (1

CMeTHa5I ,L(OKYMeHTaU;I15I COCTaBJIeHa B COOTBeTCTB1111 co CMeTHOHopMaT11BHOH 6a30H rOCCTp05I POCCH11 (POCCYp05I). B XO,L(e npOBe,L(eH115I 3KCnepT113hI JIOKaJIhHhIX 11 06'heKTHhIX CMeT 06HapY)I(eH P5I,L( cynrecrsenaux 3aMeLIaH11H B LIaCT11 HenpaB11JIhHOrO np11MeHeH115I CMeTHhIX paCIJ;eHOK 11 K03<p<p11IJ;11eHTOB. BhI5IBJIeHhI Oill116K11 B pacxerax, BJIeKy.r.u;11e sa C060H 113MeHeHI1e CMeTHOH CT011MOCT11 CTp011TeJIhCTBa.

TIo pe3YJIhTaTaM npOBe,L(eHHOH BhI6opOLIHOH npOBepKI1 CMeTHOH:

,L(OKYMeHTaU;1111 pa60LIeH rpynnoii C,L(eJIaHhI CJIe,L(YIO.r.u;11e BhIBO,L(hI:

1. ilpoeKTHo-CMeTHa5I ,L(OKYMeHTaU115I np11Ka30M OAO «IJ;YTI «BCTO» YTBep)I(,L(eHa «B np0113BO,L(CTBO pa60T» H 11CnOJIh30BaHa npa onpe,L(eJIeH1111 CT011MOCT11 nO,L(p5I,L(HhIX pa60T ,L(JI5I npOBe,L(eHIDI KOHKypCHhIX ToproB no CMP.

2. 3aBhlilleH11e CMeTHOH: CT011MOCT11 no 06'heKTY B pe3YJIhTaTe

neofiocnonaanoro np11MeHeH115IKo3<pqmU;11eHTa 1,03 K CTOHMOCT11 MaTep11aJIOB 11 o6opY,L(OBaH115I no pe3YJIhTaTaM 3KcnepTHOH: OueHK11 06ocHoBaHHOCT11 np11MeHeH115I CMeTHhlX pacnenox 11 K03<P<P11U11eHTOB na npmrcpc 06'heKTa «Tpy6onpOBO,L(Ha5I C11CTeMa BOCTOLIHa5I C11611Ph - T11X11ll OKeaH. fIepBhIll rrycxonoii KOMnJIeKC. JI11HeHHa5I LIaCTh KM 130 - KM 239» COCTaB11JIO 64,3 MJIH. pyfi. (c H,l(C).

3. 3aBhlilleH11e cMeTHoH CT011MOCT11 no 06'heKTY B pe3YJIhTaTe

ap11cpMeT11LIeCK11X ollI1160K no pe3YJIhTaTaM sxcnepraoa Ou;eHK11 060cHoBaHHocTH np11MeHeH115I CMeTHhlX pacnenox 11 K03CPCP11U11eHTOB na npavepe 06'heKTa «Tpy6onpOBO,L(Ha5I C11CTeMa BOCTOLIHa5I C11611Ph - T11X11ll OKeaH. Ilepasm

.', ~ :

I , ( .,

F

I

~

~",

,

I '

~

,

,

i '

J.:

~

,

,

( ,

nYCKOBOH KOMl1JIeKC. JhIHeHHa5I -racrr. KM 2119-KM 2281» ysacrox KM 2119-KM 2195» COCTaBIfJIO 36,7 MJIH. py6. (c H)],C).

4.3aBhlmeHHe cMeTHoH CTOMMOCTM no o6beKTY 3a c-rreT HenpaBMflbHoro npMMeHeHH5I pac~eHoK no pe3YflbTaTaM 3KcnepTHoH o~eHKM 06ocHoBaHHocTM npMMeHeHM5I CMeTHblX pacnenox M K03<pcpM~HeHToB aa npMMepe ofir.exra «PacIIIHpeHHe BCTO. ffi1C N2 14» COCTaBMJIO 6,5 MJIH. py6. (c H)],C).

5. 3aBbIllIeHHe CMeTHOH CTOMMOCTM no o6beKTY sa cuer neooocaosaanoro npMMeHeHM5I n05ICHbIX K03CPCPM~MeHToB no <pCCo; 81-2001 -rraCTb 1 npan.Z K aarparav na aBToMo6MflbHble nepeB03KH rpY30B no pesynsraraa sxcnepraon onenxa 06ocHoBaHHocTM npMMeHeHM5I CMeTHblX pacueaox M K03cp<PM~MeHToB na nparaepe BbI6opo-rrHoro nosropnoro CMeTHoro pac-rera no6 o6beKTaM M3 52 COCTaBMflO 449,4 MJIH. py6. (c H)],C). Saasnnenae sarpar na TpaHcnopTMpoBKY rpY30B opHeHTMpOBO-rrHO B 2 pasa.

6. TIo pesyasrarav nposepxa flOTOB N2 N2 1-5, 16, 27-29, nne N2 1, N2 4, N2 21 no «I-MY nycxoaosry xoxrnnexcy ... » M flOTOB N~ N2 1-16, N2 N2 22-27, HIIC NQ 8, N2 10, N2 14, N2 17 no «Pacnrapemno ... » B rrepaouasarrsnyro TIC)], BHeceHO 3254 M3MeHeHM5I . Hs HMX 724 llIT. BbI3BaHbI OllIH6KOH npoexrapoauraxa; 106911IT. He nocrarosnoii npopa60TKOH TeXHM-rreCKHX penreaaii. Yaemmeaae CMeTHOH CTOMMOCTM CTpOMTefl.bCTBa 06beKTOB BCfle.n;CTBHe cymecrneaasrx OllIM6oK M He.n;OCTaTKOB npoeKTHpOBaHM5I no pe3YflbTaTaM 3KcnepTHOH o~eHKM M3MeHeHMH nC,IJ; sa rrepaozr C 2006 no 2008 ron (no 31 o6beKTY M3 52) COCTaBMflO 1 494,8 MJIH. py6.

3aMe-rraHM5I K CMeTHOH .n;OKYMeHTaU;MM no BceM paccsrorpemrsur B xozre rrposepxa ofisexraxs rrpnsezteasr IIpOTOKOfl rrponepxa N2 2- I(I1BC12008 cMeTHoH .n;oKYMeHTal(MM no npoexraxr «Tpyfiorrposomraa CHCTeMa BOCTO-rrHa5I CH6MPb - THxMH OKeaH (BCTO). Ilepasni rryCKOBOH KOMnJIeKC» M «Pacnrapeaae rpyfionposonaoii CMCTeMbI "Bocro-nraa CM6MPb - TMxHH OKeaH. (BCTO)>> OT 27.08.2008 (cMeT.bI, K03<P<PMl(MeHT.bI) (npanoaceaae 2 HaCT05Irn;erO or-rera),

3.2.5 Pe3YflbTaT.bI 3KcnepTM3.bI nCll Ha COOTBeTCTBMe PbIHO-rrH.bIM u;eHaM (u;eH.bI Ha MTP)

,IJ;fl5I onpenerreaaa COOTBeTCTBM5I CTOMMOCTM MTP B CMeTHOH

,l(OKYMeHTal(MM cpeznrepsraosnosry ypOBHIO paccsrorpema rpyrmsr ofiopyztcaaaaa:

Tpytisr MarMc1paJIbHble, rexrronoravecxac. -<PacoHHble M3.n;eflH5I.

-OTBO,l(bI rHYT.bIe .n;fl5I MarMc1paJI.bHbIX ueqrrenposonoa.

- 3a.n;BM)KKH C npMBo.n;aMM.

- EflOK-6oKC.bI.

-HaCOCbI.

. - Kafienn M npoBo.n;a.

-<PMJIb1pbI-rp5I3eYfloBHTemf, KaMepbI nycxa - rrpnexra CO)],.

-CMcTeMbI aBTOMaTMKH.

-3fleKTpoTeXHM-rrecKoe ofiopynoaaaae (KTTI, KPY, Il(CY).

~

f.I,

r

,

~,

'\' '

i

~ r--

t

~

I ( ! !

- EbICTpOB03BO,lJ;IiMble 3,n;aHIDI.

1. fIo rpynrraxr MTP: cj_)aCOHHble Ii3,n;eJIIDI rpytionponozros, OTBO,n;bI rnyrsre ,n;JI51 MarHCTpaJIbHbIX Hecj_)TerrpOBO,n;OB - CMeTHa51 CTOHMOCTb onpezrenena na OCHOBe l1paHC-JIHCTOB e,n;HHCTBeHHbIX rrpOH3Bo,n;HTeJIeH YK83aHHOH nponyxnaa, BKJIIOqeHHbIX B Peecrp TY H TT KOMrraHHH.

2. ITo rpyimaviMl'P: rpytisr MarHcTpaJIbHhIe, rpytisr TeXHOJIOrHtfeCKHe, 3a,n;BH)l{KH C rrpIIBo,n;aMH, <prY, KTIfI CO,D;, 6bICTpOB03BO,n;HMbIe 3,n;aHH5l, 3JIeKTpOTeXHHQeCKOe ofiopyztoaanae (KTfI, KPY), CMeTHa51 CTOHMOCTh onpezteneaa na OCHOBe KOMMepQeCKHX npennoarenaii H npaiic- JIHCTOB oznroro l1POH3Bo,n;HTeJI5l, 110CTaBID;HKa (CM. l1pHJIO)l{eHHe), CJIe,n;OBaTeJIbHO, CMeTHa5l CTOHMOCTb MTP He MO)l{eT paCCMm:pHBaTbC51, KaK cpe,n;He - PbIHOqHa5l.

3. Ilo rpynrraxr MTP: HaCOCbI MarHcTpaJIbHbIe, HaCOCbI nonrropasre, 6JIOK - 60KCbI, CHCTeMbI aBTOMaTHKH - CTOHMOCTb MTP B CMeTHOH ,n;OKYMeHTan;HH onpeztenanacs opHeHTHpOBOqHO na OCHOBe 3KCl1epTHOH onerrxa OAO BHI1I1CT (N2 963-12439 OT 02.05.2008) HarrpaBJIeHHOH B azipec 000 «I(YfI BCTO», TaKHM otipasoa, CTOHMOCTb MTP B fIC,D; He COOTBeTcTByeT cpezae-psnroaaosry ypOBHIO.

4. B npouecce paccxrorpeaaa CMeTHOH ,n;OKYMeHTan;HH BbI5lBJIeHbI, T.H. «KOMnJIeKTHbIe 110CTaBKH». B npencraaneaaax ,n;oKYMeHTax OTCYTCTByeT COCTaB KOMnJIeKTHbIX nOCTaBOK, a TaIOKe ,n;OKYMeHTbI, nonrsepacaaromae ofiocaoaaaaocrs onpezteneaaa HX CTOHMOCTH.

B pe3YJIbTaTe BbI6opOqHOH l1pOBepKH BbI5lBJIeH CJIe,n;yIOID;HH cj_)aKT. B ITC,D; no 06'beKTY «Ilepsaa osepezrs rpyfionposozraoti CHCTeMbI «BOCTOqHa5l CH6HPbTmGIH OKeaH». JIHHeHHa5l -racrs. HH)l{eHepHa51 sanrara. YqaCTOK KM 0 - KM 570» BKJIIOqeHO HeTKaHHoe reOTeKCTHJIbHOe nOJIOTHO Merarexc- TC300 B 'o6'beMe 60JIee 200 TbIC5l:q KB. MeTpOB co CTOHMOCTbIO OT 505 zto 850 pyfinca sa KBa,n;paTHbIH MeTp. B TO )l{e BpeM51 saxynxa BrIT Merarexc- TC3 00 npOH3Bo,n;HJIaCb B Mae 2006 rozta 000 «Oacxaedrrerascnencrpoa» no IJ;eHe 36 py6. sa KB. MeTp, OAO «Kracrpyoorrposoncrpon» no 30,55 py6. sa KB. MeTp.

B xozte nposeneana nposepxa npoaezteno BbI6opOQHOe cpasaeaae CTOHMOCTH MTP, BKJIIOQeHHbIX B ITC,n: co CTOHMOCTbIO HX saxynxn no cj_)aKTHQeCKH 3aKJIIOQeHHbIM KOHTpaKTaM no npoexry TC «BCTO». ITo pe3YJIbTaTaM BbI6opOQHOrO aHaJIH3a no n03Hn;H5lM MTP (TPy6a 1220, 1067 MM, MarHcTpanbHbIe H nozmopasre HaCOCbI, 3a,ZJ;BH)l{KH IIIH6epHbIe, 6bICTpOB03BO,n;HMbIe 3,n;aHH5l:, 6JIOK-6oKCbI fIKY, <t>ry, rcasrepsr CO)];, KTIT, CHCTeMbI aBTOMaTHKH H TeJIeMeXaHHKH) rrpeasnnerrae KOHTpaKTHoH nema Ha,n; neaoa MTP B l1C,l( COCTaBHJIO OT 0,16 zro 290,56% na 06ru;yIO CyMMy 363 MJIH. py6. C yaeroxi H,n;C.

~

! .

! I

It. if\

I

f

~

.

j

rL. ~

! •

~

.

.

! '

3.2.6 Pe3YJIbTaTbI 3KcrrepTH3bI fICll Ha COOTBeTCTBHe KOJIHqeCTBa rrpe)lycMoTpeHHblx npoeKToM MTP )leHCTBHTeJIbHbIM nOTpe6HOCT51M H 06'beMaM pa60T

fIo pe3YJIbTaTaM rrposepxa HaJIHtfIDI He BOCTpe6oBaHHbIX MTP (He HaIIIe,n;IlIHX B HaCT05l:ID;ee BpeM5I npHMeHeHIDI), HaxO)l5IIIJ;HXC51 na cxnaztax aa ofisexrax TC BCTO,

tL .. ~ :

!

otimaa CT011MOCTb rrOCTaBJIeHHOrO 11 HeBOCTpe6oBaHHOrO na HaCT05Ir.u;11M MOMeHT 060PY,lJ,OBaH115I 11 MaTep11aJIOBCOCTaB11JIa 81.5 MJIH. py6JIeii.

Pe3YJIbTaTbI 3KCrrepT113bI TIC,n: aa COOTBeTCTB11e KOJIJ11:reCTBa

npenycsrorpennsrx npoexroxi MTP ,lJ,eMCTB11TeJIbHbIM rroTpe6HOCT5IM 11 o6beMaM pa60T npanenemr B rrp11JIO)KeHI111 5 nacrosurero OTl.JeTa.

3.2.7 Pe3YJIbTaTbI 3KCnepT113bI ITCll Ha COOTBeTCTB11e YCTaHOBJIeHHoMY nOp5I,l!KY rrpoBe,l!eH115I 3KCnepT113bI 11 YTBep)KL(eH115I ITCLI B pa60TY

1) B XO,lJ,e rrpOeKT11pOBaH115I 06neKToB no npoexrav «Tpytionpoaozmaa C11CTeMa BocToLIHa5I C11611Ph - T11x11M OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBbIM rrycxoaoii KOMnJIeKC» H «PacIIIHpeH11e Tpy6orrpOBO,lJ,HOH C11CTeMhI BOCTOl.JHa5I C11611Pb - T11x11H OKeaH (BCTO)>> 000 «U;YTI BCTO» ocyr.u;eCTBJI5IJIaCb BHyTpeHHIDI 3KCrrepT113a IIC,n:, paccxrorpeaae IIC,n; na TeXHJ11feCKOM COBeTe 11 YTBep)l()J;eH11e IIC,n; B np0113BO,lJ,CTBO pafior.

2) CBe,lJ,eH115I 0 cpoxax nocrynnenna IIC,n: na BHyTpeHHIOIO 3KCnepT113Y 000 «WIT BCTO» He npe,lJ,OCTaBJIeHbI. Onemca cpsraa CPOKOB npe,lJ,CTaBJIeH115I OAO BID1JiICT TIC,n; na nepaa-raoe paCCMOTpeH11e 000 «WII BCTO» B XO,lJ,e npOBepKI1 He npOBO,lJ,11JIacb.

3) CpOK 3aBepIIIeH115I BHYTpeHHeH 3KCnepT113bI 000 «WIT BCTO» no 50 o6beKTaM 113 52 rrpeasnnaer CpOK npOBe,lJ,eHH5I 3KCnepT113hI, YCTaHOBJIeHHbIH B ,lJ,OrOBOpe na BbIIIOJIHeH11e Ill1P. ITo 2 06neKTaM CBO,lJ,Hble sxcneprnsre 3aKJIIOLIeH115I 000 «WIT BCTO» OTCYTCTByIOT.

4) 3KcnepTH3a ITC,n: npOBO,lJ,11JIaCb B COOTBeTCTBH11 C «PerJIaMeHTOM CPOpMHpOBaH115I nnaaa I1HP, BhI,lJ,aLI11 3a,lJ,aH11H na npoeKTHpOBaH11e, pa3pa60TK11 H 3KCnepT113bI IIC,n; ,lJ,JI5I CTp011TeJIbCTBa, TeXH11LIeCKOro nepesoopysceana, peKoHcTpYKU;11H 11 KaII11TaJIbHOrO pexroara 06neKToB OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrrs» H ,lJ,eHcTBYIOII1;11M B 000 «WII BCTO» «PerJIaMeHTOM OpraH113aU;1111 pa60TbI no npOBe,lJ,eHHIO 3KCnepT113bI IIC,n; B 000 «WII BCTO».

5) IIp11 YTBep)K,lJ,eHH11 IIC,n; B np0113BO,lJ,CTBO pa60T npOBO,lJ,11JI11Cb 3ace,lJ,aH115I Texnaaecxoro COBeTa 000 «llYII BCTO» no paccsrorpeamo IIC,n; (113MeHeHHH K IIC,n;) 11 CBO,lJ,HbIX3KcnepTHbIX 3aKJIIOl.JeH11H 3KCnepT113hI 000 «IJ;YII BCTO». 6) IIPOTOKOJIbI TeXH11LIeCKOro COBeTa 000 «WII BCTO» B HaJI11l.JHH no 51 06neKTY H3 52.

7) EOJIbIII11HCTBO npOTOKOJIOB TeXH11LIeCKOro COBeTa 000 «IJ;YII BCTO» o4>opMJIeHbI B HapYIIIeH11e IT.9.S, IT.9.8.2 ,lJ,eHcTBYIOII1;ero «IIOJIO)KeH115I 0 TeXHI1l.JeCKOM COBeTe 000 «l(YIT BCTO», yTB. npHKa30M 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» NQ 62 OT 28.03.2006 (,lJ,ei1cTBOBaJI ,lJ,O 23.11.2007). B COOTBeTCTB1111 C YKa3aHHbIM11 nYHKTaM11 ITOJIO)KeH115I TeXH11l.JeCK11H COBeT npasoxroxea peurarr. nsmecenaue aa ero paCCMOTpeH11e sonpocsr, eCJI11 na 3aCe,lJ,aHH11 np11CYTCTByeT He MeHee 2/3 LIJIeHOB TeXH11l.JeCKOrO COBeTa.

ITo pe3YJIbTaTaM BbI6opOLIHOH npOBepK11 npOTOKOJIOB Texansecxoro COB era 60JIbIII11HCTBO npOTOKOJIOB no YTBep:>K,lJ,eH11IO ITC,n: 11 H3MeHeHI1H K HeH B np0I13BO,lJ,CTBO pa60T COrJIaCOBaHbI xrenee qeM nOJIOB11HOH QJIeHOB TeXH11qeCKOrO COBeTa.

~ ~

(

~

I "

~

'\

) '.

'; :I

~

I

(

,

>""'\ ,

I I,

, '

j •

8) ITo peaynsraraa paCCMOTpeHIUr na TeXHIiLIeCKOM COBeTe 000 «L(YD BCTO» pa60LIa5I ,n;OKYMeHTall;I15I yrsepaczranacs npHKa30M 000 «IJ;YD BCTO» B npOH3BO,n;CTBO pafior.

9) <PaKTHLIecKHe ztars; YTBep)l{,n;eHH5I DC,[( B npOH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T na OTTHCKax IIlTaMnOB «B rrpOH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T» no 41 06'beKTY H3 52 He COOTBeTcTByeT ,n;aTe npnxasa 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» 06 YTBep)l{,n;eHHH TIC,[( B rrpoH3Bo,n;CTBO pafior. ITo 23 06'beKTaM sanepaoca B cpoxe normacaans npnxaaa 06 YTBep)l{,n;eHHH TIC,[( COCTaBHna fionee 10 ,n;HeH.

TIo pszry 06'beKTOB urrasm «B npOH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T» na ITC,[( rrpocrasnea pansnre nposeneaas TeXHHLIeCKoro COBeTa 000 «IJ;YIT BeTO» H YTBep)l{,n;eHH5I TIC,[( npHKa30M 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO».

TIo 1 06'beKTY na TIC,[( CTOHT IlITaMn «B npoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T», npa 3TOM npcroxon TeXHHqeCKOrO COBeTa H rrpaxas 06 YTBep)l{,Il;eHHH pafiosero npoexra OTCYTCTBYIOT.

Oparaaansm.re OTTHCKH IlITaMnOB «3KCIIEPTH3A DPOBE,l(EHA», «YTBEP)l{,[(AIO B I1P0I13BO,Zl;CTBO P AEOT» aa npoexrao-craeraoa ,n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH COOTBeTCTBYIOT OTTHCKaM llITaMnOB B KHHre perHCTpaU;HH IlITaMrrOB 000 «llYI1 BCTO».

IIlTaMn «Dxcneprasa nposezreaa» H nrravn «B npoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T» C rrozmacsro OTBeTCTBeHHoro JIHu;a, orrpenenaesroro npHKa30M renepansnoro zrapexropa ,nA0 MH na THTYJIbHOM JIHCTe TeKCTOBbIX MaTepHaJIOB H aa Ka)l{,n;OM JIHCTe rpa$HqeCKHX MaTepHanoB OTCYTCTByeT HJIH rrpOCTaBJIeH C HapYllIeHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX Tpe60BaHHH na 30 % nposepeaasrx KHHr.

KOMHcCHeHBbI5IBJIeHbI cpaKTbI HapYllIeHHH YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO rropanrca npoaezreaaa BHYTpeHHeH 3KcnepTH3hI CneIJ;HaJIHCTaMH 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» nocrynaronrax H3MeHeHHH K TIC,Zl; - no 06'beKTY «PacIlIHpeHHJI ... » na yqaCTKe 1924 - 1999.8 KM nponren 3KcnepTH3Y H yrsepzctea B npoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T H3M • .N2 6 (paspeurenae 32-08) ..

Cornacao ,n;aHHOMY H3M. ,I1;OJI)l{HbI 6bIJIH 6bITh OTKoppeKTHpOBaHbI Be,n;OMOCTH 6ypOB3PbIBHbIX pa60T, HO npa 3TOM H3MeHeHH5I B DC,L( He BHeCeHbI. BMeCTO Be,n;OMOCTH 6YPOB3PhIBHbIX pa60T npanoaceaa Be,n;OMOCTb paCKJIa,n;KH Tpy6 (see JIHCTbI npourraxmosaau «B npOH3Bo,n;CTBO pafior»),

B 000 «l(YI1 BCTO» npHHHMaIOTC5I na paCCMOTpeHHe BHYTpeHHeH

sxcrreprassr H3MeHeHH5I K I1C,Zl; 6e3 ,n;OKYMeHTOB, 060CHOBbIBaIOIIJ;HX

Heo6xo,n;HMOCTb HX BHeCeHH5I B rrpoeKTHYIO ,n;OKYMeHTaU;HIO.

Pesynsrarsr npoaepxa xozta pa3pa60TKH H npaexnca DC,L( no npoercry «Tpyfionposoznraa CHCTeMa BOCTOLIHa5I CH6HPb - THxHH OKeaH (BCTO). I1epBhIH rrycxoaoii KOMnJIeKC» H «Pacumpeaae Tpy60rrpoBo,I1;HOH CHCTeMbI BOCTOqHa5I CH6HPb - THxHH OKeaH (BeTO)>> rrpaaezterrsr B DPOTOKOJIe rrpoaepxn N2 1- urrnC/2008 OT 27.08.2008 (npHJIO)l{eHHe 1, npHJIO)l{eHHe 3 HaCT05IID;erO oTLIeTa).

1P5.1 !'l

I:

Il '1 .8

I I

'- ;,

~

I. ;

~ 1\

~

i i.

I :

I. f\

I )

f

\

,

j ::

It ~\ j i

~.

,

It,

f\

\

!

3.2.8 Pe3YJIbTaTbI

IIcn

Ha

060CHOBaHHOCTb

3KcnepTH3bI

CBoeBpeMeHHOCTb OnJIaTbI

<PaKTWleCKHe CpOKH npe,lJ,CTaBneHIDI B 000 «UYII BCTO» nOJIHOrO KOMnJIeKTa IIC,n: aa 6yMa)KHOM HOCHTeJIe B COOTBeTCTBHH C Tpe6oBaHH5IMH 3a,lJ,aHH5I na npoexrnponanne (no HaKna,lJ;HbIM)npeBbIIIIaeT CpOKH npe,lJ;CTaBJIeHH5I IIC,n: no 3aKJIlO~eHHbIM ,lJ;OrOBOpaM no 15 06'beKTaM H3 52 na CpOK OT 32 ,lJ;O 408 ,lJ;HeM. Pa60TbI no paspaficrxe IIC,n: no YKa3aHHbIM 06'beKTaM 3aKpbITbI aKTaMH BbIllOJIHeHHblX paoor. IIpeTeH3HH OAO BHI1I1CT He BbICTaBn5InHCb.

IIo 4 06'beKTaM BbI5IBJIeHbI cpaKTbI 3aKpbITH5I aKTOB BblnOJIHeHHblX pa60T ,lJ;O MOMeHTa nonYQeHH5I nOJIHOrO KOMnJIeKTa IIC,[( OT OAO BHHl1CT H YTBep)K,lJ;eHI15I ,lJ;oKYMeHTaIJ;HH B npOH3BO,lJ;CTBO pafior.

Pesynsrarsr nposepxa XO,lJ;a pa3pa60TKH H npHeMKH TIC)]; no rrpoexry «Tpy6onpOBO,lJ;Ha5I CHCTeMa BOCTO~Ha5I CII6HPb - THXHM OKeaH (BCTO). IIepBbIM nYCKOBOH KOMnneKC» II «Pacnmpenae Tpy6onpOBO,lJ;HOM CIICTeMbI BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - TIIXHM OKeaH (BCTO)>> npaaezrensr B Ilporoxone nposepxa NQ 1- rumCI2008 OT 27.08.2008).

CpbIB cpoxa BbIllOnHeHH5I pa60T no ztorosopy na npoexr «Pacmnpeane Tpy6onpOBO,lJ;HOH CHCTeMbI "BOCTO~Ha5I CH6HPb - TIIXIIH OKeaH" (BCTO)>> BbI5IBneH no 3 06'beKTaM. Paasrep npeTeH3IIOHHbIX Tpe60BaHIIH K OAO BHI1HCT sa CpbIB CpOKOB BblnOnHeHII5I pa60T no onenxe -rneaos pa6o~eH rpynrrsr opHeHTIIpoBO~HO COCTaBJIJIeT 5218 905,71py6.

BCBJI3H C TeM, qTO no 26 06'beKTaM (norav) II3 52 npoeKTHo-CMeTHa5I ,lJ;OKYMeHTa:U;II5I OAO BHI1l:ICT npencrasneaa B MeHbIIIeM xonavecrse 3K3eMnJIJIpOB, ~eM npenycxrorpeao B 3a,IJ;aHII5IX na rrpoexraposaaae, saasnrreaae CMeTHOH CTOIIMOCTH npoexrao-aaucxarenscxax pa60T no onenxe ~neHOB pa6o~eH rpyrmsi opHeHTIIpOBOqHO COCTaBn5IeT 5 335 905,79 py6. (c yseron CTOHMOCTH pa3MHO)J(eHIDI 1 zrononaaremaoro 3K3. I1C,n:B pasxrepe 0,5% OT cMeTHoH CTOHMOCTII srana Ill1P no zroroaopy).

~

I I

I

4 BhIBO.r.hI

1. CMeTHa5I ,lJ;OKYMeHTa:u;H5I Tpe60BaHIDIM 3a,lJ;aHIIJI aa npoexraposaaae He COOTBeTcTByeT H rpeoyer KoppeKTHpoBKII.

2. I1MelOru;a.SIC.5I npoeKTHo-CMeTHa5I ,lJ;OKYMeHTa:U;II5I HenOJIHa H

HeKOMnneKTHa.

3. Ilposepxa COOTBeTCTBH5I rrpoexrrrsrx peIIIeHIIH ,lJ;eHCTBHTenbHbIM

nOTpe6HOCT5IM, CTpOIiTenbHbIM H 3KCnJIyaTa:U;HOHHbIM CTaH,lJ;apTaM POCCH.H:CKOH CDe,lJ;epa:U;HH no Tpy6onpOBO,lJ;HOMY rpancnopry BhI5IBHna MHOrO~IICJIeHHbIe 3aMe~aHII5I, na OCHOBaHIIH KOTOPbIX B nepaonaaam.nyro I1C)); BHeceHO 3254 H3MeHeHH5I. Hs HHX:

- 724 illT. BbI3BaHbI OIIIH6KOH: npoeKTMpOBIIJ;HKa;

- 1069 urr, He,lJ;OCTaTO~HOM npopa60TKOH TeXHHQeCKHX penremrii.

H

~

.

r

! ..

4. YBeJIJ.rqeHHe CMeTI-IOH CTOHMOCTH crpoarenscraa 06'beICTOB BCJIe,aCTBHe cyiuecrsenaux OIDH60K H aezrocrarxos rrpoexrnpcaanan no pe3YJIbTaTaM sxcnepnron OIJ.eHKH H3MeHeHHM ITC,n: COCTaBHJIO 1 494,8 I\1JIH. py6.

5. BhI5IBJIeHO sansmreaae cMeTHoH CTOHMOCTH cTpOHTeJIbCTBa no

P33JIWIHhIM 06beICTaM BCJIe,aCTBHe neofiocnonaaaoro npHMeHeHH5I K03c]J(pHIl}IeHTOB na cyMMy 64,3 MJIH. py6., apHcjJMeTHl.leCICHX OIIIH60I( aa cyMMy 36,7 MJIH. pyo., sa cner neofiocnosanuoro npHMeHeHH51 n051CHbIX K03 (l)(fJI.:IIJ.He HTOB no <pCClI, 81-2001 I.J:aCTI:) 1 npHJI.2 K sarparan na aBTOM06HJIbH.ble nepeB03KH rpY30B (no 6 o6beKTaM H3 52) na CyMMy 449,4 MJIH. pyo.

6. IIpHeM, xpaaeaae, BHyTpeHHIDI sxcrreprasa H YTBep)J(,aeHHe rrc,n: B npoM3Bo,aCTBO pa60T B 000 «llYIT «BCTO» nposozranacs C MHOrOI.J:HCJIeHHhIMH HapyrneHIUIMH.

5 llpHJIO-'KeHHH (nepexem, .D;OICYMeHTOB ICOMHCCHOHHblX rrponepoic)

1. ITPOTOKOJI nposepxa Nl1-u;rIBCI2008 pa60'Ieti ,n:oKYMeHTall,HH no rrpoexry «Tpytionpononaas CHCTeMa BOCTOI.J:Ha51 CH6MPb - TMXMH OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBhIH nycxosoa KOMnJIeKC» H npoexry «PacIIIHpeHl:Ie Tpy60npoBo.n;HOH CMCTeMbI "BocToLIHruI CM61:Ipb - TMXHH OKeaH" (BCTO»>oT 27.08.2008.

2. ITPOTOKOJI nponepxa .N22-UITBC/2008 cMeTHoH .n;oKYMeHTa:U;HM no npoexrare «Tpytionponozraaa CHCTeMa Bocrosnaa CM6MPh - THX1:IH OKeaH (BCTO). IIepBbIH rrycxosok KOMnJIeKC» M «PacIIIHpeHHe rpy60rrpOBO,l(HOH CHCTeMbI "BocToI.J:Ha5I CH6HPh - THXMM OKeaH. (BCTO)>> OT 27.08.2008.

3. ITPOTOKOJI nposepxa .N21 OT 28.08.2008 npoexrno-csrernoji

,l(oKYMeHTaU;MH no npoeKTy «Tpy60npOBO,l(Ha51 CHCTeMa BocToLfHa5I CI16HPb - Tnxna OKeaH (BCTO). ITepBbIH rrycKOBOH KOMrrJIeKC» I1 npoexry «Pacnmpeaae rpyconposorraof CMCTeMbI "BocToLIHruI CM6MPb .- TMXMH oxean" (BCTO)>> OT 28.08.2008.

4. ,n:orrOJIHeHHe N2 1 K IIpoTOKOJIY nposepxa N2 1 OT 28.08.2008 rrpoexraocMeTHoH .n;oKYMeHTaU;HH no npoexry «Tpyoonposonaas CMCTeMa BocToLIHa51 CH6MPb - THXMH OKeaH (BCTO). Jlepsaa rrycxcsoii KOMl1JleKC» M npcexry «Pacnrapenae rpyoonposonaoii CHCTeMbl "BocTo"C.IHa51 CH6MPb - THxMH oxeaa" (BeTO)>> OT 19.09.2008.

5. Cnpasxa no HaJIMLIMlO He BOCTpe60BaHHbIX MTP (He HaIIIe.n;nII1X B HaCT05Itu:ee BpeM51 npMMeHeHH5I) Haxo,a5IIll,MXC51 na CICJIa,aax rra ofisexrax TC BCTO.

LIJ1EHbI P ABOlffiH fPYI1I1bI:

Be.n;yIll,MM crrel\I1aJIMCT KAO qmmfaJIa 000 «Tpaacaedrrs <pm-IaHC» B r.H'Hoeropon

B.A. Kopnesa

15

1 r:

I

i .

',,'I

,.I

HaIfaJIbHHK OT,IJ,ena,IJ,OrOBOpOB o A 0 «Fnnporpyfonpoaozr»

3aMeCTHTem, HaIfaJIbHHKa OT,IJ,ena OAO «I'arrporpytionposon»

~

pl

~

r"'

I

I

l

~ [ r

J1

i !i

:1

'I

~ I !

~ I'

.. !

~ ~

j ,

~ ~ ,

\ .,'

~ ,l

) ,

,I

3aMeCTJnenb HaIfaJIbHHKa Ilpasosoro yrrpaBneHH.H - HaIfaJIbHHK IOpH,IJ,HIfeCKOro OT,IJ,ena OAO «AK «Tpancaerprs»

fnaBHbIH IOPHCKOHCYJIbT IOpH,IJ,HIfeCKOro OT,IJ,ena Ilpasonoro yrrpaaneans OAO «AK «Tpancnerprt,»

3aMeCTJITenb ,IJ,HpeK,!,opa apraaerrra

«Cnysfia 6e30naCHOCTH» - HaIfaJIbHHK OT,IJ,ena 3KoHoMHIfecKoH 6e30rracHocTH OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrn,»

fJIaBHbIH cne:U;HaJIHCT OT,IJ,ena 3KOHOMHIfeCKon fieaonacnocm OAO «AK «Tpancaeqm,»

3aMeCTHTenb HaIfaJIbHHKa rrpOH3BO,IJ,CTBeHHoro OT,IJ,ena OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqm,»

(/j¥/ !iii

HaIfaJIbHHK OT,IJ,ena 3KonorHIfeCKOH fiesonacnocra H paIJ;HOHaJIbHOrO rrpHpO,IJ,OnOnb30BaHH.H

OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

fJIaBHbIH cne:U;HaJIHCT OT,IJ,ena uenosoro KOHTpOn.H

OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

3aMeCTHTenb HaIfaJIhHHKa OT,IJ,ena crparernnecxoro pa3BHTH.H

OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

M

~

H.M. PYCJI.HKOB

<D.E. )l{aBopoHKOB

n.n, BOJI.HHCKHn

E.JI. Pa,IJ,IfeHKO

C.H. IOran

,n:.A. Tepexon

B

I .

J

F

1

~.

I,

I, ~:

, '

P:

I I

I, ~'

IJ ~~,

I

~.

I I

AKT

o cfiope MaTepHaJIOB H HH~OpMaI(HH no sonpocy 0 cofinronenna YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX HOPM, npaBHJI H nopaznca npOBe,neHH5I ropros 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» no BbI60py nonpanasrx H rrpoexrnsrx opraHH3aI(HH, nOCTaBliIHKOB o6opy,nOBaHH5I, HCnOJIHHTeJIeH pa60T (ycnyr) ,n;JI5I peaJIH3aI(HH npoexra CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC «BCTO», 060CHOBaHHOCTH npHH5ITbIX na xoaxypcax peIlIeHHH

r.MocKBa

25 asrycra 2008 rona

Pa601IM rpynna B COCTaBe: ,[(eMHHa A.M.

3aMeCTHTeJI5I nane-npeaaneara OAO «AK«TpaHcHe~Th»

PYCJI5IKOBa H.M.

3aMeCTHTeJUI zrapexropa zrerrapraveara «CJIY)J{6a 6e30naCHOCTH» - HaqaJIhHHKa OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30nacHocTH OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,»

HaqaJIbHHKa OT,neJIa npasoBoro H HopMaTHBHoro

COnpOBO)J{.ll:eHH5I ropros OAO «AK «Tpaacneqm,»

HaqaJIhHHKa OT,n:eJIa rrponezreaaa ropros no MTP OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrn,»

HaqaJIhHHKa OT,n:eJIa no,nrOTOBICH repros no CMP OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,»

maBHOrO roPHcKOHcYJIhTa npeTeH3HoHHO-HCKOBOH CJIY)J{6hI TIpaBOBOrO ynpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,»

Kapnosa C.A.

Bouzrapesa A.IO.

,[(paqeBa A.A.

Po rOB oro s.n.

ParY30BOH H.ll.

rJIaBHOrO IOPHCKOHCYJIhTa IOpH,n:HlIeCKOrO OT,n;eJIa

Ilpasosoro yrrpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrrr,»

rJIaBHOrO CneI(HaJIHCTa OT,n;eJIa 3KOHOMHQeCKOH

6e30nacHocTH OAO «AK «Tpancnerprr,»

)l{aBopoHKOBa C!>.n.

XaplIeHKO K.I1.

sezrymero CneI(HaJIHCTa OT,n;eJIa cpHJIHaJIa 000 r.Hosopoccaacxe

KOHTPOJIhHO-aHaJIHTHlIeCKOrO «Tpancaedrrs C!>HHaHC» B

BO HCnOJIHeHHe PaCnOpJIIKeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» OT 21 HIOJI5I 2008 rona N2 21 rrpoaena MepOnpH5ITH5I no, cfiopy H nonrorosxe MaTepHaJIOB H HHCPOPMaI(HH ,n;JI5I ClIeTHOH rranarsr POCCHHCKOH C!>e,n;epaI(HH no sonpocy 0 C06JIIO,n;eHHH YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX HOPM, npaBHJI H rropaznca nposezreaaa ropros ,nJI5I peaJIH3aI(HH npoexra cTpOHTeJIbCTBa ofisexros TC «BCTO», 06ocHoBaHHocTH npHH5ITbIX na xomcypcax peIlIeHHH.

Ilposenenae ropros ,n;JI5I peaJIH3aI(HH rrpoexra cTpOHTeJIhCTBa ofir.exron TC «BCTO» 000 «I{YTI BCTO» npezrycvorpeac nYHKToM 1.5 norosopa HHBecTHpOBaHH5I N2 25-01- 2006/114-06 OT 20.04.2006 r. H perYJIHpyeTC5I CJIe,nyIOIIJ;HMH HopMaTHBHhIMH npaBOBbIMH aKTaMH (TIpHJIo)J{eHHe N2 2):

C!>e,n;epaJIhHhIM 3aKOHOM «0 3aII(HTe KOHKypeHI(HH» N!! 135-C!>3 OT 26.07.2006r.; fpa)J{.ll:aHCKHM Ko,neKCOM POCCHHCKOH C!>e,n;epaI(HH OT 30.11.1994 r. N!! 51-<D3; IIoJIQ)KeHHeM «0 nopazrxe nposezremra nonpsznrsrx roproa (KOHKYPCOB) no

BhI60py nonpxzrraxon na npoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T (npeztocraanenae ycrryr) no CTpOHTeJIhCTBY, peI<OHcTpYKI(HH, TeXHI1QeCKOMY nepesoopyacenaro, KanHTaJIbHOMY 11 TeKYIIJ;eMY peMOHTY

J\I )il

\

Jil Gl

j r-

~j i, ~

~'

,

! I

~

.

(

\

~

J

~

I I , I

~

fr

..

t

i r

fh

I

06'beKTOB OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrs» (YTB. IIpHKa30M OAO «AK «Tpancuedrn,» OT 27 cpeBpaJUI 2006 r. NQ 22);

PernaMeHTOM opraHH3aI(HH H rrpoaeztenas ncnpanasrx ropros rro BbI60py nonpazrraxos aa rrpoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T rro cTpOHTeJIbCTBY, peKoHcTpYKI(HH, TeXHHqeCKoMY nepeaoopyacemno, KarrHTaJIbHoMY H rexymeny peMoHTY 06'beKTOB OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» (YTBep)I(,n;eH rrepBbIM nane-npesaztearov OAO «AK «Tpaacneqrrs» 31 Ma5I 2006 r.);

PerJIaMeHTOM opraHH3aI(HH H nposezreaas ropros rro BbI60py rrOCTaBrn:HKOB o6oPy,n;oBaHH5I H MaTepHaJIbHO TeXHHqeCKHX pecypcoB ,n;JI5I 06'beKTOB cTpOHTeJIbCTBa rrepBoH osepezra TPy60rrpoBo,n;HOH CHCTeMbI «BoCTo't{Ha5I CH6HPb- THxHH OKeaH» (YTBep)!(,[(eH rrpHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 23 MapTa 2006 r. NQ 51, HOBa5I pe,n;aKI(H5I yrnepaoreaa npHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 27 ,n;eKa6p5I 2006 r. NQ 385);

IIoJIo)!(eHHeM 0 KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH 000 «L(YII BCTO» (yrsepaoieno rrpHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 23 MapTa 2006 r. NQ 52);

IIoJIo)!(eHHeM 06 sxcrrepraoa KOMHCCHH (yraepsoreao npHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» oT23 MapTa 2006 r. NQ53);

PerJIaMeHTOM npaeva KOHKypCHbIX npezmoxesna Y't{acTHHKoB ropros H rrponenypsr BCKPbITH5I KOHBepTOB C KOHKypCHbIMH npe,n;JIO)!(eHH5IMH B 000 «L(YII BCTO» (YTBep)!()J;eHo rrpHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 04 HIOJIH 2006 r. NQ 161);

IIoJIo)!(eHHeM 0 rropamce nepeztaxa, ysera, xparrenna Ii HCrrOJIb30BaHHH ,n;OKYMeHTOB B apxnse 000 «L(YII BCTO» (yrsepaoreao rrpHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 23 HOH6pH 2007 rozta N2 452);

HOMeHKJIaTypoH zren 000 «WII BCTO» (yrsepzoiena npHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 28 ,n;eKa6pH 2007 rozta N2 491).

B pe3YJIbTaTe aHaJIH3a HopMaTHBHoH ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HH, perYJIHpYIOII(ell nposeneaae ropros B 000 «L(YII BCTO» (IIpHJIo)!(eHHe N23), BbI5IBJIeHbI napymeaaa ,n;eHcTBYIOII(ero 3aKOHo,n;aTeJIbCTBa, BHyrpeHHHX ,n;OKYMeHTOB OAO «AK «Tpancaeqrrs» H 06bNaeB ,n;eJIOBOrO ofiopora npa rrposeneaaa KOHKypCOB:

1. Pernasrenr opraHH3aI(HH H rrpoaezreaaa ropros rro BbI60PY lIOCTaBII(HKOB o60Py,n;OBaHHH H MaTepHaJIbHO TeXHH't{eCKHX pecypcoB ,n;JI5I 06'beKTOB CTpOHTeJIbCTBa nepBoll otrepezra TPy60npoBo,n;HOH CHCTeMbI «BOCTO'IfHa5I CH6HPb- THxHH OKeaH» (YTBep)!(,[(eH rrpHKa30M 000 «L(YII BCTO» OT 23 xrapra 2006 r. NQ51):

coziepxar Heo6ocHoBaHHYIO CCbIJIKY na <De,n;epaJIbHbIH 3aKOH «0 pa3MeII(eHHH 3aKa30B na nOCTaBKH TOBapOB, BbIIIOJIHeHHe pafior, OKa3aHHe yCJIyr,n;JIH rocynapcrseaasrx H MYHHI(HrraJIbHbIX Hy)!()J;» OT 21 HIOJI5I 2005 rozta N2 94-<1>3 H IIpHKa3 MHH3KOHOMHKH POCCHHCKOH <1>e,n;epaI(HH OT 30 ceHTH6pH 1997 rona NQ 117 «06 YTBep)!(,n;eHHH MeTo,n;HqeCKHX pexoneazranna rro npOBe,n;eHHIO ropros (xonxypca) na saxyrncy TOBapOB (pafior), KBaJIHCPHKaI(HOHHOMY oT6oPY rrOCTaBrn:HKOB (rronpazrraxon) - (KOHKypCHOH ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HH)>>, T.K.npaKTH'leCKH PerJIaMeHT yrrOM5IHYTOMY 3aKoHY H IIpHKa3Y He COOTBeTcTByeT;

penrerme 0 cpopMe npOBe,n;eHH5I TOprOB (nYHKT 6.2. Pernaveara) ,n;OJI)I(eH npHHHMaTb opraaasarop ropros, a He KOHKYPCHa5I KOMHCCHH (rro aHaJIOrHH C nYHKTOM 4.1.8. PerJIaMeHTa opraHH3aI(HH H rrposeneaaa nonpazmsrx ropros no BbI60py nonpazrmxos na rrpoH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T rro cTpOHTeJIbCTBY, peKoHcTpYKI(HH, TeXHHqeCKOMY rrepesoopyaceamo, KarrHTaJIbHoMY H rexynrevy peMOHTY 06'beKTOB OAO «AK «Tpaacnedrrs», YTBep)K,n;eHHoMY rrepBbIM BHI(e-rrpe3H,n;eHTOM OAO «AK «Tpaacrrerprr,» 31 MM 2006 r.);

KpHTepHH, nonycxaromne B03MO)!(HOCTb npoaeztemrx saxpsrroro xomcypca, cy6'beKTHBHhI, MorYT npasecra K 3JIoyrroTpe6JIeHHHM;

2

~

I, !

I '

\ ,

11. r

I ,

naaerueaae 0 nposezrenaa KOHKypCHbIX TOprOB He cortepxorr CBe,n:eHlI5I 0 HalJ:aJIbHOH nene II IIOP5I,n:OK onpeztenenna JIHlI,a, asrarpasurero ToprH (rrYHKT 7.1.3.2. Pcrnaaeara), LITO nporasope-nrr lJ:aCTlI 2 CTaTbH 448 FK P<D;

B rrYHKTe 7.1.3.7. CPOPMYJIlIpOBI<a 0 cpoxax rrpOBe)J;eHI:I5r npezmaparensnoro

KOHKypcHoro oT6opa He rr03BOJI5IeT orrpe,n:eJIlITb COOTBeTCTBlIe ,n:eHCTBYlOrn;eMY

3aKOHO)J;aTeJIbCTBY CPOKOB rrponeneaaa KOHKypCHbIX repros;

rrYHKT 7.1.17. PerJIaMeHTa He CO)J;ep)KHT 065I3aHHOCTH JIHu;a, ssmrpaamero roprn, H opraaasaropa ropros nonnacars B )J;eHb rrpOBe)J;eHlI5I xonxypca rrpOTOKOJI 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX ropron, KOTOPbIH lIMeeT CHJIY zrorosopa, lITO npornsopeaar lJ:aCTlI 5 CTaTbH 448 Fpazcraacxoro xozrexca POCCHHCKOH <De,n:epaU;lIH.

2. ITOJIO)!CeHHe 0 KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH 000 «WIT BCTO», YTBep)!()J;eHHoe ITPHKa30M OT 23 MapTa 2006 rona NQ 52:

cozrepzorr Heo60cHoBaHHYlO CCbIJIKY na <De)J;epaJIbHbIH 3aKOH «0 pasaememrn 3aKa30B na rrOCTaBKH TOBapOB, BbIIIOJIHeHHe pafior, OKa3aHHe ycnyr ,n:JI5I rocyzrapcraeamrx H MYHHIJ;HnaJIbHbIX Hy)K)J;» OT 21 HlOJI5I 2005 rona NQ 94-<D3;

K CPYHKIJ;H5IM KOHKYPCHOH KOMHCCHH He MO)KeT OTHOClITC5I rrpHH5ITlIe pemeaaii 06 H3MeHeHHH CPOKOB paccMOTpeHH5I KOHKypCHbIX npe)J;JIO)!(eHHH B CJIyrra5IX, He nporaaopesanmx )J;eHCTBYlQrn;eMY 3aKOHO)J;aTeJIbCTByPOCCHHcKoH<De)J;epaIJ;HH (nYHKT 7.6. Pernaxrerrra), T.K. 3TO 5IBJI5IeTC5I npeporarasoa opraansaropa repros.

3. ITOJIO)KeHHe 0 rrOCT05IHHO )J;eHcTBYlOrn;eH apxaano-sxcneprnoti KOMHCCHH 000 «l(YIT BCTO», YTBep)KJJ:eHHOe rrpHKa30M OT 23 H05I6p5I 2007 rona NQ 453:

He CO)J;ep)!(HT YKa3aHH5I 0 TOM, lITO onHCH ,n:OKYMeHTOB, nonaexanrax YHHlJ:TO)KeHHlO ocyrn;eCTBJI5IlOTC5I B COOTBeTCTBlIH C HOMeHKJIaTypOH )J;eJI 000 «l(YIT BCTO», YTBep)KJJ:eHHOH rrpHKa30M 000 «UYIT BCTO» OT 28 ,n:eKa6p5I 2007 rozra NQ 491.

4. ITOJIO)KeHHe 0 nOp5I)J;Ke rrepeztasa, ysera, XpaHeHH5I H HCnOJIb30BaHH5I ,n:OKYMeHTOB B apxase 000 «WIT BCTO», YTBep)KJJ:eHHOe npHKa30M 000 «I(YIT BCTO» OT 23 H05I6p5I 2007 rona NQ 452:

He nponacan nOp5I)J;OK YHHlITO)KeHH5I )J;OKYMeHTOB C yaerosr ITOJIO)KeHH5I 0

rrOCT05IHHO ,n:eHCTBYlOrn;eH apXHBHO-3KcnepTHOH KOMHCCHlI 000 «l(YIT BCTO»,

YTBep)KJJ:eHHOrO npHKa30M OT 23 H05I6p5I 2007 rozra NQ 453.

3a rrepaozr pearasanaa npoexra TC BCTO KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHeH 000 «I(YII BCTO» rrposezteno .ropros no 131 JIOTY (ilplIJIo)KeHHe NQ 1), B TOM lIHCJIe:

no BbI60py nocrasnraxoa MTP na 06'.beKTbI CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO - 101 JIOT; no BbI60py nO)J;p5I)J;lJ:HKOB na BbllIOJIHeHHe CMP na 061>eKTaX cTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO - 16 JIOTOB;

no BbI60PY lICnOJIHHTeJIeH ycnyr )J;JI5I peaJIH3aU;HH rrpoexra CTpOHTeJIbCTBa 06'.beKTOB TC BCTO - 14 JIOTOB.

B nepaozt C 04.08.08 r. no 10.08.08 r, pa60lJ:eH rpyrmoii OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» nposeztena nposepxa MaTeplIaJIOB KOHKypCHbIX TOprOB 000 «I(YIT BCTO». Henocpencraeaao BO BpeM5I pa60TbI KOMHCCHlI cOTpy,n:HHKaMlI 000 «l(YIT BCTO» He3aKOHHO YHHlJ:TO)KeHbI MaTeplIaJIbI KOHKypCHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaIJ;HH no JIOTaM MTP, CMP II YCJIyraM CITpHJIO)!(eHHe N24):

• KOHKYPCHa5I ,n:OKYMeHTaU;lI5I (I1HCTpYKlI,H5I YlJ:aCTHHKY ropros, npoexr KOHTpaKTa,

TeXHHlIeCKa5I xacrs);

•

MaTepHaJIbI IIKO (npeztsaparenr.aoro KBaJIlIcjJlIKall,HOHHOro orfiopa);

3 ,

'J

f1 i;J

\

~

I

I

j ,

I r'

I I

I I

I ~

I

\

~

\ '

• MaTepI1aJIhI 3KCrrepTHOH KOMI1CCI1I1;

• KOHKYPCHhle rrpe~JIo)I<eHI15I yqaCTHHKOB TOprOB (rrpHJIo)ICeHH5I K HTOrOBhIM

rrpOTOKOJIaM) B qaCTH:

KOHI<YPCHhle 3a5IBKH, rrorrraepsoieaaa COrJIaCH5I C YCJIOBH5IMH ztoroaopa; KBaJIHqHIKaI(I10HHO-TeXHHqeCKa5I nacrs I<OHICypCHOrO rrpe~JIO)l<eHH5I; KOrrHH 06'h5IBJIeHHH;

nepermcxa C yqaCTHHKaMH TOprOB;

rrpOTOKOJIhI BCI<PhITH5I, OpraHI13aI(HOHHhle rrpOTOKOJIhI, rrpOTOKOJIhI IlKO (npeztaaparensnoro KBaJIHCpHICaI(HOHHOrO orfiopa);

KOrrHH 6aHKOBCKHX raparrraii.

YHI1qTO)l(eHHe rrpOH3Be~eHO B napynrenae CJIe~yroII(HX HopMaTHBHo-rrpaBOBhIX aKTOB:

1) I1onO)l(eHH5I 0 nOp5I~ICe nposeneaas nO~p5I~HhIX ropros (KOHKYPCOB) no BhI60py

nO~p5I~qHKOB Ha rrp0I13BO~CTBO pa60T (rrpe~OCTaBJIeHHe yCJIyr) rro cTpOHTeJIhCTBY, peKoHcTpYICI(HH, TeXHI1"CJeCKOMY rrepesoopyzccrrato, I<arrI1TaJIhHoMY I1 'rexymeay peMoHTY 06'heKTOB OAO «AK «Tpaacnedrrs», YTBep)l(.IJ:eHHOrO rrpHICa30M OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» 27 <jJeBpaJI5I 2006 rona NQ 22.1

2) HOMeHKJIaTYPhI ~eJI 000 «U;YI1 BCTO» aa 2008 ron (nazrercc rtena 09-01-36),

YTBep)l(,neHHoH rrpHI<a30M 28 ,neI<a6p5I 2007 rozta NQ 491?

3) <De~epaJIhHOrO 3aKOHa OT 22 0I<T5I6p5I 2004 rozta NQ 125-<D3 «06 apXHBHOM zrene

B POCCHHCI<OH <De~epaI(I1H» 3

,lJ;aHHhIH c.paKT 5IBJI5IeTC5I rpy6hIM aapynreaaea zreacrsyromcro 3aKOHo,naTeJIhCTBa, pernaaearapyromero nopanox XpaHeHH5I ,nOKYMeHTOB B KOMMep"CJeCI<HX opraHH3aI(H5IX, H BHYTpeHHI1X ~OKYMeHTOB 06II(eCTBa. B COOTBeTCTBHH co CTaTheH 27 <De,n;epaJIhHOrO 3aKOHa OT 22 OKT5I6p5I 2004 rozra NQ 125-<D3 «06 apXHBHOM zrerre B POCCHHCKOH <De,nepaI(HH» ropI1,nI1"CJeCI<He JIHI(a, a rarose ,nOJI)l(HOCTHhle JIHI(a H rpaacaaae, BHHOBHhle B napymenaa 3aKOHO~aTeJIhCTBa 06 apXHBHOM zrene B POCCHHCI<OH <De,nepaI(I1H, necyr rpaaoiaacxorrpasonyro, ~MHHHCTpaTI1BHYro H yrOJIOBHYro OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh, YCTaHOBJIemI)'ro 3aKOHo,naTeJIhCTBOM POCCHHCKOH <De~epaI(HH (I1pHJIO)l(eHHe NQ4A).

ITo c.paI<TY YHI1"CJTO)l(eHH5I KOHKypCHOH ,nOKYMeHTaI(I1H PYKOBO,n;CTBOM OAO «AI< «Tpaacneqrrs» B HaCT05III(ee BpeM5I Ha3Ha"CJeHO H rrpOBO,lJ;HTC5I CJIY)l(e6HOe paCCJIe,noBaHI1e.

HCCJIe,noBaHHe COXpaHHBrneHC5I "CJaCTI1 KOHKYPCHOH ~OKYMeHTaI(HH, a HMeHHO OPHrHHaJIOB HToroBhIX rrpOTOKOJIOB sacenaaaa KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHI1 000 «U;YI1 BCTO» C ITpI1JIO)l(eHI15IMH4 aa COOTBeTCTBI1e Tpe6oBaHH5IM HopMaTHBHhIX rrpasoasrx aKTOB, CBH,neTeJIhCTByeT 0 MHorO"CJI1CJIeHHhIX napymeanax npasnn I1 nponenypsr nposeneaaa ropros:

1

nYHKTOM 3.9.6. YKa3aHHOrO I10JIQ)KeHlliI npenycaorpeao, qTO rrpOTOKOJIbl, COCTaBJIeHHbJe B XOJle

rrpOBeJleHJ1H repros, 3aHBKJ1 aa yaacrne B roprax, KOHKypclIaH ,UoKYMeHTaU;I-IH, J13MeHeHJ1H, saeceansre B KOHKYpCHYIO JlOKYMeHTaQIDO, J1 pa3MICHeHJ15! KOHKypCHOH ,UoKYMeHTaQI1J1, a raioxe aynno- J1 BI1,Ue03arrI1Cb BCKPbITI1H KOHBepToB C 3aHBKaMI1 sa YQaCTl1e B roprax XpaHJlTCH He MeHee rpex JIeT.

2 Co maCHO YTBep)!(JleHHoi1 HOMeHKJIaType 000 «llyn BCTO» CpOK XpaHeHI1H MaTepl1aJIOB KOHKypCHbIX ToproB I1CTeKaeT B 2009-20 I 0 r.r.

3

qacTblO 1 CTaTbl1 17 125-<1>3 npenycaorpeao, QTO OpraHI13aUl111 o6H3aHbI otiecne-maars coxpanaocn,

apXI1BHblX JlOKYMeHTOB B reseaae CPOKOB I1X xpaaeans, YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX <jJe,llepaJIbHbIMI1 3aKOHaMI1, HHbIMH HOpMaTI1BHbIMH npaBOBbIMI1 aKTaMI1 POCCI1HCKOi'i <1>eJlepaUHH, a TaK)!{e rrepeLIHJlMH ,llOKYMeHToB, npenycaorpenauan YKa3aHHbIM <1>e,llepaJIbHhIM 3aKOHOM (QaCTh 3 CTaTbl1 6 H uacn, I CTaThH 23).

4

CoxpaHHBWl1eCJl IIpHJIo)!{eHHH K HTOroBbIM npOTOKOJIaM B 'IaCTH:

a) JIOTbI no CMP H YCJIyraM:

- pac-rer CTOHMOCTH JIOTa, CBO,llHbIJ1 cMeTHhIJ1 paCLJeT 11 rparpn« BhIIIOJlHeHHH pa60T 3aKa3L[HKa;

4

~

,

\

\. ;

11 II'

I '

{

~

,

I

l

f

- rro 101 JIOTY ITO MTP BhI5IBJIeHO 459 HapYIIIeHl:IM (ITpHJIO)I(eHI:le N25):

- KOHKypcHa~ .n;OI(YMeHTaQH~ 6hIJIa yraepscieaa paaee YTBep)K.n;eHH5I paCqeTHOM

CTOHMOCTH nora;

- 06b~BJIeHHe xonxypca B CMI1 paaee yrnepxnenaa KOHKYPCHOM .n;OKYMeHTaQHH rro

JIOTY;

- KOJIHqeCTBO rro3HQHM B KOHKYPCHOM .n;OKYMeHTaUHH He COOTBeTCTByeT, YKa3aHHhIM B paCqeTHOM CTOHMOCTH JIOTa.

- 6aHKOBCKHe rapaaraa, BhI.n;aHHhIe B ofiecnesenae ysacraa B xonxypce, O<popMJIeHhI C HapYlIIeHHeM CPOKOB .n;eiiCTBH5I, nozmacansr HeyrrOJIHOMO'LleHHhIMH JIHuaMH, JIH60 6e3 HaJIWllI5I nozrraepaoteaaa rrOJIHOMOqHii (.n;OBepeHHOCTeM);

- OTCYTCTBYIOT OPHrHHaJIhHhIe nonnaca yrrOJIHOMOqeHHhIX JIHU, He YKa3hIBaeTC5I ,IJ;aTa rrozmacaaaa, HeBepHO YKa3hIBaeTC5I HaHMeHOBaHHe JIOTOB, He YKa3hIBaeTC5I 6aHK, KOTOPhIM o6~3yeTC5I npeacrasan, ooecneseaae BhIIIOJIHeHH~ YCJIOBHM noronopa (6aHKOBCKYIO rapaHTHIO), KOHKypCHhIe rrpe,IJ;JIO)I(eHH~ nonnacansr HeyrrOJIHOMOqeHHhIMH JIHuaMH, JIH60 6e3 HaJIHqH~ rrO,IJ;TBep)I(,IJ;eHH~ rrOJIHOMOqHii (noaepeauocren).

- rrpHHHMaIOTC5I pelIIeHH5I 0 .n;OCPOqHOM BCKPhITHH 6e3 c06mo.n;eHH5I YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO 3aKOHo.n;aTeJIhCTBOM cpoxa B 30 )J;HeM;

.,. B HTorOBhIX rrpOTOKOJIaX He YKa3hIBaeTC5I HeCOOTBeTCTBHe KOHKypCHhIX rrpe.n;JIO)I(eHHH: yqacTHHKOB Tpe6oBaHH5IM KOHKYPCHOM ,n;OKYMeHTaUHH, YKa3aHHhIe B aHaJIHTHqeCKOM cnpasxe H zrpyrae HapYIIIeHH5I.

- rro 30 JIOTaM rro CMP H ycnyrau BhI5IBJIeHO 215 HapYlIIeHHH: (ITpHJIO)I(eHHe N26, I1pHJIO)I(eHHe No6A):

- 06b5IBJIeHH5I xoaxypca B CMIl panee YTBep)I(,IJ;eHH5I paCqeTHOH: CTOHMOCTH rrora;

- KOHKypCHM ,n;OKYMeHTaUH5I YTBep)I(,IJ;eHa paaee YTBep)I(,IJ;eHH5I paCqeTHOH CTOHMOCTH rro

JIOTY;

- csonasre CMeTHhIe pacxersr He HMelOT nrraxma «B rrpOH3BO,IJ;CTBO pa60T», OTCYTcTByeT ,IJ;aTa rrO,IJ;rrHCaHH~ CBO.n;HhIX CMeTHhIX pacseroa;

OTCYTCTBYIOT OpHrHHaJIhHbIe rrO,IJ;IIHCH yrrOJIHOMOqeHHbIX JIHU, -racrs <pOPM pacnesaraaa na UBeTHOM npaarepe C rrO,IJ;rrHChIO H nesarsro;

- K MaTepHaJIaM nposepxa He rrpHJIO)I(eHhI .n;OBepeHHOCTH na rrpaso IIo,n;IIHCaHH5I <pOPM

KOHKypCHoro rrpe,IJ;JIO)I(eHH5I, xacrs <pOPM nozmacaaa He yrrOJIHOMOqeHHbIMH JIH60

HeH3BeCTHhIMH JIHUaMH;

- rro MaTepHaJIaM JIOTOB HITC-14 H C- IT HMeIOTC5I 3aMeqaHH5I 110 pa3pelIIHTeJIbHOH: ,IJ;OKYMeHTaUHH.

- rrpHHHMaIOTC5I pelIIeHH5I 0 ,n;OCPOqHOM BCKPbITHH 6e3 C06JIIO,n;eHH5I YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO 3aKoHo,n;aTeJIbCTBOM cpoxa B 30 ,n;HeM;

- B rrpOTOKOJIe BCKPbITH5I YKa3bIBaeTC5I HeCOOTBeTCTBHe KOHKypCHhIX rrpe.n;JIO)I(eHHM yqaCTHHKOB Tpe6oBaHH5IM KOHKypCHOM ,IJ;OKYMeHTaUHH, rrOCJIe qero qaCTb IIpeTeH,IJ;eHTOB He ,IJ;OIIYCKaeTC~ K ,n;aJIhHeMilleMY yqaCTHIO B roprax, a rracrt, rrpeTeH,IJ;eHTOB rrpO,IJ;OJI)I(aeT ysacrne;

- B rrpOTOKOJIe BCKPhITH5I YKa3aHO HeCOOTBeTCTBHe KOHKypCHoro IIpe.n;JIO)I(eHH5I Tpe6oBaHH~M KOHKypCHOM .n;OKYMeHTaUHH, pemeane rro npereaaenry He rrpHH5ITO, K

- <popMa 13 (rpadnr« BbITIOJIHemI5I pa60T) H <popMa 14 (pacser uensr xoaxypcnoro npe)lJIO)IwHWIM) Y4acTHHKoB roproa, HTorOBbIH npOTOKOJI oneuxn KOHKypCHbIX npe)lJIO)l{eHHH H 3aKJII04eHHe no ouenxe KOHKypCHbIX npennozseank;

6) JIOTbI no MTP:

- HOMeHKJIaTypa nOCTaBJIReMoro 060PY)lOBaHHR, xcepoxonna BH30BOH 4aCTH KOHKypCHOH )lOKYMeHTaUHH Y4aCTHHKY ropros, )lOKYMeHT 06 YTBep)l{)leHHH pacseraon CTOHMOCTH, yrsepisneanue 3aKa3llHKoM;

- q)OpMa 2 (pacser ueasr xouxypcnoro npennoxeaas) YlIaCTHHKOB repros, 3aKJIIOlJeHHe no ouenxe KOHKYPCHblX npennoacenufi H HTorOBhlH npOTOKOJI oueaxn KOHKypCHhlX npe)lJlO)l{eHHH 3KcnepTHoH KOMHccHei1, aHaJlHTH4eCKail cnpasxa no flOTY, yraepaoieansre 3aKa34HKoM;

5

~

\,

~

/'

\

I "

\ _!

J1 r

I \

MaTepHaJIaM npHJIO)J{eHO nHChMO-YBe,n:OMJIeHHe YI<a3aHHOMY npereanenry 0 He,n:OnYCKe K

TOpraM; J

- B HTOrOBhIX npOTOKOJIaX ecrs CChIJIKa aa ,n:OKYMeHThI. npencrasnenasre n03)Ke zrars: npOBe,n:eHH5I HTDrOBOrO 3aCe,n:aHH5I;

- peIIIeHHe 0 BhI60pe n06e,n:HTeJI5I rro JIOTaM, CYMMa no KOTOPhIM npessnnana 30,0 MJIH.py6. (ycnyrn) rrpHHHMaJIOCh KOHKYPCHOH: KOMHCCHeH: H ztpyrae napynrcnaa.

Y CTaHOBJIeHhI <paKThI, cBH,n:eTeJIhCTBYIOm;He 0 BHeceHHH HCrrpaBJIeHHH: B MaTepHaJIhI ropros rrOCJIe 3aBepIIIeHH5I KOHKypCHhIX nponeztyp:

- COrJIaCHO MaTepHaJIaM JIOTa NQ BCTO/3-4 arorosoe sacezraaae KOHKypCHOH: KOMHCCHH COCT05IJIOCh 23 OKT5I6p5I 2006 r., ozmaxo rrpHJIQ)KeH CBO,n:HhIH CMeTHhIH: pacser, .n:aTHPOBaHHhIH rroazmea .n:aTOH: (npnxas OT 18.05.2007 r. NQ159) (TOM 7, CTp. 516, CTp. 526).

- TIo JIOTY NQ BCTO/P-3 B COOTBeTCTBHH C HTOroBhIM rrpOTOKOJIOM sacenaaaa KOHKypCHOH KOMHCCHH CTOHMOCTh rro6e.n:HTeJI5I COCTaBJI5IeT 11 231 830 000,00 py6JIeH:, onaaxo, B xonaa aroronoro rrpOTOKOJIa, npezrcrasneaaoro 000 «WIT BCTO» aa Tennepasrii KOMHTeT OAO «AK «Tpaacrredrn,» CTOHMOCTh rro6e.n:HTeJI5I COCTaBJI5IeT 11 231 000 830,00 py6JIeH: (TOM 7, CTp. 101, 106).

- TIo JIOTY NQ BCTO/HTIC-14 .n:aTa COCTaBJIeHH5I arorosoro rrpOTOKOJIa sacenaaaa KOHKypCHOH: KOMHCCHH 18.06.2007 r., onnaxo, B xonaa nroronoro rrpOTOKOJIa, npeztcraanemroro 000 «l.(YTI BCTO» na Teanepnsra KOMHTeT OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqm,», ztara COCTaBJIeHH5I HTOroBOro rrpOTOKOJIa 16.06.2007 r. (TOM 7, CTp. 107, 115).

- TIo JIOTY NQ BCTO/HB3-4 .n:aTa COCTaBJIeHH5I nroronoro rrpOTOKOJIa saceztaaaa KOHKypCHOii KOMHCCHH 28.06.2007r., ozmaxo, B xonaa arorosoro rrpOTOKOJIa, rrpe.n:CTaBJIeHHOrO 000 «l.(YTI BCTO» na Teanepnsni KOMHTeT OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,», .n:aTa COCTaBJIeHH5I aroroaoro npOTOKOJIa26.06.2007 r. (ToM 7, cTp.121, 127).

B pe3YJIhTaTe rrpaBOBOH: onenxa BhI5IBJIeHHhIX HapYIIIeHHH: YCTaHOBJIeHO, qTO npa nposezteaaa 000 «I(YTI BCTO» ropros .n:JI5I peaJIH3au;HH npoexra c1poHTeJIhCTBa 06'heKTOB TC «BCTO» HMeJIHCh aeozraoxparasre CJIyqaH napymenas nponenypsr H npaBHJI' npoaezreaaa ropron, YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX,n:eH:CTBYIOm;HM 3aKOHo.n:aTeJIhCTBOM H JIOKaJIhHhIMH HopMaTHBHhIMH aKTaMH OAO «AK «Tpancaerprs» H 000 -uvn BCTO CTIpHJIO)l(eHHe NQ7).

Hapymeaas npOn;eJJ:YPhIH npaaan repros rrpa peanasanna npoexra CTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC «BCTO», YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX ,n:eH:CTBYIOm;HM 3aKOHo,n:aTeJIhCTBOM H JIOKaJIbHhIMH HopMaTHBHhIMH aKTaMH OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» H 000 «l.(Yil BCTO, B cosoxynnocra MOrJIH nOBJIH5ITb na COCT05ITeJIhHOCTh repros H CTaB5IT non COMHeHHe ofiocnoaaaaocrr, rrpHH5IThIX na KOHKYpCax pemeaaa rro BhI60py nofieztarenetl ropros.

B COOTBeTCTBHH co CT. 449 Fpascraucxoro xoztexca PeI> B cnynae npOBe.n:eHH5I ropros C napynreaaea npaBHJI, YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX 3aKOHOM, ropra MorYT 6hITh npaaaaasr He.n:eiicTBHTeJIhHhIMH rro HCKY saanrepeconaaaoro JIHn;a. TIpH3HaHHe ropros He.n:eH:CTBHTeJIhHhIMH BJIeqeT He,n:eH:CTBHTeJIhHOCTh zroroaopa, 3aKJIIOqeHHOrO no arorav ropros.

Paaee, B HIOJIe 2007 rona COTpy,n:HHKaMH YrrpaBJIeHH5I repros OAO «AK «Tpaacnerprr,» ocynrecrsnena nposepxa opranasauna H nponeztypsr nposeneaaa ropros rro CTpOHTeJIhCTBY 06beKTOB BCTO, B pe3YJIhTaTe KOTOPOH: 6hIJIH BbI5IBJIeHhI MHOrOqHCJIeHHhle, rro cymecrsy, MaCCOBble napyntenaa Tpe6oBaHHH: 3aKOHo.n:aTeJIhCTBa H JIOKaJIhHhIX HopMaTHBHhIX aKTOB 0 nposeztenna ropros, B TOM qHCJIe:

- OTCYTCTBHe orry6JIHKOBaHH5I H3Bem;eHHH: B CMI1 0 nepenocax CPOKOB npaexra 3a5IBOK, ,n:aThI BCKPhITH5I KOHBepTOB C KOHKypCHbIMH rrpe,n:JIO)l(eHH5IMH;

6

E1 i1

J !

~

It

i :

, ;

~

I ;

~

\ I

I r \ .}

~.

)

00 ~h

I i

- OTCYTCTBHe npOTOKOJIa 0 ,L(OnYCKe npeTeH,UeHTOB K ysacrmo B xoaxypce no scei« npoaepeaaua JIOTaM;

- OTCYTCTBHe p3.3pellIHTeJIhHhIX ,UOKYMeHTOB; B COCTaBe KOHKYPCHOH ,UOKYMeHTaU;HH

OTCYTCTByeT 060CHOBaHHe paCqeTHOn

CTOHMOCTH JIOTOB, pacseraas CTOHMOCTh He YK3.3hIBaeTC5I, He YK3.3hIBalOTC5I CpOKH OKOHqaHH5I npaeaa KOHKypCHhIX rrpe,UJIO)J(eHHH H CpOKH BCKPhITH5I KOHBepTOB C KOHKypCHhIMH rrpe,UJIO)J(eHH5IMH, BhI5IBJIeHhI HeCOOTBeTCTBH5I Me)IC,UY ,UaTaMH YTBep)IC,UeHH5I H COrJIaCOBaHH5I KOHKypCHon ,UOKYMeHTaU;HH;

- yqacTHHKaMH xorrxypca He rrpe,UOCTaBJI5IeTC5I ofiecnesemre KOHKypCHhIX rrpe,UJIO)ICeHHn (6aHKOBCKa5I rapaHTH5I);

- 6aHKOBCKHe raparrraa, BhI,UaHHhle B otiecnesenae YQaCTH5I B xonxypce, orpopscreau C aapymeaaea CPOKOB ,UenCTBH5I, nozmacamr HeynOJIHOMOQeHHhIMH JIHu;aMH, JIH60 6e3 HaJIH~5I rrO,UTBep)J(,UeHH5I rrOJIHOMO"lfHn (,UOBepeHHOCTeH), a TaK)J(e C YKa3aHHeM HeBepHhIX HaHMeHOBaHHn JIOTOB;

- OTCYTCTBYIOT oparaaansaue no,UnHCH ynOJIHOMO"lfeHHhIX JIHU;, He YKa3hIBaeTC5I zrara nonnacanaa, HeBepHO YKa3hIBaeTC5I HaHMeHOBaHHe JIOTOB, He YKa3hIBaeTC5I 6aHK, KOTOPhIH 065I3yeTC5I npe,UCTaBHTb 06eCneQeHHe BhITIOJIHeHH5I YCJIOBHn ztorosopa (6aHKOBCKYlO rapaHTHIO) HJIH YKa3hIBaeTC5I 6aHK, OTCYTCTBYlOmHH B KOHKypCHon ,UOKYMeHTaU;HH, KOHKypCHhle rrpe,UJIO)J(eHH5I nozmacaasr. HeyrrOJIHOMOQeHHhIMH JIHU;aMH, JIH60 6e3 HaJIH"lfH5I rrO,UTBep)J()l;eHH5I nOJIHOMOQHH (,UOBepeHHOCTeH);

- B npOTOKOJIaX no YTBep)J()l;eHHlO pe3YJIhTaTOB rrpeztsaprrrensrroro KBaJIHcpHKaU;HOHHoro oroopa (nanee - TIKO) BhI5IBJIeHhI aeofocaonaaasre penreaaa KOHKYPCHon KOMHCCHH 0 ,L(OnYCKe/OTKJIOHeHHH yqacTHHKOB;

- npHHHMalOTC5I penreans 0 ,UOCPO"lfHOM BCKPhITHH 6e3 rrpHJIO)J(eHH5I COrnaCH5I yqacTHHKOB ropros, B TOM QHCJIe 6e3 C06JIlO,UeHH5I YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO 3aKOHo,UaTeJIhCTBOM cpoxa B 30 ztaea,

TIo OKOHQaHHH nposepxa, rrpoBo,UHBITIenC5I pa60THHKaMH OAO «AK «Tpancaerprs», B HIOJIe 2007 rona MaTepHaJIhI TOprOB, KOHKypCHhle rrpe,UJIo)J(eHH5IYQaCTHHKoB rrozraeprnncs HCnpaBJIeHH5IM H H3MeHeHHHM, ,UencTBHTeJIhHhle ,UOKYMeHThI H 06CT05ITeJIhCTBa nposeneaanx KOHKypCOB 6hIJIH c}JaKTHQeCKH HCKa)J(eHhI (I1pHJIo)J(eHHe No8).

BhIBO,L(hI:

1. Toprn no BhI60py rro,UpH,UHhIX OpraHH3aU;Hn, rrOCTaBmHKOB o6oPy,UoBaHH5I, HCrrOJIHHTeJIerr: pa60T (ycnyr) ,UJIH peaJIH3aU;HH npoexra cTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC BCTO rrpoBo,UHJIHCh C MHOrOQHCJIeHHhIMH H rpy6hIMH HapYllIeHH5IMH ,Uerr:cTBYIOIu;ero 3aKOHo,UaTeJIhCTBa, HOpM H npasnn YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX JIOKaJIhHhIMH HopMaTHBHhIMH aKTaMH (ycTaHOBJIeHO 674 HapYllIeHHH). TIo cymecrsy ropra 5IBJI5IJIHCh CPOPMaJIhHhIMH, a HX pe3YJIhTaT sapaaee npezronpenenenasne.

2. B HopMaTHBHon ,UOKYMeHTaU;HH, perYJIHpYIOIu;en npoaezrenae repros B 000 «I.{YTI BeTO», HMeIOTC5I HapYllIeHHH ,Uerr:cTBYlOmero 3aKOHo,UaTeJIhCTBa H BHYTpeHHHx ,UoKYMeHToB OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,».

3. B 000 «I.{YI1 BCTO» ztonymeasr c}JaKThI He3aKOHHoro YHH"lfTO)J(eHHH MaTepHaJIOB KOHKypCHhIX ropros rro JIOTaM MTP, CMP H YCJIyraM, QTO HBJI5IeTC5I rpy6hIM napynrenaex CTaThH 27 <1>e,UepaJIhHOr03aKoHa OT 22 OKTH6p5I 2004 rona N2 125-<1>3 «06 apXHBHOM ,UeJIe B POCCHHCKOH <1>e,UepaU;HH» H ztpyrax HopMaTHBHhIX ,UOKYMeHTOB.

4. B aapymeaae Tpe60BaHHH ,UeHCTBYlOIu;ero 3aKOHo,UaTeJIhCTBa, B MaTepHaJIhI ropros rrOCJIe 3aBepllIeHH5I KOHKypCHhIX rrpouezryp 000 «I.{YI1 BCTO» BHOCHJIHCh HCnpaBJIeHH5I.

7

l jJ

~

I !

" ,I

~

I ;

\: ,i

~

I 'l i

\ .j

rr

n

l "

~

.

!'.!

~

, '

t

\ .;

~.

,

i!

\ ",

~

, ..

, i "

~

I I

L'

llpHJIO'leCHHH:

Ilepesem, zterr C MaTepI:IaJIaMH npOBepKI:I;

IIpI:InmKeHI:Ie . 1. Ilepcsem, nOTOB, no rrpoaenerrasn« 000 «L{YII BCTO» roprau sa nepaozi 2006 - 2008 r.r., no,n;JIe)I<aBIIII:IX I:ICCne,n;oBaHI:IIO (ToM 1, CTp. 1-22);

IIpnnmKeHI:Ie2. KOnI:IH HOpMaTIfBHhIX npasossrx aKTOB (ToM 2, CTp. 1-323); IIpI:InmI<eHHe 3. IIpaBoBaJI onenxa BHyrpeHHI:IX ,n;oKYMeHToB 000 «L{YII BCTO», pernaMeHTI:IpYIOrn;I:IX rrposenerrae 'ropron (ToM 1, CTp. 23-25);

IIpI:Ino)l(eHI:Ie 4. ,l{oKYMeHThI 06 YHI:IqTO)l(eHI:II:I MaTepI:IaJIOB ropros (ToM 1, cTp.26-76);

IIpI:InmKeHI:Ie 4A. Ilpanosoe 3aKnIO"'IeHI:Ie no rpaKTY yHI:IqTO)!CeHI:I~ MaTepI:IaJIOB

KOHKypCHhIX repros no nOTaM MTP, CMP I:I ycnyrax, xoropue nposonanacs B 2006-2007 .r.r. (ToM 1, c1p.77-78);

IIpI:Ino)!(eHI:Ie 5. AKT no peaynsrarax npOBepKI:I OpraHI:I3aU;I:II:I I:I nponenypsr nposezteaaa roproa no BhI60py nOCTaBrn;I:IKOB ooopyaosaaaa I:I MTP ,n;AA CTpOI:ITenhCTBa 06'heKTOB BCTO (ToM 3 CTp. 1-286, TOM 4 crp, 287-676, TOM 5 cTp.677-1046);

IIpI:Ino)l(eHI:Ie 6. AKT no pesynsraraa npOBepKI:I OpraHI:I3aU;I:II:I I:I npouenypu nposeneaas ropros no B:hI6opy no,n;p~,n;"'II:IKOB na npOI:I3Bo,n;CTBO P(i60T (ssmonaeaae ycnyr) ,n;n~ crpoarenscrna 06'heKTOB BCTO (ToM 6, cTp.1-396, TOM 7, cTp.397-653);

IIpI:Ino)!ceHI:Ie 6A. AKT no peaynsraraa npOBepKI:I OpraHI:I3aU;I:IH H nponeztypsr rrpoaezteaaa ropros no BhI60py no,n;p~,n;"'II:IKOB na npOI:I3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T (BhIIIOnHeHl:le ycnyr) ,n;AA cTpOHTeJIhCTBa 06'heKTOB BCTO (MaTepHaJIhI, npezrcrasnenasre 000 «L(YII BCTO» na TeH,n;epHhIH KOMHTeT OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs») (ToM 7, crp, 1-132);

IIpI:Ino)l(eHHe 7. Ilpaaosoe 3aKnIO"'IeHI:Ie no pesynsrarax paccxrorpeaaa co6nIO,n;eHI:I~ YCTaHOBneHHhIx HOPM, npasan I:I nopaznca nponenenas ropros 000 «L(YII BCTO» no BhI60py rronpazrasrx H rrpoexrasrx opranasanan, nOCTaBrn;HKOB o60py,n;OBaHI:I~, I:ICnOnHHTeneH pa60T (ycnyr) ,n;AA peaJIH3au;HI:I npoexra CTpOI:ITenhCTBa TC «BCTO», 06ocHoBaHHocTH npHH~T.hIX na xoaxypcax pemeana (ToM 1, cTp.79-90).

IIpI:Ino)l(eHHe 8.Pe3ynhTaThI npOBepKI:I opraHH3au;I:II:I H nponezrypsr npoaezreaaa TOproB no CTp0I:ITenhcTBY 06'heKTOB BCTO na Tn., MaTepI:IaJIhI rrpoaepxn 2007 rona na 278 n,

IIflEHbI KOMl1CCHH ,l{eMHH A.M.

PyCJI~KOB H.M.

Kaprros C.A.

Boanapes A.ID.

POroBOH B.H.

ParY30Ba H.H.

)l(aBopoHKOB <P.B.

Xapseaxo K.H.

8

OTqCT

pa60qeH rpyrmsr no sonpocy N2 4 TIepeqH5I MepOnpH5ITHH no cfiopy H nO,IlTOTOBKe ,Il;OKYMeHTOB H HHCPOPMaU:HH ,Il;JI5I CqeTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <De,IJ:epaU:HH

Bo HCrrOJIHeHHe Pacnopascenaa OAO «AK «Tpancaedrrs» OT 21 HIOJI5I 2008 rO,IJ:a N2 21 H TIepeqH5I MepOnpH5ITHH no cfiopy H nO,Il;rOTOBKe ,IJ:OKYMeHToB M HHCPOPMaU:HH ,IJ:JI5I CqeTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <I>e,IJ:epaU:HH pa60qeH rpyrmoii B COCTaBe:

- Xap,IJ:bIKHHa C.A. - 3aMeCTHTeJI5I snne-rrpeaaneara OAO «AK «Tpaacaeors» - ,IJ:HpeKTOpa zrenapraeenra «CJIY)K6a 6e30naCHOCTH»;

- fJIa3YHoBa P.B.- 3aMeCTHTeIDI nasansnaxa KPO 000 "TH<I>";

- Kapnosa C.A. - nasansnaxa OT,Il;eJIa npasoaoro H uopaarnaaoro cOnpOBO)l(,Il;eHH5I

ropros OAO "AK "Tpaacaeiprs";

- ,n:paqeBa A.A. - uauam.aaxa OT,IJ:eJIa nO,IJ:rOTOBKH ropros no CMP OAO "AK "Tpaacaedrn," ;

- Tpycosa C.A. - 3aMeCTHTeJI5I HaqanbHHKa IOpH,Il;HqeCKOrO OT,IJ:eJIa Ilpasosoro ynpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»;

- ParY30BoH H.H.- rJIaBHOrO IOPHCKOHcYJIbTa IOpH,Il;HIJeCKOrO OT,IJ:eJIa Ilpasosoro yrrpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpaacneqrrs»;

- PycIDIKoBa H.M. - 3aMeCTHTeJI5I ,IJ:HpeKTOpa ,Il;enapTaMeHTa «CJIY)K6a 6e30nacHocTH» - HaIJaJIbHHKa OT,IJ:eJIa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30nacHocTH OAO "AK "Tpaacnerprs'';

- )J{aBopoHKoBa <I> .B. - rJIaBHOrO cneU:HaJIHCTa OT,IJ:eJIa 3KOHOMHIJeCKOH fieaonacrrocrn OAO "AK "Tpaacneqm,";

- BOIDIHcKoro n.,n:. - 3aMeCTHTeJI5I HaIJaJIbHHKa npOH3BO,IJ:cTBeHHoro OT,IJ:eJIa OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,» ;

- Tepexosa ,n:.A. - 3aMeCTHTeIDI HaIJaJIbHHKa OT,Il;eJIa cTpaTerHIJeCKOrO pa3BHTH5I OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,», -

nposezreasr MepOnpH5ITH5I no cfiopy H rrO,Il;rOTOBKe ,Il;OKYMeHToB H HHCPOpMaU:HH ,Il;IDI CIJeTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <I>e,Il;epaU:HH no sonpocy 0 CPHHaHCOBOH U npOH3BO,IJ:cTBeHHoH COCT05ITeJIbHOCTH opramrsanan, npH3HaHHbIX n06e,IJ:HTeJI5IMH .roproa, npHBJIeqeHHbIX K cTpOHTeJIbHbIM pa60TaM cy6nb,IJ:p5I,Il;HbIX opraHH3aU:HH.

B pe3YJIbTaTe npOBe,Il;eHHbIX MepOnpH5ITHH YCTaHOBJIeHO CJIe,Il;YIOru:ee.

B 2006 - 2007 r.r. B roprax no BbI60py nO,IJ:p5I,IJ:HbIX opraHH3a:O;MH ,IJ:IDI BbIIIOJIHeHH5I cTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa)KHbIX pa60T aa o6beKTax TC BCTO yqaCTBOBaJIH 9 (,Il;eB5ITb) opraHH3a:O;HH: 3AO «KpaCHO,IJ:apCTpOHTpaHCra3», 000 «CTpoHcHCTeMa», 000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT», OAO «TIPOMCTPOH», 000 «AH TIH Cerr, CTI6», 3AK 00 «Asrepxo HHTepHeIIIeHeJI flHMHTe,IJ:», 000 «MoHTa)l(Crreu:CTpoH», 000 «CTpoHHoBaU:H5I», 000 «CYMMa TeJIeKoM» (JIH,Il;ep npocroro TOBapHlu:eCTBa 000 «CYMMa TeJIeKOM» H 000 «TpaHCHH)l<HHHPHHr»).

TIo6e,IJ:HTeJI5IMH ropron npH3HaHbI 6 (IIIecTb) opraaasanati:

- 3AO "KpacHO,IJ:apCTpOHTpaHCra3" - no 6 (IIIecTH) JIOTaM;

- 000 "Crporicacrena'' - no 4 (serrapea) JIOTaM;

- 000 "CTPOH KOHTHHeHT" - no 3 (rpexr) JIOTaM;

- OAO "TIPOMcTPOH" - no 1 (O,Il;HOMY) JIOTY;

- 3AK 00 "Axrepko HHTepHeIIIeHeJI flHMlfTe,IJ:" - rro 1 (O,Il;HOMY) JIOTy;

- 000 "AH TIH Cers CTI6" - no 1 (O,Il;HOMY) JIOTy.

2

~. r

~

ll'

~I

\ j

~

~

.

( I

M

i J

~

,

\ i I i

Ha OCHOBaHI:IH COrJ1alIIeHHH 0 saverre CTOPOHbI B CeHT5I6pe 2007 rozra pa60TbI na ofit.exrax TC BCTO BMeCTO 000 «CTpoHcHCTeMa» B Ka'IeCTBe rearroztpszrrmca BbIl10J1H5IeT 000 «CHcTeMaCneu;CTpOH», BMeCTO 000 «CTPOH KOHTMHeHT» - 000 «BoCTOI{ CTPOH».

I1HCj}QpMaU;H5I 0 J10TaX, npenaere, y'IaCTHHKax H n06e,n;MTeJ15IX ropros no B1160py noztpaznnrx opraaasanati ,n;J15I B1III0J1HeHH5I cTpOHTeJ11HO-MOHT3)KH1IX pa60T na 06beKTax TC BCTO rrpeztcraaneaa B ITpHJ1Q)I<eHHH NQ 1.

B OTHOlIIeHHH n06e,n;HTeJ1eH ropros - reanonpazursrx opraHH3aI.J;HH no 06beKTaM

CTpOMTeJ1bCTBa TC BCTO n0J1Y'IeH11 CJ1e,n;YIOLUHe ztanasre:

3AO «Kpacnozrapcrpoarpancraa» (I1HH 2310048310, OrPH 1022301628524), saperacrpnposaao 15.04.1998 PemCTpaIJ;HOHHOH naJ1aTOH r. Kpacnozrapa. IOpH,n;H'IeCKHH anpec: r. Kpacnoztap, YJ1. O,n;ecCKa5I, ,n;. 48.

<PaKTH'IeCKHH aztpec: r. Kpacaozrap, YJ1. KpaCH35I, 15511.

Y'Ipe,n;HTeJ11- CTpO.HTpaHCra3 ITaHnJ1aHH flHMHTe,n; (Pecny6JIHKa Kanp), YCTaBHbIH KanHTaJ1 - 50000 py6.

reHepaJ1bHbIH nnpexrop - Hcaxapos Feaaaaaa MHxaHJIoBH'I.

Ha MOMeHT 3aKJIIO'IeHH5I rronpxztasrx noronopoa aa CTpOHTeJIbCTBO 06beKToB TC BCTO 3AO Kpacaorrapcrpoarpaacras» HMeJ10 CTa)J( pa60TbI B He<pTera30BOH OTpaCJIH 7 JIeT.

Pe3YJIbTaTbI <pMHaHcoBO-X035IHCTBeHHoH ,n;e5ITeJIbHOCTM sa nOCJIe,n;HHe ro.nsr

xapaKTepH3YIOTC5I cJ1e,n;YIOmHMH nOKa3aTeJ15IMH:

Bsrpysxa: 2003 r. - 115,1 MJ1H. py6., 2004 r. - 1016,5 MJ1H. py6., 2005r. - 322,7 MJ1H. py6., sa 9 MeC5Iu;eB 2006 r. - 2717 MJ1H. py6.

BbIl10JIHeHO CMP C06CTBeHHbI.MH CHJIaMH (OT otintero 06beMa pa60T B %): 2003 r. - 0%, 2004 r. - 0%, 2005 r, - 44%.

C06CTBeHHbIe OCHOBHbIe cpezrcrsa: 2003 r. - 5,5 MJIH. py6., 2004 r. - 4,4 MJ1H. py6., 2005 r. - 35,8 MJ1H. py6., aa 9 MeC5IIJ;eB 2006 r. - 35,5 MJ1H. py6.

ITo COCT05IHHIO aa 15.11.2006 06LUa5I 'IHCJ1eHHOCTb rrepconana 3AO

«Kpacaozrapcrpotrrpaacras» no pe3YJ1bTaTaM nposepxa, npoaezreaaoa CneIJ;HaJ1MCTaMH 000 «I(YIT BCTO», COCTaBJ15IJ1a 291 pa6oTHHKa, B TOM 'IHCJ1e HH)J(eHepHO-TeXHH'IeCKH.H nepCOHaJ1- 92 'IeJIOBeKa, pa60'IHX CTpOHTeJ1bHbIX cneIJ;HaJ1bHOCTe.H - 149 'IeJ10BeK.

Bvecre C TeM, no O<pHIJ;HaJ1bHbIM ,n;aHHbI.M TeppHTOpHaJ1bHOrO opran a <Pe,n;epaJ1bHOH CJ1Y)J(6bI rocynapcrseaaoa CTaTHCTHKH (POCCTaT) no KpaCHo,n;apCKOMY xparo 3AO «Kpacaoztapcrpojrrpaacraa» B 2006 rozty HMeJ10 cpe,n;HecnHCO'IHYIO 'IHCJ1eHHOCTb rrepconana OT 35 ,n;o 45 'IeJ10BeK, a B 2007 r.r. - 12 - 14 'IeJ10BeK. TaKHM 06Pa30M, CBe,n;eHH5.I 0 'IHCJ1eHHOCTH nepconana nonpaaaoa OpraHH3aIJ;HH, yxasaansre B KOHKypCHbIX npcztnozccaaax OpraHH3aU;HH, He COOTBeTCTBOBaJ1H ,n;eHCTBHTeJ11HOCTH.

B c06CTBeHHOCTH y 3AO «Kpacnozrapcrpcarpaacras» HMeJIOCb 26 e,n;HHHIJ; TeXHHKH H ofiopyzioaaaaa, B TOM 'IHCJ1e 2 e,n;HHHIJ;bI rpysonozrsesmsrx MalIIHH H MeXaHH3MOB, 20 e,n;HHHIJ; CBapO'IHOrO 060py,n;oBaHH5I, 4 e,n;HHHIJ;bI TpaHCrrOpTHbIX cpeztcrs.

COrJ1aCHO KOHKypCHbIM rrpe,n;J1o)J(eHH5IM 3AO «Kpacrronapcrpotirpaacraa»,

npencraaneaasrv na ropra no BbI60py nonpsnasrx opraHH3aU;HH ,n;J15I BbIIIOJIHeHH5I CMP na ofir.exrax TC BCTO, npaKTH'IeCKH BC5I TeXHHKa ,n;J151 BbIl10J1HeHH5I cTpOHTeJ1bHO-MOHTa)KHbIX pa60T apeanyerca,

B CBOHX KOHKypCHbIX rrpe,n;J1Q)KeHH5.lX 3AO «Kpacaoztapcrportrpaacras»:

- no 06beKTY «I1epBa5I O'Iepe,n;b rpyfionponoznron CHCTeMbI "BOCTO'IH35I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH". flHHeHH35I 'IaCTb. Y'IaCTOK KM 2144 - KM 2281, D 1220MM» (JIOT NQ BCTOlfl-2) 3MBHJ10 ,n;J15I BbIIIOJ1HeHH5I pa60T 6 cytinoztpxnasrx opraHH3aU;HH C 94,9 % OT ofirnero o6beMa pa60T. CBe,n;eHH5I 0 rrpaanexaeasrx nepconane H TeXHHKe cy6rro,n;PMHbIX opraHH3aU;HH B KOHKypCHOM npezmoxeann OTCYTCTBYIOT. 3AO «Kpacaozrapcrpoarpaacras» rrpaKTH'IeCKH HHKaKHX CMP na ofisexre C06CTBeHHbIMH CHJ1aMH He BbIII0J1H5IJ10;

~'

I ! I !

I. ~ i

I .

~

,

I '

I.

~ ~,

J

I •

~,.

.

,

J I

I :

t:

!lB ~1

II','":,.

~I

3

I I

- no 06beKTY «ITepBaJI Oqepe.n;b rpytionposozraoa CHCTeMbI "BOCTOqHaH CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO). Pacnrapeaae rpyoonposonaoa CHCTeMbI BCTO. YqaCTOK N2 2 (r. Tsrnzra - r.AJI.n;aH). flHHeHHaH sacre, KM 2202 - KM 2620» (JIOT N2 BCTOIP-2) 3a5IBHJIO .n;lliI BbITIOJIHeHH5I pa60T 4 cy6no.n;p5I.n;Hble opranasanaa C 11,57 % OT ofirnero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHHH 0 rrpHBJIeKaeMbIX nepconane H TeXHHKe cytinonpsmrsrx opraHH3aI(HH B KOHKypCHOM npennosceaan OTcyTcTB)'lOT. <DaICTHqeCICH B pafiorax na ofiseicre rrpHHHMaJIH ysacrne 11 cytirtoztpxzmsrx opranasauaa, xoropsre BbITIOJIHHJIH sees o6beM pacer, 3AO «Kpacaonapcrpoarpancras» rrpaICTHqeCICH HHKaICHX CMP na ofii.exre co6cTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH He BbITIOJIHHJIO;

- rro 06beKTY «ITepBaH OtIepe.n;b rpytionpononaofi CHCTeMbI «BOCTOtIHaJI CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH» (BCTO). Pacnrapeaae rpyrionposozmoii CHCTeMbI BCTO. YtIaCTOK N2 3 (TaJIaKaHCKoe MeCTopo)Ic,n;eHHe - r. AJI.n;aH). flHHeHHaJI xacrs, KM 1570 - 2202 KM (JIOT N2BCTO/P-4) 3a5IBHJIO .n;lliI BbITIOJIHeHH5I pa60T 9 cytinozrpazunrx opraHH3aI(HH C 59,6% OT ofimero o6beMa pafior, CBe.n;eHH5I 0 npHBJIeKaeMbIX nepconane H TeXHHKe cyfinonpaztaux opraHH3aI(HH B KOHICypCHOM npezmcoxeaaa OTCYTCTBYlOT. <DaKTHqeCKH B pafiorax aa ofisexre rrpHHHMaJIH ynacrae 16 cyononpannsrx opraHH3aI(HH, xoropsre BbIIIOJIHHJIH sees o6beM paoor. 3AO «Kpacnonapcrpokrpaucras» rrpaKTHtIeCKH HHKaKllX CMP na o6beKTe co6cTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH He BbITIOJIH5IJIO. K HaCT05III(eMY BpeMeHH KOHTpaKT N2 568-07 OT 20.04.2007 pacroprnyr 3aKa3qHKOM B O.n;HOCTopoHHeM nopxznce B CB5I3H C HeBbITIOJIHeHHeM IIo.n;p5I.n;tIHKOM KOHrpaKTHbIX 065I3aTeJIbCTB, BMeCTO Hero B anpene 2008 r, 3aKJIlOtIeHbI rrpavsre KOHTpaKTbI C 9 (.n;eB5ITblO) opraHH3a~H5IMH, pa60TaBIIIHMH y 6bIBmero reanozrpamaxa na cytinozrpane,

no o6beKTY «ITepBaJI onepezts rpyooupoaonaon CHCTeMbI «BOCTOtIHaJI CH6HPb - TI:IXHH oxeaa", CrpOHTeJIbCTBO HITC N2 21 "CKOBOPO.n;HHO», BKJIlOtIa5I o6beKTbI naemnero 3JIeKTpocHa6)J(eHHH» (JIOT N2 BCTO/HIIC-CKoBopo.n;HHo) 3aJIBHJIO .n;JI5I BbmOJIHeHH5I pa60T 3 cy6rro.n;p5I.n;HbIe opraaasanna C 85% OT ofinrero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHH5I 0 rrpHBJIeKaeMbIX rrepconane H TeXHHKe OT cytinoztparnrsrx opraaasanaii B KOHKypCHOM rrpennozceaaa OTCYTCTBYlOT. <DaICTHqeCKH B pafiorax na ofisexre rrpHHHMaJIH ysacrne 8 cyononpszmsrx opraHH3aI(HH, xoropsre BbITIOJIHHJIH necs o6beM pafior. 3AO «Kpacaozrapcrponrpaacras» rrpaKTHtIeCKH HHKaICHX CMP na o6beKTe co6cTBeHHbIMH CH:JIaMH He BblrrOJIH5IJIO. K HaCTO?III(eMY BpeMeHH KOHTPaICT N2 584-07 OT 15.06.2007 pacroprnyr 3aKa3tIHKOM B O.n;HOCTopoHHeM nopamce B CB5I3H C HeBbIIIOJIHeHHeM. ITO.n;P5I.n;tIHKOM KOHTpaKTHbIX 065I3aTeJIbCTB, BMeCTO Hero 3aKJIlOtIeH KOHrpaKT N2 912-08 OT 15.04.2008 C KpacHo51pcKHM qmJIHaJIOM OAO «CTpoHTpaHCra3» ;

- rro o6beICTY «ITepBaJI o-repens rpytionponozraoa CHCTeMbI "BOCTOtIHaJI CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH". CTpOHTeJIbCTBO BITC N2 8» (JIOT N2 BCTO/HITC-8I1) 3aJIBHJIO .n;JI5I BbIIIOJIHeHHH pa60T 3 cytirroztpaaasre OpraHI:I3a~HH C 87% OT ofirrtero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHH5I 0 npHBJIeKaeMbIX nepconane H TeXHHKe OT cy6no.n;p5I.n;HbIX opraaasauaa B KOHKypCHOM npennoxeaaa OTCYTCTBYlOT. <DaICTHqeCKH B pafiorax na ofisexre rrpHHHMaJIH ysacrae 6 cytinonpazrasrx OpraHH3~HH, xoropsre BbIIIOJIHHJIH sees o6beM pafior, 3AO «Kpacaozrapcrpoarpaacras» HHKaKHX CMP na ofisexre co6cTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH He BbITIOJIH51JIO. K HaCT05I~eMy BpeMeHH KOHTpaKT N2 601-07 OT 28.06.2007 pacroprnyr 3aKa3tIHKOM B O.n;HOCTopoHHeM nopaznce B CB5I3H C HeBbITIOJIHeHHeM ITO.n;P5I.n;tIHKOM KOHTpaKTHblx 065I3aTeJIbCTB, BMeCTO Hero 3aICJIlOqeH KOHTpaKT N2 952-08 OT 25.04.2008 C 000 «CTpoHHOBa~H5I»;

- no o6beKTY «ITepBaJI o-repezts rpyoonpoaozmoa CHCTeMbI "BOCTOtIHa51 CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH". CTpOHTeJIbCTBO HITC N2 14» (JIOT N2 BCTO/HIIC-14) 3aJIBHJIO .n;JI51 BbIIIOJIHeHH51 pa60T 3 cytinonpamnae opraaasanaa C 85% OT ofintero 06beMa pafior, CBe.n;eHHH 0 npHBJIeKaeMbIX nepcoaane H TeXHHKe OT cyfinoztpaztasrx opraaasanaa B KOHKypCHOM npe.n;JIO)J(eHHH OTCYTCTBYlOT. <DaKTHqeCI<H B pafiorax aa 06beKTe rrpHHHMaJIH YtIaCTHe 4 cytirroztpazmsre opraH:I:I3aI(HH, xoropsre BbIIIOJIHHJIH sees o6beM pafior, 3AO «Kpacaozrapcrpoarpancras» npaKTHtIeCKH HHKaICHX CMP aa 06beKTe co6CTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH He BbIITOJIH5IJIO. K HaCT051II(eMY BpeMeHH KOHTpaKT N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007 C 3AO «Kpacaozrapcrpoarpaacras» pacroprayr rro COrJIaIIIeHHlO CTOPOH B CB513H C H3MeHeHHeM 06CT05ITeJIbCTB (H3MeHHJIOCb MeCTO

I

·

I

·

·

I

,

4

CTpOHTeJIbCTBa 06'beKTa), BMeCTO Hero 3aKJIIOqeH KOHTpaKT N2 927-08 OT 30.05.2008 c3AK 00 «Avepxo YIHTepHeIIIeHeJI JIHMllTe,ll».

ITo COCT05IHHIO na 15.11.2006 B KOMMCCHIO 000 «~YIT BCTO», npoBo,n:HBIIIYIO B paxxax YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX KOHKypCHbIX npouezryp nposepxy 3AO «Kpacaoztapcrpojtrpaacras», rro,n:p5I,n:qHKOM 6bIJIH npeztcraaneau ,n:OKYMeHTbI 0 TOM, qTO Y opraaasanaa B pacnopsaceamr llMeeTC5I 618 e,n:HHM~ cTpOMTeJIbHOH TeXHHKM, MaIIIMH, MexaHH3MOB M o6oPy,n:oBaHM5I, B TOM qHCJIe: 100 MaIIIMH ,n:JI5I no,n:rOTOBHTeJIbHbIX M 3eMJI5IHbIX pafior, 84 ezraaausr rpysonozrseaaux MaIIIHH M o6oPy,n:oBaHM5I, 141 eztaaana CBapOqHOrO otiopynosaaas, 38 e,n:MHH~ MaIIIHH H ofiopyzosaaaa ,n:JI5I nponssoncrsa OqllCTHbIX, ll30JI5I~MOHHbIX II cnenaansasrx pafior, 8 e,n:HHH~ MaIIIHH H ooopynonarraa ,n:JI5I cTpOHTeJIbCTBa nepexoztoa pex Tpa,n:ll~llOHHbIM cnocofioxr, 2 YCTaHoBKll ropM30HTaJIbHOrO 6ypeHH5I, 50 e,n:llHll~ MaIIIllH M o60py,n:OBaHM5I ,n:JI5I nponanozrcraa otintecrpoarensnux pafior, 147 e,n:HHM~ rparrcnoprnsrx cpezrcrn, 4 eztaaansr MaIIIHH II ooopyncsasas ,n:JI.5I nporcranxa Ka6eJIeH CB5I3ll, 12 cneuaansasrx MaIIIHH M ofiopynonaaaa ,n:JI5I CTpOllTeJIbCTBa BJI II cOOPY)I<eHllH 3X3 II ztp, YI3 YKroaHHoH TeXHllKH 96% ee ofimero KOJIHqeCTBa 3HaqHJIOCb B apeane.

COrJIaCHO 06'beKTHbIM nJIaHaM opraaasanaa CTpOllTeJIbCTBa (ITOC) aa BbIIIOJIHeHlle pa60T no CJIe,n:YIOm;HM 06'beKTaM:

- «ITepBM Oqepe,n:b rpyfiorrpoaozraoji CllCTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5I CH6MPb - THXllH OKeaH".

JIHHeHHa5I xacrs. YqaCTOK KM 2144 - KM 2281, D 1220MM» (KoHTpaKT N2 135-06 OT 07.05.2006) Tpe6yeTC5I 412 ezmaan rexnaxa M ofiopynoaanaa, Ilorpeonocrs B nepcoaane C yseroa rpaoaxa cTpOMTeJIbCTBa M pacnpeneneaas pa60T no TeXHOJIOrllqeCKHM nOTOKaM COCTaBJI5IeT OT 469 no 1611, B TOM qnCJIe YITP OT 66 ,n:o 228, patio-tax cTpOllTeJIbHbIX Cne~HaJIbHOCTeH OT 403 no 1383;

- «ITepBa5I oxepezrs rpyoonposonaoa cMcTeMbI"BoCTOqHa5I Cll6MPb - TJrXM:H OKeaH" (BCTO). Pacurapeaae rpyoonpoaoznroa cacreasr BCTO. YqaCTOK N22 (r. Tsrana - r. AJI,n:aH). JIHHeHHa5I xacrs, KM 2202 - KM 2620» (KoHTpaKT N2 406-07 OT 01.02.2007) Tpe6yeTC.5I 1075 e,n:HHH~ TeXHMKM M ofiopyztonaaaa. Ilorpefiaocrs B rrepconane C yseroa rpadnnca CTpOllTeJIbCTBa II pacnpezreneaas pa60T no TeXHOJIOmqeCKllM nOTOKaM COCTaBJI5IeT 3377 qeJIOBeK, B TOM qHCJIe I1TP - 330, pafioxax cTpOllTeJIbHbIX Cne~MaJIbHOCTeH - 3047;

- «ITepBa5I Oqepe,n:b rpytionpononnoa CMCTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5I CM6MPb - TllXMH OKeaH" (BCTO). PacIIIMpeHMe rpyfionpoaoztaon CllCTeMbI BCTO. YqaCTOK NQ 3 (TaJIaKaHCKoe MeCTOpO)I(,n:eHMe - r. AJI,n:aH). JIllHeHHa5I qaCTb, KM 1570 - KM 2202» (KoHTpaKT NQ 568-07 OT 20.04.2007). COrJIaCHO pa60qeH ,n:OKyMeHT~Hll KOHTpaKT pasfirrr aa 5 06'beKToB. Ilorpefiaocrs B TeXHHKe II otiopyncsaaaa COCTaBJI5IeT 13 79 ezmnan, qTO 60JIee qeM B rma pasa npessnrraer KOJIllqeCTBO MMeIOm;eiic.5I y Ilonpxzrraxa B nana-raa. Ilorpefiaocrs B rrepconane C y-rerou rparpaxa cTpOMTeJIbCTBa M pacnpeneneaaa pa60T no TeXHOJIOrMqeCKMM nOTOKaM na Ka)K,n:hIH M3 5-THno,n:06'beKTOB COCTaBJI5IeT OT 288 zto 1663, B TOM qHCJIe I1TP - OT 41 zro 162, paooxax cTpOllTeJIbHbIX Crre~HaJIbHOCTeH - OT 247 ,n:o 1501;

- «ITepBa5I Oqepe,n:b .rpytioupoaonnof CMCTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5I CM6HPb - TMXMH oxeaa", CTpOHTeJIbCTBO BITC N2 21 "CKOBOPO,n:llHO», BKJIIOqa5I 06'beKTbI BHeIIIHero 3JIeKTpOCHa6)I(eHll5I" (KoHTpaKT NQ 584-07 OT 15.06.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 335 eznrann TeXHllKM M ofiopyztosanas. Ilorpetiaocrs B nepconane C yseroa rparpmca cTpOllTeJIbCTBa H pacnpeneneaaa pa60T rro TeXHOJIOrllqeCKHM rrOTOKaM COCTaBJI5IeT 582 qeJIOBeKa, B TOM qMCJIe I1TP - 82, pa60qHX cTpOllTeJIbHbIX cneuaam.aocrea -500;

- «ITepBa5I Oqepe,n:b rpytionposozraoa CllCTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5I CM6HPb - THXllH OKeaR".

CTpOliTeJIbCTBO BITC N2 8» (KoHTpaKT N2 601-07 OT 28.06.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 223 e,n:HHll~ TeXHllKH H o60py,n:OBaRH5I. Ilorpetiaocrs B nepcoaane C yseroi« rpaqnrxa cTpOMTeJIbCTBa II pacrrpenenenas pa60T no TeXHOJIOrllqeCKHM nOTOKaM COCTaBJI5IeT 233 qeJIOBeK, B TOM qHCJIe YITP - 82, pa60"'IHX cTpOllTeJIbHbIX Cne~llaJIbHOCTeH - 200;

5

- «Ilepsaa Ol.Jepe)l) TPy60npOBO,lJ;HOM CMCTeMbI "BOCTOl.JHM CM6MPIJ - THXHM OICeaH".

CTpOHTeJIIJCTBO HnC N2 14» (KoHTpaKT N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 253 e,lJ;HHHD;IJI TeXHHKH H 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I. nOTpe6HOCTIJ B nepconane C Yl.JeTOM rpaipnxa cTpOHTeJIbCTBa H pacnpeneneaas pa60T no TeXHOJIOrHl.JeCKHM nOTOKaM COCTaBJUIeT OT 94 ,lJ;0 385, B TOM l.JHCJIe I1TP - OT 13,lJ;0 55, pa60l.JHX cTpOHTeJIIJHDIXCneD;HaJIIJHOCTeM - OT 81 ,lJ;0 330.

BblBO,LJ,:

3AO «Kpacaonapcrpoarpancras» na MOMeHT 3aKJIlOqeHHSI KOHTpaKTOB H B nepRO,LJ, UCnOJIHeHUSI ,LJ,OrOBopHhIX o6S13aTeJIhCTB 6hIJIO He B COCTOSlHHH co6CTBeHHhIMU CUJIaMU H C YQaCTHeM opraHH3aU:UH, 3aSlBJIeHHhIX B KOHKypCHhlX npe,LJ,JIOLKeHHllX B KaQeCTBe cy6nO,LJ,pSI,LJ,QUKOB, BhIIIOJIHHTh CTpOUTeJIhHO-MOHTaLKHhIe pa60ThI B nOJIHOM 06beMe, B H:OHTpaI<THhle CPOKU, C C06JIIO,LJ,eHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX npaBHJI npOH3BO,LJ,CTBa pa60T HH no O,LJ,HOMYH3 3aKJIIO'IeHHhIX KOHTpaKTOB no 06beKTaM CTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC BCTO, He pacnonarano ,LJ,JISI sroro Heo6xo,LJ,IIMhIM KOJIII'IeCTBOM nepconana H CTpOHTeJIhHOii TeXHIIKII.

000 «Crpoacucreera» (I1HH 5401167165, OrPH 1025400507945), saperacrpapoaaao 04.08.2000 HOBOCH6HPCKOM rOpO,lJ;CKOM pemCTpal(HOHHOH naJIaTOH

no ropH,lJ;Hl.JeCKoMY aztpecy: r. Mocxsa, YJI. IQ)lCH06YTOBCKM,,lJ;. 45. 03.04.2008 000 «Crpoacacrexra» JIHKBH,lJ;HpOBaHO.

Yl.Jpe,lJ;lfTeJIIJ 000 «Crponcacreaa» - KOMnaHH51 Synteo Limited (Pecnyomnca Kanp), YCTaBHbIH KanHTaJI - 8350 py6JIeH.

Fenepam.nsra ,lJ;HpeKTOp (aa MOMeHT JIHKBH,n;au;HH) - CeHHIIIHH BJIa,lJ;HMHP HHKOJIaeBHl.J.

Ha MOMeHT 3aKJIrol.JeHH5I nO,lJ;pJI,lJ;HbIX ,lJ;OrOBOpOB na CTpOIITeJIIJCTBO 061>eKTOB TC BCTO

000 «Crpoacacreaa» HMeJIa onsrr BbIIIOJIHeHH5I pa60T no KanHTaJIIJHoMypeMoHTY H peKOHCTpYKD;HH MarHCTpaJIIJHbIX He<pTenpOBO,lJ;OB 4 rorra, 000 «Crpoacacresra» B OCHOBHOM BbIIIOJIH5IJIO pa60TbI na 06'beKTaX OAO «TPaHCCH6He<pTh».

Pe3YJIbTaTbI ~HHaHcoBO-X035IMCTBeHHoM ,lJ;eJITeJIIJHOCTH sa nOCJIe,lJ;HHe rO,lJ;DI

xapaKTepH3YIOTC5I cneayrornaaa nOKa3aTeJIJIMH:

Bsrpysxa: 2003 r. - 133,4 MJIH. py6., 2004 r. - 124,1 MJIH. py6., 2005 r, - 2 130,1 MJIH . py6., 2006 r. - 9429,1 MJIH. py6., sa 6 MeC5ID;eB 2007 r. - 5787,6 MJIH. py6.

BbIIIOJIHeHO CMP C06CTBeHHIJIMH CHJIaMH (OT ofintero 061>eMa pa60T B %) no aroraa OTl.JeTHIJIX nepHO,lJ;OB OT 5 ,lJ;0 8 %.

C06cTBeHHbIe OCHOBHDIe Cpe,lJ;CTBa: 2003 r. - 1 MJIH. py6., 2004 r. - 0,7 MJIH. py6., 2005r. - 114,6 MJIH. py6., 2006 r, -71 MJIH. py6., aa 6 MeCJID;eB 2007 r, - 136,9 MJIH. py6.

no COCTOJIHMro na 13.11.2006 06:rn;M "IIHCJIeHHOCTIJ nepconana 000 «Crpoacacreua» - 349 l.JeJIOBeK, B T.l.J. HH)l(eHepHO-TeXHHl.JeCKHH nepCOHaJI - 179 l.JeJIOBeK, pa60"IIHe C1pOMTeJIbHbIX CneD;HaJIbHOCTeH - 86 "IIeJIOBeK, BO,lJ;HTeJIerr - 75 l.JeJIOBeK .

B co6cTBeHHocTM y 000 «Crpoacacreaa» 131 e,lJ;HHHD;a TeXHHKH M 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I, B TOM l.JHCJIe 9 e,lJ;HHHD; rpY30nO,lJ;1>eMHIJIX MaIIIHH H MexaHH3MOB, 76 e,lJ;HHHD; CBapOl.JHOrO 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I, 36 e,lJ;HHHIJ; rpancrroprnsrx Cpe,lJ;CTB.

COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npe,lJ;JIO)lCeHHIO 000 «Crpoacacresra», npe,lJ;CTaBJIeHHoMY aa 'ropra no BIJI60py nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;HIJIX opraHM3aIJ;HH ,lJ;JI5I CMP na 06'beKTaX TC BCTO, B c06cTBeHHocTH opraHH3aIJ;MH HaxO,lJ;MTCJI 92 % OT 06:rn;eli l.JMCJIeHHOCTM cTpOHTeJIIJHOH TeXHMKM, MaIIIHH, MexaHH3MOB H 060PY,lJ;OBaHH5I.

no COCT05IHHro aa 13.11.2006 B KOMHCCHro 000 «IJyn BCTO», rrpoaozraamyro B paaxax YCTaHOBJIeHHIJIX KOHKypCHbIX npouenyp nposepxy 000 «Crpoacacreaa», nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;l.JHKOM 6bIJIH npe,lJ;CTaBJIeHIJI ,lJ;OKYMeHTbI 0 TOM, l.JTO Y 000 «CTPOHCHCTeMa» B pacnopasceaaa HMeeTCJI 143 e,lJ;HHHl(bI cTpOHTeJIbHOM TeXHHKH, MaIIIHH, MexaHM3MOB H 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I, B TOM l.JHCJIe: 11 MaIIIHH ,lJ;JI5I nO,lJ;rOTOBMTeJIbHIJIX H 3eMJI5IHIJIX pa60T, 14 e,lJ;HHMD; rpY30nO,lJ;'beMHbIX MaIIIHH M MexaHM3MOB, 80 e,lJ;HHHIJ; CBapOl.JHOrO 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I, 36 TpaHcnopTHbIX Cpe,lJ;CTB, 5 e,lJ;HHHIJ; cneIJ;MaJIIJHoro 060pY,lJ;OBaHH5I.

I

.

I

.

I I)

I

.

I II

I

,

.

II mJ

6

COrJIaCHO 06beKTHbIM nnanav OpraHlf3aUIU1 CTpOIUeJIbCTBa (TIOC) rro KOHTpar<TaM:

- N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 rro o6beKTY «TIepBa5I ouepens rpyrionpoaozmon CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH oxean". JIHHeHHa5I 1:J:aCTb. Y1:J:aCTOK KM 0- KM 795, D 1067 MM; Y1:J:aCTOK KM 795 - KM 897, D 1220 MM» (JIOT N2 BCTO/JI-l) cTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa:>KHble pa60TbI zro 496 KM ocyruecTBJI5IIOTC5I 5 KOMrrJIeKCHbIMH TeXHOJIOrH1:J:eCKHMH nOTOKaMH, no KOTOPbIM Heo6xo,n:HMO npHBJIe1:J:eHHe rro pa601:J:HM CrreUHaJIbHOCT5IM OT 267 zto 802 pa6oTHHKOB, HH)KeHepHo-TeXHH1:J:eCKHM OT 44,n:o 132 pa6oTHHKOB, a TaK)Ke OT 258 no 517 e,n:HHHU OCHOBHbIX MaIIIHH, MexaHH3MOB H o6oPy,n:oBaHH5I. Ha1:J:HHa5I C 496 KM norpeoaocri, B xanpax, MaIIIHHax H MexaHH3Max paCCl.JHTbIBaeTC5I rrOMeC5I1:J:HO H COCTaBJI5IeT no pa601:J:HM CneUHaJIbHOCT5IM OT 8 no 494 pa6oTHHKOB, I1TP - ,n:o 28 pa6oTHHKOB, a TaK)J{e no 393 e,n:HHHU OCHOBHbIX MaIIIHH, MexaHH3MOB H o6oPy,n:oBaHH5I. B COOTBeTCTBHH C 3aKJII01:J:eHHbIM ,n:onOJIHHTeJIbHbIM COrJIaIIIeHHeM N21 OT 25.05.2006 6bIJIO H3MeHeHO HaHMeHOBaHHe ofir.exra cTpOHTeJIbCTBa, a HMeHHO, «TIepBa5I ouepezn, rpyoonposonnoa CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH oxeaa". JIHHeHHa5I 1:J:aCTb. Y1:J:aCTOK KM 0 - KM 570, D 1067 MM».

- N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 rro o6beKTy«TIepBa5I o-repezrs rpyrionpoaonnof CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH". PacIIIHpeHHe Tpy6onpoBo.n;HOH CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CM6HPb - THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO). Y1:J:aCTOK N2 1 (r. YCTb-KYT - TaJIaKaHCKoe xrecropoarzteaae). I1pKYTcKa5I 06JIaCTb, Pecny6JIHKa Caxa(5IKYTH5I). JIHHeHHa5I =racrs, Yl.JaCTOK 570 KM - .1105 KM.» (JIOT N2 BCTO/P-l) B COOTBeTCTBHH C TIOC na cTpOMTeJIbCTBO, xoropoe pa36MBaeTC5I na 12 TeXHOJIOrH1:J:eCKHX nOTOKOB, aeooxonaao npHBJIe1:J:eHMe no Ka)J{.n;oMY nOTOKY no pa601:J:HM CneU;MaJIbHOCT5IM OT 293 zro 503 pa6oTHMKOB, I1TP - OT 21 zto 54 l.JeJIOBeK, Bo.n;HTeJIeH - OT 26 zto 167 1:J:eJIOBeK, a TaK)J{e OT 294.n;o 575 e.n;MHMU MaIIIHH, MeXaHM3MOB M ofiopyztosaaaa.

- N2 579-07 OT 11.04.2007 no o6beKTY «TIepBa5I osepens Tpy6onpoBo.n;HOH CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CM6MPb - THXHH oxeaa" (BCTO). PacIIIHpeHMe 'rpyfionpoaozmori CMCTeMbI BCTO. Yl.JaCTOK N2 3 (TaJIaKaHCKoe MecTopQ)£(.n;eHMe - r.AJI,n:aH). JIMHeHHa5I xacrs, KM 1105 - KM 1570» (JIOT N2 BCTO/P-3) B COOTBeTCTBHH C TIOC na cT}JoMTeJIbCTBO, xoropoe pa36MBaeTC5I na 10 TeXHOJIOrH1:J:eCKHX nOTOKOB, aeorixozraao npHBJIe1:J:eHMe no Ka)J{JJ;oMY nOTOKY no pa601:J:HM CneU;HaJIbHOCT5IM OT 269 .n;o 355 pa6oTHMKOB, I1TP - OT 40 zto 48 1:J:eJIOBeK, Bo.n;MTeJIeH OT 72 zto 157 1:J:eJIOBeK. TaK)J{e rro Ka)J(.n;oMY TeXHOJIOrM1:J:eCKOMY nOToKY Heo6xo,n:MMO npMBJIe1:J:eHHe OT 193 zro 237 e.n;HHHU; MaIIIHH, MeXaHH3MOB M ofiopyztosaaaa.

B CBOHX KOHKypCHbIX npe.n;JIo)J(eHM5IX 000 «Crpoacacrexa»:

- no o6beKTY «TIepBa5I cxepeas Tpy6orrpoBo.n;Hoil: CMCTeMbI "BOCTOl.JHa5I CM6MPb - THXMH oxeaa", JIHHeHHa5I 1:J:aCTb. Y1:J:aCTOK KM 0 - KM 795, D 1067 MM; Y1:J:aCTOK KM 795 - KM 897, D 1220 MM» (JIOT N2 BCTO/JI-l) 3a5IBHJIO .n;JI5I BbIIIOJIHeHH5I pa60T 11 cyononpazmux opraHM3aUHH C 55% OT ofimero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHH5I 0 npHBJIeKaeMbIX nepconane U TeXHHKe cyfinoztpsztasrx oprasasarraa B KOHKypCHOM npeznroaceaaa OTCYTCTBYIOT. <DaKTM1:J:eCKH na B:bInOJIHeHHe CMP reanoztpazrrax rrPHBJIeK 21 cytinozrpazrayro opraaasanaro;

- rro o6beKTY «TIepBa5I oxepezn, rpyfionpoaozmoa CMCTeMbI "BoCTo1:J:Ha5I CM6HPb - THXHH OKeaH". PacIIIHpeHHe rpyoonposonaoa CHCTeMbI "BOCTOl.JHa5I CH6MPb - TMXMH OKeaH" (BCTO). Y1:J:aCTOK N2 1 (r. Y CTb-KYT - TaJIaKaHCKoe MecTOpo)J(.n;eHHe). I1PKYTCKa5I oonacrs, Pecny6JIHKa Caxa (5IKYTH5I). JIHHeHHa5I 1:J:aCTb. ysacrox 570 KM - 1105 KM» (JIOT N2 BCTO/P-l) 3a5IBHJIO 7 (cesrs) cyfinoztpaztmax OpraHH3aU;HH C 68 % OT ofimero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHH5I 0 npHBJIeKaeMbIX rrepconane H TeXHHKe cytinoztpanasrx opraHH3aU;HH B KOHKypCHOM npe,n:JIQ)KeHHH OTCYTCTBYIOT. <DaKTH1:J:eCKH na BbIIlOJIHeHHe CMP reanozrpazrsnx npHBJIeK 11 cyfinozrpanasrx opraHH3aU;HH. TIpaKTH1:J:eCKH 000 «Crpoacacrexa» HHKaKUX CMP na ofisexre co6cTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH He BbIIlOJIH5IJIO;

- rro 06beKTY «TIepBa5I oxepezrs rpyfiorrpoaoztaoa CHCTeMbI "BOCT01:J:Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH" (BCTO). PaCIIIupeHHe rpytiorrposoznroii CHCTeMbI BCTO. Y1:J:aCTOK N2 3 (Tanaxaacxoe MecTopo)J(,n:eHHe - r. AJI.n;aH). JIHHeHHa5I 1:J:aCTb, KM 1105 - KM 1570» 3a5IBHJIO 8 (noceras) cyfirrozrpsztasrx opraHH3aUHH C 94 % OT ofinrero o6beMa pafior. CBe.n;eHH5I 0 npMBJIeKaeMbIX nepcoaane H TeXHUKe cytinonpazmsrx opraHH3aUHH B KOHKypCHOM rrpe,n:JIQ)KeHHH OTCYTCTBYIOT.

II I

I

·

II I

I

·

,

I

·

7

<DaKTllqeCI<H aa nsmorraeane CMP reanozrpaasnx rrpnanex 14 cyrirronpszmsrx opraaasauna. 000 «CTPOHCllCTeMa» rrpaKTI1QeCKH HHI<aKllX CMP na 06'heI<Te c06cTBeHHhIMll CllJIaMH He BhInOJIH5IJIO.

BbIBO,a::

000 «CTPOHCHCTeMa» na MOMeHT 3aKJIlOIJeHHn KOHTpaleTOB H B nepaon HCnOJIHeHHn AorOBopHblX 06maTeJIbCTB 6b1JIO He B COCTonHHH co6CTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH H C YIJaCTHeM opraHII3a~HH, 3anBJIeHHblX BKOHKypCHblX npennoacermax B KaIJeCTBe cy6noApnAIJHKOB, BbInOJIHHTb CTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTaiKHble pa60TbI B nOJIHOM 06beMe, B KOHTpaKTHble CPOKII, C Co6JI10AeHlleM YCTaHOBJIeHHblX npaBHJI npOH3BOACTBa pa60THII no OAHOMY 113 3aKJIlOIJeHHblX KOHTpaKTOB no 06beKTaM CTpOIITeJIbCTBa TC BeTO, He pacno.narano AJIn aroro Heo6xoAIIMbIM I<:OJIIIIJeCTBOM nepconana II CTpOHTeJIbHOH TeXHHKH.

I

·

000 {{CIICTeMaCne~CTpOH» (I1HH 7731549423, OrPH 5067746072961), saperacrpapouaao 11.08.2006 MI1<DHC N2 46 no r. Mocxse.

IOpH,l(HQeCKHH aapec: r.Mocxsa, YJI.BepxHHe IIOJI5I, ,lJ;.11, xop.J, <DaKTHqeCKHH aapec: r.OMcK, YJI.KeMepOBCKa5I, 9, narepa Zl

E,lJ;HHcTBeHHhIM yspenarenev 000 «CHcTeMaCneu;CTpOH» ,lJ;0 19.11.2007 3HaqHJIOCh nO,lJ;CTaBHOe JIHn:O - rpaaoraaxa POCCllH Eaesa IOJIH5I I'eaaansesaa. C 19.11.2007 yspeztareneu 5IBIDIeTC5I KOMnaHH5I «BeH,lJ;eTTa JIHMHTe,lJ;» (Pecny6JIHKa Kanp).

Baesa IO.r. 5IBIDIJIaCh TaK:>Ke HOMHHarrhHhIM yspezrareness 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH». B nHChMeHHOM 06'h5ICHeHllH OT 04.09.2008 Baena IO.r. yxasana, qTO Pemenae Yqpe,lJ;HTeJI5I N2 5 OT 10.09.2007 0 Ha3HaqeHHH reaepam.asne ,lJ;HpeKTOpoM opraHH3aU;HH Tanynxax T.r. He nO,lJ;IIHCLlBarra H nozmacs na npOTOKOJIe OT ee HMeHH C<paJI:bCHq)HU;HpOBaHa. TaKHM 06Pa30M, COrrraITIeHH5I C 000 «U;YII «BCTO» OT 12.09.2007 0 saxene CTOPOH B KOHTpaKTax N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006, N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006, N2 579-07 OT 11.04.2007, nO,lJ;nHCaHHLIe Tanynxax T.r. OT HMeHH 000 «CHcTeMaCIIeu;CTpOH» MoryT 6LITL npH3HaHLI He,l(eHCTBHTeJILHLIMH.

YCTaBHhIH xanaran - 10 ThIC. py6.

Fcaepansaan ztapexrop - CeHHITIHH BJIMHMHP HHKOJIaeBHq (6LIBllHH reaepam.aaii ,l(HpeKTOp 000 «Crpoiicacrena»), zto HIOH5I 2008 rozta reaepansasra zrapexropora 3HaqHJIC5I

Tanymcax T'F, '

Ha MOMeHT aasana pa60T 000 «CHcTeMaCneu;CTpOH» na 06'heKTaX TC BCTO (ceHT5I6pL 2007 rona) CTOHMOCTh scex ero aKTHBOB COCTaBJI5IJIa 10 TLIC. py6. OnhIT pa60T OTCYTcTBoBarr.

IIPH IIO,l(IIHCaHHH cornamenaa 0 3aMeHe CTOPOHLI (12.09.2007 rona) B KOHTpaKTax 000 «CHCTeMaCrreu;CTpOH» He HMeJIO Heo6xo,lJ;HMLIX ,lJ;IDI BLIIIOJIHeHH5I pa60T na ofisexrax TC BCTO JIHu;eH3HH. COrJIaCHO IIHChMY <De,lJ;eparrhHOro rOCY,lJ;apCTBeHHoro yspeaoreaaa «<De,lJ;eparrhHhIH JIHu;eH3ll0HHLlli nerrrp rrpn POCCTpOe» OT 27.08.2008 N2 2091 CTpOHTeJILHM JIHu;eH3H5I 000 «CHcTeMaCneu;CTpOH» 6LIJIa srazraaa 17.09.2007 co CPOKOM ,n:eHcTBH5I zto 09.1 0.2011. ,[(0 17.09.2007 000 «CllCTeMaCneu;CTpOH» HMeJIO C1poHTeJILHYIO JIHu;eH3HIO, B KOTOPOH OTCYTCTBOBarrll pa6oTLI, CB5I3aHHhle C nOBhIlleHHOH onaCHOCTLIO rrpOMLIllJIeHHLIX npOH3BO,l(CTB H 06'heKTOB (xtaracrpansmre raso-, nedrre-, nponyxroupoaonsr).

IIo COCT05IHHIO na 17.10.2007 06ru;a5I qHCJIeHHOCTL nepconana 000

«CllCTeMaCrreu;CTpoH» no ,l(aHHLIM rrposepxa, rrposezrenaoa cnennanacraaa 000 «U;YII «BCTO» COCTaBJI5IJIa 572 qeJIOBeKa, H3 HHX HH)KeHepHO-TeXHI:IqeCKHH nepcoaan - 264 qeJIOBeKa, patio-me OCHOBHhIX cTpOHTeJIhHLIX cneuaansnocrea - 282 qeJIOBeKa, BO,l(HTeJIH - 135, pafioxae npOQHX cnenaansnocrea - 26 QeJIOBeK.

Bxrecre C TeM, no 0<pI:IU;HarrhHLIM ,l(aHHLIM Mocropcrara 000 «CI:ICTeMaCneu;CTpOH» B 2006 - 2007 r.r. 5IBIDIJIOCh cy6'heKTOM. MaJIOrO rrpe,l(IIpI:IHI:IMaTeJIhCTBa, T.e. QI:ICJIeHHOCTh pa60THI:IKOB Orirnecrsa COrJIaCHO 3aKOHo,n:aTeJILCTBY 0 MarrLIX rrpe,l(IIpI:I5ITI:I5IX COCTaBJI5IJIa He 60JIee 50 QeJIOBeK. TaKI:IM 06Pa30M, CBe,l(eHI:I5I 0 QI:ICJIeHHOCTI:I nepconana IIO,l(P5I,l(HOH OpraHI:I3a[(I:II:I na nary IIpOBepKI:I He COOTBeTCTBOBarrI:I ,l(eHCTBHTeJILHOCTI:I.

11 11

I

·

i

1M 11

I

·

·

I

·

1\1 I

8

I

B C06CTBeHHOCTH Y 000 «CHcTeMaCne~CTpoih> 119 e,[(HHH~ TeXHHKH H

060Py,[(oBaHH5r, B TOM 'IHCJIe: 8 ManIHH ,[(JIH no,[(rOTOBHTeJIbHbIX M 3eMJIHHbIX pafior, 8 e,[(HHH~ rpysonozrseaasrx MallIHH M MexaHH3MOB, 80 e,[(MHH~ CBapO'IHOrO 06oPy,[(oBaHMH, 1 0 e,[(HHM~ ManIHH M ofiopynosaaaa ,[(JIH npoaaaozrcrsa 06meCTpOMTeJIbHbIX pafior, 11 rpaacnopraux cpencrn, rrponee 060py,[(oBaHMe - 2 e,n:HHH~bI.

COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npe,[(JIo)ICeHMlO 000 «CHcTeMaCne~CTpoH» 62 % TeXHHKM ,[(JIH npOH3BO,[(CTBa CTpOI:ITeJIbHO-MOHTa)KHbIX pa60T opraaasanaea apeanyerca.

TIo COCTOHHMlO aa 17.1 0.2007 B KOMHCCMlO 000 «UYTI «BCTO», npoBo,[(MBIlIYlO B pavxax YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX KOHKypCHbIX rrpouezryp nposepxy 000 «CHcTeMaCne~CTpoH», no'[(pH,[('IMKOM 6bIJIH rrpeztcraaneau ,[(oKYMeHTbI 0 TOM, 'ITO Y 000 «CMCTeMaCne~CTpOH» B paCnOpH)KeHMH MMeeTCH 313 e,[(HHH~ cTpOMTeJIbHOH TeXHMKM, MaIlIMH, MexaHM3MOB H 060PY,[(OBaHMH, B TOM 'IHCJIe 48 MaIIIHH ,[(JIH rro,[(rOTOBMTeJIbHbIX M 3eMJIHHbIXpa60T, 46 e,[(HHM~ rpY30nO,[('beMHbIX MaIIIHH M MexaHH3MOB, 123 e,[(HHM~bI CBapO'IHOrO 06oPy,[(oBaHHH, 18 e,[(HHH~ MaIIIHH H 06oPy,[(oBaHHH ,[(JIH npoaasoztcraa 06mecTpOHTeJIbHbIX pa60T, 89 rpaacrroprasrx openers.

COrJIaCHO TIOC no KOH'TpaKTaM:

- N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 (c H3MeHeHMeM rro ,n;onOJIHHTeJIbHoMY cornanreaaro N21 OT 26.05.2006) rro 06'beKTY «TIepBaH ouepezts Tpy60npoBo,[(HOH CMCTeMbI "BOCTO'IHaH CM6MPb - THXHH oxeaa". JIHHeHHaH 'IaCTb. Y'IaCTOK KM 0 - KM 570, D 1067 MM» (JIOT N2 BCTO/J1-1) cTpOMTeJIbHO-MOHTa)ICHbIe pa60TbI ,[(0 496 KM ocymeCTBJIHIOTCH 5 KOMrrJIeKCHbIMM TeXHOJIOrM'IeCKHMH rrOTOKaMM, rro KOTOpbIMHe06xo,[(HMO rrpHBJIe'IeHHe rro pa60'IMM cne~ManbHOCTHM OT 267 ,[(0 802 pa60THHKOB, MH)l(eHepHO-TeXHM'IeCKMM OT 44 ,[(0 132 pa60THHKOB, a raxse OT 258 ,[(0 517 e,[(HHH~ OCHOBHbIX MaIIIHH, MexaHM3MOB H 060Py,[(oBaHHH. Ha'IHHaH C 496 KM nO'Tpe6HOCTb B xaztpax, MaIIIHHax H xrexanasaax paCC'IHTbIBaeTCH rrOMeCH'IHO H COCTaBJIHeT no pa60'IMM cne~HanbHOCTHM OT 8 ,[(0 494 pa60THHKOB, MH)l(eHepHOTeXHH'IeCKMM ,[(0 28 pa60THHKOB, a raioxe ,[(0 3 93 e,[(MHH~· OCHOBHbIX MaIIIMH, MexaHH3MOB H 060Py,[(oBaHHH.

- N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 no 06'beKTY «TIepBaH ouepezu, rpytionpoaozuroa CMCTeMbI "BOCTO'IHaH CM6HPb - THXHH OKeaR". PacIIIHpeHHe rpytionpononaoa CHCTeMbI "BoCTo'IHaH CH6MPb - TMXHH OKeaR" (BCTO). Y'IaCTOK N2 1 (r. YCTb-KYT - Tanaxaacxoe MeCTOp0)l(,lJ:eHHe). HpKYTCKaH 06JIaCTb, Pecnyfinaxa Caxa (.5IKYTHH). JIHHeHHM 'IaCTb. Y'IaCTOK 570 KM - 1105 KM.» (JIOT N2 BCTO/P-l) B COOTBeTCTBHH C TIOC na cTpOHTeJIbCTBO, xoropoe pa36MBaeTcH aa 12 rrOTOKOB He06xo,n:HMO rrpHBJIe'IeHMe no Ka)l(,[(OMY rrOTOKY no pa60'IHM crrenaansaocrax OT 293 ,[(0 503 pa60THHKOB, HH)l(eHepHO-TeXHH'IeCKHX pa60THMKOB OT 21 ,[(0 54 pa60THHKOB, BO,[(llTeJIeH OT 26 zto 167 'IeJIOBeK, a rarose OT 294,[(0 575 e,[(MHH~ MaIIIllH, MexaHH3MOB H ofiopyzronanaa.

- N2 579-07 OT 11.04.2007 no 06'beKTY «TIepBM osepezn, rpytiorrposozraoti CMCTeMbI "BOCTO'IHaH CH611Pb - THXllH OKeaH" (BCTO). Pacmapcaac Tpy60npoBo,[(HOH CHCTeMbI BCTO. Y'IaCTOK N2 3 (TanaKaHCKOe xrecropoacieaae - r. AJI,[(aH). J1HHeHHaH 'IaCTb, KM 1105 - KM 1570» (JIOT N2 BCTOIP-3). B COOTBeTCTBMH C TIOC na CTpOllTeJIbCTBO, xoropoe pa36MBaeTcH na 10 TeXHOJIOrll'IeCKHX nOTOKOB ueotixozraao rrpMBJIe'IeHHe rro Ka)l(,n:OMY nOToKY no pa60'IHM cnenaansnocrsra OT 269 zto 355 pa60THHKOB, HH)l(eHepHO-TeXHll'IeCKliX pa60THMKOB OT 40 zro 48 'IeJIOBeK, BO,[(HTeJIeH OT 72 ,[(0 157 'IeJIOBeK. Taioxe no Ka)l(,lJ:OMY TeXHOJIOrH'IeCKoMY nOTOKY He06xo,[(HMO npasneseaae OT 193,[(0 23 7 e,n:HHH~ MaIIIHH, MeXaRM3MOB M 060py,n:oBaHHH.

Bsraon:

000 «CHcTeMaCnen;CTpoii» na MOMeHT nonrmcarma COrJIameHHH 0 aameae CTOPOHhI H B nepnon HCnOJIHeHIf.H ,ll;OrOBOpHhIX Ofi.H3aTeJIhCTB fihIJIO He B COCTO.HHHH cofiCTBeHHhIMIf CIfJIaMH BhlllOJIHHTh CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTa~Hble pafiorsr B nOJIHOM Ofi'heMe, B KOHTpaKTHhIe cpoxn, C cofimoneaaeer YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX npaBHJI npOH3BO,ll;CTBa pafior Hlf no O,JJ;HOMY 1f3 KOHTpaKTOB no Ofi'heKTaM CTpOIfTeJIhCTBa TC BeTO.

II II

I ;,

I

II 11

9

000 «CTPOH l{oHTHHeHT» (MHH 7710530848, OrPH 1047796126410), saperacrpnpoaaao 01.03.2004 MMcI:>HC N246 no r. Mocxse.

IOpI1.lJ;I:IqeCI<MH anpec: r. Mocxsa, CTapOnI1MeHOBCKI1H, ,n;. 11/6, CTp. 1. cI:>aKTHqeCKI1Ea,n;pec: r. HOBOPOCCI1ECK, noc. L(eM,n;OJII1Ha, YJI. TIpoMbIlIIJIeHHaH, 4A Yqpe,n;HTeJIb - KOMnaHI15I «BMcTa JIMMMTe,n;» (Pecny6JIMKa Kanp),

Y CTaBHbIE KarII1TaJI - 10 000 py6.

I'eaepam.nsra ,n;I1peKTOp - MamICI1H AH,n;peE Anexcaanponas.

Ha MOMeHT 3aI<JIIOqeHI15I rronpazmsrx rtorosopoa na CTPOI1TeJIbCTBO ofisexron TC BCTO 000 «CTPOE KOHTMHeHT» I1MeJIO onsrr BbInOJIHeHI15I pafiorvno CTpOI1TeJIbCTBY I1 peKOHCTpYKI.J;MH peaepsyapm,rx napxos 2 rona.

Pe3YJIbTaTbI qmHaHcoBO-X03HH:CTBeHHOH: ,n;e5ITeJIbHOCTM sa nOCJIe,n;HHe ronsr

xapaKTepM3YIOTC5I CJIe,n;YIOIIII1MM nOKa3aTeJIHMI1:

Bsrpysxa: 2004 r.- 21,7 MJIH. py6., 2005 r.- 1 029,9 MJIH. py6., 2006 r.- 3 209,8 MJIH.

py6.

~

·

·

~

·

C06CTBeHHble OCHOBHbIe cpeztcrsa: 2004 r. - 0, 2005 r. - 166,8 MJIH. py6., 2006 r. - 519,8 MJIH. py6.

TIo COCTOHHHIO na 15.11.2006 06IIIa5.I QMCJIeHHOCTb nepcoaana 000 «CTPOH KOHTMHeHT» - 1653 qeJIOBeKa, B r.a. MH)I(eHepHO-TeXHMQeCKMH: nepconan - 346 QeJIOBeK, pa60QMe OCHOBHbIX CTpOMTeJIbHbIX CneI.J;I1aJIbHOCTeH: - 860 qeJIOBeK, noncofiasre patio-rae - 179 qeJIOBeK, Bo,n;HTeJIeH: - 218 QeJIOBeK.

OpraHH3aI.J;MH He I1MeeT B C06CTBeHHOCTH TeXHHKM I1 060py,n;OBaHHH, rrpeztaasnaseauoa ,n;JIH npOH3Bo,n;CTBa CTpOMTeJIbHO-MOHTa)I(HbIX pa60T.

ComaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npe,n;JIO)I(eHMIO 000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT», rrpe,n;CTaBJIeHHOMY na ropra no BbI60py nonpxnaux OpraHI13aI.J;I1H: ,n;JIH BbIIIOJIHeHHH CMP na 06beKTax TC BCTO, 86 % TeXHMKH H otiopynosaaaa Haxo,n;MTCH B JIM3MHre, a 14 % B apenzre.

TIo COCTOHHI1IO na 15.11.2006 B KOMI1CCMIO 000 «L(YTI BCTO», rrpOBo,n;MBlIIYIO B paxncax YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX KOHKypCHbIX nponeztyp nposepxy 000 «CTPOH: KOHTHHeHT», rro,n;pH,n;qMKOM 6bIJIM rrpencranneasr ,n;OKYMeHTbI 0 TOM, qTO Y 000 «CTPOE KOHTI1HeHT» B paCnOpH)I(eHMH HMeeTCH 362 e,n;IIHHI.J;bI TeXHIIKII H o60py,n;OBaHIIH, B TOM qIICJIe: MaIIIIIHbI ,n;JIH rro,n;rOTOBHTeJIbHbIX II 3eMJIHHbIX pa60T - 33 e,n;IIHI1IJ;bI, rpyaonom.exnrsre MalIIIIHbI II MeXaHII3MbI - 29 e,n;I1HIII.J;, CBapOqHOe ofiopyzrosamre - 126 e,n;IIHIIIJ;, MaIIIHHbI II ooopynosaaae ,n;JIH npoassoncraa OqIICTHbIX, II30JIHI.J;IIOHHbIX II cneI.J;IIaJIbHbIX pa60T - 20 e,n;IIHI1I.J;, MaIIIIIHbI II ofiopyztosanae ,n;JIH rrp0I13Bo,n;CTBa o6ru;ecTpOHTeJIbHbIX pa60T - 40 e,n;IIHHI.J;, rpancnoprasre cpencrsa - 89 e,n;HHI1I(.

B CBOIIX KOHKYPCHbIX npe,n;JIO)I(eHHHX 000 «CTPOH: KOHTI1HeHT»:

- no o6beKTY «TIepBa5.I Oqepe,n;b rpytionpoaonaoji CIICTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5.I CII6IIPb - TIIXIIH: oxean''. rHTIC "TaH:lIIeT: RTIC, Pcsepsyapasra napx. BHelIIHee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)I(eHHe fHTIC "TaH:IIIeT". TIo,n;CTaHI.J;I1H» (J10T N2 BCTO/RB3-1-1) 3a5.IBHJIO 2 (zme) cyorronpaznnre OpraHI13aI.J;I1II C 8 % OT 06IIIero 06beMa pafior. Cseneaaa 0 npnnnexaesrsrx nepcoaane II TeXHIIKe cyonoztpanasrx opraHH3aI.J;IIH: B KOHKypCHOM npe,n;JIO)I(eHIIH OTCYTCTBYIOT. cI:>aKTIIqeCKII aa BbIIIOJIHeHHe CMP reanozrpannax npIIBJIeK 4 cytinoztpzzrasre OpraHH3aI.J;IIII;

- no 06beKTY «TIepBa5.I oxepezrs rpyconposonaoa CI1CTeMbI "BOCTOlJHa5.I CII6I1Pb - TIIXI1H:

OKeaH". CTpOIITeJIhCTBO RTIC N2 10 C pesepayapasnr napKOM»JIoT N2 BCTO/RTIC N2 10) IIH<j_)opMaI(HH 0 npI1BJIelJeHHH cyfinonpazmsrx opraHH3aI(I1H: OTcYTCTByeT. <PaKTHqeCKI1 aa BhIIIOJIHeHHe CMP reunonpanua« rrpHBJIeK 5 cyrinonpaamrx OpraHI13aI.J;HH:;

- no 06beKTY «TIepBa5.I oxepezts rpytionpononnofi CHCTeMbI "BOCTOqHa5.I CI16I1Pb - TI1XHE oxeaa''. BHelIIHee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)I(eHI1e. HTIC N2 8, RTIC N2 10» (JIOT N2BCTOIB3C-8) 3aHBHJIO 1 (O,n;HOH:) cyfirroztpaaayto opraHH3aI.J;HIO 3AO "3KOHOMI1Ko-<PHHaHcoBaH 3HepreTHlJeCKOCTpOHTeJIbHa5.I xopnopanas C 80 % OT 06IIIero 06beMa pa60T. CBe.n;eHHH 0 npI1BJIeKaeMbIx nepconane I1 TeXHHKe cytinoztpazmsrx opranasarmit B KOHKypCHOM npe.n;JIO)I(eHIIH OTCYTCTBYIOT. cI:>aKmlJeCKH na BbIIIOJIHeHI1e CMP reimozrpazrnrx npHBJIeK 3 cycrrozipazmsrc OpraHI13an;I1I1.

I

,

I I

I

·

II I

I I

It I

I

·

·

10

I

,

I

000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT» npaKTHqeCKH HHKaKHX CMP na 06'1eKTe C06CTBeHHhIMH CIfJIaMH He BhIIIOJIHJIJIO.

ComaCHO ITOC Heo6xo,[(HMO rrpasneseaae na BhIIIOJIHeHHe KOHTpaKTOB:

- N2 329-06 OT 27.12.2006 no 06'1eKTY «I1epBaJI oxepens Tpy6onpoBo,[(HOH CHCTeMhI "BOCTOqHaJI CH6HPh - THXHH oxean". [,BITC "TaHIIIeT: BITC, Pcsepsyapasra napx. BHeIIIHee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)KeHHe [,BITC "TaHIIIeT". ITo,[(cTaHIJ;HJI» (J10T NQ BCTO/BB3-1-1) - 314 qeJIOBeK, 3aHJIThIX na CMP H noncofinsrx rrponsaozrcraax; a TaK)I(e 199 e,[(HHHIJ; cTpOHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH, MaIIIHH H otiopynoaaaa».

- NQ 465-07 OT 14.03.2007 no 06'1eKTY «ITepBaJI oseperrs Tpy6onpoBo,n;HOH CHCTeMbI "BOCTOqHaJI CH6HPh - THXHH oxeaa". CTpOHTeJIhCTBO BI1C NQ 10 C pesepsyapnsnr napxoa» (J10T N2 BCTO/BITC N2 10) - 433 qeJIOBeK, 3aHJIThIX na CMP H noncoonsrx npOH3BO,[(CTBax, a TaK)l(e 112 e,n;HHHIJ; cTpOHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH, MaIIIHH H otiopynoaaaaa.

- NQ 45-07 OT 20.04.2007 «I1epBaJI o-repens rpyoonponozraoa CHCTeMhI "BOCTOqHaJI CH6HPh - THXHH oxean". BHeIIIHee anexrpocaatixenae. HITC N2 8, HI1C N2 10» (J10T NQBCTO/B3C-8) cpennecnaco-raaa nOTpe6HOCTh B xanpax COCTaBJIJIeT 354 qeJIOBeKa, 3aHJIThIX na CMP H rroztcofiasrx nponsaoncraax, a ratoxe 203 e,n;HHHIJ;hI cTpOHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH, MaIIIHH H otiopyrtoaaans.

B o6IIIeH CJIO)l(HOCTH na BhIIIOJIHeHHe pa60T C yseron CPOKOB CTpOHTeJIhCTBa no scea KOHTpaKTaM Heo6xo'[(HMO npaane-reaae ,n;o 1101 pa6oTHHKa, 3aHJITOrO na CMP H nozrcooaux npoaaaoncrsax, a TaK)I(e 514 e,[(HHHIJ; cTpOHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH, MaIIIHH H ofiopyztoaaaaa.

BblBO.ll::

Ha MOMeHT BhIllOJIHeHHH CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTa'KHhIX pa60T no BceM 3aKJIIOQeHHhIM KOHTpaKTaM 000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT» 6hIJIO He B COCTOHHHH co6CTBeHHblMH CHJIaMH O.ll:HOBpeMeHHO BhIllOJIHHTh CMP no 06beKTaM CTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC BCTO.

II 11

I

-

I

.

,

,

OAO «TIPOMCTPOH» (I1BB 8610000479, O[,PH 1028601499189),

saperacrpapoaaao 02.06.1994 A.ll:MHHHcTpaIJ;HeH MYHHIJ;HnaJIbHOrO 06pa30BaHHJI Harans XaHThI-MaHcHHcKoro aBTOHOMHoro oxpyra-Kirpsr no aztpecy: XaHTbI-MaHCHHCKHH AO, r. Harans, YJI. Jlasapesa, ,n;. 30/8. <DaKTHqeCKH Haxo,n;HTCJI no anpecy: XaHThI-MaHCHHCKHH AO, r. Haraas, YJI. Jlasapena, ,[(. 30/8.

Yqpe,[(HTeJIH:

- KOMHTeT no ynpaBJIeHHIO rocynapcrseaasnr HMYIIIeCTBOM XaHThI-MaHCHHCKoro aBTOHOMHoro oxpyra;

- aKIJ;HOHephI - cpH3HqeCKHe JIHIJ;a (cBe,n;eHHJI 0 "llI:ICJIeHHOCTI:I H COCTaBe nOJIyqHTh He

npe,n;CTaBJIJIeTCJI B03MO)l(HhIM).

YCTaBHhIH KanHTaJI-199 421 py6JIeH. I'eaepansmaa zrapexrop -mMIJ;eB I1eTp ErOpOBH"ll.

Ha MOMeHT 3aKJIIOqeHHJI nonpszrasrx ,n;oroBopoB na cTpOHTeJIbCTBO 06'1eKTOB TC BCTO OAO «ITPOMCTPOH» HMeJIO crax pa60TbI B HecpTera30BOH OTpaCJIH 14 JIeT.

Pe3YJIhTaTbI CPHHaHCOBO-X03JIHCTBeHHoH ,n;eJITeJIhHOCTH sa nOCJIe,n;Hl:Ie rozrsr

xapaKTepH3YIOTCJI CJIe,[(YIOIIIHMH nOKa3aTeJIJIMH:

Bsrpy-nca: 2004 r. - 405 MJIH. py6., 2005 r. - 660 MJIH. py6., sa 2006 r. - 684 MJIH. py6., sa 9 MeCJIIJ;eB 2007 r. - 1 074 MJIH. py6.

BhIIIOJIHeHO CMP co6cTBeHHbIMI:I CI:IJIaMH (OT ofirnero 06'1eMa pa60T B %): 2004 r. - 47%, 2005 r. - 38%, 2006 r. - 41 %, 9 MeCJIIJ;eB 2007r. - 56%.

Coocrseaasre OCHOBHble cpencrsa: 2004 r. - 49,5 MJIH. py6., 2005 r. - 71,4 MJIH. py6., 2006 r. -75,9 MJIH. py6., sa 9 MeCJIIJ;eB 2007 r. - 95 MJIH. py6.

ITo COCTOJIHHIO na ,n;eKa6ph 2006 rozra 06IIIaJI qHCJIeHHOCTh nepconana OAO «ITPOMCTPOH» - 460 qeJIOBeK, B TOM "llHCJIe I:IH)l(eHepHO-TeXHHqeCKI:IH nepCOHaJI - 73 "lleJIOBeKa, pa60qHe cTpOHTeJIbHhIX CneIJ;HaJIhHOCTeH - 354.

B C06CTBeHHOCTH y OAO «ITPOMCTPOH» 162 e,n;HHHIJ;hI TeXHI:IKI:I H otiopynosaaaa, B TOM qHCJIe 12 MaIIII:IH ,[(JIJI nO,[(fOTOBHTeJIbHhIX H 3eMeJIhHbIX pafior, 2 e,n;HHHIJ;hI ztopozcao-

I

,

.

11 II

III IE]

EJ

11

; I

,

fA I

CTpOHTeJIhHOH TeXHHKH, 10 e,n;HHHI( 3eMJIepOHHOH TeXHHKH, 14 e,n;MHMI( rpysonom.eam,rx MallIMH M MexaHH3MOB, 4 e,n;HHHI(hI caapo-raoro 060py,n;oBaHM5I, 38 e,n;MHMI( aarorpaacnoprasrx cpencrs.

ComaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npennozeenaro OAO «ITPOMcTPOH» 065I3aJIOCh BhIITOJIHMTh sees ICOMnJIeICC cTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTa)ICHbIX pa60T na 06'.beKTe c06cTBeHHhIMM CMJIaMM. <DaKTMLfeCI<M zce ITO,n;P5I,n;LfMK nOCJIe 3aKJIIOLfeHM5I KOH'IpaKTa npMBJIeK no COrJIaCOBaHHIO C 3aKa3LfHKOM ,n;JI5I BhIITOJIHeHH5I pa60T 4 (nerupe) cyfinozrpannsre opraHM3aI(MM.

ComaCHO 06'.beKTHbIM nnanav opraHM3aI(HH CTpOHTeJIhCTBa (nOC) na 061.eICTe «ITepBa5I oaepezts Tpy60rrpOBo,n:HOH CHCTeMbI «BOCTOLfHa5I CM6HPb - THXHH OKeaH». CTpOHTeJIbCTBO HaCOCHOH CTaHI(HH HITC N2 4, BKJIIOLfa5I 061.eKThI BHeIIIHero 3JIeKTpOCHa6)I(eHH5I C noncraauaea» (KoHTpaKT N2 447-07 OT 06.03.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 199 e,n;MHMI( TeXHMKH, B TOM LfHCJIe CHerOOLfHCTMTeJIhHble H JIeCOrrOBaJIOLfHble MamHHhI, Tpy6oYKJIa,n;LfHIC, Tpy60B03bI H T5IraLfH, xoropsre y OAO «ITPOMCTPOH» na zrary nposepxa cpMHaHcoBoro COCT05IHM5I, TeXHMLfeCKOH OCHaru;eHHOCTH, LfHCJIeHHOCTM H ICBaJIHcpHICaI(HH nepcoaana OTCYTCTBOBaJIH.

Ilorpefinocrs B nepconane C YLfeToM rpadmxa cTpOMTeJIbCTBa H pacnpezrenenaa pa60T no TeXHOJIOrHLfeCKHM nOTOKaM COCTaBJI5IeT OT 30 ,n;o 250 LfeJIOBeK, B T.Lf. I1TP - OT 4 ,n;o 33, pafionax cTpOHTeJIbHbIX CrreI(HaJIhHOCTeH - OT 24 no 200, LfTO cOOTBeTCTByeT MMeIOru;eHC5I y opraHM3aI(HH LfHCJIeHHOCTH nepcoaana cooTBeTcTBYIOru;eH CneI(MaJIM3aI(MH .

BLIBO,lJ,:

OAO «TIPOMcTpoii» aa MOMeHT 3aKJIlOqeHHB KOHTpaKTa H BLIIIOJIHeHHB eMP He pacnonarano CTpOHTeJILHOii TeXHHKoii H 060PY,lJ,OBaHHeM B Heo6xo,lJ,HMOM KOJIHQeCTBe H 6e3 rrpHBJIeQeHHB cy6nO,lJ,pB,lJ,QHKOB He MOrJIO caMOCTOBTeJILHO BLIIIOJIHHTL KOHTpaKTHLIe 06beMLI pa60T B YCTaHOBJIeHHLIe CpOKH.

I

.

·

I

·

·

I

3AK 00 «Asrepxo HHTepHemeHeJI JIHMHTe,lJ,»,

aaperacrpaposana 13.07.1999 B r. Jlonnone, perMCTpaI(HOHHhm N2 03597040, rro anpecy: 10 KpOMBeJIJI nJIeHC, CaYT KeHrcHICToH, JIoH,n;OH SW7 2JN UK.

3AK 00 «AMepICo I1HTepHemeHeJI JIHMMTe,n;» OTKPbITO M axspenaroaaao npn I'ocynapcrseaaoii perMCTpaI(MOHHOH rranare MHHMcTepcTBa IOCTMI(MM P<D (cBM,n:eTeJIbCTBO N29931.1 OT 16.07.2003 r.). ITpe,n:cTaBMTeJIbCTBO 3aKpbITOH aKI(MOHepHoH KOMrraHMM C orpaaaseaaoa OTBeTCTBeHHOCTbIO «Axrepxo I1HTepHemeHeJI JIMMMTe,n;» (BeJIMKO6pMTaHM5I), I1HH 9909034571, ropM,n;HLfecKHH aztpec: r. Mocxsa, YJI. KPbIMCICMH BaJI, ,n;.8; cpaKTMLfeCKMH aztpec: r. Mocxsa, rpY3MHCKMH nep., ,n:.3, KB.79.

Y Lfpe,n:MTeJIM:

- <DMJIMn HaTaJIJI, saperacrpaponan no azrpecy: BpMCTOYC KOTTe,n:)I(, PeKTopM JI3HH, LJapJIBY.rr;, Cyppea RH6 0 EF, 5IBJI5IeTC5I nepzcarenea 1 06hIKHoBeHHoH aKI(MM CTOMMOCThro B O.rr;MH CPYHT CTepJIMHrOB;

- KOMnaHM5I Harepnopr KOHTpaKTC JIJIC, pacnonaraerca no aztpecy: 1220 Hopr xrapxer CTPHT, BHJIMHHITOH, ,D;eJIaB3p 19801, ClilA. KOMnaHHH rrpHHa,D;JIe)I(HT 999 06bIKHoBeHHbIX aICI(HH npezmpaaraa,

Y CTaBHOH KanHTaJI COCTaBJI5IeT 1000 CPYHTOB CTepJIHHroB. ITpe3H,n;eHT KOMnaHHH - MHXaHJIO ITepeHLfeBHIJ.

I'nasa MOCKOBCKoro npencraaarenscrsa KOMrraHHH - <DpaHKo Jlarmepr.

Ha MOMeHT 3aKJIIOIJeHH5I noztpazmsrx zroreaopos aa cTpOHTeJIbCTBO 06'.beKTOB TC BCTO 3AK 00 «Aaepxo I1HTepHeIIIeHeJI JIHMHTe,n;» HMeJIO CTa)!( pa60TbI B HecpTera30BOH OTpaCJIH 5 JIeT.

I

·

·

It I~

~

Pe3YJIbTaTbI cpHHaHcoBO-X035IHCTBeHHoH ,n;e5ITeJIbHOCTH aa nOCJIe,n;HHe roztsr

xapaKTepH3YIOTC5I cnezryrouraaa nOKa3aTeJI5IMH:

BbIpYLfKa: 2003 r. - 501,5 MJIH. py6., 2004 r. - 1028,9 MJIH. py6., 2005 r. - 3 296,4 MJIH.

py6.

IIpaKTHIJeCKH sees 06'.beM CMP B 2003-2005 r.r. BbIITOJIHeH CMJIaMM cytinozrpaztasrx OpraHM3aI(MH.

12

I I

.

C06CTBeHHhIe OCHOBHhIe cpezrcrsa: 2003 r. ~ 0,05 MJIH. py6., 2004 r. - 6,7 MJIH. py6., 2005 r. - 4,0 MJIH. py6.

I10 COCTO)lHIHO na 23.05.2008 06m;M ~n:ICJIeHHOCTh nepconana 3AK 00 «Avepxo MHTepHelIIeHeJI JII:IMI:ITe,l.(» - 987 qeJIOBeK, B TOM qI:ICJIe MTP - 42 qeJIOBeKa, patio-rae CTpOI:ITeJIhHhIX CneI(I:IaJIhHOCTeH - 945 qeJIOBeK.

B C06CTBeHHOCTH y 3AK 00 «Anepxo MHTepHelIIeHeJI JIHMI:ITe,l.(» I:IMeeTC)l 355 e,n:I:IHI:II( TeXHHKI:I I:I otiopynosanaa, B TOM qI:ICJIe 13 MalIII:IH ,n:JI)l 3eMJI)lHhIX H nO,n;rOTOBHTeJIhHhIX pa60T.

COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npe,l.(JIo)I<eHHIO 3AK 00 «AMepKO YIHTepHelIIeHeJI JII:IMI:ITe,n:» 3MBHJIO ,n;JI)l BhmOJIHeHI:I)l pa60T aa 06'beKTe «Ilepaas onepens Tpy60npOBO,l.(HOH CI:ICTeMhI "BOCTOqHa)l CI:I6HPh - TI:IXI:IH OKeaH". CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBO HI1C N2 17» 4 (serape) cyononpaaasrx opraHH3aI(I:II:I, BMeCTe C TeM, KOJIHqeCTBO nepcoaana H TeXHI:IKH 3THX opraHH3aI(I:IH He pacxpsmaerca. <I>aICTI:IqeCICI:I reanonpazrsnx nOCJIe 3aICJIIOqeHI:I)l KOHTpaICTa npI:IBJIeIC no corrraCOBaHI:IIO C 3aICa3qI:IKOM ,l.(OnOJIHI:ITeJIhHO erne ozmoro cyrinonpazrnnca (000 «BOJIraHeq)Tera3CneI(CTpOH» ).

K CTp0I:ITeJIhCTBY 06'beKTa «Ilepsaa osepens rpytionpoaozaroii CI:ICTeMhI "BOCTOqHa)l CI:I6I:IPh - TI:IXI:IH OICeaH". CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBO HI1C N2 14» 3AK 00 «AMepICo MHTepHemeHeJI JII:IMI:ITe,l.(» npI:IBJIeqeHO BMeCTO 3AO «Kpacaorrapcrpozrpaacras» B pe3YJIhTaTe· 3aMeHhI CTOPOHhI no KOHTpaICTY N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007.

Bxrecre C TeM, cornacao 06'beICTHhIM nJIaHaM OpraHI:I3aI(I:II:I CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBa (I10C) na 06'beICTax:

- «Ilepnaa Oqepe,n:h Tpy60npOBo,n;HOH CI:ICTeMhI "BOCTOqHM CI:I6I:IPh - TI:IXI:IH OICeaH" .

CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBO HI1C N2 17» (KoHTpaICT N2 583-07 OT 02.06.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 225 e,n:I:IHI:II( TeXHI:IICI:I I:I 060py,n:oBaHI:I)l, B TOM l:II:ICJIe rpyaonozrseaasre, CHerOOqI:ICTI:ITeJIhHhle, JIeCOnOBaJIO~hle, necorrorpyso-rasre MalIII:IHhI, TpeJIeBOqHhIe rpaxropa, 6YJIh,n:03ephI, Tpy60YKJIa,n;qI:IICI:I, ICOTOPhIe Y I10,n:p5I,n:ql:J:ICa OTCYTCTBYIOT. I1oTpe6HOCTh BnepCOHaJIe C yaerov rpa~I:IICaCTpOI:ITeJIhCTBa I:I pacnpe,n:eJIeHI:I5I pa60T no TeXHOJIOfI:IqeCKI:IM nOTOICaM MeCJIqHOrO rparpaxa CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBa COCTaBJI)leT OT 36 ,l.(0 400 qeJIOBeK, B T.q. YITP - OT 5 zro 55, pa60lfI:IX CTpOI:ITeJIhHhIX CneI(I:IaJIhHOCTeH OT 29 zro 330 I:I (131 % OT I:IMerom;erOc5I).

- «I1epBM Olfepe,n:h Tpy6onpOBO,l.(HOH CI:ICTeMhI "BOCTOqHM CI:I6I:IPh - TI:IXI:IH oxean".

CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBO HI1C N2 14» (KoHTpaICT N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007) Tpe6yeTC5I 253 e,n:I:IHI:II(hI TeXHI:IICI:I I:I 060py,n:OBaHI:I5I, B TOM qI:ICJIe rpyaonozrsescrsre, CHerOOlfI:ICTI:ITeJIhHhle, JIeCOnOBaJIOlfHhIe, neconorpysoaasre MalIII:IHhI, rpeneso-rasre TpaICTopa, 6YJIh,l.(03ephI, Tpy60YKJIa,n;qI:IICI:I, ICOTOPhIe y I10,l.(p~I:IICa OTCYTCTBYIOT. I1oTpe6HOCTh B rrepconane C yseros, rparpaxa CTpOI:ITeJIhCTBa I:I pacnpeneneaaa pa60T no TeXHOJIOrI:IqeCICI:IM nOTOICaM COCTaBJI)leT OT 101 zto 412 lfeJIOBeIC, B T. If. MTP - OT 13 zro 55, pariosax CTpOI:ITeJIhHhIX CneI(I:IaJIhHOCTeH OT 81 zto 330.

C yseroa onaoapeaeanoro rrposezteaaa CMP na YICa3aHHhIX 06'beICTaX o6m;ee ICOJII:IqeCTBO Tpe6yeMoH TeXHI:IICI:I I:I 060pY,l.(OBaHI:I)l COCTaBJI)leT 478 e,l.(I:IHI:II(, lfTO npeBhIlIIaeT KOJII:IqeCTBO TeXHI:IICI:I I:I 060pY,l.(OBaHI:I)l, I:IMerom;I:IXC)l B pacnOp5I)I<eHHI:I 3AK 00 «AMepICO HHTepHelIIeHeJI JII:IMI:ITe,n:». KpOMe roro, y I10,n:p)l,l.(qI:IICa OTCYTCTByeT B He06xo,n:I:IMOM ICOJII:IlfeCTBe I:IH)KeHepHO-TeXHI:IqeCICI:IH nepCOHaJI. I1pI:I nOTpe6HOCTI:I B orrrensnsre MeC5II(hI,l.(O 55 HTP no ICa:>K,l.(OMY I:I3 zrsyx 06'beKTOB, ~aICTI:IlfeCICOe KOJII:IqeCTBO I1TP COCTaBJI)leT 42 qeJIOBeICa.

Bsmon:

3AR 00 «Asrepxo HHTepHemeHeJI JIHMHTe.n:» na MOMeHT 3aKJIIOQeHHH H nocnenyromero HCnOJIHeHHH KOHTpaKToB 6bIJIO He B COCTOHHHH co6CTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH BbIlIOJIHHTb CTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa3l:HbIe pa60TbI B nOJIHOM 06'beMe, B KOHTpaKTHbIe CPOKH, C C06JIIO.n:eHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHblX npaBHJI npOH3BO,lJ,CTBa pa60T.

G II

I 11

000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» (MHH 7720558240, Of PH 1067746819524), 3apemCTpI:IpOBaHO 17.07.2006 Ml1<I>HC N246 no f. MocICBe. IOpI:I)J;I:IqeCKI:IH azrpec: r. MocICBa, ,lJ;MI:ITPOBCICI:IH npoeszr, ,l.(. 10, CTp. 8.

(,,-I \'L::.:;I

13

I I

<DaKTHqeCKHH a,I(pec: 353960, KpaCHO,I(apCKHH xpati, r.HOBOPOCCHHCK, rroc.Lleanonana, yn.Ilposcsnuneauas, 4a.

Yqpe,I(HTenb - Koprropanns «Ilaperr CHcTeM C.A.» (Pecnyfinnxa I1aHaMa). E,I(HHCTBeHHbIM yspeztarcneu 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» ,I(O 11.04.2008 3HaqHJIOCb nO)J,CTaBHoe JIHU;O - rpaxoraaxa P<D Eaesa 10nmr Feauanseana, KOTOPM aa ,I(aTY rrO,I(IIHCaHH5I cornameaaa 0 sasreae CTOPOH rro KOHTpaKTaM 5IBn5InaCb raroxe HOMHHaJIbHbIM yspeztarenev 000 «CHcTeMaCrreJJ;CTpoH». B rrHCbMeHHOM 06b5ICHeHHH OT 04.09.2008 Eaesa 1O.r. yxasana, 'lITO PelIIeHHe Yqpe,L(HTeml N2 5 OT 10.09.2007 0 Ha3HaqeHHH reaepansasra zmpexropoa opraaasanaa MaHcYPoBa P.IO. He rrO,I(rrHCbIBaJIa H nozmncs aa rrporoxone OT ee HMeHH crpanscatpanaponana. TaKHM 06Pa30M, cornanrenaa C 000 «i(YIT BCTO» OT 12.09.2007 0 saveae CTOPOH B KOHTpaI(TaX N2 329-06 OT 27.09.2006, N2 465-06 OT 14.03.2007, N2 545-07 OT 20.04.2007, nonnacaaasre OT HMeHH 000 «BOCTOK Crpoa» Maacypoasra P.IO. MorYT 6bITb rrpH3HaHbIHe,L(eHCTBHTenbHbIMH.

YCTaBHbIH xarmran - 10 rue. py6.

Feuepam.aua ,I(HpeKTOp - MaH)KHH AH,I(peH Anexcarmpoaas (,I(O 13 aBrYCTa 2008 rona reaepam.nsra ,L(HpeKTopoM 3HaQHnC5I MaHcYPoB P.IO.). MaH)I<HH A.A. TaK)I(e 3HaqHTC5I reaepaasnsra ,I(HpeKTOpOM 000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT» (r. Mocxsa).

Ha MOMeHT nanana pa60T 000 «BOCTOI< CTPOH» na 06beKTax TC BCTO (ceHT5I6pb 2007 rozra) CTOHMOCTb scex ero aKTHBOB COCTaBmma 10 TbIC. py6. Orrsrr pa60T OTCYTCTBOBaJI.

Kpoxre roro, na ,I(aTY rrO,L(rrHCaHH5I cornamenaa 0 saxreae CTOPOH B KOHYpaI<Tax

(12.09.2007) 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» He IIMeno He06xo,L(HMbIX ,I(JUI BbIl10nHeHII5I pa60T na ofir.exrax TC BCTO nIIn;eH3HH. ComaCHO nHCbMY <De,I(epanbHOro rocY,I(apCTBeHHOrO y-qpe)!(,I(eHII5I«<De,L(epaJIbHbIH nHJJ;eH3HOHHbrH nerrrp npa POCCTpoe» OT 27.08.2008 N2 2091 crponrensaaa JIHn;eH3H5I 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» 6bma BhIL(aHa 17.09.2007 co CPOI<OM ,I(eHCTBH5I ,I(O 21.09.2011. ,[(0 17.09.2007 000 «BOCTOK CYpOH» (,I(O 13.06.2007 opraHH3aJJ;H5I nassraanace 000 «CYpoHTexHOKOM») HMeno cTpoHTenbHYIO nHn;eH3HIO, B KOTOPOH OTCYTCTBOBaJIH pafiorsi, CB5I3aHHble C rrOBbIlIIeHHOH orraCHOCTbIO npoxrsnnneaasrx npOH3BO,I(CTB II ofisexron (MarHCTpaJIbHbIe raso-, nedrre-, nponyxronposozna), Ha OCHOBaHHII PYKOBO,I(5Ir:u;HX .n;OKYMeHTOB OAO "AK "Tparrcnerprr," npa OTCYTCTBIIII B crpoarensnoa nIIJJ;eH3HH YKa3aHHbIX pa60T opraHII3aJJ;H5I He Morna 6bITb ztonyrneaa I< pa60TaM aa 06beKTaM KOMrraHHII.

ITo COCT05IHHIO na 01.07.2007 rona CTOHMOCTb scex aKTIIBOB npe,I(rrpH5ITH5I COCTaBn5Ina 10 TbIC. Py6JIeH.

ITo COCT05IHHIO aa 24.10.2007 06rn:a5I qHCneHHOCTb rrepCOHCUIa 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» rro .n;aHHbIM nposepxa, riposeneaaoa cnerraanacraxra 000 «i(YIT «BCTO» COCTaBn5Ina 2 055 xenoaexa, B TOM QHCne IIH)I(eHepHO-TeXHIIYJeCKHH nepcoaan - 409 qenOBeK, patio-rae CTpOHTenbHbIX crreJJ;HaJIbHOCTeH - 1 646 YJenOBeK.

Bsrecre C TeM, rro OCPIIJJ;HaJIbHbIM .n;aHHbIM Mocropcrara 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» B 2006 - 2007 r.r. 5IBJUInOCb cy6beKToM MaJIOrO npennpaaasrarenscrsa, T.e. 'lIHcneHHOCTb pa6oTHHKOB Otimecraa cornacno 3aKoHo.n;aTeJIbCTBY 0 ManbIX npezmpaaraax COCTaBn5Ina He 60JIee 50 qenOBeK. TaKHM 06Pa30M, CBe,I(eHH5I 0 'lIHcneHHOCTH nepcoaana na .n;aTY nponcpxa He COOTBeTCTBOBaJIH .n;eHCTBHTenbHOCTH.

B C06CTBeHHOCTH Y 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» HMeeTC5I rorrsxo 9 e,I(HHHI( TeXHHKH H o60py.n;oBaHH5I. COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npenrrozcesaro opraaasanaa rrpaxra-rccxa BC5I TeXHHKa, 060PY,I(OBaHHe ,I(n5I BbIIIOJIHeHH5I CTpOIITenbHO-MOHTa)!(HbIX pa60T apeH,I(yeTC5I H B35ITa B nH3HHr. B pacnopaxeaaa 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» HaXO,I(HnOCb 283 e,I(HHHI(bI crponrensaojt TeXHHKlI, MaIIIHH, MexaHH3MOB H 060PY,I(OBaHH5I, B TOM qIICJIe: 38 MalIIHH .n;JUI nonroroaarensasrx H 3eMJUIHbIX pa60T, 181 e,I(HHHn;a asrorpaacnoprnsrx cpezrcra, 52 e.n;HHHI(bI rpysonozrsexersrx MaIIIHH H MexaHH3MOB, 12 e,I(HHHn; CBapOQHOrO o6opY,I(OBaHH5I.

Cornacno cornanreaaaa 0 saveae CTOPOH 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» 3aMeHHnO npexaero reHnO,I(p5I,I(QHKa 000 «CTPOH KOHTHHeHT» rro cne.n;YIOII(HM KOHTpaKTaM:

I I

i I

,

-

14

- NQ 329-06 OT 27.12.2006. 06beKT: «I1epBa5I o-repezn, rpytionpoaoztaoji CHCTeMhI «BoCTOqHa5I CH6HPh - THXHH: OKeaH». fRITC «TaH:Il1eT»:RITC, Peaepsyapasra napx. BHeIl1Hee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)I<eHHe fRITC «TaH:Il1eT». ITo,n:cTaHlJ:H5I»;

- N2 465-07 OT 14.03.2007. 06beI<T: «ITepBa5I oaepezn, rpytionpoaozmoa CHCTeMhI "BOCTOqHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH: OKeaH». CTpOI1TeJIhCTBO RITC NQ 10 C peaepsyapnsra rrapxov»;

- NQ 545-07 OT 20.04.2007. 06beKT: «ITepBa5I onepens rpyoonpoaoznroa CHCTeMbI "BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THxHrr oxean". BHeIl1Hee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)KeHHe. RITC NQ 8, BITC NQ 10».

cDaKTHQeCKHe 06CT05ITeJIhCTBa CBH,n:eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 TOM, qTO rrpe)ICHHrr reanonpazrsax 000 «CTPOH: KOHTHHeHT» npocro CMeHHJI «BhIBeCKY», aero nepconan, TeXHHKa H ooopyaosaaae QaCTH~O rrepenaau B HOBoe IOpH,n:HqeCKOe JIHIJ:O 000 «BOCTOK Crpoii». TaK, HHTepeChI 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» rro ,n:OBepeHHOCTH 6hIBIl1erO reaepansnoro zrapexropa MaHCYPOBa P.IO. rrpe,n:CTaBJI5IJI Ka3aqeHOK ,D;.B., KOTOPhIH: o,n:HOBpeMeHHO .5IBJI5IJIC5I cpHHaHCOBhIM ,n:HpeKTOpOM 000 «Crpoii KOHTHHeHT», MaHcypOBhIM P.IO. 6bIJIa BhI,n:aHa TaK)I(e ,n:OBepeHHOCTb N2 19 OT 26.09.2007 caoevy 3aMeCTHTeJIIO MaH)I<HHY A. A. , xoropsni onaonpeaeaao 5IBJI5IJIC5I renepansasnr ,n:HpeKTopoM 000 «Crpon KOHTHHeHT». Kpojse roro, 000 «BOCTOK CTPOH» HMeeT 3JIeKTpOHHhrn aztpec, rrpHHa.D:JIe)I(aIIJ:Hrr 000 «Crpoa KOHTHHeHT» Stroi - Kontinent@ramb1er.ru.

Bxrecre C TeM, cornacao 06beKTHhIM rrnarrax opraHH3aIJ:HH CTpOHTeJIhCTBa (ITOC) na 06beKTax:

-«I1epBa5I osepens rpytiorrpoaoztaoa CHCTeMbI «BOCTOqHa5I CH6HPb - THXHrr OKeaH». fRITC «TaHIl1eT: RITC, Pesepayapnsra napx. BHeIl1Hee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)1(eHHe T'RITC «Taamer». ITo,n:CTaHIJ:H5I» (KOHTpaKT NQ 329-06 OT 27.12.2006) Tpe6yeTC.5I 199 e,n:HHHIJ: TeXHHKH H otiopyztosaaas, B TOM qHCJIe CHerOOqrrCTHTeJIhHbIe, JIeCOrrOBaJIOqHble, necorrorpysouasre MaIl1HHbI, TpeJIeBOQHble rpaxropa, Tpy6oYKJIa,n:qHKH, asrorpejinepsr n rrp., xoropsre y ITO,n:p.5I,n:qHKa OTCYTCTBYIOT. KpOMe roro, Tpe6yeTC.5I nepcoaan B KOJIHqeCTBe 390 qeJIOBeK, B r.a. pa60qHX CrreIJ:HaJIbHOCTeH: - 314, HTP - 52.

- «I1epBa5I Oqepe,n:h rpytionpononnoa CHCTeMbI «BOCTOqHa5I CH6npb - THXHH OKeaH».

CTpOHTeJIbCTBO RITe N2 10 C pesepsyapasra napxon» (KOHTpaKT N2 465-07 OT 14.03.2007) Tpe6yeTC.5I 110 e,n:HHHIJ: TeXHHKH H oriopyzrosaaaa, B TOM qHCJIe CHerOOqHCTHTeJIbHble, JIeCOrrOBaJIOqHbIe, necorrorpyso-msre MaIl1HHbI, TpeJIeBOqHbIe TpaKTopa, Tpy6oYKJIa)J;qHKH, asrorpeanepsr H rrp., xoropsre y I10,n:p.5I,n:QHKa OTCYTCTBYIOT. I1oTpe6HOCTh B nepcoaane COCTaBJI.5IeT 504 QeJIOBeK, B T.Q. pa60QHX CrreIJ:HaJIbHOCTerr- 433, HTP - 71.

- «I1epBa5I OQepe,n;b rpyfiorrpoaozmoti CHCTeMbI «BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPh - Taxaa OKeaH».

BHeIl1Hee 3JIeKTpOCHa6)1(eHHe. RITC N2 8, RI1C N2 10» (KoHTpaKT. NQ545-07 OT 20.04.2007) Tpe6yeTC.5I 119 e,n:HHHIJ: TeXHHKH H ofiopynoaaaaa, B TOM QHCJIe BaJIO"LfHO-rraKeTHpYIOIIJ:He MaIl1HHbI, TpeJIeBOQHble rpaxropa xoropsre y I10,n;p5I,n;QHKa OTCYTCTBYIOT. I1oTpe6HOCTb B nepcoaane COCTaBJI5Ier 407 QeJIOBeKa, B T.Q. pa60QHX CrreIJ:HaJIbHOCTell- 354, HTP - 53.

06IIJ:ee KOJIHQeCTBO Tpe6yeMorr TeXHHKH H ooopyzroaanaa ,n:JI.5I BbIIl1eYKa3aHHbIX oor.exron cocraanaer 428 e,n:HHHIJ:, a B HaJIH"L{I:IH - 283. Y ITO,n;p.5I,n:QHKa OTCYTcTByeT CrreIJ:HaJIbHa5I cTpOHTeJIbHa5I TeXHHKa: CHerOOQHCTHTeJIbHble, JIeCOrrOBaJIOQHble, rreconorpysoxasre MaIl1HHbI, TpeJIeBOQHble rpaxropa, Tpy6oYKJIa.n:QHKH, asrorpejiziepsr BaJIOQHO-rraKeTHpYIOllJ:He MaIl1HHbI. 06IIJ:a5I norpefiaocrs B rrepconane COCTaBJI5IeT 1301 QeJIOBeK, B T.Q. HTP - 176, pa60QHX cTpOHTeJIbHbIX cnernransnocrea-. 1101.

BhIBO,n;:

000 «BOCTOK CTPOii:» na ,n;ary 3aKJIIO'1eHHH COrJIameHHH 0 aasrene CTOPOHhI B 3-x noroaopax na BhIUOJIHeHHe CMP He HMeJIO 06H3aTeJIhHOH JIHu;eH3HH na CTpOHTeJIhCTBO 3,n;aHHii: H coopyaeenaa 1 H 2 yposnen OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH. Y IIpe,n;IIpHHTHH OTCYTcTBOBaJIa B Heo6xo,n;HMOM KOJIH'IeCTBe TeXHHKa H ofiopynoaaune, '1TO He II03BOJIHJIO eMY BhIDOJIHHTh necs 06'heM CMP co6CTBeHHhIMH CHJIaMH B KOHTpaKTHhle CPOKH, C C06JIIO,n;eHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHhlX IIpaBHJI IIPOH3Bo,n;CTBa pa60T.

IJ Ii

11 I

I 11

I

,

I

1M I~

If I

I.

"

.

~

.

.

15

000 «Ail: ITu Cers CITG» (I1HH 7813128747, OrPH 1027806859222), saperncrpaponano 27.01.2000 PemCTpaIJ;llOHHOli rranaroa A,n:MllHllcTpaIJ;llll r. CaHKTIlerepfiypra.

IOpll,n:ll'IeCKHH a,n:pec: r. CaHKT-TIeTep6ypr, Eonsmori np.B.O., ,n:. 36/40. <DaKTll'IeCI<HH aztpec: r. CaHKT-TIeTep6ypr, Bacanseacsna OCTPOB, Cpeztami npocnexr, ,n:.36/40.

Y'Ipe,n:HTeJIH - KOMnaHH5I «DHKOJIJIO Kocanranr JIT,n:», KOMnaHll5I «Jlaap 3HTepnpaH3Hc

JIHMHTe,n:» (Pecny6JIHKa Kanp).

Y CTaBHblli KaIIHTarr - 317 MJIH. py6.

Fenepansnun ztnpexrop - Apacros Cepreii AJIeKcaH,n:poBH'I.

Ilo aerrozrraepxneaaoa llH<popMaIJ;llH B aBrYCTe 2008 rona 000 «Ali Ila Cers CIl6»

JIllKBll,n:llpOBaHa B cpopMe npacoezraaenas K 3AO «KaHTpllKOM» (r. Mocrcsa, OrPH

1037739567535).

Ha MOMeHT 3aKJIIOqeHll5I no,n:p5I,n:HbIX rtoroaopoa na CTpOllTeJIbCTBO 061:.eKTOB TC BCTO 000 «Ali Ila Cers CD6» llMeJIO OnbIT BbmOJIHeHll5I pa60T no BOJIC, MOHTa)lCY otiopynoaaana H peMOHTHbIM pa60TaM cnsnne 3,5 JIeT. 000 «Ali Ila Cers CD6» B OCHOBHOM BbmOJIH5IJIO pa60TbI na 061:.eKTaX OAO «CB5I3bTPaHcHe<pTh».

Pe3YJIbTaTbI <pHHaHcoBO-X035IHCTBeHHoH ,n:eSITeJIbHOCTll sa nocxeznrae rozrsr

XapaKTepll3YIOTC5I CJIe,n:yIOIIJ;llMll nOKa3aTeJI5IMH:

BbIPY'IKa: 2005 r. - 707,9 MJIH. py6., 2006 r. - 786,9 MJIH. py6., sa 9 MeC5IIJ;eB 2007 r.- 916,7 MJIH. py6 .

Bsmonaeao CMP C06CTBeHHbIMH canaan (OT ofimero 061:.eMa pa60T B %): 2005 r. - 11, 2 %, 2006r. - 6,9 %, 3a 9 MeC5IIJ;eB 2007r. - 3,9 %.

C06CTBeHHhIH xanaran: 2005 r. - 217,6 MJIH. py6., 2006 r. - 216,3 MJIH. py6., sa 9 MeC5IIJ;eB 2007 r. - 214,4 MJIH. py6.

Do COCT05IHHIO aa 03.10.2007 06IIJ;aSI 'IllCJIeHHOCTb nepcoaana 000 «Ali Ila Cers CD6» - 61 'IeJIOBeK, B TOM 'IllCJIe llH)l(eHepHO-TeXHll'IeCKllli nepCOHaJI - 54 'IeJIOBeKa, paoosae cTpOllTeJIbHbIX CneIJ;HarrbHOCTeH - 6 'IeJIOBeK, soznrrena - 1 'IeJIOBeI<.

Opraaasanaa He llMeeT B C06CTBeHHOCTll rexaaxa II ooopynonanaa, npeztaasaaseaaoa ,n:JIsr npoasaozrcrsa CTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa)l(HbIX pa60T.

COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHOMY npeztnoxeaaro 000 «Ali TIll Cers CD6», npe,n:CTaBJIeHHOMY na ropra no BbI60py nonpazrasrx opraaasanaa ,lJ;JI5I BbmOJIHemfSI CMP na 061:.eKTaX TC BCTO, 100 % rexaaxa II o6opY,lJ;OBaHll5I apeH,n:YIOTC5I.

Ilo COCT05IHHIO na 03.1 0.2007 B KOMllCCllIO 000 «IJ;YD BCTO», npoaoztaamyro B paxrxax YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX KOHKypCHbIX npoIJ;e.n;yp rrpoBepKy 000 «AM Dll Cers CD6», nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;'IllKOM 6bIJIll rrpeztcraaneasr ,lJ;OKYMeHTbI 0 TOM, 'ITO Y 000 «AH Ila Cers CD6» B pacnopaacenaa llMeeTcsr 42 ezranam« cTpOllTeJIbHOH rexaaxa, MaIIIHH, MexaHll3MOB H o6opY,lJ;OBaHll5I, B TOM 'IUCJIe: 4 MallIHHhI ,n:JI5I rro,n:rOTOBHTeJIbHbIX II 3eMJIsrHhlX pafior, 5 rpY30nO,lJ;1:.eMHhIX MaIIIHH II MexaHll3MOB, 5 e,lJ;HHllIJ; CBapO'IHOrO o6opY,lJ;OBaHll5I, 16 e,lJ;llHHIJ; MallIHH H o6opY,lJ;OBaHH5I ,n:JI5I npoaasoncrsa 06m;ecTpOHTeJIbHbIX pafior, 7 rpancnoprasrx openers, 2 MallIHHbI ,lJ;JI5I cTpOllTeJIbCTBa rrepexozion pex MeTO,n:OM rHB.

K HacTOsrIIJ;eMY BpeMeHH KOHTpaKT N!~ 631-07 OT 11.07.2007 pacroprnyr 3aKa3'IHKOM B O,lJ;HOCTOpOHHeM nopamce B CB5I3H C HeBbmOJIHeHHeM TIO,lJ;psr,n:'IHKOM KOHTpaKTHhIX o6sr3aTeJIhCTB, BMeCTO Hero B anpene 2008 r. 3aKJIIO'IeHbI npaxsre KOHTPaKTbI C 4 ('IeTblpbM5I) opraaasamrasra, pa60TaBllIHMH y 6bIBiliero reanonpszrsaxa na cytinozrpane,

I1H<popMaIJ;Hsr 0 npHBJIe'IeHHH 000 «Ali IlH Cers CTI6» no 061:.eKTY «Ilepsaa osepezts rpytiorrposozmofi CHCTeMbI "Bocro-nraa CH6HPb - THxHH oxeaa". JIHHeliHaSI 'IaCTh. YqaCTOK KM 0- KM 795, D 1067 MM; yqaCTOK KM 795 - KM 897, D 1220 MM» cytinonpsnasrx opraHH3aIJ;HH OTCYTCTByeT. <I>aKTHqeCKH na BbmOJIHeHHe CMP reanozrpxrrrax npHBJIeK 12 cydrroztpaznrsrx OpraHH3aIJ;HH.

16

I

·

·

COrJIaCHO TIOC pa60T1I no KOHTpaKTY OT 11.07 .2007 N!~ 631-07 no 06'1eKTY «Ilepsaa oxepezrs 'rpytionpoaozurotl CI:ICTeM11 "BoCTOqHa5.! CI:I6I:Ip1 - TI:IXI:IH oxean", CI:ICTeMa CB5I3I:I» (JIOT N2 BCTO/C-TI) pa3,[(eJIeH1I aa 3 srana (YQaCTOIC ICM 570 - KM 1105, yqaCTOK KM 1105 - KM 2202, yqaCTOK ICM 2202 - KM 2620). Ha B1IITOJIHeHI:Ie pa60T no nepsovy srany (570 KM - 1105 KM) no KOHTpaKTY Heo6xo,n;I:IMO npI:IBJIeqeHI:Ie 537 pa60THI:IKOB, 3aH5ITbIX na CMP I:I rroncoonsrx npoassoncrsax, 70 I:IH)KeHepHO-TeXHI:IqeCKI:IX pa60THI:IKOB .I:I 207 BO,l(I:ITeJIeH, a TaK)lCe 224 e,l(I:IHI:IU;1I OCHOBHbIX MallII:IH I:I MeXaHI:I3MOB aa no,n;rOTOBI:ITeJIbHOM srane, 318 e,[(I:IHI:IU; MallII:IH I:I MeXaHI:I3MOB B OCHOBHOH nepaozr.

B COOTBeTCTBI:II:I C rpaqJI:IKOM CTpOI:ITeJI1CTBa pacxer nOTpe6HOCTI:I B xaztpax no aranaa: yqaCTOK KM 1105 - KM 2202 I:I ;nraCTOK KM 2202 - KM 2620, oCYIIJ;eCTBJI5IeTC5I no 14 I:I 7 TeXHOJIOrI:IqeCKI:IM nOTOKaM COOTBeTCTBeHHO. Ha B1IITOJIHeHI:Ie pa60T no Ka)l(,n;oMY TeXHOJIOrflqeCKoMY nOToKY YQaCTKa Heo6xo,[(I:IMO npI:IBJIeqeHI:Ie 88 pa60THI:IKOB, 3aH5ITbIX Ha CMP I:I nozrcofinsrx npOI:I3BO,[(CTBax, 11-12 I:IH)l(eHepHO-TeXHI:IqeCKI:IX pa60THI:IKOB, 16-18 BO'[(I:ITeJIeH, a TaK)Ke 90 e,[(I:IHI:IU; MaIITI:IH I:I MeXaHI:I3MOB.

BbIBO~:

000 «An TIll CeTL CIIfi» na MOMeHT 3aKJIlOQeHII.H KOHTpaKTa II B nepnon IICrrOJIHeHII.H ~orOBopHLIX Ofi.H3aTeJILCTB 6LIJIO He B COCTO.HHIIII co6CTBeHHhIMH CHJ!aMH BhllIOJIHIITh CTpOIITeJILHO-MoHTaacHLle pa60TLI B rrOJIHOM 06'LeMe, B KOHTpaKTHhIe CPOKII, C C06J110~eHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHLlX rrpanan rrpOII3BO~CTBa pa60T.

Ii It I

I I

·

·

I I

,ll;aHHble B OTHOIITeHI:II:I cy6nO,l(p5I,n;H1IX OpraHI:I3au;I:IH, yqaCTBOBaBIITHX I:I yqaCTB)'IOIIJ;I:IX B CTpOI:ITeJIbCTBe 06'1eKTOB TC BCTO no ,l(OrOBOpaM C BbIIIIeYKa3aHHbIMI:I rearronpamaxaaa, coztepxarca B ilpI:IJIO)KeHI:II:I N2 7.

Bo Bcex KOHKypCHbIX npe,[(JIO)lCeHI:I5IX YCJIOBI:I5I COTpY,[(HI:IqeCTBa yqacTHI:IKOB ToprOB C 3a5IBJIeHHbIMI:I cy6no'[(p5I,l(qI:IKaMI:I orrpezteneasr B CaMOM 06IIJ;eM BI:I,l(e B COmaIIIeHI:I5IX 0 HaMepeHI:I5IX 6e3 YICa3aHI:I5I npI:IBJIeKaeMOro KOJII:IqeCTBa nepconana I:I TeXHI:IKIL

BBH,[(Y. OTCYTCTBH5I Y reHIIO,l(p5I,[(HbIX I:I cyfinozrpaznrstx opraHH3aU;HH ,[(OCTaTOqHOrO ICOJII:IqeCTBa CTpOI:ITeJIbHOH TeXHHICH I:I o6opy,n;OBaHH5I npe,l(npH5ITH5IMH KOMnaHHH «Tpaacaeqrn,» 6bIJII:I 3aKJIIO'leHbI ztorosopsr JIH3I:IHra, nOJIyqeHHa5ICTpOHTeJIbHa5I TeXHHKa HanpaBJI5IJIaCb na cTpOHTeJIbCTBO 06'1eKTOB TC BCTO na YCJIOBH5IX apeazrsr, 'ITO TaK)Ke rronrsepxnaer BbIBO,l( 0 npOH3BO,[(CTBeHHOH HeCOCT05ITeJIbHOCTH reanozrpxnnsrx OpraHH3au;HH I:I 3a5IBJIeHHbIX I:IMH cy6no'[(p5I,l('lI:IKOB npHMeHHTeJIbHO IC nO,[(JIe)KaIIJ;I:IM BbIIIOJIHeHHIO 06'1eMaM pa60T no 3aKJIIO'leHHbIM ICOHTpaKTaM.

OTHOIITeHHH aljJljJI:IJII:IpOBaHHOCTH B CMbICJIe 3aICOHa PC<!>CP «0 KOHKypeHU;HH I:I OrpaHI:IqeHHH MOHOnOJII:ICTI:IqeCKOH ,[(e5ITeJI1HOCTI:I na TOBapHbIX psnncax» H <De'[(epaJIbHOrO 3aKOHa «0 3aIIJ;HTe KOHICypeHU;I:IH» Me)lC,[(y opraHH3aIJ;I15IMH, yqaCTBOBaBIIJI:IMH B roprax, He BbI5IBJIeHO. BMeCTe C TeM, P5I,[( 06CT05ITeJIbCTB YKa3bIBaeT aa COrJIaCOBaHHOCTb H xoopzrananmo B ,l(eHCTBI:I5IX reHno'[(p5I,[('lI:IKOB, a 'raroxe B OTHOIIIeHH5IX Me)!(,[(y reHno'[(p5I,n;qHICaMI:I H OAO «AK «TpaHCHeIjJTb» :

- COCTaB H COQeTaHI:Ie yqaCTHHKOB ropros no OT,[(eJI1H1IM JIOTaM H B u;eJIOM no BceM 06'1eKTaM;

- 6JII:I30CTb KOMMepqeCKI:IX npe,[(JIO)lCeHHH no6e,[(HTeJIeH ropros H paC'leTHOH CTOHMOCTH JIOTOB, a raxzce HX COOTHOllIeHI:Ie C ,[(pyrI:IMI:I yqaCTHHICaMH ropros;

- npe,[(onpe,[(eJIeHHOCT1 pe3YJIbTaTOB ToprOB;

- 6e30CHOBaTeJIbHOCTb peIITeHHH, npHHHMaBIITHXC5I B anrepecax reanonpaznrsrx

opraHH3aU;I:IH I:I BOnpeKI:I I:IHTepeCaM KOMnaHI:II:I «Tpancnerpn,»;

- naecenae O,lJ;HOTI:InHbIX cynrecrseaasrx H3MeHeHHH B 3aKJIIOLIeHHble ICOHTpaICTbI C pa3HbIMI:I reHno'[(p5I,[(QI:IKaMI:I B qaCTH I:I3MeHeHI:I5I CPOICOB npOBe,[(eHH5I pa60T, OnJIaTbI, OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI:I sa HapYIIIeHHe ztoronopmrx YCJIOBHH H ,l(p. sonpexa HHTepeCaM KOMnaHHI:I «Tpaacaedrrs» ;

I

·

·

17

- nenpaaouepnsre ,n;eHCTBH5I npn saveae CTOPORhI B ,n;OrOBOpaX H Ha3HaqeHHH IIO,n;P5I,n;qIU<OB 6e3 npOBe,n;eHH5I TOprOB. COrJIaCHO nHChMY 000 «L(YI1 BCTO» OT 02.09.2008r. N2 03-06-20151 savena ocymecrsneaa no YCTHOMY YKa3aHHIO 6hIBilieropYKoBo,n;cTBa OAO «AK «Tpancneqm,»;

- aenpnaneseaae K OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH opraHH3aU:HH, HapYIIIaIOru:Hx YCJIOBH5I ztorosopoa;

- O,n;HH H 're xce yspezurrena, pyxoaozrarena, nepconan opraHH3aU:HH H ztp.

06m;HM BbIBOU:

HH ozma H3 rennonpanasrx opraHH3aU:HH na MOMeHT 3aKJIIOqeHH5I KOHTpaKToB H B nepaon HCrrOJIHeHH5I norosopaax 065I3aTeJIhCTB He 6hIJIa B COCT05IHHH co6CTBeHHhIMH CI:IJIaMH H C ysacraesr opranaaauak, 3a5IBJIeHHhIX B KOHKypCHhIX npe,n;JIo)KeHH5IX B xasecrne cy6no,n;p5I,n;qHKOB, BhIIIOJIHHTh CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHT3)KHhIe pa60ThI B rrOJIHOM 06'heMe, B KOHTpaKTHhIe CPOKH, C C06JlIO,n;eHHeM YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX npaBHJI npOH3Bo,n;CTBa pa60T HH no O,n;HOMY H3 3aKJIIO"lJeHHhIX KOHTPaKTOB rro 06'heKTaM CTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC BCTO, He pacnonarano ,n;JI5I sroro Heo6xo,n;HMhIM KOJIHqeCTBOM nepconana H CTpOHTeJIbHOH TeXHHKH. II03TOMY, np06JIeMhI, B03HHKIIIHe npa CTpOHTeJIhCTBe 06'heKTOB TC BCTO, KacaIOru:HeC5I CPOKOB, nOJIHOThI H xasecrsa BhIIIOJIHeHHhIX pa60T, HeraTHBHhIX <pHHaHCOBhIX pe3YJIhTaTOB npa peaJIH3aD:HH npoexra BO MHorOM 06YCJIOBJIeH.bI rrpHBJIe"lJeHHeM K CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTa)J(HhIM pa60TaM B Ka"lJeCTBe reanonpazrraxos opraHH3aU:HH, He pacnOJIaraBIIIHX ,n;JI5I aroro Heo6xo,n;HMhIMH rrpOH3Bo,n;CTBeHHhIMH B03MO)J(HOCT5IMH, onbITOM H KBaJIH<pHKa:UHell.

I1pHJIO)l(eHH5I:

1. Cnpasxa 0 roprax, reanonpaznrsrx H cytinonpazinsrx OpraHH3aUH5IX, na 4 JIHCTax.

2. BhIIIHCKH H3 EfPIOfl B OTHOIIIeHHH 72 OpraHH3aU:HH.

3. KonHH aKTOB nposepxa <pHHaHcoBoro COCT05IHH5I, TeXHH"lJeCKOH OCHaru:eHHOCTH, "lJHCJIeHHOCTH H KBaJIH<PHKaD:HH nepconana, na 223 JIHCTax.

4. BhIKonHpoBKH H3 nJIaHOB opraHH3aD:HH cTpOHTeJIhCTBa (IIOC), na 485 JIHCTax.

5. KonHH ,n;oKYMeHToB 6yxraJITepCKOH OTqeTHOCTH no <pOPMaM N2 1 H N2 2, na 114 JIHCTax.

6. KonHH ,n;oKYMeHTOB H3 KOHKypCHhIX npeztnozceana no <pOPMaM N2N2 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, aa 76 JIHCTax.

7. KonHH nacesr H3 000 «L(YII BCTO», Mocropcrara, Kpacaonapcrara, <I>flL( npa Poccrpoe, na 18 JIHCTax.

qJIeHLI KOMHCCHH:

Xap,n;hIKHH C.A.

'JI~YHOB P.B.

Kaprros C.A.

Tpycos C.A.

ParY30Ba H.M.

PYCJI5IKOB H.M.

)l(aBopoHKOB <p.E.

BOJI5IHCKHll II.,lJ;.

Tepexos ,lJ;.A.

AKT

06 HCnOJIHemm nYHI<Ta 5 «ITepeqH51 MepOnpH5.1THH no cfiopy H nonroronxe ,n:OKYMeHTOB H HH<p0pMaUHH ,n:JI5.1 CqeTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <Pe,n:epaUHH»

r.MOCKBa

«

» 2008 r.

-----

Bo HCnOJIHeHHe PacnOp5.1)KeHH5.1 OAO «AK «Tpancneqm,» NQ 21 OT 21.07.2008r. H «ITepeqH5.1 MepOnpH5.1THH no cfiopy H nonroronxe ,n:oKYMeHToB H HH<p0pMaUHH ,n:JI5.1 CqeTHOH nanaru POCCHHCKOH <Pe,n:epaUHH» pariosaa rpyrma B COCTaBe:

Cyposua 11.A.

- ztapexropa zterrapraaeara crpoarenscrsa H crpareraxecxoro pa3BHTH5.1 OAO «AK «Tpancaedm.»;

- 3aMeCTHTeJI5.1 HaqaJIbHHKa OT,n:eJIa cTpaTerHqeCKOrO pa3BHTH5.1 OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprs»;

- 3aMeCTHTen5.1 HaqaJIbHHKa npoH3Bo,n:cTBeHHoro OT,n:ena OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprt,»;

- 3aMeCTHTeJI5.l Ha'laJIbHHKa IOpH,n:H'leCKOrO OT,n:eJIa Ilpasonoro ynpaBJIeHH5.1 OAO «AK «Tpascaedrn,»;

- rJIaBHOrO ropacxoncynsra IOpH,n:HqeCKOrO OT,n:eJIa Ilpaaosoro ynpasnenaa OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrrs»;

- HaqaJIbHHKa KOHTpOJIbHO-aHaJIHTH'leCKOrO OT,n:eJIa <pHmraJIa 000 «Tpancneqrrs <PHHaHC» B r. OMcKe;

- 3aMeCTHTen5.1 ,n:HpeKTopa ,n;enapTaMeHTa «CnY)K6a fiesorracrrocra» - HaqaJIbHHK OT,n;ena 3KOHOMHqeCKOH: fiesonacaocra OAO «AK «Tpaacnedrn,»;

- rJIaBHOrO CneUHaJIHCTa OT,n;eJIa 3KOHOMHQeCKOH 6e30nacHocTH OAO "AK "Tpaacnerprs'',

Tepexosa .a.A.

I

.

.

BOJI5.lHCKOrO IT . .a.

TpYCOBa C.A.

ParY30BOH H.11.

I I

MaTBeeBOH n.H.

PYCJI5.lKOBa H.M.

)J{aB0pOHKOBa <P.E.

I

ocymecrsana cfiop H aHaJIH3 MaTepHaiIoB H HH<p0pMaUHH no sonpocy NQ 5 CQeTHOH nanaru POCCHHCKOH <Pe,n;epaUHH 06 060CHOBaHHOCTH OIIJIaThI CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTa)lmhlX pa60T.

II II

I

,

1. AHaJIH3 OIIJIaTLI eMP B COOTHomeHHH CTOHMOCTH reHIIO.l(pSl)1;HhlX H Cy6IIO.l(PSl.l(HhIX .l(OrOBOpoB (Ilpunouceuus .Nil 1 u.Nil 2)

ITo COCT05.1HHIO aa 01.07.2008r. 000 «L{YTI BCTO» 3aKJIIOQeHO 37 KOHTpaKTOB aa CMP no 06'beKTaM TC BCTO na CyMMy 173 529,0 MnH. py6. B COOTBeTCTBHH C ycnOBH5.1MH KOHTpaKToB reanonpaaasma opraHH3aUH5.1MH BbIITOJIHeHO pa60T na CyMMy 54 075,896 MJIH. py6. 000 «L{YIT BCTO» OnJIa"<IeHO no,n;p5.1.n:HbIM opraHH3aUH5.1M 71 046,1 MJIH. py6., B TOM "<IHCne B BH,n;e aBaHCOB 40826,745 MJIH. py6.

B CB5.13H C aeacnonaeaaea I'eanozrparrraxaaa YCJIOBHH KOHTpaKTOB pacroprnyro 5 KOHTpaKToB na CyMMy 36027,0 MJIH. py6.:

c3AO «Kpacaonapcrpoarpaacras» pacroprayrsr KOHTpaKTbI NQ568-07 OT 20.04.2007, NQ 601-07 OT 28.06.2007, NQ 602-07 OT 29.06.2007, NQ 584-07 OT 15.06.2007 rra CyMMy 24 202,0 MJIH.py6.;

C 000 «AH TIH Cers CIT6» pacropryr KOHTpaKT NQ 631-07 OT 11.07.2007 aa CyMMy 11 825,0 MJIH.py6.

113 37 KOHTPaKToB na BbIITOJIHeHHe CMP no 13 - He npe.n:YCMOTpeHO npHBJIeQeHHe cytirronpannsrx opraHH3aUHH, no 24 KOHTPaKTaM B COOTBeTCTBHH C ycnOBH5.1MH KOHTpaKTa

I{ B

II II

1

CIUICOK npHBJ1eKaeMhIX cy6nO'[(p51J(HhIX OpraHH3aIIH:H COrJmCOBaH reHnO'[(p5I'[(HhIMH

OpraHH3aIIH5IMH C 000 «L(YTI BCTO».

Bcero no COCT05IHHIO na 01.07.2008 B OAO «L(YTI BCTO» '[(eHcTBYlOT 32 KOHTpaKTa na 06rrrYIO cyMMY 137502,023 MJIH. py6.

ITOCKOJIhKY reanonpsnaae opraHH3aII1111 11 P5I,[( cy6no,[(p5I.D;HhIX opraHH3aIIHH OTKa3aJIH OAO «AK «Tpaacacdrrs» 11 000 «IJ;YIT BCTO» B npenocrasnenaa ,[(oKYMeHToB 11 cBe,n:eH11H, He06xo,n:HMhIX ,n:JI5I aHaJIH3a H ncpczraxa B C'leTHYIO rranary POCC11HCKOH <De,n:epaII11H, pafio-ras rpyrrna 11CnOJIh30BaJIa npa aHaJI113e nann, nocryrmue ,n:oKYMeHThI 11 HHcpopMaII11IO, nonysenasre OT npeznrpaaraa CHCTeMhI AK «Tpancneipn,» 11 OT HeKOTOPhIX cyonozrpaaasrx OpraH113aIIHH.

AHaJI1:I3 06'heMOB H CTOHMOCTH pafior, BhIIIOJIH5IeMhIX cy6rro,n:p5I,n:HhIMH opraHl:I3aIIH5IMH B paspese ztoronopon reaepansaoro noztpana (Ta6JIHl(a .N21.)

Tafinaua N2 1 6 H

11 I~ -.

MnH.pyt .c l1.C
CTOIlMOCTb OTKJlOHeHlle
HallMeHOBaHIlC 06beKT3 N2 Fenepansnsut Cyfinonpannan BbInOJlHlIeMblxpa6oT
N2 Y'IaCTOK
CTPOIITeJIbCTBa KOHTpaKTa nO,LIPll,LI'l11K opraauaauna no no B MJlII. p. B%
AorOBOpy noroaopy (rp.7- (rp.7!
reHnOAPlI,LIa cy6nO,LIplilla rp.8) rp.8)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
000
"Oacxneqrreraacn 120-140 460,4 285,4 175,00 38,0%
encrpon"
I osepens TC «BCTO». N2123-06 000 OOOKCY
1. J1MHeiiHaJl 'IaCTb. Y'IaCTOK OT 28.04.06 "Cacrevatlneu "CM6HetjlTenpOBO.LI 140-272 3 060,8 2 049,2 1011,5 33%
KM 0 - KM 570 Crpon" crpon"
OOOKCY
"CM6HetjlTenpOBO.LI 362-410 889,4 726,08 163,35 18,4
crpoa'
I osepens TC «BCTO». 000
"Bonraaeqrreraacn 908-926 458,15 373,13 85,19 18,6%
PTC «BCTO». Y'IaCTOK N2 I eucrpoa"
(r. Y cTh-KYT - Tanaxaacxoe 000 000
2. MeCTOpOll\lleHMe ). N2332-06 "CMCTeMaCneu "Bonraneqrrerascn 926-964 1227,26 633,13 594,13 48,4
I1pKYTcKaJl ofinacrs, OT 28.12.06
Pecnyfinaxa Caxa (RKYTMJI). Crpoa" el.lcTpoii"
J1MHeMHaJl '1aCTh, Y'IaCTOK 000 964 -
KM 570 - KM 1105" "Oacxaeqrreraacn 1020 1432,08 1 0 16,9 415,15 29,0
encrnort"
000 1192-
1 osepens TC «BCTO». "Bonranedrreraacn 1250 981,19 876,85 104,34 10,6%
PTC «BCTO». Y'IaCTOK N23 eucrpon"
(TanaKaHcKoe N2579-07 000 000
3. "Cacreaaf.nen 1250 -
MeCTOpOll\lleHMe - r.Anaaa), OT 11.04.07 Crpotl" "Oacxaerpreraacn 1285 715,14 642,18 72,96 10,2%
J1MHeMHaJl 'IaCTh, KM 1 105 - eucrpon"
KM 1570" 000 1285 -
"Oacxaeqrreraacn 1372 1056,47 919,19 137,28 13,0%
eucrpoa"
nTOrO: 10280,89 7522,06 2758,9 26,83 I

.

i

I

,

I

.

TIo 06'heKTY CTp011TeJIbCTBa: «Ilepnaa onepens Tpy6onpOBO,lJ;HOH CHCTeMLI

"BOCTOqHan CH6HPL - THXHH OKeaH". JIHHeHHan qaCTL. YqaCTOK KM ° - KM 570, ,l1;y 1067 MM» 3aKJ1IO'leH KOHTpaKT N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 C renrronpazmori OpraH113aII11eH 000 «CHcTeMaCrreIICTpoH» (no cornamenaro 0 saveae CTOPOHbI 000 «CTPOHC11CTeMa») 06rrreH CTOHMOCTbIO 15 998,5 MJIH. py6. TIpOT5I)l(eHHOCTh JIl:IHeHHOH 'laCTl:I COCTaBJIReT 559 KM. ,lJ;JI5I BbIIIOJ1HeHH5I pa60T rrpaaneaeasr no COCT05IHl:IIO aa 01.07.2008 10 cytinonpaztnsrx opraHH3aIIl:IH, B TOM 'lHCJIe 3aBl:IC11Mble ofinrecraa KOMrraH1111 000 «OMCKHecpTera3CrreIIcTpOH», 000 KCY «CH6HerpTerrpOBO,[(CTpOH».

- YqaCTOK Hln 120-140 KM:

000 «OMcKHe(jJTera3cneQCTpoii» BbIIIOJIH5IJ10 no ,n:aHHOMY yxacrxy KOMrrJIeKC pa60T B paxrxax CTpOl:ITemCTBa JIHHeHHOH 'laCTH TC BCTO, a 11MeHHO YCTPOHCTBO 3X3, rH,n:paBJIH'leCKHe HcnbITaH115I H nponyc« npodianeaepa, BKJIIO'la5I MOHTa)l(-,n:eMOHTa)l(

2

kl

3

BpeMeHHhIX xaxep CO,a, 6HOJIOrIF:IeCKy:IO, TeXHW:leCKy:IO peKYJIhTHBaI(HH, CTpOHTemCTBO YCTpaHeHHe nenonenox no CTpOIiTeJIhCTBY B,n:OJIbTpaCCOBOH BJI .H T.,n:. CTOHMOCTh COOTBeTCTBy:IOru;IiX pa60T Y feHIIO,n:p5I,n:qHKa rro KOHTpaKTY NI! 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 - 460,4 MJIH. py6., CTOHMOCTb aroroxce KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ztoronopy cytinozrpana N2 05-BCTO OT 03.05.2006 - 285,4 MJIH. py6. OTKJIOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T - COCTaBJI5IeT 175,00 MJIH. py6 . .HJI.H 38%.

II Ij

I

- YqaCTOK Hln 140 - 272 KM

000 KCY «CH6HeljJTenpOBO)l;CTPOH)' BbIIIOJIH5IJIO no ,n:aHHoMyyqacTKY KOMIIJIeKC pa60T B paxrxax CTpO.HTeJIbCTBa JI.HHeHHOH qaCTH TC BCTO, a .HMeHHO YCTPOHCTBO 3X3, rH,n:paBJIHqeCK.He .HCnbITaH.H5I .H npodnorcacrpmo, BKJIlOlJa5I MOHTa)K-,n:eMOHTa)K speveaasrx KaMep CO,a, 6.HoJIOrHlJecKyID peKYJIbT.HBaI(HlO, npOKJIa,n:KY rpyoorrposona (L=0,142 KM), YCTPOHCTBO JIe)J<HeBbIX zropor H T.,n:.

CTOHMOCTb cooTBeTcTByIDrn:.HX pa60TY I'ennonpazr-raxa no KOHTpaKTY NI! 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 - 3 060,8 MJIH. py6., CTO.HMOCTb sroro zce KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ztoroaopy cyfinozrpana N2 4-0282-BCTO/6811-06 OT 03.05.2006 - 2 049,2 MJIH. py6. OTKJIOHeH.He CTOHMOCTH pa60T -1 011, 5 MJIH. py6. HJI.H 33%.

- YqaCTOK H/n 362-410 KM

000 KCY «CH6HeljJTenpOBO)l;cTpoii» BhIIIOJIH5IJIO no ,n:aHHoMY yqaCTKY KOMnJIeKC pa60T B pasrxax cTpOJiTeJIhCTBaJIHHeHHOH lJaCTH TC BCTO, BKJIlOqa5I py6KY rreca, YCTPOHCTBO 3X3, r.H,n:paBJIHlJeCKHe HcnbITaHH5I, cTpOHTeJIhCTBO anonsrpaccosyro BJ1, aBTOMaT.HKY, 6JIaroycTpOHCTBO, cTpOHTeJIbCTBO TITIMH, Y3JIa nycxa-npaeua CO,a H r.n.

CTOHMOCTb COOTBeTcTByIDrn:HX pa60T Y I'earronpazrsaxa no KOHTpaKTY NI! 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 - 889,4 MJIH. py6., CTOHMOCTb aroro )}(e KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no zroroaopy cyfinozrpazra NQ 4-0283-BCTO/691l-06 OT 03.05.2006 - 726,08 MJIH. py6. OTKJIOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T - 163,35 MJIH. py6. HJIH 18,4%.

TIo o6'beKTY cTpoHTeJIhCTBa: «YqaCTOK XI! 1 (r. Y CTb - KYT - TaJIaKaHCKoe MecTopo~eHHe). HpKYTcKa.H o6JIacTI>, Pecny6JIHKa Caxa (HKYTH.H). JIHHeHHa.H IIaCTI>, YIJaCTOK KM 570 - KM 1105» 3aKJIIOIJeH KOHTpaKT XI! 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 C reHno,lJ;p.H,lJ;HOH opraaaaannea 000 «CHcTeMaCnen;CTpoii» (no COrJIarneHHlO 0 sasreae CTOPOHbI 000 «CTpOHCHCTeMa») o6rn:eH CTO.HMOCThlO 12 494,8 MJIH. py6. TIpOT5I)}(eHHOCTh JIHHeHHOH lJaCTH COCTaBJI5IeT 535 KM. ,aJI5I BhITIOJIHeHII5I pa60T npHBJIelJeHhI 7 cyononpxmrsrx opraHH3aI(.HH, B TOM lJHCJIe 3aBHCHMhIe 06rn:eCTBa KOMnaHHH - 000 «Oxrcxaerpreraacneiicrpoa», 000 «BOJIraHecpTera3CneI(CT]JOH».

- YqaCTOK H/n 908 -926 KM

000 «Bonraaedrrer-aacneucrpoit» BbIIIOJIH5IeT no ,n:aHHOMY ysacrxy KOMnJIeKC pa60T no npOKJIa,[(Ke rpytiorrposozta 22,894 KM, BKJIlOt:Ia5I py6KY neca, paClJHCTKY nOJIOChI orsorra, npOKJIa,[(KY rpytionpoaozra, YCT]JOHCTBO 3X3, rH,n:paBJIHqeCKHe HcnhITaHH5I, aztorn.rpaccoayro BJ1, aBToMaTHKY, HH)l(eHepHyIO 3arn:HTY H 6JIaroycTpoHCTBO. CTOHMOCTb cooTBeTcTBy:IOrn:HX pa60T y Termonpazrraxa no KOHTpaKTY N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 - 458,15 MJIH. py6. (CTOHMOCTh npOKJIa,n:KH 1 KM. HecpTenpoBo,n:a B paMKax ,n:oroBopa reHno,n:PMa B cpe,n:HeM no ,n:aHHoMY ysacrxy - 20,0 MJIH. py6.), CTOHMOCTb sroro zce KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ziorosopy cytinoztpxna NQ 03-BCTOIlP-BHrCC OT 28.12.2006 - 373,13 MJIH. py6. (CTOHMOCTh npOKJIa,[(K.H 1 KM nedrrenponozra B panxax ztorosopa cytinoztpana B cpenaex no ,n:aHHOMY YlJaCTKY - 16,3 MJIH. py6.). OTKJIOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T - 85,19 MJIH. py6. HJIH 18,6%.

, - YIJaCTOK Hln 926 - 964 KM

000 «Bo.nranedrreraacneucrpoti» BhIIIOJIH5IeT no ,n:aHHoMY YlJaCTKY KOMnJIeKC pa60T no rrpororaznce rpytionposorra 34,481 KM, BKJIlOlJa5I py6KY neca, paClJ.HCTKY nOJIOChI orsona, npOKJIa,[(KY rpytiorrposona, YCTPOHCTBO 3X3, rH,n:paBJIHlJeCKHe HcrrhITaHH5I, nztonrrpaccosyro BJI, aBToMaTHKY, HH)l(eHepHy:IO 3arn:.HTY .H 6JIaroycTpoHCTBO. CTOHMOCTh COOTBeTCTBy:IOrn:HX

If II

4

pa60T Y I'canozrpamnxa no KOHTpaKTY N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 - 1 227,26 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTh npoxnanxa 1 KM. aerprenposona B pavxax zroronopa reHIIO):(p5I,[(a B cpezraeu no ,[(aHHOMY yqaCTKY - 35,6 MJIH. py6.), CTOllMOCTh sroro )!(e KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ,L1;OrOBopy cytirrozrpszra N2 03-BCTOIlP-BHfCC OT 28.12.2006 - 633,13 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTh npOKJIa):(KH 1 KM nedrrenposona B paxncax zroronopa cytinonpsna B cpeznrev no ,[(aHHoMY ysacrxy - 18,36 MJIH. py6.). OTKJIOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T - 594,13 MJIH. py6. llJIH 48,4 %.

- ¥qaCTOK HIll 964 - 1 020 KM

000 «Osrcxneqrrer-ascnencrpoib BhIIIOJIH5IeT no ,L1;aHHoMY ysacrxy KOMnJJeKC pa60T no npoxnanxe Tpy6onpOBO,L1;a 55,79 KM, BKJIlOqa5I py6KY JIeca,. pacxacrxy nOJIOChI oTBo,L1;a, npOKJIa,L1;KY rpytionposona, ranpasnasecxae ncnsrraaas, B):(OJIbTpaccoBYIO Bfl, aBTOMaTllKY, HH)!(eHepHYIO sannrry H 6JIaroycTpoHCTBO. CTOllMOCTb coorsercrayiomax pa60T y feHrro):(p5I,L1;QHKa no KOHTpaKTY N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 - 1 432,08 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTh npOKJIaAKll 1 KM He~TenpoBo):(a B paMKax ):(oroBopa reHnO,L1;p5I,L1;a B cpe,[(HeM ITO ,L1;aHHoMY YQaCTKY - 25,67 MJIH. py6.), CTOHMOCTb sroro )J{e KOMITJJeKCa pa60T no zrorosopy cyonozrpszra N203-BCTO/IP-OHfCC OT 28.12.2006 - 1 016,9 MJJH. py6. (CTOHMOCTh npoxnanxa 1 KM nedrrenposozra B paxxax ziorosopa cytirroztpxna B Cpe,L1;HeM no ,[(aHHOMY ysacrxy - 18,23 MITH. py6.). OTKJIOHeHlle CTOllMOCTll pa60T - 415,15 MJIH. py6. ana 29%.

ITo 06'.beKTY cTp0HTeJIhCTBa: «¥qaCTOK Xl! 3 (TaJIaKaHCKoe MeCTOpO:ll\,lJ;eHHe - r. AJIL(aH). JIHHeiiHaR xacrr., 1105 - 1570 KM» 3aKJIIOqeH KOHTpaKT Xl! 579-07 OT 11.04.2007 C reHnOL(pRL(HOii oprarmsauaea 000 «Crrc'resraCnenti'rpoa» (no cornameamo o 3aMeHe CTOPOHbI 000 «Crpoiicacrexa») 06rn;eH CTOHMOCThlO - 11 312,7 MJIH. py6., ITpOT5I)J{eHHocThlO 449,27 KM. )J;JI5I BbIIIOITHeHll5I pa60T rro COCT05IHHlOHa 01.07.2008 ITpllBJIeQeHbI 6 cy6no,[(p5I,L1;HbIX opranasanaa, B TOM "llllCJIe saaacasrae 06rn;eCTBa KOMITaHHll 000 «Bonrarrerprerascrrencrpoa»; 000 «OMCKHe~Tera3CITen;CTpOH».

I

·

,

- ¥qaCTOK H/n 1 192 - 1 250 KM

000 «Bonraneqrreraacnencrpoa» BhIIIOJIH5IeT ITO ):(aHHoMY YQaCTKY KOMITJIeKC pa60T ITO ITpOKJIaAKe rpytiorrpcsona 47,91 KM, BKJIlO"lla5I py6KY neca, pacsncrxy nOJJOCbI OTBo,[(a, npOKJIaAKy rpytionpoaona, ranpaamrsecxae ncnsrranaa, B):(OJIbTpaccoBy:IO Bfl, aBTOMaTllKY, llH)J{eHepHYIO sannrry H 6ITaroycTpoHCTBO. CTOllMOCTb cooraercrsyromax pa60T y Fearrozrpazrsaxa ITO KOHTpaKTY N2 579-06 OT 11.04.2006 - 981,2 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTh ITPOKJIa,L1;Kll 1 KM He~TenpoBo,[(a )J;y1200 MM B paMKax ,[(oroBopa reHnO,L1;p5I):(a B Cpe,L1;HeM ITO ,L1;aHHOMY yqacTKy - 20,5 MJIH. py6.), CTOHMOCTb aroro )J{e KOMITJIeKCa pa60T ITO ,L1;OrOBopy cy6no,L1;p5I,L1;a N2 03-BCTO/P-3-BHfCC OT 11.04.2007 - 876,86 MJIH. py6. (CTOHMOCTh npoxnanxa 1 KM nerprenpoaozta )J;y1200 MM B paxrxax zroroaopa cyfirroztpana B Cpe,L1;HeM no ,[(aHHOMY ysacrxy -t- 18,3 MITH. py6.). OTKJIOHeHlle CTOllMOCTll pa60T - 104,3 MJIH. py6. llITll 10,6%.

I

·

·

I I

I

·

·

I

·

- ¥qaCTOK H/n 1 250 - 1 285 KM

000 «OMcKHerjJTera3CneIJ,CTpoii» BhIIIOJIH5IeT no ,L1;aHHOMY ysacrxy KOMITJIeKC pa60T no ITpOKJIa,L1;Ke rpyoonposozra 34,97 KM, BKITlO"lla5I py6KY neca, pacxacrxy nOJIOCbI OTBO,L1;a, npOKJIaAKy rpyoonposona, m,L1;paBJIllQeCKHe llCITbITaHll5I, B,L1;OJIbTpaCCOBy:IO Bfl, aBToMaTllKY, llH)!(eHepHYIO sanmry II 6ITaf0YCTPOHCTBO. CTOllMOCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOrn;llX pa60T y feHrrO,Zl;p5I,Zl;QHKa no KOHTpaKTY N2 579-06 OT 11.04.2006 - 715,14 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTh npOKJIa,[(KH 1 KM He~TerrpoBo):(a )J;y1200 MM B paMKax ,Zl;OrOBOpa reHITO,L1;p5I,L1;a B Cpe,Zl;HeM no ,L1;aHHOMY ysacrxy - 20,45 MITH. py6.), CTOHMOCTh 3TOro ace KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ,L1;OrOBopaM cytinonpazra N2 04-BCTO/P-3-0HfCC OT 11.04.2007 II N2 11-BCTOIP-3 OT 01.12.2007 - 642,18 MJIH. py6. (CTOllMOCTb npOKJIa,L1;KH 1 KM nedrrenpoaozra ,[(y1200 MM B paxxax ,L1;OrOBopa cytinozrpana B cpezmex ITO ):(aHHOMY YQaCTKY -18,36 MJJH. py6.). OTKJIOHeHlle CTOllMOCTH pa60T - 72,97 MJIH. py6. llJIll 10,2%.

[:]

5

- YqaCTOI\: H/n 1 285 - 1 372 KM

000 «Oxcxaedrreraacnencrpoa» B1IIIOJIH5IeT no ,UaHHoMY Y1:JaCTKY KOMnJIeKC pa60T no npOKJIa,UKe rpyoonpoaona 48,125 KM, BKJIIOqa5I py6KY neca, paC1:J11CTKY nOJIOC11 OTBo,Ua, npOIma,UKY 'rpyfonponozra, nI'upaBJI11QeCK11e 11Cn1ITamI5I, B,UOJI1T_PaccoBYIO BJI, aBTOMaT11KY, 11H)l(eHepHYIO samary 11 6JIaroycTpoiicTBO. CT011MOCT1 cooTBeTcTBYIOIT(11X pa60T y f'eHno'up5I,UQ11Ka no KOHTpaKTY N2 579-06 OT 11.04.2006 - 1 0.56,47 MJIH. py6. (CT011MOCT1 npOKJIa,UKI1 1 KM sedrrenponona ,n;y1200MM B panxax zicroaopa reHno'up5I,Ua B cpenaev no ,UaHHoMY YQaCTKY - 20,95 MJIH. py6.), CT011MOCTI:. sroro )l(e KOMnJIeKCa pa60T no ztorosopaa cyfinozrpszta N2 04-BCTOIP-3-0Hf'CC OT 11.04.2007 H N2 11-BCTO/P-3 OT 01.12.2007 - 919,19 MJIH. py6. (CT011MOCT1 npOKJIa,UK11 1 KM aedrreriponozta ,n;y1200 MM B paxncax zrorosopa cyorronpana B cpezraex no ,UaHHoMY Y1:JaCTKY -19,10. MJIH. py6.). OTKJIOHeH11e CT011MOCT11 pa60T - 137,29 MJIH. py6. 11JIH 13%.

BblBO,lJ;:

ITo BceM paccaorpeansnr ztoroaopaa CTOHMOCT1 pa60T y cy6no,Up5ILJ:H1IX opraHH3aI(11H, Henocpe,UCTBeHHO BbIIIOJIH5IBIII11X CTp011TeJIbHO-MOHTa)l(Hble pa6oT1I, cymecrseaao OTJI111:JaeTC5I (OT 10% ,UO 48%) OT CT011MOCT11 3TMX )l(e pa60T B reHno'up5I,UH1IX KOHTpaKTax, rrpn TOM, 1:JTO reHnO'up5ILJ:Ha5I opraHH3a~115I 000 «CTPOHCHCTeMa» (nOCJIe 3aMeHbI CTOPOH11 - 000 «CHCTeMaCne~CTPOH») Henocpe,UCTBeHHO HHKaKHX CMP na YKa3aHHbIX 06'1eKTaX He BhIIIOJIH5IJIa. Pa3HHI(a B CTOHMOCTH no reanonpaznrsn« 11 cy6nO,Up5I,UHhIM ztoronopaxr COCTaBHJIa 2758,9 MJIH. py6. HJIH B cpeztaex 27%. OnJIaTa YKa3aHHOH CYMMbI reaeparrsaouy no,Up5ILJ:1:JHKY, Henocpe,UCTBeHHO He BhIIIOJIH5IBmeMY CMP M asrcrynaameay JIHIIIh lIOcpe,UHHKOM Me)l(,Uy 3aKa31:JMKOM (000 «IJ;YI1 BeTO») H cy6no,Up5I,UHhIMH OpraHH3aI(H5IM11, n03BOJI5IeT xapaxrepasonars ,UaHHhIe3aTpaThI KaK 3KOHOMH1:JeCKH Heo6oCHOBaHHhIe. B cnysae, eCJI11 H ztpyrae reHnO'up5ILJ:HhIe H cy6nO'up5ILJ:HhIe ,UOroBOPhI na CMP no 06'1eKTaM TC BCTO 6hIJIH 3aKJII01:JeHhI na aHaJIOrH1:JHhIX YCJIOBH5IX 11 B YK8.3aHHhIX COOTHOIIIeHH5IX (27%), neooocnoaanasre sarparsr na CMP COCTaB5IT rrpmrepao 47 MJIP,lJ;. py6JIeii.

I

II II

I I

,

2. AHaJIH3 conOCTaBHMbIX ,lJ;aHHblX 0 neue CMP B nC,l1;, KOHKypCHbIX npennoseeaaax, rennonpanasrx KOHTpaKTax, cy6nO,lJ;pH,lJ;HblX noronopax

Pa601:JeH rpynnoa npoaenea aHaJIH3 conOCTaBHMhIX ,UaHHbIX B IIC,n;, KOHKYPCHhIX npe,UJIO)l(eH5IX, reanozipxnasrx KOHTpaKTax, cy6no,Up5I,UHhIX ztoroaopax no COOTBeTCTBYIOru;HM 06'1eKTaM TC BCTO.

ITP11 aHaJIH3e HCnOJIh30BaJIHCh rermortpaztasre ,UorOBop11 C 000 «CTPOHC11CTeMa» (nocne 3aMeHhI CTOPOHbI B ztorosope - 000 «CMcTeMaCneI(CT_Poii»):

- N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 no o6'1eKTY «ITepBM osepezrs rpytionpononaoa CHCTeMbI «BOCT01:JHM CH6HPh - TMXHH OKeaH». JIHHeHHM 1:JaCTb. Y1:JaCTOK KM 0 - KM 795, ,n; 1067 MM, Y1:JaCTOK KM 795 - KM 897,,n; 1220 MM» (JIOT N2 BCTO\JI-1);

- N2 579-07 OT 11.04.2007 no 06'1eKTY «ITepBa5I osepens rpytiorrposonnoa CHCTeMhI «BoCT01:JHa5I CH611Pb-THXHH OKeaH». PaCIIII1peHMe TC BCTO. Y1:JaCTOK N2 3. (TaJIaKaHCKoe MecTOpo)!(,UeH11e - r. AJI,UaH). JI11HeHHa5I QaCTh, KM 11 05 - KM 1570, ,l( 1220 MM», (JIOT N2BCTO\P-3),

I I

M 3aKJII01:JeHHble ,UJI5I BbIIIOJIHeHM5I pafio'r, npenycuorpenasrx reHno,n;p5I,UHbIMM KOHTpaKTaM11, cyfirroztpanasre ,n;oroBopbI:

- N2 4-0282-BCTO/68/01-06 OT 03.05.2006 Me)!(,Uy 000 «CeBepHa5I rpynna» (cy6no,Up5I,U1:JHK 000 «Crpoacacreaa») M 000 KCY «Catiaedmpononcrpoa»;

- N2 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 Me)l<.D:Y CDMJIHaJI MIT «EeJICTpOllTpaHCra3» (cy6no,n;p5I,U1:JMK 000 «CTPOHC11CTeMa») M 000 «Oncxnerprerascneucrpoa»;

- N2 05-BCTO OT 03.05.2006 Me)l(,Uy 000 «CeBepHa5I rpynna» (cy6no,Up5I,n;1:J11K 000 «Crpcacacresra») 11 000 «Oacxaeqnerascnencrpon»,

6 - N2 4-0283-BCTO/69/8-06 OT 03.05.2006 Me)K,n:y 000 «CeBepHa5I rpynna» (cytinoztpazrmx 000 «CTPOH:CHCTeMa») H 000 KCY «Cnfiaedmpononcrpoji»;

- N2 07-BCTO/P-3 OT 17.08.2007 Me)K,n:y 000 reHno,n:p5I,n:'IHKOM «CTPOH:CHCTeMa» H cy6no,n:p5I,n:'IHKOM OAO «BOJDKCKHH: nonsonaax».

Kpove roro, npOaHaJIH3HpOBaHI:,I KOHTpaKTbI 000 «L{YI1 BCTO» na BbIIIOJIHeHHe CMP no o6'beKTY «I1epBa5I osepens .rpytionposozmoa CHCTeMbI BCTO. CHcTeMa CB5I3H» no y'IaCTKy KM 570 - KM 1105».

B pe3YJIhTaTe aHaJIH3a BbI.SIBlIeHbI CJIe,n:YIOrn;He cpaKTbI, 06CT05ITeJIbCTBa,

aaxoaovepaocra:

1) Feanonpsnmsre KOHTpaKThI 3aKJIlOQeHhI na YCJIOBHHX, OTJIHQHhIX OT YCJIOBHii, cO,lJ;ep:IKaBIIIHXCH B KOHKypCHhIX npe,lJ;JIO:IKeHHHX 000 «Crpoacacresra» - COCTaB, 06'beM, CTOHMOCTb pa60T B KOHKypCHOM npe,n:JIO)KeHHH H B KOH1paKTe Pa3JIH'IHbI.

TaK, aanpaxep:

- B n. 4-1-7 cf>OPMbI 14 «PaC'IeT KOHKypCHOH: 3a5IBKH» xoaxypcaoro npe,n:JIo)KeHH5I 000 «CTPOH:CHCTeMa» yxasaasr CBapO'IHO-MOHTa)KHble pa60TbI 06'beMOM 75,38 KM CTOHMOCTbIO 258,348 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C. B nYHKTe 4-13 I1pHJIO)KeHH5I N2 2 K KOHTpaKTY N2 123-06oT 28.04.2006 yxasaaaue pa60TbI OTpa)KeHbI B 06'beMe 73,65 KM, CTOHMOCTbIO 277,808 MlIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C;

- B n. 4-1-3 cf>OPMbI 14 «PaC'IeT KOHKypCHOH: 3a5IBKH» xoaxypcnoro npe,n:JIO)KeHH5I 000 «CTPOH:CHCTeMa» YKa3aHhI pa60TbI no cpesxe rpYHTa 06'beMOM 19110 M3 CTOHMOCTbIO 564,570 TbIC. py6. 6e3 H,[(C. B nYHKTe 4-2 I1pHJIO)KeHH5I N2 2 K KOH1paKTY N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 yxasaaasre pa60TbI orpazcensr B 06'beMe 38 452 M3, CTOHMOCTbIO 1,268 MlIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C;

- B n. 4-1-5 cf>OPMbI 14 «PaC'IeT KOHKYPCHOH: 3a5IBKH» xonxypcaoro npe,n:JIO)KeHH5I 000 «CTPOH:CHCTeMa» YKa3aHbI pa60TbI no yxnaznce 100 npoTHBo3PP03HH:HbIX rronorenen CTOHMOCTbIO 1,014 MlIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C. B nYHKTe 4-11 I1pHlIO)KeHH5I N2 2 K KOHTpaKTY N2 123- 06 OT 28.04.2006 YKa3aHbI pa60TbI no YKJIa,n:Ke 142 npoTHBo3PP03HH:HbIX nonorenen CTOHMOCTbIO 1,609 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C.

J ]

2) Hexoropsre BH,lJ;hI pafior, rrpenycerorpeaasre H OCMeQeHHhIe B TIC));, OTCYTCTBYIOT B KOHKypCHOM npe,lJ;JIO:IKeHHH 000 «Crpoiicacresra» H B KOHTpaKTe N2 123- 06 OT 28.04.2006.

TaK, B pasnene 4 «I1pOKJIa,n:Ka rpyconpoaozra ,[( 1067 MM KM 0 - KM 76» I1pHrrO)KeHH5I N22 K KOHTpaKTY N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 OTCyrCTBYIOT pafiorsr, npenycssorpenasre CMeTHhIM paC'IeTOM N2 2-1-1 no 06'beKTY «I1epBa5I o-repens rpytiorrpoaormoa CHCTeMbI «BoCTO'IHa5I CH6Hpb-THXHH: OKeaH». flHHeH:Ha5I 'IaCTb. YYIaCTOK KM 0 - KM 130 (MPKYTCKa5I ofinacrs)» o6rn;eH: CMeTHOH: CTOHMOCTbIO 9,272 MrrH. py6., B TOM 'IHCrre (I1pHrrO)KeHHe N2 __):

- pa60TbI no BbIB03Y lIHIIIHerO rpynra OT cpesxa aa paCCT05IHHe 50 KM, 06'beMOM 56 348 TOHH CMeTHOH: CTOHMOCTbIO 7,031 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H.L(C (paszien 6 cxrernoro pacxera N2 2-1-1 no 06'beKTY «I1epBa5I ouepezn, rpytionposozraof CHCTeMbI «BoCTO'IHa5I CH6HPb- THXHH: OKeaH». flHHeH:Ha5I YIaCTb. Y'IaCTOK KM 0 - KM 130 (HpKYTCKa5I ofinacrs)»;

- pa60TbI no 3aCbIIIKe npoTHB03P03HH:HbIX nonoreaen rpyrrrosr, 06'beMOM 45 440 M3 CMeTHOH: CTOHMOCTbIO 1,485 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C (paszten 16 cxreraoro pacsera N2 2-1-1 no o6'beKTY «I1epBa5I osepezn, rpytionpoaonaoa CHCTeMbI «BoCTO'IHa5I CH6HPb- THXHM OKeaH». flHHeH:Ha5I YIaCTb. Y'IaCTOK KM 0 - KM 130 (HpKYTCKa5I ofinacrs)»;

- pa60TbI no norpysxe lIHIIIHerO rpyrrra H BbIB03 na 50 KM, 06'beMOM 5 632 TOHH, CMeTHOM CTOHMOCTbIO 755,067 ThIC. py6. 6e3 H,[(C (paszten 17 cxrernoro pacxera N2 2-1-1 no 06'beKTY «I1epBa5I osepens .rpytionposonaoa CHCTeMbI «BoCTOYIHa5I Cafiaps- THXHH: OKeaH». flHHeMHa5I tIaCTb. YtIaCTOK KM 0 - KM 130 (Hpxyrcxax ofinacrs)».

Hexoropsre BH,n:bI pafior, aanpaxep CBapOtIHO-MOHTa)KHble H H30JI5IUHOHHO-YKrra,n:OtIHbIe B KOHKypCHOM npe,n:JIO)KeHHH H KOHTpaKTe YKa3aHbI B YKpynHeHHoM BH,n:e (I1pHlIO)KeHHe N2 _), 'ITO He n03BOrr5IeT npOaHaJIH3HpOBaTb HX 60rree ,n:eTaJIbHO.

3) TIo PRJJ;Y n03HIJ,Hll CTOHMOCTb pa60T B reHnoJJ;pRJJ;HOM KOHTpaKTe .N!! 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 3HaQHTeJ1bHO npeasnnaer CTOHMOCTb pafior.. IWTopaR 6b1J1a YKa3aHa B KOHKypCHOM npeJJ;J10)l(eHHH 000 «Crpoiicacreua», npeJJ;cTaBJIeHHOM na yraepaorenae B Teanepnsra KOMHTeT OAO «AK «Tpancaeqm.»:

KOHTpaKTHa51 CTOHMOCTb pa60T B
N2 YT.JaCTOK CTOI1MOCTb pa60T KOHKypCHOM npennoscenaa Pasaaua (py6.) 6e3
n\n (py6.) 6e3 H,Z:(C 000 «CTPOHCI1CTeMa» (py6.) HAC
6e3 H,Z:(C
1. 130-239 KM 2250856920 J 683644070 567212850
2. 239-372 KM 2748 157771 2220177 970 527979801
3. I1I1MH p.Aarapa, 1 080511 776 1 020338980 60 172 796
299KM
4. 372-496 KM 2 178481 113 1952711860 225769253
5. 496-616 KM 2469659470 2 102962710 366696760
Hroro: 1747831460 II 1m

I

.

4) B zroroaopax NQ 4-0282~BCTOI68/1-06 OT 03.05.2006 Me)l(,l(Y 000 «Cenepaaa rpynna» (cytinonpazrnnc 000 «Crpoiicacreaa») H 000 «KCY «CH6He¢TenpoBo.n;CTpOH»

(cyc-cytinozrpazrsa«), NQ 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 Me)l(,l(Y noztpazrraxoa <DmIHarr nIT

«Eencrpoarpaacras» (cyononpamax 000 «CTpoHcHCTeMa») H 000

«OMcKHe¢Tera3CneI(CTpOH», NQ 05-BCTO OT 03.05.2006 Me)l(.n;y 000 «Ceaepaaa rpynna» (cy6rro.n;p~.n;'lHK 000 «CTpoHcHCTeMa») H cy6-cy6no,l(pM'lHKOM 000 «OMcKHe¢Tera3CneI(CTpOH», NQ 4-0283-BCTO/69/8-06 OT 03.05.2006 Me)l()J;y 000 «Cesepaaa rpynrra» (cytinozrpaaaax 000 «Crpoiicacrexra») H cy6rrO,l(p~,l('lHKOM 000 KCY «CH6He¢npoBo.n;cTPOH» OTCYTCTBYIOT CMeTLI H HMeeTCR TOJ1bKO Pacnpeneneaae KOHTpaKTHoll nensr H Tpaqnnc o6beMoB f}>HHaHcHpoBaHHR (ITpHJIO)l(eHHe NQ 2 K ,lJ;oroBopy). ITo YCTHbIM n05ICHeH~M npczrcrasarenea 000 KCY «CH6He¢TenpOBO,l(CTPOH», 000 «OMcKHe¢Tera3CneI(CTpoH», OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH rrO,l(BO,l(HHK» CMeTbI He COCTaBJI~JIHCb, neaa ,lJ;oroBopOB 6:bIJIa onpezreneaa HM Cpa3Y rroztpanaok opraaasanaea JIH60 COCTaBJIeHH:bIe HMH cserasre pacnersr He npaaaxranacr, BO BHHMaHHe.

TaK, Me)l(,l(y 000 «U;YIT «BCTO» H 000 «CTPOHCHCTeMa» 3aKJIIO'leH KOHTpaKT NQ579- 07 OT 11.04.2007 no 06':beKTY «ITepB~ oxepezts TC BCTO, JIHHeHH~ nacrs, Y'laCTOK NQ 3, KM 1105 -1570», B KOTOP:bIH BKJIIO'leH:bI pafiorsr no 06':beKTY «ITITMH xepea p. HI05I KM 1493,07- KM 1495,3» CTOHMOCT:bIO 131,550 MJIH. py6JIeH C H,lJ;C. 000 «Crpoiicncreaa», B CBOIO osepezrs, na sees 06':beM pa60T no ITITMH p. HI05I 3aKJIIO'lHJIO KOHTpaKT C OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH nO,l(BO,l(HHK» NQ 07-BCTOIP-3 OT 17.08.2007r. CTOHMOCT:bIO 100 MJIH. py6JIeH C H,lJ;C, HeCMOTp5I aa TO, 'ITO OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH nO,l(Bo.n;HHK» HanpaBJI~JIO BODO «Crpoacacreaa» CMeTY sarpar na CyMMy 135,655 MJIH. py6JIeH C H,D;C. 000 «CTpOHcHcTeMa» orpepry OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH no.n;BO,l(HHK» npoaraopaponarro, HO ozraospeaenao npHMeHHJIO K Ka)K.l(OMY sazty pa60T K03f}>f}>HIJ,HeHT reHepaJ1LHOrO nOJJ;pRJJ;a 1,24. ITpe,l(JIO)KeHHe OAO «AK «TpaHCHe¢T:b» CHH3HT:b K03¢¢HI.J;HeHT sa ycnyrn rennoztpazta «no rrpaaaroro - He 60JIee 5%» He BocnpHH~TO. OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH nonsoztaax» 6:bIJIO B:bIHY)l(,l(eHO 3aKJIIO'lHTb 3aBe,l(OMO y6:bITO'lH:bIe .n;~ ceria .n;oroBOp:bI (c npHMeHeHHeM peansnoa 60JIee B:bICOKOH CTOHMOCTH pafior, 'leM 3TO onpezrenerro B zrorosope NQ 07-BCTOIP-3 OT 17.08.2007r.). TaK, pa60T:bI no KOTJIOBaHY .n;~ CJIHBa BO,l(:bI nOCJIe ranpoacnsrraaaa, KOTOp:bIe B:bIIIOJIH~JIHCb OAO «TpaHCCH6He¢Tb»no .n;OTOBOPY NQ 8487/2008 OT 02.02.2008 rozta, 6bIJIH pac-raraasr no COOTBeTCTBYIOII(HM <PEPaM na 1 xsapran 2008 rozra H COCTaBHJIH 1,015 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H,D;C, rorna KaKB KOHTpaKTe NQ 07-BCTOIP-3 Me)K,l(y 000 «Crpoticacreaa» H OAO «BOJI)l(CKHH no.n;BO,l(HHK» YKa3aHHbIe pa60TbI pacnenemr TOJI:bKO B 703 T:bIC. py6. 6e3 H,lJ;C.

I I

I] If

,

I

5) U;eH:bI na pa60T:bI, YKa3aHHbIe B Pacrrpenerreana KOHTpaKTHoH I(eH:bI H Tpadiaxe 06':beMOB ¢HHaHcHpoBaHH~ B ITpHJIO)l(eHHH NQ 2 K cytinoztpsnaoery noroaopy NQ 4-0282- BCTO/68/01-06 OT 03.05.2006 Me)l(,l(y 000 «Cesepnaa rpyrma» H 000 KCY «CH6He¢npoBo.n;cTPOH» COpa3MepHbI cyMMaM, nOJIY'laeMbIM na OCHOBe paCI(eHOK B ITC,lJ; B

7

uenax 2004 rozra 6e3 nepesozra HX B ~eH1I 2 KBapTaJIa 2006 rona (K03cpq)H~HeHT 1,34), a raxace 6e3 YTIeTa ztpyrnx Ha~eHOK H nOBhIIIIaIO~HX K03cJ.)<pH~HeHToB (npenennsre 3,[(aHH5I II coopyzcenaa, 311MHee Y,I(OpO)I(aHHe, nepefiasaposxa TeXHHKH, KOMaH,I(HpOBOTIHhle paCXO,I(.hI, cnerotiopsfia, rrepesosxa pa60TIHX II zrp), xoropsre B cosoxyrmocra COCTaBJI5IIOT OKOJIO 43 %. YTIHThIBa5I TO, TITO nee pa60ThI rro npezerery noroaopa BhIITOJIHeHhI 000 KCY «Catiacdmpoaoncrpoa», pasaauy B 43% OT CTOllMOCTH pa60T nonysnna reHrrO,I(p5I,I(Ha5I opraHH3a~H5I 000 «CTpoHcHCTeMa».

B cnyxae, eCJIH TaKa5I npaxraxa onpeneneaaa uensr CMP npHMeH5IJIaCh H no ,I(pyrHM reHrrO,I(pMH.hIM H cy6no,I(PMH.hIM ,I(OrOBOpaM, pasanna B OIIJIaTe no HllM MO)I(eT COCTaBJI5ITh ,I(eC5ITKH MHJIJIHap,I(oB py6JIeH.

6) ITo nexoropsrv 061>eKTaM KaKaJI-JIH60 rrornxa B npHMeHeHHH nen soofime OTCYTCTByeT, TITO npOCJIe)I(HBaeTC5I na rrpaaepe CTOHMOCTH pa60T no HH)I(eHepHOH 3a~HTe H cTpOHTeJI.hCTBY BepTOJIeTHOH nJIO~a,I(KH B ITC,Z:(, KOHKypCHOH 3a5IBKe, reHnO,I(p5I,I(HOM KOHTpaKTe, CMeTHhlX paCTIeTaX cy6nO,I(p5I,I(TIHKa, ztorosope C cy6nO,I(p5I,I(TIHKOM:

HH~eHepHaB samara (CTOHMOCTh B py6. 6e3 H.LI:Cl
TIC,n;, KOHKypcHaJi feHno.u.pJl.u.HbIH Caeraue pacseru Cy6no.u.pJl.u.HbIH
nonroroanenaas 3aJlBKa 000 KOHTpaKT N!! 579-07 OT OAO «BOJDKCKI1H KOHTpaKT N!! 07-
3AO «TIMPC» «CTPOHCI1CTeMa» 11.04.2007 no.u.Bo.u.HI1K» BCTOIP-30T
17.08.2007
349721 16997877 1 966768 1 529383 1 581 254
BepTOJIeTHaB nnomamea (CTOHMOCTh B py6. 6e3 H.LI:C_)
TIC,n;, KOHKYPcHaJi feHno.u.pJI.u.HhIH KOHTpaKT CMeTHhJe pacsersr Cy6no.u.PJl.u.HhIH
no.u.rOTOBJIeHHaJI 3aJlBKa 000 N!! 579-07 OT 11.04.2007 OAO «BOJDKCKI1H KOHTpaKT N!! 07-
3AO «TIMPC» «CTPOHCI1CTeMa» nO,LIBO,LIHI1K» BCTO/P-30T
17.08.2007
1 304 120 200655 196 5760723 2294281 4631 665 7) ITono3H~HOHHaJI CTOllMOCTh pa60T B reHIIO,I(pMHOM KOHTpaKTe N2 123-06oT 28.04.2006 II cy6no,I(PMHOM ,l(oroBope N2 4-0282-BCTO/68/1-06 OT 03.05.2006 OTJIHQaeTCB (YBeJIHQeHo) aa O.z.HO H TO ace 3HaQeHHe:

- no ysacrxy KM 140 - KM 238,75 na 49,75%;

- no yxacrxy KM 240,4 - KM 271,99 - na 49,82%.

ITon03H~HOHHa5I CTOllMOCT.h pa60T na ysacrxe KM 362,15 - KM 372 B remrozrpazraon KOHTpaKTe NQ 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 II cy6nO,I(p5I,I(HoM,Z:(oroBope N2 4-0283-BCTO/69/8-06 OT 03.05.2006 OTJIHTIaeTC5I (YBeJIHTIeHo) na O,I(HO H TO)I(e snaneaae - 85,19 %.

8) CTOHMOCT.h OT,I(eJIbH.hIX n03H~HH CMP B KOHTpaKTe NQ 123-06 OT 28.04.2006r. xparno npessnuaer CTOHMOCTh cooTBeTcTBYIO~HX pa60T B cy6rrO,I(pMHOM ,Z:(oroBope N203/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 Me)I(,I(y <PHJlliaJIOM MIT «beJICTpOHTpaHCra3» (nO,I(p5I,I(TIllK 000 «Crpoacacrena») II 000 «Oucxaedrrerascnencrpoa».

Tax, B COOTBeTCTBllH C nYHKTOM 1-1 IIpllJIo)I(eHll5I N2 2 K cycnonpszraoay noronopy, CTOllMOCT.h pa60T no paCTIllCTKe rpaccsr OT neca COCTaBJI5IeT 181,771 T.hIC. py6. 6e3 H,Z:(C aa O,I(HH rexrap, a B rr.l-l reHnO,I(p5I,I(HOrO ,I(OrOBOpa CTOllMOCTh YKa3aHHhIX pa60T COCTaBJI5IeT 879,791 ThIC.py6. 6e3 H,Z:(C aa O,I(HH rexrap (Ilpnnoaceaae NQ 2);

IIono3ll~HoHHa5I CTOHMOCTh pa60T B reHnO,I(p5I,I(HOM KOHrpaKTe N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 B cpenaesr na 162,76% npessnuaer non03ll~HOHHYIO CTOHMOCTh pa60T H cy6nO,I(p5I,I(HOM ,Z:(oroBope N2 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 (ITpHJIO)I(eHHe N2 2).

9) MMeIOT MeCTO 3Ha"IHTeJIhHhIe pacXO)K,lJ.eHHB Me)I(,I(y CTOHMOCThIO pa60T II MTP, npenycaorpemroa npoexrao-cxrernoil ,I(OKYMeHTa~lleH, II I.J;eHaMH, rro KOTOPhIM cpaKTllTIeCKH BhIITOJIH5IJIllCh pa60ThI II saxynanacs MTP.

TaK, nanpanep:

8

9

II I

- B KOHKypCHOM 3a5IBKe no JIOTY N2 BCTO\P-3 no 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I osepezn, Tpy6onpOBO.ll:HOM CI:ICTeMbI «BocTolJHa5I CI:I6I:IPb-TI:IXI:IM OKeaH». PaCllII:IpeHI:Ie TC BCTO. YlJaCTOK N2 3. (TaJIaKaHCKoe MeCTOpO)K.ll:eHI:Ie - r. A1I.ll:aH). J1I:IHeMI-Ia5I nacrs, KM 1105 - 1570.,I:( 1220 KM» 000 «CTPOMCI:ICTeMa» (KoHTpaKT N2579-07 OT 11.04.2007) npe.ll:JIo)KI:IJIO BbIITOJIHI:ITb pa60ThI Ha TITIMH p. HI-05I sa 2 527,499 MJ1H. py6. 6e3 H,I:(C, rorna KaJ( yraepzctemraa 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» paClJeTHa5I 6a30Ba5I CTOI:IMOCTb 3TI:IX pa60T COCTaBJI5IeT scero 194 MJ1H. py6. 6e3 H,L(C;

- B COOTBeTCTBI:II:I C paanenov 1 «Csieraoro pacsera N2 1-1-1 I:I3M.2 na py6KY rreca» CMeTHa5I CTOI:IMOCTb pa60T no pytixe neca na YlJaCTKe KM 0 - KM 130» no 06'beKTY «IIepBa5I osepezrs rpyoonposonaoa CI:ICTeMbI «BocTolJHa5I CI:I6I:IPb - THXI:IM OKeaH». J1HHeMHa5I xacrs. YlJaCTOK KM 0 - KM 130 (l1pKYTcKa5I 06JIaCTb)>> cocranana 553,776 TbIC. py6. 6e3 H,I:(C sa O.ll:I:IH rexrap. <PaKTI:IlJeCKH naanue pa60TbI 6bIJII:I BhIITOJIHeHbI 000 «Oncxaeqrreraacnencrpoit» no IIeHe 181,771 TbIC. py6. 6e3 H,I:(C sa O,[(I:IH rexrap (TIpI:IJIO)l(eHI:Ie N2 2);

- B TIC,I:( no 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I oaepezts Tpy6onpOBO.ll:HOM CI:ICTeMhI «BocTolJHa5I CH6I:IPhTHXI:IM OKeaH». J1HHeMHa5I nacrs. I1H)KeHepHa5I 3aIIII:ITa. YlJaCTOK KM 0 - KM 570» BKJII-OlJeHQ HeTKaHHoe reOTeKCTMJIhHoe nOJIOTHO MeraTeKc-TC300. Ha ,[(aHHOM YlJaCTKe YKa3aHHbIM MaTepI:IaJI BKJIlOlJeH B CMeThI B 06'beMe 60JIee 200 ThIC5IlJ KB. MeTpoB co CTOHMOCThI-O OT 505 .ll:O 850 py6JIeM sa xaanparasni MeTp. B TO )l(e BpeM5I saxyrnca HrTI Merarexc- TC300 npOI:I3BO.ll:HJIaCh B Mae 2006 rona 000 «OMcKHe<pTera3CneI(cTpOM» no nerre 36 py6. sa KB. MeTp, OAO «Kracrpytionponoztcrpoti» no 30,55 py6. sa KB. MeTp.

10) CTOI:IMOCTh pa60T no KOHTpaKTY N2 631-07 OT 11.07.2007 no 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I oxepezrs rpytionpoaonnca CI:ICTeMhI BCTO». CI:ICTeMa CB5I3I:I. YlJaCTKI:I KM 0 - KM 570, KM 570 - KM 2620» Me)K.n;y 000 «D:YTI «BCTO» I:I 000 «AM TII:I Cers CTI6», COCTaBJI5IBlla5I 10 012,711 MJIH. py6. 6e3 H,lJ;C, 3HalJI:ITeJIhHO npeasrmaer I(eHhI 3TI:IX pa60T a ztoroaopax C HOBhIMI:I no.n;pMlJI:IKaMI:I no 3TOMY 06'beKTY nOCJIe paCTOp)l(eHI:I5I KOHTpaKTa 000 «AM TII:I Cers CTI6». TIpI:I 3TOM nepBOHalJaJIhHa5I CMeTHa5I CTOI:IMOCTh CHcTeMhI TeXHOJIOrI:IlJeCKOM CB5I3I:I TC BCTO B nenax 2 KBapTaJIa 2007 rona, onpezreneaaaa OAO «BHI1I1CT» I:I YTBep)l(,lJ;eHHa5I 000 «D:YTI «BCTO» no YlJaCTKY KM 570 - KM 1105, COCTaBJI5IJIa TOJIhKO 1 965,473 MJ1H. py6. 6e3 H,I:(C.

Ha npaaepe norosopa noztpazta N2 999-08 OT 07.05.2008 Me)l(.ll:Y 000 «D:YII BCTO» I:I 3AO «MeXKOJIOHHa N2 159» no 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I o-repens Tpy6onpOBO.ll:HOM CI:ICTeMhI BCTO». CI:ICTeMa CB5I3I:I», KM 570 - KM 673» (CTOI:IMOCTh 149 475 ThIC. py6JIeM 6e3 H,I:(C) pa3HI:II(a B CTOHMOCTI:I BhIrJI5I.ll:I:IT CJIe.ll:YIDII(I:IM 06Pa30M:

I

,

.

It I

I

I

,

I

,

~

.

N2 HaI:IMeHOBaHHe KOHTpaKT 631- KOHTpaKT 999-08 A6coJII-OTHa5I BeJII:IlJI:IHa
n.n. BI:I.ll:OB pa60T 07 OT 11.07.2007 OT 07.05.2008 I:I3MeHeHI:I5I CTOHMOCTI:I
(py6. 6e3 H,I:(C)
YqaCTOK KM 570 - KM 673
1. Bhlpy6Ka neca 4 IIJIOma.ll.KI1 I IIJI 0 maaxa - I I 15 403
2. TIO.ll.rOTOBKa 4 IIJIOma.ll.KI1 2 IIJIOma.ll.KI1 - I 944750
IIJIOma.ll.KI1
3. CTOI1MOCTh Co CTaBmIeT Ilpenycacrpeaa - 65 837323
IIpl106peTeHI1Jl 11 I 13 787299 py6JIei1 IIOCTaBKa 3aKa311HKa -
)),0 CTaBKI1 35259258 py6.,
o6opy)),oBaHI1Jl 3aKYIIJIeHO
IIO)1.PJl)),lII1KOM -
12686718 Jly6.
4. Ilorrsesnnue CTOI1MOCTh sa e.ll..- CTOI1MOCTh 3a e)),. - - 39 791341
aBTO.ll.OpOrJ1 20 055 922 py6. 3441 583 py6.
5. Ilycxoaananosuue CTOI1MOCTh sa e.ll.. ~ CTOI1MOCTh 3a e,ll,. - - 4 427886
pa60Thl 34389 192 py6. 10388349 py6.
6. PeMoHT H CTOHMOCTh sa He rtpenycaorpeao - 31 680662
conepzcanae e,ll,I1HHllY - 866 776 PeMoHT 11 conepxaane 36,55 KM
nozrsesnaax nopor py6JIei1 ,lI,opor
Hroro: 144 797 365 py6J1eii. q

TaKHM 06Pa30M, H3MemJJI COCTaB pa60T, CTOllMOCTb o6opy,n;OBaHH5I nOCTaBKH nozipazrraxa, pacuenxa na orzrensnsre BH,n;bI pa60T, 000 «U;YTI BCTO» YMeHbIIIHJIO aa 97% nepBOHa1:laJIbHy.IO CTOHMOCTb pa60T no YLIaCTKY KM 570 - KM 673 rro KOHTpaKTY C OAO «AM TIH Cerr, CTI6», cOBrra,n;aBIIIYIO C 6a30BOM CTOHMOCTblO JIOTa.

I

·

i

TIo 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I onepem, rpytionpononaoa CHCTeMbI BCTO». Cncrena CB5I3H», KM 789 - KM 1105» 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» 3aKJII01:leHbI KOHTpaKTbI C 000 «AM TIH Cers», 000 «TIHPC» (r. Caaapa) H OAO «YpaJIbCKa5I 3HepreTH1:leCKa5I cTpOHTeJIbHa5I KOMnaHH5I» (r.Exarepaafiypr) (ztanee - OAO «Y3CK»), CTOHMOCTb pa60T no KOTOPbIM KaK B u;eJIOM, TaK II norr03ll:O;HOHHO 3Ha1:lHTeJIbHO OTJIH1:laeTC5I.

TaK, CTOHMOCTb rro KOHTpaKTY N2 999-08 OT 29.04.2008 Me)l()J;y 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» H 000 «TIHPC» (YLIaCTOK KM 789 .,... KM 1105) COCTaBJUICT 700 MJlH. py6. C H,[(C, a no KOHTpaKTaM N2 1105-08 OT 11.07.2008 (YLIaCTOK KM 789 - KM 946) H N2 1131-08 OT 22.07.2008 (YLIaCTOK KM 946 - KM 1105) C OAO «YpaJIbCKa5I eaeprerasecsas cTpoHTeJIbHa5I KOMnaHH5I» npa H,n;eHTll1:lHOM COCTaBe pa60THa YLIacTKe KM 789 - KM 1105 COCTaBJI5IeT cYMMapHo no-rm 750 MJlH. py6. C H)1,C.

CTOllMOCTb pa60T no cTpollTeJIbCTBY nozrsesmrsrx ztopor aa YLIacTKe KM 570 - KM 1105 Y pa3HbIX rronpszrraxos cym:eCTBeHHO OTJIH1:laeTC5I. TaK, y OAO «YpaJIbCKa5I aaeprenrsecxaa cTpoHTeJIbHa5I KOMnaHll5I» nena 1 KM nozrsesnasrx nopor COCTaBJI5IeT OT 13,7 LJ,O 15,2 MJlH. py6. 6e3 H~C, y 3AO «MeXKOJIOHHa N2 159» OHa COCTaBJI5IeT 3,442 MJlH. py6. 6e3 H,[(C, y 3AO <<K3C-3HeprOCTpOMllH)KllHllpllHr» (KoHTpaKTY N2 1001-08 OT 29.04.2008 no 06'beKTY «TIepBa5I o-repezrs rpyoonposonaon CllCTeMbI BCTO». Cacrexa CB5I3ll», KM 673 - KM 789») - JIllIIIb 1,278 MJlH. py6. 6e3 H~C. TIPH 3TOM CTOllMOCTb YKa3aHHbIX pa60T B KOHTpaKTe C 000 «AM TIll Cers CTI6» COCTaBJI5IJIa 20,056 MJlH. py6. sa 1 KM 6e3 H,[(C.

I

·

·

B KOHTpaKT C OAO «Y3CK» BKJII01:leHbI sarparsr, OTCYTcTBoBaBIIIlle B KOHTpaKTe C 000 «AM TIll Cers CTI6»: no rrpaexxe MTP, apeazre II otiopynosaaaro ryrraxos, npa-ranos, norpysxe, pasrpysxe, cxnaztaposaamo, ,n;OCTaBKe K MecTY npcaasoncrsa pa60T CTOllMOCTblO 24,582 MJlH. py6. 6e3 H~C, rorna KaK B aHaJIOrll1:lHbIX no npemrery pa60T KOHTpaKTax 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» C 3AO «MeXKOJIOHHa N2 159» H 3AO <<K3C-3HeprocTpOMHH)KllHllpllHr» TaKlle sarparsr He YLITeHbI.

TOJIbKO CTOHMOCTb CTpOllTeJIbCTBa nozrsearrasrx asrozropor, ax peMOHTa II conepzcaaaa no YCJIOBH5IM KOHTpaKTa C 000 «AM TIll Cers CTI6» (YLIaCTOK KM 570 - KM 1105) 3aBblIIIeHa B cpasaeaaa C nenoa B KOHTpaKTax C 3AO «MeXKOJIOHHa N2 159» (YLIacTOK KM 570 - KM 673), 3AO «K3C-3HeprocTpOMllH)KHHllpllHr» (YLIacTOK KM 673 - KM 789), OAO «YPaJIbCKM 3HepreTH1:leCKa5I CTpOHTeJIbHa5I KOMnaHH5I» (Y1:laCTOK KM 789 - KM 1105) aa CyMMy 60Jlcc 240 MJlH. py6. C H,[(C.

I-

I II

I

pa60T, pa60T

3. 06 HMCBmHX MCCTO napymermax IIpH BbIITOJlHCHHH IIOLJ,PSlLJ,HblX

l}laJlbCHrllHKa~HSlx OTQCTHblX LJ,OKYMCHTOB, 3aBblmCHHH CTOHMOCTH

(IIpUJlOJlCeHuJ( K2 3, 4, 5)

B xone CTpOIfTeJIbCTBa 06'beKTOB TC BCTO llMeJIll MeCTO neezranasnsre <paKTbI <PaJIbcH<pllKa:O;HllllCnOJIHllTeJIbHOM ,n;OKYMeHTaI(Hll, I1CnOJIb30BaHll5I no,n:JIO)KHbIX ,n:OKYMeHTOB.

TaK, npa cTpoHTeJIbCTBe nozraoztaoro nepexozia MH lJepe3 p. Tonopox (ofisexr «I1epBa5I oaepens rpytiorrpoaonaoa CHCTeMbI «BocTo1:lHa5I CH6llPb - TllXHM OKeaH». JIHHeMHa5I 1:laCTb. YlJaCTOK KM 0 - KM 570, D 1067 MM») Y reHIIO,n:p5I,n;HOM opraaasanaa 000 «Crpoiicacrexra» npaaarsr B ztexaope 2006 rozra H OnJIa1:leHbI B cyMMe 17,1 MJIH. py6. pa60TbI no BbIB03Y II YTllJIH3a:O;HH 6eHTOHHTOBoro pacraopa (4-M KJIaCC onacnocra) B 06'beMe 6 410 M3. <PaKTH1:leCKH 6YPOBOM paCTBOp He BbIB03llJIC5I, 6bIJI rrepexreuraa C rpYHTOM B MeCTe CKJIa,n:HpOBaHll5I. Cyfinonpsznraa opraaasanas 000 «CTPOM KOHTHHeHT» Cr. Msrrmna MOCKOBCKOM 06JI.) npezrcraaana B COCTaBe HCnOJIHHTeJIbHOM ,n;OKYMeHTaI(HI-I aKTbI OCBH,n:eTeJIbCTBOBaHH5I CKpbITbIX

II I

10

40

11

I I

pa6OT, B KOTOPBIX 6bIJIH c!jJaJIhc:miHfIlJ'IpOBaHI:>I nO.zl)IHCH H ne-rara npencrasnrena aBTOpCKOrO nansopa pa60TI-IHKa OAO «Fnnporpytionposon».

AHaJIOmqHa5I cHTyaI(H5I HMeJIa MeCTO npn CTpOHTeJIhCTBe nO,n:BO,n:HOrO nepexozta MH qepe3 p. Y,n:a (06beKTa «TIepBa5I ouepezts Tpy6onpOBO,n:HOH CHCTeMhI «BOCTOqHa5I CH6HPh - THxHH OKeaH». JIHHeHHa5I qaCTh. YqaCTOKKM 0 - KM 570, D 1067 MM». TIpHH5IThIe B H05I6pe . 2006 rona y rennonpaznroii opraHH3aI(HH 000 «CTPOH:CHCTeMa» H onnaueaasre B cyMMe 20,4 MJIH. py6. pa60ThI no BhIB03Y H YTHJIH3aI.J;HH B YCTaHOBJIeHHOM MeCTe 6eHToHHToBoro pacrsopa (4-H: KJIaCC onacnocrn) B o6beMe 13 792 M3 !jJaKTHqeCKH He 6bIJIH BhIIIOJIHeHhI. TIO,n:P5I,n:qHK B COCTaBe HCnOJIHHTeJIhHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaI(HH npe,n:CTaBHJI c!jJarrhCH!jJHI.J;HpOBaHHhle aKThI OCBH,n:eTeJIhCTBOBaHH5I CKphIThIX pa60T. B ,n:eH:CTBHTeJIhHOCTH, 6eHTOHHTOBhIH paCTBOp 6hIJI BhIBe3eH cytirrozrpannon opraunsanaca 000 «CeBepHa5I rpynna» B HeYCTaHOBJIeHHOe MeCTO.

TIo YKa3aHHOMY !jJaKTY CJIe,n:CTBeHHhIM OT,n:eJIOM Yet>CB no I1PKYTCKOH 06JIaCTH 17.10.2007 B036Y:>K,n:eHo yrOJIOBHOe ,n:eJIO no q. 4 CT. 159 YK Pet> (MorrreHHHqeCTBo).

B HIOHe 2007 rona rennoztpszmas opraHH3aI(H5I 3AK 00 «Avepxo Harcpncmenen JIHMHTe,n:» nepenana npe,n:cTaBHTeJI5IM TeXHHqeCKOrO naztsopa (000 «,n:HaH3Kc») B COCTaBe HCnOJIHHTeJIhHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaI(HH !jJHKTHBHhIH zrorosop Me)J(,n:y 3AK 00 «Axrepxo Harepaemenen JIHMMTe,n:» H I'ocyztapcrsenasna 06pa30BaTeJIbHbIM yqpe)J(,n:eHHeM asrcmero npotpeccaoaansaoro C6pa3CBaHH5I TexHHqecKHM HHCTHTYTOM 5:IKYTcKcro rocynapcraeanoro YHHBepcHTeTa HMemI M.K.AMMcccBa (HcnhITaTeJIhHa5I JIa60paTCpH5I «HepIOHrpHcTPCH:») aa nafioparoptroe HCCJIe,n:CBaHHe npoexrnsrx xapaxrepacrnx rpyHTa B CCHCBaHHH !jJYH,n:aMeHTcB na 06'beKTe «CrpcHTeJIhCTBO HTIC NQ 17» B r. AJI.n;aH. B ,n:eH:CTBHTeJIbHCCTH, norosop co CTOPCHhI «HepIOHrpHCTpCH» He nc,n:rrHChIBarrC5I,rrpCTOKCJIhI JIa60paTcpHbIX HCrrbITaHHH: npoexrasrx xapaKTepHCTHK rpynra na 6JIaHKaX «HepIOHrpHCTpCH» ObIJIH c!jJarrbcmpHI.J;HpOBaHbI, PYKCBC,n:CTBOM «Hepronrpaerpoti» HH ozrnoro natioparopaoro rrpCTOKCJIa He asrzrananocr., He rrozmacsrsanocs, nexara aa HHX He CTaBHJIHCb. B aezrymenca na C6'beKTe «)l{YPHarre KOHTPCJI5I rrJICTHOCTH H BJIa)!(HOCTH rpynra» rrpHMeH5IJIHCb rrecymecrayromae B HaYKe K03!jJ!jJHI.J;HeHTbI. Ha CCHCBaHHH c!jJarrhCH!jJHI.J;HpCBaHHbIX 3aKJIIOqeHHH O!jJCPMJI5IJIHCb aKThI CCBH,n:eTeJIbCTBOBaHH5I CKpbITbIX pa60T.

B aBrYCTe 2008 rona BbI5IBJIeH !jJaKT nepeziaxa 3aKa3qHKY reanoztpxzraoa cpraHH3aI.J;HeH: 000 «CHcTeMaCneI.J;CrpoH:» B COCTaBe HCnCJIHHTeJIbHOH: ,n:cKYMeHTaI(HH rro,n:JIC)J(HbIX aKTCB CCBH,n:eTeJIbCTBOBaHH5I CKpbIThIX pa60T NQ 18 H NQ 19 CT 26.05.2008 0. BbIIICJIHeHHH pafior no YCTP0H:CTBY 6aHKeTa C yxpyrmeaaev OTKCCCB na IlK 183+83 - IlK 184+00, IlK 153+07 - IlK 154+42,8 npa CTpOIITeJIbCTBe nonsozraoro rrepexozia MH qepe3 p. Aarapa (299 KM TC BCTO) na CYMMy 962 TbIC. py6. Yxaaaaasre B axrax OTBeTCTBeHHble pa60THHKH 000 «IJ;YTI BCTO» 3a5IBHJIH, qTO npencranneaasre aKTbI He nozmacsrsana.

B aBrYCTe 2008 rona B pe3YJIbTaTe BHYTPHTPy6HCH: ,n;HamOCTHKH c6HapY)J(eHhI MHCrCqHCJIeHHhle ,n:e!jJeKThl na nocrpoemrca aerprenpoaone: na ysacrxe KM 1024,5 - KM 1089- 196 ,n:e!jJeKToB (reaepanr.asnl rronpszrsmc - 000 «CHcTeMaCrreI.J;CTpOH», cytinozrpazraaxa ~ 000 «PbI)!(KOB H K» H 000 «BOCTOKCTPCH»); na ysacrxe KM 2205 - KM 2221 - 58 ,n:e!jJeKTcB (rennoztpsrrrax - Kpacrrozrapcrpoarpaacras», cytinoztpanxa« - KHTaH:CKa5I KOMrraHH5I «CPP»). Bee ,n:e!jJeKThI no TeJIY rpyfin rnna «BM5ITHHa» HMeIOT yrnosoe rrOJIO)J(eHHe .CKCJIC 180 rpanycos, QTO CBH,n:eTeJIbCTByeT 0 aapymenasx npn YCTpcHcTBe rro,n;CbIIIKH H3 M5IrKOrO rpyrrra H npa YKJIa,n:Ke rpytisr B rpaamero. Yxaaamnre 06CT05ITeJIbCTBa YKa3hIBaIOT na MaCCOBble !jJaJIbcH!jJHKaI(HH aKTOB CCBH,n:eTeJIhCTBOBaHH5I CKpbIThIX pafior H aKTCB KC-2, na OCHOBaHHH KOTCPbIX rrpoaasezreaa OnJIaTa pafior rro YKJIa,n:Ke nedrrenponona.

OAO «Bepxaenonarcxnedrrenpoaon» npa nposepxe 06ccHoBaHHccTH Kpe,n:HTcpCKCH: 3a,n:CJI)!(eHHOCTH y ztoxepnero ofiutecrsa 000 «BOJIraHe!jJTera3CrreI.J;CTpoH» BbI5IBJIeHbI !jJaKTbI 3aKJIIOQeHH5I B !jJeBparre H MapTe 2008 rona 6bIBrrrHM ,n:HpeKTopOM 000 «Bcnraaedrrerascrrencrpoa» ,n:Byx ,n;orrOJIHHTeJIbHbIX cornanreana K ,n:orcBopy C 000 «He!jJTera3CTpOHMOHTa)J(» (r. OMCK) na BhIIIOJIHeHHe «,n;orrOJIHHTeJIbHbIX» pa60T no CTpOHTeJIhCTBY ztopora ,n;. Hsepa - Tpacca 942 KM o6meH: CTOHMOCTbIO 12,5 MJIH. py6. COrJIaCHO

I ;

.

11 I

I I

12

I Ii!

I

·

·

nozmacaaaua aKTaM pa60T.1I B1IIIOJIHeHI:,I 000 «HecpTera3CTpOHMOHTa:>K» II rrO,L(JIe)I(aT OIIJIaTe B rrOJIHOM 061>eMe. B ,L(eHCTBllTeJI1HOCTll, BCe YKa3aHH1Ie pa60T11 61IJIll rrOJIHOCT11O CaMOCT05ITeJI1HO BWIOJIHeH11 000 «Bonraaedrrerascnencrpoa» II rrpllH5IT11 no aKTaM B ztexafipe 2007 rona. TIo ,L(aHHoMY cpaICTY nanpasneno 3a5IBJIeHlle B rrpasooxpaaarem.asre opraasr,

B 2007 - 2008 r.r. 000 «Bonranedrrerascrrencrpoa: 3aKJIlOlIllJIO co CBOHMll cy6rrO,L(p5I,L(H1IMll opraaasanaaaa 7 ,L(OrOBOpoB na B1IIIOJIHeHlle pa60T no pacsacrxe rpaccu OT neca, B:bIB03 JIeCa,ycTpOHCTBY JIe)I{HeB.1IX zropor na cTpOllTeJI:bCTBe 061>eICTOB TC BCTO. Ilposepxoii, nposeneaaoa OAO «BepxHeBOJI)I(CICHecpTenpOBO,L(», YCTaHOBJIeHO, lITO YICa3aHHble pa60T11 nOJIHOCT11O ana lIaCTlllIHO B1IIIOJIHeH11 C06CTBeHHlIMll CllJIaMHOOO «BHrCC», CTOllMOCT1 pa60T no )J;BYM ,L(OrOBOpaM cymecrseaao npessnnaer CTOllMOCTb COOTBeTCTBYlOru:llX pa60T B ztoroaopax Me)I()J;Y 000 «Bonranerpreraacrrencrpoii» H nO,L(p5I,L(Hoii opraaaaauaea 3AO «Crpoiicacreaa» (cy6rrO)J;p5I,L(lIllK 000 «Crpoiicacreraa»): no ,L(OrOBOpy N2 440-1O-07 OT 01.12.2007 C 000 «K030PllC H K» na 2,2 MflH. py6., no ztorosopy N2 06103/2008 OT 06.03.2008 C 000 «Anrapa Jlec» - na 12 MflH. py6.

B arrpene 2008 rona B pe3YJI:bTaTe B116opOlIHOii rrposepxa II5ITll 06':beICTOB cTpOllTeJI1CTBa TC BCTO 000 «Tpaacaedrrs <PHHaHc» YCTaHOBJIeH11 cpaKT:bI ueofiocnonanaoro 3aBbIweHlUI CTOHMOCTH na 187,1635 MJIH. py6. (TIpHJIO)I(eHHe N2 __), B TOM lIHCJIe:

- He B1IIIOflHeHH1Ie TIO)J;P5I,L(':IllICOM pa60T:bI no pe3YJI1TaTaM ICOHTPOJIbH:bIX o6MepoB 63,562 MJIH. py6.;

- pa60T1I, He nO)J;TBep)I(,L(eHH1Ie llCnOJIHllTeJI1HOH ,L(OICYMeHTa~Heii - 48,616 MJIH. py6.;

-Heo6ocHoBaHHoe 3aB1IlIIeHlle CTOllMOCTll pa60T no pe3YJIbTaTaM nponepxa CMeT,

paC':IeTOB II ICoHTpaKTa - 74,985 MflH. py6.

i I

E

.

·

I

·

4. AHaJIH3 noroaopon B qaCTH 06ocHoBaHHocTH BbIllJIaT H 3aKphITHH asaacon, C yqeTOM rpadmrca BbIllOJIHeHHbIX pa60T (Ilpunoucenue M 6)

B pesynsrare aaanas ,L(OrOBOpOB na CMP B lIaCTll 06ocHoBaHHocTH B1IIIflaT H 3aKp:bITll5I aBaHCOB C yseros, rpadnnca B1IIIOJIHeHHblX pa60T YCTaHOBfleHO, lITO no COCT05IHlllO na 01.07.2008 C nensro peanasanaa npoexra Tpyfionponorraaa cacreua «BOCTO~IHa5I CH6HP:b - Taxaa OICeaH»» 000 «l(YTI BCTO» B o6ru:eii CJIO)I(HOCTH 61IJIO 3aICJIlO':IeHO 37 ICOHTpaKTOB na B:bIIIOJIHeHlle CMP aa o6ru:YIO cyMMy 173 528,958MJIH. py6., H3 HHX 32 ICOHTpaICTa aa CyMMy 137 502,023 MflH. py6. ,neiiCTBYIOT B nacroanraa MOMeHT, a 5 ICoHrpaICToB na CyMMy 36 026,935 MJIH. py6. 61IJIll pacroprayrsr.

<PaKToB neofiocaosaaaoa BbI,na':Ill aBaHCOB HeB115IBJIeHO. ABaHc11 6bIJIllB1I,L(aH:bI B COOTBeTCTBHll C KOHTpaKTHbIMll rpacpllICaMH CPllHaHCllpOBaHll5I (TIpllJIO)I(eHHe N22 K KOHTpaICTaM «Pacnpenenenae KOHTpaKTHoii u:eH11 H rpacpllIC 06':beMOB cpllHaHcHpOBaHll5I»). TaIC no COCT05IHHlO na 01.07.2008 B:bIIIflalIeHO aBaHCOB na CyMMy 40826,746 MJIH. py6., H3 nax CYMMa aBaHCOB, OCBoeHH1IX no,npMH1IMll opraaasanasxra COCTaBJI5IeT 20 519,917 MJIH. py6. (llJIH 50% OT o6ru:eH CYMMbI BbI,naHH1IX aaaacos). ,Ue6llTOpCKa5I 3a,L(OJI)I(eHHOCTb nO,L(p5I,L(lIllKOB no' B.1I,L(aHHbIM aaancasr COCTaBJI5IeT 20 306,828 MJIH. py6.

CTpYKTypa ,ne6llTopcKOH 3a,L(OJI)I(eHHOCTll no BbI,L(aHHbIM asaacaa na 01.07.2008 B:blrJI5I,L(llT cneztyromax 06Pa30M:

i

I-

I

11 II

NQ HallMeHOBaHHe 06beKTa CYMMa, CTpYKTYpa
cTpOHTeJIhCTBainO,lJ,p5I,lJ,'IllKa B MJIH. py6. 3a,lJ,OJI)KeHHOCTll %
BCErO: 20306,8 100
1. ITo pacropruyrsnr KOHD!aKTaM, B 'r.n.: 9448,70 46,53
- 3AO "Kpacuooapcmpoiimpanceas" 5 904,20 29,08
- 000 ''ALI Ilu Cems CIl6" 3 544,5 17,45
2. Cne~MopHeq)TenO_l!_T "K03hMHHO", B T.q.: 4713,40 23,2
- 000 "Kopnopauus HHJK:mpaHCCmpou" 2 265,00 1 1,15
- 3AO "Tpecm KOKCoxUMMOHmaJK:" 2448,40 12,05 13

3. A,1l;3C .o;ml HIIC Xl! 14, B 'r.x.: 1660 8,17
- 000 "Cucmescailneutlmpoii'' 1660 8,17
4. HIIC .NHO C pesepayapmaa napxon 908,4 4,47
- 000 "Bocmox Cmpou" 908,4 4,47
5. JIuHeHHaH 'faeTh, Y'faCTOK Xl!3 (TaJIaKaHCKoe 810,60
MeCTOpo)KtJ:eHHe - r, AJI.o;aH) KM 1105 - KM 1570, B 'r.x.: 4
- 000 "Cucmeuatlneuilmpoii'' 810,60 4
6. U npyrae 12 oObeKToB CTpOHTeJIhCTBa TC BCTO 2765,70 13,63 B 2008 r. OCHOBHhIM np06JIeMHhIM BonpOCOM B IIaCTlI 3aKphITH5I aBaHCOBhIX CYMM 5IBJI5IJIOCh ynepxaane aBaHCOB, BhIl1JIaIIeHHhlX B paxncax KOHTpaKToB na BhIl10JIHeHHe eMP Me)K,[(Y 000 «l(YII BCTO H 3AO «Kpacrrczrapcrpompaacras» (N2 568-07 OT 20.04.2007 06'beKT - YIIacToK N2 3. Tanaxancxoe MecTopmK,[(eHHe - r, AJI,[(aH. JIHHeHHa5I IIaCTb, KM 1570 - KM 2202; N~. 601-07 OT 28.06.2007. 06'beKT - CTpOHTeJIhCTBO RITC N2 8; N2 584-07 OT 15.06.2007. 06'beKT: CTpOHTeJIhCTBO RIIC«CKOBOPO'[(HHO», BKJIIOIIa5I 06'beKTbI naemaero 3JIeKTpOCHa6)KeHH5I, N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007. 06'beKT: ITepBa5I oxepezn, rpytionpoaozmok CHCTeMhI «BocTOIIHaH CH6Hph-THxllH OKeaH. CTpOHTeJIhCTBO HITC N2 14»). <PaKTHIIecKoe BhIl10JIHeHHe CMP no BhlIIIeYKa3aHHhIM KOHTpaKTaM COCTaBHJIO 1 356,3 MJIH. py6., scero nepeIIHCJIeHO aBaHcOB na CyMMy 7 260,5 MJIH. py6., TaKHM 06Pa30M, ,[(e6HTOpCKa5I 3a,[(OJI)KeHHOCTh COCTaBJI5IeT 5 904,20 MJIH. py6.

B pauxax nponezrypu paCTOp)KeHH5I KOHrpaKTa N2 602-07 OT 29.06.2007 rrozmacano COrJIameHHe no yperYJIHpOBaHHIO pa3HOrJIaCHH, a no KOHTpaKTaM N2 568-07 OT 20.04.2007, N2 601-07 OT 28.06.2007, N2 584-07 OT 15.06.2007 C 3AO «Kpacaonapcrpoarpaacras» sonpoc 3aKphITH5I aBaHCOB yperYJIHpOBaH, nozmacaaaeu H YTBep)K,[(eHHeM Ap6Hrpa)KHbIM CY,[(OM MpKYTCKOH o6JIacTH MHPOBhIX corrrameaaii no HCKaM 000 «l(YII BCTO» K 3AO «Kpacaoztapcrpoarpaacraa»; npenycaarpasaromax norameaae CJIO)KHBIIIeHC5I 3a,[(OJI)KeHHOCTH 3AO «KCTr» B COOTBeTCTBllll C YTBep)!(,[(eHHhIM rpacpllKoM OnJIaThI.

IIpo6JIeMHhIM aonpocoxr B IIaCTll 06ocHoBaHHocTH 3aKpbITll5I aBaHCOB OCTaeTC5I OnJIaTa B paaxepe - 3 544, 5 MJIH. py6, B pasncax KOHrpaKTa N2 631-07 OT 11.07.2007 Me)K,[(y 000 «l(YII BCTO» H 000 «AH TIll Cers CIT6» HaBhIl10JIHeHHe CMP «rrozt KJIIOII» no 06'beKTaM CB5I3H TC BCTO. <PaKTllIIecKoe BhIl10JIHeHHe CMP no KOHrpaKTY OTCYTCTByeT. B HaCT05IIu;ee BpeM5I KOHTpaKT, B CB5I3H C aeacnonaeaaexr 000 «AH Ila Cers CIT6» KOHTPaKTHhIX 065I3aTeJI.hCTB, B O,[(HOCTopoHHeM nOp5I,[(Ke pacroprayr, 000 «l(YII BCTO» Be,[(eTC5I npeTeH3HoHHO - llCKOBa5I pafiora no B03BpaTY aBaHca .

~

,

j

.

,

5. Jlponepxa COOTBeTCTBHH l}>aKTHqeCKOrO KOJIHqeCTBa HCIIOJIh30BaHHblX MTP K 06'heMY l}>aKTHqeCKH BhIlIOJIHeHHhlX pa60T (Ilpunoucenue M! 7)

AHaJIll3 nepsasnoa YIIeTHoH ,[(oKYMeHTaU;HH no BOBJIeIIeHllIO MaTepHaJIhHO-

TeXHHIIeCKHX pecypcos rrOCTaBKH 3aKa3IIHKa (IIplIJIO)KeHHeN2 10K KOHTpaKTY) II npaexrxe BhIIIOJIHeHHhIX cTpOllTeJIhHO-MOHTa)KHhIX pa60T (KC-6a H KC-2) B xozre cTpOHTeJIhCTBa 06'beKTOB TC BCTO npanenea B ITpHJIO)KeHHll N2 _.

B pe3YJIhTaTe BhI6opOIIHOH nposepxn 06'beKTOB crpoarenscrna TC BCTO, uposeneaaoa B anpene 2008 rona 000 «Tpaacaedrrs <PllHaHC» BhI5IBJIeH P5I,[( HapYIIIeHHH, CB5I3aHHhlX C cy:meCTBeHHhIM HeCOOTBeTCTBIreM cnacaaaoro KOJIllIIeCTBa ofiopyzronamra II MaTepllaJIOB COrJIaCHO Be.n;OMOCT5IM rrepepatiorxa ,[(aBaJIhIIeCKllX MaTepHaJIOB H Peecrpaxr CMOHTHpoBaHHoro ofiopyztosaana 06'beMaM BhIIIOJIHeHHhlX pa60T COrJIaCHO )KypHaJIaM ysera BhIIIOJIHeHHhIX pa60T (cpopMa KC-6A) H aKTaM BhIl10JIHeHHhIX pa60T ccpopMa KC-2), B TOM IIllCJIe:

- CTOllMOCTh YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO 060pY,[(OBaHll5I H nepepaticrannsrx MaTepHaJIOB, He nO'[(TBep)!(,[(eHHhIX 06'beMaMH BhIl10JIHeHHhIX pa60T, COCTaBJI5IeT 170 267,4 ThIC. pytinef (6e3 H,lJ;C), H3 aax: CTOHMOCTh ofiopynonaaaa - 137 267, 4 ThIC. py6JIeH (6e3 H,lJ;C), CTOHMOCTh MaTepHaJIOB - 32 980 ThIC. py6JIeH (6e3 H,lJ;C);

- CTOHMOCTb pa60T, OTpa)J(eHHbIX B KC-6A, npa KOTOPblX cpaKTHlIeCKH nepepafioransi MaTepHaJIbl H 060pY,[(OBaHHe, HO He cnacaasr cornacno PCO H BTI~B, COCTaBJUIeT 20 623,3 rsrc. py6JIeH (6e3 H~C).

TIo aKTaM BbIIIOJIHeHHblX pa60T KC-2 rrpHH5IT 60JIbIIIHH 06'beM pa60T rro rrpoxnaaxe TeXHOJIOrHtIeCKOrO rpytiorrpoaona na rHTIC «TaHIIIeT», tIeM cpaKTHtIeCKH HCrrOJIb30BaHO MaTepHaJIOB rro Be,l(OMOCT5IM nepepatiorxn ,l(aBaJIbtIeCKHX MaTepHaJIOB MHHHMyM na 1582,2 MeTpa HJIH na CyMMy 10 054,3 TbIC. py6JIeH (6e3 H~C).

OCHoBHble rrpHtIHHbI B03HHKHOBeHIDI BblIIIeyr<a3aHHbIX cpaKToB:

- HeKatIeCTBeHHO pa3pa60TaHHa5I rrpoeKTHo-CMeTHa5I ,l(OKYMeHTaU;H5I, rrOBJIeKIIIa5I sa C060H 60JIbIIIOe KOJIHlleCTBO KoppeKTHpoBOK 'rpefiyroutax rrOCT05IHHOH aKTyaJIH3aU;HH Tpadnrxou pacnpeneneaas KOHTpaKTHoH nem; (TIpHJIo)J(eHHe N2 2 K KOHTpaKTY) H Fparpnxoa rrOCTaBOK MaTepHaJIOB H 060PY,l(OBaHH5I» (TIpHJIo)J(eHHe N2 10K KOHTpaKTY).

- Hecaoeapeveanoe co CTOPOHbl 000 «II;YTI BCTO» npanezreaae B COOTBeTCTBHe OTKoppeKTHpOBaHHOH TIC~, KOHTpaKToB na BbIIIOJIHeHHe CMP.

- CJIa6bIH KOHTPOJIb co CTOPOHbl 000 «II;YTI BCTO» sa cpaKTHtIeCKHM cnacaaaev MaTepHaJIOB H YCTaHOBKoH 060PY,l(OBaHH5I OTHOCHTeJIbHO 06'beMOB BbIIIOJIHeHHbIX pa60T, npa KOTOPbIX 6bIJIH rrOTpe6JIeHbI (Jm60 HerrOTpe6JIeHbI) MaTepHaJIbI H o60pY,l(OBaHHe.

6. Ilponepxa 06'beMOB BhIpy6KH neca, onpHXO~OBaHHSI H BOBJIeqeHHSI B

CTpOHTeJIbCTBO ~peBeCHHbI nOCJIe paCqHCTKH TpaCCbI (IIpUJloJICeHue.NQ 8)

Ha OCHOBaHHH peIIIeHHH opraHoB rocY,l(apcTBeHHoH BJIaCTH cy6'beKTOB POCCHHCKOH <De,l(epal(HH (I1PKyrcKOH 06JI., AMypCKOH 06JI., Pecrry6JIHKH Caxa (5IKYTH5I», 000 "Bocroxrrerprenponon" B nopaznce, rrpcztycaorpeaaozs CTaTbeH 45 Jlecaoro KO,l(eKCa P<D (zranee - JIK P<D), npenocraaneasr B apeH,l(Y,l(JI5I crpoarem.craa 06'beKTOB TC BCTO necasre YtIacTKH B npenenax 3eMeJIb JIeCHOrO cpoH,l(a.

I1crrOJIb30BaHI:le JIeCHbIX YtIacTKoB 000 "Bocroxaerprenposon" (Apeanaropoa) ocyru;ecTBJI5IeTC5I na OCHOBaHHH 3aKJIIOtIeHHbIXH saperacrpapoaaaasrx B YCTaHOBJIeHHOM nopanxe zroronopos KpaTKOCpOtIHOH (aa nepaozt cTpOHTeJIbCTBa) H ,l(oJIrOCpOtIHOH (na nepaozt 3KCrrJIyaTal(HH) apeamr.

JIecOrrOJIb30BaHHe co CTOPOHbI Apeazraropa ocyru;eCTBJI5IeTC5I na OCHOBaHHH BbI,l(aHHbIX B 2006 - 2008 roztax JIecopy60tIHbIX 6HJIeToB.

TIpH crpoarenscrse TC BCTO rrOJIYtIeHo JIecopy60tIHbIX 6HJIeTOB na 2 246 360 Ky6.M. zrpcsecaasr: ,l(eJIOBOH - 1 451 211 Ky6.M., ,l(POB5IHOH - 696 807 Ky6.M., xnopocra - 98 342 Ky6.M.

000 «Bocroxaerprenponozt» npoaasezreaa onnara JIeCHbIX nozarea B qaCTH MHHHMaJIbHbIX CTaBOK H B qaCTH, npessnnaronreit MHHHMaJIbHble CTaBKH aa zipeaecaay, omYCKaeMYIO na KOPHIO B cyMMe 64812, 7 rsrc, py6.

TIo COCT05IHHlO aa 25.08.2008r. Bblpy6JIeHO rrO,l(p5I,l(HbIMH OpraHH3al(H5IMHrrO CMP H nozrrsepacaeao aKTaMH Bblpy6KH, BbIB03KH H CKJIa,l(HpOBaHH5I ,l(peBeCHHbI - 2 .I 16 818 Ky6.M. (BKJIlOtIa5I XBOpOCT).

OrrpHXO,l(OBaHO na 6aJIaHC 000 «Bocroxaedrrenpoaozi» - 2 065 613 Ky6.M. (6e3 ysera xsopocra).

PeaJIH30BaHo rrO,l(pMHbIM OpraHH3al(H5IM npesecaaa B 06'beMe - 1 173 114 Ky6.M. (,l(eJIOBOH H ,l(POB5IHOH zrpeaecnmr) na CyMMy - 85 006, 8 TbIC. py6. (B TOM qHCJIe H~C), T.e. B cpenaesr no nene 72,5 py6. aa O~HH Ky6oMeTp, T.e. B 2 - 3 pasa HHm:e PbIHOqHOH CTOHMOCTH (pbIHOtIHa5I CTOHMOCTb ,l(eJIOBOH zrpesecaasr B pa3HbIX peraoaax cTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO COCTaBJI5IJIa OT 140 no 220 py6JIeH sa O,l(HH Ky6oMeTp, ,l(POB5IHOH zrpenecmrsr - OT 45 no 150 py6JIeH sa Ky60MeTp).

OCTaTKH rreca ITO COCT05IHHlO na 25.08.2008 COCTaBJI5IlOT 962 620 Ky6. M.

14

15

I

,

,

"

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM OCBI:l:):\eTeJIbCTBOBaHIUI MeCT py60K ,n:eJIOBOH H ,n:POB5IHOH npesecauu na 49 080 Ky6.M. nOJIYLIeHo MeHbllle, LIeM no JIeCopy6oLIHbIM 6HJIeTaM.

TIo,n:JIe)!<HT peanasanna B asrycre-ceirrafipe 2008 r. rrpeaecaasr B o6beMe 880214 Ky6. M. na CyMMy 70 405,8 TbIC. py6.

Kpoxre 'roro, na repparopnn AMypCKOH o6JIacTH ocpopMJIeHbI 6eCnJIaTHble

necopycosasre 6HJIeTbI na 10 644 Ky6. M (B TOM LIHCJIe ,n:eJIOBOH H ,n:POB5IHOH 9 636 Ky6.M). ,naHHa5I .n;peBeCHHa He HCnOJIb30BanaCb ,n:JI5I ~eJIeH CTpOHTeJI1CTBa TC BCTO. Ilposeneso KOMHCCHOHHoe 06CJIe,n:OBaHHe 3THX repparopaa B COCTaBe npe,n:CTaBHTeJIeH 000 "I(YTI BCTO", rrozrpsztasrx opraaasanaa, asropcxoro rransopa, 000 «,aHaH3KC» H YLIaCTKOBbIX JIeCHHLIeCTB. I1HcpopMa~H5I zroaeneaa no opranos I1CnOJIHHTeJIbHOH BJIaCTI1 AMypCKOH 06JIaCTH, opraaos MeCTHoro caMoynpaBJIeHI15I, M'K', POCJIeCX03a, JIeCHI1LIeCTB.

AHaJI113 COOTHOllleHI15I CT011MOCT11 ,n:peBeC11HbI, npe,n:YCMOTpeHHOH KOHTpaKTaM11 na BbIl10JIHeHI1e CMP, 11 CT011MOCT11 ,n:peBeC11H1I, peaJI1130BaHHOH 000 «BOCTOKHecpTenpOBO,n:» rro,n:p5I,n:HbIM OpraHI13a~115IM noxasan, 'ITO B CMeTHOH ,n:OKyMeHTa~1111, YTBep)K,n:eHHOH lJIaBrOC3KcnepT1130H P<l>, 113 pacnenox na YCTPOHCTBO JIe)KHeBbIX nopor I1CKJIIOLIeHa CTOI1MOCTb rreCOMaTepI1aJIOB (060CHOBaH115I no COOTBeTcTByIO~eMy 11CKJIIOLIeHI11O OTCYTCTBYIQT).

KOppeKT11pOBKa TIC,a B LIaCT11 I1CKJIIOLIeH115I 113 sarpar CTOHMOCT11 neca,

npeztaasnaueaaoro ,n:JI5I CTP011TeJIbCTBa JIe)KHeBbIX zropor, He 6bIJIa YLITeHa Y'IaCTH11KaMH roprcs, 'ITO nOBJIeKJIO BKJIIOLIeHI1e sarpar aa saxyrrxy JIeCOMaTep11aJIOB B KOHKypCHble rrpe,n:JIO)KeH115I - B pacser nemr KOHKYPCHOH 3a5IBK11 (cpopMa NQ 14) 11 B Be,n:OMOCT11 MaTep11aJIOB 11 ofopyaonaana, nOCTaBJI5IeMbIX no,n:p5I,n:LI11KOM (rpopaa NQ 11).

TaK, B KOHKypCHOM npe,n:JIO)KeH11I1 no6e,n:I1TeJI5I .roproa no JIOTY NQ BCTOIB3C-8 «TIepBa5I o-repezrs rpytionposozraoa C11CTeMbI» «BOCTO'IHa5I C116I1Pb - T11X11H OKeaH». BHeIIIHee 3JIeKTpocHa6)KeHHe. RTIC NQ 8, HTIC NQ 10» 000 «CTPOH KOHT11HeHT» npenycvorpeasr sarparsr na np1106peTeH11e JIeCOMaTep11aJIOB ,n:JI5I CTp011TeJIbCTBa JIe)KHeBbIX zropor (fipesna) B o6beMe 22 074 Ky6. MeTpa na CyMMY 67599378 pyfineji, T. e. B cpenaev no 3062,4 py6JIH aa O,[(HH Ky60MeTp (CM. nsnne: PbIHOLIHa5I neaa ,n:eJIOBOH rrpeaecaasr B peraonax CTpOHTeJIbCTBa COCTaBJI5IeT 140 - 220 py6. sa O,n:I1H Ky6oMeTp, ,n:POB5IHOH ,n:peBeC11HbI 45 - 150 py6. aa O,n:11H Ky6oMeTp).

Y'I11TbIBa5I, LITO TOJIbKO na YCTPOHCTBO JIe)KHeBbIX ztopor npz CTpOHTeJIbCTBe JIHHeHHOH 'IaCT11 TC BCTO Heo6xo,n:11MO 673 TbIC. Ky6. MeTpoB ,n:peBeC11HbI, ymepf KOMnaHH11, B cnysae BKJIIO'IeH115I BceMH reHno,n:p5IJJ:LII1KaMI1 sarpar na saxynxy JIeCOMaTep11aJIOB no ueaan, aHaJIOm'IHbIM ~eHaM 000 «CTPOH KOHT11HeHT», COCTaB11T np11MepHO 2 MJIP,[(. py6JIeii.

&I 11

I I

I

I I

7. AHaJIH3 qmHaHcoBhlx pe3YJIbTaTOB ,[(OqepHHX,

KOMIIaHHH, BbIIIOJIHHBmHX pa60TbI

(Ilpunoucenue Ni: 9)

3aBHCHMblX H "BHyqaTbIX" o6111ecTB

na cTpOHTeJIbCTBe BeTO

Ha OCHOBaHI1I1 npencrasnemrsrx ,n:oLIepHHMI1 o6~eCTBaM11 ,n:oKYMeHToB rrpoaezren aHaJI113 .ycnyr (pafior) OKa3aHHbIX 06~eCTBaMI1 aa ofisexrax CTp011TeJIbCTBa TC BCTO sa nepaozt 2006 - 2008 r.r.

Bcero ,n:O'IepHI1M11 o6~eCTBaMI1 OAO «AK «Tpaacnerpn.» na CTpOI1TeJIbCTBe ofisexroa TC BCTO BbIl10JIHeHO ycnyr aa cyMMy 5259,659 MJIH. py6., cpaKTI1LIeCKa5I cetiecroauocrr, BbIIIOJIHeHHblX pa60T (oKa3aHHbIX ycnyr) COCTaBI1JIa 8404,182 MJIH. py6.

TIo pe3YJIbTaTaM pa60TbI sa 2006 - 2008 r.r. na 06beKTaX TC BCTO ,n:O'IepHI1MI1 11 3aB11CI1MbIMI1 06~eCTBaMI1 IIOJIyqeH y6blTOK B paasrepe 3144,523 MJIH. py6., B T.LI. ,aAO MH - 2275,147 MJIH. py6.; 3aBI1CHMbIM11 06~eCTBaMI1 ,aAO MH - 869,376 MJIH. py6. TIp11 3TOM, ,n:OLIepHI1M11 06~eCTBaMI1 nonyseno 72,4 % OT CYMMbI y6bITKOB, 3aB11C11MbIMH o6~eCTBaMI1 - 27,6 % OT CYMMbl y6bITKOB.

Y6bITKH, noaeceanue ,IJ,AO MH COCTaBHJIH 2275,147 MJIH. py6. H pacrrpcnerranncr, CJIe,n:)'lOr.u:HM 06P3.30M, CM. Ta6JIHIW N!~ 1:

Ta6JIHIJ:a No 1

11 I

~

·

·

CTOHMOCTh ct>aKTH'IeCKaH Y~eJIhHhIH nee
HaHMeHOBaHHe .nAO MH ceoeCTOHMOCTh YOhITOK y6hITKa B OOme"
BhInOJIHeHHhlX
ycnyr (T. py6.) BhIllOJ1HeHHhlX (T. py6.) cyMMe y6hITKa no
ycnyr (T. py6.) .nAO MH, %
OAO «CH6HeqJTenpOBO)l,» 72 562,0 534905,0 -462343,0 20,3
000 «BocToKHeqJTeIlQOBo~» 192560,0 427884,0 -235324,0 10,3
OAO «Cesepo-Sanazmsre MH» 43464,4 260521,4 -217057,0 9,5
OAO «Tpaccafinedm,» 101 967,4 289389,4 -187422,0 8,6
OAO 40708,0 233317,0 -192609,0 8,5
«Ilpasonsccxnedrrenponon»
OAO «Hepxoaoprpaacnedrrs» 32249,3 227476,7 -195227,4 8,5
OAO «Cesepasre MH» 51013,0 239473,0 - 188460,0 8,3
OAO «Vpancatisedrrenpoaon» 39719,0 205 177,0 -165457,1 8,3
OAO 32970,0 170209,0 -137239,0 7,3
«Ilenrpcnonedrrenpcaon»
o A 0 «,l(IJy)!{6a» 129647,0 225950,0 -96303,0 6,0
000 «Earrrnedrrenposon» 43829,6 138022,5 -94 192,9 4,2
OAO 62864,0 155274,1 -92410,1 4,1
«BepHeBOJI)!{CHe<jJTenpOBO)l,»
OAO «BOJI)!{CKHH nO)J.BO)J.HHK» 28092,5 39194,7 -II 102,2 0,5
000 CMHll «Ko3hMHHO» 49607,0 49607,0 0 0
Hroro: 921254,1 3196400,8 -2275146,7 100,0 I

Y6bITKH, nonyseaasre 3aBHCHMbIMH o6r.u:eCTBaMH ,n:AO MH, COCTaBHJIH 869,376 MJIH. py6. H pacrrpenenanacs CJIe,n:)'lOr.u:HM 06P3.30M, CM. Ta6JIHIJ;y NQ 2:

Ta6JIHlJ,a No 2

I

·

,

-
CTOHMOCTh <l>aKTH'IeCKaH Y6hITOK (-) Y.QeJIhHhIH sec
HaHMeHoBaHHe 3aBHCHMoro BhInOJIHeH ceoeCTOHMOCTh y6hITKa B 06meH
otiurecraa .nAO MH HhIX ycnyr BhInOJ1HeHHhlX npH6hIJIh cyMMe YOhlTKa no
(T. pyti.) ycnyr (T. pyo.) (+), ThIC. pyo. ,n:AO MH, %
000 KCY 2 127210,0 2431431,0 -304221,0 35,0
«CH6HeqJTenpOBO)J.CTpoH»
000 «Bonraneprerascneucrpoa» 828.962,0 1 125796,0 -296834,0 34,1
000 «Oxcxnedrrerascneucrpoa. I 330 115,0 I 603 198,1 -273 083,1 31.4
000 «ToMcKHe<jJTecTpOH» 49661,0 43 854,0 5 807,0 0,6
3AO «TOM33JI» 2 457,1 3 502,1 -I 045,0 0,1
Hroro: 4338405,1 5207781,2 -869376,1 100,0 I

.

ComaCHO HHc:popMaIJ;HH, IIpe,n:CTaBJIeHHOM ,n:O MH 83% CTOHMOCTH ycrryr BbIIIOJIHeHbI 06r.u:eCTBaMH na OCHOBaHHH paCIIopMHTeJIbHbIX IIHceM OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,», 4% aa OCHOBaHHH IIJIaHOB KanHTaJIbHOrO cTpOHTeJIbCTBa, aa 13% CTOHMOCTH ycnyr IIHCbMeHHble 06ocHOBaHHjl OTCYTCTBYIOT .

,n:OqepHHMH 06r.u:ecTBaMH sa IIepHO,n: C 2006 no 2008 r.r. OK3.3bIBaJIHCb CJIe,n:YIOr.u:He yCJIyrH, CM. Ta6JIHIJ;y NQ 3:

II II

Ta6JIHlJ,a No 3

-
CTOHMOCTh ((>aKTH'IeCKaH Y)J.eJIhHhIH nee
ceoeCTOHMOCTh
.N'~ BH~ pa60T (ycnyr) lj>aKTH'IeCKH OTKJ10HeHHH - YOhITKa B oomeii
n.zn, BhlllOJIHeHHblX ,+ TbIC. pyo. cyMMe YOhITKa no
BbInOJ1HeHHblX pafio'r (ycnyr)
ycnyr TbIC. py6. TbIC. py6. ,l(AO MH, %
I Ilepesosxa rpY30B 417414,1 I 883424,2 -1466010,1 46,6
2 CMP 4441435,6 5488896,9 -1 047461,3 33.3
~ Texnoxours 174299,9 635746,7 -461446,8 14,7
.)
4 Apeana TeXHHKH 220095,2 387854,7 - 167759,5 5.3
5 Apenna 6414,4 8259,5 -1 845,1 0.1
06~)l,OBaHHR
Bcero: 5259659,2 8404182,0 -3144522,8 100,0 16

17

I

.

MaKCHMaJ11HbIH y6bITOK norrysen OT nepeaosxa rpY30B H COCTaBHn 46,6% OT 06II.J;eH CyMMnI nonyseannx y6bITKOB. CYMMa y6bITKa 1 466,010 MJ1H. py6.

,nOLJ:epHHMH 06II.J;ecTBaMH OKa3aHhI ycnyra no nepesosxe rpyson, TeXHHKH, 060py,aoBaHH5I scero na cyMMy 417,414 MnH. py6., cpaKTHLJ:eCKa5I cefecroaaocrs anroycnyr COCTaBHna 1 883,424 MnH. py6.

Ilposenea BbI60pOLJ:HnIH cpaKTHLJ:eCKHX 3aTpaT Ha OKa3aHHe noroaopasr).

A HaJIH3 rrOKa3aJI, LJ:TO rro Ha3BaHHhIM ztorosopaa OKa3aHO ycnyr na CyMMy 62,241 MnH. py6. <DaKTHLJ:eCKHe sarparu no HHM COCTaBHnH 430,008 MnH. py6. Y6bITOK - 367,767 MJ1H. py6. Cpe,aH5I5I nena ycnyr no npezrcraaneaasnr ztorosopax COCTaBHna 31,08 py6. sa 1 T/KM.

Ilonyseaae y6.bITKOB npa OKa3aHHH ycrryr no nepesoaxe rpY30B otiycnosneno cne,a)'IOII.J;HMH ¢aKTopaMH: ¢HKcHpoBaHHoH neaoa CTOHMOCTH ycnyr sa 1 T/KM, YCTaHoBneHHoH I1HCbMOM DAD «AK «Tpaacnedrn,» NQ 12-03-08/1548 OT 09.02.2007 (B pasnepe He 60nee 5,29 py6. C yserox H,nC); csepxnnaaossraa 3aTpaTaMH na nepeoasaponxy TeXHHKH; YBeJIHLJ:eHHeM pacxoztos na nonzrepacaaae B pafiorocnocofinou COCT05IHHH TeXHHKH B CJIO)KHbIX KnHMaTHLJ:eCKHX YCJIOBH5IX; pacxozros na KOMaH,aHpoBKH H ztp.

Kposre 'roro, HMeJ1H MeCTO (jlaKTbI BKJ1IO'IeHHH B (jlaKTH'IecKYIO CTOHMOCTb YCJJYr npoxax paCXO,lJ;OB: ycnyr CBH3H, CTOHHKH, nO,lJ;rOTOBKH xaapos H npoxee, 'ITO HenOCpe,lJ;CTBeHHO He CBH3aHO C aarparaa, OTHOCHw;HMCH K nepeaosxe,

,nOLJ:epHHe 06II.J;eCTBa BbIIIOnHHJIH CTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa)KHhIe pa60TbI aa CT_POHTenbCTBe TC BCTO na CyMMy 4441,435 MnH. py6. <DaKTHLJ:eCKa5I cetiecroaaocrs BbIIIOJIHeHHbIX pa60T COCTaBHna 5488,897 MnH. py6. CYMMa y6hITKa - 1 047,461 MnH. py6. Y,aeJIhHhIH sec y6bITKOB rro OKa3aHHIO ycnyr cTpOHTeJIbHOrO xapaxrepa sa nepaon C 2006 no 2008 r.r. COCTaBHn 33,3%.

Y6nITKH na cTpOHTen.bCTBO TC BCTO 06YCJIOBneHbI npeasmreaaex ¢aKTHLJ:eCKOH BeJIHLJ:HHnI ce6ecToHMoCTH pa60T HM cMeTHoH BenHLJ:HHOH ce6ecToHMoCTH, no npasnne 3aHH)l(eHH5I CTOHMOCTll cytinonpaaasrx pa60T, no neaaxr HH)Ke, LJ:eM na ,n:aHH.bIe pa60TnI YCTaHOBJIeHHnIe KOHTpaKTOM zrna Tcanonpaaaax opranaaanaa,

TaK, aanpaaep, 000 «l{YTI «BCTO» 3aKJIIOLJ:HnO KOHTpaKT NQ 123-06 OT 28.04.2006 na CTpOllTeJIhCTBO aedrrerrponozraoa CHCTeMbI «BocToLJ:Ha5I Cll6HPb- THxHH OKeaH» C reHno,n:pMLJ:HKOM 000 «CT_POHCHcTeMa» (zranee feHnO,lJ;PMLJ:HK). I'eanonpazrsax npaanex K pa60TaM ¢HnHaJI aaocrpaaaoro LJ:aCTHOro ymrrapnoro npoassoncrseaaoro npe,anpH5ITH5I OAO «CTpoHTpaHCra3»- «EeJICTpOHTpaHCra3». B CBOIO o-repezrs ¢HnHaJI MI1 «EeJIcTpOHTpaHCra3» - I10,n:PMLJ:HK npHBJIeK K cy6rro,aPMHnIM pa60TaM 000 «Osrcxaedrrerascnencrpoib (Cy6no,ap5I.IJ:LJ:HK), 3aKJIIOLJ:HB C HHM ztorosop NQ 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 na BbIIIOJIHeHHe CTpOHTenbHO-MOHTa)l(HbIX pa60T «I1epBa5I osepens rpytionpoaonaoa CHCTeMbI BOCTOLJ:Ha5I CH6HPh-THXHH OKeaH», JIHHeHHa5I LJ:aCTb. YLJ:aCTOK KM 0 - KM 570,d 1067 MM. YLJ:aCTOK KM 74- KM 78.

Cy6no,aPMLJ:HK, cornacno aKTaM 0 npnexnce BbIIIOJIHeHHbIX pa60T H cnpasox 0 CTOHMOCTH BbIIIonHeHHbIX pa60T (¢OpM KC-2 H KC-3), BbIIIonHHn ,an5I TIO,n:p5I,n:LJ:HKa cTpoHTenbHo-MOHTIDKHble pa60TbI na CyMMy 17,699 MnH. py6. (c H,nC). TIo ,n:oroBopy NQ 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 06beM pa60T 6bIn onpezrenea B cyMMe 18,075 MnH. py6. (c H,nC).

aaanas npeztcrasneaaux ,aOLJ:epHHMH 06I[(ecTBaMH

ycnyr no nepesosxe rpY30B no IlIeCTH ,nO MH (no 16

I I

.

I

.

CTOHMOCTh pa60T (B py6.) Y CTOHMOCTh pa60T (B py6.) Y OTKflOHeHHe ITO cjJaKT)' (B py6.)
BhIITOflHeHHR pa60T Me)!(.n.y
Feanonpansnsa no KOHTpaKTY cy6ITO.n.pR.n.4HKa ITO norosopy N2 feHITo.n.pR.n.4HKOM H
N2 123-06 OT 28.04.2006. 03/06/481 OT 25 .08 .2006 C_y6no.l!£_R.n.4HKOM
36637567,0 17699523,0 18938044,0 OTKnOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T, xoropsre I'eanonpazrsax nonysan OT Cy6rro,ap5I.IJ:LJ:HKa H nepenpezrsaaan 3aKa3'IHKY, COCTa13HnO 18,938 MJIH. py6. (36,638 - 17,699).

TaKHM 06Pa30M, CTOHMOCTb BbIIIonHeHHhIX pa60T no zrorosopy Y Cy6no,ap5I,n:LJ:HKa 6bIJIa saaaaceaa na 51,69% (18,938/36,638*100%).

1/1

18

B pe3YJI1TaTe cy6nO.IJ:p5I.IJ:1fHK 000 «OMCKHeq)Tera3Crre[(CTpOH:» no .IJ:OrOBOpy .N2 03/06/481 OT 25.08.2006 B1IDOJIHHJI pa60ThI na CYMMY 15 MJIH. py6. (6e3 H~C), cpaKTHqeCKa5I ce6ecToHMoCT1 B1II10JIHeHH1IX pa60T 16,025 MJIH. py6. Y61ITOK COCTaBHJI 1,025 MJIH. py6.

~OqepHHMH o6I[(eCTBaMH OKa3aH11 ycnyra TexrrOMOI[(H aa CyMMY 174,3 MJIH. py6., HX cpaKTHQeCKa5I ce6ecToHMoCT1 COCTaBHJIa 635,747 MJIH. py6. CYMMa y6bITKa - 461,447 MJIH. py6. Y.IJ:eJI1H1IH: sec y61ITKOB no OKa3aHIllO ycnyr TeXrrOMOI[(H sa nepHO.IJ: C 2006 no 2008 r.r. COCTaBHJI 14,7%.

Y61ITKH OT OKa3aHH5I TeXrrOMOI[(H: JIHKBH.IJ:a[(H5I TeXHOJIOrH1feCKHX pa3p1IBOB; YCTpaHeHHe nerpexros; npOBe.IJ:eHHe .IJ:HarHOCTHKH; BbIIIOJIHeHHe CBapOQH1IX pafior; MOHTa:>K BpeMeHH1Ix nepexnrsex H ztpyrae, 3KOHOMHQeCKH He 060CHOBaHHbI. COrJIaCHO nYHKTy 1 «PerJIaMeHTa rro 01fHCTKe, m.IJ:poHCnbITaHHIO H nporpnneaerpna nedrrenposona BCTO nOCJIe 3aBepmeHH5I cTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa:>KHbIX pa60T», YTBep:>K.IJ:eHHOrO 04.04.2007, nO.IJ:P5I.IJ:1fHK nOJIHOCTbIO OTBe1faeT sa paspafiorxy npoexra rrpOH3BO.IJ:CTBa pafior, a TaK:>Ke sa peaJIH3a:QHIO scex pa60T H nposenenae HCrrbITaHHH:: rH.IJ:pOHCrrhITaHHH:, YCTaHOBKH KaMep npaeva-nycxa cxpeoxon, 01fHCTKH BHyTpeHHeH: nOJIOCTH, npodraneverpaa H oCBo6o:>K.IJ:eHHe OT BO.IJ:bI. ComaCHO n.4.28 Pernaxrerrra, BbI5IBJIeHHbIe npn Hcn1ITaHH5IX .IJ:ecpeKTbI H nOBpe:>K.IJ:eHH5I H HX nOCJIe.IJ:CTBH5I YCTpaH5IIOTC5I nO.IJ:p5I.IJ:1fHKOM 3aMeHOH: .IJ:ecpeKTHoro ysacrxa.

8. AHaJIH3 3aMeqaHHH anropcxoro H TeXHHQeCKOrO aansopa (IIpUflo:JICeHlIJI .Nl!10, 11)

Bcero C aaxana cTPoHTeJIhCTBa no 15.10.2008 npe.IJ:CTaBHTeJI5IMH asropcxoro aansopa no o6beKTaM TC BCTO BhI5IBJIeHO H saaeceao B :>KypHaJIhI anropcxoro aaztsopa 8 740 3aMeQaHHH, H3 HHX, He YCTpaHeHO - 498, B T.1f. BJIHHIOll(HX na 6e30nacHYlO 3KCnJIyaTaUHlO 06'beKTa - 25 3aMe1faHHH:.

TaK, npe.IJ:CTaBHTeJI5IMH asropcxoro Ha.IJ:30pa OAO «I'anporpytionponon» B rrepaozt cTpOHTeJIhCTBa 6bIJIH C.IJ:eJIaHbI CJIe.IJ:yroI[(He cYI[(eCTBeHHhIe 3aMe1famUI:

- HecaHK:QHoHHpoBaHHoe npaxeaeaae MTP, B 1faCTHOCTH, Tpy6HOH:, Ka6eJIhHOH:

npO.IJ:YK[(HH, sanopnoa apaarypsr, He npe.IJ:YCMOTpeHHhIX npoeKTHhIMH pemeHHHMH; YKJIa,n:Ka TPy6hI B rpanmero, 3anOJIHeHHyro BO.IJ:oH:;

csapxa TPy6 6e3 COOTBeTCTByroI[(HX npacnocofinenaa;

.IJ:ecpeKThI npa csapxe CTbIKOB;

nOBpe)K.IJ:eHHe 3aBO.IJ:CKOH: H30JIH[(HH na rpytie;

3aCbII1Ka YJIO:>KeHHOrO Tpy6orrpOBO.IJ:a Mep3JIbIM rpyHTOM C 06JIOMKaMH CKaJIhHOH:

nopoztsr pasxepo» OT 1 .IJ:O 3-x MeTPOB;

3aChIIIKa TPy6onpOBO.IJ:a 6e3 yrrJIOTHeHH5I rpyara;

YKJIa.IJ:Ka Tpy6onpOBO.IJ:a na rpYHT C neconopytio-msnra OCTaTKaMH;

HapYIIIeHHe TeXHOJIOrHH rrpOH3BO.IJ:CTBa pa60T npa MOHTa:>Ke pesepsyapos PBCDA- 50000 101.5;

HeBbII10JIHeHHe nO.IJ:ChIIIKH nrc rrozr YCTaHOBJIeHHhIe onopsr BJI;

YCTaHOBKa onop BJI 10 KB 6e3 MeTaJIJIH1feCKHX CBaH: H nozt HaKJIOHOM K BepTHKaJIhHOH: OCH, npeBbIIIIeHHe HOpMhI nponacanaa rrpOBO.IJ:OB H .IJ:p.

3aMeQaHH5I Crre[(HaJIHCTOB aBTopCKoro Ha.IJ:30pa K H3MeHeHHIO KOHTpaKTHOH: CTOHMOCTH H BHeceHHIO H3MeHeHHH: B pafiosyro .IJ:OKYMeHTa[(HIO He rrpHBO.IJ:HJIH.

ITo HHH[(HaTHBe nO.IJ:PH.IJ:HhIX opraaasamra 000 «U;YIT BCTO» HeO.IJ:HOKpaTHO o6paI[(aJIOCh B npoexrnsre opraaasanaa C npe.IJ:JIO:>KeHH5IMH 0 COrJIaCOBaHHH BHeCeHH5I Pa3JIH1fHhIX H3MeHeHHH: B ITC,l.(, B TOM 1fHCJIe Heo6oCHOBaHHhIX: 0 BKJIIOQeHHH B rrpoexr CTpOHTeJI1CTBa 6ypOB3P1IBHbIX pafior, 3Ha1fHTeJIhHO YBeJIHQHBaIOI[(HX CTOHMOCTh pa60T, rrpHMeHeHH5I BepTHKaJIhHOrO 6ypeHH5I .IJ:JI5I YCTaHoBKH onop BJI no npH1fHHe OTCYTCTBH5I y nO.IJ:p5I.IJ:QHKa Heo6xo.IJ:HMOH: CTpOHTeJIhHOH: TeXHHKH H .IJ:p.

B xO.IJ:e CTpOHTeJIhCTBa HMeJIH MeCTO cpaKTbI rrpen5ITCTBOBaHH5I co CTOPOHhI nO.IJ:p5I.IJ:H1IX opraHH3a:QHH: B .IJ:OrrycKe npe~CTaBHTeJIeH: aBTopcKoro Ha.IJ:30pa Ha o6beKTbI CMP,

I, I

I

I

I I

I

III

s ) I

I I

19

nCMXOJIOnrqeCKOrO ,I(aBJIeHM5I na HMX B u;eJI5IX nozrrracaaaa aKTOB npMH5ITLIX pa60T C HeYCTpaHeHHBIMH HapYllIeHH5IMH.

B pe3YJIBTaTe B1I60pOQHOrO aHaJIH3a 3aMeQaHHH aBTOpCKOrO Ha,I(30pa no YQaCTKY 372- 570 KM H no HITC-4 (no pe3YJIBTaTaM H3yqeHH5I )KypHaJIOB asropcxoro Ha,I(30pa) BBI5IBJIeHO, qTO B· )KypHaJIaX asropcxoro Ha,I(30pa He CO,I(ep)KHTC5I MH<popMaIJ;HH 06 H3MeHeHM5IX npoexraoa ,n;oKYMeHTaU;HH, BHOCHMBIX CneIJ;HaJIHCTaMM npoeKTHBIX opraHH3aIJ;MH B nponecce Be,I(eHM5I aaropcxoro Ha,I(30pa (BHOCHTC5I na OCHOBaHMM nMCBMeHHBIX o6paII(eHMH 3aKa3qHKa B npoexrayro opraaasanmo).

B COOTBeTCTBMM C Tpe60BaHH5IMH Pernasreara OP-91.010.30-KTH-141-07

«OpraHH3aIJ;H5I MocYII(eCTBJIeHHe asropcxoro aansopa sa crpoHTeJIBCTBOM, peKoHcTPYKIJ;HeH, TeXHIfl:IeCKHM nepesoopyxenaea H KanMTaJIBHBIM pevoaroa npoM3Bo,n;cTBeHHlIX o6beKToB MamCTpaJIBHlIX nedrrenpononon» n.8.1, cneIJ;MaJIHCTBI asropcxoro Ha,I(30pa HMeIDT rrpaso YCTpaH5ITB na MeCTax 06HapY>KeHHBIe B npoexraoa ,n;oKYMeHTaIJ;MH OllIM6KM, onMCKH, eCJIH OHM He CB5I3aHBI C Tpe60BaHH5IMM HopMaTHBHOH ,n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH, a TaK)Ke npHH5ITBIMH TeXHHqeCKHMM pellIeHH5IMH npoexra, xoropsre He npHBo,n;5IT K YBeJIHqeHHID CMeTHOH CTOHMOCTM H (MJIH) CPOKOB CTpOHTeJIhCTBa.

B )KypHaJIaX aBTOpCKOro nansopa OTpa)KeHhI BbI5IBJIeHHhle oTcTynJIeHH5I OT npoeKTHOH ,n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HM, YTBep:>K,n;eHHOH «B npOH3Bo,n;CTBO pa60T}), HapYllIeHM5I Tpe60BaHMH crpoarensnsrx HOpM H npaBHJI, TeXHM"tJeCKMX YCJIOBHH no npmI3Bo,n;CTBY CMP M YKa3aHM5I 06 MX YCTpaHeHHH, CpOKH H <paKTbI MX BblllOJIHeHM5I.

He3aBHCHMbIH TeXHHQeCKHH Ha,lJ;30p sa BblllOJIHeHMeM pa60T na ofisexrax TC BCTO B nepaozt C 2006 r. no MIDHb 2008 r. OCYII(eCTBJI5IJIO 000 «,Z:(MaH3KC».

Bcero C aasana crpoarenscrsa no 30.06.2008 npe,n;cTaBMTeJI5IMH HTH BbI,n;aHO 27 882 IIpe,lJ;IIHCaHHii, B r.s.:

- 4 707 llIT. (17 %) no nJIOII(a,n;O'IHbIM o6beKTaM (HITC), M3 HHX 653 npermacaaaa C rrpaocraaosxoa pafior;

- 23 175 llIT. (83 %) no 06beKTaM JIHHeHHOH "tJaCTM (Jlq), M3 HHX 1572 npezmacaana C npaocraaoaxoa pa60T.

2 225 npczmacaaaa HJIM 8 % OT MX ofimero KOJIM"tJeCTBa CB5I3aHbl C npaocraaosxoit pa60T. ITo COCT05IHHlO aa 30.06.2008 He HCIIOJIHeHO 345 IIpe,lJ;IIHCaHHii, B T."tJ. C rrpnocraacaxoa pa60T 49 IIpe,lJ;IIHcaHHii. He ycrpaneasr B YCTaHOBJIeHHbIH CpOK HapYllIeHM5I no 205 M3 345 He MCIIOJIHeHH:bIX npezmacaana, M3 HMX no 29 rrpennacaaaav HapYllIeHM5I He YCTpaHeH:bI M no COCT05IHHlO na 10.10.2008r.

HaM60JIee cymecraeaasnra 3aMe"tJaHH5IMM He3aBMCHMoro TeXHMqeCKOrO nansopa 5IBJI5IIDTC5I :

MOHTa)K rpyconpoaozta na 3eMJI5IH:bIX npaasrax BMeCTO npMMeHeHM5I MOHTa)KH:bIX

onop;

HeCOOTBeTCTBHe rJIy6MH:bI M mapaasr .rpamnea non TPy60npOBO,n; npOeKTH:bIM

BeJIIflIHHaM;

OTCYTcTBMe noncsmxa M5IrKHM rpYHTOM naa rpaanrea B CKaJI:bH:bIX nopoztax; neooecrreseaae nOJIHOrO npMJIeraHH5I TeJIa rpytiorrpoaozta KO znry TpaHllIeM; aenposeneaae KOHTPOJI5I CBapH:bIX llIBOB MeTo,n;OM ITBK;

neofiecneaenae COOCHOCTM CTBOPHhlX JIMHMH rpytionpoaona C npOeKTH:bIMM; KOHIJ;BI pa3phIBOB HIT BhIJIO)KeHhI He B crsope npoeKTHOH OCM;

napymenae M30JI5IIJ;HH rpyfionpoaona Me)K,n;y CThIKaMM;

nposeneaae peMOHTa CBapH:bIX llIBOB Henpe,n;YCMOTpeHH:bIMH npoexrov TMnaMM 3JIeKrpO,D;OB M HeaTeCTOBaHHhIMH CBapII(MKaMM;

HeBhlllOJIHeHMe 3JIeKTpOXMM3aIIJ;MThI YJIO)KeHHOrO H sacsmaanoro rpyrionpoaona M

,n;p.

ITpaKTHqeCKH na scex ysacrxax crpOHTeJIhCTBa JIq MH BBI5IBJIeHhI Hee,n;MHHqHhle <paKThI npOH3Bo,n;CTBa CBapOQHO-MOHTa)KHhIX pa60T B OTCYTCTBMe KOHTPOJI5I co CTOPOHhI He3aBMCMMoro

1·1·'

.

TeXHI:ILfeCKOro nazrsopa, 6e3 OcpOpMJIeHHOH paspenrarensaof H ~OnYCI(HOH ~OKYMeHTa~HH, 06YCTpOHCTBa HeCaHK~HOHIIpOBaHHhIX rrepeesztos ~JI5I npoxozta TeXHIIKH Qepe3 yace YJIQ)KeHH1IH H 3aChmaHH1IH nedrrenpoaon.

npe~nHCaHH5I HTH, 3aKp1ITHe KOTOP1IX nOTpe6oBaJIO HJIII nOBJIeKJIO YBeJIIILfeHIIe KOHTpaKTHOH CTOHMOCTH 06'heKTOB CTpOHTemCTBa TC BCTO, OTCYTCTBYlOT.

ITpHJIO:IKeHHe: ua I tf-6'O. JIHCTaX:

r'--- I ----------.---------- ..... --~- .. -- .. ------- .. -.--------·--··--·-·--··-·------T·--·-··--···----·-···-··--·-···--·------'··'1

I I Cnpasxa B oraomenan aH~am13a o nJIaThI B paapese npHBJIeqeHHhIX,' i

I 1 I cy6nO,n:p5I,n:HhIX opraansanaa C YKa3aHYJeM 06beMaII CTOHMOCTI1! aa 100 J111CTe( ax) I I I BhmOJ1HeHHhlX I1MH pa60T B COOTHOllIeHHI1 C reanonpazrasnm noroaopava 11 I (8 T.~. npnn, Hagn.) .

r-'-'---rc~~:~: :a~~~:e::~ ~~~;a aKrOB B~In~;HeHHhI~-pa6oT n~ thop-~aM Kc~jl:-----·-----·--·------··-----l

i I 'l' , aa __r__ J111CTe(ax) i I 2 ! 2 11 KC-3 na COOTBeTCTBHe KOH~Tpa~TaM no COCTaBY, o6beMaM H CTOHMOCTI1 I _ I

! I no 06beKTaM HTIC N!!. 4 11 JII1Hel1HOI1 qaCTI1 372-570 KM. , (B v!. npnn, ua -- n.) i

f---r --.----.---------.-----------------.---j-- ... ----.--- .. -- .. --.-.--.- ... -----i

I ,. Cnpasxa 000 «Tpaacuedm, <I>I1HaHc» 06 YCTaHOBJIeHHhIX B 2008 rozty I! H1 !

I· . ~ . Hd 1 AI JII1CTaX .

; 3 I cpaKTax HapYIIIeHl111 nOHRhTnOJ1HeHI1l.:l nonpannsrx pa60T na CTpOHTeJIhCTBe I -.'

I TC BCTa. ,(BT.~. npnn. aa , ~ 1.) . I

r---··-+-------· ·-------·--···-----'I-··--:_----··--··········· .. --r------r.;---···-·····------.;r---·-·- .. ··· .. · .. r-··---·---··-··--- .. -· .. - .. -- .. -.-.- .... ,--.-----1

I i Cnpasxa (aHaJJI13) 113MeHeHI1I1 npoexrnsrx peIIIeHl111 no pe3YJ1hTaTaM i na ___A_ J111CTe(ax) I I 4 I .!

tr::?~H =~:;B:~!::£; H~::V:hI~- pellieH~ n~htiTa,. ~~Hc:(~-I

l-.--., npoBepKH )1()'PH~.~B _ _::~::HHqe~~_~~_~_~~.~p~ ._._. __ L<':3..I~_[).l:'_H.!.I.,.!.!.!l......=.....!I.:L .... __ j

I 6 I Cnpasxa C aHaJJH30M ztoronopos B qaCTH 06ocHoBaHHocT11 BhInJ1aT 11 I na .u.. JI11CTe(ax) I ! I 3aKphITH5I aBaHCOB C yserou rpadnnca BbmOJ1HeHHhIX pa60T I (B VI. n HR. aa (3 1!l !

r----I CnpaB~a (a~H3 r--;;---;~~BeTcTB~~-·---cpa~~I11.feCKO~~-~-OJIHqeCTBa-r~-;-;·-2.~2··-~11CTe(a~)-'-'I! -

171 j --- .

I l' 11CnOJIh30BaHHhlX MTP K o6beMaM cpaKTHqeCKH BhInOJIHeHHhlX pa60T I (B VI. n HR. aa 19 1-nJ.. I'

L_ ... _._ . . .. --------- __ . . __ . ,._. ._-.- __ . .-·-------I-··-·---··--P.......··--···--··----· ..... - .. --;

I II Cnpasxa (aHaJJ113) no 06beMaM 11 CTOHMOCTH Bhlpy6JIeHHOrO neca B I (J L () i

I na .::J.:J J111CTe ax i ! . 8 I conOCTaBJIeH1111 C 06beMaMH 11 CT011MOCThlO onpaxonosaasoro --- i

l__j_- 000 ~OcTo~~Tenp~~~~._!Ie~1!_~_.!.!.~~~!lHoro ~~t!P_5!WI_~~y . I_~~.~~: .. np~~ Ha "-~-~-~l..- . ...J

I' I Cnpasxa (aaanas) no cpHHaHcoBhIM pe3YJ1hTaTaM nosepnax, 3aB11C11MhIX H i .1 II' !

Ii rra 'I 10 J111CT~aX) i

! 9 «BHyqaThIX» 06l.QeCTB KOMnaH1111, BhInOJIH5IBIII11X pa60ThI aa CTp011TeJIhCTBe I --- J .411 I

i i TC BCTO 3a nepaon 2006 - 2008 r.r. I (B T.'!. npan, Ha.l1J.. n.) i

f--.---. =--.-----.-------------.------.----------- .. -.-----.-.·--·--·------··----'--------·--·· .. ·--···-···-·- .. ·--1

I· i AHaJJ113 npe,n:OCTaBJIeHHOM 11HcpopMa~HI1 no 3aMeqaHIDIM asropcxoro I 1 (J.. ) i

I nans: aa ......1...:.L J111CTe( ax j

~.~-~~J::;;~~ic~;:e;~i~i~~~:-~~acT:~:~~-7~~--~~ .... 57~_.:_~~~!!. I ~~:~~r.~~~~~-.-~~-.~.L-..J

I 11 I AHaJJH3 3aMeqaHHM He3aB11C11MOrO TeXHHLfeCKoro nansopa, BhI,n:aHHhlX B I aa 12'8 J111CTe(ax) I

L_I_~:pHO,n: CTp011TeJ1hCT~ .. !C_~~!O ._ .. ._ .. __ . ._~. __ .. _ _~ .. ._._. ..J...~...!.:...'!.:_!!P_J:l_l!.:_J:l..!l.. (2·~1. __ j

1{JIeHhI pa60QeH rpynrrsr:

II" I

Cyposen M.A.

TepeXOB ,a.A.

BOJI5IHCKHH Il.Il,

TpYCOB C.A.

ParY30Ba H.M.

Marseena JI.H.

PYCJI5IKOB H.M.

)I{aBopoHKOB <p.E.

20

20

TeXHHqeCKOrO Ha.D;30pa, 6C3 OCPOPMJICBHOH pa3penUITeJIbHOH H .uOrrYCKHOH ,nOKj'MeHTaURH, 06YCTpOHCTBa HeCaHKUHOHHpOBaHHbIX nepeesnon .um.! npoxozta TeXHHKH l.Iepe3 Y)KeynO)KeHHhIH 11 3aClInaHHhIH aeqrrerrponon.

Dpe.LJ;IUICUHHR HTH, saxpsrme lWTOPI,IX norpefionano IIJIll rrODneICJIO ysemrsenae KUlnpaKU10M CTOliMOCTI1 06'beKTOB CTPOJ1TCJJbCTJ3Cl TC BCTO, {)TCYTCTBY!OT.

Ilpanoseeuae: Ha J1UCl'ax:

CI I

-,-- ._'_ ...... _n._ ... __ . _

i Cnpasxa B OTHOrneHHI1 aHaJIH3a onnarsi B paspese npaanexeunsrx i

1 I cyonOJlpSl.ll.HhIX opraml3aUHH c yxaaaaaeu o6beMa H CTOHMOCTI1! aa nacretax)

! BbInOJ1HeHHbIX HMI1 pa60T R COOT'HOHlem·1VI C reHnc)JlplIllHhlMI1 noronopaa a 11 I (8 VI. npwl. HlI __ n.)

---} ~~~;~.~~~~~~~;:~ :1:~3a ~-;-;:OI3 OL~~~JlIle;O~-LIX pa6~;-no CPOPMa~~KC-+--- ( )

\ ! aa JIHCTe ax

r 2 i 2 11 KC-3 ua CQOTBOTCTBJ1e .KOHTpaKTaM no COCTaBY, 06'beMaM H CTQHMOCTI1 ! --- . I

i 110 o(heKTaM Hne N!14 11 mlHei1Hoi1 '"IaCTI1 372-570 KM. 1 (B T.'!. npun. aa n.) i

r: j I~!~;~;:~;=~;:=;~2;~~;;;;::~:'"~~~~~

I '1' npOBepXI1 IKYPHaJIOB anropcxoro Ha,D,30pa I (n T.'I. npun. lla n.)!

t------ ~ .. " - .' - ------.~---------.:.---.---.--.---- . . --------- .. - . - -.

I' Cnpasxa (aHaJTHs) H3MeHeHHH npocKT.HhlX pCWeHl-fH . no pe3ynbTaTaM fin JIHCTc(ax) I

5 npOBepll:11 mypHaJlOB TeX~m'leCKOrO Ha,D,30pa (II 1.'1. npJIJl. na 11.)!

l---.L-. - _m" •.• '· .. _,, ._,_~-- .. -------.----.---- .. -.-- ---.-.---- --------- .. -----.-- -.--"".-.--. -"-_ "-1

! i Crtpasxa c aHaJIH30M zroroeopoa B <laCTH 06ocHoBaHiHocTH asmnar H na JUlCTe(ax) i

, -:+~~;;,;:" a~(:~:R:t;:'M r::!:~~~nHe~~~~ Kon'j;~Bar;~""~';;"={;;;')1

.. !_ ... J ... ~.:!:~!_~.~~!_:'~_~IX MTP II: ~~2'eMaM <P~.~~~~.~.::_~I1_~.r..~?~"~~~.:':...::~~I~~ m ... __ rl ... ~ .. !.:...'!;...!!P2!~~! JI.) J

! Cnpasxa (aHUJU13) 110 oG'ht:MaM 11 CTOI1M~)CTI1 13hlpy6J1eHHQI'o neca B " ( .) !

i .' . , Iia JIHCTe ax i

8 I conocraenenaa C o6beMaMJ.:I H CTOHMOCTh:fO onpJ.:IXO,D,OsaHHOro I .. --- . j

~I --bg~~B~~~·9{i~~~:35T~~~:~~:~~:,E-~~;::1i~9M~;~{~J~~~3aBHcH~.I-hi;tH""'I! .. ·~·~~·~~-~!~~~·~·~-" '(~)"-'l

. 1 aa JlHCTe ax j

i 9 i «BHYllaTbIX» 061l1eCTB KOllUlaI-lHH, BbIHQJII·ISlBWHX patiorsi Ha CTpOJ.fTeJlbCTBe i --- .'

'~i ~~~~p::~~~:~~:~::~a;:::~;a;;~:;~:~~t~ "PM "~~l

r-.Jri~~;;~;;~;~~~}~ll::;;:~~~~~~ ':~~XBH~ec~~r~- -H;i;~pd~-;;h;;~~~·~~;;:· .. ~+ ~~~:.~I~"~·~~~;;;;~e~~) :

III' . 1-- I

l nepaon CTpOI1TeJlbCTBa TC BCTO ! (8 T.'!. n "no H8 JI.);

, _ .. __ _._ .. _ ,... "'~ . . __ .. _ _. .. _ __ . __ __ .~ _ __ .. "_ -I __ ._._._ " .. p. .. ,_~._._

I

·

·

i •

1'-)

Cyposen .vLA.

TepeXOB .l(.A.

I

BOilllIICICHH IT.)]..

TpyCOB CA.

I

·

·

·

Parysosa H .11.

Marneesa ILl-I.

PYCJnU{OB H.M.

)KaBOpoHKOR ID.Fl.

YTBEF)K,n:AIO ,n:HpeKTOp ztenapraaerrra 3KOHOMHKH

OAO ( «TpaHC eqm,»

ART

rro HTOraM pa60TbI pa60YfeH rpynnsr rro ncnonaeamo

sonpoca 6 «IIepeYfH5I MepOrrpH5ITHH rro cfiopy H rronroronxe .n;OKYMeHTOB H HHcpopMaUHH ztna CYfeTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <Pe.n;epaUHH», yraepxzreaaoro paCrrOp5I)KeHHeM IIpe3H.n;eHTa OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrn,» OT 21.07.2008 N221

r.MOCKBa

Pa6oYfa5I rpynna B COCTaBe:

Jlotiaerosa A.H.

I

·

·

Kapnosa C.A

Boaztapena A.IO.

i I

·

·

Senenaaa A.B.

COKonOBa A.II

PYCn5IKOBa H.M.

Ii II

)l(aB0pOHKOBa <P.E.

BOn5IHCKOrO II.,lJ;.

IOra5I C.H.

Tepexosa ,lJ;.A.

27.10.2008r.

3aMeCTHTen5I HaYfMbHHKa KOHTponbHo-aHMHTHYfeCKOrO orzrena cpHnHana 000 «Tpaacaeprs <DHHaHC»B r.ycpa

Hasansnmca orztena npanosoro H nopaaranaoro cOrrpOBO)l(,Il;eHH5I ToprOB OAO «AK «Tpancnedm,»

3aMeCTHTen5I zrapexropa zrenapraaeara OpraHH3aUHH H nposeneaaa ToproB OAO «AK «Tpaacneqrrr,»

Hasansnaxa rrpeTeH3HoHHO-HCKOBOH cnY)l(6bI Ilpasoaoro ynpasneaaa OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

Fnasnoro ropacxoacynsra rrpeTeH3HoHHO-HCKOBOH cnY)l(6bI IIpaBOBOrO ynpasneaaa OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrn,»

3aMecTluen5I zrapexropa zterrapraxeara «Cnyzfia 6e30rraCHOCTH» - aasansaaxa ornena 3KOHOMHYfeCKOH 6e30rracHocTH OAO «AK «TpaHCHecpTb»

I'nasnoro crreUHMHCTa orztena 3KOHOMHYfeCKOH fieaonacaocra OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

3aMeCTHTen5I HaYfMbHHKa npoaasozrcraenaoro orztena OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,»

3aMeCTHTen5I HaYfMbHHKa orztena nenonoro KOH1pOn5I saxynox MTP ynpasneaaa neaonoro KOHTPOn5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaeprs» 3aMeCTHTen5I HaYfMbHHKa ornena crparerasecxoro pa3BHTH5I OAO «AK «TpaHcHecpTb»

PaCCMOTpena H npoaaanaaapoaana sonpocsr, rrpenycaorpenasre sonpocoxr 6 «IIepeYfH5I MepOrrpH5ITHH rro cfiopy H nonrorosxe .n;OKYMeHTOB H HHcpopMaUHH .n;n5I CYfeTHOH rranaru POCCHHCKOH <De.n;epaUHH», YTBep)l(,1J;eHHOrO pacnopaacennea IIpe3H.n;eHTa OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,» OT 21.07.2008r. N221.

060CHOBaHHOCTh geH Ha MTP B nCll

B pasncax ztaanoro sonpoca nposenen aHMH3 npoexrao-cnerrroa .n;OKYMeHTaUHH B YfaCTH 06ocHoBaHHocTH onpeztenenas CTOHMOCTH MTP B CMeTHOH .n;oKYMeHTaUHH na 06'beKTbI CTpOHTenbCTBa TCBCTO.

1

I

,

.

i I

I

I

.

B Ka'1eCTBe .n;OKYMeHTa perJIaMeHTHpYIOIUerO nOp5I.n;OK orrpezrenemra CTOHMOCTH MTP B CMeTHOll .n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH npHH5ITa «MeTO.n;HKa onpenenerras CTOHMOCTH CTpOHTeJIbHOH rrpO.n;YKIJ;HH aa 'repparopaa POCCHHCKOH <De.n;epaIJ;HH» M,1J;C 81-35.2004, YTBep)K.D;eHHa5I rrOCTaHOBJIeHHeM rOCCTp05I POCCHH OT 05.03.2004 r. NQ1511 (nanee M)];C 81-35.2004).

Jlposenen BbI6opOqHbIH: aHaJIH3 JIOKaJIbHbIX CMeT co CTOHMOCTbIO ooopyzroaaans nOCTaBKH 3aKa3QHKa,HaJIH'1He 060cHOBbIBaIOIIJ;Hx .n;oKYMeHTOB H HX COOTBeTCTBHe YKa3aHHOll MeTo.n;HKe.

Paccvorperrsr cneztyromae rpyrmsr oriopyzrosaaaa:

1. Tpy6bI MamCTpaJIbHble, TeXHOJIOmQeCKHe.

2. <DacoHHble H3.n;eJIH5I.

3. OTBO.n;bI rnyrsre nna MafHCTpaJIbHbIX He<pTenpoBo.n;oB.

4. 3a.n;BH)I(KH C npHBo.n;aMH.

5. BJIOK-6oKCbI.

6. HaCOCbI.

7. Ka6eJIH H nposona.

8. <DHJIb'TpbI-rp5I3eYJIOBHTeJIH, KaMepbI npneva - nycxa CO)];.

9. CHcTeMbI aBTOMaTHKH.

10. 3JIeKTpOTeXHHQeCKOe ofiopyztonanae (KTIT, KPY, mCY).

11. BbICTPOB03Bo.n;HMble 3.n;aHH5I.

Pe3YJIhTaTbI aHaJIH3a:

1. ITo rpyrmav MTP: rpytisr MarHc'TpaJIbHble, rpytisr TeXHOJIOrH'1eCKHe, cpacoHHbIe H3.n;eJIH5I rpytiorrposozros, OTBO.n;bI rHYTbIe .n;JI5I MarHc'TpaJIbHbIX aeprenposonos, npenocraaneasr .n;OKYMeHTbI, nozrrsepacrarontae ofiocaosaanocrs onpeneneaas .CTOHMOCTH MTP B ITC,n; COOTBeTCTBYIOT M,n:C 81- 35.2004 n.4.24. Onpezteneaae CTOHMOCTH MTP npoH3Bo.n;HJIOCb no cpaKTH'1eCKoil: CTOHMOCTH (HMeIOTC5I B HaJIH'1HH npanC-JIHCTbI, KOMMep'1eCKHe npe.n;JIO)l(eHH5I npoassoznrrenea H rrOCTaBIIJ;HKOB).

2. ITo rpyrmasr MTP: 3a.n;BH)J(KH C npaaoztaxa, <DrY, KITIT CO,n;, 3JIeKTpOTeXHH'1eCKOe ofiopyztonamre (KTIT, KPY), 6bICTPOB03Bo.n;HMbIe 3.n;aHH5I - B KaQeCTBe nozrrsepamaronrax .n;OKYMeHTOB rrpencraaneasr KOMMepqeCKHe npennoxeaaa npOH3BO.D;HTeJIeH H nOCTaBIIJ;HKOB, QTO He npOTHBOpe'1HT M,n:C 81- 35.2004, ozraaxo ztaaasre npe.n;JIo)J(eHH5I 6bIDH aztpecosaasr B azipec 000 «WIT «BCTO» H nepeztansr B npoexrnyro OpraHH3au;HIO .n;JI5I onpezrenenaa CTOHMOCTH MTP 3aKa3QHKOM rrpoexra.

3. ITo rpyrmasr o60py.n;OBaHH5I: HaCOCbI Mam:cTpaJIbHbIe, HaCOCbI nozmopasre, 6JIOK-60KCbI, CHCTeMbI aBTOMaTHKH, CTOHMOCTb MTP B cMeTHoil: .n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH onpenenanacs opHeHTHpOBO'1HO na OCHOBe sxcrrepraoa OIJ;eHKH OAO «BHI1I1CT» (NQ 963-12439 OT 02.05.2008) aanpaaneaaoa B azrpec 000 «L(YII «BCTO», '1TO He COOTBeTcTByeT nn.4.24, 4.25, 4.48 M,n;C 81-35.2004.

Ilepenpoaepxa nen npoaanonareneit, BKJIIO'1eHHbIX B Peecrp TY H TT KOMrraHHH B COOTBeTCTBHH C CTT .n;JI5I BCTO H B nenax 2006 rozta CHJIaMH ynpaBJIeHH5I neaosoro KOHTPOJI5I HeB03MO)J(Ha.

4. B nponecce paccMOTpeHH5I cMeTHoH ,n;oKYMeHTaIJ;HH BbmBJIeHbI, T.H. «KOMnJIeKTHbIe nOCTaBKH». Cocras KOMnJIeKTHbIX nOCTaBOK, a TaK)J(e .n;oKYMeHTbI, nozrrsepactaronrae 060cHoBaHHocTb orrpezrenenaa HX CTOHMOCTH OTCYTCTByroT.

IIpHJIo)l(eHHe NQl

CrrpaBKa-OTQeT 0 rrpoaenennoxr aHaJIH3e npoexrao-cxreraca .n;oKYMeHTaU;HH B QaCTH 060cHoBaHHocTH onpeneneaaa CTOHMOCTH MTP B cMeTHoil: .n;OKYMeHTaIJ;HH na 06'beKTbI cTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO.

IIpHJIo)l(eHHe NQ2

B ITC,a He YCTpaHeHbI 3aMeQaHH5I no 06'beKTaM CB5I3H. TaK, B ITC,n; He rrpenycvorpeasr CKJIa.n;CKHe nOMeIIJ;eHH5I H MeCTa B rapasce .n;JI5I aBTOM06HrreH pcvoaraoa 6a3bI, aeofixoztaxnae )J;JI5I HOpMaJIbHOrO CPYHKU;HOHHpOBaHH5I 06'beKTOB CB5I3H. Cpezrcrsa, neofixozneasre TOJIbKO .n;JI5I .n;opa60TKH ITC,n; Ou;eHOQHO

2

I

·

I

I I

I

,

·

I

·

COCTaBHT 122 MJIH. py6J1eH. Kpoxre roro, rroTpe6YIOTcH ,n:orrOJIHHTeJI1Hhle sarparsr na saxynxy MTP H BbIIIOJ1HeHHH CMP na YKa3aHHhIX ofisexrax.

Ilepe-rem, 3aMeqaHHH npasenea B IIpHJIo)lwHHH NQ2.1

Ta6JIHI:(a aHaJIH3a 06ocHoBaHHocTH onpenenenna CTOHMOCTH. MTP B IIC~ na 4-x J1HCTax.

060CHOBaHHOCTb u,eH H3 MTP B ,goroBop3x no,gpH,g3

B paxrxax nannoro sonpoca rrposenen aHaJIH3 COOTBeTCTBHH CTOHMOCTH MTP B zrorosopax noztpazra PbIHOqHhIM rreaaa,

BKaqeCTBe 6a30BOro HCCJIe,n:OBaH KOHTpaKT C 3AO «Kpacaonapcrponrpancraa» OT 07.05.2006 NQ135-06 H ,n:orrOJIHHTeJ1hHlIe cornanreaas K HeMY rra npeznrer pa3,n:eJIeHHH HOMeHKJIaTypbI rrOCTaBKH Ilonpazrsaxa H 3aKa3qHKa H nposepxa COOTBeTCTBH5I nea aa MTP PhlHOqHhIM neaaa.

Pe3YJILT3TbI aHaJIH3a:

B IIpHJ1o)l(eHHH NQI0 K YKa3aRHOMY KOHTpaKry «Tpadrax rrOCTaBKH MaTepHaJIOB H otiopyzronaaaa 3aRa3qHKOM» CTOHMOCTb MaTepHaJIOB He YKa3aHa.

I1H<pOPM~HH 0 rrOCTaBKe MaTepI:IaJIOB H 060py,n:OBaHI:IH I10,n:PH,n:qHKOM, 06 I:IX CTOI:IMOCTH B KOHTpaKTeHe coztepaorrca, B rrepexae rrpHJIO)KeHHH K KOHTpaRTY ztanaoe rrpHJIO)KeHHe OTCYTCTByeT.

B CBH3H C OTCYTCTBHeM Heo6xo,n:I:IMhIX ,n:aRHhIX H cBe,n:eHHH nposecra nposepxy rrpaBI:IJIhHOCTI:I pa3.n;eJIeHHH HOMeHKJIaryphI rrOCTaBKH I10.n;pH,n:qJ:IKa H 3aKa3l1l:IKa B COOTBeTCTBI:IH C .n;eHcTByrom;I:IMH perJIaMeHTaMH OAO «AK» Tpaacneqm,» CHJIaMH yrrpaBJIeHI:I5I neaosoro KOHTPOJI5[ HeB03MO)KHO.

IIpI:IJIo)l(eHHe NQ3

Cnpaaxa-orner 0 nposeneaaou aHaJIH3eCOOTBeTCTBHH CTOI:IMOCTH MTP B zrorosopax noztpazta PbIHOqHOMY ypOBHIO. I1I:IChMO 000 «KO.,I1HBecT», HCX. NQ375/08 OT 29.08.08r.

BLIHBJIeHHe !lJaKTOB .llY6JIHpoBaHHH H 3a,1l;BoeHHH nOCTaBOK MTP 3aKa3qHKaMH H no,gpH/l,QHKaMH

B pasccax ztaanoro sonpoca nponeztea aHaJII:I3 B03MO)KHOCTI:I HaJII:IqI:I5I H 3a,n:BoeHI:I5I MaTepI:IaJIhHO-TeXHI:IqeCKHX pecypcos na 06'heKThI CTpOI:ITeJIbCTBa Tpyconpoaoznroa «BOCTO~as.r CH6HPh - THXI:IH OKeaR». B paspese IIo,n:pH.n;l1l:IK-3aKa3qI:IK.

Pe3YJILT3TLI aHaJIH3a:

rrOCTaBKH CI:ICTeMhI

B pe3YJIhTaTe aHaJIH3a COCTaBa I13C (rro06'heKTHaSI 3aKa3HaSI cnenadnrxanaa) BbISIBJIeHO, "'ITO

Ka)K.LJ:OH rr03H~HH npoexra (C60pHHKa crre~H<l>HKa~HH 060py,n:OBaHI:IH) rrpI:ICBaHBaeTCH I:IH,n:HBI:I.n;yaJIbHhIH meCTI:I3Ha1{HhIH H,n:eHTI:I<pHKaIJ;HOHHhIH HOMep (PID) H npa <pOPMI:IPOBaRHH I13C sazrsoeaae HeB03MO)KHO, TaR KaK PID ,n:JI5I Ka)l(.LJ:OH rr03HIJ;HHMTP HH,n:HBI:I.n;yaJIeH H HCKJIIO"'IaeT B03MO)l(HOCTh ,n:y6JII:IpOBaHHH.

Kpoxe roro, HH,n:HBH,n:YaJIhHhIH H,n:eHTH<pHKaI(HOHHhIH HOMep (PID) Ka)l(,n:OH rr03H~HH YKa3bIBaeTCH B KOHKYPCHOH ,n:OKYMeHTa:IJ;HH npa nposezteaaa TOprOB, B ztorosopax rrOCTaBKH (crre~I:I<pI:IKa~I:I5IX), B KOHTpaKTax na BhmOJIHeHI:Ie CTpOHTeJ1hHO-MOHTa)KHhIX pa60T (IIpHJIo)KeHI:Ie NQ10 «I1ocTaBKa 3aRa3tII:IKa» ), B rrepBH"'IHhIX 6yxraJITepCKI:IX ,n:OKYMeHTax, qTO B CBOID onepezrs TaK)Ke I:ICKJIIOqaeT B03MO)KHOCTh 3a,D;BoeHI:IH rr03HU:HH MTP.

06rn;ee KOJIHqeCTBO MTP ,n:JI51 CTpOHTeJIhCTBa 06'heKTOB TC BCTO COCTaBJIHeT 95 589 rr03I:I~HH(*):

3

I

,

I I

I

II 11

11 It

I

.

,

I1CXO,n:5I 1I3 COCTaBneHHbIX 113C H pa3,n:eJIHTeJIbHbIX Be,n:OMOCTeH nOCTaBI<H MTP H o60Py,n:OBaHlI5I 3aKa3'tJIIK-110,n:P5I,n:qIIK YCTaHOBJIeHO, qTO pacnpeneneane nocrasnaeaux na 06beKTbI BCTO MTP II o6opy,n:OBaHII5I cnenyromee:

rrOCTaBKa 3aKa3'tJHKa - 18 370 rr031I[(IIH, rrOCTaBKa 110,n:p5I,n:qHKa - 76 840 rr031I[(HH,

rrOCTaBKa MTP, IICKJIlO'tJeHHbIX B pe3YJIbTaTe 1I3MeHeHHH I1C,D; - 379 rr03H[(IIH (cBII,n:eTeJIbCTByeT 0 HH3KOM yposne pa3pa60TaHHOH npoexrrro CMeTHOH ,n:OKYMeHTa[(lIlI, 'tJTO npaserro K HaJIlIqHlO rreaocrpefiosanasrx MTP CM. paszten axra COOTBeTCTBHe nOCTaBJIeHHbIX MTP Tpe60BaHHHM nell H peaJIbHbIM nOTpe6HOCTHM.)

(*)Be3 ysera MTP na crpOIITeJIbCTBO 06beKTa «CMHI1 «K03bMIIHO» I1pIIJIO)I(eHlIe N24

Cnpasxa-or-rer 0 B03MO)l(HOCTII 3a,n:BoeHII5I rrOCTaBKII MaTepmUIbHO-TeXHHqeCKHX pecypcos aa 06beKTbI crpOIITeJIbCTBa Tpyoonposozraoa CIICTeMbI «BOCTO'tJHa5I ClI6lIPb - TIIXHH OKeaH».

AHaJIH3 ,llOrOBOpOB B 'IaCTH aBaHCHpOBaHHH H BbmJIaT no ,llOrOBopaM' H d!aKTH'IeCKOU: nOCTaBKH 060PYJlOBaHHH H MaTepHaJIOB

B paMKaX ,n:aHHoro Borrpoca rrpOBe,n:eH aHaJIlI3 ,n:orOBopOB B 'tJaCTII aBaHClIpOBaHIIH H BbIlIrraT rro ztoroaopan II cj:>aKTlIqeCKOH rrOCTaBKH o60py,n:OBaHH5I II MaTeplIaJIOB na 06beKTbI crponrem.crsa TCBCTO.

Pe3YJIbTaTbI aHaJIH3a:

TIo COCT05IHlIlO na 01.03.2008 HalI60JIbIIIHH y,n:eJIbHbIH nee B COCTaBe aBaHCOB asinaaasrx na rrOCTaBKY MTP COCTaBlliIIOT aBaHCbI, ssrzraaasre rro ztoroaopax rrOCTaBKII B azrpec 3AO «Coenaaaremasie OTBO,n:bI rpyoonposozroa» (nanee 3AO «COT») na rrOCTaBKY KOMrrrreKCHbIX HaCOCHbIX CHCTeM B CYMMe 2372 032,5 TbIC.py6. IIJIH 32,5% OT o6Il(eH CYMMbI aBaHCOB na rrOCTaBKY MTP (7304 175,2 TbIC.py6.).

1. BbIHBJIeHbI «i>aKTbI neofiocaoaanaoro ,lJ;JIHTeJIbHOrO aBaHcHpoBaHHH nOCTaBID;HKOB.

Y CTaHOBrreHbI cj:>aKTbI, xorzta napymeaae CPOKOB noranrenaa aBaHCOB OTHOCIITeJIbHO rrepsoaasansao 3aKITlO'tJeHHbIM zrorosopaa na rrOCTaBKY MTP rreraJIH30BaJIOCb nyrex 3aKJIlOtIeHH5I rronorrmrrem.ar,rx cornamenaa na nponneaae CPOKOB rrOCTaBKH II BbIlIOJIHeHH5I pafior, ,D;oKYMeHTaJIbHOe 06ocHoBaHHe npO,D;rreHH5I CPOKOB aBaHCHpOBaHHH OTCYTCTByeT.

CpOKH OTBJIe'tJeHH5I ,n:eHe)I(HbIX cpencrs rro BceM rrOCTaBIl(HKaM II rro,n:p5I,D;tIIIKaM B paspese zrorosopca crpaaceasr n (I1pIIJIO)I(eHHH N2 6).

B:bI5IBrreH:bI cj:>aKT:bI, xorna aBaHCbI Ha rrocTaBKY MTP COrJIaCHO ycrrOBIIHM nepBOHatIaJIbHbIX KOHTPaKTOB nsrztaaanacs na CpOK OT 3-x MeCH[(eB ,n:o 1 rona 6 MeCH[(eB, ztorromrarensasnra cornamenaaaa CPOKH norameaas aBaHCOB rrpO,D;IT5IJIHC:b aa CpOK OT 2-x MeC5Iu;eB zto 7-MH MeC5Iu;eB, T.e. cj:>aKTHtIeCKH CpOKII aBaHCHPOBaHlI5I COCTaBJIHIOT OT 5-MII MeC5I[(eB zto 2 JIeT.

Heo6xo,n:IIMOCT:b YCTaHOBJIeHIIH ,n:ITlITeJIbHbIX CPOKOB aBaHCHpOBaHHH 000 «I(YTI BCTO» 06bHcHHeTcH ,n:rrHTerr:bH:bIM TeXHOJIOmqeCKHM CPOKOM 1I3rOTOBJIeHlIH ofiopyztoaaana H CPOKaMlI ,n:OCTaBKH ero K MecTY Ha3HatIeHIIH. (I1pIIJIO)l(eHlIe N2 7).

AHaJIH3 B:bI,n:aHHbIX aBaHCOB no ztoroaopaa C 3AO «COT» B paspese crre[(H!jmKaU;HH npeztcraanea B Ta6JIHu;e: (I1pIIJIO)KeHlIe N2 8, I1pIIJIO)KeHlIe No 9).

4

I I

.

.

II 11

I I I

TIo COCT05IH11ID Ha 01.03.2008 ro.na cpaKTHtleCK11e CpOI<I1 aBaHcHpOBaH115I no .noroBopaM C 3AO «COT» COCTaBI1JII1 OT 305 zto 570 .nHeH: 11 pacnpeztcnanacs CJIe.nymIIJ:11M 06Pa30M'

jcPaKTHl.J Ilepaonaxansir CpOKH YBeJ1I1t[eHHe TIpH'-IHHa nepenoca CPOKOB aBaHCHpOBaHHH.
jeCKHH hIH CpOK asaaca aBaHCHpOBaHHH C CPOKOB
r--POK .ll.O MOMeHTa yseroa aBaHCHpOBaHfUl
JaBaHca nOCTaBKH (no npO,ll,JIeHID! no OTHOCMTeJlhHO
jHa Pa3JlH'-lHhIM non.cornaureaaa nepaonasam.nsrx
P1.03.08 cneum}JMKal\I1H M (no YCJlOBHH
1r.(,n:Hei1:) M) Pa3JlH'-lHhIM KOHrpaKTOB
cnenaeaxanaa»)
,ll;oroBop OT 26.05.2006 r. N~145-06J CYMMa asaaca na 01.03.08 r, - 1 836779,8 ThIC.Py6.,
570 OT 462 .ll.O 570 OT 570 ,n:o 723 OT 108 .ll.O 203 Baecenae H3MeHeHrrH B fpaqJMK MCIIblTaHMH,
.ll.Hei1: ,n:Hei1: .ll.HeH .ll.Hei1: nOCTaBKMM MOHTa)!(a HaCOCHhIX arperaros na HTIC2
(Ilnanoxenae N~ ] 0 11)
,ll;oroBop oT23.11.2006 N~307-063 cyMMa asanca na 01.03.08 r. - 380 880,3 ThIC.py6.,
403 282.ll.HH 213 .ll.Hei1: 495.ll.HeH Baecenae H3MeHeHHH B fpacpMK MCIIblTaHHH,
.ll.HH nOCTaBKH II MOHTa)!(a HaCOCHhIX arperaros na HTIC4
(DDHJlO)!(eHHe N~ 10 ill.
,ll;oroBop OT 16.03.07 N!!520 -oi CYMMa anaaca aa 01.03.08 r, - 154372,3 ThIC.py6.
305 OT 92 .ll.O 245 OT 31 ,n:o 243 OT 214 .ll.O 366 TIPH 3aKJUOQeHHH norosopa He 6blJlH cornacoaaasr
.ll.Hei1: ,n:Hei1: ,n:Hei1: ,n:Hei1: nonpocu, CBH3aHHhIe C paspafiorxoa
KOHCrpYKTOPCKOi1: M TeXH11t[eCKoi1: ,n:OKYMeHTaUHeH
Me)!(.LJ:Y 000 «WTI BCTO», OAO
«Fanporpytionposon» H 3AO «COT». Yxasaaasre «}1aKTbI CBH.r.eTeJIbCTBYIOT 0 aeofiocaoaaarrosr OTBJIeqeHHH neaeacasrx cpencra H3 060pOTa rrpennpaarna B .r.JIHTeJIbHOe aaaacnpeaanae rrocraannncon MTP, a 'raxace 0 He rrpHHHTHH Mep co CTOPOHhI 000 «l(YTI BCTO» K llOCTaBm:HKaM sa aapymeane CPOKOB rrOCTaBKH.

2. BhIHBJIeHhI «}1aKThI aecaoeepeaenaoa rrOCTaBKH MTP, qTO rrOBJIeKJIO aa C060H necaoeapesrennoe saxpsrrae aBaHCOB, paaee BbI.r.aHHbIX Ilocraamaxaa.

2.l._B napynreaae n.5.2.6 ztoroaopa OT 26.05.2006 NQ1457-06 arrorosopa OT 16.03.07 r. NQ 520-078 B YCTaHOBJIeHH:bIH: CpOK He.r.onOCTaBJIeHO ofiopyaoaanae na CyMMy 1 585 125,9 ThIC.py6. CpOKH rrOCTaBKH rro pa3JIHqHhIM crreUH«}1HKaUHHM aapymeasr OT 29.r.o 91.r.HH.

CYMMa He CBoeBpeMeHHO 3aKphITbIX aBaHCOB (OTHOCHTeJI:bHO Tparpaxos nOCTaBKH C yqeTOM npO,Il;JIeH115I CPOKOB no YCJIOBH5IM zron.cornamemrit) no zroroaopaa IIOCTaBKH, 3aKJIlOqeHHbIM C 3AO «Coe,Il;I1H1:ITeJI:bH:ble OTBO,Il;:bI Tpy6onpOBO,Il;OB» no COCT05IHHID aa 01.03.08 rona COCTaBJI5IeT 475537,8 ThIC.py6.

2.2. BhIHBJIeHbI «}1aKTbI He npezn.annenaa rrOCTaBII(HKaM illTpa«}1HhIX caHKUHH sa HeHCrrOJIHeHHe YCJIOBHH KOHTpaKTOB ua rrOCTaBKY MTP.

J ,ll;oroBop nOCTaBKH OT 25.05.06 rona na nOCTaBKY KOMnJleKCHbIX HaCOCHhlX CHCTeM, JlOT N!!MTO-2.1. 2 I'paipax cornacosaa H nanpaanen nHCbMoM AK «TH» N!!06-02/16225 OT 07.12.2007 rozta,

3 ,ll;orOBop nOCTaBKM OT 23.11.2006 N!!307-06 aa nOCTaBKY ofiopyztonaana CHCTeMbI )!(H,n:KOCTHOro OXJla)!(,UeHID! MamCTpaJIhHhIX HaCOCOB, JlOT 2.30.

4 Fpatpnx cornacosan H aanpaanea nMCbMOM AK «TH» NQ06-02/16225 OT 07.12.2007 rona,

5 ,ll;oroBop nOCTaBKM OT 16.03.2007 rozra NQ520-07 aa nocrasxy CHCTeM Bo,n:OOXJla)!(,UeHI1H HTIe.

6 TI.5.2 THnOBhIX KOHrpaKTOB sa nOCTaBKY MTP YKa3hIBaeT: «TIocTaBKe no nacroxnreay ,ll;OroBOpy nO,ll,JIe)!(I1:T TIpO,n:YKUHH cornacao HOMeHKJlaType B CpOKH, no CTOHMOCTM H no peKBH3HTaM, YKa3aHHhIM B Cneum!JHKal\I1HX, HBJlHIOmllXCR HeOTbeMJleMoi1: t[aCTbIO HaCTOJImerO ,ll;oroBopa».

7 ,ll;oroBop nOCTaBKH OT 25.05.06 N!!]45-06 sa nOCTaBKY «Koxrnnexcnsrx HaCOCHbIX CHCTeM» JlOT N!!MTO-2.1. 8 ,ll;oroBop nOCTaBKH oTI6.03.2007 N!!520-07 aa nocrasxy CHCTeM BO.ll.OOXJla)!(,UeHMJI HTIC.

5

11 II

I I I

II I

I II

11 I

I JJ

I

.

I 11

I Il

Ii 11

B napymenae Tpe60BaHHH n.16.1.1.9 YKa3aHnbIX ,lJ;OrOBOpOB nOCTaBKH 000 «:U;YIT BCTO»ne npe,lJ;MIBJICHbI ITocTaBm.HKY Tpc60naHHH 06 ynnare HeycToHKH aa npOCpOTJeHHylO nocrasxy B cyMMe 7 718,6 TbIC. py6. CM. (ITpIlJIOll(eHHe X!! 12)

TIp11JIO)l(eH11e N!6

Cnpasxa-or-rer 0 npOBe,n;eHHOM ananase noronopos B qaCTH aBaHCHpOBaHlUI H BbIIIJIaT no zrorosopaa

H <paKTHqeCKOM nOCTaBKH o6oPy,n;OBaHH5I 11 MaTepHaJIOB na 06beKTbI CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO.

TIpHJIO)l(eH11e N26

ABaHCbI, BbI,lJ;aHHble ~YTI BCTO aa CTpOHTeJIbCTBO TC BCTO no HHBeCTHIl;HOHHOMY zrorosopy 25- 0112006/114-06 OT 20.04.06r. (no COCT05IHHIO na 01.03.2008r.).

TIpHJIO)l(eHHe N27

TI05ICHHTeJIbHa5I 3anHCKa zrapearopa no KOMnJIeKTaIl;HH ~YTI «BCTO».

TIpHJIO)l(eHHe N28

AHaJIH3 aBaHCOB, BbI,lJ;aHHbIX 000 "~YTI BCTO" no ztorosopaa nOCTaBKH 3AO "Coenaaarensnne OTBO,n;bI rpytionposonoa" na 01.03.08r.

TIpHJIO)l(eHHe N29

Ta6JIFIIl;a cpaBHeHHH CYMMbI OCTaTKa asanca, nepeqHCJIeHHOrO 000 "WTI BCTO" 3AO "COT", co cpoxaaa nOCTaBKH B paspese cneU;H<pHKaIJ;HM K ztorosopaa no COCTOHHHIO aa 01.03.2008

ITpHJIO)l(eHHe N21 0

CJIY)l(e6Ha5I 3anHCKa zrapexropa no KOMnJIeKTau:HH WTI «BCTO».

ITpHJIO)l(eHHe N211

IToHcHHTeJIbHbIe 3arrHCKH zrapexnaa no KOMIIJIeKTaIJ;HH WIT «BCTO».

ITpHJIO)l(eHHe N212

Ta6JIHIl;a pacsera HeycToHKH no npOCpOqeHHbIM nOCTaBKaM 3AO "COT" no COCT05IHHIO aa 01.03.2008.

COOTBeTCTBHe nOCTaBJIeHHbIX MTP Tpe60BaHHHM ITCll H peaJIbHhIM nOTpe6HocTHM. HaJlHqHe ,l!OKYMeHTaUHH, nO,l!TBepm,l!alOmeH npoHcxogeHHe H KaqeCTBO MTP

B paxncax .n;aHHOrO sonpoca rrposeztea aHaJIH3 HaJIHqH5I HeJIHKBH,n;HbIX 3anaCOB na ofisexrax TC «BCTO» 11 HaJI11TJH5I .n;OKYMeHTaIl;HH, nozrraepamaronrea npOHcxo)l()J;eHHe H KaTJeCTBO MTP, rrOCTaBJIeHHbIX na 06'beKTbI TC «BCTO».

Pe3YJIbTaThI ananaaa:

1. HaJIHTJHe HeBocTpe6oBaHHbIX sanacon MTP na cxnaztax.

B pe3YJIbTaTe H3MeHeHH5I npoexrasrx pemeaaa no PMY 06'beKTOB TC «BCTO» aa cxnanax 06Pa30BaJIHCb OCTaTKH MaTepHaJIbHbIX nenaocrca, xoropsre no COCTOHHHIO aa ztary npoaezreaas nposepxa He HamJIH cnoero npHMeHeHH5I na ofisexrax TC «BCTO».

06m;a5I CT011MOCTb rrOCTaBJIeHHOrO H He BOCTpe6oBaHHOrO na HaCT05IlIl;11H MOMeHT o6opy.n;OBaHH5I 11 MaTepHaJIOB COCTaBHJIa 81,9 MJlH. py6J1eii. ITo HOMeHKJIaType aenocrpetiosaaasre MaTepHaJIbI rrpe.n;cTaBJI5IIOT C060H:

• Tpy6H)'IO npozryxumo Pa3JIHqHOrO ,n;HaMeTpa 584 xrerpa,

9 n. 16.1.1. «B cnysae aapymeaas CPOKOB nOCTaBK11 npO,!(YK~1111, YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX B HaCTOlII~eM ,ll;oroBope, Iloxynarens snpaae npezrsasnrs nOCTaB~11KY Tpe60BaH11e 06 ynnare HeycTOHK11, a nOCTaB~11K 06JI3aH TaKOeTpe6oBaH11e y,!(OBneTBOp11Tb 113 pacsera 0,05% sa Ka)K'!(bIH ,!(eHb rrpOCpO'lK11 nOCTaBKI1, HO He fiorree 5% OT CTOI1MOCT11 nenonocraaneaaof npO,!(YK~11I1. BbITIJIaTa TaKOH HeycTOHK11 JIBnHeTCJI ero nonaon 11 e'!(I1HcTBeHHoH MepoH OTBeTCTBeHHOCT11 sa YKa3aHHYIO npocpoxxy».

6

I

I II

I

·

·

I

·

II I

I

·

,

I

·

• zreramr rpyfiorrpoaozros 18 e,n;HHHI( ( coeaaaarem.nsre zterana, ,n;HHII(a H r.n.)

• Ka6enbHYIO rrp0,lJ;yKI(HIO 23.1 KM

• MexaHO-TeXHOnOmqeCKOe otiopynosanae 44 e,n;HHHI(bI

• 3JIeKTpOTeXHHqeCKOe ofiopyaonanne H MaTepHMbI - 714 e,n;HHHI( ( pasnaxaorc pona BbIKnIOqaTenH, pene H r.n.)

• nposne MTP - 2116 e,lJ;HHHI( na 06II(YIO CYMMY 7.8 MJIH.py6neM , qTO COCTaBlliIeT 9 % OT scex MTP He nameznnax B HaCT05III(HM: MOMeHT rrpHMeHeHH5I aa ofrsexrax BCTO.

IhMeHeHHe npoeicrnsrx pemennti B xone npOBe,lJ,eHHH CTpOHTeJIhHO-MOHTaIKHhIX pa60T BhI3BaHO HH3KHM ypOBHeM pa3pa60TaHHOH npoex'rne-csreraoti ,lJ,OKYMeHTanHH co CTOPOHhI OAO BHHHCT - HBJIHBmHMCH renepansm.nr npoeKTHpoBIllHKOM no 06beKry.

TaK, B COOTBeTCTBHH C aKTOM 3KcnepTH3bI upoexrao-caeraoa ,n;oKYMeHTaI(HH no 06beKTaM TC BCTO B qaCTH CHcTeM CB5I3H K pa3pa60TaHHoM .n;OKYMeHTaI(HH 6bmo BhIHBJIeHO 721 3aMeQaHHe, npHqeM H3 HHX 17 HBJIHIOTCH rpy6eilmHMH H CB5I3aHbI C HeBbIIIonHeHHeM Tpe60BaHHM T3 H HopMaTHBHbIX ,n;OKYMeHTOB.

TIpHnO)KeHHe N213a

AKT 3KcnepTH3bI npoexrao-cxeraoa .n;OKYMeHTaI(HH no 06'beKTaM TC BCTO B qaCTH CHcTeM CB5I3H npoaeneaaoa OAO «CB5I3hTpaHCHe<iJTb»

Hoxemorarypa MTP He namezmrax B HaCT05IlI(HM MOMeHT npHMeHeHH5I aa ofisexrax BCTO MO)KeT 6bITb npaaeneaa na ofisetcrax, KaK BCTO, TaK H aa 06'beKTaX KOMnaHHH.

BMeCTe C TeM OTMeqeHO, qTO B xozre paspsrsa KOHTPaKTOB na npOH3Bo,n;CTBO CTpOHTenbHOMOHTa)KHbIX pa60T no 06'beKTaM TC BCTO C 3AO «KpaCHo.n;apC1pOMTPaHCra3» 6bID YCTaHOBneH QlaKT HMHqH5I MaTepHMOB H o6opy,n;OBaHH5I, rrepezaaaorc 3aKa3quKOM nonpazrsnxy, HO He HCnOnb30BaHHOrO HM npa rrpOH3Bo.n;CTBe pa60T, qTO caazrerenscrsyer 0 He,n;OCTaTOqflOM xonrporre co CTOPOHbI 3aKa3qHKa sa nepenasea .n;aBMbqeCKHX MaTepHMOB.n;lliI rrpOH3Bo.n;CTBa CMP.

TIo HCKOBOMY 3a5IBneHHIO IJ;YI1 «BCTO» 0 paCTOp)KeHHH KOHTPaKTOB na nposeneaae CMP

cynefiaoe pa36HpaTeJIbCTBO He sasepmeao.

Kpoue roro rro pe3YJIbTaTaM npoaezreansrx KOHKYPCOB nOCTaBKa scex MTP H ooopynoaaana no 06beKTaM, na KOTOPbIX nposozranacs rrposepxa OCYlI(eCTBlliIJIaCb 13 KOMrrJIeKCHbIMH rrOCTaBII(HKaMH C 061I(HM 06'beMOM nOCTaBKH 148,5 MJIp.n;. py6JIeM., rrpHqeM orzrensnsre xoxmnexcasre nOCTaBII(HKH oCYlI(eCTBlliIJIH rrOCTaBKY MTP cosepmeaao Pa3JIHqflOM HOMeHKnaTypbI, TaK 000 TI1K «HrC» - nOCTaBlliIJIO: xaxepsr npaeva nycxa, pesepsyapsr, <iJHJIbTPbI, MexaHO-TeXHOJIOrHqeCKOe ofiopyzronaaae, ofiopynosaaae 3X3, snemaee 3HeprOCHa6)KeHHe, H T . zr, na 061I(yIO CYMMY - 10,5 MJIP.n;. pyfinea,

OTCYTcTBHe HMHqu5I rrOCTaBII(HKOB, crreI(HaJIH3HPYIOII(HXC5I na KOHKpeTHoM sane rrpoztyxnaa, HMeIOII(HX Ha,n;e)KHbIX napraepos H zronrocpo-msre KOHTPaKTbI C KOMnJIeKTOBII(HKaMH OTpHI(aTeJIbHO OTPa3HJIOCb aa cpoxax BbIIIOJIHeHH5I KOHTPaKTOB na rrOCTaBKY MTP.

2. Hamrtae ,n;OK)'MeHTaI(HH, nozrrsepzoiaromea nponcxozcreaae H KaqeCTBO MTP.

B I(eJI5IX ofiecrreseaaa COOTBeTCTBH5I xanecraa nocraanaeaoro MTP .n;lliI KOMrrJIeKTaI(HH 06'beKTOB cTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO Tpe6oBaHH5IM HopMaTHBHo - TeXHHqeCKOM ,n;oKYMeHTaI(HH OAO «AK «TpaHCHe<iJTb» BC5I nocrasnaeaaa npozryxnaa npoxozrana HeCKOJIbKO 3TarrOB KOHTPOlliI xa-recrna.

TIPOH3BO,n;CTBO MTP oCYII(eCTBJI5IJIOCb rro TeXHHqeCKHM YCJIOBH5IM 3aBo,n;OB - H3roToBHTeJIeM

BKJIIOqeHHbIM B «Peecrp TY H I1MM» OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqrrs»: ¢>YHKI(HH no Be,n;eHHIO H OI(eHKe COOTBeTCTBH5I (sxcrreprase) TY H I1MM na OCHOBHble BH,n;bI nponyxnaa HopMaTHBHbIM ,n;OKYMeHTaM, rrpHMeH5IeMbIM B CHCTeMe OAO «AK «Tpaacnerprs» B03JIO)KeHbI B HacToHII(HM MOMeHT na OAO «I'anporpyoonponozt» (panee na DAD «BHMMCT).

Ilponecc rrpOH3Bo,n;CTBa ofiopynosaaaa ua 3aBo.n;aX-H3rOTOBHTelliIX B qaCTH KOHTPOJI5I

TeXHOJIOmqeCKOrO npouecca H3rOTOBJIeHH5I KOHTPOJIHPOBMC5I TeXHHqeCKHM Ha,n;30POM 000 «IJ;YII

7

I

It I

I

.

I

I

.

II 1M

I

..

BCTO». Kpoxie TOrO )])151 ocy:w:eCTBneHI15I TeXHI1QeCKOrO aansopa sa rrpOIJ;eCCOM npOH3BO,n:CTBa na 3aBO,n:aX H3rOTOBHTen5IX npasnexanacs nonpazmaa OpraHH3aIJ;H5I OAO «BHI1I1CT-,IJ.HarHOCTHKa» H B HaCT05I:W:HH MOMeHT 000 «I(eHTp MO» (npaxas OAO «AK «Tpancnedrn,» N2156 OT 2l.12.2007) B paxrxax 3aKmOQeHHOrO ztoroaopa, TeXHHYfeCKHe CneIJ;HanHCT11 000 «I(YI1 BCTO», 000 «BOCTOKHerpTenpOBO,n:», ,IJ.AO MH.

B "LIaCTHOCTH TaKa5I nposepxa ocynrecrananacs na rpytiasrx 3aBO,n:aX: Qen5I6HHCKHH

Tpy60npoKaTHbIH 3aBO,n:, B1>IKCYHCKHH Tpy6HbIH 3aBO,n:, I1)KOPCKHH Tpy6HbIH 3aBO,n:, KHTaHCKHe rpyfinsre 3aBO,n:bI JULONG Steel Pipe, W ANCHI Steel Pipe. Kpoxe TOro, KOMHCCH5IMH B COCTaBe crreIJ;HMHCTOB OAO «AK «Tpancaerprs» ,n:OYfepHHX 06:w:ecTB H I(YI1 BCTO rrpHHHMaJIOCb ooopynosaaae HMnopTHoro npoassoncrsa na sasonax H3roToBHTen5IX, 3TO MarncrpMbH1Ie HaCOCHble arperarsr, sanopao-perynapyromaa apxrarypa (3a.D:BH)KKH), aBTOHOMHa5I nasensaaa 3JIeKTpOCTaHIJ;H5I H r.zt, IIpHeMKa 060py,n:OBaHH5I nozrrsepzoreaa aKTaMH YCTaHOBJIeHHOrO c.popMaTa.)

Ilposeneaae sxoztaoro KOHTPOn5I onpezteneao HopMaTHBH1IMH ,n:OKYMeHTaMH OAO «AK

«Tpancaedrrs» (CTT, OTT). BXO,n:HOH KOHrpOJIb BKnIDYfan B ce65I nposepxy KOMnneKTHOCTH nOCTaBKH, nposepxy 3KCnJIyaTaIJ;HOHHOH H pa3penIHTeJIbHOH ,n:OKYMeHTaIJ;HH na rrpezruer ee nOJIHOTbI, a. TaK)Ke Pa3JIHYfHble BH,n:11 KOHTPOn5I - BH3yanbHbIH, HHcrpYMeHTanbHbIH, HCnblTaHH5I na repMeTHYfHOCTh H ztp,

I10 pe3YJIbTaTaM sxozraoro KOHrpOn5I COCTaBn5IJIHCb aKT1I, Oc.popMn5IJIaCb npaesoca nOCTaBJIeHHOrO MTP H OpraHH30BbIBanaCb nocJIe,n:YIO:W:a5I nepenaxa no,n:p5I,n:HOH cTpOHTeJIbHOH opraHH3aIJ;HH ,n:n5I BOBneQeHH5I B MOHTa)K.

BMeCTe C TeM B xozre rrposezreaaa nYCKO-Hana,n:OYfHbIX H ranpoacnsrraaati CHCTeM HI1C 6hill 06HapY)KeH ,n:ec.peKT nacoca MHA N21 HIIC N24 npOH3Bo,n:CTBa rpHPMhI Sulzer Pumps nOCTaB:W:HK 3AO «COT». BWIBJIeHHhIH ,n:erpeKT rpeoyer 3aMeHhI nacoca. CTOHMOCTh HaCOCHoro arperara 50 MJIH. py6JIeH.

,D;aHHhIH CJIy-qaH cBH.n:eTeJIhCTByeT 0 He KaYfeCTBeHHO npOBe,n:eHHOM BXO,n:HOM KOHTpOJIe H nposezteaaa npHeMO"LIH1IX HCIIhITaHHH aa 3aBO.1l:e H3rOTOBHTeJIe npe,n:CTaBHTeJI5IMH3aKa3"LIHKa.

IIpHno)KeHHe N213

CI1P ABKA no HanH"L{J:IIO HeJIHKBH,n:HbIX (He nameznnax B HaCTOH:w:ee BpeMH npHMeHeHHH) 3anaCOB aa 06"beKTax TC «BCTO».

IIpHJIo)KeHHe N214

CI1PABKA no HMHYfHIO .n:OKYMeHTaIJ;HH, nozrrecpaoiaromea npOHCXO)K,lJ;eHHe H Ka"LIeCTBO MTP, nOCTaBJIeHHbIX na 06"beKTbI TC «BCTO».

3KOHOMHQeCKaH 060CHOBaHHOCTh 3aKYITKH HM)'meCTBa ITO llorOBopaM JIH3HHra B lleJIOM ITO CTpYKTYpe OAO <<.AK<<TpaHCHeWTh» (B pa3pe3e llorOBopOB H 06"heKTOB)

B paaxax ,n:aHHOrO sonpoca nposeztea aHMH3 3KOHOMHYfeCKOH 060CHOBaHHOCTH IIPOH3Be.n:eHHbIX 3aKynoK no JIH3HHrOBbIM ,n:orOBOpaM .

Pe3YJIhTaThI aHaJIH3a:

I10CTaBKa B 2006-2007 rr. npe.n:npH5ITH5IM CHCTeMbI OAO «AK «Tpancnedm,» no JIH3HHry TeXHHKH H 060py.n:OBaHH5I ocy:w:eCTBnHJIOCb no sapanee rpopMHpyeMbIM nJIaHaM nOCTaBKH, rrpezmonarasmaa 060cHoBaHHe norpefiaocrn B ,n:aHHbIX BH,n:ax MTP no Ta6eJIHM OCHa:w:eHHOCTH C yaerora BbI6bITHH aHanOrHYfHOH TeXHHKH H 060py,n:OBaHH5I scnezrcrane rpH3HYfeCKOrO H MopMbHoro asaoca, a TaK)Ke 06eCneYfeHHOCTH c.pHHaHCOBbIMH cpezicrsaaa.

B TO)Ke BpeM5I HMeIOTC5I ornensasre napraa MTP, nOCTaBJIeHHble BHe YKa3aHHOH cxexre, a HMeHHO:

8

I I

,

.

I I

11 I

I

II II

I

I

,

I R

I II

- eznorcspexreaasre 3aICyrrKI:I TeXHHKI:I ,lJ;JI5I Hy)i(,lJ; 000 «IJ;YIT «BCTO» (npmrensr-drypronu, nerxossre

aBTOM06HJIH, MHKpOaBT06YCbI, oprrexamca H rrp. ,lJ;JI5I 06eCrre1:JeHH5I ,n:e5ITeJIbHOCTH llITa60B

CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO). ITocTaBKI:I ocy:ru:eCTBJI5IJIHCb TOJIbICO B 2006 rozty;

- enanonpeeremnre saxynxa xpynnux naprnii CneU;HaJIH3HpOBaHHoH H cTpOHTeJIbHOH TeXHHKH ,lJ;JI5I 000 «Bocroxnedrrenponon» (80 en. CaMOCBaJIOB KAMA3-6522, 100 en. aBTOnOe3,lJ;OB Tpy6011JIeTen03HbIX B COCTaBe T5I:ra1:Ja YpaJI-4402 H npauenos-pocnycxoa), xoropsre HCnOJIb30BaJIHCb u;eJIeBbIM Ha3Ha1:JeHHeM ,lJ;JI5I npOH3BO,lJ;CTBa pa60T na ofisexrax CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO na Y1:JaCTKax OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH nO,lJ;p5I,lJ;'llIKOB. C Y1:JeTOM T5I)KeJIbIX YCJIOBHH 3KCnJIyaTaU;HH, nOCT05IHHOH CMeHHOCTH BO,lJ;HTeJIbCKOrO COCTaBa Ho6'beKTHBHbIX rpyaaocrea C 06CJIY)I(lIBaHHeM TeXHHKH B MaJIOOCBOeHHbIX paaoaax 5IKYTHH ,lJ;aJIbHeHIIIee HCnOJIb30BaHHe ,n:aHHOH TeXHHKH B npezmpaaraax CHCTeMbI OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,» npe,lJ;CTaBJI5IJIOCb nenenecooopasmra. 113 nOCTaBJIeHHbIX TpeXCTa e,lJ;HHHU; ,lJ;BeCTH IIIeCTb,lJ;eC5IT e,lJ;HHHU; 6bIDH BnOCJIe,lJ;CTBHH (rpespans 2008 r.) nepenaasr no comaIIIeHH5IM 0 saveae CTOPOHbI JIH3HHrOnOJIY1:JaTeJI5I B ztoroaope JIH3HHra (rrepeaaera) 3AO «KpaCHO,lJ;apCTpOHTpaHCra3- BOCTOK»;

- 3aKynKH He60JIbIIIHX naprna ztoporocrosmea T5I)KeJIOH c1poHTeJIbHOH TeXHHKH H

CneU;HaJIH3HpOBaHHoro CBap01:JHoro 060py,n:oBaHH5I OAO «BoJI)KCKHH rronsozmax» (cyfinozrpazrrax na cTpOHTeJIbCTBe TC BCTO), OAO «Tpaaccafiaedm,» H OAO «Bepxnenonsccxaerprenpoaon», xoropue nepeztasanacs ,n:01:JepHHM ofintecraax ,n:JI5I BbIIIOJIHeHH5I nozrpannsrx pa60T na 06'beKTax TC BCTO (000 «OMcKHe<pTera3CrreU;1pOH» H 000 «Bonraaeprerascrrencrpoa»), no 3aBepIIIeHHH rroztpaaasrx pa60THa cTpOHTeJIbCTBe TC BCTO rrpezrnonaranocs ztansneamee HCnOJIb30BaHHe B OAO «Tpaaccafiaedrrs», OAO «Bepxaeaonxcxaeqrrerrpoaozt» H OAO «BOJI)KCKHH nO,lJ;Bo,n:HHK».

ITo YCJIOBH5IM 3aKJII01:JeHHbIX ztoronopos JIH3HHra cpe,n:H5I5I CTaBKa y,n:opO)KaHH5I npezoreroa JIH3HHra Haxo,n:HTC5I aa yposae 29,5%. ,[(aHHbIH yposeas, HCXO,n:5I H3 CPOKOB JIH3HHra, 5IBJI5IeTC5I PbIH01:JHbIM. O,n:HaKO, YCJIOBH5IMH JIH3HHroBbIX KOHTpaKTOB, 3aKJII01:JeHHbIX C OAO «C,[(M-JIH3HHD>, npeztycnorpeao aBaHCHpOBaHHe JIH3HHrOBOH KOMrraHHH na CyMMy B 30% OT CTOHMOCTH npezerera JIH3HHra, YKa3aHHOH B HOMepHoM ,n:onOJIHeHHH (HJIH OT 16 zto 25% OT coaoxyrraoii C)'MMbI JIH3HHrOBbIX nJIaTe)KeH) na CpOK OT 1 MeC5Iu;a ,lJ;0 1 rona, I1Ha1:Je roBOP5I, ofimecraa rpynrrsr «Tpaacaedrrs» BCEf,[(A Kpe,n:HTyIOT JIH3HHrOBYIO KOMrraHHIO na 30% OT CTOHMOCTH 060PY,lJ;OBaHH5I, rrpezmonaraeeroro K rrOJIY1:JeHHIO B JIH3HHr.

TaKHM 06Pa30M, rrOCT05IHHOe OTBJIeqeHHe ,n:eHe)KHbIX Cpe,lJ;CTB rpynnsr «Tpaacnedm,» na aBaHCHpOBaHHe JIH3HHroBoro 060PY,lJ;OBaHH5I TOJIbKO sa nepaozt C 01.01.2007 r. rro 01.03.2008 r. COCTaBHJIO nopaznca 2 444 - 3 228 MJIH. py6. ITPH 3TOM c)'MMa ynYII(eHHOH BbITO,lJ;bI, H3 pacsera 8% rO,lJ;OBbIX npa pasxemeaaa YKa3aHHOH C)'MMbI na 6aHKoBcKOM ,lJ;en03HTe, COCTaBHJIa He MeHee 288,8 MJIH. py6.)

Kposre Toro, B nepasre ,n:Ba MeC5Iu;a JIH3HHra ,lJ;OnOJIHHTeJIbHO OnJIa1:JHBaeTC5I erne OT 15 ,lJ;0 30% JIH3HHrOBbIX nJIaTe)KeH. ITo BbI60p01:JHbIM ,lJ;aHHbIM, B nepssra rozt JIH3HHra OrrJIa1:JHBaeTC5I ,lJ;0 91 % CTOHMOCTH 060py,n:oBaHH5I. AHaJIH3 nea na 060pY,lJ;OBaHHe C Y1:JeTOM TpaHCnOpTHbIX paCXO,lJ;OB, npencrasneaasrx OAO «C,[(M-JIH3HHD> H nen na ofiopyzrosaaae, YKa3aHHbIX B TOBapHbIX HaKJIa,n:HbIX rrOCTaB:ru:HKOB (6e3 Y1:JeTa TpaHCrrOpTHbIX pacxozros) BbI5IBHJI 3aBbIIIIeHHe nen nOCTaBKH OAO «C,[(MJIH3HHD> 13 cpaBHeHHH C <paKTH1:JeCKHMH nenaxa, no KOTOPbIM rrpOH3BO,lJ;HJIaCb saxynxa y rrOCTaBm:HKOB 060py,n:oBaHH5I npaaepao na 10%-12%. B arore, cYMMa3aBblmeHHJI CTOHMOCTH JIH3HHrOBoro HMYm:ecTBa COCTaBJIJleT He MeHee 1 419 MJIH. py6.

,[(aJIbHeHIIIee ynopoxaaae JIH3HHrOBoro 060py,n:OBaHH5I rrpOHCXO,lJ;HT BCJIe,lJ;CTBHe rtpH06peTeHH5I npezereron JIH3HHra sa C1:JeT 3aeMHbIX openers, nOJIY1:JaeMbIX OAO «AK «Tpaacrretpre» B pavxax CPHHaHCHpOBaHH5I HHBecTHU;HoHHOH ,lJ;e5ITeJIbHOCTH ,lJ;0 aeztaarrero BpeMeHH non 6,8% rononsrx. I1ocTaBJI5IeMa5I JIH3HHrOBa5I TeXHHKa, cpaKTH1:JeCKOe y,n:opO)KaHHe KOTOPOH COCTaBJI5IeT 36.3 % (29,5% H 6,8%), rrpe,n:oCTaBJI5IeTC5I B apenzry rro,n:p5I,lJ;HbIM opraHH3aU;H5IM C y6bITKaMH BBH,n:y HeB03MO)KHOCTH YCTaHOBJIeHH5I apeaznron rrnarsr, noxpuaaromea JIH3HHroBbie rrJIaTe)KH.

Ilposenea aHaJIH3 3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH 3aKJII01:JeHHbIX zroroaopoa JIH3HHra zrsyx CaMbIX xpyrmsrx rpynrr o6opY,lJ;OBaHH5I, B cpaBHeHHH C rrp5IMOH saxynxof 06opy,n:oBaHH5I na saeraasre cpeztcrsa:

9

1 rpyrma - ofiopyzrosaane co CPOKOM m:I3HHra 21 Mec. C o6beMoM JIM3MHrOBhlX IIJIaTe)l{eH 4 117 117 221 py6. C H,ZJ;C (3 489082391 py6. 6e3 H,ZJ;c)

l

~J

2 rpynna - oriopynoaaane co CPOICOM JIH3MHra 29 Mec. C 06beMOM C 06beMOM JIH3MHrOBhIX nJIaTe)KeH 12645761 323 py6. C H,ZJ;C (10716746884 py6. 6e3 H,ZJ;C)

KpMTepHeM OIJ;eHKH JIH31IHrOBoro KOHTpaKTa 5IBlliIeTC5I n0J10~HTeJ1hHa.H. BeJIHqHHa qHCTOH npanenenaoa CTOHMOCTH. ECJIli JI1I31IHr lIMeeT 0TPlIIJ;aTeJIhHYlO qlICTYIO rrpaseneaayro CTOMMOCTh, 3TO cBM,aeTeJIhCTByeT 0 He3cjJcjJeKTMBHoCTli ,aaHHoH cnenxa.

COrJIaCHO pacseraa, BbIIIOJIHeHHhIM B I1pMJIO)l{eHMlI N2 1,2 no ,aB)'M rpyrmau ooopyzrosanas co cpoxaua JI1I3MHra 21 H 29 Mec., nonyseso OTPMIJ;aTeJIhHOe saaaenae qHCTOH npaseneaaoa CTOliMOCTlI, qTO nOKa3bIBaeT nessrroztnocrr, 3aKJIlOqeHlI5I JI1I3HHrOBoro KOHTpaKTa, na YCJIOBlI5IX OAO «C,ZJ;Mfl1I3HHD> .

OAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» 1I ero ,aOqepHlIMH oonrecrsaaa rronansr HCKOBhle 3MBJIeHH5I 0 np1I3HaHHM

3aKJIIOqeHHbIX ztorosopos JI1I3MHra He,aeHcTBHTeJIbHbIMH, xoropsre B HaCT05Iru;ee BpeM5I

paccMaTpHBaIOTC5I B ap61ITpa)l{HOM cyzte r.Mocxsu. (rrpanoxenae N2 18a I:I N2186)

I1PMJIO)l{eHMe N215

Cnpasxa-or-rer na npezraer 3KOHOMlIqeCKOH ooocaonannocra npo1I3Be,aeHHhIX saxynox no JIM3MHroBbIM ,aoroBopaM.

I1pMJIO)l{eHlIe N216

3aBhIIIleHlIe CTOMMOCTli ooopynoaaaaa aa 12%.

IIpMJIo)l{eHMe N217

Ynynreaaaa ssrrozra B pe3YJIbTaTe OTBJIeqeHlI5I ,aeHe)l{HhIX cpeztcra na aaaacaposaaae.

IIplIJIO)l{eHMe N218

Pacser qlICTOH rrpaaeneaaon CTOHMOCTM JIM31IHra.

IIpMJIo)l{eHMe N218a, N2186

I1cICoBoe 3MBJIeHlIe KOMnaHMlI 1I ,ZJ;AO MH K OAO «C,ZJ;M-fl1I31IHr» 0 npM3HaHMM He,aeHcTBlITeJIbHhIMM ropros B BH,ae xoaxypca, npOTOKOJIa 0 pe3YJIbTaTaX ropros 1I zrorosopon, 3aKJII01:JeHHhIX no pe3YJIhTaTaM repros.

AHaJ1H3 3KOHOMH'IeCKOH 3d)(beKTHBHoCTH JlOrOBOpoB apeHJlhI TeXHHKH, 3aKynJ1eHHOH: no J1H3HHrOBhIM JlOrOBOpaM

B paxncax ,aaHHOrO sonpoca .rrposeztea aHaJI1I3 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 3cjJcjJeKTMBHoCTM zrorosopoa apeazrsr TeXHMKM, 3aKYIIJIeHHoi:i: no JIH3HHrOBhIM norosopaa.

Pe3YJ1hTaThI aHaJ1H3a:

OTKPhIThIMM aKIJ;MoHepHbIMH ofimecrsaxra CHCTeMhI MamCTpaJIhHhIX aedrrenpoaoztoa «AK «Tpaacaedrrs» sa nepaozr C nepsoro nonyronaa 2006r. no 2008r. B o6ru;ei:i: CJIO)l{HOCTH 6hIJIO HanpaBJIeHO na CTPOHTeJIbCTBO TC «BCTO» 727 e,aHHMIJ; JIH3HHrOBoro HMyru;ecTBa na 06ru;yIO CyMMy 2 444 195,0 ThIC. py6.

B TOM qHCJIe no zrorosopaa apenzrsr H OKa3aHHlO rparrcrroprnsrx ycrryr 6hIJIO sazreacraoaaao 570 e,aHHHIJ; na 06ru;yIO CyMMy 1 851 295,6 ThIC.py6. OCTaJIbHM qaCTh JIM3HHrOBoro HMyru;ecTBa 6hIJIa saaeacrsoaaaa npn BhlIIOJIHeHHH pa60T no ztorosopaer cTpOHTeJIbHO-MOHTa)I{HhIX parior.

06m;HH: pe3YJ1hTaT pa60ThI no JlOrOBOpaM apennsr H TpaHcnopTHhIx ycnyr B paapese J1H3HHrOBoro HMym;ecTBa npHBeJ1 K y6hITKaM aa CyMMY 631 047,1 ThIC. py6.10

]

10 IIpHMeqaHHe: B namrsrx CBe,n;eHl1JIX OTj)a)KeHhI TOJIhKO npHMhle sarparsr no conepzcaaaro TeXHHKH. Ho KpOMe npHMhIX sarpar HMeIOTC5I KOCBeHHhle, TaKHe KaK sapnnara H KOMaH,n;HpOBOqHhle pacxonu MexaHHKOB, HaqaJIhHHKOB yqaCTKOB. KOCBeHHhle sarparsr B namrsix CBe,n;eHHHX He OTpa)KeHhI.

10

B TOM qHCne oTpa6oTaJIO C nOno)KHTem~HbIM pesyrn.raron no ztorosopaa apeaasr Ii rpaacnoprmrx ycnyr 35 e,lJ;HHHII n1I31IHrOBoro lIMYIlJ;ecTBa na CyMMy 16812,7 TblC. py6.10

Ilpanoxenae N219

Cnpasxa-orser no npOBe,lJ;eHHoMY aHaJIH3Y 3KOHOMlIQeCKOH 3cpcpeKTHBHoCTli ,lJ;OrOBOpoB apennsr TeXHlIKH, saxynnennoti no nH3HHrOBbIM noronopax.

Ilpanozcenae N220

Pesynsrar HClIOnb30BaHH5I nasaaronoro lIMymecTBa no ,lJ;OroBOPaM apennu 1I TpaHcnopTHbIX ycrryr.

OCHOBHbIe BbIBO,nbI:

~ ~

i

m ~

1. 060cHoBaHHocTb CTOHMOCTH MTP B IIC,n: norrraepaoraerca He B nOJIHOM 06beMe.

BLlRBJIeHbI «KOMrrJIeKTHLIe rrOCTaBKH», COCTaB KOTOPbIX, a TaIOKe ,lJ.OK)'MeHThI, rrO,lJ.TBepac,lJ;aIOIIJHe 060CHOBaHHOCTb onpeneneaaa HX CTOHMOCTH, OTCYTCTBYIOT.

2. B IIC,n: BbIHBJIeH cpaKT OTCYTCTBHR rrexoropsrx 06beKToB, He06xo,lJ.HMhIX ,lJ.JIH ofiecne-renaa pa60TbI CBH3H. IIpRMbIe paCXO,lJ.bI na ,lJ.Opa60TKY IIC,n: no 3THM 3aMeqaHHHM ou;eHHBaIOTCR B 122 MJIH. Py6JIeH.

3. B XO,lJ.e paspsma KOHTpaKToB na npOH3BO,lJ.CTBO cTpOHTeJIbHO-MoHTaacHbIx pa60T rro o6beKTaM TC BCTO C 3AO «Kpacnozrapcrporrrpaacraa» 6b1JI YCTaHOBJIeH cpaKT HaJIHqHR MaTepHaJIOB H o60Py,noBaHHH, rrepeaannoro 3aKa3qHKOM no,npR,lJ;qHK)', HO He HCnOJIh30BaHHoro HM npn rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBe pa60T, qTO CBH,neTeJIbCTByeT 0 He,lJ;OCTaTOqHOM KOHTpOJIe co CTOPOHbI 3aKa3qHKa sa nepeaaxea ,lJ;aBaJIbqeCKHX MaTepHaJIOB ,lJ;JIR rrpOH3BO,lJ.CTBa CMP.

4. BbIHBJIeHhI cpaKThI ,lJ;JIHTeJIbHOrO aBaHcHpoBaHHH rrOCTaBIIIHKOB.

5. BbIHBJIeHbI cpaKTLI necaoeapesreaaon rrOCTaBKH MTP, qTO rrOBJIeKJIO sa C060H HeCBoeBpeMeHHoe 3aKpbITHe aBaHCOB, paHee BbI,lJ.aHHbIX IIocTaBIIIHKaM e : '

6. CTaBKa yztopoacaaaa npemreros JIH3HHra na 29,5% He MoaceT paCCMaTpHBaThCR eaMOCTORTeJIbHO, KaK COOTBeTCTBYIOIIJaR PhIHOqHOH, 6e3 ysrera cpaKTa aBaHCHpOBaHHR JIH3HHrOBOH KOMrraHHIl aa CyMMy B 30% OT CTOHMOCTH npenmera JIH3HHra na nepnon OT 3 MeCRu;eB ,lJ;0 1 ro,na. B nepasnl ron JIH3HHra BhIIIJIaqHBaJIHCb 50-60% JIH3HHrOBbIX rrJIaTeaceH, qTO rrpOTHBOpeqHT KJIaCCHqeCKOH cxesre npaofipereana o60py,noBaHHR B JIH3HHr.

IJ;eHLI rrOCTaBKH, 3aHBJIeHHhIe OAO «C,n:M-JIH3HHn>, aaasnnensr rro cpaBHeHHIO C

cpaKTHqeCKHMH uenasra rrOCTaBIIIHKOB, npasrepno na 10%-12%.

IIPH oCYIIIeCTBJIeHHH saxynox rro JIH3HHrOBbIM noronopaa He 6bIJIH paCCqHTaHhI HH nOTOK neaeacasrx Cpe,lJ.CTB, HH qHCTaR npaseneaaaa CTOHMOCTb JIH3HHra. B COOTBeTCTBHH C rrpOBe,lJ;eHHOH HaMH ou;eHKOH, qHCTaH npaaeneanaa CTOHMOCTb JIH3HHra oTpHIIaTeJIbHa, qTO CBH,lJ;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 He3cpcpeKTHBHOCTH JIH3HHrOBhIX KOHTpaKToB.

B noroaopax JIH3HHra OTCYTCTBYIOT rapaarun rrepexona npaa c06cTBeHHocTH na 060pY,lJ;OBaHHe rrOCJIe OKOHqaHHH JIH3HHrOBbIX rrJIaTeaceH.

KpOMe Toro, C TOqKH 3peHHH «HarrOJIHHeMOCTH» TapHcpa na TpaHcrropTHpoBKY HecpTH ,lJ;eHeacHbIMH Cpe,lJ;CTBaMH aa saxymcy 060pY,lJ.OBaHHR, cxesra JIH3HHrOBhIX aarcynox rrpHBO,lJ;HT K «He,lJ;OrrOJIyqeHHIO» TapHcpHOH BbIpyqKH, BbI,lJ;eJIReMOH opranosr peryJIHpOBaHHR na 3TH u;eJIH.

~""":

~~,

l

~,';

11

~

·

·

I

r

I

•

I I

7. OTCYTcTBHe 31WHOMHQeCKOH 3cpcpeKTHBHoCTH LJ:OroBOpoB apeaas; TeXHHKH, 3aKynJleHHOH no J1H3I1HrOBhIM noroaopasr.

lIrreHhI KOMHCCHH:

n06aCTOB A.H.

KapIIOB C.A

3erreHHH A.B.

COKorrOB A.IT

/

BOJUIHCKHH IT.~.

IOraH C.H.

TepeXOB ~.A.

12

AKT

/_t---_-+--r---.C.H. CYBOpOBa -t-f----- 2008r.

no rrrorasr pafiorsrpariouef rpynnsr no HCnOJ1H~ 10 Bon ca .N'!. 7 «KoHTpaKThI, aKThI, OTQeTHhle, nnareamsre H rmsre ~oKyMeHT OAO- " MMCT" no BhIIIOJIHeHHIO npoexrnsrx H cTpOHTeJ1hHhIX pa60T no TC "BCTO", acex reanonpannsrx opraumauati, a TaKme opraaaaanaa, OCYIIIeCTBJ1HIOIIIHX aaropcxaa H TeXHHQeCKHii Ha~30p».

r.MocKBa

08 CeHT.SI6p.SI 2008 rozra

Pafionaa rpyrrna B COCTaBe:

KpaBU;OBa B.A.

3aMecTlfTeJUl renepansaoro zrapexropa 000 «Tpaacaedrrs <I>HHaHC» no sonpocaa ficaorracaocra

lJIa3YHOBa P.B.

HaqaJIbHI:IKa KPO 000 «THcD»

CJIHBHHOH T.B. HaqaJIbHHKa KAO <pHJIHaJIa 000 «TH<I>>> B r. Casrape

PYM.SIHu;eBa E.B. HaqaJIbHHKa KAO <pHJIHaJIa 000 «TH<I>>> B r. YXTe

Jlofiacrosa A.H. 3aMeCTHTeJUl HaqaJIbHHKa KAO <plmHaJIa 000 «TH<I>>> B r. Y<pe

II II

3eJIeHHHa A.B. HaqaJIbHHKa npeTeH3HoHHO-HCKOBOH CJI)')K6bI Ilpasonoro yrrpaBJIeHIDI DAO «AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

Porosoro B.H. Fnasnoro IOPHCKOHCYJIbTa npeTeH3HoHHO-HCKOBOH CJIY)K6bI Ilpasosoro yrrpaBJIeHH.SI OAO «AK «Tpaucaedm,»

BOJI.SIHCKOrO IT.,l.{. 3aMeCTHTeJI.SI HaqaJIbHHKa npOH3BO~CTBeHHoro OT,n:eJIa OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm.»

Tepexosa ,l.{.A. 3aMeCTHTeJI.SI HaqaJIbHHKa OT,n:eJIa CTpaTerHqeCKOrO pa3BHTH.SI OAO AK «Tpaacaedrrs»

Esepcxoa H.H. HaqaJIbHHKa OT,n:eJIa norosopoa DAO «I'anporpytiorrponon»

THTOBOH M.K. 3aMeCTHTeJUl HaqaJIbHHKa CMeTHoro OT,n:eJIa OAO «Fanpotpyoorrponozr»

I

.

,

PYCJI.SIKOBa H.M. 3aMeCTHTeJI.SI znrpexropa ztenaprajaetrra «CJIY)K6a 6e30naCHOCTH» - HaqaJIbHHK OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30naCHOCTH OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,»

)l{aBopoHKoBa cD.B. Fnasaoro CrreU;HaJIHCTa OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMHqeCKOH 6e30naCHOCTH OAO «AK «Tpancnerprs»

1

BO HCnOJIHeHHe PaCnOp5DICeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,» OT 21 mona 2008 r. NQ 21 nposena MepOnpH5ITH5I no cfiopy H no,[(rOTOBKe MaTepHaJIOB H HH<popMa[(HH ,n:lliI CqeTHOH rranarsi POCCHHCI<OH <De,n:epa[(HH no sonpocy «KoHTpaKThI, aKTbI, orsernsre, nJIaTe)KHhIe H nasre ,n:OKYMeHThI OAO "BHI1I1CT" no BhIIIOJIHeHHlO npoexrnsrx H cTpOHTeJIbHbIX pa60T no TC "BCTO", scex reHno,n:p5I,ZJ;HhIX opraaasanaa, a TaIOKe OpraHH3a[(HH, ocyrn:ecTBJI5IIOI[(HX asropcxaa H TeXHHqeCKHH nazrsop».

I

I

Pa60qeH rpyrrne He Y,[(aJIOCb cotipars B He06xo,n:HMOM 06'beMe ,[(OKYMeHTbI H CBe,n:eHH51, yxasaaaue B sonpoce N2 7, B CB5I3HC OTKa30M OAO «BHI1I1CT»H reanonpaaasrx opraaasanaii npezrocrasars Tame ,[(OKYMeHTbI H HH<popMa[(HIO co CCbIJIKOH na KOH<pH,[(eH[(HaJIhHOCTh H KOMMepqeCKYIO TaHHY, na He06xo,n:HMOCTb MOTHBHpoBaHHoro sanpoca aerrocpencrseaao OT CLJ:eTHOH nanarsr POCCHHCKOH <De,n:epa[(HH, na HenpaBOMepHOCTh npOBe,n:eHH5.I CqeTHOH naJIaTOH POCCHHCKOH <De,n:epa[(HH npOBepOK B OTHOIlleHHH KOMMepqeCKHX opraaasanaa, xorna 3TO He CB513aHO C 'pacxoztoaaanen cpezrcrs H3 <pe'[(epaJIhHOrO 61O,n:)Jcem, 'ITO He n03BOJIHJIO npOBeCTH Ha,n:JIe)J(aIIlHH aHaJIH3.

YLJ:HTbIBa5I nens npoaozuororo CLJ:eTHOH naJIaTOH POCCHHCKOH <De,n:epa[(HH

KOH1pOJIhHOrO MepOnpH5lTH5.I, - «nposepxa paCXO,[(OBaHH5.I openers, BbmeJIeHHbIX aa CTpOHTeJIhCTBO aedrrenposozta «BoCTOLJ:Ha5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH», - pa60LJ:a5I rpynna nJIaHHpOBaJIa npOaHaJIH3HpOBaTh COOTHOIlleHHe 06'beMOB BhIl10JIHeHHhIX pa60T H HX CTOHMOCTH no 3aKJIlOqeHHbIM B paxncax peaJIH3a[(HH rrpoexra reanozrpanasre Hcy6no,n:p51,n:HbIM ,n:OroBOPaM, LJ:T06bI onpeztenars CTOHMOCTh npoeKTHpOBaHH5l H c1poHTeJIbCTBa 06'beKTOB TC BCTO Y aerrocpeacrseaasrx HCnOJIHHTeJIeif pa60T, ax COOTHOIlleHHe CO cMeTOH, a TaK)J(e passrep H 060cHoBaHHocTb B03Harpa)l(.IJ:eHH5l, nonyseanoro reanonpazrasnra OpraHH3a[(H5.lMH.

C HCnOJIh30BaHHeM ,lJ;OCTyIlHLIX,n:lliI OAO «AK «Tpaacaedm,» ,n:oKYMeHToB H cseneaaa YCTaHOBJIeHO CJIe,n:YIOIIIee.

I

·

·

1. AHaJIH3 CTOHMOCTH IIpOe:KTHLIX pa60T y OAO «BHlIHCT» H 1I0,lJ;PH,lJ;HLIX opraHH3aU;HH, HeIlOCpe,lJ;CTBeHHo ocym:ecTBJIHBmHX pa60TLI 110 IIpOe:KTHpOBaHHIO.

B nenax npoeKTHpOBaHH5l 06'beKTOB c1poHTeJIbCTBa TC BCTO 3aKJI1OQeHO zraa ztoronopa C OAO «BHMI1CT», cyMMa OnJIaTbI no KOTOPbIM COCTaBHJIa 19 205 768 TLIC. py6. (6e3 H,ll;C):

- ,n:onOJIHHTeJIbHOe COrJIaIIIeHHe N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005 K ,ll;oroBopy reaepansaoro noztpana NQ336/14/03 OT 29.08.2003 na BbIl10JIHeHHe npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T H asropcxoro aamopa Me)l(.IJ:y OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,» H OAO BHHI1CT (c ,n:onOJIHeHHeM N2 1 OT 14.02.2005 K,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, ,n:onOJIHeHHeM N2 2 OT 30.06.2005 K,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, ,n:onOJIHeHHeM N2 3 OT 15.11.2005 K,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, COrJIameHHeM N2 1 OT 16.05.200606 H3MeHeHHH,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornameaaev N2 2 OT 04.11.2005 06 H3MeHeHHH ,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornameaaeu N2 3 OT 15.03.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,ll;C N20855 OT 25.01.2005, Cornameaaesr N2 4 OT 16.05.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH ,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005, COrJIaIIIeHHeM N2 5 OT 26.09.2006 06 H3MeHeHHH nc N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005) no 06'beKTY «Tpytiorrposoztaaa CHCTeMa BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). T30 (npoexr), Pa60qa5I ,n:oKYMeHTa[(H5l. ITepBhIH nycxosoa KOMnJIeKC». 06rn:a5I CTOHMOCTb pa60T no ,n:C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005 r. COCTaBlliIeT 10492 748,9 TLIC. py6. (6e3 H,ll;C). OnJIaTa npoaaseneaa nOJIHOCTblO.

- ,n:oroBop nonpazta Me)J(.n:y 000 «WIT BCTO» H OAO «BHI1I1CT» N2 P 0855/2/U;YIII 111106/165-06 OT 23.06.2006 (c ,ll;C N2 1 OT 11.08.2006, ,ll;C N2 2 OT 07.11.2006, ,ll;C N2 3 OT 06.02.2007, nc N24 oT07.03.2007,,ll;C N2 5 OT 30.03.2007,,ll;C N2 6 OT 24.08.2007,,ll;C N2 7 OT 11.02.2008, nc N2 8 OT 19.02.2008, ,ll;C N2 9 OT 05.02.2008, nc N2 10 OT 01.04.2008, nc N2 11 OT 16.05.2008,,ll;C N2 12 OT 20.05.2008) na BbIIIOJIHeHHe npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIhCKHX pa60T no 06'beKTY «Pacmapeane TPy60npoBo,[(HOH CHCTeMhI BOCTOLJ:Ha5I CH6HPh - THXHH OKeaH».- 06m;a5I

I

·

·

I I

I

2

~

·

·

II I

11 IJ

I

·

I

·

·

.<

CTOHMOCTb pa60T no ,I:(oroBoPY 8 718 019 TbIC. py6. (6e3 H,I:(C). ITo COCT05IHHIO na 25.08.2008r. OIIJIa'IeHO 8 636 670 TbIC. py6., T.e. 99% OT 06m:eH CTOI:IMOCTH.

B pe3YJIbTaTe aHaJII:I3a ~OKYMeHTOB no HCnOJIHeHHIO ,I:(onOJIHHTeJIbHOrO COrJIaIIIeHHJI .N!.~ 0855 OT 25.01.2005r. YCTaHOBJIeHO, 'ITO sees 06'beM rrpoexrnsrx pa60T BbIIIOJIHeH aa cytinonpane Y OAO «BHMMCT» ~O"LIepHHM 06m:eCTBOM OAO «AK «Tpaacneqm,» - OAO «Fanporpytinpoaon» H ero Cy6IIO~PJI,n:"LIHKaMH. ITPH 3TOM CTOI:IMOCTb pafior uro ztoroaopy rennozrpana C OAO «BHMMCT» 6bIJIa onpeneneaa B pasvepe 10492 748,9 ThIC. py6., a CTOHMOCTb 3THX zce pa60T Y OAO «Fanporpytinposon» COCTaBHJla 8375 148,7 TbIC. py6., T.e. pasnana B CTOHMOCTH COCTaBJI5IeT 2 117 600,2 TbIC. py6. Cpezrnee OTI<JlOHeHHe CTOHMOCTH pa60T y reHIIO~p5I,n:qHKa OT CTOHMOCTH pa60T y cy6nO~p5I,I('lHKa COCTaBHJIO 20,2%, a no OT~eJIbHblM BH~aM pa60T OTKJIOHeHlfe CTOHMOCTH napsapyerca OT 13,0 % no 95,9 %.

TaK, CTOHMOCTb pa60T no «axcneprase T30 B cpe~epaJIbHblX 3KcnepTHbIX opraaax» y reHIIo,n:p5I,I('lHKa BbIIIIe CTOHMOCTH pa60T y cy6no,n:PJIMHKa aa 95,9%, IIpH 3TOM B CYMMOBOM asrpaaceaaa 3TO OTKJIOHeHHe COCTaBHJIO 106 262,8 TbIC. py6.

CTOHMOCTb pa60T no paspafiorxe pa60"LIeH ,n:oKYMeHTaU;HI:I no JIHHeHHOH "LIaCTH aerprenposozta KM 0-130; KM 239-372; KM 496 - 616,5 y reanonpazrsmca nsnne CTOI:IMOCTH pa60T y cytinonpxzrsaxa aa 13%, IIpI:I 3TOM B CYMMOBOM Bblpa)lCeHI:IH nanaoe OTKJIOHeHHe COCTaBHJIO 129 996,4 TbIC. py6. CpaBHHTeJIbHbIH aHaJIH3 npe,I:(CTaBJIeH B ITpHJIO)ICeHHH NQ 3.

ITo ,I:(OroBOPY nonpana NQ P 0855/2/uyIII111/06/165-06 OT 23.06.2006r. CTOHMOCTbIO 8718019 TbIC. py6. OAO «BHMMCT» OTKa3aJIOCb IIpe,n:CTaBHTb ,n:OKYMeHTbl H CBe,n:eHH5I 0 IIMP, BbIIIOJIHeHHbIM cy6IIo,n:p5I,I("LIHKaMH. Bsrecre C TeM, B pa3pa60TaHHoH BO HCnOJIHeHHe ztanaoro ,n;oroBopa npoexrao-caernoa ~oKYMeHTau:HH raroae KaI< B IIC,n;, pa3pa60TaHHOH no ,n;C N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005r., OTCyrCTBYIOT npoexrasre ,n:oKYMeHTbI, BbIITOJIHeHHble nenocpeztcrseaao OAO «BHMMCT», "LITO yxassraaer na «nocpenaasecxoe» Y'laCTHe OAO «BHIll1CT» B HCnOJIHeHHH 065I3aTeJIbCTB H no 3ToMy,n;oroBopy.

BblBO~bl:

KOHCTP~HJI rtorosopnsrx oTHoIIIeHHH na BbIIlOJIHeHHe npoeKTHo-H3bICKaTeJIbCKHX pa60T no 06'beKTY «Tpy60IIPOBO,n:HM CHCTeMa BOCTO"LIHM CI:I6I:IPb - THXHH OKeaH (BCTO). T30 (npoexr), Pa60"LIM ,n:oKYMeHTaU;H5I. ITepBbIH nycK0:j30H KOMnJIeKC» C nocpe,n:HH"LIeCKHM ysacraea OAO «BHHMCT» He HMeeT 060CHOBaHHoro 3KOHOMHWJeCKoro CMbICJIa. IIoCKOJIbKY 100% III1P BbIIIOJIHeHO OAO «Fanporpytionponozr» Hero cy6no,n:p5I,n:"LIHKaMH, 06'beKTHBHMHe06xO,IJ;HMOCTb B 3aI<JIIO"LIeHHH ztorosopa C OAO «BHHHCT» OTcyrcTBOBaJIa. C OAO «Fanpcrpyoorrpoaon» ztoronop na IIMP Mor 6bITb 3aI<JIIO"LIeH nanparayro.

B pe3YJIbTaTe 3aI<JJIO"LIeHH5I ,n;onOJIHHTeJIbHOrO COrrraIIIeHH5I N2 0855 OT 25.01.2005r. C OAO «BHHMCT» KOMnaHHH «Tpaacaeprs» npHWJHHeH ymepf B pastaepe 2 117 600,2 TblC. py6JIeH sa He060CHOBaHHoe IIocpe,IJ;HH"LIeCTBO.

YKa3aHHM BeJIHWJHHa ymepfia OT OIIJIaTbI IIHP IIO ,I:(orOBOpaM C OAO «BHHHCT» He HBJIHeTCH OKOH'1aTeJIbHOH H MO)ICeT YBeJIH"LIHTbC5I npa rrposeztenaa aHaJIH3a COOTHOIIIeHH5I 06'beMOB BbIIIOJIHeHHblX pa60T H HX CTOHMOCTH no ,I:(oroBOpy noztpazra Me)J(,I(y 000 «L{YII BCTO» H OAO «BHHMCT» NQ P 0855/2/L{YIIII111061165-06 OT 23.06.2006r. B cnyxae, eCJlH COOTHOIIIeHHe B CTOHMOCTH reanonpazraoro H cyfinonpanasrx ztoroaopon 6y.n:eT TaKHM )ICe, KaI< B ,n;C NQ 0855 OT 25.01.2005r., T.e. OKOJIO 20%, He060cHOBaHHbIe sarparsr no zrorosopy COCTaB5IT 1 743 604 TbIC. py6JIeH, a conoxyrrasni ymepf KOMIIaHHH «Tpaacnedrrs» OT BbIIIOJIHeHHblX IIHP no 06'beKTaM TC BCTO COCTaBHT 3861204 TblC. py6JIeH.

OnJIaTa B aapec OAO «BHHMCT» rax aassmaesrsrx «rearrozrpanasrx» npasena K Heo6oCHOBaHHOMY YBeJIH'1eHHIO H3paCXO~OBaHHblX cpeacrs na npoererapoaaaae TC BCTO na BeJIH"LIHHY pa3HHU;bI CTOHMOCTH Me)J(,I(y reHno,n:pJI,IJ;HbIMI:I H cy6no,n:p5I,n:HbIMH .n:orOBOPaMH.

3

I

·

I

2. AHaJIH3 06bCMOB eMP H HX CTOHMOCTH Y rCHnO.LJ;pH.LJ;HLIX H cy6nO.LJ;pH.LJ;HLlX opraHH3aI(HH.

B nenax c1poHTeJIbCTBa 06beKToB TC BCTO 000 «~YTI BCTO» B 2006 - 2007 r.r, no pe3YJIbTaTaM ropros 3aKJIIO"tJeHO 16 reanonpszmsrx KOH1paKToB na C)'MMY 169 346 612,0 TbIC. py6. TIpHJIo)JceHIfe N2 4.

COrJIaCHO KOHKypCHblM npennoxeaaax 000 «C1pOi1c:HCTeMa», 3AO

«Kpacaonapcrpoarpaacras», 000 «C1pOM: KOHTHHeHT», OAO «TIpoMC1pOM:», 3AK 00 «Auepxo HHTepHeIIIeHeJI JIHMHTe,[(», OAO «AM: TIHCeTb Cll6», npH3HaHHbIX n06e,[(HTeJU£MH 'ropros, HMH na cyononpaa npezmonaranocs nepeztars OT 5,1% zto 94,75% scero npezrycaorpeaaoro IIC,n; no 06beKTaM CTpOHTeJI:bCTBa 06beMa pa60T. B '[(eM:CTBHTeJIbHOCTH, npaKTHqeCKH see C1pOHTeJI:bH:ble pa60T:bI B:bmOJIHJIJIHC:b cy6no,n:p5l'[(H:bIMH opraHH3a.u;H5IMH (CM. TIpHJIo)JceHHe N2 2).

YqHT:bmaJI, llTO reanoztpanaue OpraHH3aU;HH OTKa3aJIH B npezrocranneaaa He06xo,[(HM:bIX ,[(OK)'MeHTOB H HH<p0pMa.u;HH, pa60"tJaJI rpynna nposena B:bI60po"tJR:bIM: aHaJIH3 COOTHOIIIeHIDl o6beMoB CMPH HX CTOHMOCTH Y rearronpazmsrx H cyononpazrasrx opraaasanaa aa OCHOBe ,[(OK)'MeHTOB H CBe,n:eHHM:, rrpe,n:CTaBJIeHH:bIX npennpaaraaxa rpynnu AK «Tpaacaeqm,» 000 «KCY «CH6He<pTenpoBo,n:C1pOH» (nosepaero oomecraa OAO «Catiaedrrenposon»), 000 «Bonroaedrrcrascrrencrpon» (ztoaepnero 06m:eCTBa a A a «BepXHeBOJI)ICCKHe<pTerrpOBO,n:»), 000 «OMCKHe<pTerrocneU;C1pOM:» (noaepaero 06m:eCTBa OAO «Tpaaccafiaedrrs»), xoropsre B:bmOJIHJIJIH CTpOHTeJI:bHO-MOHTa)J(H:bIe pa60TbI aa cytirrozrpazte y reanonpannsrx OpraHH3aU;HM: 000 «C1pOHCHCTeMa» (000 «CHCTeMaCneu;C1pOH» - rrOCJIe 3aMeH:bI CTOPOH:bI B zrorosope) H 3AO «KpaCHo,n:apCT_POHTpaHCra3». HH<popMaU;HJI 0 3aKJIIOqeHHbIX KOH1paKTax na cyononpaaasre pa60TbI H pe3YJIbTaT:bI HX B:bmOJIHeHIDl B paspese 06beKTOB H zrorosopoa npencraaneasr B TIpHJIO)ICeHHH N2 1.

I I

06m:aJI CTOHMOCTb pa60T, B:bmOJIH5IBIIIHXC5I 000 «KCY «CH6He<pTerrpoBo,n:cTpoif», 000 «Bonronedrrerascnerrcrpofi» H 000 «Oacsnedrrerascrrencrpoa» B paxncax reanoztpanaax ,n:OroBOPOB Me)J(,lJ;y 000 «uvn BCTO» H 000 «CT_POHCHcTeMa» (000 «CHcTeMaCrreu;CT_POH»), COCTaBHJIa 11 461 669,5 T:bIC. py6. (6,8% OT CTOHMOCTH 3aKJIIO"tJeHHbIX norosopos na CMP), a CTOHMOCT:b 3THX )ICe pa60T rro cy6no'[(p5l'[(HbIM .lI:OroBOPaM - 8 561 513,3 rsrc, py6. Pa3HHu;a B CTOHMOCTH pa60T B rrOJI:b3Y reaepansnsrx nonpazrraxoa COCTaBJIJIeT 2 895 676,6 T:bIC.py6., I T.e. CTOHMOCTb pa60T rro rearronpanasm ,[(OroBOPaM rrpensnnaer CTOHMOCTb 3THX )ICe pa60T no cy6rro,n:PMHblM ,n:OroBOPaM B cpeztnexr na 33,8%.

TIo COCTOJIHHIO aa 01.03.2008r. rro <paKTHlleCKHM 06beMaM B:bmOJIHeHHbIX pa60T pasnana B CTOHMOCTH rro renrronpszrasn« H cy6rro'[(PMHblM ,[(OroBOPaM COCTaBHJIa 1 808487,0 T:bIC. py6JIeH, (28 %).

C)'MMa y6:bITKOB, rronyseansrx 000 «KCY «CH6He<pTerrpoBo'[(CT_P0M:», 000 «BOJIrOHeq)Tera3crreU;C1pOH» HOOO «OMcKHe<pTera3CrreU;CTpOH» OT BbIITOJIHeHH5I pa60T no ztoroaopaxr C 000 «Crpoacacrexa» COCTaBHJIa 692829,0 TbIC. py6.2

Bbl5lBJIeHa rrp5IMaJI 3aBHCHMOCT:b Me)J(,lJ;y B:bIITOJIHeHH:b1M 06beMoM pa60T H C)'MMOM: y6:b1TKOB rrpe,n:npHJITHH KOMrraHHH. TaK, npa BbIITOJIHeHHH CMP na 06beKTe «PaCIITHpeHHe rpytiorrpoaoztaoii CHCTeM:bI «BOCTO"tJRaJI CH6HPb - THXHM: OKeaH» (BeTa). YllaCTOK N2 1 (r.YcT:b-KYT - Tanaxancxoe MecTopo)J(,lleHHe). HPKYTCKaJI 06JIaCT:b, Pecrrytinnxa Caxa (.5IKYTH5I). J1HHeHHaJI xacrs, ysacrox KM 570 - 1105, ysacrox KM 926 - 1105»3 rronysea y6:bITOK B c)'MMe

I

·

I

•

I C)'MMa paCXO)K)],eHIDl B CTOHMOCTH pa60T y reHTIo)]'pH,l('II1Ka 11 cyonozrpazrraxa onpeneneaa nyrea conOCTaBJIeHIDl CTOHMOCTH pafior, O'I'pa)KeHHOH B rea.nonpsnasrx KOH'I'paKTaX aa CMP 11 CTOHMOCTI1 pa60T B cy6no)J,pH)J,HhIX KOH'I'paKTaX na CMP, 3aKJIlOtJeHHhlX C 06ll(eCTBaMI1 Fpyrmsi AK «Tpascaedrrs» no COCTOHHHlO na 01.03.08 rona . 2 C)'MMa y6bITKOB onpeneneua 6e3 ysera npl16bIJII1, nOJIyqeHHOH no OT)J,eJIbHhIM norosopaa cytinonpazra.

3 KOH'I'paKT reaepansnoro nO)J,pH)J,a .N!!332-06 OT 28.12.2006 rona, 3aKJIlOtJeH Me)K,1l)' 000 «I.J;YTI BCTO}) 11 000 «C'I'pOHcI1CTeMa}), saaena CTOPOHhI na 000 «CI1CTeMa Cneu Crpok»,

4

254 878,0 TbIC. py6., OTKJ10HelI11e CT011MOCT11 pa60T y 000 «Oxcxaedrrerascnerrcrpoa» OT CT011MOCT11 pa60T y 000 «Crpoacacreaa» COCTaBJ15IeT OT 5% ~o 30,2 %, a no 06'.beMY cpaI<T11lIeCKH BbITIOJ1HeHHblX pa60T - 26,1 %4.

[1

j

I

B CB5I311 C Herrpe~CTaBJ1eH11eM ~OI(YMeHTOB 11 11HCPOpMal(1111 pa60lIeli rpynne He y~aJ10Cb coopars ~OKYMeHTbI 11 11CCJIe~OBaTb 060CHOBaHHOCTb OIIJ1aTbI CMP no ztoronopan B 3BeHe «cy6no~p5I~tIMI< - cy6-cy6no~p5I~tIMK». Bxrecre C TeM, no 11MeIOIl(11MC5I ~aHHbIM, 11 no TaKHM ,l(OrOBOpaM HCn0J1b30BaJ111Cb nporasonpaarrsre cxesrsr, azrynrae spaspes C 11HTepecaMH KOMnaH1111 «Tpancaedrn,». TaK, zroxepaee 06Il(eCTBO OAO «Bepxaenonaccxaedrrenpoaon» - 000 «Bonraaeqrrerascrrencrpon», BbITIOJ1H5I5I pa60TbI no 06'.beKTaM TC BCTO na cyononpsne y 000 «CHcTeMaCnel(CTPoH», caao 3aKJ1IOtIMJ10, B CBOIO osepezrs, 7 ,l(OrOBOpoB C cy6- cy6no.np5I~HbIMH opraHH3al(H5IMH na BbITIOJIHeHHe OT,l(eJIbHbIX pa60T no pacaacrxe 'rpaccst OT neca, BbIB03Y rreca, YCTPOHCTBY J1e)l<HeBbIX zropor, Ilposepxa Kpe~HTopcKOH 3a~0J1)l(eHHOCTH no H11M nOKa3aJ1a, lITO pa60TbI nOJIHOCTbIO HJIH lIaCTHtIHO 6bIJ111 BbITIOJ1HeHbI co6CTBeHHbIMH C11J1aMH 000 «BHrCC», O~HaKO onJ1aTY npennonaranocs npOH3BeCTH B anpec cy6- cy6no.np5I~HbIX opraaasanaa nOJIHOCThIO. Kpone roro, CTOHMOCTb pa60T B zmyx H3 cexra ,l(oroBOPOB OKa3aJ1aCb BbIIIIe, lIeM CTOHMOCTb 3T11X )l(e pa60T B norosopax Me~y 000 «BHrCC» H reanoztpanaoa opraaasanaea 000 «C11CTeMaCnel(CTPOH»: no ~oroBopy NQ 440- IO-07 OT 01.12.2007 C 000 «Kosopac H K» - na 2,2 MJIH. py6J1eH H no ~oroBopy NQ 06/03/2008 OT 06.03.2008 C 000 «Aarapa JIec» - aa 12 MJ1H. py6JIeii.

I

,

I

·

I

BhlBOtJ;hI:

Teaepansasre nO~PMtIMKH npaKT11lIeCKH He BbITI0J1H5IJI11 pa60T no CTPOHTeJ1bCTBY 06'.beKTOB TC BCTO co6CTBeHHbIMH C11J1aMH H 5IBJ15IJIHCb JIHmb nocpe~H11KaM11 Me~y 3aKa3tIMKOM (000 «L(YTI BCTO») H cy6nO~p5I~HbIM11 OpraHH3al(ll5IMH, nOJIyqa5I sa 3TO Heo6oCHOBaHHO BbICOK)'IO OnJIaTY B BH~e Pa3HHl(bI OT CTOHMOCTH pa60T no reHnO~p5I~HbIM ~OrOBOPaM H CTOllMOCTH pa60T no cy6no~PMHbIM ~OrOBOPaM.

CTOMMOCTL CTpOMTeJILHO-MOHTa~HblX paOOT no . 06'.beKTaM, rzte cy6nO~p5I~KaMH 5IBJ15IJIHCb 000 «KCY «C116He<pTenpOBO~CTPOH», 000 «Bcnronepreraacrrencrpoa» H 000 «OMCKHe<pTera3Cnel(CTPOH», saasrmeaa B cpeaaesr na 2895676,6 ThlC. pyfi, HJIM aa 33,8%.

YKa3aHHa5I c)'MMa 5IBJI5IeTC5I, no CyIl(eCTBY, YIl(ep60M KOMnaHHH «Tpaacnedm,» 11 Heo6oCHOBaHHbIM ynopoxaaaea cTPoHTeJ1bCTBa TC BCTO.

B crrysae coXpaHeHH5I raxoro )l(e COOTHOmeHH5I Me~y CTOllMOCTbID pa60T H no ~pyrHM 3aI<J1IOlIeHHbIM reanonpaaasra H cy6no.n;p5I~HbIM .n;orOBOPaM, T.e. C 3aBbIIIIeHHeM na 33,8% CTOHMOCTH reHnO~p5I,n;HbIX ztoronopos no CpaBHeHHIO C cy6no.n;pH,l(HbIMH, ofirnee 3aBbIIIIeHHe CTOHMOCTH CMP no 06'.beKTaM TC BCTO COCTaB11T 6oJ1ee 57 MJIP,lJ;. pyoJIeii.

,lJ;J15I onpezteneaaa peaJ1bHOH CTOllMOCTH CMP no 06'.beKTaM cTpOHTeJ1bCTBa TC BCTO Tpe6yeTC5I raiose ,n;eTaJ1bHa5I nponepxa ztorosopos B 3BeHe «cytinonpazrrax - cy6- cytinonpazrrax», lITO He 6bIJ10 cztenano H3-3a OTCYTCTB115I B pa60lIeH rpynne Heo6xo.n;HMbIX .n;oKYMeHToB.

OpraHH3al(HH, npasnaaasre no6e~HTeJI5IMH ropros H CTaBm11e reaepansnsraa nO,l(p~KaMH no 06'beKTaM cTpOHTeJ1bCTBa TC BCTO, npa npOBe,l(eH11H repros npe,l(CTaBHJIH xoaxypcasre npe.n;J10iKeHH5I C nenocrosepaoa 11H<popMal(11eli 0 CBoeM ysacraa B BbITIOJIHeHHH pa60T H pacnpenenenaa 06'.beMOB CMP Me)l(,l(y reanonpazrraxaua H cy6no.n;p5I.n;HbIMH OpraHH3al(H5IM11.

YlIHTbIBa5I TO, lITO no6e.n;HTeJIH ropros TOlIHO «BnHCaJ1HCb» B paClIeTHYIO CTOHMOCTb CMP COrJ1aCHO TIC,n; H YCJ10BH5IM nposenenasrx KOHKypCOB, no CBH.n;eTeJIbCTByeT 0 Bep05ITHbIX aapynreaasx npa COCTaBJ1eHHH CMeT aa 06'.beKTbI CTpOHTeJ1bCTBa, 0 B03MO)l(HbIX MaHHnYJI5Il(HHX

I

·

·

,

" I

4 ,[(OroBOP C 000 «OMCKHeqnera3CneQC1pOM» N203/1-BCTO/IP-OHrCC OT 28.12.2006 r,

5

C 06'beMaMH pa60T H :o;eHOH MTP, 0 3a6JIarOBpeMeHHOH OCBe,n;OMJIeHHOCTH rr06e,n;HTeJIeH TOprOB B KOHqm,n;eH:O;HaJIbHOH HHcpOpMa:O;HH, KaCaIOIIJ:eHC5I paCYfeTHOH CTOHMOCTH JIOTOB.

06WHH BbIBOll:

IIpH peaJIH3a~HH npoexra TC BCTO HCKYCCTBeHH06bIJIa C03)),aHa CXeMa B HHTepeCaX renepansnoro rrpOeKTHpOBWHKa H renepansm.rx nonpanxmcoe, xoropsre, rrpaKTHtIeCKH He BbIIIOJIH5I5I co6CTBeHHbIMH CHJIaMH III1P H CMP H, rrOCYTH, 5IBJI5I5ICb nams nocpezmmcaaa Me)!<.n:y 3aKa3tIHKOM H cy6rro,n;p5I,n;HbIMH opraHH3aU;H5IMH, nOJIyqaJIH Heo6oCHOBaHHO BbICOKYIO onnary, KOTOPa.H TOJIbKO no paCCMOTpeHHbIM B AKTe cHTyaU;H5IM npessnnaer 5,7 MJIPll. py6. YKa3aHHa.H cYMMa no cYIIJ:ecTBY 5IBJI5IeTC5I ywep60M )),JIR KOMrraHlIH «Tpaacnedm,» H Heo6ocHoBaHHblM y.a:opoxmHHeM CTOHMOCTH YCJIYr nonpsmn.rx opraHH3aI(HH.

PJ'

i'i, ...

I10,n;rrHCH:

KpaB:O;OB B.A.

CJIHBHHa T.B.

JIo6acTOB A.H.

PorOBOH B.ll.

TepeXOB .n;.A.

THToBaM.K.

)KaB0POHKOB <D.E.

rJIa3YHOB P.B.

PYM5IH:o;eB E.B. t'jf/!,,/C',(_

.1" t,

3eJIeHHH A.B. 4;:;:~):j!~~~...e.-r~

_.':-,.,.-----"--"-"'-- (

BOJI5IHCKHH I1k:.:-~~:-·--:1~ cX,=-

E3epCKa.H H.H.

PYCJI5IKOB H.M.

6

I I

I I

I I

I II

I

.

AKT

o cfiope ,n:OKYMeHTaJI1HhIX MaTepHaJIOB H HHcpOpMaU;HH 0 npasnaax (06CT05ITeJIhCTBaX), rrOBJIeKIIIHX Heo6xo,n:HMOCTh 3aKJIIOqeHH5I ,n:OrrOJIHHTemHhIX COrJIaIIIeHHH K KOHTpaKTaM rro 06beKTaM CTpOHTemCTBa TPy6orrpOBO,n:HOH CHCTeMhI «BOCTOQHa5I CH6HPh-THXHH OKeaH» (BOrrpOC NQ 8 CQeTHOH nanarsr P<f»

r.MocKBa

« » 2008 rona

Pa6oQa5I rpyrrrra B COCTaBe:

- HaQaJIhHHKa KOHTPOJIhHO-aHaJIHTHQeCKOrO OT,n:eJIa cpHJIHaJIa 000 «Tpaacaedm, <f>HHaHC» B r. YXTa

PYM5IHu;eBa E.B.

- Ha1:JaJIhHHKa rrpoH3Bo,n:cTBeHHoro OT,n:eJIa OAO «AK «Tpancnedrrs»

Fopana Af..

- 3aMeCTHTeJI5I Ha1:JaJIhHIIKa OT,n:eJIa cTpaTerH1:JeCKOrO pa3BHTII5I OAO «AK «Tpaacnedm,»

- 3aMeCTIITeJI5I Ha1:JaJIhHIIKa IOpH,n:H1:JeCKOrO OT,n:eJIa Ilpasosoro yrrpaBJIeHH5I OAO «AK «Tpancaedm,»

- rnaBHoro IOPHCKOHcYJI1Ta IOpH,n:H1:JeCKOrO OT,n:eJIa Ilpasonoro yrrpaBJIeHII5I OAO «AK «Tpaacaeqm.»

- 3aMeCTIITeJI5I ,n:lIpeKTopa ,n:errapTaMeHTa «CJIY)K6a 6e30rracHocTII» - Ha1:JaJIhHHKa OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMII1:JeCKOH 6e30rracHocTlI

OAO «AK «Tpaacnedrrs»

- rJIaBHOrO CrreU;lIaJIlICTa OT,n:eJIa 3KOHOMH1:JeCKOH Gesorracnocra OAO «AK «Tpaneneqrrs»

Tepexona ,a.A.

TpYCOBa C.A.

CopOKIIHa A.B.

PYCJI5IKOBa H.M.

)J(aBopOHKOBa <f>.£.

B COOTBeTCTBHII C PaCrrOpH)KeHHeM OAO «AK «Tpaacnerprs» OT 21 1I1OJI5I 2008 r. N2 21 nposezreasr MeporrpHHTH5I no cfiopy ,n:oKYMeHTaJI1HhIX MaTepHaJIOB H HHCPOpMau:HH 0 rrpH1:JHHaX (06cTOHTeJI1CTBax), rrOBJIeKIIIHX Heo6xo,n:HMOCTh 3aKJII01:JeHIIH ,n;orrOJIHHTeJI1HhIX COrJIaIIIeHHH K cneztyronrmr KOHTpaKTaM no o6beKTaM cTpOHTeJIhCTBa rpyoorrposonnoa CIICTeMhI «BocTo1:JHa5I CH6HP.b-TIIXIIH OKeaH» (TC «BCTO»):

• na BhIIIOJIHeHHe crpoHTeJIhHO-MOHTa:>KHhIX pa60T (CMP): OT 28.12.2006 N2332-06, OT 06.03.2007 N2447-07, OT 20.04.2007 N!645-07, OT 11.04.2007 N2579-07, OT 29.06.2007 N2602- 07 - B QaCTH YBeJIH1:JeHH5I CPOKOB 3aBepIIIeHH5I pafior;

• na B.bIIIOJIHeHHe CMP: OT 01.02.2007 N2406-07, oT06.03.2007 N2447-07, OT 20.04.2007 N2545-07, OT 11.07.2007 N2631-07 - B QaCTH rrOBhIIIIeHIIH CTOHMOCTII pafior;

• na B1IIIOJIHeHHe rrpoeKTHo-1I31ICKaTeJIhCKHX pa60T (I1I1P): OT 29.08.2006 N2MK085517mYI11l11106/227-06, OT 23.06.2006 N2P0855/2mYI11111l061165-06 - B 1:JaCTH rrOB1IIIIeHII5I CTOHMOCTH pafior;

• na B1IIIOJIHeHHe TeXHII'IeCKOrO nazrsopa (HTH): OT 26.04.2006 N2145-I1YTH-20061l24-06 - B 1:JaCTH rrOB1IIIIeHmr CTOIIMOCTH pafior.

- 1 -

II I

I I

,

II I

I I

~ " .. j

Y CTaHOBJIeHO CJIe,LJ:YlOrn;ee:

1. KOH'IpaKT N2 332-06 OT 28.12.2006 C 000 «Crpoiicacrexra» (c 26.09.2007 npOM30IlIJIa saxreaa CTOPOHhI B zrorosope na 000 «CMCTeMaCneuCTpoH») na BhIIIOJIHeHMe cTpOHTeJIhHOMOHTa)KHhIX pa60T (CMP) no 06'heKTY «TIepBa5I o-repezn, TPy6onpOBO,LJ:HOH CMCTeMhI «BoCTOqHa5I CH6MPh- THXHH OKeaH». «Pacmapcaae rpy6onpOBO,LJ:HOH CHCTeMhI «BoCTOqHa5I CM6HPh-THXHH oKeaH»(BCTO). YqaCTOK N2 1 (r, YCTh-KYT - TaJIaKaHCKoe MeCTOpO)K,LJ:eHHe) I1pKYTcKa5I 06JIaCTh, Pecny6JIMKa Caxa (5IKYTH5I). JIMHeHHa5I xacrs, yqaCTOK 570-1105 KM. JIOT N2BCTOIP-1» - B IfaCTH YBeJIMlfeHM5I CPOKOB 3aBepIlleHH5I pafior:

•

uena, COCTaB, 06'heMhI M CpOKH BhIIIOJIHeHH5I pa60T onpezrenensr B KOHTpaKTe no pe3YJIhTaTaM rcproa, npOBe,LJ:eHHhIX 000 «L(YTI «BCTO»;

aa MOMeHT npOBe,LJ:eHM5I nposepxa KOHrpaKT MCnOJIH5IeTC5I cTOpOHaM11;

ncpsoaasansnaa CTOMMOCTh pa60T no KOHTpaKTY - 12574029,0 TbIC. py6., CT011MOCTh C yserov scex ,LJ:OnOJIHHTeJIhHhIX COrJIaIlIeH11H - 12 508 789,3 ThIC. py6.;

• nepaonavansmra CpOK 3aBepIlleHM5I pa60T no KOHTpaKTY - 31.07.2007;

•

•

• scero K KOHrpaKTY na MOMeHT nposepxa 3aKJIlOqeHO 8 (socem.) ,LJ:OnOJIHMTeJIbHbIX COrJIaIlIeHHH, M3 HHX 2 (,LJ:Ba) na YBeJIMqeHMe CPOKOB 3aBepIlleHH5I pafior;

• K KOHrpaKTY 3aKJIlOqeHbI CJIe,LJ:YIOrn;He ,LJ:OnOJIHHTeJIhHble COrJIaIlIeH115I na YBeJIMqeHHe cpoxa 3aBepIlIeHM5I pafior:

,LJ:OnOJIHHTeJIhHOe cornameaae N2 2 OT 24.07.2007 co CPOKOM 3aBepIlleHH5I pa60T no KOHTpaKTy- 01. 12.2007r. na OCHOBaHMH oopatneaas (nacsaa) 000 «Crpoacacreua», B KOTOPOM Heo6xo,LJ:MMOCTh npO,LJ:JIeHH5I cpoxa pa60T 060CHOBhIBaJIaCh OTCYTcTBHeM )K/,LJ: ztopor, aBTO,LJ:OpOr, HaJII1qHeM He6JIaronp115ITHhIX nOrO,LJ:HhIX YCJIOB11H (TenJIa5I 3MMa, paHH5I5I BeCHa H pacnyraua), 113HaqaJIhHhIM npoM3Bo,LJ:CTBOM pa60T na OCHOBe He KaqeCTBeHHO pa3pa60TaHHOH npoeKTHO-CMeTHOH ,LJ:OKYMeHTaUMM (no COrJIaCOBaH11lO --600 «L(YTI «BCTO»!).

,LJ:OnOJIHHTeJIhHOe COrnaIlIeH11e N2 J OT 10.09.2007 co CPOKOM 3aBepIlIeH115I pa60T no KOHTpaKTY - 30.09.2008r. 3aKJIlOqeHO na OCHOBaH1111 o6parn;eHlIH (n11CeM) 000 «CTpoHcHcTeMa»211 000 «L(YTI «BCTO»3, B KOTOPhIX Heo6xo,LJ:MMOCTb npO,LJ:JIeHM5I cpoxa 060CHOBbIBaJIaCb HaJI11qMeM CJIO)KHbIX KJI11MaT11lfeCKHX YCJIOBHH, HeB03MO)l(HOCTblO 3ae3,LJ:a na OT,LJ:eJIbHble TPY,LJ:HO,LJ:OcTynHble yqaCTKH, BHeCeHM5I 60JIbillOrO KOJI11qeCTBa 113MeHeHHH B

pa6oQYIO ,LJ:OKYMeHTaUHlO (He KaQeCTBeHHO pa3pa60TaHHa5I npoeKTHO-CMeTHa5I

,LJ:OKYMeHTa:[~M5I), Heo6xo,LJ:HMOCTblO nepeodiopanerraa aaxasa na MaTep11aJIbI M

060pY,LJ:OBaHMe (no COrJIaCOBaHMlO OAO «AK «Tpaacaerprr.x");

Bvecre C TeM, aHaJI113 xO,LJ:a CTpOMTeJIbCTBa (I1pHJIO)l(eHHe N2 3) CBH,LJ:eTeJIbCTByeT 0 TOM, QTO TIO,LJ:P5I,LJ:QMK 3a,LJ:eHCTBOBaJI na 06'heKTe 5IBHO He,LJ:OCTaTOQHOe KOJIMQeCTBO nepcoaana (18% - 19% OT rrorpefinoro KOJIMQeCTBa) M cTpOHTeJIbHOH TeXHMKI1 (57%), ,LJ:OnycTMJI cymecrsemroe OTCTaBaHMe OT .Fparpaxa BbIIIOJIHeHM5I pa60T (31 % sa 7 ,LJ:HeH ,LJ:O nepBOHaQaJIbHOrO cpoxa OKOHQaHM5I pacor), nOCTpOMJI TOJIbKO 5% JIe)l(HeBblx,LJ:Opor OT Heo6xo,LJ:HMOrO KOJIMQeCTBa. TIpM 3TOM I10,LJ:P5I,LJ:lfMK csoespeaeaao H B nOJIHOM 06'heMe nOJIYQMJI OnJIaTY, BKJIlOlfa5I aBaHC, MaTepMaJIbI 11 060PY,LJ:OBaHMe nOCTaBKH 3aKa3Q11Ka.

J Ni02-32-9597 or 20.06.2007, 2 N~B423411 or 31.08.2007 ..

3 N202-3 1-14681 OT 05.09.2007.

4 ~27-03-06/11817 or 06.09.2007.

- 2 -