Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J
M
C
bQ VjdG IjdG
O 20 : dG 1813 OdG. 2011 hGC 20 dG VjQ ej
www.elheddaf.com
S .`gGHGE :``G ```dGE/ SH .:``fa ```dGE / .I`````M - SQ``a . - ``SGE .S - ``S . - ``Sj . -```H .S - ````c.GC :fJ GE :''GqdG'' `Ke
:```````Y
``````a ```LCS ''
c GE cCJ
C `T
C H
''h``dG ```He
:````````M
dH `````cGC d''
`````eGC ````S dG
''```jT `````S
G`Fb `jQ qjo jU
q ```K
`````fqMh Q```
USMA
JSK
MCA
CRB
''g
C G eGC OGS
E G qGC Y fGCh He c'' :GOqR
h````qGh ``````Wj ''```````HGQ'' ``````e`e
I```````jL IQh`````e ```e ```````aqeo
19:36
QaEG
d c
,GjY M
HdG LdG
TGdG OJ
jOdeh
d fGC ,FGdG
cGC'' GC d j
W ''eQ
,hdG QGe
GC j d
fjo YdG
M Gc
j hGC Qj
C FU gh
AGLGC a UN ,qeoh GL T e
C G
FU dGh QdG dG e'' :bh ,IQM
fGC j GP cJGC ,dG IQGM X a
e
C G
C Cqa TGdG OJGE e dGC c
.''dG cGC d ,GL bT c
S`````Hd
Y `j
``````VjdG
aGdG GC hj
HdG dhdG
SHd dU
dGE j Gj
M dG j
C G
q
c GEh ,FdG T U a Y c
a UN ,fH QdG UGe f
H j M ,dG eQ T
VjdG IOdG YdG a jQdG
GC ij gh ,AbU
C G H e hRh H
SQoj d GPGE ''Tdj e'' eQ T
e eg GAL gj dGh ,VjdG
.dG dG Gg a Jej
04:25
`j YGC `e
C Iq`d ba bGC dG R`qdG b''
''jdG GQ`dG ``qaGCh ...qdG `a `jOddG
?OdG eh jQJ
.FGdH 1975/02/07
ZJ jFGdG W e AT
?J a
a d jd c g
?g eh dW
dG jS f ,L a AT
.HYGCh a qf GC Yh ,IadGh
,''cc'' gh d d c f
baQh FY OGaGC c M
.SEG GH fhOjo
?HdG a U eQ e c
?H jOoj Gj eh
j b a MGhh fa a 13 hGC 12
b jGC Hh ,QdG Of a d
.''dG'' e UdG d J fc eY
?J GCH e
ce a ,M QjdG YGC
d aGC QqJ h qU ,cCj e hj
.INBGh fdG a
?Gc J e
M dGE LM a edG ? d
.Y f GC Yh
FQ ea ej J
?d dJ dG a ,jQdG
e JOY H d bh dGE
W j d SGE d'' :GOdG
fh eQO GC a VdH QdG
IOT ,''d fe e QhH fGC
qJCS e dGC eYh ,H Ma
.Y qdG jo GCh adGh dG d
?eQ a J e dGE
Lh hJGCh dG b JGC f
.a VjQ
?dG HGE j e
,N IdG J OH g BG
S e jGH jh dGh a e S
.HdG hGC SOdG
...aQ `cQa U
:`````jU
eEG
?ec eQ U eh
.''e d eR dG'' C ,d
?dG GC #dG dG qJ
Lh Y ee fGC QJ g ,
.eQ a Gc gaGC dG IdGdG
IFdG AGLGC H QJ GC d
a gAGLGCh ''eGC'' a dGh
?QGhdG H
LGC FGdG a ,H ST a
,QaEG IFe Y gOGaGC Lh FY
a .HGEh LhR e Mh fGC g d
,M AHGC ,FbUGC ''edG'' QGhdG H
.eQ a L AT c ,''OdG jQ''
Ma FdG qW IOY e g
?Ie h
C eH
?fH bGE g
?jQdG H J dG e
jFGdG Yd f
?eQ a hj jdG
e d SSGC iha Gj GC Y
GCh ,ec ejGC Gej GCh dG
C , b G Y Y Z a g a a G j
60 `H ej Vqjo GC Y GY j e
.dG j e MGh H dh ej
j eCG C QNGC GC d j
c'' g GC g Ida ,qdG H
.''c
d``
```H`q Q``j
Ad M Y jYGE '':`fM
''````j ````HqQh ````cH OGORH
HdG
`cGQdG
,HdG
d ,`cGQdG
b ,d
..RdG
a GC fa a jhGdG IU
?FGdG
j dG dG e fGC g
?eQ a Gc
Hj dG dG e fGC gh
?UT
C G e
?
B G M GBdG e GCb c
YCSh HM dG N e HbGE
T jf b Je hGC Ie JAGb
.qdG H eQ
a qoJ dG LdG g e
?Qa
E G IFe Y
e b hJGC GC H ,RdG b
.ej
dGE jQH e j fGC H
?''eGC''
H jU Lj jQH a ,f
ah ,jdG RdG dG OGYGE a dG
jGC j dG T e Se c
,dG g dG Y c e cGC
a RdG b qaGC FGdG QhRGC eYh
gj dG U g ,OGdG H
OJGE hUe j dG RdG H
Id ba bGC dG RdG b d ,FGdG
.IOLh
?GPd
id GVM j GC H h ''GQdG''
j GC qaGCh ,''ja HdG'' hJ
dhJ GQH aGC fC jS ''GQH''
.BG M
?IdG GC dG
02
`g 1432 eQ 20 `d aGdG 2011 hGC 20 dG - 1913 O``dG
WdG dG
...eGC OY a ''GqdG'' Y cGC e
````j bh ''``WfZ'' `a S Ij
fJ LGS ''``G''
G```S 3 ``Y ````Y G``Z hGC ````dG
`af 12 j FG`G
e a S ja HS
GM
E G QGe jGH
Ij j ja HS ''WfZ'' S
fGE dG aGMEG QGe jGH e fGdGC
dG fdG ''chGC'' e (2002-2001) Se a
b ,2005 fL M WMEG ja a d
J e d dG ''a'' dGE GQe j GC
Se fdG fdG LQdG dH a dhCG
OdG dGE TGC 6 Id Oj GC b e c
dGE j dP Hh ''chGC'' `d W MEG
-2007)h (2007-2006) Se d jGC ''ed''
-2008) Se a d ,dhCG LQdG a (2008
4 Id GY e eGC dG ''H'' dGE (2009
Qj GC b a hCG SdG d M GS
fEG ''JQH'' dGE dGdG SdG a
.djEG ''dHf'' dGE QdG SdG K
''#dG'' S
,''#d HS'' ,''1 d'' H
''ddG''h '' d dG''
dG eh INGE f''
FGG qfo GC
''e Y
e dG FQ OG M Q fGC cGCh
j d fGC , dG I d f dG
FGdG GE b d'' :b M JjJ
fC ,iNCG dG c b JCJ
dG Gd ,IMGh dhO jJh INGE
dG W af GC dG e c
IGQe AGLGE Y VY dG ddG
cH a IO Y A d T a jOh
fNG d ,dG af 12 jQH
H Vf jNGC IGQe Sh FGdG
a T a J d dG LGdG
hj e g GC OGM cGCh .''VdG
fJ J N e b NG
Cj fGC dGE Ge ,FGdG LGe
Y cCJ GOe g dG OhO H
JCJ jdhGC gjGE Ge FGdG QNG
.NGB e GC b
e H iS IGQG
jL 5h IdG
FQ j J e b fGh
a iS AdG GC fdG edG
S fGC cCa ,MGVh UdG
fC IdG eh jL 5 e H
g M gD dG G M dG
jGH Me S hCa ,LGdG
jOde IGQe Sh SdG Gg
,bEG FdG T eGC FGdG
jY GC H gL f dG dGh
,VdG jCG a jRM NdG
H AGLE J jL e Qhj bh
LGd GOGSG H jQdG dG
d SCG g Hc jZ dGEh ,fGfJ
.IGQdG iS jGC Oj
Y iS fJ IGQe
j dG G f
SdG jaGE Ad
iS dG dG Ea cCdHh
dG f g S fJ IGQe a
jaGE ae ''dG'' a j
GC j e ,HcGC T jGH SdG
e e eeGC j d jRM
jCH fGfJ IGQe a ,Qd bdG
dG CH be j GC Y S
WdG dG a j dG
,dG jf b dG JQdG
dG ddG Y AH S e gh
cJ Gch jL 5 Y Y S
.dG dG IdH
S.f
j d dG AdG jd Sh
dh ,VdG a 9 j dG H
a S dG dG BG M Oj
IdH cJ e H IGQdG g
hS a ,UdH jL 5h
e NGB OY jJ jRM NdG
jO dG IGQ dG g a Y dG
gh ,dG jO T b jdG
hGC 23 jd j GC a jj dG IdG
SCc J QZ H Nj Y 24
jfe J gHh ,2013 jaGE
.YdG QhO a 2014
fdG eG
j
E H eGC OQ
''dG'' ca Y
j FG dG jO JG MQh
edG FQ OGM QfGC jH
dGE ''GdG'' Kd cGC dG ,fdG
H jOdG IGQdG eg Y fJ
AGLGE eCj fGC , d eh W b Q f
H dG a f a jOh IGQ e
jOJG eJ M , dG
hGC Hc W Gg Y AH jFGdG
aGh dG fdG Jf dGE eGC
SS fGC edG FQ d cGCh ,Y
dGE aGdG j dG HdG OdG
H dJG e d H '' dG''
dG S c ,(GX c JEG)
.(FTF)fdG edG be Y
eG FQ) OGqM
qK IhGQhQ'' :(fdG
IGQGh JjJ
UdG iS
''`````jFGG
f
C G ddG
1 VjdG HO Qeg- fe QH 14:00
2 VjdG HO fQf- fJQhO jQH 14:30
fdG ddG
03
d dG SCc Ff
5+ VjdG IjdG JdG- jRGdG 2:00
dGE efGE cC J e I j `d Sh
cGC e IMGh a dG fSEG ''WfZ''
dG e S e gh HhQhCG dG
''jdG''h ''UQdG'' IQU a dY jfGC eGC
edG g fSEG QhdG Sh ,UN
H aGMEG QGe AH e a S dG
,dJdG ,fdG QhdG a HS d GC
Y cCdG j ddHh ,djEGh fEG
FGdG YdG HQh Xe j Ij GC
H 3 cGC a dG e J dG MdG
j fEG , f SEG fh HhQhGC a
.djEGh
bdG eeGC S
YGd GqL dG L
C
''#dG'' IdG
a dG b dG BG I j eGC Sh
c fGC UN jdG Sd dG d
HdG jOf a HSGC e OGfGE Y Qj
VhdG YdG c Y qM dG ''H''
jh ,hCG jdG e GHQj GC d
j M adG bdG jd Ij GC cCdG
jdG jOf J dG idG YGd GgL
18 j ''jQa'' LGH jGH ''#dG'' a
H LGe K HGdG ddG d S
26 j ITdG ddG d fTH HhQhGC
b e ddG d ''jQe jQ''h HcGC
8 j (18 ddG) gdG Me e INCG
.eOdG dG e fL
JGQ Y S
jS hQhGC dGC 700 j
e Qe e Y e M BG cCGh
e jS JGQ S NCG Gg GC Ij e GL
''H'' e dj c dG j ''WfZ''
gh ,jS hQhGC dGC 700 `H QdGh ''dHf''h
jO jR"'' ej Y c dG JGdG
QdG SdG gOGYGC MGC a djEG ''QS
jdG YdG c JGhQ UJ eb jGC
JGQ Ea T hOh ,''ddG'' a j
e hQhGC eh hQhGC dGC 750 H hGS Ij
.jdG jOf
S G c `a
`JGEh ''`WfZ'' e
FdG QGb
JGE Ij Ea fQe d c e Mh
GL Sh ''WfZ'' e dH FdG QGb
j c fGC ZQ OdG Gg dGE fEH
a cQdG d j Of a dH dG
Qj GC YdG Qqbh ,HhQhCG a dG
j c jGC WQdG SdG jQS
S Z b INCG YdG a GE Lh a
dGE fG d AG S dG j dG
djEG ''dHf'' hGC ''fEG ''JQH''
NCjh GjT V j j c e gh
fjh jdG Sd GdG a Gc
.dG a SSGC fe V b Gc
T Y aGjo ''WfZ''
YdG Y AGH ''H''
fSEH dG S Ij
IN
C G dG AGL
E
VhG e
Y Y dG bjo b
K
E G j J fh
Y
E G FSh GE
M GC dJdG ''OQjQ'' be ch
dGE aVGEh YdG C S d Ij U
''WfZ'' a dG jj j d jGdG a fGC
a cQdG d j Od dG a Zd
a dhCG QGhOCG Y dGh HhQhCG adG
SdG ag OM WfZ) dG ddG
cGC jGdG e Ij Ea ,(#dG a AdG H
Y K fS
E G adG
dG JGH j e
QdG
q GC dG dGE bj QOe e ''GqdG'' Y
-fGdG'' Ibe j jb ?WdG d YdG
j c ,dG dG j
C G a VH SGE ''FGL
dG dG jdG e AGHG '' dG'' G dGC H
d Le e J jb
q Ea Y e Mh ,J
d ,U
C G d dG a ZQ e dh Jg fdG
,FY aQ e
C G a e j M FdG aGe e CLQGC
eOdG dG j
C G a L Y Y jb e JGh
.VdG a d
Lh H j YdG
M a f dG VH Ea dG Y j ch
Gj ,jN
C G SdG a Hc
C d d Of e d fe
jdG j e ,S 19 e bGC d fa d j
S c GE ,Lh a dG IOY
E adG bdGh edG
d j GC ,FGdG OGLGCh FHGB SGCQh SGCQ e d
GC Z ,fa jhdG SQGe a ch YJh a HJ dG
Yh d ,H Lh a j d YdG qM dGEh YdG
a FdG c j GC Y ,jb Y e
C G a dH
.jRM YH S dG dG N VdG
WdG dG
jJ a cGC SdG GC ZQ
S d Qqjo d fGC
...`````HhQh
C G ````ddG ````a 18 ```Fb ```Y ``HGC
d
G
e
C
G
d
G
M
IQ```T `Y ```aoj ```j Y
```dG ``FdG ``f
C ```FdG hGC 31 ````b ````LhN ```j ```dah
,FdG IQT M IN
C G JjH IjT V jRM Mh WdG NdG MGC
d fGCh ,j e iS GYa
B G e jJj d dG Fb IQT GC cGC eY S
.N
C G dG a dd gGC Gfj GC hO a H gj eh AjR
C G VQd j
Y qjo jRM
fjRh I"H Yh
Y Y e M jRM qjh
j eCGh ,YG Fc UY KK
U j GC Y ,j Y hCG FdH
GE jM Gh K F c jR c
GE dH dPh dK Fc I"H j
dG hCG IG gh ,jGC g ebGC
c eH ,dG Gg I"H a Nj
dhO dG LGJ X dP Y GH
.HS jUh Qe
Qj d jQe M
SSc e Yf Y
T .
d Y j d SdG
AjR
C G VQY Y J
j dG J hqD j W c GQh
jhCdG ZGC Uh ,UG jH
jG J SdG GC gh GC ,IMGh fN
j Y G FdG GUb jdG H
G U Y G e LG J dG
Z ,INCG IdG d d dG jfCGh
e Y e Mh L dG GC
YGC fGC H ,NGB Y h j Y j
LQ eM ij GC jj fCH f Lh
,GG a dG e CH GFb GjU
j M ah M LGC e j e
.eCG fGh Fb Y
jRMh Y `d IQdG
jYe e j
M L a eY
E G e FcT e eQ H J f
`Y
E G ae T Y Qa h N
f
- FG dG J d W dG
jdG eQ T SH S
C G Gg ,f
T Y M Qa h e feQ IS
.eY
E G
Y edG d dG KdG Gg
dG ,d dG j dG Q H dG dG
Y f UJ G J g L jR L
.S c e eQ T a H GdG
17 AHQ
C G j f dG fedG IdG
YGP
E G je b a ILGdG dH hGC
e d Ua fc f h jFGdG
dG Gg c Y
E G FSh e
dG h Yf e jdG adG h adG
Se efH ''RdG b'' h dG e H
c h .''Triana dAlger'' ba f K
jdG H Od fS Ua jGC AdG
UN VGdG e M aV h dG
dG f h .J
E G H dG J
dG IRdG FdH dG g N L
.2011 d h
C G SGdG N f M
YO ,adG J JWf QWGE f a h
e GQWGE h WdG adG dhDe f
dG fedG QdG dGE JG b
FGdH WGdG H hGC 18 dG j
Uh Sh aT Y dG h UdG
.Oe dG Y dG e
Q dG G g N j Y d c a
L jRL dG dG jdG U ,fedG
HJ dG IdG bdH Qa L fGC'' :
d Fah Y cTGC .jFGdG adH
e a d aGe h FGdH fLGJ e
e cGT UGf GC eGB .jQe h JWf
L a e gjJ h WdG adG
id h''.dOdG dG h a dG O J
,d N
C G SGdG M dGE b J
Jd WdG JGC...:L dG U
L FH 2011 d h
C G SGdG FGdG
IdG H fQe ,e f a h IRe
M h HQ
C G j a S ,2010 d
Y dG f h .GQSG M h dG
h IdG JGQSG H jFGdG dG a fe jJ h jYdG IJdG g
.dG idG Y h dG
Y
E G FSd e jc fe f cDJ ,adG J dG JWf N e
.dG a QJ GC fCT e cGT . WdG adG h
GL TH HGE Yj ,NGB fL e
LGC e INCG fhBG G W dh
Ua fh IdG JfeGE Y gdG
S Se `H qe eH ,EG jdG
jGC ''Rg Qe'' HdG QG e jd
NGB jc ch a Ge 3 iS j
QM ,M jL Y ddGh ,dG
Y H HQJh GdG GE jGdG e
e YG PGE ,dG bdG IO H dPh
j FGG Y qCH ''j JQe'' jL
e gh ,jQdG G jLh IH
Y g Sh S Y Af j
dG bdG W e H dG j dG
.?d G YGhdGh
IH j da
jh ''d HhQhGC'' a
''egdh'' a GZ
id IH da V ,NGB S
eGC hGC IS fGchGC aSGE
HJ dG AdG ''d HhQhGC'' He
cT O e Y , LQG e M
GgGC AL M ,OQ hO ec KH
hQGB aGG jW Y EG O dG
,O c jeCG F Kh R g
eb FGG hdG AaQ Vh dHh
Me NdG j dG G QhdG
GE dG eGC da Ojh Gg ,YG
eY ,IRG jEG ddG AGLGC
M ,''RQQfh egdh'' LG j
YG e M Q M G e
,GGE Z Sh bGdG jG GE G
.e 18 Fb LGJ d
eGC .U .
j ''ScdhGC'' Qe
Y hY jh FH
```YdG L
jQJ cqGC
ffj eYGE
fQGC''
q GC eGC
QdG ''OQda
Od fS
E G
LGE ''ScdhGC''
IN
C G j
C G N
OdG FQ e
L M Md
OL Y
b jdG Yd
LGB AfG
,eGS
E G
Qe
q GC aVGCh
W S
C G ''TGE''
Sh Y hY L e GQa bdG
a aVGE d WdG dG Ge
Nd GOGSG dPh GdG Sh
.HhQhGC HGC HGQ He QZ jdG
MGh AH bjo jU
HGdG YGC
Id fdG
eGC j dG
JHY Y
dGh YS
C G
Y Sb fc
a ,jf
C G H
SH cT
cdG f
YGC dG
jdG LGe
SQdG
e ,ed d
JGC iNGC L
jU aQ cP
Y bdG V
Ad fK a fdG QGf
E G Y J
,SdG Gg ed ja e Vj
,agd eGC QdG S
C G Gg M
ja IGQe eGC d jU d bh
e HGdG ddG SH cfe eGC
j HY J j GC Y ,''2.d''
QS dH'' LGj eY dG dG
a OW b c jU GC cj .''Qe
bY bh ,GhJ eGC SdG L dhGC
.jGC MGh AH ej
Y M'' :''j''
YJo d hdGh qL
''JGQb RGH
E
e c Y fCH ''j'' c c
FGG YdG LGC e Sh
jQdG jL GL j dG
d a Q e Mh , JGQ b RG HE
H NGB ja GE MdG Y Y
M ec VGC eY ,ge QXGE
LGC e IH YGC fGC'' :HS jdG Fb
jH jGC j gh d dH M OjGE
j a NGB O f c GPGEh ,I c
IQGOEG ''j'' cGC c ,''JGQb QXGE
31 b WdG G aGe f CH
J Fb GE jGdG FYSG ZQ
L eGdGEh Q Gf Y 19
M aQ j ,OdG jQ J
Ad GE IYG FdG e SGE NCG
d dG QG Vh M ,''h fO''
Y S dG GQG ''j JQe''
a LGj dGh Ie e G G
jdG e Y H , M
jhdGh Rg d jEGh ,ShQ S
ASGC fL GE ,adG Q ffg
Lh jH Je ,c S `c iNGC
JJ Qe OqL c ,bhQCG Y hjQ
QN M qCH cCJ HS Jg
.YadG GQG OJ e JHM
jj da Qeh IQGOGE
hGC 31 b e qdG
c ,da Q jJ NGB h
hdG e dG OdG f ''j JQe''
dG fG Ia jf b FGG
dPh ,QG hGC 31 j HGHGC Jo dGh
qGC ZQh ,JQYGE hGC M Y H AGS
OdG e QGSG Qb '' G'' aG e
,dG JcG GE bCG Y dG
e IQGOEG Mh dG bdG hj
YadG GQG OJ X ,QGSE
da j M ,JeN GE LG Yh
eGC b c dGh M h jW Y
eOb ,VG dG EG jdG e
.jJ hQhGC e H fd H e
dG MQ H
QhdG ,''hdS''
M Y
Ic jH Qj
,QdG GYHh
!?T
E G jCa
FdG J GC Qj
S S jGdG e
YdG Y
e J b dG O dG ch
aGc j c dG ''hdS'' G
eY ,HdG jCG N jGC Xh ShGC
WdG dG
dG H idG a VGh QdG'' :fe
''```fdG ````fdGh h
C G
Qc cqGC fdG ''Je SQc'' U e jM a
H Gc ba Lh qfGC WdG dG aGe fe
S ja Se qGC GcqDe ,hCGh fdG dG ie
e a eGC J eY'' :VGCh ,HdG jZ a
,qdG YH CLJ ,c H J hdG qEa d
cGC f GC Y Gd S j d Se qCH f
dhCG LQdG a AdG qC e a dH dG Y
.''dP Y S
````SS
C G fe j b
``jGE ``eGC cLGC ``aO ``a
fe fe Lj GC dG e ,iNGC L e
fJ jGE Ad N cLGC aO a SSCG
eGC VdG ddG Ad N jH QT GC H QdZ
e e Y j b f eCGh ,WdG dG HJ e IOdG a NCJ H d
''L'' e e OdG H OY b cLGC ch .VdG AdG a NBG g jH bGC dG
.SdG Gg ''1 d'' a dhCG dG RGMGE e Jh
SL dG SCc
Y Qj jRh joh Rj H
dG SCc Hd h
C G QhdG e IN
C G ddG ae V
OQ hO H dG Of aQ H jf Ra ,b a dG SM
dG RdG ZQh ,dG IS bGC dG AdG N aGdG Of eCG
f QhdG dGE QhdG a d j d dP
q GC GE dG Y M
eGC fjR jc YH dG OJ f YdG Vh .FdG
fdG YdG IQGU a FdG f dGE dH gCd (2-2) dG
. M
C G GZ U GC LGS M
N QfGC H j
jffS cCdG jjoh
fS
E G UdG a IQOdG ''J je'' U f
HGfH eJ VGQ d aN Of gL GC jQe
fG H H J dG IdG OYdG e ZdH IQGO
E G
dhdG GC IjdG cGCh ,HO IQeGE eM dGE jdG e
H ,Gd d ,Qf
C G Vjo d d e FGdG
S Yh ,jffS SGQ e eOb QYH S
id SQo dG IdG J Y Z j e jGH d
e jdG SdG N jdG GAd hGC a aN Y
''SGQ'' HdG jOH d S fGC dG eh ,''dG''
.jffS a ''hjOQdG'' H
AGV
C G Y OH
E G UGoj PdG Y
b GE j HQeh
b cGCh jU c Qe M
d d Gc qJ'' :Y e jRGC
''fYj d d ,fd
OJ GC oj eQO GC hQ Gg
05
fa Z `d S
C G J V IOHH
dG V d e
B G e aGe IOHH gGHGE ''fha SGh'' IjL QNG
HS FGdG jOde Y qbh ,''2 d'' dH e ddG ddG a fa d ddG
```````fGfJ
GL jb dG HJ a S dH
WdG gDJ Se Ye
GjR Gd Y e aCG J b
ddG SCc d Gj dh
WdG j YH Se Ye GC cCG jh
H Y L e aGC J b AfG hQ dh
ja e GC cDj NGBh FGL fCH j fCH j
,eeGC he Z QNG Ve GCh FGdG e gGC ''GQ''
eh dG c a Gfj d YdG ADg GC UN
SCc L dG GjR jdG jR e jFGdG Id Geb
jRGdG jfe Y f d dG c ah fd ddG
OqY bh a b jfe M ShQ h H dG h
ZdGh QGUEG Z a J gMh ASCG GC QdG
.GdG Y j H GE J VjQ a jdG
S .f
N
C Hh ''dG'' a Lj dG dG VdG aO
jj dG jRM Mh SH fGdG QdG
dGE UdG dGE N
C G Gg ,j e SCH Vh
C G J
j e j d OGJh Y e j H fGC Yb
..GgGC e dGE
f Vh dG g FGdG
WQdG g a
jdhGC fa j dG L
GH
C G U GPGE FGdGh
``````S
C G QGM
:`````jU
?c c SQdG QNh
?qS c IOe GC ah
IN
C G JdGh dh
C G JdG Y dM
dG FGdG f
E d M e j
...GCS
C G hGC M
C G j GC j
W j GC j FGdG fEG ,f M
dGE jh HYGC j GC j fGC c ''M''h
jae jFGc W g ,Qe ST fGE
dGE IdG ddG e f ,NGdG e GL W d
ddG dGE f ,b bh a dGh dG ddG
,SdG a Gc W ,dPh dP H SdG
.jNBG a dG S GQGTGC h
H j j dG I J S
C G a jGCQ e
?edG
MCG H a j GC j dG dG a
e d fGC ,d W g dh ,QeCG j d
j'' hGC eJ Y ''JGQdG'' SQj dG PSCG
a j d J g d ,''ZedGh IHdH Y
IJSCG Hj e g edG GC XCa BG eGC ,eR
.''QGO edG''h J bda ,dG dh
.eGC
e AS M GC YGC dh ,U G g f
eh ,''dZ dG'' dh L Y g ,a WdG dG
IQGM'' j FGO GZ GC g fCH fjh fj
Tc e...IMGh jdG dh ''hY TGh ec jh
.''GRe'' WH GgGC
GCH S GC a...b dG I c `c d
?eQ T U
?dG a
...''GqdG'' IjL e a H Me dU
jaGE d H J a ,dP b J ,f
a UNG c dG MQ dGh ,hdG VjQ a
jdG jdG a VjQ c fGC c , e 3000`dG
dGh bdG dP a jd GQe c ,''FGdG jOde''
jGE'' ddG IQSCG e HJ fGC M ,aj c
e e c fGC M ,Gc VjQ c HGC ,''HJGR
ja a We c fGC M ,YGfGC H VjdG
.''#jdG'' Vjd
a SQe VjQ GC ,dU fGC Y GPeh
?`cU
.jGC L Y c
Y dG e MGC e ,G L c g
?e d jdG jQdG
c d dH ,?dW SGE j e eh ,W
gh ,dG e ''jdG''`H fYj AbUCGh gCG
.''ddG SGE'' jo c hGC ,''dU'' dG S J
?FdG ddG
.dG dW
e dG j Y M M e c dU
?jdG GBdG
ch M M c aGC dh e dG H ,f
JcGP a J HQ ''GH Te jT SH'' df
e cP Y e fGC ,GMGC 9 dGM
dG J b dG ATCG g
GC H d , ''GhqR'' fGC SSGC Y
fCa jdG GBdH j eCG
GMGC 9 MGC fCH aGCh bGC
e fh GCf GC feGC da ,e
Y Lj e gh ,e J
d S Gdh ,a c
GMCG OY M dGE d H
AGdG J LGC e MGC dG
LGC eh ,GBdG M Y GdG
f d Ih b f GC
.dGh dG
SQ dG a
N
g d dG
GC f c
?Ze
SQ dG a
b ,''b Y'' c
c ,''dG''...NGB dY f JGh Ge
Ic a Yb fGC H a'' j
g ,UGhGC GPa ''dG
MGC c Y
d c J e
.HfH dG
dG d fGE
f eY Y
a jL fGC
H dG I c
g e J dG
dGC , dG
?dc
fGC...KQc fGE
fGC XGC T
a'' j c
YGC c a ,''H
Y cGC d fGC
c ,G HGC G c
GL V
H j a , f a F Khh L
?GPd ,hN
B G
h g f TH qa j eR e GPGE''...j
Y IOjR FGL fGC d b ,a eGC fGC ...''qf
dGE gdG OQGC d ,dG e S dG aGC fGC
,BG dh HT c eY dP a a d HhQhGC
a dh dG jdG IQjR dGE JGC HdG a dh
QhRGC GC FGdG d fGE ,jCG e j a ''jH'' je
W b e QRGC d fC ,a dh dG dG iQGCh
.JM
'' j H'' j e a `cG HGC LG J c
jFGdG HdG e fc g ,fdG
e
''GdG''
:fJ dGE
S .SGE
YdG j fG
HJ e a fG e dG JH T Ye fG j
,c J Sh OdG bh a AT a ,"QH H ''OGdG'' H
Mh ''dG'' YH Gc OTGC ''OGdG'' a je CH Y c
Mh jNGC e cGC YdG H bdG GC c dc YdG NGC
FGa H e Ggh ,''U hh'' dG H J J d dG UdG
.HdG
dG jjh YdG Sh Qj S
ae Y H j d ''dG''
hGC 27hGC 26 j
G dG
''OGdG'' a je
J J JQS j
dW
dG GU YdG
"QH ib iMEH
e AGMG Y Hh
C h ,e Y "QH M
MbG a ,dG j g eGC
Y f ''OGdG'' a IQGOGE
idG Le MGC dGE ''dG''
M ,"QH M e jdG
JOYGE K dG IU H GhOGC
.GOe dG dGE ITe
100 Y GJ
'' fJ QjO
''L he
c dW adG FQ S
e "QH M dGE J Y
j (O 6500) fJ QjO 100
AbG LGC e ,L he
UQ c jQhdG H
GC ZQh ,''fjfJ'' jT
H J GC GQe c dG
QGUGE GC GE ,FdG Uh
FdG NCJ MGh YdG
e j L UdG a QGf
.Y ddG dG jRJ dW
aQ J dW
fach L
bW dGE
dW ''dG'' H FQ J
je Vh dG IQdG e Y
dGE aJ J ''OdG'' a
Y Gc J dG ,bW
QU dG LGC e "QH M
Vd ,fach `d T
eh ITCdG jJ e a
Gg dW j GC JdG
e j M dG dGE KG
,fH IdG FGdG IQS
GC QYH dG GjGE b
Md dG IdG
RhJ FGdG a JTCJ
.GT
jQdG dG eb
dH eGC Y ''dG''`d
bh ,GY HGdG dGE dG
eH Y dG bdG OYG
edG hGC edG YdG Y
e fc dG
C ,fh
hdG LGe Y IdG a
.d jOh He hGC a
a S QGf
jN
C G edG
HdG e
HH QGf FdG S
edG a Y e M ja
Ic H ,e jN
C G
jh ,dG JfG
JG a Lj dG QGf FdG
Y dW dG FQ e ej
HdG J Ich IU c
GC eGC Y ,YdG LMGh
.Mf
E hdG MGC a j
bdG LGB jJ ZQ
''OGdG'' a je Vh
J JQS "QH H
Oe ''dG'' H FQ J
e ad LGC e ,dW
Gf Gf jQhdG LdG
e dG N e gh ,dG
e IQS icG fGC c dG
e fach L eY f LGC
Y dW Y bh ,OhdG
.dG jd Th feG
eb MQdG M
H HGdG dGE
hdG He
dG gh ` Va ` SdG SG Y gQH M
Y aVEH d j J dG GRLEG OY Ea
.gOGJ dGE NGB
S IQGO
E G fc jGC
?adG AS
C G
Y GC f d'' :QGf
''OLdH cGh
Yj d JH T OGJ CH SQ Hh cCJ
jJ Y Ggh ,IdG g N jL NGB Y CH
IQGOEG GC ZQh ,QdG dG e 24 dGE bdG LGB
d Qe aGe Y H MQ a jb bh dGE fc
gNGBh eGSG Y gGJ fc dG ASCG V
hLGj jdG YdG L e J L fT
jJ Y HdG a LGe ,jOY H jdG e
- dG Q fGC M - IQGOEG QG b jh ,Y GC
.bf Gj OGdG C Ic Iee
d IOdG e jb c fT
jJ aQ ''U''
25 Vh IQGO
E G GC N
B G dG
HGdG dhW Y IRLEG
YaO Qe CH dG aJ H
QfGC WGC ,jOMGC e dP dGE eh e
Jh Y Ia N fCH d chDGCh ''dG''
M ,dH Y Gj GC j ddHh
UH eGC ,ddG jGH b aGC S
dG bdG eE H c GPGE e M dGD S
Y fCa adG Qe e a Y OYG
.NGB e GCh dG Gg T LGC e OGSG
Y N CH Qf
C G J PGE
.ja
jdG Y N fCH Qf
C d chDGC f
f d Mh ,IfdG g e f e ch
bCa OGdG OJ H ddG jGH a HU
c Y OSh JdG Sh a S fGE d
.dG
.INGC c
07
JH T
Gg a jd e c f GC h S
c ,jJ Me gGC j dG H dG
IU c f LGC e e J Y cTGC
S.G
.''GdG'' Y jH d Ggh Ich
H jgdG f Y j dG j
,HdG Gg a HdG e O d V N
HJ a JGJ J c
?"QH M
jd FGQ hX Sh j HdG
AT c MGU ,YdG e Ic ZQ Shh
f j fEa YdG jZ dGEh hDdG dGE Yj
L eY dG OGRh Lf HJ j GC
QfH a f ,YdG SM e jQdH
bdG VY Y ''GqdG'' jM
IjL IQhe e aqj jqdG L
dG a jM GC cqDJo GW
C G H
''HGQ'' J d jFGL e a
,G j M e gh ,IMGh bO H bGCh
c dG dG e dH qJh eGC M
eGC GC hdG X eH UN ,Y Vhe
q
g SG c .YTEG GbqUh ''S .SGB .S''
J Y G WTG cGC GC fC UdG
qf jZh C ,AeEG He JGhQ KK
JGdG b M M Ja ,dG g GE GHGC
Yh ,eCG e c Gg ,dG Iqeh dG
eh fT J Te'' fCa ..Ic OH a LJ
jOdG QGe d Gh ,''ce J fGQ
.''OhM jh e Y GC cDj BG M GE
fCjh aj LGH
jQdG
j M YG c ,GOqR GE aVEHh
jQdG qL GE LGH jqdG IOY e G
aVGE ej MGQ e OSG eH FeR e
M ,dG e j c dG HUEG H
e gh IgdG gCG eGC qdG GE VG
dGh H J LGH HUGE d ,GOqR e
GE j gH d qd NCG AdG e
bh Ggh H R PGE .jGC N MGQ
b ,dG dG Gg gCG e jGC N
e jQdG Tjh eGC hGC UdG GE Oj
gh ,HUEG e Ff J qe ,YG
28 j gCG Ad GOGSG dG e jH qj
.jL 5 e hGC
,dG a jo ThT
IN d d
dG SQ eGC''
YTGE H dG e qJh
''S .SGB.S a bJ
bdG NqCdG Gg c S Y d GDS h
e e j NGB jZ GE QfGh dG Y
(OdG G GE Oq GC b) hCG jdG
:GOqR LGC ,IRLEG Wh dG Y d
qc Y jZ e gJ GC b e d MU''
qc a Lh dG jOdG H fGCh AT
T GeGC GQGC c dG bdG GE j .MGQ
IH fG dG QNCG d GM dH VGh
aQh jQd We Y jdG
AdG GC c ,gOYH IQGOEG J GPGE dG j
c GOqR GC g ,YTEG g jJ gS dG
Ia jf b Y OqL j dG MdG YdG
GE LCG HGdG Oq GC b ,hGC 18 j jdG
.QG hGC 25 j
a f b HGE e jM eGC d c bh
j He WhT Vh hGC IQGOEG hS j GC
Y j L dG MdG dG CH e ,dG
,He c fGC g dhCG edG jQdG
YGC GC j jdG G GC d G'' :Fb
gCG Ad dh MdG HUGE e
LGC e Ggh e fGCh G
''MGhQ Y `ef R
B G d ,`eN OGOdGh `LdG IGQe''
gCdH Fe fGC ec e f g
a J fGCh gdG HdG dGE
?IMh H IN
C G JdG
``HSGC 3 qV GPGE dG dG
JCj K jOddG Y
GC dG e fCH d U b c jZ
dGC ,dG M
C G SSGC jRH j
?jdG J a KDJ
K
E G Ae FGdG a HGQ
H L e jM d c fGC jZ Y c
GC eGC d Qa
E G Ye b b d HGQ
j eGC FGdG dGE dH Yh fdG QdG
fGC jZ dGE fG HGQ `cJ M,K
E G
dG f a AL dG MGbG c Y aGe
ee dGE ej b gdG Y H SQGC dG
a S dG Y bdG CH jZ VGCh HGQ
H Ge fhdG jdG Y dh FGdG
b jGC S dG bdG SGCQ Y HGQ LGJ
.c AT dG g
C G LGe Ye
cGCh ,SG M jH dG d
eGC JGQe Gc Y jh j GRe fGC
q
h GL HG UTCG e jZ ,gCG
H MQj CT GQGb j hGC j GC jj
fGC G ,YEG FSh dh Ld Lh
GPGE d chDGCh dG bdG j QGb GC MGC
hGC cGCh d aCa Ua Y jRH
.j e
.?QGdG Gg f GC OJ GPH
NGO AGL
C G g c
a SGC b jdG
jdG JGQe Y
?dG g
C G eGC
dG dG hGC ,ATGC KK g
dG bdG H j dG dG
e j c Y M jQdG
QL H eb QJh Je ,Me GE Me
J U J GC dG e d fC d j
eGC LdG OJ a fdG dG eGC .IQG
gCdG eGC MGC dG g ,hdG OGOdG
g e dG dG NJ dG c Lh GO
IOGQGE a ddG AdG eGC ,ae H ddG
g e T d gh dG IdG YdG
d j e f h c ja jOdG ,IQhdG
fh jEG dG af GC Y fgJ dd
.Ib H ddG
e fj c dG HU
E G e AdG dGE KJ eH ,eGC hGC Y ,YdG e jQdG L dGE GOqR IM FGdG jOde aGe OY
...dG g
C G eGC gdG IGQe b MdG ie Y
''``````````HGQ'' ```````ee
`Y Oq`dG ```a ```Wj
`````jOddG ````Me
````aqeo hq`````dGh
I``````jL IQh`````e ``e
FGG jOde
dG h
C G
,''````fT `````J ````Te'' ````fGC ``````cDjo GOqR
```````jo ```````ThTh O`````````j ````````LGH
:`````jdG ```Y
08
:J
e e bhU TGa jORG SH
dG cH Y S dG H HH IQSS
bhU FY OGaGC d j ,''eQ de''
dG fH Qb
C Gh g
C G c dGE aV
E H
jdG aGd adGh dG e ,ddG
.`che dGC dGC..dG AfGE bhU FY Y
dG h
C G
b e ''GqdG'' H OfGE c
cdG HM e VZ IQGO
E G
HS jO jJ aj ShY
''WGdG'' oS g
C G
a ''WGdG'' a a dG ad UdG IQGO
E G M
Ia GC dP ,QdG hGC 28 j LGe b FGdG a ebGE Ia
S M ,YS 48 RhJ d FGdG a dG jdG ebGE
q J UN IFW Y
dGE IOdG J GC Y ,hGC 26 j adG
.AdG jf H ITe IgdG
```jo ````jfe
QG`W ``````dM
jOdG Ad b
g
C d dG bdG j
e adG Y j
C G g dG
a dhdG FdG je
eh hL Lf jdG U
WdG H jJ HGC
a H Gj dG IjdG
GOfG H IN
C G fh
B G
M ,d VJ dG IOdG
GC dGE jQdG ej QTGC
VQdG Y h
C G hDdG
e W b jfe RL dG
QcdG g
C d fdG dG
L j GC a e
H jJ HGCh hL e UN
jGC b Y dG J
eGC j
E G IGQe Y b
ddG d FGdG jOde
YdG QhO e HGdG
HGC LGjh .jaGE HGC Qhd
j
C G a SGh M jJ
IjY GWGC e IN
C G
MdG hGC GYH a dJ
Ge LGJ H OdG e
Y aGO jfe RL GC ZQ
jOddG IGQe jf a IH
idH OTGC M ,IgdG a
d fGC Y cGCh H X dG
j e de IGQe
hL Lf J dGE dJdG
,hGC28 j jOddG Ad f
Z e YdG Gg fj M
a adG ee eGC ddG
L e gh IN
C G jQdG
e YP GOfG dGE VY
QGgGE H g
C G gL
.UdG e dG
:''jQG'' M
``dM ``jo RL''
Wjoh QGW
''```Y
GC jQdG ej a AL b h
YGC g
C d dJdG QdG
Ad GOGSG QGW dM
dGE J M ,FGdG jOde
IQhV Y Mh Y
FGdG e IOdGh RdG J
AGQh e j c ,OGdG eH
Je jOddG Y RdG
FGdGh IgdG a de
dG dG T IOSG dGE
jQdG a Y HZ
Y jfe dW c ,IN
C G
h LPdG AN
C G Y OHH
J OJ
.dG UdG
...QO``````c ```````H
dG Y QdG jh j jZ
09
''dG GE jQG Uh
Y J e IFdG e''
'' jd fc GPGE IhGgH e
''IMGh ''W
dG dG d dG jZ Vh NCG ah
N d FQ Y J dGE J f c
IjT d Vjh MdG a Zj dG IhGgd
Idh dG d cDhGC'' :Fb Uh fe a j M
dPh cd dG FdG g S IhGgH GC INCG
AGd YCG LQ MGC Jh SCG a jZ dGE
GC hGC IGgH e Y J e IFdG e ,ZCG
YGC fGCh ''IMGh W'' jd fc GPGE ,NGC T
GC chDGCh ,dG a T J d IdG g GC GL
.''dh b UT
C d AVQGE hGC dG LGC e dG Y
d .
dG UdG jZ Y dG e j Mh
N jOddG a j c e M IQU a
`d dbGC e c'' :Fb jM UGh a ,HdG GdG
Jh djGE e GQGdG QGUGE H ,H g je
ZQ ,Z hGC je dGE dSQ ...JdH jOddG
jdGh dG qJ dG GC g ,Gc eMGC fGC
dG g GeCG MU Ea dd e Of UGC
Yh SCG dZ AGd j e J GPGEh ,Q j
gh jdG d JCa SFd Se Gj dG dG
.''a j a M
`M T g c GPGE''
H G ``SFQ j
''j``ZY a GM
E G
GC J aQ S M jUh Te GDS ah
Y j dG IhGgd N cd FQ NGB T
dG dG ''jZY'' dG Ic a e qj d
e AYGC H W e X AGQh ''J'' fc
UN ,je TQ dG LdG e QhdH IQGOEG
NCG ZQ UH eGC H fOfG dG dG H
H JGh ,d FQ OR dG Y J a
dG Ud ATGC IY Vd eGC U ''jZ''
U a ITe NO M ,hdG Y dG jh
e e d MGH'' :Fb d Uh V dG
chDGC GC Qb dd ,J dG ORh ,je jM
M hg Of dh cT dG jOddG GC d
,OR ,je jc e ,Oh g e c a j
Va dG hj GPd iQOGC h MGC dG fGC dG
LdG Gg H a GC Lj jGCQ a fGC ZQ Y
.''IhGgH QOdG Y ddG FdGh
je S c jGC''
TH ef c
''YdG qfh gGQdG
dG h
C G
````````e
''Gq`````dG''
``fJ dGE
CH hj IQGZH
HdG dG GWh fG
S .SGE
!O 5000 `H Y e j
ej dG dG hGC fH NEG M f Y dG Aj HQ
Y hGC jQdG a IdG eQ dG S Y gh ,a dG e IQGZH
a YdG NGO Gg ,dP HT eh QdG AGf H SdG bdG a QdG
OdG YdG e a j dG bdG H e dGE da LQN eGC jQdG
J M c ,YdG FbUGC MGC aZ a Y LGJ hGC aZ dGE
.UQ e QjO 5000 N MU
ef dh dG g dG'' :jY
''H NGE GC eGC
Y J hG
GZ LGJ ae
hdG L Qe j d
ae GC Y YdG jZ dGE
Ad dK a dG IS LGj
c LGe H Ggh ,J
ZQh ,eGC ''dG''h IdG e
H HdG a J OLh
aj IQGZH GC GE gGQdG
e He hGC
C Ggh LGe
eGC S dG SdG dH
fgQ c ddHh jdG Gg
NCJ dG fdG dG Y
.gGQdG H dG a
fK IdG LGS
hGC 23 j
Gg a adG b Hh
Qb dG bdG Ea HdG
OJG H FQ e dH
H fK He eH IdG
23 H jQJ OM jdG
jOh LGe dK S hGC
a HdG Gg N jJ
ae GC Y QdG Y M
.hGC 21 dG jQJ a
HjGE ''dG'' Ad
G GE j
MdG eNh
27 j
a LM JH T j d
IQGZH e Y aGdG
H j
E G LGe jH Ggh
dGE "QH H HJ
c dG gh dG dG
26 dG j iJ GC GQe
GC dGE dG Ojh ,hGC
eN LGe eH ''j''
Y eGC e dGdG dG a
N S dGh ha
J GC Y dG efdG
VQGC dGE ITe gH MdG
.dGdG dG U WdG
M LGC dG
eGC hGC dJ
H e f dG dG H
He a gdH dG OdG
dG bdG NGC a ,IdG
eGC hGC Y jdG Y
dGE FdG dG jGH b
e dG LGC e dJ M
d dG L e ,dG
dG fdG TfG Mj
fCch YdG H Qj c
.dP b ej IdG GLGj d
GeGC Hh eM
cdH cG
eMh GeGC H e c cG
cdH eGC hGC IS M a
Ggh ,QJ YdG H
e fj dG HU
E G H
d VJ dGh dG a h
C G
H fdG a IdG eGC
h ,HdG dG a Jfe
he FdG HUGE J
e dG Z eh Ic
jdG W e dG J
eGC M a efG b j GC
.jJ bGC Y dG hGC
H b e Y OQ b j IdG ` J He
dhCG He a ja NBG g jY dG fGY
c dG jQdG dG bh b M PGE ,IdG eGC
e N Ggh YS f dGH Vd j
MdG H hqO b NBG g jh ''j'' LGC
GC dG M eh He hGC a J J dG
.bGQhGC L Y QhH a j d IQGZH
Hh IQOG Y e W
bW aQ cG
IS M a dG FfGE H ''j'' Qe ch
dGE YdG j GC adG FS e W b eGC hGC
e AdG a M ,bW hO Ggh ebGE a
S OGOdG C J eGC IdG He LGC
QOj dh ,ddG e dhCG ddG a ja ae
a GE gGQdG Y ce HhdG dG Qe
H S GC H HdG e INCG dG FbdG
j d fGY GC ZQ OGOdG J dG MdG
j dG ddG dG Td TGC LGe a
.Y OYG
fG j GC hj
AKGC fG e dG d IQGZH hj dh
N e gGQdG Y cH J eGC IdG He
Y Qj b e a bW AYGC aQ SL
cGQOE Ggh ,a jg ae fdG jdG
dH LGJ e fGY cCJ GPGE fCH (IQGZH)
dG UdG e XH bGQhGC N dGE dH a
j dG dG J hGC Y OYG j
GC fCT e e ,RdG e cGC K e b J
aQ OGOdGh dG Ea IQTEd .IQGZH dj
.H LGe
d N e
gCJ IOYGE M
"QH
09
hdG L
dG TQ e aGdG N
dG e e HUGE e fj
HdG jGH e YdG e
fK gCJ IOYGE M dGE
dG "QH M cH
FSdG e Y j
GCH bh ,IQdG dG
J Yd dG ddG
GC cDdGh M
C G f jQJ
gS aVGE LY M
cGC YdG M J a
Y jgL LGC e Ggh
jdG IOY Y ITe b
C G
.WdG VQGC dGE
d GY je Y OQ
IdG eGC ja
M jf H gGQdG Y cH IQGZH AH
AfG b jZ dGE eGC hGC IS jQdG ja
aO e dZ dG Gg e jQe Ff
GC ,dGE QhdG H K dG H
?edG Gg J
QKGB J dh Ic hO HUGE UH J d
dGSG QdG a Gd ,J a LQ Y HUEG
Y fGCh UN HUGE dGE VJ e Y aJ
.Gc IdH j
.HdG H dG hdG Y KM
Va e J dP eh jb ae LGh d
jgL Y dG j G g Z Q d , Y e
.IMGh jJ He a eY e jdG
GC GC jdG jgL Y jG g
?fGh
C HS bdG
?H eJ dG dG Gg cDj g
SQ``a .
Ke
''GqdG''
`````````dGE
``fJ
. ` S
S ah
dG h
C G
GQ`e 20 `dGE `YdG `b j QGq``S
`VdG ``SdG `b H 2012 `ahh
GE OdG YdG H e J
d IH dG Y e fGC
g ,J e h
C G dG a
a NdG Y dP YS
?jdG AGLGC
IQGOGE e JG b c dG a
iS j dh AT c Y TGdG
Gd efG Sd dG bJ
QdG H YGC GC H UN ,OdG
LCJh IQGOEG WJ d .QT
Gch Ie c a bdG Ve
TGdG a bhGC fL ,dG
.adG dGE JGBh
AGQh ddG fdG j dGC
H S a bdG `cQNGE
?TGdG
SdG a adG iJ ch
?jdG
fe VGC GC g hCG ag
M Y dGh ,dG a SSGC
c ,jQdG SCch ddG d
WdG dG H dGE WGC
.adG HGH Y d
jQdG SCc cJ Ie c a
SCc J J d fCch
?2008
GPe ,OGOdG e Je c d
?dH M
jGH bh OdG J H
W bd eb 2009 -2008 Se
CLJh ,jOY H IRLEG
AeEH d OGOdG IQGOGE AYGC dH
jdG e aVGE Sd Y jJ
J eGCh .ZQ Y c e gh
Y bdG Qb ,bH W c
.SdG dP a dG
dG Y bJ QGb CH iJ GC
?AdG H GNh jL c
OdG a GLGC Y
C G LN Hh jOY
`Yh Q``qY f `e 15
e
B G `YHQ Q`LGC `b e 6^5h 5 H
ddG dG J a j QGqS
dG dGE
fTGCh dedG e MH Qe 21
Ie h
C M YGC IQGO
E G
JQOeo d Z
C G S c hdG
bY GC ddG d d ,
d fC ,S a bJ dCH
HJ a cQT a e MJ
a SCdG Fd dG TGdG
a c adG a bJh ,e T
,jW Ia gh jL T e
c a a LDJ jdG IQGOGE X
fGC dP Y ddGh .bdG Ye Ie
JG ad a bh dG dG a
ej e e Wh jdG H
g adG IQGOGE bGh GC c ,aVGE
a dG OLh AGQh fc dG
H ITeh IQGOEG C ,S
d dG d SQGC JG M
Y c e ,WJ dh bd
.jdG IQGOGE e dG
OGOh e d d ,U Gg
H GY d eGC dG J
,2007 -2006 Se e AGHG GS
fdG WdG dG dGE df ejh
,idG a jGE Me jOGC fGC ZQ
e ddG a MGC H e ch
d j d dP GC Z ,FdG Mf
Me a dG FdG X a
a FdG dG fc dGh gdG
f f d fGC cDj eh ,WS
ZH g SdG dP a dG
eGC JQNh jQdG SCc Ff
a ,LdG cH jH T
Y MCG dG a c IGQe
e fK Se d dP H .GdG
e Mh fdG dG a OGOdG
ah ,2008 -2007 Se a OdG
L e d bh ddG SdG
.OdG Gg e UGhGC
jT e 100 H Y 7
H f fh HdG jGH e
e MGC Y J c QeCGh jL
dG IJh ,hdG MGC ah Gj
j c ah NGB dGE j e JJ
WT b ,jL aVGE Y g
Sd fdG dG fL e Gc
J Y Y e IGRGe ,jdG
N e jdG Y H fG
H f dG dGh dG dG
e fGC dGE aVGE .Sc QdG e
Y a S jGC J eeGC Gj
dG IJdG H dG UGe
fdG jJh ,HdG H fGCH
e OY H Yd dG
jgL d jOdG HdG
.MGdG L e dG
jT e 150 S OMh HL
``ej 15 `a I`L a `Y `j e
S `a ``V`j `e Ge 8 O``jo
dG AGU
C d Gf ,dP Y IQGOGE dGE dGE adG VY e b S Ojh
a e e fdG dG Y j e GC ZQ .Y jW M H dG
JG dG dG Ge 8 Oj ,adG e JQG GC e GM a S dG ej 15
YdG Gch IL OJG IQGOGE e GeGC Y j fGC UN ,adG IQGOGE e Y
.gDj dG
Y efH V `L
C ddG e`fRQ G`LQ e W
GLQ Od dG LdG e e W ,AdG Y adG IQGOGE e bJG Hh
Y Y efH j M ,e T jf jZ dGE jdG SdG efRQ e
.SdG OGeG
G hCG
GA``e
E G I```a ``j'' :Q```M
''`H S fCH HGC jdGh MGQGC
I a j H Y Y fGC HQ
.NGB S
C GAe
E G
H H JGE M dH Y d ,LGC
SC GAeEG Ia jH fHGCh baQ
.HGdG W e L QGb Ggh NGB
TGdG OJGE
0 dGhS . - 5 TGdG .GE
.Vd dH ej QGdG Gg
OS ah ec SGC eeGC GR e
.QGdG PJG a qJGC dh cGC IQdG
j dG F dG e gh
?GO
a e ah FO g c d H
.f a qM eGC g d ,VdG
?g e
AT c Y jdG FdG e JG d
M H CLJGC GC b AeEG Hh Ia e
.LGJGC L e AeEG d N
`g .
q GC G
''JdG'' QJ dG
dGC G h fe jo dG IGQe
11
dG M e g H Qb e Z e Gc fJ TGdG qGC Y e N jh
dG qGC GE OdG Gg e e JEG Za ,dG eGC Oh Ad eH Y VdG
Gfj d dG bdGh YdG qGC LQd OdG AdG VN e g MWe c dG
S fc aGe C QYGE dG qGC dG dh ,S dG dH Y Y
.e be a TGdG
.`g .
Se SbH
AH
E H QT YH QdG b dGE fTGC c e
eGC dG SbH IdG OJ
E HdG SQdG Y
,TGdG a Sd Y Y VdG dG Y
.dh NhO H TGd ddG SQdG dH d
QGS
E G qa'' :j"
''G````e
C G ```Y
e QhJ FGG jh e
IQf
E G TGC UH jG
T
C H qS ''QGE'' cT
IQjdG g eg Y QJ fEa Y e Mh
jhJ TCH edG IQf
E d ''ejGE'' cT J
E H af hGC e
q GC UN ,bh SGC a IQf
IQf
E H dG jhJ Vh b fc WdG HGdG
.H aV TGdG S
E c
YGE Y e VZ Qf
C G
GAdG d e
Y jdG Z Y TGdG QfGC e c OY qY
dG dG Y dG Y H QT QdG
Y S Gj d M ,jd Oh Ad GC j
.jdG GAdG g gQM Ia QT qJ
QH
C Gh dG H GJ
GhS GE GJ GUe 50 GM
O QqJh GVM c QM
Y qe QM S TGdG LdG hj ,S ah
OH QJh dGhS H GVM c M ,YH IOdG
.Y j dG dG efdG ah
KH f Vj TY H
`` N
B ``VhY J''
''jGC IVM fc Ge
C Gh
a AeGE
q GC jM S a j" cGCh
NGB ja OLh Y H j d TG dG
Z b MGh j AH dGE dH dGE j
dGE Ge ,(IdG jJ J) jdG S
VhY IY Uh AHQ
C G IS jZ dGE fGC
Ge
C Gh je fc fGC ZQ aQ dh
AH
E Gh QGS
E G Y H f
C IgL fc
.TGdG d gYGC dG c Y
''HdG dG H Fe''
GdG H jdG GM
C Jf Yh
J Y H dG a Y dG
jdG dhDJ jb j d IdG dZ
SdG a UdG g RhH e KGh fGE bh
ADg a dG Vh j fGC GcD e , j dG
TGdG CH j f
C je JYeh dG
`g . .jdG SdG dH a f VS
Hh Tj Y j QT
Y YG dG d ah Gj e QT QdG qGC Xh
Tj Y OYEG UGe N e HdG jOdG GAdG a
V H dW YdG
MQe Y Y SCJh
jGdG e H
d jo jdG
jdGh QT e
Ad N e
GhS
L dG SGE ` e S ah
dGhS eGC OdG AdG Ua QM
jh QT YH HQe e d
qGC d GcDe ,FeGE Y Ve a e
g c dG jdG ee a JH IdG
e Jh dGhS e a GVM NBG
e Oe be AYGE hO QM
.H S fGC Y cCdH
g .
jdG `d cGC QM
L
C dJGE fGE fGC
Ae
E G Ye j
jdG Y Y bd jdG H
b c YdG GC M , L e aQ
Y J Y dG jdG Y TGE
d dP d dH Yh FdGh A eEG
YdG L e gh ,Fd Y j
e fEG Q jh A eEG a j
a j d b dG GC ZQ Vh dG
jdG Ia jf GC QYEH e
.VdG dG IS IQe fc
H J
E H dW jdG
aM QMh IdG
HYGC Ahg Y
HS bh a QM d c eh
Fd Oj TGdG a FeGE NCJ Ea
H S fGC d VhGC dG jdG e
bh a H JEG H dG d
GC dG dh ,dG M d HS
dG N Q M d j dG
d e d AHQCG Id jQdG
d dP d dJGE j X fGC cGC YdG
a ,VdG a Jj d dd j
AdEG QM e TG dG F dG
H QeCG d dG Y H
.jdG dG Y bdGh Ff
Zh jdG LH CLJ
Ae
E G Y Ge
C G
Gj e MGC Y AT c QS Hh
j gh IjT QM ICLe fc
NGB bG J GhS
jf a ae OjGE e GJ a TGdG M dh
Y aGh dG dGhS OH eCG jh jOh LGd dG
hdG OYGC e gh ,OdG AdG VNh fGH TGdG SGE
.QJ Ad H K Oh AH HdG AfGE LGC e dG bd
.`g .
Y HUGE H QYGE
Y d NGB a hQj dG e L dG dG Yh
dG HUEG d LGQ dP CH Y a TGdG LGe
SQ``a .
dG h
C G
Ke
''GqdG''
`````````dEG
``fJ
.`S
IS M
IdH G
a Sc QdG cqQ
JLGC dG jQdG dG
e a adG J
eGC hGC IS SOGQ
e dG dG Y dG
GH UdG jQdG N
S ,IdG GSH fdG
H fG d e
dGE UdGh YdG
UdG ''dG he''
.Y j dG jdH
GeSCG HJ QGb
FU c eBG e
H J Y H Z d G A S C G e h
f J a j C G g Q d G a d G
LdG f SS a UGS dGh
e j d d G G e S CG f d G
S RGL b S H HdH dG
dG HjEG dG Jh ,HY a
Gg b e eJ a IQGOEd J
jdG eBG e Hd dSQEG YdG
J Y h U d H d G h S a
LSG b jJ QfG a bdG
.hGb e M e S RGL
a a d G H J e j U G J
gh ddG YSCG NS dG fJ
L eh ,jOdG HdG Me
HH dG adG OGJ j iNC G
d G d G H c G b f J
dG Y fGhe eC G Y aQ eQ"
QGqS e IOYEG H ad GOe eCG
a I Q G O E G A Y CG g d Z d G
.YdG Gd jJ
Ae dG eQ"
GL eGC
eQ" Oj C G QdG e c eH
I S G H f J a a d G H J d EG
,bdG e qJ VdG dG
GL j CG IQGOEG AYCG a M
a eCG Ae fJ -FGdG MQ a
J A e f h H G d G O h M
.cCG bgQE
Y aQ J
a d G I Q G O EG H U EG H e a h
e H d f d G L d G d S Q E H
S E a d G h S a j d G e BG
YdG AH e IGRGe hGb b d
Jo S f j dP QfG a
CG a C G e c d G I Q G O E G Y
e H e b d G f A G L E H J
H d j CG h G b S Q E H G e S CG
aCG S dP C ,jdG eBG e
j J Q f G a b d G J e
M ,SdG GJ jJh dG
c Z e B G e H J c EG
YdG H J dG dG jd
.fJ a
QfG j hGb
dd b jJ
25 j ddG adG ae jg
Oq GR hGC
11
dG j '' :OM
''HJ jdG H
Qj QY
dG VH cGh
JLGC dG dG aY
dG IS dG
cQe Y SOGQ H
dG
B G H QY dG
ie Y e fj
HH cG bh ,cdG
Y dG Vhh FeR
. d
C G Ve
QqJ Se H
B G ZQ
IS M Y Z eH
dG
B G H AHQ
C G
ie Y e fj
Y Se H OY ,dG
e jQdG AGLGC
IS M a YdG
.
B G QGSG ZQ dG
QqJ LN H
N IJH
H BG e Jfe ZQ
H ''dh'' `H j e
EG ,YH ddG SdG
QT LN H SQdG
q CG
dG IS M a
N IJH QJ d
e f dH j dh
.SGdG H
SV f
LCJ LN H
dG GE
LN H SQdG j d
d j dG SdG H
LQ
C G ie Y eGB
M ,eGC Ge c e
.dG dGE dG LCJ
HL ,Se H
GN jHh
UN d
`e e
H e c N L e
d jHh HL ,Se
H ,fdG dG e UN
Hh jH e c qV GC
AHQ
C G IS M Se
.
B G H
ac Ff
e jH
Qhj jOh
dG
T
C H H b GC H
Y GB e Jfe H
FdG AL cdG ie
Oj dG jH `d e
f Y dGE eGB S
jf gGLGC dG hdG
Ve KCJh VdG SdG
N dG fdG dH
jO fY L e .HdG
gh QU a
B G H e
dG IQjR dGE aO e
S
C G ad eGC
.dCdG g deh
dG jOdG HG Me Nj adG
ITdG Y hGC 23 j ''eR'' LGe
e L gP e''
''adG QeGC J
fC HdG a KCj d adG GC OM VGCh
dG YdG QdG dGE Ge) e QOZ GCh M
eGdG YdG Hh (QGdG e Y H Z c
jL L JCSh NGB L ALh Y e Geb GC H
.ddG dG j
e fGCh QTGC''
''jQdG qVGC Y
ja jG SG ''
''Y j e
''2007 dH cJ HdG''
IcDe QG Ife''
''d h
Lh b dG eGC a H L dG dG a
SdG ah a aCG YdG j FbH QdG
Gch HdG ej Y OM MdG Y VdG
jGdG a OM bh .ddG jdG d Jf
MdG e IcdG jdG H dG d j d fGE
dGE aVGE ,YdG hGC dG bdG e AGS fdG
HjGE GTDe j e Ggh YdG H IdG AGLCG
g HdG a dG dG C L Se AGOGC LGC e
fdG d jdGh ,hdG SdG a dG jGH
.e LH
Th fGC G VZ''
''HdG b
fGC aW e fc dG dG dO GC OM VGCh
HdG a GLGe ch jeH QGg QH dG
FdG e Jg de J OH hCG ej e
fV GC j GC hO a dH e bJGh QGqS
e QH GeCG j Yc fGC VGCh ,de JhGC
jdG Sd JLGC b Mh dGh dG Ic j
.S e 20 `H iS VdG SdG Y jJ
e Sd S ah a S fGC OM VGCh
GL 30 a S jdG e Y GC ZQ ,dG H
GL Je fC dG jJ YW H Qb fC ,2012
.adG a
S c e ch MGC e MGC''
''M
C G g
LGe S f IG
ja
E G HcGC e ''IhGG''
Y N fGE j GC jj e CH QGqS db Yh
GE NCG b OMh HL j GC Y adG e
GC j d dG Gg C ,d dG e c a eCG
Ic a IdG dG dG Y QGqS db H fGE
JYe Y e jdG N T Y cGC c ,dG
OS fGCh d ej dG IdG FdGh HdG a d
.GdG a d dG
je a S dG jJ Y qGC OM VGCh
Hh H J GC j fC jdG IOY H S
b JdG a KJ'' :UGhh ,ITe H QGqS
hT GC LJ h AT c Y JG Jh HdG
.''dG jJ He
ja LGe W dG g Sc
SG hO
LQ f d ie d ja''
''hOj AG
. S
S S jdG''
''hT He LJ h
```````FdG ```````T
qjoh HUGE CH b `Y
``MGL ```Y AGLGE `a
dG aQ a baQ j GC b U e JGC
,BG e SGC H fdG a gJ dG LGdG a
jRGdG b Y hQOb fCH Ic a Kh
GC fGC c ,g e HjGE H IOdGh ,dd
.''feQ U'' jFGdG d bGC
SdGE.
fGh jdG M e eJ Y S c
dGE aVEH ,KG a j eCG Ggh ,aGMGh
T a Iae dCdGh dG eGY c Ea ,Gg c
NGB AT GC a dG Y GC SH j M ,FdG
,ddG IdG a dU a AT c Ea ,Gd ,dG GY
fC ,jhdG e a fL eGC d ''a dG'' MGHh
q
FdG T a dG a GE j Y GC GC cG
GC c ,NGB AT GC dh MGH Y HGC c e Ggh
OHGh ''MdG'' Y qN OjRh jg e HGE LGJ
.(j) ddG Y
,dG aO N a ST S adG
?JdG H IOY X a UN
INCG fhBG a fL jM d c d ,f
jdG jh VGe T a cG d ,MGHh
````dG
`````H J d
```dGE `````MQ ``Ye
````fdG
IQe FdG T IQGOGE dGR
,fdG dGE dG
q j a
eb dG hdG c GC UN
M ,dH AH
B G M dGE H
jdGh .IRe ce
C G Lh
ch iMGE GC g eGC GCW dG
MQ OLH IQGO
E G NGC dG
24 j HdG AdG QGdG Y
dGE IOdG jQJ GC Z ,QdG hGC
j `d Qqe f
C FY j FGdG
Y Oj b e gh ,hGC 30
IQGO
E G H J d Gdh ,dG
a d TM QGb J Jh
.iNGC GH Y OqdG YdG
fdG dGE j QJ
''QdG'' Ge Sh GC qJ GNGC
FdG adG e S QJ YS
,dfdG ''Tc'' je dGE
IOdG IGQe a cQdG b
''Je'' Of eGC S dG
H Gg JCjh ,QdG hGC 27 j
be M b dG dG dG
WdG dH bdG Gch
.fGfJ dGE d
fGC Y jS
Y HUGE e fj
hdG
ie
Y AGLGE dGE jh
Y j a ,MGL
jGC IY e cGC jOdG
.c
C G Y
```j
``a ``HUGE dGE VdG e
````ddG hGC `cdG ```HQ
C G
j GC g Y SQdG j e cGC Ea ,HdH
hGC cdG HQ
C G ie Y HU
E VJ b
,HU
E G g e fj fGC T
C G cGC GPEa ,ddG
Ia hJ GC jh cGC Ge S e
C G Ea
HdG SQdG jj e Ggh .jW Ie LY
GC UN ,QGO
E Gh dG bdG M h ,jd
ZQ SdG Gg ee SQM GC J d dG
Sc a j dh aH OGe ,d ae hGC IQOe
.QGRe f SQdG iS dG MG
Y .S
T
C H a AGLGE e W ''"''
H L Jg JG a Y SQdG cGC e Mh
Y TQ dG W e W a ,eGC hGC IS
IRM TCH a L
B G bGC a j GC (") QdG
eh e fj dG HU
E G Yf e cCdG LGC e
dG jH jGQO Y j M ,JQN ie
SQM j bh .AdG dGE Kd S dG
,M bCc M
C G GZ hGC dG U eGE dP dG
bh bGC a jdG W dGE FdG j GC Y
a j ''"'' GC UN ,H dG j e Qj M
.cdG HQ
C G hGC hdG eGE jeGC
M Y AGL
E e fEa Y cGC e Mh
e M a Gg d ,Ff H HU
E G g e j
hdG ie Y HUGE dGE VJ GPGE
dGE VJ dG HU
E G fc GPGE eGC .(mnisque)
,MGL Y AGLEH ej a dP e NGC
e gh ,jW Id GdG Y OHG dGE jh
dCJ J a IjT ZQ iHGC dG Y jj
dh
C G IYdG J H UN ,SdG Gg dG e
dG T
C G KGC GPGE e M ah .WdG dG e
:`Y
''JWMGE N
B hdG a He c GE cCJ
C T
C H a LCS ''
IS jQdG dG J d
ae feEH a ,VdG dG
?dG
a IOM BH T d ,U Gg
dG jQdG dG jGH b M ,cdG
jGdG e ah ,IdG a IQe fc
dG ,''"'' ddG Gch eCH HQe NGC GC
K GL Ib Ia HQJ ddHh ,H J
Y GQOb cGC d fC ,GdG QOZ
aQ jQdG dG e J e UGe
.FeR
?d VJ dG HUEG W g e
dG HUEG H d Y MGH
,cdG a IOM BH T d ,d VJ
W a AGLGE Y dG e fGCh
GC JGCh ,HUEG d ,TCH
fGC ''"'' d cGC bh ,IN HUEG J
.UdG a h HQCG a d
H dG QfG a ,dG jJ H jGdG
dGE FdG fCS K ,dG j Ae TCH W
fYGC dG HUEG W Y jh Y d ''"''
.e
fGC UN HU
E G g AGL b dGC
dGE dG e b YS b J
?IOdG Ad a cQdGh fdG
VdG GC U ,UH e b d
j GC j GdG e IdG g a HUE
d HUEG GC Y eH d ,JGJh Y
TCH UdG Ff QX QfG a JQG ,IN
aQ Qd OYCS fGC cCe fGC ,H bCS dG
e JGCH dG dG UGhCSh ,dG jCG a FeR
X a UN SM bh a JGC HUEG GC ZQ ,Ie
d ,IOdG IGQe AGLE fdG dGE d JGOGSG
.jdG QdG GE Y a ,YdG f fGj eCG
a HUGE UH b e Y AH
IOdG IGQe a `cQoS g ,cdG
?Qd IQdG J M eGC fdH
FH ge AT c ,UdG Gg a d Ia
Y e fGC c ,H bCS dG dG UdG
dG MdG ,VdG GH dG bdG QGb QfG
Y QOb fGC ij c GPEa ,QdG g Qj GC j
ej a dG M a eGC ,aCa cQdG
GC ZQ cQd GgL cGC GC JGCh ,ebEH
eeCa ,fGhC HS fdG IGQe a dG Y jdG
.OGe .dG e jdG J GC jh jGC IY
f g d VJ dG HU
E G g
jT S'' IGQe H d VJ dG
?dG ''RQS
e f '' :f
''IH OS fGC a
FdG jdG e Y NCf GC jCJQGh
c JGOGSG Yh ,VdG Gg Y fKd
fdG AH jGH dd jRGdG d
GdG Y dG GAd e Ad hGC a ,OdG
.a LJ dG VdG e dG GNGEh
:OdG Gg a bh ADg H e f ch
a dG Ige Y YGC d eCG M a''
fe GC d MU ddh ,INCG cGdG
Y dG J gh dG fdH d
jQdG SCdG UHh .Se c dhCG QGhOCG
cdG a f GC Vf d fGC d chDGC
jGdGh bWGE NCJ d jdG JOYh ,NCG
.''HH bGC fGC e ZdG Y fdG AH
RdG'' :jGdGH
eOdG LGdG a
''je fS
dH cGC d'' :M
''jT S eGC S dG
dG hDdG If e M c j dh
LGh e fGC ijh ,jNBG AeR J
S dGE jdG IOYGE Y Gj GC Yc
,dG c e j c HjEG FdG
a'' :Fb dG FGd HdG GdG U M
eGC S dG dG fYS d ,dG
fJ fGC e ZdG Y Gc jT S Of
dG j d fGC dGE TGC GC jQGC d ,dP H
dG adG NOGC GC bh ,d dH NCG
SCc a g e cGC SGC GC Y YCS
GC dh ,ag g Ggh GNDe f dG dG
Lj dG VdG e jdG f GC g gCG
.''dM a
bCdG GC cDjo jU
a S f
E Gh
eOdG LGdG
jU Se QdG c j d ,fL e
dH Ob aCG GC Y hDdG If e
c j GC QhdG e fGC cDj M ,dTC
S fGh bCdG GC ,UY e Y
bCj GC e aGC Lj h ,jQdG Qhe e
UdGh ,BG e dG H e YdG
Y .dP d ddG ''dG'' SCc a JGe
ag fjj TMh jU GC e ZdG
Ua GE g eh ,LGC e aS FQ
dG dG ad Qd jdG d
.T H gJ
ja SGQO jjo
RdG dH
SdGE .
J d dG GC Y JGE
N
C G cdG a QGdG
fdG dGE S dG
RdH IOdG LGC e
GC ,YdG e Ic Ye iJh
OdG AdG a Ic H j b ''jdG''
Gg Ge VQGC Y eH Je Of eGC
j b dG eY GC e ZdG Yh ,NCG
dG GC g cCG GC GE ,e jdG eGC FY
LGdG a ,dd dG J c S
FGLE WGjdG fdG dGE S dG
Y GE YdG H jM Lj fEa Gd .g
e HjGE H IOdG d J dG jdG
.dhGC Ic WGjdG fdG
dG OdG ag
f 9 M LGC e
12
?dG d a GPeh
a ae Ze Y Gc dj PGE ,CdG
,j dG h d f dG QG Z Y gQjO Y
fGC GS jNCG jg GC UN
ee Y dG dheh dG d je
Y LdG ee a IdG d .dG
LJ LGC e ,Mh jGdGH ,fj QGZ
fGC H ,dd GgGC dGE cdG dG
eeGC JGe UdGh ,Gc dP a hj
.eOdG IGQdG a ddG IOS
13
c ,dH dG NGB H e c
?
B G jZ dGE hRh J je AGLGC Lh
:(H Je Of Qe)h```c
dG ddG a RdG ``fo `d''
''````````gdG ```HdG ```dGE ``gCS
Je'' dfdG Od dG VQdG Y h
C G hDdG cGC
fGC ,dG Id ja
E G OJ
E G bd IN
C G JjJ a ''H
f QhdG dGE QhdGh jQdG NO dGE dTGC IOH GL Fe
Y J GPGE e dM a UN ,jQdG adG g e FdG
VQGC a S dG dG JQdG gQ c e
K ,QdG hGC 27 j FdG T e c eGC dGdG Y fGe
a dP Ve dG S 10 j dG ''RQS T S''
Of M Y FGdG e H fY dG RdG GE dG j'' :db
S dGE fOYGCh eCG d OYGC b ,gdG Ad a FdG T
VGh Qe
C G GC YGC ,gdG HdG dGE gCdG ITCJ bG
Jh UdG SG GE Y a gCdG fOQGC GE d dH
dGE gCS ddG g a ,fGe VQGC a de jQfG
.''jQdG Nfh gdG HdG
T
C H dG Ff H j
```dG h
C G
```dG h
C G
dG e SGC H ,fdG bd
J d GN dG dG fdG
,jS MO fdG dG GTGE
AGLGC Y dG Oj GC Y
M ,M
C G Gg IS jQdG
e fdG MdG S
dG LGd J GdG
Je Of eGC QdG J dG
M ,hGC 27 j fdG a H
dG IJh N a jU GCS
dGE dG b Y gQ
E jOJ
.eh bT MQ a fdG
Y .S
jdG d dG jU QdG Gc
MJe Sh ,Y id dG a
.dG a fdG Gg e
W b j jU
eGC eGC efH
jU Se QdG j ,L e
J Oj c dG efdG LGC b
IS dGE ,eGC hGC YdG Y
dGE FHdG QdG OY GC a ,eGC
dG bdG eEH UGC ,dG
M NGB a dG AdG eH
d MGQ YdG e b jQJ
de SQdG Ife X ah ,MGh
cdG ie Y HUGE e Y
,jdG H e QdG Y Yh
e SQH SG b jU j
QGRe f fL dGE d SGh
C G
.j
C G g N
eGC h
C jQdG dG aY
dG Y e SQdG e c Z
cdG ie Y HU
E VJ
G VdG e c M ,GNDe
Hjh ," Y dG dGE j
,N
C G Gg J e UN efH
FHdG QdG f Gf fGC Z
dGE cdGh dG Y a a
dG dM J GC Y MGdG
aGdG jGC dG Y Z c ,cGC
Gj dG N S QdG
d S dG UdG efdG Hj
dG HU
E G H ," dG W
dGh ,dG ie Y e fj
dG LGe N d VJ
Je OH L dG IN
C G
.dfdG H
IOdGh MGQ dG
M
C G Gg
OY FHdG QdG
dG e a
Id jQdG dG jf H
e jQ Y FdG AeR OSG ,eGC
M dG Gg MGh d MGQ
ec LSG e dG j
dG jQdG dG jf H
SH dG bdG eH dG
IQf
E G OY ,YdG GQS AGVGC
UGE J M ,hRh J je dGE
HZ Yh N
dG Y
q dG
GSG Y
GcGh GQdG IQfGE
dG M cdH
dG hCG
``j '' :H
adG b ae
''eeGC `J ```M
d dG bdG aj
jRGdG IOH b
M ''SfS ShO''
N
B j e jQdG
e cGC Qhe H
fG Y YSGC
LGC e Ggh ,HdG
a UdG NCdG `cQGJ
H fQe GdG
WT b dG dG
Sd dG a Gc
M ,jdG hdG
hGC IS jdG QJ
jGH Me Y eGC
dG jJ YH
e dGE LdG K eh
J
E hM dG
,dG e fdG dG
eR AaQ L e gh
jT H hj
fdG efdG f
S dG dG
.QdG
b T
QL hH jQdG
dG e
Y cJ
fdG fdG
?Qe
C G J c ,GdG e ddG S
C G NO
Y C j h b T U a e Y Oe fGC
H g IL hdG c GC ZQ ,HdG AGLGE e Vj GC
LGC e YdG H UGdG Y j e MGh H j da
a ,HdG f GTDe c jd b jeh fG N
e c GC GC dG jJ YH dch W Te H Qf
NGO jfGC IY OLh dGE aVEH g ae dG Me a Lf
.jOh e iQj OGf OjGE jdG Y j e WdG
?INGC c e g
dG M
N fc
dG dG Y Y
M AaQ gGLGC
e fc dGh YdH
ShO'' QdG Ea ,jd
J dGE Y ''SfS
N Y gQGE
H eH dG dG
dGh hM dG
c ,ANSd N
jQJ H Y bG
AH fGh dG
.jW j d J
j jjGE
jdG bQh Y
j jf
ej jRh
YdG e
j jf jc efG
H YdG e jRh
dG dG N jOY
eGC hGC IS L
dG jJ YH
dG H K eh
HZ GC H Ggh ,hM
IdG j dh Id
W cdH cG M
H jJ SGC
Y HU
E G e Jfe
,HdG HQ
C G ie
QdG LefG Yd
.efdG J a
UGj M H
Y QdG
OGfG
RJQG Y UGj
QdG M H dL
H Ggh ,OGfG Y
Y HUGE e Jfe
,HdG HQ
C G ie
de j d M
N
C G AdG H jdG
Ggh efG LGC e
,HU
E G bJ N
Y j M
cdH HS ''HdG''
a dG eg Y
dM J GC QfG
bdG Qhe e J
YdG e ejh
.jOY H
QJ ''SjGE''
YdG e
Ie h
C
e ee JG jd
''dG''h ''dG''
d Qf
C G
jJ j
I"H OGDa hb
a bh dCe
jH WdG HGdG QGb GC hj
hGC 25 dGE YdG GAeGE Ia
I"H OGDa YdG e a S
VjdG OdG IQGOGE NO dG
,e ee JG a dG
Ia jJ J M a fGC d cGC M
''S.SGC.S'' `d bS fEa GAeEG
IQGOGE dGE H UN ,Ic H
QJ .eeCG dG YJ Y jdG
VdG SdG d I"H GC dGE IQTEG
HGC HGd dG QhdG J
.HhQhGC
IQYGE T Y S
e Je Gj I"H C Gf
IQGOGEh Se Id H dG ja
jJ hGC Y RdG aJ jdG Gg
OdG Ea ,Je e He GE
Ghj d dhDeh dG VjdG
Se Id YdG IQYGE Ia W GE
M dGE bCG GbG gh ,ec
H e e Qe d cGC M ,dG
Y aGh jdG IQGOEG GC dG
Y MGh Se Id fe YdG IQYGE
YdG hT M a dG j GC
.jOdG
jJ IQGO
E G
aVGE Le
Vhe a NO IQGOEG GC ZQ
e He GQe GC GE ,I"H e ee
UGj jdG GC d cGC dG H
UN aVGE Le Y dG MQ
dGE Sj IM YdG VJ H
,jW Id jOdG Y J b HUGE
dG O hO H dG b dG b G Y h
QJ .NCG OdG AdG a eeCG
H ''RL'' QdG GC dGE IQTEG
bdG VjdG jdG e W bJ
.Le N e
QfCG jM e a dG eCG
eGC hGC jQdG dG jf H
dG YdG jJ N cCJ H UN
MdG j jjGE GC ,dG Y Z
GLQJ jdG jdG AHGC e H dG
LGJ e ZdG Y aUGC e a
dG QdG je e KG Y
H jdG f dG M FK g
.jGC Ma hjdG - SS
CJ d Sj IM HUGE GC hj
dG a YdG dCJ a ,bh a
bd a hj c M ,jd jQdG
j QdG L e IL fH
SH d dAj QfCGh JfeEH
H e HdG QOdG H Ea ,c
jJ feGE GC d cGC dG
Y OHG Ia GC UN ,IOQGh YdG
e M TGC 4 Y J d jOdG
.He MGC d H U
H Y NGB fGC UN
jdG AHGC e
dG YdG QJ
h
C ''cGjGE SjGE''
e YdG e Ie
dG H bdG
eGC M AKdG j
Id aGMG Y Y S .IM
jQdG Mh Se
dH OdG AdGh
Y d ,b fdG
eGC HS RH f
jdG ''adG'' QfGC
SdG U fhj
hGC Id jQdG dG T
IQH Qj gh
Y gL QM VGC eGC
jhDQ QfG a ,W
,hM dG e LQe
H a e
b GdG fG e Ggh
jOdG LGdG
OY Uh M ,jJ YSGC
gGC e c eGC edG
Ojh ,GB 5 dGE ''adG'' QfGC
HY je OJGh dG
ja GC e gcCJ dGE dG
dG dG Gg N
.YdH QS
.hM dG H
gL QM VGC
eGC hGC M a c
Sj J bh ...
Ia a S
''JcdG''
,dG H e cDe Qe Mh
d Sj jJ a a IQGOEG Ea
ITe YLSG jJ H Ff d
jGH GC HUGE e Ad KJ H
,jO T a dG ''JcdG'' Ia
aVGE IRLGE HQ jJ WH fC
QJ .aVGE LH jdG YJh
Y J b Sj GC dGE IQTEG
Ia a jdG
J HJ
de Qf
C G
VdG H
Gj GC ''adG'' Y Y j
j eCG C VjQ hQ H VdG
Se jOCJ dGE edG ja H
dGE J IQGOEG GC M ,FSG
bdGh Yd MGdG hX c aJ
H HdG fGE LGC e dG
ddG GAd hC IH NdGh Ic
e VQGC Y jH T eGC
.hM dG
''SfS ShO'' M
IdH MQ
ShO'' QdG fj d ,L e
H IdG SG M QGdG ''SfS
Y YS dP CH iCJQGh JQG
efH Vh jL cCH dG
GCh UN ,Lh cGC Y dG
N U jJ Y e jdG
dH j eCG C jdG SdG
g e IOSG e H h hCG
.j c MdG
Ia jJ N
IQGO
E G GQGC GAe
E G
Ae dG Id WdG HGdG Qb
18 e GAeEG LGC jJ eGC hGC
hGC 25 `d aGdG dG dG dGE hGC
Y gCJ e cG Y H
a S dG dG gh ,dG e
dG VjdG OdG e
,JeGSG H J d IQGOEG GC H
eN BG jd J d M
ShO'' dGE H dG LdG
,eeCG IWdG YJ Y ''SfS
GAeEG Ia LCJ Ea ddHh
jdG OdG hDT Y FdG GQGC
g AfGE LGC e JJG S
.e bh bGC a dCdG
aO Y QJh ...
YdG e
d NGB a
S jd dG JdG c eH
WdG HGdG e dGE Le e
Vh LGC e eGC hGC Ae UdH
jdG a S ,YdG gCJ e
e ,dG GjGE AfGE Ye LCJ H
YdG gCJ LCJ QJ IQGOEG L
e cG QfG a ,d NGB a
a e bdG S jdG YdG
GRLEG OY cGh dG jCG
.jjGE jJ H UN
''f'' dG cQ bh
YH fdG fdG Y
M ,dG jJ
dG jQdG e fc
dG LGC e eH
dG Y jJh
RGdG Y YJ dG
,GdG VQGC Y
dG GC e ZdHh
GC GE Gc e fc
''GdG'' `d GhcGC YdG
OSh jQhV fCH
Qhe e IFdH Y
Gj d c bdG
jH HYGE HdH
.''f'' Y
````````````H
aj ''RL''
jQdG M
OGORH T
G hCG
``a GB `e ``fY'' :``fS `VQdGh ``fG Q``j ``f"
''jdG SdG a c bCSh ``jL ``FQ ``d G``S J
FeR e jQdG GE Y
fGC dP j a jL e
?T
e jQd IOdG e J
LGC QGdG ) dG jL e FeR
cG eH (dG IS
,AHQCG M a OH QdH
,HUGE e TG h H d
bGC L BH ICa T a
.jQdG IJh e
dG ac H Gg Q
?H eJ dG
BG g AL c QOGC
,dG g dG ac GC YGC h
eGC d dh OY eGC H f a
adG Y bf d fGC f dG
d j dh jL T jGH a GE
dGE fYh MGd bdG e dG
L e gh jL e jQdG
.OLEH f
c jQdG Y jH
?jdG AGL
C G iJ
?SG Gg jd aGg GS gh
Gj e MGC Y AT c
fh jgL f d Ic jH Qj da
g dP Y fYj eh ,jd e bGC H hf
ch Je Jja jQdG a FGdG AGLCG
.d e
VG SG Ja e jd j G
e ec OGdH MG jdG GCh UN
?db
jGH e ej jY b Qf
C d J GPe
?ddG
H j
E G Me IH Y VG SG
?db e gdG Me U jGH
We a hqj YdG H
Je H GdG
jT d Vj H
dSG jh
15
. .
LGj dG
dG IS eOG
OGORH T LGj
YdG Y dG IS
jOde IY jOdG
IGQe dK a eOdG
a cSh jJ
Y SdS QdG
fGC UN f
E G eY
dG Y j
jj
dG
ddG
qGC UN ,Y OYG
a dfG UdG M
QfG a UdG c
gGC eGC dG IGQdG
.AKdG Gg dG
jdG UQ e H cJ
cU S fCH gYhh
e gh eCG bG d H UN
UGe hQj YdG L
.jOY IQH jQdG
GE J H
IS jQdG
fCWh G
YdG H Z N Hh
e QS dd jdG dGE
dH HdH jdG FQ H
e jdG LGC e hGC 20 e dGE
qGC UN fCWh YdG
Z X a L jQdG dG
YdG e J M ,jdG
dCdG qGC d cGCh FdG jdG
Y S fGCh bh b
.LdG jdG a Je
f" fG QGb
j dG L
Vh Y
Y YdG b ALh
jhDdG JG Y H Vh
dJ dCeh f" jdG Y CH
c fGC UN jdG SFQ
GhOqg GC S
bGC f"h WH
OY dG e GC hjh
d fGC UN SdG Gg Ge
H a Wj dG dhCG IdG
a M M jQdG YdG
e Z GC GdG jGH
fGC c ,MdG Y Hh HQh
LCJ dG jGC dhCG IdG d
fC Je e Y a
IQOdH GhOg GC d S
GC b VdG SCG e
qGC d Vjh f" H j
e j d IOLe GeCG
Y dG fH CLJ f"
eGC IS jL e LG VQG
G IS dG Jg ZGCh VZ
jd FQ d de QNG f
eY e JG dG dG
d cGC e NGBh OdG Y GeGC
hDS dG dH S fGC
dG qGC Z ,Je H
Ie d QeCG qCH GhT
bGC f" fG feGE Nh
GC d cDj H L e gh
hDT jJ IQGOGE j dG
.Je H Jh jdG
fCj S
jQdG
jQdG fS SGE fCSG
M Y Z eH eGC hGC Ae
a HUGE dGE VqJ H AHQCG
L dG jQdG dG iMGE
b fGC e gh ,HS bh a
HUGE qCH cCJ dG dG bdG
N fGC UN IN d fS
dG e jc jdG Fb OL
a MGL Y dGE N
.YSGC Id Sh hdG
T b j eGY
eGC Ae jQdG
d jdG dG j
Ae jQdG a T b eGY
dG M Y Z eH eGC
j GC VdG e c dG
c eH dPh ,jQdG a dN
Se Je Y Y bqh b
.dG e Vqd
jdG e W GW
C G H
GZ S AT ch
J e Y bdG H dG be QKGCh
OGORdG dG NGO jdG VeG jd FQ f"
a Nj L e gh jjDe e hj jdG
IOM BH T Y
Ua iLGCh
hGC M Y Y Ghe Z
20 e a L dG eGC
a IOM BH T eH hGC
dGE Qj L dG Y
UN W Ua AGLGE
OH HUGE e a fGC
d ,VdG j
C G a Y
fj fGC d cGC UdG
bJ hGC IjL HUGE e
b j dd ,HdG HUGE
jQdG dGE eGC Ae OY
.dG e NH
YG f
C Ua jLGC'' :Y
q GC
''JOhY HU
E G
HUGE GC VdG dG IS Jg JG a Y d cGCh
a IOM BH T jQdG AKGC fGC M e ch Ie
BH T f
C jQdG Y Z'' :VGCh ,HU
E G Ve
dG dGE QSGC Lh bGC e gh HU
E G e a IOM
,OJ d HU
E G GC cGC e W Ua LGC d
J e gh Gc f L
C M MGdG dGE cdG
q Y d
dG GZ Ae jQdG dGE OYCSh GfGeh SdS
.''(eGC Ae j)
dG h
C G
J TGC eJ qj GYGC
````e
B G ````ebGE ````e
JH dGE dG
edG Y
fh
Y f d G d G F Q j
Y GYCG HdG dG jOde ie
H a fd GdG ac AfEG
e b EG e i e Y d G T CG
M ,QY TQM d HdG dG
j dG dG e QGL AfEG S
M e G S G S c '' d G '' ` H
Q G Z Y d G a d c e CG h A G N
c , dG dC G Hh ff G T
eBG Y Vh jC G GYC G j d
d G G g j Q d c d G h R S j d G
gMd H UN L J Qbh
e C G j h H e S h Q d G L G d
.Y 4`H
cG QGR ''GdG''
M Y bhh
fH oS cG ''
''QU NGO
GYGC fdG dG FQ VGCh
j NGO fb OGYGE OH fGC HdG
M ,eBG ce NGO AT c Ojh
bhGCh LGdGh dG jJ S
e AHdG e Sh NdGh hdG
fdG dG FQ e jH GE NdG
cd dG dG lj M Ggh
e eJ jM a eBG Y jh
.LQdG dG
Y fGE GE f ''
''Hc
C d AcG j
CG G Y CG c CG d EG j M N a h
CG H d G d G j d G c e h e
j dG i dG Y jh W h e g
fC jeh jOe dG YO jh
Y fEG dEG f ` G Y CG j `
G S G Y Z a H c C G j
a O h e d G Q N e Y
.d Ic GeCG
Q .jdG N
eCG Ae N IQjR d fc bh
J d G d G j d G c e d EG
'' a '' a T Q M e H e K G S G
b h b e d e f c
d G e J C H F G Q c e Y b h
h d G h F S d G a c Y a j
,M ,e e eBG ebE jQhdG
AT ch aJ Aa ,YLG Yb
e Mh cdH dG Lj
M J c d a S d G M d G
j Q d G e d EG H b Y I O j R
.iNCG aGdG ach ''TQM''
cG Qhj e c'':GYGC
''Y fS
GYGC HdG dG e jM ah
GC dG d cGC eBG QeGC dj dG
j eBG Yd jdG ebEG e
cGC C Ieh H jd K e
Gce J FGdG a dG YGCh
Of ASH HcCG a a M He
Qhj e c GC GYGC VGCh HQ hOGQH
H J e AfG b M cdG
dG Gg Y dG j ec
.ceG Y gjh
15
LGd J
eGC fc dG jOdG
,eGC IS HdG
JH dGE dG c
YdG OhM a
Ae fh edG
adG Uh bh
UY dG
M e SGQh
C G
.Qa
E G Ye
G``c Y `J ```dG
GY 24 Y FdG oJ hGC
YSG bh
dW e HQdG
IGQd SY ch
L eGC HdG
jdG 25`dG YdG
OGdG fj
j GC hO ddG
C Ggh ,Y GC
J YdG
.a
IMGh M
dG IS
dGE IOdGh
GZ M
d GC Hh
dG UdG
IS jOh LGe
jOde eGC eGC
e S ,JH
IS jZ dGE MGQ
S M dG
H AcG
a IMGh jQJ
e d IdG
GC Y AdG J
dG bdG Oj
efdG dGE GZ
H HdG
.ej M
GC cDj GYGC
N e'' N
dG a ''dGh
j dNh
FQ eGC H JG
fdG dG
dG jOdd
cDd GYGC HdG
OJG SGhGC Y GC
N cGC HY
eGB dGE fG dG
a Lj HdG
GM
C G MGC
a Vhh dH
e hdG aGC
gh MGdG ac
''dGh Ne''h Je
Yj e Y
HY a dG
N IOH Ggh
Y YdG YdG
dGh fMQ GRdG
dG dGE eGC J
Y H WGh
dG IdG hdG
YdG a LGj
.cGC N
M dGdG dG ah hGC 17
H AeEG ch FGdG UdH
.YH AT c Y JG GC
Leh jS H
H fLh
?dP M c ,dG
e H H d
GC Lf J `d hG
QfGC Gg j GC
?dG
a ja e JG d fc
JdG a KG jah djGE
OL ja fC dG NG d
FSdG ch Ic jJ dh
.L Se AGOGC LGC e Iae
H j GPe GE
B Gh
?dG e
J GC f f `d d
,YdG g Qe
C G
?JG L a
M L Se dGE W WGC
FGdG a JfeGE Y gHGC
dG dG d cGCh
MGC e GMGh cGC GC jQGCh d
Q .jdG N
.YdG
jS AL QeCG ,a
jGdG fch J c Leh
a fGCh H FGL Le JH
bQ Y H fGC d cGC M fa
GC d ch j GC b jW
aj fGCh Le dGE J dG
j dP ch GL JfeGE jh
SCH fG Ia jJ H
SYh dW
c YSG
YdG
hG Iae J dG FSh'' :H
''G H b aS dG h
hdG e GL J d QeCG
d dG hT C TGC 6 hGC a
fdG dG a dh Iae J
L L LH X SdG e
d AdG e J hdG IQGOGE
jJ GQhGC Wh aQ
.dG jOde NGh
dG jOde
Q f G a d G j O d e I Q G O EG
h CG N G O e Q O f Q Y Q X
25 YdG d WdG QN
Q d G G g j d M a h
a Y 2 4 Y F d G S
.HcCG
:PH
Y fLh GPGE''
''af d ,GL
dG jOde FQ d cCG
e Fe fG fCG PH Qe
j d G S d G O G J V
a dG IRLEG UHh
j fCG cCG a HcCG U
dY UGH L SG QX
fE a E Gh FdG Zh eGS
N BG Y CG G S H j d
.OY
Y g c GPGE
S jL
jQ`e aGe
F d G e a e M h
Y g c G P EG f E a P H
S fEa FdG S jL
Gg C G dE G dH ,jQe aGe
Y e Z G j e d G
Y j e gh adG dH
.PH FdG
Q .jdG N
Y Y eGCh
UdG FGG
Mh bdG d Gfh
a J dG dG a H
18) FGdG a fG e
jdG IQGOGE SQGC a (hGC
YdG e f dG e
H Y AeGE Jh UdG dGE
H e ITe jJh g
.WdG HGdG dGE dG
c H
djGE e JG
JdGh
H cGC dG QNG bh
JG a c fGC (QGdG fGC)
fdG dG e IQe a e
a d djGE eh JdH
GJ cGC Yhe C dG
d j e gh b e jLh
.HdG e QGe H IOYEH
Y J IQGO
E G
J d GEh Gc
SG GC
N BG H c CG H h
f CG S S CG Y , e CG b d G
fG e e NCG dG
j J J C j CG b d G
J a V EG S C H L B G
Y CH dG j fGE ZQ
dG jOde a eGSG
bdH eGC a H fG
GC GE ,QY H dG e
dG fG Ia jJ
HGdG W e aVGE SCH
feGE j dG Id WdG
U dGE 25 YdG aVGE
.V H dh IOQGh HcCG
eGC H
Y dM H
hG e jdG
e GCH JG
fa gh 17 j
dG Vh jJ H GeGC H Y G aJ HGdG
M WdG HGdG Y aQ jdG YdG Fb V aJ GeGC H Hd HdG YdG AL
Y 3 dGE aVGE JH jOde S
C G ja e ddG e jJ H dPh ,iNGC a dGE fG
.e GYh gGHGE e dGO ,e H e
C G jh jNGB
hT e do HdG IGQe
dG h
C G
````e
''Gq```dG''
````````````dGE
S.gGHG ````dG
G Y AeGE
Y qe Ic eGBh YdG jo
Of dGC fU fG N c
GQS Y M H dG ''IQ S S''
eCG Sh Hh dG Y d
GH M ,YdG Gg IN e IOSd
YdG e OY e jM N e
RhdGh dG e Y H dhDJ
gh VdG SdG b Y c e
adG b hGC HUEG e AGS fj
hRGR , j L , dG Y ,Q " S e
.fGOSh
a dG dG LGC
dGE dUd h
C G dG
jQJ M dG
Qa
E G b fc dh
C G
Y cJh YH
dheh N jQJ
YdG LSG
a fdG eGC ,bd
d ITdG YdG Y
.fdG fd Nh
dG bdG aS c
dG efH Y dG
Qa
E G b M H
d ,H fK Mh
H HdG jGC W d
jJ g S
jdG j d UN
S M jOh IGQe
M hGC jQJ M
.MGQ UY jGE j
jJ Y QOb Y
jL
GL aj jGE
Y dG H c e GC g L J
qJ Y OGR e gh ,dG bdGh
.dG GdGC d
S Y'' :hGR
''aVGE aO JH
dH Y dG Y hGR qYh
H j dG IdG H'' :Fb dG
YGC j dG IdG feEGh Y
H d j e Y dGE LH fGC
Ea Gg Y a ,L H ddG
Mh Ic jJ Y e jdG
J IN UGC Y jd j
Y Y gGC SdHh ,ae GC
.''H bdG
.S gGHGE
e Y efG Y j eh
d jHh H QdG ae YdG
c M AGS JfeGE Y bh eH
hGC GO M f UdG Od FQ
c Y Hjh HQe c M b
e e Wh ,ddG a YdG ie
Ge Ea d Y ej c
.Y Kj JNh
d b dG Yh hGR
dG Y IL GQeGC
Ge Sh M dG QeCG H e
FdG e VhdG Y HS ''IQSS''
db dG dG dG g QGhe dG
hGR S dG a HdG eR d
CH fQOe e Y M ,dG Yh
GC d GcCa dG a jGCQ W Y
h jdG Gg a IL H J QeCG
G GE Y 26 `H J dG
,dG V Y 26 ''Sdh'' ce dGE eGC hGC GJ jdG YdG OY Uh
ec OdG d dGh dG bdG AYGC e 10 dGE f dG OdG gh
.GOa 36 h
C G dG e NO dG
G j ThGRh 27 YdG S Y
dGE HdG a jLGdG YdG OY JS dG Qf M Y dHh
H Y eH Qj jdG dH jh OGdG ThGR e gH d ,27
.jdG U ,SH ,bhRe gh SGh
C G e e KK Y 28
jG GE j H
U dGE fH Qe edG GdG Sh fG dG e jJ J eH
AHQ
C G Ae Y bhh adG fdG LQdG dH V TdG jdG dhGC
LJ SGCQ e ja e gRHGC VhY IY d fc fH Ea IQT
E d ,QdG
.jdG dGE jJ a dG IQGOGE d fe
G YdG e QGhe
HH dG dG YdG a QGhe jdG Y FdG j GC dG e
IQT
E dh ,''Sdh'' ce a e Qe
C G Sh dG GJ Y d jdG
ja UY jJ fc dG jQdG dG e Gc GOY qj d QGhe Ea
.dG a
15
LGC dG
hGC M
dUh e j
ThGRh HdH dG j Y
dG dGE S LDj
aSh ...
efdG Y
jGC GYe
jOdG GAdG
dj YdG
''GdG''
h
C G JYS
jM N e cG
g YdG e OY dGE
IU c GC dG a
ddG J Ich
YdG cMh WdG
Y g jdG S e
fSG Mh ,H WGE
,Q"S ,hGR b e
C G Y
fGE hN
B Gh de
OY Vh hj
a be Y ''GdG''
Ged ff
C G T
deh IjdG H
.jf
C G a j e c
GhQUh ...
Y ee
''H ja''
UGJ
q GC f c
dG Y YdG
''H ja'' YLG
a QdG Y S
YdG e OY Y
ILGC e GL jdG
GC UN e Jc
J eQ a IdG
H YL jMh dCH
GC VGdG d ,YdG
W qZ ''`cH ja''
c QU M YdG
jh RL j Y
a J e dGE ITe
e d jb dG
Ea IQT
E d .FbUGC
Y aj ''Sdh'' ce
TJ e ''jdG'' eN
.GS HQGC b
SGG
Zh bj
GcQh
C G Fb
cJ N e GH
hGC dG H a YdG
a M hGC dG a
GC IQU J e QdG
dZ ,Ge KdG SGdG
H ,bj hGMh
hGMh Ge dG j
IdG d IL Ua
a j dG dZ e
.GcQh
C G Fb gf
jdG J Y ej b MGC
bdG UM Gd dG dGE
YdG J Y dGh dG
.aVGE jGC Kd gGC aQ
S Y'' :QGhe
''jd jb YO
HdG eR dG Y J GPe
?Y M UdG OGE
?e q
a eGC a e GC Lj L e
,Qj dG g QdGh dG LGC e dG
GE YdG H j jGE qGC GL QOGC
j e Ggh GdG VQGC a OhOdH
dG g agh J adG qGE bGC
.dG a SSGC fH
?dG dG G Y GPeh
Gj e MGC Y J dG a QeCG
GdG qJ dG IjdG IQGdG Za
dGE Gf Gc H f fGC GE dG jGCh
W e AGS,YdG J dG jdG
jdG e j b
''S'' GE
dG e Y J GPGEh
IQGOEG Ea HdG H G c H
''S'' je dGE jdG e S
AGLEH Je dG S jGC
M Ua gh ,jOh IGQe hGC
ijh jdG ja Y j
.GdG a FeR J LQO
dG j GC Q dG e
L U a jdG dG
H dG dh dG Y dGh dG
Y M U dG O JE
a jj dG j a H H
H Ggh ,HdG IQSH je
UdG GAGLEG eH b GC
j dG dG a gCH
.QdG dG
G NGB ThGR
SS IQGO
E G
j e
QG
e Ea Y Y Yh
LDS ThGR e ''Ih dG''
e M MCG j dGE S Ye
c bh ,dG IQGOEG d JcGC
T I ah H ThGR Z
jGC J jj Y GC Hh
fGC cGC dG IQGOGE Ea bO
e SQGE dGE dG S
e Qe a j U N
f d AdG QGdH edG
jQG H qJ dG g cG je
dG a HJ Ia N eH J dG GAdG Ea dG e MGC d c e Mh
jOdG jQdG H b dG ''Sdh VjdG cd dG ce'' ce jd dG a Oj
.dG a g jd ebEG hX ec Y Sh d
dG M dG Y J e
?G GE gb
J YdG Sh J Ie c MdG
Y fOq J eCG G gh dGh j dG
fGC YGC jdG ja dG a d ,Yc
UGC Y e f iJ d UN Ie
Y eGC ,dGh Oe ,hGR eGC e IN
H jW J d fGE bCa JGP M a MdG
hGC QdG a LGC QGdG) .Se e Yf
.(eGC
GdG e H SGC K K H
j a Q e
C G Lh c
?jG
Gj e MGC Yh L H J QeCG
e dG c fdGh hCG SCG a
e Y dGE N jGC fdG f d
gH d ,dG e UN Gc eh
j dG bdG GCH M ddG SCG dGE
dG jQdG L dGE jh dG a
LJ eGC dG Y c e jO dGh
eOdG jCG a jS e jGCh fe
.dG a g
fdG bd
q GE dG g
dG hCG
:```````dL
d j d fC ,U fc jGdG ,U Gg
U c OdG Gd J ddHh ,jH QR GC
dh ,JY H fQe e IOdGh dG ,jGH a
KGC eGdG g c ,g SdG e dG YGC cGC
dM fGCh ,OdG e bCJ bdG Qhe e dh ,a
e gh ,K hGC S e jH a dGC fCc TGC
TGC ,H bGC dG dGh jQdG N e L j
fGC UN MGdH TGC fC ,fdG FY a fGC
d GSh ''ea OhG'' Y c J f
S M e dG YGC fGC jGC dG ,e
aVGE ,jdG e LefG S e gh ,e dG d
.QdH ae dGE
.S
.Sj
`````````Ke
Gq``````dG''
```````````dGE ''
```````fJ
KCJ d c edG Gg GE dG j g
c GC H ,jH a dG `cQNG a
?jf
C G e jdG a He
Th Y c ,QNG e f d c d ,f
dh ,dG AeGE iS j dh NGB Of a bdG
dG YH e KJ d ,GeCG Y dG MGQ a
IL AGLCG GC d cGCh ,VdG SdG d HQe c
gh ,dCdGh dG Y Y GC YJ fGCh ,jH a
e fC Gc S fGC MGU ,Y HGC dG eCG
Je fGC ,SdG QNH b fGC cCeh ,jH
S fGC YGC d ,GL Se MGC GC JGCh ,jd
.Y j e gh jH a Jeh
```Y ````HGC''
````dG ````MGQ
````JLh GPGEh
''dG hS
e ja LGe ,dG H
a bY j dG fdG LdG
dG Y fYj gh ,jaEG IdG
,IH GJ fGC ZQ jaEG ad
fOGSG ie Y dN e dG j
Of e dGh ,jaEG ad
jh HJ YdG S ,jd e eGC Ke
jf ODj Lda ,ddG idG cH d
bj d M AdG b a dM gh ,Ie Se
AdG ddHh ,jd dY JJhh BG d Y
.d M GQNG S
K S dhDdG d
ff LdG VS fGC H
a Rh d c dGh ,dG
J GC ,jhdG dG
?dP a KDj GC
dG dG LGC e jQ" j
.Y hS dG dG Jh
ff `d jQJ Ad
GE OdG HW ZQ IGQdG
Yh ,d jQJ S fGC
ff fj LdG Y SGCQ
a dG HdG ja LGS dG
eGC hGC fj d ,dCdG GHGC d
c j ch ja jQJ a
LGS c d f j e
fc Vh eHG ,AeR
bJh ,GjT GKCJ gAGQh J
,d eg S dG YdG Gd
SG e GEh jOh fGC M dh
.eJ a dG ff
GjT S afG
HU
E G e QGMh
j GC jGC bdG e
,dG IS GjT fdG afG
j fdG LdG GC UN
dG hdG OGOdG eGC Fd
c ,QdG hGC 27 j S
H e f QdG a S
LdG jj jdG OdG YdG
QGjGE Lc e bdG
ddHh ,fJ ee SQMh
j f AdGh afH S
LGS fC ,dG Y Y
j Gd ,dG QdG e ae
VdG Od QdG NJ
ddG IdG GC UN ,HUE
fj YdGh ,jd SM
dG fdG dGh dG AGL
QdG cS ddHh ,H ej
,T hO e MdG g Y YH
Gc IedG H dTGC djh
j ddG jGH GC UN
`c.Sj
.dG Y
Y GC GC g cCG eCG
LGdG g a Ge AGOGC S
dCdG C ,Jje MCH QdGh
GC GE j LdG f eGC
QdG id aVGE Wf j
dG OhOdG S M ,YH
fe bSGh JGQb Y GcCJ
NSh ,SSCG dG a
J M Y IMGh gH YdG
j e j dG'' :gMGC
ZdG Y j e gh ,''UH
LGC e YdG hJ dG jdG
.dG LGe a RhdGh dCdG
C ```dG ``a `a
AGO
C G `g ```j e
J dG gCG ZQh
Y bdG M e AGS ,IGQdG
jgLh dG OGSG ie
jhdG Y j fGC GE ,jdG
Y dG a a bdG OJ
Jh RdG H ,dG
JH j dP C ,dG IQdG
h J dGh ,Oh AdG C
AHGC j GC j H ,T J
Y eRY YdG GC M
jJh idG a LGe AGOGC
L H Geb fGC cCdGh ja
,QdG efH e Hhj fGCh
hCG fC jQJ AdG Sh
H fdG LdG j dG
f H Yh e M ,SSCG
a d cGCh jH e e
.dG QGM
hjj YdG c
```cQdG
dG N fd bh
hjj jH Y c GC jQdG
UN ,LGdG g a cQdG
ae d d j d jdG
e aGC Ua LJ a ,jaGC
bCdGh Y dG LGC e g
j LdG GC UN ,FGLGC e
gh ,jaEG jfCG bGC H e
f SdG Gg HK H Lj
WHQ SCc Ff HQ dGE gCdG
,H RdG g agh jaGE HGC
QdG Gg e jfGC LGe Jh
IN jh Y C eg GeGC
e Qc YH Ma ,Ic
QhV eGC jNGBh LGQdG eSGC
M Y C eh dG Ic a
.IdG j
``S ``YH
```d UdG
''`````eHhGC'' ```dL
jJ M VY YH
eGC hGC dG
dG jJ M V GC H
,SQdG CN H VdG AHQCG
L e dG e NGCh QOZ dG
jh dG a ej Qj jdG
d ,J IGQeh jOY jQJ
,efH eGC YH QdG Z
Y jJ H dG ah
d fGC ZQ FdG dG jd
.IQe J
jdG bh ...
Ye dGE
,e bh a J d dG
bh 18:00 YdG Y GCH M
,Ye dGE ja YH QdG
,dG J h IU YdG GC H
bO 20 Ie HQJ Ye c
H dG e ,YdG NGO a
dG fG bh ,LQN jQdG
Uh NCJ M NCe bh a
.Qa
E G Y YdG
eGC jQS Y L ag S
J J g ,(eGC hGC LGC QGdG)
?ddG a Ke GgGC
`c.Sj
gaY Ge
C G Y dG MGQ J
c NGC aQ M ,S JQOH
M c ,QGS gOGC e gh ,dGeGC
?dP
Ae
E d GgL UGC NGdG fdG
j dh ,GH 20 dGM j dG NGdG fdG OGYGE e HY OJG IQGOGE fG
,eGC M b j dG e
C G gh .Y Ae
E G LGC e YdG Y VY iS
c j dh ,dG eGC hGC IS jQdG GfCSG b Gfc YdG GC GOe
.SG M YdG
dG fdG
HY OJG
dG jOh H
C G dG LGj OJG
Qj b QGOH
Qf
C G dG''
IQGO
E Gh jdG M
''IdG g a QhV
AGf SY Qe QdG Lh c
jd IYdG j e e dW ,Qf
C d
dGE dH ,GL U IH j dG
GJ Y fG dG jQGOEG cdG
fG LCJ Y Mh ,OdG
Nj S e ,IdG g dGE jQdG
JJ IOYGE LGC e dSG Me a
eCG Ggh ,bh bGC a jOddG H
UN dG e Ic J j
AaQ fL dGE bdH ddG QfCG
QGJ Od Y dG Yh ,fQH
.VdG SdG JQG dG ANCG
dN
SY Qe b jOde Qe cGC
UGC IOd GOe JOH S fGC eGC
N OdG Y TGC e H ,AdG dG
dGh VdG SdG e INCG dG
e IdG OJ HdG QdG dN J
U hX a jOddG e AdG J
Y fGE d jJ a SY b M ,GL
N iNGC Ie jdG IOd OGSG JGC
he Gc Y j dG ,jdG SdG
dG GTCdG iMEH dG LGC e OdG
ej dPh ,dG hCG dG dGE gDdG
QfCG e -SY M- Ic J
GgCG J LGC e YdGh IQGOEGh
.OdG IQGOGE W e IdG
Y IQGO
E G e JGC d''
''IdG Gg
C G
SY Qe dG QdG GC ZQh
jQJ M dhGC Y eGC hGC Y TGC
j d fGC d cGC fGC GE ,b jOdd
dfG X a IQGOEG e AYGC
SY TH Gdh ,jdGh eGSH
GJ JT dG NCdG dGE dH Y
IQGOEG e QdG j GC Y ,OdG
,LdG jdG a hdG Y dG Vd
e QGJ aj SY Qe GC S
SdG dH e INCG dG N M
Y gh ''dG'' Y TGC M ,VdG
dGh dG d IGdG b dGE hdG Th
.jdG AHGC
a GL NCe jdG''
OHGE hSh GdG
''SdG dG
e jM a SY QdG j dh
a Gc GNCJ J b jOde GC
OdG j M ,jdG Sd JGJ
jQdG M aj SY
,eGC hGC Y SY Qe b jOdd jdG jdG QdG aQ
a aGdG AaQ cG GC H dG a M dGE jQdG M
Yh ,H jN e
B G ja Qe Y TGC IMGh H jGdH
GdG a dG NCd Gf efdG H SY Qe QdG IOY
eH M e (ej 20 H) dG fdG dG dH fG GbGh
YdG jQH T LGC e ,dG jJ YH fK jQJ M
.SY d cGC e M eOdG IdG N dG dG a NdG b
IQGO
E d Ua GAe
E G LGB jJ
IQGOGE ,OdG Sd J YdG gCJh GAe
E G LGB jJ N CW
V e J Y dGE dH QGW dM TY dG ,b jOde
J b M ,dG ''JcdG'' Z e b YS b FdG gOGJ
SdG N Y OYG J fc e YdG H aQH IQGOGE
d fGC GE ,KdG dG a Yf eGSH eb fGC ZQh ,jdG
hGC Y Jh jGCQ J bh VdG SdG Y H AH Y VGQ
.iNGC ASGC GSG LGC e KG
iNGC Ie jL MQ hjj Qf
C G
IQGOGE e ,eGC U ''GdG''`H GJG e jOddG QfGC e jdG W
YH jJh ,bh bGC a jL j
C G aGdG Y H aQH Oe
GC S ,jQO H f aGdG IYd ad idG dG jd b
c ja a dH d j jL ie GC GhYG Qf
C G H
.b jOde e jYh
SG M QGOH YdG j d Ge c e Yh
ITdG YdG e jGH ,dG eGC hGC jdG gGLGC dG
IQGOEG GC e ZdG Y ,e 19 d dG dH dGh
e Mh ,VdG AKdG j e bdG GAGLGE ec SG
YdG QGOH j dh .WdG HGdG dGE eGC dSQGE J gCJ W
d NBG g H LdG C ,SG M Y Z dG MdG
Hh QGOH YdG jh .jQdG dG J a QM j
e j AT GC Lj fC eGC M a gQM S b
TM QdGh IQGOEG CH cQj YdG GC c ,dP a
.GdG Ia N UN WfG QeCH j
hM
M ,HGdG dG Ad dG IS HY OJG j
jdG YdG HCG dG QdG jdG e 19 e Y LGS
VdG e ch .(Sh -T YdG) HGdG H e dd
,S ah HGdG jdG JGQe a OJG ae j GC
a YSGC e a T dG HJ jdG Gg e jJ d
OJG e L e ,AdG AGLGE hO M NGB SC fJ
,eJ jOdG IGQdG J M HCG dG jH hj
J dG jdG GJ S a Yf KDS c dG eCG gh
.hdG MGC a BG d
H
C G dG e YJH SG
dG J adGh dG
Se AGO
C JGC'' :f
''fG dG e aCG
jGH Y HSGC KK b
GfJ GC bJ g ddG
?jgL
S jQdG a f f
dG bdG ej dG jQdG
, d dG jG H Y jgL f M
b dGE f GC dG e d
eCG Gg C ,hCG AdG e Jje
.L N hGC HQGC Qhe H j
j jQdG dGE JY
LGC GdG) VdG dG
?JOY fc a (eGC
H a cGC fH YdG
,dG bd cGC jhDdG VJh
e dGE Uh dG dG UH
.fdG jgdG M
d GgGC HQGC S dG
Gg ,GAd KK a
B G
jd jd CH Cj e
C G
?dc dGC ,L g
INGC c
IS jJ Ad S
dG eGC dG Z
?db e ,H
C G
fH c Y dGE Oj IOSH
M eH ,IOSH gdG Y fdG dG IOY SG M aY
IOSH IOY ALh .dG dCe UH JG Oe FdG Hh H
e ,fdG jgL ec dGE H Gj d GdGRe YdG
C bh a
.TM QdG d c
b jOde
16
:TM
a YT''
dG
jd
hGC e
e j
''GdG
e jM d c
H TM QdG
dG jf
eGC h
C jQdG
dN dCS ,dG
dG hdG Y
,GdG a J
Uh dG dGh
YdG jgL dGE
b c GPGE e dch
de jJ e fG
,SS
C G dG
dG a T gh
dh
C G ddG Ad
a ja S dG
YT'' :HY OJG Qe a ,dG dh
C G eGC jdG
.''GdG e j hGC e jdG Ad dG a
SSGC Y Lj d dH''
''WMG hGC
dG de jJ e fG GPGE e UH GDS ah
Y Lj d dH'' :TM QdG b SS
C G
b c jdG YdGh ,WMG Y hGC SSGC
dG jdG KdG JGAd a jGdG e cTGC
e
C G Gg d aGC dh .IYdG Y g
B G d gd
IOdG a J IYb d J GC H ja GC GE bGC cGC
e bfG QdG j dP Hh ,eGdG YdG e e
adG jW Y ,SS
C G dG GSH IYdG g
,jN
B G YdG H h IYdG Y H S dG
Y e Y GC fe NGC dG g e Y
C jh
.''adG SGH j e
C G Ggh ,IYdG
.IM
G hCG
e
''GqdG''
fJ dGE
ja
E G OdG - Ggh . jOh IGQe eH f
H Qe M QdG j
ed WdG VQGC dGE IOdG
iNGC jJ jOh IGQe
,SdG adG fG b
jg jJ j d
B G dh
LGS dG jdG
dH dG d ,jOddG
Ad eH
q j GC Qd
ie Y bdG L
C
c e YdG jgL
jJ Gch ,MGdG
dG SS
C G dG
Y ddG a NS
a TGdG OJG SG
.fHR e
G``````````gh jOde
...''Th T'' S J a a eb
E G
j HdG
qde hO
AdG a Qj d GY
HUGE e fj GY MGC S Gj
eJ dG HdG dG ie Y
j a dHh ,baQ H e QqdG e
Gg a cQdH e jOddG d fU
LC dG dGE dH Sh ,AdG
GY eCjh .Z LQdG e AdG He
e jh e bh SGC a aj GC
Gg a eOdG JGQdG a cQdG
GdG e Ja e QG Jh ,H dG
.e jdG N cGC M
Qe M
dG M j
aj S ah
''IhGdG'' LGe
fH jgL Z YdG
jOddG Y Ea ,L eh
je Zh bd ec a hLj
j eCG GC UN ,LGdG g AGLE
Y dh ,dGMGC MGC a Lj aH
GjRh ec aQ GC GE Gg c e ZdG
jOCJ LC Sh a e H eS
Qb e IOSGh idG a IGQe
YH MG N e Ggh ,dG
a j jdG dhGC e a e
Y H d YGC bh .jaEG OdG
JCJ d j Gfc fGC jO d dG
Gg jf a jaEG OdG LG e
Sb e GJ d ,bCG Y HdG
.jgL ie
Sb jj Qe M
jgL ie
Qe M QdG qj a eGC
AdG Gg a UdG d j fEa
cQd YdG e e OY cC
e j M G gh , ja E G O dG e C G
dG UdG H ie Y bdG
MdG e jgL i eh a j
Yd dH AdG fh ,fdG
CG hO ,Gc Y qjh aj jdG
````eGh ,QH
eGC GdG jQch
j OGdGh
f LdG eGC dG
eGh SQdG ,QH jdG
dG jdG aGdG jQch
fCSh baQ e dG
.dG e AGHG jQdG
j KdG Gg UHh
dGE aV
E H ,jOddG OGJ
QdGh jdG de dG
Qe Gch Qe YdG
M d ,MdG SGdG
c a GY 33 dGE OGdG
dG QfG a ,dG
a d
E G Y HdG FdG
.dG dG YdG
j jQc
jJ Kh Y
``````S e
Kh Y jQc J
e d NGB a jJ
S ah HdG ja
e dH Jh ,GqM UGCh
SQ jOddG dGE dG
dGe e j dG gh
IRLGE Y jh 1991
a AdG fh ,e
B G
jdGh jHh GY `H j
a qdG YdG e
.Ggh jOde
e b HGdG
jOddG
b dGE eGC bJ c
d HGdG b Y
a gCJh OdG YdG
jdG OqJ d dG dG
bh ,Vh jJh
GC GE ,je KdG
OaGC JRH dG edG
e b HGdG GC
jJ j GC Y ,jOddG
dH ddG jdG
.IOqdG jQGdG M
''hJdG''h FdG ec
e g fLGJ N e jGC Y bh eh
bY GC g ,edG HJ a Ggh jOde
dG gh FGQ L Y e Qe M QdG
e Y aGTGE H YdG dZ j
S ,IOSH , Y H QG Z Y S
dG QdG j dG NCG Gg ,ech
hO fGgdG dG Fbh jdG a Y RHCc
J e jh e e j jGC ,Re
gf ,d AMEG jQJ H AGLGEh YdG
baQ e Gc GbG hj ec GC Y
,gaGH QdG J J e djh
e jd ddG FdG Y M IQU a
cdG H j GC b ,FGO dG Y c
.QdG SdG
j Qe M
dG Y e
Y e Qe M QdG dG S
dG ''dG J'' a g YLd Yb a
QdG Sh ,''IhGdG'' a j dG dG
Y dG Vh Y LG Gg a dG
qdG efdG d jJ Gch ,Y e hdG
h hdG MGC a j dG edG Hd
,MGdG c e BG d GRhJ GC g LJ
j YdGh FGQ ebEG hX GC UN
QdGh QaEG a eqdG LdG e bWGE
ebEG YdG YG dG ,''dG J'' H
.''Th T'' a
. IM
e d VjdG
q dG M''
''dG e QqdG qdG
d OLh
QdG a jQJ
MJe YdG
dG e Hhjh
MJQG jOddG Y j a ,L eh
M g J d fCH eYGE qJ eH dG
MGQ e dH hSh ,QdG a jQJ
hO hdG MGC a dG e Gjh e
GhcJh ,fdG jQdG AY dGE Vq dG
M HdG HdG a d j c e L
e H NBG J MGdG YdG Vj c
NO e M G j d j dG gh , dG
N e bhh .e bd MGC a adG
YdG GC ,edG HJ e dhCG YdG
.Gc dG HQe Y e Hhj
NOh eH HdG fG H
J dG Me a ITe jOddG
YdG Ea ,Qe M QdG IO b
jOh IGQe AGLGE e dG IS S
hCG jH jaEG OdG eGC jJ
Od fdG jdG LGS S ah)
GC QqdG e dG IGQdG gh ,(jaEG
a LG dG dG e a J
ebGE qe Y GH GC ,fJ UdG
ah S jGC ,Gec 70 `H jOddG
LGJ dG UdG adH ''IhGdG''
fH gLGJ Ga W aqJ J
Qe M QdG GL Qjh .''AGdG''
Y dG QdG e g dG IGQe GC
bd MGC a Y Lj ja LGe
QhO a cQ j j dG gh , f H
.jCG g ''dG'' SCc e YdG
Ue jOddG ah J
QGZ Y YdG H e
aGdG Gch eGh ,QH
j d a ,jQc jdG
dHh ,jdG de adG e
.de hO fG HdG Ea
YdG H iHGC a
de LGJ Y e geJ
jdGh ,e HdG UN
H dG hjj Gfc
UdG H UN ddG
e JOb bT jS e
e
q K ,GqH UdG dGE Ggh
gHh ,GqL fJ dGE FGdG
dGE UdG fJ e
.adG Y edG
dG M a dG J
````S'' :Q``e M
`dH 50 ``jgL ``d
''``HdG G``g A``fG `H
jd e bqJ IdG a Qe M QdG e L d fc
g jdG NO dG HdGh jOddH dG dG H Y
jgL feGE ieh GdG AGLGCh ,fdG edG jH
MGC a j HdG'' :dG a .HdG Gg AfG H YdG
Y IdG dhDdG H YGh YdG hgJ c ,hdG
Yeh dG LC M e AT Ggh ,L H j JY
H YdG jgL feEH j a db j eh .GOdG
e cCG Y dH 50 `H fS fGC g ,HdG Gg A fG
,IM Y Y c L Y bj AT c cCdHh ,jgL
.''ah HdG Gg e IqLdG aGgGC dGE f GC fh
.S
.Sj
dG hCG
`````````Ke
Gq``````dG''
```````````dGE ''
```````fJ
A`````````````d
H J
`````YdG
```````dLh
```````Hh
````````dCj
bHh dG NQ j Hj
```HdH ``j ``d `eb
E G
Hj fhedG Ea jH T IQGOGE e He QOe d JcGC e M
FGdG a jQGOEG GAGLEG H j GC b fJ dGE dG e j d
dGE dG e gH j M ebEG bHh dG NH eCG jh
IOdG e j d a ITCdH fJ dGE j d fC ,OY H fJ
b HdH bdG ddHh ,iNGC ITCJ Y dG jZ dGE FGdG dGE
.OdG KG j dGE NCj
Qa
E d hdG jMh MGQ Y j YH
`dG `H `TG H
dG e jdH YH e N bh
Th ,dG LdG LGe b edG
a H jY dCJ dG IGQdG
.H aGdGh dL e g fd
ja Y j Ie ja
(1-3) H QaGR
eGC hGC IS J
SG dS Y
jQJ dGE SGQ e
dG jhdG dG
M ,dG H L
jQdG e fL HJ
e j Mh
adG AYGCh jdG
Y fGC aY Mh
GjL ee j b
,jH T U a
aY e HbG Mh
e RJQG Y fGC
a d dG
ddG dG
dG e jh SGh
C d
fJ a Ljh S 22
bh ,Y Ab LGC e
jdG Fb Y J
bGh QaGR gGHGE
dG Ia Y
YGC e gh ,dH
.Gc YdG
Wh AdG a QT jR
jdG H UN efH
:jdG J
YdG c TGC YH
fY J#eh "hRe
B G H e
dG e f dG j dG Id fJ e
edG a dH j fdG VjdG Ld HdG jdG a c
T fL dGE j dG dG Id fdG dG YH e
C G jh VdG
ce Y aj dG IdG fe
E G cDj hDHh fdG dG Uh ,jH
.eQ H j e
C G GC UN IH f J dG c
C G e ZQ jdG
jb c dG afG
QqM d dH dW YH
HU
E G e
(2-4-4) `H d Ie ja
(2-5-3) `H QaGR jah
h
C G ``jdH `LdG j GC ``j '' :```YH
''`````efH `````UGf GC ````dG
17
GdG a J cGC c Ie ja
dG e Gc GOY V fGC ZQ Ya cGCh
,IGQdG jf a Rj c Yh OdGh
GE jGC IL jH Gd QaGR AaQ GC Za
M ,MCG dG UGC e fc YdG GC
hCG dG J e Ie FdG J
b AGL cQ jW Y hCG dG a jd
fdG dG a fdG dG dL j GC
,d ddG dG ee V J#e S K
Y NCG jdG J AdG jf bh
d ,H HGQH LdG gf AGL cQ
.Ie AaQ d (1-3) H AdG
UN jH IGQdG d qf d''
''jJ IGQe UGC g H
UN jJ efH Vh b j GC YH QdG fh
C jdG H j fGC cGC M ,adG M ZQ LdG IGQd
H LdG eGC HjGE f J Y j h J Ia a ja
fdG dG Y cGC jh YdG W e dG AGOCG Y j
LGdG d UN jH qf d'' :bh ,jQdG g e H
Y a f h d jJ IGQe JGP M a g fC WH H
fdG MdG e UN dG Y f H IL f J
Gd QeCG d j jdG IdG a jOh LGe d ,dGh
.''dG Y f d
dG fdG
..dG IS jN
C G LGj g
C G
S ,S OG eGC dG d jOh IGQe hGC eGC IS g
C G d eH
jN
C G OG eGC efdG HGdGh dG jOh IGQe K e YG dG
,d IY jOG OhM ,IGqg dG dG dH GE jG YdG ''hdH''
-h TGG -G eGC UdG HJ g
C G VN dG JQG MH
QJ GC b ,dG eeGC Qd Me gQhH fc jH - GC IQT
E d .eOG
.jN
C G `H OSG GE iOGC e
24 e GAH UdG a K HJ
jQdG H AKdG IS dG
17
Qf
C G j ''SjdG''h GdG
eGC hGC Ae hGL VjdGh dG jeh e jdG dGh SG
aQ f dG fMQ dG FQ e H Qf
C G d e AYGC dG
eR
C G dP eh ,gGdG IdG a MhdG fG e FeR
e OY eGC M a Vh e ,''dG Qf'' cT a J dG ddG
Y a a ddG NCdG ,Je e h
C G dG hj e YdG
jYGh fG c ''SjdG''h dGdG hqO bh .dG ..edG dG
.VdG a dH
edG G CH j ''SjdG''
CH Qf
C G d e AYGC hGL VjdGh dG je CW ,fL eh
dG QGO a M
C G Gg IS S fGC d cGC M ,edG dG b
Ge ,fTGC GCh S e ''Gd'' eDdG Y M a bGdG ''gdG N''
jdG GY 52 `dG Y J d edG dG AYGC Fb GC dGE GC d
dH hGC SH ,GMG jdG NO Y VdG SdG GbOU
.ae
jjYH H gGC
YdG e aGE
a
''``````dG''
e aGE QdG W
H eGC hGC IS Y
NdG SG M N
N Y ,''dG'' a dGE
e OY j c e
hj Gfc jdG YdG
e jJ a QGMGC fGC
dG IdG SH ,ebGE
,dG a dN S
''jGdG'' QdG bGC bh
M ,dG a fL dGE
g a H hj H j
f dG jdG a ,IdG
.OdG
Qe e VG
e SGG
SG
hGC Ae dG e
SG M a eGC
fGY OdG SGdG Qe
M V dG e
YdG fL dGE SG
QdGh LH Y
fGY Uh bh ,aGE
,dG je dGE YdG a
Z ,dG S J
bh ,ibGC c VdG GC
j dG IQN gR qJ
YdG H SdG QhH
Y fGY H QdGh
''dG'' a dGE dUh
.Jj M
IH G bdG
L QGOGE Jh
g
C d dG bdG c
M a YdG a
PGE ,eGC hGC Ae SG
,GOe QM S
,Yeh gH ,cQe
jdG Qf ''LdG'' Y a
jdGh IQN gR ,Y
c dG IHH YGC dG
Y H e jM d
e GAL GHJ jdG e
B G
MdGh .jQdG dG
IQGO
E G qj GL J GC
j c M ,SdG Gg
dG QhdH dG MGh c
.''ehqj HQ'' ..H
QdGh Qa
E G
e
''gdG dG''
jGdG IQGO
E G QNG
FdG ''gdG dG'' e
dGE jODdG jdG a e
S L e ''fe'' a
a hd (HS) dG
Qa
E G qLh YdG
JGP dG gh ,QdGh
YdG a aGC dG
J b ,VdG SdG
e eb
E fJ dGE
YdG q TO bh ,J
Lh SH ,dG Gg
e dG H ITe QdG
GC Y ,SG M
H dG e dGE GhOj
.eQ T NG
,jQdG dG e Y d c jGC ,d
Y Ye dGE YdG H j GC b
jdG YdG e c hJ Sh ,IdG SH
,SG M qe dG AGLCH Gc GYGC
jZ j d dP GC H ,OdG Yd dH S
M ,VdG SdG YdG GJ jdG eGdG Y
.fdG dG a dhCG eb jdG Vh eH
S dG jJ
''fhdG'' IGQe
M jf a Y Y aGE QdG Jh
dGh (eGC) dGdG dG efH eGC hGC SG
edG e bfG ,dG jJ a M qJ
,hGC 20 H UdG dG jJ Yb a fh
a M 4 H ,Yf e edG dG gh
ebGE e f dG IS a YdG d ,UdG
,IGg fdG dG e S OJG eGC jOh IGQe
.GdG Ia fG e Yf e ddG g
Qf
C G id JQG
OdH hDJh
ja j Q``f
C G GC ```cG'' :````e
''``X ``M ``Y ``Sh ``dG ``LQO dGE
? dG e
CG cDdGh ,jJ c Y Z Qe
Y j e M H h H a d G
e a J adG e i dG dG
G O G S G h j g L c C G CG H , j d G
dG AdG .S e g IGQdG j
b j a j J a f I Q G O E G CG
a UdG c a LGhORG Y aqj
a fCG M ,hCG dG dEG IOdG jW
h CG H U E G d EG Y CG V J M
a J e ,OLe jdG Ea ,HdG
.a IY
fGC ec N e VGdG
g ,jG ja GL Je
? dP cDJ
fGCh dG dG dG NG
H dG e LqJ dG
? dP c ,ddG
AGL
C G Y J GC GPe
jQJ M hGC S
? dG
FbUGC e dG Y MW GDdG Gg
q
dGE ''HL'' dG AdG ..e HdGh
d ah dGh OdG gQ g dG
M LJ dG eRdG feEG IQGOEG
fQe f d .hCG dG e a IY a
,dG a IOLdG feEG H H
Jh ,dG AGK dG H dP eh
dG GC f ,iNGC a a IOLdG
OdG g Y dGC GC qaGC ..ST
OJ Y hCG dG a dGC e aGC
.hdG
HU Lh g
HdG fGCh UN ,bCdG
dG QN a d fdG
? OGORH H H
,MdG g e e GC LGC d
SG Y dG H FGdG a dCS fd
e OH dG ae GC c ,jdG
dGC d fGC ZQ ,e qS YdG e
a H e iS b e dGC d ..qL e
M eh SGhGCh TGC WdG dG
MGh Sd hCG ,dG a HGQ eh
.KG Sd fdGh
GgL J GC J GC
,SG fG e dG dH
b jQe GE J `d fd
,UdG HJ GE e f d
Y ``````````aJ ````dG''
a IY e aGC feGE
''h
C G ```````dG `````e
? fCH J GC GPe
e AGLGC a iL UdG HJ
Lf c fGC YGCh SdGh jdH
T a iL fGC ZQ ,jdG aH
LQO dGE SH Uh M ,eQ
UGe QfG a ,H SCH fH jgL
jQdG e e OY cGC dh dG
fG H d J dG jOdG
fj dG dG jdG a RdG
.hCG dG dGE Od
jf ,TH ,YdG a dG
b GhNCJ aHh
YdG eb Qf
C G d
Qd fahe
SH ,H J GC QfCG d qUGCh
N e ,hGC 20 e Y g
C d jQJ M hGC
dG Od fahe YdG jJ Y eGbGE
FdH dG fSG bh .GhM jdG QfCG e
UdG 1 bdG e ''GdG'' Y c dG FdG
TM `H UdG (25) bQ NGB dGE jf SQdH
.fj SG c e QfCG YJ Sh (JdH)
j Y ch jT YJ
dG Oj SG
b ''cL jdG''
Iqe AGLGCh bfG
Oe Hh W H
ejh j
Y Ye dGE YdG J
e
''GqdG''
fJ dGE
dG h
C G
MGQ Oqjoh HUGE e j Gj GY
Qe a oj Qe M
ITCdG Y j K ''Wb''
.IM
H jQdG dG a cQdG
S jGC ,jJ bCc KG Z
,IN d fc N b HUGE
e a fC aRdG a aQ bh
j H UEG e dG G g
,ITe SG K c QqdG
GQ dG GY GL cQj e gh
fY dG dG edG V
d jGC ,dG SdG a e
JWJQG H MGQ GC e j
WdG dG ,Ggh jOde e
dG Gch S 23 e q bC
.dd H e qJ dG dG
NGB cQG jj
g Oqh Ad
''eG''
QTh ,b e Y fc H fQe
Jje e dG aQ Gg JQH
a g FGQ hdG'' :b dG gh
AGOdG dG SCdh ,edG
HUGE e fYGC fGC g d dH
dh HdG dG ie Y
e jQdG SG e H JGC
qJ a dM GC dGh ..baQ
Od aRdG jQGC h ,qe
e qe eeGC Sh ,dG
.'' IOd bdG
. IM
cj dG GY e j Hh
g jCG g a MG d
f q j fE a , e d H
NCG OdG AdG a cQdH
VQCG dEG IOdG b fJ a g
eCG CG GL Qj dh ,WdG
,d Oj AT qch H d
dG UG e EG Y eh
K ,Z H jQdG SGh
j gh ,QeCG QqJ c ij
H Of eGC cQdG YSH
.dG hGC ON
q dM'' :GY
aRoG jQGC h
''G Od
MJQG Y GY d YGC bh
dM qJ dGE dH AdG H
S jOddG d fU fj
dG a HUGE e GY MGC
JLGC dG HUEG gh ,HdG
Yh dG MGdG dGE cdG Y
GC fCT e GOe qCH dG
d cGC e bJ HUEG J
GY Ea Yh .dP jdG W
h HQqj baQ HH j
e dhCG edG a e Qj
jOddG jJ dG HdG Gg
,fdG e dG j e a
jdG qde e a IQTEG jh
H e jQdG a j d
QH dP j dG gh ,AedG
hO aZ a AdG S fC dG
YS 24 `dG W AT CH dG
.dGh cCG GYe
jQdH e Z
OGfG Y M
Ea ,b e dGE f TGC ch
C GO e C H j G Y
,HdG dG a bO HUGE
a a VGE hGC W N c M qGCh
cGC jQeCe J GC fCT e hdG
e Qqj dG G dh , cC a
J QfG a OH M h baQ
N e BG dh . NCG A dG
dM Ea ,eGC U e jM
QfG Yh ,H qJ d GY
Y GQOb c GE id iNGC YS
.jQdG dG a cQdG
Z H fCS
jJ bCc
,JRH dG edG Mh
Y S H S G Y E a
YG `a NdG fGC'' :S
''```NGB ```jM ```S ``gHh
b e d fGC M M e
Qe M e e Qe Y
,YdG e j c j dG
bdG S g OdG GMGh
aj fEa dG fdG eh .e
a b e Y d dG fGCh
e jGC g ahGC hGC JGCh ,dG
Hh Qe M e jOddG
.YdG
OGORH T QOZ c
e Je c dG fGCh
?H
17
YS e cGC H adH dG
QSG Y jOddG Y bj d ,L eh
OhdG WT e QdH d dG qJ gh HQe Y
dGE NdG ITCJ Y JRM Y dGE dH ,fdG
NO qd ec aQ Gc ah ,fdG VGQCG
QaEG Lh hJh dUh H YS HQe Y
Y Y CWGh ,YH LdGh e H aQ
H MGdG dGE Od aZ dGE GhU K dP H
.IdG a jQdG dG AGLGE b ,AdG
. IM
gh fJ dGE Qe M jOddG Qe J
e gh ,fdG VGQCG dGE NdG ITCJ Y Rj
adG Uh Qa Wb Qe a FGdG H d T
C dG dGE dG QOZ eHh .fJ dGE fGgdG
dG dG FQ H ,M b c dG GPGC bh
a OhdG WT e Y Qe M aQ e H
S ANGE qJ K YS f RMG qJ jGC QdG
bdG a ,QdG a ITCdG eh S RGL W H
Y j GC Qe M `H VdG e c dG
.jOddG hqe dH jh ,FGdG e ITCdG
Y hdG MGC a Uh d
H e fc MdG GC e ZdG
dG LC g fC qj d ,AdG
jGQ aQ S a J I H
.dY jOddG
?HdG AGLGC g c
,hdG MGC a fG H dG
MGC a j A T c i J ch
d jL H j dGh hdG
.dG idG a
e h b e `cM
?e e `cg g ,AadG H
hCG dG e d ,U d ,
fGQ'' L a ,YdG a NJ
gHh ,YdG a NdG ''Qf
.NGB c d S
dGE f H aGh e Y
```b ```e ```Y''
b fGC j Ga jO d dG
?GPe e NGB c
eh ,j AT h q d H bh Qe M e
a AdG GE Y e adG j ''jOdG ``a qdG YdG e jOY GOa UGC GC e
Yh .dG Ic SQe Yh H
fCa ,e qJGCh dG e LGCh
JGC fGCh S a adG
SdG JOY e dh YLG fGE
qf GC qdGh ,fdG H dG Y d ,SSGC dG
...(j) S d Gg ,ddG Jh ,OH
q
.ah GdCG
?jOdG Y H J g
?jOdd jG SG iJ c ,e MGC GC e d GC j d d ,dZ YGC
q
j gh ,dG L Y U jdG SdG
g fC ,FY GC hGC ce d S Gg GC YGC dh
dHh ,MfGE Yh ,edG HJ e d dH e LC H H YS Lh dG LC
a Sh Y N a ,JRH dG YdG dGE
.AT qc b OdG
.Y dG eBG qf dh dG idG
M QG GTGE d GC d S d
. IM
MGC d Qe M GC j GC MC j h
d Gj d jdG ,fGdG FTGC W e ee
Y JRM Y ZQ OhdG WT e a Gc
J d ,fdG VGQCG dGE NdG LC ITCdG
M S ANGE dN e J jS qM dGE UdG
H qdG Lh jGC ,dG AYGC H bdGh Qe
dG ,MGC YH LdG eh QfG a e
qd fdG OhdG WT e SdG a NBG g gS
.Qe M dG QdG b
GE UdG c c , jG dG
?fJ
2011 hGC 20 dG @
,fh ITdG Y ja
E G OdG eGC jOh IGQe
''RcL''h dG a M gHh
2011 hGC 21 M
C G@
H e a d ITdG Y dG jd M
.jQdG
2011 hGC 22 KG @
a (d ITdG) jQdG H e a jQJ M
.YUG Te e
2011 hGC 23 AKdG @
a (d ITdG) jQdG H e a jQJ M
.YUG Te e
2011 hGC 24 AHQ
C G@
a e a M K LL Of e jOh IGQe
.''S J''
2011 hGC 25 dG @
.''S J'' a a eh ,''fU'' ,M
2011 hGC 26 dG @
.LG K dG a jQJ M
2011 hGC 27 dG @
H Of LGe) d fh ITdG Y jOh IGQe
(dG hGC ON
2011 hGC 28 M
C G@
d c MGQ
2011 hGC 29 KG @
.FGdG Y Ggh dGE IOdG
S jQeCG GC J GC
SSGC f d
OLh qX adG Q `e
?jOdG IRQH ASGC
dG H d
''fGdG'' W e
''GCdG'' GYh jH
jH Ggh jOde f Y he g c
gdG dGE dH bj GOj fEa GYh
PGE ,H bGdG bYh H OLdG dG
a H GRH GdG gh ''GCdG'' e Gj
FdG Gg LGJ GC hjh .QdG SdG a
,bY cGC Wqh dh
C G dG e Y W
a dG Y c H fQe Y bh e gh
.QdG SdG
cqdG e j IOSH
bj TeRh Gd
LdG Sj
GjdG
TeRh Gd
g adG f
J'' a a
gh ''S
GdG
bj
HJ UGCh
bY H
M ,bGU
dZ j
eGC JbhGC
q c GC H ff
HSM j a Y
C G
,IdG a UN GdG Ga H jh UdG
be Y jOddG Y dZ UGj jGC
q dG ''JhdG'' Y AdG L
.
C ''`cH jdG''
M hGC Qqj dG
IFdG j Gj S
qj d jHdG jR S j
C G dG GC hj
e Ggh ,NGB QTGE jZ dGE IFdG e aN e
e MdG f a e fLGJ N e Y bh
VGdG jh qj H jGC ,fJ dGE FGdG
AdG fh IFdG Od j M dG
H e hj baQ L e gh ,dhf Y
NGO he S
C Yj d d ,AdG
e GQPfh ,MdG YdG H e fGC YdG
qj Gdh ,LYRGE GhcGC d M baQ e Yj
.jOddG Y Gc
''qN'' jQ" H
S RGL H QG `a
H Wb Qe a Gc jQ" H S Z
MGC e QGUGEh S H Ggh ,S RGd fGa
WT eGCh ,Y dG e j d dG baQ
d L M ''N''h VZ QK fdG OhdG
,jGE e J H ,d j d fGC d cGCh RGdG S
bh GCqgh WdG LQ MGC dGE qJ dP Hh
hPgh qf f fNGC ,FGL fGCh FU fGC'' :d
dG ,jhQh H gH GCa ,''e j baQ
.dG KCJ J gh ''dG GedG'' V GQ
QG GE HG UG GjR
dGE e IdG HG GjR eGC aGdG UG
S fCH d cGC dG gh ,jeH QGg Qe
.eQ T a UN bQe Ooj dh Gc dGE
cGCh ,HH YOqhh HH Gc e GjR GHh
dG hCG
``LCJ IQGO
E G
YdG e
`````Je
``KG ```dGE
dG bdGh Yd qb
OdG AdG HJh
e qj CG GkQe c fGC ZQ
dG dGeGC YdG
jT JLGC H
eGdG Yd h b
C G Y
Gj d ADg GC GE ,kUN
gYh bh AT CG
Vh jH hdG
cGC bh .dG K
E G j
GQe j d fGC hdG
Gg dGeGC d Gj GC
jN GC kUN dG
d dN jdG
d Gd e
C G hHqS
dG K
E G j bM
dG c Gj GC H
d jdG Yd d
b h .
B G d AT GC Gj
Vh a hdG GH
GC kUN ,AdG H U
hj Gfc YdG
b
C G Y bM SG
d dP dh dG IS
.j
''HQc'' Y qj GR ge
LGC e Y IQY
E qeh
QGjEG qV Y qj ge f QdG GR
Gqj d fGC d GhcGC jdG GC ZQ ,''HQc fGa''
GC dGh .kdZ K W dG ,d Le e
e gh kjT e 40 H dW b c LdG
fhj jdG dh idG Se Y GC j
Ge j MGC GC hcDj fGC kUN kJe
qj H L Y keRY X a ,ge eGC .dG
GC H ''HQc'' qd IRLGE e d Y IQYGE a
.NGB SC GAe
E d LGC NGB jH Y
.
VZ YdG
kT Gj dh
dG YdG T
jdG dH jdH
CG c Gj d H
AT GC d J d IQGO
E G
CG hj Gfc jdG gh
jT ILGC b
C G Y Gj
Vh a L e gh
kT Gj dh e kYf U
H ,e j d
e dH j
dG Ge
C G J S
QH dG gj
e jdG GC H ,dG
a gh FY HQGC hqj
j dG eQ T
CG c jQdG e jdG
Y SQdG NdGh dG
.OhGC jd d GH
C G
hqj hdG
QG````````UGE ```a
```NGO ``fb
jdG GC Y bh Gg
fb QGSG a hj
GC H Ggh Yd NGO
g dG b W
jW Y dG GCdG dGE
IQGO
E G GC M a ,adG
dG J GC J fc
j d NGO GeGC
IQGO
E G GC hjh .H dG
Y GC be a qJ
qJ QeGC AaEH j
e M e dG
,g dG b
M
q dGE J fGC H
YGC Y GkH ce
.adG
.
GO M f
IRJ e a e QL QM
,Thbh jdG H jOqdG IGQdG e QL M
H e bh e fc IdG dG GC H
a j qe da fL dGE jdG QfGC
GH Gkc YdG qJ bh .dG fH IRJ
a ZQ JOGR d JJ GC H ,QdG
d dG dG hdG ZQ jd e aGC jJ
dG e d H fcP GCh S c IGQdG a
.bWGE dG a dG
d M dGE J ge
jQd M Y
dGE dHh M dGE ,ge f ,QdG J
M Y dG LGC e dPh dG dG
GC H IdG a kUNh dG dP a jQd
GC Y bh .IRJ e a Gkc V IQf
E G
ZQ M e dhDe e MdG c Lh ge
H gaJ Y j Qe
C G H dW fGC
dG e
C G gh jd ec dH Y dG GhOGQGC
H Qqj dG ddG M fGC H aJ j
.dH HH L Jq YdG
j h Mh AT H qj
I```Ye GC
Ea Y GT
E Gh d jQJ fL dGEh Gg
jGC j h AT H Md qj ,ge ,QdG
k e ge jh .jdG e IYe
H
qj fGC c jOdG jQdG dh Qd YdG
,d jOqh LGe J LGC e dH
c iNGC fL QeGC a M NJ dGE aV
E H
OjGE Y dGh dG dhDe e LdG J
QhH dG Gch ,QdG dH YLSG M
H YdG e dG H fdG UNG
.ddG Jd J Y
```L Ve g
jGC dG FGQ e OdG YdG eGC dG dG c
e ab T Y a H S PGE ,GkL L ,Ve
b YdG j dH ,Thb SQM YON dG dG
Gg e dCdG j dG jdG ja e OGY a
a Zj jdG jdG e H dP ch
.Yd Ib Od AeEGh HdG ANCG QGJ
AeEG jdG Qqb c MdG e jdG j dh
M a KdG H b j Yd jdG IdG d
Ea eGC e j eh .S 28 j d Y GC g cDj
dG L IOYEH IqL H eb fGC iJ IQGOEG
FdG eSG d fd e H dCJ b c
Ge j MGC GC ZQ ,JcdG a d SCG
Y ge QdG j GC j H ,BG d dG
.jOdG jQdG H a cj GC H dG Ge
Qf
C G d jdG dGE J
e H GS K Jqe Y Y eGC
dG idG Y e dG hjj jdG jdG
q TGC aYGC jH j eCG GC kUN ,dG bh k Gc dOLGC d ddh faGC c
.eJ K d FdG Y a fh Sd d d H adG
?jdG dGE JOY iJ c
``dG ````fdG
?dGMGC g c
f M ,jOY jH J jQdG
dG dG bdG e Lh cGC Y dH
g fdG dG C ,bCdG Y fYj
d eCG Gg j YdG Lh UCG
g YGCh ,jgL f M Ye Y
Ic H a OJ H gGC MdG
.eS dG OhOdGh YdG jgL
?YdG NGO AGL
C G g ch
````gQ
E G ````e ```fj ```YdG
jJ c jf H M ,GOe LSH Yd j e GL j fGC ThY
.UY d Ff j
Y e GHhJ YdG
jQdH j Geh SH
SS
C G dG Y j ThY
YdG LGC M ,N
C G AHQ
C G Y fG jdG dhGC jQJ GC ZQ
..gQ
E e f YdG ZGC GC GE ,a jQJ M S
ITe dG Me NO ThY
Qe
C G c Y jh Y a e
MGC Y j AT c ,d dGh H
.gGdG bdG a d dH gCG gh Gj e
jdG dhGC
`````Y'' :``jGQ
P```dG ````Y
`````f ``````M
''dd jgL
dG fdG
ee Tj Oe
SGdG e
NGO AGL
C G g c
?dG
IQH J QeCG BG d
fdG dG qGC UN HjGE
dG H ee Me H
dG cQe dG H b dG
IJH j dG dG fdG Y j f dGh ,SdH f
.QeR QdG GTGE J H f dG hOdG dG AV Y HjGE
e ,Qa
E G b jQJ M eH Y fG dG
?db
4 e e dG bdG qGC UN dP a f j e g d
,jQdG a eRdG ddG AVGEh dG H j e gh HQe
.dG Gg Y UGJ GC fh Gj e Y J QeCG c qEa MGHh
HGfG AV Y jdG cdG iH VGQ fGC g
?IdG UGj jdG eGdGh
S ,GY Y dG aJ YGdG d
GeGC Hh
''Gd
E G'' fGE Y gGj Qf
C G
UdG ''Gd
E G'' fGE Y jOddG QfGC e eg Ye gGJ
dG GdG N e ''Gf GfH'' SG J dG OdH
hdG Sd IdG GdG e IGRGe H ej dG
e gh Ue 40 FGd J jdG Qf
C G OY Hh ,jdG
N e IdG fGEh aGdH OdG e H dj L
eg Y hdG dG Y e a FdG GAdG
.GdG
YS Id cQ #Yh WGT
GTGE J Yh jQJ efH dGE #Yh WGT YdG j
cQ M ,dG dM qJ e eGJ dGh dGh bdG
dM J b eGC hGC IS L dG dG N YS Id
AV Y IdG YGe a hdG QfG a UdG Y fdG
.OdG W e N
C G AdG J
JfeGE j GCHh ej Y
dG OGdG a ITe IQH Y YdG efG HdG a
dGE KJ j e gh FeR e jOY IQH QJh jOdd
qj j gh ,GNDe d VJ dG QhdG OM H AdG
efdG cGeh JfeGE d dG dG SG Y
.QeR QdG b e FdG dG
dG'' :Oe
dGE fOYGC
SGdGh jOddG
j KdG
''dY ie
`d jJ a gdG Oe cGC
dG dG GC ''GdG''
JH jOde dGE GOe OYGC
gQOZ eH SGd Qc
c M GS IY e
a bh ,ee SQc j
a dG'' jM S
CH eDf GC jh dG QNG
e a c QhO d dG
S fGCh ,GQdG g
h jOddG dGE JOH
dG IdG Y dG j
fGC cDdG d a YCS
aV
E G e Y gGQGC
c e jd eRdG
fGC c M Y gGQGC
TGCh ,ee SQc
IhM Y dG SdH
fe
E H qfGC c SG
KdG SGdG H j dG
Y YCS jdG jOdd
dG dH gGe jJ
jgL H j
.''ddG Yd
jOddG IQGOGE
Qa
E G Lh ebGC
''GM'' a d
jOdd IdG dG eb
JdG H JH
dG OdG AdG UH
eGC IS MG b j
hdG dG Y e
Y Qa
E G Lh ebGCh
jOde eh Y T
Ggh ''GM'' a a dG
IRe hX aJ H e
AGLGEh ''HdG'' IS
C
hX a jOdG LGdG
HdG g CH Y ,je
dG dh
C G jdG
hdG e jOddG VJ
.jQdG a
GhOM hdG
O 100 e
NdG He
e JdG IQGO
E G OM
dGE NdG He O 100
LGdG Qd dG
eGC IS L dG jOdG
JCjh ,dG jOde eGC
J H e AGL
E G Gg
IYe Y jOddG e
e Jh jOe ja
e jJ a IQGO
E G
fgdG X a dG
hX aJ Y dG
dGh jQdG a je
Gg MW GgGC SQ Y
.SdG
LGj b AdG
dG jOh YH
He JdG IQGO
E G eH
M ,dG dG iNGC jOh
UdG J GC dG e
eGC jOdd jdGh HdG
a dG Ae YH f
hdG dG Y e
eGC Y JG J e
jdG e H h
C G
AGLGE b b YS
jdG eGC e
B G LGe
dG H e Ggh ,f
aGh If NCH dG bd
.dG OhOe Y
GQU NGCh dG Y qS
jdGh YdG e jQcJ
JQOd KCdG b a cQe fdG dG GHh
ah ee AfG e IGRGe jOdd dG dG
bh M ,JdG IQGOEG e e dG Jd
YdH HJ JH dG jdG bdG Y QdG
aj L e gh ,OdG e Y HdGh
e jQcJ GQU NG c edG Qj gh dG
dG dG bdG J AGLGC a YdGh jdG
.jOddG eh JdG UdG e HQ
Y jW e efG YdG e c j dh
jQdG a AGVCG N dG cQe fdG dG
QeR QdG AHGC H dOGC dG GQGdG a Mh
e gh ,cQe Y jH Ie c a gqj jdG
Y AHEH QeR IQGOGE dj e dG L
cDj e gh ,e JOS Se U OjGE hGC
UGC H dG jW a VGdG fG Y
.S dU .cQe dGh OS
C Gh HCG fdG
YH eGC jOh ej e
B G
jOh IGQe hGC h
C G eGC JH jOde eGB qf
IM dGE jdG YdG YH f eGC jJ
OdH dh
C G MdG fGh ,HGdG H e
d dG dG Y Lj GC b H
C G
e IGRGe fdG dG a GgGC HQGC H
,dG a OY QdG KMGC dG GdG
AS
C H dh
C G MdG jOddG eGB NO bh
,jhGR ,TH ,e S ,YH ,jO ,SS ddG
MGC K ,de ,SGQO ,Y ,MH ,Me
UdG d UdG eh dH GJ QdG
,She ,IQGfH gh fdG MdG f dG
Y ,Y ,JGJ ,TQ" ,b ,dH ,OGM
.gZh
C G Gg d YH
q GE bh ,f YHH N
c aYh e feGE XGC dh
C G dG
b dh
C G MdG W adG eGC d dG J
a GgGC IY J e dG Y j GC
aY dG IdG GdG e eGJ fdG MdG
ie Y bdG g j e
q GE OY bh ,ja
dG jdG hdG Sd J jQdG GdG
OQ dGE dH dG jdG a db M J
jh ,jQdG AKGC Yd Hj
E G dG
Hc
C G ja ie Y QS dG GQGdG OY
Y jY IOSG feGEh OGdG V H
dH ja AGK
E JeN Y gGj jdG e
B G
.ddG a ae NO J Y j dG
RHGCh hGC dG Ad
Yd QNG
cQe H VGQ dG
jgdG Y bdG hjjh
Yd adG
QOjh J cQe e
edH jOddG
Y H hCG eGC IS L dG dG fc
cQe fdG d dH INCG hdG dG
AGLGC Sh dG eGC djGE We dGE OY dG
YdGh OdG ISGC Sh SCdG e dG ge
jMh Y jW e GbCJ GC H UdG Y
qYh dG cQe j d c ,jQdG AKGC FGdG
SG IhM X a JH IQOe HH KCJ Y
SGQhCG UY a LGJ Ia W H M dG
.jQdG dG AfG H dG ae Y UGCh
GdGC GJ GC S Y 3 Y dG aQ YGdG d Qb
hGC JdG IQGO
E G e Vh jJ QGb M a QUh jOddG
S e H e
C G jh ,jdG SdG N dG e feM
ddG YdG GeGC Hh JH T e QGe UGe d S dG
N
B G g Vh iS dG GY e dGE aVGE dG jOdd
.jdG SdG e e jOddG GdGC d JOY e eGJ
JH jOde
GC.c
,gS ,hH
hNCj jHh
YS 24 `H
d hM jJ H Re hO
dG Rhe LGH SdG Gg
aVGE SSGC d NBG g j
ae jj dG HH dGE
SSCG SQdG e Ea jGC
jGH b e dGE LDe S
dhCG dG GC dh SdG
ad Rheh L TJ
.SSGC fe Y
GE j
UN efH
Y Z L SQdG GC H
L dG jQdG dG H
dG Hh J a
fJ a g L dG jQdG
j GC Qb fGY QdG Ea
dG e U N e f H dGE
fdG JfeGE j M fdG
j L dGE
SGG Y aG
aGe hN aj GY
AGG bdH H
QdG bGC dh
C G MdG jGH e a FbO 10 H
`cQjh eS eH HH GdG Sh jJ Y fGY
GC fCT e a FbO 10 H YdG jJ GC fGY GL
H bGCh HH f LJ dd YdG f Y KDj
jW J a ZQ dGE Oj dP GC d cGC M jJ
.QGdG j HH L e dG
dG dG Y Cjh j j
AdG JH Td Rh
G e
Gc TGE e H
G NdG e
e dG NdG e Gc e H g LdG TGE
dG NJ j Ie c a c M Y IdG aGe W
fL e Y MGCh NGC e H ch ,adG Y QGf
E
.dG Nd VY L e LGdG g a OGOdG
aQ GYh jdG W
e H LdG d VJ dG dG NdG iMGE H
fGY QdG e YdG W fdG MdG e a
HU
E G H IGQdG AfGE Y QOb Z fGC H jJ
e H j GC Y UGCh dP aQ fGY GC Z dGh
.jdG IaU jZ dGE IGQdG
dG YGE H fGY H b jW d
dh
C G MdG a IdG dd AGL cQ
N
C G Gg JEH Td fGY Re M
OQh de e He RdG Y AdG M e
h Ia IdG CH jGC MRe Td Y
.Ge
C G J
LM G G
cGC J GE
J GPe jGdG
dG dG Y
ja H e
eGC jOdG IGQG
I dG OGE
H LGC QGG)
jf
?(IGQG
`d ja GC ec e f
?dG J J
H eG SGM Ic S aG
f Va e KGh fGC g L dGE
?SSCc
AGOCG J Y f c f ,dG H
e a dG C GdG VQGC a de OjGEh
OjGEh fEG Y dG g jOdG jQdG g
J fc dG IdG Y Ggh dG dG jW
.dhCG LQdH dG dG Y
je YJ dG dG M d
?RdG j dG jdG
j d Gc dG
c Y j GY
AGO
C G d
b jOdG IGQdG g a ja jg Y J a
LGe hGC VN jah a jGH GE ge fGC fGY
d fGEh S SCG d H j dh d jOh
HjEG dG H hO dP ZQh WMEH
N cQGJ Y S dG dG dG Hh
e Z Y d GDS ah ,dG jOdG jQdG
IQN j fGC fGY b IdG Y fNh dG
GhJ IdG Y C KGE hGC Y j GC Y IGQe
c C dd e GH d GdG H a fdG
.gL fGC gj GC jj Y
SS
C G NO e''
''H aGC S
j `d dG ja eb dG AGO
C G M
?dG ge e
G e Gc Z GY
AdG bH dWh
WM
E G dG bGC GY
SS
C G Hh
OGOdG
a h
C G YS HdG
Va M idG a YS HQ OGOdG J d
dhCG jd Ua Nh jdG Y JS
SQdG eGC Ld Lh f Lh dG jT H SGH
Ua JGC c ,QWEG a e JjJ GC Z fhY
LNGC fhY SQdG d e H Ld iNGC
.cdG dGE HH
J IdGh AGO
C G LGJ gH
GNCe h
C G MG j OGOdG
J GdG
JS UGJ IdGh
IGQ dG g g
f dG dhCG jOdG
CG YCGh HdG Gg a
dG Y j c adG
dH dhCG LQ d H dG
H d dG I dG IQG dG
f dH H e fMC G fch
Y j c dG ja Y
dhCG LQ d H AGOCG J
dG H fEG Nh
jdG g CG bCG dd KdG
.JH Y KDJ d
UY GC M LGdG QGWC He N e
H d dG fdG e jd ae fc OGOdG
dG bGC NCG Gg GC Hh ,Td QdG TGC
LGC e Ic IQGH d e MGh c Ea WMEG
L e IVM fc fdG Ea ddHh QdG bGE
.HUEG OJ dhj fGY TGC
fGCh dG g feGE a f Yc f
jOdG jQdG a IH OS OGOdG GC KGh T
S GQfEG Mh e GAGOGC jh dG
HS b c SSCG IOY e UN IVM
.IdG LGe a gJQGE dG ANCG Jh
ae Gfc OGOdG Y
fG e
:Rhe
``dG `e VZ ``fGY
````````c `Y ```jh
dGE b e c e
OGOh H H L SQ dG
RGL OSGE eH eGC hGC J
f SEG dG e S
AGLGE Th Y c jGC FGdH
,fSEG jfCG iMGE a QdG
a dGE L SQdG Uh bh
HGdG YdG OhM a ''dG Qf''
jQdG dG a QTh GAe
J d dG UdG JLGC dG
.IdG a IdG AH e
jJ H HH bGC GY
a FbO 10 H
c.GC
2 IdG .GE - 0 J .h
e ej GC b dhCG LQdH
jQdG a Qjh YdG
.jOdG
`c.GC
dG hCG
.OdG
K````e
''Gq``````dG''
```````````dEG
gGQdG Y
.OdG
GC.c
dG fdG
K````e
''Gq``````dG''
```````````dGE
gGQdG Y
0 J .h - 2 IdG .GE
aH OGOdG Y RdG ZQ
hcDj WMG
SS
C G hOjh
dG a e Yf dH HUGE j hM
dG a HUGE qT dG
GC jdG W a ,e e ch BG e j c hM GC H
(dG) cCJ a ,YdG HUGE d dG dGE dG Uh jZ dGE j
Ea BG Y TG GPGE d ,dH S TCG AGLGE YJ HUEG GC
.HUGE IQN ie Y bd TCH W c AGLGE Y Ge S YdG
dG fK J LGJ IdG
dG IS J OGOh eGC fK jOh LGe Td QdG eH
d Y JG b fGYh Td ch ,fh ITdG YdG Y
j GC dG eh ,eGC hGC jdG d dG H fK LGe
a Y OYG a Zj Td
C SS
C G dG e c
.dG LGe
GZ hdG Y Th
ITdG YdG Y dG IS hdG Y T IdG LGS c
IQT
E G QJ ,HdG Gg a ddG jOdG LGdG gh ,fh
YdG HGdG H e b a TdG hdG Y T GC dGE
.f dG a IdG e jh gGQdG Y a Hj ,bdG
Z QH LGe
,QdG hGC 25 j jOh LGe eH j Td QdG c
LGe GC Z ,"QH M cH Hj dG QH Of eGC
.GZ dG HJ S QH GC H e Z jdG Gg
G e J
E H Td R GY
eGC hGC Qj d J
hGC IS dG bdG eH dG jQdG dG J j d
e j d f
C J OGOh LGH dG Z Ud ,eGC
.hdG L LGe a dG a gJ dG ,HUEG
f AGO
C G M fdG MdG a M
19
H Td QdG H N dG UdG
idG a UY ceG g ,IGQdG jf
a dH JQGL KGC MG e Y
c dG jOH QGZ Y ,SSCG dG
,eMh hM dGE aVGE IGQdG cG
hOj WMG GC GL QdG Qjh
a fH dG Y hQObh SSCG
.SSCG dG
VGQ N Td
Y AGOGC Y
:Td
cGC Jeh fj RdG''
''RdG a YdG Zd
Y AdG jf a Td QdG d c
:Fb LGdG g a ja OhOe a jGCQ
d jdG YdG bGC J OGOh eGC''
Y bd hdG L eGC GcQj
idG a IGQe ADg b bh ,gGe
,dG jQdG a fj dG RdG GMh
dG idH jd Je fCa AGOCG Y eGC
a ZdG M e UN ,dG J eb
jGC IVM IOGQEG g J GC JGCh ,RdG
.''ddG jQe a
`c.GC
GdG H iLGC Td
fdG dG a
Y GdG H Td QdG iLGC
e c bGC M ,fdG MdG a dG
gL ,Td ,eM ,MGC S ,dG N
FbdG a eR SQdG TGC c ,jQGJh
GC j d M a ,fhY e INCG
L LGe a GcQT jdG e Y
AGLEH hDaQh aO cG M ,hdG
.H Y AdG Heh jQJ M
Hc fdG MdG
IdG J j eM
L SGCH
dG jQdG a SSGC j b
jOH j GC f fEa ,d dG FbdG a YdG eb dG idG dGE dH
He e jM a cGCh ,Ge Y VGQ GH Td QdG GC H dG jQdG a SSGC
.dG LGdG a f jdH dG UGj d c CT d S YdG Gg GC
j M eR `d FdG IQT e
LGC e Sh a e c j fGC GE ,fe SS
C G dG a fhY fe GC ZQ
J INCG FbdG a ,dP cDj eR SQdG e H b eh ,ONh eR eR IYe
,aVGE GOe H Y cGC j M eR SQd FdG IQT e LhN Hh jJ
`c.GC
.OGOdG g e JN Jc U eR GC H QK JGC e gh
eh je c J OGOh Y M dG RdG
eGC H e dG jdG e YS 24 H JGC fC ,jd
N g jOdG jQdG e dG GC ZQh ,hdG L
d jW OjGEh OdGh eGdG YdG H fG
K H d j fC e j RdG M fGC GE ,VGh
.JfeGE a cGC
NdG e dGh fH YafG Y AdG
hMh QGJ HUGE a J e dG
GjT aJ AdG j GC f c bh ,U Gg
dG jOdG jQdG W fC ,fdG e fH YafGh
Me a fC ,SdG GAdG Y afEG M e J
de HQdG j IdG g ah GdG e SM
c LGC e Sh a e c j YdGh ,SSCG dG
.dG H j dG IQGdG j e gh ,QdG K
?dc dGC J OGOh Y e T IS Va
Td QdG bGC be c e
e jY d VGCh ,WMG dG
eCG jh hdG L eGC GcQT jdG
,c GdG Shh fhY Ghe SQdH
,OhL ,GY ,fhY e c d M
,Hb ,hM ,HY ,jOH ,dL H ,ff
.c ,Qe
e
C G Cch c fH afEG
SQ IGQH j
Y JS Va dG
dh
C G MdG a OGOdG
Y JS jdG dG Va
a c dG ,dhCG MdG a OGOdG UY
QdG Gc (AGOCG) GQGCh idG a AGOCG
dGE j Hbh Qe Oc M ,Td
YGHh dG d Se a OGOdG T
.jGC OGOdG SQM
AGL cH dG j Hb
:Q`e
Y RdG''
`e OGOdG
```````je
a cDSh
``jQdG
''````dG
dG fdG
IH OJGE
````fGhe ``eGC
````Sh `````j ``````SS H`J
O```J ''AG```dG''
``dG ```a `ZQh `J ``fGE
Oh A````d hGC ``a
YdG j GC jh ,WdG
Y KG Z H U FeH
IQTEd .IQGOEd GcGC e jJ bGC
e FeR e j d Ie YdG Ea
SGCQ H adG QfG ah ,IH
.N jH
jdG H SGCQ
''dG'' `H YdG Hh
IKDe c dGC gS
L S TGC dG Y
YadG SdG
j jYh MQ
OGdG c j GC jj c QdG GC ZQ
,I M Y Y c jgL L QO Y b d
a .a Y 22 GTEH NCG a cG d
Y H jYh MQ Qj d M
j QdG L dG eCG gh ,jgL
.dG YGdG jZ dGE MGQGE
c S j GjdH
19
H ITe GjdH Yd jJ ah
dH S f d fGC XGC'' :b AdG jf
Gc bYGC dG IQGdG e e IY dGE
IGQdG GC dGE aVEH ,c OhOe jJ a
dG OhOdG UHh .d dH dhCG J
HCSh ,QdGh Qd dG JG eb
cGC J g SdG Gg ag GC UN YGC
.''jdG Gg cGC dh GgCG e e OY
J Y YG dG Y
T c
GR hGC WT iOGC M
T .
e
C G j GRL
E G aO LGC j
dG j dGE YdH UdG GRLEG aO jQJ jJ dG Id WdG HGdG Qb
dU a U dG QGdG gh .HGdH UdG fhdG bdG a AL c ,2011/08/25 dG
UN ,jd aVEG jJ feEHh HJh IN J UH dG YJ LGC e eCG
KK IQGOEG IRH GReh .GNDe edG YdG jOhe Y c INCG N IGQe GC
Y J c (1991) dGe eBG e Y 3 J ddG Y 25 Fb GC dGE dH GRLGE
.''dG'' fGb
IGdG dG
HdG e fdG dG d dG dG
.INCG dG a dG dOH
MSh j SMH
AGL cQ j
fL e Y IY dCJ LGdG g aY
,L SMH jdG dG S ,OJG
bh ,AGV
C G c Nh dG a WT iOGC dG
a SdG Gg Qhd QdG ICLe QH HG j
dG Uh Ic a Y HGC M ,GdG Sh
j c
B G e TJ Gd IL jhDQh
Y GC e OdG d
C G fUh jdG hjdG
dGE aV
E Hh ,AGdG jT HdG YdG
L MS jd jdG SQdG iOGC a SMH
he Id U M e GRe WT QhH jdG
cQ U e jGC Jh ,''JdG'' dG W e
j d
B G e Tj e ,fdG dG a AGL
.SS
C G dG Y T SQd RH
C G adG
dU
N OG
ie Y j Qhd
''H'' eGC Y
QdGh MM Y FdG Z ah
J ,IdG a adG S jdG Oc
j O H O d G a Q g S d G
U M , J Q O e M Y d G
c d CG h Y b EG b a d g S
e h M , Y d G e e Y I K D e
M I Q d G a j CG d N
Ia N fH dG gC H j
e YdG gS dW M .HdG
a G f j CG g d CG d G d G N
CG h , a V h d G d G i e
hYjh Oc QdG GQGb Gej
Y G O e , e H d G N e
O J E G Y a e I Q U A Y EG I Q h V
a j d G S d G I d G N
IOg dG eCG LGJ S bh .SS
dG dEG aVEH ,dG adG V
QJ dG Y Y H Md dG
.dG Y
eGC Uh dG
MU
MQdG IS M hGC
adG S Och MM
IdG
b YdG e dG adG c GPGEh
aM e Y eGC hGC IS J
QdGh MM Y FdG Ea ,fe
H ITe) IdG a adG S Oc
,(YdG e Y dG LEG jf
dG JdG e Y bd
OhdG cdG WT e YdG QhH
gQEGh bdG d jOJ ,TH
cH QfG W AGL j b dG
QeCG JJ Y a .fdG OhdG
Y YdG jRJh dH dG
.''UH OGdG'' H dG
Me Sd ,J fG
G hGC SSh
Q d G d b d G d G J h
dG Y Ea ,LG N Oc
,WfG hX Sh L SS dEG
d j d G d h D d H f G Y CG
M .HdG a dG d YdG
b MdG SdH gLGJ Y bh
e e b CG d G , a d G f EG
. O dG b dG a h dG O H jdG
h CG S S S S Q d G c h
F e R H a G j CG b d G
aCG a j dG L H ,YJ
.NCJ CG hOh hdG
QdGh jY
fG Ieh j
N adG
GC QYEG a IQGOEG Vh bh ah
,YdG dLEH dG OGdG j
J jdG dG Yd dH M
Sb Ie a gS GRGL GSG
,IQGOEG AYGC MGC dH dG OdG H
H OLh e j d eCG Ea
jY YdG J M .GASG
a S RGL NCJ H hCG ,QdGh
e NJ dGE Ld fdGh QhdG
edG a OLh H ,adG IQGRh
ASCH O
E G OGJ
ebQGCh YdG
```eG``dG
LfQR 3 ,b dh 24 ,Z af 10
jR QL 21 ,HdG e dGN 7 ,f
.af Y 30 ,dh dN jRH 26 ,Se
OdG edG
6 ,dG Y HR 19 ,jdG Y b 13
jg 11 ,a jY 8 ,dG Y SGCQ
,d e QeR 20 ,aJ Ie18 ,e
OhGO 31 ,e Hc 23 ,VQ e QdG 22
,S SS 1 ,e fjQ 32 ,e
.QW Ijb 39
bdG dG
H```````c
C G ````dGE
dMQ 34 ,dG Y Y H 33
37 ,S gS H 36 ,QY HL 35 ,Se
MH 40 ,JM NO 38 ,jj aT
.eQ
U e IH OJG J LJ
SS jH HJ H dG eGC
,GjJ ''OGdG'' a a fdG
cGC e IH fG dG d SG
QdG gGj M .HSGC KK e
Gg f Y IQGOEG AYGC ch Oc
Y IFdH Oj dG dH ,HdG
GC UN ,ddG fG N OJEG
YdG J J Vh hdG c
OdG H ,dG Gg J LGC e
AYGC aQ MM Y FdG dH dG
dG S dG YdG N IQGOEG
.fJ dGE
YdH LG Oc
dG b
dG JdG
J
E Gh
Oc Jg e
dG LEG N AL e RHGC jh
a jd Y e Oc QdG Y
JG dG QGdG g ,WfG fGdG
dG JdG GSGE H OJEG Qe
.YdG L Y HdG Ia N
feEH Y c CH d cGC M
IQhdG YSGE M a FH JG
eh ,dG Oc Jg N e ,dP
MGC W e Jd GSG Ca Gg GY
IQdG HdG jf jZ dGE YdG
MU VS dG SCG N
.QdG M Hd
91 S dGe e Y 8
JYGC dG Fd dh
C G IAGdG N e USG j Me RHGCh
.1991 S dGe e e fK OLH YdG QYGC QJ g ,IQGO
E G
fjQ ,e OhGO ,af Y ,dh jRH ,QW Ijb e H e
C G jh
.JM NO ,jj aT ,Se dMQ ,e
U
C G SSh KdG S a Y 3
e
C G jh ,S KdG j S Y KK g HdG dG ah
S YdG cGC h
C G j M jYh Ie ,SGCQ OdG edH
e jY GNGCh (1979/1/23) dGe e fdG j (1978/4/2) dGe e
UGC ,SS S ah e dG SQdG j a .(1980/12/23) dGe
.(1993/2/2) dGe e fGC PGE OGdG a Y
dG h
C G
IS jOde
`dG I`S LdG `LGJ ``jOdG ''cjcH'' ,Ae
E G aj ''GQc''
````Kd QG``Hh ``Sd ``bj
e fJ dG GJ dG FdG e L
dG j H dG adG Qe ie Y UN
HGhQ QdG AHGC Y j dG eCG ,IS a
f QXGE bCG Y hGC dG LGe a RdG J
.OdG SdG dH N dhCG QGhOCG d a
dG j b ''gGHGE''
''GQc'' aQ
Y TS HGhQ
SS
C G dG V
QXEH de YdG
G dG Ff
jOddG J jS dG AdG f GC ZQ
HGhQ QdG AHGC GC GE ,Gc J dG IS
,QfCG j dG LdG QXEH de fS
dG ie RGHEH de jGT AaQ S PGE
a dG GCh UN QfCG MGQGE LGC e dG
eSG GC H UN SdG Gg aJ iHGC IS
.de ASGC IQGOEG
Qf
C G bGC gdG Ad f
OGORH T
VQdGh fG Qj f"
jL FQ d GS J
e gh jd FQ j d
.KhM a f" T
Vj H
jh jT d
dSG
dG bh AK
C G g ah
e HdH jdG FQ Y
M a f Lh dG H
e H dG g M jT
jd FQ f" J jj
H HdG jdG deh
QGdG PJ FQW eY L
jdG SFH j a FdG
a Ye jJ jGCh L e
fhj dG cdG e SGCQ
HGH d Y djh H
e jL e dG dGE JOY
dG Gg eGCh .iNGC L
dG eGS
E G e Y gf
M ,a dG IS fG
dSH HS Hb Ff a
UN jdG dG J d
jdG SFQ M GdG GCh
Y Y ej dGh MG
dCdG a GOe be PJG
e gh SdG e dH ceGEh
.Wb aQ H aj
e LG VQG
eGC IS jL
19
id eGC IS YdG ch
UGC e hGC HdG jdG
OGORdG QdG id j
YLG GhY eY VQdH
eh jdG Vh SGQd GNGB
d jGCh GQJ e j
.H eS dG dG Id
dG dGE VQdG J M
SGCQ a a dG YhH
dG GC H cdG e
a 75 `H HS bh a MG
dG AY
C S
C G e FdG
Hb VQj c e gh edG
a GJ S fGC cGCh HS
L N e M e gh fdG
AGT OGQGC d FdG a 75`dG
AYGC QN e M S
C G
edG dG
d de QNG f
jd FQ
jdG GC fQOe ch
jJ a hj HdG
jh jdG SFd Te
bh a fcGC dG dH e
C G
jdG SFQ a Zj fG HS
dG eh .dG H jh
M GE f#d ae de j GC
dG a AdG f" Qbh
e fMh L e c Sh
.IQGO
E G e AYGC RHGC H
dG a GMCG QJh
VQdG GCh UN OGORdG
jd UdG Yhe L jJ
IQGOGE dJ GE fCH Yh fGC M
d hJ QeGC IYH jdG
OY .
.ddG bdG a
J jdG JS
e Gj
E Ud
Y 4
d fGCh UN dG eGC
H a j dG dh
C G IdG
dG Y bd jdG
j L VGh dSQ gh
dGE fH a Ze Z fCH
dhMh .jOGORdG FdG
e ad eGC Ae H JG
Jg f Ie c a d M
d cDJ GC b e dG
H e VZ f" GC fQOe
S J fCH jh jdG
b GC H eGbGC J e dG
jdG gQGC dG dG dH
YdG bGE e J eY
gOY ch gOY dG
dG a AdH Y 18 HGb
dG ddG Je eh
VdG SdG e dY fc
Je YdG e a Th
GC b jdG SdH UdG
jj H dG CH Lj
j L e gh jd FQ
ZGCh fG ah M
E H
.c dG Jg
W GW
C G H
AT ch jdG e
GZ S
H dG be QKGCh
f" J e Y bdG
jdG VeG jd FQ
jdG OGORdG dG NGO
L e gh jjDe e hj
e M IOM aN a Nj
fH f" QGb eGCh .M
GC a ZdG OaGh jdG e
FYGC H jd FQ j
,gVh d H Y GfG
IQGO
E G e AYGC H hM
Yh jdG e GWh FJ
fG QGb PJG a dG
a e c S fGC d GhcGCh
jd FQ J Y Sh
M
C G Gg iNGC e e GWh
dG bdG GYj d
OGORH T Y He UCG
QGSH h AhdH j CH
c a ,Se c jf a
M YGU f UCG FU
g d ,jd FQ j e
Th JhQP GdG H IdG
a fTCG c a .Ic GQJ
f" jdG Y CG HS OY
b Hb N d TdG
jZ dEG jd e e
e LCG e VdG dG
FQ j CH Ff be
S EGh eY e hCG jd
M e gh Ff jdG e
e fG f" Qb eH
e J LCJ eH jdG
.IQGOEG d FQ jL
fH CLJ f"
Y dG
dG Ae YdG ch
cdG OJ LGC e VdG
UN jd FQ f" d
hd e dG dG GCh
M M ,jdG Y aQT
GhOLh gdG Hh f"
d J e Y bJ
C dG Gg Y bJ Qe
C G
dGE Ghj d jdG H
hH fCH GJh LG
e Gj dh UdG Y
Ggh OdG bdG a UdG
e Y Y Gfc fGC e ZdH
fG Y f" a e gh YdH
jdG ADg e VGh dSQ
gh IQGO
E d FQ fhjj fCH
Gfc eH Y HfG YG e
Gbhh Y jGH a jGC e hGC
Md aO dG e
C G fH
.OGORH T e fGh
Jg ZGCh VZ
G IS dG
b a f" GC fQOe ch
e bh dG KOdG H dG
Y WdG HGdG J GC b
b YdG e aO e jJ
jdG JS J ,gCJ
GjGE LGC e UdG dGE LdG
H GeGC Y HQGC e
Y e H eCG jh ,SCG
aGdGh " YadG GdG Sh
dGE aVEH ''cjcH'' QdG
UdG OJG e jjdG jaGdG
GC dGE IQTEG QJ .jSh TM
AHQCG IS fG IQGOEG e
aj M ''GQc'' AeGE VdG
NCG Gg d HGdG id e
.dG AeGE aQ
jdG Qf
WdG HGd e j M
e jJ J GC Hh d ,YGjE
Id YdG gCd dG aO
Gg Y jdG IQGOEG HGC ,SGC
aGdG Uh J GC ah YdG
j M ''jc gGHG'' jdG
MCH MG Qj K eh HGhQ
.''GQc'' hGC ''jc'' eGE YdG
AH Sj ''cjcH''
S h
IQGOGE V ,f dG a
LGC Y hGC eN jOddG
,SdG Gd dG U V
AHQCG IS ddG dG M
cjcH'' ddG QdG aGdH
jdG VH bG dG ''S
aGS S Je GY eGCh
Hh ,jOddG GdGC Y dN
dG J YdG Gg AeGE
d aGH YJ b jdG
j GC j PGE Ie feGE
YdG a HJ H dG
dG jdG H Hh jaEG
GC dGE IQTEG QJ .H j
Y jOddG fJ dG dG
QdG L adG Qe ie
e ''S'' YdG j HGhQ
Y ''jc''h ''GQc'' eR ae
.jdG V fH dG
QGH
SGe Kd
dG j ''GQc''
Y MbG dG
JOM dG dG C Gf
YdG e ad WdG HGdG
IS J GC dG e fc
SC gjJ j GC b dG
HGhQ aJ QdG e ,aVGE
M jdG IQGO
E d NCG AdG
dPh ''GQc'' jdG aGdG e bJ
,WdG HGdG id e aO d
j dG c dG bdG ah
Y aGdGh YdG Gg AeGE
''GQc'' aQ ,ddG IQGOGE hT
jOddH HS dG dG AeGE
Z gYG dG ddG dG H
ddG dG b ''GQc'' ch ,ac
dGE dN fdG Le aQ
AHQCG IS VhdG dhW
dG j GC hO jW AdG GOh
''GQc'' a S dG dG Y
.jdG U V
d e W
aQ HGhQh
IQGOGE) adG Uh GC Hh
jd (GQc YdGh jOddG
IQGOEG e ''GQc'' W ,Ohe
M d e HGhQ QdGh
fGC dd cGC M ,e Qj
U a FdG QGb S
d ,dG j GC dGdG dG
aQ jdG FQh HGhQ QdG
QGb j GC Y GUGCh YdG W
MGC GC H IdG J N
''GQc'' AeGE j c jdG
G M N I AGLGC
Y TGC dGh QdG G IS jaGC 13 jLGC dG jQdG G T
ZHh SH YdG U I AGLGC HGhQ aJ QG IOH dG bdG
hGC je
C G dG Ic Ad QG H g G g e e gGC dh ,HdG GE
N
C G dG OYh Sh jGT AaQ H TGC Y adG c M ,''"hdG''
.GgGC IY S dG jGT jd
V
C G G TjMh ''"hdG'' dCj jGT
GG VQGC Y Y MGC c M ,''"hdG'' H IL ae jGT YdG iHCG
bd e MGC bj GC hO aG e GE jh dc j c fGC dH
fCH cCJ M AdG Gg N dG G TjM c H ,H j dG fdG
V f
C LGNGE HGhQ e W dG hOe eR ZGC dG e
C G ,dG g T j
.YdG H GG VQGC Y FGQ AGL
C G L dP c ,GdG e dG
YH GfG OG
jdG OG GH M ,jdG NGO IFdG hdG g IN
C G jQdG G e eh
GH jdG GC dH dG YH GfG fCch SG Gg jOdG GdGC S
CH cDj dG e
C G ,OGh eGdG YdG H J GC G J `dh IMGh c
.jd OG jaGdG fG Y GgS c AaQ
GdG AGL
C GhOY HG
LJ eGC VG AKdG j d dG OdG AdG cQG UdG H eEH j `d
TjM LGh c SQG QGZ Y d GVJ dG HU
E G H dPh e
JG dG fCSG GC Hh d ,Sh YdGh Qf aGG GE aV
E H ,hOeh
fCH YfG YGC dG e
C G ,jOY H GHQJh Yd GfGh YdG ADg OY
.d GVJ dG HU
E G e e GT
dG fdG
````dG FGQ
````HH jOde
bGC dG LdG J H
M aH dG FGQ IQGOGE
,L
B G AfG b GdG
.. NGB e hdG LGh
:````MH
dG j GC H''
''S TGdG N GC
Y jUdG H MG H
H TGdG OJ NdG
QJ T eGC jOdG JGQe
fe e b ,OGM H H
AdG eH GC ZQ fGE MH S
H fGC qGE ,IQGOEG f QN fc
S TGdG N GC dGE IQTEG dGE
aV dG J SG M
af hGC H VdG a
ch ,fh Se W TGdH
jdG dGE j QfCG
jRe hOjh dG jh
Ve ,MH J M Y ee
c ad Fe UdG g GC
H VjdG hdH dGh OMCG
jj .
.jdG Ue
Thb LGS dG
dG QJh KG
LGS e
B Gh
OGORHh S
S 21 e bGC a S gQhH
Y ,"" QdG Y j dG
ej jJ LGe e Ye
ah e FGf eGC dGh dG
,dGdG Y OGORH Th S
W
E G jj fe
2011 jJ Y
```j QG```H
```jQdG a
efG QGH SQdG SQ eH
jOde OGJ dGE VdG AHQCG IS
T ,Se GY FeEH jH
jQdG S OJ HdG SQdG
dG a QT M ,jdG ja e
eGC hGC Ae L dG dhCG jQdG
.IJ HJ a dG
L
B G jJ
dG j
hTh fY
GMdG FdG
HGdG GC dG M M eh
hGC 25 dGE YdG gCJ LGB Oe
GPGE d OdG j e gh ,QdG
eR H FdG TEG M qJ
jQdG b fe dGE cdG
e Ea dG M ah ,QcdG
SQdG hO IJ HJ fG
Z M , h T a G d G h f Y
e fj dG HUEG AGL hCG
J M a H d G d G a
, j d G O d e I a h H h T
jdH dG eCG dG b jh
.jQdG e THh
.S
IG````````````dG fdG
MS ,QGRH ,He
GcQj d Tdh
SQ j N
Y 22 TGC dG bdG
je e RdGh e AGOGC
dH ,e jOh LN fK a jdG AGOGC ch
jfGC MGC eGC ah fH dG eb dG ie dGE
``````````dG f
IN d Ma HUGE
jOdG IGQdG N dG a d VJ dG HU
E G GC ,Ma d jdG SQdG gLGC dG UdG cGC
H Oj GC Y ,bJ M MGd cdGh dG H dG f M .IN d OGORH T eGC
.YdG e ej GC b jOa H jQdG dGE dP
dG TCH dG dG c
H ,eGC hGC fY SQdG GLGC
dG a d VJ dG HUEG
dGE cdG YJ dM GC HdG
fGC j e ,bCG Y SG Ie MGdG
a T dG IJ HJ S
HG S Yh ,hCG eGC Ae ja
jQdH Ad KJ Y KG S
d S dG efdG ah Md
jQdG fCj GC Y ,dG bdG
.jH dGE JOY Y dG e
jOh GAd
efdG a
Me a ''dG'' J Sh
AGLEH ,KG GZ H adG b e
dhCG S jOh JQe
a iQJ GC Y jNCG OJH
OSh ,H dG gGC eGC fdG
gh ,M bh a FGLGE Ye
a S d G L G d G
Q e CG V Y f M Q Q d G
Y j Gdh ,GQYG Id jd U S
ddG a fGC Va LGC e Ic J H
Ggh ,AdG V a dGh dG dG Jh
Y aGS H AdG Y dH S fGC j
X a S c b feEH fC ,IH XM
.jdG fQL e S dG dG YdG
?ja GMGC g c
UGe VH IJ a a Gj e MGC Y
a VdG SCG H a YT dG GdG
SG jJh dG Y cJ YdG ch ,jH
Y YdG a J M ,j c GdG Ia
.ddG jGH
?IJ HJ CH J GPeh
g ,HSGC KK H S ddG
?YdG a S ja GC J
J c dG HU
E G e aJ gh
?MdG a e
LGh J fdG dG
eGC S jQaH
FcQ e jdG J dG fdG dG Jh
jQaH OGOh eGC IS LGh b dG SdG
dGE jdG J a ''`cdG'' Qe GC M ,H
YdG d cQdG Ua e VH ,J
V a j GC b ,jgL Y bdGh
eGC eOdG LGdG N SS
C G OGJ
.OdG S
C G OGORH Th TGdG OJGE
c SH jh dCj GS
SQd S eGC hGC LGe fc GPGEh
,IS jOde e dG jT H jjdG
Y cCdH IQhdG OJGE e dG gGHh
GS SGh
C G Le dCJ aY fEa ,JfeGE
,dh
C G MdG N bh dG H a d
e a dG bJh jdG JcH fGEh
''jhQ'' aGd S YdG c M ,dG
,JQN e dG a ghLh dG HdG dH
Y c dG dG fdG OGSG dGE dH
e aGgGC fK eGC hGC bh dG ,S 19 MU
a MdG dG MU c eH ,''`cdG'' HcGC
dd fG dG ,HY OJGE eGC dh
C G LGdG
.
.d aH TM TGC
hOGQ```H Of
YafG T IGQdG
bJ Och fH
j fY
IJ HJ
.HSGC KK H S dG
dG AGLGC a hdG jdG NOh
dG dG ZQ ,IJ dGE dUh Qa
K GO dG dG AGL Y e f
eH M ,dG eYh YS
,jQJ M fMQ QdG
Ae SOdG YdG Y dhCG L
M a IJ cd jPdG HdH
Gg UGSh ,IdG a fdG eH
fG b MCG Z dGE efdG
.adG b e Me
M OJGE
a h d G b S S C G d G
ddG e dhCG ddG Ad J
dE G jdG IOY Y I H OJG eC G
b d G e j CG j M , j H
S dK jOh LGe dG
.INCG dG Vd
TH
jH jOde
eGC hGC Ae
HJ dG
ah ,IJ
efdG
e dG
bdG W
dG dG
Y gGj
,IdG g
NdG `cQGd
aY dG
GJ
Vh ja
jgdG
J Yd
ad
..SdG
IG````dG fdG
e Y L
Se H ,N :edG SGM @
.HZ ,(JH T)
hGT ,(bJ) IeH :aGdG @
qe ,fhGC ,(b jOde)
OJGE) H ,(Tc Y L)
,(N OJGE) HQO ,W ,(IH
.(bJ) bRGe ,YTH
gGC) jGc :GdG Sh Y @
q b ,IhY ,(dG
qN ,YH ,
,dg ,cR H ,(IH OJGE)
jQ ,QZR
OJGE) eO ,jZ :LdG @
dW ,(fGhe eGC) SbH ,(IH
.(eOdG jOde)
. .
QfG a ,KdG dG ie
N e cGC bSG J
''U'' j dG eOdG dG
.c Y a
J TGC e
Y 20 Xqhh
WT W e QdG bGCh
ch e J IGQdG
cQe g MdG ASG
ALh ,jdG dGE IhYh YTH
:ddG dG Y hCG dG J
,HQO ,fhGC ,YH ,N
H ,dg ,IhY ,qb ,YTH
NO M a ,jZ ,QZR ,cR
fdG IGQdG T ''U''
,hGT ,Se H :ddG ASCH
,(bRGe) QZR ,YTH ,H
,eO ,SbH ,jQ ,qN ,IhY
,W IGQdG a Qj dh .dW
.IeHh qe ,HZ ,jGc
Y LGj fT
''dG'' `d Ojh Ae
E G
Ia e NCG dG M
jZ dGE LGC Oqj GC b bdG
ee 13 j OGdG
``````Y 12h
VdG SdG e
aQ dG dGE J bh
J HJ AGLE ''IhdG''
ddG dH MQH L
q J
Sf TGC'' :b M dG Qd
dG N FdG UN e Y
Vhd dH e jb c
dG SdG jY a e dG
d ,GL qj c dN Y
e d NGB a JG dZ dG
fOb dG QGhe dG L FQ
fGC ZQ ja a Ae
E d dG
.''e d dG jQGC c
Y jOh RJ ''U''
c Yh dG
gj
HhQH ,IHOH
HdG QN gLh
dG ah Y fG Ea dGE IQTEG S c
e Y 28 dGE Jj jhdG OGJ L QdGHh OGM
dG bdG L e g h GRLEG W Y GeGC 27
AL dG d ,KG Y eN Y dG Y Ge
Y gLh IHOH jjdG edG LGH jS
Fe EG A dEG M j FdG e W M d G
b d G Q b c , d S G e g h T h d
Y e O d G j C G a G d H M G Y d G
e M h G RL E G jc Y H HhQ H T J
J jh a MCH j b aGdG Gg Ea Y
L e . H G d G H e d H a T d G K d G
Yd NCG AdG fCG QdG e a iNCG
Y eCG M jdG J c dG IhY SdG
.bqdG NBG d IRLEG W
fe LGhORG
jdG ASH
S 23 e bGC dG Y e
Sd dG ah OGJ
(2012-2011)
OY b j jQhGC
dG dGE eGC
Je bhQR
jdG e H
Le H VhdG jJ ZQ
ja VdG SdG a jdG dhGC
Y bdH dG ah IQGOGEh bhQR
dhGC e HS H WJQG GC GE Y
hO M TGC 6 H j jdG
gh ,dG ah dGE YdG Gg fG
.Y dG J IQGOEG L e
:edG
IQS Y HJ
Vqjh j
UdG a HH
b dG ah IQGOGE fc GC H
H jGC 10 Id e HJ eH
jJ QNH de
Y H VhdG fc GC H
dG ah IQGOGEh QNH HY OJG
NGB a J dG jdG a J
Y b dG ddG H d
fGE d c dG Ic a FQ
V QNH TG M ,jJ
L e dh jT e c aQ
Y J IQGOEG L e gh hdG
.IMGh aO QcdG KdG eN
AdG Y OJGE
S OJGE
```j je
jaGdG NGB jR
jQdG dG aY a eGSEG U Yh
YdG QM VdG AHQCG j jdG gGLGC dG
jdG H eGB jS
jd Oj MGa
j d T
T jRH QdG j d
hGC AHQ
C G IS d GQe c e
dG e c M ,dG M
e VhdG dhW dGE j GC
VQdG Y GT
E G LGC e IQGO
E G
Qd N jd dG
b IQGO
E G J ddHh ,dH
JGE a NOh Y dG aU
jNGB HQe IY e jL
.dG Y GT
E d
. .Q
dG eGC SG
S ShdG OJG
Oh ae hGC
e d NGB a qZ IQS
j GC dG e M ,HdG
H UdG FGdH HdG
.YSGC hSh hTH
:MQH
Yh d QYGC''
''N FdG SGCQ
```jhdG OJG
dG L a FeGE ZQ
dG e Y L d Wh
GE aH dG e jb c
GC OGQGC MQH eGC LdG GC
ISGC e aGMG H ej
e be Vjh gQfGCh ''U''
a jh ,OdG dG VdG
fGC e Qd dG J JGP bdG
hP dGE f
E d f qL GC S
.OSCGh MCG dG
```dG ah
dG fdG
dG jJ H GNCJ dW Hh QLe
,fJ dGE adG e dG LGC e ,dhdG jeH QGg Qe dGE UdG a Ggh L e Y NCJ
Y H K dGE eGC hGC U J M ,dG dG Y dW Hh QLe e H e
C G jh
Y J e gh ,WdG VQGC IQOH d dG b g IQGO
E G W e jdG Y dG LGC e
.Qqe g c fH eGC IS dG b fj a
Ggh L
...dG OHGE jj QG GC ZQ
e
''GqdG''
fJ dGE
.IM
jOdG e AaQ dG eH
H e eH jOdd HdG YdG dH dGh ,eGC hGC jOddG e FGf e Ggh L Y dG
e Y IY e IWh bY j dG gh ,Qe M HQeh HdG a e GOLe c jdG FaQ
VjQ hQh YdG H M FY AGLGC Y bhh ,dGh Y H ,ec ,IOSH QGZ Y IhGdG
.LQN hGC N
C G dG Y IhdG e IhGdG j eY FGO IVM fc c ,dY
S`````H O``````G
'' :QOdG Y H
GQhGC Y H GC
OQ fGh jJ
''W FdG
QOdG Y H LdG Uh
dG O dG A dG e g Y
fje eCG dG VN
jRQCG dEG J'' : F b G gh
dhCG FQ e e KJh
H YbEG b W dG
ed IQGOEG CG EG , j J GQhCG
,d e e Wh aQ
e YG j CG JCGh
e dG jQCG fC dG
NBG Mh .''SH F Y
b dhCG IQGOEG E a Q NCG
V ,YdG OYG W YOhCG
SdG S dG dG
.QRCG dH dG
.dL
HU
E Vj OGe
e OGe SdG Y J
Y MCG b e Le HV
dG e Y ,G gh f j e
Y VG bh dG H
,GdG VQCG IQOe dEG gKEG
dEG A dG A fG H fh
QOdG Y edG dG
b e H dG J jCG ,fM
JRZ d GVh jdG AWCG
GHh .dG dG ie Y
Y dG jdG e S
W e CG H , jQ dG
MGQ j eZ dG j dG
cCGh .FeH fQe a VEG
I H IGQ dG O JG OG J
OG e h N H a Y
ec FbO 10 Id dPh ,He
,Vj N QdG j d PEG
Z dEG YdG L QOZ CG H
.HdG J
cG QOdG Y H
cdH
YdG j H QdG j d
AdG a ddG Y QOdG Y H
24 e Y d dG O dG
LdG cG M ,56 jGa
QOZh fCj M
SGCQ e GE
M LdG HUEG eM
fKh hCG VN e QGdG
VQCG Y ''IdG'' `d LGe
QWEG a ,gQL eCGh
eCG d dG jOdG jQdG
M ch .''edG''h ''GQd''
dG M N VJ b
ie Y HUEG dEG QdG
e Ff e j dh ,MdG
MGQ j dG bdG L
L dEG Oj CG Y ,aVEG
,dG M e jGH dG
Y H SCGQ e e eOb
jf Y b jCG fH
.SCG
dG bGC j H
hGC WMG
GZ e Z LGe
,OJG IQGOGE eH dG jOdG LGdG QWGE a
Y GZ NGB jOh Ad ''IdG'' VJ GC GL dG e
dGE dG e dZ eGC ,d 56 jGa 24 e
dK dH Sh .HdG YdG IGg fdG IM
Y Ggj M j H Q dG TC LG e
UN gJG QfCG If e S dG ,JfeGE
LGC e ,jdG IUd IOdG Qb e dG fGC
.OdG bQh V gh LdG dG J
dH ,H ,T ,jGe
IN UGC eHh
SdG Gg dG H MJ dG GTDdG H eh
j dG dG OGdG g ,OdG bQh d Y IQOb
a dG Y c e Y SdG Gg dOT H QdG
fCT e IN UGC Y da ,HdG SdG
L QGZ Y ,ag J a ''eR'' Gc Yj GC
gh eH Gch dH ,qT ,jGe g dG SQdG
dGE IOdG hjjh hCG dG a dG d S Y
Ye H eb L e IQGOEGh ,dG HGH e
dG IQOe J H IRQH UY GSG LGC e
.INCG GdG a dG e S dG fdG
''jH d'' eb
E G
j e hQGC e
H Sj eM je a g dG ah j
dM MGdG FSh c Y aj dG ,bGdG ''jH d''
GdG a j dG ''dG J'' a M dP a
a jdG J d ''eR'' IQGOGE Sh ,Ggh jOde
j c dTGC dOT H j M hdG MGC
j d IOdG Z Yh ,HdG Gg a jh
dG dGE dNO Qa fC ebEG hX e YdG
fC ,a IFdG FGdG hdGh ebGE H GhfG
.edG H HQjh OdG aGC a hLj
IhGG LG OLh
GC Ic feGE g GC fJ dGE J b S
HJ a Ggh jOde dG jZ dG LGJ
''eR'' e Y fSG dG eCG gh ,edG
a g jdG LGe GC a jOddG e Gch
dG efH M ja c C ,ee Z fJ
.edH g jOh LGS jdG adG OMh
.IM
IOdG Z Y YdG id SM
jG iOj OT H
OdG Y
dG H fG OT H
Lh dG Y hJ edG dGE UdG H I T e
aZ dGE dhU AaQ U g H , dG e a Q a
E G
dG dG dGE dH c GhQfG M ,MGdG H e IOSd
ITe fG d ANSG M dOT H dGC dHh ,b dG
a jQJ M AGLEH ,dGdG dG a QdGh OdG dG a
.fdG fdG Y cQ M edG H dG
fH fdG Id Hj jdG
fc eY ,GS 5 e fH h
C G HJ Ggh L VN
dh
C G IqdG gh ,YH OGDa QdG IOb J h
C G dG a J
Jh ,SdG JGOGSG a joh edG je jdG QhS dG
fL
C G dG gjh FOg gh fdG MGdG Y jdG
c
C Gh ,ddG RGdG e ba Beh aGe Jh ,GL Ic OGYCH
M jOdG HdG V a j q dG f M a '' eR'' GC
GC dW je GJ S fEa ,dG bdG YGC dG efdG
.QH Mh eh dG jJ Ybh e e Iaqe fe
E G c
20 I d dG M c d H
c H j CG b , bO
dG eR aQ N
Z dEG ITe jh ,Hj
e b jCG H dG J
AdG QGWCG Hd SH
.dP H
LJ a d M J c d ,dG HdG
,OdG bQh Y J GC QhdG a dG a
.''QeCG S c iSh
dG SH OJG IQGOGE a
G eGC aG d H H j dG
dG JdG c eY ,VGdH
W e V H j M
WdG HGdG dhW Y GRLEG
Y AH QGdG Gg ALh .dG Id
V e GC cGC dG Y dG W
fH AdG Y Lj JdGh
e gh ,TG d H SGCQ H
LQGC GC H IQGOEG d H SG
dG hCG dG e G eGC
a GC H ITeh .gVJ
,GeGC YdG Y O JG IQGOGE
e JG IY jdG Le HQ
,GeGC aN b aGe IY
HG dG a VGC GC H S
GSGE LGC e SGC Ie WdG
.eGSEG Me Y QdG
OG Fb j SGhh M
YdG GW
C G H GC e Qe c
YJ LGC e IQGO
E G Y V ,Ggh L
,M Sh SGh HhR aGH OGdG
hO jOLG Ggh jOd HdG YdG
b hG ch ,HdG SG jf e ja
aGe bJ H eGSG Fb Z GhQb
YdG jg fH M ,j H jRQGC hGC
eGC gh GjL Y 12 L b jdG j
dG a c ,H eGC e d j
HQ
C G GRL
E G e IOSG ''eR''`d IG
eOdG jdG fG Me G
Ea ,f QG Mh ,QW
C
Mh SGh hb Ia aQ dG LG
.iNGC Ge b eOdG j
C Gh
MOh GH
Ggh je aj
GE JQYGE Ia MOh GH YdG aQ
,OdG IQGOGE Y MbG e Ggh je
e JOSG Y ZQ jdG e AdG qah
d S dh ,d bdG j M NdG
Oj GC b dG e QdH hqG
.dG ''JcG'' e
IGg dG
IOSH eGC
jQaH OGOh
% 60 H qJ OGdGh jdG Sd Y 25
jdG YdG e Gj
E dG Id WdG HGdG e dGE Sb IOSH eGC FQ dG eGC hGC J
d OGdG GC j e ZT e jGC jo dh Y 25 FdG Jh ,dG SdG dH jdG H VS
YdG Y (jhdG ddG) idG Gg a YdG j M dG ''JcdG'' a YJ GC e j
...''GC'' NQ UGC ddG
Y j c ,dG eN a
d dG HY e Y f
.SGe HQGC hOGQH Od
Sd e
C G OGJ
(2012-2011)
Ta ,(jJ) dGO :SGdG
(jdG OJGE) jO H ,(hOGQH Of)
,bH ,fg GC :aGdG
Qe VGH ,H ,aYH
,(dG f) hT ,(jJ)
(dG ah) IOMh Se
,(jJ) OM :SdG Y
,(bJ) d ,(jJ) QGe
VGH ,(TdG H T) Rf#dG
OhGC OJGE) e ,(Y S)
(jJ) hdG Y ,(jf
HY ,(bJ) O"R :LdG
,(jdG OJGE) aT ,(hOGQH Of)
ah) HhR ,(GC NQ) L
TM ,(jJ) OhGO ,(dG
(TdG H T)
HQe jY SY :jQdG bW
,GYe HQe OS e ,FQ
SGd HQe dG Y VH
.GE
.edG
NGB fL e .S 33 H GC H
e MdG aYH QH j
OqL dG VdG SdG ''fGH''
Y dG QOZ GC H NGB Sd
,he ,QY aYH ,TeqQ QGZ
,Ja ,QGRH ,dOY ,IhN
,IQH ,jH ,QGd ,dH
jdG dG YdG eqGC ,hH
,fg GC ,OM ,dGO a GhOL
,Qe VGH ,OhGO ,bH ,H
.QGeh hdG Y
,OM ,IOM IN
a fg GCh HhR
dG eN
Sd IOSH eGC OGJ j
UGC Y H je dG
d feGE j Th IN
IN Sh ,IdG dGE LH
d OM FdG IQU a Y
e) jdG a Y bGC j dG
GC aGdG fL dGEh (1979 dGe
Hc
C G U a j dG fg
FdG dGE j SGe S e
IQd IOM dG ad HdG
HhR S JGP jdG Leh
dG ah
YdG e QM a dG M aj SH
YdG e AGHG dG eGC hGC jQJ M SH dG ah Qe eH
N e adG Qe jh .fdG fd N jdG H ,GhR edG
jdG MdG a jQJ dG IJh aj GC Y Yd YdG QdG
Y UY OJ b ,jdG eQ T jGC W dG a J dG ,dh
C G
.H Ye Oj d UdH e HJ eH b ,Y jW
Y 25 Fd IAGb N eh
%60 H qJ OGdG
q GC Mf
Y IY IOY jdG Th
.HS SGe a fGdGC GJ
OL ee 8
H jOSdG IQGO
E G ebh
e
C G jh OL Y fK
SQdG hOGQH Of YH
Y ,HY LdGh Ta
e dH dGE dG jdG OJGE
(HdG YdG) HGdG H
,aT LdGh jO H SQdG
jf OhGC OJGE Ge Sh Y
FdG bGC c ,e e
e Y KK L Y Sb
e
C G jh dG ah QdG
GdGC M dG HhR LdH
(2004-2003) Se jGE a e
C G
dG IQd IOM adG bh
(2009-2008) Se a e
C d d
.Se aGdGh
j jdG
T Y 5
fK GSH dG fL dGEh
IOYEH IQGO
E G eb OL Y
S jdG AHGC e Y N
M ,Se e hQOZ GC d
jdG Rf#dGh TM e c OY
H T IFd Se NGB a d
hT JS aGdG Gch TdG
YGC c ,dG f GdGC M dG
SdG c dG VGH Sj
S OJG OGJ V VdG
dGE Oj Y eN ch Y
dG Y dG e
C G U
T SGh
C d dG L
HJ VN e jb ch OGORGH
MGC e IYO J d WdG QN
AGLGE b fdG jf
C G
jQGO
E G GAGL
E G GC Z QJ
.dP hO dM
OGOd jdh
C G e b c'' :HZ
''h
C G dG a d Y M a
jZdG Of
edG Fb j OHh H
21
.QdG AHQ
C G eGC M ,OJG OGH dG e NGB jZdG Of Y Hh jdG dhGC Y OH c
.VdG SdG J e Y 11 H e 23 dGE YdG OY Jj dHh
T .T
HGdG H e
jhdG OGOh
SQ j Hh M
Qf
C d Qj jUhGC
VhGC M ,jQaH OGOH dG GC H dhDdG Gch Qf
C d JGQGYG jUhGC jcR OGOd HdG SQdG Lh
jhdG N j d fGC jUhGC VGCh .d FdG hdG jQaH a Lh d OGOdG a AdG eCj c fGC
.Ic jfGC gG e Lh dCdG GHGC d a dG jdG f
C
T .T
IQSh Y T
Hd ,HY ,dG Y ,S
dG jL jObh
e e HY ,Hd Y dG f SH e
C G jh ,OL Y N U dGE IQSh Y T V
YdG HG dG Y Gch ,(dGE jh) UH S e S a ,YSH e OGe jOb ,HY
,jeh dg Y j dG YdG e GdG dG YdG TH bh .FdG d HdG
IQGO
E G GC Y c .dG dG eGC "GhdG a dG eGC eGC jOh Ad VN b dG Jh
.VdG SdG OGJ e H MG J jdG dGE aVGE OdG YdG ASGC Y eOdG YdG a S
.YSGC Id jH a j GC QJ a ,dG S T jGH jdG NS dG HdG UH eGC
.GE
fK g g GC dW eOdG
.dG VJ jOh LGe
hO J dG
gGHh Y S
He N
dG jOdG LGdG fG
Ae AHQCG eGC UY VN
QGdG T eGC ,dG eGC hGC
,NCG Gg e Y AdG
GLH S QdG AHGC GfH
jdG g Jh .(2 -4) H
NdG hd Gf GL e
,LGdG a L dG IQdG
HdG e jdG dGE aVEH
c .e SC S dG
e dG bd Ua IGQdG fc
FdG H Y bdG LGC
LGdG a cQGJ b ,dG
jN
C G a SQ e
eH ,jN
C G OJ efG Y dG eGC hGC SQ M e IjdG jOde ee SQM eGC
YGC b e SQdG ch .VdG dG L dG AdG N IQb e FdG e JG dGE UJ
.Ma aQ fdG SQdG dH d ,OOJ hH aGe
edG jL OGLh a , e
OGe H e QdG Y a LdGh dG Y e UdG dhGC Ge Sh e c OJG IQGOGE eSG c
eH IdG g JCJh .FdG T eGB e j c dG MdG Y OGL aGdG dGE aV
E H ,jGQ
QdG a eb dG dG AGO
C G N e ,YdG ADg Y aj dG fe
E H jGM QdG bG
.gVN dG
I#e f
c Y qNh YJH j SS
T .T
AHQ
C G eGC
jN
C G OJG
Vhe H ,dG eCG hCG U jZdG Od fZO HGQ UdG OJ HdG YdG eCG
YdG Och .fZO bEG a dG FQ a H dG a NJ dG Qhe HGQ dG FQ e
d ,jJ Kh H S fCG d cCG TH jdG Y OJd HdG FdG C dG OJH j
.dG NBG a jZdG a fZO
dG N OJG
''OGOdG U a bqh'' :H
e Y bJ
GhOqL 10h SGh
C G
Y fK L fL dGEh
bJ J jNGB N IOSGh
SGh
C G U e KG Y
O"Rh d e H e
C G jh
OGdG a U
C G Gj M
Y cGC IOM IQd j a
e Gfch GL V ghDGOGC c
UN jdG W e jT OfG
GhQOj GC GhOc jdG dG
.dG
H ,T ,hGM
GcQj d ah OGg
e jd dG bdG qa
Lh hGM SH Yd MGQ
Y BH SMGE H a jdG
jQdG dG a dG ie
a ,VdG KG j L dG
T dN YdG Z M
dh OGg H jdG J SQdGh
.jdG e j
IGQeh eGC SG
dG IS g
C G
H a e dG AHGC J ah
N dCdG jW Y dG
e QN e e aH
(39O) a jQ j GC b ,dG
dG dOe e TdG fL e
dG gh AGL cd J H
dG hCG dG Y fG dG
c ,dG Y Se Ge c
e VjdG Z NdH qJ
Z QKGC e gh TdG Y fL
UN I#d QGOEGh dG bdG
HUGE a S fc NdG J qGC
f J M MdG ie Y H
dGE fdG jdG GYGC W e
dGE dO eR VJ c dG
bGdG dh dG ie Y HUGE
dG eqGC ,c dGE Vqd qJ dG
,TH ,SS a QT dG fdG
,he ,TeeR H ,SGe
N ,H ,Qe ,VGh ,eO
GC Och HS e c a fjRh
H Se IY a bj
qJ Yh VjdG Z NdG
,#H e qdG dG bW
M ,IGQdG a dG Sh GhU
H hGC 20 e MG
IGQdG AHQCG IS jjYH
I#e f H fdG jOdG
qe dG TdG f eh
e jd dGh QGOEG bdG
UN YdG c Y Ia NGC
SQdG QGZ Y ,OdG edG
e bO 70 d dG SS Sh
feGE od ac fc IGQdG
YGE df IRe ah fH
YJH e qb c ,dG bdG
e hCG dG a W GOhOe
GRe c dG
q N U eR
fGC gHh GdG Sh a JOc
.a adG J c Y
GcQT Y 21
IGQdG a
a U a QdG qah
dG Y OYG hCG dG
(SGhCG) je SQdG a dG
Vqj GC b bO 20 d dG
qg ,TH ,H ,SS SQdH
,(SGe) H ,YJH ,(he)
,dG Y Hh jeGC ,eO ,N ,dO
"GdG T
"GdG dGE Oj Yh T
Y jJ a J IQGO
E G
e QdG IOb J jH jdG hdG Sd JGOGSG fS SQdG aQ UGj dG bdG a
25 RhH j fGdG GC H jdG j jdG Y 27 e e Y jJ a J IQGO
E G Ea S
X a JeN Y ASG S jdG YdG jg jJ a HU Lh IQGO
E G d ,ja d IRLGE
. .
.dG UY H idG a QdG
HGdG H e
OGdG SGCQ T
IGdG dG
HY AGM
''AG```````dG''
```````NJ d GPGE'' :````````dY
I``d J
''``````SC`````a ````````````dG Y fdG
```````````dGdG
dG f
Oh Ad dK a Oj dG
20 H VdG AHQ
C G IS d jOh LGe dK a dG f OJ
MdG dG e AeR bh bh ,(1-1) I#e f dG eGC dH hGC
J H GhcGC idG a He Gebh jhG#dG eGC d dG JGJ d
HGQ cGe OdG QdG AHGC VSh Gg ,N
B Ad e dG ie
.IOSH eGC eGC hGC 20 H K
E G Gg IS jOh LGe
.S
TdG H T
dG bdG j dG
SGgGC S ah
jdG f
Uhh dh
C G jQdG e iLGCh SGgGC S ah OGJ a c fGC ZQ
NGB a jGCQ Z SNH e LdG GC GE ,jGhQ FdG e Ff JG dGE
a e jdG IQGOGE e Ff JG dGE UJ eH jdG f QNGh d
dG GdGC Y aGd GH ZR QdG YGC bh .fMQ VQ FQ
.jQdG TH M OdG SdG
YG M JOS Y YdG Y ,jd fG H jJ ah
a J jfGC IY e JG IY JRH fc fGCh UN FU QNfGC
b HG cGC FeR W e gS dG adG Yh ,b
C G e
.IHdG Y S H gj fGC
''Gj e MGC Y J Qe
C G'' :ZR
c GCh jdG NGO L H J Qe
C G GC ZR LGQdG QdG cGC
:bh ,jQdG Jh dG e HhJ H dG d GS YdG
QYG Y dG dG QGd eOdG j
C G a jQdG J hS''
d e HJ AGLGE ZR eCjh .''GNCe JjQJ TH jdG GC
.L H jdG
.`g
fLJ L
OGdG j dG
21
OGdG V Y Ea ,fLJ L FQ Ff QY dG a M
fCH VGCh ,fdG ddG eR
C d J U hX a L OdG Sd
M a ZQ GhHGC jdG YdG e jdG e jd M IY H
GC Y ,H j d e FdG JG GR ddG SQdG ASH ,Gd
C G
:SGdG a S ''SdG'' Ea ,dG jdG S Z b j
f fe ,L jOH ,aJ fGZ :adG a ,OY Yb ,he Re
a ,jdG T db ,jY eS ,eQ GQO ,dG Y QS ,jdG
,e fGY ,Ja Te M ,gdG e j ,OY HY :SdG
M ,eQ OM ,H MSH :dG a ,Y dHQOH ,hhDdG Y N
,e hT ,g IjS ,SfdG fGd ,SdG g d ,YS Te
.S YH
.
fLJ aO
Qhe Od Vj fa
Qhe OM dGE dG jOde SGhGC e dG L fa YdG VJ
jdH adG e IGPH fLJ jH dPh ,dG dGE AHQ
C G d
f bh ,jQf LGQO e Y gh dG Y fRGJ a M ,hOdG
SGCdG ie Y HUGE GC J jGC dG dGE YdG L Y YdG
fa IQjR dGE gdG jb OdG FQ SGC bh ,ej 21 Id MGQ YJ
dG dG AYGC H j GC b ,dG e LGNGE GAGLEH dG K
. YdGh dG bdGh
.
QdG OJG
d QX hGC a j d QdG
fG e d jOh IGQe hGC VdG dG eGC QdG OJG VN
N
C G Gg H L eQ OGOH L bh ,jdG Sd JGJ
Ie c a j QdG ja ch ,(2-2) Hj
E G OdG f Y fGh
Qcch MGC ZGH e c SGH Oj e YS d dG a J
AGO
C G a dG e Yf Y id hd jf jdG Qe S a ,Y
.dG dG ac f jOY dP Ge
MGC
jGB ,jf
Gd TW Y
.c IGQdG
Qe a fdG dG a
e jdG MGQGE AGdG
UdG AYGE H UdG
KK dP e e gd
jGB ,IM jf g Y
jdG HGQ TWh S Y
ah fH GOGSG Y GfHGC
Gg e e gGC jh ,Ic
MOdG AN
C G g dG
dG fMQ jdG SQd
dG dH GL KCe fGC hj
AedG H aQ d j dG
e SdG IdG g N
Sd jdG GJ
.jdG
a GgGC S
bSGh JQe
```````````He
GgGC S AGdG `cT J
`T a c S JQe a
GC dGh ,fMQ SQdG
e a Ic dhDe
dP Oj bh dG Gg
C G
OdG f cdG d
jQdG a dj dG dG
e Gg f ,FeR H aQ
Gg feGE f fGC H
Y gH dGh dG SQdG
hGC a VdG SdG W
.Hc
C G U e d QX
K'' :H
''fMQ a Ic
Y QdG d cGC ,L e
LJh AGdG IGQe jf
T a edG K d"
fMQ jdG T SQdG
J fGC U'' :Fb d Uh
dP d JQe a GgGC S
GH K e T j d
H d CJGC dG dG
j Gc GeGC GC e ,''c
dH de d
.bGH
`H jh Oj jT
''AGdG''
AGd FdG FdG M
JdG H LJ dGh HY
Mf GRdG Y jL dG
SG IGd WdG HGdG
jT jd HdG YdG
SdG QOZ dG d e
hdG H dGh VdG
,dG h
C G dG dH e
S T hO e jT IOY
OhOe Y Hj
E G gKGC d
e dG Gg H j d jdG
d UdG GC M Ad feGE
SdG ja a d J
gJ LGC e VdG
.Y gdGh
Tj QNH
H JOY
OJ HdG LdG TO
dGE JOY AGd ddGh HY
ee a HUGE bH jdG
J d GEh M d" LJ
IGQd FdG dG a T
e Yd Ge j dP GC GE
jd IdHh jdG MdG
da Y gGj dG
dG Y Ad edG
d jdG Rj dG edG
.JQe a aH e ,
B G
MGC
IS T
dG bdG jj GAe
E G LGB jJ
GZ Sh FKh q`S Hc
YT
E G c jh S `L
Y KK jJ j IQaH
dhqGC QdGHh
L eQ OGOh
(2-2) QdG e jOh Oj ''OQdG''
NO M (1-2) OQdG H fG b hCG dG ch
,fS :ddG dH IGQdG L eQ OGOh
,SGe ,VM ,cf ,fj ,jGE ,adH ,HQO
:e c NO fdG dG ah ,jOhGC ,LdH ,SH
jO ,TH ,HK ,bH ,WH ,T ,S
.fdG SQdG Yh
j SGeh LdH
dCj HQOh
,L ed ag J jOdG HdG aY
e dG dG Y LdH jW Y c hCG
SGe eQ jW Y fdG dGh e Y L
(0-2) dG fc M ha Y T e dG
hd jf QdG TGC b e dG a IOdG b
.(2-2) HdG AfGh
Sd ''OQdG'' OGJ
2012`/2011
dG fdG
jdG jS
0 IQhdG .T - 2 M .GE
RJ Mh UdG U IQhdG
eGS
E G Fb jh bj eGH
d S eH jdG AHGC e j dG ,Qhb eGH Ggh L aGe e gbJ H FdG OGdG jdG jS IQGOGE V
eGCh .Ggh L GNGCh e da fe LJ K jH jOde f QOj GC b ,SGe Id dJdG Gd
C G J GC
FQ W e d dG VdH dHh bG eH ,2013 jZ dGE jdH HS dG dG Y QdG AHQ
C G SQ eGH
.dJdG dG a edG NGB dH d ,dG a H ''dG''
jdG V Ge
GdG e
Gc Ua GU jdG YdG H e
V dG fGe dG b f ,jd
H dhCG MdG N GgCG e jdG
ja j Oc M ,ddG fh dG
c ,GdG e jdG a dG a ee
QLh dG bdG SG f AGOGC GC
b dG dG Hd U dG ,M
.eR e FGQ a H H
Qd iLGC Tg
M HGCh
dG Id adG HGdG e GC H
,YdG GSG UGH jfCd NJ
dGE dG jdG S Z LCJ H
e IQhdG FQ Ea ,QdG hGC 25 jZ
AGLE YdG d UdG NBG g
b e ,d bdG eGC Y QdG
dG jdG Qf Tg b T g
YG bh ,M jd jGC HQGC e M
bd fdG dG a dG bdG Y
XGC M ,fdGh dG JfeGE Y
M AH HGCh H SCH eg gDe
.HQe H j j b dG eCG
Theh H afG
YdG H
a Ie hC IQhdG T M bh
,dG fdG dG dGE OdG jQJ
JKGE TbH AaQ OGQGC dG RfEG gh
,M OJG eGC d dG LGdG a
LGe Y GQOb S ja GC jcDe
,dG ,''HdG'' IQU a IdG jfCG
.S
H jh e e j WGhQR
f IY Y j
j d M ,hDdG Y J J d WGhQRh e H bdG Ea dGE fTGC eh
e Wh jOa GQGb PJc dG fdH bY d dG dG e jdG Y
SCdG VaGC dG IdG eGC ,eGSG a UN ee a NdG Y jdG
L dG e
C G gh ,OdG J a NJh QGO
E G fdG a f bEH a
.dH J QdGh FdG H bdG
de Ge 3 OU M H
21
````jOG `````fe
E G ```````jd'' :````WGhQR
''````dG ``````Y `````cGC GC ````` h
''IQhd HQe SQ Hh e e JGC ''
HH SG GC GE IQGO
E G Y c e ,IhQd dG VQdG e QOZ GC Hh
J dG UdG GL jh dG jH jGQO jd dG H e dG
Ge K OdG e Mh 2008 S e HQj c e g fGC UN ,dG GdGC
,IQhS a H b GC Qd j d RfG gh ,dG fdG dG dGE H d ,de
.S
.jQhV fc H IOY Ea Yh
jdG g GE dG j d ,ASGC d d
Y Mjh H j YdG Ach e
,c GC YGC dh QGb GC JGC d fGC Z ,Y
j GC b QdG hS YdG L C
.SQ H MG
VQdG Y J GCW Lh X
IOYh e gP j ,dG
?dG e ,H
e f d fC ,fG IQhS a e e
WhT j GC OGQGC Qe a ,QeCG e jdG Y
Y dG eCG gh ,jGC WhT d FQ fGCh
dG HH JG iS Y c eh ,dH
fGC ZQ ,IQhd GjL HQe UGC dG H e
Ge K OdG e M GC H jdG a jb
.FU fQGb Ea Yh ,2011 jZ dGE 2008 e de
hJ dG Gg
C G g e
?jG SG
Idh d T Gg a dG QHh d GT
.FGdG dG
?UdG g fGCh e e
iM ,jQZ ,HH
LGG Y GHZ ShYh
a HH ''dG'' Gg Qj d
HUGE e Jfe H ,jOdG &S IGQe
dG iMGE a d VJ N
b H QdG L e ,WQdG jQdG
c .HUEG bJ e aN MGQGE j
dH M eH jQZ SQdG Qj d
b H QdG e NH dPh fdG
J d a ,jQGOGE SC IQGOEG Gch
.ShY -iM FdG Z SCG
IGQG d dG dG
dG jd dG bdG V
jQdG efH IQGOEG e dHh
jdG LGS M ,SCG Gd jOdG
HGdG YdG e AGHG KG Z H
jdG &H dG dH ,GhR dGh
S a .dG jdG jd fdG
Ia fG e HGdG OdG AdG
dG IS jOde eGC GdG
dGh ITdG YdG e AGHG ,OdG
.IH jaGC 13 H d
S .
GE Me S fG S GC
L a g ,QG hGC 25 jZ
?OL Y
BG fh Me GJ jdG S LGC
M ,dG H Yf iNGC ASGC Y dG OH
ddHh ,adGh dG gh e jJ Y
f d b aGeh g b dGE LH a
.eGSG
h
C G dG
dG J
d UdG dG bdG eh
Rh M ,cQdG LGC e YdG
a V dhCG J Y OGdG
e J d d OdG edG e
45 AY J M .e Ge c
aCG a fc dG dhCG bO
VGh SQdG ee GhOg jdG ,d
H (30O) a gRHGC Se e cGC a
d iJ dG e NGO e ab
dhe Jh ,HYCH jdG SQM
.OUdH VGh d c (38O) a iNGC
fdG MG TfG
IdG j Jh
''Gd'' `d j Z
IQYGE T Y
eGC hGC a H jdG FQ S
IFd Y Z dG aGdG dG
Se Id IQYGE T Y ,fe OGOh
jdG e H Je YdG GC H MGh
J Z IQYGE ALh .2014 jZ dGE
e IQhV Y j X eH d
ZdG Y ,JfeGE jJh dG Ua
IQhV Y b H QdG QGUGE e
.dGE LH jdG C JeH MG
K `#S J ''dG''
jOh LN
IGQe H d jOh LN K a
eGC hGC jdG jS J ,''eR''
dG IGQdG a &S g Y dG
,&H dG dH jdG L
Y fJ LdG bJ e j H
Hh .fdG dG N AGL cQ jW
dPh IGQd FdG dG Y dG
JGe Ua fc a ,OdG Hd
TGQ dG jdGh b H ''dG'' Qd
HH jOde
jQdG j QGH
OGJ dGE VdG AHQ
C G IS efG QGH SQdG SQ eH
OJ HdG SQdG T ,Se GY FeEH jH jOde
jQdG dG a QT M ,jdG ja e jQdG S
.IJ HJ a dG eGC hGC Ae L dG dh
C G
IJ HJ j Y
hGC fY SQdG GLGC dG T
C H dG dG c
dM GC HdG dG a d VJ dG HU
E G H ,eGC
fGC j e ,b
C G Y SG Ie MGdG dGE cdG YJ
,h
C G eGC Ae ja a T dG IJ HJ S
jQdH Ad KJ Y KG S HG S Yh
IG````dG ````fdG
?g AGL
C G d H ch
jh j c Qj jdG ,j AT
d M ,jdG Sd GJ jOdG JLGe
dOJ AdG QGdG T eGC hCG jOh jAd
OJG eGC a efG fdGh ,T c a ag a
jOdG jQdG Ff d ,U He aH M
YdG feGE Y bdG j e QH J
.dGE GUh dG dG dG ie aeh
e OJG
h
C G jQH fe QM GAGb
fdG H Ye c jQdG dG a YGC dG efdG GC UN ,FY hGC a Y j GC e OJG Qe jj
gh JdhDe J MGh c Y M Y d Uj GC jj dG IdG gh ,UGdG dG Y SSGC eh fdGh dG
eH dGE aVGE ,eOdG ddG a QM QdG Y S dG ,SSCG dG a H RdG hjj jdG YdG cQj e
.d aH IdG AHGC H fG dGh ,SH OJH QGRH AaQ L dG LGdG QGZ Y jOdG jQdG e jdG
OGdG J h
C G G
dhdG QN
C G
`````dGE O```j `jQ
H LQ
C G dG
G````YGC `KK OSG
dG Id HhQh
C G OJG a
a SQGB SQGC Qe H kJ
ajEH keJ GdG H eJ
e UGJ GC H dPh ,IMGh IGQd
IGQe N ''SGdG'' `H Y
OdG L dG VdG AKdG
QhdG gP a (0-1) jOhH fdG
ch. HhQhGC HGC HGd dG
ajEH a bY HhQh
C G OJG
H dG Of IMGh IGQd
SdG fTH e ja IGQe
j d fdG QdG d ,VdG
UGJ PGE H IQOdG HdH eJ
MGC SGH dG bdGh Y e
a fL dGE kdL c dG jYe
j gh ''GQe
E G e'' LQe
k e kJg
OaG e a eJh .
g j e a VdG dGE fdG
HhQh
C G OJG GC GkcDe ,dCdG
e UGdH P
E G e
C G AiOH a e
d ,''SGdG''`H MG Ye
.e
C G Gg f N
C G
jQ ehQ GN dCG fU Oj
e GYGC KK H LQCG dG dGE
KGE jdG e dG aQ Yh ,dG
.fhOGQe jO SCG QdG e N
HS hQfdGC jdG QdG YSGh
YdG e ja e cQd YdG
JQe a jRGdG LGd dG
28h 14 ej ja c VQGC Y jOh
SjGB jH jH dG S
GN jGC dG dGE Oj c .Hh
fdG JGQb IOS j dG ,ha
FdG QJh .MdG a HUGE d jT f b MGd N GC H
ah ,VdG a HS HQO dG jdG ,JH O fjOSG Y
.ja c e Y S bGH ddG d eM SQS
dj
E G jOdG J SCc H f
C G
J SCc e fGC M
cGC M H dj
E G
jQe a dG e OY
bGC dG MGdG dG
e Hh H
fGE Rah .SaLh
hGC a SaL Y e
LdG HH GT
C G
He f d ,6-7
,RdG IdG Od f
,1-2 e Y Ra dG
fGE Ra ddG dG ah
f H e Y
ddG H f
C G d
fdG Id jS J dG
.dGdG Y
WdG dcdH JG hGC 021 73 14 17 cdG .021 73 14 37 :JdG Y QTEG H GJG JfYE
.56150 :dG 021 73 95 59 :cdG .021 73 24 03 :JdG .FGdG - QS> QT ,1 :QTEGh d
.jRd WdG SDdG :jRdG SIO dG SIE - dG SIA - SdG :dG
(UdG FGdG) S QH 66 bQ . .U :ddG GdG Y H GJG :JSGe d
.HUGC dGE OJ IjdG dGE J dG WdGh FKdG c :Me
eH ,aVGE Sb Hd jfj fe VJ
aGe GC Za dGC SG HQe c
HSGC N YdG Y S ja ff Fbh
jf a bS a HU
E ja VJh. HU
E G H
,ddG a jd dh
C G IGQdG N VdG S
C G
c dG ,fjOa jQ adG b HUGE kjGC T Ad a
hj d ,HSGC d YdG Y j GC VdG e
eGC ddG MdG IGQe N ja dGE OS fGC
ja Z X ah .ddG dG 28 a SQGB
fL a jdG aGdG dGE Za S fjOah
.JJ eGC adG b ce T LGC e fjGE fLh
:fTH FQ Ff
jRGdG dG OY
dGE jdfhQ
e J
Id OH
e dh
C G
af
VdG
eH
YSG
fe QdG
je
LGd
a fZ
jOh IGQe
edG a J
dG dG e
JCjh .d a
H jdfhQ AYSG
dOGC dG jdG Y IOhe jGC
fTHh eL S jQH Le H
Y a YGC M ,kHS eh
GdGC Y adG dGE IOdH ZQ
IQTGE gQ fGC dGE Gke ,''hS''
Le ZQ GC hjh .je
je id gGU d c ea
jd U Vh a f Lh dG
Hc Ff HQ e jRGdG hN H
JQN K GZGQdG j Y jeGC
.fdGC eGC kjOh
fSEG ddG J
Se a dG Ae fd
bJ Sh 2012-2011 jdG
dhCG MdG LCH jb
jfGC Y QGUGE H
Y fdGh dhCG LQdG
dGE UJ Y H GVEG
M M dG e JG
gL ja GC hj ,GVEG dCe Y k GHh .M bh a SdG QGdG Sh YdG dG
'' d GC kUN k GOe ''dG FdG'' jd TdG jQe jQ-fTH ce a Nd
2000-1999 Se hQc JQjO) IjdG dCG e Ge K iS NGB ja C gj d ''d
k GL MW jdG jdG H SdG Gg dG hJh .(2004 -2003h 2002-2001 Se dah
jdG SdG S Y Y c dG HdG SCc He jGE a VdG AHQCG M eh
M Vh Y e bh GC e cGC ke jQe jQ Sh .dG VQGC QNh NGO Qe e
jQe e d. dGdG Y ddG Id VdG SdG H qJ dG d fdJdG jZ QM
dGC dH RY dG ddG H KGC fTH C WEG Y S J d dLQh
dG YdG AGOCG Mf e c GE jQdG a dG aGC MGC fCH SjHa Sh fS
Ze LGH QGe fTH jh .e fd H J dG YdG Mf e hGC dGh
S GAdG H ah .hH JGC LGe a e Y GZ Se jQe jQ j a ,OdG
e jQah ,bS e fdh ,keY 35 e dhCG Id dG dGE FdG WfZ e fSGE
e QffS SGQh ,cQje jQ e fda jGQh ,da e fSShGCh ,N JQS
.jQe JGCh OGSS jQ AH MdG J GC Y ,TGE QL e FdG Hh ,aN
````d HhQj
O```j ````jdfhQ
``jRGdG `d
````gCJ ``dG
Sh `fd
````````````bJ
G`````````V
E H
j HhQhCG OJG
```a `H k``J
36 idG
idG
04: 34
21 :03
19: 36
16: 36
```dG
12: 52
IdG bGe
,GMh S e dG e Aj e Oj GC d Rj
!dG e T Oj GC Rj dh
- 36 idG : ```````````````````b
- 31 idG : G````````````````````````````gh
:a d
gJ a ..dG c Y J dG g
dG R`c e
VQ eeGC HGC Y
o JGC :b Y dG
dG U dG nSQ
:a Sh Y
oNGB eCH freo
Y'' :a ,Y
e qfEa qdH
.''d
FdG GhQ
:GdG
,dG a dG Y j dG jd NQ b dJ dG GE
VdGh .''nNnGCom jsGCn reu Ilspan mnnS nYn hrGCn kjpen ncn enhn'' :dJ a
,FH NCJ hGC JOjR j hGC ,dG e j dG g d dG
AfG H jCG J Ab ejh ,a dG RL HdG H c a
.eQ
!eQ a dG dGE dG H e dG
:GdG
:GdG
IdH d qJ e e J K dG hGC J GC SG GE
AYdGh Qd J K ,dG e GAL J K GBdG e IAGdGh
IdG MGC'' :Sh Y dG U dG d ,aGC a QSGh
c ,OhGO U dG dGE dG MGCh ,dG Y OhGO IU dG dGE
e .''ej jh ej jh ,SS jh K jh dG f j
.Y
Lfh ,QdG H dGh dG AMGE a Y M a J d Ea
Ja Y VJh M dG J dG GH fC eJ eU j GC
.dG e a dGh dG H ef j GC aCGh ,dH MGdG e
?J g
c dG dG
q GC
Se Mj
g dG Y
Y f H Tj
?dG
eQ a S
C G dCG
SV QX H S
C G a jT dGC e fYGC :GDdG
a dG a ..QX cG d N SGC h ,dG
?eQ Qf a FqdG jhO
C G hJ
GBdG c e
YCG IQS
IodG H nnrSGC hGC OnrSGC :inM
r GC
p SGH
n dGE Mpfo e :hDoS
Y jL
dG
J
E Gh pdG pIb e GknHCG :J a
n oaufo :iod oqfo
a iodG pjd
merGC c
o Nojn :idG QqdG rjn
gsM
n sL
n pSoj hGC
prodH Rna :arCG
u Jn :cqnJ
UdGh dG e n
p j
(HdG nHQ
C G
B G) Qncd :Ggn
q GE
eQ a dG aGB
e c H HG dG a
B G e aBG
gh ..UN eQ a dG
````M
d Y j e a ..dG Ic
e fGC Yj dGC hGC e
..dG Joh bdG qJ d
GC Gc SGC
Hc f
E G j
a c GE K dG bh cCdHh
e Ie dGC ..S
hDe f
E G
C ,Z hGC eQ
dG FGdG e jdG d eS
E G GOdG ch dGh IdG
d M j GC
.edG j Y Y
k
d
G
d
G
A
d
G
h
M
h
d
G
e
G
f
C
G
N
,
f
E
d
b e j
NCJ hGC FGdG J dG a
JbhGC a dG IU GC jdG dG cGC bh ..edG dG Y QhH
H N hH Jh ,bh Y
Z JefG Jh jdG Y J Y J eQ T N
Qj j dG jdG AY
E G
Y Jh dG eR
C Gh WdH HU
E G e Jh H ,HZdG
,T JU e j h ,SdG
.jedG IQhdGh fedG
YL a dG j SdG Hh
AYGC L J M ,fH dG IU IFa cGC IQdG H
C a
UN fedG RGaGE OGOa ,bdG dP a Wf b a dG
j h dG dGE gj K
e jh dG L jh ,dG eg SH hdG djQO
C G
Y qa dHh ,dG IU b GE
..AY
C G c dGE j M dG a jh ,fWdG GQh
C G
dG U dG SQ a b e f
a RGaGE GCj djQO
C G eg GC a J g d
E G dGh
e
C QH dG'' :Sh Y
.dG IU bJ gh kMU edG
Y qah ..''gQH a
e Ic H dG dG dG AGg CH FN
C G cDjh
cd SdG f
jedG Yh
C G VfG e qjh ,dG qj c
C G
dGE dG H dG
e fedG Y jh ..dG JQ dG
,dG W
IOjR a Yj e kej dG IU Y UdG N
Y jGC qah
jdGh dG Y d RdG dG f
H f
`````````````b
.IcGdG a J e dP j eh ,dG
pcnndp eQ a ufn
AGOGC ,dG
s o qdn G
R
Y
E
d
'
'
d
G
j
G
d
G
Y
'
'
f
H j b
,pQpGfGC AppHp rbn Qrufhn ,pQpSGC
S
qH
H'' :dG Sj
pQpKGBp uJG dGE pFYrGC uoHp rNohn
j dJ dG CG
n aQdG
p obo Qnuneo j `ncQpoHp
s o qdn G ...
:edG j Fdh
C
n pe pa frYpHhn ,
dG
a Y f
mrNn uco pe kfn d nrLGhn ,pjrsdGhn
:
d
G
g
IU gh
OnnLGC j
n OpHp ,pa doprJo
r nobn bh fdG
b ,HGhq
C G
...njOnrL
C G
..cdG e GhcGC ,ddG g a OLG GYV
Y gT
a
C
G
e
B
G
e
G
h
c
C
G
,
I
d
G
e
G
h
c
C
G
.
.
B
G
d
G
I
h
e
G
h
c
C
G
rQZh ,HT
C G
IdG
U a ..FdG J e GhcGC ,bdG
r qLh ,YGC
j'' :dGh
a j e dG a j c dG SQ GC e
dG Gfc ,fH
e eS c Y
.gZ
GWJh ,f a
dG UCH fH Ad kSe fd L e
a ,bU cMGC
''H a SCdG
k d Qfh ,GkQf d Gd L h ..GdGh
GqJh ,
IJ ch ,bU J
a bdG Jh dG M e dGE dGh ,dGh dH dG JYS
eGCh ,bU IJ ch ,bU
!..gZh gdG
dG Y fh bU hdH
..dGE e e dG GcQOCa
cj cQ dP e jh ,bU
.''dG e
j eQ Qf a f GPGE j SdG Hh
fGC j dH d ,dG e b b
a ..fnhO dG GZGC bh cCj Gfc b Y W qe
..Gk`````H
..dG Id a
e fe :d b d GqJ qa ..dGE fh QGdG Y
..Gk````Lh
!AdG e a ..VQCG
AYO
HG
heddafdine@Gmail.com
:```Me
jEG A`d
SYO YS :PS
C G OGYGE
NGh
C G dG d
eQ e
NO GPGE dG SQ c'' :db ,Y dG VQ FY Y
.gGC jGCh ,d MGCh ,Qe qT dG
:cf eQ e NGh
C G dH UdG Y
C G eh
,dZ AMGE dG AMEH jj GC jh :dG AMGEYGC e'' :db ,FY Y e U a e jDjh
.''dG M d b
Y dG U da :MU LhdG MGC jGE Z hO dG dd a Id gGC bj c Sh
fGC Sh Y dG U dG Y U bh .ddG e
.Jjo GC OGQGCh J b GPGE dH FY bj c
dG qa dHh ,AdG GYG OGdGh :QdG qT J OQhh ,QdG S e edG F
C Gh
j M TGa dGE Sh Y dG Up phCj d fCH
YGh ,TGa iWh'' :fGC jM ah .eQ
.''AdG
FY jM e hQo a :dG dGE QdG NCJ j dG dd a c Sh Y dG U fGC fGCh
GPGE dG SQ c'' :FY jM dh .GkQS AY
LGh ,QdG qT dG NO GPEa ,fh b eQ c
.''GkQS AdG Lh ,fGP
C G H ZGh ,AdG
dG Y ,QdG S HGC Yh .UY HGC HG GhQ
GC OGQGC jCa ,GUGJ '' :b Sh Y dG U
SQ j UGJ fEa :Gdb ,''dG dGE UGa UGj
jo
l peo d HGC fGE ,c d fGE'' :b ?dG
fGC Y j Gg gXh ..QdG GhQ .''j mSh
GBQ f
C dP a fGE j bh ,c dG UGj c
dP j dh ,dG dd a OLG Y d fGC
.jh j c dG Ea ;dG Y d ke
:FY jM e J bh :jAdG H ZG ,AdGh dG GPGC :OGdGh .''fGP
C G H ZGh''
e d c Gj GC j Gfc'' :jL HG b
.''NGh
C G dG dd
VQ Ijg HGC Y QdG U a :YG IY eQ c a j dG SQ c'' :Y dG
.''jY YG a bo dG dG c a ,jGC
g a Sh Y dG U dG j c fGEh
kjJh ,dT
C kb ,QdG d a jo dG dG
..FYOh cPh HQ ILd kJh ,dd
bh ,cPh dG YW Y f M b da
Y dbh H Yh ,Y j ZT c f Y
Vjo eh dG iS g d H a ,e Hj eh HQ
.Y
NGh
C G dG bGCh..
g g ,GH
C G Y eQ e NGh
C G dG gg
.eb b eQ Jh ,eQ IHRh ,eQ UN
?f c iJ a
dG SQ c d
Sh Y dG U
dG g j
..YGC IH NGh
C G
e dG a
c'' :FY jM
NO GPGE dG SQ
MGCh Qe qT dG
dh .''gGC jGCh d
SQ c'' :e Y
e dG a j dG
h ,''gZ Z j
GC'' :dG a d
j c dG
e NGh
C G dG
aJ M eQ
.''dG
c Sh Y dG U dG GC if jOM
C G g a
:ddG Y
C H j
M H MQh T GE GP eh :gGC jGE -1
.dG ddG g a dG Gg Jj
M ,j h j c eQ c GPGE fEa :dG AMGE -2
.L
C G dG NO e GPGE
o hGC c dG MGC NGh
S a c AdG GYG H OGdGh :QdG T -3
.Zh QdG
dG jJh IOd dG hd gh :YG -4
.QYGh d
Y dG U dG SQ j GPd :qM
C G jGC ioJ
?Gg c Sh
d ,dG dG J ,gGdG dG J j fGE
.T dGC e N d ,GBdG hf d ,QdG
d oZ HMGh fjGE eb e dG :QdG d fGE f
ed ah GE dG QdG d fGE ..fP e J e
.eY (83) e cGC dG Y fCc d c
d Ja GE JMGh ..dG g Ja GE d GBh
!QdG
IOY Ja e ,IdG Ja b e j c h
,hdG a JJ e GE ,eY fKh K e cGC
.OhdG gh
GC !?d H a ,b c dG GE dGh :NGC a
..a d H LGC e f GC QdG d J
eb J dYGC SdG aj eY dG Y j GZ
M ,JUh H J dG Y j GZ ..eUh
.dG gGC qj
d d aj en ep J GC Cf qfGE dG
.ec
C G cGC fGCh QdG
:dG M
23
24
`WdG `dG
de a e j RHOH
RH eY dPh SdG Gg jdG jGH TS Ge Sh RHOH VjQ cqGC
de LGd fGchGC dGE TS J M HhQhCG dG Y IdG g
,''d HhQhGC'' ae e YdG Qhd gDdG QhdG gP SH cQN
LGdG fGh TS a RHCG dG ch IL IGQe RHOH qbh
.QdG SCG jf S dG IOdG IGQe QfG a dG OdH
```f
E G ```Ua qoj ```Y ```M
`````ffdG ''````fL SH'' ```dGE
''fL SH'' Of
C G jf ffj eYGE jQJ cP
q GC dG S
WdG dG Ge Sh Y Y M gd e bdG a eCj c
bH ffdG OdG IQGOGE CLJh ,jdG SOdG dGE GNDe fG dG
SQ VY jJ a ZJ fc fGC UN jdG OdG e Y M
YSGE aU V j fL SH
q GC cdH jL .HGfG LGC e d
Y Z b Y M j ,NBG S ah .WdG dG aGe jRH
Y H dG bGC dG jdG dG dh SCc a edG IGQe
.jdG jOf a gCJ