Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Craig C. Byers , Mofreh F. Saleh & Bryan D. Pidwerbesky (2004) Evaluation of Melter Slag as a Base Course
Material, International Journal of Pavement Engineering, 5:4, 193-199, DOI: 10.1080/10298430412331320653
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10298430412331320653
The International Journal of Pavement Engineering, Vol. 5 (4), December 2004 pp. 193199
Opus International Consultants Ltd, Auckland, New Zealand; bDepartment of Civil Engineering, University of Canterbury, Private Bag 4800,
Christchurch, New Zealand; cFulton Hogan Ltd, PO Box 39815, Christchurch, New Zealand
(Received 5 February 2004; Revised 12 September 2004; In final form 28 September 2004)
The demand for quality natural aggregates for use in pavement construction is approaching a critical
state in some parts of New Zealand and other countries around the world. The search for alternative
sources of aggregate to minimize the utilization of natural aggregates and provide a high quality
substitute has led to slag. The purpose of this study was primarily to examine the engineering,
environmental and economical issues relating to the utilization of melter slag as a base course material.
New Zealand pavements are predominantly thin-surfaced unbound granular flexible pavements where
the main design criterion is the vertical compressive strain at the top of the subgrade imposed by each
axle load. Laboratory testing used Repeat Load Triaxial apparatus to determine the resilient modulus
and permanent deformation characteristics of the melter slag aggregate and two traditional aggregate
materials. The principles of multi-layer elastic theory were then used in a pavement design exercise to
determine the engineering and economic benefits of the slag. Additives were also attempted in the
laboratory testing to investigate the effect they would have on the melter slag aggregate. Results showed
the performance of the slag exceeds that of the natural aggregates in terms of both resilient modulus and
permanent deformation characteristics, and the addition of lime and cement binders enhanced these
characteristics even further. The study also investigated various environmental and economic factors
associated with the use of the slag and concluded that melter slag should be considered as an adequate
substitute for traditional premium aggregates in road construction.
Keywords: Slag; Aggregate; Base course; Resilient modulus; Permanent deformation; Slag as a base
course material
INTRODUCTION
The demand for quality natural aggregates for use in
pavement construction is approaching a critical state in
some parts of New Zealand, especially Auckland. Due to
the exhaustion of several existing quarries within the
region, Auckland is experiencing difficulties in sourcing
high quality aggregates for use in its growing road
network and the large corridor projects due to start in the
region. Consequently, the search has turned to investigating alternative sources of aggregate such as melter slag.
New Zealand has a road network of approximately
100,000 km including an 11,000 km state highway system.
This infrastructure is supported by a population of only 4
million, which means that road funds have always had to be
spread thinly. This has resulted in a form of pavement
construction comprised of a carefully specified unbound
granular base supported as necessary on a lower quality
unbound sub-base (to further reduce costs) and surfaced
with a one- or two-coat surface treatment. High quality
*Corresponding author. E-mail: mofreh.saleh@canterbury.ac.nz
ISSN 1029-8436 print/ISSN 1477-268X online q 2004 Taylor & Francis Ltd
DOI: 10.1080/10298430412331320653
194
Research Objectives
. Determine whether the resilient modulus and permanent deformation behaviour of crushed melter slag
under loading is equivalent to or better than those of
natural aggregates that satisfy Transit New Zealands
specifications (1995) for base course aggregate.
. Provide information about melter slag to promote its
usage as a construction aggregate with confidence in
terms of its engineering, economic and environmental
impacts.
TESTING METHODOLOGY
The bulk of the laboratory work involved testing the slag
aggregate in Repeat Load Triaxial apparatus to determine
its resilient modulus and permanent deformation characteristics and compare with common materials to determine
its suitability. The laboratory testing also included
stabilisation of the slag aggregates by cement, lime and
TABLE I Typical chemical composition values for Melter, blast furnace
and steel slag
Blast furnace slag (%)
Compounds
CaO
SiO2
Al2O3
MgO
Sulphur
FeO
MnO
TiO2
K20
Fe2O3
Melter
slag (%)
Emery
(1982)
Jones
(1982)
Coventry et al.
(1999)
14
15
18
13
1
34
36 45
33 42
10 16
3.0 16
1.0 3.0
0.3 2.0
0.2 1.5
40.0
36.8
16.0
5.4
0.4
0.2
0.5
0.3
0.4
3150
1124
5.018
2.08.0
6.022
5.030
Material properties
Slag
Basalt
Greywacke
Specific gravity
Plastic limit
Plasticity index
Optimum moisture content (%)
L.A. abrasion no.
Sand equivalence
Maximum dry density (kg/m3)
3.20
N/A
N/A
3.5
29.2
100
2500
3.05
14.5
5.5
5.4
N/T
N/T
2242
2.70
18
4
6.5
N/T
N/T
2250
LABORATORY TESTING
MATerials Testing Apparatus (MATTA) capable of
undertaking both Resilient Modulus testing and Permanent Deformation testing was used in the Transportation
Laboratory, Department of Civil Engineering, University
of Canterbury. Figure 1 shows the apparatus used in the
testing process.
Samples were placed within the triaxial cell and
positioned between the base plate and crosshead of the
testing machine. Axial stress was generated from a
feedback-controlled hydraulic actuator capable of accurately applying a loading stress pulse of rectangular shape.
A confining stress was generated by a closed loop
controlled actuator to simulate the support from
surrounding material as experienced in the road. The
confining pressure was applied by filling the triaxial cell
with water, leaving a small amount of air at the top to be
pressurized via a feedback controlled pressure regulator.
The machine imparted a vertical dynamic force of
rectangular waveform with a period of 3 s and a load
pulse of 1 s duration, in accordance with the requirements
Portland cement
Hydrated lime
CSS-1 emulsion
195
196
% Weight passing
Sieve size
TNZ M4 Spec.
Slag
Basalt
Greywacke
37.5 mm
19 mm
9.5 mm
4.75 mm
2.36 mm
1.18 mm
600 mm
300 mm
150 mm
75 mm
100
6681
4357
2843
1933
1225
719
314
010
07
100
80
55
39
28
21
10
6
1
0
100
79
56
40
26
17
12
9
7
5
100
72
50
33
22
14
9
6
4
3
FIGURE 3 The relationship between bulk stress and the resilient modulus for slag aggregate.
197
ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS
The use of approximate costs for processing, transportation, and construction enables one to make a gross
198
FIGURE 7 Comparison between permanent deformation for the three different aggregates.
Mix
Melter slag
Basalt
Greywacke
1.5% Emulsion
2% Lime
4% Lime
2% Cement
Basecourse
thickness (mm)
Cost/lane/km ($)
Ratio
(cost/slag cost)
140
150
145
150
135
130
120
18,375
17,656
17,128
19,688
17,719
17,063
15,750
1.00
0.96
0.93
1.07
0.96
0.93
0.86
199